Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Vehicle-to-Grid: Fuel and Energy Bills for Free
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome to the Deep Dive. We're here to pull out the
- 0:11absolute best knowledge Nuggets from some pretty complex
- 0:15research and get them straight to you.
- 0:17And today we're looking at electric vehicles.
- 0:19If you own one, you probably know this maybe intuitively, but
- 0:23your car is parked well something like 95% of the time.
- 0:2695% and it's not just sitting idle, it's holding a huge amount
- 0:31of unused energy. That's right, modern EV.
- 0:34Some of them can have up to 100 kilowatt hours stored inside.
- 0:38It's basically a giant battery on wheels doing nothing most of
- 0:42the day. So that brings us to the big
- 0:44question for this deep dive. And we're basing this on some
- 0:47really interesting modeling from the German energy market.
- 0:50Can that parked EV of yours actually make you money?
- 0:54The short answer, yes. It involves a concept called
- 0:57Vehicle to Grid V2 GV. 2G OK, sounds a bit sci-fi.
- 1:00Let's break that down. What exactly is it?
- 1:02Think of it like a two way St. for electricity.
- 1:04Right now your EV mostly just pulls power from the grid one
- 1:08way. You charge it.
- 1:09V2G makes it bi directional so when there's loads of cheap
- 1:13solar power maybe midday your car charges up but then say
- 1:17demand spikes later your EV can actually and power back to help
- 1:21stabilize the grid and. If you have lots of EVs doing
- 1:24that. Exactly.
- 1:25If you get enough of them working together, they form
- 1:28what's called a virtual Power plant, or VPP A.
- 1:31VPP. Yeah, like a power plant spread
- 1:33across thousands of driveways and garages, it can provide
- 1:36instant support to the grid, which is becoming super
- 1:38important with more renewables coming online, you know, because
- 1:41their output fluctuates. So our mission today is to dig
- 1:45into whether this V2G thing makes economic sense,
- 1:48specifically for you, the EV owner.
- 1:51We're leaning on this detailed research model from Germany.
- 1:53And the really cool thing about this study, the innovation, is
- 1:56how it handles battery degradation.
- 1:58Past studies often just used a fixed cost.
- 2:01Like OK, using the battery costs X cents per cycle.
- 2:04It was a bit basic. A bit of a guess really.
- 2:06Yeah, pretty much. This model uses an online
- 2:09dynamic battery degradation model.
- 2:11It looks at the actual battery chemistry and conditions in real
- 2:14time. Much more accurate.
- 2:16OK, that leads us straight to the elephant in the room,
- 2:18doesn't it? The main worry for any EV owner
- 2:20thinking about this. We all like the idea of extra
- 2:23cash, but nobody wants to kill their very expensive battery,
- 2:26right? So what's the main problem?
- 2:29The main problem? Holding people back from jumping
- 2:31into V2G. It's absolutely that fear of
- 2:34degradation, that irreversible loss of capacity, the idea that
- 2:38cycling your battery more often for V2G beyond just driving is
- 2:42going to wear it out faster. And degradation is tricky,
- 2:45right? It's not straightforward.
- 2:46Not at all. It depends on so many things.
- 2:49How full you keep the battery, the state of charge or SoC, how
- 2:52deeply you discharge it, the depth of discharge.
- 2:55DoD temperature plays a huge role.
- 2:57Even the battery's past history. It's complex.
- 2:59So owners worry about needing a costly replacement sooner than
- 3:03expected. Exactly.
- 3:04That's the core fear. OK, so let's dive into how this
- 3:06specific model tackled that. It used a dynamic model but
- 3:10focused on a particular type of battery.
- 3:12It did, yeah. They used something called the
- 3:14Zu model and applied it to lithium manganese oxide
- 3:18batteries, LMO. You'd find those in some earlier
- 3:20EV's like the Nissan Leaf from around 2016.
- 3:23OK. An older chemistry and they
- 3:25simulated a typical owner. Yep, a standard commuter
- 3:28pattern. Charge at home overnight drive
- 3:30to the office, park up the V2G. Action happens during that
- 3:34parked window, say 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM.
- 3:36Makes sense? And they built in a safety net.
- 3:38Crucially, yes, the model assumed the car always kept at
- 3:41least a 10% state of charge buffer, just in case you needed
- 3:45to suddenly drive somewhere unexpected.
- 3:47Right now, here's where it gets wild, because the model spat out
- 3:50something totally counterintuitive about that
- 3:52degradation fear. What was the big finding?
