Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De’ah 294:10-19. Orlah: Safek, Planting Orlah, Non-Jew Partner, Swapping Years, Transplanting, Havracha

Transcript

Yoreh De’ah 294:10-19. Orlah: Safek, Planting Orlah, Non-Jew Partner, Swapping Years, Transplanting, Havracha · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:00
  Good morning. We are in Resh Saadi Dalid
• 0:05
  summon Resh Saadi Dalid Sif yud Karam Shu suffik Arla baharets
• 0:12
  baris Israel asur ubisuria Moto a vineyard which the whole
• 0:19
  vineyard, we don't know if it was planted within the last
• 0:22
  three years or not. So the whole thing is Arla.
• 0:27
  So in Eretz Cesarol you can enjoy the grapes from from that
• 0:31
  venue. And in Syria you are allowed to
• 0:34
  and of course Vince Arflong with the Hutzlarats and the rest of
• 0:36
  Hutzlarats that you would be allowed to enjoy the Paris
• 0:41
  because the Suffolk, right, because it's a Suffolk.
• 0:44
  So therefore the Paris will be more than that.
• 0:45
  Before we saw in Tess that there's a difference between
• 0:49
  Syria and the rest of Fotzlarats that you needed like an extra
• 0:54
  level of Suffolk in, in, in Syria.
• 0:57
  But that was where there was definitely a kosher Karim.
• 1:02
  And some of the, some of the some of the vines were known to
• 1:10
  be, were known to be Arla Here the entire Karim is a safik
• 1:14
  Arla. So safik Arla.
• 1:15
  But what's the R, as we say is mutter yud aleph kavashal yayin
• 1:21
  hatsumanabe Karim. If you find a barrel of wine
• 1:25
  hidden in a vineyard, the Karamichal Arlo where the the
• 1:29
  whole Karam is vada arlo muta, you can you may drink that wine.
• 1:35
  You don't have to assume that that wine came from Orlo grapes.
• 1:38
  Shane Hagana Ghonev MI Karamazeh, the Tom and bisarfa
• 1:42
  because we have we have a fazaka.
• 1:45
  This is this is a rule that we're saying, therefore we it's
• 1:48
  not even a suffix. It's not even that we'd have to
• 1:50
  worry about it. Well, in there, it's just well,
• 1:52
  maybe no, we have a rule that a Ghana doesn't steal the grapes
• 1:58
  from this vineyard and then hide the wine from that vineyard in
• 2:02
  in that vineyard, right. So Shana got a gun in me.
• 2:05
  Caramazeba tell me the sofa. He wouldn't hide the wine that
• 2:09
  comes from those grapes in that vineyard.
• 2:12
  Avil Anavim, Shinim Sutzman and Beau.
• 2:14
  But if you find grapes hidden in, you know, clearly stowed
• 2:18
  away in that vineyard, a surum. So those grapes would be
• 2:23
  awesome. Shakarov Hadavar And the same
• 2:25
  way we said it was a rule that that wouldn't happen.
• 2:27
  Now we're saying that's a rule that it would happen.
• 2:29
  Shakarov Hadavar it's it's very likely Shaganva Mimenova, Tamnam
• 2:34
  Bisova that he stole the grapes from that vineyard and and Stow
• 2:38
  them away in that vineyard. That's a likely thing to happen.
• 2:40
  So that's why we don't say that is Suffolk Fuslar as well.
• 2:44
  Why don't you say that maybe, maybe these, these grapes came
• 2:47
  from somewhere else? No, it's not really a Suffolk.
• 2:50
  It's very likely that they came from that vineyard.
• 2:53
  So that's what we don't. That's why we wouldn't say
• 2:55
  Suffolk Arla in this case and Fuslar's that would be much
• 2:59
  like, no, if you find grapes stored away in a, in a vineyard
• 3:03
  of Arla, it is Vada Assam or it's likely Assam.
• 3:08
  It's likely. We're saying that it's likely
• 3:11
  because it's likely that's that we're no human behavior.
