Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E014: Why Bitcoin is the Ultimate Form of Value Investing with Brian Cubellis
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop, and
- 0:04we're going to be left holding the biggest bag of bodarous
- 0:07extras ever assembled in the history of doubtless
- 0:131974198792972 thousand. Whatever we want to call this,
- 0:19it's all just the same thing over and over.
- 0:21We can't help ourselves. I say when we.
- 0:24Sell, hey, I say when we sell. The button has been hit,
- 0:31gentlemen. We've got four of us in the
- 0:33studio today. It's great to have everybody in
- 0:35person. Jesse, how are you?
- 0:38Marty. This is some production magic by
- 0:42Logan behind the the computer back here in the studios, in the
- 0:48Bitcoin Commons in Austin, TX. Big week down here in Austin.
- 0:52We got the Bitlock Boom conference this weekend,
- 0:54tomorrow and Saturday. And they're.
- 0:59He's an army of bitcoiners in town.
- 1:00First slew of events. Activity started last night,
- 1:04rolling into today. Energy is high, obviously.
- 1:07We got people in town from all over the country, all over the
- 1:10world. One of those being Brian.
- 1:12Cabela's Brian, welcome to the show.
- 1:14Thank you for having me. Great to be here.
- 1:16Welcome to the Bitcoin capital of the world as well.
- 1:18I think that was true. Great to.
- 1:19Be in Austin my first time, first time.
- 1:21The big block boom. Pump for it.
- 1:23First time big block. Boom.
- 1:24Yeah, first one. That's the first one I'm gonna
- 1:26miss. You're gonna be here for a
- 1:28majority of that. Don't sell yourself, George.
- 1:30No, I have to leave tomorrow morning.
- 1:31Oh, really? Hey, I have a wedding.
- 1:33Oh, I thought. You're leaving. 1st I'm gonna
- 1:35miss. I've been to everyone.
- 1:36Gary, if you're listening, I'm deeply sorry, not disappointed
- 1:41because it's not something I can control.
- 1:42I can't control when two people decide to get married.
- 1:44It just so happened to be on the weekend a bit block boom.
- 1:50But it's a great, a great conference.
- 1:52You you should. You made it to the one that
- 1:54really counted, which was the 2020 where it all started.
- 1:57Yes, the. Conference in the middle of of
- 1:59COVID lockdowns. We all came to Texas.
- 2:02Some of us got COVID, but we all, I think everybody survived.
- 2:04Not that we lost anybody, but we're here.
- 2:08Jesse's in town, floating. Yeah, I flew in 5 minutes before
- 2:14the podcast. It's great to have you.
- 2:18Sorry we stuck you in this tight little corner here.
- 2:21For people who can't see, Logan spun up a little picture in
- 2:25picture where it looks like I'm part of the crew, but it's just
- 2:28my disembodied head. When you said you you flew in or
- 2:34just flew in, it hit me with Brian was saying coming in from
- 2:37New York, I was like, I don't even, I can't own do it.
- 2:39Just as how was the heat when you stepped up the flame?
- 2:42Yeah, it was a ton of bricks coming out of the coming out of
- 2:45the airport. Wasn't wasn't fully.
- 2:46Prepared for it. Humidity.
- 2:48Straight to the face. But yeah, like 110, that's my
- 2:53Uber driver was telling me like, oh, it's going to be really cool
- 2:55today. Looked at my weather app, it's
- 2:57going to be 110. I'm like, OK, I guess that's
- 3:00that's cool for here for now. I do love that.
- 3:04I love that departure out of the ATX airport.
- 3:07And and you hear like the crackle noises and it's like, ah
- 3:10yeah, the humidity. Suddenly your hair picks up and
- 3:14you know you're about to eat some BBQ.
- 3:16It's. It's a character builder
- 3:18gentleman for sure. You know, I was.
- 3:22I went on a 7 mile walk this morning in the heat.
- 3:24You know, it's nice to get a good sweat, and I don't want a
- 3:26humble brag on the show, but I guess I just did.
- 3:30You did. I mean, I like in, I like in the
- 3:31heat and and when individuals complain about it to Bitcoin's
- 3:35volatility, it's just like a it's a it's a filter like you
- 3:40you if you can't handle the heat, like should you really be
- 3:42in Texas? Like what do you stand for?
- 3:44Yeah, what's the old city? If you can't handle the heat,
- 3:46get out of the kitchen. Can't handle the heat.
- 3:48Get out of Texas, I. Think that's how in the place
- 3:51this is a inherent like friction, there's a you have to
- 3:54jump. Yeah, you get soft.
- 3:55If the the weather was always like San Diego, it it would be a
- 3:58different place. I mean, people from California
- 4:02are really soft it. Seems to be true.
- 4:10This isn't a weather podcast or a Manisphere podcast around here
- 4:13to call PeopleSoft. We're here to talk about
- 4:15Bitcoin. Brian, once you introduce
- 4:19yourself, you had a strategy and research at On RAMP.
- 4:22You've been doing some incredible things behind the
- 4:25scenes on the research side, on the content side, once you give
- 4:29us a little bit of information about your background, how you
- 4:32got in a Bitcoin and why you decided to join the On Ramp
- 4:35team. Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
- 4:38It's been, it's been an interesting and long journey.
- 4:41I mean, I, you know, when I was. Back in undergrad, so I
- 4:46graduated 2014 from from University of Virginia.
- 4:49And you know, at the time I majored in econ and history.
- 4:53And at the time I didn't know that that would be sort of a
- 4:57formative foundation for eventually understanding
- 5:00Bitcoin. But, you know, I didn't really
- 5:02come across Bitcoin in a real way until much later than that,
- 5:05you know, 20/17/2018. But I think that that was
- 5:09formative in terms of just getting my bearings on, you
- 5:13know? History and and you know I took
- 5:15multiple courses around like the history of technology so I
- 5:17already always had an appreciation for innovative
- 5:20things and and trying to you know dive deep into into those
- 5:23sorts of things and and from there you know I I didn't really
- 5:26know what I wanted to do after that right.
- 5:28Like coming out of college, I really all I knew is I wanted to
- 5:31move to New York and be in the finance world generally, which
- 5:36was sort of the case for a lot of people in my circles.
- 5:39Like that was just kind of that was the route, right and.
- 5:43So I applied to, you know, a bunch of different banking
- 5:45positions and ultimately found my way to Brown Brothers
- 5:49Harriman, which is a large private bank headquarters in New
- 5:54York, but they've offices around the country and globally.
- 5:59And there, you know, I was there for eight years.
- 6:01And so I was, you know, throughout that period became
- 6:04very ingrained in sort of the traditional finance world.
- 6:06And at the onset I was actually more on like the relationship
- 6:11side of things and. Pretty early on in that, in that
- 6:15role I I kind of decided that you know, I was much more
- 6:19interested in sort of the investment side of of the
- 6:21business. So I was within the private bank
- 6:23and there's a few different business lines at Brown
- 6:25Brothers, but the private banking business line is you
- 6:29know, lots of high net worth clients, some endowments and
- 6:32foundations and it's unique in the sense that it's largely like
- 6:38a discretionary model. So you know.
- 6:41Clients can sort of like opt out of certain strategies or
- 6:44investments, but for the most part like they take the, the
- 6:48investment team's best thinking, right.
- 6:50And so I eventually moved away from sort of the relationship
- 6:53side of things and got onto the sort of centralized investment
- 6:56team within the private bank and the small flat team and and was
- 7:00you know, working directly with our CIO and it was a really just
- 7:05formative experience for me because you know, I was.
- 7:07My early 20s and and you know my day-to-day was effectively going
- 7:12out and diligencing you know third party managers.
- 7:15So anything from you know hedge funds to long only equity
- 7:19strategies, private equity, you know I was a generalist and we
- 7:22were all generalist. So got to work sort of across
- 7:24the asset class spectrum and really every day I was just sort
- 7:29of like picking the brains of some of the smartest investors
- 7:32in the world And so along that journey, I mean.
- 7:36The Brown brothers like I said is a very old institution
- 7:39founded in 1818. You know they're very generally
- 7:43like conservative in in their in their thinking and had a very
- 7:47value oriented investment philosophy and so that's that's
- 7:51sort of how I honed my own investment philosophy was
- 7:54through that lens of value investing and and you know
- 7:59generally we were all sort of. Praising at the altar of Warren
- 8:02Buffett to an extent right, like Warren Buffett, Ben Graham,
- 8:06security analysis, all that stuff, buying things you know
- 8:09cheaply and and and basically understanding the fundamentals
- 8:12in the long term trajectory of something.
- 8:15And so that was, that was sort of how I I honed my own personal
- 8:19investment philosophy over that time was by talking to you know
- 8:21some really smart people and and ultimately you know making
- 8:26investment decisions and allocating capital on on behalf
- 8:29of our, our private clients. And so, you know, I, like I
- 8:33said, I didn't really come across Bitcoin until sort of
- 8:37late 2017, end of that bull run. And, you know, I had buddies who
- 8:40were like pulling out their Coinbase apps and like, showing
- 8:42me this thing. I was like, OK, seems
- 8:45interesting, but I don't really know what this thing is.
- 8:47I think it was around that time that I actually heard of you,
- 8:50Marty, from The Barstool Days, Tales from the Crypt.
- 8:55And that sort of prompted me to take a take a.
- 8:59Deeper look honestly and like I said, like I had that sort of
- 9:02history in fascination around new technologies and innovations
- 9:06and it sort of the whole area sort of struck me immediately as
- 9:10like there's so much intellectual capital moving
- 9:12towards this thing that it was hard to ignore.
- 9:15And so, so from sort of 2017 to 2021, I was still Brown Brothers
- 9:22and you know. Having that value investing
- 9:25lens, but sort of on my own personal time trying to apply
- 9:27that lens to Bitcoin effectively.
- 9:30And you know it's not entirely intuitive that the value
- 9:36investing framework could be applied to something like
- 9:38Bitcoin. Because if you, you know, if you
- 9:39read security analysis, you go back to all these sort of
- 9:42frameworks, you know they're they're really more geared
- 9:45towards securities, right, like cash flowing businesses and so.
- 9:51It was my only lens though at the time.
- 9:53And so like, you know that that's what I had been learning
- 9:56and experiencing throughout my career.
- 9:58And so I just sort of force, you know, force functioned it.
- 10:02Force applied that lens to this thing that was Bitcoin and
- 10:06ultimately found that there's a lot of sort of foundational
- 10:10tenants of value investing that really apply to the Bitcoin
- 10:14thesis and and being able to understand Bitcoin.
- 10:19And we can we can go more into into that but just to sort of
- 10:22continue the story a bit you know sort of end of 2020 I guess
- 10:29early 21 or no end of 21, early 22.
- 10:35I kind of realized like you know, I wasn't I wasn't changing
- 10:39hearts and minds within Brown Brothers like it was.
- 10:41I would try to talk to my CIO and and you know chief
- 10:45investment, you know chief strategists and economists that
- 10:48that were there. Talk to them about Bitcoin and
- 10:50just, you know, pick their brain on it and see if they were even
- 10:53open to it. And it largely largely fell on
- 10:55deaf ears. And so I kind of realized at a
- 10:59certain point, like, in order to really embrace this thing and,
- 11:03you know, not only learn more about it, but just be serious
- 11:05about it and more so align what I was becoming very passionate
- 11:10about with sort of my occupational trajectory.
- 11:12Like I needed to eventually leave Brown Brothers and so.
- 11:16Actually before I left, it was interesting because there was,
- 11:20there was sort of this like working group like a digital
- 11:22asset working group at Brown Brothers.
- 11:24It wasn't actually within the private bank.
- 11:26It was with in another business line, our investor services
- 11:29business line, which actually got bought by State Street like
- 11:32a year or two years ago. But that that business line was
- 11:36more of like a global custody business.
- 11:38And within there, there was a working group that was just
- 11:41thinking about digital assets, but.
- 11:43And I and so I talked to them and and like, you know, tried to
- 11:46see if there was a fit there where I could help them better
- 11:48understand this thing. But they were so entrenched in
- 11:52blockchain, not Bitcoin at the time and like distributed Ledger
- 11:56technology and it was just kind of a nonstarter and and I I
- 11:59didn't want to be in the position of having to really
- 12:02convince these people that of something that I I thought to be
- 12:07true and and to be worthwhile. And they were kind of just, you
- 12:11know, going along this other path and so.
- 12:14Ultimately, I left and started figuring out how I could sort of
- 12:19jump head first into Bitcoin and sort of the broader digital
- 12:23asset space. And I had a buddy who was at
- 12:27Coinbase at the time and he honestly pinged me and was like
- 12:31this new position just got listed.
