Latest / Star Wars Alliance / Star Wars Master & Apprentice Review Star Wars Alliance CLI
Transcript
- 0:00The Force will be with you always. Hello and welcome back to another episode
- 0:24of Star Wars Alliance. But of course, if you're here live with us
- 0:28on YouTube, you're gonna see a very different background. We'll get to that
- 0:32later. Of course, I'm your host, Clay and with Melike always is
- 0:39Katie. That almost got a glimpse of a little too much of my family
- 0:45earlier, just a few minutes ago. But we don't know. You laughed
- 0:50at what I said, but we're not gonna repeat what I said. It
- 0:58makes sense. You have since students. It totally makes sense, and people
- 1:03could probably connect the dots there. So, hey, how how is your
- 1:10dapen really crappy? I spent forty five minutes on the phone with my insurance
- 1:17company to only find out that the hospitals admitted, Yeah, still having that
- 1:23issue. That sucks. I hit. I was like, I told the
- 1:26guy, and Matt was in here because he was trying to keep me calm,
- 1:30and I was like, I'm seriously trying not to cary on the phone
- 1:34at this point, and the guy's like, well, there's just nothing I
- 1:37can do. You're gonna have to talk to the hospital, and the hospital's
- 1:40already told me, no, the insurance company needs to tell us that we
- 1:44can submit this, and I'm just like, please, can somebody get their
- 1:48ever loving shit together so that I don't have to pay this motherfucking bill.
- 1:53So and then they finally, the insurance company finally found it and the guy,
- 1:59the guy on the phone was really nice, don't you wrong? He
- 2:01was super nice and he was like, oh yeah, I found it.
- 2:05So now we can call Prisma and do all these things. And the billing
- 2:09department for Prisma is closed till the end of the year. Yikes, that
- 2:17sex. It's just my luck. It's just my luck. Well, hopefully
- 2:27we will talk in better light of things with Percy Jackson. That's what we're
- 2:32gonna have as our opening crawl today. We are bringing that back to talk
- 2:38about a series that Katie enjoys very much, a series that I was introduced
- 2:45to just this past week or month or whatever you want to call it,
- 2:51something that I am really interested in. It's gonna be a very interesting review
- 2:57for these first two episodes, I'll tell you that, and then of course
- 3:01we will get into all the nitty gritty Star Wars stuff. Now. The
- 3:06difference is if you're listening to this in the podcast form, You're not going
- 3:10to hear any of the Star Wars stuff because this is of course the Percy
- 3:14Jackson and the Olympians review, which is going to be on the g Way
- 3:17feed. But I'm gonna be pretty lazy with the Star Wars Alliance and probably
- 3:23just post the entire episode how it is. Probably I'll cut out the Percy
- 3:32Jackson review, of course, but but everything before and then after it,
- 3:38of course, so a dual intro if you will, yes, yes,
- 3:44So what's our main topic so you don't have to edit it in later?
- 3:49Our main topic for Star Wars Alliance is, oh yes, Master and Apprentice
- 3:53is going to be our main conversation piece. Katie just reread it today.
- 4:02I don't know how, but I have gotten i think two and a half
- 4:11reads on that book. I have some interesting things to kind of point out,
- 4:16because the entire reason why we even wanted to talk about it is,
- 4:21of course, uh, it being one of the Cannon books, you know,
- 4:27stuff that you were wanting to introduce to me with, you know,
- 4:30not just high republic stuff, but also the oh so slight mention of the
- 4:35Nameless, which is of course a very big prominent deal in the High Republic.
- 4:43So we will talk about that later tonight. Hey, maybe you're on
- 4:46YouTube. I'm sorry, I keep yawning, y'all. I'm sorry. Some
- 4:51news. So the first thing we have up in our Star Wars Alliance chat,
- 5:00I want to go ahead and say congratulations to Young Jedi Adventures for winning
- 5:08Children's and Family winning. Yeah, for outstanding editing, and I agree the
- 5:16editing is amazing but sound everything absolutely perfect. Still need to finish the season,
- 5:25but congratulations on Young Jedi Adventures for that. You posted this in the
- 5:32chat that the Acolyte has had reshoots this month. Yes, there was nothing
- 5:41particularly special in it. It was from Besban bulletin. I don't want to
- 5:44get too much into like the scenes and stuff, because they did have some
- 5:46scene details, but they did have some reshoots. So I still think that
- 5:53can put it on track for May. But everybody's thinking it's going to be
- 5:57August when act like so you nearly gave me a heart attack. What was
- 6:05it yesterday? Yes? And or got postponed season to twenty twenty five.
- 6:12This was in a press release from Disney Plus and Star Wars NewsNet. Twitter
- 6:18post tweet says the bad Batch Sason three and Tales of the Jedi season two
- 6:24confirmed for twenty twenty four, Hama. But then they capitalized along, so
- 6:30it makes you think it's a new sentence, and it's so they said,
- 6:33come along with the Acolyte and Skeleton Crew and then as Simmy Colin and Or
- 6:40season two moves into twenty twenty five. This is a horrible tweet, people,
- 6:44This is a horrible tweet. It confused the fuck out of me.
- 6:47So when I read it, I read it as along with Acolyte and Skeleton
- 6:53Crew and OR season two moves into twenty twenty five, and I'm like,
- 6:57are you freaking kidding me? I'm not going to get any live action Star
- 7:01Wars until twenty twenty five, and it's all gonna be animation for twenty twenty
- 7:06four. That's what I thought it said. And then Travis was the one
- 7:11that was like, no, no, no, no, no, no,
- 7:14back it up. Reread it. It says that act Like and Skeleton
- 7:19Crew are confirmed with bad Batch and Tales of the Jedi in twenty twenty four.
