Latest / AI in the UK / Is the UK Institutionally Capable of Dealing With AI?
Transcript
- 0:01All right, your luck. Listen up.
- 0:17Hello and welcome to AI in the UK.
- 0:19I'm Neil Footman. And I'm Matt Wilkinson.
- 0:22Professionally, we help organisations, leaders and
- 0:25individuals learn about and implement this big scary
- 0:28behemoth called AI. There's some amazing stuff going
- 0:33on with AI in the UK that doesn't always get the attention
- 0:36it deserves. With AI in the UK, we want to
- 0:40change that. Who do you trust with the
- 0:57infrastructure of the British State Open AI, who took the
- 1:02government's endorsement post for the cameras and has zero
- 1:06trials to show for it eight months later?
- 1:08Palantir, who has £500 million in public contracts and a data
- 1:15format that makes leaving them practically impossible?
- 1:19Or the institutions themselves, who keep signing frameworks with
- 1:22no mechanism to verify anything actually happens.
- 1:27Lots and lots of meaty questions today, so let's get into it with
- 1:31this week's AI in the UK. Over to you, Niels.
- 1:35Thanks, Matt for that spirited introduction.
- 1:38And leading off this week, we've got something about Open AI and
- 1:42its relationship with the UK. So eight months ago, the UK
- 1:47government signed what it called a landmark partnership with Open
- 1:51AI, the company behind ChatGPT. Obviously, the deal was
- 1:55presented as a cornerstone of Britain's AI ambitions,
- 2:00deploying advanced AI models across public services, tackling
- 2:04what ministers described exercised as society's greatest
- 2:08challenges. A Freedom of Information request
- 2:11reported by the website Computing has now revealed the
- 2:15government has conducted zero trials under that agreement.
- 2:19DSIT, the Department of Science, Industry and Technology,
- 2:23confirmed it held no records of any such activity.
- 2:27The government's defence is apparently that civil servants
- 2:30at the Ministry of Justice have been allowed to use ChatGPT
- 2:33since October. Critics aren't impressed.
- 2:37Valiance, the consultancy that filed the Freedom of Information
- 2:42request, puts it plainly. Using ChatGPT in one department
- 2:46is no more a strategic AI partnership than using
- 2:50PowerPoint makes you a Microsoft partner.
- 2:53But the deeper problem isn't the open AI deal specifically.
- 2:58The government has signed similar agreements with Google,
- 3:00DeepMind, Anthropic, and NVIDIA. The pattern of progress across
- 3:05them all is thin. the ADA Lovelace Institute, which is a
- 3:11nonprofit based here in London actually that that researches
- 3:16data and AI issues and and around security, has pointed to
- 3:20a structural flaw. None of these agreements contain
- 3:24a mechanism for measuring progress or any protection
- 3:28against becoming locked into a single provider.
- 3:31The deals may then have been built for the announcement, not
- 3:35the delivery. OK.
- 3:36And with that rather sour ending to the story, Matt, what did you
- 3:41make of this? Well it is rather sour, isn't
- 3:44it. But if you look at the
- 3:45memorandums memorandums of understanding the language
- 3:49appears to be deliberately non binding may include will
- 3:54collaborate to identify that it's not evasion of what they've
- 4:00agreed to. It's just how governments have
- 4:02structured these partnerships and it just looks like things
- 4:06are moving at the pace of government rather than at the
- 4:09pace that AI really needs it to work at.
- 4:12What's your take So? There were a couple of things
- 4:15that came to me when I was reading this story.
- 4:18On rereading it, one of them, did you ever used to watch?
- 4:21Yes, Minister, no going back at we're going back always here.
- 4:27Obviously we're showing her vintage, but I think no.
- 4:31But anyone who remembers it from that time, no programme has
- 4:33perhaps captured the bizarre nature of government interaction
- 4:38with the civil service in a comedic manner better since
- 4:40since that show. And I did hear Jim hackers and
- 4:43and Sir Humphrey's voices in my head with this.
- 4:46I can you can almost imagine the Prime Minister pushing or
- 4:50somebody pushing forward with this with great enthusiasm and
- 4:53and a senior civil servant commending them for making such
- 4:56a bold decision. And all of a sudden the
- 4:58politician really and say, whoa, hang on, what's bold about it?
