Latest / Deep Dive / Why Your Customers Lie to You: The Startup Mistake That Kills Great Ideas
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine you just you just spent your life savings and like 3
- 0:05entire years of your life building a product.
- 0:08Oh man, the absolute worst nightmare.
- 0:10Right. You poured your blood, sweat and
- 0:12tears into it. You miss birthdays, you didn't
- 0:15see your friends. You literally ate ramen noodles
- 0:17for 1000 days straight. Just grinding away in total
- 0:21isolation. Exactly.
- 0:22And you did it because every single person you spoke to, your
- 0:25family, your friends, industry experts, they all said your idea
- 0:28was absolutely brilliant. They loved it.
- 0:30They couldn't wait to buy it. Yeah, so launch day finally
- 0:34arrives. You put it out into the world.
- 0:36You're sitting there, you know, refreshing your screen, waiting
- 0:38for the sales to roll in and nothing.
- 0:42Zero sales, Just crickets. Crickets.
- 0:45Why does it happen? Well, it happens because human
- 0:48nature practically compels people to lie to us.
- 0:51Welcome to the deep dive. It's great to be here.
- 0:53This is such a fascinating topic.
- 0:55It really is. Our mission today is to explore
- 0:59this fundamental human puzzle. Like how do you discover what
- 1:03people actually value and what they actually want when they are
- 1:06basically socially conditioned to deceive you to your face?
- 1:10I mean, it is arguably the most important question anyone trying
- 1:13to build something can ask. It's the rock upon which so many
- 1:17businesses, internal projects, and honestly, even relationships
- 1:21just completely shatter. Because we all know we need the
- 1:23truth to succeed, right? Right, but we are uniquely,
- 1:27almost comically, terrible at extracting it from other human
- 1:30beings. We really are.
- 1:31And to crack this case, we have two completely different sources
- 1:35on the desk today. I mean, structurally,
- 1:37philosophically, geographically, they seem like they shouldn't
- 1:39even be in the same. Room.
- 1:40Yeah, they are wildly different. 1st, we have this gritty, highly
- 1:44practical battle scarred handbook for entrepreneurs
- 1:47called The Mom Test by Rob Fitzpatrick.
- 1:49It is St. level, tactical and just brutally honest about the
- 1:53mistakes founders make every single day.
- 1:55And then, on the exact opposite end of the spectrum, we have
- 1:58this dense, fiery, highly theoretical academic defense of
- 2:04a macroeconomic marketing theory.
- 2:06It's quite the contrast. It really is.
- 2:08It's a paper from the European Journal of Marketing called
- 2:11Service Dominant Logic, a Necessary step by Robert Lush
- 2:15and Stephen Vargo. And it's abstract.
- 2:17It is steeped in academic history and it operates at like
- 2:22the 30,000 foot, a macroeconomic view of how value is generated
- 2:26globally. We're basically looking at the
- 2:28difference between a street detective interviewing A
- 2:30terrified witness in a dark alley and a sociologist studying
- 2:34citywide crime patterns from a university tower.
- 2:36That's a great analogy. We need both perspectives.
- 2:38We really do. And if you're listening to this
- 2:40right now, whether you are starting a tech company,
- 2:42pitching a new workflow process to your stubborn boss, or maybe
- 2:45just trying to figure out why a product your marketing team
- 2:47launched totally flatlined, these sources hold the key.
- 2:50Absolutely. We are going to connect the
- 2:52street level interrogation tactics from Fitzpatrick
- 2:55directly into the grand academic theory of economic value from
- 2:59Lush and Vargo. Because the detective gives you
- 3:01the immediate conversational tactics to bypass human
- 3:06deception in the moment. Yes, exactly.
- 3:09But the sociologist gives you the overarching structural
- 3:12theory to understand why that truth is the only thing that
- 3:16actually creates value. So I think we have to start down
- 3:18in the mud with the detective work.
- 3:20Let's do it, Fitzpatrick points out right away in the Mom Test
- 3:23that the price of getting this wrong isn't just, you know, a
- 3:27minor set back. It is utterly devastating.
- 3:29Devastating is the exact right word because we all know the
- 3:32golden role of modern business, right?
- 3:34Talk to your customers. It's written on every whiteboard
- 3:36in Silicon Valley. It's basically a cliche at this
- 3:39point, but Fitzpatrick argues that the vast majority of us are
- 3:42doing it in a way that actually generates negative value.
- 3:45Right, we are gathering actively harmful data.
- 3:48And he learned this the hardest way imaginable with his first
- 3:51startup, this advertising technology company called Habit.
- 3:55The story of Habit really grounds everything we're going
- 3:58to talk about today. It really sets the stakes.
- 4:01Oh completely. Fitzpatrick and his Co founders
- 4:03didn't just casually mess around with a side hustle.
- 4:06They spent three full years working on this social
- 4:08advertising technology. Three years, that is so much.
- 4:11Time and they burned through almost all of their investor
- 4:14capital. They literally relocated their
- 4:17lives internationally just to be physically closer to their
- 4:21presumed target market. Wow, talk about being committed.
- 4:25The stress was so high, they even survived one of their
- 4:27cofounders facing deportation issues.
- 4:29I cannot even fathom the emotional toll of that moving
- 4:33across borders, dealing with immigration crises.
- 4:36The sheer volume of stress and sunk cost is astronomical.
- 4:40And the tragic irony is that Fitzpatrick was actually doing
- 4:42what every business book told him to do.
- 4:45He wasn't hiding in a basement, you know.
- 4:46Right. He was out there talking to
- 4:48customers full time for months on end.
- 4:50Having endless meetings, showing off his ideas, getting feedback.
- 4:53But at the end of that three-year slog, with a
- 4:56thoroughly exhausted team and a bank account approaching 0, he
- 5:00realized a horrifying truth, which was The startup failed not
- 5:04because he didn't talk to people, but because the way he
- 5:07talked to them actively encouraged them to give him
- 5:11false positives. False positives.
- 5:13That's the killer. Believing with all your heart
- 5:16that people want what you are building when they actually
- 5:18don't care at all. It's brutal, yeah.
- 5:20And he uses this incredibly vivid analogy in the text that I
- 5:25think perfectly illustrates the danger here.
- 5:27Oh, the archaeological big site. Yes, he compares the process of
- 5:31learning from customer conversations to excavating a
- 5:35highly delicate ancient archaeological site.
- 5:38It's such a beautiful framing because the truth about what a
- 5:41customer actually wants, the underlying pain point they're
- 5:44willing to pay to solve, is buried deep underground.
- 5:47Right, it exists, but it's a fragile artifact.
- 5:50If you expose it to the wrong elements, it just crumbles.
- 5:52And he says most of us walk onto this delicate site driving a
- 5:55massive bulldozer and carrying a creative dynamite.
- 5:58Which is just the worst possible approach.
- 6:00We use these incredibly heavy-handed blunt force
- 6:03questions. We walk up to someone and say
- 6:05hey, do you think my business is a good idea?
- 6:06And boom, we just detonate the dynamite.
- 6:09The artifact is instantly shattered into a million pieces.
- 6:12Yeah, by asking such a direct ego driven question we
- 6:17essentially put a gun to their head and force them to say
- 6:20something nice to us. The actual truth is destroyed in
- 6:24the blast radius of our own need for validation.
- 6:27But then you know you have the inverse problem too.
- 6:30Other founders, maybe the more introverted or anxious ones,
- 6:33walk into the dirt with a tiny soft bristle toothbrush.
- 6:36They're terrified of breaking the artifact.
- 6:38Or worse, they're terrified of finding out that there is
- 6:40absolutely nothing buried in the dirt at all, so they just
- 6:44lightly dust around the edges of the conversation.
- 6:46They make small talk. Exactly.
- 6:48They flinch away from digging deep and asking the scary,
- 6:51probing questions that might invalidate their entire life's
- 6:54work. OK, wait.
- 6:55I have to push back on this fundamental premise before we go
- 6:57any further. Sure, go for it.
- 6:58The bulldozer approach assumes that when we ask a direct
- 7:01question, people will lie to us. Are people really out there
- 7:06maliciously lying to entrepreneurs?
- 7:07Maliciously, no. Like, is there some conspiracy
- 7:11to bankrupt startup founders, or is it more like, you know what?
- 7:15A friend asks does this shirt make me look weird?
- 7:17And you just say no, you look great because you want to
- 7:21preserve the relationship and get out of the room alive.
- 7:23Yes, that's exactly it. It is entirely 100% politeness.
- 7:29And that is exactly what makes it so incredibly dangerous.
