Latest / Under The Pallet Wrap / Episode 18 - Why Commercial and Operations Drive Each Other Mad?
Transcript
- Keith: Welcome to Under the Pallet Wrap, episode 18 where we are joined by legend Jalil Rahman. Quick intro, why are you here? Jalil Rahman: Well, obviously I've been invited by you two to talk about the Dan Culverhouse: you Jalil Rahman: ongoing saga between worlds of commercial and operations and I hope to be able to shed a little bit more light on the commercial side, maybe a bit more on the commercial pressures that we face, Keith: Absolutely. In the unsuccessful businesses I've been at, there's definitely been a massive gulf between the ops team and not just the commercial team, but other teams as well. So Jalil Rahman: Yeah, yeah, yeah, I agree. Keith: to get to the point, why do we think that that happens? Jalil Rahman: Well, certainly from my point, I think what I've learned and I'm speaking from experience here where even I have not considered the impact of my operations colleagues. And it's basically because of, well, a couple of things, you know, the insane pressure that lots of commercial teams are under and surprise, surprise. It's obviously because revenue needs to be billed invoices need to be sent or something financial is kind of over on the company's head and certainly on the commercial team's head. And so oftentimes certainly in my career, there's been this kind of assumption that, yeah, they'll get on with it. They know what they're doing. But without there being kind of a formal interaction and without a bridge being built, it's basically assumptions, right? And so, I mean, one of the best examples I remember, because this was the moment later in my career, I won't give you the exact year, but I was working on a project and the project was effectively our brand. working with a world famous IT computer brand. And we were launching a laptop together. And at that time, as a brand, we did not sell laptops, we did not sell anything electrical. We were selling fashion garments. And did I think about contacting my ops guy? I didn't, because I was like, no, they just have to ship it. But there was a lot of factors, as I'm sure you guys know, that have to be Dan Culverhouse: yeah. Jalil Rahman: respected and all the other aspects of it that needed to be built in. Plus, what about these laptops being worth a pretty penny? What about the impact on insurance and security and all the rest of it in the warehouse, let alone the delivery chain? And so I recall specifically at that time saying to myself, do you know what? Maybe I should go and speak to our ops guy just in case. And lo and behold, he welcomed me with open arms. It was like, finally someone's giving us a heads up. And I think after that, that moment probably shifted a lot of my experiences. in what I'd done today in my career and certainly, you know, what I did thereafter, which was having an ongoing dialogue and respecting warehouse operations, shipping, all of those kind of connective pieces, because that gulf between me getting a contract signed and then a consumer purchasing a product that I was responsible for is pretty vast. That gulf is massive. And if you don't gently respect and build that bridge. Unfortunately, you you can have the best contract in the world, paying you the best amount of money, but if consumer dissatisfaction occurs because it's been just stumbling, mumbling and fumbling, alas, you know, it's a failure in my book. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, I'd just like to say that I'm very happy that when you finally went to operations that they welcomed you with open arms and they didn't just Jalil Rahman: Yeah, that was... Dan Culverhouse: abuse you because, I mean, let's be honest, you know, that historically this has always been a challenging relationship. So I think it's nice to hear that the ops team were actually doing rather than just like, what the hell are you doing here? Get out. Jalil Rahman: Yeah, no, the thing is, you know, when you, certainly in my experience I've found, and in the last few years especially so, when you depersonalise, like, some aggression or some previous assumptions about aggression or whatever it could be, when you kind of gently bring it down and you kind of, you just say, look, I understand that's what's happened in the past, but we're trying to build a bridge and work together. I've found certainly my ops colleagues, being real supportive and exemplary in trying to make sure because ultimately their job is about delivering operational excellence, right? And they can't do it without there being some dialogue. And that dialogue can't be loaded with, you know, previous thoughts about how they're X, Y and Z. I think just disarming things makes life a lot easier. Dan Culverhouse: I think there's a lot of, you you said it right at the start that we're all under pressure in different ways, right? We all have different objectives that don't always align. And, you know, that makes you get a little bit focused on the things that you get paid for and the things that your bonus determines that you're going to be recompensed for. You know, and it's then, you know, I've been doing this a long time and, you know, I've got endless examples of how, you know, just something that changes. You you change something about a SKU, you make it a bit bigger, you make the pack size different or whatever. And it's like, well, what does that matter? It's still the same product inside, but suddenly the warehouse is then dealing with two boxes of completely different. And nobody understands why the ops gets so bloody upset about it because they've Jalil Rahman: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Dan Culverhouse: now got these two products that they can't differentiate between. I'm very much a retail background, the classic is... a big promotion, you know, commercial and marketing work in secret because they don't want it to get leaked out into the Jalil Rahman: Mm-hmm. Dan Culverhouse: market. They want to make a big impact. So they get all this set up, order a whole load of stock, and then they go next week we're doing this huge thing. And then, course, you know, the poor operation. It's like, what? But these are very classic problems Keith: and by stressful times, I- Jalil Rahman: you know. Dan Culverhouse: