Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Judge Rakoff Makes A Ruling On Unsealed Exhibits In The USVI/JP Morgan/Survivor Lawsuit (Part 1)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome back to the Epstein Chronicles.
- 0:04Speaker 1: In today's episode, we're going to take a look at
- 0:06Speaker 1: the Judge Raycoff order in regards to the New York
- 0:09Speaker 1: Times motion that they filed as a non party entity
- 0:13Speaker 1: to unseal five different exhibits that were filed in the
- 0:16Speaker 1: usvii's lawsuit with JP Morgan and the Epstein Survivors Case
- 0:22Speaker 1: Number twenty two Dash CV DASH one zero zero one
- 0:26Speaker 1: nine Opinion and order Jed S. Ray Cooff before the
- 0:33Speaker 1: Court is a motion of a non party, the New
- 0:35Speaker 1: York Times to unseal five exhibits that were filed in
- 0:38Speaker 1: the above captioned actions. The exhibits contain excerpts of the
- 0:42Speaker 1: deposition of plaintiff chain do Number one. Three of the
- 0:45Speaker 1: exhibits were filed in connection with summary judgment briefing in
- 0:49Speaker 1: the underlying actions and all contain the same portion of
- 0:53Speaker 1: dose deposition related to her alleged non consensual interactions with
- 0:57Speaker 1: Jess Staley. The other two exhibits were filed in connection
- 1:00Speaker 1: with plaintiff's motion for class certification and contain a different
- 1:04Speaker 1: portion of Doe's deposition where she recounts how she was
- 1:08Speaker 1: initially recruited by Jeffrey Epstein. During the course of the litigation,
- 1:13Speaker 1: the court granted the class certification motion, but never ruled
- 1:16Speaker 1: on the summary judgment motions because the case settled while
- 1:19Speaker 1: the motions were pending. The Times argues that common law
- 1:23Speaker 1: and First Amendment right of access to court filing's mandate unsealing.
- 1:27Speaker 1: Do opposes unsealing all five exhibits, arguing that doing so
- 1:31Speaker 1: would risk revealing her identity and would force her to
- 1:34Speaker 1: relive her traumatic experiences. Plaintiff Government of the United States
- 1:38Speaker 1: Virgin Islands opposes unsealing on similar grounds. Staley opposes unsealing
- 1:43Speaker 1: only the summary judgment transcripts, arguing they are not judicial
- 1:47Speaker 1: documents because the court never ruled on the motion and
- 1:50Speaker 1: that he is in his own life privacy interest in
- 1:53Speaker 1: keeping those untested allegations sealed. For the reasons set forth below,
- 1:57Speaker 1: the Court grants in part and denies in or the
- 2:00Speaker 1: Times motion one the legal standard. Federal courts employ two
- 2:04Speaker 1: related but distinct presumptions in favor of the public access
- 2:08Speaker 1: to court proceedings and records, a strong form rooted in
- 2:11Speaker 1: the First Amendment and a slightly weak reform based in
- 2:14Speaker 1: federal common law. Both presumptions follow a three step analysis.
- 2:19Speaker 1: With their first step in common the court must first
- 2:22Speaker 1: determine whether the filings are judicial documents, as only judicial
- 2:26Speaker 1: documents are subject to a presumptive right of public access,
- 2:30Speaker 1: whether on common law or First Amendment grounds. At the
- 2:33Speaker 1: second step of the first Amendment analysis, documents must satisfy
- 2:37Speaker 1: one of two tests. Under one test, the right of
- 2:40Speaker 1: access applies to documents that have historically been open to
- 2:43Speaker 1: the press and general public, and public access to those
- 2:47Speaker 1: documents plays a significant positive role in the functioning of
- 2:50Speaker 1: the particular process in question. Alternatively, the second approach considers
- 2:55Speaker 1: the extent to which the judicial documents are derived from
- 2:58Speaker 1: or necessary corollary of the capacity to attend the relevant proceedings.
