Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Practical Asset Protection Planning: Modern Tools That Actually Work
Transcript
- 0:03I am Jennifer McNeil -Ozano, co -chair of the
- 0:06Beverly Hills Bar Association's Trust Net States
- 0:09Law Section. I'm delighted to introduce our speaker,
- 0:13Jacob Stein. Jacob Stein Esquire is the managing
- 0:16partner of Alliant LLP, where he specializes
- 0:20in asset protection, complex US and international
- 0:24tax planning, and structuring cross -border business
- 0:27transactions. Recognized by chambers and partners
- 0:31and consistently honored as an AV rated attorney
- 0:34and super lawyer, he represents high net worth
- 0:37individuals, global families and major corporate
- 0:40leaders while authoring leading publications
- 0:42and lecturing widely to legal and financial professionals.
- 0:47Thank you, Jacob, for being here. Now let's get
- 0:49started. Thank you, Jennifer, for that introduction.
- 0:54Greetings, everyone. I'm excited to see a lot
- 0:57of familiar names on the list of attendees. So
- 1:03greetings to everyone I know personally and to
- 1:06those of you who've taken my courses before.
- 1:10We'll get into the slides in a second. I'm going
- 1:12to start off with a couple of more general topics,
- 1:16more foundational topics that I think would be
- 1:19helpful to you and interesting. And let's start
- 1:22off with what asset protection is all about.
- 1:25When do we help clients with asset protection
- 1:28clients and what circumstances do clients seek
- 1:32asset protection and what is it and what is it
- 1:35not, just as importantly. So asset protection
- 1:41focuses on protecting our clients assets from
- 1:46claims of plaintiffs and creditors. So I'll give
- 1:49you some recent client stories. situations as
- 1:54an illustration of that. Let me think of some
- 1:57quickly here. So we very frequently represent
- 2:00real estate developers who have signed personal
- 2:04guarantees on loans and they're defaulting or
- 2:07will be defaulting on those loans. So before
- 2:10creditors come calling, they would like to protect
- 2:13their personal assets. We represent a lot of
- 2:19defendants in commercial litigation cases. Again,
- 2:22similar, they are expecting that there will be
- 2:25a judgment against them. Sometimes they call
- 2:27us after the judgment has been entered and they're
- 2:31looking to protect their assets. We represent
- 2:36tenants, let's say, who likewise may have signed
- 2:40the personal guarantee or the lease. We represent
- 2:44all sorts of businesses and individuals who are
- 2:47facing any sort of a government audit, government
- 2:52inquiry. Usually these are by the non -taxing
- 2:56agencies or like the FTC, the SEC, maybe the
- 3:00U .S. Attorney's Office is looking at them and
- 3:02the client is worried about civil penalties,
- 3:06fines, forfeitures, restitution, things of that
- 3:09nature. Run -of -the -mill tort cases where we
- 3:15are not tort lawyers but we do protect assets
- 3:19in context of tort claims. So these can be car
- 3:23accidents or what have you, can be malpractice
- 3:25claims against professionals. So I think we can
- 3:31stop there, right? So that's a big ball of wax
- 3:37there, right? To a lot of people, a lot of different
- 3:39circumstances that expose our clients to some
- 3:43sort of a threat, some sort of a financial threat
- 3:46against their assets, and they're looking to
- 3:49protect their assets. So what asset protection
- 3:52planning is, are legal, lawful, obviously strategies
- 3:56of how our clients can own their assets in a
- 4:00way that will be protective, right? That's all
- 4:02it's about. At a foundational level, it's all
- 4:05about how do we own our assets to thwart credit
- 4:10reclaims. What we are not trying to do with asset
- 4:13protection planning is we are not trying to make
- 4:16it impossible for creditors because that is very
- 4:19rarely in the cards. It is very rare that we
- 4:22can say to a client that your asset is not protected
- 4:25in an absolute sense, right? What we're looking
- 4:29to accomplish with asset protection planning
- 4:31is we're looking to make it more difficult, more
- 4:35expensive for a plaintiff to come after our client's
- 4:38assets to change the economics of the case for
- 4:42the plaintiff, maybe introduce a level of uncertainty.
- 4:45often a significant level of certainty into litigation,
- 4:49and force them to settle. Or maybe if we do this
- 4:52early enough, maybe we prevent the plaintiff
- 4:56from bringing the case in the first place, and
- 4:59that's the best possible result. Often, I would
- 5:04think that people associate asset protection
- 5:06planning with the hiding of assets. And hiding
- 5:10of assets can be a form of protection. It's usually
- 5:12not what we do for clients. Because if you are
- 5:16relying on hiding assets, while that may work
- 5:20in some cases, you are leaving yourself vulnerable
- 5:23to something like a debtors examination, right?
- 5:26Where a creditor's lawyer can ask you questions
- 5:29under penalty of perjury. And then if you're
- 5:32simply hiding assets, you are now in a position
- 5:34where you have to perjure yourself for that approach
- 5:37to work. But hiding assets is not a bad thing.
- 5:40Again, if the plaintiff cannot, find your assets,
- 5:44perhaps they will never bring the claim in the
- 5:48first place. Or if there is already litigation
- 5:50and now the assets are again difficult to find,
- 5:54maybe they are more willing to settle. So that's
- 5:58what asset protection planning is and is not.
- 6:01And now we can start getting into the meat of
- 6:05it. And by the way, you do have the Q &A. capability.
- 6:11I am happy to answer questions as we go through
- 6:15these materials. So just type in a question.
- 6:20I'll try to glance at the Q &A box as we go through
- 6:25this and answer questions if you would like or
- 6:28if you'd prefer to save your questions still
- 6:30after we are done. You can ask them at that time
- 6:35as well. Okay, so let's start getting into the
- 6:39into the materials. There is no single right
- 6:44way to protect assets. And if you do see that,
- 6:48and you see some, you know, intranet based service
- 6:52providers selling asset protection services,
- 6:55try to make claims that like, this is the best
- 6:58asset protection structure, like always set up
- 7:00a co -coiling structure. If you see something
- 7:03like that, you should run, there is no one best
- 7:06way to protect assets. What I usually tell my
- 7:08clients is that it is always a trade -off. We
- 7:13are trading off the level of protection on the
- 7:17one hand versus cost and complexity of accomplishing
- 7:20the protection on the other hand, right? So there
- 7:23are probably a couple dozen different structures
- 7:25that are used in asset protection planning. Some
- 7:28are used on a very frequent basis and they're
- 7:30sort of the cornerstone foundational structures
- 7:33of asset protection planning. We'll talk about
- 7:35a couple of them. at this presentation, there
- 7:39are a lot of more esoteric structures that are
- 7:42not used as often, right? But there are, I would
- 7:44say, a couple dozen different structures that
- 7:46we use from time to time. None of them are right,
- 7:49none of them are wrong, right? We kind of have
- 7:51to pick and choose what makes the most sense
- 7:54for the client. And the client has to pick and
- 7:57choose what makes the most sense to them. What
- 7:59is the trade -off between the level of protection
- 8:02that either they need or they feel they need
- 8:07versus the cost and the complexity of setting
- 8:10it up. So in our practice, we go through the
- 8:14spore factor analysis to help us narrow down
- 8:17the choices we are looking at for a particular
- 8:20client, the choices of structures. So we, first
- 8:25of all, look at our client, how risk averse is
- 8:28our client. For example, is the client a real
- 8:30estate developer and he is a risk taker by nature?