- 7:25I was like, Okay, thank god that I you nearly gave me
- 7:30a heart attack there. It does look like and Or is back filming right
- 7:34now. The woman who plays U Sybils whatever his name is the Imperial Enemy
- 7:45guy who like is the inspector guy. His mom took pictures on Instagram and
- 7:51posted those, and so it looks like they're back filming for and our season
- 7:56two, so hopefully we'll see some production wrap up things on there soon.
- 8:03The other bit of news that we had second to last is Knight Errant,
- 8:09Raith Squadron and Order sixty six are the next Legends at A Legends additions to
- 8:16the Essential Legends collection, so those will be out in February sixth, twenty
- 8:22twenty four. I'm super excited for the Race Squadron one, but I know
- 8:26we'll be talking a lot about John Jackson Miller's stuff in February, and so
- 8:31Night Errant was one of those books. So yeah, very very cool stuff.
- 8:37Last thing from Empire magazine, Dave Filoni teas Thrones future in Star Wars,
- 8:45saying his foil throughout Rebels was Hara, he tells. He tells Empire
- 8:50this being of course Filoni pinning the two generals against one another is something that
- 8:56I find interesting. So it looks like Hara is probably gonna have a little
- 9:01bit more of a staple role in season two, which is gonna be very
- 9:07interesting because of where we left off with our main characters in a completely different
- 9:15galaxy. So, so do you think we'll get them in Mendlor in season
- 9:18four? I know we'll get thrown, but how much Ezra and Harrah will
- 9:26we get? And man Laurien, I wouldn't mind a little bit of din
- 9:35Jar and Ezra team up. I think that would be kind of fun.
- 9:41Yeah, he could teach Greby some new tricks. Well, I think Ezra's
- 9:45gonna like because even out in a different galaxy with his life on the line
- 9:50and everything else, he was still like kind of cracking jokes and being a
- 9:54little silly. He was a little bit more of the stoic individual. But
- 9:58I think now that he's kind of home, he's going to get back to
- 10:01where he was where I hope, so where he might be a little bit
- 10:05more silly. He might, you know, of course, he's grown up,
- 10:07and I think that he will, you know, be an adult when
- 10:11he needs to be an adult, and be serious when he needs to.
- 10:13But I hope that he can relax a little bit now being at home,
- 10:20and I think that would be really cool if he was able to be his
- 10:24normal self around individuals like Grogu and Dinjarn. Oh, for sure. That
- 10:33is really all the bits of news that we have. So is it time
- 10:41to talk about Master and Apprentice? I believe So I think we're gonna jump
- 10:45right into this Master and Apprentice. Let me go ahead, And I know
- 10:50you probably already have the wiki up. I do. I do. But
- 10:56this was written by a Claudia Gray. Right, yes, written by Claudia
- 11:03Gray. I want to ask when was this published? This was published April
- 11:13sixteenth to twenty nineteen. Really, yeah, I thought this book was a
- 11:22lot older. Oh that's what I said. This is the last book.
- 11:31This is the last book Claudia wrote before diving into the High Republic stuff.
- 11:37That's crazy. Oh no, okay, she has Star Wars lea Princess of
- 11:41Walderan. Okay, so I'm gonna go never mind, I'm gonna go ahead
- 11:50and say this one thing first and for it. Uh, this book is
- 11:58very awkward with the existence of Christian White's Padawan. Those two books existing together
- 12:13in canon don't make the other like it would be okay with one existing and
- 12:22one not existing. But now that they both exist. It don't make no
- 12:28sense. Why do you think that? Because I disagree, but I want
- 12:33to hear why you think that. So in Kannotic timeline, Padawan is first.
- 12:41Padawan is this conversation piece between Obi Wan and I guess non communicative conversation
- 12:56between Obi Wan and Qui gon being that these two do not work well together,
- 13:03right, And there's like this yes, and there's this like weird like
- 13:13Obi Wan is like, oh, he doesn't like me, he doesn't want
- 13:16me as a padawan anymore. I'm gonna go do my own thing. And
- 13:18that's when he leaves Corroussant and gets himself stuck on the planet, and you
- 13:24know, goes throughout the adventure and whatnot, and then ultimately at the end
- 13:30he's like, Okay, he really did want to come with me on this
- 13:33mission, and he does like me, and you get the same exact end
- 13:37result as you get in Master and Apprentice, Like they both start the same
- 13:43and in the same in the sense of the relationship between master and apprentice Qui
- 13:48gon Jin and Obi Wan Kenobi. So I remember saying that in Padawan,
- 13:54yes, that it kind of felt like we were saying said, however,
- 13:58kind of looking at it now, I feel like Paduan is more about Obi
- 14:03Wan believing in himself to be a Jedi, and then Master and a Prentice
- 14:07is mainly about Qui Gon coming into himself and buying himself, but it's also
- 14:13about Qui Gon and Obi Wan's relationship and then learning how to trust each other.
- 14:18Fully, I do agree with you, but I still stand on it
- 14:28feels very much the same as far as the sentiment between the yes completely,
- 14:35So that's why it makes it a little awkward, especially when like it almost
- 14:39feels like a little check mark is being hit with these two books. It's
- 14:46like, Okay, Master and Prentice need to have a confrontation to make them
- 14:50feel like they are uh not fit for each other. You need to have
- 14:56one high republic teas and and uh finish the conflict within your book. And
- 15:03that's what all all three of those checks are hit with these books. Yes,
- 15:09my main qualm with Master and Apprentice is the fact that it feels very
- 15:16similar to The Phantom Menace, minus the relationship and minus the prophecy stuff.
- 15:24You have an underage queen, you have like you have a planet that is
- 15:31like is desperate for a treaty to kind of interact better with the world.