that you see. And I'm amazed how often, you know, you go to another business and you see it again. And it's just like, how does this keep happening? Keith: Well, it's the most stressful part of being in an operation sometimes, those last minute launches, those crazy promotions that suddenly hit you. And I've always found it puzzling because as Jalil said at the beginning, we are actually all judged on revenue and profitability Dan Culverhouse: Ultimately. Keith: and efficiency. So it's always a bit strange when perhaps from top leadership level, the two are not connected. I've always found it's my duty to connect. the gaps because otherwise how can I do the job as well as I want to? I've been involved in so many scenarios where my superiors have said to me, why do you spend so much time speaking to buying and marketing and commercial teams? said, well, why not? I need to understand what's happening. Jalil Rahman: Yeah. Keith: Up the chain at the end of the day, it's a supply chain and they're up one end of it, I'm down another, customers down the other and now with circular logistics it's just a loop it all feeds into each other so we all need to know what we're doing Jalil Rahman: Yeah. Keith: and I make it my duty to find out what everyone's role is when we got a small business like a startup etc I've always found it incredibly strange where people don't talk to each other about their particular needs and their particular pressures because you all sit next to each other Jalil Rahman: Yeah. Keith: that's where it puzzles me the most Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. And I think that there is a, you know, a founder leader, I guess, root cause here in that if you're the founder and you're looking after both the operation and the commercial teams and you set them objectives, which are conflicting. So you tell the commercial team, you know, increase revenue, increase revenue, and you tell the supply chain or the ops team Jalil Rahman: Hmm Dan Culverhouse: operate for less. make yourself as lean as you can. Those two do not work together. know, one drives a problem for the other and the other drives a problem for the other. And, you know, and if you can't if you can't do that, you know, Jalil Rahman: You kind of touched on it. Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: if those two leaders then end up, well, I need to win. I need to win because I want my bonus. So, you know, Jalil Rahman: Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: And all the funny, silly stories that are real and cause a lot of pain, you know, all come to reality. Keith: Was it Dale Carnegie in 1936 who promoted win-win as the concept? I might be wrong, I might need to fact check myself there. it's been, it's the concept is Dan Culverhouse: It might not have been 36. Keith: universal, it's always been there, but it's not necessarily shared. It seems like two separate worlds sometimes. So educate us, what is the perfect partnership, the perfect commercial deal from your perspective? Jalil Rahman: Well, so it first has to go through like a filter. I'm going to speak from my experience, right? So a Keith: Yeah. Jalil Rahman: commercial partnership, whether it's licensing or some type of kind of collaborative effect or franchising, whatever it even may be, it's usually predicated on a real strategy. And that real strategy has to take into account kind of two broad areas, in my opinion. Number one is obviously knowing the brand, right? Knowing the reality. Like what is the brand? What does it mean to its customers? Where is it operating? Where is it allowed to operate? So for example, if you're a sportswear brand, should you be launching bed linen? Understanding the kind of intricacies of how in the markets that you're in, you're perceived. adjacencies in store, whether you're in wholesale or not, or if you're a kind of direct to consumer business. your price point, all of these things kind of form that basic knowledge of the business. I take that and then I try to apply that to what a commercial structure could look like around that, right? So the brand is the kind of nucleus of the idea. And then around it is, well, if we're going to be entering into contracts, do we have intellectual property protections in certain markets? Do we need to register for that? How much would that cost? Do we need to, when we're negotiating on a commerciality have a number in mind that we need to be able to achieve. How are we going to internally support this? There's all these factors that kind of go around. knowledge is obviously kind of critical around it, but then you've got the commercial discipline because I have worked with some interesting characters over the time. I've been working and some, some leaders just don't care at all. They're like, no, I just want as much money as possible. You know, that's not how it works because, you know, commercial leadership, whether it's a franchising agreement, a licensing agreement, whatever, it has to feel like win-win, exactly like Keith said. Both parties have to be able to shake hands and be like, I've got a good deal out of this. And the minute Dan Culverhouse: Uh-uh. Jalil Rahman: it feels lopsided, the minute it feels like someone is being cantankerous for the sake of it, then you kind of create this tension that never goes away. And that tension can appear in, you know, them not wanting to push the boat for developing new products or... them not wanting to do a good enough job for distribution. And it really comes down to goodwill. So that win-win mention Keith is effectively how I feel like I have to, you know, get deals in place because you've also got to remember that the pressures on the business in 2026 are immense. And then you've got, you know, this natural filter, right? So number one, can we do it ourselves? And if we can do it ourselves, how much is it going to cost? Because we're going to have to develop, source, pay, operations will have to obviously get involved. So there's all these people working together. You then got a kind of the licensing structure, which is effectively my bread and butter for the last few years. Licensing is basically finding a specialist, a brand specialist who takes the risk off your shoulders and says, look, I'll manage the design and development, I'll manage distribution