- 8:34right then maybe he doesn't want to push or doesn't
- 8:37need to push for such aggressive structures or
- 8:40maybe the client is a doctor and he is risk averse
- 8:43by nature and then he wants to do everything
- 8:45possible to protect his assets as well as can
- 8:48be protected. We look at the timing when the
- 8:54asset protection planning is taking place. Timing
- 8:58in our practice tends to be usually a bit iffy
- 9:02meaning that about I would say 95 % of clients
- 9:05come to us after something bad has happened to
- 9:09them, meaning there is now an existing cause
- 9:11of action against them. They ran over a pedestrian.
- 9:15They defaulted on a bank loan. They're about
- 9:17to default on a bank loan. They were just named
- 9:20in a lawsuit. They just got a letter from the
- 9:23US attorneys. Something bad has already happened
- 9:26to at least put them on notice. Maybe the claim
- 9:30has not yet been filed. but they are already
- 9:33on notice that there is some foreseeability,
- 9:39there's some probability that a claim will be
- 9:41filed against them. So they are acting after
- 9:44the fact in the context of a fraudulent transfer
- 9:47analysis. We'll talk about that in a second.
- 9:51So timing, it is what it is. We can go back in
- 9:54time usually. So if clients come to us and say,
- 9:57hey, I was sued yesterday, right? Those are the
- 10:00circumstances that we are working with. And certainly
- 10:03when we are protecting assets on this last minute,
- 10:06very reactive basis, we need to do a lot more.
- 10:10We need to set up much more robust, more aggressive
- 10:12structures to have the same likelihood of the
- 10:15structures working. Then when we plan ahead of
- 10:18time before something bad has happened, when
- 10:20we can do something really simple. and it still
- 10:24will be highly effective. I'm not addressing,
- 10:29by the way, everything you see on the slides
- 10:31because we just do not have time in a one hour
- 10:34presentation to go through everything in detail.
- 10:38These slides are actually for a full day presentation,
- 10:42for like six hour presentation. So I'm kind of
- 10:45going to pick and choose what we are covering
- 10:47and spending time on. You have received the materials.
- 10:51They're fairly detailed if you've taken a look
- 10:54at them. These are materials they've been developing
- 10:56over the past 20 some years practicing acid protection.
- 11:00So you have all the citations, case law, discussion,
- 11:05my thinking on different topics. So if there's
- 11:08anything specific you are interested in that
- 11:10I'm not covering, it is in the materials. And
- 11:14if you cannot find it anywhere, always reach
- 11:17out to me with questions. You have my email address.
- 11:21I'm always happy to answer questions. I work
- 11:23with a ton of lawyers across LA and supporting
- 11:26their clients with their asset protection needs.
- 11:29And if you just want to run something by me,
- 11:31I'm always happy to help. Identity of creditor,
- 11:35that is hugely important. And by identity, I
- 11:37mean, what kind of a creditor will this be? Is
- 11:41this going to be a creditor that will be aggressive,
- 11:45will aggressively pursue our client? or will
- 11:48this be a creditor that will get a judgment and
- 11:51will just kind of sit on that judgment, right?
- 11:53Then that happens more often than you would think
- 11:55so. Is this a creditor that's knowledgeable about
- 11:58collection laws? Is this a creditor that is personally
- 12:04somehow emotionally motivated to go after our
- 12:07client and his assets? Usually kind of in a more
- 12:11live presentation, I ask people, what do you
- 12:15think is the most difficult credit for us to
- 12:18go up again? Who are we most scared to go up
- 12:22again? And usually the answer to that question
- 12:27is that, well, the IRS probably is the scariest
- 12:30credit out there. And then someone else will
- 12:32say, no, it's the franchise tax board. Yes, and
- 12:35definitely the franchise tax board is much scarier
- 12:37than the IRS. But no, the scariest credit for
- 12:43us to go up again. is a creditor that is not
- 12:47rationally motivated, not commercially motivated,
- 12:50right? So usually this is someone for whom pursuing
- 12:54our client has some sort of an emotional element
- 12:57to it. So perhaps it's a former spouse, perhaps
- 13:00it's a former business partner, right? Someone
- 13:03who's trying to right or wrong and not simply
- 13:06get paid, right? That is a very difficult credit
- 13:09to go up again, because with a creditor like
- 13:12that, It is not enough to make it expensive for
- 13:14them. It is not enough to make it difficult for
- 13:17them. Now we are really trying to push into the
- 13:19impossible category, which as I said is rare.
- 13:25But knowing what kind of a credo we have, how
- 13:27aggressively, how intelligently, how diligently
- 13:31they will pursue our client, certainly plays
- 13:33into the structures we are looking to set up.
- 13:36Finally, the final factor in considering the
- 13:39right structure. What are the specific types
- 13:42of assets that we need to protect? Are we protecting
- 13:48someone's primary residence? We're protecting
- 13:53their residence. Is there an exemption that applies?
- 13:56So that depends on what state they live in and
- 14:00how big that exemption is. California actually
- 14:02has a fairly meaningful Homestead exemption,
- 14:06right? It's 700 ,000 or so. In most counties,
- 14:09inflation adjusts. I don't recall the exact number,
- 14:12but it's about 700 ,000. In some states, the
- 14:15homestead exemption is 35 ,000. It's nothing.
- 14:19In a couple of states, the exemption is not limited
- 14:22by value. It's only limited by the size of the
- 14:24property. So I think it's Texas, Florida, and
- 14:28Kansas have the unlimited by value exemption.
- 14:33There are other types of assets that maybe are
- 14:35exempt, like in some states, annuity policies
- 14:37are exempt, cash value and life insurance is
- 14:41exempt. All types of retirement plans are exempt.
- 14:45And again, in some states, those exemptions are
- 14:48much more limited. So in California, all the
- 14:51other exemptions, annuities, life insurance,
- 14:53retirement plans are very limited compared to
- 14:57the remaining state. So if you have a client
- 15:00who lives in Florida, All of their retirement
- 15:02plans are exempt under Florida law, for sure.
- 15:05Some of them will also be exempt under federal
- 15:08law. Annuity policies will be exempt. Life insurance
- 15:12will be exempt. But in California, those exemptions
- 15:15are very limited. The vast majority of assets
- 15:19that our clients own, that you perhaps own, do
- 15:23not have an exemption that applies to them, right?
- 15:25So for example, if you own income producing real
- 15:28estate, there is no exemption. If you have money
- 15:31sitting in a bank account, a brokerage account,
- 15:33if you have intellectual property and interest
- 15:35in a business, in a professional practice, none
- 15:38of these assets are exempt. And then looking
- 15:41at these different categories of assets, real
- 15:44estate, business, intellectual property, liquid
- 15:48assets, retirement plans, we are looking at different
- 15:52options of how each of these categories of assets
- 15:55can be protected. Okay. Again, reminder, if you
- 16:01do have questions, please go ahead and type them
- 16:03into the Q &A box while I take a sip of coffee.
