Latest / Newcomer Pod / Brands Are Not Human Beings (w/Jack Conte)
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome, full-time, salary. Hey everybody.
- 0:14Welcome to volley game room. Thank you for coming and
- 0:18drinking our drinks and crashing the party and welcome to
- 0:23everybody. What the fuck?
- 0:24It up? Austin, Texas.
- 0:27Tom has the enthusiasm. So I'm Eric new Comer, I run the
- 0:30newsletter newcomer named after myself.
- 0:33We are co-hosting the event. This is my have a podcast called
- 0:38dead cat, with Tom, dote on here.
- 0:41Hey, what you guys like? That fucking wheel up there,
- 0:45guess what? I got a quick question.
- 0:51All the people that were spinning the wheel out there,
- 0:53who got a free? Who's got free drinks tonight?
- 0:56Who wants free drinks. You got The Wristband.
- 0:59Show me your wristbands if you got the wristband, big winners.
- 1:03All right, I got another question for you guys out there
- 1:06who got a free subscription to newcomer.
- 1:10I realize it one in 200 you. Somebody is there somebody got a
- 1:13free subscription or newcomer. No, gonna grab really, somebody
- 1:18email you the subscription later come up over here.
- 1:22You might want to come upstairs for a second.
- 1:24We got a real winner in the house here and I want him to
- 1:26understand what he's in for. Hey, Mike.
- 1:34If it's not all that easy Mike, this is life.
- 1:36Yeah. Yeah, you know what sucks is
- 1:37that was next to the unlimited drinks?
- 1:39I know they set me up, so your by putting it, I know, but I had
- 1:44it and then everyone was cheering and then it right over
- 1:47right over the next bankruptcy right there.
- 1:49Yeah, thank you for that. Thank you.
- 1:51Okay, so just a quick question here.
- 1:53So thank you. What's your name, Daniel?
- 1:55Hey, Daniel, welcome, are you from Texas?
- 1:58Well, I live here now, but no, I'm not from Texas.
- 2:00Are you one of those California guys?
- 2:01I moved out to Texas. Yes.
- 2:03Yes. Okay.
- 2:04Okay, wait, wait. I'm from the better half of
- 2:07California, though. So San Jose, not La.
- 2:09Fuck La. I'm I've lived in both places.
- 2:13I'm not taking his side. Do you work in Tech?
- 2:15I do had you heard of newcomer the sub stack that focuses on VC
- 2:21and other Venture related issues before this.
- 2:26Tell the truth. Tell her like a sniper here.
- 2:28If I say, no, no, no. We don't have that budget
- 2:30marketing here. That is a mighty.
- 2:32I know. No, I have not.
- 2:33No. Okay, well, we're going to check
- 2:35back in with you, in six months, with your free newcomer
- 2:38subscription. We're gonna find out if it was
- 2:40worth any of your time. So, thank you so much.
- 2:42Thank you. Thank you.
- 2:42Thank you for coming. Thank you, Daniel.
- 2:46We're going to have a jack Conte.
- 2:47The patreon co up here in one second.
- 2:49So we'll be much more legit. I just this event is being held.
- 2:54Hosted by volley, which is an audio voice chat.
- 2:58You should play audio voice game.
- 3:00They have song quiz. I'm watching Max child right
- 3:04now. Judge my marketing pitch for
- 3:07him, which as a recursive feedback loop backs.
- 3:11But yeah, they have a Jeopardy game.
- 3:13They have a song quiz. You should play their voice
- 3:16games on Alexa or whatever Google labs.
- 3:19They got to deal with Jeopardy, they got a deal with Wheel of
- 3:21Fortune, which you probably saw out on the front.
- 3:23That was the original. A wheel from Wheel of Fortune.
- 3:25By the way, you guys were all spinning.
- 3:26So as a big fucking deal. All right, so we got Jack Conte,
- 3:32like we said, coming up here later before that.
- 3:34I feel like this is my first time at South by Southwest.
- 3:37Yeah, I came pre-pandemic. Sort of several times in the wet
- 3:43back when apps were still really trying to go viral South by but
- 3:47after I think absolutely legitimate well, that's
- 3:50amazingly. The Tech conference was that
- 3:52people. There was a breakout apps, like
- 3:54you can Come here, you could like demo your app like Vale and
- 3:57then it would become the next big thing and then he would say
- 3:59like oh in the way that ex broke out at South by the next thing
- 4:02the breakout. Yeah right well I mean Twitter
- 4:05Twitter Foursquare, where the relapse this sort of did it
- 4:09right. Right.
- 4:09So there's Twitter and then like it's a huge drop-off from there
- 4:14to the rest of the other apps that were sxsw meerkat for a
- 4:18second. I think people thought like
- 4:19really break. Can you go through that will go
- 4:21through that but since we have a couple minutes here before we
- 4:23get Jack coming up, On stage. I thought it'd be fun to kind of
- 4:26talk about South by Southwest as a as a tech at the history of
- 4:29tech at South by because like Eric was saying, I think it was
- 4:32Twitter that made South by a name like a place you want to
- 4:36break your app out. But I did a little bit of
- 4:38research Eric and I are both journalists so you know so we
- 4:41Google Google old articles. Yeah.
- 4:43We know how to read from, it's called research and we and we
- 4:49pulled up some of the old winners at South by Southwest.
- 4:54And so I'm going to pull it up here.
- 4:56This is an article that came out.
- 4:57This was in wired and by the way, I don't want to call out
- 4:59any other journalists because we all have to file fucking stories
- 5:02from here. We're here because our companies
- 5:04paid us to be here and the best we can do is file enough copies
- 5:08that our editors don't ask us why they sent us out here, but I
- 5:11want it. I want to read an article from
- 5:132008, which was two years after Twitter broke out here and it
- 5:17was talking about the next breakout app at South by.
- 5:19So 2006 was was Twitter. I think 2007, With Twitter.
- 5:24And by the way, the Twitter breakout was not like, oh, we
- 5:27can conceive of the possibilities with this app or
- 5:30we can consider this as you know, the next wave and how
- 5:33democracy will be, you know, that was that was practiced age
- 5:35of Twitter where you would tweet, like, I'm drinking a
- 5:38coffee. That was the reason people
- 5:39fucking use of Twitter at South by was like, I'm at I'm at the
- 5:43conference, right? The pre politics, I'm here in
- 5:46Michael Dell talk right now and this is fucking, you know,
- 5:49crazy. That's what they used it for.
- 5:50It wasn't about like right. Well forces.
- 5:53Are invading Kharkov right now. So anyway, so this is from, this
- 5:57is from a 2008. This is from, this is the
- 6:00breakout app, two years after Twitter broke out last year.
- 6:03Twitter was the big winner at South by Southwest in 2008.
- 6:06It's all about sked dot-org. Every year one web service
- 6:11captures, all the buzz of the to week-long conference by proving
- 6:14itself to be an Innovative geek friendly and perhaps most
- 6:17importantly, insanely useful this year.
- 6:20A simple calendaring service is the site most plugged into South
- 6:24by Southwest dike Zeitgeist. So that that was, that was where
- 6:27things went. We have a lot of people yawn,
- 6:29sked dot-org, still. Yeah, hardcore users got in how
- 6:33to the scared. Dot-org.
- 6:34Founders. Raise your hands.
- 6:36So I don't know what, you know what could try guys.
- 6:39We're all were all Just trying here.
- 6:41No no shade for the scheduled or guys.
- 6:43But quickly with the comments for me, bring Jack on stage.
- 6:45I want to run down the other breakout apps that they had at
- 6:48at South by want to do that. Let me let me bring up an
- 6:53article. This is from box.
- 6:55This is written by her friend Kurt Wagner.
- 6:57By the way, no longer at vaux, you guys know girl back, this is
- 7:01a tech Insider podcasts real Insider shit.
- 7:06I see we got Josh constant in the crowd.
- 7:09Yeah. We love.
