Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Advanced Trial Tactics: Punitive Damages Business Torts with Lynn Fiorentino, Malcolm McNeil, Hillary Johns
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to Advanced Trial Tactics. How do you
- 0:05get those punitives? And this is punitive damages
- 0:08as to business torts. And today we have back
- 0:11our dynamic duo, which is our beloved Malcolm
- 0:15McNeil, VHB's past president on so many boards
- 0:19in the Saturday Illustrious career, and just
- 0:20a great guy. So Malcolm has over 35 years of
- 0:23litigation and commercial experience in a wide
- 0:26variety of matters, including business, commercial,
- 0:28construction. employment disputes, administrative
- 0:31proceedings, trade secrets, probate media and
- 0:33entertainment, intellectual property, partnership
- 0:35disputes, and real estate. Malcolm has over 25
- 0:39years in resolving civil disputes as a mediator
- 0:41and panel mediator of the United States District
- 0:43for Central District of California, as well as
- 0:45having a very admirable international practice.
- 0:49Malcolm is litigating issues for a variety of
- 0:51businesses, including those in venture capital
- 0:53formation, retail, entertainment. textile manufacturing,
- 0:57import -export, real estate investment, aviation,
- 1:00and publishing. He is keenly aware of the legal
- 1:02and business needs that enable his clients' business
- 1:04to keep moving forward. He also has experience
- 1:07in cross -corner negotiations, has had an established
- 1:09network of colleagues globally, assisting foreign
- 1:12countries as needs arise. Malcolm's practice
- 1:15has included repositioning clients in most forms,
- 1:17including a range of administrative work, statewide
- 1:20and nationally, and and internationally as well.
- 1:24Known for his leadership and accomplishments,
- 1:26particularly for clients with business interests
- 1:29in China, Malcolm is a panel member of the Shenzhen
- 1:32Court of International Arbitration, the Beijing
- 1:34International Arbitration Commission, and the
- 1:37Harvard Arbitration Commission. Malcolm served
- 1:39as the co -leader of Aaron Fox's International
- 1:41Group and is the, as we know, past president,
- 1:43one of our past presidents. And Lynn is a partner
- 1:47at Aaron Fox, and she and Malcolm have tried
- 1:51several cases together. Lynn heads up one of
- 1:54the several departments in Aaron Fox's San Francisco
- 1:58office, with often trips to Los Angeles, and
- 2:01is also the co -leader for the firm's consumer
- 2:04products industry group. Besides her knowledge
- 2:07in the subject matter, she's co -chaired and
- 2:08handled cases involving these issues with Malcolm
- 2:10and other attorneys. and her experience is broad
- 2:15and runs through the broad gamut of sectors and
- 2:18industries. So I'm going to turn this over to
- 2:21Malcolm and Lynn promptly. Malcolm and Lynn,
- 2:23we're really looking forward to a nice presentation.
- 2:26Well, thank you for that very generous introduction,
- 2:30Hillary. That's wonderful. And yes, first of
- 2:32all, good morning, good afternoon or good evening
- 2:35to you wherever you may be when you're watching
- 2:37this program. Yes, it's Lynn and I's both our
- 2:42honor as well as our lots of fun time to work
- 2:45together to talk about these topics that we hear
- 2:47about as lawyers, but we don't always know exactly
- 2:51how they interplay in actual practice. Our last
- 2:54program actually broke it was a one one session
- 2:58program which we ended up breaking into two sessions
- 3:01on BMP code section 17200 and that's because
- 3:04of the density of the material we had a lot to
- 3:07go through and wanted to make sure that we are
- 3:09completely explaining those things would be necessary
- 3:12for you to for you to either present or defend
- 3:15a 17200 claim so guess what As we put together
- 3:19this program on punitive damages and business
- 3:22torts, we started reading cases and said, oh,
- 3:25what about this one? What about this one? What
- 3:27about this one? And the next thing you know,
- 3:29we prepared a PowerPoint, which is comprehensive
- 3:32and formidable. And how that happened is that
- 3:36we were both experienced practitioners. But the
- 3:39real issue is that when you talk about punitive
- 3:42damages with colleagues who have not necessarily
- 3:45had to make the actual plunge into proving punitive
- 3:48damages at trial, there's a lot of mystery around
- 3:52the punitive damages, a lot of lore. You'll hear
- 3:55somebody say that the limitations are 10 times
- 3:58the compensatory damages. 30 times, you'll see
- 4:01an article in the paper saying $65 million reward.
- 4:05And clients have their own opinions about what
- 4:07should be the punitive damages in their given
- 4:09case. So what we tried to do is to put together
- 4:12a program that was going to help you to dissect
- 4:16both from a plaintiff standpoint and a defense
- 4:18standpoint, the whole concept of punitive damages
- 4:21and how you apply it in court. So I'd like the
- 4:24next slide, please. That's just us. That's Lynn
- 4:28and Malcolm and how to get a hold of us at some
- 4:31point in time. And this is the agenda for today.
- 4:33The agenda in the first session is going to be
- 4:36what constitutes malice, oppression, despicable
- 4:39conduct and fraud. The problem when you read
- 4:42those is when you read them together they sort
- 4:44of blend together and you sort of think of the
- 4:46same conduct. But the case is explained very
- 4:50clearly that each one of those words has a separate
- 4:53connotation and denotation when you're in court
- 4:57and the evidence to support each one is quite
- 4:59different. The starting point that we're going
- 5:02to go through is establishing the basics through
- 5:04our two jury instructions. That's Casey 3943
- 5:08and 3945. They're very, very, very similar. So
- 5:11we won't talk too much about the distinctions
- 5:13between the two, but we will talk about what
- 5:16Casey requires that you prove in order to get
- 5:19to the punitive damage phase of your case. Determining
- 5:23punitive damages, that's our third factor. The
- 5:25factors to consider. what strategies you should
- 5:28have as a plaintiff, and finally, what strategies
- 5:31you should have as a defendant to defend against
- 5:33those. Then of course, we'll open it up for questions.
- 5:38Let's have the next slide, please. Malcolm, if
- 5:40I could just add quickly on the agenda, which
- 5:42I just realizing it's not on there. We also have
- 5:45a couple of hypotheticals to go through at the
- 5:48end where we can really apply some of these facts
- 5:52that you need to prove punitive damages. to the
- 5:57law. And so that'll be interesting to see very
- 6:01different types of scenarios and cases where
- 6:04punitive damages may or may not apply. No, absolutely,
- 6:08Lynn. And that may be where our viewers and listeners
- 6:11are going to end up. You'll see a breaking point
- 6:15at some point in the program because we need
- 6:18to get you through the basics before we get to
- 6:21our examples. But we have specific examples for
- 6:24you and also specific examples as applied to
- 6:27existing cases. Thank you, Lynn. Since Lynn wanted
- 6:33to jump in, I'm going to let her jump in right
- 6:35now. Go ahead, Lynn. Why did you start by giving
- 6:37us the basics? Sure. Just for everybody's edification,
- 6:42and you may remember this code section from prior.
- 6:46cases or reviewing the case law, but the basic
- 6:49rule that sort of overlays this whole jurisprudence
- 6:53is in the Civil Code in Section 32 -94A. And
- 6:57what that section says is that when you have
- 7:00a case not arising from a breach of contract,
- 7:03so here we're talking about business torts. Again,
- 7:06this is kind of an extension of the prior programs
- 7:09that we've done over the last several months
- 7:11or maybe a year, whether it's, you know, interference
- 7:15with contract or 17200 or something like that,
- 7:20where the plaintiff is able to prove by clear
- 7:24and convincing evidence, that's your standard
- 7:27of proof, that the defendant has engaged in oppression,
- 7:32fraud, or malice, and we're going to get into
- 7:34each of those, what they mean, then the plaintiff,
- 7:37in addition to seeking its compensatory damages,
- 7:41may also recover damages that are there to punish
- 7:46the defendant. We call those punitive damages,
- 7:48as everybody knows. That's the basic rule. You've
- 7:52got to have malice, fraud, or oppression, or
- 7:55despicable conduct. That's not actually listed
- 7:58here, but that's another factor that can be used.