- 5:02You know, as if they said a dirty word.
- 5:04I mean on on a on a somewhat more serious note, it also
- 5:08really smacked of stuff. I'm sure we've seen, I've no,
- 5:11I've seen many times. And I should add, I have no
- 5:14inside track in the the civil service, senior or otherwise.
- 5:18But this thing about very publicly and enthusiastically
- 5:22saying we are going to embrace open AI and use it to across
- 5:26services, it really smacks of an institution that was not that
- 5:32didn't really know what they were doing that they they saw an
- 5:35opportunity, but they didn't know how to actually implement
- 5:38it and actually get people using it.
- 5:41And this is a pattern you see your eyes see certainly repeated
- 5:43across companies of all sizes that that the intention is
- 5:47frequently there. But actually, as this story kind
- 5:50of alludes to, buying a bunch of Co pilot licences or ChatGPT
- 5:54licences does not mean you have transformed your department into
- 5:58an AI capable department or, or organisation or whatever it is
- 6:03just to just to sort of drag this back, back to the, the
- 6:06point we're making. I think as well, they, they kind
- 6:10of made a rod for their own backs a bit in, in the way they
- 6:12announced this. They said it's a landmark deal
- 6:17to deploy AI across government and address society's greatest
- 6:20challenges. When you say that you are really
- 6:23setting yourself up for a fall. And if, if they're now kind of
- 6:26trying to roll back on that as as, as you as you mentioned it,
- 6:32if, if the ambition was always just to identify opportunities.
- 6:37Why was Sam Altman standing next to the Technology Secretary for
- 6:41the cameras to announce this? While the government's own press
- 6:45release promised to turbocharge UK infrastructure and transform
- 6:49public services, it's. It's interesting, isn't it, The,
- 6:52you know, the public, you know, the civil service has been a
- 6:56target for much criticism for many years.
- 7:00I think the the most vociferous of those was probably Dump
- 7:04Dominic Cummings, the the gentleman that was sort of at
- 7:07the centre of the the the Barnard Castle scandal.
- 7:12Test his eyesight, wasn't it? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 7:15We decided to go for a drive to test his eyesight.
- 7:17Yeah. Who among us?
- 7:19Hasn't done that. Yeah, exactly.
- 7:22But he, he was a big, big critic of the civil service.
- 7:26And I, you know, I don't have the inside track either, so I
- 7:29can't, you know, I, I can't comment really.
- 7:33But it, it smacks to me that what the these sort of these
- 7:39governmental announcements say, they're going to transform
- 7:44things. And I think the ministers want
- 7:47to transform things, but then they get stuck in the
- 7:52bureaucracy and the status quo. And I think that that's really
- 7:55where it, it's, it struggles. Government doesn't move at start
- 8:00up pace. I mean, I worked at an
- 8:02organisation that had been spun out from the government in the
- 8:0870s under Margaret Thatcher, you would think, and this is, this
- 8:11is definitely a decade ago. So you would have thought that
- 8:14sort of that 4045 years or so would have sort of caused the
- 8:20organisation to change. And what was really stark was
- 8:23that, you know, you go to HQ and it still felt very sort of slow
- 8:29on corporate and methodical. And then you went to the some of
- 8:32the sites that had all been acquired and were small start,
- 8:35you know, well, small, medium sized startups that have been
- 8:38acquired and they, the pace was so much quicker.
- 8:42And I think this is exactly what we're seeing here, that the pace
- 8:47of government and certainly it can't keep up with the, the pace
- 8:52of the announcements. And certainly in the age of AI
- 8:55where the pace of change is just mind blowing.
- 8:58I mean, before we started recording, we were talking
- 9:01about, you know, licences for, you know, large language models.
- 9:04And Can you believe that it was only a year ago that the
- 9:07frontier models and deep research was, you know, was mind
- 9:11blowing and now it's sort of part of a daily, daily work.
- 9:15I mean, it's just insane. Yeah, yeah.
- 9:18I mean, I think it's very easy to poke front at the civil
- 9:21service and I certainly wouldn't consider myself of the Dominic
- 9:24Cummings, let's tear everything down school of thought.