- 15:35You have a corrupt business environment who is manipulating the planet to try and get
- 15:41what it wants. The like the Prophecy and like a what was his name?
- 15:50Avros, I think, oh my god, I'll be one goes into
- 15:54the freaking ship and shoots it with oh my god. It's similar to Phantom
- 16:02Menace. And like if you read Claudia Gray's stuff, it's like Claudia is
- 16:07so freaking talented. But then yet we take this where this is eight like
- 16:15pretty much eight years before the Phantom Menace. This is this takes place in
- 16:18forty b B Y and we literally have an epilogue in the Phantom Menace,
- 16:23and it just feels like we going back and forth between like negotiations. So
- 16:32I will say this jumping a little bit ahead the epilogue where it jumps into
- 16:38the future at Qui Gon's funeral. Yes, I don't like it. I
- 16:45didn't like it. No, like I like cause you end on and again
- 16:55this may just be my whole thing, and listeners, you know me,
- 16:59I always want the happy for the Star Wars universe, but like you win
- 17:03on such a good note between the two. It's like you could have left
- 17:08some room there for another adventure for Obi Wan kenobi in Qui gon Jin,
- 17:15because she like the yeah you even mentioned it in in in that epilogue,
- 17:22obi Wan is like, oh, I don't remember anytime before that one mission,
- 17:30all those years ago. It's it's every mission after. It's like,
- 17:34I want those missions. I don't want to hear about Qui gon Jin's funeral
- 17:38just yet, Like like you're jumping ahead a little bit, you know.
- 17:42I still think they're waiting to one day give us the Obi Wan Stine adventure.
- 17:49I I would be okay with that. I would bake money for that.
- 17:55Bill Ray, Random House World, whatever your name is. But with
- 18:00Wink, with this book, I I dug the prophecy stuff only because not
- 18:12just because of the nameless stuff, but because it cemented who Qui gon will
- 18:22be and how important he is to the eventual Skywalker saga that we all know
- 18:29and love. Because of these prophecies, uh and I do have a list
- 18:36here. There are a total of six prophecies in this book, so I
- 18:48want your opinion on what these prophecies mean. So the first prophecy says,
- 18:56she who will be born in darkness will give birth to darkness. Now there's
- 19:03an exploit. There is a throwaway explanation of who this might be. In
- 19:10the actual book, Obi Wan explains it to Qui Gon Jenny. It's like,
- 19:14oh, well, that's clearly this person because of what happened at this
- 19:18one time or whatever. Is there any person that you might think it is?
- 19:30Now, I'm terrible with these prophecies. Stop, well, I looked
- 19:33it up in these websites and stuff. So this website is saying we have
- 19:37run into a Have we run into this prophecy already? Could this be Leah
- 19:42born to Darth Vader and then given birth to Kylo Red? Maybe so,
- 19:48could be a possibility there prophecy too. When the Kaiber is not Kayber shines
- 19:53forth, the time of prophecy will be at hand. This is clearly in
- 19:57the book. That's one of the bare the plot points is. Uh,
- 20:03there's two jewel thieves, which I absolutely loved them in this book. Uh
- 20:10it's Packs and uh, oh I nowhere name. Oh it's on the tip
- 20:17of my tongue. I just remember Packs because I just love him as a
- 20:23character. Did did it starts to start with the right Rahara Rahara, Rahara
- 20:33and packs. So uh, they're the jewel thieves. But they thought that
- 20:38they came upon this refinery of uh kyber and it wasn't kyber. It was
- 20:45a different type of crystal uh. And it plays a huge part into this
- 20:52book. But there is a prophecy here, and even I love the relationship
- 20:59between because we do get this these moments in the book also that were like
- 21:02years prior with Zuku as Qui gon Jen's master, and then looking at the
- 21:11Book of Prophecies or the Holokrona Prophecies and we get these small moments where Qui
- 21:17gon Jen and Obi Wan are talking about these prophecies. So I like the
- 21:19parallel there and how Qui gon Jen is always in the center of it.
- 21:23I do like that prophecy three, when the righteous lose the light, evil
- 21:33once dead shall return. This one was a little weird to me. The
- 21:41website has the explanation of this prophecy gets more and gets me more the most,
- 21:48even in the Chosen One prophecy, it feels like something that could have
- 21:52have a lot of weight behind it. Does this refer to look Luke been
- 21:56someone else? This is a prophecy I would want to dive further into want
- 22:03pete the prophecy again. When the righteous lose the light, evil once dead
- 22:08shall return. So let's talking about the Jedi. It could be the Jedi.
- 22:15It could be Luke, considering the fact that you know, we're reading
- 22:21the Jedi Academy where they did, you know, reference the fact that at
- 22:26one point Luke did fall into the dark side, being the right hand of
- 22:32a resurrected emperor. We have Kylo Rinn Ben Solo. You know, he
- 22:40was I guess righteous to some aspect, being good and then turning evil.
- 22:48So it could be a lot of different things. But I do like the
- 22:52Jedi as a whole, yeah, because I feel like if the Jedi hadn't
- 22:56fallen and we're like more apt to discover who the Sith were and kind of
- 23:03handle it a little more appropriately, I feel like the evil wouldn't have risen
- 23:07and Luke wouldn't have had his problem with Ben. So I think the catalyst
- 23:11ultimately is for the the darkness will rise, I think is what you said.
- 23:21I think that's one hundred Jedi Order of the Republic Prophecy number four one
- 23:30will ascend to the highest of the Jedi. Despite the foreboding of those who
- 23:34would serve with him. Now uh uh Anakin mace Windu for voting. Well,
- 23:45yeah, yeah, this website does say. Oh, that sounds like
- 23:48a lot like Anakin in the book Master and Apprentice. The other Jedi that
- 23:55we follow in this story, rail avro Rail He was and this is a
- 24:02correction from last week where I said he was Qui Gon's first apprentice. He
- 24:06was Douku's first apprentice before took on Qui Gon. Yeah, rail Avarass.
