Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / The Bystander Effect: Why We Don't Help & the Psychology of Altruism
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the psychology undergrad. So today
- 0:03we are reviewing our notes for the upcoming exam
- 0:05on chapter eight of our textbook, which is all
- 0:08about helping an altruism. Right. The helping
- 0:11chapter. It's a it's a really heavy one actually.
- 0:13Yeah, it really is. And the mission for this
- 0:15deep dive is basically to figure out. if human
- 0:18beings are actually good or if our helpfulness
- 0:21is just this series of selfish biological and
- 0:25psychological tricks. Which is such a cynical
- 0:27way to look at it, but it makes for a great study
- 0:30session. Totally. Well, to start, the textbook
- 0:32has this wild example from 2005. Yeah. So right
- 0:36after Hurricane Katrina, actor Brad Pitt didn't
- 0:39just write a check for $5 million and quietly
- 0:41donate it. Right. He got super involved. Yeah.
- 0:44He literally built 150 of these massive bright
- 0:47monopoly -shaped houses all around New Orleans
- 0:50to publicize the need for rebuilding. Which is
- 0:53visually striking, to say the least. Oh, for
- 0:56sure. But it brings up this huge question for
- 0:59the exam. Like, why do people go to such extreme
- 1:02lengths for complete strangers? Is that true
- 1:06altruism, meaning, you know, increasing another
- 1:09person's welfare with zero direct reward to yourself?
- 1:12Or is it something else? Yeah. And to really
- 1:15answer that, we have to start at the absolute
- 1:17bottom. Like, to understand grand gestures like
- 1:20Brad Pitt's, we first have to look at the microscopic
- 1:23evolutionary baseline of helping. Right. Because
- 1:27evolutionary psychology has a very specific take
- 1:29on this. It does. From an evolutionary standpoint,
- 1:31the idea is that we help others simply to ensure
- 1:33our own genes survive. Wow. OK. So it's not about
- 1:36being a good person. Not at all. It's strictly
- 1:38biological. The textbook breaks down the kinship
- 1:40percentages. So we share 100 % of our genetic
- 1:44material with an identical twin. OK, makes sense.
- 1:46Right. And we share roughly 50 % with our siblings
- 1:49and our parents, and then about 25 % with grandparents
- 1:51or half siblings. So a good way to remember this
- 1:54for the test, I like to call it genetic math.
- 1:56Oh, genetic math. I like that. Yeah. Because
- 1:59you are literally, on a subconscious level, calculating
- 2:02your genetic survival when deciding who to help.
- 2:05Like, If you're deciding who to give a kidney
- 2:08to, you'll give it to a sibling because that's
- 2:10a 50 % return on your genetic investment. Exactly.
- 2:13But a second cousin, suddenly the math is bad
- 2:16and you're hesitating. It is entirely up the
- 2:18math. And the notes give these really surprising
- 2:21animal examples to back this up. The animal stuff
- 2:24is crazy, like the cellular slime molds. Yeah,
- 2:27the slime mold. They are literally brainless
- 2:29single cell organisms. But when food gets scarce,
- 2:33some of the cells will actually sacrifice themselves.
- 2:36They voluntarily die to form a stalk so that
- 2:39the other cells can climb up and release spores
- 2:42to survive. It's pure biological self -sacrifice.
- 2:44And then there's the vampire bats. Right, the
- 2:46buddy system. Yeah, they have this whole system
- 2:48where if a bat has a bad night and comes back
- 2:51starving, a successful bat will literally regurgitate
- 2:54blood to feed its unlucky friend. Which is so
- 2:57gross, but a perfect example of reciprocal altruism.
- 3:01Exactly. It's an evolutionary insurance policy.
