Latest / Forgotten Hollywood / Episode 234- History vs Hollywood w/Author MJ Trow
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to You've Forgotten Hollywood with doug Hess here on Jiljmedia. Hello everyone,
- 0:22and welcome to Forgotten Hollywood, your podcasts and memories of yesteryear. My
- 0:26name is doug Hess, and if you're tuning in and Forgotten Hollywood for the
- 0:29first time, what I do on this podcast is take you on a journey
- 0:32back in time and share with you pieces of Hollywood that you may or may
- 0:36not know about. And in this episode we have a very special guest with
- 0:40us today, MJ Trolled in his latest book, History Versus Hollywood, How
- 0:48the Past is Filmed. Now, if you're in the UK, it's already
- 0:52out, but if you're here listening in the States, you're going to have
- 0:55to wait until May thirtieth of this year, twenty twenty four to pick up
- 0:59your car. But m Jay, first of all, welcome for going Hogwood
- 1:06Hollywood. Yeah. Well, like everybody of my generation, Doug, I
- 1:11was brought up with Hollywood. We went to the pictures back in the day.
- 1:17We were all cowboys and Indians or if we worked out, I mean,
- 1:21were lights in armor and quite literally, my interest in history came from
- 1:26that source, from watching movies. I didn't realize then that they weren't quite
- 1:32accurate. I thought what I was seeing was absolutely right and correct and true,
- 1:38that the good guys wore white hats and row white horses, and the
- 1:42values wore black hats and black horses. And when you're seven, that's absolutely
- 1:47fine, you know, no problem at all with that. It was only
- 1:51a long time afterwards that I realized life isn't quite that simple. Absolutely,
- 1:57And you know what, it's a double sword in my opinion. One is
- 2:04it's great that Hollywood is bringing some of these individuals to life which may have
- 2:09been forgotten, if you will, in the history books. But the negative
- 2:15part is a lot of people are basing these films, like you just said,
- 2:20on facts, and they're getting some misinformation regarding history. That's exactly right.
- 2:29If I give you two examples. One is El Sid with Chuck Heston,
- 2:35one of my all time favorites. Nobody outside Spain had heard of El
- 2:38Sid before Hollywood got hold of it, so my thanks to Heston for making
- 2:45it available to us. All. I was eleven when I saw that one
- 2:49in the cinema, and I was bowled over by it. Unfortunately, almost
- 2:53nothing it is true, but that's another story. The other one, much
- 2:58more recently, is Mel Gibson's Brave Heart, which isn't true either. It's
- 3:05a great story. It's a rattling goodyear and I saw that in the cinema
- 3:09as well. I thought, right, they bring back epics. This is
- 3:14wonderful. Now. I remember epics in the nineteen sixties, but Brave Heart
- 3:19was much more recent, and I thought, terrific, we're back. We
- 3:23were back, but we were also back with all the usual mistakes. Yeah.
- 3:28Absolutely, I mean that's a great film. I have a copy of
- 3:31the film. I love watching the film. But you're right, and what
- 3:38you have to be very cautious about is you have to watch these films and
- 3:44then basically pick up a book and do your own research to figure out what's
- 3:47true and what was Hollywood made up. That's exactly right. The problem I
- 3:54think for a Hollywood producer and a scriptwriter is that he or she has to
- 4:00write a very simple story. It has to make sense quickly to an audience
- 4:04that knows nothing about the situation. So there has to be a good guy,
- 4:09there has to be a bad guy, there has to be some love
- 4:11interest, and it doesn't have to end happily ever after. That's not essential,
- 4:16but there's going to be a little bit of humor on the way,
- 4:20a lot of color, a lot of excitement. If you had a film
- 4:26script written by an historian, my god, it would be dull, it
- 4:30would be terrible. It would be maybe if far. But there again,
- 4:34the usual historian arguments the ding dong, and that doesn't work for a movie.
- 4:40You've got to tell the story quickly, simply and straight. Yeah.