- 16:10I'm gonna skip actually this slide in the interest
- 16:13of time. Let's very briefly talk about voidable
- 16:17conveyances. So this is the body of law that
- 16:20historically was referred to as fraudulent transfers.
- 16:25That name It was a bit scary. It was misleading
- 16:29and nothing to do with fraud. It was a term of
- 16:31art. So a few years ago, the legislature in California
- 16:34renamed it. And I think nationwide, because it's
- 16:37a uniform act, who renamed it to be known as
- 16:40the Uniform Voidable Conveyances Act. But it
- 16:44is what you used to know as the Uniform Fraudulent
- 16:47Transfers Act. There are two types of avoidable
- 16:50conveyances. One is where you look at what was
- 16:53the intention behind the transfer, like why did
- 16:56the debtor transfer the ownership of his residence
- 16:58into an irrevocable trust? Was it estate planning?
- 17:01Was it estate tax planning, succession planning?
- 17:04Or was it because he just lost the judgment and
- 17:07he was trying to protect that residence, right?
- 17:09So there we look at intent and usually we try
- 17:12to establish intent through circumstantial evidence
- 17:15because debtors will not actually come out and
- 17:18say, this is why I did it, right? They're gonna
- 17:20do the opposite. So no, no, no, no, I didn't
- 17:22do it for asset protection reasons. I did it
- 17:25for a host of other reasons. So courts will look
- 17:28at circumstantial evidence, what are called badges
- 17:31of fraud to try to induce, deduce intent. So
- 17:36they would look at like the timing of the transfer,
- 17:39like, oh, you transferred assets the day after
- 17:42you ran over a troop of Girl Scouts. Perhaps
- 17:45that's in this of intent. You transferred assets
- 17:48to a family member or to an entity that you control.
- 17:52You transferred assets for less than fair market
- 17:54value. You try to hide the transfer of assets.
- 17:57So there are 20, I think, or so badges of fraud
- 18:01that are commonly used in case laws. Of course,
- 18:05we'll look at that to try to infer the intention
- 18:10behind the transfer. And then there is a type
- 18:12of avoidable conveyance that does not look at
- 18:15intent, where we do not care about intention.
- 18:18We're looking purely at the numbers. It's a very
- 18:21objective task. So any transfer that is for less
- 18:24than fair market value that leaves the debtor
- 18:27insolvent is considered avoidable transfer or
- 18:32fraudulent transfer. So we definitely, we're
- 18:37worried about a plaintiff creditor challenging
- 18:40what we're doing as avoidable conveyance. We
- 18:44do want to make sure that at the very least we're
- 18:46engaging in transfers for fair market value.
- 18:49so that we can knock out the constructive fraud
- 18:52test. And that also knocks out the most important
- 18:55batch of fraud after the actual intent test.
- 19:02What state has, sorry, there's a question. What
- 19:04state has the best APT asset protection trial?
- 19:08I don't know. What's APT statute? Does the use
- 19:10of the state law act as a badge? Oh, that's an
- 19:14interesting question. So I guess. The question
- 19:16is, if you are setting up your asset protection
- 19:19structure in a particular state, like let's say
- 19:21instead of setting up a trust for your California
- 19:24client in California, you set up a trust for
- 19:27your California client in Wyoming or South Dakota,
- 19:31can that be a badge of fraud? I don't think I've
- 19:35ever seen that argued, but I can see how that
- 19:39could be argued as a badge of fraud. Like why
- 19:41did you set up a trust in South Dakota? And again,
- 19:44you can come up with all sorts of reasons. Like
- 19:46South Dakota does not have the traditional rule
- 19:49against perpetuities, right? So we're looking
- 19:51to set up a dynasty trust. Cannot do that in
- 19:53California, so we need a jurisdiction that eliminated
- 19:56it. But very interesting question, actually.
- 20:00So one thing, like one final thing I want to
- 20:04say about voidable conveyances. So this is usually
- 20:08the reason. why people argue that you cannot
- 20:11engage in asset protection planning on a last
- 20:14minute basis, right? And usually when I talk
- 20:16to people and they say, well, what do you do
- 20:18if a client calls you and they've already been
- 20:20sued? And I tell them, well, if they've already
- 20:23been sued, that's exactly where you represent
- 20:2595 % of the time. And you can still do something
- 20:28for these people. Yeah, we can still do something
- 20:31for these people. And they're very surprised
- 20:33because like, what about this voidable conveyances
- 20:36act? And how do you get to do last minute planning?
- 20:39So I'm going to tell you an actual story, a real
- 20:42story from one of my clients from a few years
- 20:44ago. It's one of my favorite stories to share.
- 20:47And I think it's very illustrative as a way of
- 20:49answering that question. So a few years ago,
- 20:52I represented a lady who at the time, I think
- 20:57she was in her mid 70s, like 75, 76, and her
- 21:02son. Person at some point decided to become a
- 21:05real estate developer. He had no assets of his
- 21:08own, no track record, no experience. But he went
- 21:12to the bank and borrowed six, seven million,
- 21:16I think, from the bank, if I remember correctly.
- 21:19And his money, my client signed the personal
- 21:22guarantee to cover that loan, to guarantee that
- 21:26loan. He was a real estate developer for a few
- 21:29years. At which point in time, all of his projects
- 21:33were upside down and he just walked away. He
- 21:36had no skin in the game. He had no assets of
- 21:38his own. The bank, the lender never went after
- 21:41him. Then Mami was left there sitting with this
- 21:46personal guarantee in her hand. This personal
- 21:50guarantee with interest and legal fees and this
- 21:53and that. you know, grew to be close to her net
- 21:57worth. Her net worth was just the money she had
- 22:00in the brokerage account. I think it was like
- 22:02around $8 million. And she went to a number of
- 22:05law firms across the country saying, hey, what
- 22:07do I do? I'm going to lose everything that I
- 22:09have. I spent my entire life working really hard.
- 22:12This is the money that I saved. I've done well
- 22:14for myself, but now I'm 75 and I'm going to be
- 22:17left with just the social security check and
- 22:20nothing else. And she went to a few law firms,
- 22:25they've all said, sorry, it sucks what happened
- 22:29to you, but there's nothing we can do to help
- 22:32you because it is too late. There has already
- 22:34been a default on the loan. So let's look at
- 22:38it from her point of view. So from her point
- 22:44of view, she has a binary choice. She can either
- 22:49do what these law firms are recommending, which
- 22:51is nothing. She can choose to do nothing, that's
- 22:54a choice. Or she can choose to do something to
- 22:57protect her assets. And if she chooses to do
- 23:00something to protect her assets, maybe the bank
- 23:03is going to challenge that as avoidable conveyance.
