Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [13F] Berkshire Hathaway: Warren Buffett bought Alphabet?!
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the debate. Our focus today is Alphabet Inc.
- 0:04That's Google's parent company, of course, a stock that has,
- 0:08well, it's become the epicenter of this extraordinary
- 0:11intellectual divide within the investment community.
- 0:13This split really intensified following their strong Q32025
- 0:17earnings report and, maybe more significantly, the revelation
- 0:22that Berkshire Hathaway initiated A multibillion dollar
- 0:25stake. That Berkshire move is
- 0:26fascinating, yeah, but it certainly hasn't quieted the
- 0:29critics. Absolutely not, and you know
- 0:31that's the central tension we have to address.
- 0:35Does Alphabets monumental AI driven capital expenditure and
- 0:39we're talking 10s of billions here.
- 0:41Does it justify the premium valuation the market currently
- 0:45affords it? Or does its undeniable failure
- 0:48to meet traditional deep value metrics mean the stock is just
- 0:52priced for perfection with virtually no margin of safety?
- 0:55I'm here to argue that Alphabet is a wonderful company at a fair
- 0:59price. It's superior quality and growth
- 1:02metrics, while they overwhelmingly justify its
- 1:04valuation, fitting perfectly into a growth at a reasonable
- 1:08price or GARP framework. And I come at it from a very
- 1:11different perspective. I'm going to argue that while
- 1:14Alphabet is certainly a wonderful company, it
- 1:16fundamentally fails traditional defensive deep value screens.
- 1:20The soaring fixed costs associated with this AI arms
- 1:23race combined with some pretty substantial governance risks
- 1:26mean that at current prices, well, the stock simply lacks the
- 1:29margin of safety required for a prudent long term investment.
- 1:33The risk profile has just fundamentally changed for the
- 1:35worse. I wish the sheer quality of the
- 1:37underlying business which the Q32025 results confirmed, I mean
- 1:42vividly. Alphabet reported its first ever
- 1:45quarter with revenue exceeding $100 billion.
- 1:49That's a powerful 16% year over year increase.
- 1:53More impressively, diluted earnings per share growth surged
- 1:5735% year over year. So this isn't some mature
- 2:01company running out of steam. It's a high growth compounding
- 2:04machine firing on all cylinders. Now look, I readily acknowledge
- 2:09that Alphabet fails the strict gram style PE less than 15
- 2:12screen. It's PE is currently around 27.
- 2:15When traditional deep value investors look for a defensive
- 2:18multiple of 15 or less, 27 is a huge hurdle.
- 2:22It's more than just a hurdle, it's a complete non starter for
- 2:25classic value investing. But this is where we need to
- 2:28introduce a little bit of nuance.
- 2:31The high PE of 27 is, I think, mathematically justified when
- 2:36you consider its rapid growth. This company passes the crucial
- 2:40growth at a reasonable price, or garb test.
- 2:43Garb is a philosophy where you pay a little extra for
- 2:46exceptional growth. The key metric here is the PEG
- 2:50ratio, the price to earnings divided by the growth rate.
- 2:54Alphabet's PEG ratio sits at a remarkably low .79.
- 2:58A peg below one point O suggests that you know relative to its
- 3:02high earnings growth, the stock is actually undervalued.
- 3:06Furthermore, the operational quality is undeniable.
- 3:10Return on equity soar to 30.8% in return on invested capital
- 3:14consistently sits above 20%. These are truly world class
- 3:19figures that prove management is exceptionally efficient in
- 3:22deploying and generating capital.
- 3:24That's a compelling argument for quality, I'll grant you that.
- 3:28But I just don't buy that the market price is rational simply
- 3:31because the growth rate is currently high.
- 3:34Growth is fleeting. Price is eternal.
- 3:36Let me tell you why traditional metrics must still hold sway if
- 3:40we stick to fundamental, time tested deep value standards.
- 3:44Alphabet fails almost every classic test.
- 3:47We've established the failure on PE, but consider the price to
- 3:50book ratio, which is currently 8.70.
- 3:54This means you are paying nearly nine times the liquidation value
- 3:58of the business, dramatically exceeding the defensive standard
- 4:01limit of 1.5. This removes almost all
- 4:05statistical safety. But perhaps the most damning
- 4:08failure for a value investor concerned with true long term
- 4:11earning power is the owner's earnings yield.
- 4:14Owners earnings, for those unfamiliar, is essentially net
- 4:17income plus depreciation minus the capital expenditures needed
- 4:21to maintain the business. It's a measure of the cash flow
- 4:24truly available to owners. Alphabets OE yield is only 4.0%
- 4:31against the desired deep value minimum of 10%.
- 4:35We are simply not being compensated for the operational
- 4:37risks with a sufficient yield and those risks are growing
- 4:40because the company is fundamentally transforming.