- 7:32Because you can't tell they're lying.
- 7:33Right. If it were malicious deception,
- 7:35you could spot it. You can see the villainy in
- 7:37their eyes. But it's not.
- 7:39It is a well-intentioned, warm hearted fib.
- 7:42It is social lubrication. Fitzpatrick calls this the
- 7:46pathos problem. The pathos problem break that
- 7:48down for me. What does he mean by that?
- 7:50The pathos problem is the psychological wall that goes up
- 7:53the exact millisecond you expose your ego to the person you were
- 7:56talking to. Humans are deeply social
- 7:58creatures, right? We're wired for empathy.
- 8:01We generally don't want to hurt each other.
- 8:03Exactly. So if you walk up to a
- 8:05colleague, a friend or even a stranger at a networking event
- 8:09and say I just quit my stable corporate job, I remortgaged my
- 8:13house and I'm working on this top secret new software, what do
- 8:16you think of my idea? You have just handed them your
- 8:20beating heart. Oh man, you have made yourself
- 8:23wildly vulnerable. So their social conditioning
- 8:26completely overrides their analytical brain.
- 8:29The moment you expose your ego, they feel a crushing social
- 8:32obligation to protect your feelings.
- 8:34They're going to pull their punches.
- 8:35Yeah. Your mom will lie to you because
- 8:37she loves you unconditionally and wants you to be happy.
- 8:40Your friends will lie to you because they want to be
- 8:42supportive cheerleaders. And strangers.
- 8:44Strangers will lie to you because it is incredibly
- 8:46socially awkward to look a proud creator in the eye and tell them
- 8:49their baby is ugly. Or frankly, they will lie just
- 8:53to get you to stop talking so they can go back to eating their
- 8:55lunch. Just to escape the awkwardness.
- 8:57OK, If we accept this premise that human nature dictates
- 9:00people will politely deceive us to protect our feelings or to
- 9:03protect their own time, then all traditional market research is
- 9:07basically broken. Pretty much, yeah.
- 9:09How on earth do we bypass this? If we can't ask people if our
- 9:13idea is good, how do we know if we should build it?
- 9:15We need a system to cut through this polite deception.
- 9:19And that brings us to the core thesis of the book, the rules of
- 9:22the Mom Test. The rules are brilliantly
- 9:25simple, but they are completely counterintuitive to how we
- 9:29naturally converse, aren't they? Highly counterintuitive.
- 9:31Yeah. The foundational premise is that
- 9:33you must never, ever ask anyone if your business is a good idea.
- 9:37You have to craft your conversations so carefully that
- 9:40even your own mother, the person who loves you most in the world,
- 9:43cannot lie to you. Let's lay out the three golden
- 9:46rules of the MOM test right now. OK rule #1 talk about their life
- 9:50instead of your idea. Rule #2 Ask about specifics in
- 9:53the past instead of generics or opinions about the future.
- 9:56And rule #3 talk less and listen more.
- 9:59Simple to say, really hard to do.
- 10:02To really grasp how transformative these rules are,
- 10:05we need to dive deep into the iPad cookbook example from the
- 10:08text. Oh, this is a master class in
- 10:10conversational design. Yeah, it perfectly illustrates A
- 10:13dichotomy between failing the test and passing the test.
- 10:16Let's walk through the failing scenario first, because this is
- 10:19what 99% of people do, right? So picture a young guy.
- 10:22He goes over to his mom's house. He has this burning idea for a
- 10:26business a premium digital cookbook app designed
- 10:29specifically for the iPad. OK, I'm picturing it.
- 10:32In the failing scenario, he sits down at the kitchen table and
- 10:34starts by saying, Mom, I have an idea for a business, can I run
- 10:37it by you? Strike one, the bulldozer just
- 10:40rolled onto the site. He has explicitly exposed his
- 10:44ego. The pathos problem is fully
- 10:46activated. The mom's maternal instincts
- 10:48kick in. Exactly.
- 10:50She is now on high alert to protect her son's dreams.
- 10:53Then he starts leading the witness.
- 10:54He says, you like your new iPad, right?
- 10:56You use it a lot. She smiles and says yes.
- 10:59Then he drops the hammer. Would you ever buy an app which
- 11:02was like a cookbook for your iPad?
- 11:04Now what does she do? She pauses, looks a little
- 11:07unsure, and goes. Let's pause right there.
- 11:09That is a massive red flag. It is a lukewarm, non committal
- 11:14signal. Internally, she doesn't want it.
- 11:17But the Sun is entirely deaf to that signal, right?
- 11:19Completely deaf, he ignores the hesitation and immediately
- 11:23pushes forward into sales mode. He starts pitching hard.
- 11:25It only cost $40, which is cheaper than buying hardcover
- 11:28cookbooks. He starts listing features.
- 11:30You can share recipes with friends.
- 11:32It automatically generates a grocery shopping list.
- 11:35It even has high definition videos of that celebrity chef
- 11:38she likes. He is practically begging her
- 11:41for validation. And finally, under the weight of
- 11:43all that pressure, the mom caves.
- 11:45She smiles warmly and says, Oh well, yes, honey, that sounds
- 11:48amazing, and $40 is a very good deal for all of that.
- 11:52Will it have pictures of the recipes?
- 11:54This is where the tragedy occurs.
- 11:56The sun leaves that kitchen feeling on top of the world.
- 12:00He takes that conversation as absolute, undeniable market
- 12:03validation. He thinks he nailed it.
- 12:05He thinks to himself, My mom represents the target
- 12:08demographic perfectly. She loves the concept.
- 12:11She verbally agreed the price point was fair.
- 12:14She even gave me a feature request about adding pictures.
- 12:18So he quits his day job, he hires a developer, and he sinks
- 12:21his life savings into building this app.
- 12:23But what actually happened at that kitchen table?
- 12:26What actually happened was a master class in polite
- 12:28deception. The mom just rationalized the
- 12:32price point entirely outside of a real world purchasing.
- 12:35Concept. Yes, she was never going to buy.
- 12:36It never She gave a noncommittal compliment to boost his
- 12:39confidence, and she offered a completely fake feature request
- 12:43asking for pictures just to appear engaged in the
- 12:46conversation. And then, as Fitzpatrick points
- 12:49out, she probably offered him a plate of lasagna because she's
- 12:51secretly terrified he's going to starve to death pursuing this
- 12:54ridiculous venture. It is heartbreaking, yeah,
- 12:56because the son thought he was doing the right thing.
- 12:58He read the blogs. He talked to a potential
- 13:00customer, but his methodology guaranteed failure.
- 13:04So let's rewind time. Let's look at the passing
- 13:06scenario. Same son, same mom, same kitchen
- 13:09table, same iPad cookbook idea. But this time he operates under
- 13:14the rules of the Mom test. How does he open the
- 13:18conversation? He completely cloaks his idea.
- 13:21He hides his ego entirely, applying rule #1 talk about
- 13:25their life instead of your idea. He sits down and casually says,
- 13:28Hey mom, how's that new iPad treating you?
- 13:31Which is just a normal question. She says she loves it.
- 13:33Then he asks, what do you usually do on it?
- 13:35Now Fitzpatrick flags this specific moment, asking what she
- 13:38usually does is a trap. It violates rule #2.
- 13:41Because it's too generic. Exactly.
- 13:43Asking about generic habitual behavior leads to generic fluffy
- 13:48answers. When you ask people what they
- 13:50usually do, they give you an idealized version of their
- 13:53routine. So the mom replies that the
- 13:54generic fluff. Oh yeah, I read the news.
- 13:56I play a little Sudoku, the usual stuff.
- 13:57That doesn't help him, so the Sun quickly pivots and applies
- 14:00rule #2 correctly ask about specifics in the past.
- 14:03He narrows the focus and asks. What's the absolute last thing
- 14:06you did on it today? And suddenly the dynamic shifts,
- 14:10we get real hard data. She stopped generalizing and
- 14:14recalls a specific event. She says.
- 14:15Oh, actually this morning I was looking up places to stay for
- 14:18our trip to London. So he learns she uses it for
- 14:21utility and planning, not just mindless games.
- 14:24Then he asks, did you use an app for that?
- 14:26And she says no, I just used Google.
- 14:28I didn't even know there was a specific app for that.
- 14:30What's it called? This is where the gold dust
- 14:31starts accumulating. Yeah, by anchoring her in a past
- 14:35action, he discovers a business saving fact.
- 14:39His own mother, his primary target demographic, does not
- 14:42know how to navigate the App Store.
- 14:44She realized entirely on Google search.