- 3:54Well get this, for the LMO battery they studied, actively
- 3:58participating in V2G actually resulted in less battery
- 4:01degradation compared to just letting the car sit there fully
- 4:04charged all day. The no V2G scenario.
- 4:07Roy, hang on. Using the battery more made it
- 4:09degrade less. It seems backwards.
- 4:11It does sound it, doesn't it? But it comes down to the 2 main
- 4:14ways batteries age. There's cycle aging, which is
- 4:18the where from charging and discharging.
- 4:20That's what we usually worry about.
- 4:21But there's also calendar aging. This happens just from time
- 4:24passing regardless of use. Think of it like metal fatigue
- 4:28or a rubber band slowly losing its elasticity even if you don't
- 4:31keep snapping it. And what makes calendar aging
- 4:34worse in a battery? Keeping it stored at a really
- 4:37high state of charge for long periods, especially when it's
- 4:40warm. So if you drive to work, plug in
- 4:43and leave it sitting at say 90% charged all day.
- 4:47That high charge level actually stresses the battery chemistry
- 4:50and speeds up calendar aging. The V2G system in this model was
- 4:55intelligently discharging the battery during the day, bringing
- 4:58it down to a lower, less stressful SoC.
- 5:01So by avoiding that long period sitting at high charge.
- 5:04It reduced the calendar aging enough that it actually
- 5:06outweighed the extra cycle aging from the V2G activity.
- 5:09Net result? Slightly longer battery life for
- 5:11this specific chemistry and use case.
- 5:13That is a fascinating result. OK so maybe, maybe V2G isn't the
- 5:17battery killer people fear. So let's talk money.
- 5:21How much can you actually earn? Let's look at profit stream #1
- 5:24energy arbitrage. Right, arbitrage is the simplest
- 5:27idea. It's basically buying low and
- 5:29selling high. Your EV, or more likely some
- 5:32smart software managing it, watches the electricity prices
- 5:35on the German day ahead market. It charges the car when power is
- 5:39cheap, sells it back to the grid when prices peak.
- 5:41Pure market play, no complex grid services involved yet.
- 5:45Exactly. And the model looked at a base
- 5:47case first, an older EV like that 2016 Leaf with a 24
- 5:51kilowattr LMO battery, only doing V2G on weekdays, so about
- 5:55261 days a year. And the profit?
- 5:58Using what they called the balanced profit approach, trying
- 6:00to make good money but also minimize battery wear, the
- 6:03estimate came out to 93.45 per year.
- 6:06OK, nearly €100, it's not life changing, but it's definitely
- 6:09found money and it proves the concept works financially even
- 6:12with older tech at ready TTO, as you might say in Italian, it is.
- 6:16Profitable, precisely edited a tutsio even in that basic
- 6:18scenario. But that's the old battery.
- 6:20What happens when you plug in modern EV specs?
- 6:23Big battery, better efficiency. That's where things get really
- 6:26interesting. The study modeled a best case
- 6:29arbitrage scenario. Imagine a big hundred kilowatt
- 6:32are battery maybe 95% efficient. And crucially, the owner doesn't
- 6:36drive very far each day, leaving lots of energy available.
- 6:39And the profit number there? It jumps dramatically.
- 6:42The estimate goes up to 662.3, 7 per year.
- 6:47Wow. OK.
- 6:48From under 100 to over €650, that's a huge difference.
- 6:52It is and to get that the EV is shifting a lot of energy, almost
- 6:5630,000 kilowatt hours a year back and forth with the grid so.
- 6:59Capacity clearly matters. You mentioned driving distance
- 7:02was also key. Which one has a bigger impact?
- 7:04Both are really sensitive, but driving distance actually has
- 7:07the slightly bigger lever according to this model.
- 7:09How so? Well, for capacity, every extra
- 7:13kWh you have increases the potential profit by about 185
- 7:16per year. More storage means more energy
- 7:19to sell when rices are high retty.
- 7:21Straightforward, but driving distance.
- 7:23For every kilometer less you drive each way on your commute,
- 7:27the annual profit potential increased by 6.64 per year. 664
- 7:33per kilometer save. That's substantial.
- 7:35It really is. It highlights how much your
- 7:37driving habits impact the energy leftover for V2G during those
- 7:40peak price hours at work. Drive less, earn more,
- 7:43essentially. It puts a real financial value
- 7:45on shorter commutes or maybe using other transport sometimes.
- 7:48Definitely. Now, before we leave arbitrage,
- 7:50there's the efficiency catch, right?
- 7:53Moving power in and out isn't perfectly efficient.