- 7:10We love older. All right, so Twitter, 2007, big
- 7:14deal. We like that.
- 7:15That worked out 2009 Foursquare. I mean that's basically an ad
- 7:20tech company right now. I think that right sleeve You do
- 7:23right? They utilize their location data
- 7:25and sell it to things. Kind of fell off a bit.
- 7:28From being the mayor of like you know, Franklin's Barbecue, 2012
- 7:33was highlight, the app was highlight.
- 7:35Big break out at you as member highlight.
- 7:39Do you really do you guys remember highlight?
- 7:42I don't remember. It was about like it was
- 7:44location-based. It was like you could find out
- 7:46if your friends were nearby, it was the founder of Clubhouse.
- 7:48Yeah. I mean it was he the meerkat guy
- 7:51to or no? That's a different guy.
- 7:53Yeah. All right, there are a lot of
- 7:57social apps meerkat, which several months after South by
- 8:01Southwest had to Pivot to house party, right?
- 8:04Which is no longer a thing and that's it.
- 8:07That's the end of the article. That is the that is the full
- 8:11extent of the breakout asked by side by side.
- 8:13All right, let's get Jack. I'm here.
- 8:14Jack Conte to see you at patreon.
- 8:20Also a musician, his company was recently valued at four billion
- 8:25dollars. He is an expert on the Creator
- 8:28economy. Jack thanks.
- 8:31Thanks so much for being here. Ah thanks for having me psyched
- 8:33to be here. Yeah, you missed live.
- 8:35Audiences your musician. So and it's been obviously two
- 8:37years since we've had. I mean it's at where else.
- 8:39Can you get drunk and talk about trust and safety and content?
- 8:42Palestine Free Speech. Right?
- 8:44Right. How have you I was asking this
- 8:47away. I have you done, many, have you
- 8:49performed Itself by or what's your history with my wife?
- 8:52My wife has and I've always, you know, I've probably been to like
- 8:56two or three of these. So not not a ton really.
- 8:59Yeah, what? And by the way, the name of your
- 9:01band, you've got a couple, right, you've got a couple of
- 9:03outfits and when people probably know the most is pomplamoose,
- 9:05pomplamoosemusic a high pockets. Yep, okay, but never performed
- 9:09here at South by. Nope, never performs out that we
- 9:11actually don't both bands are interesting.
- 9:13We own our masters. Okay, and so touring and live,
- 9:17isn't like the primary income stream for the band's.
- 9:20So we kind of, you know, we like cell songs, we have memberships
- 9:23through patreon. We like sell merch, other stuff
- 9:25like that, but we don't do a ton of live stuff.
- 9:27Really interesting. Yeah, what's the reason why it
- 9:30just doesn't fit with the vibe or you just would rather keep
- 9:33everything Studio based or what's we're completely
- 9:35independent? Okay, we we again on our masters
- 9:40so like our money comes from streaming and and other things
- 9:44where, you know, Like we that we do with our fans.
- 9:47I just wanted we're going on sound, right?
- 9:49You all here is great. Make sure to let's keep the mics
- 9:52close. Oh and friends are showing up.
- 9:54Sorry to cut you off. I just knows mine.
- 9:56It's important that they hear us you know it's one of the thing
- 10:00here you. Yeah.
- 10:02So by the way I mean live performing is so let's actually
- 10:07for the audience here that doesn't know what patreon is.
- 10:09We can probably just give that run down before use that as a
- 10:11launching pad for the rest of gravitation.
- 10:13So why don't you give the the elevator for For B now, for
- 10:16billion dollar company patreon. Sure.
- 10:18Yeah, it's a membership platform that helps creators, run
- 10:22subscriptions, and in exchange, for exclusive content and
- 10:25Community with their fans. This is a way that a lot of
- 10:27craters have been kind of running businesses and building
- 10:29that that die-hard fan base and getting paid for it.
- 10:32Yeah. What like podcaster number one
- 10:36or what sort of, in terms of people running real like
- 10:39membership, businesses and generating revenue for you guys
- 10:42like what are sort of the greatest hits or and Is and then
- 10:45specific. So it's a lot of video, a lot of
- 10:48podcasting is a lot of visual artists and web comics but it's
- 10:53pretty Diversified. I mean it's folks across all
- 10:55types of categories at the end of the day it's like do you love
- 10:58your fans and do your fans love you back.
- 11:00Those are the creators that are crushing it and and you know
- 11:02doing a really good job. Yeah.
- 11:04I mean let's go back to the origins of patreon because I
- 11:06think I you and I kind of cross pass along like 2014, which is a
- 11:11very early days for patreon because we're just getting off
- 11:13the ground. So what was the?
- 11:15The inspiration for the app. Why did it need to exist?
- 11:17As far as you were concerned and what problem were you
- 11:19addressing? Yeah, I was solving a problem
- 11:23for myself, right? I had just finished like three
- 11:25months of working on this music video that cost me 10 grand.
- 11:29I trained my savings account to do this video.
- 11:32Well, I'm maxed out to credit cards.
- 11:34I built a replica of a man named Falcon cockpit in my studio.
- 11:38I work with this, like the video involved, this animatronic head
- 11:41and this 3D printed hexapod, robot.
- 11:43Like I went all out on this video.
- 11:45It's like Like, okay, go Aero. Yes music videos, right.
- 11:48It was like, remember that a feat of heroics, right?
- 11:52And and it's a video up on YouTube, can we find is up on
- 11:55YouTube and has over 2 million views?
- 11:57Like it was a thing that I knew was going to like reach my
- 11:59community. Like, people would be psyched
- 12:02about an excited about it. And I knew I'd upload this video
- 12:04and I get paid 150 dollars in ad revenue, and I was like, right,
- 12:07fuck this. I cannot keep doing this, right,
- 12:10right? So you're going to get 2 million
- 12:11views on YouTube and then, excellent.
- 12:13Okay. You can do, it has about.
- 12:14I think it was like, Tune into like sorry, sorry.
- 12:16Yeah, there's always number inflation.
- 12:18But yeah, it's getting $200, Instagram.
- 12:21Yeah, I think that, like over the lifetime of the video now,
- 12:23it's maybe like, maybe like, 800 bucks or 900 bucks, something
- 12:27like that. Right?
- 12:28And what saying, what year was this?
- 12:30This was 2013, okay? So like the YouTuber Creator
- 12:34economy was you know getting off the ground in a big way back
- 12:37then right? Like YouTube is trying to kind
- 12:39of cultivate these groups of people.
- 12:42They have the Creator program they were trying to make it
- 12:43happen. Yeah but it is.
- 12:45It clearly wasn't enough like why didn't you tubes own
- 12:47efforts? Give you the revenue and
- 12:50business that you thought you should have gotten.
- 12:53I think it's a matter of the business model on on YouTube.
- 12:58If I'm a fan of a Creator and suppose, I'm a die-hard fan of a
- 13:03crater suppose, I have all the shirts.
- 13:05I go to all the shows. I watch every single video.
- 13:09I follow them on Instagram. I'm like die hard fan of that
- 13:11crater when I watch that crater is video.
- 13:15Under the ad model. I'm essentially transferring
- 13:181/1000 of a CPM to that Creator in value, which is maybe pennies
- 13:23or less, even though I'm a DOT. Like I love this person and
- 13:28their video might change. My life doesn't fucking matter.
- 13:31It's 1/1000, you know, of a CPM that business model sucks.
- 13:37Right for individual creators. Yeah, turns out.
- 13:39It has some pretty big problems with Society at large as well,
- 13:42right? But for creators, it's not in
- 13:44the mediations. Yeah, it's not an efficient like
- 13:46economic engine to fuel their creativity, right?
- 13:48Yeah. And so when you actually start
- 13:51paid how soon after this YouTube video is patreon exist in some
- 13:55form. So, it's funny, I was working on
- 13:59the video leading up to patreon and it was before I posted the
- 14:04video that I was like, had this dark realization is like, this
- 14:09is the best thing I've ever made in my life.