- 8:01You have to prove it by clear and convincing
- 8:03evidence. That sometimes gets lost in the discussion.
- 8:09We all live normally day by day. under a preponderance
- 8:13standard. Most of our cases in the civil world
- 8:15are preponderance standards of proof unless you're
- 8:21practicing in criminal law, which if you are
- 8:23obviously that's beyond a reasonable doubt. Clearing
- 8:25and convincing is somewhere in between and so
- 8:28it is going to require a higher level of proof
- 8:31than just your regular preponderance standard.
- 8:33So this is the basic rule that you want to keep
- 8:35in mind. So I'm going to break down each of these
- 8:39malice, fraud, oppression, and despicable conduct.
- 8:42If we could go to the next slide, please. What
- 8:47constitutes malice? As Malcolm noted, a lot of
- 8:50these terms, malice, fraud, oppression, despicable
- 8:53conduct, they do start to blend. It's really
- 8:56not until you get into the cases where you can
- 8:59actually see the factors at play and see where
- 9:03there are distinctions and differences. Generally
- 9:06speaking, and this comes out of the jury instruction,
- 9:10malice is where a defendant, whether it's an
- 9:14entity or an employee of a company, maybe it's
- 9:18a manager of a company. We've got a case that
- 9:20we're going to talk a little bit about today,
- 9:22and Malcolm's going to talk about it. It's involving
- 9:24Ralph's grocery store. And in that case, there
- 9:27was a manager who engaged in some sort of unbecoming
- 9:31conduct, if you will. And we'll get into that.
- 9:35Malice essentially means that a company or an
- 9:39employee of an entity acted with the intent.
- 9:43Intent is key here for malice. It's got to be
- 9:46in an intent to cause injury to someone else
- 9:50or that the conduct was despicable. We'll get
- 9:54into what despicable means. knowing disregard
- 10:00of the rights or safety of another. This term
- 10:03malice really is rooted in intentional conduct,
- 10:08as you can tell by the definition, a willing
- 10:12and knowing disregard of someone else's rights
- 10:15or safety, what comes to mind, chemical exposures,
- 10:21purposeful. We see these cases a lot with back
- 10:27in the 80s, maybe, where we had a lot of the
- 10:31rollover accidents, where it was alleged that
- 10:34the vehicles were purposely designed in a way
- 10:37that subjected people to the car to rollover
- 10:41and people were killed or became paralyzed from
- 10:46these accidents. That's what we're talking about
- 10:48here, that knowing and willful disregard of somebody
- 10:52else's rights or safety. It's really just horrendous
- 10:56conduct, if you think about it. And the person
- 11:01who's engaging in the conduct has to be aware
- 11:04of the probable dangerous consequences of that
- 11:06conduct. And they deliberately fail to avoid
- 11:09the consequences. They know that what they're
- 11:12engaging in is likely to cause injury or death
- 11:15or harm to someone else, and yet they go ahead
- 11:17and they do it anyway. There's going to be a
- 11:19case we're going to talk about involving Roundup.
- 11:24And you may remember the Monsanto Company and
- 11:27some of the litigation that went along with that.
- 11:29And I think that one is a really solid example
- 11:33of malice. And we'll get into that a little bit
- 11:35later. All right. If we could go to slide six,
- 11:39please. All right. So oppression. What constitutes
- 11:44oppression? If you remember back to the basic
- 11:46rule we had. You've got to show as the plaintiff
- 11:50either malice, fraud, or oppression in order
- 11:53to demonstrate the recoverability of punitive
- 11:58damages. Again, clear and convincing evidence.
- 12:00So what's oppression? Under the statute, oppression
- 12:04essentially means that a defendant, an entity,
- 12:09a corporation, an LLC, or an agent of a company,
- 12:14an employee of a company, any of those combinations
- 12:19of people and organizations, the conduct was
- 12:23despicable and it subjected the plaintiff to
- 12:26cruel and unjust hardship in knowing disregard
- 12:31of their rights. This is a bit of an overlap
- 12:34with malice in that the knowing disregard of
- 12:38someone else's rights is at play. Whereas with
- 12:41malice, what we saw was the knowing disregard
- 12:44of the rights or safety, specifically the term
- 12:48safety was used. With oppression, the term safety
- 12:52is not used, but the term disregard of someone
- 12:55else's rights is used. I think, Malcolm, are
- 13:00we going to see an example of this with the Ralph's
- 13:03case? I'm trying to remember if you could remind
- 13:05me. Yes, well actually it's a common combination
- 13:09and we there's a case called gober versus Ralph's
- 13:13Grocery Company and I think this is a good place
- 13:15to. May I interject on that then, Lynn? Please,
- 13:19yes. Absolutely. Great. Great. Gober was an interesting
- 13:23case because there was a manager who was a little
- 13:25bit too touchy -feely and a little bit too belligerent
- 13:28and hostile. And he was a manager of a store.
- 13:32They then called him store directors. And he
- 13:35was transferred from store to store and eventually
- 13:37ended up in the Escondido store. There were three
- 13:40sets of plaintiffs. that were making claims at
- 13:44different points in time. But they were all joined
- 13:47together for purposes of this case. And what
- 13:50happened was that Ralphs ended up... they got
- 13:56a huge award against Ralph's. I won't talk about
- 13:58the specifics, but Ralph's of course went in
- 14:01on a remitted or in a J -O -N -O -V and the plaintiffs
- 14:04came back and said that they wanted the awards
- 14:08to be undisturbed, et cetera, and went up on
- 14:10appeal. And for those of you that read it, it
- 14:12was a very complicated procedural history in
- 14:14the case because there were several different
- 14:16post -judgment motions that were going on at
- 14:19the same time. But one of the most important
- 14:22things in the case is that the court talked about
- 14:26the conduct of Ralph's, that it transferred the
- 14:30manager in conscious disregard of rights, but
- 14:33that it was basically a minimal conscious disregard
- 14:36of rights because Ralph's also attempted to take
- 14:39the manager and put him in other positions. They
- 14:43demoted him. They changed his income level to
- 14:48less than half of what he was making as a director.
- 14:51So what the court said is that there were no
- 14:53There were no facts in the case which caused
- 14:56the conduct of Ralphs and placing a manager there
- 15:00to begin with as despicable. And now none of
- 15:03it could be characterized as despicable. And
- 15:06it went on to say that despicable could have
- 15:08meant that if Ralph's placed him in position
- 15:10and they did nothing to change the behavior at
- 15:14any time, then that would have been a different
- 15:17story and perhaps a higher level of culpability.
- 15:20And if there is such a word, despicability in
- 15:23the case. So it gives you a very good example
- 15:27that when you're looking at the facts of your
- 15:30case and you're trying it, Is there anything
- 15:32that you can demonstrate as a plaintiff to show
- 15:36that the conduct was despicable, meaning that
- 15:39it was just, it was abhorrent that any juror
- 15:41is going to wince when they hear it? Or on the
- 15:44defense side, you're going to want to show that,
- 15:46no, we took remedial actions. We weren't despicable.