- 7:56There are losses. Absolutely.
- 7:58That's the round trip efficiency or RTE.
- 8:00You always lose a bit of energy in the conversion process, both
- 8:04charging and discharging. So how much higher does the
- 8:06selling price need to be just to cover those losses, just to
- 8:09break even before even thinking about profit or degradation?
- 8:13Yeah, the basic physics means the selling price divided by the
- 8:16buying price has to be greater than 1 divided by your RTE.
- 8:20So say your system is 85% efficient, which is fairly
- 8:23typical. Then you need to sell that power
- 8:26for at least 1 / .85, which is about 1.176 times the price you
- 8:31bought it for. So you need a price spread of
- 8:33almost 18% just to cover the energy losses.
- 8:36That's a tight margin. You definitely need Mart
- 8:38software managing that, not just guessing.
- 8:40Oh for sure, human guesswork wouldn't cut it.
- 8:43OK, so that's arbitrage buying low, selling high.
- 8:47Now let's move to the second potential profit stream,
- 8:51ancillary services. This sounds more involved.
- 8:53It is. This isn't just playing the
- 8:55market. This is actively helping to
- 8:57stabilize the grid frequency, keeping it right at that precise
- 9:0050 Hertz standard they use in Germany and much of Europe.
- 9:04So a more demanding job for the battery and it's regulated.
- 9:08Highly regulated. You can't just decide to do it.
- 9:10You typically need to go through an aggregator, a company that
- 9:13bundles up lots of EVs or other resources and bids them into the
- 9:17official grid services market. And Journey has different types
- 9:20of these services, yes. They have three main frequency
- 9:22regulation reserves based mostly on how fast they need to
- 9:25respond. OK, walk us through them.
- 9:26What's the fastest? That's FCR, frequency
- 9:29containment reserve. Think of it as the grid's first
- 9:32responder. Instantaneous reaction needed
- 9:35within 15 seconds to stop a frequency deviation getting
- 9:38worse. Primary control. 15 seconds.
- 9:40Wow. OK, what's next?
- 9:42Then you have an automatic activation Frequency restoration
- 9:45reserve. This is secondary control.
- 9:46It kicks in within about 5 minutes to actually bring the
- 9:49frequency back to its target level.
- 9:51Right, pulling it back into line.
- 9:52Exactly. And finally there's MFRR manual
- 9:56Activation Frequency Restoration reserve.
- 9:58This is tertiary control. It's a slower, more sustained
- 10:02response. Activated manual annually within
- 10:0415 minutes, often to handle larger, longer lasting
- 10:07imbalances. OK, FCRAFRRMFRR Fast, medium,
- 10:12slow response. Now the critical difference
- 10:14seems to be how they pay you for these services.
- 10:17That's the key for profitability.
- 10:18Absolutely. FCR, the Super fast one, only
- 10:21pays what's called a capacity payment.
- 10:23Basically, you get paid just for being available and ready to
- 10:26respond instantly. But you don't get paid for the
- 10:28actual energy. You might push or pull.
- 10:30Not for FCR no, but AFRR and MFRR, the secondary and tertiary
- 10:35ones, They pay both. You get a capacity payment for
- 10:38being ready, and you get an energy payment for the actual
- 10:41kilowatt hours you deliver or absorb when called upon.
- 10:45Ah OK, that sounds like it could make a big difference.
- 10:48But first, back to degradation. These services sound like they'd
- 10:51work the battery harder, maybe cycling up and down constantly
- 10:54to keep things balanced. They generally do, yes.
- 10:56Especially FCR and AFR often require more symmetrical
- 11:00cycling, being ready to charge or discharge immediately.
- 11:04This tends to increase the cycle aging component compared to the
- 11:07more optimized one way flows you might see in pure arbitrage.
- 11:10So potentially more wear and tear.
- 11:12Potentially yes. However, as we'll see, the
- 11:14payments for some of these services can be high enough to
- 11:17more than compensate for that extra degradation cost all.
- 11:19Right, let's see the numbers. The study looked at these
- 11:21services assuming like a 10% utilization rate.
- 11:25Yeah, a standard assumption for modeling.
- 11:27So starting with FCR, the fastest service that only pays
- 11:30for availability. What was the verdict?
- 11:32Nonprofitable actually resulted in a small estimated loss, maybe
- 11:35a couple of EUR over the period studied.
- 11:38The loss. Why?
