Latest / My Sister's A Therapist- Mental Health, Wellness, and Healing with Humor / Forced Joy
Transcript
- 0:01The sisters, a therapist, and I tell jokes.
- 0:05We both want to help all kinds of folks.
- 0:09Hello and welcome to my sisters, a therapist.
- 0:12My name is Virginia Jones and I'm a stand up comedian, but
- 0:15this podcast is actually named that because my sister is a
- 0:18therapist. Hi, I'm Laura Ryan.
- 0:19I'm a licensed marriage and family therapist, but my main
- 0:22credit is sister to Chuckle Chief Virginia Jones.
- 0:25Guys, my voice doesn't sound so great.
- 0:27She's actually smoothing hers out.
- 0:30This is the level of sister competition we have.
- 0:33Going on I'm trying to make my voice extra velvety.
- 0:36Not trusted. You're terribly scratchy 1.
- 0:39This is how low my voice can get when I'm still.
- 0:43Thank you very much. This is not a filter.
- 0:45This is just my own. Yikes.
- 0:47Any voice recording agents who want to get a piece of this?
- 0:52You can reach me at hello at mysisters@therapist.com.
- 0:55Laura, what's on your mind? Today, oh so many things.
- 0:58I just wanted to give everybody an update on our listenership
- 1:01and see what the numbers are looking like.
- 1:03United States, we are solidly at the top.
- 1:07Guess what? Turkey still #2 UK crawling up
- 1:10to three. Love you for it.
- 1:12Australia. Good day, mate.
- 1:14You're at 4, followed by Chile, followed by Canada, followed by
- 1:18Bangladesh, followed by South Africa.
- 1:21And in last place we have New Zealand, followed by Germany.
- 1:25Thank you, Germany. 3 Gates, baby.
- 1:27Oh, Peter. Zane I had a run in with one of
- 1:30our listeners this week. I saw her in two different
- 1:33places but before I saw her I saw her car and it had a 94.5
- 1:38edge sticker K. EGE.
- 1:41Yeah, I hadn't seen one since high school.
- 1:43And then I saw her get into her car and I thought, hey, that's
- 1:46our listener's car. So thank you, listener, and
- 1:49thank you for supporting KDG. That was the alternative radio
- 1:52station of high school. We were forever calling up to
- 1:56get concert tickets that wound up to be the most horrible GA
- 2:00tickets and we would have to decide is it worth trying to get
- 2:03my non driving ass out to Las Colinas to get this lawn
- 2:08Morrissey ticket. They did have the Adventure Club
- 2:10which is great on Sunday nights and remember the Smith's
- 2:14competition was so awesome. They did a mash up of tiny less
- 2:18than a second sounds and you needed to identify what songs
- 2:22they were and Laura worked so hard.
- 2:23I spent about two weeks solidly not sleeping and just listening
- 2:27to the radio all the time. I never got through except one
- 2:31time and after the fact my boyfriend told me.
- 2:34Oh, I knew that it was this song.
- 2:36You know, would have been really cool if you told me because I
- 2:38guessed incorrectly. On the one time I got through, I
- 2:41was trying to get backstage passes, but instead I got a lot
- 2:44of lawn tickets to the Morrissey concert.
- 2:47Laura, apart from lawn tickets and Morrissey, what are we
- 2:50talking about this? Week This is a new term, but
- 2:52it's kind of an old thing. If you've ever worked in
- 2:54customer service, you know that you're supposed to have this
- 2:57sort of bubbly personality, which I've always been lacking.
- 3:01And now they're calling it forced joy, and that comes from
- 3:05Tiffany and Co. I'm going to start off with an
- 3:07article by Beth Cowett called Force.
- 3:09Joy is a Miserable corporate Trend.
- 3:12Starbucks Corporation baristas have a new job requirement.
- 3:15In addition to remembering to make your latte with no foam or
- 3:18your cortado with oat milk, they must also write a little missive
- 3:22on your cup. It's a directive that comes
- 3:24straight from CEO Brian Nickel. Oh my Lord.
- 3:26It says that handwritten notes foster moments of connection,
- 3:30part of his strategy to get more customers into stores and turn
- 3:33around the faltering coffee giant that's.
- 3:36Awful, yeah. It is in addition to remembering
- 3:40your whole coffee order, smiling at the counter, getting your
- 3:43cash right. I have to think of a thoughtful
- 3:45message for a stranger at work. Starbucks has been suffering
- 3:48under a boycott because they are trying to shut out unionization.
- 3:53They have always been a job that people took because they had
- 3:58good Benny's. You know it doesn't pay a ton.
- 4:01You need benzodiazepine well benefits.
- 4:05Workers hours are being cut and restricted so that they don't
- 4:08get the health care and they don't get the other things that
- 4:09they signed up for. And now I have to write
- 4:12thoughtful messages on randos. Now I have to write a thoughtful
- 4:15message on every randos cup. Here's my industry secret.
- 4:19I never give people at Starbucks my name.
- 4:22I go by Bobby at most places where they're going to write my
- 4:24name down. You're tired of looking down at
- 4:27your cup and having to say vulva.
- 4:28Vagina. Yeah, I'm tired of it.
- 4:30I definitely think in the service industry where you are
- 4:33open to tips, being bubbly and full of energy and joy is in
- 4:38your own best interest. Right.