- 3:04The bat shares blood tonight with the hardwired
- 3:07expectation that if it starves tomorrow, the
- 3:09favor gets returned. Oh, wait, I have to push
- 3:11back on this a little. If even brainless slime
- 3:14molds are considered altruistic and bats are
- 3:16just doing it for the insurance. Yeah. Does true
- 3:19moral altruism even exist or is it all just biological
- 3:23programming? Well, that's the big transition
- 3:26because biology explains why we help family or
- 3:29why bats help their neighbors. But Why do we
- 3:32ever help total strangers, like someone we will
- 3:34never see again? Right, where there's no genetic
- 3:37payoff at all. Exactly. Social psychologists
- 3:39say it comes down to a subconscious calculation
- 3:41of costs and rewards. And this brings us to Darley
- 3:44and Batson's famous Good Samaritan study from
- 3:471973. Oh, man. This is maybe the most ironic
- 3:50study in the entire textbook. It's brutal. So
- 3:52they took students studying at a religious seminary.
- 3:55These are people whose whole life goal is to
- 3:57be moral and helpful. The researchers asked them
- 3:59to prepare a speech. Half the students were assigned
- 4:02the parable of the Good Samaritan, which is literally
- 4:05a story about stopping to help a stranger. The
- 4:08other half got a boring, neutral topic. Like
- 4:12seminary jobs or something? Yeah, exactly. Then
- 4:15they had to walk to another building to record
- 4:17the speech. But on the way, they had to pass
- 4:20through this alley where an actor was slumped
- 4:23in a doorway, coughing and groaning, clearly
- 4:25needing help. So half of them were literally
- 4:28just thinking about the Good Samaritan. The setup
- 4:31is almost too perfect. And think the ones who
- 4:33just read the parable would stop. Right. I mean,
- 4:35that's the obvious guess. But the big reveal
- 4:38is that the topic of the speech didn't matter
- 4:40at all. It had zero effects. Zero. What actually
- 4:44mattered was time pressure. The researchers messed
- 4:46with their schedules. They told some students
- 4:48they were early, some they were right on time,
- 4:50and some that they were late and had to hurry.
- 4:52The numbers for this are wild to me. So of the
- 4:57early students, 63 % stopped to help. The on
- 5:01-time students, 45 % helped. But the students
- 5:05who were told they were late, only 10 % stopped.
- 5:0810%. Literally 90 % of these guys, guys studying
- 5:12to be priests or ministers, stepped over a groaning
- 5:15man because they were running late to give a
- 5:17speech. Sometimes literally a speech about the
- 5:20Good Samaritan. It's so dark. It is, but the
- 5:23moral implication is profound. It shows that
- 5:26religious and moral priming is incredibly fragile.
- 5:30It can be completely overridden by something
- 5:32as trivial as looking at your watch and realizing
- 5:34you're five minutes behind schedule. We call
- 5:36it the economics of time. And this actually ties
- 5:39into the legal context we studied, right? Oh,
- 5:41definitely. Because if we can't trust people
- 5:42to help naturally, we have to legislate it. Like
- 5:44in Germany, they have... Good Samaritan laws
- 5:47where you can actually be fined for not helping
- 5:49someone in an emergency. Right. They are artificially
- 5:52increasing the cost of ignoring the person. Yeah.
- 5:55And then in the U .S. we have angel of mercy
- 5:57laws that protect you from being sued if you
- 6:00accidentally hurt someone while trying to save
- 6:02them. We literally have to manipulate the rewards
- 6:05and costs to force people into being altruistic.
- 6:08We absolutely do. But that seminary study also
- 6:11brings up another big theme for our exam review.
- 6:14Does being religious actually make you a better,
- 6:16more helpful person? Oh, this is the section
- 6:19on Batson's research where he categorizes students
- 6:22religious beliefs. Yeah, he broke them down into
- 6:24four types. I have a good mnemonic for this one
- 6:26too. I think of them as four classic campus personalities.
- 6:29Okay, lay it on me. So first is the atheist.