- 4:45No, I'll give you even a more recent film. This past Thanksgiving,
- 4:48my youngest son and I went to watch Napoleon. You know, you have
- 4:54a very complex individual that spans many, many, many years, and you
- 5:00have to basically take his life, if you will, and cram it into
- 5:05three hours, which is a impossible and me, you're just picking and choosing,
- 5:13and like you said, in order to make it entertaining and make the
- 5:18audience kind of draw in to watch it, you've got to give it a
- 5:21little bit of fluff. Yeah, you have. Unfortunately, my book was
- 5:27written before Napoleon came out, so I refer to it in the book,
- 5:30but I hadn't seen it then. I have now, and I finally enjoyed
- 5:35it. But Phoenix is very good. Yes, of course. The problem
- 5:40is when you're following a man's life. Phoenix was too old for the young
- 5:45Giberal in Italy, and he was I think he was something like three years
- 5:51too old even when the Polian was defeated at Waterloo, and you can't do
- 5:58anything about that. You make up these days is wonderful, and Phoenix is
- 6:02a constant actor, but it's impossible, I think, to give that impression
- 6:09of the boy general becoming the god of war, which is a hell of
- 6:13a transition, as you say, in three hours. It really can't be
- 6:16done right. Absolutely. Now, I'll tell you a film that I truly
- 6:21enjoyed from the nineteen seventies was Patent with Georgey Scott portrarian Patent. I mean,
- 6:29that's an incredible film. The problem with that is a lot of people
- 6:34have, you know, kind of glamorized Patent in that film, made him
- 6:42out to be maybe something that he truly wasn't. The thing about Patten a
- 6:48bit like George Custer in a different era. He was a great self publicist.
- 6:54And anybody who carries two guns with ivory handles, you know, I
- 6:59mean, come on, and his statements he's going to hang that paper hanging
- 7:04son of a bitch, Hitler. This is tremendous stuff and it galvanizes the
- 7:11men speechmaking stirs them up, which is exactly what you want in a general.
- 7:16But how far can you possibly then believe in him? I'd love to
- 7:23think that he was really a shy, retiring little soul behind the scenes,
- 7:28but I don't think he was. I think he was larger than life and
- 7:30he knew it. Damn good soldier, but he wanted everybody to be aware
- 7:35of that, and I think George Scott caught him absolutely. Oh. His
- 7:42performance deserved the Academy Award for Best Actor for that film, and it's a
- 7:48wonderful film. Unfortunately, like you say, not only in your book,
- 7:53but as we're talking here right now, is that a lot of this stuff
- 7:57is Hollywood ad lib to sell Pitcher. Yeah. I think the problem with
- 8:05Pattern comes down to that one incident, doesn't it, where where he slapped
- 8:11that wounded soldier. Everybody was appalled by that and thought he'd gone too far.
- 8:16But of course there are many other examples of Pattern doing the reverse where
- 8:20he praises his men and is extremely supportive of them. So it really is
- 8:26very difficult, and if you have a biography of pattern, then you would
- 8:31have all that discuss the nuances would be there. But as I said a
- 8:35moment ago, you can't really show that in a movie, right. Yes,
- 8:39it's very difficult, especially with the time refraints and ensure we have films
- 8:45that are three hours and every once in a while you'll get something that's a
- 8:48little bit longer. In that then you risk the viewer tuning out no matter
- 8:54how good it is. Yeah, that's exactly right there now, of course,
- 9:00is for much longer movies than they used to make. Or the television
- 9:05series can do it another way by looking at a long period over time,
- 9:13maybe in ten to fifteen episodes, which is better. I think it makes
- 9:18life easier, but in a sense, you lose the single simple story that
- 9:26way, and I think a lot of people get a bit bored with television
- 9:31series, to be honest, if I can introduce one that I thought was
- 9:33superb The Vikings, I don't know if you know that one, but I
- 9:39thought that was brilliantly done. Everything about it was right, It looked real,
- 9:46it felt real. They took actual history, although they tended to constant
- 9:50tenerating Two. How much tighter time span than really happened. But unfortunately,
- 9:56of course they introduced the idea of Field Maples and I'm sorry any ladies who
- 10:03are going to watch this podcast, but they didn't exist. Okay, spoiler
- 10:09alert, they are not real. We wish that Lagatha was. She was
- 10:13a wonderful character and you were there Alongsideer fighting away hacking with the sword.
- 10:20But it didn't. It didn't gel for me. It just didn't work.
- 10:26And I think in many ways, just now and again, I'd be happy
- 10:31if I went into a movie well I didn't know the history, you know,
- 10:33I think I'd enjoy it much more. I realized that what mistake,
- 10:39you know? Yeah, yeah, and no, I think that's a great
- 10:45point is sometimes walking into a film and not knowing anything about it other than
- 10:50this sounds like a great topic for a movie. Is better than walking in
- 10:56and then what you're doing is your second guest in the film, even though
- 11:01it may be a beautifully done film, and you're like, well, that's
- 11:03not right. They didn't do this. This didn't happen. And I think
- 11:07a lot of times it runs the movie, at least for me, when
- 11:11I know too much about what's actually going on. I think so. I
- 11:16had a friend who went to see Nicholas and Alexandra many years ago about the
- 11:22Russian royal family, the Romanovs, and he had no idea what happened to
- 11:28him, And as he was watching it, he thought, Oh, they're
- 11:31going to be rescued in a minute, the white Russians are going to come,
- 11:35the Cossacks are going to arrive, the cavalry will come to the rescue
- 11:37and get him out. And he was gobsmacked to find that actually didn't happen.
