Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Tesla Q3 2025 Financial Analysis: Risks and Valuation
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the deep dive. You know the drill.
- 0:02We take your complex research and notes and we extract the
- 0:06absolute core insight. Today we're tackling, well, one
- 0:09of the biggest names out there, a really polarizing deep dive
- 0:12into the financial health, the business model, and yeah, the
- 0:15sky high valuation of Tesla Inc. You sent us quite a mountain of
- 0:18sources. This time we got the latest
- 0:20Q32025 financials competitive analysis, those crucial
- 0:23forward-looking DCF models. Our mission, as always, is to
- 0:26cut through all that noise. We need to figure out exactly
- 0:29what kind of future the market is betting on.
- 0:32I mean, what kind of growth is actually needed to justify this
- 0:35colossal stock price? Is it a car company?
- 0:37Is it a tech giant? Or something else entirely?
- 0:40It really is a phenomenal case study in growth investing, isn't
- 0:42it? But that ambition, it leads to
- 0:44massive volatility. You know, traditional metrics,
- 0:47they often just fall short here because the bulk of the
- 0:49potential earnings, the stock seems to be pricing in thankful
- 0:52self driving energy. Well, they're probably years
- 0:54away if they haven't at scale. So to kind of anchor this
- 0:58discussion, maybe we should start with a tough conservative
- 1:00check, the Buffett checklist. The value investing lens.
- 1:05Good idea. Yeah, let's see how Tesla stacks
- 1:07up against a really disciplined value benchmark.
- 1:09Then we can dive into the more aggressive scenarios needed to
- 1:13make sense of its current valuation.
- 1:15OK, sounds like a plan. But before we unpack any
- 1:18numbers, just the necessary note.
- 1:20The analysis we're presenting is based strictly on publicly
- 1:23available sources. It's intended for educational
- 1:25purposes only. This discussion, it doesn't
- 1:28constitute investment advice. Please always conduct your own
- 1:31due diligence before making any investment decisions.
- 1:34Right disclaimer, done. OK, let's begin.
- 1:37Q32025 snapshot. What was the the core financial
- 1:42tension? What really jumped out from the
- 1:43latest reports? Well, what stood out immediately
- 1:45was this kind of conflict between volume and profit.
- 1:48The company reported record total revenue, which is great,
- 1:51hovering somewhere between say, 23 and $25 billion for the
- 1:54quarter, mostly driven by record deliveries.
- 1:57OK, so lots of cars going out the door.
- 1:58Exactly. But the cost of that volume was
- 2:01steep. Net profit declined
- 2:03significantly year on year. We're talking down maybe 40 to
- 2:0650%. Wow, that's a big drop.
- 2:08And that profit decline, it's basically all tied to the price
- 2:10war, correct? Precisely.
- 2:12It's a direct consequence of those aggressive global price
- 2:15cuts on the Model 3 and Model Y. And the key strategic insight
- 2:19here is the trade off you see in the margins, automotive gross
- 2:23margin. So the profit on each car sold
- 2:26fell sharply down into the high teens.
- 2:29High teens, That's a huge drop from where they were.
- 2:31Oh. Absolutely drastically down from
- 2:34the, you know, roughly 25% average they're enjoying in the
- 2:37prior year. And this is where management's
- 2:38long term bet becomes crystal clear, right?
- 2:41They're choosing volume over immediate profit.
- 2:44Exactly. Elon Musk has explicitly stated
- 2:47this. He's prioritizing volume,
- 2:48expanding the vehicle installed base, getting as many cars on
- 2:51the road as possible. He's sacrificing that near term
- 2:54profitability, betting that this larger fleet will eventually,
- 2:57you know, serve as a gigantic revenue pipeline for future high
- 3:00margin software like FSD and other services down the line.
- 3:04It's a classic Silicon Valley playbook, the land grab
- 3:07strategy. Fly to hardware, Yeah, but it
- 3:09definitely punishes the quarterly earnings right now.
- 3:12OK. Speaking of that whole
- 3:13ecosystem, yeah, let's maybe detail the revenue streams.