- 12:33Seems like it's kind of up your alley and so.
- 12:36I applied to it and and was hired as the first analyst to a
- 12:40dedicated research team within the institutional line of
- 12:43business at Coinbase. And to be honest like and I've
- 12:46told you this guy, you guys this before but like you know at the
- 12:49time I my my main conviction was was with Bitcoin.
- 12:54But you know at that point it was sort of me doing this on my
- 12:58personal time. Like I didn't feel necessarily
- 13:00like an expert on any of this, and so in some ways.
- 13:04Coinbase opportunity was interesting to me because it
- 13:08would force me to, you know, test my hypothesis, right, test
- 13:11my own thesis and and really challenge myself to look at the
- 13:15rest of the crypto space and you know, do actual diligence on it
- 13:20and and ensure that like, I'm not wrong about this stuff and
- 13:23that the rest of crypto, my my skepticism was was rooted in
- 13:27reality. And so in that sense it was a
- 13:31formative year. So, so I was there for about 12
- 13:34months. And it was a really interesting
- 13:37experience in many different respects, which I'm sure we'll
- 13:40get into. But the main one just being,
- 13:43again, codifying my own thesis around why Bitcoin is different.
- 13:49And I always sort of had this trajectory in the back of my own
- 13:53mind, like I ultimately want to be working on Bitcoin only.
- 13:57But you know, coming from eight years in Trid 5, didn't really
- 14:00know anything else. I'd only ever worked at one
- 14:02company like. Making that jump, it felt
- 14:06Coinbase honestly at the time felt like a safe bet because
- 14:09this was early 22. Luna Terra was collapsing, like
- 14:14entering a bear market. I was pretty confident that like
- 14:17Coinbase wouldn't go out of business within the next like 12
- 14:20months. And so in that respect, it was a
- 14:24good opportunity that I felt confident in and always sort of
- 14:27viewed it as like a stepping stone to to doing something in
- 14:30in Bitcoin only and then. Back in April of this year saw
- 14:34Michael and Jesse on your podcast Marty and heard about on
- 14:39RAMP. And it really sort of
- 14:42immediately resonated with me in terms of the approach and how
- 14:46you guys were going about it. Because throughout my time at
- 14:49Brown Brothers and at Coinbase, I saw the gap in the market like
- 14:54that white space of institutional capital.
- 14:57That's. Still on the sideline, maybe
- 14:59they're thinking about Bitcoin. They want to get exposure, but
- 15:02they're nervous for a variety of reasons, whether it's regulatory
- 15:05fears, custodial risks or just like a general lack of
- 15:10understanding. And so I thought the approach
- 15:14that Y'all were taking was spot on in that let's have a better
- 15:18custody set up. Let's continue to educate these
- 15:21people about this thing because it is complex and there is a lot
- 15:25of. Honestly, misinformation out
- 15:26there and misunderstanding generally.
- 15:30And so it just really struck me as something that that could be
- 15:32really, really powerful and so reached out to you guys and I
- 15:36guess the rest is history. And here we are.
- 15:38Here we are in Austin, TX, Michael Jill.
- 15:43I just, I think it's so interesting how Brian's story is
- 15:47is such a perfect little like microcosm of what's happening
- 15:51for lots of people in our generation in particular like.
- 15:56When you're working at A at a large private bank with 200
- 15:59years of history, you're not going to get far talking about
- 16:04digital assets yet with leadership.
- 16:10Well and OK. That's one thing I want to jump
- 16:13It's Brown brothers been around for 205 years, Like to make it
- 16:18this far, they had to be pretty conservative, like you said, but
- 16:21also innovative in a way to be able to adapt.
- 16:26And survive for two centuries. They I'm not going to try to
- 16:31talk about like. Well like you you survive by by
- 16:38not being the 1st through the door when any new trend arrives
- 16:42or something changes. But you know you you move when
- 16:46the when the middle of the bell curve is starting to move right
- 16:49like. For sure.
- 16:51That's a big part of it. That's a big part of it, Jesse.
- 16:53It's like. The career risk associated with
- 16:56diving into something like Bitcoin, it's just not worth it
- 16:59to those people, right? Like they'd rather see it.
- 17:02They'd rather see other people try it first and make sure that
- 17:05they're not gonna be coming out looking foolish.
- 17:08Yeah, the gravity of being the managing team that's holding the
- 17:13bag when that multi century institution goes down, it's not,
- 17:17yeah, it's pretty heavy I imagine.
- 17:18I think I think this is really where.
- 17:23A lot of the weight falls on on your shoulders and and and not
- 17:26just yours but there's a lot of the opportunity and it hasn't
- 17:29been figured out yet in the delivery for these firms and how
- 17:33do you package what's happening here in a way to meet them.
- 17:35And we think we're starting to do that and and that's where a
- 17:38lot of the things that we're doing are intentional including
- 17:40this podcast. But we've seen glimpses of this
- 17:44Parker's writing graduated and suddenly is an excellent.
- 17:48Example of a Ross Stevens, a Michael Saylor referencing it
- 17:52before they made large positions delivering it.
- 17:54I think Jesse's content there's a lot of versions of this but it
- 17:58hasn't fully been put together in the right way for the
- 18:02experience that Brian's had to say okay.
- 18:05Now we can like create the right playbook and the right way and
- 18:09and it's different mediums, right.
- 18:10It's like just when somebody gets Bitcoin, they don't.
- 18:12Ultimately, they all come from different angles and.
- 18:17So that's the the rub. It's like once it gets figured
- 18:19out then everybody's just going to like fall in but it hasn't
- 18:22been done yet and that's really like the opportunity the the,
- 18:25the, the back end stuff is interesting, right like better
- 18:28custody, better client services, all the things that that still
- 18:31need to be done. But those those are like the
- 18:32table stakes. It's the the real like
- 18:34opportunity almost Alpha is being able to figure out how do
- 18:37you actually deliver this value, prop this opportunity in a way
- 18:41that somebody says, Oh my God, like.
- 18:45There's something here and it doesn't have to be a big
- 18:46position. It's just enough to like start
- 18:48looking at it because we all know whether it's the single
- 18:50individual on cash up that buys a little bit or it's an
- 18:53institution with, you know, whatever small amount basis
- 18:56points. Then everybody starts paying
- 18:58attention, and that's when it begins.
- 19:00Yeah. And and I and I think that part
- 19:03you know big this is a common talking point for me, but I
- 19:06think a big part of that is that the having cadence where you
- 19:10know the having implements this increased scarcity.
- 19:15The price drifts upwards. It's A and it turns into a
- 19:19little mini or not so many bubble and then you know crashes
- 19:25and we have a higher low on the on the back end of that.
- 19:28But we've had three of those and it's pretty easy to wave away
- 19:33the early days. You know the 2012 having who who
- 19:37really knows who's starting from such a small point and it was
- 19:40just drug money on the Internet. So you know.
- 19:44Wave away that one and then there's and then you've got two
- 19:47data points of the having happening in the bull market
- 19:51following. So you can't really rely on that
- 19:55if you're, you know, if you're thinking from like a traditional
- 19:58investment point of view. But here comes another one.
- 20:02And if, if it happens again, how many people start to view that
- 20:06career risk of continuing to ignore it?
- 20:12Becoming, you know, competing with the career risk of of of
- 20:15taking the risk of entertaining it as as a serious investment
- 20:19class. And so you know, over time I I
- 20:23think that the, I think that the difficulty of understanding
- 20:28Bitcoin trends down because more people are doing it, more people
- 20:33are creating content explaining it.
- 20:35There's a longer track record, more Lindy, and there's more
- 20:39data points of what happens when having rolls through.
- 20:43And that downward trend of of the difficulty of understanding
- 20:47Bitcoin is what we're, you know what we're relying on.
- 20:54People will get it as it gets easier to get and we just need
- 21:00to be a part of communicating why it's happening.
- 21:03One thing to pull a little on that thread of the the having
- 21:07and and you know the marketability and all the things
- 21:09with price appreciation is there was a share with Marty there.
- 21:13I got an e-mail from Name Cheap for Domains about the raising
- 21:16prices, you know, close to 10%, it was 9% and it hit me that
- 21:22we've seen the having and there's, you know been this
- 21:24consistent inflation since bitcoins existed.
- 21:26But it hasn't been like the inflation topic hasn't been at
- 21:30the forefront. And so thinking about that just
- 21:32contrasts next year when the supply cuts in half
- 21:35programmatically while inflation runs and it will run, we see it
- 21:39even though people say 3%. It's just going to be
- 21:41magnificent to see just in real time that happened.
- 21:44Well it's funny because the last having April, May 2020 never was
- 21:49exactly, I forget, but that was right at the beginning of the
- 21:54massive monetary base expansion and diving up interest rates
- 21:58post COVID lockdowns. And so we have like 2 havings
- 22:01book ending like the the beginning and the end of of that
- 22:04saga. 6 trillion at that time 6 trillion printed and and the
- 22:08mainstream point of view at that time it it was May 2020 was that
- 22:14there wouldn't be any inflation from stimulus like that was
- 22:17still the firmly held belief of everyone except these crazy
- 22:21bitcoiners who were saying you can't just print a bunch of
- 22:24money and not expect inflation to creep through the system And
- 22:28then we weren't even yet at inflation is transitory at that
- 22:31point. That came a few months later.
- 22:34So, you know, I think Michael's right that the, in a way the
- 22:38Overton window of is inflation, a part of our landscape has
- 22:43shifted in this last four years and so now we're going into a
- 22:47new. Can we play the J Pal clip?
- 22:48Do we have it? Did you get put it?
- 22:51I can send it to. Logan, send it to Logan.
- 22:52But before we even get into that, like the J Pal clip.
- 22:57Ever referencing was I think it was represented from Nevada
- 23:00asked him why the Fed targets 2% inflation, Like why did they
- 23:04pick that number and his response was pretty funny.
- 23:08But beyond that, this week, Harvard economist Jason Furman
- 23:14wrote an oped in the Wall Street Journal saying that the Fed
- 23:18should target 3% that was picked up.
- 23:22On social media, most notably by Paul Krugman, A Blogger for the
- 23:28New York Times who likes to think of himself as an
- 23:30economist. And he said yes, we should be
- 23:32targeting 3% inflation. So again, going back to the
- 23:35Overton window shifting, it is even shifting at the academic
- 23:39economist level where they're saying that the Fed needs to
- 23:45target 3% inflation instead of 2% and just the arbitrary nature
- 23:50of picking. These inflation targets out of
- 23:53the hat is astonishing #1, but #2 the the impact and like
- 23:58that's a 50% increase of the inflation rate that you're going
- 24:03to target and that has material impacts and the speed at which
- 24:07the purchasing power of a dollar decays.
- 24:09I believe the half life of a dollar with 2% inflation, so
- 24:14like 30-4 years at 3% drops down to like 22.
- 24:18Yeah, 2223. And so I didn't know this fact
- 24:22that Zero Hedge tweeted about this this week of where does
- 24:25that 2% inflation target come from?
- 24:27Like this, this law. Yeah, it was 0 Hedge said New
- 24:33Zealand in the 1980s. It was just like a thing they
- 24:39tried and and that became, yeah, oh this, this little experiment
- 24:46from 1983 to 1988 suddenly becomes in New Zealand, suddenly
- 24:51becomes like the hard, hard and fast rule of economics,
- 24:57globally, indefinitely into the future.
- 25:00How the hell did that happen? And it just shows you how
- 25:02arbitrary it really is. Well, not only is it arbitrary
- 25:05in the context of the Federal Reserve, the Federal Reserve has
- 25:09two mandates, price stability and.
- 25:13Making sure that that unemployment is full employment
- 25:18and price stability a 2%. They're doing a magnificent job,
- 25:22by the way. What do you mean not just being
- 25:25physicians? 2% inflation target or 3% now
- 25:29inflation target. It's a literal double speak,
- 25:31like their mandate is price stability, and they attempt to
- 25:34create price stability by targeting A perpetual inflation
- 25:37rate of two, or now potentially 3%.
- 25:42Which over a 33 year period is extremely unstable.
- 25:46It literally decays the purchasing power by 50%.
- 25:50Yeah, and. And that's where all the charts
- 25:52from What the Fuck Happened in 1971 come from.
- 25:56For anyone who hasn't checked out that website, WTF happened
- 25:59in 1970? one.com.
- 26:01Just a collection of charts of like there's a a, a divergence
- 26:06that occurs in all of these economic indicators around 1971
- 26:10when we went off the gold standard and the the most
- 26:14painful one in in my book is the the productivity and
- 26:19compensation were lockstep up until 1971 and then productivity
- 26:24continues chugging on up and to the right and compensation
- 26:29really meaning for the working class flat lines there because
- 26:35that's when we started to see more inflation and the easiest
- 26:39thing to do is just kind of lag on keeping up with workers wages
- 26:44like to update workers wages in line with true inflation.