- 3:04Speaker 1: If either test is satisfied, the First Amendment right attaches
- 3:08Speaker 1: and ceiling of the documents may be justified only with
- 3:11Speaker 1: specific on the record findings that ceiling is necessary to
- 3:15Speaker 1: preserve higher values, and only if the ceialing order is
- 3:19Speaker 1: narrowly tailored to achieve that aim. At the second step
- 3:22Speaker 1: of the common law right of access, the court must
- 3:25Speaker 1: determine the weight of the presumption by assessing the role
- 3:29Speaker 1: of the material at issue in the exercise of the
- 3:32Speaker 1: Article three judicial power and the resultant value of such
- 3:35Speaker 1: information to those monitoring the federal courts. Then, after determining
- 3:40Speaker 1: the weight of the presumption of access, the court must
- 3:43Speaker 1: balance competing considerations against disclosure. As compared to the common
- 3:48Speaker 1: law right of access. The First Amendment right of access
- 3:51Speaker 1: is stronger and can only be overcome under more stringent
- 3:54Speaker 1: circumstances than the common law presumption first Amendment right as
- 3:59Speaker 1: more string Accordingly, when at the second step a court
- 4:03Speaker 1: finds the First Amendment right attaches, it need not engage
- 4:06Speaker 1: in such a common law analysis, because in any case
- 4:09Speaker 1: where the First Amendment presumption of access is overcome, so
- 4:12Speaker 1: will the common law presumption. To the discussion, the exhibits
- 4:17Speaker 1: the time seeks to one sealer divided into two categories.
- 4:20Speaker 1: A the summary judgment papers for the motion mooted by
- 4:23Speaker 1: settlement and B the filings attached to the motion for
- 4:26Speaker 1: class certification granted by the court. Each category is discussed
- 4:31Speaker 1: in turn. A exhibits attached to the motion for some
- 4:34Speaker 1: rey judgment one step one judicial document status. As noted,
- 4:39Speaker 1: the threshold requirement for the First Amendment of common law
- 4:43Speaker 1: right of access to apply is that the item under
- 4:46Speaker 1: a scrutiny must constitute a judicial document. Staley argues that
- 4:50Speaker 1: the summary judgment transcripts do not satisfy this requirement because
- 4:54Speaker 1: the case settled while the summary judgment motions were pending
- 4:57Speaker 1: and before the court ever ruled on the matters. See
- 5:00Speaker 1: Daily Opposition Docket to ninety three at one in three.
- 5:04Speaker 1: To be a judicial document, an item must be relevant
- 5:07Speaker 1: to the performance of the judicial function and useful in
- 5:10Speaker 1: the judicial process. In general, documents filed with the court
- 5:14Speaker 1: that asks the Court to grant or reject some relief,
- 5:17Speaker 1: such as pleadings in some rejudgment papers, satisfy the test,
- 5:22Speaker 1: but the mere filing of a paper or a document
- 5:24Speaker 1: with the court is insufficient to render that paper a
- 5:27Speaker 1: judicial document subject to the right of public access. The
- 5:31Speaker 1: Second Circuit has held that some rejudgment papers qualify as
- 5:35Speaker 1: judicial documents at least as a general matter. See Lugosh
- 5:39Speaker 1: four to thirty five ft three d at one twenty one,
- 5:41Speaker 1: holding that document submitted to a court for its consideration
- 5:45Speaker 1: in a sumary judgment motion are as a matter of law,
- 5:48Speaker 1: judicial documents, even though the summary judgment motion was still
- 5:51Speaker 1: pending and had not yet been ruled on. Brown versus Maxwell,
- 5:55Speaker 1: nine twenty nine ft three d forty one forty five
- 5:58Speaker 1: two D to xix out to nineteen, finding denial of
- 6:02Speaker 1: motion for some rejudgment does not abrogate judicial document status
- 6:06Speaker 1: even when documents were not relied upon in ruling. Furthermore,
- 6:10Speaker 1: the Second Circuit is held, at least with respect to
- 6:12Speaker 1: pleadings that were filed under seal, the fact that a
- 6:15Speaker 1: suit is ultimately settled without a judgment on the merits
- 6:19Speaker 1: does not impair judicial record status. Bernstein versus Bernstein, Littowitz
- 6:24Speaker 1: Berger Engrossman, LLP. Eight fourteen ft three dter one thirty
- 6:28Speaker 1: two one forty Second Circuit, twenty sixteen. However, the Second
- 6:33Speaker 1: Circuit has not addressed the question of whether the settlement
- 6:36Speaker 1: of a case while the summary judgment motion is pending
- 6:39Speaker 1: impacts the judicial document status of those moving papers. Other
- 6:43Speaker 1: courts addressed the question have split on the issue. The
- 6:46Speaker 1: Fourth Circuit has recently held that papers filed with the
- 6:49Speaker 1: summary judgment motion continue to be judicial documents even where
- 6:54Speaker 1: the case settles before the motion is ruled on. So
- 6:56Speaker 1: United States versus XR. L Oberg for AIX Schnell Neet Incorporated.