and I'll manage marketing. you as the brand owner have to help me ensure that all those three ports are being fed into consistently. And when they take over that risk from you, obviously, you know, it means that as a business, you can potentially make far more profit. But there's another aspect to it, which is, you know, licensing might sound like a rich opportunity, but if your brand's kind of natural reach, doesn't feel like it could work in those spaces, you've got to pull back. Now, All of these points might sound a little bit out there, but the reason I mention them is because when it comes to the operational side, again, speaking from experience, when I've worked and explained to warehouse partners, ops partners in the businesses, what we're going to be doing, what we're going to be testing, how we're going to be doing it, what the consumer experience is, what the commercial strategy behind these new products look like, I found the buy-in a lot easier and I found projects get off. the ground smoother certainly on the brand side. That was a lot of talking, but tell me if any of that actually landed. Did that make sense? Dan Culverhouse: I mean, absolutely it does. I think I guess one of the things I was thinking while you were while you were talking, you know, there's a lot of. Partnership and collaboration. But that's between the commercial team and the external partner, the brand, the license. And I guess what was running through my mind while you were saying that is like, I wonder how much time they spend building a partnership with their operation or involving the operation in that partnership with the external. And, you know, it's easy for me to sit here and go, well, if you did that, it would be much better. I do recognize the challenge sometimes of having an operator in the room in those discussions because operators have a little bit of a tendency. We would call ourselves pragmatists, realists, I do recognize sometimes that that can border on pessimism, Jalil Rahman: No, no, no. Dan Culverhouse: bringing everything down. But it is true, right? It Jalil Rahman: Yeah, that's true. Dan Culverhouse: is true that an operator will look at it and say, if we're going to do that, then Christ, that's going to cause this problem, this challenge, that's going to make that more expensive. Keith: Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: So there is, even if they are being absolutely real, pragmatic and honest, how that can be perceived in a commercial, you you're trying to drive a deal is like this guy's just trying to derail it. You know, so I do really Keith: Yeah, I- Dan Culverhouse: get that there are times when it's just not the right person to be in the room or you need the right kind of operator. Keith: yeah, I can see why they left out. I've always tried to use the words yes but rather than no we can't. Like yes we can do that but it means we do this that and the other. Whereas some people, I've seen Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, these are the implications of. Keith: it, old school directors, nope, nope, it's gonna cost you an arm and a leg, it's gonna cost, Jalil Rahman: Yeah. Keith: we can't cope, we haven't got the resources. I mean we've all been in a warehouse, I mean I don't know if you've ever been in a warehouse down where there's absolutely hundreds of commissions. and a different process for each one and it can get a bit chaotic and it does become like many many elements of a business you know it seems a good idea at the time the first one the second one but by the time you get to 20 everything is all over the place. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. It's always the exceptions that blow everything out, right? So, you you can have a Keith: Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: broadly similar process, but, with this one, we have to do this. This one, we have to do that. Keith: we need an adjustment on the platform to do this and this and no, no Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, and it just. Keith: don't someone come steaming and don't do that for that brand. Why did you do that? We agreed not to and it's fine. But like anything, I think it's like, okay, you get to a point. What's the best way to support this direction we're going in? But when we're up against it, I think there's a lot of people holding their hands up in all departments. So from my experience, commercial going old. shut that person up and who do you think you are? Everyone's just trying to do their job. They're only trying Dan Culverhouse: And there's no doubt. Keith: to do their job. And I think, yeah, you're right. Like involving people as early as possible is great, but I can see why in some situations. Maybe someone from the commercial side Dan Culverhouse: There's a need to pivot. Keith: would leave it to the COO. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, there's a need to pivot. know, I think the commercial guys need to understand the implications of what this means in the operation, but that doesn't necessarily mean the right thing to do is to bring the operator to the custom to the, you know, the partnership meeting. But you need to understand where you can go. Yeah, you know, I think I think people need to recognize not always, Keith: certainly not, but involved them in the planning, in some part of the planning. Jalil Rahman: But you know. I'd say, you know, it Dan Culverhouse: not always. Sometimes it can be good. Jalil Rahman: also feels like there's a bit of a generational shift, if I'm being completely honest, with ops people, and that's not, I don't want to be mean. In the last 10, 15 years, people who are willing to be shared, people who are willing to be accountable and are willing to take a bit of transparency on both sides of the fence, by the way, commercial and ops, and frankly have respect for the other. in the brief time I've worked with Keith, for example, we were working on a project and it was a wild project of sorts. And, you know, there was a line delivered to us, which is, you you sit on that side and you do your thing and that person just has to do what you've basically said. And I remember the first few conversations where Keith and I sat down with each other, you know, mutual respect, mutual accountability, mutual clarity. mutual