- 14:46If he had blindly built his cookbook app and just dumped it
- 14:49onto the Apple App Store, his target market would literally
- 14:52never be able to find it. In 2 minutes.
- 14:55He just saved his hypothetical business from a catastrophic
- 14:58marketing and distribution failure.
- 14:59OK, here's where the conversation gets incredibly
- 15:02deft. He needs to pivot the topic to
- 15:04cooking, but he still cannot mention his app idea.
- 15:07Right. It takes discipline.
- 15:08So he looks over at the kitchen counter, points to a stack of
- 15:11brand new glossy hardcover cookbook and asks where they
- 15:15came from. She rolls her eyes and says here
- 15:17were Christmas gifts from relatives and she hasn't even
- 15:20cracked the spine on a single one.
- 15:22She says as if I need another lasagna recipe at my age.
- 15:26I've been cooking for 40 years. An incredible insight.
- 15:29He just learned that older experienced home cooks do not
- 15:34value generic recipes. They already have the basics
- 15:37memorized. If he builds an app full of
- 15:39generic spaghetti and chicken recipes, she will never ever
- 15:43open it, let alone pay $40.00 for it.
- 15:45He instantly realizes that maybe younger, inexperienced cooks in
- 15:48their 20s are a much better target demographic for a generic
- 15:53recipe platform. But he doesn't stop there.
- 15:55He pushes one layer deeper. He asks, well, what is the last
- 15:58cookbook you did buy for yourself with your own money?
- 16:01Again, specific action in the past.
- 16:03She thinks for a second and says, actually, I bought a
- 16:05highly specific niche vegan cookbook about three months ago.
- 16:09Your father's trying to get his cholesterol down, and he
- 16:12complained that my healthy meals didn't have enough zazz.
- 16:15Boom, another massive revelation.
- 16:18Experienced chefs will open their wallets to buy recipes,
- 16:21but only to solve a highly specific, novel problem that
- 16:25they haven't encountered before. Like pivoting to a niche vegan
- 16:28diet for health reasons. So in one short casual
- 16:31conversation, without ever once uttering the words I have an
- 16:34idea for an app, he extracted 3 vital pieces of intelligence.
- 16:38One, older demographics won't buy generic recipes, 2 younger
- 16:43cooks might be a better market for basics.
- 16:45And three, the App Store is a useless distribution channel for
- 16:49seniors. That is the sheer power of the
- 16:51MOM test. It's.
- 16:52Brilliant. But let me stop and process this
- 16:54because it sounds incredibly difficult to pull off in the
- 16:57real world. It reminds me of the golden rule
- 16:59for lawyers in a tense courtroom cross examination.
- 17:02Never ask a question to which you do not already know the
- 17:05answer. Yes, except here the dynamic is
- 17:07slightly twisted. You are desperately trying to
- 17:10discover the answer, but you are forbidden from leading the
- 17:13witness. You cannot put words in their
- 17:14mouth. It's a delicate balance.
- 17:16But honestly, if I'm an entrepreneur or a product
- 17:19manager, my idea is literally the only thing I care about.
- 17:24It is burning a hole in my brain.
- 17:26How do you maintain a conversation for 20 minutes
- 17:28without talking about the one thing you actually showed up to
- 17:31talk about? It requires an unbelievable
- 17:33amount of conversational discipline.
- 17:35Yeah, you have to suppress your ego entirely.
- 17:38You have to stop acting like a salesperson pitching a product
- 17:41and start acting like an investigative journalist
- 17:44uncovering the mundane workflow of their daily life.
- 17:47And I imagine you're going to face some hazards along the way.
- 17:49Inevitably, to do that successfully, you have to learn
- 17:52how to navigate the psychological hazards that will
- 17:55pop up in these conversations. Because here is the tricky part.
- 17:58Even if you strictly follow the rules and never mention your
- 18:01idea, people will still try to throw bad data at you just to be
- 18:05polite. Which brings us to the defense
- 18:06of maneuvers. Fitzpatrick categorizes this bad
- 18:09data into 3 distinct buckets that we have to learn to
- 18:11recognize and deflect in real time.
- 18:14Compliments, fluff and ideas. Let's start with compliments.
- 18:19He is brutal about this. He says compliments are shiny,
- 18:22distracting and entirely worthless.
- 18:25They are the fool's gold of customer discovery.
- 18:28They look incredibly valuable to an insecure founder, but they
- 18:32have zero actual purchasing power.
- 18:34Like when someone says wow solving that is a great idea, I
- 18:37love it. Exactly, you have learned
- 18:40absolutely nothing about whether they will open their wallet and
- 18:43hand you a credit card. People use compliments as a
- 18:46polite stalling tactic. It's a way to gracefully end a
- 18:49meeting. So taking that back to the team
- 18:52is a disaster. The absolute worst thing you can
- 18:55do is take that compliment back to your engineering team and
- 18:57say, guys, the meeting went great, they loved it.
- 19:00Keep building you who are literally marching your startup
- 19:03over a Cliff with a smile on your face.
- 19:05So what is the tactical move? If you're listening to this and
- 19:07someone in a meeting says that sounds incredible, what do you
- 19:10do? You deflect it.
- 19:12You treat it like a distraction. You ignore it completely and
- 19:15steer the conversation immediately back to hard facts.
- 19:18You smile, say thanks, and then ask.
- 19:21But let me ask you, how are you currently dealing with this
- 19:24problem right now? You brush the compliment aside
- 19:26and force them to prove that the problem is actually painful
- 19:29enough to warrant action. Precisely.
- 19:31OK, the second bucket of bad data is fluff.
- 19:35This is the stuff that sounds like data but isn't.
- 19:38It includes generic claims like I usually do this or
- 19:42hypothetical maybes like I might try that, and worst of all
- 19:46future tense promises. Fitzpatrick identifies one
- 19:49specific phrase that he considers the single most deadly
- 19:52piece of fluff an entrepreneur can ever hear.
- 19:54What is it the deadliest phrase in business is?
- 19:57I would definitely buy that. But it sounds so good if someone
- 20:00says they will definitely buy. By it, it feels like you can
- 20:02take that to the bank. It sounds incredibly concrete,
- 20:06but it is almost always an over optimistic lie.
- 20:10Humans are wildly, irrationally optimistic about the kind of
- 20:13people they will become in the future.
- 20:15Oh, like a New Year's resolution.
- 20:17Yes, when someone says I would definitely buy that productivity
- 20:21app, they are imagining a future version of themselves.
- 20:25A future self who wakes up at 5:00 AM, goes for a run, has
- 20:28plenty of disposable income, and has the mental energy to learn a
- 20:32new software tool. But when that future actually
- 20:35arrives, they're going to be just as tired, just as broke,
- 20:38and just as lazy as they are today.
- 20:40Anything involving the future is a hypothetical fantasy.
- 20:43So how do you defeat the fantasy of fluff?
- 20:46You drop an anchor into the past if someone says.
- 20:49I would definitely buy a tool to fix this workflow problem you
- 20:53immediately counter with. Interesting.
- 20:55When is the exact last time this problem happened to you and?
- 20:58What if they say it was a few months ago?
- 21:00Then you ask, can you talk me through the steps you took to
- 21:03try and fix it? And here is the kicker, if they
- 21:06reply with well I didn't really try to fix it, I just sort of
- 21:09lived with it, then you know with absolute certainty they are
- 21:13lying about buying your product. Because they never tried to
- 21:15solve it. Exactly, If they haven't
- 21:17actively spent time or money looking for a solution in the
- 21:21past, they are not going to magically buy your solution in
- 21:24the future. That is such a crucial litmus
- 21:26test. What else have you tried?
- 21:28If the answer is nothing, you do not have a customer.
- 21:31You have someone with a mild annoyance, not a burning pain
- 21:33point, right? OK.
- 21:35The third bucket of bad data is ideas, specifically when a
- 21:40customer gives you a feature request.
- 21:42And this is where Fitzpatrick shares another painfully vivid
- 21:46story from his Habits startup days.
- 21:48Let's talk about the MTV story. This is a classic devastating
- 21:52trap that almost every B to B founder falls into.
- 21:55Habit was trying to sell their social advertising technology to
- 21:58a massive, prestigious client, MTV.
- 22:01MTV Total Whale. They finally get a meeting.
- 22:04MTV looks at the tech and says this is interesting, but we
- 22:07can't use it unless you build this custom analytics and
- 22:09reporting tools. I can see where this is going.
- 22:11So Fitzpatrick, eager to land a whale of a client, takes this
- 22:15feature request as absolute gospel.