- 23:08Because it's not something that creditors challenge
- 23:10in 100 % of cases. As a matter of fact, in my
- 23:14practice, and we've represented in a couple thousand
- 23:16clients, I want to say. over the past 20 some
- 23:20years practicing as a protection. I've seen creditors
- 23:25bring fraudulent transfer, wearable conveyance
- 23:29challenges less than 10 times. So theoretically
- 23:32it's possible, right? That may happen, but the
- 23:36mathematical statistical likelihood of that happening
- 23:40is very low. And we have a fairly high risk.
- 23:44practice, right? We get referrals from other
- 23:47asset protection attorneys across the country.
- 23:49When they feel it's a high -risk case, they do
- 23:51not want to touch it. They send it to us. So
- 23:54even with our high -risk and also high -profile
- 23:58practice, we see fraudulent transfer challenges
- 24:02just rarely. It's a rare thing. And even if the
- 24:04bank challenges what our client did as a fraudulent
- 24:08transfer, they're not necessarily going to be
- 24:13successful in that. challenge, right? There's
- 24:17some chance that our client will prevail against
- 24:19the Prodigal and Transfer attack. And even if
- 24:22the plaintiff prevails, right, and they establish
- 24:25that what our client did was a Prodigal and Transfer,
- 24:28again, voidable conveyance. I'm still myself
- 24:30getting used to the new terminology. What is
- 24:33the remedy? What happens? Well, the remedy is
- 24:36that the credit gets to reach the transferred
- 24:39asset. Theoretically, in some cases, perhaps
- 24:43there could be punitive damages for a fraudulent
- 24:45transfer. But if someone is going to lose everything
- 24:48that they have, that's sort of a meaningless
- 24:50remedy, right? They're already going to lose
- 24:52everything that they have. So thinking of this
- 24:55from a client's point of view and that binary
- 24:58choice they have, do nothing or do something,
- 25:00if she chooses to do nothing, there is a 100
- 25:03% chance that she's going to lose it all. And
- 25:06if she chooses to do something, there is now
- 25:09some chance. that she gets to keep some or all
- 25:14of her assets. I think it was Wayne Gretzky who
- 25:17used to say that 100 % of the shots you do not
- 25:21take do not go in. And I think that's been applied
- 25:25in a lot of sports now, that metaphor. And it's
- 25:29true here, right? 100 % of the shots you do not
- 25:32take do not go in. So if she doesn't try to protect
- 25:36her assets, her odds of success are zero. So
- 25:40while we do always try to anticipate avoidable
- 25:43convenience challenge, we try to plan around
- 25:46it. We try to minimize our own risk exposure,
- 25:49right? And certainly there will be some cases
- 25:51that we will not take. From a client's point
- 25:55of view, often this is not something that should
- 25:59give them a lot of pause. You consider it, you
- 26:02plan around it, and you move forward. Okay, a
- 26:06couple of questions that came up. What about
- 26:08people who have not been sued, but there is a
- 26:11high risk, like a very elderly driver or other
- 26:15risk condition? Yeah, so that if you do have,
- 26:23it's called a future crudder. So for the purposes
- 26:27of avoidable conveyances now, there are different
- 26:31types of crudders. present creditors so that
- 26:34someone has a cause of action against against
- 26:36you currently at the time of the transfer. There
- 26:38is a future creditor. Future creditors someone
- 26:40who doesn't have a cause of action against you
- 26:42today. But today when you're engaging in the
- 26:45transfer of assets, it is reasonably foreseeable
- 26:48that someone will have a cause of action against
- 26:50you tomorrow. And it could be a very elderly
- 26:53driver. It can be someone who is let's say like
- 26:56a plastic surgeon and he gets sued on a very
- 26:58frequent basis. So maybe that patient is not
- 27:02the plaintiff today, but it's reasonably foreseeable
- 27:05that any patient will be a creditor in the future.
- 27:09So, and it is what it is. As I said, like you
- 27:12plan around it, try to make your transfers stand
- 27:16up to avoidable conveyance attacks, but you know,
- 27:20the facts are what they are. And we don't, we
- 27:25do not allow that to stop us from planning and
- 27:28protecting. If the next question if a defense
- 27:34lawyer takes a deed of trust and the UCC won
- 27:38on everything to cover defense fees and causes
- 27:41the lower than the target to The answer is no
- 27:44because that's a fair market value transaction
- 27:47its arms length So the lawyer in that case should
- 27:51be fine. It's perfectly perfectly okay to Seek
- 27:56secure remedies right and security the obligations
- 27:59that are owed to you Do you have your client
- 28:04sign a waiver of the possibility of the claim
- 28:07of claiming of fraudulent transfer? We do not.
- 28:12I don't know if that would work. I don't know
- 28:16if anyone has ever done that. I don't know how
- 28:18a court would look at it, how the state bar would
- 28:20look at it. It may be something that would be
- 28:24somewhat valuable to have. I guess there is no
- 28:27harm. to have it. I'm going to ponder now that
- 28:32you asked this question, if it would make sense.
- 28:36Maybe I should ask my favorite AI what it thinks
- 28:38about it. It's not a bad idea, right? The more
- 28:42we can have clients wave in our favor, the better,
- 28:46if they're willing to do that. But I don't know
- 28:49how well that would work. OK, let's get into
- 28:53our first planning structure. planning for a
- 28:58married couple in California right will limit
- 29:00this to California for now well to really any
- 29:03community property state so in a community property
- 29:06state from an asset protection standpoint there
- 29:09is this big downside and the big downside in
- 29:12a community property state is that any property
- 29:16acquired during marriage is presumed to be a
- 29:19community property asset and if it's a community
- 29:21property asset it is deemed to be owned 100 percent
- 29:26by either spouse. So if we are representing a
- 29:32married couple, and let's say only one of them
- 29:34is likely to be sued. One of them is in a higher
- 29:37risk occupation and a higher risk profession,
- 29:39and the other one is not. So even if only one
- 29:42of them will be sued, all of the community property
- 29:45assets are exposed to that lawsuit, right? Because
- 29:47that one spouse is deemed to own all of the community
- 29:51property assets. So this is just kind of a good
- 29:54reminder for everyone. community property is
- 29:56divided 50 -50, it is owned 100 -100, right?
- 30:00That's a co -extensive sort of overlapping ownership
- 30:03interest. And because a creditor by default can
- 30:05go after any asset that you own, because you
- 30:08own all of the community property assets, it's
- 30:11all reachable. So in a community property state
- 30:16like California, One of the first structures
- 30:19we will discuss with the client is a transmutation
- 30:23agreement. The transmutation agreement is an
- 30:27agreement where spouses agree to transmute to
- 30:31change the character of the assets that they
- 30:34own. So they can go from community property assets
- 30:37to separate property and from separate property
- 30:40to community. So in an asset protection context,
- 30:43we're going to take their community property
- 30:45assets, the co -owned assets, And we're going
- 30:47to split them up into two separate bundles, sort
- 30:50of his and her separate property. We want the
- 30:54split of the assets to be equal by value for
- 30:58a few reasons that I am not going to get into
- 31:01just for lack of time. And then we're going to
- 31:04cherry pick what assets go to which spouse. So
- 31:08if, for example, we are worried that let's say
- 31:11the husband is the one in the high risk occupation.
