Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #40: Are Congress and State Legislatures Productive...or "Do-Nothing"?
Transcript
- 0:00Is it that time again?
- 0:01Yes.
- 0:01It is.
- 0:02Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast.
- 0:06I'm your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:08Today, we're gonna talk about the productivity of congress and state legislatures.
- 0:14Do we really have a do nothing congress?
- 0:18The phrase do nothing congress can be traced all the way back to 1948 when democrat Harry
- 0:23Truman was in the midst of his election campaign to secure a full term as president
- 0:28after succeeding FDR when he died at the beginning of his fourth term for president.
- 0:34After the end of a special session that Truman called that year for the Republican controlled
- 0:39congress, a reporter asked president Truman, would you say it was a do nothing session,
- 0:44mister president?
- 0:45To which Truman gleefully replied, I would say it was a do nothing session.
- 0:50Now whether or not that was accurate, this depiction of a do nothing congress has stuck
- 0:56throughout the decades, though, to varying degrees for each congressional session.
- 1:01But is it accurate?
- 1:04Does congress really whittle its thumbs or sit on its hands or just generally act obstinately?
- 1:11Well, I'm not gonna say that we're gonna answer those questions once and for all because as
- 1:16you'll see in here on this episode, answering whether or not congress is productive isn't so
- 1:22straightforward.
- 1:23You can also look at it through the prism of the entire legislative body or just one chamber
- 1:28or specific legislators to name a few dimensions.
- 1:32But that being said, the goal is to get you, the listeners and viewers, some steps closer to
- 1:37answering that question yourself.
- 1:40And we're going to extend this to state legislatures as well because undoubtedly some,
- 1:45if not all of them, have been lamented as do nothing legislatures as well.
- 1:50So today, we'll talk about some ways legislative processes can differ between states
- 1:55and how that can affect productivity, at least some of the ways that we typically define
- 2:00productivity, as well as between as well as differences between state legislatures and
- 2:06congress and some data on bills introduced and enacted in the states and congress because
- 2:11usually productivity is thought of as how many bills that they enact from how many did they
- 2:18introduce, and some more normative and philosophical questions about what defines a
- 2:24productive legislature.
- 2:26Here we go.
- 2:27So not not gonna get too much into all of the finer workings of the legislative process in
- 2:32general.
- 2:33Focus on that maybe for another episode, but do wanna highlight some of the key differences
- 2:39between legislative processes because it matters for this discussion on productivity.
- 2:45Legislative processes look largely the same or similar between states and congress or and also
- 2:52just between the states amongst themselves, but there are some quirks to pay attention to.
- 2:58There's actually quite a few of them that we could go over.
- 3:01A lot of them that we could go over, but for time's sake, I'm just covering, four things.
- 3:07So first of all, talking about legislators needed for a quorum.
- 3:12So a quorum is a minimum number of legislators that are required for chamber business to
- 3:17proceed, especially for voting on bills.
- 3:20If you don't have the quorum, there's you can't really officially conduct business.
- 3:26Now in what what that what is a considered a quorum differs from legislature to legislature.
- 3:35Quorums or the quorum needed for both chambers of congress is just a civil majority, and most
- 3:40state legislatures are the same as that.
- 3:43But Massachusetts only needs two fifths of its state senate and three eighths of its state
- 3:49house to be considered a quorum.
- 3:51So they don't even need half of their chambers.
- 3:55Meanwhile, Indiana, Oregon, Tennessee, and Texas, their state legislatures chambers need
- 4:01to have two thirds people present.
- 4:04But within a state, though, a quorum requirement might be different depending on
- 4:09what activity is being done by that legislative body or the type of legislation they're talking
- 4:15about.
- 4:15For example, in Wisconsin, normally, you just need a simple majority for a quorum.
- 4:21But when it comes to dealing with budget bills, they need two thirds of the chambers to be
- 4:26there.
- 4:27So what is the impact of a quorum on productivity?
- 4:31Well, if a quorum can't be reached, you can't vote on bills.
- 4:35You can't introduce them.
- 4:36You can't really do anything really except yell and shake your fist at the people who aren't
- 4:42showing up.
- 4:44And because of quorum requirements, sometimes the minority party has strategically used a
- 4:49walkout to prevent the majority party from voting on bills and and conducting certain
- 4:55business.
- 4:55They say, well, if they're just gonna ram things down our throats, at least in their
- 4:59eyes, if they're gonna ram things down our throats, we're just not gonna show up so they
- 5:04can't actually do anything.
- 5:06But in a lot of cases, this isn't feasible because the minority party a lot of times
- 5:11doesn't have enough members to prevent a quorum, especially in those states where you
- 5:16just need a simple majority for a quorum or in congress where you need a a simple majority for
- 5:22a quorum, you rarely have a third party or no party elected official in those seats, so they
- 5:31can't really tip the balance in a way where they could stage a walkout.
- 5:38But whereas in a place like Indiana and Oregon and Tennessee and Texas where you need two
- 5:43thirds to reach a quorum, it's a little bit easier or I should say it's much easier in some
- 5:50well, in Oregon, at least, it's easier because it's a little bit more balanced even though
- 5:56Oregon is definitely a democratic state.
- 5:58It's definitely a blue state.
- 6:00It's there there is still a big enough republican presence that they can sometimes
- 6:06stage a walkout, which actually they did.
- 6:10Oregon Republicans in 2021 and 2023 were able to to do that.
- 6:16And and on the democratic side, Minnesota democrats were just able to do that with the
- 6:21end of 2024, through the start of this year, '25.
- 6:27It right and it ended.
- 6:28The quorum requirements have had noticeable impacts on productivity, for example, in Oregon
- 6:35and Minnesota.
- 6:36Another key difference between legislatures that can affect their productivity is when you
- 6:41can file bills.
- 6:43Most state legislatures, 41 of them to be exact, allow for what is called prefiling of
- 6:49bills, although Minnesota only allows it for sessions and even numbered years.
