Latest / Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer Podcasts / Public Law Podcast EP26: Getting procedure right: important lessons from recent cases
Transcript
- 0:09James Wood: Hello and thank you for joining us on this episode of the Public Law Podcast.
- 0:13James Wood: I'm James Wood, a partner in the Public Law and Regulatory Practice at HSF Kramer, and I'm joined today by my colleagues Jazvir Randawa and Antonia Smith, also in the Public Law and Regulatory team.
- 0:25James Wood: So in today's podcast, we'll discuss some recent High Court Courts of Appeal and Competition Appeal Tribunal decisions in the public law context, focusing in particular on cases where we've seen the courts and the tribunal grapple with procedural issues.
- 0:40James Wood: Now, you might be forgiven for thinking that a podcast on procedure sounds a little dry, but do bear with us because what should become apparent is that these points are really important, and getting them wrong can risk upsetting the court, and some of them can even be fatal to your case.
- 0:54James Wood: So a few of the cases later in the podcast will be of particular interest to businesses operating in sectors where subsidy control issues arise, and that's in sectors such as energy, transport, and real estate development.
- 1:07James Wood: But there's a real range, and other cases are in other contexts.
- 1:11James Wood: So all of the cases that we plan to talk about today go to the broader procedural theme for today's podcast.
- 1:18James Wood: And that's essentially what we're seeing from the courts is a clear insistence on getting the procedure right for both claimants and defendants.
- 1:26James Wood: And that theme is relevant to the whole spectrum of businesses and public authorities who might find themselves needing to litigate on a public law topic in the courts or tribunals.
- 1:36James Wood: So without any further ado, Jazz, can you take us through the first case?
- 1:40Jasveer Randhawa: Yeah, sure.
- 1:41Jasveer Randhawa: So the first decision was handed down by Mr.
- 1:44Jasveer Randhawa: Justice Chamberlain in the administrative court just a few weeks ago.
- 1:47Jasveer Randhawa: And it's Frye and Secretary of State for Defence.
- 1:51Jasveer Randhawa: I'm not going to go into too much detail on the substance of the claims.
- 1:54Jasveer Randhawa: Essentially, it concerns Afghan nationals seeking relocation to the UK.
- 1:59Jasveer Randhawa: But the procedural background was that there'd been lots of applications by the government for extensions of time to file evidence and other documents.
- 2:07Jasveer Randhawa: And many of those applications had been made after the expiry of the relevant deadline.
- 2:12Jasveer Randhawa: And the reasons given by the Secretary of State for seeking the extensions were basically vague, unparticularised, and unsupported by witness evidence.
- 2:21Jasveer Randhawa: And that was to such an extent that in the judgment, Mr.
- 2:24Jasveer Randhawa: Justice Chamberlain described the Secretary of State's team's conduct as characterised by an apparently total lack of planning or organisation.
- 2:33Jasveer Randhawa: And he said that they seem to have come to regard procedural directions as optional.
- 2:38Jasveer Randhawa: And he also described one of their applications for an extension as a textbook example of bad litigation practice.
- 2:45Jasveer Randhawa: So some really strong criticism there from a senior and well-respected judge who was clearly frustrated by the government's conduct.
- 2:53Jasveer Randhawa: And he talked about the intense strain that dealing with these kinds of repeated applications for extensions puts on the court's resources and the knock-on impact on other litigants.
- 3:04Jasveer Randhawa: Ultimately, in this case, a substantive hearing had to be moved to give the claimants and their representatives enough time to consider the new material provided by the Secretary of State.
- 3:15Jasveer Randhawa: And the government was ordered to pay the claimants' costs relating to the most recent delays on an indemnity basis, which is quite unusual.
- 3:24Jasveer Randhawa: So I think all of this really emphasises the importance of practical points, you know, being across your deadlines, not assuming necessarily that extensions will be granted, and if you are in a position where you have to seek an extension, providing proper reasons and potentially a witness statement.
- 3:40Jasveer Randhawa: I think this judgment makes it clear that without good reasons and evidence, your application may well be refused, and there could be some pretty harsh cost consequences.
- 3:50Jasveer Randhawa: The judgment also refers to a practice statement that was issued in March this year on applications for extensions of time.
- 3:58Jasveer Randhawa: And that explains that the court is just getting too many of these applications that are last minute and unsupported by evidence.
- 4:05Jasveer Randhawa: And there are some requirements in there around, for example, things like how to mark applications to ensure they're considered in the correct order of priority.
- 4:14Jasveer Randhawa: I'm not going to go into those in detail today, but I think it is just worth listeners being aware that that exists if they find themselves in that situation.
- 4:22Jasveer Randhawa: And of course, another really important document to be aware of is the admin court guide, which has fairly recently been updated for this year, and that contains very detailed rules on all aspects of judicial review procedure.
- 4:34Jasveer Randhawa: So again, a really important document to be consulting.
- 4:38Jasveer Randhawa: Finally, I think one interesting aspect of Fry, and it comes up in other recent cases as well, is that it's not only claimants who are being held to procedural standards.