- 6:32That's the non -religious person who just has
- 6:34no interest. Second is the networker. These are
- 6:37the externally religious people who use religion
- 6:40for like social status or comfort. Just trying
- 6:42to look good to the community. Right. Third is
- 6:45the devout. They are internally religious, so
- 6:47religion actually guides their inner everyday
- 6:49life. And the fourth is the philosopher. These
- 6:51are the quest -oriented folks. For them, religion
- 6:54is this lifelong search for answers to really
- 6:57hard moral questions. That's a great way to remember
- 7:00them. Because when Batson tested these groups,
- 7:03the results were super telling. He asked them
- 7:05to help a woman in need or do a difficult walkathon.
- 7:09But he gave them an out, right? Yes. He gave
- 7:11some of them a very easy, socially acceptable
- 7:14excuse to back out. And when given that excuse,
- 7:17the externally religious here networkers were
- 7:19the least likely to help. Because they just want
- 7:21the social points without the work. Exactly.
- 7:24The internally religious, the devout, they helped
- 7:26when it was easy. But the second the walkathon
- 7:28got physically difficult and they had an excuse,
- 7:30they bailed too. Wow. The only group that stayed
- 7:33and helped when it was physically difficult were
- 7:35the quest -oriented ones, the philosophers. They
- 7:38were the true altruists. So it was the philosopher
- 7:40who actually shows up to help you move couches
- 7:42on a Saturday. Precisely. But the fact that the
- 7:45internally religious bailed when it got hard
- 7:48points to this massive concept called moral hypocrisy.
- 7:52Oh, the coin toss study. This is my favorite
- 7:54one in the whole chapter. It is brilliant. So
- 7:56Batson gave students a coin. One side was marked
- 7:59self -depositive and the other was other -depositive.
- 8:03Right. And they had to secretly decide who gets
- 8:05this super fun task that comes with the $30 prize
- 8:09and who gets stuck with a boring, tedious task.
- 8:11And before they did it, They all claimed that
- 8:15tossing the coin was the moral, fair thing to
- 8:17do. But then they were left completely alone
- 8:19in the room. Left completely alone. And what
- 8:21happened? They overwhelmingly rigged the outcome
- 8:24for themselves. They gave themselves the $30.
- 8:27Yep. They wanted to appear moral. They probably
- 8:29even flipped the coin to feel good about the
- 8:32process. But they didn't want to actually pay
- 8:33the cost of losing the prize. It's the hypocrisy
- 8:36coin. We all want to think of ourselves as good
- 8:39people, as long as it doesn't cost us $30. Exactly.
- 8:42So long -term... is clearly very fragile. But
- 8:45what about short -term moods? The textbook gets
- 8:47into how our immediate feelings dictate our helpfulness.
- 8:51Right, emotional economics. We basically use
- 8:53helping as a tool to regulate our own emotions.
- 8:56Yes, so if you're in a positive mood, like you
- 8:59just found a coin on the sidewalk, or someone
- 9:01subtly mimicked your body language, or you smelled
- 9:03a nice perfume. Wait, smelling a perfume actually
- 9:06makes you more likely to help someone? It really
- 9:08does. Because you want to maintain that good
- 9:11mood. Helping feels good, so it keeps the positive
- 9:13vibes going. OK, but what about bad moods? Because
- 9:17there's that study where students were tricked
- 9:20into thinking they broke an expensive camera.
- 9:22Oh, the guilt study. Yeah, they felt terrible.
- 9:25They thought they ruined this piece of equipment.
- 9:27And because they felt guilty, they were way more
- 9:29likely to help a totally different person later
- 9:32on. They were basically trying to wash away their
- 9:35sins. And you using the phrase wash away. is
- 9:39perfect because that leads to the Macbeth effect.
- 9:42Named after Lady Macbeth furiously washing the
- 9:45imaginary blood off her hands. Exactly. The textbook
- 9:48points out this fascinating neurological quirk.
- 9:51The researchers found that if guilty people,
- 9:53like the ones who broke the camera, are given
- 9:55the opportunity to literally wash their hands
- 9:57with soap, or even just watch someone else wash
- 9:59their hands. They're guilt. It just vanishes.