- 14:11And I'm going to be paid less than $200.
- 14:14I won't do that. And that's when I simultaneously
- 14:16started working on the idea for patreon.
- 14:18I sketched out the ID on 14 pieces of printer paper.
- 14:21I sent it to my freshman year roommate in college.
- 14:23He looked at it was super inspired thought we should do
- 14:25this. I said great, let's do it right?
- 14:28And then he started basically engineering the first version of
- 14:32patreon. He's so he started you know?
- 14:33Riding the. He's listening to you by CTL.
- 14:36Yeah, okay. And and then we launched patreon
- 14:39with that video. That was the video where I post
- 14:42it on YouTube at the end of it. I put a little Vlog.
- 14:44I said, Everybody trying this thing.
- 14:47I think it could help a lot of people like you know, join me.
- 14:51How many members did you get you remember?
- 14:53Yes, within two weeks. I was making six figures as an
- 14:58artist. Wow.
- 14:59Which like you know right. I mean yeah like I didn't change
- 15:03my music through the monthly subscription.
- 15:06You like a shit. Exactly.
- 15:07Do you know, have you tried to see if any of those people are
- 15:09still giving you their money? Or did you cut it off or they're
- 15:12still? No.
- 15:13I have a date. Job now.
- 15:16So I don't post much on that account anymore.
- 15:18Actually, I haven't posted in like seven years on that
- 15:20account. Ironically, I built this thing
- 15:22to help me be a Creator and then I had to stop posting but I
- 15:26popped loose in scary pockets are very, very prolific, you
- 15:28know, so I'm actually making like a hundred music videos a
- 15:31year between those two bands but just not for my solo stuff.
- 15:34I don't have a team around. Those are on patreon like those
- 15:36are people that can sign up for ya the shit.
- 15:38Those are ya both bands. Have memberships and both bands
- 15:41are, you know, it's have active communities and are releasing
- 15:44weekly. And Elite Daily, both bands are
- 15:45releasing daily. Yeah, did you know that you
- 15:48wanted to go down the like the vent?
- 15:50Like raising through Venture Capital route?
- 15:51Because theoretically this is a business.
- 15:53You guys take. What is it?
- 15:5410 percent. We have three tiers of pricing
- 15:565. 8 and 12 5-12. Yeah.
- 15:58So, theoretically from day one you guys were producing Revenue
- 16:01like this was a real big boy business.
- 16:03Yeah, I mean, within a month, the company was profitable,
- 16:06right? Because it was, it was making
- 16:08money and Sam and I weren't taking salaries.
- 16:10And so yeah. And then there came a point
- 16:13where we were getting so much in Found so many emails.
- 16:17You know, we realized we needed to hire a team to kind of help
- 16:21with the operations of the business and that's when we
- 16:23started looking at options and trying to figure out, you know,
- 16:25do we need to raise money? Do we just hire people?
- 16:28Do we try and bootstrap it and yeah what?
- 16:31I mean, you really emphasize membership.
- 16:34Right. What distinction are you drawing
- 16:36there? I, you know, I'm in sort of the
- 16:38newsletter business, which is, you know, related to Media
- 16:41companies and there's much more of like They say subscription
- 16:44and you know, there's this sense that it's very clearly tied to
- 16:47like a recurring product, I don't know, what do you see is
- 16:50sort of the membership subscription lying?
- 16:53I think it's an emotional component that makes it
- 16:56different. A subscription is very
- 16:58transactional. Now there can be subscriptions
- 17:01that you deeply care about organizations that have missions
- 17:04that you really care about your voting with your dollars.
- 17:06You want to support them. But I think what distinguishes a
- 17:08membership is that it is deeply emotional.
- 17:12I'm paying Not just for exclusive content and Community.
- 17:15But I'm paying because this is something that I want more of in
- 17:18the world. It's a beacon of my identity.
- 17:21It's like a I'm a super fan of this thing.
- 17:24And I think the other the other component of it that's different
- 17:26is it allows structured tiered benefits that a crater can offer
- 17:30to their fans, right? So Creator can have three or
- 17:32four tiers of membership. Whereas the subscription is kind
- 17:36of just one thing for the exclusive content or you know,
- 17:40the box in the mail or whatever it is whereas membership is
- 17:42more. Holistic more about the
- 17:44community more about the emotion.
- 17:45You have tears of newcomer, right?
- 17:47You've embraced that model as well have monthly annual and
- 17:49then I have founding, which is just sort of you have a lot of
- 17:52money with water to give its right?
- 17:53Yeah. Yeah, that's cool.
- 17:55What do you call that validated? No sir.
- 17:57I got founding. It smelled a just like it is it
- 18:02is it is a surprise like oh wow, that's a little touch.
- 18:14Oh my God, I think I should be even more.
- 18:16Like, that's just funding your therapy at that.
- 18:18Right? You're on your own.
- 18:20I mean when you guys got going there was sort of like there was
- 18:23like the I feel like there's a lot of hype around like the
- 18:26kickstarter like crowdfunding thing right.
- 18:28And that's much more go. Go did towards like the Creator
- 18:32economy or the idea that these is actually people's jobs and
- 18:35less like one off. I mean have you how Have you
- 18:39actually seen a shift in like the mix of type?
- 18:42The types of projects you're doing or you feel like you're
- 18:44always on sort of that the Creator economy side rather than
- 18:48this? Because I'm sorry too.
- 18:50But I'll let you answer but like I have a cousin who created like
- 18:52a comic book and that was sort of like you know almost he did
- 18:57on patreon but it had sort of to me that sort of like Kickstarter
- 19:01feeling this like a one-off. I'm supporting him.
- 19:03Wasn't his main business. I don't know.
- 19:04How do you sort of? There are a lot of Trends there,
- 19:07you know, we hear less, I think about crowd.
- 19:09Any relatives or Creator economy now?
- 19:11Yeah, I think crowdfunding kind of had its day and it works for
- 19:15some things, but at the end of the day, it's a very different
- 19:18thing than what we're doing. You know.
- 19:21Crowdfunding is like I have this thing I want to do but I can't
- 19:24do it until I get funding. Whereas membership is like, hey,
- 19:27I'm doing this thing, it's working its media.
- 19:30And this is now an economic engine for media, and it's a
- 19:33subscription engine and a community engine, like all these
- 19:36things, whereas, you know, something like Kickstarter.
- 19:39Like I have this idea for a project and I need funding for
- 19:43it and it's this one off chunk and it allows me to do this
- 19:46other thing. It's just like a very different
- 19:47type of business model than like, I'm a crater, outputting
- 19:50regular stuff, and I'd like to be paid for that.
- 19:53And I'd like to build a business around that that's a little bit
- 19:55more, like something like the guardian or like New York Times
- 19:59subscription business and a little bit less like, you know,
- 20:03I need money to put on a play and I have this idea for a play
- 20:06happen. Do you think the crowdfunding?
- 20:07I don't hear as much about it. You know, I mean, for a time
- 20:10like in I used to cover media and there was a real thought or
- 20:13argument on the part of these companies that this was going to
- 20:16supplant, you know, big media companies because why couldn't
- 20:19it Creator, why do they need to go to Sony or Paramount or you
- 20:23know, Disney to say, give me money to make this thing.
- 20:25I want to do versus the audience that I already have.
- 20:28That might be excited about this idea.
- 20:29I mean, what, what happened to that?
- 20:31If you don't think it, you know, has Merit anymore, why not?
- 20:35Yeah, it's such a good question. I think there's actually not a
- 20:41ton of interest in most craters that I've talked to for
- 20:45crowdfunding it feels a little bit like Please help me.
- 20:50It feels a little bit like I can't do this unless I get
- 20:54funding, it's a little needy. I don't know, guarantee really
- 20:59that you're going to get it right?
