Latest / Kentucky Tonight / The U.S. Economy, Tariffs and Federal Government Shutdown
Transcript
- 0:15Kentucky. Tonight I'm Renee
- 0:17Shaw. Tonight we're joined by
- 0:19economics and business experts
- 0:20of different perspectives as we
- 0:22discuss the current state of
- 0:24the U.S. economy and the impact
- 0:25of recent tariffs and the
- 0:27federal government shutdown,
- 0:28which is in its 13th day. How
- 0:30have Kentuckians, including
- 0:32Kentucky's federal government
- 0:34workforce, been affected by the
- 0:36shutdown? How have tariffs
- 0:37affected Kentucky industries
- 0:39like soybeans and bourbon? We
- 0:41have four guests in our
- 0:43Lexington studio to talk all
- 0:44about this. We start with
- 0:46Charles Hall, vice president of
- 0:48policy and head of the center
- 0:49for Policy and Research at the
- 0:51Kentucky Chamber of Commerce.
- 0:52Doctor Thomas Lambert,
- 0:53professor in the College of
- 0:55Business at the University of
- 0:56Louisville. Doctor Mike Clark,
- 0:58director of the center for
- 1:00Business and Economic Research
- 1:01and associate professor of
- 1:02economics at the University of
- 1:04Kentucky's Gatton College of
- 1:05Business and Economics. And
- 1:07Jason Bailey, executive
- 1:08director of the Kentucky Center
- 1:10for Economic Policy. We
- 1:11certainly want to hear from you
- 1:13tonight, and you can send us
- 1:14your questions and comments. By
- 1:16X, formerly known as Twitter at
- 1:18Pub Affairs KET. Send an email
- 1:20to KET tonight at ket.org or
- 1:23use the web form at ket.org
- 1:26tonight. Or you can simply give
- 1:28us a call at one 800 494 7605.
- 1:32Welcome to all of our guests.
- 1:34We appreciate you all being
- 1:35here on this night. Doctor, all
- 1:37I want to begin with you first,
- 1:40because we've had several
- 1:41government shutdowns over the
- 1:43last several years, right. If
- 1:44we date back into the 70s and
- 1:46before the most recent shutdown,
- 1:49December 2018 through January
- 1:512019 lasted about 35 days, was
- 1:54the longest in history. The
- 1:56five week impasse cost the U.S.
- 1:58economy an estimated $3 billion
- 2:01in lost GDP, according to the
- 2:03Congressional Budget Office,
- 2:04and it was a partial government
- 2:06shutdown then. Right now, there
- 2:08is no partiality. It is full.
- 2:10So talk to us about what you're
- 2:12watching right now as you see
- 2:13this unfold and the potential
- 2:15impacts that we should brace
- 2:17ourselves for.
- 2:17>> Yeah. Well, first of all,
- 2:19Renee, always thank you for
- 2:21having us. Absolutely.
- 2:22Oftentimes these shutdowns sort
- 2:23of depend on how long they last.
- 2:24And you pointed out with the
- 2:26shutdown going back to 2018,
- 2:292019, that $3 billion, that's
- 2:30$3 billion that the economy
- 2:32never quite recovered. And
- 2:33that's a significant hit to
- 2:35overall GDP, especially at a
- 2:37time when we have an economy
- 2:39that I think, as we'll talk
- 2:40about, is we're kind of getting
- 2:42mixed signals from with some
- 2:43some significant signs of
- 2:44concern from the perspective of
- 2:46the business community, these
- 2:47government shutdowns are never
- 2:48good. These are things that we
- 2:50would like to see taken off the
- 2:52table. You know, we elect our
- 2:53members of Congress to work
- 2:55through difficult questions and
- 2:57to enter into negotiations with
- 2:59each other. We would like to
- 3:01see them do that. Businesses in
- 3:03Kentucky and throughout the
- 3:04rest of the country depend on
- 3:05various government services for
- 3:07a variety of different things.
- 3:08So you can think about federal
- 3:10contractors. You could think
- 3:12about things like seeking IPO
- 3:14approvals for through through
- 3:17the SEC.
- 3:17>> IPO stands for.