- 15:49What we in fact did was you did steps A, B, and
- 15:52C. And that's the basic, and by the way, Ralph
- 15:56sent it up, the damages were reduced, et cetera.
- 16:00We'll talk about awards and percentages later.
- 16:03But the point was is that the case is very instructive
- 16:06on the issue of what it takes to rise to the
- 16:08level of despicable. Thank you for that, Malcolm.
- 16:12That's a great example. I think what was also
- 16:14interesting about that case, when we look at
- 16:16the despicability, if that's even a term, of
- 16:20the manager's conduct. This was a guy who threw
- 16:24a phone at a female bookkeeper. He engaged in
- 16:29conduct. Obviously, he was accused of making
- 16:32profanities at people, throwing objects at people,
- 16:37physically harming them. There was one allegation
- 16:42that he hurled a plastic shield about the size
- 16:45of an envelope at someone's face. There's some
- 16:48pretty nasty behaviors going on there. I think
- 16:52it is factually a really interesting case to
- 16:56look at through the lens of some of these elements,
- 17:00whether it's suppression, malice, or what have
- 17:03you. Thank you for. One distinction to that too,
- 17:08then you're quite right. And what they what the
- 17:10court was doing is it was also applying that
- 17:12standard to what was it that Ralph's knew and
- 17:15what did Ralph's do? I think everybody sort of
- 17:18agreed his manager was a loose cannon, to say
- 17:22the least. And as a consequence, that loose cannon,
- 17:25the question was to what extent was Ralph's responsible
- 17:28for his behavior or did they know that he was
- 17:30going to be throwing phones and belittling people
- 17:34and being belligerent and hostile and all of
- 17:36that, including, and with all of the normal,
- 17:39harmful and offensive touching that we know about
- 17:41in the... unemployment cases. So there's a distinction
- 17:46between what the defendant does and what the
- 17:48entity does. The knowing piece of it is key,
- 17:51I think, for punitive damages, as we can see
- 17:53from these elements, these just basic elements
- 17:56that you have to prove under the civil code.
- 17:58And we're going to get more into some of that
- 18:00later. But certainly, in a case like Ralph's
- 18:04as well, you have patterns of behavior. which
- 18:09becomes relevant to punitive damages. We're going
- 18:11to get into that. These are things just for the
- 18:14audience to be thinking about as we go through
- 18:16the very mundane elements of the outset to really
- 18:21diving in deeper. All right. That's oppression.
- 18:25Let's go ahead and jump, if we could, to the
- 18:28next slide. prove punitive damages. We've already
- 18:39been talking about this in conjunction with the
- 18:41Ralph's case. But if you think about it, it's
- 18:44really any conduct that the average ordinary
- 18:48person would find to be so vile, base, or contemptible
- 18:52that it would be looked down upon by ordinary
- 18:55people, reasonable people. And the examples we
- 18:58just gave, you know, just pulling them right
- 19:00out of the Rouse case, I mean, you know, throwing
- 19:03objects at other people, profanities, you know,
- 19:07maybe profanities aren't quite as despicable,
- 19:09but you get the idea of something that is just,
- 19:13it's so vile. that you're going to be frowned
- 19:15upon by the ordinary citizen. So that's really
- 19:19despicable conduct in a nutshell. All right.
- 19:23Let's go to the next slide if we could. And then
- 19:28another way, as a plaintiff, you can prove punitive
- 19:31damages is through fraud. And we obviously all
- 19:34sort of know what fraud is. We talked about it
- 19:36in our 17200 presentation as well, because that's
- 19:40one way to prove a violation of 17200. a hundred
- 19:45and essentially, you know, engaging in intentional
- 19:49misrepresentations as a defendant or an employee
- 19:53of a defendant or a high ranking officer, director
- 19:56of a company we see. punitive damage cases brought
- 20:01all the time where there's conduct that's ratified
- 20:04by an officer, a director, and it's fraudulent
- 20:07misrepresentations to a consumer, for example.
- 20:11In the case of consumer products, if you will,
- 20:17there have been a number of cases over the years
- 20:19where a company has concealed from the public
- 20:24that certain products, I put out there the example
- 20:27of talc. You know, Johnson and Johnson had some
- 20:31very serious awards, peer damage awards against
- 20:34it. Everybody may remember from the lawsuits.
- 20:38over the last many years where it was alleged
- 20:40that the talc products that it manufactured had
- 20:44asbestos in it and that they knew it and that
- 20:46the company knew it was harmful and dangerous
- 20:48and yet didn't warn, didn't warn citizens of
- 20:51that. So that's a clear example of the fraudulent
- 20:54side of punitive damages and where as a plaintiff,
- 20:59you would marshal evidence to show in discovery,
- 21:03for example, you would want in that type of a
- 21:05case, you would want to seek historical internal
- 21:09communications going back many, many years when
- 21:12product formulas were being put together and
- 21:15what kind of scientific literature was reviewed
- 21:18by the company and its epidemiologist or its
- 21:22toxicologist or what have you to show that the
- 21:24company knew. They knew that this product, for
- 21:26example, had asbestos in it and that the asbestos
- 21:29could have been harmful to humans, but that they
- 21:32didn't warn the public. clear -cut example of
- 21:35fraud. And there's other ones as well, but I
- 21:37think fraud is probably the most obvious of the
- 21:40punitive damage factors. to be discussing. So
- 21:44those are really the key, again, the basic rule,
- 21:47and then malice, fraud, oppression, and despicable
- 21:49conduct. Were you going to? Yeah, Lynn, thank
- 21:53you. I just wanted to jump in because I recently
- 21:56completed a case, and it's over, which involved
- 22:00a partnership dispute. And one of the allegations
- 22:02against one of the partners was fraud, that they
- 22:05were stealing money from the other partner. And
- 22:07I think that's a Let's say a little bit of a
- 22:11garden variety case that we all run across from
- 22:14time to time that that is occurring as the it
- 22:17is it was clear from the facts of the case that
- 22:21the partner who was allegedly stealing. was in
- 22:25fact, he was tipping the scale in his own favor.
- 22:30But the judge found that the tipping of the scale
- 22:33was more inadvertent and negligent and found
- 22:36it to be a breach of fiduciary duty, but not
- 22:39a breach of fiduciary duty that rose to the level
- 22:42of fraud. which was interesting because what
- 22:45that means to you is if you're representing a
- 22:47plaintiff in a fraud case, you want to look at
- 22:50a pattern of misbehavior that shows that you
- 22:52can imply from the nature of the misappropriation
- 22:59that in fact what happened was that it was done
- 23:03as a pattern. If it's not a pattern and it's
- 23:06an intermittent sort of goofy kind of removal
- 23:11of money from the company and he was doing different
- 23:14kinds of behavior. The defense side can argue,
- 23:17well, no, it wasn't fraud. He might've been part
- 23:19of the gang that couldn't shoot straight, but
- 23:21it doesn't matter as the gang that couldn't shoot
- 23:23straight doesn't rise to the level of fraud.
- 23:25So in a business example, I would tell you look
- 23:27for, as Lynn said, going, she talked about going
- 23:30back several years in product development, same
- 23:33issue. You go back several years in the issue,
- 23:35in how the finances were divided between the
- 23:38parties and see if in fact, there were specific
- 23:41instructions to the accountant or to the bookkeeper
- 23:44or to whoever, and you look to see these, then
- 23:47you're going to raise the clear and convincing
- 23:49and meet the clear and convincing standard that
- 23:52fraud existed rather than just inadvertent misappropriation.
- 23:56Yeah, that's a great example, Malcolm. And I
- 23:58think too, just looking at the elements of fraud
- 24:01here on the slide, again, it's intentional misrepresentation.