- 6:53But prefiling of bills is when a legislature puts a bill up or officially put puts the bill
- 7:02into consideration for when the legislature actually starts.
- 7:06So let or the session actually starts.
- 7:08The session hasn't actually started yet.
- 7:10It's during the downtime between sessions, but the the but they do it to get ahead of things.
- 7:20And it's not like with congress where congress meets almost the entire year with that with the
- 7:26exception of a couple recesses.
- 7:28Vast majority of of state legislatures are far shorter.
- 7:31Their sessions are far shorter than that.
- 7:34But even for states that allow prefiling, there are stipulations as to when they can be filed.
- 7:40For example, there's different times for when prefiling can actually begin.
- 7:44It's not like you can necessarily do it any time during, the off season for lack of a
- 7:52better term.
- 7:52Although some states do let you do that, but some states, they only let you do it at a
- 7:57certain point.
- 7:57For example, Utah, you you can start prefiling sixty days after the end of the previous
- 8:03session.
- 8:04And then there's also different times when prefiling must end.
- 8:08So you can't necessarily just prefile up to the beginning of the legislative session.
- 8:15You might have to stop it some days or weeks beforehand.
- 8:19So how does this how does prefiling impact productivity?
- 8:23Well, it allows legislature legislators to get a drafted bill ready for a session as soon as
- 8:31the session begins.
- 8:32They don't have to use up as much session time to draft bills, and other legislators can
- 8:38already look at the bill to get some sense of what it is.
- 8:41The pre filing is a way for you to just get the bill out there ready to go so you don't have to
- 8:47spend all that time drafting and as much time trying to get people to support.
- 8:53Another key difference between state legislatures and between state legislatures and
- 8:59congress is which legislative committees exist in those state legislatures because each state
- 9:08or some states have committees that don't exist in other states.
- 9:13Or for example, the appropriations committee in one state may be broken down into different
- 9:20subcommittees that another state doesn't have, you you'll see different committees and
- 9:24subcommittees within each state compared to another state.
- 9:30And this affects which committees a bill has to go through before it gets to the whole chamber
- 9:36floor because bills have to go through committees that deal with that bill's subject
- 9:40matter.
- 9:41So if it's k through 12 education or or health care or or veterans, It whatever the bill has
- 9:51to deal with, it has to go to those committees.
- 9:54And if it has to deal with more committees, it gets a little bit more bogged down.
- 9:59So what is the impact of these difference in legislative committees?
- 10:03It's well, if you may need more committees to sign off on a bill.
- 10:08It might need to go through a subcommittee before the full committee if it's a large
- 10:13enough committee for a large enough subject area.
- 10:17Whereas some other states, it might just be a more straightforward process, just one
- 10:22committee to get through and then gets to the rest of the chamber floor.
- 10:26And then the last thing we'll cover in terms of how much it impacts legislative productivity is
- 10:33the robustness robustness of the legislative staff.
- 10:38So in Washington DC and in all the state capitals, there's various kinds of staff on
- 10:44hand in the legislature.
- 10:45There's committee staff.
- 10:47So the staff that is for for a specific committee, like the Armed Forces Committee in
- 10:52in in congress.
- 10:53There are staff members specifically for that committee.
- 10:56Chamber staff.
- 10:57So for a house or or and for a senate for specifically for those chambers, you might see
- 11:02staffs there or or staff members just for that chamber.
- 11:07Party staff.
- 11:07So Republican party members Democratic party members might be Democratic house reps and then
- 11:14Democratic senators and then Republican house reps and then Republican senators, legislative
- 11:19aids that are for specific legislators, and and all these vary considerably across these
- 11:27legislatures.
- 11:28Oh, there's also some policy arms that are either officially part of the legislature or
- 11:33they're closely tied to a legislature that assist in policy analysis.
- 11:39But, yeah, there's tons of these kinds of people on Capitol Hill.
- 11:42States with full time legislatures tend to have more robust staff because there's a lot of
- 11:46legislature legislatures that are considered part time.
- 11:52So they they these lawmakers tend to meet for much fewer days than a full time legislature.
- 12:01They have less compensation.
- 12:03They have smaller staffs.
- 12:05So the impact on productivity in terms of the robustness of legislative staff is,
- 12:11theoretically, at least, if you have more staff members, it helps legislators be more
- 12:16productive because they these staff members provide more information to on bills to these
- 12:23legislators, take care of and or take care of other duties that the legislator doesn't have
- 12:27to take care of themselves.
- 12:28They have to set up meetings with another legislator, for example.
- 12:32You'll see a lot more of these kinds of people on in in Capitol Hill for congress.
- 12:37You might see them in a more well funded legislature state legislature like New York's
- 12:44or California's, but you don't necessarily get this big staff in other states with part time
- 12:53legislatures.
- 12:54So those four things are four key differences between state legislatures and the state
- 13:02legislature and congress that can really affect how productive those legislators are.
- 13:07So now that we've talked about some of the more qualitative things that affect the productivity
- 13:13of legislators and productivity here, for the sake of argument, we're measuring productivity
- 13:17based on how many bills were introduced and the percentage of those that were enacted.
- 13:22So first, we're gonna cover congressional bills.
- 13:25And GovTrack has data that's g o g o vTrack, has data going back to the ninety third
- 13:33congress, which was 1973 to 1974 on how far bills went.
- 13:38So it includes enacted legislation, passed resolutions, whether it got a vote, whether it
- 13:44failed to pass, if they were vetoed, or they were introduced, but they just didn't go
- 13:47anywhere.
- 13:48And I'm not gonna bore you with every single legislative sessions, or congressional
- 13:53sessions, number of bills introduced and and, which how many were the percentage that were
- 14:01enacted.
- 14:01Although, I'll give you some real top line info in a minute, but I will say that the if you if
- 14:07you were to visualize it, the percentage of bills that were enacted and and to an extent
- 14:13also the number of bills that were introduced kind of ebbs and flows throughout time.
