Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / Israel-Hamas War: Facts, Propaganda & The Road Ahead - Irina Tsukerman's Analysis
Transcript
- 0:20Welcome to the second episode of The World According to Irina
- 0:23Superman, our very special series on global politics on the
- 0:27KJ Master class Live. Irena Superman is AUS based,
- 0:31national security and human rights lawyer as well as a
- 0:34renowned geopolitical analyst. Her writings and commentary have
- 0:38appeared in diverse US and international media and have
- 0:41been translated to over a dozen languages and every fortnight in
- 0:45the World according to Irena Superman.
- 0:48We traversed the geopolitical landscape, delve into pressing
- 0:51international issues and gain insight from Irena's expert
- 0:55perspective. And today we will talk about the
- 0:58Israel Hamas war, The road ahead with Irena.
- 1:01Welcome to the show, IRENA. Thank you so much and I'm happy
- 1:06to be back. Wonderful, wonderful and this is
- 1:09a very important topic, Israel, Hamas war.
- 1:13We will talk about that first to understand from just to 1st, I
- 1:18want to congratulate you Irena on the on the award.
- 1:21I read it on your LinkedIn profile, the award that you have
- 1:24got from the Ukraine government. Tell our audience a bit about it
- 1:28what this is all about. Essentially, it's Brier.
- 1:33It's an award by their strategic Communications centre focused on
- 1:38media accuracy and it's a certificate of appreciation for
- 1:42my work encountering fake news disinformation from Russia and
- 1:47various affiliated. Networks, which is important at
- 1:52times of war especially to make sure that the information is
- 1:55accurate, that people can form clear opinions based on facts
- 2:01and not just propaganda, of course, of course.
- 2:05And that is what we are talking about, you know, facts,
- 2:08propaganda. Even in the Israel Hamas
- 2:11conflict that is ongoing at the moment in terms of, you know, in
- 2:15terms of you are top information analyst, you know about this.
- 2:20We have talked about this aspect earlier on, you know the role of
- 2:24propaganda. I just read earlier on about a
- 2:28lot of propaganda or different sort of misinformation going on,
- 2:32on the social media even about the Israel Hamas war.
- 2:36So how does a person who is not in that part of the world in not
- 2:40in the, in that in that particular country or countries,
- 2:45how should they understand? How do I understand this
- 2:48particular war sitting down in India and understand it from a
- 2:52factual perspective? Help us what is going on and
- 2:56what is happening, why it is happening.
- 2:58Help us with the background, with the present and then we'll
- 3:01talk about the road ahead on the Israel Hamas conflict.
- 3:05So the first thing I would start is that Hamas does not represent
- 3:09all of Palestinians. I think it's important to make
- 3:13that distinction because I've seen at times.
- 3:15Networks, newspapers create this duality between Palestinians and
- 3:23Israelis. The problem is here is that the
- 3:26Palestinians are represented by two separate entities that are
- 3:30often at conflict with each other, and both are
- 3:33dictatorships. There is no freedom of choice of
- 3:37political elections and Palestinian Authority, which is
- 3:41headed by Mahmoud Abbas, there has haven't been elections in.
- 3:46In now 17 years, Hamas came to power through popular will.
- 3:51But since then, you know, once it got into power, it no longer
- 3:56allowed free elections and created a dictatorship.
- 4:00Both entities have been extremely abusive to their own
- 4:04citizens. There are legitimate grievances
- 4:07between Palestinians and Israelis In disputes.
- 4:09There is a territorial dispute. That is normal.
- 4:13There are issues for contested land, different claims,
- 4:17historical tensions. Those issues should be resolved
- 4:21in courts, through political negotiations, through exchange
- 4:26of rational opinions. That cannot happen when one of
- 4:29the sites is a flawed but a real democracy, and they are.
- 4:33That makes mistakes but admits them and investigates them, and
- 4:38has a judiciary system and has a.
- 4:40Military oversight and people go to prison if they do something,
- 4:45if they commit a war crime, and the other side encourages war
- 4:49crimes, educates people, misdirects humanitarian funding,
- 4:53steals it from their own people and uses them to incite violence
- 4:58and uses its own population, civilians, as human Shields at
- 5:03times of conflict. That's completely unacceptable.
- 5:06What happened now is that Hamas, which is an Islamist.
- 5:10Nkiki created It's an violent offshoot of the Muslim
- 5:13Brotherhood, which has been backed by Iran primarily, but
- 5:18also various other states. Qatar has poured money into it.
- 5:23Turkey has poured money weapons into it, Russia and China both.
- 5:31Granted political legitimacy, and though most of the West
- 5:34recognizes it is a terrorist organization, it's on an
- 5:39official sanctions list in the United States.