- 3:16We know it's mainly an auto company today, but where does
- 3:19its competitive edge, its Moat, actually lie, Especially if the
- 3:24margins on the cars themselves are, well, eroding?
- 3:28Good question. Currently, the revenue picture
- 3:30is pretty clear. Automotive sales dominate.
- 3:32That's roughly 79% of the 2024 total revenue.
- 3:36Then you have services and other and energy generation and
- 3:38storage. They kind of split the rest
- 3:40around 11% and 10%. Respectively in those regulatory
- 3:43credits still a factor. They are, yes.
- 3:46High margin, definitely, but pretty minimal in the grand
- 3:49scheme of things. Maybe 2% of the overall picture.
- 3:52But the Moat, yeah, it's really not just about selling cars
- 3:54anymore. Manufacturing expertise is well
- 3:57becoming more common across the industry.
- 3:59Tesla's real advantage is built on 4 core kind of integrated
- 4:02pillars. OK.
- 4:03Let's break those down. Where do we start brand?
- 4:05That's the first pillar, brand and technology leadership.
- 4:08I mean Tesla is still the aspirational name in EVs for
- 4:12many people synonymous with cutting edge tech.
- 4:15The second is pure execution scale and efficiency.
- 4:19They're pushing towards what, nearly 2 million units a year
- 4:22now? Incredible scale.
- 4:23It is and their expertise in high volume, vertically
- 4:27integrated production, especially making their own
- 4:30batteries and powertrains. It drives unit costs down faster
- 4:33than most competitors can manage right now.
- 4:35But the real lock in, the thing that creates that network
- 4:37effect, that's pillars 3 and 4, right?
- 4:40The stuff legacy automakers just don't have in the same way.
- 4:43That's exactly right. Pillar 3 is vertical integration
- 4:46and charging. They design their own ships,
- 4:48their own software, which is significant, but the critical
- 4:51piece here is the proprietary global Supercharger network.
- 4:55Yes, the charging experience it's.
- 4:56Huge reliability and availability of charging is
- 4:59probably the symbol biggest factor in EV anxiety for
- 5:02consumers. For years, that proprietary
- 5:04network gave Tesla owners confidence they could actually
- 5:07road trip reliably. Creating a powerful ecosystem
- 5:09advantage and buyer loyalty too, I imagine.
- 5:12Definitely. And then the 4th pillar, which
- 5:15is arguably the most valuable or at least the one with the
- 5:17biggest potential value is data and software.
- 5:21FSD. Think about it, over 5 million
- 5:24vehicles on the road constantly collecting billions of miles of
- 5:28real world driving data that feeds its AI development for
- 5:31autonomous driving. A date advantage no one else can
- 5:34really match at that scale. Not currently, no.
- 5:36And crucially, that FSD software.
- 5:38It sells for up to what, $15,000 per car?
- 5:41$15,000 for software pure. High margin software revenue if
- 5:46and it's still a big if, but if it achieves true scalable
- 5:49autonomy, it completely transforms the business model.
- 5:52OK. That software potential clearly
- 5:54explains some of the premium valuation.
- 5:56But connecting this back to the bigger picture, the sources you
- 5:59looked at warn about significant pressures, competitive,
- 6:01structural what are the major headwinds that could actually
- 6:04erode this powerful mode? Yeah, there are definitely risks
- 6:08on the short term. The pressures are mostly
- 6:10macroeconomic. I'd say high interest rates are
- 6:12making all expensive purchases, including car loans, less
- 6:15attractive for consumers. Right, Hertz demand directly.
- 6:18Exactly. And that forces those price cuts
- 6:20we talked about, which is why we saw the margin pain in Q32025.
- 6:24And alongside that we are seeing truly intensifying competition.
- 6:28Specifically from China wasn't that mentioned?
- 6:30Absolutely. It's not just the legacy
- 6:31automakers finally bringing compelling EVs to market.