- 22:18He takes his engineering team and they spend months, literal
- 22:21months of runway building this incredibly beautiful, deeply
- 22:24complex self-serve analytics dashboard where NTV executives
- 22:28could log in and slice and dice their campaign data however they
- 22:31wanted. And then he finally presents
- 22:32this masterpiece of engineering to them, and they oh and ah over
- 22:36how pretty the graphs are. Exactly.
- 22:38But they don't actually log in. They don't use it.
- 22:40Instead, every single Friday afternoon, an MTV Rep calls
- 22:45Fitzpatrick up on the phone and ask him to just e-mail the the
- 22:48spreadsheet of the week's stats. You're kidding after building a
- 22:51custom dashboard, but. Trying to be accommodating,
- 22:54Fitzpatrick goes back to the engineers and has them build a
- 22:56CSV export feature into the dashboard.
- 22:59Then MTV says, actually our clients don't like spreadsheets.
- 23:02Can you make it a PDF? So he spends more time building
- 23:05a PDF export feature. And still they just call him
- 23:07every Friday and ask him to generate the PDF and e-mail it
- 23:10to him. Finally, the MTV Rep asked if
- 23:13you can add Mt VS corporate logo and custom color hex codes to
- 23:16the PDF. At this point, the frustration
- 23:19must have been unbearable. He's acting like an exasperated
- 23:23parent on Christmas morning. You weren't even playing with
- 23:26the incredibly expensive toy I built for you.
- 23:28Why do you care what color the wrapping paper is?
- 23:31Right. And out of pure boiling
- 23:34frustration, he accidentally asks the one question he should
- 23:37have asked on day one. He asked the Rep why do you even
- 23:41want this logo feature? What do branded reports get you
- 23:45that unbranded ones don't? You guys don't even log in to
- 23:48read the data. And what do they say?
- 23:50The MTV Rep casually responds. Oh, we don't care about the data
- 23:53analysis. Our clients just like getting an
- 23:55e-mail at the end of the week, so they feel in the loop, and we
- 23:57think they'd be happier if the report looked a bit fancier,
- 23:59more professional. Wow, it had absolutely nothing
- 24:03to do with data analytics. Nothing at all.
- 24:05MTV didn't want to analyze data, They just wanted a prop to look
- 24:09prestigious to their clients. If Fitzpatrick had paused on day
- 24:13one, ignored the feature request for an analytics dashboard and
- 24:17dug into the motivation behind the request, he would have saved
- 24:20months of engineering time. He could have just had an unpaid
- 24:23intern manually copy paste some numbers into a branded PDF
- 24:27template in Photoshop every Friday and MTV would have been
- 24:31ecstatic. He wasted three months of his
- 24:33life because he blindly obeyed a feature request instead of
- 24:37investigating the underlying need.
- 24:39OK, I have to jump in here because if you're a listener who
- 24:42has a feature request sitting in your inbox right now from your
- 24:44biggest client, this advice feels completely
- 24:47counterintuitive. If MTV, a multi $1,000,000
- 24:51corporation, looks you in the eye and says build an analytics
- 24:54dashboard, it feels incredibly arrogant to say no, you don't
- 24:58actually want that. Are we saying the customer is
- 25:00always wrong about what they want?
- 25:02It's a nuanced but vital distinction.
- 25:04The rule of thumb here is that customers absolutely own the
- 25:07problem, but you, the creator, own the solution.
- 25:11Customers are incredibly accurate at knowing what causes
- 25:13them pain, but they're generally terrible at designing the
- 25:16optimal technical solution to fix it.
- 25:18So when a customer comes to you and asks for a specific feature
- 25:21like, can you make this sync to Excel?
- 25:23You have to realize that is just their amateur attempt at solving
- 25:27A workflow bottleneck. Your job is to ignore the word
- 25:31Excel completely instead you asked.
- 25:34Interesting. What would syncing to Excel
- 25:37actually let you do? How are you currently coping
- 25:40without it? You have to dig beneath the
- 25:42specific feature request to excavate the root motivation.
- 25:46So the customer isn't wrong about their pain, they just
- 25:49don't know the right medicine to prescribe themselves.
- 25:51Exactly. But to even get to that
- 25:53prescription stage, you have to make sure you are solving a
- 25:55problem they actually care about in the 1st place.
- 25:57You have to ensure they are even sick, which requires us to
- 26:01navigate what Fitzpatrick calls the premature Zoom and face the
- 26:05terrifying elephant in the room. The premature Zoom is a
- 26:08conversational pitfall that generates massive amounts of
- 26:11false validation. It happens when you assume a
- 26:14specific problem is a top priority for someone, and you
- 26:17force the entire conversation to focus exclusively on that
- 26:20problem. Let's use the gym app example
- 26:22from the text because it's a perfect illustration of how
- 26:25easily we can trick ourselves. Let's role play this out.
- 26:28I'll be the eager entrepreneur. You be the potential customer.
- 26:31We're getting coffee. Hey, thanks for meeting me.
- 26:33I'm doing some research on fitness apps.
- 26:35Tell me, how often do you go to the gym?
- 26:38Honestly, not really ever. OK, got it.
- 26:42But what would you say your biggest problem with going to
- 26:45the gym is? Hmm, I guess probably the time
- 26:50it takes to commute there. I have a pretty busy schedule so
- 26:53driving back and forth is a hassle.
- 26:55Perfect, so if I built an app that let you work out
- 26:58conveniently at home with 0 commute, would you use?
- 27:01It sure. Yeah, that sounds great.
- 27:02I'd love to try it. OK, end scene.
- 27:04The entrepreneur walks out of that coffee shop pumping their
- 27:06fist, thinking, yes, I successfully validated the
- 27:10commute problem and they verbally confirmed they'd use my
- 27:13home workout app. What actually just happened in
- 27:16that psychological exchange? You completely and utterly led
- 27:19the Witness. You forced me into a tiny
- 27:21conversational box. You made me talk about the gym
- 27:24even after I explicitly told you I'd never go.
- 27:26I just wouldn't let it go. Right when you pushed me to name
- 27:29my biggest problem with the gym, my brain just invented a
- 27:33plausible sounding problem to satisfy your question.
- 27:36I threw out commute time as a logical guess, but the harsh
- 27:40reality is I don't care about fitness at all.
- 27:43So even if I build it perfectly. Even if you spend a year
- 27:46building a beautifully designed homework ad app that completely
- 27:50eliminates the commute, I am still never going to download it
- 27:54because fitness is simply not a priority in my life hierarchy.
- 27:58You zoomed in on a micro problem before taking the time to
- 28:01validate that the macro problem actually mattered to me.
- 28:04So to avoid the premature Zoom, you have to start the
- 28:07conversation incredibly broad. You have to ask things like what
- 28:11are your big goals for this quarter or what's taking up most
- 28:14of your mental energy right now? Let them lead you to the
- 28:17problem. Right.
- 28:18If they mentioned they are trying to fix their roof, get a
- 28:20promotion and save for a wedding, but they never once
- 28:23mentioned improving their health, you know immediately
- 28:26they were not your customer. You don't zoom in in until they
- 28:29lead you there. Exactly.
- 28:30You let them reveal their priorities organically, and that
- 28:33leads directly into confronting the elephant in the room.
- 28:36The elephant is the single biggest, most terrifying risk
- 28:40your business faces. The question you are so scared
- 28:43to ask because the answer might destroy your entire premise.
- 28:46Fitzpatrick divides these existential risks into two
- 28:50distinct categories, right market risk and product risk.
- 28:53Yes. Market risk is the fundamental
- 28:55question. Do they actually want it and
- 28:58will they actually pay for it? Product risk is the technical
- 29:01question. Can I actually build it and can
- 29:03I scale it? As a founder, you have to
- 29:06ruthlessly identify which of these two risks is your actual
- 29:09elephant. He gives 2 great contrasting
- 29:12examples in the text. First, let's look at the Farm
- 29:14Animal Fertility Tracker. Oh, this is a great one.
- 29:17A hardware engineer wants to build a digital tracker for
- 29:20dairy cows to boost birth rates. He goes out and asks dairy
- 29:23farmers if I could give you a cheaper, highly effective
- 29:26tracker that guaranteed a 10% increase in calves, would you
- 29:29use it? The farmers all say absolutely.
- 29:32If you can actually build that, I'll buy it for my entire herd
- 29:34tomorrow. Right.
- 29:36In that scenario, there is absolutely 0 market risk.
- 29:40It is a proven, undeniable fact that dairy farmers want more
- 29:44calves because calves equal money.
- 29:46The market is begging for a solution.
- 29:48So the elephant is entirely product risk.