intent to deliver a good project and he was like very very realistic and pragmatic to your point Dan but it was never delivered in a apprehensive or harsh way and I must say you know it could be a reflection of our personalities or it could be a reflection of a much more modern approach to these things Working in tandem with people, working in partnership with people, I've found has always been a little bit easier than the walls. And I know that sounds like so obvious, right? I mean, I've certainly experienced that. Dan Culverhouse: It's not rocket science, right? So, you know, and I think you're right. mean, some of the, you know, the way that we've been we've been talking, we're kind of over emphasizing. And although it actually has been very much like that, but I agree with you that, you know, that it's almost like it's comedic. Some of the things that you think about when we were younger. And, you know, I can I can name you five or six very successful operations managers. Exactly what you've described. And you know what? They're bloody good at what they do. They get an operation over the line, but it takes a certain type of person. And that model of a leader isn't good when you pivot it and point it inwards to the business. They're very good at dealing with the operation. when you talk, you kind of like managing upwards, but managing outwards maybe is a better description. And I think... So it becomes a little bit more nuanced now. I think the kind of comedy things that we've described of being so polar opposite are probably not so common. I think they still do occur at times. I think that the nuances are still there. And I think some of it comes down, it's personality, right? It's the type of personality that becomes a commercial leader is a very different personality to the leader who becomes an ops leader. You know, you kind of look at the world differently. You have different strengths, which therefore means there is still a natural gap. mean, you my experience over the years is generally the commercial lead is probably more more senior than the ops lead. I mean, not always the case, but it's quite common for it to be kind of it may be not even in the hierarchy, but in closeness to the CEO or something, you Jalil Rahman: Mm-hmm. Mm. Dan Culverhouse: know, and You know, the mindset of a commercial leader is optimism, is drive, it's growth, it's belief, right? We can make this huge. Whereas the ops manager tends to be a little bit more, yeah, I need to get this over. It's all very well, I Jalil Rahman: Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: haven't these dreams, but I need to get it out every day. So they tend to downplay a bit of protectionism and, you know, it's analysis and I need proof of this. you know, And so there's a natural personality difference that makes that relationship harder. It means there's a natural place Keith: I think that world is shrinking. Dan Culverhouse: for to be in a point of disagreement. Keith: Yeah, to go back to your old point, I think that world is evolving. I think you see a lot more ops-based supply chain CEOs these days than you might have done in the past. And it always used to be that the financial element really worked on your side as a CEO. But now I see a lot more appointments from people with supply chain background. Because I think that a commercial-minded supply chain person is a commercial directors dream and Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: vice versa. So think the world is evolving to be a bit more lean, to be a bit more, you have to make the best of what you've got. I people have had to learn more skills. don't, again, I don't know if this is my personality, but I've never really seen the benefit of not knowing as much as I can about other people's needs because... Therefore I make everybody's life more easy and we get to the goal quicker. I've never really seen the benefit of holding information within or keeping people at bay. I've always been very open. Come and have a look at the operation. Get the buyers down. Come and look at the Jalil Rahman: you Keith: warehouse. Because I want them to understand our challenges and I want to know theirs. But yeah, I think in the past it was very much two separate worlds, but I think they're probably... Jalil Rahman: Mm-hmm. Keith: emerging a little bit more. And over the years I've had a few clients who have been commercial based and they've come to me just for that steer, that analytical Jalil Rahman: Mm-hmm. Keith: steer on some of their proposed processes and decisions. You know, is it the right thing to do operationally? Is it the wrong thing? So Jalil Rahman: Hmm. Keith: maybe that comes from being like that in the past, but I do see it changing. Jalil Rahman: And have they been open to your ideas, Keith? Has there been any resistance or have they just been willing to accept your professional guidance on that? Keith: I mean I've had some tense moments over the years, shall we say. But I've tried to learn from them, know, like mainly, I mean as we've all alluded to, we've got loads and loads of stories here, but I mean, yes, I've been there when Dan Culverhouse: you Keith: maybe the buying team was, I'm going back to your point on the bed linen you mentioned. Clothing we're going to lean into bed linen when I've been there before we're going to lead in lean into luggage and bikes Okay, well, we've got an automated Warehouse, so I mean you can't you can't not resist it Can you you got you got to say something and that is how do you propose that we process these products and? It'll be fine. It'll be fine now Some very rude things have been said about the operation but I have chosen not to take them personally and shield my team from some of the comments I chose not to lean into that. I chose to lean into the okay you've got a problem he's resisting the problem how can we solve it but yeah we had to come up with work around for certain products. And you know, it's almost, it's not a funny thing or a positive thing, but when the bike we sold came back as returned as a selection of bike parts in a box, I mean, it does lead you to chuckle between you, know, just a little bit. Like, why was this our big priority? I said it was a bit crazy, but... You you've got to things a go. I've always been of that mindset as well. You've