- 6:35You've got rivals like BYD in China who are well, well, often
- 6:39highly subsidized and competing very aggressively on price and
- 6:42volume. So Tesla can't just raise prices
- 6:44back up easily. Not without losing market share,
- 6:46no. It makes the price cuts feel
- 6:48more like a structural necessity now, not just a temporary
- 6:51choice. Then looking longer term, the
- 6:54structural risks are maybe even more concerning.
- 6:56The first one is obvious key man risk.
- 6:58Elon Musk. Tesla's reliance on him is just
- 7:01profound. His attention is constantly
- 7:03split across these massive, demanding ventures.
- 7:06SpaceX X Twitter and his, let's say, controversial public
- 7:10profile creates unique legal and reputational risks that could
- 7:14frankly impact the Tesla brand and its stock price almost
- 7:17instantly. Is there a worry in the market
- 7:20that his focus on, you know, Mars or achieving full autonomy
- 7:24distracts from the day-to-day grind of running a massive car
- 7:28company in a tough market? I think that's the central
- 7:30tension, yes. Second, major risk market
- 7:32commoditization. What happens if the technology
- 7:34stabilizes? If everyone starts making great
- 7:36affordable Ev's, which is already happening to some
- 7:38extent? Then the cars become like
- 7:40gasoline cars today. Potentially.
- 7:42And if that happens, Tesla's historical, you know, 2530%
- 7:45gross margins could permanently erode.
- 7:47It just becomes a low margin product like any other car.
- 7:50A tough reality for a company priced like a tech.
- 7:51Leader, indeed. And third, they absolutely must
- 7:55sustain their tech LED. What if a competitor, say Waymo,
- 7:59achieves regulatory approval for scalable true level 4 autonomy
- 8:03first? Or if a battery rival develops a
- 8:06radically cheaper or significantly denser battery
- 8:08pack. Then Tesla's core advantages
- 8:10could just vanish. They could be significantly
- 8:13diminished. Yes.
- 8:14They have to keep running faster than everyone else just to stay
- 8:16ahead. The innovation pressure is
- 8:18immense. OK, so despite those threats and
- 8:21the price wars, Tesla somehow still maintains better margins
- 8:24than most traditional automakers on their EVs.
- 8:27How? Let's touch on their efficiency.
- 8:29How are they managing this cost advantage?
- 8:30They are masters of cost discipline in many ways,
- 8:34especially in managing their variable and operating expenses.
- 8:37Predictably, the largest variable cost is materials and
- 8:39components. The battery I assume.
- 8:41The battery pack, yes, it's the single most expensive item in
- 8:45the car, costing roughly let's say 100 to $150.00 per kWh.
- 8:51That number is crucial. Their fixed costs are obviously
- 8:54massive too, 10s of billions invested in R&D, about $4.5
- 8:58billion in 2024 alone. And of course the depreciation
- 9:02of those huge gigafactories. They leverage those fixed costs
- 9:05better. That's the key.
- 9:06They mitigate those factory costs by demanding extremely
- 9:09high volume and utilization. They spread those fixed costs
- 9:12over far more more units than any competitor currently can
- 9:15with their EB program. And then there's the big one,
- 9:17the key differentiator that makes their operating margins
- 9:19look so much better compared to legacy auto, that famous lack of
- 9:23a traditional marketing budget. Absolutely.
- 9:25This is, you could argue, structural genius.
- 9:28Tesla famously spends almost 0 on paid advertising. 0 compared
- 9:32to billions for the others. Billions.
- 9:34Annually. Yes.
- 9:35TV spots, digital ads, sponsorships.
- 9:38Traditional automakers spend hundreds, sometimes thousands of
- 9:40dollars per car sold just on marketing.
- 9:43Tesla basically substitutes that massive direct ad expense with
- 9:47brand buzz, media attention, and, well, Musk's immense social
- 9:52media presence. Which saves them a fortune.
- 9:53A fortune That structural difference dramatically lowers
- 9:57their operating costs relative to peers, and it's a huge
- 9:59component of why their margins have historically been superior.