- 11:39Because the capacity only payment just wasn't high enough
- 11:42to cover the calculated cost of the battery degradation caused
- 11:45by being constantly ready for those ultra fast symmetrical
- 11:49cycles. Too much wear for too little
- 11:51reward. OK, so FCR is out.
- 11:54What about AFRR secondary control?
- 11:57The one that pays for capacity and energy.
- 11:58Now things look much better. AFRR turned out to be nicely
- 12:02profitable. The estimate was around 530 to
- 12:04534 per year. OK.
- 12:06That's significant. Yeah, similar ballpark to the
- 12:08best case arbitrage, maybe a bit less.
- 12:10Right, the addition of that energy payment made all the
- 12:12difference, making the increased cycling worthwhile financially.
- 12:15And now for the grand finale. MFRRR, tertiary regulation,
- 12:21slower response, the capacity and energy payments.
- 12:23What did that bring in? This was the clear winner.
- 12:25In terms of pure revenue, MFR showed the highest profitability
- 12:28by far, estimated between 1373 and 586 seats per year.
- 12:34Whoa, over €1300? That's more than double the best
- 12:37arbitrage case. Exactly.
- 12:39Here's where it gets really interesting.
- 12:41Is Servicio pure remunerativo? The most remunerative, the most
- 12:44profitable service was clearly this tertiary regulation.
- 12:48Why so much higher? It seems a combination of the
- 12:50payment structure in the German market for MFRR, perhaps less
- 12:54demanding cycling patterns compared to AFR, and still
- 12:57getting paid well for both capacity and energy just hit the
- 13:00sweet spot. Even with the degradation cost
- 13:03factored in, it was highly lucrative in this model.
- 13:06That kind of potential income, 1300 + a year, could genuinely
- 13:10influence someone's decision when buying an EV or make the
- 13:14total cost of ownership look much better.
- 13:16Absolutely, it could offset a big chunk of your monthly
- 13:19payment or insurance or maintenance costs.
- 13:21The data really makes a strong case that yes, V2G can be
- 13:24financially beneficial for EV owners in Germany.
- 13:27So summing up, the profitability is there, but the best approach
- 13:31depends on what you prioritize. Seems like it if you want decent
- 13:35profit and potentially even help your battery life.
- 13:38At least with ALMO chemistry optimized arbitrage is good.
- 13:41If you want the maximum cash return and are willing to accept
- 13:44potentially faster degradation, then aiming for those high
- 13:48paying ancillary services like AFRR and especially MFRR is the
- 13:52way to go. But there's always a, but is.
- 13:55There's a rather large one here, yes.
- 13:57The study giving us these exciting profit numbers up to
- 14:00nearly €1400 a year made a very big assumption.
- 14:03It assumed the existence of an ideal aggregator.
- 14:06That's the term they used, yeah, an ideal aggregator.
- 14:08And that's the company in the middle that handles everything.
- 14:10The tech, the market bidding, the connection to your car, all
- 14:13the complexity. And ideal in this context means.
- 14:16It means they do all of this for free. 0 cost to the EV owner.
- 14:20All that profit goes straight to you.
- 14:21Which, let's be honest, is not how things usually work in the
- 14:24real world. Middle men need to get paid.
- 14:27Precisely setting up and running that kind of sophisticated
- 14:30service costs money. So the huge unanswered question
- 14:34is how much of that potential 600 or 1300 profit will a real
- 14:40world aggregator need to take as their cut their service fee?
- 14:44The actual profit you see could be significantly lower once that
- 14:47business model gets factored in. It's the crucial missing piece
- 14:50for widespread adoption. We know the potential is there,
- 14:53but the business case for the companies enabling it and how
- 14:56much they pass on is still developing.
- 14:58Which leaves us with a final thought for you to chew on.
- 15:01As VDG eventually takes off, who stands to gain the most?
- 15:04Is it the grid operator getting stability?
- 15:07Is it you, the EV owner, pocketing maybe a few €100?
- 15:10Or could the biggest winners be the companies that successfully
- 15:13build and scale these aggregation platforms, the ones
- 15:16who essentially create the digital toll booths, managing
- 15:19that flow of energy and value between millions of cars and the
- 15:22grid? Something to think about.
- 15:24Well, we really hope this deep dive is giving you some solid
- 15:26insights into how your parked car might just become an active
- 15:30part of the energy system and maybe even earn you some money.
- 15:33Gratzi Peravera Ascotato, thank you for listening.
- 15:37Yeah, thanks for tuning in. Don't forget to follow the
- 15:39channel for more deep dives like this Sigrid del Canali.
- 15:42We'll catch you on the next one.