- 4:40I have done much better when there was a cash incentive for
- 4:43being nice. I remember when I was working at
- 4:46Easy's, which is a milkshake slash pizza slash burger place
- 4:51that's set up like a 50s diner. Why not?
- 4:53I took the job because I knew that they were paying 750 an
- 4:56hour, which was much higher than most places during that time.
- 4:59I would be manning the cash register, minding my own
- 5:02business and my employers didn't expect me to smile, but all of
- 5:07the male older boomer customers did.
- 5:10Yes, because they are paying $4.50 for a milkshake and why
- 5:15wouldn't they also get the smiling complicit Ness of a
- 5:19young woman at the register? I think adoration from a strange
- 5:23woman that works in a fake 50s diner.
- 5:27It just makes sense. On a whole other topic, men,
- 5:30older men especially, are very entitled to women smiling at
- 5:33them, to women coming to them with a positive energy.
- 5:36And if they don't get it, they want to know why.
- 5:39What's the matter? I'm working at an hourly wage
- 5:42job. I've been standing for six hours
- 5:45and I have a final tomorrow. That's what's the matter.
- 5:48Are you actually interested? Or maybe we should be doing
- 5:51Benny's for the staff? Well, it would make you sleepy.
- 5:55But it would make me happy. Starbucks employees are also, by
- 5:58the way, mad because they are being asked to buy uniforms,
- 6:02which everybody in the world provides free uniforms.
- 6:05I worked at jack-in-the-box not showing off for three years.
- 6:07I was given uniforms. So that is a bit insulting.
- 6:10My friend Amy Miller just wrote threads.
- 6:13LA coffee shops, if we're going to make this Starbucks boycott
- 6:16work, you have to start staying open past 3:00 PM.
- 6:20Well they need to stop making weed legal and then maybe people
- 6:23will stay longer. In a memo he sent out in January
- 6:26detailing the plan, the CEO. He had some ideas.
- 6:28For those not sure what to say, they can scribble an
- 6:30affirmation. You're amazing.
- 6:32Share well wishes, seize the day or draw a :).
- 6:36What are the odds that young women writing You're amazing on
- 6:39Starbucks cops are going to be harassed by male customers?
- 6:42I'm going to go ahead and say 100% also, if I don't know you
- 6:47at all, if I'm just rolling up trying to grab my coffee before
- 6:51I go to work and you don't know me and you're writing some
- 6:53cutesy message, I'm actually kind of grossed out.
- 6:55Right, it's weird because of the political Hells gate that we
- 6:58live in. I have been doing letter writing
- 7:02actions and signing petitions online and stuff.
- 7:05I sent a form letter to my representation in Congress and
- 7:10the Senate about the Republican bill that is going to gut
- 7:13Medicare, and I sent them a form letter.
- 7:16And then I got a form letter back from them confirming that
- 7:18they received my form letter. Is this anything?
- 7:20We're just automating responses back and forth.
- 7:23Is this worthwhile? So in the same way, when someone
- 7:26who doesn't know you and let's face it, doesn't like you
- 7:29particularly write something on a cup, is that going to foster a
- 7:32moment of connection? No.
- 7:35If some Miranda Wright sees the day on my cup as I'm rushing to
- 7:39work, I'm not going to be inspired.
- 7:40Or seize the carp. What they're doing is someone
- 7:43has had a moment of connection or a funny joke with a cashier
- 7:46and they wrote something on a cup.
- 7:47They had a real moment of connection.
- 7:49There was a communication between the two people.
- 7:51That does happen all the time. And you have a little moment of
- 7:53human connection sneak in there. And it's just nice.
- 7:56And it's part of what makes a human being in interacting with
- 7:59other human beings nice. But they're trying to backward
- 8:01engineer. Yeah, right.
- 8:02And you rule on a cup. That's what does it.
- 8:04If you're doing a for everyone, it really loses its meaning.
- 8:07The underlying message to employees is this It's not
- 8:09enough to manufacture a product for customers.
- 8:12They must also manufacture a feeling.
- 8:14And if Nickel can't motivate workers to do so organically,
- 8:17he'll decree it by edict. It's not just Starbucks that has
- 8:20made trumped up enthusiasm an expectation.
- 8:23Most companies aren't going as far as The Japanese supermarket
- 8:26chain that's using an AI system to evaluate and standardize its
- 8:31employees smiles. But the trend is.
- 8:34Clear. It's kind of like if you get a
- 8:35Valentine from your crush in elementary school and you get so
- 8:39excited and then you see your friends Valentine's and realize
- 8:43they sent the same one to everybody.
- 8:44It does cheapen it a. Bit I used to get a yearly
- 8:47birthday card with a scratch off in it from my landlord and it
- 8:52just didn't feel that personal. One of the scourges of modern
- 8:55living is I'll get a birthday greeting from every business
- 8:58that has my birthday. I'm going to say the one from my
- 9:01old dentist that I stopped going to is the one that means the
- 9:05most. Also the veterinarian for the
- 9:07dog that died. Tell me about the message from
- 9:11the dentist. We at Super Smile Dental are
- 9:13just thinking about you on your special day, are ya?
- 9:16I don't have to sift through piles of emails and Facebook
- 9:19messages and voicemails from people I actually give a crap
- 9:23about. Now I know me and I know them.
- 9:24Now I have messages from my old dental office.