- 9:28That said, and and yes, before I get into that said, there are
- 9:32good reasons for it and and in many respects, the civil service
- 9:35does a good job. I mean, these things are set up
- 9:38as they are for a reason. There are certain elements of
- 9:41civil service work that you would be quite alarmed if they
- 9:44absolutely tore through and are doing very quickly with a kind
- 9:47of move fast and break things mindset.
- 9:50But as you said, in an environment where the the world
- 9:56of business, in the world of culture and education technology
- 9:58is moving at the pace it is, the structure of the civil service
- 10:02can only be an impediment, I'm afraid.
- 10:04I mean, I think that I think it is that that stark the way it's
- 10:07currently configured. I don't pretend to have the
- 10:10answers in in how to deal with this.
- 10:11It is a, every government comes in and, and says, you know,
- 10:15they're dealing with quote the BLOB and then they've got big
- 10:17ambitious plans to streamline it or change it or reduce it in
- 10:20size. And it is an absolutely
- 10:22formidable job. Again, for what it's worth, I, I
- 10:25don't think this problem is unique to the UK.
- 10:27Yes, I, I think what might be different to us is the degree to
- 10:30which we're centralised. I mean, I think what, but we are
- 10:32more centralised than many countries, But the, the the
- 10:36civil service is it, it is structured to, it is structured
- 10:40to operate in a way that is not conducive to kind of start up
- 10:44pace. And and there there would only
- 10:47be a few examples perhaps where they have been able to
- 10:49successfully counter that. I mean, Singapore perhaps being
- 10:52one. Yeah.
- 10:53I mean, it's, it's not for me, it's, it is not a very
- 10:58optimistic picture. And I'm not entirely sure how
- 11:02short of and much, much reluctance I'm to say it, short
- 11:07of having someone who does have the kind of single minded bloody
- 11:11mindedness of a, of a Dominic Cummings or someone like that.
- 11:13It's difficult to see exactly how something like the civil
- 11:17service could make the structural changes required to
- 11:20adjust to the age of AI. Yeah, and I know that you've
- 11:23been, you know, that that we've both been seeing how
- 11:25organisations, you know, you know, private organisations or
- 11:29public, you know, commercial organisations, maybe I should
- 11:32say, are struggling to incorporate AI and to adopt it
- 11:36and to move up that maturity ladder.
- 11:39So it's not surprising really, but I think it, you know, the
- 11:43ADA Lovelace Institute really is right that these agreements,
- 11:47they do lack accountability frameworks.
- 11:49But I don't think it's just the accountability that's the
- 11:52important thing. I think it's better designed,
- 11:55you know, memorandums of understanding.
- 11:58But it's also, I think about the ministers that are stood there
- 12:02announcing these, these, you know, making these big
- 12:05announcements, not just doing it for the cameras, but actually
- 12:08looking at the plan of how are we going to start getting this
- 12:11moving? And that and in that is the
- 12:14trick. How are they going to actually
- 12:15make sure that the announcements lead to adoption and, you know,
- 12:21exploitation of the, you know, the technology that's now around
- 12:24us because we're going to need it.
- 12:26Yeah, very much so. Look, there are other issues
- 12:29around the extent to which we grow dependent on foreign
- 12:34infrastructure and interoperability and so on, and
- 12:38we'll come back to that. There's a story we're going to
- 12:40cover later that actually touches on those issues as well.
- 12:44So with that, shall we move on to the same story that you're
- 12:47covering this week, Matt? Yeah, and this is again sort of
- 12:51saying that the UK isn't ready, but this time it's about AI and
- 12:55crisis disinformation. The Alan Turing Institute's
- 12:59Centre for Emerging Technology and Security has published a
- 13:04report called Adding Fuel to the Fire, and it's warned that the
- 13:10UK is structurally unprepared for AI enabled disinformation in
- 13:15the aftermath of crisis events. The report draws an analysis of
- 13:1915 major international incidents since July 2024, interviews with
- 13:2525 cross sector experts and a live crisis tabletop simulation
- 13:31exercise. And the research has found a
- 13:33consistent pattern. Deep fakes, AI powered, not bot
- 13:37networks, and data poisoning attacks are deployed in the
- 13:41chaotic hours immediately after a crisis, precisely when
- 13:45institutional response capacity is stretched and public trust is
- 13:49most fragile. The report points to real events
- 13:52such as the Southport murders in July 2024 and the Bondi Beach
- 13:55attack in December 2025 that both featured coordinated AI
- 14:00disinformation campaigns in their immediate aftermath.