- 14:18But there was a particular dip in the number that were introduced in the late nineties and
- 14:24early two thousands.
- 14:25But more in-depth look at the GovTrack analysis.
- 14:31On average, when we're talking about the highest activity by month in a congressional
- 14:34term, we saw the highest percentage of bills introduced in the first month of a
- 14:39congressional term, so the January of the first session.
- 14:43The highest percentage of bills enacted was in the October of the second session, so near the
- 14:49end of that congressional term coming right up onto mid well, not necessarily midterm
- 14:55elections, but federal elections, followed by December of that second session, so the month
- 15:00right after, and then December of the first session.
- 15:03So coming right up to the end of the calendar year is when you see a spike of legislation
- 15:08being enacted.
- 15:09And in the case of the second session, since it's coming right up on election time,
- 15:13suddenly, you see legislators get a little bit more antsy about making sure to pass
- 15:20legislation conveniently.
- 15:21But, also, I mean, the term is about to end, and so they need to get if they're gonna get
- 15:26legislation passed, they need to get it passed then.
- 15:30So in terms of top and bottom five purse in terms let me let me rephrase this.
- 15:39The top and bottom five congressional sessions in terms of the percent of enacted legislation.
- 15:46So bills that were passed divided by the bills that were introduced since the start of that
- 15:52ninety third congress, nineteen seventy three to '74.
- 15:55So highest percent of enacted bills.
- 15:59Number one was the one hundredth congress, which was 1987 to 1988.
- 16:03That was 8.9%.
- 16:06The second highest was the one hundred fifteenth congress, which was '17 2017 to 2018.
- 16:11That was 8%.
- 16:13Third, ninety ninth congress, nineteen eighty five to 86, eight point zero percent.
- 16:18Again, just the decimal place is a little bit little bit lower.
- 16:26Fourth, one hundred and first congress, nineteen eighty nine to nineteen ninety seven
- 16:33point seven percent.
- 16:34And then the fifth one was the ninety eighth congress, nineteen eighty three to 1984, and
- 16:41that was 7.4%.
- 16:43So there was a if we're talking about percentage of enacted bills, the congresses
- 16:50that were the most productive in that regard, four of the top five were in the eighties.
- 16:57So that's the highest percentage of enacted bills now onto the other end, which congresses
- 17:05since that ninety third congress saw the lowest percent of enacted bills.
- 17:10So the lowest percentage goes to the one hundred eighteenth congress, which was 2023 to
- 17:142024.
- 17:15So it was the last congress that we just had.
- 17:18That was 3.2%.
- 17:20And second place was the ninety fourth congress, which was 1975 to '76.
- 17:24That was 4%.
- 17:26Third place was January sec one hundred twelfth congress.
- 17:31I put 01/2012 January instead of January.
- 17:38'20 '11 to 2012, that was 4.1%.
- 17:43The fourth place was 01/2013 to 2014, which was 4.2%, and then the ninety third congress, which
- 17:51was '19 or 1973 to 1974, the beginning of this analysis, which was 4.3%.
- 18:01So the percentage of enacted bills in in congress for this period over the past about
- 18:09fifty two years now, it ranged anywhere from 3.2% to 8.9%.
- 18:19And and then now if we're talking about just led total legislation introduced, the highest
- 18:25number that were introduced, the ninety third congress had over 26,000 bills.
- 18:29The ninety fourth congress had over 24,000.
- 18:33The ninety fifth congress had over 22,000.
- 18:37The one hundred eighteenth congress had over 19,000.
- 18:42And then the one hundred seventeenth congress had which was twenty twenty twenty one to 2022,
- 18:47that was closing in on 18000.
- 18:50So the one hundred eighteenth congress had the lowest percentage of enacted bills, but it had
- 18:56the fourth highest number of bills introduced.
- 19:00But you you saw at the from the beginning of this analysis that '9 ninety third congress,
- 19:06nineteen seventy three to 1974, and then the couple of congresses after, there was a lot of
- 19:13bills introduced.
- 19:15There were a lot of bills introduced.
- 19:19Meanwhile, the lowest number of bills introduced, was the one hundred fourth
- 19:23congress, which was just under 8,000, the one hundred fifth congress, which was 1997 to 1998,
- 19:29that was somewhat over 9,000.
- 19:32It's over 9,000.
- 19:34One hundred third, 19 90 three to 1994, '19 '90 '3 was when I was born.
- 19:39Woo hoo.
- 19:41Somewhat under 10,000 is about 9,800.
- 19:45The one hundred and thirteenth congress, twenty thirteen to 2014, '10 thousand '6 hundred
- 19:51thereabouts.
- 19:52And then the and fifth place was a one hundred seventh congress, two thousand one to 02/2002,
- 19:57'10 thousand '7 hundred '80 '9.
- 20:00So the like I said, earlier, the late nineties to the early two thousands saw a major dip in
- 20:06the number of bills introduced, and then it kinda came back up.
- 20:09So to go back over those again real quick, highest percentage of enacted bills was 8.9%,
- 20:16eight point zero %, eight point zero %, seven point seven %, and 7.4%.
- 20:22Lowest percent lowest percentage of enacted bills was 3.2% to 4% to 4.1% to 4.2% to 4.3%.
- 20:34And then for top and bottom, a number of less pieces of legislation introduced was a little
- 20:45over 26,000 to a little over 24,000 to somewhat over 22,000 to somewhat over 19,000 and then to
- 20:54somewhat close to 18,000, a little bit under 18,000.
- 20:59And then the lowest number of introduced bills was just under $88,000 to a little over 9,000
- 21:07to closing in on 10,000 to about 10,600 and then, a little bit closer to 11,000 for fifth
- 21:16place.
- 21:16So that's going to cover the congressional side.
- 21:19Now what about the state legislative side?
- 21:21What are the statistics on the success of state legislative bills there?