- 9:29I just feel like we need to start separating humanity from
- 9:33commercialism. Companies ending their remote
- 9:35work policies want butts back in seats, and they want employees
- 9:39to be happy about it. At Alphabet Inc, returning
- 9:41Googlers were reminded that office time should be, quote,
- 9:44not only productive but fun, UN quote.
- 9:46This in particular is hard because many studies have shown
- 9:50that remote work makes workers lives better.
- 9:53If you're a mom, not having to leave at 2:00 PM because your
- 9:57kid has an appointment, not having to worry about
- 10:00emergencies has been a life changer, a game changer.
- 10:04And just trusting that employees are adults and they're going to
- 10:06do the work that they need to do.
- 10:07But if you show up to work and plaster a smile on your face,
- 10:10that's going to be better. That Tiffany and Co executives
- 10:13required staffers to post and engage more with Tiffany Joy, an
- 10:17internal app designed to boost morale.
- 10:19I don't know if any app has ever boosted morale.
- 10:23No wonder employees mockingly gave the app a new nickname,
- 10:25Force Joy. That could just as easily be the
- 10:27moniker of the era we're entering.
- 10:29This is from the same article In the Age of Force Joy, employers
- 10:32are requiring positivity and passion because workers aren't
- 10:35voluntarily producing a whole lot of either right now.
- 10:38In fact, they don't like their jobs much at all.
- 10:41A recent Gallup poll found that employee engagement is at a 10
- 10:45year low. Only 39% of workers feel that
- 10:47someone cares about them as a person at their company, down
- 10:50from 47% in 2020. That's rough.
- 10:54I don't think the app is the song.
- 10:56That's the thing where these are real human issues and problems,
- 11:00and the corporate solution is bizarre and not workable.
- 11:05Employees can smell that stuff a mile away.
- 11:07It's strange to be in an environment so toxic that you
- 11:11have to remind and tell people. If morale's already good, you
- 11:14don't have to do any of this stuff.
- 11:15But if morale's bad and everyone gets an e-mail telling them to
- 11:18play a game or interact on an app to make them happier, it's
- 11:21going to get worse. I think the issue here is that
- 11:24these folks are missing the point.
- 11:26What they're trying to do is they're going, hey, problem
- 11:29here, we don't want to invest any time, energy or resources to
- 11:34this thing because our whole thing is developing a commercial
- 11:37product that we can sell and make money off of because
- 11:40capitalism. They're forgetting we're not
- 11:42dealing with a bunch of AI robots in an office.
- 11:45We're dealing with real people. Everybody wants a passionate
- 11:48worker when they're happy, and nobody wants a passionate worker
- 11:51when they're angry. Try to walk in the middle so the
- 11:54things that work, you don't take them on.
- 11:56I remember in Madeline Pendleton book, she was talking about how
- 12:00studies show that if you have one angry employee who's not
- 12:04doing well, that they will infect up to six other
- 12:07employees. Her thing was if somebody was
- 12:10having a bad day, even if it was just they're in a bad mood, she
- 12:13would send them home and they would be paid, but they would
- 12:15not be at work. In times in my life when I've
- 12:17been having a hard time, I remember my longest lasting
- 12:20corporate job. I had pretty bad burnout at the
- 12:22end and I was dealing with a divorce and I was having a lot
- 12:24of feelings all of the time. And I remember thinking it's
- 12:28cruel that I have to come to work and act like a regular
- 12:30person when all this stuff is going on.
- 12:32Absolutely. I had to do therapy for people.
- 12:36That is the beauty of not being a corporate employee.
- 12:38You have to do all that stuff and you don't get paid if you
- 12:41stay home to be. Fair part of work has always
- 12:43been performance. Employees, especially those in
- 12:46the service sector, have long been required to project a
- 12:48certain emotion, even when it's mismatched with how they truly
- 12:51feel. This is what sociologist Arlie
- 12:52Hoschfield famously coined as emotional labor quote when
- 12:55seeming to love the job becomes part of the job, UN quote, as
- 12:59she wrote in her 1983 book The Managed Heart.
- 13:02And I think this is what people talk about when they talk about
- 13:04their work selves who make severance jokes like, oh, that's
- 13:07my innie, that's my Audi. Many people, especially in the
- 13:09service industry are very different people at home than
- 13:11they are at work and part of the fun of work events.
- 13:14And when I say fun, it's likely right.
- 13:17Part of the AIR quote fun. Part of the experience is
- 13:19meeting people's spouses and partners and observing how
- 13:23different they might be with them, or how that person might
- 13:26be an odd match with their innie, but it might be a
- 13:28perfectly good match with their Audi, a super buttoned up,
- 13:31strict lady. And then you meet her biker
- 13:33husband. You're like, well, something's
- 13:34going on that I don't know. About and I had a client this
- 13:36week who went on a work excursion.
- 13:39It was an out of town meeting that they all had to go to and
- 13:42she was just saying, gosh, everyone was just getting drunk
- 13:45and acting ridiculous and I just thought, I don't want to know
- 13:48you like. That there's a limit to how much
- 13:51I want to know you. Because I think that's the
- 13:52biggest issue. There's so many issues, but we
- 13:55have this story in our society that my classmates or my
- 13:59coworkers are going to be my friends.
- 14:01They're going to be people I spend a lot of time with, but I
- 14:04don't actually have to like them.
