Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E011: Multigenerational Security for Bitcoin with Matt McClintock
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop, and
- 0:04we're going to be left holding the biggest bag of bodarous
- 0:07extras ever assembled in the history of doubtless 19.
- 0:13Seventy 419-8790, 297-2000. Whatever we want to call this,
- 0:19it's all just the same thing over and over.
- 0:21We can't. Help ourselves, I say, when we.
- 0:24Sell hey, I say when we sell. Gentlemen, what a week.
- 0:32It's been a lot going on in the markets.
- 0:36Not going to lie, I'm a little bit tired.
- 0:37Took a trip up to New York to check out what's going on at pub
- 0:40Key. We had a great minding meet up
- 0:41last night. I'm excited to end the the week
- 0:45of recording with this discussion.
- 0:46We're joined by the Executive Manning Director.
- 0:49Managing Director, excuse me, of Bespoke Group, Matt Mcclintock.
- 0:53Matt, thank you for joining us today.
- 0:56Yeah, absolutely. Thanks a lot.
- 0:57Thanks for having me. I'm really excited to dive into
- 1:02what you're doing at Bespoke Group.
- 1:04I think it's actually a great, this will be a great followup
- 1:07conversation to the episode recorded this week with Morgan
- 1:11Rashard. But before we jump into that,
- 1:13like I said, there's been a lot going on in the macroeconomic
- 1:18landscape this week. And so I'll rattle off a few of
- 1:21the headlines that are top of mind for me and then I'll just
- 1:23throw it to the board here to begin discussing them.
- 1:28So last Friday we had the Bank of Japan make a a questionable
- 1:33policy move sort of changing their strategy when it comes to
- 1:37yield curve control. That sent the J, GB markets into
- 1:41a bit of hysteria and the yen was pumping against the dollar.
- 1:45We had Fitch come out earlier this week and downgrade the US
- 1:51is credit rating from AAA to AA plus at the same time the
- 1:55Treasury unfortunately for them came and announced that they're
- 2:00they're planning on issuing $1.85 trillion worth of debt
- 2:04throughout the rest of this year.
- 2:05And at the same time we have interest payments on the debt
- 2:11that we've accrued here in the US approaching a trillion
- 2:14dollars and WTI crude ripping above 80 bucks.
- 2:19I think it was sitting around $83 today the last time I
- 2:22checked. So all those headlines mind the
- 2:26narrative that is really been getting stronger and stronger in
- 2:31the mainstream which is that it seems like the Fed is going to
- 2:34be able to to execute a soft landing here With all those
- 2:39headlines of mind, what do you guys think about the the
- 2:42probability of a soft landing materializing on the back end of
- 2:46these these interest rate hikes that the Fed's been on?
- 2:51Really really low in my book it's it's kind of it's a little
- 2:57frustrating to to you know Marty I'm sure you experienced this
- 3:01where you write about something you're trying to draw attention
- 3:06to it week after week month after month and and then you
- 3:11know a year later it starts to play out and everybody's
- 3:14surprised by it and and you're like well I've I've been trying
- 3:17to talk about how. This is going to happen and and
- 3:21this is kind of the position that I've been in this week of
- 3:25like I, you know the the math on the national debt and where it
- 3:29all points to has been out of my North Star.
- 3:36In terms of why the US dollar is going to continue to erode at an
- 3:40accelerating rate and why Bitcoin makes a ton of sense.
- 3:44More sense than ever in this current economic.
- 3:48Climate and and future outlook. And it's it's happening now.
- 3:54You know you you can't. You can't go from zero interest
- 3:59rates from the Fed for a decade and then suddenly Jack up
- 4:04interest rates to five plus percent, knowing that the
- 4:09national debt will have to roll over what interest rates apply
- 4:15to the national debt. Such that you're 30 plus
- 4:19trillion dollars of national debt eventually roll over to a
- 4:235% interest rate, which means $1.5 trillion of interest
- 4:27expense. When you're already running $2
- 4:29trillion of annual deficit and that's been normalized over the
- 4:33last 20 years, you can't have that happen and it not point to
- 4:38the bond market falling apart. And the continuing erosion of
- 4:44the US dollar, it's just finally happening and arriving in the
- 4:47mainstream. Yeah, I think I got that,
- 4:57Michael. I was just, I just anchor.
- 4:59You know there's these different takes.
- 5:01We fall on different sides of the curve where Jesse gets in
- 5:03the math. I just think back to Parkers
- 5:05just pretty much debt, not enough dollars.
- 5:07It's been like this and they have to continue to print it.
- 5:09Everything's bound to break because you have to continue to
- 5:12deploy more and more dollars into the system, hence inflation
- 5:16and just a matter of time between these little like cracks
- 5:19starting to show up in fissure and then we consistently see it
- 5:23every 36912 months. Shit breaks and everybody's like
- 5:26what happened and it's like we've been saying it the whole
- 5:28time. And and Japan is looking to our
- 5:33future too. Like Japan is just a little
- 5:35further along in this in this late stage Fiat process, they've
- 5:41had to embark on yield curve control.
- 5:43They approached it in a terrible way because they drew a line,
- 5:46They drew a line so low that on their interest rate graph and
- 5:52then the Fed has like quickly. You know raise rates way beyond
- 5:57that. So now when you draw a line
- 5:59you're you're beholden to defending that line and not
- 6:03allowing the free market to play out which is a terrible position
- 6:07to be in and and we're seeing that breaking with the the yen
- 6:13being the release valve for it all.
- 6:16So you know, if you want to know what's going to happen to all
- 6:20Fiat currencies eventually. Just look at what has been the
- 6:24trajectory of Japan over the last 10 years and then imagine
- 6:27that on a kind of compressed timeline, it maybe some
- 6:30countries they collapse way faster US, maybe it's the same
- 6:35rate, but yeah, that's that's the next decade for us.
- 6:41I think Japan provides some lessons, but I think there's
- 6:45some key difference, some key differences.
- 6:47I mean, the US is, you know? Much more important on the
- 6:51global scale, it's a much larger economy.
- 6:54But one certain case in point is just the aging population in the
- 6:59USI don't know. I think that in some cases I
- 7:05tend to agree, Marty, that a soft landing is impossible.
- 7:11On the other hand, I would not underestimate Washington's
- 7:14ability to financial engineer something that just continues to
- 7:17kick the can down the road. I don't think that argues
- 7:22against Bitcoin as the pristine store of value because it allows
- 7:28people to save wealth and kind of build up value in non-us
- 7:31dollar denominated terms. But you know, I kind of ascribed
- 7:36to this theory that yeah, all Fiat currencies are are broken
- 7:41and corrupt at their core. It's just that I think the US is
- 7:45probably the strongest of a terrible system and I think
- 7:48we're going to see. Other economies fall on much
- 7:51harder terms before the US, before the US follows suit.
- 7:56I think that one of the things that's been really interesting
- 7:59to see is the BRICS nations really starting to denominate
- 8:05trade agreements outside of the US dollars.
- 8:08So I wonder if we're starting to see a faster erosion of the US
- 8:11dollar system, excuse me, the the euro dollar system, which
- 8:16can then begin to undermine the. U.S.
- 8:20Dollar as a global reserve currency.
- 8:24Yep, absolutely big part of it you reminded me of Greg Foss
- 8:29likes to say that the US, the US dollar looks like the the best
- 8:34looking horse at the glue factory say it's ultimately it's
- 8:41not going to matter too much but for now it's it's in the best
- 8:44shape and. It's great to have auction,
- 8:48Yeah. And I actually, I listened to a
- 8:50podcast and actually the Galaxy Brains podcast that Alex Thorne
- 8:54has from Galaxy Digital, and one of his recent guests works for
- 8:58one of the chain of analytics companies.
- 9:00But he was telling an anecdote about the shipping vessels that
- 9:04sit off the coast of South America, different countries,
- 9:08Ecuador being one of them. They fish the land and then they
- 9:12smuggle goods into the country too.
- 9:14But he was saying that via their analytics, they were able to
- 9:18find that they're actually sort of doing what the US did in the
- 9:2270s after we went out the gold standard began flooding markets
- 9:26with dollars for goods across the world, he said.
- 9:31They're seeing that with the digital yuan in places like
- 9:34Ecuador where there's communities in Ecuador beginning
- 9:37to transact with the digital yuan as the Chinese are sort of
- 9:42integrate it into their economy via these fishing vessels, which
- 9:46I thought was very interesting and is again like sort of
- 9:50trifens, the land playing out. But instead of the dollar
- 9:54flooding international markets with dollars, seems like the
- 9:57Chinese in some form or another, maybe on a very small scale at
- 10:01this particular point in time. Or doing that with Yuan which
- 10:05would play into that thesis you just described Matt, where it
- 10:09seems like the dollars dominance is waning.
- 10:16And then on top of that too like going back to like all these
- 10:19headlines and the soft landing. I agree.
- 10:23I think the Fed will find a way to create these facilities and
- 10:26kick the can down the road. But in terms of like having egg
- 10:29on their face, I think the really the signal here is
- 10:32everything going on in the bond markets and then you have WT I3
- 10:37means the same time which with CPI from June being a 3.3%,
- 10:42we'll find out what it was in July Eker too.
- 10:47But when we get the August number next month, I think it's
- 10:50going to be surprising especially if WTI stays
- 10:53elevated, it even rises more and then the situation in the bond
- 10:57markets continues to deteriorate and then the Feds forced to
- 11:00pause in September, remember they don't have a meeting this
- 11:03month. So I think we could find
- 11:05ourselves in a scenario where especially oil ribs like it
- 11:09becomes pretty obvious that inflation hasn't been tamed and
- 11:12that actually materializes in CPI and that's just like big egg
- 11:16on the face for Jerome Powell. And I guess that's the big
- 11:19question at that point does the psychological, does the psyche
- 11:24of of people using the dollar begin to change like holy crap,
- 11:27they they just did all those interest rate hikes and they
- 11:30actually didn't tame inflation as well as they were.
- 11:32They were saying they did. Yeah, it is very notable that
- 11:40you talked about a few things there already like price of
- 11:43oil's up. Gold is reacting positively to
- 11:46this this week. That means that you know, people
- 11:53are are fleeing from bonds. Bill Ackman is betting that
- 12:00yields are going to go to 5.5% for 30 year U.S.
- 12:03Treasuries. Billionaire.
- 12:08Big personality and that that's that's a big bet and I wrote
- 12:14about this recently, this the bondholders burning platform.
- 12:18The math just doesn't add up. Bill Ackman's bet is more medium
- 12:23term based. He thinks that inflation is
- 12:25going to be sticky and it's here to stay basically.
- 12:29And and then, you know, I come back to the the 70s and the 30s
- 12:34and 40s. We had three waves of inflation.
- 12:38Did we just go through you know one up and down and and we're
- 12:42finding some sort of base here before the next structural set
- 12:47of inflation comes because specifically because the with
- 12:53interest rates going up. So fast.
- 12:56So over the last 18 months, the bodies are going to start
- 13:00showing up more and more. Now the banking crisis I think
- 13:03is not over. It's kind of more on pause.
- 13:06The bodies start to show up. the Fed has to print to stimulate us
- 13:10out of this. And then you get that situation
- 13:13where the Matt's talking about of it.
- 13:17It looks like a soft landing because they print so much, They
- 13:22print so much that markets start to go up again quickly.
- 13:25In order to try to paper over the the real harm that has been
- 13:29caused to to the actual economy in terms of businesses going
- 13:35bankrupt and and and job losses starting to materialize more.
- 13:42So you print a bunch to make it look like everything's fine, but
- 13:46that triggers inflation. So, you know, they've painted
- 13:49themselves into a corner. And and it's just a matter of
- 13:54time until the shoe drops. But when the shoe drops, it
- 13:58won't look like it's dropping because they'll print so much
- 14:00money. It'll look like it.
- 14:01It's floating in midair, you know, like I think that's the
- 14:05how this manifests in in reality.
- 14:08But when you're messing with the measuring stick, when you're
- 14:14messing with what a dollar is because you're printing so much
- 14:17of it. There's no way around it like
- 14:22that is an era of economic destruction.
- 14:27If you're using that as your unit of account, if you're
- 14:30holding those, that asset. And that means if you're holding
- 14:34actual dollars or if you're holding bonds, which are
- 14:36promises of future dollars. And in that context, gold, hard
- 14:42assets, gold land, Bitcoin do well.