• 3:13
  It's it's a mytheism. Since it's likely it's therefore
• 3:16
  not a Suffolk you'd base also lead to a priest show Arlo.
• 3:21
  You're not allowed to plant an entire Prix from Arlo right.
• 3:27
  Let's say you have a Peach and want to just put that whole
• 3:29
  Peach in the ground or even the pit from that Peach and put it
• 3:32
  under the ground and grow a new Peach, a new Peach tree from it.
• 3:35
  You're not allowed to do that because the Paris are also
• 3:38
  including the seeds, including using it for for growing new
• 3:43
  fruit, the emnata. But if you did plant Peres of
• 3:47
  Arla, then not the hyperos chaos emnata Paris.
• 3:51
  If you did plant Peres chaos mimena mutarum that which grows
• 3:56
  out or hyperos, I'm sorry, hyperos chaos mimena mutarum the
• 4:00
  the fruit that would grow from a fruit that you planted of Arla.
• 4:05
  So those fruits would be mutter Zeviza garam, because both the
• 4:10
  Arla and the planting it in the ground where the ground is
• 4:13
  mutter. So you have something which is
• 4:15
  usser and something which is mutter together grow the new
• 4:19
  tree that that grows out of that tree of Arla Zeb zagarin is
• 4:23
  mutter. So you're not supposed to you're
• 4:26
  not allowed to plant the Paris of of Arla.
• 4:31
  But if you did the fruit that grow from the tree that grow
• 4:34
  from the Arla are mutter well muta Lita yikhor you are allowed
• 4:39
  to plant a cutting pirish anaf minha ilan.
• 4:44
  If if you you make a cutting from from a tree and then you
• 4:46
  plant that into the ground shell Arla, even though that tree is
• 4:49
  meanwhile still Arla, that yikhor is lahara yikhor of Arla.
• 4:53
  No, that's muta do Shane Arla Ellebert PRI.
• 4:55
  We saw in Sif Aleph that Arla only applies to the fruits.
• 4:59
  It does not apply to the wood. It doesn't apply to to the
• 5:05
  Lulava and it doesn't apply to to the wood to the to the tree
• 5:07
  itself. You'd gimmel you have to wait
• 5:10
  three years for the E4 of all time.
• 5:12
  Yes, if you plant a E4 that's much to do and then that E4 that
• 5:17
  that that cutting which grows into a tree the the the fruits
• 5:21
  of that of those first three years would be it's like any
• 5:25
  other anything else that you plant, you'd gimmel.
• 5:28
  Oh, how many Sarah, you shouldn't have been it to you.
• 5:31
  If there's a guy and a Jew who are partners in a sapling in in
• 5:37
  in planting something in lo histnamitkila if they didn't
• 5:41
  arrange originally ASA so then the the the fruits of the first
• 5:47
  three years are ASA. There's not much to do then
• 5:53
  histnamitkila. But if they if they made-up
• 5:57
  originally at the beginning of their of their shutfish say hey
• 6:02
  ho with the hum Oh Shne Arlo that the guy will take the
• 6:05
  fruits of the first three years. We saw Al awful Gimel Chernan
• 6:09
  Michnay had to connect get Schnee Arlo and the Jew will eat
• 6:14
  three years after the first three years and they'll they'll
• 6:18
  be totally his right. The so the guy gets all of the
• 6:21
  fruits of the first few years. The guy, the the Jew gets the
• 6:23
  the all of the fruits from the next three years.
• 6:26
  Or is it not you're allowed to do that.
• 6:28
  You're allowed to you're out of break up your shutfist that way.
• 6:31
  Vuvanchalo Yevola Peshban, as long as they don't make a
• 6:36
  counting of the actual number of fruits.
• 6:38
  Keitz odd could go on Shayashov coma Paris.
• 6:42
  Oh, hello to Hava missionary Arlo and say OK, you ate 500
• 6:45
  fruits during the first three years.
• 6:48
  Actually, if he's troll, can I get also not Paris.
• 6:50
  So now the the the Jews going to get 500 of the next of the next
• 6:54
  couple of years. Those will be completely his.