- 24:15I do like him as a character. He kind of like reminds me of
- 24:23oh, what's his name? Season four of Clone Wars? What's his name?
- 24:34That that is racist to Clones? I don't know. It's song in
- 24:45Bara. Yeah. He he holds the two uh double bladed lightsabers. Yes,
- 24:52I literally I got the episode title right, Jedi punk Krell punk Krell.
- 25:00Yeah. Here he reminds me of Travis Is in the chat to.
- 25:07I don't know why, but it it. He just reminds me of Punkra
- 25:14And I was like, oh, that would be so cool. So,
- 25:18especially with the fact that he doesn't follow Douku, Doku invites him along,
- 25:23like if he wants to leave the Jedi order, and bro I was like,
- 25:27I'm gonna go back to course. I think I'm gonna go back to
- 25:30course, at which I do love because of the because of a conversation that
- 25:33him and Qui Gon have in the middle of this book. There's a moment
- 25:37where they're talking a little bit about what's going on plus the prophecies and everything
- 25:41else. Rail tells Qui Gon He's like, hey, did you ever think
- 25:48about what this prophecy means? A talking about the chosen one says, if
- 25:52this prophecy comes to pass, that means the dark is going to be just
- 25:56as powerful as the lights, so it doesn't matter which side we choose.
- 26:03And I think that's a little bit of a tease of him knowing what Dooku
- 26:10was doing and the path that he's about to walk on, and him trying
- 26:15to decide whether he wants to follow Dooku or follow the Jedi. Like I
- 26:22think that in this book, specifically with Rail, you you're supposed to look
- 26:29at Rail as a renegade, as a rogue, as somebody who doesn't care
- 26:34about the rules, and then by the end of the book he's like,
- 26:41no Qui gon Qui Gon was right, like we choose the light for a
- 26:44reason, and I love that kind of turn for the character. Yes,
- 26:55Travis brings a quote from the book. He said, because we want to
- 26:59win, which is because it is l Yeah, I completely agree. Probably
- 27:03one of my favorite things from the book. Even though this is lower on
- 27:07my Claudio Gray list, Like, she has some very good quotes that come
- 27:11here. She's a fantastic writer, no matter how many issues I have,
- 27:18And I feel so bad having issues because I remember, I remember I think
- 27:22this was like one of the first times I interacted with Snell and Taylor was
- 27:29during their review of Master and a Prentice and Snell loves this book like with
- 27:33a passion. But yeah, for me, I'm just like, so Travis
- 27:41does bring up, uh, you know, of the three Padawan focus prequels,
- 27:48you have Padawan, you have Master Apprentice, and then you have Brotherhood.
- 27:52He says, I like Brotherhood more, but this is a good one
- 27:56out of the three. Katie and I had issue is with Padawan. I
- 28:03definitely feel like this book and that book are a little bit redundant. But
- 28:08Katie explained some things, so I was like, Okay, they can exist
- 28:11within the same realm. Whatever. I really do enjoy this book. You
- 28:18know, Katie kind of opened my mind's eye with this just being Phantom Menace
- 28:23eight years prior, But am I am I wrong? It's when you look
- 28:33at it, it's definitely it's definitely phantom Menace, which I think is hilarious
- 28:38and like even even uh, the the Hunt is just the pod race,
- 28:44That's all it is. It's a pod race that's hilarious, absolutely insane.
- 28:52But the fifth prophecy, I want to go back to these because this is
- 28:56one of our biggest moments, uh, talking about you know, this book
- 29:00in you know, the High Republic and the Connections and everything. Prophecy number
- 29:03five. Only through sacrifice of many Jedi will the Order cleanse the sin done
- 29:11to the nameless. The danger of the pass is not passed, but sleeps
- 29:15in an egg. When the egg cracks, it will threaten the galaxy entire.
- 29:21When the force itself seconds past and future must split and combine, a
- 29:26chosen One shall come, born of no father, and through him will ultimate
- 29:33balance of the Force be restored. So I thought that the Chosen One prophecy
- 29:40was an entirely different thing from the Nameless prophecy, but it's one very long
- 29:47prophecy that can really be cut into different parts here. So first part the
- 29:55Jedi, the sacrifice of many Jedi, will the order cleans, the sin
- 30:02done to the nameless, not by the nameless, to the nameless, that's
- 30:07very odd for me. And then the danger of this. You can go
- 30:12this in like two ways, Like you could go, okay, there's a
- 30:17sin done to the nameless that we haven't seen done before. Or you can
- 30:22say this was Marta, Sunshine, Dobs and them all just pulling the nameless
- 30:30from planets on the planet, and that was the sin done. But the
- 30:36Jedi are ultimately held responsible as the caretakers, the main caretakers of the force
- 30:41force and the ones involved. Ooh, okay, okay, I like the
- 30:48I like the explanation. I like it. The danger of the pass is
- 30:52not passed, but it sleeps in an egg, that egg being, of
- 30:56course, the creatures of the nameless. When the egg cracks, it will
- 31:00threaten the galaxy entire We have been seeing that here in the Higher repolicy.
- 31:06Yep. When the Force itself sickens, past and future must split and combine.