- 14:06Co workers, you don't get to pick.
- 14:08It's like family in that way, but it's not like family in the
- 14:11way that you are their family. Certainly at every job I have
- 14:15left with a couple people that I keep in touch with and that I do
- 14:17consider to be friends. Mostly no.
- 14:20Yeah, just because we got hired by the same people doesn't mean
- 14:22we're going to be friends. So you may recognize it from the
- 14:25cult famous pieces of flair scene in the 1999 movie filmed
- 14:30in Austin, TX Office Space, where Jennifer Aniston's
- 14:32character is criticized for failing to contribute to the
- 14:35Quote UN quote fun atmosphere at the restaurant where she works
- 14:39because she's not wearing enough goofy pins on her uniform.
- 14:42Or more recently from Apple TV Severance, where the macro data
- 14:46refinement team is forced to awkwardly groove out during the
- 14:49quote music, dance experience and quote.
- 14:52I think Adam Scott. Apparently that's how he
- 14:55actually. Did his real dance?
- 14:57Look, he's a white man. He's never pretended to be
- 14:59anything other than that. His lip ferociously and thinking
- 15:03that that's a move. I think that's why a lot of
- 15:05people like dancing in dark environments.
- 15:08People can't really see that well.
- 15:09Or you're drinking and you're not just eating a fruit plate.
- 15:12To speak to the Jennifer Aniston scene in particular, and that
- 15:15was a genius scene about the meeting between the slacker
- 15:19ethos and this kind of fake corporate joy.
- 15:23Jennifer Aniston just wants to know what the bare minimum is,
- 15:25and then she's going to meet that.
- 15:27That needs to be a requirement. She keeps asking, what do I need
- 15:29to do? They're like, we don't need to
- 15:30do anything, but it would be great, right?
- 15:32OK. You want two more pieces of
- 15:33flair? Sure.
- 15:34Done. I want you to be actively
- 15:36interested in what was basically a Bennigan's uniform that you're
- 15:40going to be wearing to work. Our family had a little bit of
- 15:42experience with this. Many members of our family
- 15:45worked at Applebee's, and when I say many, I mean two.
- 15:48I think 2:00. Yeah, I was 2.
- 15:49Our baby sister worked at Applebee's as a host, took that
- 15:52experience with her to her overseas study, and they had an
- 15:57Applebee's type restaurant in her college town.
- 15:59What was it? It was called Old Orleans.
- 16:02They wanted to be like an American style quote UN quote
- 16:06party atmosphere that sold apps and beers.
- 16:09She was horrified by the lack of customer service and taught them
- 16:13the American way. When you're getting paid a
- 16:17living wage, there's no motivation for that, right?
- 16:20At its most basic, emotional labor is that old classic
- 16:22service with a smile. When Hochschild's book came out
- 16:25some 40 years ago, she surmised that about a third of all jobs
- 16:28required, quote, substantial demands for emotional labor, UN
- 16:31quote. But by 2013, she had estimated
- 16:33grown to about half. Today, it's likely even higher,
- 16:36as, quote, hard skills UN quote, are taken over by robots.
- 16:39Emotional labor is the human skill in otherwise digitized AI
- 16:42dominant in personal environments.
- 16:44Rose Hackman, the author of Emotional Labor with Invisible
- 16:47Work, Shaping Our Lives and How to Claim Our Power was written.
- 16:50Having customers watch us be extremely backed up and still
- 16:53having to write something on a cup is so embarrassing.
- 16:56In my experience in the service industry, I was working at the
- 16:59jack-in-the-box on the Party St. in my college town, which is now
- 17:04embarrassingly sterile. I was always very friendly.
- 17:07Most of my jobs have been personality forward and for the
- 17:10most part it was great. I was working with people my age
- 17:12and serving people my age, and some of them were on drugs.
- 17:15I got a lot of adult male unwanted attention and I
- 17:18remember being perplexed by it. But as an adult, I'm like, oh, a
- 17:21young woman was giving them attention and it was sad.
- 17:25They were so starved for that attention that they took it to
- 17:28mean an interest that was not there.
- 17:30My most memorable admirer was a gentleman who had done time for
- 17:34robbery for B&E and he was in his 50s, I believe, could have
- 17:39been 60s. He was working as a house
- 17:41painter. He was out of jail.
- 17:42He was doing his best and he wrote me a love letter.
- 17:45I was embarrassed by it. I threw it away, but it was bat
- 17:48S hit and he was like you know, it doesn't seem like a 20 year
- 17:53old college student and a 50 year old felon would see each
- 17:56other but like crazy things happen all the time.
- 17:58Pearl Harbor imagine Pearl Harbor.
- 17:59That doesn't make any sense. The space mission these.
- 18:02Things are not connected. Sir, I was able to let him down
- 18:05easy and he understood, and then he stopped coming into the
- 18:07jack-in-the-box covered in paint.
- 18:08Well, that's a relief. Back to the article.
- 18:10The online critics might be on to something.
- 18:12Happy and engaged employees are good for business, but so is
- 18:15creating an environment where workers can effectively do their
- 18:17jobs and find their own sources of workplace joy.
- 18:21Companies might find if they invest in the latter, the former
- 18:24will organically follow. No faking required.
- 18:27But that's the hard thing is making a good place to work and
- 18:30making a place where employees feel supported and trusted.