- 5:43It attacked Israel in an unprovoked way that shocked the
- 5:48international community. Now, how that came to be, that
- 5:52Israel came to be suppressed is a separate topic that we can
- 5:56address later. But the attack was shocking.
- 5:59There was nothing. There was not no particular
- 6:02tensions before that. Actually, in the period leading
- 6:06up to this, relations appeared to be improving, which is why it
- 6:10was such a shock. Israel was allowing 17,000
- 6:15workers from Gaza to enter its territories for work and was
- 6:19planning to increase that up to $30,000 and 30 to 7000 people.
- 6:24Moreover, Israel has just negotiated a solution with the
- 6:29United States. To a visa free immigration
- 6:33status that would allow Gaza citizens, people with Gaza
- 6:38citizenship to enter Israel per agreement with the United
- 6:43States. So all of these things pointed
- 6:45to clear goodwill by Israel, clear indication that they were
- 6:49investing efforts and we're hoping that the arrangement that
- 6:53they have made through Qatar allowing Qatar to pay salaries.
- 6:57For Hamas, workers investing in education would bear fruit and
- 7:02Hamas would not attack. And indeed, Hamas appeared to
- 7:07have stayed out of some of the major attacks in the past.
- 7:12And so the thought was not to be confused with the Islamic Jihad,
- 7:17which didn't, which did most of the attacking.
- 7:20So there was a thought that maybe they moderated, maybe they
- 7:23were tired of fighting. Maybe their leadership is
- 7:25corrupt and they just want to. Enjoy international humanitarian
- 7:29aid and not bother anybody. So that's not good, but at least
- 7:33it's better than war. But that's not what happened.
- 7:36I think it's clear that there was a period of deception that
- 7:40allowed Israel to be distracted with other things.
- 7:44Focus more on West Bank, where the Palestinian Authority was
- 7:50appeared to be more aggressive than Hamas at the time.
- 7:55Israel moved their forces in that direction and Hamas took
- 7:58the opportunity to attack. It was not just an attack on
- 8:01military sites. Hamas likes to use the language
- 8:05of resistance. If you resist, you attack
- 8:07military sites, government size, institutions.
- 8:11That happens during times of war.
- 8:13It's not good, but it's understandable because the
- 8:16government, you know, sites, at least you can say it's sort of a
- 8:21legitimate, you know, symbolic. Political goal.
- 8:25But they have deliberately actually did not go for any
- 8:28military targets at all, except for military bases, which they
- 8:31did not to bomb empty buildings as some symbolic gesture they
- 8:37took. They murdered soldiers in their
- 8:40sleep, some were lying around in their underwear, they overran
- 8:44for military bases and they also took over.
- 8:48Many small cities and communities around Israel
- 8:53slaughtered civilians, abducted over 100 people.
- 8:57Somewhere between 100 and 200. Nobody knows exactly.
- 9:02And this morning came the shocking news that they've
- 9:05uncovered multiple places where there were entire families
- 9:08slaughtered in their beds. Houses were burned down with the
- 9:12purpose of forcing out people outside, where they were
- 9:15systematically shot. And they found bodies of
- 9:19murdered babies, some beheaded, some mould and distorted,
- 9:29tortured to death. Women were raped in at mass
- 9:33events. And the hostages that are held
- 9:37in Gaza are being systematically abused.
- 9:40They were horrible stories. Somebody called a woman.
- 9:43A woman who? Whose daughter was held hostage
- 9:47and told her that the daughter would be raped and murdered.
- 9:50And then they did that right after that call.
- 9:53During while on the call, they abducted an 85 year old
- 9:57Holocaust survivor in a wheelchair.
- 9:59They killed another 85 year old woman and seemed to murder on
- 10:03her Facebook page. I don't know why social media
- 10:06would allow something like that and not block it immediately,
- 10:09but the things that rise to the level of genocidal.
- 10:14Efforts of ISIS, the sort of crimes that ISIS committed
- 10:19during their attacks on the EC DS.
- 10:23And this is a whole new level for Hamas.
- 10:26They had no problem attacking civilians previously with rocket
- 10:30fire, explosions, suicide bombers, but this level of
- 10:35torturers intend this level of sadistic butchery is new.
- 10:39It's a new level that has previously not been expected
- 10:43from a group. And it became sort of familiar
- 10:46to the Israeli soldiers and to the international community.
- 10:50It was so to be more like a local insurgency than part of
- 10:54some international terrorist network.
- 10:57But the the events of the past few days completely changed that
- 11:01perception. Absolutely, absolutely.
- 11:05And before I come to to the different aspects related to
- 11:10this, I want to understand about you know what happened to shin
- 11:15bed or other Mossad and forget about even these what happens to
- 11:20the Five Eyes. They where these all eyes
- 11:22focused only on what India was doing and then which Trudeau
- 11:27took that example of where these eyes are.