- 14:50It's interesting cuz we keep talking.
- 14:51We talked about this with Dylan about the different CPI metrics
- 14:54and all these different ways to measure.
- 14:56And we talked about like the coast and the news and there's
- 14:59things that are happening on CNN versus what's happening in the
- 15:01real world. And I think about in the same
- 15:03example of Jesse, you reference the bodies and like we know the
- 15:06bodies are everywhere. If you look they're like just
- 15:08like sitting there there was this there was not to you but
- 15:12just in general like it's all the signs are there in a macro
- 15:15and micro scale. There was a recent, if you guys
- 15:18remember 21, I think it was late 20, but 21 during COVID there
- 15:22was a company called Hoppin that was like software like we're on
- 15:25right now, you know web video for you know basically to take
- 15:31what happened in physical world when it came to conferences and
- 15:34put online, it was a multibillion dollar firm.
- 15:35I think at the highest point they raised that close to $7
- 15:38billion. On the valuation side, they
- 15:41raised over a billion dollars in in venture capital.
- 15:44And they just sold like the past week for a couple $100 million
- 15:48to RingCentral and they took the capital and they, you know, kind
- 15:52of dispersed it to the venture of, you know, pennies on the
- 15:56dollar. I think the CEO, you know, he
- 15:58made out like a bandit. He sold on secondaries.
- 16:01But the point in all that is like there's a big body there
- 16:04when you think about the amount of dollars destroyed, the trust
- 16:07from an LP to the venture side, the the valuation that was at
- 16:10that time, people took those dollars and went and bought cars
- 16:13and all the things from an employee standpoint, those
- 16:14people out of jobs. Now that inflation is running
- 16:16that, you know, capital amount of capital chasing fixed goods,
- 16:20whether it's oil, cars, whatever Bitcoin.
- 16:23But that's just like one example that's all over the place.
- 16:26And you reference Jesse Gold. Bitcoin and land.
- 16:30And it's fascinating because you talk about bonds, we talk about,
- 16:34you know venture all these different asset classes that
- 16:37people are traditionally like put whether they're you know
- 16:40their mutual fund or if they're a very high net worth
- 16:42individual. It's going into private equity
- 16:43via venture, other assets. So where do you park it if you
- 16:47know all these things, if you know that like there's bodies
- 16:50continue to pile up but you don't know where the actual
- 16:52trade is. And you see this also like
- 16:53Russia season 300 billion in treasuries.
- 16:57It all just like points to these things that are are foundational
- 17:00and Golden Land have been that for thousands of years.
- 17:02And it's easy and it's like if you put the time and you start
- 17:05to recognize bitcoins right up there and it's kind of crazy to
- 17:07think about, right because it's like a 13 year old asset.
- 17:10But it's like where else would we feel good Just personally
- 17:12people on this call outside of the three things we mentioned,
- 17:16maybe a few others that you know, you can touch, feel, grab,
- 17:19move at a moment. I mean, I guess you can't move
- 17:21the land, but you have other assurances around it.
- 17:24It's just a fascinating situation to be in because
- 17:26everybody would think that that's that's insane.
- 17:27But the reality is there is only so many things that I think
- 17:30anybody on this call will feel comfortable in parking, you know
- 17:33their wealth in. Well, I think that's that's a
- 17:36critical point because it's a matter of how do you store value
- 17:39versus what do you use it as a medium exchange.
- 17:42I know a lot of times we talked about this in the broader
- 17:43context of Bitcoin, but I mean, there's so many things that
- 17:48Jesse, you kind of particularly zeroed in on that I think are
- 17:51worth kind of digging in on. A little bit, because I was kind
- 17:55of making some notes on this. I I mean, look, we're looking at
- 18:00the largest generational transfer of wealth in the
- 18:03history of the world, and it's underway right now as the
- 18:06enormous baby boom population begins to die, transition their
- 18:10wealth to younger people. Sometimes they're old folks like
- 18:14Gen. Xers like me, but then more like
- 18:17more than likely it's Gen. Z and Millennials that are on
- 18:20the receiving end of this. There is a natural tendency for
- 18:25younger adults, kind of the, what I would call the inheriting
- 18:28class now, to be interested in 21st century assets.
- 18:32They're already used to a global world, They're already used to a
- 18:35digital world. A digital store of value is much
- 18:39more logical for a lot of the inheriting class then a lump of
- 18:43gold, a brokerage account, a piece of real estate that
- 18:47nobody's ever visit visited in a long time.
- 18:49So there's there's already this shift underway.
- 18:54Another thing I kind of wanted to 0 in on a little bit is
- 18:59again, things, things are just different now, which which
- 19:02undermines, I think, the likelihood of a true soft
- 19:06landing. I mean, I believe that like the,
- 19:09you know, the historian Neil Ferguson wrote a book called
- 19:11Colossus years ago, and it's basically documenting the the
- 19:15death of an empire. And it you don't have to be a
- 19:18genius to figure out, he's basically talking about the
- 19:20American empire coming to an end.
- 19:22This book was years ago, but look at it.
- 19:26We've got the gerontocracy class that occupies all the seats of
- 19:30power. And from the White House through
- 19:33both seats of Congress, through a lot of the, you know, a lot of
- 19:36the legislators across the country, we're generally
- 19:39speaking, we're ruled by a bunch of septagenarians and
- 19:42octogenarians. And not only is it a
- 19:44gerontocracy like our friend. Nick Carter talks about it's
- 19:48also what I refer to, what the the better word for I think is
- 19:51kakistocracy. And if you look that up, a
- 19:54kakistocracy is ruling by the least fit and most incompetent
- 19:58class within a society. I think that's kind of where we
- 20:01are. And if you look at it, you look
- 20:04at where the innovation and regulations are taking place,
- 20:08the innovation in legislation is taking place.
- 20:11It's not here. It's not the United States.
- 20:13It's in places like Switzerland. It's in places like Singapore.
- 20:17It's in places like Dubai. And what do we see as a result?
- 20:19Well, naturally we're seeing outflows of capital and outflows
- 20:23of talent, and that is a sign of a dying Republic.
- 20:27So unless and until we get a significant change in leadership
- 20:32really kind of across the board throughout this country, I think
- 20:36the United States is going to be entering an era where we're
- 20:38trailing economically from a policy perspective and from a
- 20:42talent perspective. And I think all of that stuff
- 20:45argues against the idea of a long of a long term bullish
- 20:51outlook on American hegemony. You know, back in the 70s and
- 20:55even the 80s, we had the undisputed most powerful
- 20:59military in the world and we had the undisputed global reserve
- 21:02currency. But now we see that as being
- 21:05eroded farther and farther as time progresses.
- 21:09And now we sit here, you know, in the first third of the 21st
- 21:12century, and there are significant fissures in the
- 21:16foundation on which American power is built.
- 21:20And so I'm afraid that if we don't find a way to provide some
- 21:25freedom and flexibility in how Bitcoin digital assets, other
- 21:31innovation is built, going to something that more represents a
- 21:35sound monetary policy than just this print our way out of any
- 21:40disaster we can think of. But I'm afraid that we're we're
- 21:43beginning to see the longterm decline of of a Republic.
- 21:48Yeah, absolutely. I always think about the
- 21:52intransigent minority concept of I I'm with you.
- 21:58I think that the, the only way that we can save the Republic
- 22:02from the inevitable decline that comes from having been the world
- 22:05reserve currency. You know, like I think about
- 22:09what has happened to. The UK over the last 100 years,
- 22:13they were the world reserve currency going into World War
- 22:17Two and and then that was kind of their last gasp of of
- 22:22dominance, you know World War One really and and fading away
- 22:29and since then it's been kind of a story of slow erosion of their
- 22:34global standing and and that's our fate too unless we can.
- 22:40Hitch our wagon to something that has eternal staying power
- 22:46economically and and can't be eroded in the way that, you
- 22:50know, a national currency can be eroded because of taking on too
- 22:53much debt by printing, you know, U.S.
- 22:56Treasuries. And so Bitcoin becomes this
- 23:01existential hope, this hope for for the American endeavor that
- 23:07we can. Ride this thing by just waking
- 23:12up enough people to the economic reality of what's going on and
- 23:15what drives Bitcoin to higher and higher over time.
- 23:21And so if you can get to that tipping point of the
- 23:23intransigent minority, which is a tiny portion of the population
- 23:28but a loud and vocal portion of the population believing in
- 23:32something such that they can influence policy of of the
- 23:36whole. And and that's something like 10
- 23:40million US bitcoiners. So you know 130th of the
- 23:44population holding Bitcoin, believing in it, understanding
- 23:49it and seeing it as a way to build a brighter future for
- 23:53America. How far away are we from that
- 23:56we're that's that's within a decade's reach I think.
- 24:00And if we can get there, we can hopefully shape policy enough
- 24:06to. Do what RFK is floating.
- 24:09You know, RFK Junior is floating this ridiculous idea of what if
- 24:12we back a small percentage of our national debt with hard
- 24:15assets like Bitcoin? And it's a ridiculous idea right
- 24:18now, but that Overton window shifts.
- 24:21And you know, this is a fringe political character saying it
- 24:24right now, but there's substance to it.
- 24:28And if we, as bitcoiners, loudly encourage this kind of
- 24:34conversation? That fringe idea can
- 24:37increasingly become a mainstream idea as politicians receive
- 24:42positive feedback for talking about it.
- 24:44And hopefully we can, you know, converge on having enough
- 24:48American Bitcoiners loudly advocating for Bitcoin and
- 24:54politicians seeing this receptive audience, this
- 24:57energized audience, and catering to them.
- 25:01Such that we can find some way to shore up America's fiscal
- 25:05position by incorporating Bitcoin into our financial
- 25:10landscape in a more deep way. That's that's the way where
- 25:15that's the the path forward where the US doesn't fade into
- 25:21obsolescence and instead retains its power on the global stage.
- 25:31Piggybacking on that, This is why we brought Matt on the show
- 25:35this week, because I think what you and your team at Bespoke are
- 25:38doing to sort of empower that intransient minority that's
- 25:41getting getting larger is extremely important.
- 25:44I think the discussion that myself, Michael and you had
- 25:48earlier this week was extremely illuminating to me because I
- 25:50think your approach and your perspective and how seriously
- 25:55Bitcoiners should be taking their their holdings.
- 25:58And protecting it over time is going to be imperative to have
- 26:02successful and transient minority in the long run.
- 26:05So I think this is a good jumping off point to talk a
- 26:08little bit about your history, Matt, why you started Bespoken
- 26:12and how you guys are sort of integrating yourself into the
- 26:15world of Bitcoin. Yeah, I mean I think this is
- 26:19stuff that we're seeing all the time.
- 26:22So just as a maybe a quick background on a practicing
- 26:25attorney, my my focus and my career has entirely been around
- 26:30wealth transfer structures. So kind of broadly under the
- 26:34umbrella of estate planning but with an I not just towards what
- 26:39happens to my stuff when I die, but how do I then pass my wealth
- 26:45on? Well, I guess first of all, how
- 26:47do I structure it in tax efficient ways that are private,
- 26:51that are protected from potential creditors, that may
- 26:55seek to separate me from this wealth that I've built?
- 26:59And when it does, when I do pass away, how do I pass on my
- 27:04wealth, however modest or vast it might be?
- 27:07How do I pass that on to the people I care about in ways that
- 27:11set them up to become the best versions of themselves?
- 27:14So that whatever I saved for however many Sats I stacked or
- 27:18whatever during my lifetime, now it's time to give that to
- 27:22somebody else. How do I make sure that I give
- 27:24it to them in a way that is tax efficient, that protects them
- 27:28from bad decisions and maybe you know self destruction often?
- 27:34How do I help them not be vulnerable to have that well
- 27:37taken away from them and voluntarily from somebody else.
- 27:41And so that's that's been the essence of my career in 2017.
- 27:46Well, I guess you know as I've because I've been doing this for
- 27:48a long time, I've got a very broad focus in that world.
- 27:53The vast majority of my clients are highly affluent.
- 27:56So we're doing a lot of tax mitigation planning whether it's
- 27:59capital gains tax or gift and estate tax planning, but it's
- 28:05also kind of multi jurisdictional in scope.