- 18:33That is a big disconnect from working from home and working in
- 18:36the office. There is part of our monkey
- 18:38brains that if they don't physically see you, they don't
- 18:41really think you're there. But I think that that is the
- 18:43case. But if you make a fun working
- 18:45environment where people don't feel, say, under the microscope
- 18:49for not smiling the right way, joy will occasionally happen.
- 18:53I saw a tick tock ad today for these glasses that have speakers
- 18:58in them so you can pretend that you're paying attention when
- 19:01you're not. The woman who's creating this,
- 19:04it's an ad basically. But she's like, you know, my
- 19:05boss said we can't listen to music at work anymore, so this
- 19:08is what I'm doing instead. People will always find a way.
- 19:11One of my first jobs out of college was working in a testing
- 19:15laboratory, and they told us we couldn't listen to music at
- 19:17work. And you're just like, oh, OK,
- 19:19that makes sense. I've never been able to before.
- 19:21But if you did work on a Saturday, you could listen to
- 19:24music at work. And I got so excited to bring my
- 19:27little boom box in and a little stack of CD's.
- 19:30That's another severance thing, right?
- 19:32Right. They're getting really excited
- 19:34about being offered finger traps as a price because they don't
- 19:38have anything else. Sometimes in Texas the lab got
- 19:42very hot and we were allowed to wear shorts when it was 80°
- 19:46inside the washroom. Like wow, this is really
- 19:48amazing. We mentioned it earlier.
- 19:50The Japan supermarket chain uses AI to gauge staff smiles in
- 19:54speech tones in quality service push.
- 19:56Japanese supermarket chain Aon has adopted an artificial
- 20:00intelligence system to assess and standardize its employees
- 20:02smiles, renewing the debate about workplace harassment.
- 20:05On July 1st, the national brand announced it had become the
- 20:08world's first company to promote an AI smile gauging system,
- 20:12which it is using across its. 240 shops called Mr. Smile.
- 20:15It was developed by the Japanese technology company Insta VR, and
- 20:18it's said to be able to accurately rate a shop assistant
- 20:21service attitude. You are training people to
- 20:25impersonate a happy person. I think the skill that we have
- 20:28all developed unconsciously as a society is looking like you're
- 20:32listening when you're really looking at your phone.
- 20:34That's job one. People aren't allowed to have
- 20:36free will anymore. You're putting my face into a
- 20:39machine that shows whether my smile is authentic or not.
- 20:43So what is that? What in the Terminator 2 is this
- 20:46right? Exactly the system.
- 20:47Draws on more than 450 elements, including facial expressions,
- 20:51voice, volume and tone of greetings, and has also been
- 20:54designed with game elements that invite staff to improve their
- 20:57attitude by challenging their scores.
- 20:59Aon said it ran a trial of the system in eight stores with
- 21:02about 3400 staff members and found service attitude improved
- 21:06by up to 1.6 * / a period of three months.
- 21:10The company said its goal was to standardize staff members smiles
- 21:13and satisfy customers to the maximum.
- 21:15Hey, what's your score? On butt kiss AI oh I got a 75.
- 21:20Oh wow, I got to kiss more. Butt you were talking about men
- 21:23being interested in you and Jack and the crack.
- 21:25When I worked at Easys, which I called Sleazies, no man ever
- 21:30approached me because I have chronic and terminal resting.
- 21:34Beeface just a little rain cloud in the corner.
- 21:38When I was working at jack-in-the-box and then when I
- 21:39was working as a waitress, I would frequently get guys
- 21:42hitting on me and writing me notes on the bill and stuff.
- 21:46The most optimistic guy wrote, I can't tip, but here's my phone
- 21:49number. You can't tip $1.50 on Mugu Guy
- 21:52Pan I'm going to jump right on that.
- 21:53But I thought I'm like, it's because they're bringing the
- 21:55food and they think that we're their wives.
- 21:58Women who bring you food are your partner.
- 22:01But now I'm like, Oh no, it's just a younger woman in a
- 22:03subservient position. That's what they like.
- 22:05I remember a chauvinistic man that I used to know who married
- 22:10a waitress, and he was talking about past relationships and all
- 22:14of the women had been in service industry positions.
- 22:16And I said, what's up with that? I don't know.
- 22:18I guess I just like people taking care of me.
- 22:21Barf Recently news the supermarket in Japan had
- 22:24implemented a extra slow checkout counter where customers
- 22:28can spend up to 20 minutes checking out without feeling
- 22:30pressured, was well received. The measure was intended to show
- 22:32consideration for elderly and disabled customers.
- 22:35Despite having fewer customers pass through the checkout, sales
- 22:38increased by 10%, according to Asahi TV.
- 22:40What the customers are receiving is human contact, genuine human
- 22:44connection, right? And not a robotically enforced
- 22:49smile. Right, because what we're doing
- 22:51is we're making space for humanity.
- 22:53And I don't think that the AI robot face thing is making space
- 22:59for humanity. Tiffany workers mock force joy
- 23:02that exacerbated staff exits. When Tiffany and Co executives
- 23:05were looking for ways to boost staff morale, they rolled out an
- 23:08internal app called Tiffany Joy, which we mentioned earlier.
- 23:10They asked workers to post photos celebrating couples
- 23:14getting engaged, colleagues, big sales and other meaningful
- 23:17moments at stores. It didn't take long to turn to
- 23:20a. Chore, right?