- 31:14This was an interesting line, of course. When the Force sickens,
- 31:18when we are seeing the individuals get consumed by the nameless. It makes them
- 31:25sick, It makes them ill, it makes them crazy, It does a
- 31:27whole lot of different things. They are consuming the force, like the forces
- 31:33no longer existing within beings when the nameless feed on them. Past and future
- 31:41must split and combine. What do you think that means? I think and
- 31:47a lot of people were talking about how this prophecy mainly applies. When it
- 31:52was announced that Phase two was going to go back in time. That was
- 31:57like, oh, so past and future must split and then combine? Is
- 32:04that was talking about? Okay, so we're gonna see a lot of characters
- 32:07from Phase two come into Phase three and kind of unite to help free the
- 32:13force and kind of help the nameless get to where they were. I don't
- 32:20know if that's the case anymore, because I feel like with what we got
- 32:22in Phase two, it's very different from what we were expecting with this prophecy.
- 32:30I feel like it is. I'm gonna go ahead for those who haven't
- 32:39beaten Jedi Survivor, I'm gonna name a little bit of a spoilers here,
- 32:44or talk a little bit of spoilers, So skip ahead just a little bit
- 32:46all right, y'all, we're gonna hit our first ad break and we will
- 32:50be right back in three two one. In Jedi Survivor, the new PS
- 32:58five game, the High Republic mentioned is almost literal visions of the High Republic
- 33:10path. There is a hyperspace corridor that opens up to a planet that literally
- 33:21is an inhabitant non inhabitant planet, and so it like kind of opens up
- 33:30some doors for some stuff in the future. But I I'm pretty sure I
- 33:36said this that if and not, I'll go ahead and say it. Now,
- 33:39what if the Nameless become a problem for Ray and the new Jedi Council,
- 33:53and so the line past and future must split and combine. Ray is
- 34:00learning a lot as one of the last Jedi about the past, about being
- 34:08a Jedi bringing up the Council again, or a possible council, and she
- 34:15learns of the Nameless, like it could be a possibility, couldn't I could
- 34:21be throwing something a curveball, for sure, But maybe I don't think that's
- 34:30possible because I feel like a Claudia Gray didn't know where Ray was gonna end
- 34:39up after the Rise of Skywalker because this came out the same year as the
- 34:45Rise Skywalker. Rise Skywalker was December twenty nineteen. This was April twenty nineteen,
- 34:52So I think that's a tough ask. Mm hmm. If that's mega
- 34:58future planning plus no wing, probably at the time LUCASLM was like, Oh
- 35:04yeah, we're gonna be using Ray, Poe and Finn and like going off
- 35:10in our own direction. I think this is purely like this is setting up
- 35:16for the publishing amarment because I think the way you have to think about this
- 35:21is the chosen one line comes after this line, so it's like a two
- 35:25like it's following in step. Okay, it's not jumping ahead because I think
- 35:32to say, like, oh, yeah, we're gonna plug this. I
- 35:36if it really was meant to be, oh Ray and her future Jedi order
- 35:42is going to discover it, we will never see that never ever. Okay,
- 35:47Okay. Now, Like just like for me, I I always think
- 35:53of like like the craziest theories when I when I first read the book,
- 36:00when I heard or when I yeah, because I was listening it's an audible.
- 36:05When I heard Past and Future must split and combine, I was thinking
- 36:08of freaking, uh what is it called the the uh? The space between
- 36:15worlds or whatever it is between worlds. Yeah, the world between worlds.
- 36:21Like I thought about that, and I was like, oh, they're gonna
- 36:22bring it, like it's gonna be. I was thinking all sorts of stuff,
- 36:25So it's just what my brain does. And then of course the Chosen
- 36:30One shall come born of no Father, and through him will ultimate balance in
- 36:36the forest be restored, of course, being Anakin Skywalker creating Luke Skywalker,
- 36:43and then of course we get Ray Skywalker. The Skywalker family is that that
- 36:49gets that balance. When I read Past and Future must split and combine,
- 36:52my first thought was Ray and Kylos splitting Luke's saber only for Ready to repair
- 36:57it. Likely not the case, though, interesting thought, what do you
- 37:02think? Yeah, I could see it, especially with like the fact that
- 37:09we had gotten the Last Jedi, so yeah, she would have probably been
- 37:14writing it after the Last Jedi had come out, so I could totally see
- 37:19it. Plus she was involved in the Last Jedi planning with h Leah,
- 37:23Princess of Alderon, so it could totally be feasible that that was meant for
- 37:30it. And I mean, if that's the case, then we've seen it.
- 37:34I just don't know what that has to do with the nameless or the
- 37:38Chosen One, because again, as everyone always likes to tell me, the
- 37:44Chosen One is Anakin Skywalker, it is not the Skywalker name. I think
- 37:47if you're going towards the Chosen One, then I feel like the Chosen One
- 37:52being the Skywalker name and that balance that's achieved at the end of the Nine
- 37:57Movies. I feel like that's like the balance ultimately, yeah, versus Anakin's
- 38:02balance in the stage of things. So I can see that with my interpretation
- 38:07Chosen One. But I was going off of like everybody else's I like that.
- 38:13Yeah, I I ultimately think it is the Skywalker name. It's just
- 38:16it makes the most sense, especially because you could consider them combining to be
- 38:22the diad in the force. Yeah, very true, very very true.
- 38:28H And then there's the sixth prophecy. He who learns to conquer death will
- 38:31through his greatest student, live again, this of course being Qui gone Jin.
- 38:38Travis also mentioned this in the chat. He says, he who learns,
- 38:40of course, he gives the uh the prophecy, and he says this
- 38:45ties back to an early draft of some One where Qui Gon is called Obi
- 38:51Wan his apprentice taking his name in his death fast. That's interesting. I
- 38:57didn't know that either. Uh. Travis also brings something up right here.