- 26:48Pretty easy to fudge the numbers or just kind of delay on that or
- 26:52obfuscate from the fact that workers salaries aren't aren't
- 26:56earning as much anymore and that right there, that little trend.
- 27:02The divergence of those two lines is I think the the heart
- 27:07of the decay of the American middle class since 1971.
- 27:11And you know, the rise of like the Hillbilly Elegy kind of
- 27:14suffering of the working class in America and the rise of
- 27:18populist politicians like like Trump is because of the pain
- 27:23that the perceived falling out of middle class status and into,
- 27:31you know, poverty that so many blue collar folks have suffered
- 27:41and families and communities have suffered over the last 50
- 27:43years. And it all comes back to that
- 27:45inflation driver. How?
- 27:47How did Browns Brothers like? I would imagine Inflation
- 27:51doesn't get talked about when it's an analysis.
- 27:53It's just benchmarks are completely different.
- 27:55Going to go there with it, like when I said, you know, I would
- 27:58talk to people about Bitcoin. You know, this is 3-4 years ago
- 28:04now and it fell on deaf ears. It was largely because they
- 28:08didn't think inflation was a problem and it was just like a
- 28:11complete blind spot and you know, historically had like no
- 28:16exposure to gold like they didn't.
- 28:18Because of that value investing framework, there's almost,
- 28:22there's almost this reluctance to even think about hard assets
- 28:26because there's no yield. There's no yield and there's no,
- 28:30like, advanced models and due diligence that you can rely on
- 28:35to say, oh, I've done the work, this thing is cheap, so it's
- 28:40inherently harder to value. And so, you know, what I found
- 28:45is like there was sort of this almost an air of sophistication
- 28:50around value investing that sort of like perpetuated the idea of
- 28:56it being a valuable thing. And and to be clear, like I do
- 29:01think there is merit to a lot of it, right?
- 29:25That's a fundamental core piece of of the value investing
- 29:29framework is that volatility is actually your friend.
- 29:03Like buying something for cheaper than it's worth should
- 29:06be an axiom of all investing, right?
- 29:11And and Jesse, going back to what you were saying about the
- 29:13cyclical nature of the thing, you know, one of one of the way,
- 29:18one of the first ways that I sort of tried to apply that lens
- 29:21to Bitcoin was saying volatility is not.
- 29:32Like you know, Buffett has a ton of quotes around that.
- 29:36It's an opportunity to get in cheaply right like you should.
- 29:39You should be comfortable with that volatility because if you
- 29:43have a real deep fundamental understanding of the thing and
- 29:46its trajectory and it and what you think, it will be valued in
- 29:49the future as the market comes to appreciate that value.
- 29:53Volatility is is just an opportunity, right?
- 29:55And it's not a risk And and the unfortunate thing about the
- 30:00cyclical nature in some ways is that people perceive that as
- 30:03risk and it's like it. It's just they're missing the
- 30:07point in that you know Bitcoin has its own risks, right?
- 30:10It's not necessarily risk free. You might think it is, but like
- 30:15there's perceived risks around it.
- 30:16But it's not that it's volatile like that is not the risk, but.
- 30:22That seems to be, you know, a big sticking point for people
- 30:25still which which is wild to me. But you know that was that was
- 30:29one of the first ways that I applied that lens in saying the
- 30:34near term volatility is just noise and this is just an
- 30:36opportunity to get a better entry.
- 30:39Yeah, I think an example of that's also the hurdle rate cuz
- 30:42Jesse and I were talking about. It's like, well, what is the
- 30:44true hurdle rate? And there's the numbers.
- 30:46On the sophisticated version or the hurdle, the true hurdle rate
- 30:50would be your cost or the the purchasing power of your money.
- 30:54And that's not how they measure it.
- 30:55They measure it from a nominal versus real.
- 30:59And so there it's a game that's being played that's just it's
- 31:02it's the wrong game. And that's I think part of why
- 31:06it's so hard because it's an ephemeral academic exercise
- 31:09versus I think Marty and I were talking about it last night.
- 31:11It's like at the end of the day, for us as individuals, you have
- 31:14to look at. Like a portfolio or how you
- 31:18would map to like you know whether whether it's real
- 31:21estate, equities in the bank, but we know what which has
- 31:24happened with Silicon Valley Bank and then we know that SF
- 31:27and these cities are starting, you know the liquidity of real
- 31:30estate, it's like so at the end of the day if you need to put
- 31:32food on the table and you need your money to work, well then
- 31:35where do you start to look And that is like at the micro level,
- 31:39but when you go back to the macro, it's so hard to get from
- 31:41there to the to that point. And I think that.
- 31:47The overarching point that we're getting into during that part of
- 31:49the discussion last night was in building on your comments about
- 31:53volatility. Yes, the volatility is there.
- 31:55It's not a risk. I can stomach the volatility
- 31:57because I know the liquidity profile, if I'm holding Bitcoin
- 32:00a certain way, is better than anything on the planet outside
- 32:05of like cash in your pocket, maybe even better like I can.
- 32:08It's definitely better send Bitcoin whenever I want anywhere
- 32:12around the world. I need to liquidate on an
- 32:14exchange. They trade 24/7, 365 like that.
- 32:19Volatility is easy to stomach when you know that that
- 32:23liquidity profiles there. And then if you're holding it in
- 32:25self custody like that, counterparty risk is eliminated.
- 32:28You have your money, you can go buy groceries if you need to.
- 32:30You're holding real estate, very illiquid stocks, even not as
- 32:38liquid. Yeah, that.
- 32:40That's my my recent piece was to try to explore the opportunity
- 32:48cost of capital between different asset classes and
- 32:52right now U.S. Treasuries are yielding 4.3% a
- 32:57year, which is just in terms of recent history high.
- 33:03And you know, then then equities over the last 30 years deliver
- 33:078% on average, your average compounding annual growth rate,
- 33:14your kegger and private equity 15% and venture capital 25%.
- 33:24And whereas Bitcoin over last halving era has returned 45%
- 33:30annually on average. And there's been a diminishing
- 33:34over time of of the annual growth rate.
- 33:37But looking forward, you know what, what will it be?
- 33:41I think it's reasonable to conclude that because of the in
- 33:45the playing out of of the having mechanics and following the same
- 33:50diminishing returns over time, a phenomenon something like 25%,
- 33:57which would mean that Bitcoin with the liquidity
- 34:02characteristics of U.S. Treasuries, OK, you can buy it
- 34:05and sell it immediately. You can, there's no lock up time
- 34:10period that you have to hold it whereas with private equity
- 34:13funds or venture capital funds you are locking up your capital
- 34:16for 10 years. So with Bitcoin you get US
- 34:21Treasury's liquidity and and you know time periods but you get
- 34:30venture capital returns going forward.
- 34:33So that becomes the an important part of that is assessing that
- 34:39it's actually low risk because the volatility is is
- 34:44misdiagnosed as risk, but it's not risk it, it's just
- 34:48volatility. So you have a low risk asset
- 34:51with great liquidity that delivers venture capital returns
- 34:57and so then that becomes the the opportunity cost for any
- 35:00incremental dollar for you know where where should you park your
- 35:05dollars. You want to park it in the place
- 35:06that has the best opportunity and lowest risk and Bitcoin
- 35:14seems to have the lowest risk you know or or at least matches
- 35:17in my opinion is better than U.S.
- 35:20Treasuries and yet delivers the highest risk asset classes
- 35:26returns. Looking forward, there are
- 35:28assumptions there, but that's the place to hold capital then,
- 35:33and I, and you know then the the entire world of value has to
- 35:37learn this lesson that the four of us have stumbled into
- 35:41earlier. And everyone listening to this
- 35:43podcast just happened to stumble into this, this stupid simple
- 35:49north star of investing in modern era, which is Bitcoin
- 35:53should be the default. I was going to say like, I think
- 35:57it's a really interesting conversation to be diving into.
- 36:00Right now because like value investing is like really hard
- 36:02these days. Like feds monetary policy really
- 36:05dictates the perceived value of any given company on the market,
- 36:10any given point in time, particularly the public markets.
- 36:13And I think important point to add to this conversation is like
- 36:18through Bitcoin and eventually if Bitcoin does become the
- 36:21reserve currency of the world, like actually be able to get
- 36:24back to value investing the correct way, which is you have a
- 36:29monetary system. That operates on a sound
- 36:32monetary policy and then you actually bring opportunity cost
- 36:35back to the market, a true cost of capital back to the market.
- 36:39And they can actually do good due diligence as a value
- 36:45investor, actually make good decisions about what's actually
- 36:49producing sats flows and what is actually producing value and not
- 36:52just just something that's manipulated by Fed policy.
- 36:54So two things. That was something that I was I
- 36:58don't know who I was talking about it with but it's like what
- 37:01is the cost of capital like what is the true cost of capital and
- 37:04I don't know if we if we know it's like yeah but even on bit
- 37:08with Bitcoin it's like like what is your Bitcoin worth today to
- 37:12give up for tomorrow whether it's the equity in a in a in a
- 37:16firm or you know risk adjusted if what the Bitcoin would be in
- 37:20the future. And then what ultimately, if
- 37:22we're on a Bitcoin standard, what is the interest rate that
- 37:25would need to be returned if you were going to give up your
- 37:27Bitcoin to invest in something? So it's just an interesting
- 37:31thought experiment that we'll see play out, but going back to
- 37:34what Jesse was saying about. The benchmark with venture that
- 37:39is caveat in in the upper quartile which almost nobody
- 37:42gets access to just no just to get but so that's just this.
- 37:46So it's a lot more like a 10X more pronounced and like that
- 37:49delta of that most people are losing all their money if they
- 37:52go into to venture there's like 2 to 3%.
- 37:54And the equity returns to like yeah, 8%, but what is that in
- 37:57real terms? That exactly was thinking about
- 37:59it in real terms and and Marty just going touching on the point
- 38:03you just made around. How value investing is so hard
- 38:06now you've seen that reflected in, you know, the past two
- 38:10decades of really underperformance generally
- 38:13speaking from sort of value strict value strategies compared
- 38:17to like growth strategies where you're really just chasing
- 38:20revenue and chasing growth and that is a function of that low
- 38:25cost of capital, right? And so you've seen this
- 38:28divergence over the past 20 years where these value
- 38:31strategies have largely underperformed.
- 38:34And then at the same time because of that dynamic you've
- 38:36seen massive concentration in the actual indices of you know
- 38:42we've seen the charts of like the top six to seven companies
- 38:45accounting for the vast majority of the performance of the index.
- 38:49And so that's you know also indicative of the general sort
- 38:52of shift from active investing to passive investing and and
- 38:58really like it, it's it's. Getting to your point much
- 39:01harder to actually execute a value oriented strategy where
- 39:07you're going to outperform the S&P like it's it's
- 39:10extraordinarily difficult. If you're being sort of strict
- 39:13about margin of of safety and like and how you're you know the
- 39:18price at which you're entering certain security, it just
- 39:22becomes very, very difficult and and you know when I was at Brown
- 39:26Brothers like you know sitting on the allocator side.
- 39:29I mean, we had a few, we had a few sort of challenges in that.
- 39:33One was like sort of logistically like we were
- 39:36allocating from a 50 to $60 billion base of capital.
- 39:42And so if we wanted to go out to a manager and and make a 1%
- 39:45position, you're talking about 1/2 a billion dollars.
- 39:47And so really talented managers with like outstanding track
- 39:51records don't have half a billion of capacity to give you.
- 39:54So we were in this interesting situation where we were trying
- 39:56to thread this needle of. Really talented smart people
- 40:01have a great track record, but also can you know take a billion
- 40:04dollars from us because you know ideally we, I mean we were
- 40:07making allocations the, the entire aggregate portfolio was
- 40:10actually relatively concentrated in the sense that there weren't
- 40:13a ton of managers, right. Like if you go to like a Goldman
- 40:15Sachs or one of these other sort of more commercial private
- 40:18banks, they give you a roster of 300 to 400 funds to pick from.
- 40:23And like I mentioned, like our model is much more discretionary
- 40:25where we were actually. Creating policy portfolios with
- 40:29a concentrated roster of managers and you know we had
- 40:32sort of four different portfolios and it sort of varied
- 40:34by client risk appetite and you know on sort of the stable value
- 40:38side it was much, much higher percent to bonds and then sort
- 40:42of on the gross side obviously a higher allocation to equities.