• 6:56
  And then after that they'll, they'll, they'll split evenly.
• 6:58
  But that's something that you can't do.
• 7:00
  You can't now say, OK, I'm going to get 500 fruits till, till the
• 7:03
  Jew gets 500 fruits. Then they're all his.
• 7:05
  Your name wasn't that Paris Shazza Asar.
• 7:08
  That would be asar to do Why Neshubum Kamaflev Paris Allah,
• 7:12
  because now you're like bartering.
• 7:14
  You're using the the Jew is now bartering his halak in the Arla
• 7:20
  fruits against, you know, for, for, for other fruits.
• 7:24
  And that's as if he's, he's using them for payment.
• 7:27
  He's getting Hana from the Orla fruits themselves.
• 7:30
  We're not worried about what the guy is doing, but the Jew is now
• 7:33
  getting Hana from from the, the, the Paris of dollars.
• 7:36
  What's the difference between you get the first three years
• 7:39
  and I get the second three years and you eat all of the Paris.
• 7:42
  We're going to count how many Paris those are and then I'll
• 7:45
  get the same number against it. So the difference is, are you
• 7:50
  looking at a year's worth or are you looking at the number of
• 7:52
  fruits? So if you're looking at the
• 7:54
  crop, if you're looking at, well, you got the first three
• 7:56
  years, I got done the next three years.
• 7:58
  That's OK. The guy is getting the, the Arla
• 8:00
  of the first first three years. The guy is not in Suvan Arla.
• 8:04
  But but when you're, when you're counting fruits against fruits.
• 8:08
  So now you're actually you're bartering with with the fruits
• 8:11
  that are awesome. Viesh Matirin Afilulo, his in
• 8:16
  the mitilo. There are those we we're going a
• 8:18
  little further back in in you'd Gimel.
• 8:20
  There are those that Mata, even if they did not originally say,
• 8:24
  OK, the guy's going to get the first three years produce and
• 8:27
  then you'll get the next three years produce.
• 8:28
  By the way, it could be that we that they'd say the next two
• 8:31
  years produce doesn't actually have to be 3 against three, but
• 8:34
  it does have to be, you know, a yearly crop, the Aish Matira
• 8:38
  Matila Lo, his new Mithila that even if the the Jew and the
• 8:41
  guide did not make up with the originally when they said that
• 8:44
  the their shufus Raksha Yisrael Omar Lovid Kufavan told Arthur
• 8:49
  Sneha Arlo Vani, Ethel Schne, Heather Kenegdun.
• 8:53
  You take the first three years, I'll take the next three years.
• 8:56
  It doesn't have to be at the forming of the shufus.
• 8:59
  It could be even later Udala motto lomalovic hava mishnay
• 9:06
  Arla avod carmi de hito parisal A Jew is allowed to say to a
• 9:12
  guy, OK, you work my land, you work my vineyard during the
• 9:19
  first three years and then you're entitled to eat all of
• 9:22
  the fruits. Then the tainly Karmatha, you
• 9:25
  give me your vineyard to work Shah Abdullah that I'll work
• 9:30
  your your vineyard which where this where this vineyard is is
• 9:40
  ready past Arla, the tenant of Rue alleged named Arla that it's
• 9:45
  already past Arla the eve then and I'll work your vineyard,
• 9:49
  that's the Paris and I'll enjoy the fruits of your vineyard.
• 9:52
  Why is this not? Why is this not the Jew having
• 9:58
  enough from his, from his Paris, from his Karen of Arla?
• 10:02
  Because we like we saw in Yudemo that if you do year against
• 10:06
  year, that's fine. So now here also in a similar
• 10:10
  way, we're saying that the person that that is working the
• 10:13
  land is entitled to the fruits and we're just in order for it
• 10:18
  to be a Mishtalian for the for the Jews.
• 10:20
  So he's doing the same thing with the guy, but he's not, he's
• 10:23
  not actually exchanging his fruits, the Jews, fruits of his
• 10:29
  carom for the guys fruits of the guys carom which are after
• 10:32
  Harlow. That's not what's going on here.