- 21:26Like with congress, for argument's sake, we'll measure productivity based on how many bills
- 21:31were introduced and the percentage of those that were enacted.
- 21:37Unfortunately, though, it is more difficult to study state legislature productivity and to
- 21:42compare them with congress because, there's a lot more data that you have to research because
- 21:47it's 50 legislatures.
- 21:49It's not thoroughly studied like with congress.
- 21:52Congress, federal government, federal politics get a lot more study inherently.
- 21:59And even when state legislatures have been studied, it can be sometimes tedious to find
- 22:05the info.
- 22:07There is also just much more variety in the rules and laws that govern legislative
- 22:15procedures.
- 22:15Legislative procedures look look largely the same across legislatures, but there are some
- 22:21key differences in those as well.
- 22:24Different partisan and group dynamics between states.
- 22:26So have a really heavily democratic state like Hawaii, then you have a heavily republican
- 22:32state like Wyoming, one that's a bit more split like Michigan.
- 22:38So bunch of different ones that you have to consider, the different partisan and
- 22:43ideological and group realities that you have to account for in those, varying standards,
- 22:49and, yeah, and varying standards as to what constitutes productivity, which we'll
- 22:55definitely get into at the end of this.
- 22:56But all that being said, we do have at least a few studies that we can point to.
- 23:01I'm only gonna focus on a couple of them, that center on how many bills a whole chamber or
- 23:07legislature passed.
- 23:08There are some of this some studies I found that were focusing more on individual
- 23:13legislators.
- 23:15So I'm gonna, skip those for today because only have so much time to cover all this stuff.
- 23:22But I'm gonna point to a study by Quorum, not not like the Quorum we talked about before, an
- 23:29actual company called Quorum.
- 23:30They're a government affairs company, and they do things like, bill tracking and, a lot of
- 23:35different kinds of software for political groups.
- 23:40But, they had a study where, us on average from 2011 to 2015.
- 23:45At least I think this is what it was doing is for those years.
- 23:49The study didn't explicitly say it was those years, but it did have a chart for for them.
- 23:55On average from that 2011 to 2015, time frame, state legislatures introduced 23 times the
- 24:04number of bills that congress did.
- 24:06States overall averaged about a 28,000 bills per year.
- 24:10However, must account for the fact that there are 50 state legislatures, and the vast
- 24:17majority of them meet for a much shorter session than congress, and they also don't
- 24:22start sessions at the same time.
- 24:24Most of them begin in January, but you do have some that start in a different month.
- 24:30But then it also that quorum study covers the or has a has analysis on the first half of
- 24:37twenty sixteen.
- 24:38So I'm guessing this study didn't say specifically, but this study came out in, like,
- 24:43late twenty sixteen.
- 24:44But in the first half of twenty sixteen, there were just over 63,000 state legislative bills
- 24:50introduced.
- 24:5163,018 to be exact.
- 24:53Top five states by amount of legislation introduced, New Jersey, which had over 6,300.
- 24:59New York was about 4,700.
- 25:01Illinois was about 3,500.
- 25:04Montana was just over 3,000, and then Mississippi was closing in on 2,800.
- 25:10Top five states in enactment rate of legislation.
- 25:13So many bills were enacted divided by how many were introduced?
- 25:16Arkansas had 94%, passed, and Arkansas is a very red state.
- 25:24So that being so lopsided towards one party is probably pretty easy to have a higher enactment
- 25:31rate.
- 25:31More bills that are gonna be introduced and heard are gonna be coming from the Republican
- 25:35Party and be the same thing if it was a heavily Democratic state.
- 25:39Although we don't although not quite to that degree of legislative enactment.
- 25:46So number one was Arkansas with a 94% enactment rate.
- 25:52Number two was South Dakota at 56%, so still a lot of bills being passed, but a considerable
- 25:58drop off.
- 25:58Colorado, fifty five percent.
- 26:01Number four was Utah, fifty two percent, and then number five, Wyoming was 44%.
- 26:07So in that first half of twenty sixteen analysis, 19.3% of state senate bills and 13.3%
- 26:16of state house bills were enacted on average.
- 26:19But just 3.6% of US senate bills and 1.9% of US house bills were enacted.
- 26:27So very stark difference.
- 26:29But, again, remember, a lot of those state legislatures, they only meet for that certain
- 26:35time period.
- 26:36A lot of state a lot of state legislatures have a session that's two to six months long, so
- 26:42they kinda have to get all that done in that time frame, whereas congress has the whole
- 26:48year.
- 26:51And then another study too I wanna highlight is from fiscal note, which is has is some
- 26:56similarities to to quorum.
- 26:59There are another government so there are another government affairs company that
- 27:02includes services like bill tracking.
- 27:06In their most effective state's legislative report from 2021, they found that overall about
- 27:14150,000 bills were introduced in all 50 states that year, and 33,000 of them were passed.
- 27:22So there was about a 21% enactment rate.
- 27:26Top and bottom five in number of introduced bills.
- 27:29Top five in intro in introduced bills was New York with about 16,800.
- 27:34Massachusetts at second place was 13,400 or a little bit closer to 13,500.
- 27:40Number three, Texas was a little over 11,000.
- 27:43Number four, New Jersey was 10,800 ish.
- 27:46And then number five, Illinois was about 8,700.
- 27:49And then the bottom five was Alaska with just 436.
- 27:53So stark contrast, but Alaska has one of the shortest legislative sessions in all the
- 28:00states.
- 28:01But Alaska was the lowest introduced bills with 436.
- 28:06Number two was Wyoming with 441.
- 28:09Three was South Dakota with five fifty.
- 28:12Delaware was fourth place with 636, and then Colorado was fifth with 678.
- 28:20And then top and bottom five in percentage of enacted bills.
- 28:23So top five in percent of enacted bills.
- 28:27Number one was Colorado with about 81.3%.
- 28:32Louisiana was second place with 68%.