- 23:22That's aggravating. Most employees feel like the
- 23:24workload that they're doing is all they can do.
- 23:27Any additional demands are going to be met with criticism.
- 23:31A good place to find forced joy is LinkedIn because it has
- 23:35become Facebook for people who are on the job market.
- 23:38But every post is positive, everybody responding.
- 23:40It's like, I'm so excited to see the next step in your journey.
- 23:44There's this real forest LinkedIn speak that is funny to
- 23:48observe, but it's very much part of corporate America.
- 23:50You can also find forest joy at your local Chick-fil-A and white
- 23:53men. Love Chick-fil-A because they
- 23:55love that super obsequious subservience by a young person.
- 24:00Executives started telling US staff they weren't posting
- 24:03frequently enough and asking workers to quote, like, UN quote
- 24:06post more quickly. What started as a way to make
- 24:08Tiffany a more enjoyable place to work turned into a reminder
- 24:11that the iconic jeweler was not hitting the mark in the US.
- 24:14Tiffany has tied employees paychecks to sales goals that
- 24:17workers rarely met, reneged on a pledge to pay some bonuses and
- 24:21told store directors that they were not doing enough to attract
- 24:24wealthy clients to exclusive gatherings, according to 16
- 24:27current and former Tiffany executives and employees who
- 24:29weren't authorized to speak publicly.
- 24:31When you work in a sales environment and you're rewarding
- 24:34people for sales and you don't pay bonuses, you are dead in the
- 24:38water. You are taking on stink.
- 24:41I think we're just all forgetting that we're not here
- 24:44because it's fun. I remember having an employer
- 24:47tell me the thing I love about you is that you act like you own
- 24:51this thing. You take personal initiative.
- 24:54You do things because you really care about this company.
- 24:57Ultimately that led me to nothing because I ended up
- 24:59getting laid off. That's an important lesson, too.
- 25:01No matter what your commitment to a job is, you might lose it
- 25:04at any time. Don't go out of your way.
- 25:06Do what you want to do, but don't do what you don't want to
- 25:08do. I had a gig and it was contract
- 25:10gig and it was pretty far South in the LA Metroplex.
- 25:14People ask why don't you move closer to here?
- 25:16I'm like, I'm a contractor baby. I don't do anything for anybody.
- 25:19This reminds me of when you are interviewing for a job and the
- 25:23deadly question that people are still asking, like, why do you
- 25:25want this job? Why do you want it?
- 25:26Because it pays money. Because I like food.
- 25:29I like food, I like living indoors, I love having
- 25:32electricity, I love my phone. This is a disingenuous question.
- 25:36You are asking it in a disingenuous way, and I'm going
- 25:39to answer in a totally false way.
- 25:42If I didn't need money, I wouldn't be here.
- 25:46And this is a very middle class conversation.
- 25:48But like, what if you won the lottery?
- 25:49Would you quit your job? Of course I would quit my job.
- 25:52I actually wouldn't. Yes, your job is different.
- 25:54You're your own boss, for one. And two, this job, even though
- 25:58it's very hard, gives you something back.
- 26:00Creatives, people who are doing their passion projects, they
- 26:03would keep doing what they're doing.
- 26:04Do you think I'm going to show up and wash clothes when I have
- 26:07all the money I need? No.
- 26:08What are we going to do to solve this problem?
- 26:11Are you happy yet? The Dysfunction of Forced Joy
- 26:14and Toxic Positivity V Pastor Tanji Research indicates that an
- 26:17overemphasis on positivity can discourage individuals from
- 26:20forcing their frustrations, hinder effective problem
- 26:22solving, and even contribute to imposter syndrome or
- 26:25accomplished individuals they're worth.
- 26:27According to Psychology Today, toxic positivity is defined as
- 26:30the excessive promotion of positive thinking at the expense
- 26:33of acknowledging real difficulties.
- 26:35This tendency ultimately alienates employees and fosters
- 26:37an inauthentic workplace culture.
- 26:39You have to walk a line when someone asks how you're doing,
- 26:42you might not tell them, well, this just just being a real
- 26:46piece of work. I think my dad's sick.
- 26:48I lost my car. You want to soft pedal it more
- 26:50than that. But constantly telling other
- 26:52people everything's great. I'm great.
- 26:54It's a disease that I've talked about before in LA.
- 26:57There's a real fake it, so you make it theology.
- 26:59Yeah. And you absolutely can.
- 27:01But you will start to be depressed because your body
- 27:03knows that the things you're saying aren't real.
- 27:05You're saying stuff. And your brain is experiencing A
- 27:08cognitive dissonance. You start feeling like you don't
- 27:11know what's real and what's not because everything that's coming
- 27:13out of your mouth is BS. And that will turn depress you.
- 27:16And I think the implication is that all human beings are just
- 27:20supposed to be naturally happy all the time, when that's not
- 27:22really human nature. Toxic positivity often sneaks in
- 27:25disguised as a cultural norm. Phrases like we are a happy
- 27:28family can feel more like hollow mantras than genuine sentiments.
- 27:32In contrast, force joy is unmistakably blatant, resembling
- 27:35a set of cheerful standard operating procedures.
- 27:38I once worked with a hotel company that included how to
- 27:41smile in their lobby management SOP.