- 29:51Exactly. Can this guy actually invent,
- 29:53manufacture and distribute a highly complex, durable, cheap
- 29:57bovine fertility tracker that survives being attached to a cow
- 30:01in the mud? Talking to farmers in coffee
- 30:03shops will never solve that risk.
- 30:05He has to stop talking and start prototyping.
- 30:07And the counterexample is the entrepreneur who wants to build
- 30:10digital teaching tools for underfunded inner City Schools.
- 30:13The entrepreneur talks to the teachers, and the teachers
- 30:16absolutely love the idea. They are crying out for it.
- 30:18They desperately need the tools to save time and help their
- 30:21struggling students. So there is almost 0 product
- 30:23risk here. Building basic educational
- 30:25software is a solved technical problem.
- 30:28What is the elephant? The elephant is massive market
- 30:30risk, specifically budget risk. The teachers passionately want
- 30:34the product, but the teachers are not the economic buyers.
- 30:37The poor, underfunded school districts literally do not have
- 30:40the budget to pay for it. Wow, so he could validate all
- 30:43day and still fail? The entrepreneur could spend 18
- 30:46months validating the teachers emotional pain, completely
- 30:50ignoring the elephant in the room that the entity required to
- 30:53write the check has empty pockets.
- 30:55I have to say, this entire philosophy sounds absolutely
- 30:59terrifying. You're basically telling the
- 31:00listener to actively hunt down the exact specific piece of
- 31:04information that could bankrupt their idea and destroy their
- 31:07dreams. How do you psychologically
- 31:10prepare a team to do that? It requires a complete rewiring
- 31:13of how you perceive failure. You have to learn to genuinely
- 31:16love bad news. Think of it mathematically.
- 31:19If you have $50,000 of savings to start a business and you
- 31:22spend $5000 and two weeks of your time to conclusively learn
- 31:26that your idea is flawed and the market will not pay for it, that
- 31:29is not a failure. That is a massive, life altering
- 31:31victory. You just save $45,000 and
- 31:34potentially years of stressful, agonizing labor.
- 31:38You're actively hunting for a meh response.
- 31:40If they are just lukewarm, it's a blessing in disguise because
- 31:43it frees you to pivot or move on to a better idea.
- 31:45Precisely. A quick no is infinitely more
- 31:48valuable than a lingering polite maybe.
- 31:51But to consistently get those honest, brutal meh responses,
- 31:55you have to completely deconstruct the environment in
- 31:58which you're asking these questions.
- 31:59You cannot extract this kind of vulnerable truth in a formal
- 32:03corporate boardroom. You have to actively kill the
- 32:05formal meeting. Yes.
- 32:07This is such a great pivot in the book, Fitzpatrick argues the
- 32:10deep foundational learning works infinitely better in a casual,
- 32:14unstructured 5 to 15 minute chat that it ever will in a formal,
- 32:18calendar blocked 60 minute boardroom meeting.
- 32:20We lean on formality as a crutch, don't we?
- 32:23We use calendars and agendas because approaching strangers
- 32:26and asking them about their problems is inherently awkward,
- 32:29But formal meetings completely ruin the interpersonal dynamic
- 32:32required for truth telling. He uses a brilliant dating
- 32:35analogy here that exposes how absurd our business behavior is.
- 32:39Oh, this is such a good analogy. Imagine you were sitting alone
- 32:42at a cafe reading a book, and suddenly the absolute person of
- 32:45your dream sits down at the table next to you.
- 32:47They smile at you, you make eye contact.
- 32:49There's a spark. You have a moment.
- 32:51A. Perfect serendipitous moment.
- 32:53No, instead of just saying hi, what are you reading and
- 32:56striking up a natural human conversation, you stand up, walk
- 33:00over, hand them a business card and say excuse me, I think
- 33:03you're highly attractive. Could we schedule a formal
- 33:07coffee date for next Tuesday at 2.00 PM so I can ask you a
- 33:12series of validated questions to determine our long term
- 33:15compatibility? It's completely absurd.
- 33:18It kills the magic instantly. You are already there, you're
- 33:21already in the cafe. The opportunity is live.
- 33:23Just talk to them. It is the exact same dynamic
- 33:26with early stage customer research, right?
- 33:28It is if you are standing at an industry conference buffet line
- 33:33right next to your ideal target executive.
- 33:35Do not ask to exchange business cards so you can schedule a
- 33:38formal Zoom call for next Thursday.
- 33:40Just turn to them and casually ask your most important burning
- 33:43question right then and there. Hey, you guys are in logistics,
- 33:45right? How do you handle international
- 33:47debt collection? Is it as much of a nightmare as
- 33:49everyone says? Boom.
- 33:51You are instantly doing high level customer research without
- 33:54them ever feeling like they are being researched.
- 33:56It strips away all the corporate pomp and circumstance.
- 34:00Think about a standard 60 minute meeting.
- 34:03The 1st 15 minutes is just getting coffee, testing the
- 34:06projector, and making painful small talk about the weather.
- 34:09The last 15 minutes is just summarizing next steps.
- 34:12The actual core meet of the meeting could have been handled
- 34:15in a 5 minute conversation in a hallway.
- 34:17Exactly. However, there is a crucial
- 34:20caveat here. Well, early discovery must be
- 34:22casual. Eventually, if your business
- 34:24survives, you do have to transition to a formal product
- 34:27meeting once you actually have a concrete solution to sell.
- 34:31And when you make that transition from casual
- 34:32researcher to formal vendor, you have to be aware of the most
- 34:36dangerous creature in the startup ecosystem.
- 34:38The zombie leads. The Walking Dead of the
- 34:40corporate world. These are the potential
- 34:43customers or even potential investors who keep taking
- 34:45meetings with you. They reply to your emails.
- 34:48They keep looking at your updated slide decks.
- 34:50They keep saying wow the product looks great, keep me in the loop
- 34:52on your progress, but they never ever under any circumstances
- 34:57actually cut a check or sign a contract.
- 34:59They are keeping you perpetually in the corporate friend zone,
- 35:03and the harsh truth Fitzpatrick delivers is that it is entirely
- 35:06your own fault. You have zombie leads because
- 35:09you are being clingy and you are terrified of rejection.
- 35:12You are accepting their worthless compliments as
- 35:14progress instead of forcing them to make a hard commitment.
- 35:17To escape the friend zone, you have to force what he calls an
- 35:20advancement. You have to put them to a binary
- 35:22decision. You have to force a commitment,
- 35:25and he defines 3 specific currencies of commitment that
- 35:28prove a lead is actually alive. Time, reputation, and cash.
- 35:33Let's break those currencies down because they escalate in
- 35:36value. Let's do it.
- 35:37Remember, a verbal compliment cost them absolutely 0 calories,
- 35:40so it is worth nothing. But if you ask for their time.
- 35:43And I don't mean a vague promise to look over a PDF.
- 35:46No, I mean a hard commitment. For example, will you agree to
- 35:49sit down with your entire engineering team for two hours
- 35:52next Tuesday to actively test our wireframes?
- 35:56That is a real, measurable commitment of a valuable
- 35:59resource. And what about reputation?
- 36:01Reputation is when they put their own internal social
- 36:05capital on the line to champion your product.
- 36:08Are they willing to introduce you to their boss, the person
- 36:10who actually holds the purse strings?
- 36:13Are they willing to write a public testimonial or do a case
- 36:15study? If an executive tells you they
- 36:18love your software but they refuse to introduce you to the
- 36:21procurement department, they are a zombie LED protecting their
- 36:25own reputation. They don't actually believe in
- 36:27you enough to risk their neck. And then obviously the ultimate
- 36:30currency, cash, a deposit, a preorder, a signed letter of
- 36:34intent. Even just swiping a credit card
- 36:36for $10 proves they are serious if they will not give up time,
- 36:40reputation or cash. You do not have a lead, no
- 36:43matter how many times they smile and say I love your vision.
- 36:46And that is the only metric by which a meeting succeeds or
- 36:49fails. A meeting doesn't succeed
- 36:51because everyone laughed at your jokes or praised your slide
- 36:54deck. A meeting succeeds solely
- 36:56because you secured A tangible commitment to advance to the
- 36:58next stage of the sales funnel. If you leave a room without a
- 37:01clear, committed next step, the meeting was a complete failure.
- 37:06OK, let me pause and play devil's advocate again.
- 37:08All of this makes sense once you are actually talking to someone,
- 37:11but if we are avoiding formal meetings in the early stages,
- 37:14how do we actually find these high level people to have these
- 37:18casual, serendipitous chats with?