- 28:35Number three, Utah, 60 five point four percent.
- 28:38Number four, Arkansas, 60 point four percent.
- 28:43Number five, North Dakota was 58.9.
- 28:47And then bottom five in enacted legislation, number one, Massachusetts was 0.41%.
- 28:54You know?
- 28:54So that was another one of those cases where tons of introduced legislation, very, very few
- 29:02actually passed.
- 29:03So, again, the lowest percentage of enacted bills was Massachusetts, zero point forty one
- 29:11percent, followed by Minnesota, one point twenty two percent, then Missouri, two point
- 29:15seventy five percent, then Pennsylvania with four point, 1%, and then New Jersey with about
- 29:234.2%.
- 29:25So if we use the data for congress in 2021, given that it was the same year, 11,302 bills
- 29:34and resolutions were introduced in the 2021 session, and 833 of them passed.
- 29:39So 7.4% passage rate.
- 29:43So only New York and Massachusetts' state legislatures, introduced more bills than
- 29:50congress had that year.
- 29:52Texas was very close to having as many as congress did, but 45 states had a higher rate
- 29:58of enacting introduced bills than congress did in 2021.
- 30:04It's an interesting contrast with how very few states actually introduced more bills than
- 30:14congress did, but almost all the states had a higher rate of enacting introduced bills than
- 30:20congress did.
- 30:21So all in all, if our metric is for productivity is purely how many bills are
- 30:27introduced and passed and and that's all there is to it, there's a mix of state legislatures
- 30:32that are more productive than congress and others that are less productive.
- 30:38But you may ask yourself then, well, why do so many bills die so early?
- 30:44I mean, it just seems like it just seems pointless to have so many bills if you know so
- 30:50many of them are going to die.
- 30:53It's it's inevitable that most bills aren't gonna make it to the end.
- 30:56And lots of them die even in the committee stage, and the committee stage is very, very
- 31:00early.
- 31:01It's one of the earliest parts of the process.
- 31:03After you draft the bill and you and you introduce it, it goes to the committee and a
- 31:08lot and vast majority of them do not even make it out of there.
- 31:13So why why why does that happen so much?
- 31:17There are several big reasons, and you you can find more than these, but I wanna highlight
- 31:22four of them specifically for why the demise of bills often is so early or even if it's later
- 31:30on down the road.
- 31:33But one big thing is the time constraints.
- 31:37Time is a valuable resource because of how finite it is.
- 31:40You you sometimes hear the phrase that time's the most valuable resource that you have.
- 31:46It's impossible to hear every piece of legislation, let alone get it up for a vote.
- 31:53But you also it also means the political agenda means some issues are just going to get
- 31:58shelved.
- 31:59Could be a lack of power for the legislator that's introducing the bill.
- 32:04Another legislator who doesn't like that bill might be trying to find ways to tank that bill
- 32:09by knocking it down the agenda, not even so much trying to kill it in a committee.
- 32:13They just try to or they try to kill in the committee.
- 32:16If they don't, they just just bury it down the ledger.
- 32:20Anyways, who the leadership is in that legislature sets the tone for what the agenda
- 32:26is.
- 32:27And while congress meets the vast majority of the year, minus a couple of those recesses,
- 32:32almost every state legislature meets for a much shorter period of time.
- 32:36Mentioned that earlier.
- 32:38Most of them are only one or more like two to six months long.
- 32:43Some of them might be close to the length that congress meets up for, but, a state's regular
- 32:49session could be as short as thirty days.
- 32:51So a lot of these state legislatures just they don't meet very often.
- 32:57Doesn't mean they're not working.
- 32:58They could they're they still got town halls and and constituent service and all that to to
- 33:03do, but they're not doing the primary job that they were elected to do just because state laws
- 33:11just have shorter sessions.
- 33:13And that's a whether you should have longer sessions or not, that's a that's a whole other
- 33:18topic that I wanna cover at some point.
- 33:20But, so you just time constraints just tank a lot of bills.
- 33:26And it's not necessarily even anything nefarious.
- 33:28It's just there's just a lot of things that need to be heard, or there's other topics that
- 33:32are considered more pressing because they're part of the zeitgeist.
- 33:37They're they're on top of everybody's mind right now.
- 33:41Number two is political relationships or lack thereof.
- 33:46Wheeling, dealing with party members, so republicans with republicans, democrats with
- 33:51democrats.
- 33:52Sometimes you gotta wheel and deal with the opposing party, especially if that opposing
- 33:57party has majority control of the chamber.
- 34:00Because if they have majority control of the chamber, they control the agenda, so you
- 34:04sometimes need to have a little give and take with them.
- 34:06Even if a legislator has is not on the outs with the legislative leadership, that
- 34:11leadership may have built relationships with other legislators who get their bills heard
- 34:17first.
- 34:17So it's not even necessarily anything that that particular legislator did.
- 34:21It's it's just the other legislators are more buddy buddy with the leadership than this other
- 34:27one is.
- 34:28And then rank and file members, generally speaking, are less often going to get bills
- 34:32heard and passed because they're new.
- 34:35They're trying to forge relationships.
- 34:37They're trying to learn how everything works.
- 34:39So you really need those political relationships, to really be productive.
- 34:49Because if you don't have those relationships, it's it's it's gonna be a very, very long
- 34:54session for you.
- 34:55And the third big reason I wanna highlight for why so many bills die so early is poorly
- 35:04written and or sloppy bills.
- 35:06Regardless of the party or ideological leaning or or issue beliefs that a legislator has, some
- 35:17bills are just really poorly put together.
- 35:21State constitutions and state statutes have some stipulations for how bills need to be
- 35:26written and what they need to include, and then the the legislative chambers also have certain
- 35:31rules.
- 35:32Just because a legislator has introduced a bill, it does not mean it's a well written
- 35:36bill.
- 35:37And I've seen some bills that are pretty like, oh, boy.