- 31:14He is still going to get half of the assets by
- 31:17value, but we are going to give to the husband
- 31:20either those assets that are easier to protect.
- 31:24So for example, he's going to get liquid assets
- 31:26as opposed to real estate. Real estate is very
- 31:28difficult to protect. Liquid assets are much
- 31:31easier to protect. Or we will give to the husband
- 31:34those assets that are not so desirable to creditor,
- 31:38maybe assets that are exempt from creditor claims
- 31:40under state law. like interest in certain types
- 31:43of retirement plan, right? So for a married couple,
- 31:49this is a bit of a gimme. In most cases, we do
- 31:53need to remind our clients that once they enter
- 31:55into this agreement, it is binding for all purposes.
- 31:59If tomorrow they, you know, pile for divorce,
- 32:02the assets already have been split. But from
- 32:06an asset protection standpoint, half of the assets
- 32:08at least is moved to the other spouse, and perhaps
- 32:12more so because we are cherry picking who is
- 32:15going to get what type of an ad. So this is something
- 32:19we do quite frequently, a transmutation agreement.
- 32:24Legal entities are fairly frequently used to
- 32:27protect assets. Legal entities are not going
- 32:30to get us a super high level of protection, but
- 32:33it's infinitely better than just holding ownership
- 32:36of assets. just in your name. So for example,
- 32:39let's say that my client owns an apartment building
- 32:42in his name. My client is driving down the street
- 32:45and he runs over a troop of Girl Scouts. There
- 32:48are thin mint cookies all over the place. He
- 32:50gets hit with a huge lawsuit. There's now a judgment
- 32:54entered against my client individually. He owns
- 32:58the real estate individually. The plaintiff can
- 33:00go after that real estate, right? Propose in
- 33:02it and take it from my client. But if my client
- 33:05takes that same real estate, transfers the ownership
- 33:08of that real estate into a limited liability
- 33:11company, he no longer owns the real estate, he
- 33:15now owns a membership interest in an LLC, and
- 33:18a membership interest in an LLC is not subject
- 33:21to attachment by the creditor. There are a lot
- 33:24of nuances here, distinctions between single
- 33:27-member LLC versus multi -member LLC, the plaintiff's
- 33:31ability to and the appetite to pierce the corporate
- 33:34veil of an LLC. But generally speaking, holding
- 33:40ownership of assets through an entity like a
- 33:42limited liability company, even a limited partnership,
- 33:45maybe even sometimes a general partnership is
- 33:48preferable to holding ownership of assets directly.
- 33:51Because when you own assets through these partnership
- 33:54type entities, your interest in the entity is
- 33:59not subject to uh attachment um sorry another
- 34:05question came in does the spouse approach i presume
- 34:08the transmutation agreement per estate planning
- 34:12tax why assume a larger state um so perhaps yeah
- 34:19so uh if it's a larger state and we want to make
- 34:23sure that all of the assets receive a basis step
- 34:26up uh when one spouse passes Well, if they no
- 34:31longer have community property, then the spouse
- 34:34who was the first to die no longer owns all of
- 34:36the assets. So only the decedent assets get the
- 34:40basis step up and the survivor separate property
- 34:43will not get a basis step up. So what we'll do
- 34:46from that standpoint with transmutation agreements
- 34:48is we will transmute assets when there is a credit
- 34:52threat. And once our clients feel that that's
- 34:55sort of in the past and they will never get sued
- 34:58again. which is what everyone believes, right?
- 35:01Once they do away with that initial loss, we
- 35:05can transmute back to community property and
- 35:08regain the full basis step up. Okay, good question.
- 35:13So using LLCs to protect assets, it's low hanging
- 35:19fruit. It's easy to do. It's inexpensive, minimal
- 35:23tax consequences. And we do get some level of
- 35:26asset protection, but it is not as high as some
- 35:30other options that are coming up, which would
- 35:34be planning using a trust. And I want to specifically
- 35:38kind of maybe rush a little bit. I hope I'm not
- 35:42rushing too much, and you guys can follow along,
- 35:44because I wanted to leave a lot of time to talk
- 35:46about trust. First of all, you are, from what
- 35:49I understand, primarily trust lawyers, since
- 35:51this is an estate planning group. And I'm sure
- 35:57you deal a lot with trusts. So for you, perhaps
- 36:01this may be a greater interest than some of the
- 36:03other structures. So we use trusts a lot in asset
- 36:08protection planning. I would say that trusts
- 36:11are really kind of the cornerstone of most asset
- 36:14protection planning. So what kind of a trust?
- 36:20Well, I'm not gonna bore you guys with what a
- 36:23trust is. That's perhaps more appropriate for
- 36:25other audiences and you guys understand what
- 36:27it is. So let's talk about what is a good asset
- 36:31protection trust. So first of all, we want a
- 36:36trust that is irrevocable. If we're dealing with
- 36:39a trust that is irrevocable, traditionally, historically,
- 36:45that kind of a trust has no asset protection.
- 36:48That has changed recently. I will talk about
- 36:51it in a second. We actually fairly recently figured
- 36:55out a way how to have an asset protection trust
- 37:00that is irrevocable. And I think it's fairly
- 37:03revolutionary and maybe interesting to you. But
- 37:07traditionally, historically, all asset protection
- 37:11trusts have been irrevocable. And certainly at
- 37:13the time of the creditor, sort of going after
- 37:16the assets, it should always be irrevocable.
- 37:20So, irrevocable, let me kind of spend a couple
- 37:23of minutes on this because different people have
- 37:26different understanding what irrevocable means.
- 37:29I think most of us, even if you are, let's say
- 37:32an experienced estate planner, just because you
- 37:34are so used to seeing it a certain way, you think
- 37:37of an irrevocable trust that is, let's say globally
- 37:40irrevocable, right? And it's globally irrevocable,
- 37:43meaning that What makes a trust irrevocable is
- 37:46a sentence in the trust agreement that says,
- 37:49this trust is irrevocable. And often it is followed
- 37:53by other clauses like, and it cannot be amended,
- 37:56and it cannot be terminated. From an asset protection
- 38:00standpoint, we just need the trust to be deemed
- 38:03irrevocable under state law. For a trust to be
- 38:06deemed irrevocable under state law, only one
- 38:09narrow fact has to be true, which is, the Lord
- 38:13of the trust cannot have the power to revoke
- 38:16the transfer of the assets to the trust. The
- 38:18Lord of the trust cannot have the power to get
- 38:21his assets back. So it has nothing to do with
- 38:25the ability to terminate the trust. It has nothing
- 38:28to do with the ability to amend the trust. And
- 38:30it has nothing to do with the general ability
- 38:33to revoke a trust. The distinction is, if you
- 38:37haven't noticed, the distinction is that the
- 38:40state law for the trust to be deemed irrevocable
- 38:43requires that the settlor cannot have the power
- 38:45to get his assets back, which is not the same
- 38:49as saying that this power cannot exist. The settlor
- 38:52cannot have this power. So the way we draft our
- 38:55irrevocable trust is kind of much more narrowly.