- 40:45But it became very difficult to find managers that we were
- 40:51comfortable with and fit our mandate strategically and
- 40:54philosophically. But we're also able to to take
- 40:57our money basically because those people who are really good
- 41:01and have a 10 year track record like their fund is full and
- 41:04they're not going to take your money.
- 41:05And so I mean a lot of our best investments were actually
- 41:08finding like investors who had a track record somewhere else and
- 41:12then spun out and started their own thing and then we could
- 41:14become like an anchor investor and get a lot of capacity.
- 41:19But it's interesting because you know, one thing that I noticed
- 41:23while I was there is that if you've heard sort of the phrase
- 41:26like style drift and investing, like generally seen as a bad
- 41:29thing, right. And I think Gary from last week
- 41:32was talking about this a bit in terms of like you know, there's
- 41:35sort of this perception that as an investor, as a portfolio
- 41:39manager, like you need to have your strategy, your process,
- 41:41your philosophy and it needs to be repeatable.
- 41:43And if you're drifting from that, it's a bad thing.
- 41:48And so like when we were you know, we would on board a fund
- 41:51and we would have sort of quarterly calls with them and do
- 41:53annual reviews of the fund. And one of the things that we
- 41:55were assessing was, is there any style drift here?
- 41:58Are they changing their strategy at all?
- 42:00Is there anything we should be concerned about?
- 42:02Are they doing things that they previously said they would never
- 42:04do? And interestingly over time, not
- 42:11only did we see it at the manager level, but we actually
- 42:13saw it at our level like our investment team level because
- 42:18value was underperforming for a decade and we had a we had a
- 42:20bias towards these value strategies.
- 42:23And so you know there were years where we were underperforming
- 42:25the market and we started to sort of in some ways chase
- 42:30growthier strategies. And so you did see that style
- 42:33drift even from our point of view.
- 42:35But I guess what I come back to is what Gary said last week in
- 42:38that I don't think that's a bad thing.
- 42:40Like you should be able to adapt and be and be flexible and and
- 42:43understand new things and be willing to change your mind
- 42:46about stuff. And so I think in a weird way,
- 42:50like style drift over the long term, it's kind of like a good
- 42:53thing for Bitcoin because ultimately people will wake up
- 42:56to this thing and they'll they'll be more open minded
- 42:58about it. Yeah, that's a very good point.
- 43:00Hey, you have to be adaptable and flexible as time changes,
- 43:05policy changes like that makes a lot of sense.
- 43:09I want to apologize to anybody watching.
- 43:12The video Right now we've got former MLB All Star CJ Wilson
- 43:16doing some calisthenics right behind us in that video.
- 43:18Sorry if that's that's distracting for you now, but
- 43:23it's it's hard out there like like and I I listen to and
- 43:27invest like the best Podcast. Patrick O'Shaughnessy
- 43:33interviewed David Einhorn, who's infamous.
- 43:37Yep. Value investor of the last 30
- 43:40years and he essentially admitted on that puck because
- 43:42he's like, I think value investing is dead at the moment.
- 43:44Like it's literally impossible to allocate as a value investor.
- 43:48And that's that's a symptom of the money dying.
- 43:52Like when when the measuring stick starts to make less sense
- 43:58as a, as a as a place to store your value, your savings, you
- 44:02shift your strategy to what makes sense and.
- 44:06I mean over the last 20 years what's emerged is pilot into
- 44:09your 4O1K and so this, this, this automatic bid every two
- 44:14weeks in America of equities being bid up and and really your
- 44:21core equities and and that's sort of starting to trend
- 44:24towards Fang stocks like that becomes money that's that's
- 44:28monetization of tech stocks over the last 1020 years and and then
- 44:34you start to see these silly price.
- 44:36PE ratios a price to earnings, ratios of which are outside of
- 44:42what is you know, value. Investing is designed around
- 44:46finding PE ratios that are are low.
- 44:51What's What's the video's P/E ratio after this week?
- 44:54And they have like another 25%. Good question.
- 44:57I I don't even know there there's there's always there's
- 45:00like few outliers that are silly right?
- 45:02Like. Vivian or or you know other EV
- 45:07companies in particular, there's this mimetic investing that has
- 45:13been a part of crypto investing and and is very much a part of
- 45:18the stock market now. Which is silly, but it like that
- 45:22is crowded out value investing over time.
- 45:24Like Preston Pitch talks about, he's come to this conclusion too
- 45:28of. The the thing that he's planning
- 45:30on doing is just holding Bitcoin until it appreciates enough that
- 45:37and restore sanity to markets such that value investing
- 45:42opportunities reemerge and and that's his that's going to be
- 45:46his strategy for the next decade or two and yeah I I so I think
- 45:51that everybody is chasing a way to store their money safely.
- 45:58In the stock market and and that is where the mainstream
- 46:01continues to be. And yet, if you think through
- 46:04this logic and get to this conclusion that Bitcoin is
- 46:07delivering venture capital returns for US Treasury's risk,
- 46:11that's the place to be. Yeah, Jesse, I wanna, I wanna
- 46:14see your live reaction to this chart we're about to pull out.
- 46:18And everybody's reaction, It's pretty, pretty insane.
- 46:22Nvidia's price earnings ratio. It's the third chart.
- 46:30I I don't even know what like, oh boy, it's two. 45.5.
- 46:38So I I remember a decade ago people talking about like, you
- 46:41know, price to earnings ratios of 30 are are just silly high,
- 46:45right? And now we've entered this, this
- 46:48this absolute nonsense world 200 and and one of the one of the
- 46:53knock on effects of this you know broader sort of
- 46:56consolidation of of indices and sort of chasing growth and and
- 47:01mega mega cap tech is that it really hinders sort of the
- 47:07entire presentation and and perception of value investing in
- 47:10the sense that you can't justify the fees.
- 47:14Like if if the best portfolio to own over the past two decades
- 47:18was like Google, Amazon, Apple maybe a few others no one's, no
- 47:23one should be paying you fees to do that right.
- 47:25Like you either just own the S&P or you own those five companies
- 47:27and it's pretty easy to do. And so all of these active
- 47:32investors are now in the position of having to justify a
- 47:352% management fee and and probably even a a performance
- 47:38fee of some kind and that's just become really, really hard to
- 47:43deal in this context. You need.
- 47:45So this is a good transition to talk about.
- 47:49I think there's two parts what we're describing in.
- 47:52Traditional investors and and what a portfolio and
- 47:56diversification and how that fits into crypto and where
- 48:01individuals have come in And then what you saw at Coinbase,
- 48:06but then also some of the conversations we've been having
- 48:08of like, so wait, will you know what's the strategy?
- 48:11Right. And yeah, no, I mean Coinbase
- 48:14was interesting for a number of reasons.
- 48:18I mean in terms of just the mindset, it was, it was such a
- 48:22stark difference from being at Brown Brothers for eight years.
- 48:25And I say that because, you know, part of that value
- 48:29investing philosophy, part of what I had honed my own
- 48:32investment philosophy on was a very longterm approach, like a
- 48:36longterm investment horizon And everything at Coinbase and in in
- 48:41sort of the crypto world, generally speaking is extremely
- 48:44shortterm in nature, right? Like you're thinking about
- 48:47things more so as a trader and really I mean ultimately the
- 48:52entire business model of Coinbase was inherently tied to
- 48:56that short termism and and and pushing people out the risk
- 48:59curve and getting them to trade all these other tokens.
- 49:02When in reality like I wanted to be telling institutional clients
- 49:05like you guys should just buy a Bitcoin but that was not that
- 49:10was not aligned with the business model of Coinbase as
- 49:12you might imagine. So that was, that was certainly
- 49:16frustrating in a certain sense, but it was kind of just
- 49:19interesting to see that stark difference of short termism move
- 49:25out the risk curve, trade all these tokens and at the same
- 49:29time being there, I really saw sort of under the hood of a lot
- 49:35of just inherent conflicts of interest at the business.
- 49:38Where like you know, at the same time where you know Coinbase is
- 49:43like a launch partner for token XYZ, launch partner for X
- 49:47protocol and like being early liquidity to it.
- 49:51The same time, like I'm being prompted to like maybe write
- 49:54about these things and it's like well, no, like I should just be
- 49:57coming at this from a first principles point of view and and
- 50:00writing about what I think is interesting.
- 50:01And I tried to do that as much as I could.
- 50:03But ultimately there was some amount of like party line,
- 50:07right. And so you know throughout that
- 50:11year I forced myself to write about like Tesos and fucking
- 50:14like Matic and some of these other coins.
- 50:17And and frankly I couldn't really write what I actually
- 50:21thought which was frustrating and and tiring in some sense.
- 50:25You know towards the end. Towards the end of my stint
- 50:27there, I did write a report about File Coin, which I thought
- 50:30was was pretty good in the sense that like it was probably the
- 50:33most like, polite takedown of an alt coin that you could you
- 50:36could write like it was just enough along party lines.
- 50:40But I was really just calling out the entire incentive models
- 50:42and just really calling it out for what it was.
- 50:45And and yeah, I think there were some people that didn't like
- 50:49that report, but it got published because it was all
- 50:52factual. It might be down the street, the
- 50:53file Queen offices somewhere in the city.
- 50:57I mean I do you think it's and as you I think recognize it is
- 51:00an important journey though because it's one like to
- 51:04internally recognize it but then it there it had so much
- 51:06credibility when you go back to the market.
- 51:08And it's like been on the other side of that.
- 51:10And I had a cent. I was at the block for, you
- 51:12know, six months. I was like, holy crap, what am I
- 51:13doing here? You know, just like.
- 51:15I was in Barstool trying to get everybody to stop trading ass
- 51:18coin and everything. Yeah.
- 51:22And it's it's also formative in the in the experience or getting
- 51:25to the place because it just requires to hone the thesis, the
- 51:29understanding to see and then also just go back.
- 51:33To the market and explain that you said in that those shoes,
- 51:35you experience it, you understand the angle of the
- 51:38incentive model. So when they come in and it's
- 51:40well, we gotta diversify or we gotta be more open minded just
- 51:42like, no, we actually don't. Let me explain why.
- 51:44Yeah. And that goes back to the value
- 51:46investing thing is like, you don't need diversification.
- 51:49Like, if you know the winners and you're confident in the
- 51:52trajectory of whatever you're looking at, you should size
- 51:57accordingly. And you should.
- 51:58You should mostly own that one thing.
- 52:00What's the quote of a diversification?
- 52:01Is selling your winners to buy losers?
- 52:03Yeah, something says that along those lines.
- 52:06I think Sailors said the I think it's a sailing.
- 52:08I mean, it's probably a a try, Yeah.
- 52:11I think it appreciates Sailor. Yeah.
- 52:14And and I think Buffett likes to say that concentration is how
- 52:19you get rich and diversification is how you stay rich, something
- 52:24like that. Which is to say like that's how
- 52:28you flatline your wealth relative to the rest of the
- 52:31world and and maintain that in in the equities model in
- 52:35particular. But if you're trying to
- 52:37outperform, you have to concentrate.
- 52:40Yeah, that's true. I mean even just thinking about
- 52:44the the funds that we had our on our platform at Brown Brothers,
- 52:48the best performing funds were the most concentrated funds like
- 52:51long only equities like six to seven stocks in the portfolio
- 52:55and those were the best performers for the entire time
- 52:57that it was there. So that that really resonated
- 53:00with me too. And and I applied that lens to
- 53:02like, yeah, just think, just be focused on this one thing.
- 53:06And you've got that, you've got Portnoy figuring out that the
- 53:09take away from that after not too long in the stock market if
- 53:12stocks only go up you. Have the green hammer it was.
- 53:19His latest, his latest comments on Bitcoin are interesting of
- 53:23the he. He plans to, I guess.
- 53:26It was with Jack Mallers on that podcast.
- 53:29He plans to put Bitcoin on the balance sheet when he when he
- 53:32gets the opportunity, which is the latest chapter in his long
- 53:36journey. Isn't it, Marty?
- 53:38It is Dave. I sent you a text earlier this
- 53:40week. If you're listening to this, you
- 53:42should respond I. Think he's probably generally
- 53:45waking up. It's just a process of the
- 53:46amount of dollars. I I think what just happened to
- 53:49Barstool is sort of a product of what we're seeing in the markets
- 53:53right now with interest rates where they are.
- 53:54Obviously Pence stock was suffering.
- 53:58They had this opportunity to make a move with ESPN bets they
- 54:01had to take it. Part of that was getting rid of
- 54:04Barstool, which was essentially a marketing arm for pen Gaming,
- 54:07which is a loss leader, and they were spending millions of
- 54:11dollars via Barstool and not really making up for it.
- 54:16With sports book with the stock price obviously.