- 39:01He says the nameless could be the kid from the end of the Last Jedi,
- 39:07the idea that prior to the Jedi dying, that kid would likely have
- 39:10been taken at birth. So a lot of theories, a lot of things
- 39:17that can be connected. I mean, we're all fans, you know,
- 39:21we're gonna wear our ten foil hats and say wild things. But the explanation
- 39:28that this website has for the sixth Prophecy says this looks like one that could
- 39:32be directed related directly related to Qui Gon. It would be very interesting if
- 39:37while Qui Gon was studying the prophecies, this one was about him, or
- 39:42did the prophecy only become about him because he read it and learned that there
- 39:46is another type of life after death? You know. The big point of
- 39:54this book was both Doku and Qui Gon, at some point in their lives
- 40:02started to look at these prophecies as words of fiction, and they're just like,
- 40:07oh, these are metaphors, these aren't to be taken literally, you
- 40:09know. Eventually, which I thought was really weird. Qui Gon gets a
- 40:20vision from the force, and apparently this rarely, if not ever, happens.
- 40:27So yes, uh, Siphos and Dooku Jedi Lost had the visions more
- 40:34frequently and was even like he worked with a master who was gifted in the
- 40:39prophecy like division. But that's why Siphadius ultimately ends up dead is because of
- 40:46the Council rejecting the vision aspect. And I mean, even if you look
- 40:54at like the Yoda comic, for instance, I think it's Jodi Houser's iteration.
- 41:02Her three issues dives into like a Wookie that gets a vision of the
- 41:12mortal enemy of the Yeah, I remember those. It was like two issues
- 41:20or three issues. Yeah, three issues of him attacking Yeah, him in
- 41:25his sleep or something. Yeah, it's commonplace, but it's like you have
- 41:30to learn how to interpret it, which Doo Whu was working with Qui Gon
- 41:36in order to do so. It's like, yeah, Travis says, from
- 41:43Clone Wars, we get the implication that life after death was unheard of,
- 41:49and Qui Gon communing with Yoda was shocking to the Jedi. We also see
- 41:53him communing with Yoda in Clone Wars, which was very very cool. I
- 42:02dig this just because again, like when it comes to Qui gon just this
- 42:10random Jedi and phantom menace one day and he becomes one of the most important
- 42:15parts of Star Wars history. So I dig this. I really love him
- 42:22as a character and I love the idea of him. And we've talked about
- 42:30this before, him being a little bit of the rebel and when they do
- 42:36ask him to be on the council, like the Council does take that into
- 42:42consideration and they're like, you will bring and Qui Gon's like diplomacy. They're
- 42:50like no, no, no, no, no, no balance. You
- 42:52know, you will disagree with us, and that's okay. But also hearing
- 42:58that Yoda was not for Qui gon Ye being on the council was very interesting.
- 43:06How did you take that and feel about that? Well, I definitely
- 43:12think that's just Yodo wanting the Council to stay in his ways. I do.
- 43:17I'm always dying for like a Yoda biography, like just to kind of
- 43:22get chronicle his life story, because man, the man is nine hundred years
- 43:27old. He dies nine hundred at the end of Return of the Jedi,
- 43:30Like, what has the man seen? We have seen him at like six
- 43:34hundred a seven point fifty or like the masks off on that. But you
- 43:38get my point, like, yeah, like we've seen him in like his
- 43:45like the height of the Jedi's power. So what about like him growing up?
- 43:50What causes him to change? And I imagine we'll get some more of
- 43:53that in The Acolyte honestly, So Travis is still talking in the Jay he
- 44:01says, when George said jar Jar is the key, I saw it that
- 44:07Qui Gon's optimism in taking a chance on him is what grants them victory coming
- 44:15full circle when Luke takes a chance on the Ewoks. Yes, yeah,
- 44:21it's very very cool. But I know we haven't talked a very great detail
- 44:28of this book. We always want you guys to read it for yourselves,
- 44:30have a great time with it. I you know, there was just a
- 44:36lot to talk about with these prophecies, and I think they're very very fun.
- 44:39They're fun to think about, you know, in the consideration that some
- 44:43of these haven't come to pass yet. Is I think something that's very fun
- 44:46too, Yeah, And I mean ultimately, like when you take a look
- 44:51at it, like besides Obi Wan and Qui Gon's relationship kind of building to
- 44:55where they finally fully trust each other. The prophecies are the best part of
- 45:01this because, like even you get like the false Kyburg or whatever they call
- 45:07the crystal, You get that introduction which I thought was gonna be so interesting,
- 45:14but then you turn it around immediately in the same book to go,
- 45:19oh, yeah, it really means nothing because you can just make weapons out
- 45:22of it that can then defeat the shields that it built. I love that.
- 45:28I love that there because I hated that so much. Well, I
- 45:35love it and I hate it because for me, I love the shield aspect
- 45:39because of course, in Knights of the Old public, shields on characters were
- 45:44very famous. It was the only way you, as a character holding a
- 45:46lightsaber would be able to like not be like super Opie and just slicing everybody
- 45:53down. So seeing the shields here, I thought that was very fun.
- 46:00And it goes full circle because in the very beginning of this book we have
- 46:04a confrontation with the Huts and Qui Gon and Obi Wan, and you learn
- 46:09about the black market of these crystals and shields and everything going basically to the
- 46:19huts and people that they're connected to, and so I really love that.
- 46:22But the idea that like, hey, we're gonna completely do a one to
- 46:30eighty on these crystals and make them completely useless because I don't want to get
- 46:37another nine to ten books about lightsabers not being badass anymore. Like that would
- 46:47have been boring, Like it just would. No, but you could have
- 46:52had a little more discovery into like the weapon creation of this false kyber to
- 47:00like be counteracted because like you just think about it, and like, I
- 47:06think they've just missed opportunities because and you haven't read this book. But Throw
- 47:09On Alliances also gets into where the separatists are making battle droids or no,
- 47:21no, there's a factory that is creating lightsaber proof stormtrooper armor. Okay,
- 47:30And so like when did Thrown Alliances come out? I feel like it was
- 47:37a little before that twenty eighteen, So July twenty fourth, twenty eighteen.