- 11:30Are these eyes now all bruised? I want to understand because it
- 11:34is a colossal failure of the world intelligence system.
- 11:38Nobody could gather one thing and obviously this sort of a,
- 11:42you know, attack or whatever invasion or whatever one may
- 11:46wants to call it, it clearly shows that nobody was listening.
- 11:51Maybe everybody was listening what India was doing, what India
- 11:55was saying. I am trying to understand from
- 11:58your point of view because it is a 9/11 moment for Israel, it is
- 12:02for for others also. They must look at it.
- 12:05How does citizens in their own countries be feel safe going
- 12:10forward? Help us understand this
- 12:13particular part in brief, and then we'll come to the road
- 12:16ahead, exactly what this conflict means for the world.
- 12:20So I will start with the Israeli intelligence and their failures,
- 12:23and then I'll move on to Five Eyes and everyone else.
- 12:26A new article came out in New York Times that breaks down some
- 12:30of the problems. I don't know that those are the
- 12:33only problems. They were probably a lot more.
- 12:37But some of the problems included the fact that while
- 12:40they were monitoring the channels of communications by
- 12:46Hamas, they were simply not listening carefully because they
- 12:52have grown to understand that Hamas is not no longer a primary
- 12:59threat that terrorists in West Bank are.
- 13:02So they shifted the tension. And So what happened was.
- 13:06Most apparently possibly engaged in deliberate disinformation.
- 13:11They used these public channels that are normally being
- 13:14monitored to claim that they're no longer interested in the in
- 13:19the war, that they're not prepared, that they're not
- 13:22regime. And so both the IDEA and the
- 13:25National Security Advisor of Israel made statements.
- 13:30Based on these on what they heard from this commentary, they
- 13:32did not corroborate and verify that information.
- 13:36They did not follow up of it. Another problem problem was over
- 13:40reliance on technology that was remote controlled and distant.
- 13:45So they thought that a combination of different signal
- 13:48systems in the in the wall would prevent the terrorists from
- 13:52infiltrating moved troops elsewhere.
- 13:55And they were kind of. The first of all, they
- 13:58underestimated the force, the level of force that would be
- 14:02used to take down the wall. Second, these systems were
- 14:07easily disabled by drone technology and other means.
- 14:11Third, it was not it was a mistake not to have human beings
- 14:16to respond to attack because it And 4th there was also when they
- 14:20did finally deliver the message that they didn't because of the
- 14:24failed systems begins first. Get the information that
- 14:28something was wrong in time, and by the time they got it to the
- 14:32superiors, those were slow to react because they simply did
- 14:36not believe such a thing was possible or they were not
- 14:39getting all of the information at the same time.
- 14:43So there was this complacency over lines of technology,
- 14:47underestimation of human sources and these human informants were
- 14:53also kept. Deliberately not informed, the
- 14:58information was highly compartmentalized and Hamas
- 15:04operatives took much higher degree of precaution meeting
- 15:07face to face, essentially engaging in deceptive
- 15:13communications and just being much more careful so.
- 15:18Because Israel was not expecting already created a certain image
- 15:23that they were being murdered. They also did not care for
- 15:27follow every lead to make sure that they were in fact not lying
- 15:32or pretending or planning something, despite, as I
- 15:34mentioned previously, public indications that something was
- 15:39terribly wrong. These indications included Iran
- 15:45incitement to violence. Going back six or more months,
- 15:51Interception of explosives from Turkey to Gaza only three weeks
- 15:55before the event, potentially warnings by neighbouring allies
- 16:00such as Egypt, who may not have had the exact information, but
- 16:04they felt that there was a preparation for violence and the
- 16:07fact that in the past attacks Hamas has accumulated a lot of
- 16:10weapons. So what were they going to do
- 16:12with them? In general, not to mention
- 16:15nobody, there was no oversight of Qatari funding and where that
- 16:18was going. So that was a colossal mistake
- 16:21on everyone's part. And unfortunately US has played
- 16:24in part in that politically by systematically relying on Qatar
- 16:29as a as a partner, as a major non NATO ally.
- 16:33Whereas Qatar, whenever it taxes an intermediary and negotiator
- 16:38it it has, it is not a neutral broker, it is favourable to
- 16:43Iran. And that's sorted to Islamist
- 16:45organization. So the result is always skewed.
- 16:48It never works out well. We have seen what happened with
- 16:51the Taliban, with the Iranian nuclear deal JCPOA in the past,
- 16:56none of these things. And of course, the famous
- 17:00scandal with the abducted Qatari Royals, which was used as an
- 17:04excuse to distribute billions of dollars to Qassem Soleimani to.
- 17:11Militias in Syria and various terrorist organizations.
- 17:14So whenever Qatar is in baltis intermediary, you have to be
- 17:18sure that the problems are to follow.