- 14:03In those windows, false narratives embedded themselves
- 14:06before any counter response was operable.
- 14:08You know, operational, you know. The researchers argue that this
- 14:12isn't a technology problem, it's a governance problem.
- 14:16The UK currently lacks crisis specific AI protocols, severity
- 14:20thresholds that would trigger escalation, and the cross sector
- 14:23coordination mechanisms needed to move at the speed that this
- 14:27threat requires. The recommended fixes are
- 14:30specific. The Cabinet Office DSIT that you
- 14:33mentioned earlier and the AI Security Institute should
- 14:36develop dedicated crisis response protocols.
- 14:40The Government Communications Service should update its Resist
- 14:44to Counter Disinformation toolkit, which has a range of
- 14:49protocols and tools for people to use to incorporate AI
- 14:53specific threats, and the Frontier Model Forum, which
- 14:57incorporates members such as Google, Anthropic, Amazon Matter
- 15:04will expand its threat sharing channels between frontier AI
- 15:08companies during active incidents.
- 15:11They also call an Ofcom to examine the financial incentives
- 15:15behind AI generated disinformation as part of its
- 15:18upcoming Online Safety Act consultation, which is going to
- 15:22happen this summer. The report is not short of
- 15:24recommendations. The question is whether the
- 15:28institutions it is addressing are capable of moving at the
- 15:32pace the threat demands. What do you make of this?
- 15:36Neil that that last line could have come from the story before,
- 15:38I think exactly. It's great that a prestigious
- 15:45serious institution like the Turing Institute is generating
- 15:49fairly concrete proposals and you know, the, the, the bodies
- 15:52that it wants to get involved, the Cabinet Office, DC,
- 15:55etcetera, the Frontier Frontier Model Forum, which I would guess
- 16:01most people haven't heard of. But it's, it is something that
- 16:04looks into security issues and has the involvement of some of
- 16:06the biggest names in AI. You know, there's sort of open
- 16:09AI, Google, Anthropic, etcetera. But something else the report
- 16:14highlighted was since July 2024, So what we know we're we're
- 16:19almost in April 2026, so a little under 2 years.
- 16:23It found at least 15 major International Crisis events
- 16:27featuring AI information threats.
- 16:30OK, very specifically that that boils down to roughly one every
- 16:34five to six weeks. So this is not something that
- 16:38has been slowly gathering pace. This is something that is
- 16:41already with us and it's happening frequently at a really
- 16:44significant level. Now the Southport incident, we
- 16:49all in the UK remember that very clearly.
- 16:51I mean, that was what the, the, the consequences of that were
- 16:55really quite shocking. What what happened there.
- 16:59And yes, it apparently did generate some activity from the,
- 17:04the DSAT, but this is knocking on two years that they've,
- 17:11they've had something to do something about this.
- 17:13And it seems we're still at the urgent action needed stage.
- 17:17No, no actual protocols, recommendations, but no
- 17:21protocols. Now to, to say again, I, I, I
- 17:25don't envy the people that have to do this, that this is not an
- 17:28easy job. It is such a fast changing
- 17:31field. It is so politically fraught,
- 17:34but it needs strong leadership from someone within the
- 17:37responsible bodies to actually get a grip of this.
- 17:41And make serious, serious proposals and implement them to
- 17:45to so we actually have a coherent and well understood way
- 17:51of dealing with these threats. Yeah, It seems that we're sort
- 17:53of participating in, you know, editorial tinkering rather than
- 17:58actually getting on with the job.
- 18:00I don't know if you've on any of your social media feeds have
- 18:04seen some of the some of the information wars that are going
- 18:08on between the US and what appears to be, you know, Iran or
- 18:14supporters of Iran at the moment.
- 18:16But some of the social media posts that are going out with
- 18:20particularly some some of the Lego sort of Lego characters
- 18:27over, you know, with, with songs it it's just, you know, it's
- 18:33catching. You missed this entirely.
- 18:35Oh, I, I highly recommend you go and search some of them out just
- 18:38because they're so well executed.