got to give things a Jalil Rahman: Yeah. Keith: go. I know why people are leaning into these different collaborations and the pressures they're under. So I think it's always a good thing to try and make them work, but also provide that evidence whereby this is going to cost us money. It's not going to make us money. I would never hold back on that. I would always say this is actually going to drain our margin. We've all been there before. Ringing the bell, sales team generally ringing the bell. We both believe it's a ringing the bell, having worked together, like to celebrate your small wins. But sometimes sales go crazy with the bell. Yeah, yeah, yeah, we've got X amount of revenue. We're hemorrhaging money. It's not joined up. Do you know how hard it's been trying to keep up with this? It's absolutely, it's disjointed, so disjointed. Dan Culverhouse: And I think this is this has a lot of the challenge built into it. So people are under pressure when you're under pressure, but you focus on your basics. You're not worried about what commercials do. And I have to survive this operation today. And that's what I'm worried about. If commercials under pressure to hit a revenue target, then they just have to get every revenue they can get. So Jalil Rahman: Hmm. Dan Culverhouse: much of it is driven by culture in the company. And another area that I've always found drives so much behavior is, are you measuring the right stuff that drives a collaborative approach or is it Jalil Rahman: Hmm. Dan Culverhouse: driving a divisive approach? I worked in a very large business who they gauged supply chain performance based on the percentage of the supply chain cost was on margin. And that was it. If the percentage was low, great. If the percentage went up, supply chain was underperforming. It didn't matter. that maybe they just pushed a huge promotion of low value, low margin product. So the fact that the price of a product was maybe a dollar, Jalil Rahman: Hmm. Dan Culverhouse: but it still costs 50 cents to ship every unit. And if we were selling units that were $20, it still only costs 50 cents to ship it. So suddenly, depending on where the demand was going, is the performance would be like this. Keith: We suddenly Dan Culverhouse: 10 years life to try to defend this perspective. And Keith: turned from a luxury brand. Dan Culverhouse: it took me a long time to break it, but I did and said, look, we cannot measure supply chain. It's an interesting measure and it's an important one to know, but it's not a supply chain performance measure. Jalil Rahman: Hmm. Dan Culverhouse: you know, but sometimes, so if you can't got the right measurement, you're not hiding to nothing. And it just drives division between those two teams. Jalil Rahman: You kind of hit the nail on the head though, that was a really good point around revenue because in my opinion as a commercial person, not all revenue is good revenue because as kind of Keith alluded to in his comment, you can be a luxury brand and when things start to get a bit shaky or in some instances from leadership they're saying, we need some money ASAP by the end of this month, you can sometimes be forced to, sorry, some businesses might be forced to do what you've just described, which is, a lower quality product or something that just makes tension for everyone in the business and actually from a pure purely financial perspective doesn't return much for the business apart from you know what looks like inflated revenue but is really Dan Culverhouse: stress. Jalil Rahman: nothing unprofitable and it's damaged their brand the brand structure or brand positioning for me that's when like seriously good commercial leadership needs to to get involved and say look whilst you think that this action might give us a little rush before the end of the year or the end of the month even, it could be detrimental because it might, for example, let's say, you know, the knee jerk reaction from your executive is, let's just do a sale. Let's do a sale three weeks early. All you're doing there is you're training your customers for the next round to just wait. So they'll no longer be buying Dan Culverhouse: That way. Jalil Rahman: full price product. They'll be waiting until you do this knee jerk reaction where you're like, my God, 70 % off everything. And it starts to... it starts to impact not just that moment in time, but long term your brand's opportunity to license, collaborate, build out your kind of categories of the business and indeed long term commercially win. So I always find it quite dangerous when I've got a senior executive making these kind of knee jerk reactions because whilst of course you could respect while they might be doing it, there's completely obliviousness. to the impact it has long term on brand, on even operations to be quite honest with you, Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Jalil Rahman: on everything long term. So that's a good point, yeah. Dan Culverhouse: Once you get into that cycle, it's very hard to get out of it. I it's, you know, I work to distribute a business and same thing that, you know, the customers, they just used to wait towards the second half of the month and everybody would be panicking. So the price would be crashed and then all the demand comes in. you know, you used to, from an operation perspective, the first two weeks of a month, the dead quiet, the second two weeks of the month were insane. Jalil Rahman: Hmm. Dan Culverhouse: And then, you and you just go through this cycle week after week or month after month. And it's really very difficult to get out of. Keith: I've been there before and of course then your cost per unit is affected because you're working with lower margin products. It's Jalil Rahman: That's it, exactly. Keith: completely irrelevant. Your targets get skewed and then that becomes your business model. You drive it lower and lower and lower. You make sacrifices. know, Dan Culverhouse: misaligned objectives. Keith: when brands don't wish to collaborate because they don't want that mark down, then you start with a problem. Jalil Rahman: Yeah, you know, it's a really important point because as I said, you know, your elasticity of your brand is limited after that. When you start making these knee-jerk reactions, unfortunately, what tends to happen is