- 47:40So you had like these really too cool like weapons that like make a whole
- 47:45lot of sense. But in Throng Alliances the factory is blown up and Anakin
- 47:51never hears about I believe it was stormtrooper proof lightsaber armor. It might have
- 47:55been droids either way, but it was like your first inclination. I think
- 48:00it was the Stormtrooper, because your first inclination like, oh, who's making
- 48:04a lightsaber proof stormtrooper armor? Like what does this mean? And stuff?
- 48:09And like he and Thron and padme below the factory up so they don't have
- 48:15to worry about it. And then you get this one where it's like,
- 48:17Okay, here's another potential lineup. And obviously you can't use these weapons in
- 48:23the movies because the movies have already come out, so it's like what does
- 48:27it matter in the end scheme of things. But you could have built like
- 48:30a really cool trilogy about like, oh crap, we have this weapon.
- 48:35And I mean, they're eight years for Obi Wan and Qui Gon to like
- 48:38do research into the false Kiber and try to build something up. Like I
- 48:43get the sentiment of being I guess the satisfaction of them finally being like,
- 48:50oh, why don't we just use the crystal itself? You know, I
- 48:54guess that could have been something in this book. But it's totally done on
- 49:00accident. I think that's probably what you hate the most about. It is
- 49:04just happenstance, like it's it's it's it's Claudie Gray's mcguffin in the book.
- 49:09It really is. It's just like, oh, this very you know,
- 49:14big thing that I made, like could basically stop all Jedi. Well,
- 49:17actually, let's just like this, just throw it away. Booh, look
- 49:21at that. Obi Wan accidentally has the lightsaber of it. Yeah, but
- 49:27because of that, it ultimately makes it to where obi Wan's lightsaber is useless
- 49:32because even obi Wan is like, Okay, I can't use this because I
- 49:37don't know how unstable this crystal is compared to my lightsaber and everything else that's
- 49:42you know, a component within it, So he doesn't use it for the
- 49:45rest of the book. Trava said, I believe the Clone Wars episode with
- 49:51the Zillabeast was the first time in Cannon where they hinted to lightsaber proof tech
- 49:54with Palpatine taking interest to the beast. Yes, I think that was the
- 49:59first Cannon mentioned as well, Travis, because in Legends you have this stuff
- 50:02called cortosis, which was an ore that was used. It's a big feature
- 50:08in the hand of Thrown duology. So uh, and then I think,
- 50:15yeah, Clone Wars, that was like the first time. But yeah,
- 50:19I'm always really and maybe that's why I like legends so much. I love
- 50:22like different weapons. I find like the fascinating and so just to like kind
- 50:29of pick it up and go, oh yeah, there's this thing, but
- 50:31oh yeah, it also means an ethic and just like throw it out.
- 50:36It's just like, oh, I I mean, I thought it was a
- 50:40cool like visual thing if if if I don't know if you're the type of
- 50:45reader that is able to visualize things, but like the idea of Obi Wan
- 50:52just like turning on his lightsaber and it being orange, like that's pretty cool,
- 50:57especially with of course the looming threat of this vision that Qui gon Jin
- 51:02is having, like he's so worried about what's going to happen during this treaty
- 51:07ceremony and then everyone being able to save himself I think was really really cool.
- 51:15But like going back to rayl Avros, like we have this individual who
- 51:22is doesn't play by the rules with anything, you know, he was a
- 51:30individual, a master to somebody. He did have an apprentice. He did
- 51:36have a paddle one that was killed by a droid with a splicer dart I
- 51:44believe is what they called. It basically just was non functional but could still
- 51:52have break capacity. Before she died and she got to see her master just
- 51:58kind of run away and save her everybody else while she died. And it
- 52:01was very traumatic and clearly very traumatic for him still within this book because it
- 52:07still haunted him until the very end, and that's ultimately what kind of kept
- 52:13him from really seeing the Princess for who she was. But I like a
- 52:21rail story, I really really do. It was very weird, just like
- 52:27the way he was introduced with being in the bar, like trying to like
- 52:32talk up this girl. Oh, she has a big chest, maybe she'll
- 52:38have some fun tonight. Like it was. It was very odd, but
- 52:44also being the non traditional Jedi with you know, threatening people with his lightsaber,
- 52:51because he was also in a position of power, which was very weird.
- 52:55I thought that he was just like a bodyguard type of thing, but
- 53:00because of the age of the Princess and there still be needing a ruler,
- 53:07he was basically the ruler of a planet for eight years, which is wild,
- 53:14especially when you think about him being a Jedi, like the Jedi said,
- 53:17oh, yeah, we hate power, but yes we're going to send
- 53:21this guy, this Jedi Knight who has PTSD and all this other emotional crap
- 53:27probably and he's going to become the ruler of this planet. Not only that
- 53:31his master was Count Duku. We're gonna give him this position, right,
- 53:37But Duku at the time was not like because Duku had only had left the
- 53:44Jedi Order for two years in like the main timeline of this book. Oh
- 53:47that's true. That's true. He hadn't left at that point when he when
- 53:52Rail had gone uh to that planet. But yeah, I I thought it
- 53:59was really because even like Yoda and Qui Gon talked about it a little bit,
- 54:04and like Yoda was kind of trying to explain like their reasoning, and
- 54:07he's like, well, we we kind of messed up on this one.
- 54:14But I think that is it for the book. I really enjoyed it.