- 38:59And instead of saying, no, you know, this trust
- 39:01is irrevocable, which means no one can revoke
- 39:05it. Like even Donald Trump cannot revoke it,
- 39:08right? we will be much more narrow and we will
- 39:10say the set law of the trust does not have the
- 39:13power to revoke it. Because if that is what we
- 39:15say, it leaves us room to appoint someone to
- 39:19hold the power to revoke the trust. Okay, a couple
- 39:24of questions. Let me pause to answer them. If
- 39:27a client has various rental properties in a revocable
- 39:32trust, is it better to transfer them to an LLC
- 39:38to protect them from potential litigation? And
- 39:40the answer is yes. Usually income producing real
- 39:43estate, we like to hold it in an LLC because
- 39:46this way it's easy for the client to retain access
- 39:48to the cash flow. And then the LLC itself should
- 39:51go into the living trust. Next question, how
- 39:56much control do I have if I use an irrevocable
- 39:59trust and I still sell assets? I'll get to that
- 40:02in one second. Give me a second to get there.
- 40:05Okay. So first thing is this again notion that
- 40:09irrevocable does not need to necessarily be this
- 40:12traditional language for making a trust irrevocable.
- 40:15I do strongly encourage all of you who draft
- 40:17trust to look into this distinction because I
- 40:20think it is quite valuable. So what we do with
- 40:23our irrevocable trust again we narrow this sentence
- 40:27to say the settler has not retained the power
- 40:29to revoke and then we will appoint the trust
- 40:32protector for the trust and the trust protector
- 40:36will hold all sorts of powers over the trust.
- 40:39The power to revoke it, meaning and return the
- 40:42assets to the settlor, the power to terminate
- 40:45the trust, meaning accelerate distribution to
- 40:47the beneficiaries, power to amend the trust in
- 40:51a wholesale fashion, power to change the trustee
- 40:54of the trust, perhaps power to change the beneficiaries
- 40:57of the trust, power to change the governing law
- 41:00of the trust, and maybe a couple other powers.
- 41:03And we can give the trust protector one or two
- 41:05of these powers. We can give the trust protector
- 41:07all of these powers. And usually for, I would
- 41:10say 99 % of our clients, it's all of these powers
- 41:13because the trust protector is how our clients
- 41:16retain indirect control over the trust. Because
- 41:20our client retains the ability to remove and
- 41:22replace the protector. And the protector then
- 41:25has all of these powers over the trust. So our
- 41:27client then feels comfortable. that if they need
- 41:30something done, they can ask the protector to
- 41:32do it. If the protector says, I'm not going to
- 41:34do it, they will fire that protector and appoint
- 41:38someone else as the new protector of the trust.
- 41:43So we want a trust that's irrevocable. We want
- 41:46strong trust protector powers. Obviously, you
- 41:52want to spend the provision on the trust, but
- 41:54I think every trust should have that. And then
- 41:58we want the trust to be discretionary, but let's
- 42:01spend a minute discussing that. So if you look
- 42:08at case law on asset protection from a trust,
- 42:13the most protective type of a trust is a trust
- 42:16that is irrevocable, spendthrift, and fully discretionary.
- 42:20right? Because if you have a trust that is irrevocable,
- 42:23spendthrift and fully discretionary, and let's
- 42:26say you are a beneficiary of the trust, you have
- 42:29no property interest in the trust. No property
- 42:31rights, no property interest in the trust. What
- 42:34you have is a mere expectancy, because the trustee
- 42:37has complete discretion when it comes to making
- 42:39distributions, and the trustee may choose not
- 42:42to distribute anything to you. So when we are
- 42:44protecting beneficiaries in a trust, we want
- 42:47to give the trustee as much discretion as possible.
- 42:51Some clients do not like that. They want to have
- 42:54some certainty for distributions. They want to
- 42:58make sure that their beneficiary is going to
- 43:01get the periodic distributions, specific distributions.
- 43:05So how do we balance that? So what I do in my
- 43:08trust is if I do have to include mandatory distributions,
- 43:14I will then override them. in the event of a
- 43:17creditor collection action, right? So I will
- 43:19say that the trustee will make quarterly distributions
- 43:22of income to this beneficiary, but if this beneficiary
- 43:26is being threatened by a creditor, obviously
- 43:29it's drafted a bit more eloquently and much more
- 43:32detailed, what would that mean? Then we force
- 43:36the trustee to stop making those distributions
- 43:39and either distributions become discretionary
- 43:43while there is a pending creditor action, or
- 43:47distributions are prohibited entirely while there
- 43:51is a creditor action. And then once that goes
- 43:55away, then mandatory distributions can resume.
- 44:00So I said, let's come back to that in a second.
- 44:04Okay, I said that historically, every single
- 44:08asset production draws has always been an irrevocable
- 44:11trust. And that is because under state law, like
- 44:14in California and the probate code, there is
- 44:16a provision that states that creditors are allowed
- 44:19to go after assets that are titled in a trust
- 44:22that is irrevocable. And that's true across every
- 44:25state in the US. And that's all derived from
- 44:29the English common law. So it's fairly uniform.
- 44:32So for the past 25 years of practicing asset
- 44:36protection, we would always set up an irrevocable
- 44:40trust for a client if we are using a trust. And
- 44:44by the way, what kind of irrevocable trust does
- 44:47not matter at all, so long as it meets these
- 44:49three requirements. I don't care if it's an IJIT,
- 44:52or if it's a GRAT, or it has some fancy marketing
- 44:55name attached to it, you know, the Bridge Trust,
- 44:58the Fortress Trust, the whatever trust, so long
- 45:01as it's irrevocable, spendthrift and discretionary,
- 45:04it's a good asset protection trust. Names are
- 45:07irrelevant. A few months ago, six months ago,
- 45:11I think, we realized that we actually can use
- 45:18a trust that is irrevocable for asset protection.
- 45:23For me personally, it was a fairly revolutionary
- 45:26realization because sort of attended decades
- 45:31of how I was practicing asset protection law.
- 45:34So we've developed what is known as the intelligent
- 45:38wealth trust. And I'm sure some of you have already
- 45:41seen it out there. So the intelligent wealth
- 45:43trust, sort of the key term is intelligent. It
- 45:48is intelligent because it's a trust that automatically
- 45:51adapts to circumstances and becomes the type
- 45:54of trust you need it to be. So we start off with
- 46:00a living trust, meaning a trust that's revocable
- 46:03like your standard living trust. And then the
- 46:07trust provides that, okay, the trust is irrevocable.
- 46:10Fine, operates like any irrevocable trust would.
- 46:12But if there is a creditor threat against the
- 46:16settler of the trust, then this trust either
- 46:18automatically or on an action by the trust protector
- 46:22converts into an irrevocable trust. It is not
- 46:26something that's done by the settler. And because
- 46:29the settler is not the one doing it, it cannot
- 46:32be avoidable contains by the settler. right,
- 46:34it's an automatic transfer that is taking place
- 46:36that was sort of preordained when the trust was
- 46:40drafted. So the trust converts from revocable
- 46:42to irrevocable. And then, so that's phase two.