- 18:40But it's so easy to see how by doing something in a way that is
- 18:45a little bit unexpected can actually change the narrative
- 18:48around what's going on and can highlight different things.
- 18:50I, I think it's really, really interesting to see that you've
- 18:53now, we've now got these ability to create, whether it's
- 18:56cartoons, whether it's deep fakes, ways of delivering a, a
- 19:00message that over time can build up and actually change opinions.
- 19:05It it beggars belief really. It does, it does.
- 19:09And there's another big part of this story toward the end that I
- 19:12think is, is actually very significant that's related to
- 19:15the financial incentives. So Ofcom, as you said, is going
- 19:19to be examining that with a view, yeah, part of its upcoming
- 19:24Online Safety Act consultation in summer 2026.
- 19:27Now a bit of a broken record. So that is, I mean, that's in
- 19:31the nearest future, but that's just recommendations When, when
- 19:36these things will actually be implemented, who knows, I mean,
- 19:39perhaps sometime in 2027. So it's getting pushed further
- 19:42and further out. But the whole issue around
- 19:44financial incentives, looking at the actual incentives for
- 19:47producing this deep fake stuff, it's, it's, it's interesting
- 19:51timing because we've just had this court case with Facebook or
- 19:54or Meta and YouTube, as you'll, you'll, you'll be well aware
- 19:58that is really from an understanding, from a reading of
- 20:02it could pose quite a significant threat.
- 20:04I mean, if it gets past the appeals stage that there are
- 20:07apparently thousands of these many more people.
- 20:12Just waiting to to sue Facebook and YouTube for less for for the
- 20:18actual content itself than than for the infrastructure
- 20:21underpinning it. But anyway, it's long been known
- 20:24that one of the problems with social media is that it
- 20:26incentivizes very provocative or downright shocking content as as
- 20:30a means to draw in interest. There's a massive financial
- 20:34incentive to produce these deep fakes.
- 20:36If you produce something that captures people's imagination or
- 20:39convinces people of its authenticity and it and it's
- 20:43it's a particularly shocking clip or it's trying to convey a
- 20:45very controversial message, the financial incentive is clear.
- 20:50I have no doubt at all that there will be elements of those
- 20:52companies that are sincere in what they're doing around safety
- 20:55and and are very concerned, but they too have financial
- 21:00incentives to pull more, more users toward their site.
- 21:05Like many of these things enormously complicated and and
- 21:08devilishly difficult to fix. And I I am not convinced by what
- 21:12has been said in this announcement.
- 21:14Like we say many times, definitely steps in the right
- 21:17direction so far to go. Yeah, I agree.
- 21:20And so moving on to our final story this week regarding
- 21:23Plantier and it's gaining of a prominent contract with the UK
- 21:28government. The UK's financial watchdog, the
- 21:31FCA, has handed a new contract to Palantia, the American firm
- 21:35that specialises in using AI to analyse vast quantities of
- 21:40sensitive data and has quietly become one of the most embedded
- 21:43artificial intelligence companies in British public
- 21:47life. The Financial Conduct Conduct
- 21:49Authority has hired Palantia to apply it's AI platform, known as
- 21:53Foundry, to the regulator's internal intelligence files for
- 21:56a three month trial. The contract is worth around
- 22:00375,000 lbs, modest by government standards but
- 22:03significant for what it grants access to.
- 22:07The idea is to use AI to spot patterns of financial crime
- 22:10faster than human analysts can across the 42,000 firms the FCA
- 22:15overseas, from major banks to crypto exchanges.
- 22:19The data a foundry will possess includes fraud investigations,
- 22:23money laundering cases, insider trading, files and
- 22:26communications, including phone recordings and emails.
- 22:29There was only one bit, one other bidder, and it was
- 22:31anonymous, though the FCA says the process was run blind,
- 22:35meaning it didn't know who had won until it concluded, The
- 22:38Guardian reports The FCA chose to use real, sensitive data to
- 22:43test the AI rather than synthetic data.
- 22:46Despite its own guidelines recommending otherwise.
- 22:50The FCA is acting strictly as a data processor.
- 22:54Well, the FCA, sorry, the FCA says planter is acting strictly
- 22:57as a data processor under its instructions that all data
- 23:02remains UK hosted, that U.S. law compelling American firms to
- 23:05share data with Washington does not apply to this arrangement,
- 23:09and that everything must be destroyed when the contract
- 23:13ends. Now you have heard of Plantier,
- 23:16I take it, Matt? Oh.