- 24:05So we have that intent element that is sort of
- 24:08streaming through each of these examples we've
- 24:11given, whether it's malice or oppression or fraud,
- 24:14there has to be that intent there. Again, that's
- 24:17because punitive damages are there to punish.
- 24:21The policy behind them is we want to punish the
- 24:24defendant and we want to deter this type of conduct
- 24:28from occurring down the road versus compensatory
- 24:32damages, which we're all used to from are civil
- 24:35cases that we work on, right, which those are
- 24:37meant to compensate the plaintiff for the harm
- 24:40that he or she has suffered. Punitive damages
- 24:43take on a very different role and they have a
- 24:45different purpose in our society and in the jurisprudence.
- 24:49So just kind of high level issues to kind of
- 24:53keep in mind. Malcolm, I'm going to put the ping
- 24:55pong ball back in your court if you don't mind
- 24:57to go on to the next slide. No worries. Thank
- 24:59you. Thank you. Well, here, I gave you a preview
- 25:04of this a little while ago, talking about the
- 25:06Ralph's case. And I may, in fact, talk about
- 25:07it again, because I think there's a lot of dicta
- 25:10in the case that is going to be helpful when
- 25:12you're looking back on the evidence presented
- 25:14at trial. So this relates to the punitive damages
- 25:18when you're looking at the employer as against
- 25:21the actions in that case of the store manager
- 25:24or store director. And let's go on to the next
- 25:28slide. Okay. KC 3943, punitive damages may only
- 25:34be awarded against a defendant entity for conduct
- 25:37of an employee or agent and only if the plaintiff
- 25:40can prove by clear and convincing evidence that
- 25:42the employee or agent engaged in the conduct
- 25:45with malice, oppression, or fraud. So it's a
- 25:49two -step process because number one, you have
- 25:52to show that there by clear and convincing evidence,
- 25:54as Lynn has already defined for us, with malice,
- 25:58oppression or fraud. Next slide, please. Okay,
- 26:04so the plaintiff must show the employee or agent
- 26:07was an officer, director or managing agent or
- 26:10acting on behalf of the defendant entity, that
- 26:13the entity knowingly employed an employee who
- 26:16is unfit with disregard to the rights or safety
- 26:19of others. Now, that's a very important thing
- 26:23when you weigh it against the facts and Ralph's,
- 26:26because they did They did find that there was
- 26:29a conscious disregard of the rights of the employees
- 26:32who were injured by the conduct, but they also
- 26:36found that there was not a disregard of the rights
- 26:38or safety of others for the entire length of
- 26:41the conduct by the very fact that Ralphs was
- 26:45taking remedial actions against the manager.
- 26:48So on this second point, Ralphs was able to argue
- 26:51that we did what we thought we should do, maybe
- 26:53not as soon as we should have done it, but we
- 26:55did it at some point in time. And I think we
- 26:58can all glean from that, that if Ralph's took
- 27:00no action at all against the manager, that the
- 27:04result would have been different in terms of
- 27:06the result against Ralph's. Third, the defendant
- 27:10- I have a question on that. Sorry, Malcolm,
- 27:11can I just interject for just a moment on that
- 27:13second point about the unfit employee? When Ralph's
- 27:17took the remedial action, was there any argument
- 27:20by the plaintiff's counsel that it was essentially
- 27:22an admission by remediating do you know what
- 27:26I'm saying that they were admitting that they
- 27:27were in the wrong essentially not not revealed
- 27:30in the facts of the case but that question crossed
- 27:32my mind too was it was it as we know a subsequent
- 27:36remedial measure something that could be commented
- 27:38on but I'll tell you something that was very
- 27:40interesting the plaintiffs were precluded from
- 27:44showing post event evidence of misbehavior by
- 27:48the manager because the court reasoned that we
- 27:53review the punitive damages as of the date of
- 27:55the misconduct that took place. And while many
- 27:58of us would like to look at subsequent behavior
- 28:01and say, well, by the way, he went to another
- 28:02store and he did this, this, and this, that evidence
- 28:05was not allowed in. That evidence was not allowed
- 28:07in because the court said, we're going to look
- 28:09at everything from day one of alleged misbehavior
- 28:13up to the date of the action that was taken.
- 28:16But we're not going to allow post actions or
- 28:20post events to come into play and post facts
- 28:23because that would blur the punitive damage analysis
- 28:27as of the date of the injury. And so that's interesting,
- 28:31I think, too, just as a practice pointer, Malcolm,
- 28:33for the defendant, right? If you're representing
- 28:35a defendant, one of these cases, you're going
- 28:37to trial and the plaintiff tries to bring in
- 28:40or maybe you bring this up on emotion and lemonade.
- 28:43You move to exclude any post. incidents, alleged
- 28:48bad conduct or misconduct based on what you were
- 28:51just saying. You try to, at the start of trial,
- 28:55make sure that's not going to come in. I think
- 28:57as a defendant, you would probably want to attack
- 29:00that. Well, absolutely. And the last point here
- 29:07is what was very interesting, because I think
- 29:09the court applied it to Ralph's directly. the
- 29:13defendant entity knew of the employer agent's
- 29:15wrongful conduct and approved the conduct after
- 29:18it occurred. And that was not so fast. No, we
- 29:21took some feeble actions by transferring the
- 29:26manager and giving him some instructions. But
- 29:29then later we said, No, no, no, no. We put them
- 29:34on the remedial program, so they were not found
- 29:38to have approved the conduct after it occurred,
- 29:40even though initially there was conscious disregard
- 29:42of the rights of the plaintiffs. So that's why
- 29:45I like the Ralph's case so much because it sort
- 29:48of goes back and forth and weaves like a figure
- 29:50eight between the needs that for on both sides
- 29:53and gives us a lot of instruction for the trial
- 29:56and your trial. And I would advise everyone to
- 29:59read it. So the first two, the first two are
- 30:02where they were found, let's say responsible
- 30:04for the second two they were found to have mitigated.
- 30:08Interesting. And that the Ralph's case was a
- 30:11California Court of Appeal case? Yeah. And let
- 30:13me by the way, since I'm talking about it so
- 30:15much, let me give everybody the citation. It's
- 30:1840 Cal Reporter, third, 92, 97 Fair Employment
- 30:23Practice cases, BNA 1181. And it's a 2006 case
- 30:28from the fourth district. So it's relatively
- 30:32recent. OK, let's go on to the next one. OK.
- 30:37So how the defendant can contest show by clear
- 30:39and convincing evidence that the defendant had
- 30:41no knowledge of the employee or the agents on
- 30:44fitness or bad conduct. Now, this is also interesting
- 30:47in the Ralph's case because the case goes on
- 30:50to talk about the fact that a couple of the plaintiff,
- 30:53I mentioned earlier that there were three sets
- 30:55of plaintiffs and one of the sets of plaintiffs
- 30:58complained of bad behavior internally in the
- 31:01store. Another complained at a different level
- 31:03and the third never complained. So the court
- 31:07went through a very interesting analysis to say,
- 31:12well, Ralphs didn't understand exactly what was
- 31:15going on. They knew that there was some misbehavior
- 31:17that they were trying to correct, but they were
- 31:19never fully advised of the nature and extent
- 31:21of the misconduct until the very last complainants
- 31:25that were complaining and ended up filing suits.
- 31:29The defendant, it wasn't that the defendant didn't
- 31:32have knowledge, but in the Ralph's case, the
- 31:34defendant didn't have full knowledge of the allegations
- 31:37that were being made by the plaintiffs in the
- 31:38case. So I think that's also a mitigating factor
- 31:41if you're on the defendant's side. Draw a timeline.