- 3:18>> Initial public offerings, as
- 3:20well as simple things like
- 3:22asking questions at government
- 3:23agencies, because when the
- 3:24government shuts down, the
- 3:25rules are all still there,
- 3:27right? The questions are all
- 3:28still there. And so this is
- 3:29another one of those things
- 3:31that can create even more
- 3:32slowdown to an economy. And so
- 3:34it is something that we're
- 3:35concerned about. And our
- 3:36message to Congress is to do
- 3:38your job, go in, negotiate,
- 3:40figure these things out and get
- 3:41the government back open. We
- 3:43would like to see Congress, as
- 3:44well as the white House, engage
- 3:46in these meaningful discussions
- 3:47and not let this flounder for
- 3:49for too much longer. As you
- 3:51noted, just a partial shutdown
- 3:52alone led to significant hits
- 3:54to overall economic growth. And
- 3:56when we have a shutdown on the
- 3:58scale that we have right now,
- 4:00that really can cause some
- 4:01significant damage. And I think
- 4:03one of the things that we're
- 4:04most concerned about right now
- 4:05is there's not really an end in
- 4:07sight with past shutdowns, you
- 4:09could sort of point to
- 4:10different benchmarks, for
- 4:12example, things like military
- 4:13pay. Those were moments where
- 4:15you tend to see members of
- 4:17Congress sort of move a little
- 4:19bit more. Now we're hearing
- 4:21from the white House
- 4:22potentially paying troops.
- 4:23That's on the whole, we want to
- 4:25see that happen. But at the
- 4:26same time, that's this is
- 4:27another way that they're
- 4:28kicking the ball down the road
- 4:30and potentially extending this
- 4:31even longer. So it's something
- 4:33we certainly want to see
- 4:34remedied as soon as possible.
- 4:35>> Yeah. Jason Bailey, how do
- 4:37you view it. And perhaps we're
- 4:39Democrats because we've talked
- 4:40about the political blame game,
- 4:41and we've handled that with
- 4:43poli sci professors about where
- 4:44goatthe ssiesorc
- 4:54ngsso tt. tttl
- 5:02wi? ds gngo heanvellegiv iaconf
- 5:07of that one particular item?
- 5:09>> Absolutely. The the
- 5:11expiration of the subsidies for
- 5:12the Affordable Care Act
- 5:14insurance that people buy on
- 5:15the exchange, the marketplace
- 5:17in Kentucky, we call that
- 5:18connect those subsidies expire
- 5:21at the end of the year. And so
- 5:2320 million Americans, nearly
- 5:24100,000 Kentuckians, will see
- 5:26their health care costs more
- 5:28than double if those subsidies
- 5:30are not extended. And that
- 5:31begins November 1st. The open
- 5:33enrollment period starts
- 5:35November 1st. So it is not a
- 5:37thing you can do later on. It
- 5:39has the action has to happen
- 5:41now, and it coincides with the
- 5:43debate over the federal budget,
- 5:44where the Democrats have some
- 5:46leverage because it requires 60
- 5:48votes in the Senate to to pass
- 5:51a budget, and the Republicans
- 5:52only have 52, 53. So it's a
- 5:56critical issue. The subsidies
- 6:00are applied to people who can't
- 6:04get health insurance in other
- 6:05ways. They don't get it through
- 6:07their employer. They work for a
- 6:08small business or they're
- 6:10self-employed themselves.
- 6:10They're an independent
- 6:11contractor. We're talking about
- 6:12people who work for nail salons.
- 6:14We're talking about farmers who
- 6:16get their health insurance on
- 6:17the exchange, salespeople,
- 6:19people from all walks of life.
- 6:21I looked at some numbers just
- 6:22in Kentucky, 1102 people in
- 6:26Henderson County, 1028 people
- 6:27in Marshall County. I mean,
- 6:29it's it's people we know in our
- 6:31neighbors. So health care is
- 6:33one of the biggest burdens that
- 6:35Americans face. Costs have been
- 6:37going up for everything, and
- 6:38the cost of living is probably
- 6:40the number one issue facing
- 6:42Americans. And there were real,
- 6:45real improvements that were
- 6:47made when these subsidies were
- 6:48expanded back during the
- 6:49American Rescue Plan Act, and
- 6:51then continued during the
- 6:52Inflation Reduction Act. To let
- 6:54that go away, I think to say,
- 6:57trust me, we'll do it later, is
- 6:59is not a smart move because the
- 7:02majority could have extended
- 7:03these subsidies, made them
- 7:04perfect in the budget
- 7:07reconciliation bill, the H.R.