- 28:08So we're we're based in Evergreen Co, but we've got
- 28:11clients literally all over the country.
- 28:13We've got a handful of clients around the world, and so in 2017
- 28:19I got introduced to a client prospect.
- 28:23I guess at the time, they've had about $150 million worth of
- 28:27Bitcoin. So kind of OG quality type of
- 28:30person. And as you might imagine, you
- 28:34know, they're dealing with a significant amount of wealth.
- 28:36They're dealing with massive estate tax liability if they
- 28:40were to die. And even beyond that, they're
- 28:43dealing with the complexity of managing an asset like Bitcoin.
- 28:47That's a heavily concentrated position in their estate that is
- 28:52complicated for somebody to inherit in a way that they
- 28:54understand what it is and how to do it, what to do with it.
- 28:58And so they kind of exposed me to the edge of the rabbit hole,
- 29:01if you will, because at the time, Bitcoin was nowhere on my
- 29:04radar. But then I had this epiphany as
- 29:07I was talking with this person who would become a client.
- 29:10I had this epiphany that if we can figure out how to
- 29:13substantiate the owner, the change of ownership from an
- 29:17individual to a tax advantaged type of trust structure or other
- 29:22type of entity structure. If we can figure out the
- 29:24mechanics of of ownership, then every single strategy we've ever
- 29:29done for decades is on the table with the same stuff that we've
- 29:32done for private equity, venture real estate, equities, gold,
- 29:37whatever. That's all on the table.
- 29:39If we can simply figure out how to put Bitcoin in a trust of
- 29:43some sort to then get these benefits that we're looking for.
- 29:47And so I did some really interesting work for that
- 29:51client. And because of my background is,
- 29:53you know, I've done a ton of education through the years
- 29:56where I'm a presenter in continuing education for other
- 29:59professionals. I started teaching, you know,
- 30:01how do you do estate planning with Bitcoin?
- 30:05And there was a lot of interest in that topic.
- 30:08And so before long, we started getting more and more clients
- 30:10that had significant Bitcoin positions.
- 30:13I mean like massive, massive Bitcoin positions and it kind of
- 30:19allowed us to then pivot our practice largely towards that
- 30:22focus. And so on the law firm side,
- 30:24we've continued to do complex legal structuring for clients
- 30:28who have significant Bitcoin positions as well as other
- 30:31significant asset positions. But then an increasing number of
- 30:35those clients were wanting additional services that were
- 30:38beyond the scope of what the law firm is designed to do.
- 30:41We also saw an opportunity to take that to scale as an
- 30:44independent enterprise. So we still do have the law
- 30:47firm, Evergreen Legacy Planning is the name of that
- 30:50organization. But Bespoke Group became a a
- 30:54multifamily office really specifically serving highly
- 30:58affluent clients with significant Bitcoin positions.
- 31:02And so we are a registered investment advisory.
- 31:05We've got an RIA inside the Bespoke group and within Bespoke
- 31:10in addition to helping shepherd the clients strategies over
- 31:15time, helping them get the most out of the legal strategies that
- 31:19they have whether we set them up or some other law firm set them
- 31:21up. But we also facilitate qualified
- 31:25custody of their Bitcoin as long as well as their gold, their
- 31:29equities, their Fiat assets whether that's qualified custody
- 31:32with with custodians here in the US or offshore.
- 31:35So we can do qualified custody for Bitcoin as well as pretty
- 31:39much any other asset, whether it's in Singapore, whether it's
- 31:42in Liechtenstein, whether it's in Switzerland, so whether it's
- 31:48in Canada, we can we can support that.
- 31:50So clients can actually now hold Bitcoin along with their other
- 31:55assets in title held structures that are not on a financial
- 31:59institutions balance sheet that are in non-us dollar denominated
- 32:05terms, so they can get some dedollarization of their Bitcoin
- 32:08positions as well as whatever else.
- 32:11And so it's been really an interesting ride.
- 32:15So I mean that's what we do, you know, we're law firm on the one
- 32:18side and then we're the multifamily office on the other.
- 32:21And I would say that, you know, we don't believe that there is
- 32:24such a thing as an expert really in anything, but we're, you
- 32:27know, pretty damn good at what we do.
- 32:31Yeah, I would. I would go as far as saying you
- 32:33guys are experts. I I'll embarrass you a little
- 32:35bit on this pod. I used to do it in in meetings
- 32:37back in in chain where I would, you know, tell folks were
- 32:40talking to you about Bitcoin finance.
- 32:42It's like there may be somebody that knows the Fed better.
- 32:44There may be somebody that knows Bitcoin better, but there's
- 32:47nobody on the planet Earth, and I'd point to progresses that
- 32:49knows Bitcoin and the Fed better the combined.
- 32:52And I would kind of put you in that same realm when it comes to
- 32:55the work that you guys do on complex estate planning.
- 32:58And Bitcoin, because it's still so early and as we're seeing
- 33:01that's where a lot of alpha and opportunity exists because you
- 33:03mirror these two like disparate things, you put them together
- 33:07and then the market has been asking for them and you end up
- 33:09being a leader and then you can pave the way.
- 33:11And so that's where we've been really excited to have you on
- 33:13and share the message and I think it's important like that.
- 33:17You you well, you work with very large and affluent clients.
- 33:20It's always been since I've known you your interest in
- 33:23sharing the knowledge and information because you have
- 33:25that asymmetry. And it's important not just for
- 33:27a fluent it's important for me, Marty, Jesse, just the mere
- 33:30plebs that have small small stacks to protect it outside of
- 33:35certain liabilities or things that could happen.
- 33:38And so maybe that's a good way to kind of dive into how it's
- 33:40important from across spectrums. I think that was something I was
- 33:43ignorant to is. Estate tax and what that means
- 33:46if we passed away and how that's changing or how do we like just
- 33:49actually plan for revocable, irrevocable trust and why that
- 33:52matters? Maybe if you talk a little bit
- 33:54about that could be good, yeah. And Matt, I hear there's
- 33:58something changing about a state tax or or some threshold.
- 34:02If you want to touch on that too.
- 34:03Yeah, I'll, I'll probably touch on that first.
- 34:06That's probably the easiest. There's a builtin expiration
- 34:09date on the tax law. In 2017, President Trump signed
- 34:14the 2017 Tax Act, and what that did is that doubled the federal
- 34:19estate tax exemption from $5 million per taxpayer to $10
- 34:24million per taxpayer. And every year that value gets
- 34:27adjusted for inflation. So this year an individual in
- 34:33the United States can pass up to $12.92 million worth of whatever
- 34:39wealth they've got to their beneficiaries without any
- 34:44federal estate tax at all. Now there may be a separate
- 34:47state level estate tax, but from a federal estate tax
- 34:52perspective, 12.92 per taxpayer. So that means a married couple
- 34:58can pass up to 25.84 million without having to worry about
- 35:03the federal estate tax. So I mean obviously the vast
- 35:06majority of people in the United States don't have an estate tax
- 35:10problem, but the nature of these tax bills, these revenue bills
- 35:15that get enacted, is there some kind of, there's a wonky
- 35:18provision I'm going to go into, but they they all end up with an
- 35:21expiration date called a sunset date or a sunset provision,
- 35:25which means that this law that went into effect in 2017 expires
- 35:3212/31 of 2025. So what that means is Congress,
- 35:37without lifting a finger, without doing anything at all,
- 35:41the law will automatically revert on January 1, 2026.
- 35:47We're going to wake up on New Year's Day with a raging
- 35:51hangover and it's going to hurt even worse because we know that
- 35:54our estate tax exemption just got cut in half.
- 35:57So we're going to wake up January 1 of 2026 and the
- 36:00exemption has been cut from 10 million plus inflation to
- 36:045,000,000 plus inflation and the first dollar over the exemption
- 36:10amount, whether that's today or in 2026, the first dollar gets
- 36:14taxed at $0.40 on the dollar. So it's a it's a usurious level
- 36:19of tax in my opinion. I doubt I'm going to get a whole
- 36:22lot of resistance from this crowd, but the it's a very high
- 36:26tax rate. The the reality is there's a lot
- 36:30of kind of structural gymnastics we can go through to help people
- 36:36with the states that are much, much, much larger than this, you
- 36:41know, 12.92 million. We construct them in ways where
- 36:45they will never pay a penny of estate tax.
- 36:47There's a lot of work that goes into that but you know $0.40 on
- 36:52the dollar really starts to pay for itself.
- 36:55The couple of things I wanted to 0 in on real quick though are
- 36:59there is this state level estate tax that's just, you know,
- 37:02various states have them, most states don't, but like
- 37:05Washington has got state level of state tax, Maryland does, New
- 37:09York does. There's a handful of states that
- 37:11still have this state level of state tax.
- 37:14So people who live in those states, they kind of have kind
- 37:18of two bogeys to look out for. They've got the big one that's
- 37:21the, you know, IRS on the federal estate tax.
- 37:25But then they've got their state revenue authorities as well.
- 37:28So the planning gets more complicated for clients there
- 37:32but Michael one of the things I wanted to 0 in on with you come
- 37:34to your point you know club level planning which is that's
- 37:37me too guys. I mean one of these days I I
- 37:40tell my wife I aspire to someday need my services.
- 37:45I don't today, but the the reality is the regardless of how
- 37:53big your stack is or really what the composition of your estate
- 37:56is, everybody really needs to have some level of trust based
- 38:00planning. Whether that's a revocable trust
- 38:03which is like the baseline for everybody, or one or more types
- 38:07of irrevocable trusts which you get into for tax and other
- 38:11reasons. You ought to have some type of
- 38:14trust as the base layer of your plan.
- 38:16That's like your L1 protocol, if you will.
- 38:20Because what that does is that allows you to seize control of
- 38:23the decision making process. If you become incapacitated or
- 38:27ultimately when you die, you privatize things.
- 38:30Because if you don't have, if you, if you have a, if you have
- 38:34no planning at all or if you have a will that you've used as
- 38:38your base layer of planning, all you've done is now send the
- 38:43people that you care the most about into the courthouse of the
- 38:47County Courthouse where you died, in the county where you
- 38:49died, to then deal with the judge and say yes, your honor,
- 38:54no, your honor. Here's what you know.
- 38:55Michael's dead. Here's, you know, here's his
- 38:58will, or hey, he didn't have a will.
- 38:59Here, here's his who is entitled to his stuff.
- 39:02And they have to complete an inventory of the assets in your
- 39:06estate, and they're going to inventory your laptop, they're
- 39:10going to inventory your key signature devices.
- 39:12And the judge is going to say, what the hell is this?
- 39:15And they're going to have to disclose that you had a Schwab
- 39:19account, you had a stack of gold in a fire safe at your house.
- 39:23You had a house, you had a car, you had a Fiat account and you
- 39:26had Bitcoin. The judge is going to say, wait,
- 39:28what the heck is that? How is your fiduciary going to
- 39:32be able to report back to the court on whether they made sound
- 39:37fiduciary decisions with your Bitcoin stack?
- 39:39Regardless of how committed you were to Bitcoin during your
- 39:42lifetime, guess what? You're dead.
- 39:44And so now somebody else is responsible for managing the
- 39:48assets that you left behind for the benefit of the people you
- 39:52left behind. And if you don't have clear
- 39:55instructions, ideally in some privatized manner, like a,
- 39:59again, revocable living trust, that's the most democratic
- 40:03strategy. If there is out there every, I
- 40:05mean, everybody, without exception, in my opinion, should
- 40:09have a revocable living trust as the foundation upon which the
- 40:13rest of their plan gets built. And for the vast majority of
- 40:17people, that's enough. But within that trust, you have
- 40:20to deal with things like Bitcoin because.
- 40:23For so many clients, certainly the clients I see and the people
- 40:27I think the guys on this on this broadcast here, a significant
- 40:31portion of our wealth is denominated in Bitcoin.
- 40:34So you know, we got to deal with some pesky legal issues and
- 40:38fiduciary law issues in order to equip our surviving spouse, our
- 40:45surviving partner, our parents, our kids, our friend, whoever is
- 40:47going to serve as the fiduciary. We've got to equip them to deal
- 40:51with this asset in a way that allows them to protect
- 40:55themselves. Because if you have got a big
- 40:58stack of Bitcoin relative to everything else and then Bitcoin
- 41:02enters one of these protracted bear markets where we're now
- 41:05we're in a trough. Well, if you know if half of
- 41:10your wealth is Bitcoin, which is not uncommon, you know, could
- 41:14very well be 70 or 80% of your wealth for a lot of our clients,
- 41:18how are you going to, how are you going to justify the fact
- 41:21that you didn't divest even in this bear market?