• 10:34
  We're saying that because for him to do that, that would be
• 10:37
  us. But we're saying that each one
• 10:40
  is saying the worker is entitled to the fruits of the, of the
• 10:44
  vineyard that he works. So that's OK.
• 10:46
  And again, a guy is not much of A in, in Arla.
• 10:50
  So as a guy working the vineyard, he's entitled to, to,
• 10:54
  to get the fruits of that of, of that, of that Arla vineyard.
• 10:57
  So that's why it works out that it's, there's what to talk
• 11:04
  about. Let's not get into those
• 11:05
  details. Tesla muta lumpkar l'haben Paris
• 11:09
  schnee Arlo le chalo charm MI afe schlo bolololam.
• 11:12
  This one's fascinating. And the Taza actually says that
• 11:16
  it's Arafin. But even though we're saying now
• 11:20
  that I have enough from Paris Arlo, that's only after they
• 11:26
  exist. But if you can tell the guy, pay
• 11:33
  me, you know, $100 for all of the fruits of my Karen for the
• 11:38
  next three years before they ever exist.
• 11:41
  As long as those those those grapes or other fruits don't yet
• 11:46
  exist, you can sell them to the guy.
• 11:48
  And that's for some reason that's not considered Hana from
• 11:54
  from parish from Paris to Zion. EF Ed hanotea garin O yihuur
• 12:03
  oshaka kolha Elam vinata BA Malcolm affair.
• 12:09
  Somebody that plants a seed or let's say an acorn, not from an
• 12:16
  oak. An oak doesn't get fruit, but
• 12:18
  but a seed from of a tree or a or a cutting from a tree or he
• 12:24
  uprooted an entire tree from one place and then he planted it
• 12:28
  again in another place, the Efahim Markovich or the Ilan.
• 12:33
  So also someone that does Harkova, which does what's the
• 12:39
  word grafting. So also somebody that that
• 12:44
  grafts a cutting from one tree into another tree being an
• 12:48
  affair into another tree, the Efahim Navra.
• 12:51
  Also somebody that does Havrafa, which is the Heiner sha OSA guma
• 12:56
  ET alhat Elan you, you dig a hole next to the tree that that
• 12:59
  has many branches, young soft branches, umashkel ehad Mein
• 13:03
  ante hai Elan. And then you bend down one of
• 13:07
  the tree's branches, umachman and ETSO baguma and you bend
• 13:11
  that down South that the middle of that branch is inside of the
• 13:15
  hole. And then you fill it up with
• 13:16
  with dirt. So now the middle of one of the
• 13:19
  branches is in the ground and then the so one end attaches to
• 13:23
  the tree, the middle of it is in the ground and the other end is,
• 13:27
  is freestanding. And there's freestanding the the
• 13:36
  other end of the branch Vanessa Elan.
• 13:39
  And then that grows into its own tree.
• 13:42
  Kulam Khayavan BA Arlo, all of those things, you know,
• 13:46
  transplanting from the seed. All of that is five in Arlo, but
• 13:50
  but there's a caveat. Gaddafi shafaqa meetsad zam igra
• 13:54
  Elam. The case of the of the havrafa
• 13:57
  where you bent you, you took a branch and you bent it into the
• 14:01
  ground. So that is only when you chopped
• 14:04
  it off the connection from the ground to the original tree.
• 14:09
  OSHA anu yonic menu or it shriveled up and and it's it's
• 14:12
  not getting any sustenance from that tree, from the original
• 14:16
  tree. I will close Mantra Mukhabar,
• 14:19
  but anytime that the branch is still attached to the original
• 14:23
  tree and it's still drawing sustenance from the original
• 14:26
  tree, Bionic me men hush of Cafe Manafa, it's that still counts
• 14:30
  as one of the branches of the original tree and it's the
• 14:33
  original tree already passed Arlo.
• 14:34
  So then the fruits on the free standing side, as long as it's
• 14:38
  still connected to the first tree is not Arlo.