- 17:21So there needs to be stringent oversight and simply didn't
- 17:24happen by anybody. I don't know if Israel even had
- 17:28the capability to do that. US probably would have, but they
- 17:32were not paying attention. And in fact, the Biden
- 17:34administration was actually also giving.
- 17:37Gaza money and so were the Europeans.
- 17:39So all of that money was going to unclear ends and nobody was
- 17:44really looking. So that's that's as far as basic
- 17:48due diligence is concerned. What now?
- 17:50Let's think intelligence, Actionable intelligence gathered
- 17:55by allies. So that one of the issues is
- 17:57that everyone was relying on surveillance and.
- 18:03NSA grabs huge amounts of chatter from all over the world.
- 18:07There is absolutely no way anyone can sift through all this
- 18:11information but the Israelis or Americans to get make sense of
- 18:15it. Because when you have data from
- 18:17coming in from everywhere, it could mean anything and it takes
- 18:20a long time to conduct proper analysis.
- 18:22So that was one problem in the general problem before 911 US
- 18:28had problems with. Agencies sharing intelligence.
- 18:32That becomes even more difficult when you have agencies of
- 18:36foreign countries sharing intelligence, because nobody
- 18:39knows what needs to be prioritized in terms of sharing.
- 18:43Then there are concerns about your own security, whether you
- 18:45need to keep that information secret for your own thing.
- 18:49And sometimes you just don't know what to look for.
- 18:51So it seems to me that the political issues actually played
- 18:58more of a role. Then access to intelligence,
- 19:00because the Biden administration was focused on placating Iran
- 19:05and kind of working with all these groups and creating all
- 19:09these deals in the Middle East with everybody and anybody.
- 19:12And they were not really looking at who which of these actors is
- 19:16actually a threat. And so I think the information
- 19:21flow was impacted by these political frameworks.
- 19:26Absolutely, absolutely. Let's look at things at the
- 19:30ground. What is it that Hamas wanted to
- 19:33achieve through this? Because this they obviously the
- 19:37scale of the attack, the scale of the invasion clearly shows
- 19:41that there is a larger objective.
- 19:44They clearly knew that Israel will have no other option but to
- 19:48retaliate and retaliate very, very strongly.
- 19:51So obviously it's just not a one off attack when you kill a few
- 19:54people. What is it that the larger
- 19:57objective is, and now that Israel is also full pledgedly at
- 20:01a state of war with Hamas, it also wants to bring that status
- 20:06quo that by controlling the Gaza Gaza Strip, what does now?
- 20:10Where does this situation stand? What does Hamas want?
- 20:14Who are its backers and funders? What is your understanding of
- 20:18this, and where does? This end what does Israel do
- 20:22now? There is a blockade on
- 20:23everything. The humanitarian crisis begins,
- 20:27then the role of the world and the US.
- 20:28The world is divided at the moment, with the US looking at
- 20:32it, that Israel has every right to defend itself.
- 20:35The UN will look at it differently, though I don't
- 20:38think it has got great enough strength.
- 20:41Even the UN Security Council was opposed to meet.
- 20:43I don't know what happened after that.
- 20:45So help us understand, You know what is happening?
- 20:48Is this what is it that these players want?
- 20:50Not the players only in the front, but in the back also?
- 20:54What is it? How do the world feel?
- 20:56Look at it in the same because it's going to impact not only
- 20:59their own understanding of things but also businesses will
- 21:03get impacted in these difficult times.
- 21:06So let's start with Hamas, because the Hamas is the most
- 21:10direct party involved in all of this.
- 21:12There calculus was relatively simple.
- 21:15First, to undermine and disrupt Israel's image as a strong
- 21:19country and make it less valuable for regional powers.
- 21:23Which is exactly what happened. Everybody immediately backed
- 21:26off. And it it put a dent on Israel's
- 21:29security, intelligence and defence relations with
- 21:32countries. Because if Israel cannot follow
- 21:35its own procedures, cannot follow good tradecraft and.
- 21:40Good security policies. It's not a reliable ally.
- 21:43And it's not just because Hamas is so brutal or Iran is doing
- 21:47all this. There were mistakes that are
- 21:49made this possible. Let's do internal mistakes.
- 21:53They will be investigated. Things will be changed, I am
- 21:56sure, but it will take time. It will not happen overnight.
- 22:00You still need to fight with this dented image and win the
- 22:04war and deter and find a way. You still need to communicate
- 22:07with the countries, but it's now much harder.
- 22:10Second, the objective was to to draw Israel into a long, bloody
- 22:17and possibly multi front war, which is almost inevitable.
- 22:21There's talks of getting Israel into a ground war which will be
- 22:25grinding and terrible due to the density of Gaza, due to the
- 22:30internal urban planning. That is extremely, as someone
- 22:34put it well, it's Vietcong in a concrete jungle.