- 35:41That's that's that's terrible.
- 35:42Actually, just did a webinar, for a a public affairs firm in DC, talking about reading
- 35:52legislation for, client impact.
- 35:55In other words, how to read legislation to best serve your client.
- 35:59And I had seen a an example of a bill back in, like, Texas, I think it was.
- 36:08And the bill was clearly aiming to outlaw same sex marriage.
- 36:11This was something like 02/2006, '2 thousand '7.
- 36:15But the the way it was worded basically would have outlawed all marriage, or at least the way
- 36:22it was written, you could construe it to mean that.
- 36:25Now that's not what the bill was actually trying to do, but if you follow the letter of
- 36:29the law, basically, marriage would have been illegal if the bill would have been accepted or
- 36:34it would have if if it would have been passed.
- 36:36It was never gonna pass because of that, but but that's just to go to show you that there
- 36:41are some of these issues where the bill just isn't written well.
- 36:46It might require a lot more in-depth change than the bill author thinks it does, especially
- 36:51if they're new to this whole thing.
- 36:53They might have to make a major change to a regulatory structure by executive agencies.
- 36:58So executive agencies, some a lot within the law that is prescribed to them, they have some
- 37:07leeway as to determining how to best fulfill those functions and legal duties.
- 37:13And so if a legislator tries to pass a bill that really affects them, that can really cause
- 37:20a lot of headaches.
- 37:21Not necessarily that it's a that it's a that's inherently a bad bill.
- 37:25It's just that it's a lot of other stuff that needs to be considered.
- 37:29Circular definitions of key terms.
- 37:31There are some some bills will define a thing as a thing.
- 37:36Like, I mean, I can't think of a specific instance off the top of my head, but, like, if
- 37:43you said a door is a door, basically, there are bills that are written that have been written
- 37:48kind of like that or at least have a lot more language, but ultimately then be become that
- 37:55circular definition.
- 37:56So it's not necessarily obvious that that's what the bill does, but some bills do that.
- 38:02A bill might be too ambiguous.
- 38:04So if you read the wording, it might be so ambiguous that it's unenforceable or it gets
- 38:12enforced a certain way that a bill author doesn't intend or or it is enforced in a way
- 38:19that it's that the bill author intended it for to be enforced by, but the but it was written
- 38:29in a way to make it more palatable, if that makes sense.
- 38:32The bill might be too broad or narrow in scope, and that's just really gonna depend on it's
- 38:38it's just a really a case by case basis, but bills and usually, if it's about how broad or
- 38:45narrow a bill is, it'll it'll be debated in within a legislative chamber, but it can still
- 38:51relate to how poorly a bill is written.
- 38:53And then you also have single subject rules.
- 38:58So 43 states constitutions require legislation to be about a single subject.
- 39:05So it can't be about education, and then it'd be about health care.
- 39:10Theoretically, it's pretty straightforward.
- 39:12And that that single subject rule does not exist for congress.
- 39:17It's just it only 43 of the state legislators.
- 39:19Only 43.
- 39:20It's a lot of the state legislatures, but there are a few that don't have that.
- 39:24But what constitutes a single subject isn't necessarily clear, because it it just the state
- 39:30constitutions, if you read the passage for the single subject rule, just says something along
- 39:35the lines of legislation can only tackle one subject.
- 39:39Okay?
- 39:40But what kind of that may seem obvious, but that's not actually a straightforward thing.
- 39:49A good example I saw of it was apples and oranges.
- 39:54Oh, yeah.
- 39:54Those are two different subjects.
- 39:55You're talking about apples and oranges.
- 39:57Those are totally different kinds of fruit.
- 39:59But, oh, they're both fruit, so they are therefore a single subject.
- 40:04So you can have that same kind of conversation possibly with legislation and say, like, no.
- 40:12This is actually one subject or no.
- 40:15This is not one subject that has been the subject of of lawsuits in various states in the
- 40:24past.
- 40:25So just a thing to keep in mind, the the so the impact of of these poorly written bills, if if
- 40:35it's poorly written, it's inherently gonna affect the productivity of the legislature
- 40:39because the legislature a committee is gonna have to hear that bill and waste their time
- 40:45with a badly written bill.
- 40:46That legislator wasted their time drafting that bill.
- 40:50So could really cause headaches for everybody's.
- 40:53Committee's time has been wasted because they had to hear that bill.
- 40:56They're just gonna say, we we can't do this because of all these issues that the bill is
- 41:01going to have.
- 41:01So we we we're not gonna bother moving it forward.
- 41:05And then so that bill doesn't move forward.
- 41:07And then the fourth big reason that a lot of bills die so early or at least the fourth one
- 41:12I'm higher highlighting in this episode of the podcast is a bill might not follow proper
- 41:18legislative procedure.
- 41:20Now legislatures have many of the same rules, but there are for how a bill has to be
- 41:25introduced, what guidelines it has to follow, Legislatures have handbooks for their members
- 41:32that they give them, and then some of these are also available for the public to see online.
- 41:38So these legislative procedures about how they introduce bills, how they are called on to
- 41:44speak about their bill, how debates are had, how amendments to bills are introduced, how
- 41:50substitute bills are introduced, all these kinds of procedures.
- 41:55There's a lot of similarities across states, but there, can be some key differences between
- 42:00them.
- 42:00But if a legislator does not follow legislative procedure, their their bill is not gonna be
- 42:07going anywhere because, well, it has to follow rules.
- 42:11If it doesn't if you don't follow the rules and you just let it go because it didn't even
- 42:16though it didn't follow rules, then what's the part of the rules?
- 42:17So if a bill does not follow legislative procedure, you can basically say that you can
- 42:24just forget about it because it's not gonna be going anywhere.
- 42:28So those are the four big reasons I wanted to highlight for why bills die so early.
- 42:35So we've established several big reasons why so many bills die so early.
- 42:41But is it really that bad a thing that so many of these bills ultimately go nowhere even if
- 42:47they get past the committee stage?