- 37:19Are we supposed to just lurk outside corporate headquarters
- 37:22and ambush executives in the Starbucks line?
- 37:24No, ambushing people is a great way to get a restraining order.
- 37:28Not a customer, but it does require intentionally
- 37:32engineering serendipity. You have to find systemic ways
- 37:36to bring the right people into your orbit or secure warm
- 37:39introductions rather than relying on the brutal soul
- 37:43crushing grind of cold calling. Yeah, he does mention cold calls
- 37:46in the text. He admits that statistically,
- 37:48they do work. If you dial 100 random numbers
- 37:51and 98 people scream at you and hang up, you technically still
- 37:54have two conversations. But it's emotionally
- 37:56devastating. Those founders will burnout
- 37:58before they hit dial #50. So how do we engineer the
- 38:01serendipity without losing our minds?
- 38:03Fitzpatrick outlined several highly creative, proactive
- 38:07tactics. Arguably the most powerful one
- 38:10is to organize industry meetups yourself.
- 38:14Let's say you are building software for HR professionals.
- 38:18You don't buy a list in cold. E-mail 1000 HR directors.
- 38:21Instead, you call a local pub, rent their backroom for a
- 38:24Tuesday night, call it the City HR Professionals Happy Hour, and
- 38:28send out free invites on LinkedIn.
- 38:30Because you are the organizer, you are instantly perceived as a
- 38:33credible authority figure and the center of attention.
- 38:37They will show up, drink a beer, and happily complain to you
- 38:40about their workflow problems all night long.
- 38:42That is an incredible hack. You essentially build the
- 38:44watering holes so the zebras come to you.
- 38:46He also talks about speaking and teaching.
- 38:48Yes, if you have a strong opinion on why project
- 38:51management software is broken, offer to give a free 30 minute
- 38:54workshop on it at a local coworking space.
- 38:56The people who take the time to show up are literally self
- 38:58selecting as your target market and they already view you as an
- 39:01expert before you even open your mouth.
- 39:03Plus industry blogging. Just publicly writing about the
- 39:06specific niche problems will naturally attract organic search
- 39:10traffic from the exact people who suffer from those problems.
- 39:13And then there's the more aggressive guerrilla networking
- 39:15approach, which he famously calls the Seven Degrees of Kevin
- 39:19Bacon method. Oh man, the story about standing
- 39:22on the chair. This might be my favorite
- 39:23anecdote in the whole book. It's so again.
- 39:25He talks about a group of young, inexperienced grads who
- 39:29desperately needed to talk to elite high level McKinsey
- 39:32consultants for their research. But they were just kids.
- 39:35They had zero network and no warm intros.
- 39:37They were working out of a crowded Co working space.
- 39:40So what did they do? Instead of sending 1000 ignored
- 39:44LinkedIn messages, one of them just physically stands up on a
- 39:47chair in the middle of the crowded office and shouts to the
- 39:49entire room. Excuse me, does anyone here know
- 39:53someone who works at McKenzie? We will buy you a beer right now
- 39:56if you can introduce us. And the crazy thing is, it
- 39:59worked instantly. 3 people raised their hands.
- 40:02They bought 3 beers, got three warm e-mail introductions to
- 40:05McKinsey consultants, and completely bypassed the
- 40:08agonizing cold calling phase. It proves that the world is
- 40:11incredibly small. Everyone knows someone.
- 40:13You just have to be willing to swallow your pride and ask your
- 40:16immediate network for help. But look, let's be realistic,
- 40:19sometimes despite all the meetups and the blogging, you
- 40:22absolutely have to send a cold or semi warm e-mail to secure a
- 40:26meeting with a high level, incredibly busy person.
- 40:29And if you write that e-mail poorly, you sound like a
- 40:31desperate asking for a favor, and they will delete it in two
- 40:34seconds. To solve this, Fitzpatrick gives
- 40:37us a very specific psychological formula for drafting outreach
- 40:40emails, the VFWPA framework. VFWPA.
- 40:44It stands for Vision Framing, Weakness, Pedestal and ASK.
- 40:48It is a master class in manipulating psychological
- 40:50framing to disarm a busy executive.
- 40:53Let's breakdown exactly why each step works.
- 40:55I'll walk through the letters. You tell me the psychology.
- 40:58We start with V for Vision. You don't open by pitching your
- 41:01specific app feature, you start by stating your big picture
- 41:05mission. Something like I'm trying to
- 41:07figure out how to make commercial office rental less of
- 41:09a nightmare for small businesses.
- 41:12By starting with a broad vision rather than a product pitch, you
- 41:15signal that you are a peer trying to solve an industry wide
- 41:19problem, not a vendor trying to hit a quarterly sales quota.
- 41:24You invite them to join a mission.
- 41:26Next is F for framing. You explicitly set the
- 41:29boundaries to lower their guard, you write.
- 41:32We're just in the very early research stages and we have
- 41:35absolutely nothing to sell you. This is the most crucial
- 41:37sentence in the e-mail. Busy people delete emails
- 41:40because they fear getting trapped in a high pressure sales
- 41:42pitch. By explicitly promising you have
- 41:45nothing to sell, you instantly evaporate their primary anxiety.
- 41:49You disarm their defensive Shields.
- 41:51Then W for weakness you show vulnerability.
- 41:54I only know this industry from the perspective of a tenant.
- 41:56I have a massive blind spot regarding how landlords actually
- 41:59calculate risk. Admitting weakness triggers
- 42:02their empathy. It proves you aren't an arrogant
- 42:05founder who thinks they know everything.
- 42:07It creates a vacuum of knowledge that they can fill.
- 42:10Which leads perfectly into PE for Pedestal.
- 42:13You struck their ego and explain why they specifically are the
- 42:16only person who can fill that vacuum.
- 42:18You've been managing commercial real estate in this city for 20
- 42:21years and your specific expertise could really help cut
- 42:25through our fog. This is where the magic happens,
- 42:27right? You aren't asking for a favor,
- 42:29you are honoring their legacy. People, especially successful
- 42:33executives, love to be recognized as wise elders.
- 42:37By putting them on a pedestal, you transform the request from a
- 42:40burden into a compliment. And finally, a for ask.
- 42:43You keep it minimal. Could you spare 15 minutes next
- 42:46week for a quick chat? The entire framework works
- 42:49because it executes A psychological maneuver.
- 42:51Fitzpatrick calls the advisory flip.
- 42:53The advisory flip is a total inversion of standard corporate
- 42:57power dynamics. Think about it.
- 42:59Normally you were a desperate, low status salesperson begging a
- 43:03high status executive for 15 minutes of their time to pitch a
- 43:06product they don't want. But with the VFWPA framework you
- 43:10flip the script. You become an ambitious
- 43:12explorer, recruiting a wise high status advisor to help guide you
- 43:17on a grand journey. You are asking for their hard
- 43:20earned wisdom, not their wallet. It puts you in a position of
- 43:23quiet confidence because you are actively evaluating them as a
- 43:26potential mentor. And it puts them completely at
- 43:28ease, because human beings fundamentally love giving advice
- 43:32to eager listeners. It is a profound shift in power
- 43:35dynamics. You are explicitly recognizing
- 43:38that the customer, not the founder, is the ultimate arbiter
- 43:40of what actually works. The customer holds the truth.
- 43:43The customer holds the value. And that precise realization
- 43:47that the power dynamic must shift and that economic value is
- 43:50determined entirely by the customers lived reality, not by
- 43:53the creator's arrogance, is the perfect logical bridge to our
- 43:56second source today. We are now going to zoom out
- 43:59from the gritty St. level tactics of interrogating
- 44:01customers in coffee shops and ascend to the grand
- 44:04macroeconomic academic scale of service dominant logic.
- 44:08Buckle up because we are diving into the academic drama.
- 44:11We were looking at a Seminole paper from the European Journal
- 44:14of Marketing, written by Robert Lush and Stephen Vargo.
- 44:18And let me tell you, if you think corporate drama is
- 44:21intense, academic drama is the absolute best kind of drama.
- 44:26It is so deeply, wonderfully passive aggressive.
- 44:29It truly is a blood sport, played out in citations and
- 44:32footnotes. To set the historical stage
- 44:35here, Lush and Vargo had previously published A
- 44:37groundbreaking, highly disruptive paper proposing an
- 44:40entirely new, dominant logic for how we understand global
- 44:44marketing and economics. But our specific source texts
- 44:47today is actually their fiery, meticulous rebuttal to a very
- 44:51harsh critique written by two other prominent academics,
- 44:54O'Shaughnessy and O'Shaughnessy. The O'shaughnessy's had
- 44:56published a paper essentially trying to tear Lush and Vargo
- 44:59down. They called Lush and Vargo's new
- 45:01theory regressive. They called it a backwards step
- 45:04for the science of marketing and they basically accused them of
- 45:06acting like radical religious evangelist trying to brainwash
- 45:09the academic community. Radical evangelists.