- 22:38It's like. Going through these jungles, but
- 22:40house by house, door to door, could take months, could take
- 22:43years to clean everything off Some operatives that can be
- 22:47killed by air strikes, but the real people will know how to go
- 22:51underground and to hide. And of course civilians are
- 22:54being held hostage, so you can expect mass casualties no matter
- 22:58how careful you are. Because again, the the area is
- 23:03extremely dense and despite numerous calls for evacuations,
- 23:07first of all there's. Two places to go.
- 23:10And 2nd, the authoritarian regime wants as many casualties
- 23:16as possible in order to create a pressure by the international
- 23:20community for Israel to de escalate, create horrible
- 23:24optics, propaganda and all of that.
- 23:26And you know many people. In the world, and not all that
- 23:29sympathetic to Israel to begin with.
- 23:31So now when you have everyone calling, well, you're killing
- 23:34innocent children, they'll say what's the difference between
- 23:37Palestinian children and Israeli children?
- 23:39Lives are lives, and lives are being lost.
- 23:41So they don't care that Hamas went into the deliberate,
- 23:46intentional genocidal brutality. All we care is that people are
- 23:51being, you know, civilians are being killed on both sides.
- 23:53So that's how most of the vote is going to look at it.
- 23:56And the UN is not the least of it.
- 23:58They, Russia and China blocked any possibility of our
- 24:02resolution condemning it and you can tell you where they stand.
- 24:06They haven't been at the forefront of the conflict
- 24:09because like unlike Iran, Iran is the is thought to be the
- 24:14Middle Eastern controller because.
- 24:18Iran is investing into all these proxies.
- 24:21It trains them, it creates an A real high level army out of all
- 24:25of them. Russia and China will work with
- 24:28Iran. They're increasing their
- 24:30presence in the region, but they're not yet at the level
- 24:34where they can can control their own militia, nor do they
- 24:37necessarily want to. They've got their own
- 24:39geopolitical agendas. But what they do want is to.
- 24:44Advance an anti western agenda in the Middle East and
- 24:48partnering with Iran and working with these terrorist
- 24:51organizations and backing them holistically and giving them
- 24:55political legitimacy is something they can do.
- 24:59And at times it's more than that.
- 25:00At times we can. You know Russia and Iran are
- 25:03working on joint missile production.
- 25:06Where do you think that's going to go?
- 25:07Not just not just to Russia, and not just to Iran, but also to
- 25:11regional proxies and partners and.
- 25:14Russian proxies in various areas because Russia has its
- 25:17mercenaries and militias and people it recruits in different
- 25:21parts of the world, and China also has delivered weapons, the
- 25:26Chinese main weapons in in the in the hands of Hamas.
- 25:31So despite its calls for allegedly neutrality, it is
- 25:35actively involved in the conflict and it's not in favour
- 25:38of Israel. At all.
- 25:41Despite having commercial interest in Israel, it's
- 25:44doubtful that China will get directly involved in the front
- 25:49lines because it wants to keep its business in Israel and it
- 25:52wants to have access. So it could do the same thing as
- 25:55it does everywhere, which is still technology and and spy,
- 25:59but so if you are perceived as somebody who's aggressive and
- 26:02causing harm, you will have less opportunity to do that.
- 26:06But you know this this role is being.
- 26:10This image is slowly dissipating because after what happened at
- 26:13the UN, you cannot claim that these countries are neutral.
- 26:17That's not neutrality. That's favouring Hamas.
- 26:20When you have a terrorist organization engaging in
- 26:24unprovoked attacks against civilians, they cannot be
- 26:27neutrality. You have to condemn it.
- 26:30So that's as far as those interests go.
- 26:32But there are other interests. There's Qatar.
- 26:35Which is essentially an Islamist regime.
- 26:38People won't admit it. They claim that the royal family
- 26:41there is not all that religious, that they party and use drugs.
- 26:45One has. That's ever stopped anyone?
- 26:47The agenda is really is religious.
- 26:50Their partnerships are religious.
- 26:53Everything they do is using a religious rhetoric.
- 26:57The motivation may not be in line with mainstream Islam, but
- 27:01it's certainly a religious justification, and religious.
- 27:05The rhetoric and the motivation has this interest in using
- 27:09religion to further political goals.
- 27:12Turkey the same. You can say that maybe Turkey is
- 27:16not serious in rebuilding any sort of Ottoman Empire or
- 27:20religious empire with this or that, but it is absolutely,
- 27:25absolutely cultivating these militias and groups both
- 27:30internally and externally, and it hasn't stopped.
- 27:34Both Qatar and Torti harbour the real leadership of Hamas, Not
- 27:39the operatives implementing these policies, but the guys who
- 27:43call the shots. And they live a very good life
- 27:46in Doha and in in Torti in Istanbul, and they don't have
- 27:51anything to worry about. And they have not been expelled.