- 41:26So you have to plan for all that stuff, especially if you're a
- 41:28Bitcoiner. So I'll kind of pause there and
- 41:32see how that lands with you guys.
- 41:35I think there was two things, if you can expand on that.
- 41:38I don't know if you fully mentioned, but like when I think
- 41:40of some of this stuff is like what inspires action and the
- 41:43things that I've heard from your colleagues were when I'm alive.
- 41:46It also is important for the revocable because of just our.
- 41:50Where we sit on the risk profile, whether it's being in
- 41:53Bitcoin, people knowing we're in Bitcoin and somebody sues us and
- 41:55now that's available for some kind of, you know, court action.
- 42:00But then the other part is basically the market selling by
- 42:04the family because of the requirement if you're
- 42:07incapacitated and they see this volatile asset, I think that.
- 42:11Really resonates or would resonate with a lot of folks
- 42:14holding Bitcoin because they're thinking about it as a
- 42:15multigenerational asset. And the fact that it can be just
- 42:18market sold because they didn't have the right planning.
- 42:21Instead of actually going, you know, to whatever was written in
- 42:23a will, I think really would wake or at least bring the
- 42:27light. That it's not as simple as just
- 42:28putting in a will and saying here passes to somebody that
- 42:31this order of operations, if somebody you know leaves the
- 42:34earth, it could just be sold in dollars given to that individual
- 42:37and then there goes the estate tax as well, no 100%.
- 42:41So a couple of issues I wanted to provide some clarity on.
- 42:45So it's really important to folks understand that if the
- 42:48trust is revocable by you, you've got zero asset
- 42:52protection. Why?
- 42:54Because you control the trust, you set it up with your own
- 42:57assets, you're the trustee, you're the beneficiary, you got
- 43:01the power to revoke, you get sued.
- 43:04That revocable, that revocable trust is not going to help you
- 43:06one bit. What the revocable trust does do
- 43:10is it privatizes and streamlines the process of managing your
- 43:14assets. If you become incapacitated, so
- 43:17the people that you want to step into your shoes can do so.
- 43:20They've got the power to do that without having to go get
- 43:23appointed by a court to do that. And then when you pass away the
- 43:27same thing, you know they, the trust itself didn't die, just
- 43:31the person who set it up died. So now a successor trustee or a
- 43:35backup trustee steps in and now they manage the trust assets for
- 43:39the benefit of the beneficiaries.
- 43:41Maybe it's a spouse, partner, kids, whatever.
- 43:44But we can do that without having to go through the process
- 43:48of court proceedings so long as the trust instrument is very
- 43:53clear, giving the powers to deal with these complex assets that
- 43:58may be heavily concentrated and provided that anything that has
- 44:01a title is actually titled in the name of the trust.
- 44:05So for for people who are looking for asset protection,
- 44:08that becomes a really sticky wicket.
- 44:10I mean it's it's possible, but it's it's complicated.
- 44:14You're only talking about irrevocable trusts in those kind
- 44:17of contexts and you're you're only talking about irrevocable
- 44:21trust established in a handful of jurisdictions.
- 44:26They're like I said, they're complicated.
- 44:28And what you have to do is you have to effectively air gap
- 44:30yourself from the control over the trust of the property inside
- 44:34the trust. If you create a trust for the
- 44:36benefit often of somebody else, and then there's some ways kind
- 44:40of strategically you can create some indirect access back to
- 44:43you, You know, not going to get into the details there, but you
- 44:48know you can create these trusts that can can often be shielded
- 44:54from future creditors. There's nothing you can do if
- 44:58you've got an existing creditor right now.
- 45:00If if the claim has already arisen, there's not much you can
- 45:04do about that. But you can protect yourself for
- 45:08that future rainy someday if you do it very carefully.
- 45:16Very helpful. Yeah, it's funny.
- 45:21It wasn't until like a couple of years ago that I really became
- 45:26aware of like trust structures and thinking about it from a
- 45:30personal point of view and it seems like.
- 45:34Correct me if I'm wrong, man, but it seems like it's becoming
- 45:36like a bigger sort of trend. People are getting smarter about
- 45:40these structures being able to secure and preserve wealth over
- 45:45time. And I imagine this is a product
- 45:47of what we're seeing with the government, whether it be be the
- 45:50estate tax or simply the fact that they seem to be getting
- 45:54more and more Orwellian as time goes on.
- 45:57It is, is. Have trust been misunderstood or
- 46:02or? Is the awareness around them
- 46:05just been lacking for a certain period of time and now people
- 46:08are beginning to get wiser? You know, I like to think so,
- 46:12Marty. I mean, I think that I like to
- 46:16think that the American consumer is getting a little bit more
- 46:19educated. The and one thing to bear in
- 46:25mind is that it doesn't really matter where in the US you live.
- 46:30You can avail yourself of the benefits of planning under any
- 46:33state, or any country for that matter.
- 46:36So one thing I'll mention is that very often, if we've got
- 46:40clients who happen to live in a state that's got just
- 46:45particularly poor trust laws, maybe the maybe the trust laws
- 46:49don't provide a level of privacy.
- 46:51Maybe the trust laws give the beneficiaries of the trust more
- 46:56power than the creator of the trust wants to give them.
- 47:00And so we can be creative in finding the right jurisdictions
- 47:04to structure the estate plan. So you might be living in
- 47:08Colorado or California or Alabama or someplace like that,
- 47:13but we can create structures for you.
- 47:15We can create trust for you. And really desirable
- 47:17jurisdictions like Wyoming, like Nevada, like South Dakota, like
- 47:22the Cook Islands, there's, you know, you got the freedom to
- 47:26select what law is going to govern the interpretation of
- 47:30your trust. And and now really, we're kind
- 47:32of talking about that in the context of irrevocable, more
- 47:34complex trust planning. But I do think that people are
- 47:40kind of awakening to this idea that there's a better technology
- 47:44for wealth succession than just using a will.
- 47:48You know, it's it's like people are buying Bitcoin instead of
- 47:51gold. Hopefully people are
- 47:52establishing trust instead of using a will or God forbid doing
- 47:55nothing at all. I think people realize and
- 47:58especially in the in the Bitcoin space, you know, a lot of wealth
- 48:03has been created pretty quickly in the last 14 years.
- 48:06And I would say really especially since 2017, there's
- 48:09been tremendous wealth built through the various cycles that
- 48:12we've seen even even the 5:00 or so years.
- 48:15I've been part of this conversation I guess six years
- 48:18now. So they've been a tremendous
- 48:20amount of wealth. And when people who were mining
- 48:24Bitcoin early or even just kind of speculating on it early, now
- 48:28they've got a family. Now they are maybe in their 30s
- 48:31or in their 40s and they realize, wow, this is
- 48:34consequential. And I'm sure not going to sell
- 48:37it and go buy something stupid with it or something that's
- 48:41dollar denominated and can be basically printed into oblivion.
- 48:45I'm going to hold this. I'm going to hold it long term.
- 48:47It's going to be a transgenerational asset.
- 48:50I mean, hopefully the word is getting out that there's a
- 48:53better technology for managing your wealth than just, you know,
- 48:59dying with a will or with nothing at all.
- 49:01And the revokable trust is, like I said, it's like base level
- 49:05planning for literally everybody.
- 49:08Yeah, it's actually it's jogging back when we first met and you
- 49:13really recognizing having the expertise on this side and then
- 49:16finding out the power of multi seg.
- 49:19And how that changes a lot I think that changes that's
- 49:21changed a lot of like bitcoiners at least it were still early.
- 49:24But perceptions of estate planning because of private key
- 49:27ownership, it is nuclear in the sense that you can't really give
- 49:30up that material because even if you trust somebody in the event
- 49:32that they do not safeguard that material, if you're
- 49:36incapacitator, if you're still alive and they don't protect it,
- 49:39the reality of funds could be gone.
- 49:41That changes the multi cig and how you're able.
- 49:43Can you speak to any of that and just like whether it's from
- 49:46examples of? Ways you've seen in structure or
- 49:48just like the power of how that kind of changes inheritance, the
- 49:52dynamic that hasn't really existed.
- 49:55I feel like it's just really starting in the market where you
- 49:58have like different solutions or at least different protocols in
- 50:02place. So people can navigate that
- 50:04where they can be sovereign in the sense that they have
- 50:06unilateral control of the asset by having keys distributed multi
- 50:10cig but then also planning for a future where.
- 50:14Their beneficiaries or whoever's part of that can actually
- 50:17recover because I historically incorrect me if I'm wrong, but
- 50:21that really hasn't existed because you either had one side
- 50:23holding a single, you know, say seed or some kind of, you know,
- 50:27extravagant way of how you would charge that.
- 50:28But that ultimately adds a bunch of complexity or the other side
- 50:31of it sitting on Coinbase or some other third party.
- 50:34While that's good and may fall under certain qualified
- 50:36custodian standards that certain people need, at the end of the
- 50:38day that's still giving it up, which a lot of people I think
- 50:41aren't comfortable with. So, yeah, yeah, I mean there's a
- 50:45lot, there's a lot in that Michael, but I'll, I'll speak to
- 50:47that a bit. So yeah, multi cig definitely
- 50:50helps a ton, especially in the context of this revocable trust
- 50:55centered planning like we're talking about like this.
- 50:58But it's important I think to distinguish between the
- 51:00mechanical transfer of key material which multi cig helps
- 51:04provide. I mean I use multi cig, I'm an
- 51:06Unchained customer as well on my like my personal stack if you
- 51:12will. But that that definitely helps a
- 51:15lot because as you know, I think everybody here knows obviously
- 51:19you can select who has key material, you can establish the
- 51:22quorum rules and that facilitates the mechanical
- 51:25transfer. So if I get hit by a bus or slip
- 51:28off the side of the planet somewhere, you know the two out
- 51:32of three that I've selected, there are my backup signatures,
- 51:35no problem. They now still have control over
- 51:39my key material. That's great, but what if the
- 51:43people they give the key material to, I don't plan to
- 51:47give my Bitcoin to. I want them to hold that and
- 51:51manage that for the benefit of my children.
- 51:54So you know, now we've got the, you know, the basically this
- 51:59custody if you will, that's now still multi sig.
- 52:02But these people who are controlling the Bitcoin, are
- 52:07they the same people that I want to have as the trustees of my
- 52:11trust? Maybe, maybe not.
- 52:13I mean, maybe they're really great at Bitcoin, but maybe they
- 52:16don't know my kids. And so maybe they're not the
- 52:18best people to serve as the decision makers for my kids.
- 52:22Now we've got a complication. And so if we're only concerned
- 52:27about mechanically transferring Bitcoin to somebody else, multi
- 52:31sig is a brilliant solution. And like I said, I use it
- 52:33myself. But when we think about the
- 52:37broader benefits that establishing a trust can
- 52:41provide, You know, I've got the ability through a trust I
- 52:44create. I can create a trust for the
- 52:47benefit of my wife, the benefit of my children in a way that can
- 52:51provide them almost impenetrable asset protection once I die.
- 52:58So, like, if I die and I and through my estate plan, I've
- 53:04established a trust for the benefit of my wife, if my wife,
- 53:09in a profound lapse of judgment, were to remarry because, I mean,
- 53:13you're not going to get better than this babe.
- 53:14I mean, come on, If she were to remarry and that marriage ends
- 53:19in divorce, I would not want the wealth that I've built with her,
- 53:25especially the Bitcoin that we've accumulated together.
- 53:27I wouldn't want that to be subject to the claim of her soon
- 53:31to be exhusband in a divorce proceeding so I can design the
- 53:37structure for her that provides asset protection for her.
- 53:41Same thing for my daughters. I can pass my Bitcoin or my
- 53:45other wealth to them with a protective trust structure
- 53:49around it so that if my children end up getting sued from a
- 53:54business creditor, they end up getting, you know, whatever
- 53:57happens, you know, they just get sued for whatever reason.