- 21:00I mean honestly I don't think it's a scam but it's a real.
- 21:04I mean, it's an investment essentially which is not.
- 21:06It's not quite as clear cut an investment.
- 21:08I would assume like enough people did kick starters where
- 21:10they didn't pan out and stuff that there was a burnout from
- 21:13the funder where it's like, Oh, The Upfront model is dangerous
- 21:17where a patreon or any sort of Subscriptions.
- 21:19More tied to recurring output. Yeah, and I mean, I think the
- 21:24other thing about it is it's like a really heavy lift.
- 21:27Like I know a lot of creators who did these campaigns and then
- 21:32for three years afterwards, they were fulfilling physical, right?
- 21:36You get all the horny up front and then you're like, oh now I'm
- 21:39committed to this thing forever, that, and you assume a lot of
- 21:42risk in doing that. Like like to, I know craters who
- 21:45like two years later, they were getting like slips.
- 21:49German Customs saying like your package didn't go through like
- 21:53and then they're like, I have this person German, right?
- 21:55You're saying like Adidas, see like a company.
- 21:58And you have to scale instantly with no infrastructure.
- 22:00It's like it's a very difficult problem.
- 22:03Yeah. So I want to ask a question.
- 22:05I think everyone out here has probably been dying for me to
- 22:07ask this whole time. Which was why didn't you tube
- 22:10supplant patreon as a model, right?
- 22:12I mean what you guys the the reason that I think everybody is
- 22:16dying, my God. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 22:21I was gonna get you. Yeah, but I mean, like, the
- 22:28question was like, you know, when you're a platform business,
- 22:30especially when it was YouTube related, people would have
- 22:32assumed that they were just going to build that
- 22:34functionality into YouTube itself and they were going to
- 22:36crush you guys. I think I really like 50
- 22:39articles about that in 2014. Yeah, I kind of want to do the
- 22:42mean answer because I've had a beer and so what do the mean
- 22:47answer? The mean answer is they listen
- 22:50to two types of feedback lawsuits and competition and
- 22:55that's not exactly true. That's the mean answer.
- 22:57They actually have a really great product team.
- 22:59I mean, at the end of the day they do, it's just a matter of
- 23:02prioritization for them, and I understand why they didn't build
- 23:05this. I didn't understand, you know,
- 23:07before I started a product company, you know, now I
- 23:11actually do understand, I understand because the vast
- 23:14majority of their business comes from ads and this was not a
- 23:17priority for them, it's not there.
- 23:19Mission. Their mission is not to make
- 23:20sure creators make a living like that's not the mission of the
- 23:23company. They thought it was for a bit,
- 23:25right? I mean I think back to like I
- 23:26don't want to 12 the Creator spaces.
- 23:29I mean the hundred million investment in all the different
- 23:31channels. Yeah.
- 23:32But those are all means to an end.
- 23:34You know those are they were and I don't mean to talk shit about
- 23:36YouTube like it's a great company.
- 23:38I would not have a band or distribution or anything.
- 23:42I guess, I'm just offering that, like, all of those things were
- 23:47efforts to increase. Watch time.
- 23:49And right, like the primary kpi for the company was watch, time
- 23:53is watch time. That is what they're trying to
- 23:56do, right? So like look at the kpis and
- 23:59then you get a sense of like, how are they prioritizing?
- 24:01And what matters. And if you want to know,
- 24:03ultimately, if you really want to know a company's priorities,
- 24:06just look at the allocation of R&D.
- 24:08In the organization, just look at where their Engineers are
- 24:11working and in YouTube's case, they're working on ads, they're
- 24:14working on, watch time they're working on things,
- 24:16personalization recommendations algorithms.
- 24:18That's what they're trying to do.
- 24:19Do and I get it, I just and it makes sense.
- 24:21I think it's the right thing for them to do, it's their business.
- 24:24But I think you know, the problem still needs to be solved
- 24:27and somebody's got to solve it. I mean, you can look at patreon
- 24:32from so many different lenses. One is like this sort of Insider
- 24:35like yeah YouTube versus patreon versus some staggering.
- 24:39But there's also just I've heard you talk about this before.
- 24:42I mean, zooming way out. We have these assumptions about
- 24:46like bands selling CDs or like the Types of business models
- 24:50that fuel creatives. Like, I don't know.
- 24:53Do you like, do you think we take too much for granted like,
- 24:57this is the way like you run a band right now.
- 25:01Yeah, yeah yeah. We're convinced all that shit is
- 25:04bullshit is bullshit like nobody, nobody knows.
- 25:09Nobody knows that there's so many interesting new innovative
- 25:13business models around media right now, if you think about
- 25:15what's actually happened like the last 20 years, Art creation,
- 25:20Global art creation has shifted from The Real World into the
- 25:25digital world. You talking about NF, TS I know
- 25:29it makes me want to know your NF TV.
- 25:31Let him finish this. That I'm talking about the fact
- 25:34that like we used to like, make a living digitally, right?
- 25:38Like I said, the live performance aspect.
- 25:40This excluded is like, it's a minority of how we engage with
- 25:44our audience. Yes.
- 25:45And like now our art is infinitely replica.
- 25:49And no longer scarce, and that's why you're seeing things like NF
- 25:53teas and why you're seeing all these other like, you know,
- 25:56technological innovations. Because everybody's trying to
- 25:58figure out how does art survive in the day and age of of
- 26:03infinite replicability and infinite, like creation, right?
- 26:09So each infinite and reach infinite, reach and
- 26:11distribution, and the economics are still being figured out,
- 26:16right? That's why I like, people are
- 26:17excited about the crater. Economy is because Cuz it's
- 26:19there's finally a movement that's like raising their hand
- 26:22and saying, no ads are not good enough by themselves, that is
- 26:27not the answer. We need to figure this out as a
- 26:29species, do you worry? I mean, any new business model,
- 26:34has it could raise revenue a lot for the top creators, it could
- 26:38create more opportunity for a long tail.
- 26:41Yeah, I mean there's certainly resentment from some podcasters,
- 26:44you know like oh the best leftist comedy podcast gets like
- 26:47a ton of chopo choor. Coughs or whatever, you know,
- 26:50and then all the other sort of the long tail, it's just much
- 26:53harder. Same shit with sub stack to,
- 26:54right? I mean, they're not even
- 26:55claiming that like sub stack is a scam because you can look at
- 26:58Matt Iglesias, right? There's enough Edibles or are a
- 27:00newcomer the biggest create a newcomer like business do you.
- 27:04But I mean, do you think there's more of a using?
- 27:06There is more of a long tail with this new model, or do you
- 27:10think it's don't think so? I know.
- 27:12So I know so because I've seen the data looked at patreons,
- 27:16distribution of earnings by Creator and Um creators who were
- 27:20previously making a few hundred bucks on YouTube under the old
- 27:23model are now literally, making thousands of dollars in some
- 27:26cases tens of thousands of dollars and hiring executive
- 27:31teams and leasing office, space and building Studios.
- 27:34And the way I would describe it as the long tail as much longer
- 27:38and much taller. In other words, the the
- 27:42democratization efforts to empower and enrich creators have
- 27:48applied. To now hundreds of millions of
- 27:50people globally, and it's working.
- 27:53Now, will there be creators? Who haven't found content Market
- 27:57fit yet? Or only have, you know, a
- 27:59thousand fans or whatever it is and can't quite figure out the
- 28:02economics. That will always be the case and
- 28:07it's not that actually. Like I am very sympathetic to
- 28:10those craters. I was one of those craters for a
- 28:13very long time. I was trying to find fit and
- 28:15trying to find an audience and felt like I was speaking to
- 28:17avoid. And that Fucking sucks sucks,
- 28:20but it's hard for me to imagine a company that can solve that, I
- 28:26don't know that that can be solved.
- 28:27I think there will always be creative people who want to find
- 28:30an audience and can't seem to do that.