- 46:48And then there is even phase three, phase three,
- 46:51losing the ability to speak, phase three of this
- 46:54intelligent trust. And phase three is that the
- 46:56trust protector can act to convert this irrevocable
- 47:02trust from a U .S.-based irrevocable trust to
- 47:05an offshore -based irrevocable trust. Once the
- 47:08crater threat is gone, the trust protector can
- 47:11migrate the trust back to phase one, back to
- 47:14being irrevocable. And I think that's kind of
- 47:16the really unique part of this. So, you know,
- 47:20we've all seen irrevocable trust become irrevocable,
- 47:22right? Anytime the sothors of the living trust
- 47:26pass, the trust becomes irrevocable. So that's
- 47:28new. We've seen domestic trust become offshore
- 47:32trust, that's often referred to as a trigger
- 47:36trust, right? On an activation of a trigger,
- 47:39the governing law of the trust changes from domestic
- 47:42to foreign, and the domestic trustee is removed
- 47:45and replaced with a foreign trustee. So we've
- 47:47seen that. So what we've done in the intelligent
- 47:49walled trust is we sort of combine these elements
- 47:52together. We've given the trust protector very
- 47:54expanded powers to trigger the transitions. The
- 47:58transitions are very, very detailed. how they
- 48:01work, when they can be triggered, when are they
- 48:02automatic versus manual, and how it goes back
- 48:06and forth. We usually draft these trusts to be
- 48:10completely ignored for tax purposes, meaning
- 48:14that this is an incomplete transfer for gift
- 48:16and estate tax purposes, usually by having this
- 48:20authority and veto power, and obviously grant
- 48:23or income tax purposes. Okay, so that's been
- 48:28sort of the huge news in our practice area, this
- 48:32evolution, development of the Intelligent Wealth
- 48:35Trust. And it really comes from the fact that
- 48:37so many clients, like what originated this, are
- 48:41you guys, the state planning lawyers, because
- 48:43so many clients over the years would come to
- 48:46us and we would have a conversation with them
- 48:48about how we should transfer their assets to
- 48:51an irrevocable trust. And we would say, You know,
- 48:56this is the kind of trust that protects you.
- 48:58And they would say, oh, thank God I already have
- 49:00a trust. And we'd say, no, no, you have a trust
- 49:03that's revocable. It doesn't protect you. And
- 49:06their response usually is, well, why did my estate
- 49:08planning lawyer set up a trust that's revocable,
- 49:12as opposed to setting up a trust that's irrevocable?
- 49:15The irrevocable trust also avoids probate, and
- 49:17you can do the same estate tax planning within
- 49:19the irrevocable trust. And it also would have
- 49:21protected my assets from claims of predators.
- 49:24Why did they not do this? And we got in this
- 49:26whole discussion of like, you know, this is what
- 49:29a state planning lawyers do. It's the inertia
- 49:31of their practice. This is what they've been
- 49:33trained to do. Perhaps they're not always comfortable
- 49:35with creating irrevocable trust. You didn't ask
- 49:38them about asset protection, right? So don't
- 49:40blame them on this, for this. And it led us to
- 49:44think like, well, okay, if the client is setting
- 49:45up a trust that's irrevocable, there is no threat
- 49:48of litigation today. Why not set up a trust that's
- 49:52irrevocable, but that's can automatically convert
- 49:54into a new revocable trust when the circumstances
- 49:57require it. Okay, let me answer questions because
- 50:04there's a lot of questions that came in. When
- 50:08creating an LLC for an income producing property,
- 50:11do you make the revocable trust the member of
- 50:13the LLC? Yes, you always want to make sure everything
- 50:16is in some form of a trust. So either the revocable
- 50:20trust can be the member of the LLC or if you
- 50:23want a higher level of protection in a replicable
- 50:25trust on all other pieces of the LOC. Do you
- 50:30as an advisor ever become the protector? Do any
- 50:32lawyers do this? Yeah, I don't. I don't act as
- 50:36a protector, but I do know some lawyers who do.
- 50:39I know some accountants who do. They're professional
- 50:41trust protectors, but most clients will use a
- 50:45friend or a family member as the protector of
- 50:49the trust. Joe and Jane are dating, okay? They
- 50:56buy a house as tenants in common, then they get
- 50:58married. Does Jane's interest in the house remain
- 51:01separate property? The answer is yes. What happens
- 51:05to the California property taxes for real property
- 51:08in the applicable trust if the trust is revoked
- 51:11first in California and the real property returned
- 51:13to the south floor? So for property tax purposes,
- 51:21If the trust is irrevocable, then we have to
- 51:24look at who is the beneficiary of the trust,
- 51:27who is the support of the trust. If they're not
- 51:29the same, you can have a property tax reassessment,
- 51:32but that can be its own presentation. So forgive
- 51:36me for not getting into it any deeper than that.
- 51:43What drafting system do you recommend for drafting
- 51:46an LLC operating agreement? I don't know. spent
- 51:5020 years developing my operating agreement, so
- 51:53I didn't use any, you know, drafting system other
- 51:58than what I already have in place. So I can't
- 52:01answer that. You can use Claude or Gemini or
- 52:03whatever AI you use. They nowadays do a fairly
- 52:06good job of it. Are tax IDs and tax returns required
- 52:13for irrevocable trust? So No, not really. We
- 52:19do get tax ideas for irrevocable trust, but purely
- 52:22for banking reasons, just to make it more difficult
- 52:25for a plaintiff or a credit or private investigator
- 52:28to find the bank account of the trust if they're
- 52:31searching, let's say, under a client social security
- 52:33number. Technically, you do not need to get a
- 52:36separate tax ID because this is often structured
- 52:39as a grant or trust. And because it is a grant
- 52:42or trust, the tax agencies really don't see it.
- 52:45They don't care about it. everything continues
- 52:47to flow through to our client's personal return.
- 52:54Transfers to trust, the revocable and the revocable
- 52:56are still subject to avoidable conveyances laws,
- 52:58aren't they? Yes, they are. Any type of a transfer
- 53:02is subject to the avoidable conveyances law.
- 53:05And for avoidable conveyances, the term transfer
- 53:07is insanely broad. It is defined as any action
- 53:11that the debtor takes. that makes it more difficult
- 53:13for a creditor to collect or reduces the value
- 53:16of the debtor's assets to the creditor. So like
- 53:19amending an LLC agreement can be deemed the transfer
- 53:22of assets. Okay, so we can answer this one. Larry.