- 54:00A creditor would not be able to reach in and take those assets
- 54:03away from my children involuntarily.
- 54:07And so we got to deal with, I think, both the mechanical
- 54:09transfer asset aspects of Bitcoin, but also the kind of
- 54:15more qualitative outcomes that we're looking for, like the
- 54:18privacy, like the protection. Keeping my kids from saying,
- 54:21hey, cool, you know, Bitcoin is $100,000 and now I've got a
- 54:25couple 100,000 bucks. I'm just going to go you know go
- 54:28buy a really fast car and wrap around telephone pole and have
- 54:30nothing to show for myself. You know if I don't have a trust
- 54:34in place that puts some guardrails on how the money gets
- 54:36used or how the wealth gets used, there's nothing stopping
- 54:39that from happening. So you know we've we've got to
- 54:42kind of think through not just the mechanics of of key
- 54:45management, but also the more qualitative guardrails around
- 54:51long term wealth preservation for the family.
- 54:54And if my trustee that I've appointed to be the decision
- 54:59maker in my trust for the benefit of the people I cared
- 55:01about, if that trustee does not have control over the key
- 55:06material, just like they've got to have control over my Schwab
- 55:10account, just like they've got to have control over the title
- 55:12to my house, they've got to be able to do their job.
- 55:15So to a certain degree these signature controls start to
- 55:20break down. But we can build some
- 55:23protections in place by having multiple trustees, just like
- 55:27we've got multiple signature holders and so maybe each
- 55:29trustee holds a signature. Or again when we're dealing with
- 55:34really large stacks and we're needing to enter into some tax
- 55:39leverage planning, multi sig doesn't work.
- 55:42We have to use something like a qualified custodian because we
- 55:46have to substantiate ownership of the Bitcoin in the name of
- 55:51the trust or the entity, and the only way we're going to do that
- 55:55is with a qualified custodian, at least currently.
- 56:00Yeah, it's so fascinating because.
- 56:01Or go ahead, Jesse. I was gonna take it in another
- 56:04direction. So yeah, you go first.
- 56:07I was just gonna say it's really fascinating because they're
- 56:10different functions of the market.
- 56:11But we talked about this earlier in the week with Marty.
- 56:14It's like this is the natural maturation of a process and like
- 56:18what you just described, like it sounds extensive.
- 56:22It's the requirement for for large amounts of capital to come
- 56:24in in a very similar way that we're building it on ramps.
- 56:27Like there's certain institutions that need certain
- 56:30assurances or certain high net worth individuals that need
- 56:33mapping of what the old world looks like in traditional assets
- 56:36to be able to recover or know that they have, you know, like
- 56:39you mentioned the mechanical aspect of moving the funds, but
- 56:42then also the. The legal wrapper around it that
- 56:47mirrors what they're used to and their other assets before they
- 56:49can step in. And so I think what you just
- 56:51described is are the are the process and things that are just
- 56:55like we're still early but having them out being able to
- 56:58articulate them really and we've seen this first hand with with
- 57:02you know folks that we know. So it's it's really fascinating
- 57:05to see like you know this number of years in and stuff like this
- 57:08starting to happen and and it also. 30K makes sense for
- 57:12certain people when that price 10X is, it makes sense for a lot
- 57:15more people. And so it's just again, building
- 57:17that plumbing for people to step into the market and feel
- 57:20comfortable in the way they do it.
- 57:22That's right. And I don't want to step on
- 57:24Jesse real quick, but one thing I wanted to circle in on is
- 57:27that, I mean this is just part of the natural maturation of the
- 57:30market. We kind of have to have a foot
- 57:34in both worlds right now. You know, we've got the world as
- 57:37it is. We've got the Fiat world that is
- 57:39kind of the dominant world. We've got the legal frameworks
- 57:42that we have right now, We've got the tax frameworks that we
- 57:44have right now and we have this impeccable pristine asset that
- 57:48really is the bridge to the future.
- 57:50And so, you know, I don't think it's realistic to think that,
- 57:56you know, before Bitcoin or start to die, Bitcoin just going
- 57:59to take over the world and everything's going to be a
- 58:01Bitcoin standard. I think it's going to be a
- 58:02longer process than that. And so I think that the more
- 58:06likely situation is that organizations like On ramp,
- 58:10organizations like Bespoke serve as a bridge between the world as
- 58:15it currently is and the world as it's in the process of becoming.
- 58:21Absolutely. Yeah.
- 58:22That's how we see it too And obviously with the on the nose
- 58:26on ramp name choice, it's a it's a bridge.
- 58:30I I loved what you you pointed out about trustees being.
- 58:35Potentially key holders in a multisig arrangement and and how
- 58:38that you know can be done. It's like it makes a lot of
- 58:42sense that that creates that Ave.
- 58:45And so I was going to ask about a couple questions for you.
- 58:48If you're thinking about the math, you know if if 5,000,000
- 58:53plus interest plus inflation is going to be the threshold in the
- 58:57future. That and let's say Bitcoin 100
- 59:01X's over the next couple decades.
- 59:04That would mean that anybody with 50,000 or or more today in
- 59:09Bitcoin could then have a a an estate greater than the
- 59:16allowable limit before taxes kick in.
- 59:19So that would be a lot of people, a lot of bitcoiners and
- 59:24and so I guess when when does it make sense to start setting
- 59:30something like this up and? You know, what type of
- 59:33bitcoiners do you think need this who aren't currently
- 59:37thinking about it? Yeah, I think that's a great
- 59:40question and your observations are right on.
- 59:45I know it seems a little bit counterintuitive, but really the
- 59:47ideal time to plan is when values are soft.
- 59:50Because if you, I mean, I'm taking my own advice on this.
- 59:55You know, when I saw Bitcoin start to really pull back, I
- 59:58thought, you know. I've got a very high conviction
- 1:00:02with the low time preference, long threshold, long hold
- 1:00:04threshold for Bitcoin. So I created for myself an
- 1:00:09irrevocable trust that would then put the value of whatever
- 1:00:13assets I put in that trust out of my estate for future
- 1:00:18purposes. So I can get the I can get the
- 1:00:20assets out of my estate at today's value, and then all the
- 1:00:26alpha that takes place between now and then.
- 1:00:29If Bitcoin goes 2X5 X 10X or more, all of that lift is out of
- 1:00:35my estate from a estate tax perspective.
- 1:00:38Now, I don't currently have a federally taxable estate.
- 1:00:41I could die today and my parent, my family, have no concerns
- 1:00:45about the federal estate tax. However, I don't plan on
- 1:00:50checking out anytime soon and I have a longterm conviction that
- 1:00:55Bitcoin is going to be a longterm store of value asset.
- 1:00:59I got out of my estate this year.
- 1:01:02I started, or maybe it was last year, I can't remember.
- 1:01:05But it's like I started just shunting the biggest part of my
- 1:01:07Bitcoin out of my estate because it's it's stuff I don't plan to
- 1:01:11sell. I have a longterm conviction on
- 1:01:14it. Might as well get it out now.
- 1:01:15Grant that I'm in the I've got the luxury being in the
- 1:01:17business. I can set up one of these things
- 1:01:19for myself for free and I understand how they work, but I
- 1:01:22would say that people who have, you know, call it, I don't know
- 1:01:28today's terms. You know mid 6 figures worth of
- 1:01:34Bitcoin. Let's say that you've got, you
- 1:01:36call it 10 to 15 Bitcoin then and you've got a long time
- 1:01:41horizon and you've got a high conviction.
- 1:01:47Something like this might make sense and I'll tell you I mean
- 1:01:49another thing that we can that we've done.
- 1:01:51I mean I like you know I've done this personally.
- 1:01:53So I mean I know not only that you can do it and how to do it.
- 1:01:58I also understand what it's like to live with these types of
- 1:02:00structures. We, you know, it's it's legal.
- 1:02:04So we did some watch trading on our Bitcoin as the as the prices
- 1:02:07came, as the prices started coming back.
- 1:02:09So we could kind of reset our bases, claim some losses, reset
- 1:02:12our bases and so now all that lift is outside of our estates
- 1:02:17and I was able to harvest some losses all while this stuff is
- 1:02:19sitting inside this trust. Now the sacrifice that goes
- 1:02:23along with that is that I don't have my key material.
- 1:02:26I've got a trustee who uses a qualified custodian and I have
- 1:02:30visibility and I have a high level of confidence in that
- 1:02:35fiduciary, that Trust Company that I use.
- 1:02:38I can fire them at any time I want.
- 1:02:40I can replace them with somebody else, but I have to.
- 1:02:45I have to trust in a trustless environment.
- 1:02:47I have to trust. And so for me that again, this
- 1:02:51is the challenge of having to navigate the world as it is
- 1:02:55right now. Because otherwise if I have a
- 1:02:58longterm conviction that Bitcoin is going to increase in value, I
- 1:03:02don't want to give that to my wife, maybe someday my kids or
- 1:03:06beyond in a way that is to their advantage.
- 1:03:11That's, that's what's required. Because I do believe that the
- 1:03:14days of thinking, oh, I'll just kind of create a private key
- 1:03:18succession mechanism with a deadman switch in a single sig.
- 1:03:22Or I'll create a treasure map with my sharded bit 39 phrase
- 1:03:25and, you know, lead my family to find my Bitcoin someday.
- 1:03:30Those days are gone because the IRS and other taxing authorities
- 1:03:34are getting very savvy on a trace down blockchain
- 1:03:38transactions. And one of these days somebody's
- 1:03:41going to want to monetize that Bitcoin.
- 1:03:44They're either going to sell it, you know, when things are at
- 1:03:46peak froth or they want to borrow against it.
- 1:03:49At some point they're going to get KY c'd on that Bitcoin.
- 1:03:53Sorry to be the wet blanket. That's the world we live in.
- 1:03:55So then they're going to have, they're going to have to have a
- 1:03:57compelling story to tell under penalty of perjury with risk of
- 1:04:00incarceration where that Bitcoin came from.
- 1:04:03And if they don't have a compelling story that they can
- 1:04:05back up, they're going to have some significant problems.
- 1:04:08So we have to treat this asset. We have to respect this asset
- 1:04:12has the transformational store of value asset that it is and
- 1:04:15and give it the planning it deserves.
- 1:04:20Yeah, those are some really compelling points and but I
- 1:04:23can't help it but observe that you chose irrevocable trust.
- 1:04:28I had to OK, and I had to to get the benefits that I wanted
- 1:04:33because when I have a revocable trust, just like the revocable
- 1:04:37trust that Mike and I were talking about, just like that
- 1:04:39revocable trust, it doesn't give me any asset protection.
- 1:04:43It also doesn't get the value out of my estate because I I can
- 1:04:47control the trust and so it it it structures the privacy and it
- 1:04:51structures the inheritance for my family.
- 1:04:54But the value of the assets in the revocable trust are included
- 1:04:58in my estate and there's a whole litany of tax code sections that
- 1:05:00tell you that. But the specific type of
- 1:05:04irrevocable trust I created is called a completed gift.
- 1:05:08Which means that when I establish the trust, I take my
- 1:05:12hand off the wheel, I say okay, I've got to entrust somebody
- 1:05:15else to manage this. Here are the terms.
- 1:05:17And if they don't follow those terms, they get sued and they
- 1:05:21can lose their license. And so it's punitive for them if
- 1:05:23they mess up. But I take my hands off the
- 1:05:27wheel and then once I put the value, once I put assets inside
- 1:05:30that trust by transferring from my unchanged multi sig
- 1:05:34transferring from a single sig sovereign device into a
- 1:05:38qualified custodian in an account that's titled in the
- 1:05:41name of my trust that marks the completion of that gift.
- 1:05:46I then have to report that gift on a gift tax return to the IRS.
- 1:05:53And So what that does, I'm not going to pay taxes on that.
- 1:05:56But what that does is that erodes part of my estate tax
- 1:06:01exemption. So I just, I mean I did remember
- 1:06:03because we got to do the gift tax return this year, I'm on
- 1:06:06extension, so I got to file it in October.
- 1:06:08But you know, I've got that twelve points, whatever it was
- 1:06:12last year, 12 point, some odd million, 12.3 or something like
- 1:06:15that. Last year I had $12.3 million
- 1:06:17worth of exemption and I put you know, X dollars worth of Bitcoin
- 1:06:23and it completed gift trust. I then have to report that I've
- 1:06:26now used up X dollars worth of my exemption and now I have my
- 1:06:3112.92 -, X as my remaining exemption.