- 28:34Do you feel like it is patreons responsibility in any way to
- 28:37help with distribution and discoverability?
- 28:40Get us the hardest thing. Right?
- 28:41It's like I know what I'm doing is great.
- 28:43Yeah, I know an audience out there exists that wants to pay
- 28:45for it, but I don't know how to react them.
- 28:47Yeah. By the way, it's so funny.
- 28:50Like talking product strategy in this context, isn't it?
- 28:53Was like a really fun. All right, let's let's talk
- 29:01product strategy. Yeah, so you ask me if it's
- 29:06patrons, responsibility, do you feel present work on Discovery?
- 29:09So here's how I would frame it patreon, set out to solve a very
- 29:12specific problem. The specific problem we're
- 29:15solving was, there are creators, who are getting millions of
- 29:17views. Jurors who have incredible
- 29:20reach, but they're being undervalued by Society.
- 29:24Society was looking at this craters and saying, you're
- 29:26getting a million views. Here's a couple hundred dollars
- 29:29that's fucked up. Our responsibility is to fix
- 29:34that problem, because no one else was fixing that seven eight
- 29:37years ago. Now, there's turns out there's
- 29:39other companies that are trying to fix that as well, but our
- 29:42focus and our mission was to solve that problem.
- 29:47Here's where it gets interesting.
- 29:48Suppose we were to say, okay, we're actually not just going to
- 29:51solve that problem. We're going to try and help
- 29:54creators find audiences to begin with.
- 29:57That actually puts us in competition with YouTube.
- 30:00That puts us in competition with Facebook.
- 30:02That puts us in competition with Twitter.
- 30:05At the same time, I actually don't know that.
- 30:09That's a war that we would win. Like those businesses are solid
- 30:14businesses, they have moats, they have Network effects that
- 30:17make it very difficult to break into those worlds.
- 30:20I think patreons. Best bet at solving.
- 30:22This problem of crater payments is focusing very specifically on
- 30:27the problem of Creator payments and it's slightly different
- 30:30problem than audience and reach and so An effort to like Define
- 30:36the category and get into market and help creative people.
- 30:41We were very narrow and targeted with our focus on what problem
- 30:45we're solving. It's super interesting, you
- 30:47know, having my own newsletter sub stack, clearly has a can get
- 30:51hit from either side, right? If they take 10%, I'm and they
- 30:54don't give me distribution. I'm sort of resentful.
- 30:57Yeah, that they're taking so much right.
- 30:59On the flip side, we just saw. They launched an app and now
- 31:02it's like, oh, you're trying to sort of move me into Or Walled
- 31:05Garden a little bit. You know, then turn it smartly
- 31:08is that promising distribution at all.
- 31:10Like, yeah, the app you know it's much easier to read other
- 31:13newsletters when you're in it. You know, there is sort of and
- 31:16it's much more like will upsell You from One crater to the
- 31:19other. I mean, yeah.
- 31:20You see some stack is a competitor.
- 31:22I mean you're seeing more sort of we're going to sort of carve
- 31:25off part of your thing and try. And I don't know, it's call ins
- 31:30too small. But like David Sackett said
- 31:32their podcast apps or I don't know what what do you think?
- 31:35Sort of the so it's marketization.
- 31:37Yeah, it's the transition of a company from essentially being
- 31:40like a SAS company, to being a Marketplace company, right?
- 31:45It's like, I'm an enablement tool for individual sellers to
- 31:50sell things to their audiences, which is like a Shopify, but,
- 31:55like, look, what you would shopify's doing with the shop
- 31:57app, right? It's they're like, well, now we
- 31:59have all these sellers and we have all these products.
- 32:01We may as well build a Marketplace, and build, some
- 32:04demand, gen into our Engine for our own audiences, right?
- 32:07Like that's Shopify. That's what they're doing with
- 32:08the shop app and like sub stack is essentially doing a very
- 32:11similar thing. Just like look, our go-to-market
- 32:13like the, our wedge into the market, was solving this
- 32:15newsletter problem, but now we're going to build a
- 32:17Marketplace company that's going to help creators find new
- 32:20audiences and it's going to have Network effects for sub stack.
- 32:24I mean, I don't know this. I'm just, I'm guessing that
- 32:26that's probably what it is and it helps them build a moat and
- 32:29helps them build a fence ability.
- 32:30And so, I mean, I understand the move I think it's like a very
- 32:33smart move for the company. What about, what about?
- 32:36Oh, let me get the audience involved here.
- 32:37What about only fans? Yeah, I mean, what do you what
- 32:40do you for talking about porn now?
- 32:41Everything now, you guys, not only fans, you guys have your
- 32:44only fan setup. You don't have to tell me, I
- 32:48already pay. I mean, like they, by the way,
- 32:51charge less than you guys do right there fee.
- 32:53Is I think five percent know, they charge way more.
- 32:56It's 20%. That's what sorry.
- 32:58Yeah, I'm really off the beat well edit that out.
- 33:02So, only fan storage is 20%, Which is slightly.
- 33:05More than you guys charge. Oh, that's interesting.
- 33:07Yeah. Did they really charge 20%?
- 33:08Yeah, which is, you know, strategically is it gunshot?
- 33:11They charge less? I thought I was like 5 years.
- 33:13I read that somewhere, but it was corrected.
- 33:14Okay, interesting. So, you know, at that percentage
- 33:18level, you know, they're obviously going not
- 33:19intentionally, they claim to they'll go after anyone.
- 33:22But yeah, you know, 20% they feel like that's worth it for
- 33:26their audiences, it just because they're going after a group of
- 33:28people largely, you know, sex workers who you guys make a
- 33:32point of not allowing for on Patreon.
- 33:35Yeah, gosh. I think I'm in like default
- 33:40empathy mode or something right now, but I'm like trying to like
- 33:45understand why they do that. And I actually do understand why
- 33:48they do that. Yeah, I think it's like look,
- 33:54these are this is high risk content.
- 33:56It's expensive to process the payment processing fees on that
- 34:00type of content are much more expensive.
- 34:05Now they have a great business with like awesome margins and
- 34:08they're growing and it's that's awesome but it doesn't like I
- 34:13don't know that they could go much lower on that and still
- 34:16have a healthy business and they can trace your Capital.
- 34:20It seems like yes, they've had it probably have Runway so to
- 34:23speak. And again, I don't know, like
- 34:24I'm not into tried personally. So I don't know any of these
- 34:27things, I'm just talking out of my ass but like, yeah, I think
- 34:30at the end of the day, the risk is, why you don't allow why, why
- 34:32don't you allow that type of pants?
- 34:34So, When we make decisions like we've never allowed porn from
- 34:38from day one. Uh-huh.
- 34:40And it's like it's not a values decision.
- 34:42Like we have no problem with pornography.
- 34:44In fact, I'm really grateful that only fans exists as a
- 34:47company. Like this is a category of
- 34:49underserved people that need help and their industry fucking
- 34:53sucks. And their industry is unsafe.
- 34:56And it's abusive, right? And they need something like
- 34:59this so that they can like shift power and control.
- 35:02From these institutions toward these individuals sex.
- 35:05Workers who need this? I'm so glad that only fans
- 35:08exist. Now it has problems of course
- 35:10but like I don't know I'm hopeful that those problems will
- 35:13be solved in these people will be helped so why didn't we do
- 35:17that? And it's a really good question.
- 35:19We didn't do that because two reasons, not values-based
- 35:23reasons, we don't have problems with porn.
- 35:25It's that at the end of the day, it's much higher processing
- 35:29fees. It affects the like the type of
- 35:32business that we can run and how much we have to charge for it.
- 35:36We want to keep our prices super low.
- 35:38We don't want to take a ton of money for a taxi for like credit
- 35:40card companies, charge higher for products that are in that
- 35:44Arena. So it's at the end of the day,
- 35:45it's like category of processing, like what type of
- 35:48like gambling pornography. Like there's a whole category of
- 35:52the risks or yes, there's a whole category processing types.