- 27:55And Erdogan did not promote promise to expel them once
- 28:00visited the United States recently, despite all his talks
- 28:04about. We know my rising with Israel
- 28:06when it comes to these priority issues.
- 28:09He needs them for his own stay in power, for his own control as
- 28:13this cutter. So these guys were definitely in
- 28:17on the whole thing. There all needs to be exposed.
- 28:21It's not likely to be exposed because Erdogan is needed in
- 28:25NATO to. Get the Swedes in into the into
- 28:31NATO and to blockade Russian ships.
- 28:34I mean despite the fact that Turkey is doing huge amounts of
- 28:39business with the Russia. Go explain that.
- 28:42How, how, how that relationship works must be a little bit
- 28:46awkward in those meetings. But you know, and Qatar, look,
- 28:52Qatar is designated as a major narnator ever, and a huge amount
- 28:56of money was from Qatar all over the world.
- 29:00Israel even tried to do business with Qatar, despite the fact
- 29:02that Qatar refuses to recognize it and was the opposed to the
- 29:06Abraham Accords. But the United States forget
- 29:10it's there. All the leading think tanks take
- 29:13money from Qatar, and Qatar is known for hacking.
- 29:18Officials leaking the information or blackmailing them
- 29:22with sensitive information. So with a country like that, you
- 29:28know, that has infinite money to spend and is not beyond
- 29:33destroying reputations, leaking government secrets and doing
- 29:36things like that. Very few are going to be in the
- 29:40current day and age are going to be willing to press it really
- 29:43hard, much less after you already granted it huge
- 29:46privileges taking them down. You know it's going.
- 29:51There's simply no political will to do that.
- 29:55But we should not also remember the Western countries and their
- 30:00allies who are providing all this uncontrolled humanitarian
- 30:03aid without regard for the consequences of allowing violent
- 30:10and hateful ideologies to proliferate from childhood age
- 30:15to adulthood. This level of violent
- 30:18indoctrination that passes for education produces predictable
- 30:22results. And that happens all over the
- 30:24world. Manchester and Gaza, it can
- 30:26happen in Europe. It can happen in any country in
- 30:29the world where you allow this level of indoctrination to
- 30:32persist. So all of these people
- 30:34understand that they are giving this uncontrolled money to
- 30:39dictatorships with agendas, and they do that anyway.
- 30:42So moreover, they just as responsible.
- 30:45For the outcome of their money being misused, Right, right,
- 30:51Ayrina. So what happens on the ground
- 30:53now Israel is already declared that it wants to go forward.
- 30:57It has 300,000 reservists it has called.
- 31:01So it is going to mobilize and move forward.
- 31:03Already the air strikes and all these things have happened And
- 31:07Hamas's strategy, if we understand, has to call Israel,
- 31:10get inside into a long drawn, you know, war.
- 31:13So this so there will be two wars ongoing.
- 31:17One is the Russia, Ukraine, and then in the Middle East you will
- 31:21have the Hamas and the Israel conflict.
- 31:23Where does this go from here? Because and how will we Israel
- 31:28look at not only Hamas but also its backers and funders?
- 31:33How will its diplomacy evolve from there?
- 31:36Is it going to be, if it's a difficult war, how much sense
- 31:40does it mean Israel to go forward?
- 31:43Because once it goes into Gaza and then the humanitarian crisis
- 31:48begins, the world's opinions starts changing.
- 31:50Already a lot of people are talking about the loss of
- 31:54civilian life in both the places.
- 31:56How is Israel? Is a is known for its position?
- 32:00How do you see this going forward?
- 32:02What is the road ahead also in terms of, you know, not only in
- 32:06terms of the war but also in terms of Israel's diplomacy
- 32:10going forward? Till now it has been trying to
- 32:13create good relations with a lot of countries in the Middle East.
- 32:17How does it work from here on? Well, let's start with the fact
- 32:22that the Biden administration is trying to cover up Iran's role
- 32:27in this Only days before they a couple of days ago, was the
- 32:31Journal came up with the follow up report.
- 32:35It's taking that Iran approved the separation just a week
- 32:39before it happened, and then this has been planned over a
- 32:42period of time. Washington Post reiterated other
- 32:45details linking Iran directly to the separation.
- 32:49Meanwhile, the Biden administration claims that all
- 32:53of this needs to be investigated, that it hasn't
- 32:55been proven it, and is trying to kind of give Iran a pass so that
- 33:01the consequences did not repeat. And the real founder of all
- 33:04this? It may have got away with Julie
- 33:08with murder and could proceed with any potential negotiations.
- 33:12That doesn't work and that caused the administration.