- 1:06:35So now I've basically told the IRS that I have put this outside
- 1:06:41of my estate for the benefit of the people I care about in this
- 1:06:43type of legal structure that works that way.
- 1:06:46Then once I die, whatever. I mean all this, all the alpha
- 1:06:52Bitcoin hits new, all time highs, goes 3X5 X 10X whatever.
- 1:06:57All of that is outside of my estate when I die, and because
- 1:07:02of the type of trust I established when my wife dies,
- 1:07:06when my children die, when my grandchildren die, when my great
- 1:07:10grandchildren die, it's not taxed.
- 1:07:14I I chose a trust in Wyoming that allows the trust to
- 1:07:18continue for 1000 years without distributing the assets out so
- 1:07:23that the value, the assets in the trust can be used for the
- 1:07:27benefit of my beneficiaries. But unless and until the trust
- 1:07:31actually distributes the assets out to the beneficiary, it's not
- 1:07:37subject to a state tax for many, many generations.
- 1:07:40And so the value can continue to compound generation after
- 1:07:44generation after generation in a highly tax efficient asset
- 1:07:49protected structure for the benefit of the people I care
- 1:07:51about. And so that's the kind of trust
- 1:07:53I created. That's the kind of trust that we
- 1:07:55create for clients who have significant wealth.
- 1:07:58Yeah, wow. It sounds like a Wyoming
- 1:08:01Irrevocable Trust might be Bitcoiner's best friend.
- 1:08:05Wyoming is a good one. Tell you that.
- 1:08:08Like I said, your mileage may vary.
- 1:08:11Different jurisdictions have different laws.
- 1:08:13South Dakota is a great one. Nevada is a great one.
- 1:08:15Wyoming super bullish on just because they're pretty Bitcoin
- 1:08:18friendly. But I would tell you that their
- 1:08:20their trust laws generally aren't the best in the in the
- 1:08:23world. They're good, but they're not
- 1:08:25the best. But for Bitcoin, probably good
- 1:08:27enough. I.
- 1:08:29Mean I think we were talking about seven generation thinking
- 1:08:33last week on the show. This guy's well beyond that.
- 1:08:36You're going way further, which is.
- 1:08:41I completely agree. Like, bitcoiners need to be
- 1:08:43thinking about this like again. After our conversation earlier
- 1:08:46this week, I'm certainly thinking about it much more
- 1:08:50seriously. Yeah.
- 1:08:52I mean, Marty, I think, you know, I know we talked about it
- 1:08:54last week. I've made this statement before.
- 1:08:56I do think that, you know, proactive planning is the
- 1:08:59ultimate exercise and sovereignty.
- 1:09:01You know, we talk about not your keys, not your coins.
- 1:09:03I mean, I've said that a million times myself.
- 1:09:05I've believed that. And you know, I, I agree that to
- 1:09:07A to a degree that's true. But if we don't, you know,
- 1:09:14exercise our own sovereignty in creating a plan that privatizes
- 1:09:19the process, that establishes the ground rules, who's going to
- 1:09:22be appointed to make decisions, how they're going to make
- 1:09:24decisions, how the assets are going to be used.
- 1:09:27If we don't do that, we're not sovereign.
- 1:09:31And I would say that they can kind of you know rewinding a
- 1:09:34little bit you got to look at this as a spectrum.
- 1:09:39You know you don't put all of your stack in any one thing.
- 1:09:43You shouldn't have all of your stack in a self sovereign, you
- 1:09:47shouldn't have all of your stack in a multi sig.
- 1:09:49You shouldn't have all your stack in a single qualified
- 1:09:51custodian. It's a matter of degrees.
- 1:09:54And so I've got some walking around Bitcoin.
- 1:09:57If I wanted to find a lightning channel somewhere and buy
- 1:09:59Michael a coffee next time I see him, cool, I can do that.
- 1:10:02And I've got that at the ready. If I, if I, you know, want to
- 1:10:07fly around the world with the key signature device in my
- 1:10:11pocket, I can do that. I've got a qualified custodian
- 1:10:16that's got an account for my revocable trust.
- 1:10:19I've got a qualified custodian for the biggest part of my stack
- 1:10:23in this irrevocable trust. You know, I think that it's it's
- 1:10:26a matter of diversifying custody, diversifying control.
- 1:10:31But the control really begins with the bitcoiner, I think,
- 1:10:36taking responsibility for for this wealth in a frankly kind of
- 1:10:41a grown up way. You talked about sovereignty in
- 1:10:44early and then this. And like, I think about the
- 1:10:46ultimate sovereignty is like education, right?
- 1:10:49Like if you think about the the past 15 years, there's been a
- 1:10:51lot of Bitcoin loss. And I think about what we're
- 1:10:53talking about now in like 10 years, they'll laugh about what
- 1:10:56we're how we're structuring this in the same way that people were
- 1:10:59doing faucets. And I'm sure Marty's probably
- 1:11:01lost more Bitcoin than than I've ever accumulated.
- 1:11:05And that the multi sig you like we talked about it and you
- 1:11:10referenced this is the time. It's counterintuitive to set up
- 1:11:13the trust and we talk about it all the time.
- 1:11:15With custody, it's the same thing.
- 1:11:16It's like no matter what your setup is, you always want to
- 1:11:18think about if the price is 10X what it is, because it
- 1:11:22inevitably will be and you don't want to be left scrambling at
- 1:11:25that time. And so it's just education time
- 1:11:29spent and it's this thing I keep angering to that we just keep,
- 1:11:33we've witnessed the past few years really, but it's been
- 1:11:35since, again, Bitcoin inception. It's very easy to like really
- 1:11:38get Bitcoin your hands on it. It's hard to hold it long term,
- 1:11:42whether it's to the volatility, the exchange hacks, or to what
- 1:11:45you just described. Different ways that the law and
- 1:11:48rules can basically take it in the in the court of law if
- 1:11:51you're incapacitated. And so it really like it made
- 1:11:54me, I think we talk about it sometimes it's like bitcoins,
- 1:11:56alien technology. It really is in the sense of
- 1:11:58like there's just this whole new rule set that you have to, you
- 1:12:01have to plan around from the custody all the way to how the
- 1:12:05legal rapper is, how it takes care of it.
- 1:12:09And it continues to evolve and the tools and the the laws and
- 1:12:12the trust and the jurisdictions evolve with it.
- 1:12:16And that's part of the education and like the time and the proof
- 1:12:19of work and learning this stuff. So that if you and that's part
- 1:12:22of like understanding where it can go long term, because I
- 1:12:25don't think what we just talked about in the hours that each
- 1:12:29person on this pods independently looked at this
- 1:12:31would never do that if you didn't have this visit.
- 1:12:33This vision of a future where Bitcoin is worth acts and
- 1:12:37facilitates all trade across the world.
- 1:12:40And so it's just all this, just the anchoring back to the point
- 1:12:43of like it really comes down to education, which is the ultimate
- 1:12:45sovereignty because then you can think for yourself and plan for
- 1:12:47yourself and that is the proof of work.
- 1:12:49I mean that's that's the proof of work and what we do.
- 1:12:52I mean I think that's a really good kind of reference point
- 1:12:55which I hadn't connected before. Michael, I think you're exactly
- 1:12:57right. I mean you have to put in the
- 1:12:58work. You have to put in the work to
- 1:13:02learn about Bitcoin. It's it is alien technology.
- 1:13:05It's complicated. It's really hard for a non tech
- 1:13:08guy like me to get get his head around and then you've got to
- 1:13:13think through like a a guy like me.
- 1:13:15I mean, I'm an attorney. I'm a legal strategist guy.
- 1:13:20What the hell do I know about Bitcoin?
- 1:13:22Well, I, you know, put in the work and I continue to put in
- 1:13:24the work. And now I've dedicated my
- 1:13:27careers, my businesses, building a team that spans the US into
- 1:13:33Europe, building a team around this.
- 1:13:36And so, yeah, you got to put in the work.
- 1:13:40It's a it's it's it's absolutely fascinating I think to see the,
- 1:13:49you know, I don't know if this is where you want to go with
- 1:13:50this. But one of the things I would
- 1:13:52maybe kind of highlight is that the Fiat world Fiat wealth is
- 1:13:57pivoting to Bitcoin in a way that I am both surprised and
- 1:14:02encouraged by. You know we get to, we get to
- 1:14:06deal with clients at the very you know like Apex of wealth,
- 1:14:11like the 1% of the 1% of the 1%. And I was speaking earlier this
- 1:14:16week with a gentleman who is 80 years old, the founder of a well
- 1:14:20known public company had a big liquidity event back in 2010,
- 1:14:252012 something like that. And he was talking to a mutual
- 1:14:29friend of ours, mutual acquaintance.
- 1:14:31And this guy has positioned he, he used to be a typical 6040
- 1:14:37equities to equities to debt or equities to bonds kind of guy
- 1:14:41like because it worked. So now he's about 20% equities,
- 1:14:46heavy cash, a mountain of gold in Zurich, physical gold, not
- 1:14:51paper claims on gold. And he wanted to talk Bitcoin
- 1:14:54and he's like right on the edge of making a fairly significant
- 1:14:59move there and he wanted to talk to me about it from a legal
- 1:15:01structuring. What do you think, kind of
- 1:15:03thing. I got to tell you that is not an
- 1:15:05unusual conversation for me. I've got, you know, Fiat Wales
- 1:15:09that are now increasingly interested not in crypto,
- 1:15:13they're interested in Bitcoin because it's a store of value
- 1:15:16and they see it as a long term store of value that's unlike
- 1:15:18anything they've ever seen before.
- 1:15:19So the word is getting out. So I think that's just super
- 1:15:24encouraging to see and we're just, we're gonna see more of
- 1:15:26that over time. Yeah.
- 1:15:30Yeah. I was just, it reminds me of
- 1:15:35Michael Saylor's melting ice cube point of everybody has
- 1:15:39melting ice cube and billionaires feel that.
- 1:15:43More than anyone. Because when you do the numbers
- 1:15:45on that and you realize you're losing 510% in real terms every
- 1:15:51year from holding cash, that's a pretty penny and and so it's
- 1:15:57fascinating to hear an 80 year old who frankly 80 year olds
- 1:16:01barely understand the Internet, you know, so, so Bitcoin is
- 1:16:06quite a stretch but the pain point is so acute that.
- 1:16:11This can resonate and it's connecting and it's virally
- 1:16:15spreading. Yeah, I was just going to say
- 1:16:20the, to your point, Matt, like on our side of the world like
- 1:16:24it's been, it's been very interesting to see the endowment
- 1:16:27and pensions in large institutions looking at it.
- 1:16:29It's not like a joke anymore. It's just like how do you size
- 1:16:32it? How?
- 1:16:32What's? What's the total opportunity?
- 1:16:34Is it gold? How do you know the big thing
- 1:16:36custody. We've seen what's happened in
- 1:16:38the past. You know what's the difference
- 1:16:39between digital assets Bitcoin. But I keep thinking it's like
- 1:16:43risk adjusted like at this exact time is there a better can you
- 1:16:46think of a better time from whether it's building a business
- 1:16:48or allocating? Because it's like it is $500
- 1:16:51billion market cap asset and it punches so far outside of its
- 1:16:54weight class and the fact that basically everybody on the
- 1:16:56planet Earth or at least anybody connected to an Internet has
- 1:16:59heard of the brand Bitcoin and at the same time it sits here as
- 1:17:02this little like. You know what else is $500
- 1:17:04billion as an asset that we know of, You know, that's small.
- 1:17:08So it's it's a fascinating time to be alive, to build something
- 1:17:11in this space. This is the one of a new
- 1:17:14industrial revolution in some cases.
- 1:17:16I mean, I don't, I don't use that lightly and I I know that
- 1:17:19falls on friendly ears here. But I mean we really are at a
- 1:17:22generational not even generational probably
- 1:17:25multigenerational inflection point.
- 1:17:26I mean, this is, this is an enormous period of evolution in
- 1:17:32really in human history, and I think that the sovereign
- 1:17:36individual authors kind of have it right that borders matter
- 1:17:42less. We are tribes of shared
- 1:17:45interests as opposed to tribes of a particular nationality.