- 35:54I have like a lot of chargeback fees and a lot of a lot of risk
- 35:58associated with the content and the payment processors have to
- 36:01pay higher fees themselves as a we have to pay our fees and
- 36:04trickles down to the The Creator.
- 36:05So that's reason number one. Reason number two is we call it
- 36:10mission risk. It's like what we're going out
- 36:13to do is help podcasters and video creators and webcomics and
- 36:17like all these creative people and the internet has a history
- 36:22of like when you allow pornography on your website it
- 36:25suddenly becomes a website for pornography, right?
- 36:28And like it's not that I don't like like I'm fine with that
- 36:31existing. It's just like, that's not the
- 36:33company I want to build. I don't want to build A porn
- 36:35company. I want to build a company that
- 36:36helps progress a source of great with only fans, right?
- 36:38Because I was writing about them in a time where they were really
- 36:40trying to spread the message to the media that were for a lot
- 36:43more than that. We're just like in the same way.
- 36:45You guys are a platform for creators.
- 36:47Yeah. But that's again totally
- 36:48aspirational. That was never going to happen
- 36:50but they were never Beyonce name.
- 36:52Dropped it in the song like they know.
- 36:53I mean they yeah but look at the context in which his name
- 36:56dropped its like I'm gonna start an only.
- 36:58It's like like it's like sexy. Well, the analogy that they were
- 37:02using at the time which was interesting and maybe not.
- 37:05Turret was like Snapchat Snapchat.
- 37:07Yeah was you know originally for dick pics.
- 37:09Yeah it was like what people assumed its use case one yes and
- 37:11then you know the argument that Evan and those guys were making
- 37:14his life. Well no it's not and most people
- 37:16aren't using it for that but I think they sort of saw that
- 37:19similar kind of transition like the dick pic at becomes the
- 37:21multibillion-dollar. Right?
- 37:22Messaging. App in the way that only fans,
- 37:24it's just a platform, right? Why couldn't it work, right?
- 37:28And in this particular case, I think it I don't want to call it
- 37:31a lost cause but like past the certain thresholds You know,
- 37:35even when like safer work quote unquote safer work, creators
- 37:39launch on only fans. The message is that they get
- 37:41from all the consumers on the website who have been trained to
- 37:44solicit for pornography, are sending them inbound messages
- 37:47saying, like, show us your feet, like, take off your shirt and
- 37:51these craters are like, know what that someone doing this,
- 37:54right? And it like it's a
- 37:55self-fulfilling prophecy to read Comics.
- 37:57You don't want to see my. Yeah exactly.
- 37:59Yeah, but so that's why we made the decision that we made and
- 38:04again It's not, it's not that like our hearts.
- 38:06Don't go out to those people and it's why I'm very grateful that
- 38:08only fans exist. It's just not the mission of our
- 38:11company. I wanted to ask the founders
- 38:13lever people for newcomer, get to see your feet.
- 38:15You know, I wanted to ask sort of a, the higher tier.
- 38:20I mean a recurring theme is sort of you're having empathy for
- 38:23other like product companies. Obviously you're like a CEO now
- 38:27your Co you've been a CEO for a while.
- 38:29You're CEO of a four billion dollar company.
- 38:30Yeah, I mean used to be like a musician, right?
- 38:33Where were you whistling? Music.
- 38:35Yeah, you can start your a lot with two music videos and we.
- 38:37All right. Yeah.
- 38:38All right. But like, I don't know.
- 38:40I'm curious like your own personal transformation.
- 38:42Yeah. I like doing the business.
- 38:44Yeah. Big like, were you sort of much
- 38:47more, skeptical of business? People back back.
- 38:51When you were mostly a musician or I, or were you always have
- 38:54sort of? I was standing.
- 38:56I was and I and not only skeptical, I was angry and I
- 39:02still am I still am angry? I think.
- 39:04A lot of companies. Make decisions that make me
- 39:08angry. And maybe the difference now is
- 39:11like, I understand why the decision was made, because I've
- 39:16seen how this works, and I've seen like things that, like, I
- 39:20just seen it like, oh, we have a product team.
- 39:22They focus on this Earth at that.
- 39:24Yeah. And and and so the transition
- 39:28has been, one of, it's been a humbling transition, like I This
- 39:35shit is hard. Like I have a lot of empathy for
- 39:38product managers that YouTube like they're serving 2 billion.
- 39:41People do not have empathy for you've been incredibly
- 39:43empathetic this whole conversation.
- 39:45Where did you go? That's fine.
- 39:50No, that's not true. I mean, I do, but but also, like
- 39:53what is happening, is so fucked up and evil and atrocious and it
- 39:58makes me really angry. And I wouldn't describe my
- 40:00feelings doesn't pathetic for that.
- 40:01Well, actually be, I can, I can I can tie this back in because
- 40:04there was a See a great article that came out the other day
- 40:06about when all these Western companies cut off support.
- 40:10Yeah, in Russia, you had, you know, a huge number of craters
- 40:13on only fans in Russia, right. I had no ability to continue
- 40:16their business, I mean, they're obviously a victim in a way of
- 40:19policy on the part of a lot of mere Putin.
- 40:23But what have you guys done anything in terms of your
- 40:26creators in Russia? Do you guys feel the need to do
- 40:29anything other than? Yeah, if you've done anything, I
- 40:31mean, do you feel responsible for them in any way?
- 40:33So I mean, yeah. We've We, you know, that there's
- 40:37been a like, a task force at patreon.
- 40:40That's been working on this for, you know, weeks and actually
- 40:43shout out to some patreon teammates who are here, who have
- 40:46been working on that task force. It's like a very difficult, very
- 40:51hard thing to be in the middle of and it's our first time as a
- 40:54company like experiencing a global event like this, you
- 40:59know, one thing that we did is we like waived fees for our
- 41:02Ukrainian creators for the next three months, just as an effort
- 41:05to like help and send more money to those craters and help them
- 41:08get through this. Not that I'm any creators in
- 41:10Ukraine. You guys, it's thousands,
- 41:12thousands of of creators that Ukraine and like including like,
- 41:16you know, like independent journalism that are like
- 41:18reporting on the war and and that's important.
- 41:23And so so yeah there's a team that's working as a team that's
- 41:26working on, you know, misinformation campaigns and
- 41:29trying to evaluate if anybody has, you know, but spreading
- 41:31that on patreon it, did you cut off just brushing creators or
- 41:35No. So actually a lot of that is
- 41:37happening regardless of what we're doing, right?
- 41:40So like a lot of the payment processing relationships and,
- 41:44you know, Bank relationships are just failing.
- 41:49Now, regardless of any decisions that patreon is making because
- 41:53they are, you know, because of sanctions because of banks
- 41:57pulling out because of processors pulling out.
- 42:00And so, you know, last month we saw a number of, of those
- 42:03transactions fail and we're expecting even more.
- 42:05More this next month because you know, even more companies have
- 42:09pulled out. Do you guys have creators in
- 42:10Russia? Yeah I do.
- 42:12Yeah. Had there been Payment
- 42:13Processing that was going through I don't know if there
- 42:15still are would you continue to offer service to them?
- 42:18Yes we would and we are I don't think individual creators should
- 42:25have to pay for the misdeeds of their authoritarian leader.
- 42:31I want to put that on Creative people.
- 42:33They met They may disagree with the War, I don't want to punish
- 42:38them for their geographic location and our team doesn't
- 42:42want to do that either. Like we are a Creator first, I'm
- 42:44going to push back on that. And I'm very sympathetic to that
- 42:46idea, but the pushback would just be, you know, it's a
- 42:49western world like foreign policy sort of agenda item to
- 42:53create as much trouble for Russia economically as possible.
- 42:57And that means yeah, if anybody is in, Russia's going to have a
- 43:00hard time like you just don't want to be part of that sort of
- 43:04like Crackdown. I mean, if there is a way we
- 43:08could punish Putin like great, right?