• 14:41
  Once you cut them off, once you disconnect them, then the fruits
• 14:46
  of the freestanding side would be our love.
• 14:50
  Then the officer got all ha anaf shahivrif hivrah from a men who
• 14:54
  owed enough now. Well, let's say if you just do
• 14:56
  this ad infinitum, right? It's still connected to the,
• 14:59
  the, the, the havraha from the first tree grows into a new
• 15:03
  tree. So now that new tree, you take
• 15:05
  one of the one of the branches of that tree and you do have
• 15:08
  raha on that right? And you keep going ad infinitum.
• 15:11
  You keep doing that again and again.
• 15:14
  Shahivrah man old enough hafair bar it's basukane come upon you
• 15:19
  did it again and again. Zafr zah Kohl's Mann sharushin
• 15:23
  mahubala ikar. As long as the first branch is
• 15:26
  still attached to the first tree, le le ikar hai Elam kulan
• 15:31
  peturam, then all of the fruits of all of the of the
• 15:35
  freestanding trees that that are all connected through a branch,
• 15:40
  all of those fruits are Pata from Arla because they're all
• 15:43
  considered fruits of the original tree because they're
• 15:45
  all still connected and it's all still yonic hip sick arisham
• 15:50
  mihikar Elam. If you disconnected that first
• 15:55
  havraha from the first tree high oven, now all of them suddenly
• 16:00
  become Arla. The fruits of all of them come
• 16:02
  become Arla. I don't know the ones that
• 16:04
  already grew, but but from that point on, new fruits that would
• 16:08
  grow from all of those other trees would become Arlo Umasil
• 16:12
  and Luminos, Lahan Misha Shihifsik.
• 16:14
  And you would count the, you would start counting the three
• 16:17
  years from the moment that they got disconnected from that first
• 16:20
  tree, the Icra Pata. Of course, the fruits from the
• 16:23
  first, from the very first tree, those would remain, those would
• 16:26
  remain Pata, those that are growing on the actual stock of
• 16:29
  the first tree. Five years later, yeah.
• 16:32
  Suddenly Darla started five years later.
• 16:34
  Yes, yes, that's exactly what this is saying.
• 16:37
  Even five years later, you have 10 more trees or they're all you
• 16:41
  could you could trace the branch that goes to one tree to the
• 16:44
  other tree all the way back to the original tree.
• 16:46
  Yes, now they all start their Orla.
• 16:48
  Once you you saw that one, that one branch in half the Nekar
• 16:53
  Ekar Mehakaraka Posilios Tofel la anaf Chehibrif.
• 16:59
  If the not only if the, if you disconnected the second tree
• 17:09
  from the first one, then all the ones that after that that they
• 17:11
  become Arlo. But also if you were to uproot
• 17:14
  the first tree, now all of them, they become Arlo then Naka
• 17:17
  Ichamerica Joslias Tofel. But but even more so, they would
• 17:20
  all start their clock. There's start the clock now.
• 17:24
  And even the original tree which you uprooted would also start
• 17:26
  it's clock now again, of course, the Paris that are were on that
• 17:30
  tree at the moment that you did it.
• 17:32
  Those would be mutter. But everything that grows after
• 17:35
  that would now be Arlo closely. It's tough a lot enough.
• 17:38
  Shahebriya Umonen Ben Ikar Ben Anaf Misha Shenekar.
• 17:42
  And you would start counting from when the original tree got
• 17:45
  uprooted. Well, the the all the subsequent
• 17:48
  trees, that tree itself, all of them would the clock would start
• 17:51
  again from when you uprooted the original tree.
• 17:54
  Good sign. I hope that was clear.
• 17:57
  Alphabeisha Minhag hovde Adama la Havre kafana and beholshana.
• 18:02
  Even though there is a custom of people that work vineyards that
• 18:09
  every year they do this havraha kind of thing to grow new, to
• 18:13
  grow new shoots, to grow new vines.