- 45:12In the dry, polite world of academic journals, calling a
- 45:15peer A radical evangelist is the equivalent of throwing a chair
- 45:19across a room. Those are fighting words.
- 45:22So what were they actually fighting about?
- 45:23What is this service dominant logic or SD logic that caused
- 45:27such an uproar? To understand why SD logic is so
- 45:30controversial and revolutionary, we first have to understand the
- 45:34invisible water we've all been swimming in for centuries.
- 45:38Goods dominant logic. Goods dominant logic.
- 45:40Let's define that. For hundreds of years, going all
- 45:42the way back to the Industrial Revolution, economists and
- 45:46business leaders have viewed the world entirely through the lens
- 45:49of goods dominant logic. This is the ingrained belief
- 45:52that the core purpose of a healthy economy is manufacturing
- 45:56tangible physical things goods. You build a tractor, you stamp
- 46:00out a car on Henry Ford's assembly line, you stick
- 46:03together a shoe. And under this logic, the actual
- 46:05economic value is literally embedded inside that physical
- 46:09item during the manufacturing process on the factory floor.
- 46:12Right. It's the idea that a factory
- 46:14takes $10 worth of metal, bashes it with hammers, and turns it
- 46:17into a toaster that contains $50.00 worth of embedded value.
- 46:21And in that old industrial worldview, services like giving
- 46:26a haircut, waiting tables at a restaurant, or giving legal
- 46:29advice we're just viewed as the leftover intangible fluff of the
- 46:34economy. They were secondary to the real
- 46:37work of manufacturing goods. Goods were the main event,
- 46:40services were the sideshow. But then Lush and Vargo come
- 46:44along and completely flip the table.
- 46:46They look at the global economy and say that goods dominant
- 46:49logic is entirely backwards. It is a historical illusion.
- 46:53They argue that all economies since the dawn of human trade
- 46:56have actually been service economies.
- 46:58Everything is a service. And this is where the critics,
- 47:01O'Shaughnessy and O'Shaughnessy completely misunderstood the
- 47:04assignment. The critics read that and
- 47:05thought Lush and Vargo were just making a basic statistical
- 47:08observation. Like hey, the restaurant and
- 47:10hospitality sector is growing rapidly, therefore services are
- 47:13important now. But that's not what they were
- 47:14saying at all, is it? Not at all.
- 47:17Lush and Vargo were doing something much more profound.
- 47:20They were entirely redefining the core economic definition of
- 47:24the word service. In SD logic, a service doesn't
- 47:28mean someone cutting your hair or serving you a burger.
- 47:31They define service as the application of specialized
- 47:34competences, meaning human knowledge and skills for the
- 47:37benefit of another entity. Let's make this concrete.
- 47:40The source uses a brilliant example of a tailor, and this is
- 47:44the moment the entire theory clicked for me.
- 47:46Under the old rules of goods dominant logic, if you go to a
- 47:50local tailor and they measure you and spend a week hand
- 47:52stitching a custom suit just for you, economists classify that
- 47:55transaction as a service. But if a worker stands in a
- 47:58massive textile factory and operates a machine that cuts
- 48:01fabric for 1000 mass produced identical suits, economists
- 48:05classify that as manufacturing a good.
- 48:07And Lush and Vargo point out how intellectually arbitrary and
- 48:10meaningless that distinction is. In both scenarios, a human being
- 48:15is applying their specialized skills and knowledge to their
- 48:17competences to create a benefit for someone else.
- 48:20They are both fundamentally providing a service.
- 48:23The only difference is the method of delivery.
- 48:25So if everything is the application of human knowledge,
- 48:28where does the physical object, the actual suit, the car, the
- 48:32toaster, fit into this worldview?
- 48:35This is the most radical part of SUV logic.
- 48:38They argue that the physical good, the suit, the car, the
- 48:41glass screen of your iPad, is merely a distribution mechanism
- 48:44for a service. It is nothing more than a
- 48:47temporary physical appliance used to deliver human knowledge
- 48:50across time and space. A lawn mower isn't valuable
- 48:53because it's made of metal. It is just a distribution
- 48:55mechanism for the human knowledge of how to cut grass
- 48:58efficiently. A physical hardcover book is
- 49:00merely a paper distribution mechanism for transmitting the
- 49:03author's internal knowledge into your brain.
- 49:05The true value isn't the paper, the metal, or the plastic.
- 49:08The value is the applied human knowledge.
- 49:11OK, I'm going to pause and play the skeptic here, just like the
- 49:14critics O'Shaughnessy and O'Shaughnessy did, because I can
- 49:17hear a listener right now thinking OK, I understand the
- 49:20academic drama and the definitions are neat, but why on
- 49:24earth do I care if a physical product is actually just a
- 49:27distribution mechanism for a service?
- 49:30How does this philosophical semantic debate change anything
- 49:33for the entrepreneur reading the MOM test and just trying to
- 49:36build a profitable software company?
- 49:39It changes everything because it fundamentally alters your
- 49:42understanding of where value actually lives in the universe.
- 49:46If you cling to the old goods dominant logic, you will operate
- 49:49under the delusion that you can manufacture value in your
- 49:52garage, put it in a cardboard box, and sell it.
- 49:55You will look at your software code and believe that the code
- 49:57itself possesses inherent value. But if you truly embrace service
- 50:01dominant logic, you realize a terrifying but liberating truth.
- 50:06Your product has absolutely 0 inherent value.
- 50:09The code is worthless. The plastic is worthless value
- 50:12does not exist on the factory floor or in the GitHub
- 50:14repository. Value only springs into
- 50:17existence at the exact moment the service is applied to
- 50:20benefit the user. Which brings us to the grand
- 50:23finale of this deep dive, the moment where we bring the street
- 50:26detective and the sociologist together in the same room.
- 50:28The grand synthesis Lush and Vargo formalized this entire
- 50:32concept of where value lives in what they call Foundational
- 50:36Premise 10, or FP10. Foundational Premise 10 is the
- 50:39absolute pinnacle of their macroeconomic theory.
- 50:41It States and I quote value is always uniquely and
- 50:45phenomenologically determined by the beneficiary.
- 50:47Phenomenologically, that is a $50 triple word score academic
- 50:52term right there. Let's translate that into plain
- 50:54English for the listener. Phenomenology is a branch of
- 50:56philosophy that studies the structure of subjective
- 50:59conscious experience. It's the study of how things
- 51:02feel from the first person perspective.
- 51:04So when Lush and Bargo say that value is uniquely and
- 51:07phenomenologically determined, they mean that value only exists
- 51:11within the subjective, highly personal, emotional, lived
- 51:14experience of the end user. You, the creator, cannot create
- 51:18value. You can only create what they
- 51:20call a value proposition, an offer.
- 51:22It is entirely up to the customer operating in their own
- 51:25messy real world context to determine if value actually
- 51:29occurred during their experience with your offering.
- 51:31To explain phenomenology, I like to use the analogy of a joke.
- 51:35Think about a stand up comedian writing a joke on a piece of
- 51:37paper in a quiet room. Under the old woods dominant
- 51:40logic. The comedian will look at that
- 51:41piece of paper and say I have manufactured a funny joke.
- 51:45The comedy is embedded in the ink.
- 51:47But under service dominant logic, that piece of paper has 0
- 51:50inherent comedy. The joke is just a value
- 51:54proposition. The comedy, the actual value,
- 51:57only sparks into existence phenomenologically when it
- 52:00intersects with a specific audience member who happens to
- 52:02speak the language, understand the cultural context, and be in
- 52:06a good enough mood to laugh. If the audience doesn't laugh,
- 52:09the joke literally has no value. That is a perfect analogy.
- 52:13The comedian doesn't determine the value of the joke, the
- 52:15audience does. And this exact macroeconomic
- 52:19philosophical premise is the literal reason the MOM test
- 52:22exists. This is the theoretical physics
- 52:25engine running underneath Fitzpatrick's tactical
- 52:27instruction manual. Yes, it all connects so
- 52:30perfectly, Fitzpatrick tells you.
- 52:31Tactically, on a street level, Never, ever ask a customer Is my
- 52:35product valuable? And Lush and Vargo tell you
- 52:37academically why you can't ask that because it is a
- 52:39scientifically and logically invalid question.