- 23:17Right. More than once.
- 23:18Yes, right, yes. OK, so in certain parts of the
- 23:22tech world and the media, plantier is depicted as as
- 23:26little short of the devil Incarnate.
- 23:28I would say it it it has in certain areas a, a, a very bad
- 23:32reputation. I think this story is more
- 23:36complicated than that. But but before we move on to I
- 23:38think what what what do you think?
- 23:39What grabbed you about this story?
- 23:42So it's, I think that there's, there's two things here. 1 is
- 23:46the process and two is the fact that Polancia now span
- 23:50healthcare, defence, policing, financial regulation.
- 23:54They seem to have their fingers across everything and that
- 23:57creates real structural dependency and a huge amount of
- 24:00risk. So the process of doing this
- 24:05blind and not taking into account the fact that maybe the
- 24:10government is putting all of its eggs in one basket and, you
- 24:13know, and, and maybe not actually looking at some of the,
- 24:16the ethical questions around vendors is, is a big risk for
- 24:21my, you know, from my perspective.
- 24:22The other is that this ties the government into a proprietary
- 24:28setup again. And that means that any work
- 24:31that that that's done has to rely on Palantir, Yeah.
- 24:37So I think that I think for some people just to mention this name
- 24:42immediately causes suspicion. And I think it's, you know, I'm,
- 24:47I'm, I read the Guardian now and then as as much as the next
- 24:49person. I think this is exactly the kind
- 24:51of story that would raise the hackles of Guardian readers, the
- 24:54involvement of a company like this in big state projects.
- 25:00If you take, so if you take some some of the main spokespeople at
- 25:03the word, it sounds like there are fairly strict legal
- 25:07protections. And I mean this point that it
- 25:09was run through a competitive procurement the which the FCA
- 25:12says was blind. So it didn't know who'd won and
- 25:16the other applicant was anonymous.
- 25:18And you'd have to then assume that this was a qualitatively
- 25:24better bid. Now this this strikes into a
- 25:32taps into a broader issue of the degree to which some of these
- 25:35big American companies are getting their hooks into large
- 25:39government contracts and government processes.
- 25:41That is an area of concern in itself.
- 25:46How dependent do you want to be upon companies that are not UK
- 25:51based? I I don't know exactly what the
- 25:54the position is with the data to say it would be stored here.
- 26:00I'm less concerned about necessarily about where the
- 26:03data's stored, but and who's but who's doing actually the
- 26:06processing OK. What did it say about that at
- 26:09the end of the story? It's anonymous, so it's acting
- 26:13strictly as a data processor under its instructions that all
- 26:16data remains UK hosted. the US law compelling American firms to
- 26:20share data with Washington is not going and everything must be
- 26:22destroyed. Right.
- 26:23Those are making all the right noises.
- 26:25Assuming those are all adhered to, then you would think, OK,
- 26:28they they have gone into it somewhat with their eyes open
- 26:30and they've tried to have the right conditions attached.
- 26:33The devil will be in the detail and in the practise, seeing how
- 26:35it actually works once they've got their foot in the door and
- 26:39that they do start to expand their presence with these
- 26:43government contracts. I mean, I think the government
- 26:45is in a very difficult position, as it is with many things.
- 26:51I am sure many people in the government would very much like
- 26:53to be using domestic companies with this kind of capacity and
- 26:57capability to handle this kind of information.
- 27:01But you would have to assume that, at least for now, that is
- 27:05not an option. Now regarding the ethical side
- 27:08of it, I think one of the reasons Palantir's reputation is
- 27:12what will it? It is shaped certainly by one of
- 27:15its Co founders who is Peter Thiel, who is a hugely
- 27:20influential and to many infamous name in these circles.
- 27:24He invested in many of the biggest Silicon Valley successes
- 27:28in the last 20 years. But actually, so I read an
- 27:30interview with the CEOA chap called Alex Karp and I think he
- 27:34is he is quite an interesting character.