- 1:17:50So you know kind of rewinding all the way back to the macro
- 1:17:53conversation with it, what does mean geopolitically and as a
- 1:17:56Republic or whatever, like I tell you that for a lot of our
- 1:17:59clients they don't care. They they have less faith in
- 1:18:03preserving Fiat denominated wealth, especially US Fiat
- 1:18:08denominated wealth. They had a minimum, they want
- 1:18:10some exposure, they not exposure.
- 1:18:13They want direct ownership of non-us denominated Fiat wealth.
- 1:18:18So they want things like the Swiss franc, they want other
- 1:18:22harder Fiat assets but they also want non Fiat assets that are
- 1:18:27not U.S. dollar denominated because they feel that wealth
- 1:18:30eroding underneath their feet and that's and that's real.
- 1:18:34And I I think that's just going to accelerate.
- 1:18:37I don't see any sign of that changing, you know, in a in a
- 1:18:40long time. And I think that's a great
- 1:18:42opportunity for for guys like you, guys like me.
- 1:18:49Yeah I mean I'm glad you brought you brought it back to the front
- 1:18:51because I was I would I wouldn't be able to live with myself.
- 1:18:53We're talking about all these great countries and shelling
- 1:18:55points for talent. The great country of Texas I
- 1:18:57think is a is a wonderful place where you don't have to get in
- 1:19:00water where majority of the the people on this call have decided
- 1:19:04is there their shelling point to build a better future.
- 1:19:06So you know we talked about Singapore and India and these
- 1:19:09these other places like Switzerland, but I think Texas
- 1:19:12is is going to be just a you know drive down 35 if you're
- 1:19:15coming from up north. I think my tires would melt on
- 1:19:18the Interstate on the way down there.
- 1:19:21You get, you get a snowbird. You gotta you gotta pick your
- 1:19:23spots. Well, we get we gotta get the
- 1:19:26Texas bullying vault to hold Bitcoin.
- 1:19:29We gotta convince the state of Texas holds a Bitcoin on the
- 1:19:32balance sheet and if it's a matter of time, it's just a
- 1:19:35matter of time. It really is.
- 1:19:37I mean it's you mentioned how many bitcoiners in the United
- 1:19:40States is like you got 25 million sitting in Texas, so
- 1:19:43they don't even know it yet, yeah.
- 1:19:47Well, I mean, now we just describe what you just described
- 1:19:51with like the caliber of clients that you have that are beginning
- 1:19:55to turn the quarter on Bitcoin. When you factor that in with
- 1:20:00like what you were mentioning with the endowments and pensions
- 1:20:03beginning to really give Bitcoin a fair shake and then you throw
- 1:20:07Black Rock and their ETF in the mix and then you backdrop that
- 1:20:11with the subsidy having that's nine months away.
- 1:20:18I do think that we have the potential for this next cycle,
- 1:20:23not only the backdrop of the halving, but everything going on
- 1:20:25in the macroeconomic landscape as well to like to to be awe
- 1:20:30inspiring. I've been through 4 cycles now
- 1:20:33and I'm mentally preparing for this next one to be like
- 1:20:35anything I've ever experienced. A date with all those variables
- 1:20:41in mind. And again, really linking back
- 1:20:46to the conversation we had earlier this week and then
- 1:20:48building on it today with this conversation.
- 1:20:50Like setting up these structures right now seems like a very
- 1:20:55smart move for anybody. And like Matt said, Matt said,
- 1:20:59like even if you only have 500 grand worth of Bitcoin, 15 to 20
- 1:21:04Bitcoin right now. Like if all that money does
- 1:21:07flood in and we have this supply inflation reduction on the
- 1:21:12horizon, I think it makes a lot of sense to begin setting this
- 1:21:16up as quickly as possible. Yeah, you know in the and I
- 1:21:22think we all kind of get excited about the price action because
- 1:21:24we got the luxury of thinking about that here in the US And
- 1:21:29you know the ETF's that are inevitable whether it's this go
- 1:21:32around or somewhere down the road it's it's inevitable.
- 1:21:36I personally believe that Larry Fink is going to get his because
- 1:21:39he's Larry Fink. And I think that there's going
- 1:21:42to be, there will be a few others investigate will get,
- 1:21:45there's fidelity will get there's will be a handful of
- 1:21:47them that's going to make these companies acquire Bitcoin so
- 1:21:51they can then issue their paper claims against Bitcoin.
- 1:21:54And I think the end you know you factor in the having cycle that
- 1:21:56you're talking about next year I think we will see certainly will
- 1:21:59see price action in U.S. dollar denominated terms drive Bitcoin
- 1:22:04to all time highs on a large. Scale, I, Marty, I share your
- 1:22:09perspective that you know, we're probably going to see Alpha and
- 1:22:14Bitcoin unlike anything we've seen perhaps.
- 1:22:17I mean certainly in the six years I've been involved.
- 1:22:20But more than that, I kind of think about this more in the
- 1:22:25devaluation of the dollar terms. You know, I sit here in
- 1:22:27Colorado, I'm outside Denver, in the mountains a little bit.
- 1:22:31So you know, we've had a major run up on real estate just like
- 1:22:34you guys down in Austin have seen and the question then
- 1:22:38becomes, is my real estate really that much more valuable
- 1:22:44or is the dollar just buying that much less?
- 1:22:48The same thing is going to be true about Bitcoin.
- 1:22:50It's going to be great. We're all going to be super
- 1:22:52stoked to see the value of our Bitcoin go up in U.S. dollar
- 1:22:54denominated terms. Because guess what?
- 1:22:57The tax code is also denominated in U.S. dollar terms.
- 1:23:00However, you know, I believe that Bitcoin is as pristine
- 1:23:04asset, but are we going to see the value of Bitcoin go up
- 1:23:06because Bitcoin is inherently that much more valuable?
- 1:23:09Or is a sovereign currency that we measure it by just that much
- 1:23:13more eroded? It's probably a combination of
- 1:23:15those things, but I think the erosion of the value of the
- 1:23:18dollar is happening at a much faster pace.
- 1:23:20So I mean I I talked to my wife about this.
- 1:23:22You know, our our house is a very modest small house, just
- 1:23:25happens to be in a great community.
- 1:23:28The real estate that I've had has gone up precipitously in
- 1:23:33U.S. dollar denominated terms. But it's like, is it really
- 1:23:38worth that? Or is it just because you know
- 1:23:41everything else is expensive? Everything else is expensive not
- 1:23:44because it's worth more, it's just because the dollar is worth
- 1:23:46a heck of a lot less. Yeah, I mean I think that that
- 1:23:52that ties back to, I don't think it's like we we mentioned Texas
- 1:23:56or certain places. It's not like necessarily just a
- 1:23:58a meme. It's like there's food
- 1:23:59production, there's beef, there's oil, there's all these
- 1:24:02things that are natural to when a dollar loses the ability to
- 1:24:06coordinate economic activity, you need actual real goods and
- 1:24:10then a form of money that people will accept.
- 1:24:12And so that's like the longterm part of all this is you want to
- 1:24:16be in an area that. Can have our own soft landing
- 1:24:19for for lack of better work. None.
- 1:24:22I I think that I completely agree with that.
- 1:24:24Like Bitcoin's appreciation will be driven by the devaluation of
- 1:24:29the dollar in part and then also do people recognizing its
- 1:24:33inherent fundamental value. And I think that will be very
- 1:24:37interesting to observe as we head towards 2030, like how we
- 1:24:41do people selling houses, buying houses, begin to denominate the
- 1:24:46value of those things in sats and Bitcoin.
- 1:24:51And once we get to that flipping point where you go to a bodega,
- 1:24:55you go to a corner store and you have Bitcoin prices alongside
- 1:25:00like U.S. dollar prices and maybe the US dollar prices are
- 1:25:03changing every day, but the Sats are staying somewhat stable.
- 1:25:06I think that's when we'll know that that the Bitcoin standard
- 1:25:10is upon us. I know, but before we wrap up,
- 1:25:20because I remember Matt, you really wanted to touch on this.
- 1:25:24When we just when we were talking earlier this week, like
- 1:25:27we've been saying the government's been good night,
- 1:25:29buddy, the the government's been been encroaching on our civil
- 1:25:35liberties and this is really going to come into effect I
- 1:25:39believe in the beginning of 2024 in terms of what needs to be
- 1:25:44disclosed to, Fin said by Llc's from a privacy perspective.
- 1:25:50Man, you're really gonna push my buttons now, Marty?
- 1:25:52I mean, you said you wanted to touch on it, so.
- 1:25:56Yeah, I mean, you're right. You're right.
- 1:25:58But I mean, look, this is again, this is the sign of a weak
- 1:26:04Republic in my perspective. When when a when a Republic or
- 1:26:10when a government authority can no longer.
- 1:26:14Rule with soft power. They have to start ruling with
- 1:26:17hard power. And I can't read the year it was
- 1:26:21passed. Maybe it was last year, maybe it
- 1:26:23was 2021, something like that. But I think it was 2021 that
- 1:26:26Congress, unfortunately bipartisan Congress passed a
- 1:26:32corporate transparency act under the guise of, you know, you
- 1:26:38know, clamping down on funding of terrorism and all this kind
- 1:26:42of stuff and money laundering, whatever.
- 1:26:44So this Corporate Transparency Act then got sent over to the
- 1:26:49Treasury Department to go through the rulemaking process,
- 1:26:54which is this shadowy, murky process by which a whole bunch
- 1:26:57of bureaucrats who have never, you know, made, you know,
- 1:27:03altruistic decisions in their lives sit down and make rules
- 1:27:07about how do we interpret this Corporate Transparency Act and
- 1:27:10as a result of. These kind of backroom
- 1:27:13conversations that took place a new body of rules under the
- 1:27:17Corporate Transparency Act, or the CTA for short, will now take
- 1:27:21effect January 1 of 2024, where with very few exceptions, most
- 1:27:28of the exceptions are kind of irrelevant.
- 1:27:30With very few exceptions, every single US domestic limited
- 1:27:34liability company that's currently exists now or that is
- 1:27:38established in the future will have to register.
- 1:27:41With the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network inside the
- 1:27:45Treasury Department to disclose the beneficial ownership and
- 1:27:49control person information of those entities, disclosing the
- 1:27:54full name, the address, the date of birth and either the Social
- 1:27:58Security number or tax ID number or a special fence in identifier
- 1:28:03number. To just say, hey, look, you know
- 1:28:06what, we, we believe you guys are all above board.
- 1:28:09But you know what just in case, why don't you go ahead and come
- 1:28:11on in and register. And by the way, if you don't
- 1:28:13it's going to be $250,000 and probably a decade in federal
- 1:28:18prison if you fail to comply. And so every single limited
- 1:28:22liability company, even if you established it only for personal
- 1:28:25family wealth preservation, whether you're on RAMP LLC or
- 1:28:30Bespoke Group LLC or. Whether you're, you know,
- 1:28:34Marty's Mad Stacks LLC or whatever it is, if it's a United
- 1:28:38States entity or if it's a foreign entity that has to
- 1:28:42register in the US just because of the applicable state laws of
- 1:28:45wherever you happen to live. Well, January 1, you're going to
- 1:28:49have about 30 days to comply with this law.
- 1:28:52And it just, I get incensed about this because it carries
- 1:28:55with it the insinuation that if you have a limited liability
- 1:28:59company for whatever reason in the world.
- 1:29:02Just managing family wealth. If you have that, you are
- 1:29:06assumed that you are committing a crime, because why else would
- 1:29:10you be registering with the Financial Crimes Enforcement
- 1:29:12Network now granted, under the law, the database that you
- 1:29:18register with is going to be secure and private.
- 1:29:22And of course it will be until it is not, at which point.
- 1:29:27Some nation state or some hacking organization that's got
- 1:29:31an axe to grind is going to penetrate this database.
- 1:29:35And now all of a sudden they're going to have the name of every
- 1:29:39individual who's got a limited liability company.