- 11:43The entire family was wiped out. And this is a highly articulate,
- 11:46intelligent man. He was at university with me. He now has two degrees,
- 11:52and still he had no idea about that at all. Yes, and
- 11:58probably really enjoyed the film because he didn't know, and he wasn't like,
- 12:03like I said, kind of second guess in everything that you portrayed in the
- 12:07film. Question for you during your research and the writing of this book,
- 12:13did anything surprise you during the research and the writing of the book. I'm
- 12:20sorry, said again, Doug, Did anything surprise you during your research of
- 12:24this book? Oh? I don't think so, simply because I've lived with
- 12:30this whole idea for so long. It's it's a book I've always wanted to
- 12:37write. I think there's one example. I don't know if you're familiar with
- 12:43the film Kingdom of Heaven, which is about the Crusades. Orlando bloom Is
- 12:52the is the hero. It's got an excellent cast, people like Leam Neeson
- 12:56and Jeremy Irons, and I've it was directed by Ridley Scott, who was
- 13:05I think an excellent director, and I've got his director's cut DVD, and
- 13:13in that he showed us some outtakes and for the first time they had a
- 13:18Syrian actor playing Saladin. Before that, he's always been Americans or Brits,
- 13:26and he just doesn't work. If you brown somebody up and you know that
- 13:31a white man, it just doesn't make sense. So to have the Syrian
- 13:35actor in that role was marvelous because there was an air of realism which really
- 13:43added a dimension, I think to that. But in the director's cut there
- 13:48is an outtake where somebody is being decapitated and it goes horribly wrong and it
- 13:54looks ridiculous and the whole crew were falling about the actors and the camera crew
- 14:01or laughing. But a Syrian guy isn't. Obviously, this is not a
- 14:05Middle Eastern sense of humor. He didn't look for him at all. He's
- 14:09vaguely disgusted with what's going on with the whole time wasting. And I thought
- 14:13there was a very interesting take on the two cultures. You know that we're
- 14:18talking about the two cultures East West's West in the Middle Ages, but here
- 14:24we see just a tiny glimpse of it in the twenty first century. I
- 14:28thought that was that's fascinating. No, I think that's an excellent point,
- 14:33and that's something you have to be careful with when you're doing these films,
- 14:39is making sure that everybody that's in place understands what's going on, because they
- 14:46could be very offensive to somebody. Yes, I think that that's extremely difficult
- 14:50nowadays when audiences I think are more sensitive than there used to be. He
- 14:58is very easy to offend people. Again, the problem with the stript writer,
- 15:05the problem with the director. He has to take sides. If you
- 15:09don't take sides, you don't have a movie. A superb film from many
- 15:15years ago from Britain called Zulu, which was made in nineteen sixty four,
- 15:22and it deals with the defense of a place called Rock's Drift in Africa,
- 15:26where a tiny handful of British soldiers when a regiment then called the twenty fourth
- 15:31Foot, are defending it against four thousand Zulas. They're hopelessly outnumbered, and
- 15:37amazingly the Zulus let them go. They could have killed them, they didn't
- 15:43because they were so impressed by their heroism. And for that one day's action,
- 15:48the British Army was awarded eleven Victoria crosses, which is still a record
- 15:54even with two World Wars. It's still a record today. So it's a
- 15:58press ship story. It's an extremely impressive film, but it works because we
- 16:03see it really only from the white man's point of view. If we'd seen
- 16:08it from the Zulu point of view as well, it wouldn't have been quite
- 16:12so effective. And funnily enough, the same director tried that a few years
- 16:17later with a film called Zulu Dawn, which is the same campaign, different
- 16:22battle, and he did show both sides. We were in on conversation with
- 16:29Zulu warriors as well as the British, and from our mind it was nowhere
- 16:33near as good. You've got to keep your stories simple, absolutely, no,
- 16:40absolutely, MJ. Real quick, what are some examples in your mind,
- 16:45in your opinion, that completely got everything wrong and kind of on the
- 16:53negative side of things. But then I'm going to flip that around and ask
- 16:56you the same question. Film that probably got it right the majority of the
- 17:02time, do you think the audience should view Yeah, that's very difficult.