- 54:19And so I think yes, Dave got the company back, he's got 100%,
- 54:23it's incredible. But I do think there is an
- 54:27aspect of the current marketing conditions that really drove
- 54:29that decision for Penn. Yeah, yeah he's he's had that he
- 54:36got into. I mean everybody has their own
- 54:38journey. We're we're we're hearing about
- 54:40Brian's journey and Dave Portnoy has his own very separate
- 54:44journey. And all of these journeys end up
- 54:47converging on Bitcoin ultimately because in some way, whether you
- 54:51research it and you learn about how some of these altcoins are,
- 54:55incentives are screwed up. And there's really they're built
- 54:58on a foundation of sand. You can research your way into
- 55:02knowing that, or you can get burned by touching the stove.
- 55:05And Dave Portnoy went into Bitcoin.
- 55:09Then he quickly went moved on to chain Link and other things.
- 55:13And got burned. And so a year ago, his
- 55:20conclusion was maybe Bitcoin's the only thing worth touching
- 55:23the screw cane link. That was a year ago.
- 55:26Sailor Moon or Sailor Moon? Sailor Moon was the anime
- 55:30cartoon on Cartoon Network, but Dave's got some work to do.
- 55:35I listen to a couple clips from that Money Matters episode that
- 55:40Mowers and Dylan did with him. He's still.
- 55:43Is not fully. They're not there.
- 55:44Yeah, everybody gets there though.
- 55:46You know you you either take a an approach like Brian or you
- 55:50take an approach like Dave out, you know which is the more
- 55:54expensive approach and everybody figures out that there's only
- 55:58one thing that doesn't screw you over over A4 plus year time
- 56:01period. I mean, we were laughing about
- 56:03this last night at dinner. Sorry, Jesse, that you couldn't
- 56:06be there. You were missed.
- 56:07But again, we were I. Got plenty of sleep instead last
- 56:10night? Not a bad trade off.
- 56:14Parker and I have gone back and forth for years because when we
- 56:18go pitch Bitcoin, if we find ourselves pitching Bitcoin
- 56:21together with somebody, he is the king of 21,000,000 monetary
- 56:26policy. Like we're going to this is the
- 56:28shelling point. Everybody's going to pull less
- 56:31about around this, which, yes, this is exactly what you should
- 56:33do. But I lean into the network side
- 56:35of things like yes, we do have this I think.
- 56:39You lean into both, obviously. It's 21,000,000 cap supply
- 56:42extremely scarce, most scarce thing we've ever come in contact
- 56:44with. You cannot change that monetary
- 56:46policy. It's distributed consensus set
- 56:49of full nodes and then the network side really enables
- 56:53these things that were literally impossible before Bitcoin
- 56:56launched. So the point I'm trying to make
- 56:57is I actually think that's what's going to get Dave's head
- 57:02the the light bulb to go off in his head with Bitcoin.
- 57:04Is the network side like seeing? How you can monetize content and
- 57:08stuff like that, cuz that's what he focuses on in content, like
- 57:10how it can make his business better.
- 57:12That's what I think. And honestly?
- 57:14Like I thought you were gonna go and explain how you think that
- 57:17decentralization is more important than 21,000,000
- 57:20decentralization of nodes. I don't think I've ever said
- 57:22that. I thought that was the stick of
- 57:24like Parker's, that 21,000,000 matters and that and that.
- 57:27You're no, no, no. That's sufficiently dissent.
- 57:30You're mischaracterizing our our kerfuffles.
- 57:34It's no it's like he's like don't even bring up the network.
- 57:36It's not worth it. Just focus on 21,000,000.
- 57:38I do think it is worth it to bring up the network that it can
- 57:41do things that. We're literally impossible
- 57:43before 2009. If we're going down this memory
- 57:45lane of last night, it it's just to send people.
- 57:49If you've never heard, I've obviously heard of TF TC, but
- 57:53going back we were sitting at a table with like maybe six
- 57:55people, 7 people, and we brought up the montage from the first
- 57:59episodes. I don't even know if, Jesse, if
- 58:00you if you listen to this, it is.
- 58:02I'm not sure if I have. You just go back in your podcast
- 58:05player and go to the first three episode is the most I I gotta
- 58:08really listen to it cuz we start playing it.
- 58:10It's Marty like essentially manic, like explaining Bitcoin
- 58:14up into the point that he launches the pod and it's
- 58:17talking about white paper dropping like Halloween. 2010,
- 58:22like pizzas. Pizza day.
- 58:23And like, it's with Lou from Barstool and he's just screaming
- 58:27like, who fucking sells for pizza?
- 58:29I'd kill myself. It's $80 billion.
- 58:31Yeah, just like it's it's incredible.
- 58:35I was, I was. So I literally.
- 58:37It's so funny. It was six years ago now at this
- 58:40point. I literally scripted that
- 58:43podcast. Like, I wrote it on many pieces
- 58:45of paper and read it until my that's how little I knew about
- 58:48podcasting at that. Like, Lou thought I was crazy.
- 58:51I was like in the Barstool offices, people walking by,
- 58:53like, what the hell is this kid doing over there?
- 58:55Yeah, it's amazing. Yeah, it's a good.
- 58:58I gotta go really listen to it because, I mean, I haven't
- 59:00heard. It when you started playing last
- 59:02night was the first time I've heard that episode, and I've got
- 59:05a few years and it is. I mean, it is nostalgic and it
- 59:10is fond to look back on, but it is also like Fringe for
- 59:12everything. Like God and every couple years.
- 59:14It's so nervous. Every couple years, people are
- 59:15like, when's the next montage? I started writing.
- 59:19The next montage. Is that 100K once we get to
- 59:21100K, so it could could take us five years.
- 59:25It's gonna be a long montage if that's the case.
- 59:29Conference day. The content, I mean maybe on
- 59:32that is the the content. It, I mean, you know this more
- 59:37than anybody how important the content is.
- 59:40I think about my experience in that at the time, listening to
- 59:43that and thinking, you know, the prices like just crashed.
- 59:47You're sitting there 1718, it's 18 and you can't talk to this,
- 59:52to anybody about this stuff because there's too many to talk
- 59:55to you everybody's either gone or you're an idiot.
- 59:58You don't even know if you're You're in the whole you're in
- 1:00:00the red. And you're still buying, but
- 1:00:04then like you listen to the pod and then you listen the week,
- 1:00:06you know, week over week with like you, man and all the stuff.
- 1:00:09And it's just like this reinforcing, helping like
- 1:00:11there's other people out there that are doing it and then that
- 1:00:15understand it. You're not crazy.
- 1:00:16But then I think about, you know, the experience.
- 1:00:18You talk about what's the secret or the trying to put together
- 1:00:21the package to go talk to these investors.
- 1:00:23And I'm insanely excited about, like, what Brian's background in
- 1:00:27the stuff he's already been doing or whether it's like
- 1:00:30formally on the blog or the the tweet threads on Sundays that
- 1:00:35are pulling these disparate pieces that we talk about.
- 1:00:37There's like this alpha when you come and you pull it two sides
- 1:00:40of the spectrum and when it meets in the middle is like when
- 1:00:43real like magic happens. And so I don't know if you want
- 1:00:46to talk about any of the Sunday things, but also just like some
- 1:00:49of the ideas to the extent you feel comfortable and then the
- 1:00:51others you want to just throw when you launch.
- 1:00:53Generally, generally speaking, like my point of view on it is.
- 1:00:59You know, we talked about this before like meeting people where
- 1:01:01they are. I think that's part of it.
- 1:01:02But it's also just recognizing the fact that people understand
- 1:01:06things in different ways and and different things are going to
- 1:01:09resonate for different people in different ways.
- 1:01:11And so you need to just have sort of a toolkit of all
- 1:01:15different ways of approaching this thing and and so one thing
- 1:01:18that we've been working on the past few weeks is like framing
- 1:01:22the perception of like and and you guys have talked about this
- 1:01:25on the pod before, but like. How do I bucket it and it's like
- 1:01:28okay you could think about it like that and let's let's run
- 1:01:32through some possible ways that you could bucket it in your
- 1:01:36traditional asset portfolio. Whether you want to take sort of
- 1:01:40a private equity venture capital lens to it and say you know this
- 1:01:44is early stage growth tech with you know similar sort of risk
- 1:01:50reward dynamics. Another similarity, there is
- 1:01:54again that long term horizon. Jesse mentioned the lockups with
- 1:01:57you know VC and and private equity similar in that sense
- 1:02:01like you need to be thinking about this thing long term.
- 1:02:03So that's sort of one way you could bucket it.
- 1:02:05Another one is just sort of most squarely as a commodity, right,
- 1:02:12like this is a real asset, this is a digital commodity and and
- 1:02:15some people get that. But back to what I said earlier,
- 1:02:17it's like some people just don't care about commodities because
- 1:02:20they've been living in a world where they think 2% of inflation
- 1:02:22is okay and it's not a problem and.
- 1:02:25So they haven't ever thought about hard assets, but that is
- 1:02:28another way to bucket it is you know digital commodity, it's
- 1:02:31digital gold. And 3rd way is what Michael
- 1:02:33Saylor did which is this is cash, this is a cash equivalent.
- 1:02:36It's just a better version and I'm gonna put it on my balance
- 1:02:38sheet and just and hold it instead of holding cash.
- 1:02:42And so those are sort of like some different frameworks that
- 1:02:44you could think through around trying to meet people where they
- 1:02:47are in terms of how they think about asset classes and the
- 1:02:50buckets. But ultimately, it's going to be
- 1:02:53different for everyone. In my mind, like I think people
- 1:02:55have their own experiences and their own history looking at
- 1:02:59different things and that influences how they're going to
- 1:03:03grasp this thing because it is so multidisciplinary that there
- 1:03:07are a number of ways that you could come at it.
- 1:03:09And Marty, I like what you said about let's focus on the network
- 1:03:12too because there is so much sort of.
- 1:03:17Outside of price and number go up, there's ways where this
- 1:03:21network, the monetary rails is impacting society.
- 1:03:24And one of my favorite things to tell the normies are just people
- 1:03:27that are on the outside looking in.
- 1:03:29A Bitcoin is like, for the first time in human history, we can
- 1:03:31monetize stranded energy through Bitcoin mining and that
- 1:03:34typically kind of like makes people step back cuz nobody
- 1:03:38really realizes that. And it's things like that that's
- 1:03:41like. You don't have to care about the
- 1:03:42price. Like just I'm telling you that
- 1:03:44this is a technology that is doing something that's never
- 1:03:46been done before. Yeah, yeah, I was our friend
- 1:03:50Griffin Habees in in Austin this weekend.
- 1:03:53He is the king of the. I mean that exact quote is what
- 1:03:56he says. Like he's an oilman, Landman,
- 1:04:00wildcatter, wildcatter, whole 7th generation Texan.
- 1:04:03We will have to get him on the last trade.
- 1:04:05I don't know if Jesse, if we we've spoken of him before, but
- 1:04:09he's a. Might be too much stash for
- 1:04:11Jesse, I don't know he's seen. His photo.
- 1:04:14It is glorious. Yeah, we'll definitely, we'll do
- 1:04:17it when Jesse's in Austin. So we'll have this whole group
- 1:04:19just, you know, all in person. But, and he was Texas last
- 1:04:23night, but that just made me think of like it.
- 1:04:24That was his light bulb, he explained.
- 1:04:26He's like, I realized that there was no such thing as stranded
- 1:04:29energy ever again and he couldn't and it could never look
- 1:04:32back. Yeah.
- 1:04:34Yeah, it's, I mean, being. Up close and personal with that
- 1:04:37particular aspect of a Bitcoin and Bitcoin mining with Great
- 1:04:41American Mining, Cathedral and Standard Bitcoin, it is truly
- 1:04:46astonishing. Like particularly the flare gas
- 1:04:48stuff like being in the middle of nowhere, North Dakota, middle
- 1:04:52of winter. But you just have these
- 1:04:55generators, these shipping containers with these computers
- 1:04:58in it and you're literally able to monetize this natural gas
- 1:05:03that otherwise would have been set on fire in the middle.
- 1:05:05Of the North Dakotan wilderness, it's like literally you monetize
- 1:05:10it, you bring the market to the molecule, monetize it there and
- 1:05:14then it's digital gold. You can send it to China from
- 1:05:18North Dakota if you want to immediately after mining it.
- 1:05:20It's pretty crazy, yeah. And the utilities, important to
- 1:05:23everybody's point that's made is because at the micro level and
- 1:05:26you key in on this like in real time, it's like if you at a
- 1:05:29previous episode, it's if it's valuable and it increases in
- 1:05:34value, then people will want it. And so you'll need to be able to
- 1:05:36have it to spend i.e. You don't want it stuck in a in
- 1:05:40a fund that you can't actually take it out of.