- 10:02It significantly decreases. Because the human
- 10:05brain uses the same region to process physical
- 10:08disgust, like smelling rotten food and moral
- 10:11disgust, they are mapped together. That is insane.
- 10:14So physically washing your hands sends a signal
- 10:16to your brain that you are morally clean too.
- 10:19And the crazy part, once they washed their hands,
- 10:22they were less likely to help someone afterwards.
- 10:24Okay, I have an analogy for this. It's like hitting
- 10:27the reset button on a video game. Oh, I like
- 10:29that. Go on. You do something bad, so your emotional
- 10:32health bar drops to 50%. We just desperately
- 10:35want our health bar back to 100. And helping
- 10:38someone is just an item we can consume to get
- 10:40our health back up. Yes, exactly. But if we find
- 10:42a quick health pack like washing our hands with
- 10:44soap, boom, we're back at 100%. We don't need
- 10:48the helping item anymore, so we just walk right
- 10:50past the person in need. That is a phenomenal
- 10:52way to explain the Macbeth effect. But here is
- 10:55the counterpoint. We've established we help to
- 10:57fix our own minor bad moods. But what happens
- 11:00in a severe emergency, like a literal, bloody
- 11:03car crash? Does altruism survive when the emotional
- 11:07input is that extreme? Right. And to answer that,
- 11:10we have to define the critical difference between
- 11:13personal distress and empathy. Right. So personal
- 11:16distress is that sick, uncomfortable feeling
- 11:19you get in your stomach when you see someone
- 11:20suffering. It's totally focused on yourself.
- 11:23You just want the bad feeling to stop. Yes, whereas
- 11:26empathy is truly feeling the other person's emotions,
- 11:30you are focused on them. And Batson tested this
- 11:33with the shock study. Oh, the one with Elaine.
- 11:35Yes. Participants watched an actor, Elaine, get
- 11:39what looked like painful electric shocks. It
- 11:42was super distressing to watch. They split the
- 11:46participants up. For some, escape was easy. They
- 11:48could just leave the room. For others, it was
- 11:50hard. They were told they had to stay and watch
- 11:52the whole thing. And the results totally isolated
- 11:54the two emotions. Completely. The people who
- 11:57were just feeling personal distress, they bolted
- 11:59the second they had the easy escape. They just
- 12:01wanted to reduce their own discomfort. Out of
- 12:03sight, out of mind. Exactly. But the people who
- 12:05were actually feeling empathy for Elaine, even
- 12:08when they had the easy option to walk away, they
- 12:10stayed. And they actually volunteered to take
- 12:13the remaining shocks for her. Wow. So empathy
- 12:16actually overrides the selfish program. It does,
- 12:19but even with empathy, actually helping in an
- 12:22emergency is incredibly complicated. Latane and
- 12:26Darley created a whole bystander intervention
- 12:29model to explain this. Right, because helping
- 12:31isn't just one decision. It's a whole gauntlet
- 12:33you have to run. A psychological gauntlet? Yes.
- 12:36There are four steps. First, you have to notice
- 12:39the event. Which is hard if you're, like, staring
- 12:42at your phone. Right. Second, you have to interpret
- 12:44it as an emergency. Is that couple fighting or
- 12:47just joking around? Third, you have to assume
- 12:50personal responsibility. And fourth, you have
- 12:52to actually implement action, like knowing how
- 12:55to do CPR. And the biggest trap for the exam
- 12:57is that third step, right? Assuming personal
- 13:00responsibility. Absolutely. Because of the diffusion
- 13:02of responsibility? Like, if you are alone with
- 13:05someone who collapses, you have 100 % of the
- 13:08responsibility to help them. But if you're in
- 13:10a crowded subway car... Everyone assumes someone
- 13:12else will do it. Yeah, you only feel like 2 %
- 13:15responsible. Everyone is just mutually frozen
- 13:17waiting for someone else to pass that third step.