- 4:48Jasveer Randhawa: We'll often talk about the latitude that the courts can give government and regulators when it comes to substantive decision making.
- 4:55Jasveer Randhawa: But I think these recent cases are making it clear that that shouldn't be confused with procedural latitude.
- 5:00Jasveer Randhawa: You know, just like claimants, and regardless of any kind of resourcing constraints, and that was a point that was mentioned by the government in Fry, but despite those sorts of issues, public authorities are expected to meet court deadlines.
- 5:14James Wood: Thanks, Jazz.
- 5:15James Wood: I think that's right, and it certainly comes across very clearly in that Frye case.
- 5:19James Wood: Another recent example is the case of EXR and the Secretary of State for the Home Department, number three, which is a recent judgment from the administrative court a couple of weeks ago.
- 5:30James Wood: And this case was also in the immigration context, but there were some findings in relation to the government's compliance with the duty of CANDAR, which I think are of broader relevance.
- 5:39James Wood: And so the duty of CANDAR is a duty on parties to judicial review proceedings to ensure that relevant information and material facts are before the court, whether helpful to their case or not, which in this case the court characterised as applying from the preaction stage onwards.
- 5:56James Wood: So in this EXR case, the Home Secretary was found to have committed serious breaches of the duty of CANDAR.
- 6:02James Wood: And one important breach related to a record on a central system called Atlas, which the judgment explains is the Home Office's caseworking system for managing immigration decisions.
- 6:14James Wood: And so Home Office guidance requires that all decisions of the kind this case was looking at be recorded on Atlas.
- 6:21James Wood: So you might think that Atlas would have been the first place the Home Office searched when it received the claimant's preaction correspondence.
- 6:28James Wood: But somehow this was missed in the circumstances of this case, along with some other relevant records and correspondence.
- 6:34James Wood: And this was despite uh requests from the claimant solicitors to the Home Office for all relevant documents.
- 6:40James Wood: And the judge noted that the consequences of the breaches of candor in this particular case could, in fact, have been disastrous.
- 6:47James Wood: So on three separate occasions, the claimant, an individual, could have been unlawfully removed from the UK.
- 6:54James Wood: And so the Home Secretary apologised to the court and has been ordered to file a witness statement explaining the breaches.
- 7:01James Wood: And I think it just shows us that the court is really clearly taking an active role here and expects a very thorough explanation as to how the government's breaches occurred.
- 7:10Jasveer Randhawa: Thanks, James.
- 7:11Jasveer Randhawa: And turning now to some procedural cases in another area under the Subsidy Control Act.
- 7:17Jasveer Randhawa: So this relatively new regime was initially quite slow to get off the ground, but it has definitely gained momentum this year.
- 7:24Jasveer Randhawa: We've seen some really important decisions from the CAT and for the first time the Court of Appeal under this regime.
- 7:31Jasveer Randhawa: And we'll focus today mainly on cases that fit with our procedural theme.
- 7:36Jasveer Randhawa: But if anyone is particularly interested, there is an article that you can access from our HSF Kramer Public Law Notes blog, which goes into other recent cases and just gives a bit more detail.
- 7:47Jasveer Randhawa: Antonia, do you want to take us through the subsidy control decisions?
- 7:50Jasveer Randhawa: Thanks, Jazz.
- 7:52Antonia Smith: A key procedural point arising from the recent subsidy judgments is timing.
- 7:57Antonia Smith: There's usually a one-month time limit for challenging a subsidy decision.
- 8:02Antonia Smith: But in the first of our subsidy cases, the new lottery company and the gambling commission, that didn't apply directly because the gambling commission didn't treat its decision, which was about allowing national lottery revenues to be used for marketing as a subsidy decision in the first place.
- 8:19Antonia Smith: The act is silent on what time limit should apply in those circumstances, but the CAT focused on the legislative intention for subsidy challenges to proceed quickly and held the applicant to the same time and it's by analogy.
- 8:33Antonia Smith: In this case, the CAT found that there was no subsidy for the purposes of the Act, but said that it would have refused relief due to delay in any event, the applicants having waited almost four months from becoming aware of the decision before filing their claim without explanation.
- 8:50Antonia Smith: On the flip side, another recent case, Thomas and Durham County Council, illustrates the risks of filing too early.
- 8:58Antonia Smith: There'd been various public statements to the effect that the council was planning to award the grants that were the subject of the claim, but it was common ground that no final decision had been taken.
- 9:09Antonia Smith: And the cat struck out the claim.
- 9:11Antonia Smith: It distinguished between a provisional or in principle decision to give a subsidy and a final decision to give it, and said that it might be possible for there to be a reviewable decision before formal legal documents are executed, but there must have been a final decision.
- 9:29Antonia Smith: Similar issues arose in Zenobi Energy Limited and the Gas and Electricity Markets Authority.
- 9:37Antonia Smith: The applicant argued that certain documents published by Offgem in the process of introducing a new cap and floor regime for energy storage, as well as a decision to adopt previous development work on the regime, constituted decisions to make a subsidy scheme.