- 27:43Thankfully, they didn't specify the exact inches of a compliant
- 27:47smile like the Japanese company. Emotional suppression can lead
- 27:50employees to feel pressure to hide negative emotions, doubts,
- 27:53and valid concerns out of fear of being labeled.
- 27:54Quote not a team player UN quote.
- 27:56At best, this results in superficial engagement to use
- 27:59may appear aligned on the surface but lack genuine buy in
- 28:02as difficult conversations are avoided.
- 28:04Ultimately, this creates a landscape devoid of
- 28:06psychological safety. So even though everything's nice
- 28:08and shiny, everything is not positive all the time.
- 28:11What does the leader do? Leaders must ensure that their
- 28:13positivity is complemented by honesty, effective problem
- 28:17solving and emotional validation.
- 28:19True leadership is not about suppressing challenges with a
- 28:22sunny disposition, but embracing them with a clear eyed
- 28:25perspective that encourages growth and connection.
- 28:27My quote is I remember coaching a manager who was a ray of
- 28:30sunshine. Even on the darkest days, she
- 28:32could waltz into a room filled with Debbie Downer's mired in
- 28:34solving complex problems, stress, burnt out and on the
- 28:37brink of walking away. It was natural for everyone not
- 28:39to share her sunny outlook. Yet that did not stop her from
- 28:42promoting her unbridled optimism about the project.
- 28:44Eventually, her positive became a source of frustration.
- 28:47Team members became disengaged, believed she didn't understand
- 28:49the challenges they faced. Performance and productivity
- 28:51suffered. On the one side, it feels like a
- 28:53good thing, like if your manager is just always like rah rah.
- 28:57But when you have challenges and you don't feel safe going to
- 29:00her, every time you come to her with a challenge, just come back
- 29:03with a positive attitude again. It's cognitive dissonance.
- 29:06You're going to feel the only safe thing to do is disengage.
- 29:09Right. Because it's not a real
- 29:10environment. And I think the issue here with
- 29:12capitalism is that it's not really living in reality.
- 29:15It's living in this weird fake thing that they've made-up.
- 29:17It's living in a thing where everybody gets richer year over
- 29:21year. We're improving, improving,
- 29:22improving. Everybody can improve
- 29:24themselves. Everybody's happy all the time.
- 29:26There's a frequently quoted event after Zoloft came out in
- 29:30the US for a while, you saw all these ads for Zoloft and
- 29:33antidepressants and the little rain cloud ads.
- 29:36The drug maker wanted to start promoting it overseas, and they
- 29:40went to Japan and it went over like a lead balloon because
- 29:43Japanese people were like, it's OK to be unhappy sometimes, but
- 29:46Americans had gotten so on board with the idea that I'm going to
- 29:50take a drug and it's always going to be happy.
- 29:52Turns out America is deeply. Screwed up.
- 29:54Being unhappy is part of the human condition.
- 29:57Right. Exactly.
- 29:58It's my final quote. We've revamped this woman's
- 30:00approach. Instead of solely pitching ideas
- 30:03with enthusiasm, she began asking pivotal questions.
- 30:06Do you think this is possible? What obstacles could we face?
- 30:10How can we navigate potential hurdles together?
- 30:12How can I help? This shift transformed
- 30:14conversations, fostering deeper engagement and optimism paired
- 30:18with pragmatism, accountability, and understanding.
- 30:21The hardest thing is to be human.
- 30:24It's easy to just plaster a fake smile on and create your teeth
- 30:27and get through it. If you are human and listen and
- 30:32are prepared to take on bad news and deal with it, that's going
- 30:35to be a much more approachable environment.
- 30:38Bill Hicks used to say at the beginning of his act, excuse me
- 30:41while I plaster on a fake smile and go through this BS one more
- 30:45time. That's not an attitude that is
- 30:48going to connect you to people. It is something that we are
- 30:50pushed to give and receive. I.
- 30:52Just think it's the American way.
- 30:53So Virginia, what are your final thoughts on this interesting
- 30:57topic? I mean, the best way to foster
- 30:59community with employees is to invest in those employees.
- 31:03When everybody has enough, they're not going to complain
- 31:06about why are we being made to go on a golf outing.
- 31:09I don't think it's good to pretend to be happy at work.
- 31:11I don't think it's good to pretend to be happy in
- 31:12relationships. I don't think the minimum wage
- 31:15employee owes you a smile or a sincere comment or an
- 31:19affirmation on your coffee cup. I think the more important thing
- 31:22is to make an environment where those things will happen
- 31:24organically and they will be worth something.
- 31:27What are your final thoughts? I really feel like if a person
- 31:30feels safe and comfortable and like their opinions matter,
- 31:34they're going to do a better job.
- 31:36I've noticed that I'm a much better employee for myself than
- 31:39I ever was for anyone else because I know that at the end
- 31:42of the day, I've got me. I know that I'm not going to be
- 31:46randomly fired. I know that I'm not going to be
- 31:49dressed down in front of my Co workers.
- 31:50I know I'm not going to take a pay cut.
- 31:52I know that I'm safe where I'm working and I'm choosing the
- 31:56people that I work with. It's up to me.
- 31:58If you can't be self-employed, I don't know what to tell you, but
- 32:01I think. Couple calls this a lot.
- 32:03Laura's solution is run your own business.
- 32:05It does help me to be better at my job because I do care because
- 32:09at the end of the day, it is personal.