• 18:16
  Muta lustosia and migafne hovde kafen, even though that that is
• 18:20
  what people do. You're allowed to drink wine
• 18:24
  from the vines of the of the guy.
• 18:27
  Mishim de Suffolk are la Motta, because Suffolk is motto.
• 18:31
  Now the Mahaba's talking about in fist Lawrence, but a few of
• 18:34
  the Crownshe Israel Ogdemo, some even in a vineyard where a Jew
• 18:39
  is working there, but it belongs to a guy and that very him owes
• 18:42
  some the whole Shana and the Jew is actually doing the abrafa.
• 18:46
  Or maybe it's it's a caram, even if it's a caram that belongs to
• 18:49
  a Jew. But we're in futz Lauritz and he
• 18:52
  does havraha every year. Motor it's still motor.
• 18:55
  Why mission demagf a market in Haiba Allah Allah.
• 19:00
  Because havraha and and grafting are only 5 in Arla.
• 19:07
  In Arizona, Siserawa Loba, futz Lauritz and futz Lauritz have
• 19:11
  Rafa and grafting are not 5 in Arla the ehslund soheta gamluvne
• 19:17
  eretziszrel. Now, even if this happens in
• 19:20
  Eretziszrel right, every year they they they do this Havraka
• 19:24
  thing. If you have yayin, the yayin
• 19:29
  Shalkarni Havdi Kasavan, if it's if it's one that comes out of a
• 19:33
  caram of a guy in Eretziszrel, you can still enjoy.
• 19:38
  You're still allowed to have enough from that wine.
• 19:41
  Why you shouldn't do rub. But the buffanum love Arlen in
• 19:44
  who because there is still a Suffolk here, because most of
• 19:48
  the first of all, there's a Rove that most of the buffanum are
• 19:53
  not the ones that you did have Rafa.
• 19:55
  Most of the befanem are the original ones that are already
• 19:58
  passed Arla. But I feel a bit crummishy.
• 20:01
  Do a vaade shesh baham Arla. Even in a camera where you know
• 20:05
  that there is Arla in them. They do this Havraha thing Yesh
• 20:08
  bahat serum. You can still be Montier the the
• 20:12
  the wine, the grapes that come out of them.
• 20:14
  Mishum de kadam shayab do al ham sheng Arla enemos in Paris.
• 20:19
  Because the the fruit of our early years are not high
• 20:23
  quality, they're not good fruits.
• 20:25
  And so you're much less likely to get wine from those fruits.
• 20:29
  And so, since we have most of the most of the vines are good
• 20:33
  and we have that, even if this is from a if it's not likely to
• 20:38
  be from one of on top of that, it's not likely to be wine from
• 20:42
  the fruits of one of the ones that they did do of our hope,
• 20:44
  which is Barla, because those fruits typically you can't make
• 20:48
  wine from they're not good enough to do that.
• 20:50
  Then Osam hang Doc in the pollution.
• 20:52
  And if they do that, the the grapes would be thin and and and
• 20:55
  weak in poor quality Sham Rui and Las Mahem Yayin.
• 20:58
  So maybe this last point would only apply to wine.
• 21:01
  It would not apply to grapes, but the, the grapes of, of such
• 21:07
  Havraha vines would not be good enough quality to make wine from
• 21:13
  Yerfes. This one is very practical and
• 21:16
  we're going to probably end with this.
• 21:20
  It's very practical about Arlebus monaze, You, you live in
• 21:23
  Aaron Cesarol. You buy a tree and you plant it.
• 21:26
  Do you have to start the clock all over again?
• 21:30
  So Ilan Schnitzatz, the Hazar, the Godal Mahasharaj a a tree
• 21:36
  that was chopped down and then it was planted again.
• 21:41
  And I'm I'm sorry, no, that's not the case yet because of a
• 21:44
  gobble mash Arash a a tree that was that was chopped down and
• 21:47
  then from the stump a new tree grew out and Ohio, you do not
• 21:53
  have to restart Arlov from the original stump.
• 21:57
  LMK Nixas me al aras. Unless it was cut down till the
• 22:01
  ground it was cut down. It's flush with the ground.