- 31:44So you know what? On day one, we found out this.
- 31:47On day 30, we found out that. On day 90, when
- 31:49we found this out, we said, wait a minute, that's
- 31:51too much. And then we ended up placing him in
- 31:54a different position, put him on probation, terminated
- 31:56him, or whatever. So the timeline, I think, would
- 31:59be critical when you're trying to demonstrate
- 32:01the mitigation of that. And as plaintiffs, if
- 32:04you're doing it as a plaintiff, you want to show
- 32:06that, no, at every step of the way, Ralph's new.
- 32:10Again, that knowledge is key, right? The knowledge
- 32:12is really on both sides of the coin. Absolutely.
- 32:15Absolutely. Let's take a look at the next one.
- 32:22On this one, want me to toss this one to you,
- 32:24Lynn? Sure, sure. Happy to take this one from
- 32:28you, Malcolm. So this is sort of the other, we
- 32:33talked about at the outset, there would be two
- 32:35jury instructions we were going to be discussing.
- 32:37This is the second one, and it is very similar
- 32:40to the one that Malcolm just went through, but
- 32:43it focuses more on punitive damages against an
- 32:46entity defendant and not so much an employer.
- 32:50So we could go to the next slide, please. This
- 32:54is the drain structure itself. It's Casey 3945,
- 32:59just for your reference. And what it says is
- 33:02that punitive damages may only be awarded against
- 33:06a defendant entity if the plaintiff can prove
- 33:09again by clear and convincing evidence that the
- 33:13entity engaged in the conduct with malice, oppression
- 33:16or fraud. Very similar to the other jury instruction,
- 33:20we just examine together, but it doesn't refer
- 33:23to an employer or an agent acting under the supervision
- 33:29of the employer. This is really limited to the
- 33:32entity itself. Let's go on to slide 15, if we
- 33:39will. This is, again, sort of breaking it down
- 33:43for you if you're the plaintiff, what you need
- 33:45to show under this jury's instruction to essentially
- 33:50to prevail on a claim of punitive damages. Again,
- 33:54it's always going to be clearing convincing evidence
- 33:57all the way through. So you've got that heightened
- 34:00standard of proof here, which is why the discovery
- 34:05and the facts are so critical. Malcolm illustrated
- 34:10it with the Ralph's case, just talking about
- 34:12the different, you know, in that case you had,
- 34:15you know, harassment that was alleged, there
- 34:17was sexual harassment, there was physical harassment,
- 34:19there was verbal harassment, there was hostile
- 34:21work environment, the list goes on and on, but.
- 34:25it's important to really, as a plaintiff, marshal
- 34:29your facts through discovery in the form of,
- 34:32you know, obviously written discovery, but I
- 34:34think even more importantly, with your deposition
- 34:37testimony that you gather through the parties,
- 34:41not only the parties, but the third party fact
- 34:44witnesses. You know, in the Ralph's case, obviously,
- 34:48there would have been testimony from other people
- 34:50that worked at the store who may have witnessed
- 34:52some of this misconduct going on. so forth and
- 34:57so on. So as a plaintiff under this instruction,
- 35:01you have to show that the conduct was committed
- 35:04on behalf of the entity by one or more of its
- 35:09officers, directors, or managing agents. So again,
- 35:13we all know what an officer is. Everybody's familiar
- 35:16with the director, but managing agent sometimes
- 35:18has a little bit of a... a mystery about it in
- 35:21the law. And I recently had this come up in a
- 35:24case. So I've been studying the case law audit.
- 35:28A managing agent is typically someone who is
- 35:31operating on a level within the corporate setting.
- 35:35And that person has the ability to direct and
- 35:38implement corporate policy. So this isn't going
- 35:41to be someone that manages an ice cream store
- 35:45or manages a gas station or even a restaurant,
- 35:49we're talking somebody at a higher level than
- 35:51that, that is overseeing parts of the entity,
- 35:57whether it's operations or HR or something of
- 35:59that nature where they have the authority to
- 36:03direct and implement corporate policy. That in
- 36:07and of itself becomes a question of fact, is
- 36:09this person even a managing agent? The case I
- 36:13had, which is concluded, I was arguing that my
- 36:17client was not a managing agent because he or
- 36:20she did not have the authority to direct corporate
- 36:24policy. In fact, the judge agreed with me. We
- 36:29were able to get that kicked out on that issue
- 36:31alone. As a defendant, that may be one of the
- 36:34strategies in attacking the punitive damage claim
- 36:39of the plaintiff under this jury instruction.
- 36:41Nope, they're not a managing agent. end of story.
- 36:45And you can do that. One way you can do that
- 36:47is on summary adjudication or summary judgment,
- 36:49just to give you sort of the procedural vehicle
- 36:51by which it can be done. So you've got to have
- 36:55that. And then the second element is that the
- 36:59conduct was authorized by one or more of the
- 37:03entities, officers, directors, or managing agents.
- 37:07So it wasn't just that someone at the corporate
- 37:10level engaged in this misconduct, but it has
- 37:13to be ratified or authorized by someone else
- 37:16at a high level. And we'll see some examples
- 37:20of that, I think, in the hypos that we've put
- 37:22together for the audience. And then the or is
- 37:26the third element. This is an or, not an and.
- 37:30Or the conduct was adopted and approved after
- 37:34it occurred. by more or one of the entities,
- 37:37officers, directors, or managing agents. Basically,
- 37:39three different ways, if you're the plaintiff,
- 37:47to prove punitive damages by an entity. We could
- 37:53go to the next slide, please. Then here, this
- 37:59is the same jury instruction. If you're on the
- 38:01defense side of this, How can you defend? Well,
- 38:05one of the strategies I just pointed out was
- 38:09demonstrating through discovery and depositions
- 38:13that the alleged perpetrator, if you will, was
- 38:18not a managing agent at all. We know they're
- 38:20not an officer, they're not a director, and they're
- 38:22not a managing agent. They're this low -level
- 38:25manager of a small grocery store or jewelry store
- 38:28or whatever it is, that there's several layers
- 38:31above in terms of the corporate hierarchy. That
- 38:34might be one way that you can defend against
- 38:37this punitive damage claim that's directed at
- 38:40your client. Another would be to show that the
- 38:45conduct at issue, whatever it was, was taken
- 38:48but it was not approved by the entity. Someone
- 38:53acted in a way that was It was vile. It was oppressive.
- 38:59They engaged in malice, but the entity didn't
- 39:02approve it, didn't ratify it. There's no one
- 39:04at the officer director or managing agent level
- 39:08that knew about that conduct and approved or
- 39:11ratified it. That's another way as a defendant,
- 39:15you can show this was an isolated incident. None
- 39:18of our officers or directors had any awareness
- 39:21about it. We can demonstrate that through testimony,
- 39:25depositions. If you're on the defense side, of
- 39:28course, you want to be sure that your internal
- 39:32communications, your emails are clean of any
- 39:37such evidence of this. I think that's really
- 39:40where, in these cases, a lot of the evidence
- 39:44turns on emails, internal emails, and people
- 39:47don't always stop to think before they send out
- 39:49an email. five years down the road can result
- 39:53in an award of punitive damages or a very high
- 39:55jury award. So if you're on the defense side,
- 39:58you're going to have to really scrub through
- 39:59your client's emails and make sure that there
- 40:02isn't something there that could get you in hot
- 40:05water. But again, show me that too. Yeah, go
- 40:08ahead. Yeah, no, it's quite right. One of the
- 40:14other ways that the defendant can effectively
- 40:17defend is to point to their own personnel and
- 40:20policies and procedures manuals. That's why you
- 40:23saw so many times that as our sexual harassment
- 40:28laws have evolved and we've modified our employment
- 40:32manuals effectively, you'll see lots of bold
- 40:35language in there saying the company does not
- 40:37condone this type of behavior and that includes
- 40:39unwanted touching, inappropriate conduct etc
- 40:43etc etc and the reason why that's there is because
- 40:46then if it occurs the company is able to say
- 40:49well no we never approved this in fact they signed
- 40:51off and got the employment manual and that's
- 40:54his signature there and in fact we enforce it
- 40:56then they bring in the hr manager oh yes we enforce
- 40:59it as a matter of fact we took 32 actions last
- 41:01year nationwide against a variety of people and
- 41:04we had terminations etc so it's not just a passive
- 41:07position provision in our manual but in fact
- 41:10we strictly adhere to it and we hold our sexual
- 41:13harassment courses once every three months and
- 41:15we do blah blah blah and so what happens is that
- 41:20the the don't overlook the value of that policies
- 41:23and procedure ask your client have you issued
- 41:26any If you're on the defense side, ask, have
- 41:28you issued any of those, let's say, periodic
- 41:31reminders of the company's policy, periodic reminders
- 41:35that you should review the policies and procedures
- 41:37once every six months, et cetera, et cetera?