- 17:10Thank you for that. I don't think any film gets it or wrong.
- 17:18I'm talking What I did in my book was to choose movies that had real
- 17:23characters in them. Sure, so I'm not talking about b Feature Western's here
- 17:29with Randolph Scott and John Wayne and Audio Murphy because they weren't playing real characters.
- 17:34And I think that any movie that has real characters goes a certain way
- 17:41down the road to putting it right. To take a silly example, and
- 17:45don't get me wrong here, because I love this film, Calamity Jane.
- 17:51Calamity Jane with Doris Day. I mean, I fell in love with Doris
- 17:55Day when I was six, and I've been in love with her ever since.
- 18:00She is the most gorgeous, gorgeous lady. But she is no more
- 18:03Martha Cannery than I am. She just does not look like or sound like
- 18:10and she certainly doesn't sing like I don't suppose the real calamity Jane did.
- 18:15The real calamity Jane sadly was a drunk, She was a nuisance. She
- 18:21told enormously told stories about having scouted for the army, which she never did.
- 18:26She was supposedly the girlfriend of wild Bill Hicktock, which she wasn't either.
- 18:32You know, he just goes on and on, and of course,
- 18:33the film, being a very lighthearted musical and starting Darris Day and Howard Keel
- 18:40touches on none of that whatsoever. It didn't pretend to. And I don't
- 18:45criticize the film for that. It was telling a story in a totally different
- 18:49way. But to go to the other extreme to find a film that gets
- 18:56it right, I can't do that either. It's a sad indictment that I
- 19:03don't know how many thousands of movies I've seen in my lifetime, but not
- 19:10one of them has got it right, which is an awful indictment of something
- 19:15or other. There are reasons why, as I've said, you've got to
- 19:18tell a story, you've got two and a half to three hours to tell
- 19:22it. You've got to make it simple, you've got you've got to have
- 19:25the good either bad either girl. All those things are watch shape historical movies,
- 19:32but it means that there are mistakes everywhere. Things have to be simplified.
- 19:38We haven't got time to get into the nuances, the backwards and forwards,
- 19:45the various interpretations, all the stuff that historians do as a matter seen.
- 19:51Movie makers don't because they can't. So for me, my favorite historical
- 19:59film is the second version of the Charge of the Light Brigade, the one
- 20:03made by Tony Richardson in nineteen sixty eight. I saw that just after I
- 20:10left school when it first came out, and I was bowled over by it.
- 20:15I'd also seen the Evil Flynn earlier version in nineteen thirty six, which
- 20:19is tremendous. It's a rattling good yarn, but of course has nothing right
- 20:25about it at all. Flynn rides with a fictional regiment, the Thretty seven
- 20:30Lancers, that didn't exist until World War Two. He's involved in India in
- 20:37a way that wasn't true either. We have an absolute baddie of an Indian
- 20:45prince working with the Russians. What yeah, okay, if you say so.
- 20:49To make the plot work, that has to happen, except it,
- 20:53oh, dear, but the second one, the Tony Richardson won tried very
- 20:59very hard to get things right, but even there they cheat. I don't
- 21:03know if you know the film, but there is this wonderful scene where Lord
- 21:07Cardigan played by Trevor Howard, who actually led the charge Lughede, not Errol
- 21:12Flynn. But Lord Cardigan has a brief fling with the wife of one of
- 21:18his officers. He seduces her on board his yacht in Balaclava Harbor. Now
- 21:23there is absolutely no evidence for that whatsoever, but it's a tremendous scene.
- 21:30It's very funny, beautifully handled, and no big deal. But when I
- 21:37wrote a book sometime ago on a guy called William Morris who commanded the seventeenth
- 21:41Lancers, that's the right regiment at Balaklava, and I got to know his
- 21:48family, who now lives in South Africa, and they went to see the
- 21:52film, and the grandfather of the family was outraged by this scene, but
- 21:56sorry by another scene where Captain Nolan was David Hemings is having an affair with
- 22:03Morris's wife, which again never happened, but it makes for good interesting cinema.