- 33:15It revealed its efforts to promote peace between Israel and
- 33:19Saudis as a farce that was never going to succeed under such
- 33:23conditions. Saudis were not serious about
- 33:26it. Saudis knew US was not serious
- 33:28about it. That US would never give them
- 33:30defense guarantees that they wanted.
- 33:32They already had normalized with Iran anyway so it's that was
- 33:37never so. That part of the foreign policy
- 33:40is a complete bust. Next comes what happens in terms
- 33:44of deterrence value. Israel faces a dilemma if it
- 33:48goes to into the. Into Gaza ground war.
- 33:52Hezbollah has threatened to escalate.
- 33:55It has already been pushing the envelope.
- 33:57Even Syria started falling shots.
- 33:59UE allegedly pressures Assad not to get involved US sent aircraft
- 34:08carrier to avoid Hezbollah's escalation.
- 34:12But at the end of the day, what it actually does is limits
- 34:16Israel's ability to respond with full force.
- 34:19It can. Basically, the signal is focused
- 34:23on Gaza. Do what needs to be done there
- 34:25for a while, but any further than that, he cannot go because
- 34:29you've sent this carrier. Hezbollah will live to fight
- 34:34another date and you and you can't go after Iran.
- 34:39All you can do is go after this function.
- 34:41There is not even the real people.
- 34:43The real people are in Turkey and Qatar.
- 34:46These functionaries will get more money after this from
- 34:48Turkey, Qatar, Iran, whoever else.
- 34:51They will rebuild. It may take them a a while
- 34:53longer than usual, but they'll come back.
- 34:56And you know, you'd better fix your own issues and have better
- 35:01defenses. But they'll, I'm sure they'll
- 35:03figure out some way to try again.
- 35:05And so the cycle will continue indefinitely, because unless if
- 35:10if Israel wants to finally put an end to Hamas.
- 35:13It has to put an end to the to everyone who finds it and makes
- 35:17it possible. Hamas is a tool.
- 35:20Hamas without money, support, backing and training is was a
- 35:24RACTAC terrorist organization. Now it's an army.
- 35:27So unless you go after the people giving the orders, this
- 35:30is like playing back a mole, right?
- 35:35Right. I want to understand from you,
- 35:38Irina, is that Hamas spokesperson.
- 35:41He has given an interview with BBC.
- 35:43If I understand thanking Iran and future plans to expand
- 35:47attack to other countries, what does it mean?
- 35:51Attack to other countries? What does it mean?
- 35:54This could mean a few things, but I would venture to to reason
- 35:57that Hamas has already been proposed alliances with other
- 36:01Iranian proxies. Hezbollah and Hamas have been
- 36:04coordinating actions. Hoodies in Yemen have offered
- 36:09assistance. The Taliban Hamas had
- 36:13congratulated Taliban when they got into power and Taliban
- 36:17returned the favour by trying to by first of all, Taliban's
- 36:21weapons that it received from the US, which were abandoned,
- 36:25went through Iran to Gaza and 2nd Just now Taliban was
- 36:30negotiating with Iran for access to assist Hamas.
- 36:36You can see Iraqi militias being involved there with the firing
- 36:40Syria, So Hamas could be involved in any number of
- 36:43regional operations. You also know that Hamas already
- 36:47has a great ongoing relationship with North Korea.
- 36:51It has visited Moscow officials who reached out to Hamas for any
- 36:56number of reasons. So we can see this international
- 37:02terrorist network expanding, collaborating on the procuring,
- 37:07on the arms trade, on interoperability, on crime rings
- 37:14such as drug trafficking and, you know, theft of various, you
- 37:19know, importation of various valuables from Africa, Latin
- 37:23America to support themselves. We can see this huge.
- 37:28International terrorist and crime network expanding,
- 37:32integrating, dominating. Hamas was previously thought to
- 37:37be original, original organization focused on in
- 37:42Israel. But now as an integrated and
- 37:45more sophisticated part of Iran's sphere of influence, it
- 37:49can be deployed anywhere and it can work with anybody anywhere,
- 37:53right? There are so many angles to
- 37:58understand in this thing that has happened.
- 38:01One last question is, you know that it is almost like both
- 38:05parties, Hamas and Israel, they have declared the war to the
- 38:09finish. One is Hamas wants a result,
- 38:11permanent result out of this. And now Israel has also said
- 38:16they want to change the status on the ground moving towards
- 38:20Gaza. How does it look like?
- 38:22Does it look like more of optics or this is indeed going to be a
- 38:25long drawn war and and the world will have to just keep watching?
- 38:30I don't think there's going to be a quick end result.
- 38:34I think elimination of Hamas will take more than destruction
- 38:39of infrastructure and debilitation of their fighters
- 38:42because there are still millions of people living in Gaza and any
- 38:46of them could be recruited. So unless there is a plan to
- 38:49massacre everybody of. Recruit recruitment.
- 38:51Age or younger, which is obviously not the case.