- 41:40And, congressly, if you're on the plaintiff's
- 41:42side, those may be questions you want to ask
- 41:44at a deposition. How often do you remind your
- 41:46people to read the policies and procedures manual,
- 41:49et cetera, et cetera? Just flip around what I
- 41:51just said, both from the plaintiff's standpoint,
- 41:53and you'll see that that benefit can come up.
- 41:56that the manual can be. It can also be a dagger
- 42:01if you have that, if you don't have the language
- 42:03in there or if it's undefended or if it's not
- 42:08augmented by other programs within the company
- 42:11or if it's passive, it's just language that is
- 42:14sitting there. But assuming that the company
- 42:16does have a rigorous program of enforcing its
- 42:21manual, it can be a very effective defense tool.
- 42:25That's a great point, Melvin. On that same issue,
- 42:28if the company has had other claims in the past
- 42:31of harassment of a similar nature or maybe by
- 42:34the same trader, and how did they respond to
- 42:39that? What did they do? Did they mitigate? Did
- 42:41they force that person to undergo some courses
- 42:45or training or behavioral training, etc.? That
- 42:50could become relevant in a later lawsuit. The
- 42:56company would want to say, yeah, we had a past
- 42:59issue, but we right away addressed it. We mitigated
- 43:02it and here's our policy and we clearly don't
- 43:05condone this behavior. There's all kinds of documentary
- 43:10evidence that can become really critical in a
- 43:14punitive damage side of the case along the lines
- 43:17of what Malcolm's talking about. Don't forget
- 43:20about the most mundane, you know, policy and
- 43:23procedures, manuals and handbooks and training
- 43:25guides and the like, because those can be front
- 43:28and center in one of these cases, if you're on
- 43:32the defense end, if you're on the plaintiff side
- 43:34as well. All right, let's go to our next slide.
- 43:43So now we're kind of getting into determining
- 43:47punitive damages under both of these two jury
- 43:50instructions that we've just kind of walked you
- 43:52through. How do we determine if there's going
- 43:56to be an award of punitive damages? What factors
- 44:00does our Supreme Court look at? Does our California
- 44:03courts of appeal, what do they look at? Are they
- 44:06different? Are they similar? And then also, what
- 44:10about numbers? What are the ranges that courts
- 44:13permit? What's considered constitutional? What's
- 44:16considered unconstitutional? And what are the
- 44:18different ranges? So that's what we're going
- 44:20to be getting into in this next section. And
- 44:24it's really, there's a lot of meat on the bone,
- 44:27I will say, as Malcolm and I have discussed.
- 44:32And so this is where I think it really becomes
- 44:35pretty interesting and and where we uh you know
- 44:38where we may need more time with with you all
- 44:41let me let me also i i as an introduction and
- 44:44i just i like using the example because i've
- 44:47done it before is that there used to be this
- 44:49um this commercial that was on tv for some laxative
- 44:53right and they're saying well you need to use
- 44:55a laxative because oh i i'm just so confused
- 44:57is three enough or is six too many if i give
- 45:00the kids prunes okay is three enough or six too
- 45:03many To our listeners and viewers, the question
- 45:07here and the applicability of that to this is,
- 45:11ask yourselves this, what do you know right now
- 45:14about the constitutionality of the punitive damage
- 45:17awards? We see them in newspapers. We hear about
- 45:20them anecdotally. We hear about them through
- 45:22the Bar Association. We read about them in the
- 45:24journals. The question is, how many of you know
- 45:27is one times punitive damages the limit? or three
- 45:32times or five times or 10 times or 20 times?
- 45:35How much can somebody punish a defendant for
- 45:38conduct if it's proven as we talked about before?
- 45:41What are the limits? Are there limitations? And
- 45:44if there are limitations, what are they? I'm
- 45:46sorry, I just wanted to give that little - No,
- 45:48that's so important. And also I'll just throw
- 45:50in one more for you, which is who decides? Is
- 45:53it the judge? Is it the jury? Can it be either
- 45:56one? Who makes that determination about the amount,
- 46:00about whether they're awardable and the amount.
- 46:04Everybody's most interested in the amount because
- 46:05it becomes so salacious in a lot of these cases.
- 46:08You will often see, just for the audience's edification,
- 46:12you will often see where there's a remittitor.
- 46:16The juries often come back with these really
- 46:18high numbers in the punitive damage space, and
- 46:21then the judge will do a remittitor. That's pretty
- 46:24common, I think. In the cases we reviewed, getting
- 46:28ready to do this presentation for everyone. I
- 46:30think I saw that in almost every case. And the
- 46:33reason that the courts do that is that they're
- 46:35getting the numbers within this sort of constitutional
- 46:38realm, which we'll talk about what's been acceptable
- 46:43in terms of multipliers, is three times your
- 46:48compensatory damages for punitive damages. Is
- 46:52that okay? What about seven? What about nine?
- 46:5410. It's interesting. And we see a variety of
- 46:59conclusions that are reached in the cases. So
- 47:01with that in mind, why don't I go through the
- 47:05next slide and then I'll turn it back over to
- 47:07you, Malcolm, if that sounds good. All right.
- 47:09So element one, this is the reprehensibility
- 47:14of the defendant's conduct. And this is really
- 47:19where a lot of the cases, particularly the Supreme
- 47:24Court cases, both the state and the US Supreme
- 47:28Court, focus their attention is on the reprehensibility
- 47:33of the defendant's conduct. And one of the cases,
- 47:36and I can't remember which one as I sit here,
- 47:38basically said, this is the most critical factor
- 47:41that we look at. And so this kind of comes out
- 47:47of the Supreme Court seminal case of BMW versus
- 47:51Gore. And you may remember that case from law
- 47:54school or from practice. But it's a case from
- 47:57the mid -90s where the US Supreme Court actually
- 48:02set out three guideposts that courts are supposed
- 48:05to follow and consider when they're determining
- 48:09whether punitive damages should be awarded. And
- 48:13just to keep this in mind for our conversation,
- 48:16those three guideposts are number one, this element
- 48:19here, the degree of reprehensibility of the defendant's
- 48:23misconduct, and we're gonna get into what that
- 48:25means. The second guidepost that the courts consider
- 48:29is the disparity between the actual or potential
- 48:35harm that's suffered by the plaintiff and the
- 48:38punitive damage award itself. And then third
- 48:42guidepost, is the difference between the punitive
- 48:47damages awarded by the jury and the civil penalties
- 48:51authorized or imposed in comparable cases. Those
- 48:54are the three guideposts, but again, I would
- 48:57just emphasize for you that this number one,
- 48:59this element one, is really where the cases seem
- 49:03to focus. So what does that mean? How reprehensible
- 49:08was the defendant's conduct? Courts will look
- 49:11at a variety of factors to decide, or juries
- 49:14will, whether the conduct was reprehensible.