- 43:12But like this, the version of this podcast in Russia, like
- 43:18patreon, ceasing to support that this is.
- 43:21This podcast is is no. Yes, a clearly that would be a
- 43:24very important podcast right now.
- 43:26It but like you see the only voice of reason in Russia right
- 43:29now you have cats like I believe patreon empowers, the shift from
- 43:35companies and Regimes to individuals that is the like,
- 43:39that is a core element of what we do.
- 43:42So, so like that would send a terrible signal to the world and
- 43:47it would be the wrong choice for us to remove the livelihoods of
- 43:52creative people in the middle of like one of the most tumultuous
- 43:55Global events. Again, I that's just we would,
- 43:58we would never make that decision and actually, I realize
- 44:01it may be unpopular as a better than playing a moment
- 44:03controversial inside your company.
- 44:05No, it was Because we are. It's such a Creator first
- 44:09culture. Now, I'll tell you, we did
- 44:12debate, like, you know, suppose like Artie had had like
- 44:17distribution or how to funding, you know.
- 44:19Those are things that we would consider writing State back
- 44:22media propaganda. Campaigns course that like
- 44:27that's something that we have to be very careful about but an
- 44:30individual Creator who's making videos and making money.
- 44:34That's our mission. That's what we exist to do.
- 44:36And actually, Ali. I don't feel like being
- 44:39apologetic about that eating like I'm very proud but that is
- 44:41our stance and I believe in my heart that it's the right stance
- 44:45for patreon to take shift, shift, yeah, lighter topic.
- 44:51Yeah, that I do. I hey, it's very, I'm glad we
- 44:53hit on that territory. So it's important to talk about
- 45:05but nft Sort of touched on them before and I mean to some degree
- 45:09had ties to an earlier and of these in a way are like sort of
- 45:12the crowdfunding, right thing or like, right?
- 45:14There's a lot of like projects that seem to get a lot of money
- 45:17early before they've delivered, you know, it's like the board
- 45:21apes are popular but a lot of you talk to nft people.
- 45:23Yeah. Why are they so valuable?
- 45:25They're like, oh, that's going to be entering entree, into a
- 45:27great community. And we're gonna have a lot of
- 45:29things down the road, I don't know.
- 45:30Do you does do n ft's enter to your Calculus at all?
- 45:35And I'm sure curious. If you see See the same parallel
- 45:38to like the crowdfunding days with with some of the crypto
- 45:40projects. So, two thoughts on this first.
- 45:44Anything that helps creative people make money is interesting
- 45:50to us and we are excited about that because I want creative
- 45:56people to be compensated for their work.
- 45:59Like, what is happening globally right now is a labor problem.
- 46:03Like, craters are legitimate members of the workforce.
- 46:07And they're not being compensated for their
- 46:09contribution to society. That's unacceptable in my mind.
- 46:15Anything that addresses that I'm a, I want to learn about.
- 46:19I want to follow, I want to understand.
- 46:21And so of course we follow this whe under.
- 46:24We try to understand, we try to learn about it, we want to be
- 46:26very curious about these sorts of things that are emerging for
- 46:29craters. So that's the first thing.
- 46:32Second thing is with regard to end of TS.
- 46:38I'm I am excited about use cases.
- 46:41I am excited about value to creators regardless of the
- 46:48technology. Now, I think there are some
- 46:49technologies that are exciting blockchain and at ease etcetera,
- 46:53but we wouldn't do something for the sake of.
- 46:57Well, this is an exciting technology.
- 46:58Let's use it somehow. Let's leverage it, somehow
- 47:01that's not how we build things. We build things by thinking what
- 47:03is important for Creative people?
- 47:06What is valuable for Creative people.
- 47:08How can we help creative people make money?
- 47:11And so it may actually be that like some of those things are
- 47:16things that we evaluate and think about over the coming
- 47:18years. But we start with the business
- 47:21use case for Creative people and then we work backwards from
- 47:24there and art. Like would we consider things
- 47:27like entities, I think I think actually right now we're so
- 47:30focused on membership as a category, anything that isn't
- 47:33membership. We're not really working on.
- 47:36It's possible that something like And ftes or, or not even
- 47:40calling it an EFT. He's like, scarcity, I think is
- 47:43an interesting Concept in the day and age of digital Goods.
- 47:46But even a more interesting concept is the idea of access.
- 47:50And so it's interesting to us is like some people are using n FTS
- 47:52to say. Like, if you have this nft, you
- 47:54get into my Discord. That's really interesting.
- 47:56It's like it's not even about money that points about access.
- 47:59It's about because you have people working on that because I
- 48:02mean you could see the membership model to my Discord.
- 48:04That's a big perk. That's a that's a very big part.
- 48:06That's the thing you guys do a lot of what But had a greater
- 48:08that's what I mean by like benefits, right?
- 48:11That's less about the financing mechanism, then arises benefit.
- 48:14So say I want to discard with only like 100 people.
- 48:16Yeah, then I could sell if it sells to somebody else, right?
- 48:20I get like a cut of maybe the transaction, but it also means
- 48:23that the market in some ways going to solve.
- 48:26I mean, you're then only going to get your hundred richest
- 48:29fans, but I don't know yet. Is that so okay, so I think
- 48:33there's I think there's like three pieces of value to end of
- 48:38T's right now and I think there will be many more that emerge
- 48:42but the three pieces of value think first is like, access
- 48:47people are using that as access that is interesting.
- 48:52The second is like monetization of digital assets that is also
- 48:55interesting for like creative people.
- 48:57It helps them sell a thing. And then I think the third is, I
- 49:01know, they're not technically Securities, although, maybe that
- 49:03changes under Biden. Given the - order, but it is, it
- 49:09is an Essence, behave starting to behave like a security and
- 49:12that it is something that can grow in value.
- 49:14Over time, you are almost becoming an equity holder in an,
- 49:18in an asset. I mean, you are becoming a
- 49:20holder of an asset that that can grow in value.
- 49:25And all of those use cases are interesting.
- 49:26They're not patreons focus. They're not things that we're
- 49:29building into our product but they are.
- 49:30Do you have some person? Where are you working on this or
- 49:34so? I realize it probably sounds
- 49:37like I'm being very vague. I'm being vague because how we
- 49:40build things, how we built things that the company is not
- 49:44starting with a technology. It's starting with use cases.
- 49:46So, so when we hire people and think about these sorts of
- 49:49problems, we're going to hire people.
- 49:51And the charter will be give craters, leverage and control
- 49:56the charter of the team will be. How do we, how do we give
- 49:59craters? The ability to sell things to
- 50:01their fans? How do we give craters the
- 50:02ability to engage in digital Commerce?
- 50:05So how do we give craters the ability to own the relationship
- 50:08with their members? Now the team may or may not
- 50:10employ NFC technology or blockchain technology as they're
- 50:13like building those things but we don't start with this is our
- 50:17Block Chain team, okay? Team figure out how to use
- 50:20blockchain, you know we can be in Tech world where they're
- 50:23like, why not? And then ft but there is yeah
- 50:26they're like Gamers. Who is really repressed?
- 50:28Oh they're definitely start off a whole like, you know, arm of
- 50:30the company, doing Lyra like Facebook did, right?
- 50:32I mean, that's yeah. I mean So that's vase Lira Lira,
- 50:37right? Libra Libra, fuck movie and then
- 50:41it got shot. But I'm just saying, there's
- 50:43definitely a set of people would also be very angry if it says
- 50:46here at the Italian current. Yeah.
- 50:48Right. Which would be a great nft.
- 50:50That's like the opposite of view on any entity.
- 50:53Crippling personally, I don't really I don't want to have
- 50:56teeth. Yeah.
- 50:58Sorry I got us off track with this.