- 52:42Value does not exist inside your product.
- 52:44The customer cannot look at your prototype and tell you if it has
- 52:47value because the value hasn't happened yet.
- 52:49The value only happens in their future lived experience.
- 52:52Exactly. Let's revisit.
- 52:53Visit the examples from earlier through this new grand lens of
- 52:57SD logic. Think about the young man
- 53:00pitching the iPad cookbook to his mother.
- 53:02The Sun's app, the lines of code, the user interface, the
- 53:06high risk pictures. That is the physical good.
- 53:08And according to Lush and Vargo's FB 10, that good has 0
- 53:12inherent value. It is merely a digital
- 53:15distribution mechanism for culinary knowledge.
- 53:17Right. The value is uniquely and
- 53:20phenomenologically determined by the mother.
- 53:22Yeah, and what does her specific phenomenological experience
- 53:24actually look like? It doesn't look like staring at
- 53:27a screen. It looks like her husband with
- 53:29high cholesterol sitting at the dinner table tasting her newly
- 53:31prepared vegan meal, smiling and saying, wow, this has a lot of
- 53:34zazz. That specific emotional moment
- 53:37is where the value lives. It is entirely contextual.
- 53:39It is entirely experiential and you cannot build an app for that
- 53:42moment unless you understand the husband's cholesterol problem
- 53:45first. And let's apply it to the
- 53:46devastating MTV example from Habit.
- 53:49Fitzpatrick thought the value was embedded in his complex,
- 53:52beautifully coded data analytics dashboard.
- 53:55He believed he manufactured value through hard engineering
- 53:57work. But the beneficiary, the MTV
- 54:01executives, phenomenologically determine that the only thing of
- 54:04actual value in their specific corporate context was looking
- 54:08prestigious and professional to their clients via a branded PDF
- 54:12e-mail. The value wasn't in the
- 54:13mathematical data. The value was in the social
- 54:16prestige of sending a slick report.
- 54:18You cannot cheat the physics engine by fishing for
- 54:20compliments. If value is uniquely determined
- 54:23by the customer specific life context, their daily
- 54:26constraints, their past behaviors, and their highly
- 54:29subjective emotional experience, then the only way to build a
- 54:32successful business is to become an absolute obsessive expert in
- 54:36their life. You have to use the tactical
- 54:38rules of the MOM test to excavate their messy reality,
- 54:41because that reality is the only soil where value can actually
- 54:44grow. It is such a profound synthesis
- 54:47of ideas, Fitzpatrick writes in his Tactical Handbook.
- 54:50Talk about their life instead of your idea, and Lush and Vargo
- 54:54prove mathematically and philosophically in their
- 54:56academic journal that their life is literally the only place your
- 54:59idea has any worth. They're describing the exact
- 55:02same human phenomenon from completely opposite ends of the
- 55:05telescope. What an incredible intellectual
- 55:08journey. Today we have covered so much
- 55:10ground. Let's summarize the map we just
- 55:12traversed. We started down in the mud with
- 55:14a street detective. We learned how to suppress our
- 55:16own ego. Stop pitching teaching our
- 55:18brilliant ideas and start carefully excavating the fragile
- 55:22truth of human behavior. We learned why we must
- 55:25ruthlessly deflect the fool's gold of polite compliments, and
- 55:28why we must anchor fluffy future tense promises firmly in the
- 55:31reality of past actions. We learned how to identify the
- 55:35terrifying elephant in the room by avoiding the trap of
- 55:38premature zooming, ensuring we're actually solving A macro
- 55:41problem that people care about rather than a micro problem we
- 55:44invented for them. We learned how to escape the
- 55:47corporate friend zone of zombie leads by forcing real painful
- 55:51commitments of time, reputation, or cash.
- 55:54We learned how to engineer serendipity instead of cold
- 55:56calling, and how to use the psychological framing of the
- 55:59VFWPA e-mail to execute the advisory flip, shifting our
- 56:03posture from a desperate beggar asking for a sale to a confident
- 56:06explorer seeking a wise advisor. And finally, we ascended out of
- 56:10the coffee shops and into the academic clouds, where we
- 56:12realized that mathematically, economically, and
- 56:14philosophically, your product is worthless until the beneficiary
- 56:18phenomenologically experiences its value.
- 56:20The singular through line connecting all of this, from the
- 56:23gritty startup trenches to the ivory tower, is radical
- 56:26humility. Both of these sources demand
- 56:29that you completely surrender your ego.
- 56:32Whether you are building a tech startup, writing a novel,
- 56:35designing a new internal HR process for your corporate team,
- 56:38or pitching a community project to a local nonprofit, your good
- 56:42idea is completely and utterly irrelevant.
- 56:45In a vacuum, it does not matter until you deeply, empathetically
- 56:49understand the life, the problems, and the subjective
- 56:53reality of the specific human being you are trying to serve.
- 56:56It's a deeply humbling lesson for anyone who likes to invent
- 56:59things. But I also find it incredibly
- 57:01empowering because that means the answers to our biggest
- 57:03business problems aren't hiding in some stroke of solitary
- 57:06genius. The answers are already out
- 57:08there, living in the minds of other people, if we just have
- 57:10the discipline to ask the right questions without leading the
- 57:13witness. And before we wrap up today,
- 57:15there was one final somewhat provocative thought I want to
- 57:18leave you with, building on everything we've just discussed.
- 57:21Laid on us? Where else is this a play?
- 57:23Well, we spent this entire deep dive talking exclusively about
- 57:27business startups, software features, and macroeconomic
- 57:30theory. But what if we took this exact
- 57:33same framework and applied the MOM test to our deeply personal
- 57:37relationships? Oh wow.
- 57:38OK, that is a pivot. Think about it.
- 57:41Think about the mechanics of human interaction we just
- 57:43explored. How often do we sit down with
- 57:45our partners, our spouses, or our closest friends and ask them
- 57:48incredibly leading questions? Will you be happier if I take
- 57:52this stressful new job that pays more?
- 57:55Do you think we should move out of the city and buy a house in
- 57:57the suburbs? We asked for hypothetical future
- 58:00tense promises about massive life changes and what do they
- 58:03do? They give us polite, optimistic
- 58:06fluff because of the pathos problem.
- 58:08They love us, they see we are excited and they want to support
- 58:11our dreams. They protect our feelings, just
- 58:13like the mom with the iPad cookbook.
- 58:15They say sure, honey, the suburbs sound great because they
- 58:17don't want to crush our vision of the future.
- 58:19Exactly. But what if, instead of asking
- 58:21generic hypotheticals about a future that doesn't exist, we
- 58:25anchored our loved ones fluff? What if we gently deflected
- 58:28their polite compliments, stopped projecting our own ego
- 58:31onto their desires, and dug beneath their surface level
- 58:35emotional signals to find out what they truly
- 58:37phenomenologically value in US and in our shared daily life?
- 58:42So instead of asking, will you be happy if I work late to get
- 58:45this promotion, you apply rule #2 and ask about specifics In
- 58:49the past. You mentioned you were stressed
- 58:51when I worked late last Tuesday. Can you walk me through exactly
- 58:54what that evening was like for you at home?
- 58:56Precisely, you excavate the reality of their lived
- 58:59experience rather than asking them to predict their future
- 59:02emotions. If discovering the unvarnished
- 59:04truth can save a technology startup from bankruptcy, it
- 59:07might just be powerful enough to save a marriage from drifting
- 59:10apart under the weight of unspoken assumptions.
- 59:12Because at the end of the day, value is determined by the
- 59:15beneficiary, even in love. That is heavy, but it is so
- 59:19profoundly true, applying the rigorous, egoless pursuit of
- 59:23truth not just to our customers, but to the people we care about
- 59:26the most. Well, thank you so much for
- 59:28joining us on this massive deep dive today.
- 59:31We started out wading through the murky, Muddy Waters of
- 59:34diagnostic truth, desperately looking for a clean, binary
- 59:37X-ray machine that would just beep and tell us if our idea was
- 59:40validated. But we discovered that the X-ray
- 59:42machine doesn't exist. Instead, we have to become
- 59:45patient archaeologists and observant sociologists,
- 59:49carefully brushing away the thick layers of social
- 59:51politeness and fluff to uncover the fragile phenomenological
- 59:55truth of what people truly value.
- 59:57Keep digging for that truth. It's incredibly delicate work
- 1:00:00and it. Requires you to leave your ego
- 1:00:02at the door, but I promise you there is absolute treasure
- 1:00:04buried below. See you next time on the Deep
- 1:00:06Dive.