• 22:05
  So then it would you, the clock would start again.
• 22:08
  But if you left something there, if you left some real stump,
• 22:11
  anything that grow a new tree that grows out of that the the
• 22:15
  fruits of that tree that grow that grows out of the stump.
• 22:17
  You do not have to you do not have to tree like Carlo the
• 22:19
  first three years, Omar and LON Meshachusita.
• 22:23
  But if you cut it down literally down to the ground and then a
• 22:27
  new tree grew up, then you would count to three years from when
• 22:31
  you chopped down the original tree travel and Nishamimenu
• 22:34
  Kolshu Pater. But if anything was left, he the
• 22:39
  Mahavir says a Kolshu. The Shah says that the rush
• 22:42
  holds that there's a Tefhoff that that if it's a tefhoff
• 22:45
  above the ground. But if there's anything left of
• 22:48
  the stump, any, any recognizable amount of the stump.
• 22:51
  So then new fruits that grow out of that stump or Pata.
• 22:54
  Now you tested the one I was talking about Ilan Shah Akro
• 22:57
  Ruaf, a tree which was blown down in a tornado oh shark von
• 23:03
  Nohar or it was uprooted in a flood.
• 23:07
  The whole just yesterday there was a a flood in in Asia.
• 23:11
  Then you can see the trees being knocked in oh shark von Nohar,
• 23:15
  the holy kola Mokum afer and then the winds or the flood
• 23:20
  deposited it someplace else. And this is this is key.
• 23:24
  We may have afar Shasvid Sharashov emo now when it was
• 23:30
  uprooted, some dirt was taken together with its roots, the
• 23:35
  host of all of sham afar. But wherever it was deposited,
• 23:39
  there was more dirt there thanish rasham bharats and then
• 23:43
  it took root in that new place. Omdem OSO we make an umdna, we
• 23:49
  evaluate it IM hayafalithios bafar Hari shown if there was
• 23:54
  enough dirt amongst its roots from its first uprooting Sheba
• 24:01
  IMO blotos afar affair where that original dirt without
• 24:06
  counting the addition of the additional earth where it was
• 24:09
  deposited hi Razak and the two of them como upatur meha arlo.
• 24:14
  So if there was enough dirt, then that's considered like it
• 24:17
  was still from its first place because there was enough earth
• 24:21
  taken with it from its first place.
• 24:23
  So then you do not restart the clock then lav if there was not
• 24:27
  enough dirt amongst its roots when it was uprooted and not
• 24:31
  only because of the dirt in the new place that it was deposited,
• 24:34
  it's able to grow. Then high of the clock restarts
• 24:37
  again and you have to count 3 years from when it was
• 24:40
  replanted. This is very practical.
• 24:43
  This monazet when you buy a when you buy a tree from from a from
• 24:50
  a nursery, it comes with enough dirt that it should that it
• 24:55
  should be able to survive. That is not really in question.
• 24:59
  The question is, did it pass over something which considers
• 25:04
  it disconnected from the ground? That's so you will find that
• 25:10
  some posts can say that if you buy something from from the
• 25:14
  nursery and you replant it, you if it was, let's say a year in
• 25:17
  the nursery, you can count that year.
• 25:18
  You only have to do another two years.
• 25:20
  And there are others that say, well, how are you?
• 25:21
  How are you transporting it to your hat, to your home to plant
• 25:24
  it in your garden? If you took it in a car, well,
• 25:27
  then there is, you know, between the, the mat on the floor and
• 25:35
  the metal of the car and the tar of the road, whatever there
• 25:38
  that's considered a Hesse. So that whole time it was
• 25:40
  disconnected from the ground. But the the Icker, the the main
• 25:44
  point that we're learning from this Sif is that there if there
• 25:46
  is enough ground the whole time in the case that we saw on mute
• 25:51
  test where Chakfonar or Akro Haruah there it was amongst, you
• 25:57
  know, natural places where it could have grown the whole time.
• 26:00
  We'll stop here.