- 50:59What? Yeah, I wish I was more of an
- 51:01observation that there. It's not like there's a total,
- 51:03there is like a very rabid. Crypto Pro camp, but then, I
- 51:07mean, you have comic book artists and game developers.
- 51:09Like, those types of people have fans that might be very angry at
- 51:13patreon. If you were to sort of dip your
- 51:15toe, in those Waters. Yeah, there are.
- 51:19And and, and like, even like I did a podcast, I don't know, 12,
- 51:25like three months ago or so, And I just talked about and ft's,
- 51:31like, all I do is talk about Nazis and I didn't even talk
- 51:33about drove out. The value of n of t, i do.
- 51:36I asked an investor about NF T's on the podcast.
- 51:40I didn't even talk about them and it, you know, there's
- 51:42speculation and concern, along lot of brothers, I've even
- 51:45realize it. So you've got in the heat.
- 51:47Yeah, so already, we were yeah, of course.
- 51:50Yeah. I mean it's yeah, we've only got
- 51:52a couple minutes left, I think. Yeah.
- 51:54So I want to get to the maybe like a couple last topics before
- 51:57we can turn it. Audience, if anybody here has
- 51:58some questions too. But I want to talk about the
- 52:01only thing that Eric and I actually care about which is
- 52:02journalists greater. That's right.
- 52:05Yeah, we waited till the end, our budget, we're like several
- 52:08weeks into this endless cycle about whether journalists are
- 52:11Brands and whether journalists are creators.
- 52:13Now, you know, what about Taylor?
- 52:14The rent in, get her to engage with you on Twitter honor, the
- 52:18topic, the broader topic, we render wait, you said whether
- 52:22crate, whether journalist Our Brands or create, these are very
- 52:25small. You probably don't have to
- 52:26follow this, but Taylor Lorenz basically said my name's, all
- 52:30right, but she said that you're a lesser Brands and then a bunch
- 52:34of old schools are like White House.
- 52:35Maggie Haberman to the world, really like push back on it and
- 52:39was like you know, because they just don't want to think of
- 52:41themselves as a brand because it sounds very like Creator.
- 52:45I don't know. It's just such a like it's a
- 52:48Flashpoint word. So that's that sort of the fight
- 52:51that's happening. Sort of in on the journalism
- 52:53Twitter Wars at the moment relates.
- 52:55Very much to where you came from and the hole.
- 52:57Greater economy because it's this question of like, do we
- 53:00exist as employees as part of larger?
- 53:03Institutions, do we work for them?
- 53:04Or can we work this? Quasi independently of it?
- 53:07That gives us more job security or leverage that if we want to
- 53:11go off on our own or or create some some kind of income that
- 53:15exists Beyond just the brand of the New York Times or the post
- 53:19or Insider, okay? Super interesting concept.
- 53:27So A couple thoughts on that there, I hear kind of to two
- 53:32issues there. The first is like can
- 53:34journalists develop independent followings and of course option,
- 53:40right? Obviously do journalists need to
- 53:43be a part of larger institutions and Leverage.
- 53:45The the reach from those institutions historical, reach
- 53:50know obviously that is changing but the more interesting part of
- 53:55I think what you what you just said is like The distinguishing
- 53:59characteristics between this concept of a brand and the
- 54:03concept of a Creator. Exactly.
- 54:05And what I would argue is that those are very fucking different
- 54:08things, very different. A brand is consistent.
- 54:15It has Brand values. It builds trust, it has decks of
- 54:20like its style and it's voice and what it sounds like and if
- 54:24it were a person, what kind of genes would it wear like That's
- 54:28what brands are brands are not human beings.
- 54:33They're not great. I love this.
- 54:34Yeah, like a journalist creators are fucking people.
- 54:39They're inconsistent, they're human, they're beautiful,
- 54:43they're frail, they're smart, they're stupid, they're
- 54:45strategic, they are impulsive. They're human beings.
- 54:50And I think what one problem that I think is a pretty big
- 54:54problem is, we're all trying to behave.
- 54:57Like Brands today and brands are corporations, like, we don't
- 55:03have to be marketing, France. Yes, it's crazy to me.
- 55:05How much that is infected normal conversation?
- 55:08I mean, I guess I'm a tune to it because I've written about
- 55:09advertising, it does not need to be a thing that regular people
- 55:12talk about know. It's a thing.
- 55:14You used to sell jeans? Yes.
- 55:16Yeah, and it also frankly, it's only we're content by the way,
- 55:20it's not yet. It's a terrible content is not
- 55:23life, right? You know, but but we are, it's
- 55:26ineffective. Brands have lower trust than
- 55:30they've had in many many years except for the people that liked
- 55:33it. What do you mean by that?
- 55:36Well, I mean, like, the people that ascribe themselves to a
- 55:38specific brand, they trusted another, I would argue there are
- 55:43fewer people who do that now. Like, if you look at consumer
- 55:46trust, it's been dropping for a long time.
- 55:50And then, you have to ask, why are we all trying to behave like
- 55:54Brands if brands are losing trust and mass right now?
- 55:58Like I think about identity, I think people have chosen to
- 56:00identify the specific brand not brand, right?
- 56:03Like identity is personal, it's human.
- 56:05But you could draw a distinction between like authenticity and
- 56:09like intentionality or something with intentionality.
- 56:12Yes being closer to a brand and I don't know, I run a media
- 56:16company there. Like some days I'm like
- 56:19depressed. I'm like I don't know what I'm
- 56:20supposed to write. I don't always just like send
- 56:23that out as an email. I like think like oh what a my
- 56:25brand is professional. Yes to be the founders to you.
- 56:29You're so I do feel like there's like a school of the Creator
- 56:31world that would say you should just be authentic.
- 56:33Look at the end of the day. It's up.
- 56:35To a crater to decide what they want to do.
- 56:37I think there is value to some craters building Brands.
- 56:39I'm not going to say every Creator should just fucking be
- 56:42themselves, no matter what, like some people would be like, I
- 56:45don't want to follow the person. I want to follow this thing.
- 56:48That is exciting about them. That's like, something that
- 56:50would be, you know, on the interest graph as opposed to
- 56:53like a, you know, friends. But I would argue that like, for
- 56:57me my favorite artists, like my favorite artists are the people
- 57:03who are unabashedly. It's all of the good, all of the
- 57:07bad, all of the dark, all of the pessimism, and all of the
- 57:11optimism. All at once when you watch a
- 57:13prince music video, that fucking guy is just himself, no matter
- 57:18what, and I don't want him to behave like Walmart.
- 57:23I want him to be Prince and like my favorite creators.
- 57:27I want them to be themselves and I want them to feel human and I
- 57:31want them to not feel trapped by their brand values.
- 57:35So like I did get some mistake for everybody to think I need a
- 57:39personal brand. I need a Creator Brent, like
- 57:42just be yourself but it's fun. I think that's that's a great
- 57:45and why? I think I okay.
- 57:46All right. Thank you.
- 57:47Let's get a round of applause. Thank you very much Jack for
- 57:50coming. Thank you for all listening to
- 57:52us. We really appreciate it.
- 57:54That was dead cat. You can check out our podcast.
- 57:57It's distribute on the like And subscribe.
- 57:59We're Creator us. I wouldn't say we're a brand
- 58:02after that speaketh, but I do know I'm like, no.
- 58:05Not a brand-new monetize Buddha. No, it's not, sorry, it's okay
- 58:09to be a brand. I think some people need Brands
- 58:11because they're following the thing that the brand cares
- 58:13about. That's totally legit.
- 58:14Have you want to get it? Discusses, I have a lot of 30
- 58:19minutes. It's gonna be fun.
- 58:20We're gonna have buzzers, we're going to be seized testing their
- 58:23knowledge about startups and Venture Capital.
- 58:25So stick around. Thanks buddy.
- 58:28You guys later. So what comes Sally?
- 58:41Goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye,
- 58:45goodbye. Goodbye.
- 58:41Goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye,
- 58:45goodbye. Goodbye.