- 1:05:42Similarly to an institution that if there's utility in this and
- 1:05:47it gets a cash equivalent or there's some other financial
- 1:05:49products that will be delivered around having the ability to get
- 1:05:53the asset in some other form. You don't want it stuck in a
- 1:05:57fund because you can't do any of that.
- 1:05:59Like we we don't even know the different ways that credit
- 1:06:01markets will expand. And I mean, we have ideas and we
- 1:06:03know that been involved with them.
- 1:06:07The Unchained Loan products, an example, there's battery
- 1:06:09finance, it's doing stuff like that.
- 1:06:11But ultimately, it's just ties back to the utility of like
- 1:06:14explaining to them it's just not like something you just park
- 1:06:16your money and you know it's it's you're going to want to
- 1:06:19understand that you at least want optionality to take
- 1:06:22possession of the Bitcoin. Yeah.
- 1:06:26And I think the most people, when they come in, they're not
- 1:06:28going to recognize that. And then we know they're going
- 1:06:29to go to BlackRock, and then they're gonna wake up one day
- 1:06:31and they realize, oh, maybe I need this for whatever reason.
- 1:06:34And now they're gonna have a cap, gains it or whatever.
- 1:06:36Yeah, well, I think like setting the cap gains and the overburden
- 1:06:41some tax regime here in the United States and other places
- 1:06:44of the world aside, I do think there are tangible examples like
- 1:06:48this show for example, if you anybody listening out there on a
- 1:06:51podcast app actually wants to it hasn't done this yet.
- 1:06:54Maybe have exposure via GB, TC, or some other fun that it
- 1:06:58doesn't actually give you. Spot Bitcoin that you know, hold
- 1:07:02a UTXO yourself. You can actually use this
- 1:07:04podcast via podcasting 2.0 apps like Fountain Breeze, Podverse.
- 1:07:09Just download these apps, listen to the podcast that way, and
- 1:07:12they double as Bitcoin wallets. You load it up with some Bitcoin
- 1:07:15as you listen. You can send a little bit of
- 1:07:18Bitcoin to each of our wallets, which is pretty crazy.
- 1:07:22I mean, if you're looking for an example of how you actually use
- 1:07:25Bitcoin in the real world, like listening to this podcast could
- 1:07:28be. One of those things that hasn't
- 1:07:30unlocked for you, yeah. And even in that example, we
- 1:07:36don't even know like podcasting relatively, you know, new or
- 1:07:40like the medium and when you can interact in a form of money
- 1:07:43that's Program programmable. How does that change this
- 1:07:46interaction? Like ideally we play with that
- 1:07:48at some point. Yeah, I mean, Matt and I play
- 1:07:51with it on the live stream rapid, we'll recap, we'll do
- 1:07:54that. In 45 minutes when we begin
- 1:07:56recording, but we'll stream this out over Noster and we have a
- 1:08:00Lightning network public address associated with our rabbit hole
- 1:08:02recap Noster account and people go to ZAP dot stream and they'll
- 1:08:07listen live and they'll be able to comment and send us Bitcoin.
- 1:08:11Do like super chat stuff, using Bitcoin to get us to interact
- 1:08:15with them. Vita is another good example.
- 1:08:17I think they're onto some stuff. Yeah, yeah, definitely.
- 1:08:20Vita is the same. The same way.
- 1:08:22And then what they're doing, what they're doing on the
- 1:08:24telecom side is I think it's really important.
- 1:08:27This gets back to I think part of your story, Brian, which is
- 1:08:30like going to Coinbase with the skeptic lens.
- 1:08:33Like I'd pretty certain the bitcoins, the signal, but let me
- 1:08:37actually do my due diligence and dive into the stuff, right?
- 1:08:40The research about Tesla, some of this crap out, it is actually
- 1:08:42crap back to Bitcoin, but I think.
- 1:08:45This is one of the big categorical errors that Coinbase
- 1:08:49and everybody in crypto makes is particularly around like Web 3
- 1:08:52point OD Phi. It's creating all these asinine
- 1:08:56COCK and Annie tokenomic schemes with a token for each use case.
- 1:09:00Where in reality, what, quote UN quote Web 3 point O is at the
- 1:09:04end of the day is combining open protocols, the open
- 1:09:08communications protocols, open content distribution protocols
- 1:09:12with open money and Bitcoin. Particularly over the Lightning
- 1:09:15Network. So with this podcast that's RSS
- 1:09:18in Lightning Network, we put a Lightning Network address in our
- 1:09:22RSS feed that this podcast goes on, goes out to the world.
- 1:09:26You can find that lightning address in our RSS.
- 1:09:30And if you have an app that has a Bitcoin wallet as that double
- 1:09:33s as a podcast player, you can send us Bitcoin Vita.
- 1:09:37Another example combining the open SIP protocol Voipin SIP
- 1:09:41protocols for telecoms like they have. 402 hours payment required
- 1:09:46errors in that stack too, for telecommunications, and you can
- 1:09:50inject Bitcoin into that. That's what's Vita's doing.
- 1:09:53One of the things they're doing, just another example, L 402, we
- 1:09:58talked about it in a few weeks or a month ago when I was in
- 1:10:00Nashville. Like they did the same thing
- 1:10:02that Lyle and the team at Vita are doing for VoIP and SIP, and
- 1:10:06they're doing it with the HTTP stack, like fitting it in.
- 1:10:10And really, solving the 402 payment required error at the
- 1:10:13HTTP level. So it's again, when you, if
- 1:10:16you're an institutional investor, like trying to discern
- 1:10:20what's going on here, like you've heard the Web 3.0 meme,
- 1:10:23you hear defy. I'm 100% Sir, and I've become
- 1:10:28convinced that that the whole Web 3.0 meme in the crypto space
- 1:10:33has it completely wrong. It's really taking open
- 1:10:35protocols that already exists and just adding.
- 1:10:38Open money to them. Yeah, they're all competing with
- 1:10:40money. Something you just said made me
- 1:10:43think of a like there's this long game being played if if
- 1:10:47it's if it's Bitcoin only and you don't do certain things like
- 1:10:50rehypothecate collateral and and all the things that either blow
- 1:10:53you up or put like a sour taste. And you know if you're
- 1:10:56allocating capital and you go into one of these Ftx's and
- 1:10:58you're just kind of like burned, your Lp's are burned.
- 1:11:00Everybody's burned. Your your reputation is.
- 1:11:04But then it made me think of like the ultimate value
- 1:11:07investment over Bitcoin is actually working or if you if
- 1:11:11there's interest I guess I would say but working or investing in
- 1:11:14like a Bitcoin only not investing but like investing
- 1:11:17time in a Bitcoin only firm and and what it hit me in like
- 1:11:24Brian's an example of this and it's actually happened
- 1:11:26previously for years. It's like the best people I've
- 1:11:28met have cold reached out in the space because it's this form of
- 1:11:33proof of work. When somebody has a solid
- 1:11:36background and they're they're extending themselves and they
- 1:11:39don't know if they're going to respond to how it's going to,
- 1:11:40you know, happen. But they they make that jump and
- 1:11:45then to get involved if we know this to be right.
- 1:11:47And on the other side of it, Bitcoin is the winner.
- 1:11:50Whether it's relationships, the actual learnings, the the
- 1:11:57education through the process, the whether it's equity in the
- 1:12:00business, the the writing, all of it.
- 1:12:03It's like, Can you imagine any better investment of your
- 1:12:05personal time? No, Even more than Bitcoin, to
- 1:12:08be honest. Like I think it's not.
- 1:12:10Even fulfillment, it's fulfillment, but it's like the
- 1:12:13network at this point you're just watching this whole thing
- 1:12:16grow in at the very like ground level and everybody and
- 1:12:19everybody you think about the people you've known from the pod
- 1:12:21and we like talk about Matt and like meeting you guys to the pod
- 1:12:24and just like all these different interactions in the
- 1:12:26vehicles, whether it was previously on chain or this
- 1:12:28vehicle and Brian now joining and where that goes, nobody will
- 1:12:32know. But like the amount of
- 1:12:33opportunity, like actual economic opportunity, is It's
- 1:12:37just insane if this is right, so.
- 1:12:38I don't think we could fully grasp or fathom the overall
- 1:12:42opportunity. Yeah, because we're going to be
- 1:12:44shocked to the upside. That's how I thought about it to
- 1:12:46be honest. And and part of it was also like
- 1:12:50recognizing kind of Tamari what you were saying just earlier is
- 1:12:53like we have this really great foundation like let's try as
- 1:12:57hard as we can to build around it and and create all of these
- 1:13:01other things that that work around this solid foundation
- 1:13:04like you don't need all those other tokens to do those things.
- 1:13:07Let's focus on the the foundation and and build around
- 1:13:09it and that's what really you know, excited me about.
- 1:13:13Getting into you know focus focusing specifically on Bitcoin
- 1:13:16and and was just so different than from being a Coinbase.
- 1:13:20And and I'll say this like there are, there's well-intentioned
- 1:13:22people at Coinbase. There's very smart people at
- 1:13:24Coinbase, but there's also just a ton of cognitive dissonance
- 1:13:27and generally it comes back to the business model, right?
- 1:13:32Like the reason? They want all these other tokens
- 1:13:36is because that's how the business model grows, like
- 1:13:38getting people out the risk curve and having them trade all
- 1:13:40these different things. And you know what?
- 1:13:41They say? The road to hell is paid with
- 1:13:45good intentions. Yeah, I don't even know if the
- 1:13:48intentions are good. I.
- 1:13:52I don't want to shit on your former employer, Brian, but I've
- 1:13:55done that on other shows. You can go find that if you're
- 1:13:58if you're really curious about it.
- 1:14:01Yeah, it's it's the whole incentive model over there with
- 1:14:05A16Z and the the various Silicon Valley venture capital arms that
- 1:14:11have figured out that if they use their connections, their
- 1:14:16clout to get an allocation to a new crypto token and then hype
- 1:14:24it up and then use their connections to coin base or.
- 1:14:30Other, you know, legitimate tech startups to then dump those
- 1:14:39tokens. They can get great returns in a
- 1:14:42very short time frame when, you know, we talked about how
- 1:14:45venture capital usually takes 10 years because you have to go
- 1:14:48find the winners. And to Michael's point earlier,
- 1:14:52there's no guarantee that you're in one of the winners of the
- 1:14:54decade and venture capital is all about finding the Google.
- 1:14:58For the next decade, the Uber, you know there's only a handful
- 1:15:02of those every decade and you need to be in one of them
- 1:15:05otherwise you're going to under deliver you could you could
- 1:15:07deliver a 0 ultimately if if you pick the wrong ones.
- 1:15:13And so that average of 25% a year is is really a a small
- 1:15:18percentage of venture funds delivering well above that and
- 1:15:21then quite a few venture funds delivering well below that and.
- 1:15:28Being able to use these token models and dressing up in
- 1:15:33whatever the latest narrative is Web three recently, metaverse
- 1:15:38recently you know in 2017 it was it was specific use cases for
- 1:15:45niche. People like I popped into my
- 1:15:49head that Denta Coin existed, which was the cryptocurrency
- 1:15:54which was marketed as the cryptocurrency.
- 1:15:57Dentists, well, and that and that got to $2 billion.
- 1:16:01I just looked it up it got. To two Bill.
- 1:16:04Holy crap. Well.
- 1:16:05And now it's $1,000,000 in total valuation.
- 1:16:09I'll never forget that since we've been talking about
- 1:16:11Barstool Lot on this episode, I'll never forget like, during.
- 1:16:14Winter December 2017. Like by that point leading
- 1:16:19through the summer, you literally had like ICO agencies
- 1:16:21popped up that were doing consultancy work, consultancy
- 1:16:25work for companies like here. Here's we're gonna help you like
- 1:16:27ICO not ever forget like literally being pulled into an
- 1:16:31e-mail thread with like Erica Dave and people from the Churn
- 1:16:35in Group and like this ICO consultanty group like.
- 1:16:39And they were like, Marty, like your Bitcoin Marty, Like, what
- 1:16:41do you think about this ICO? It's like you can't even run a
- 1:16:43WordPress website. Like, why?
- 1:16:46Why are you gonna launch a token and attach it to your company?
- 1:16:49Like, this is the dumbest idea ever.
- 1:16:51Luckily they didn't launch an ICO, but that's how crazy got
- 1:16:54people are like approaching Barstool like you need a token.