- 42:50Really, actually, depending on the bill, that can be a good or bad thing.
- 42:53It can certainly be frustrating seeing so much legislation be ultimately for naught because it
- 43:00feels like a waste.
- 43:01You have thousands and thousands and thousands of bills over time that have just not they
- 43:07either haven't been heard by the chamber floor or they haven't they haven't even gotten out of
- 43:12the committee stage or they may have gone to the chamber floor, but they and they passed
- 43:15maybe they even passed one of the, two chambers of a state legislative body.
- 43:22But it, the governor didn't, or or, but the other state legislative chamber didn't sign off
- 43:29on it.
- 43:29Maybe both state legislative chamber signed off on it, but the governor didn't sign off on it.
- 43:34Or in the case of congress, maybe the president didn't sign off on it.
- 43:37Yeah.
- 43:37It can it could be frustrating to see that, but not every bill is a good bill.
- 43:42Now what constitutes a good good bill is obviously gonna be some matter of debate.
- 43:48A lot of it based on party and ideology and issue leanings.
- 43:52But let's refer back to those reasons we just talked about for why so many bills die,
- 43:59especially early on in the legislative process like the committee hearings or in the in the
- 44:05committee stage.
- 44:06Time constraints.
- 44:08This can be a it can be a bad thing that bills die due to time constraints if that time is not
- 44:15managed well, especially with the state legislatures that only meet for a few months in
- 44:20a year.
- 44:21But even with efficient spending of time, many bills are just not going to be heard or voted
- 44:26on, let alone pass, because you you just can't.
- 44:29There's just there's just too many of them.
- 44:33Or how about the political relationships?
- 44:35It could be a bad thing if bills die early because certain relationships are might be used
- 44:40to undermine bills depending on what the content is.
- 44:43But at the same time, leveraging political relationships to get a bill passed isn't
- 44:48inherently good either.
- 44:51So whether it's ultimately a bad thing that a a bill dies because of those of that wheeling and
- 45:01dealing behind the scenes, not necessarily a an obvious answer to that.
- 45:06The poorly written or sloppy bills.
- 45:08If it's a badly written bill, if it's truly just sucks, it's a good thing it doesn't pass.
- 45:13And that's not necessarily just because it couldn't make a bad policy.
- 45:17And let let's forget a moment what we consider good or bad policy.
- 45:21Let's say there's something that even if something had the the right idea, if we all
- 45:28agree that it had the right idea.
- 45:31So it it could have theoretically been a good idea, but it could introduce all if if a bill
- 45:38is poorly written, it could introduce all sorts of other issues like potential lawsuits about
- 45:44the meaning of that bill or of that law if that if it becomes if it gets passed into law.
- 45:51There could be confusion about what the law means if it's poorly written to begin with.
- 45:56There could be haphazard executive branch enforcement because the executive branch
- 46:00doesn't know exactly how to enforce that law.
- 46:03So all these things that you gotta think about, down the road.
- 46:06So if a bill were to become law and cause all those issues, it's a good thing that that bill
- 46:14dies early on.
- 46:17And then if it did not follow this legislative procedure, again, if a bill doesn't follow the
- 46:22rules, you can't just pass the bill, or even really entertain it much because then you have
- 46:28to start making exceptions for other bills that don't follow the rules.
- 46:31And then what's the point of having those legislative procedural rules?
- 46:36One of those bills might have what you would consider good content, but you still gotta
- 46:42follow the rules.
- 46:43So you have all those reasons why bills can die so early, and it might be a good thing that a
- 46:52bill died early because of any one of those issues, or it might not be.
- 46:56So all in all, I'm not trying to say it is or isn't a good thing that many bills get drafted
- 47:02but ultimately fail at some point.
- 47:04But it is to demonstrate how it can complicate the answer as to whether or not congress and
- 47:11state legislatures are productive.
- 47:13Speaking of which, how do we define productivity?
- 47:17Many citizens trash congress as a do nothing body and probably a lot of state legislatures
- 47:23too, but are they truly being unproductive when it comes to passing legislation?
- 47:29Those kinds of criticisms could also be because of partisan or ideological biases.
- 47:35But there's a lot of things to complain about when it comes to congress, but evaluating how
- 47:39productive they are isn't so straightforward.
- 47:43Mhmm.
- 47:44So if we take the typical conception of productivity as enacting enacting a bunch of
- 47:53the bills that get introduced, so we say, percent enactment rate.
- 47:58So the percentage of bills that get enacted out of those that get introduced.
- 48:04What is an ideal percentage of bills to enact?
- 48:08And or does that ideal percentage even exist?
- 48:12So we go back to a couple of those studies for state legislative bills like an Arkansas back
- 48:17in '26 first half of twenty sixteen where 94% of of pieces of the pieces of legislation had
- 48:24passed.
- 48:25Can you compare it to congress where a single session, it doesn't even break 10%, doesn't
- 48:30even break 9%?
- 48:33So if if you're basing productivity on the percentage of enacted bills, congress yeah.
- 48:40Of course, congress is gonna look unproductive.
- 48:43But, again, is that necessarily a good indicator of productivity in congress?
- 48:49So we'd really need to like like many times in politics, we need to come up with a clearer
- 48:56definition of our terms.
- 48:58And in this case, we need to have a more clear idea of what productivity is because debating
- 49:05and passing bills is not the only thing that legislators do.
- 49:08Not the only part of their job.
- 49:10They, in the term in in case of congress, they confirm presidential appointees, and then in
- 49:15state legislatures, they confirm various gubernatorial appointees.
- 49:20These legislators go back to their district to interact with constituents such as with town
- 49:25halls.
- 49:26They travel to foreign countries for business such as negotiating ends to wars or trade
- 49:32deals.
- 49:32There's a lot of different things they could do.
- 49:34Yeah.