- 22:07And apparently the old boy was so absolutely furious when he saw this,
- 22:12he strung up in the cinema and shouted, bloody rubbish. I had to
- 22:17be quiet escorted out what we were saying a minute ago about how easy you
- 22:23choose to offend people. Yes, happened, absolutely, you know. And
- 22:29one last film before we wrap it up here, because we're getting close on
- 22:33time. That or one individual that I think still is powerful today than ever
- 22:41before was Lincoln, Abraham Lincoln. Obviously, a couple of years ago,
- 22:48Steven Spielberg's film Lincoln came out with Daniel Dave Lewis out there, and then
- 22:53I could I know, in the forties there were several movies out there,
- 22:56Young Abe Lincoln with Henry with Henry Fonda, there was another it was yeah,
- 23:03yeah, there's another film out there with Lincoln with Ramsey Massey as Abraham
- 23:10Lincoln. The films, and you know, very few historical figures can still
- 23:17carry and demand the attention from film audience all these years later, and I
- 23:26think Abraham Lincoln is one of the few that they can pull it off.
- 23:30Yeah, you're absolutely right. He's a fascinating character, a great man.
- 23:36I would have said, your best president of all time, And were extremely
- 23:42good. The end of day, Lewis who really gets under the skin of
- 23:47the people he plays, Yes, yes he does. He's a phenomenal actor.
- 23:52But you know, even when we go back to the forties, you
- 23:55know, a young Henry Fonda and Ramsey Massey both I think portray a good
- 24:03portrayal of Lincoln during those particular time periods. Yeah, I think that's absolutely
- 24:10right. And the story itself from log Cabin to White House is such a
- 24:14magic one, doesn't it. I mean there's so much there, and talking
- 24:18about numals the other day, having to see things from two different sides.
- 24:22I think everybody day Lewis, Massey and Fonder all do that very well.
- 24:30That Lincoln is an extremely complex character. He's not straightforward. And let me
- 24:34ask you a questian dok okay, talking about presidents, why are there actually
- 24:40no films about George Washington? You know that that's a great that's a great
- 24:47question. Now you'll see Washington as a second character in some of the other
- 24:52films, and one of them is John Adams uh Out, an HBO special,
- 25:00wonderful portrait. But I think you bring up a great point. Here
- 25:04is the father of our country, the first president, and he's really playing
- 25:11second fiddle in all the films that he's ever in. Yeah, yeah,
- 25:15very odd, very odd. I think he spent sixteen years to Lincoln,
- 25:21which I think between Washington and Lincoln, there's a lot of similarities. You're
- 25:26growing a nation, founding a nation, you have a great civil war,
- 25:30a division in the country to first in a lot of ways. But yes,
- 25:41that's a great question that you bring up. Why does Washington get the
- 25:45pass? And more like Lincoln and some of the other individuals, Kennedy would
- 25:49be another one. I think that gets a film. Obviously, there's a
- 25:55lot of reasons for Kennedy because he was assassinated, that he was young,
- 26:00there's a lot of came a lot there, there's a there's a great story
- 26:04to tell there. So yeah, absolutely, Yeah, you bring up a
- 26:10great question. That's really fascinating. Uh. The one film that was on
- 26:15A and E that I remember watching about Washington was called The Crossing, Yes,
- 26:22Crossing somewhere, But I don't consider that that was a film, but
- 26:26it wasn't on the big screen. That was more made for TV, if
- 26:32you will, that's exactly right. I've seen that too. I think it
- 26:34was it was largely your German production, wasn't it, And uh yeah,
- 26:38it didn't have the coverage that it should have done. Yeah, I thought
- 26:42that was excellent. So I thought Jeff Daniels was extremely good. Absolutely absolutely,
- 26:48But you're exactly right, he does not get the attention that that he
- 26:52deserves. So yep, well again, thank you for coming on and spending
- 26:57a few minutes with us today. And I would and strongly encourage everyone to
- 27:02go out and get a copy of History Versus Hollywood, How the Past Is
- 27:06Filmed. If you're out, if you're in the UK, it's already out,
- 27:10but here in the States it's going to be out on May thirtieth of
- 27:12this year, twenty twenty four. Please go out and get a copy of
- 27:17MJ. Tros History Versus Hollywood, How the Past Is Filmed. I don't
- 27:23think you're going to be disappointed. Thank you, dog well, thank you,
- 27:29and thank you for listening to this episode of Forgotten in Hollywood. You
- 27:30search for Dodcaster Forgot in Hollywood. You can also find me on Twitter,
- 27:34Instagram at hesteg fourteen. If you listen to this podcast on iTunes another podcast
- 27:38service, please subscribe, rate and review this episode. Tune in next week
- 27:42for the latest episode of Forgot It in Hollywood. Thank you for listening and
- 27:45we will see you then.