- 10:02OK, This raises the critical question then.
- 10:05We've established they're operationally excellent.
- 10:07They have a strong Moat despite the risks.
- 10:09But if we apply that litmus test of Warren Buffett, the ultimate
- 10:13value standard, how does the world's most valuable automaker
- 10:16actually stack up? The Buffett checklist, well, the
- 10:18results based on the standard checklist metrics are pretty
- 10:21definitive. It's a clear fail on valuation
- 10:23discipline. It's not even close, really.
- 10:25OK, give us the numbers. Buffett typically looks for a
- 10:28price to earnings, or PE ratio of less than 15.
- 10:31Tesla's PE was around 181 X in 20 24. 181 versus 15, OK.
- 10:37Right then, PB ratio, price to book value.
- 10:40Buffett wants that. Under 1.5, Tesla's PB was nearly
- 10:4419 X, again, orders of magnitude different.
- 10:47Those numbers just scream growth stock, not value stock.
- 10:50Yeah, completely decoupled from current intrinsic value based on
- 10:53earnings. And it fails the earnings
- 10:55consistency test too, right? It does.
- 10:57Buffett likes to see positive, ideally rising earnings per
- 11:00share every single year for a decade.
- 11:03That signals stability and predictability.
- 11:05Tesla only became consistently profitable after 2020, and
- 11:09because of the recent price cuts we discussed, we actually saw
- 11:12EPS decline from 2022 to 2023. So yeah, it fails the
- 11:16consistency and predictability measure required by strict value
- 11:19investors. So given that pretty definitive
- 11:22failure on the value front, is there any part of the company
- 11:25financially speaking, that would actually appeal to a
- 11:27conservative investor like Buffett?
- 11:29Ironically, yes, there is one area where it passes with flying
- 11:32colors. Balance sheet safety.
- 11:34Really. Tell me more.
- 11:35Tesla has completely transformed its balance sheet over the last
- 11:37few years. It's now a financial fortress.
- 11:40Its current debt to equity ratio is extremely low, around .19
- 11:43now. Very little debt relative to its
- 11:45equity. Exactly.
- 11:46And its interest coverage, basically how easily it can pay
- 11:50the interest on its debt from its operating income is
- 11:52excellent. It was around 20X and 2024.
- 11:55So the company itself is built on a very stable low debt
- 11:58foundation. That financial conservatism
- 12:00would absolutely please someone like Buffett.
- 12:02OK, So the company is financially stable, solid
- 12:05foundation, but the stock price is clearly priced purely on
- 12:08future growth. Since the value is inflected in
- 12:10current earnings, it must be projecting something way out
- 12:13there. We ran a discounted cash flow
- 12:15ADCF analysis to try and see exactly what kind of future
- 12:18growth is currently baked into that stock price, which is
- 12:21sitting around what, $250 per share as we record this.
- 12:24Yeah, around $250. And this I think is the real
- 12:27moment of truth for understanding the valuation.
- 12:29We used a standard 10% discount rate just for consistency across
- 12:33the scenarios, OK. First, our conservative case,
- 12:36this assumes free cash flow basically stagnates around
- 12:39current levels, maybe due to heavy competition and margin
- 12:42pressure continuing. OK.
- 12:43What's the value there? That scenario yields an
- 12:45intrinsic value of only about $28.00 per share. $28.00 Wow,
- 12:50that is. That's a staggering potential
- 12:52downside if the big growth story just stops or significantly
- 12:57slows down. It really underscores the risk
- 12:59doesn't it's sort of the minimum price.
- 13:00If they just become another, albeit efficient automaker, then
- 13:04our nominal or base case. This assumes pretty robust
- 13:08continued expansion. Let's say free cash flow
- 13:11increases 20% annually for the next 5 years, then tapers off.
- 13:15Still strong growth, 20% a year. What value does that give?
- 13:17That yielded an intrinsic value of around $81.00 per share. 81
- 13:21OK. So even with strong sustained
- 13:23growth, the current price of $250 is still way, way above
- 13:28that. Untouchable by those traditional
- 13:29metrics, even with solid growth baked in.