- 54:20I think I gave this book out of five stars. Because of good Reads,
- 54:23I gave this au four point one. I think that there was some
- 54:29pacing stuff and some other things. And of course my first initial reactions to
- 54:34the idea of this book and Padawan kind of being redundant to each other might
- 54:40go a little bit lowered now that I know that it's Phantom Menace, you
- 54:44know, one point five, But it's remember pad one and this are meant
- 54:50for different audiences because of the young That is also very true. That is
- 54:54also very very true. But I still had a very fun time reading this.
- 55:00You know, the the moments of Obi Wan Kenobi connecting with the Force
- 55:06for the first time, as far as like in battle Meditation and with the
- 55:13uh. I forgot what they were writing, but it's basically the same beast
- 55:15that he is writing in episode three the Verractals. Yes, I thought that
- 55:22was really really fun, and I will say Claudia Gray has a very fun
- 55:29sense of humor, where like there's moments where I was laughing out loud because
- 55:36of like the thoughts that Obi Wan is having through like flying through the ship
- 55:43and like screaming and yelling and stuff. I thought that was really really fun.
- 55:47But yeah, it's it's a great book. I recommend it to anybody
- 55:52who is, of course big into the Star Wars Cannon and it gives you
- 55:57a fun time with these prophecies, which is kind of one of the big
- 56:00stables that we wanted to talk about. Yeah, for sure, I think
- 56:04I agree with pretty much everything you think, though, the fact that this
- 56:08takes so many plot threads from The Phantom Menace and y'all can hate me all
- 56:12you want. I hate the Force awakens. So it feels like such a
- 56:15retread of a new hope. So for me, this is in the exact
- 56:19same boat. This feels very much like a retread of the Phantom Menace.
- 56:23It's not for me. Last thing Travis has he said one thing the book
- 56:27does. It shows both characters that opposite mindsets to that of episode one.
- 56:30Qui Gon worried about the future, obi Wan fix it too, fixated on
- 56:35the present situation. Yeah, and I do. I do like how Claudia
- 56:38kind of has Obi Wan share like oh, yeah, it was such a
- 56:44rebel and then they gave me you, and like because Qui Gon's like telling
- 56:47them like, oh, yeah, you're such a rule follower and he's like,
- 56:50I'm really not. I love rebel. And then they figure out like,
- 56:53oh, the council handed me to you because the only way to fix
- 56:59a is to hand him to a rebel, which makes the padawan rebel a
- 57:05rule follower in order to rebel. Yeah. I thought that was really really
- 57:09fun. And they they both have like this very epiphany moment that's like,
- 57:14oh, that's exactly what they did. That's so clever, that's so smart
- 57:17and it was just a really fun moment. Yeah, but yeah, I
- 57:22think for me this is probably like a three and a half three point twenty
- 57:25five. Again, it's it's probably the Fallen Star came out. If Fallen
- 57:34Star's super short, I would probably say Fallen Stars maybe below this. But
- 57:38like this is like second to last on my list of Cloudy Gray books.
- 57:42I still think she's super talented. Three point twenty five is still not a
- 57:45bad book to have on the list. So yeah, that's where I'm at.
- 57:52Oklay, where can I find you? Of course you can always find
- 57:55me at fanboy Clay on Twitter, on any social media. Really haven't had
- 58:01the time to stream, so not too worried about that right now. When
- 58:07it comes to my other show, Ranger Alliance, the holidays are coming up.
- 58:12Me and Joe are very, very busy, so we're going to hold
- 58:15off on our next episode until probably either the week after Christmas or starting in
- 58:21January. So Ranger Alliance will be making a return, just not yet.
- 58:25So December is kind of like our relaxing month. The week after Christmas is
- 58:32the start in January. So I mean, you know, it's tomato,
- 58:38tomato, you know, thank you very much Travis. Travis has a great
- 58:43review by the Force of Others. Be with you. Thanks and Merry Christmas,
- 58:46Travis. So and if you're listening to this, Merry Christmas. You
- 58:50guys. We are still planning on having an episode next week. We will
- 58:55be talking about Jedi Academy number two, which is Dark Apprentice. Yes,
- 59:02Dark Apprentice. Yes. I always get them confused because I always want to
- 59:07say Dark Apprentices third, and I think Champions of the Force is third,
- 59:13right, yes, yes, so we will be talking about that on the
- 59:16second week of January. But yes, so next week come find us for
- 59:23our review of the Legends book Dark Apprentice. Y'all. You can always find
- 59:30me on most social media platforms. It is at Slace of Katie. I'm
- 59:34going to be trying to use threads more because I'm just fed up with Twitter
- 59:37at this point. I don't like some of the ads that I'm getting.
- 59:40I can't block them, I can't mute them, I can't report them and
- 59:45get them to go away. So yeah, I'm just about done. So
- 59:50yes, that is where you can find me. This show. You can
- 59:52find most of the time. It's on Twitter at Star Wars Lens with the
- 59:57eight and the war is very important. Don't forget it. The hotline for
- 1:00:01the show where you can text or leave us a voicemail, just remember to
- 1:00:05leave us some way to address you. It is eight three zero five three
- 1:00:08eight four eight two eight. You can also email us at Star Wars Alliance
- 1:00:14at gmail dot com. There is no A in the Wars. Remember that
- 1:00:17all our user names no A in the worsh because that's just the best way
- 1:00:22to do it is to have your user name the same across all your platforms.
- 1:00:27Makes business cards really simple. Just kidding, we don't have a business
- 1:00:30card. But yes, thanks for a lively chat, Travis Andrew. I
- 1:00:36know you were here earlier. I did say how to you in the chat,
- 1:00:39but we had some issues setting up the live stream so we had the
- 1:00:44wrong time for when it was supposed to start, so to apologize about that,
- 1:00:49but thanks for being here when you were and uh yeah, I hope
- 1:00:53you guys have a great day or night, whatever time day you are listening
- 1:00:57or launching, and we see on next time. Made the force to be e