- 32:11My business being successful means a lot to me for lots of
- 32:15reasons. I take pride in doing a good
- 32:17job. I I show up when I'm tired or
- 32:19when I'm sick or whatever. Also because I'm not being paid
- 32:22if I don't. How do we get people to take
- 32:24ownership of their jobs? I don't know.
- 32:25I remember learning about at this gas station, I think it's
- 32:28in California where everybody owns part of it.
- 32:31If I know that this is going to help my family or that this is
- 32:35going to help my community or my society, I'm going to do extra.
- 32:38I'm going to smile more because I own it, because it it means.
- 32:41Something to me and that community ownership model has
- 32:45been applied to things as varied as strip clubs and restaurants.
- 32:49And individual contributors always tend to step up when
- 32:52again, it's money in their pocket.
- 32:54My old boss really struggled with this.
- 32:57She was like, why aren't the designers working around the
- 33:00clock? Why aren't people on their
- 33:02phones 24 hours a day? Why aren't people as passionate
- 33:04about this as I am? And it's because we don't own
- 33:06it. This job is making money for
- 33:08you. I'm happy to be here.
- 33:09I want to make good product always.
- 33:11I don't have the investment that you have.
- 33:12I'm. Showing up for the money that
- 33:14you're paying me and I'm going to do my job, but I'm not going
- 33:16to be doing leaps and bounds. And I feel like that's another
- 33:19piece. I think we used to have an
- 33:21environment where your corporate job meant something.
- 33:24You were going to be there for the rest of your life.
- 33:26You were going to have a pension package and all these other
- 33:29things, but since we've taken all that away, people don't care
- 33:32anymore. And why would they?
- 33:34We're in an environment where financial based layoffs are
- 33:37around every corner and then the people who have sacrificed are
- 33:40just going to be left in the back sewing.
- 33:41But I sacrifice stuff for this job, Thawi.
- 33:44Yeah, that was your mistake, Virginia.
- 33:45If people want to find you on the Internet, how would they do
- 33:48that? Thank you so much for asking.
- 33:50You can find me at wawa.badiniabadinia.com.
- 33:54I'm also that on TikTok. I've been feeling very plugged
- 33:56in. I'm putting on TikTok.
- 33:57I think I'm finally in a comfortable position where I
- 33:59have a little brain space. It's also my Instagram.
- 34:02Basically anything BADINIA related should be me.
- 34:05People can write us comments and reviews and we would love it if
- 34:08you did. And you can write them for us on
- 34:10Apple, Spotify. You can do it on Amazon podcast,
- 34:13Amazon Music. You can write us and I mentioned
- 34:16earlier at hello at mysisters@therapist.com.
- 34:18You can also contact us at hire us at mysisters@therapist.com.
- 34:22If you have any money making ideas for us.
- 34:24If you have anything you'd like us to support or promote, you
- 34:26can check out at our website at wowowo.mysisters@therapist.com
- 34:30and that's also our Instagram and we would love it if you
- 34:32would follow along on our big adventures.
- 34:34Laura, where can people find you on the Internet if they should
- 34:36wish to do so? You can find me at my
- 34:38professional website, lauraryan.org and if you are a
- 34:41corporate slog person who has a marketing department and you
- 34:45need some help, let us know. And also by the way, tell your
- 34:48friends, anybody that you've met known maybe someone who works at
- 34:51a Japanese grocery store is having their smile judged.
- 34:55Just let them know that we're. We're here.
- 34:57I had lunch with a friend who said, oh, me and the wife, we're
- 35:02just obsessed with mental health and therapy stuff.
- 35:05We read all these books we talk about all the time.
- 35:07I'm like, you would like our podcast and I'm not just saying
- 35:09that to promote my podcast in like a mindless robot Japanese
- 35:13AI way. You would like it.
- 35:15You should listen to it. I'm walking into this that's.
- 35:18Why we need to have T-shirts? So you can just point to your
- 35:20T-shirt. It found most of my
- 35:22conversations personally and professionally.
- 35:24I'm at least dropping the name two or three.
- 35:27So, Laura? Sometimes on this podcast you
- 35:29will read a review that someone has left us.
- 35:31And do you have a review to read for us this week?
- 35:33I certainly do. This is from BZM.
- 35:36This was an Apple podcast review.
- 35:38The title is 2 Lovely Ladies. These two provoke smiles,
- 35:42guffaws, a few tears, and snorts on my work day commute.
- 35:46I love their honesty, relatability #narcissistic daddy
- 35:50issues right here. And sincere advice.
- 35:53And of course, it's all wrapped up in humor, giving me a dose of
- 35:56joy every morning. Keep it up, ladies.
- 35:59Looking forward to your 100th episode.
- 36:01You can make it, ladies, you and you.
- 36:05BZM thank you BZM the. Quote was even you and then it's
- 36:08a BRVC and I just realized this Billy.
- 36:11Ray Billy Ray Valentine, Capricorn, way to listen a
- 36:14little harder than other people do.
- 36:18Thank you so much. And I hope that everyone will
- 36:19follow us when we rename this podcast to Force Joy, a toxic
- 36:23positivity podcast. In closing, I'd just like to
- 36:27remind everyone of Billy Ray Valentine Capricorn when he said
- 36:30we can make it baby. Me and you.
- 36:33Bye bye.