- 1:16:57Well, yeah, one of the one of the other clear sort of
- 1:16:59manifestations of this these dynamics that we're talking
- 1:17:02about is like the reluctance of Coinbase overtime to like work
- 1:17:06on lightning, right, like. That was always so clearly
- 1:17:10reflective of the business model being tied to all the other
- 1:17:14tokens. To me, because it's like, OK,
- 1:17:15even if you have your issues with Lightning and you think
- 1:17:17it's immature, like you should be working on it to make it
- 1:17:20better. Like, why aren't you?
- 1:17:24Some cognitive distance because they can't.
- 1:17:26Like they literally need Bitcoin to be a dumb gold.
- 1:17:30No Windows 7 transactions per second right?
- 1:17:32Is expensive. They can't acknowledge that
- 1:17:35there are these. Other layers being built to
- 1:17:38completely debunk that narrative?
- 1:17:40Do you have a strong take on security tokens?
- 1:17:42And token is a tokenizing like real world assets.
- 1:17:46I don't have a strong take on it.
- 1:17:47I mean, we need to I. Think people are gonna continue
- 1:17:50to try to do it. That would be my take.
- 1:17:51Like I don't think that concept is going away because that in
- 1:17:55some sense has ultimately some amount of like more of a sort of
- 1:18:02regulatory trajectory where it'll be OK to do those things
- 1:18:05because if you're just. Mirroring other assets that's
- 1:18:08less nefarious than creating some new thing.
- 1:18:11So I think it has a a stronger path to relevance but I don't
- 1:18:15think it's necessary that that would be my take.
- 1:18:18Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:18:19I mean I I agree. I think I, I, I don't have a
- 1:18:23strong I fall in the camp there. I haven't fully thought through
- 1:18:29and articulated or have the like opinion.
- 1:18:32I want to sure completely. But I know that there's a lot of
- 1:18:34people very excited about it and I feel like we need to have
- 1:18:36somebody on that. We should chat.
- 1:18:38We should. Probably talk to Alan about
- 1:18:40this. He's got some good thoughts on
- 1:18:41it. But I think just generally like
- 1:18:44Alan Farrington, but I I don't know, I do think there certainly
- 1:18:51is a bit of opaqueness and just pure logistical incompetence at
- 1:18:59the DTCC layer like it is really.
- 1:19:02Confusing. Like most people don't even know
- 1:19:05how many actually shares are like floating around the market
- 1:19:08at any given point in time. And like the settlement for that
- 1:19:11layer of like securities is like literally working on 1970s tech.
- 1:19:17But do you need a blockchain? For it, I don't know.
- 1:19:19I do think like the point I'm trying to make is there's
- 1:19:21definitely efficiencies to be gained to that particular layer
- 1:19:23of. I I think there's.
- 1:19:25I think there's an argument to be made that the.
- 1:19:29This is a technology that can reduce the overhead for
- 1:19:33fractionalized ownership of attractive assets, like issuing
- 1:19:37shares for commercial real estate or fine art.
- 1:19:42There's a world for that. But it's but it's it's not.
- 1:19:46Doesn't, doesn't. Amount to like a.
- 1:19:48Currency. It amounts to like a different
- 1:19:51database administration system part of our angels list.
- 1:19:57Yeah, yeah, It's like, right, it's.
- 1:20:00And the reason I brought it up is because it was just like the,
- 1:20:03I think the the folks that we talk with in the circles that
- 1:20:06we've seen this, I mean to ping you every time it comes up in a
- 1:20:09feed of or like it's just like triggers, Michael.
- 1:20:12It didn't trigger. It's just like we saw in an 18
- 1:20:15the STO. At the time it was STO security
- 1:20:17token offerings. And then you start hearing
- 1:20:21through the runways and I think a lot of finance individuals or
- 1:20:24tied to it because it feels like an innovation.
- 1:20:26And there's and I don't know the angle of how they're going to
- 1:20:28like take their spread and doing this because it will Well let me
- 1:20:32finish the thought. So I think that is where where I
- 1:20:34was going is it. It ultimately, in my mind will
- 1:20:37end up as an affinity scam in the sense that when we say Icos
- 1:20:40or we say these other things, what they do is they play off of
- 1:20:42this innovation that's in the middle.
- 1:20:43And then you start moving like the blockchain, the distributed
- 1:20:46Ledger technology, the ICO. And I think this is this like
- 1:20:50revamp that will start next year.
- 1:20:51They'll go into next year of the tokenizing the real estate.
- 1:20:55And it's just something that again don't have a fully formed
- 1:20:58opinion but would love somebody that is in those world.
- 1:21:00Because my understanding like the equity market is the most
- 1:21:02efficient market on the planet Earth.
- 1:21:03And so, do you really need a token to make it more efficient
- 1:21:06is the question. But yeah, but it's expensive to
- 1:21:09to IPO. You know, like I think that's
- 1:21:12the argument is that you can reduce your overhead if you have
- 1:21:15this sort of, but I think that's on purpose.
- 1:21:17I think that's just cumbersome of bureaucracy.
- 1:21:18I don't think that has to do anything with techno like
- 1:21:21technology. People form a company like an
- 1:21:23angels less than a but they click a button.
- 1:21:25Yeah. And and at the end of the day
- 1:21:26like the these Stos will just be stocks at the other day.
- 1:21:29So like this token should just trade like on the value of their
- 1:21:31cash flows and their margins. Go through, you go through the
- 1:21:35affinity scams like it and they get the most egregious affinity
- 1:21:38scams happen and then people learn from them and and four
- 1:21:43years later they fall for less egregious affinity scams.
- 1:21:46Less sweeping and and horrendous.
- 1:21:49You know we went through our our bit connect and and then now we
- 1:21:53had FTX and those are a little bit different in terms of the
- 1:21:56the magnitude of scam. And I think that sort of process
- 1:22:01just continues with this technology in general that you
- 1:22:04go through your your overhyped over promised affinity scams
- 1:22:09with St. O's and we had that probably in
- 1:22:112017. And going forward there will be
- 1:22:14less and less of that until the terminal state of it is it's
- 1:22:17just a different form of issuing stock in a cheaper way.
- 1:22:20So we're just gonna have a longer what I heard was like a
- 1:22:23bit bit connect was whatever six months and then FTX was 18
- 1:22:26months and now we're gonna have like a 36 month affinity scan
- 1:22:29that's just gonna go until. Until the rug.
- 1:22:31Now you have to compare is it compare Ftx to like the
- 1:22:35cryptopias and milk oxes of the world.
- 1:22:38Yeah, right. They're different.
- 1:22:40But you know FTT ultimately it's fraud.
- 1:22:43Bitconnect is straight up Ponzi scam fraud.
- 1:22:47Yeah. Do you think BNB and finances?
- 1:22:51Yeah, maybe we should maybe now have some time to get into.
- 1:22:54That, Yeah. You do want to talk about that?
- 1:22:55Yeah. Because that is possibly the
- 1:22:58biggest story for the rest of the year in cryptocurrency
- 1:23:04markets. Will finance.
- 1:23:08Follow Ftx's collapse and for people who aren't aware, there's
- 1:23:15considerable evidence which is speculative in nature, but
- 1:23:20there's quite a bit of it. Speculative evidence.
- 1:23:24Yeah. There's a lot of things that
- 1:23:25line up, let's put it. There's a lot of smoke.
- 1:23:28And so there may or may not be fire here suggesting that
- 1:23:34finance. Followed a similar playbook as
- 1:23:37FTX with their their token FTT which which was to what what FTX
- 1:23:45did was they took on leverage bets.
- 1:23:49They they borrowed against their FTT positions with it, and that
- 1:23:56created a certain liquidation price point.
- 1:23:59Where if the price of FTT fell below that price point they
- 1:24:03their margin their their loan would be, there would be a
- 1:24:06margin call and they would get liquidated.
- 1:24:11And that's ultimately what happened to FTX.
- 1:24:15And that was the the, you know, the, the final chapter of the
- 1:24:20collapse of of what turned out to be a $10 billion hole that
- 1:24:25FTX had on on its balance sheet. And that was the.
- 1:24:29You know the the carnage that came out of that and right now
- 1:24:32what's happening is that finance seems to be the finances token.
- 1:24:38BNB got up to $600.00 per coin at the end of 2021 and right now
- 1:24:45it's been since then it's been trailing off.
- 1:24:48It's now in the low two hundreds and there's some evidence that
- 1:24:54finance has margin loans. That get liquidated somewhere in
- 1:24:58the low two hundreds and there's there they seem to be.
- 1:25:01Since June on finances platform, there have been moments periods
- 1:25:07where Bitcoin trades at a discount relative to other
- 1:25:14platforms, so other exchanges and in those periods finances
- 1:25:20token BNB has been surging. Which sort of suggests that
- 1:25:26finance has been selling Bitcoin in order to buy B&B, to bid up
- 1:25:32B&B in those moments in time in order to defend against B&B
- 1:25:38dropping below a certain price level.
- 1:25:40So if that's happening, they may or may not have dipped into
- 1:25:43customer Bitcoin in order to sell that and bid up B&B as
- 1:25:50they're trying to defend this price point.
- 1:25:52Which could create the same paper Bitcoin claims situation
- 1:25:56where there's a fractional, A fractional reserve for finance
- 1:26:01where they don't have as much Bitcoin as customers think they
- 1:26:05collectively have at, you know, on hand at finance based on
- 1:26:11their current accounts. So do we get to a point where
- 1:26:16finance sells off enough and runs out of cash runs out of
- 1:26:19crypto currencies to sell in order to bid up?
- 1:26:22BMB if that's what they're doing, in which case we will
- 1:26:26have a collapse larger than FTX in our near future.
- 1:26:31Yeah, I mean, I think they're definitely trying to prop up
- 1:26:34BMB. BMB is a complete scam.
- 1:26:40So is BMB connected to finance mark chain or do they have their
- 1:26:43own BSc token with that too? I forget.
- 1:26:46Good question. I don't.
- 1:26:47I never really looked too much into the mechanics.
- 1:26:50Yeah, So I'm pretty sure it's connected to the smart chain.
- 1:26:53Thanks. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:26:54And so like the all these stupid.
- 1:26:56That's right. It's the utility token for BSc,
- 1:26:59yeah. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:27:00So buying in smarts like each of these exchange tokens have
- 1:27:03different flare. FTT essentially got you profit
- 1:27:07share, right? You got to yield on the the
- 1:27:11profits that never materialized for FTX.
- 1:27:15We were just stealing people's money.
- 1:27:17Finance, the BMB has done a bit different and they've like I
- 1:27:20think they Fort Salon or some other smart contract chain and
- 1:27:23like you can actually build smart contracts with it.
- 1:27:26So like that's like a different flare, but it's complete
- 1:27:29manufactured activity. I would argue again, speculative
- 1:27:32evidence there. It's just using the heuristics
- 1:27:35of being in this industry for 10 years.
- 1:27:37They're just propping it up and gaming metrics to make it look
- 1:27:40like people are using it. I think that the best.
- 1:27:45Indicator of that the most suspicious thing in in my book
- 1:27:47is is if you look at the price chart of BNB versus Bitcoin over
- 1:27:52the last six years it it has just soared it relentlessly.
- 1:27:58Like it's the only token over a six year period that I'm aware
- 1:28:02of that has dramatically outperformed Bitcoin.
- 1:28:05And like it's not even close. It's it's it's just stair steps
- 1:28:09up and to the right versus Bitcoin and.
- 1:28:13That feels like an Icarus flight to me, like something, something
- 1:28:17unnatural is driving that. So what is the thought that like
- 1:28:23they they are bidding it up because they're skimming, like
- 1:28:25they're just selling into like liquidity into exit liquidity.
- 1:28:28So people are behind it. But if that's the case, the
- 1:28:33position one would have to be very big to whatever their
- 1:28:36balance sheet. Like the only way I could see
- 1:28:38that this actually happening because of the thing.
- 1:28:40Fundamentally, FTX was a completely different game in the
- 1:28:43sense of like it was from the start, never whole.
- 1:28:46So yeah, so, so like the to go to like this is a casino.
- 1:28:50This is like a very valuable casino.
- 1:28:53And so to make to let it fall would ultimately mean in my mind
- 1:28:58what you describe because I haven't even followed this.
- 1:28:59I haven't been able to looked at Twitter, but would mean that CZ
- 1:29:05has a bunch of Bitcoin. We know it and he's ultimately
- 1:29:07going to say I'm going to take my Bitcoin and go home and I'm
- 1:29:10going to let this run out because that's effectively what
- 1:29:14would have to happen, that all the money they've made, all the
- 1:29:17money he had, we know it's there unless it's just he keeps trying
- 1:29:20to prop it up until it goes out. But but that also like is the
- 1:29:24whole, how would a hole be that? I just don't see how holes that
- 1:29:28big versus like FTX made complete sense because it was a
- 1:29:30Ponzi from the start. I mean, going to Jesse's point
- 1:29:33of like the crazy performance that it's had over the last
- 1:29:37years, like creates like the need to keep that pressure.