- 7:01Speaker 1: One oh five four f one sixty one one seventy three,
- 7:04Speaker 1: Fourth Circuit, twenty twenty four. District courts in the Second
- 7:09Speaker 1: Circuit that have considered the issue have come out different ways.
- 7:13Speaker 1: Compare Roberts versus Maxwell, twenty twenty WL one three three
- 7:17Speaker 1: five seven zero at two four, SDN Y, January thirteenth,
- 7:22Speaker 1: twenty twenty. Undecided motions and the papers associated with them
- 7:26Speaker 1: are not judicial documents since they are not part of
- 7:29Speaker 1: the live controversy to which the Article three judicial power
- 7:33Speaker 1: can extend. In IBM Arbitration Agreement Litigation twenty twenty two,
- 7:38Speaker 1: WL THREEZH four three two two zero at two, SDN Y,
- 7:42Speaker 1: August two, twenty twenty two, some rejudgment filing mooted by
- 7:46Speaker 1: granting prior motion to dismiss are not judicial documents since
- 7:50Speaker 1: they have no tendency or ability to influence this Court's
- 7:54Speaker 1: ruling on the motion to dismiss. Alterations added with Loan
- 7:58Speaker 1: versus IBM twenty twenty two, WL three three five nine
- 8:02Speaker 1: seven three seven at four, SDN Y, August fifteenth, twenty
- 8:05Speaker 1: twenty two, arguing that Maxwell and properly conflates the first
- 8:09Speaker 1: two steps of the right to access analysis and the
- 8:13Speaker 1: summary judgment filings for mooted motions are judicial documents because
- 8:17Speaker 1: of potential relevancy to judicial function. After carefully considering these
- 8:22Speaker 1: conflicting precedents, this Court concludes that treating the documents here
- 8:25Speaker 1: at issue as judicial documents is the correct approach and
- 8:29Speaker 1: more consistent with the Second Circuit precedent, although in a
- 8:32Speaker 1: context different from some rejudgment. The Second Circuit has held
- 8:35Speaker 1: that an item may be considered a judicial document irrespective
- 8:39Speaker 1: of whether any court is actually relied on the document
- 8:42Speaker 1: in issuing a ruling. The inquiry is only whether the
- 8:45Speaker 1: documents are relevant to the performance of the judicial function,
- 8:49Speaker 1: not whether they were relied upon. The Second Circuit has
- 8:52Speaker 1: also emphasized the relevancy in this context is measured by potential,
- 8:57Speaker 1: not actual effect see Idea at forty five. A document
- 9:01Speaker 1: is thus relevant to the performance of the judicial function
- 9:04Speaker 1: if it would reasonably have the tendency to influence a
- 9:07Speaker 1: district court's ruling on a motion or in the exercise
- 9:11Speaker 1: of its supervisory powers, without regard to which way the
- 9:14Speaker 1: court ultimately rules, or whether the document ultimately in fact
- 9:19Speaker 1: influences the court's decision. Since only potential and not actual
- 9:24Speaker 1: reliance is required for judicial document status. The fact that
- 9:27Speaker 1: a summary judgment motion is never ruled on prior to
- 9:30Speaker 1: settlement does not affect the judicial document status of exhibits
- 9:34Speaker 1: filed in connection therewith cases that hold the contrary reason
- 9:38Speaker 1: that even if the items may have been judicial documents
- 9:42Speaker 1: when filed, they lose this status once a settlement has
- 9:45Speaker 1: taken place. This is because the Article three judicial power
- 9:49Speaker 1: only extends to actual controversies arising between adverse litigants, but
- 9:54Speaker 1: once a case settles, no such controversy exists. Maxwell twenty
- 9:58Speaker 1: twenty WL three five seven zero at two. These cases
- 10:03Speaker 1: for the reason that whatever need there may have been
- 10:05Speaker 1: to oversee the function of the judicial power evaporates once
- 10:09Speaker 1: a case settles, and no future ruling is possible, such
- 10:12Speaker 1: that the reason for the right of access dissipates as well. However,
- 10:17Speaker 1: this first argument conflates the first two steps of the
- 10:20Speaker 1: public Right to Access framework Loan twenty twenty two w
- 10:25Speaker 1: L three thirty five nine seven three seven at four.