- 13:32Which brings us to the final scenario.
- 13:34Even get close to the current market price of $250, we had to
- 13:37run the optimistic case. This assumed free cash flow
- 13:40would increase by an incredible 40% annually for five years
- 13:43straight. 40% growth per year for five years.
- 13:46That's extremely bullish. Extremely bullish, and even that
- 13:49scenario yielded an intrinsic value of only around $225 per
- 13:52share, still slightly below the current market price.
- 13:55So the market isn't just pricing in success or even robust
- 13:58success, It's pricing in an extraordinary almost best case
- 14:02scenario outcome. That is the inescapable
- 14:06conclusion. The market's current valuation
- 14:08around $250 implies that Tesla must execute something close to
- 14:13this extreme optimistic scenario.
- 14:15It means Tesla's annual free cash flow needs to multiply
- 14:18roughly tenfold over the next decade.
- 14:20It needs to reach cash flow levels comparable to, say,
- 14:23Apple's free cash flow today, and then sustain strong terminal
- 14:26growth after that. Which leaves almost no margin of
- 14:28safety, as value investors would say.
- 14:30Precisely at current prices, there seems to be almost no room
- 14:33for error, no margin of safety if even small operational
- 14:36hiccups occur, or if FSD takes longer or competition proves
- 14:40tougher than expected. So wrapping this up, what really
- 14:43stands out is this incredible high stakes gamble baked into
- 14:46the stock. Tesla is balancing this
- 14:48aggressive market share expansion, taking the margin
- 14:50pain today, while relying entirely on achieving these
- 14:54futuristic high margin successes in autonomy and energy storage
- 14:57to justify this extraordinary valuation.
- 15:00It's clearly a fundamentally strong business in many ways.
- 15:02Great brand, strong balance sheet now, but by no classic
- 15:06measure could you call it a value stock.
- 15:08I think that's fair and the ultimate insight maybe is that
- 15:11the massive gap between say our $81.00 per share base case value
- 15:15and the current $250 market price.
- 15:17That difference is the market's absolute expectation.
- 15:20It represents the bet on Elon Musk's non auto ventures
- 15:22eventually adding huge value and the almost certain belief that
- 15:25FSD will successfully monetize on a massive scale.
- 15:28If that core bet fails, well, the downside could be
- 15:30significant and maybe quite immediate.
- 15:32And that brings us to a final thought.
- 15:34The source material we reviewed noted how Tesla's unique
- 15:37structure relies so heavily on that Musk centric model for
- 15:40radical innovation. Will this aggressive pursuit of
- 15:44huge long term goals like achieving full FSD or colonizing
- 15:47Mars even eventually clash with a more mundane, fundamental need
- 15:51for better governance, deeper management structure as the
- 15:54company matures into potentially a trillion dollar entity?
- 15:58What happens when the CEO's attention is constantly pulled
- 16:00toward other highly demanding ventures, ventures that might
- 16:03pull capital, energy and focus away from the core automotive
- 16:07and energy businesses? That really feels like the high
- 16:10stakes gamble built into every share price today.
- 16:12Something definitely worth thinking about now.
- 16:14If you are interested in tracking things like total
- 16:16market temperature using frameworks similar to what we
- 16:18discussed like the Buffett Indicator, you can actually
- 16:21search and download the iOS app called Buffett Indicator right
- 16:24from the Apple App Store. It's a neat tool for context,
- 16:28and we really appreciate you joining us for this deep dive
- 16:31today. It was a complex 1.
- 16:33It certainly was OK one last time.
- 16:35This content is based on publicly available sources.
- 16:37It is for educational purposes only, and it does not constitute
- 16:41investment advice. Please always conduct your own
- 16:44due diligence before making any investment decisions.
- 16:47And if you want to hear more deep dives like this one, you
- 16:48can find our full archive by subscribing to us on Apple and
- 16:51Spotify podcasts. Just search for deep value
- 16:54investing. Thanks for listening.