- 38:55There's no way to avoid the expansion of Hamas, even if it
- 38:58takes time. And remember, we have seen
- 39:01pictures of this operation that included clearly foreign
- 39:05fighters from maybe African countries or somewhere else.
- 39:09So Hamas. Like everybody else these days,
- 39:11is using can, you know, attract mercenaries from other parts of
- 39:15the world, from other jihadist groups, or whatever, so they
- 39:20don't need to even rely on their own people for a source of
- 39:22fighters. So we need to be looking at
- 39:28cutting of leadership and sources of funding, disrupting
- 39:32operations and making it possible for all these networks
- 39:36to work coherently together. It needs to be a global
- 39:40offensive. It is really serious about
- 39:43putting a stuff to that. And most importantly, Iran and
- 39:46everyone else who is with it need to be held accountable
- 39:49directly for what is happening. So as long as US and its
- 39:54partners in the international community refuse to move ahead
- 39:59with that, I don't see anything changing.
- 40:01The United Kingdom, for all its support, has, you know.
- 40:05Has been pushing back against even RGC registering there as a
- 40:10terrorist organization. It's Iranian Iran just got $6
- 40:17billion for for the hostages from the from the US.
- 40:22So it has other hostages. It's still holding in it and it
- 40:26actually committed to grabbing more people.
- 40:29And Brea is all of that money going not towards the, not
- 40:33towards the people, not towards building better infrastructure,
- 40:36not towards any serious investments going towards
- 40:39terrorism and wars. Support for foreign wars is a
- 40:42huge amount of money. So we are seeing that there is a
- 40:47a process of enabling the real actors behind of this and
- 40:51strengthening and empowering them.
- 40:52And so long as that process is continuous, how can the
- 40:56landscape change? How can a small country in
- 40:58Israeli, even with the most powerful weapons and and a lot
- 41:02of will and whatever, what can they change when the real
- 41:06problem is strategic, not tactical?
- 41:11Absolutely, absolutely. One last question is that do you
- 41:15think that? Russia, Ukraine, war will now go
- 41:19into the background, background and and it will all be about
- 41:22talking about first about the Hamas, Israel conflict, There's
- 41:27two different things. One is what is actually
- 41:29happening on the ground, which is the reality of operations,
- 41:33and the second, the way media and politicians treat it.
- 41:37So just because there's a new war on this front, a new front
- 41:40to a very global war against the West by all of this, by this
- 41:44axis, Russia, China, North Korea, Iran and their and their
- 41:49non state allies doesn't mean that other conflicts go away.
- 41:53They keep fighting, people are losing their lives and they have
- 41:57their own goals and needs and none of that is going anywhere.
- 42:01What what can happen though, is that some people can try to use
- 42:05this war as an excuse to cut off, to cut off support to
- 42:09Ukraine, or to claim that Ukraine is somehow draining
- 42:14resources from this fight, that you know, Israel, Hamas is a
- 42:19much less. They will try to make a case
- 42:22that Israel and Hamas is a much less ambiguous situation than
- 42:27Russia and Ukraine. They have been trying, even
- 42:29though that is not the case. In both situations you have
- 42:32several states that have been attacked under premises that
- 42:37violate international laws without a question.
- 42:41Arguing about history and things like that does not excuse
- 42:44violation of sovereignty. You can dispute things in courts
- 42:47or politically. What you cannot do is invade.
- 42:50But actually the situation is identical.
- 42:53The methods have been identical. And the support for terror, you
- 42:57know, uses propaganda to try to split public opinion, create
- 43:02equivocations and moral distinctions that actually do
- 43:05not exist with the Israel's and Ukraine's moral case against
- 43:11invaders is equally valid. We can discuss, you know, what
- 43:17on an individual level, this or that person or group or
- 43:20political parties should or should not do, whether or not
- 43:23there's problems in Israeli government or Ukrainian
- 43:26governments. Of course there are problems but
- 43:28that but the but complicating the story.
- 43:30There's nothing for the realities that invasions and
- 43:34atrocities and war crimes are absolutely inexcusable, no
- 43:38matter what how imperfect the target states are.
- 43:44We can argue about all those other issues separately, but not
- 43:47about the basic moral, legal, political reality that allowing
- 43:53this sort of activity does nothing but destabilizes the
- 43:57whole global community, and not even just those states.
- 44:01Absolutely, absolutely. With one more crisis in front of
- 44:05the world, I guess it is time also to get the right kind of
- 44:09perspective into all these things happening.
- 44:12So we will continue to bring, you know, the right kind of
- 44:15perspective with the world according to Irina Superman as
- 44:19we go forward with this, with this, it's a wrap on this very
- 44:24special edition of the KJ Master class slide.
- 44:27Thank you so much indeed for joining us.
- 44:30Thank you.