- 13:20Which is why the standard CPR training advice
- 13:22is so specific. You don't just yell, help, to
- 13:25the crowd. You point at someone and say, You
- 13:27in the red shirt, call 911. Because it forces
- 13:30100 % of the responsibility onto that one specific
- 13:33person. Exactly. It shatters the diffusion. OK,
- 13:36so up until now, we focused entirely on the helper,
- 13:38the genetic math, the moods, the bystander stuff.
- 13:42But I want to flip the script for a second. OK,
- 13:43let's do it. The textbook has this whole section
- 13:46on the dark side of receiving help. Like, why
- 13:50do people sometimes get super defensive or angry
- 13:52when you try to help them? Ah, yes. Because helping
- 13:55inherently creates a power imbalance. It makes
- 13:58the helper look competent and the recipient look
- 14:00incompetent. We distinguish between two types
- 14:03of help here. Dependency -oriented help and autonomy
- 14:06-oriented help. Right. So dependency -oriented
- 14:09help is when you just step in, take over, and
- 14:13fix the problem for them. Which makes them feel
- 14:15like a helpless child? It crushes their self
- 14:17-esteem. Right. And autonomy -oriented help is
- 14:19when you provide the tools or instructions so
- 14:22they can fix it themselves. My mnemonic for this
- 14:26is the old fishing quote. Give a man a fish.
- 14:29Exactly. Give a man a fish. It's dependency -oriented,
- 14:32and he feels like a dependent loser. Teach a
- 14:34man to fish. It's autonomy -oriented, and he
- 14:37keeps his self -esteem. That is a perfect way
- 14:39to remember it. And we also have to remember
- 14:41that how we give and receive help is heavily
- 14:44influenced by cultural quirks. Oh, Western versus
- 14:46Eastern cultures. Right. Contrast an individualistic
- 14:49culture like the US with a collectivistic one
- 14:52like India. In India, helping someone is often
- 14:55seen as an absolute moral obligation. It's just
- 14:57what you do. But in the US, we have the norm
- 14:59of self -interest. Yes. We are deeply suspicious
- 15:02of pure altruism. We always wonder what's their
- 15:05angle. Which leads to the candle study. This
- 15:08is so hilarious to me, but also kind of depressing.
- 15:11It is very revealing. So researchers found that
- 15:13Westerners are actually way more likely to donate
- 15:16to a charity if they are given a cheap, useless
- 15:18little candle in return. Yes. We literally need
- 15:22a physical object to pretend the exchange is
- 15:25selfish. because pure altruism feels culturally
- 15:28weird to us. We need an excuse to be nice. We
- 15:31tell ourselves, oh, I'm not a bleeding heart
- 15:33altruist. I just really wanted this three cent
- 15:35candle. It's an exchange fiction to protect our
- 15:38cultural identity. That is so wild. Okay, so
- 15:41to summarize everything for our study session,
- 15:43helping is just this massive complicated web.
- 15:47It really is. It's the genetic math of saving
- 15:49our relatives. It's a calculation of time pressure
- 15:52and cognitive load. It's using strangers to refill
- 15:55our emotional health bar by washing away guilt.
- 15:58And it's this crazy bystander gauntlet where
- 16:00we have to actively fight diffusion of responsibility.
- 16:03And avoid crushing people's autonomy while doing
- 16:05it. Right. So I guess we leave you, the listener,
- 16:08with a final puzzle to mull over before the exam.
- 16:11A provocative thought. If every act of helping,
- 16:14whether it's getting a good mood, avoiding a
- 16:17fine, pleasing God, passing on genes, or washing
- 16:20away guilt if it all has a psychological payoff
- 16:23for the helper. Does pure selfless altruism actually
- 16:26exist? Exactly. And more importantly, if the
- 16:29person drowning actually gets rescued or if those
- 16:31150 families in New Orleans get a new home, does
- 16:35it even matter why the helpee did it? Wow. Does
- 16:37the why even matter if the help arrives? I love
- 16:40that. Well, thanks for sitting in on our study
- 16:42session today. Hopefully it helps with your own
- 16:44psychology exams. Definitely. Goodbye from the
- 16:47psychology undergrad.