- 53:33Okay, Larry may has a question on downloading
- 53:35materials. So that's not for me. That's for the
- 53:38Beverly Hills Bar Association. Okay. In the time
- 53:45we have left, which is limited. Time just flies
- 53:49so quickly when you guys ask good questions,
- 53:52which I appreciate. Thank you. Let's talk a little
- 53:54bit about offshore structures. So we can set
- 53:58up a trust in the United States. We can set it
- 54:01up in California, which is where we set up most
- 54:03of our irrevocable trust, because most of our
- 54:05clients are in California and have California
- 54:07assets. And setting up a trust in South Dakota,
- 54:10let's say, is not going to... from a creditors
- 54:12standpoint does not add a lot of extra value
- 54:14because creditors, third party creditors are
- 54:17not bound by the choice of law we designate in
- 54:20the trust agreement. But with the foreign trust,
- 54:24it's a little different, right? With the foreign
- 54:25trust, the ownership of the asset is now outside
- 54:30the United States. And then eventually the asset
- 54:33can be moved outside the United States. And that's
- 54:35really what offshore planning is all about. Offshore
- 54:39planning is about making sure that a US judge
- 54:43has no jurisdiction over the owner of the assets
- 54:46and over the asset itself. So we do not use offshore
- 54:50structures for illiquid assets. I, for example,
- 54:52I would not use an offshore structure for real
- 54:55estate because it doesn't matter what you do
- 54:58with the real estate. Local judge will always
- 55:00have jurisdiction over it. And if he decides
- 55:02he wants to ignore what you've done, he can do
- 55:04so, right? He can just sign a judicial deed and
- 55:08transfer the real estate to the plaintiff. If
- 55:12the trustee of the trust is in the United States,
- 55:15if the protector of the trust in the United States,
- 55:17again, you haven't done much because the U .S.
- 55:19court will have jurisdiction over those persons,
- 55:22can force them to take an action that's beneficial
- 55:24to a predator. So we want everything to be truly
- 55:29offshore. And this is really probably one of
- 55:31those few structures where we can tell a client
- 55:34their asset is really pretty much as unreachable
- 55:37as it gets. you know, short of going to Home
- 55:39Depot to get a shovel and then burying assets
- 55:42in the Mojave Desert, right, which could be very
- 55:45effective. Moving assets offshore is probably
- 55:48the only way we have that pretty much makes assets
- 55:51unreachable because once again the asset itself
- 55:54physically is outside the United States and in
- 55:58the hands of a foreign trust, foreign LLC, foreign
- 56:02asset management foundation, it is pretty much
- 56:06unreachable by a US creditor. And in the 25 years
- 56:10I've been doing this, I think I have seen creditors
- 56:13go after offshore structures like three times,
- 56:16maybe three, four times, all involving either,
- 56:19I think, one case with the FTC, one with the
- 56:23SEC, and two US attorneys actions. It is just
- 56:28extremely rare to see. plaintiff's creditors
- 56:31pursue assets overseas first. So for clients,
- 56:34one, that really high level of protection, first
- 56:36of all, they need to convert their wealth into
- 56:38liquid form. And then we move this liquid form
- 56:41overseas. Or it needs to be the kind of asset
- 56:45that can be moved overseas. So for example, recently
- 56:48we transferred a giant art collection, like physically
- 56:51transferred it to the Geneva Free Port. So again,
- 56:55the asset physically is outside of the jurisdiction
- 56:58of the US judge. So we have questions on California
- 57:04property taxes and reassessment. I'm assuming
- 57:09that putting an income property currently held
- 57:11in an owner's individual name into an LLC is
- 57:14going to trigger Prop 13 reassessment. Usually
- 57:16no, not if the individual who owned the real
- 57:19estate continues to own the LLC. There is no
- 57:22reassessment. Okay. Let me do, you know what,
- 57:30let me do one more thing super quickly. I know
- 57:33we're running short on time and then if you guys
- 57:35have more questions, I'm happy to stay on longer
- 57:38and answer questions. So retirement plans and
- 57:41primarily because there's a lot of confusion
- 57:43on retirement plans. So there is some fairly
- 57:46robust protections, exemptions for retirement
- 57:49plans under federal law under ERISA. So ERISA
- 57:53protects assets in an ERISA qualified retirement
- 57:56plan. So these are your 401k plans, defined benefit
- 58:00plans, profit sharing plans, and ERISA anti -alienation
- 58:04clause protection applies only if there is at
- 58:08least one non -owner employee with money in the
- 58:11plan. So if you have that, if you're a participant
- 58:16in a 401k plan and you're not the only participant,
- 58:19right, some employees are in the plan, then under
- 58:21federal law, There is an absolute bar on credit
- 58:25claims against that plan, with the exception
- 58:29of spouses, but we're not gonna get into that.
- 58:31And then if you have a plan that's not an ERISA
- 58:34-qualified plan, which is an IRA, right? The
- 58:36IRA is sort of the most widespread plan out there.
- 58:40IRAs, and when I say IRA, I mean any type of
- 58:43an IRA, any type of a self -employed plan. So
- 58:46KIO, Roth, and solo 401k, like all of these self
- 58:53-employed type plans, ERISA does not apply. So
- 58:56now we look to state law. Now it depends on what
- 58:59state you're in. So again, most states, let's
- 59:01say New York, Florida, Texas, unlimited exemption
- 59:05for any type of retirement plan. Not so in California.
- 59:09In California, the courts will look to see whether
- 59:15you need the money in the plan. to cover your
- 59:18retirement needs. It's a subjective test that
- 59:21California courts use for retirement plans and
- 59:25they will look at the age of the plan participant.
- 59:28They will look at other assets available to the
- 59:30plan participant to determine whether the assets
- 59:33in the plan are necessary for retirement needs.
- 59:38There's a lot of case law on this in California.
- 59:41This is a standard that historically has always
- 59:43been applied favorably as to creditors. So chances
- 59:46are if you are listening to this presentation,
- 59:49your IRA is not exempt, right? Because you have
- 59:52good income, you have other assets. So the courts
- 59:55will say you do not need the money in the IRA
- 59:57to provide for your retirement needs because
- 59:59you can re -accumulate the retirement or you
- 1:00:03have other assets to cover retirement needs.
- 1:00:06So if you do have clients being sued, worried
- 1:00:08about being sued, then perhaps they should consider
- 1:00:11converting their IRAs. into 401k plans or something
- 1:00:15similar. Okay, I know that I rushed through this
- 1:00:21a little bit. Again, there's only so much I can
- 1:00:24cover in one hour and I need to pick and choose.
- 1:00:28The materials do have like a wealth of other
- 1:00:30information on lots of other topics and the topics
- 1:00:33we've covered but like much deeper. I'm happy
- 1:00:37to answer questions that you guys did not get
- 1:00:41a chance to ask. Either right now, if you'd like
- 1:00:44to type them in, or if you would like to send
- 1:00:47me an email, there's my email address on the
- 1:00:49slide. You can just Google me. I get a lot of
- 1:00:53questions throughout the week from folks who've
- 1:00:55taken my courses over the years. I'm always happy
- 1:00:58to answer them. I really appreciate you guys
- 1:01:01listening to this presentation. I am Jacob Stein.
- 1:01:04I am a practicing asset protection attorney.
- 1:01:08If I can help you or your client, I will be happy
- 1:01:11to do so. See you next time. This concludes today's
- 1:01:16presentation. Thank you so much, Jacob, for your
- 1:01:18time and sharing your program today. And thank
- 1:01:21you so much to our audience. Have a great day
- 1:01:23everybody.