- 1:29:41They're going to have their name, their address, their date
- 1:29:44of birth, the name of the entity and their tax identification
- 1:29:48number to then do with what Malefactors will want to do with
- 1:29:52that information. I think it's the most egregious
- 1:29:56overreach and the most egregious invasion of privacy that I've
- 1:30:00seen even farther than the Patriot Act, so-called air
- 1:30:04quotes, Patriot Act. And so we are working as hard as
- 1:30:08we can to find ways to establish structures for clients that
- 1:30:13don't pull them into the disclosure requirements of the
- 1:30:17CTA because. You know, it's all well and good
- 1:30:22that we don't want to finance terrorism.
- 1:30:23I don't want to finance terrorism either.
- 1:30:25That's cool. But guess what?
- 1:30:26I live in America and there's supposed to be a sense of
- 1:30:28privacy. There's supposed to be a sense
- 1:30:29of freedom behind our personal affairs.
- 1:30:33And the burden ought to be on the government to create a
- 1:30:38compelling case that I am violating the law rather than me
- 1:30:42have to come in and register proactively with the Financial
- 1:30:45Crimes Enforcement Network to promise I'm not a bad boy.
- 1:30:50I think it's a just a terrible, terrible thing.
- 1:30:52So people really ought to know about this.
- 1:30:57If your congressman ever opens the mail, I would encourage you
- 1:30:59to write them or e-mail them. I can tell you I have tried and
- 1:31:03I've got crickets from the leadership in Colorado.
- 1:31:07Maybe in Texas you'll get better mileage, but it's it's not maybe
- 1:31:14going to happen and it's already the law.
- 1:31:16The law is going to take effect in January 1.
- 1:31:19And the the cost of non compliance is is very, very
- 1:31:25painful. What does that look like in
- 1:31:27practice? Like from or?
- 1:31:29Go ahead, Martin. I was going to say it's
- 1:31:32disgusting, especially when you consider that the US federal
- 1:31:35government is probably the largest financier of terrorism
- 1:31:38around the world. But go ahead, Michael.
- 1:31:41I was, yeah, I was before, before asking how he's going to
- 1:31:44be like Marty hasn't been in a cage and I think.
- 1:31:47Matt was going to wake him up or let him out, but I was actually
- 1:31:51just just curious. I'd rather go down the Marty
- 1:31:53Jones route, but I was just curious what does it look like
- 1:31:55in practice from existing LLC in 2024 or net new LLC?
- 1:32:00Like, what is what is that? Sounds like a sounds like a
- 1:32:03process the government couldn't even handle, let alone.
- 1:32:06Yeah, I doubt they. I doubt they have the
- 1:32:07infrastructure to take in all this data in the first place.
- 1:32:10Guess what? It's not their problem.
- 1:32:11It's yours. It's not, you know, the burdens
- 1:32:14on the burdens on you, the burdens on the government.
- 1:32:17So, you know, can you know the burden on enforcement?
- 1:32:21Yeah, big problem. But do you want to be the guy
- 1:32:24who's not compliant and get the knock on the door by the fence
- 1:32:26in guys to say, oh, by the way, Marty, we noticed that you
- 1:32:30didn't register your liability company with us.
- 1:32:32Can we have a, here's some nice jewelry.
- 1:32:35Would you like to have a seat in the back of the SUV and we'll
- 1:32:37talk about it, you know, in an undisclosed location, probably
- 1:32:42not quite that bad. But you know, for sake of drama
- 1:32:45perhaps. Yeah, it's just it's again, it
- 1:32:49kind of gets back to my point that when you are a dying power,
- 1:32:53this is what you do when you are a gerontocracy, when you are a
- 1:32:58kakistocracy, when you are on the waning days of your power,
- 1:33:02this is the kind of crap you do. And yeah, it's, you know, thank
- 1:33:09God for Bitcoin, as Cynthia Lummos likes to say, and.
- 1:33:14Thank God for options that give us the ability to at least move
- 1:33:18some of our wealth off of these shores in legal ways.
- 1:33:23I mean we don't do anything that's illegal.
- 1:33:25We see the law, we see the tax code as a playbook and it's
- 1:33:31there are advantages, there are opportunities, there are assets.
- 1:33:34The law is an asset if you know how to use it and that's what we
- 1:33:38try to do, you know and until they change it.
- 1:33:41I mean we follow the rules and if when they change those we
- 1:33:44when they change the lot we you know change what we did.
- 1:33:47But it's, you know, I say, I say, I'm probably kind of a
- 1:33:50legal strategist and opportunist more than anything else.
- 1:33:55Yeah, that's almost a call for for more legal minds to come
- 1:33:58into this space. We we talk about it that they're
- 1:34:01very rare. I'd love that.
- 1:34:03I'd probably hire them. Yeah.
- 1:34:07Well, thank you for the work that you're doing, Matt.
- 1:34:10I think it's extremely important both on actually the services
- 1:34:14that you provide your clients directly and then the education
- 1:34:16you're providing others in your industry to get them wise about
- 1:34:20what's going on so that they can onboard more people into these
- 1:34:23structures and then ringing the alarm bell about what's going on
- 1:34:28with the CTA. Yeah, it's kind of.
- 1:34:31Funny, I feel like I'm the crotch of the old man shaking
- 1:34:33his fist at the sky and yelling at the clouds and telling them
- 1:34:35to get out and telling the kids to get off my lawn.
- 1:34:38And the older I get, the crankier I get.
- 1:34:39But I but I do think that there's just some, I think this
- 1:34:43is crap. I think that what we're seeing
- 1:34:44is just crap. And you know, I'm just trying to
- 1:34:48do, I do what I can to let people know that there's, you
- 1:34:51know, the wheels are wheels are falling off the wagon.
- 1:34:54You know you need to do something about it.
- 1:34:57Agreed. Yeah, I like the joke.
- 1:35:00I think I'm bitcoins 32 year old.
- 1:35:01Boomer, We're kindred spirits here.
- 1:35:04I'm. I'm very much display it is so
- 1:35:07it was like a humiliation ritual.
- 1:35:09I'm 51, so I was born in 72, so I'm not quite a boomer, but I
- 1:35:13hear what you're saying. Definitely a boomer for Bitcoin
- 1:35:19purposes. Yeah, it's been credit.
- 1:35:24I know we had a new segment we went to roll out, but I think in
- 1:35:28respect of everybody's time, we can push that to next week.
- 1:35:30Gentlemen, what do you think? I think so, yeah.
- 1:35:33Yeah, I think that's right. I think I will say for everyone
- 1:35:37listening, if you enjoyed this content, you might also like on
- 1:35:41Ramps newsletter. Just today we had Dylan Mcclaire
- 1:35:44send out his weekly roundup of everything that's going on in
- 1:35:46the macro landscape. An incredible free research
- 1:35:51newsletter where he packages up everything that you should know
- 1:35:54from you know him spending all of his time in the market on on
- 1:35:58Twitter and researching. And so that is available at
- 1:36:01onrampbitcoin.com/research. You also get you get 2 emails a
- 1:36:07week, one being Dylan's weekly roundup and the other being a
- 1:36:14week weekly e-mail about an educational topic in Bitcoin.
- 1:36:20Often it's it's something that I've written.
- 1:36:23Recently we had a macro Jack put out his The Digital Gold Rush
- 1:36:28which was an excellent. A historical parallel, digging
- 1:36:32into what happened in the in the California Gold Rush and how it
- 1:36:36relates to what's setting up right now for Bitcoin.
- 1:36:39I'm just a fun read for for everyone, so check out on me at
- 1:36:43bitcoin.com/research. Put your e-mail there.
- 1:36:45You can unsubscribe anytime and and look forward to sharing
- 1:36:49more. Shout to Macro.
- 1:36:51Jackie was just pinging us in a separate channel that he ran
- 1:36:53into Dave column up and upstate New York the last Thursday he
- 1:36:56had Dave D Emmy over the weekend was like, hey, do you know this
- 1:37:01guy Macroge? I was like, yeah, we actually
- 1:37:04went to the same high school, which is this funny small world.
- 1:37:09Yeah, they put something in. But I like to joke with Marty.
- 1:37:10They they put something in the water down there.
- 1:37:12There's a lot of these bitcoiners that are freedom
- 1:37:14oriented writing on Twitter. And yeah, that was the focus of
- 1:37:19our high school. They the purpose was to make
- 1:37:22sure that we left and knew how to write.
- 1:37:23So I guess it was worth it. But before we wrap up Matt Work
- 1:37:28and anybody, let's just find out more about bespoke group and and
- 1:37:32what you guys are doing, how can they get a hold of you if
- 1:37:35they're they're interested? Yeah, just the website is just
- 1:37:38www.bespokegroup.io and because I'm an old man, LinkedIn is
- 1:37:45probably the best, best venue for me.
- 1:37:47I don't get a whole lot of value out of out of the bird app or
- 1:37:50now the X app or whatever the hell that's all about.
- 1:37:53So yeah, LinkedIn. You can just find me Matt
- 1:37:56Mcclintock. Name's MCC LINTOCK.
- 1:38:00And you can find me there. Yeah.
- 1:38:02And it's. You can always find me through
- 1:38:04Michael. Michael's my man.
- 1:38:05And so I. You reach out to Tangum and he
- 1:38:07can. He can get me.
- 1:38:09We can send you some of the materials, he shared.
- 1:38:11Those are some of the best materials I've seen in in the
- 1:38:14space. So yeah, happy to to pass along
- 1:38:16some of the stuff you guys worked on.
- 1:38:18Yeah, I mean anything that I've given you feel free to to you
- 1:38:21know distribute paper the world with it.
- 1:38:24I'm waiting for my I'm waiting for like some on ramp swag from
- 1:38:26you guys. Yes, we we do at some point need
- 1:38:30to make some swag. That is, she's in the
- 1:38:33intermediate horizon. Priorities.
- 1:38:37Priorities, I guess Two weeks TM.
- 1:38:42Well, Matt, thank you so much for joining us and educating us
- 1:38:45about what you're doing and how we can be smarter about planning
- 1:38:48for our future. I think it was incredibly
- 1:38:51insightful and I think people are getting a lot of value out
- 1:38:53of this. Well, thanks for thanks for
- 1:38:55letting me share. I mean I'm, I'm passionate about
- 1:38:58what I do and I think that what we do really I guess kind of the
- 1:39:04last thing I'd say and I'll just promise I'll shut up.
- 1:39:07It's just what whatever we build in life represents the economic
- 1:39:14measurement of our success. And it's it's only the economic
- 1:39:18measurement, but it does represent our time on this
- 1:39:22planet and so. When we think about, you know,
- 1:39:26how are we going to, you know, pass that on beyond ourselves.
- 1:39:32That's that's heavy. I mean, what you know what
- 1:39:34what's more important than planning to leave the people
- 1:39:39that you care about behind in the way that honors them and
- 1:39:42really sets them up to be the best, the best versions of
- 1:39:44themselves? It it goes far beyond the
- 1:39:47mechanics because it's there's much more that's important than
- 1:39:50taxes. There's a human element.
- 1:39:54To this process that often gets overlooked.
- 1:39:58When we focus on the mechanical, we focus on the tax.
- 1:40:01We don't really think about the human element of this.
- 1:40:05But it's it's it's critical. I mean, I don't know if you guys
- 1:40:08have kids or not, but a lot of the folks that will hear this
- 1:40:12ultimately will. One of these days, those kids
- 1:40:15are going to have to go on without us and how are we going
- 1:40:19to set them up to really succeed and and.
- 1:40:23Be the the best versions of themselves.
- 1:40:25Free from distractions, free from you know predators that
- 1:40:30could take advantage of them. Yeah.
- 1:40:33So it's it's that's really the most important thing of of what
- 1:40:36I do I think is is trying to blend the technical tax,
- 1:40:40mechanical, sterile, quantitative side of structuring
- 1:40:45with the human element of dealing with the totality of
- 1:40:51economic wealth that somebody's built in the hands of people who
- 1:40:55someday that will receive it. Very nicely said.
- 1:41:00Appreciate you sharing that. Yeah.
- 1:41:04It's not for us what we're going to leave behind, who we're going
- 1:41:07to leave it to, what's our legacy is going to be.
- 1:41:09I think these are very important things to think about in these
- 1:41:14troubling but exciting times. I think.
- 1:41:17I think we're going to end it there.
- 1:41:20Gentlemen, it was a pleasure. Sitting down and discussing all
- 1:41:23this with you over the last hour and a half hour and 45 minutes.
- 1:41:27We'll see you guys next week on Last Trade.