consumer interest also wanes. So you might be saying, look, we've managed to plug that hole for the end of the month, but in six months time, that customer would have moved on. And it's that long-termist view. that I find in some instances in companies, certainly much smaller companies where you've still got like a kind of founder operator model, tends to be quite dangerous. You it takes discipline, frankly. It takes discipline to leave money on the table and say, you know what, we're just gonna follow the course. We're gonna try and fix this and make it work. But alas, it's easier said than done in some instances. Keith: Absolutely. Traditionally business people, leaders, founders, with the pressures they're under, they're not always that patient when it comes to long-term strategy. How do you balance that? It's difficult with a measured approach in ops sometimes to try and relay that to leadership. Like, no, no, don't rush into this. We need a little bit more data. We need to see this out and we need to Jalil Rahman: Mm-hmm. Keith: organise. We need to prioritise. from a commercial sense, how do you slow it down? Jalil Rahman: Well, look, unfortunately, there has to be a willingness on the executive level in terms of listening, right? So let's assume they're willing to listen. The education piece or that knowledge piece I kind of mentioned earlier is so bloody important because, you know, I've been in rooms where I've had a CEO say to me, I want to be in this place and I want to be in that place. And you're like, respectfully, availability is not the same as demand. You've got to be able to build demand first and demand is that difficult pushing a boulder up a hill moment where you're like, you know, you're spending money on advertising, on PR or placement. You're really investing heavily in kind of projects that are of a collaborative nature that bring some halo awareness to your brand. And then, and by the way, just to kind of illustrate that example, I have worked on a project where a CEO said, I want to be in this piece of distribution and then introduced me to the distribution business. And we paid for windows and we paid for placement and we did not sell a damn thing. And we'd spent so much money being in this prestigious account where, you know, our CEOs are friends and they made it work. And now what happens thereafter is Well, then why would they ever approach us again? You know, when you've not earned something and you've instead jumped, unfortunately, you get exposed. And it goes back to my point around education. the education piece is critical. you rely on someone, you'd hopes the executive is open minded about listening to a play. And it's why oftentimes when I've joined businesses, my first 90 days is spent learning as much as I can about the business, the good decisions, the bad decisions, what the founders want or the senior executives want, what actually has happened in that time. And then more importantly, kind of build a five year view of what could happen because that idea of we'll just wait and see isn't good enough for an executive. They're like, well, I'm paying you all this money. I want to see some action. And it's that kind of education and guidance around it that I've found helps me get them on board to my ideas. That's not always the case, mind you. They might still say to me, yeah, that's great. And then come month end, put everything on sale. But you you explain the risks. You can explain everything to your blue in the face. It doesn't matter. You know, effectively, they'll pull the executive card out and be like, I'm the executive. Do it. And you can. warn and preach and tell them about the oncoming doom, it doesn't matter. So it takes them, it's really relying on the mindset of the executive base in a business I found. Because some are willing to like, all right, you know what, you've said enough, we believe you. And then they'll be willing to play the game according to your kind of commercial cards. But other instances, kind of speak into a brick wall. Dan Culverhouse: And, yeah, and Jalil, I think it's also about all parties need to be willing to have that conversation and to step up. if you're in that leadership team, you know, and as a commercial leader, you might well be, you know, championing what you want, even with, you know, an understanding of, you know, of the operation. If the operations guy doesn't either support you, Or say, I get all of that, Jilil, but you're not considering this, not considering that. The poor CEO, how does he make that decision? Right. Jalil Rahman: Hmm. Yeah, yeah, Dan Culverhouse: And so that responsibility of you're the leader of an operation, you're the leader of the commercial to be having that open debate with, you know, let's face it, the CEO is generally the facilitator and the referee, you Jalil Rahman: Mm-hmm. Dan Culverhouse: know, because everyone's going to come from there. You know, I need to protect my operation. Jalil Rahman: Yeah. Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: you need to drive your objectives. So there will be tension and there should be tension, Tension is good as long as it's talked about openly. Jalil Rahman: Yeah, tension's not bad. Exactly, exactly. And it's same with ambition. Because the commercial team, you mentioned it earlier, we're always kind of the optimistic type, that we're going to ring a bell for anything, all the rest of it. But the ambition has to cascade the entire business. Because if ambition is only sitting in one room, and one room forever more, it's where you get these issues, where people aren't talking to each other, there's walls built up, there's aggression, there's... passive aggression is, you know, he said, she said, all that becomes so anti-commercial, Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Jalil Rahman: Ambition's got to be shared and it's got to be realistic. Dan Culverhouse: I did a really interesting exercise once. I was in a, it was a healthcare business and in one of the markets we had a real problem between the commercial and the operations teams that the relationship was just awful. I mean, they were literally, it was almost like their mission in life was to trip each other up because they got to this place where they just, you know, were just very irritated by each other. And Myself, I