- 49:18And the first one, I think one and two are the
- 49:20most key here, but the first one is whether the
- 49:23conduct caused physical harm. Again, think about
- 49:26the rollover cases where people became severely
- 49:31injured, they became paraplegic, some died. Think
- 49:35about cases where somebody is exposed to a chemical
- 49:38asbestos. They develop mesothelioma. These are
- 49:41the key hallmarks of reprehensible conduct. That's
- 49:47number one. Number two is whether the defendant
- 49:51disregarded the health or safety of others. This
- 49:55is aligned with number one, but I think the best
- 50:00example of number two is I mentioned the Monsanto
- 50:03case earlier. and that's a California court of
- 50:07appeal case from sometime in the 2000s. I don't
- 50:11have it in front of me, but I will get you the
- 50:12site. In that case, there was actual evidence
- 50:17that the chemical used in Roundup could cause
- 50:21harm to humans, and the company knew about it.
- 50:24They knew about the studies, they knew about
- 50:26the science, but yet they tried to shift the
- 50:29narrative. When they were talking with the EPA,
- 50:32it's really not that bad. Here's another way
- 50:35to spin it. And we're going to kind of not talk
- 50:38about these studies, kind of cover up, right?
- 50:41That's really, I think, what factor two is getting
- 50:44at. And just for everyone's reference, the Monsanto
- 50:47case is Pilead, P -I -L -L -I -O -D versus Monsanto
- 50:52Company. And that's at 67 Calat 5th, 591. And
- 50:57it's from 2021. I think that's indicative of
- 51:01number two is the disregarding health and safety
- 51:03of others. You knew it was dangerous, and yet
- 51:06you didn't do anything about it. You didn't put
- 51:07a warning on that product. You buried the evidence.
- 51:11You buried the science in the journals so people
- 51:13couldn't know and they couldn't find out. So
- 51:16the third factor that the courts consider when
- 51:20they're looking at is this reprehensible conduct
- 51:23is whether the plaintiff was financially weak
- 51:26or vulnerable. and whether the defendant used
- 51:29this to take advantage of them. There's a case
- 51:32we're going to look at where a veteran who had
- 51:38pretty severe medical conditions was in a wheelchair,
- 51:43required a lot of medical treatment, was denied
- 51:48health benefits. I think that goes right to number
- 51:54three here. somebody who's financially weak,
- 51:58they're a veteran, he was unable to work, and
- 52:02yet a company, an insurer is denying his health
- 52:06benefits. And that's an example of that one.
- 52:08And then fourth, another factor that the courts
- 52:13consider for the reprehensibility aspect is whether
- 52:16the conduct involved a pattern or practice. This
- 52:18is also really important. Typically where you
- 52:23have corporate entities engaging in misconduct
- 52:26over and over and over, and not remediating that
- 52:31misconduct, that is going to be a hallmark of
- 52:36reprehensibility in the court's eyes. I think
- 52:40in the Ralph's case, it sounds like from what
- 52:42Malcolm was sharing, that Ralph did take some
- 52:45remedial conduct to address these claims of harassment
- 52:49and so forth. But where you have really salacious
- 52:54facts where a company has been accused of, let's
- 52:59say, hostile work environment, discrimination,
- 53:02harassment over and over and over again by different
- 53:06employees and they don't take action to correct
- 53:08it or they don't have a policy in place that
- 53:10even addresses it, that's going to be factor
- 53:12number four and it's going to go to the reprehensibility
- 53:15of the misconduct. Then finally, whether the
- 53:18defendant acted with trickery or deceit. Deceit
- 53:22there, that's really aligned with fraud. I think
- 53:27there's some overlap with that. Trickery, this
- 53:30is to me sounding more in fraud, but here I think
- 53:35the real key ones are causing physical harm,
- 53:38disregarding safety of others, rights of others,
- 53:41and involving in a pattern or practice of misconduct.
- 53:43That's element one. turn it back over to Malcolm.
- 53:47I think this is actually the most exciting one,
- 53:49I'll just say. When you're reading the cases,
- 53:51you can really see some interesting and varying
- 53:55degrees of misconduct. No, Lynn is right. It
- 53:59is the most exciting one, and that is why Lynn
- 54:03was the one who introduced it, because she can
- 54:05do it much more excitingly than me. I stole it
- 54:07from you. Yes. You did, but that's fine. My pleasure.
- 54:11By the way, for everyone's benefit, I sent out
- 54:14in the text the citations to both Monsanto and
- 54:18Ralphs. So if anybody missed the sites as we
- 54:21yelled them out, you will be able to get them.
- 54:24I scribble them down if you're interested in
- 54:26reading either one of them. We're closing in
- 54:30right now on an hour on our first hour. And what
- 54:34I wanted to do is let me give a little bit more
- 54:37of a discussion of this factor two. And that
- 54:40may be the breaking point for us before we get
- 54:43to our final element and then our examples. It's
- 54:46gonna be even more exciting than this. than this
- 54:49session, because we're going to actually delve
- 54:52into several examples. But I did want to say
- 54:54one thing, and I'll say it right after. Let me
- 54:57get through factor two right here of element
- 55:00one. It says, plaintiffs should seek evidence
- 55:03showing defendant knew the risks and chose to
- 55:06proceed. Defendant attempted to hide or combat
- 55:09adverse studies. Defendant did not adequately
- 55:12disclose contributions. Lynn said it. I think
- 55:17we should keep saying it. It's the F word fraud.
- 55:20fraud, fraud. Is there a misrepresentation? And
- 55:24the other one is that the K word knowing those
- 55:27are the two things that you should be looking
- 55:28for all along. Is there anything that you can
- 55:31characterize as fraud or if you're on the defense
- 55:33side, the question is, is there anything that
- 55:36you can do to mitigate that this was a harmless
- 55:38mistake by you, even if it created harm and that
- 55:41it was something that it was unintended, unexpected,
- 55:44and it cannot be perceived. So that's going to
- 55:48be the important that's going to be the fight,
- 55:51the clear dividing line when you go to court.
- 55:54It's interesting because going back to the Ralph's
- 55:59case very quickly, the reason why I find it so
- 56:04interesting is that Monsanto is a really ugly
- 56:07case. When you read Monsanto, you think, well,
- 56:10what jury could conceivably ever find that Monsanto
- 56:14acted properly? In the Ralph's case, you sort
- 56:17of go back and forth between the behavior, we're
- 56:20not talking about the perpetrator, the manager,
- 56:23we're talking about Ralph's itself and Ralph's
- 56:25conduct and Ralph's attempt to mitigate the circumstances
- 56:29and deal with the manager. At that level, it's
- 56:32more nuanced and most of the cases that you are
- 56:35all going to be faced with are going to be more
- 56:38nuanced. They're gonna align themselves. If you
- 56:41have a slam dunk case like a Monsanto, then you're
- 56:45in pretty good shape because then you can turn
- 56:47to the next section of what we're gonna be talking
- 56:49about. And you can then focus on how are you
- 56:51gonna enhance the constitutionally allowable
- 56:55amount of punitive damages that you would like
- 56:57to get. And if you're on the defendant's side,
- 57:01you're going to say, wait a minute, how do I
- 57:02mitigate this conduct so that I would go to the
- 57:05lower end of the constitutionally appropriate
- 57:09punitive damages so I can argue a lower amount?