- 9:53Antonia Smith: The CAT disagreed, noting that establishing the Cap and Floor regime was a multi-stage project, and the documents and decisions subject to challenge were steps in its wider development, undertaken with a view to the scheme being established at a later date, once a new legislative provision had come into force.
- 10:10Antonia Smith: The application was dismissed.
- 10:13Antonia Smith: Unhelpfully, there's some inconsistency between Thomas and another earlier decision.
- 10:19Antonia Smith: So aspects of the law are still a bit up in the air, and the CAT acknowledged that the question as to whether a final decision has been taken will be fact-specific.
- 10:29Antonia Smith: I think it's worth saying as well that this is issue isn't unique to the subsidy control context.
- 10:36Antonia Smith: Whether there's been a final decision which can be the subject of a challenge comes up frequently in our work on cases in the administrative court across all sectors and contexts.
- 10:45Antonia Smith: And it can be quite tricky for claimants to identify when, or indeed if, time has started to run.
- 10:51Antonia Smith: Especially when there's a m significant multistage project and or a lengthy history of consultations, government announcements, etc.
- 10:59Antonia Smith: The limitation period that applies in an ordinary, so to speak, judicial review, which is promptly and in any event within three months, is enforced strictly by the administrative court.
- 11:12Antonia Smith: And you can see that in some factual scenarios there's a tension for claimants between ensuring that a final decision has been taken so that they're not filing too early, but also that they're not risking filing too late.
- 11:25Antonia Smith: And as I mentioned, the limitation period becomes even shorter in the subsidy control context at just one month.
- 11:32Antonia Smith: And it's clear that the CAT is taking a similarly strict approach.
- 11:36Antonia Smith: So limitation continues to be a really important point for claimants in the administrative court and the CAT to have at the forefront of their minds.
- 11:44Antonia Smith: Another theme which emerges from recent subsidy control decisions concerns the proper role of the courts in the subsidy control context.
- 11:55Antonia Smith: The Court of Appeal looked at this when it handed down its first decision under the new subsidy control regime earlier this year in Vice and the Greater Manchester Combined Authority.
- 12:05Antonia Smith: The question for the court was whether the cat had failed to review an alleged subsidy decision properly by making its own determination afresh as to whether the loans which were the subject of the claim constituted a subsidy, with the cat ultimately finding that the loans were not a subsidy.
- 12:23Antonia Smith: The Court of Appeal upheld the Cat's decision, explaining that as a matter of statutory construction, it's for the cat to determine whether a public authority has given a subsidy so that it can satisfy itself that it has jurisdiction under the Act before it reviews whether the decision was made in line with public law principles.
- 12:44Antonia Smith: The Court of Appeal rejected an argument that public authorities are better equipped than courts or tribunals to determine whether there's been a subsidy, noting that this isn't a policy issue, but it's an objective question which the cat is well equipped to answer.
- 13:01Antonia Smith: The court was, however, clear that the decision to give a subsidy in the first place, as opposed to whether there's been a relevant subsidy for the purposes of the Subsidy Control Act, remains with the public authority because, for example, it involves consideration of policy objectives.
- 13:18Antonia Smith: That decision is subject only to review on traditional public law grounds.
- 13:24Antonia Smith: And the same point has been echoed in other cases this year, such as Bristol Airport and Welsh Ministers and the new lottery case I mentioned.
- 13:32Antonia Smith: It's worth noting that Bristol Airport was granted permission to appeal to the Court of Appeal just last week.
- 13:38Antonia Smith: So that's certainly a case to keep an eye on in the subsidy control context.
- 13:43James Wood: Thanks, Antonia.
- 13:44James Wood: So I think standing back, what's what's apparent to me from all of these cases is the courts and the tribunals' expectations when it comes to getting procedure right.
- 13:52James Wood: And that includes things like filing deadlines will be strictly enforced, applications for extensions should be supported by cogent reasons and evidence and won't necessarily be granted.
- 14:03James Wood: Compliance with the duty of candidate will be monitored really closely.
- 14:07James Wood: Claimants should think about when to bring their claim very carefully.
- 14:11James Wood: I think the list goes on.
- 14:12James Wood: And at first blush, I think some of these points can seem quite straightforward, but we know there can be an awful lot for parties to think about on both the substance and the procedure.
- 14:21James Wood: And sometimes, and I think as you've mentioned, Antonia, that has to happen very quickly given the relevant limitation periods.
- 14:28James Wood: So on that basis, uh, we hope that this run-through has been helpful for those who might find themselves in a position of needing to consider these issues when putting together or defending a claim, perhaps in really short order.
- 14:40James Wood: And Jazz or Antonia, unless there's anything further to add, I think that's the end of our podcast today.
- 14:46Jasveer Randhawa: Yeah, nothing further from me.
- 14:47Jasveer Randhawa: Thanks, James.
- 14:48James Wood: Nami.
- 14:48Antonia Smith: Thanks, James, and thanks, listeners.