- 4:43Management is forecast full year 2025 capital expenditure to be a
- 4:47staggering 91 to $93 billion to fund this AI infrastructure race
- 4:52that dramatically increases operational leverage and thus
- 4:55the risk exposure during any future economic slowdown.
- 4:58I see the mathematical failures you're pointing out against
- 5:01traditional screens. However, I think we are
- 5:03fundamentally mislabeling this capital outlay That $91 billion
- 5:08plus in CapEx is not reckless spending.
- 5:11It is necessary growth CapEx and we have definitive quantitative
- 5:15proof that this spending is de risked.
- 5:17We need to look at Google Clouds remaining performance obligation
- 5:21or RPO. OK, define that for us.
- 5:24Certainly the RPO is, well, it's essentially their contractual
- 5:28backlog. It represents contractually
- 5:30obligated future revenue that customers have already committed
- 5:32to spending on cloud services. That backlog has surged to a
- 5:36whopping $155 billion. So they are not guessing where
- 5:41future AI demand will be. They are building pre sold
- 5:45infrastructure to service demand that they currently cannot even
- 5:49meet. The CapEx is a high return
- 5:51deployment of capital designed to build the next competitive
- 5:54Moat in enterprise AI. And crucially, it is
- 5:57substantially de rest by signed customer contracts.
- 6:01This is the definition of deploying capital efficiently to
- 6:04compound value. OK.
- 6:06The RPO number is impressive. I'll grant you that.
- 6:10It definitely dampens the short term speculative risk of the
- 6:13spending. They have customers lined up
- 6:15today. However, you're focusing only on
- 6:18the short term demand. We have to focus on the
- 6:21structural permanent change this CapEx imposes on the company's
- 6:25cost structure. This massive CapEx introduces A
- 6:28permanently higher, riskier fixed cost base.
- 6:32We can quantify this risk directly by looking at the ratio
- 6:35of depreciation to gross profit over the trailing 12 months.
- 6:39The TTM data depreciation measures the non cash cost of
- 6:43their fixed assets data centers servers wearing out.
- 6:48This ratio has spiked to 19.8% in the most recent data, up
- 6:52dramatically from its historical average of around 11.2%.
- 6:57This signals a massive non discretionary fixed cost is now
- 7:01baked into the income statement while the $155 billion backlog
- 7:05is being worked through. Things look great, but what
- 7:08happens when those contracts are fulfilled or if macroeconomic
- 7:11conditions tighten globally? That new, higher fixed cost base
- 7:15means margins will contract far more sharply and violently than
- 7:18they have in the past. This is precisely why smart
- 7:22investors are warning that this AI CapEx race risks becoming a
- 7:25tremendous amount of capital destruction if returns on that
- 7:28capital don't dramatically exceed the cost.
- 7:31But that calculation assumes those assets are simply
- 7:34maintenance destined only to wear out.
- 7:37They are not. They are the core infrastructure
- 7:41fueling the next generation of high margin services, giving
- 7:45Google the scale advantage in AI deployment globally.
- 7:48Let's talk about the valuation metrics that actually matter for
- 7:51a compounding business rather than those designed purely for
- 7:55cyclical low growth enterprises. Hold on, price always matters.
- 7:59I challenge your reliance on the PEG ratio because it inherently
- 8:02relies on high growth rates continuing forever.
- 8:06Traditional defensive metrics cannot be ignored for a true
- 8:09value investment. Let's look at the intrinsic
- 8:11value today, our conservative discounted cash flow analysis,
- 8:15which assumes FCF growth only at 4.7%.
- 8:18And we use that floor because it's the minimum sustained FCF
- 8:22growth rate they've maintained over the last decade.
- 8:24Ignoring the current AI hype that still places the intrinsic
- 8:27value at $244.84 per share. At the current market price near
- 8:32$278, the stock is already slightly overvalued by this
- 8:36conservative floor, let alone offering the necessary 30%
- 8:39margin of safety that value investors typically demand when
- 8:43a company fails the necessary owners earnings yield test,
- 8:45offering only 4.0%. You are primarily buying future
- 8:49expectation and narrative, not present value or statistical
- 8:52protection. I'm not convinced by that line
- 8:54of reasoning because using a deeply conservative DCF that
- 8:58assumes a company currently growing EPS at 35% will suddenly
- 9:02decelerate to a permanent 4.7% cash flow growth is, well, it's
- 9:07structurally improbable given the secular tailwinds of digital
- 9:10advertising and cloud adoption. The 4.7% rate is an artifact of
- 9:15the past, not a predictor of the future for a business dominating
- 9:18the global information architecture.
- 9:20This is precisely why the market validates the GARP framework.
- 9:23The PEG of .79 suggests that relative to its achievable
- 9:27growth, it is undervalued. Look at a more realistic DCF,
- 9:30the nominal growth DCF. This assumes a very achievable
- 9:3310% growth for 10 years, followed by a 3% terminal rate.