- 10:29Speaker 1: Second circuit precedent suggests the presence of a live controversy
- 10:33Speaker 1: only speaks to the weight of the presumption, rather than
- 10:36Speaker 1: whether the documents are judicial documents. In the first place,
- 10:39Speaker 1: a contrary rule cannot be squared with the Second Circuit's
- 10:42Speaker 1: decision in Bernstein, which found that sealed pleadings remain judicial
- 10:46Speaker 1: documents even though the case was mooted by settlement before
- 10:50Speaker 1: any ruling on a motion to dismiss. The decision in
- 10:53Speaker 1: Bernstein follows from the fact that the purpose of the
- 10:56Speaker 1: right of access is broader than just monitoring actual decision
- 11:00Speaker 1: The judicial monitoring function that the presumption serves encompasses other interests,
- 11:05Speaker 1: such as the right of the public to discern the
- 11:08Speaker 1: prevalence of certain types of cases, the nature of the
- 11:11Speaker 1: parties to particular kinds of actions, information about the settlement
- 11:15Speaker 1: rates in different areas of law, and the types of
- 11:18Speaker 1: materials that are likely to be sealed. Insights into the
- 11:22Speaker 1: judicial process are essential to the public's understanding of and
- 11:26Speaker 1: the ability to monitor the functioning of the judiciary, even
- 11:30Speaker 1: though no actual or potential judicial decision making is involved.
- 11:34Speaker 1: These other interests are similarly implicated by documents attached to
- 11:38Speaker 1: a mooted summary judgment motion. Moreover, if settlement vitiated judicial
- 11:43Speaker 1: document status, an oddity would arise in light of the
- 11:46Speaker 1: Second Circuit's decision in Lugosh. In Lugosh, the Court held
- 11:51Speaker 1: that filing attached to motions for some rejudgment are judicial
- 11:54Speaker 1: documents and publicly accessible even when the motion is still pending.
- 11:59Speaker 1: If the position proposed by stalely or correct, such filings
- 12:02Speaker 1: would retrospectively lose judicial document status and become inaccessible at
- 12:07Speaker 1: any moment the case settled before the ruling. Since the
- 12:11Speaker 1: public would never know which cases may settle ahead of time,
- 12:14Speaker 1: this would incentivize filing a motion to unseal the moment
- 12:18Speaker 1: a motion for some rejudgment is filed, undesirably, increasing burdens
- 12:22Speaker 1: on courts to address such motions while briefing is ongoing.
- 12:26Speaker 1: And in a great number of cases, the motion to
- 12:28Speaker 1: unseal may be filed out of fear that the opportunity
- 12:31Speaker 1: to do so later would be lost, rather than any
- 12:35Speaker 1: ultimate desire for the sealed materials. Thus, for the foregoing reasons,
- 12:39Speaker 1: the Court concludes the deposition excerpts here in question constitute
- 12:43Speaker 1: judicial documents. All right, we're going to wrap up right here,
- 12:47Speaker 1: and in the next episode we're going to pick up
- 12:49Speaker 1: with two step two First Amendment right of access. All
- 12:54Speaker 1: the information that goes with this episode can be found
- 12:57Speaker 1: in the description box.