was leading the operation and the head of the healthcare commercial team. We actually were going very well. We worked very well together. So we went we went over to this market and we set them this task of you need so commercial. You need to present what it's like to be the lead in operations and operations. You need to present to us what it's like to be sitting in that commercial chair and running that. So walk in each other's shoes, right? Go and do that. And I tell you what, it was a brilliant session. They bought into it, the concept, and they had a really interesting conversation about what they thought it felt like to be the other person. Jalil Rahman: Mm. Dan Culverhouse: And they weren't best of mates afterwards, but there was a respect that had grown Jalil Rahman: Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: between I have a better understanding of what it means to be the commercial director or what it. Jalil Rahman: Yep. Dan Culverhouse: And it was, you and I think just that, as you say, that having a little bit of respect of saying it's not just about me, it's Jalil Rahman: Hmm. Dan Culverhouse: about everything. And if I need to have a little bit of understanding and once you get it, once you have that understanding, you can't forget it. Right. It's there then and it will niggle you. You know, I need to go and talk to the operation about this or the operator. I need I need to speak to commercial. Otherwise, we're heading down a dangerous road here. I need Jalil Rahman: Hmm. Dan Culverhouse: to I need to wave my flag and and not come in all aggressive about, you're screwing up my business, you're killing my operation. But it's Jalil Rahman: Hmm. Dan Culverhouse: just like, hey, guys, I'm seeing some things that are a bit concerning. Can I talk to you about it? Can we understand it? You know, when you've got that cadence of relationship and communication and understanding, there's nothing you can't get past, right? There's nothing. Jalil Rahman: It Keith: Well, Jalil Rahman: kind of goes back Keith: we... Jalil Rahman: to a point we touched on earlier, which is, you know, the generational change. And I'm speaking from experience. I'm speaking purely from a commercial experience. When I joined this world of retail, luxury goods, whatever you want to call it, I remember distinctly that the commercial approach was always whoever says the first number is the loser, right? Like a kind of old school game of Dan Culverhouse: you Jalil Rahman: negotiation. And over the years, I'm speaking purely from a first-hand experience. Those people still exist, although they're now in advanced positions and might be leading businesses elsewhere. But the people at my level, so kind of like delivering and managing projects and negotiating, the negotiation format is so much easier because it's less about this kind of, if you say you're number first, you're a loser. It's more about, this is how much I want to win. This is how much you want to win. And let's try and make it work. And that, for me, is a kind of example of how every other division or every other area of the business or of business has evolved with modern times. You know, it's like Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Yeah. Jalil Rahman: that kind of point around empathy and understanding. You know, even commercial we might be considered like bloody vampires. I can tell you firsthand, I can speak so transparently with people on the other side of the table. And I always intend to do that because it's not some, you know, sneaky attempt to negotiate or, you know. psychological approach to negotiation. It's like, listen pal, I want to earn this much money and you want to earn that much money, so let's just make it work. And doing that and forging alliances properly, I find is so much more helpful than that old world approach that I was exposed to when I first joined. And this was obviously back 23 years ago. And I'd say like the last 10 years of my career, I can just disarm people and say, listen, this is what I want to achieve. Tell me what you want to achieve. And we can figure it out together. The filter has almost been removed, not the filter, the block has been removed. And I wonder aloud if in other areas of the world, whether it's buying, merchandising, ops, that kind of, I wouldn't call it evolution because that'd be disrespectful, but the kind of openness of dialogue has also been happening, right? Has it? Dan Culverhouse: It's the non-ego driven. Keith: Well, I hope so. It has for me. Jalil Rahman: Yeah. Keith: Does it always happen? No. I mean, we all meet tradition this we all learn our own paths, don't we? And I don't know what prohibits people from being open, but what works for them works for them, doesn't it? And Jalil Rahman: Yeah. Keith: if it's working and they perceive it's working, they're going to carry on. I've got my own theories on leadership and successful leadership and that is that providing people with transparency is the right way to go. That doesn't mean exposing every detail to every Jalil Rahman: Yeah, of course. Keith: member of the world. It just means just say what you mean Jalil Rahman: Yeah. Keith: in the kindest way. Dan Culverhouse: think it comes with confidence. I think if you're a little bit insecure about how good you are or how effective you are, then when you go into these these discussions, which could be tense and difficult, Jalil Rahman: Mm-hmm. Dan Culverhouse: if you're not confident and comfortable about that, you know your game, then you go in with a with a protection of my ego. I don't want to look an idiot. I don't want to be embarrassed. Jalil Rahman: Yeah. Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: So you you hold back on some of the truths or you keep some stuff in your back pocket. So, you know, whereas I mean, I and I definitely know I did that, you know, when I was when I was not what I call skilled or enlightened on the art of negotiation, right? Because whether it's with an external party or in turn, you're still negotiating Jalil Rahman: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: really to get the right deal. You know, I think the days and until you said it yourself, the days of I just need to get the best deal. Jalil Rahman: Mm. Mm. Dan Culverhouse: kind of passed because everyone realized that the best deal just falls apart as soon as you walk away because one party lost and therefore they're not going to commit to it. Jalil Rahman: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Exactly. Dan Culverhouse: you know, and I think I did, I went on, you know, commercial negotiation training as quite a senior ops leader. And I was like, my God, you know, this is just common sense. It's just everybody being reasonable and thinking about both sides. You know, I expected, you know, naively, I honestly thought I was going to go in there and learn. how to win, right? And it's, I mean, Jalil Rahman: Alan Sugar style, yeah. Dan Culverhouse: maybe that's just naive on my part, but when I went into that training, I kind of was quite nervous because I'm like, I always naturally felt that well, if we can find a compromise, the art of compromise was always my stance. And I kind of went to this training thinking, all right, I'm going to learn how to be the heavyweight boxer and knock all of the opponents out. And the reality, of course, is that isn't what it was. It was exactly what I thought it Keith: Yeah. You ended up being pretty sleazy. Dan Culverhouse: would be. And I think you take your ego away, you start to understand holistically, this is what we want to achieve. What do you need to get? What do I need to get? We'll find somewhere in the middle where we both get what we need and then we'll both commit to doing it well. And it works, you Jalil Rahman: Yeah. Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: know. And I guess people, you know, as you're coming up through the ranks, you get promoted into jobs. You're not always as confident in your own ability, which means you you walk into it on a protectionist basis. Jalil Rahman: Mm-hmm. Dan Culverhouse: and I don't Keith: Well. Dan Culverhouse: want to be embarrassed. And I think that starts a problem because you're not being open. And if you're a confident commercial guy who's been successful and you're the new ops manager, you don't feel like you're on an equal footing. And I think that then that starts behaviors that are disruptive and unhelpful. Keith: That's true leadership is making people feel equal rather than dominating them. That comes Jalil Rahman: That's it. Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: Absolutely. Keith: from confidence and maturity. We're too geared up and... Dan Culverhouse: And when you are the experienced guy, you help the new guy to get there. So they don't, you know, you don't use your power over them to get a better deal or to push them down. You rise. You bring them up, right? If you really truly want the best. But of course, humans are humans and that isn't always the way it works. Keith: We're all learning. think being open to knowing you don't know everything is the first thing and a lot of people struggle with that. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: to, we shared a lot of opinions here, but for a CEO or a founder, a leader, who wants to create symbiosis between, I got that one right, between commercial ops and indeed other things. What's their playbook? What do they need to remember? What do they need to do to make it work? Jalil Rahman: Right, so this will sound so bloody basic, right? But first of all, ideas, dreams, plans, all have to be articulated. And once it's articulated, whether it's in document form or some other version, I'm not sure how they do it, that then has to be delivered. And it has to be delivered and cascaded throughout the entire business. Because once the entire business is singing from the same song sheet, excellence in execution, whether it's buying, ops or even I don't know security for example all of those things start to work and so it goes back to kind of the the piece I started on which was about knowledge and discipline having the discipline to capture your thoughts and your intent and then not just say everyone this is what we're doing but have the open dialogue does this work you know not to kind of jump off for a second but communication you know every Keith: the communication loops and the rigour, constantly check into this. Jalil Rahman: Every time I've started a new job, I intend to speak to every single person I can across the entire structure, whether they're juniors or seniors or whatever. And the idea is to basically get as much exposure to good things that are happening, difficult things that are happening, things that we could be doing better. You learn all of that stuff. And once you're open to dialogue, you can then reflect it in your approach. And once that's happened and someone sees in your strategy or your five-year plan, my God, they listened to what I said. There's a much more stronger willingness for them to go over and above. It goes back to your point, Dan, around basic empathy, Like sharing that. And so to answer your question, Keith, it's as simple as that. It's basically articulating the vision and whilst articulating it, having that dialogue with everyone in the business to understand what we could be doing better, what we shouldn't be doing. what we are doing but perhaps should back from. All these things impact the willingness for a team to go the extra mile for someone or for a business leader. just don't Yeah. Exactly. Exactly. Dan Culverhouse: be real, but recognize there's a big picture out there and we should all be working towards the same big picture. Keith: So I think we can conclude that the best deals happen when both sides talk before the contract is signed to put it even more simply. You're in it to win it. We're all in it together. Dan Culverhouse: 100%. 100%. Keith: Thanks for your time today Jalil. It's been a great chat Jalil Rahman: It's a pleasure. Keith: as ever. could have gone on for hours. Until next week, thanks everybody. Remember to like, subscribe, share, comment, join in and we'll have more fun and games next week. Dan Culverhouse: Thanks, Jadil. It's been great to have you on. Jalil Rahman: Cheers! Dan Culverhouse: And we might even invite you back, it was so much fun. Jalil Rahman: Please, I'd love it. I'd love it. We can go through all the other stuff we've not covered today. Thanks all. Cheers. Dan Culverhouse: Absolutely, absolutely. Great discussion. Thanks, everyone. Keith: Indeed. Dan Culverhouse: See you all next week.