- 49:34Obviously, the main thing that you you elected them for is to draft the bills that you think
- 49:41would be good and then get those enacted, but that's not the only thing they do.
- 49:46So it can be pretty hard or not pretty hard, but it can be kinda complicated to to define
- 49:55productivity.
- 49:56But though we because we've looked at the passing of bills as the main metric, we'll
- 50:02mostly focus on that for here.
- 50:04It's just think about other ways that you can define productivity.
- 50:09But let's just say that getting bills enacted, the high percentage of bills getting enacted is
- 50:16what we want, and that's what defines productivity.
- 50:21Some other things that you wanna consider if you if that is your benchmark for a legislator
- 50:28or legislature being productive or you hear somebody else criticize a legislature as
- 50:35unproductive.
- 50:36Is it just a matter of how many bills they pass?
- 50:39Is it the sheer number of bills or the proportion of bills?
- 50:43So is sheer number of bills that they introduce or the sheer or the proportion of bills that
- 50:48they enact?
- 50:50So if I get 1,500 bills enacted in a congressional session, but we introduced 25,000
- 51:01of them, is is that productive?
- 51:04Because that's a pretty low percentage.
- 51:06Now what if it was, oh, we we passed 1,500 p bills, but we only introduced 11,000 bills
- 51:15total this session.
- 51:17It's a much higher percentage.
- 51:18You still have the same number of bills passed, but you had a much higher percentage of
- 51:23enactment rate.
- 51:24So you had a much higher success rate in getting bills passed.
- 51:29Which one of those was more productive?
- 51:32Is it because because the same number of bills succeeded, you just had a lot more tries with
- 51:39one of those examples.
- 51:42So that's one thing to think about when you consider if a legislator's legislature is being
- 51:49productive based on the number of bills that get enacted.
- 51:53Do we also care about which topics are being addressed by bills?
- 51:57So obvious, the the the the ones that get all the fanfare and and and all the talk in the
- 52:06media, you know, those are the the ones that are the most salient topics generally.
- 52:12But there are a lot of bills that we don't hear about that also get passed.
- 52:18So if a whole bunch of those are getting passed but not the ones that are about the most
- 52:24salient topics, does that also mean that that legislature is being if if they don't get those
- 52:33big bills passed, does that mean that legislature was not being productive?
- 52:38What what defines an important important topic, quote unquote?
- 52:43Do they have to be landmark bills?
- 52:45Like, I mean, they just it's hard to get as landmark as this, but the 1965 Voting Rights
- 52:51Act, what what what is the threshold that we need it to be landmark for, and does that
- 52:58threshold indicate that a legislature is being productive?
- 53:02Even if they're not getting a whole bunch of all these other bills being passed that
- 53:06otherwise don't get really any fanfare.
- 53:09Another thing to consider is how sizable are the bills that are being passed?
- 53:14Because some bills are a lot longer than other ones are.
- 53:18And you actually look at the text.
- 53:21It's pages upon pages upon pages, whereas other bills might just simply be changing, like, two
- 53:28sentences.
- 53:29Back to that GovTrack analysis.
- 53:32Since World War two, congress has typically enacted four to 6,000,000 words of new law in
- 53:38each term of congress, so every two years because term of congress is split up into two
- 53:43sessions.
- 53:44Should've should've specified that towards the beginning, but now I said it.
- 53:51Which citizens, groups, etcetera, are being benefited most by this past legislation.
- 53:58If they're benefiting from this legislation, I'm sure they think that the legislature is
- 54:02being very productive, whereas these groups and these citizens that don't like these bills
- 54:09might not consider that legislature productive.
- 54:12I mean, that they might, but, you just gotta remember that the partisan and ideological
- 54:21leanings of people can color their judgment as to whether they think the legislature is
- 54:26productive.
- 54:27And then lastly, does productive equal getting good policies getting being passed?
- 54:36If ball if bad, quote, unquote, policies are being passed, is that still productive?
- 54:45All these things here that you really gotta consider.
- 54:47So I'm not trying to say that these legislatures are not do nothing bodies.
- 54:52I'm not saying they are do nothing bodies.
- 54:53It's just we we oftentimes levy that charge, and we don't really think about what exactly
- 55:02constitutes productivity.
- 55:03And that's what a lot a lot of these studies, both ones I cited earlier and, ones I didn't
- 55:09have the chance to cite, they they've really tried to tackle this question about what
- 55:14constitutes productivity.
- 55:16Because a lot of times in politics, we don't really define the terms that we're using, and
- 55:20this is one of those times.
- 55:22So we really need to figure out how to determine productivity.
- 55:27And, even if we did say productivity is simply the amount of the number of bills you get
- 55:33passed, well, okay.
- 55:36If a a legislature's being productive, but they're passing what some somebody is going to
- 55:41consider a bad policy, was that really being productive?
- 55:47Does productive just mean the sheer amount of output that you have, or does it mean is is it
- 55:52referring to how positive your impact is on politics?
- 55:58So bunch of things for all of you to consider.
- 56:02But that's gonna be it for today's episode of politics with Paul.
- 56:06As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 56:08Please like, comment, subscribe, share with all the people you know.
- 56:14Help this this channel grow.
- 56:16Help this whole thing I'm trying to do grow here because really enjoy doing this kind of
- 56:23thing and trying to provide a nonpartisan look at all these topics that don't necessarily get
- 56:32a lot of attention that aren't necessarily taught well.
- 56:37Hopefully, I'm teaching it well.
- 56:39But, again, thank you so much for tuning in.
- 56:44Links in the show notes, Facebook, LinkedIn, my short educational email course about mistakes
- 56:53made when we try to depolarize people that sometimes unintentionally increase
- 56:58polarization, why those mistakes are made, and how we can fix those mistakes.
- 57:06Link to my book, why independents rarely win elections, and how they could become more
- 57:11competitive, and a couple of other things as well.
- 57:15But, again, thank you so much for listening, and until next time.
- 57:20Take care.