- 27:38He actually trained as a philosopher, would you believe
- 27:41and he argues quite strenuously that in the face of accusations
- 27:46of what they do regarding working very closely and 11
- 27:50issue has been working very closely with the Israeli
- 27:52government and all sorts of accusations about what it is
- 27:54exactly they're they're facilitating.
- 27:56He argues strenuously that his that his company works very hard
- 28:02to build privacy protections into surveillance technology.
- 28:07And he's very much of the school of this, this is better being
- 28:10done from the inside by someone who's actually at the forefront
- 28:13of this technology. The question then becomes, how
- 28:17much do you trust him personally?
- 28:19And I mean, this is a question that extends across
- 28:23entanglements with many AI companies.
- 28:25I have to say. Yeah, it, it remains to be seen
- 28:29for me. I mean, I I think he he is, as I
- 28:32said, an interesting and complicated character.
- 28:34And there's many sides to him as ACEO.
- 28:38It remains to be seen exactly how this plays out with the UK
- 28:41government contracts. I think that Teal's the more
- 28:45interesting character here from from a personal perspective, you
- 28:48know, I have a lot of respect for him in the sense that I
- 28:52think he's an absolute, you know, from what I can tell, he's
- 28:54a genius that he was the he was, he features very strongly in a,
- 29:01in a really, really interesting book by one of my favourite
- 29:04authors, Ryan Holiday, a book called Conspiracy.
- 29:08And that talked about the, the court case that that was about
- 29:12Hulk Hogan and Gawker Media. And it's really, and Peter Thiel
- 29:17actually bankrolled that court case to get back at Gawker
- 29:21Media, who had outed him, you know, some years earlier.
- 29:26And the, the sort of the, the Machiavellian conspiracy playing
- 29:31was just, you know, it's just amazing.
- 29:35I have a bit of a concern when you've got a company that's got
- 29:37such a significant share holding of a of, of such powerful
- 29:42million, you know, billionaires having access to information
- 29:46about how the UK government identifies financial crime.
- 29:51You only have to look at some of the accusations of insider
- 29:55trading that are happening in the US right now.
- 29:58And I'm not suggesting that Peter Teal is involved in these
- 30:00at all, by the way. I don't want to get caught for
- 30:02libel here. But you only have to look at
- 30:04some of those accusations to think, well, actually, if we
- 30:06know how the game is played, we can play it better than the
- 30:09people that are looking at this. And so I think that there's a
- 30:14real risk involved in actually having that that sort of power
- 30:19outsourced at all. It strikes me a little bit that
- 30:23we're that we're handing the keys to the castle to, you know,
- 30:27to, to players that may not have the country's best interests at
- 30:31heart. Perish the thought.
- 30:35And, and the irony as well is that just earlier that this
- 30:39week, you know, Lord Valiance had told Parliament that the
- 30:43future procurement, if AI would, would prioritise British
- 30:47suppliers. And then the same week the FCA
- 30:50awards this to Palantir. And so we we end up in this
- 30:54massive mixed messaging and, you know, lack of coherence across
- 30:59what the government says it wants to do and what it actually
- 31:01does. It's a noble sentiment, but it
- 31:04will hit very quickly into this nasty thing called reality when,
- 31:09yeah, the the government will be under enormous pressure to
- 31:11promote British interests in terms of industry.
- 31:14But it'd be a very brave government procurement person
- 31:20that was willing to risk some kind of major security breach
- 31:23or, or some kind of inferior quality performance, you know,
- 31:27hypothetically by using a less developed or or less
- 31:32technologically advanced provider just because they were
- 31:35from the UK. But on that note, I think that
- 31:39is an excellent place to wrap up this week.
- 31:42Thanks as ever for your input, Matt.
- 31:45And and you too, Neil, hopefully next week we'll have a bit more
- 31:48positive news for for a change. See you.
- 31:50See you next week. See you next week.
- 32:01And that's it for this week's episode of AI in the UK.
- 32:06If you found it useful, you can subscribe wherever you get your
- 32:10podcasts and we'd really appreciate a great rating or
- 32:13review. It genuinely helps others find
- 32:16the show. You can also follow Neil's
- 32:19Footman and Matt Wilkinson on LinkedIn for links, notes and
- 32:23occasional extra content. Thanks for listening and we'll
- 32:27be back next week. Helping you make sense of AI as
- 32:31it lands here in the UK.