- 57:13So the issue here, and by the way, what I wanted
- 57:17to do is stop for one second through that narrative.
- 57:20Do we have any, it does not look like we had
- 57:23one Q &A and I responded to it. It was not a.
- 57:26There's a question regarding a citation, so I
- 57:28dealt with that. I don't see a further question,
- 57:34so we have three more minutes, so let's keep
- 57:37going. We're going to keep you all until the
- 57:40very end. Go ahead. If you do have a question,
- 57:43feel free to put it in the chat and we'll see
- 57:46that. Sure, absolutely. That's part two, whenever
- 57:52we, that is on a date to be determined. So we
- 57:55don't know, we can't tell you what it is now.
- 57:57So watch your emails. Let's have the next slide.
- 58:03Okay, whether defendant disregarded the health
- 58:06or safety of others, how to defend. The defendant
- 58:09did not know that their conduct had probable
- 58:12dangerous consequences. The thread that I see
- 58:17through all of the cases that are cited, as well
- 58:20as the citations within Monsanto, and looking
- 58:24at the other, some of the seminal cases, including
- 58:28the US Supreme Court standard that we had, is
- 58:31that when there is a... when there's a physical
- 58:35harm of some sort, if there is a physical damage
- 58:38to someone, if there is an injury to someone,
- 58:41it is more likely that you're going to be at
- 58:43the upper end of the punitive damage constitutionally
- 58:48allowable stage of damages. If it is not, a personal
- 58:53injury of some sort, then it's more likely you're
- 58:56going to be at the much lower end of the punitive
- 58:59damage scale, even if the jury finds that punitive
- 59:02damages should be awarded. And one of the cases
- 59:05that we have is the BMW case. And that's an interesting
- 59:08case because the jury awarded millions of dollars
- 59:13of damages where a car was repainted without
- 59:17telling the buyer of the car that the car was
- 59:19repainted. And so they said the court just sort
- 59:24of slapped the jury a little bit by saying it
- 59:26was so way outside the realm of any constitutionally
- 59:32allowable damages because the actual damages
- 59:36for the vehicle was something like $35 ,000,
- 59:39but there were millions of dollars of damages
- 59:41for it. And of course, the court then said it
- 59:44was a minimally reprehensible level of conduct.
- 59:48So I thought that language, it's very interesting.
- 59:50We think of reprehensible as either reprehensible
- 59:52or not reprehensible, but not so. There are levels
- 59:56of reprehensibility and you need to think about
- 59:59that. So since the jury said, yes, we believe
- 1:00:03in punitive damages, the short story is that
- 1:00:07they went far above, but the theme was from the
- 1:00:11court of appeal, that they awarded those damages
- 1:00:14because they were very upset with the dealership's
- 1:00:17conduct. Probably all those people bought a car
- 1:00:19at some point in time and they were all lemons.
- 1:00:22So that jury wanted to punish the automotive
- 1:00:25industry. But the reality was that it was a car.
- 1:00:28Nobody got hurt. It was paint. It wasn't hiding
- 1:00:31what was going on with the fuel injection or
- 1:00:33the brakes or something else. It wasn't a health
- 1:00:38and safety issue. So since it was not a health
- 1:00:41and safety issue, the court basically gave what
- 1:00:44I call the all come on defense, which is they
- 1:00:47said, oh, come on, you're not going to award
- 1:00:49that kind of punitive damages in this kind of
- 1:00:51a case where you can't, where the jury should
- 1:00:55not have been inflamed as much as they were to
- 1:00:57make that award against BMW. So I think that
- 1:01:02that takes us through, I will say that on this
- 1:01:06case that's coming up, we were talking about
- 1:01:08medical and scientific developments discovered
- 1:01:11after a plaintiff's injury, cannot establish
- 1:01:13that the defendant knew of the probably dangerous
- 1:01:17consequences of their conduct. One last comment
- 1:01:19before we conclude the session. In the Ralph's
- 1:01:24case, the plaintiffs tried to bring in evidence
- 1:01:27of things that happened at Ralph's after the
- 1:01:31period of time when the plaintiffs were affected
- 1:01:33by the manager's misconduct. And the court said
- 1:01:36no. You measure punitive damages at the time
- 1:01:40that the conduct occurs, not based on subsequent
- 1:01:43conduct. So you cannot use subsequent conduct.
- 1:01:46And yes, you would probably file a motion in
- 1:01:49limine, as we were talking about earlier, in
- 1:01:52order to keep that kind of evidence out. But
- 1:01:55I also wanted to make sure it was clear that
- 1:01:56I was not the plaintiff in this case. This is
- 1:01:58McNeil's bill differently. I don't know who this
- 1:02:01guy is, but who sued Whitaker. But I just want
- 1:02:04everybody to know it's not me. So I think...
- 1:02:07I think then should should we should we stop
- 1:02:09there? Do you have any? I think so. We do have
- 1:02:11two questions. It looks like in the Q &A so we
- 1:02:14can either defer those to next time or try to
- 1:02:17answer them. What if we still have a couple of
- 1:02:20minutes? They're pretty straightforward, I think.
- 1:02:25If you'd like to answer them, go ahead. Yeah,
- 1:02:27I think so. The first question is, does the clear
- 1:02:30and convincing standard come into play at all
- 1:02:33during motions to strike? punitive damage prayers,
- 1:02:37or is that only substantively used at trial?
- 1:02:41Based on my experience, it's substantively used
- 1:02:44at trial, that standard, clear and convincing.
- 1:02:47On a motion to strike, that is typically not
- 1:02:51the standard. The judge would be looking at whether
- 1:02:55the plaintiff has stated sufficient facts for.
- 1:02:59a punitive damage prayer. So have they stated
- 1:03:01that the defendant engaged in fraud, malice,
- 1:03:04oppression? Are there enough factual allegations
- 1:03:06made? But there's no proof standard that's applied
- 1:03:11at the motion to strike. space of the case. And
- 1:03:16I'll field the second one. Jordana Thigpen asked
- 1:03:19the question, what about the fact that BMW, the
- 1:03:22plaintiff, brought up the harm, which was occurring
- 1:03:24nationwide, that the painting issue came up with
- 1:03:26numerous people, which made it reprehensible.
- 1:03:29Is it accurate that numerous cases have since
- 1:03:32held, including California, that is appropriate
- 1:03:35to mention pattern and practice? Pattern and
- 1:03:38practice is something that is an appropriate
- 1:03:43It's appropriate evidence to bring up, but in
- 1:03:46conjunction with what the defendant knew at the
- 1:03:49time that the punitive conduct occurred in the
- 1:03:52case that's before the bar. See, because if there
- 1:03:57are 39 cars that were painted beforehand and
- 1:04:00they show course of conduct, et cetera, I think
- 1:04:02that would clearly demonstrate reprehensibility
- 1:04:05and would, in fact, be admissible. But what if
- 1:04:08the pattern occurred after this particular incident.
- 1:04:12At that point, I think the court would properly
- 1:04:15exclude that evidence because it wouldn't go
- 1:04:17to the punitive aspect and the conscious disregard
- 1:04:21of the defendant at the time this particular
- 1:04:23incident occurred as to this particular plaintiff.
- 1:04:26So that would be my thumbnail analysis of that.
- 1:04:29Thank you both for those questions at the end.
- 1:04:35We shall say thank you for coming. See you next
- 1:04:40time. See you for part two. Thank you all. We
- 1:04:42really appreciate it and we'll look forward to
- 1:04:44part two with everybody