- 9:37That projection yields an intrinsic value of $451.24,
- 9:42implying a significant 62% upside at current prices.
- 9:45That's a wonderful dream scenario, but it hinges entirely
- 9:48on their ability to execute that massive CapEx program and
- 9:51maintain margins. And this is where the non price
- 9:54margin of safety comes in. We're discussing a company with
- 9:57a fortress balance sheet. The debt to equity ratio is a
- 9:59minuscule .11 and they sit on $98.5 billion in cash.
- 10:05This is a non price structural defense that acts as a profound
- 10:08safeguard against the increased operational leverage you
- 10:11correctly identify. This balance sheet safety
- 10:14combined with world class net margins of 28.2% provides A
- 10:18structural note. The traditional PE multiples,
- 10:21you know, designed for capital intensive cyclical companies
- 10:24simply fail to capture. The Berkshire Hathaway purchase,
- 10:27in my view, is a tacit validation of this exact
- 10:30approach, paying a fair price for unparalleled quality,
- 10:33security and compounding power. The balance sheet safety is
- 10:37indeed their primary redeeming quality, but it brings us
- 10:40straight back to governance. That cash fortress and that debt
- 10:43free balance sheet enable the founders to pursue this high
- 10:46CapEx, high risk vision entirely insulated from activist
- 10:49pressure. The ultimate safeguard for
- 10:51minority shareholders is their voice and Alphabet's dual class
- 10:55share structure removes that voice entirely.
- 10:57Co founders Larry Page and Sergey Brin retain 51% of the
- 11:01voting power. This governance failure is
- 11:03critical precisely because it means management can commit to
- 11:06that massive $91 billion CapEx without meaningful external
- 11:10check or opposition from the public shareholders.
- 11:13We saw this reality demonstrated in the 2025 proxy vote, where
- 11:16proposals for equal shareholder voting were overwhelmingly
- 11:19defeated, receiving only 3.8 billion votes in favor versus
- 11:228.6 billion against, all due to the Founders voting bloc.
- 11:26The lack of control is a major risk when management is
- 11:29deploying capital at this scale. I agree the structure limits
- 11:33minority shareholder control, but I would frame the dual class
- 11:37structure as a strategic feature that allows for necessary long
- 11:41term strategic planning unburdened by the short term
- 11:45tyranny of quarterly earnings. This stability ultimately
- 11:48benefits all shareholders. The founders economic interests
- 11:52are profoundly aligned with ours.
- 11:54They own approximately 12% of the equity valued around $170
- 11:59billion. They are not fleeting
- 12:01executives, They are owner operators whose wealth is
- 12:04entirely tied to the company's long term success.
- 12:08The recent commitment to a substantial $70 billion annual
- 12:12buyback program and the initiation of a dividend
- 12:15demonstrates a strong unambiguous commitment to
- 12:18returning economic value even without formal shareholder
- 12:21pressure. The market isn't ignoring the
- 12:23risk, it's betting on the jockeys that their long term
- 12:27vision will continue to compound the pie effectively.
- 12:29So wrapping up my argument, Alphabets phenomenal
- 12:33profitability, it's robust growth, successful capital
- 12:36allocation evidenced by that $155 billion RPO and it's
- 12:41fortress like balance sheet all confirm it is a high quality
- 12:45compounder. The high valuation trading at a
- 12:48PEG ratio below one point O is a reflection of this durable
- 12:52quality and exceptional growth trajectory, not a flaw.
- 12:56The non price margin of safety is what truly protects this
- 12:59investment. And to summarize my view, while
- 13:02the underlying business quality is undeniable, the current price
- 13:07offers no statistical margin of safety based on traditional
- 13:12defensive value tests like PE or the owner's earnings yield.
- 13:16The dramatic rise in the fixed cost base due to aggressive
- 13:19CapEx combined with the structural lack of public
- 13:22shareholder governance represents significant
- 13:25structural risks that are just not compensated for by a
- 13:28sufficient discount in the stock price.
- 13:30It remains a wonderful company, but unfortunately it is priced
- 13:33for flawless execution, offering no buffer for investor error or
- 13:36macro surprise. Our analysis therefore really
- 13:40underscores the complexity of evaluating a unique financial
- 13:44powerhouse like Alphabet. It forces every investor to
- 13:47choose which framework to prioritize.
- 13:49Indeed, an investor's assessment depends entirely on whether they
- 13:53prioritize statistical undervaluation and safety
- 13:57measures designed to prevent losses or durable quality and
- 14:00sustain compounding growth prospects.
- 14:03The material presents compelling evidence that supports both
- 14:06sides of this enduring investment debate, confirming
- 14:09that true clarity often requires A rigorous challenge to core
- 14:13assumptions.