- 1:29:41Up right. It could be that they've.
- 1:29:43Been successfully using a like leverage trading strategy over
- 1:29:49time and that they just happened to, you know maybe they got a
- 1:29:53little too greedy and they thought, OK B&B token is at
- 1:29:58$600.00 per coin, there's no way it'll get down to 200.
- 1:30:02We'll we'll lever up to there like that'll be our liquidation
- 1:30:05point and right now, you know maybe they miscalculated
- 1:30:10basically. Maybe it doesn't pass the smell
- 1:30:14test like the whole thing with FTX when people no.
- 1:30:17No, definitely no, no, I'll, I'll explain.
- 1:30:18I'll explain. Why is be like the FTX just from
- 1:30:20a from a logical perspective. When FTX went down the common
- 1:30:24trope or the thought from everybody was like why would
- 1:30:26they ever do this? They were printing money.
- 1:30:29That was the thought. They actually weren't printing
- 1:30:31money and it was always a Ponzi. It's like finance does print
- 1:30:34money. They do have a golden goose.
- 1:30:36So like why would they risk that far is like?
- 1:30:39Degenerate trader. That's perfect, but that's
- 1:30:41perfectly fine. But that's not there's an extent
- 1:30:43where you like. Or just a businessman.
- 1:30:45We've been on the pod talking about CZ being a businessman,
- 1:30:47being a pirate. Like to just burn that down for
- 1:30:51an additional 20%. I mean, unless maybe these guys
- 1:30:54are. Degenerate gambler, You go back
- 1:30:57to like the history of CZ. They started, OK, so are you on
- 1:31:00the record saying that finances but you think finance fails?
- 1:31:03I don't eventually, yes, that would you probably.
- 1:31:07What's the probability? Let's go on the records.
- 1:31:10Over what time? Because if we're gonna, if we're
- 1:31:11gonna fall, if we're gonna talk about it and feel strong about,
- 1:31:14we should like at least. Have a feeling on the podcast
- 1:31:16for this one because he feels strongly he.
- 1:31:18Feel he's been it's. Really stupid and they all.
- 1:31:20He might just be timing it well enough where he can.
- 1:31:22He can prop it up until. And that's like all this, that's
- 1:31:25probably what he's trying to do and all the signals, I think
- 1:31:28that's right. Are there like particularly like
- 1:31:30curbing withdrawals like? Ninja launching stricter KYC AML
- 1:31:35compliance on users if they would, if they're trying to
- 1:31:38withdraw Bitcoin to delay having to deliver that Bitcoin.
- 1:31:41Like this is, again, having been around for a day.
- 1:31:44This is like all the heuristic alarm bells are going off.
- 1:31:48Like, all right, they're propping up their own their own
- 1:31:51exchange token check coin. They're the price of bitcoins
- 1:31:55moving in lockstep with this thing and they have this massive
- 1:31:57exchange, they're withholding withdrawals from people.
- 1:32:00So percentage chance. 100% eventually 50% this year.
- 1:32:07Wow, Jesse. 50% end of this year.
- 1:32:10I would say 90% eventually and 50% this year, yeah that's I
- 1:32:16mean if we if it's 50% that means we see probably like sub
- 1:32:19$20,000 Bitcoin. Bring it may or may or may not.
- 1:32:23So one thing about FTX was that was at the the very end of the
- 1:32:27bear market, right? That was the capitulation.
- 1:32:30Wick where? There was the order book.
- 1:32:34That. Was in finance goes down, we can
- 1:32:35get another one. Yeah, we'll get another one
- 1:32:37because people just get scared shitless.
- 1:32:39Yeah, we'll get another one. But will it be at a moment in
- 1:32:43the market where there's so much fear and people are so worn out
- 1:32:48after a year of downtrend? That there weren't really that
- 1:32:51many people bidding, that's what I mean.
- 1:32:53Versus now. People would love to get an
- 1:32:56entry below 20 K because they missed it.
- 1:32:58You know, what if the Fed hikes 2 times?
- 1:33:00All that happens. And and the other thing that
- 1:33:05Michael about like. That actually actually
- 1:33:07conspiracy theory Marty Jones for the tin foil hide on now
- 1:33:11like I think this is one of the big comments that the SEC has
- 1:33:14made in regards to like the ETF approvals is like hey we really
- 1:33:17don't like these offshore. Yeah.
- 1:33:22Exchanges. So I think this is actually this
- 1:33:23would actually be really good for Bitcoin if sooner than later
- 1:33:27finance goes down. Because I I do think, and
- 1:33:30there's been sort of some back channel rumors about this, that
- 1:33:34the SEC is very unhappy with their perception that finance
- 1:33:39can manipulate the Bitcoin market because they're so big
- 1:33:42and they're flouting US regulators and.
- 1:33:46And and so, you know, that may be what's holding up an ETF and
- 1:33:50and it may be that if and when finance washes out, there's fear
- 1:33:56in the market for a while and then, you know, daddy Wall
- 1:34:00Street steps in and. Says you can trust.
- 1:34:05Me, I'll, I'll issue an ETF and it'll be regulatory compliant
- 1:34:08and then the SEC green lights that and and you know for better
- 1:34:12and worse. That would be that would bring a
- 1:34:15lot more capital to Bitcoin. So that there I think that is
- 1:34:18part of the story here. I think the other thing to to
- 1:34:21Michael's phone earlier of like, how did they screw this up?
- 1:34:23Like they've got the golden goose to.
- 1:34:26Generate gamblers. Yes, they're the generate
- 1:34:28gamblers. They're also the regulators are
- 1:34:31coming down on them hard right now.
- 1:34:32So they may have, they may have expected, you know, they they've
- 1:34:37survived this long because I think that they probably had
- 1:34:39good risk assessments of like how much of a drawdown.
- 1:34:43Can we should we expect in in Bitcoin and crypto and then B
- 1:34:49and B's token price and they may have correctly accounted for
- 1:34:52that, but they may not have accounted for a simultaneous
- 1:34:55regulatory clampdown which is now cutting.
- 1:34:58They're now cut off from the US dollar.
- 1:35:00They do not have a banking partner that can get in Europe
- 1:35:05and that's now happening in Europe as well.
- 1:35:08Their Their auditor pulled out and and retracted their.
- 1:35:13Statements the DOJ is now has now charged Finance with a
- 1:35:21variety of things and several of their top executives have bailed
- 1:35:25recently. You just made me think of
- 1:35:27something. Well.
- 1:35:27They're going bad, so I'll actually start.
- 1:35:30Should we bring that in to give this?
- 1:35:33Well, hold on before that way just one second before we do
- 1:35:35that, that where I will say that it I could see this actually
- 1:35:39happening based on from the heuristic of like everybody
- 1:35:42died. Yeah, everybody blew up.
- 1:35:45So, like, it'd be weird if Binance was the only one it
- 1:35:47feels like. To you and Matt would agree, if
- 1:35:49we want to pull it in and get us quick thoughts on this, all
- 1:35:51right, let's pull them in. Here we.
- 1:35:57Just do a Jesse thing. I'm I'm gonna.
- 1:36:00I'm gonna there was a great highlights all of the shit
- 1:36:04that's going wrong for Binance right now.
- 1:36:07Are we live right now? Yeah, we're live.
- 1:36:09No. We're not live or recording.
- 1:36:11Recording. We wanted to pull you in because
- 1:36:12we're talking by Nance. What are your thoughts?
- 1:36:14Well, we're in the middle of the episode right now.
- 1:36:18No, we're at the tail in tail end, but maybe Jesse set the
- 1:36:20scene of what we're in, the sides all.
- 1:36:24Right. So we're so we're talking about
- 1:36:25you know is by Nance the repeat. Is it a repeat of FTX?
- 1:36:29Is that what's happening right now?
- 1:36:32Michael pressed us to bet, put out our wagers on what's the
- 1:36:35likelihood of finance collapsing eventually and likelihood this
- 1:36:39year. Marty and I feel similarly that
- 1:36:43it's 90 to 100% eventually, 50% chance this year.
- 1:36:47Do you think that this golden goose of finance is going to
- 1:36:51succumb to some? Fraudulent activity or over
- 1:36:55leveraged bullshit that they may or may not have been engaging
- 1:36:58in. What are your thoughts?
- 1:37:01You think 90% This is why we brought you in?
- 1:37:06Because I was just, I had this same response.
- 1:37:08I was like, what the hell? 90% eventually. 90% eventually.
- 1:37:14What does that mean? At some point, well.
- 1:37:17My my take on that is all points tend to 0.
- 1:37:22Yeah, they they're the the DOJ has accused them of flagrant
- 1:37:30money laundering, particularly with Russians like, So that
- 1:37:36camera comes down at some. Point I I I mean, I think it's
- 1:37:43completely different than the FTX situation.
- 1:37:46I'm gonna be very careful not to do a Roger veer Matt.
- 1:37:51I said. Exactly what you basically are
- 1:37:54gonna say or afraid to say or like a Mount Cox is fine comment
- 1:37:58but you know fine. Finance has been around for a
- 1:38:02long fucking time. It does not mean that they can't
- 1:38:05rug at will. Every custodian can rug at will
- 1:38:08and everyone should learn how to hold Bitcoin themselves and and
- 1:38:12and self custody. But finance has been around for
- 1:38:15a long time. They have a massive market
- 1:38:18share. It's hard to track volume
- 1:38:20numbers because they can be faked.
- 1:38:23But I I think, I think objectively everyone agrees that
- 1:38:28finance is the leader by far in terms of actual, you know,
- 1:38:33market penetration and users and and and volume and and Bitcoin
- 1:38:37held on the platform. They make their addresses very
- 1:38:41clear so people can track their addresses.
- 1:38:45I think Glass node has them at over 700,000 Bitcoin or nearly
- 1:38:50700,000 Bitcoin in in deposits held on their platform.
- 1:38:56That's like $18 billion at current valuation.
- 1:38:59And just for some context, Glass Node didn't know how much FTX
- 1:39:04had and everyone thought that they had like great opsec on
- 1:39:07their wallets, but it's probably because they had no fucking
- 1:39:09Bitcoin the whole fucking time. And you know SPF came out of
- 1:39:13nowhere. He's like this Fiat Maxi that
- 1:39:15came out of nowhere flew too close to the sun and then of
- 1:39:18course like on the Bind side you have the DOJ issues.
- 1:39:21But I I that has always been the case.
- 1:39:23I mean it's it's kind of like a tether situation in my book is
- 1:39:26like CZ is his enemy, has always been the US government.
- 1:39:30He's obviously running a shadow bank that's completely detached
- 1:39:34from them and their hegemony. So they He has a huge target on
- 1:39:38his back, so does tether. But that doesn't mean that the
- 1:39:42Tether Truthers are based in reality when they say like that.
- 1:39:46You know, Tether's an outright scam.
- 1:39:48Like Tether can rug at will. the US government could hit him with
- 1:39:51the cruise missile or some shit and it could be worthless
- 1:39:53overnight. And I kind of like I've kind of
- 1:39:57put finance in the same bucket. Like I think CZ is a massive
- 1:40:01shit corner. I think B&B is is is essentially
- 1:40:08a scam. But I think stick around.
- 1:40:12He's grounded. He's one of these like OG shit
- 1:40:14corners that's like grounded in the value of Bitcoin.
- 1:40:17I don't know how to put that but he's a he's a bitcoiner first
- 1:40:22shit corner 2nd and it's it's like a different category.
- 1:40:25It's hard to you know. Man I wanna, I wanna say that's
- 1:40:28very impressive that you you like ninja, launched you into a
- 1:40:31pod and you just rattle off exactly the case with all the
- 1:40:34data. Well, everyone's been screaming
- 1:40:38by Nance Bank Run, so I was like looking.
- 1:40:40I was actually looking into it this last few days.
- 1:40:44Just like Ninja launched in a party, right?
- 1:40:47Yeah, just to the audience, where I thought I was recording
- 1:40:50rabbit hole recap. So I joined the link and these
- 1:40:54fellas were recording the last trade.
- 1:40:56Well, we are wrapping up the last trade.
- 1:40:58I know you have to go. I'm we mean, I'm good now, but
- 1:41:01we're. Matt and I have to record rabbit
- 1:41:03hole recap. Should we just wrap recap?
- 1:41:05Should we just roll into a party?
- 1:41:06RIP for rabbit hole recap can. You like use a restroom really
- 1:41:08quick or? Yeah, yeah, let's do a break and
- 1:41:10then roll into a party, RIP. Let's do it.
- 1:41:11Works for me all. Right.
- 1:41:13Sure.