- 7:08one one big Beautiful Bill act
- 7:09this summer. They chose not to.
- 7:11So they already indicated that
- 7:12they don't want to do that. And
- 7:15so I think it is, you know, a
- 7:17government shutdown is painful
- 7:18and it needs to stop as soon as
- 7:20possible. But doubling of your
- 7:22family's health care costs is
- 7:24the difference between whether
- 7:26people get life saving care or
- 7:28not. And in a in a state that
- 7:32has so many health health
- 7:34challenges already. I think
- 7:36moving back on that and
- 7:37increasing our insurance rate
- 7:38is a big problem. And one more
- 7:40thing I'll say about this. I
- 7:42think it's important to have a
- 7:43fight about health care now.
- 7:44And there's an opportunity to
- 7:46because this is just the
- 7:47beginning of what will be a
- 7:48serious rolling health care
- 7:49disaster. To be quite frank, if
- 7:51H.R. one continues to be rolled
- 7:54out, we expect over 200,000
- 7:55Kentuckians to lose Medicaid
- 7:57because of the requirements
- 7:58that will go into effect, the
- 8:00work reporting requirements
- 8:01that will go into effect next
- 8:02year. We expect to see huge
- 8:04cuts to hospitals and providers
- 8:06that in Kentucky, we have 35
- 8:08rural hospitals at risk of
- 8:10closure if those payments go
- 8:11into effect, payment cuts go
- 8:13into effect. That's more than
- 8:14any other state. So now's the
- 8:16time, and now's an opportunity
- 8:17to have a fight about health
- 8:19care. And I think it's the
- 8:20right thing to do to do that.
- 8:22And all Congress has to do is
- 8:24extend the subsidies, which are
- 8:25very popular. 78% of Americans.
- 8:27According to one poll, 59% of
- 8:29Republicans want those
- 8:30subsidies continued. All they
- 8:32have to do is agree to do that,
- 8:34and the government will open
- 8:36back up and we will prevent all
- 8:37those problems that would
- 8:38happen from a shutdown.
- 8:39>> Doctor Clark, how do you see
- 8:41things? And there are also
- 8:42implications for the financial
- 8:43markets. I mean, this is a big
- 8:46major juggernaut here and it
- 8:47has so many ramifications. So
- 8:49talk about how you see this
- 8:50shutdown's impact.
- 8:51>> Well, certainly like doctor
- 8:53mentioned a little while ago,
- 8:55you know we're we're looking at
- 8:56kind of mixed messages when we
- 8:58look at kind of the status of
- 8:59the economy and what we've been
- 9:01seeing here over the last few
- 9:02months is that we've been
- 9:04seeing employment growth really
- 9:06slow down as you kind of look
- 9:08back at where we expected the
- 9:10economy to be as we enter 2025,
- 9:13we're kind of expecting that,
- 9:14you know, we were expecting
- 9:15employment to slow down. We
- 9:17were expecting manufacturing
- 9:18employment in particular to
- 9:19slow down, maybe even contract.
- 9:21And we've been we've been
- 9:23seeing that. But we'd also
- 9:24expected inflation to really
- 9:25start to slow down as well. And
- 9:28you know, we're seeing
- 9:29inflation go up and kind of the
- 9:31situation we've kind of got to
- 9:32is in terms of employment,
- 9:34we're basically just kind of
- 9:35flatlined. Now. You know we are
- 9:37seeing some growth. We did see
- 9:39kind of a month back in June
- 9:42where we saw actual decrease in
- 9:43terms of employment. But
- 9:45basically, you know, employment
- 9:46is just kind of kind of
- 9:48virtually no change,
- 9:49particularly when you look at
- 9:50in terms of the margin of
- 9:52errors. And so when we start
- 9:53thinking about the impacts of a
- 9:55shutdown, again, a shutdown can
- 9:56be very minor if you're talking
- 9:57about just a couple of weeks.
- 9:59But as that shutdown starts to
- 10:00extend and you start seeing
- 10:02issues in terms of people not
- 10:03getting paychecks, people start
- 10:04cutting back on their spending
- 10:06as a result of of, you know,
- 10:09not seeing that paycheck
- 10:11contracts. You know, if you
- 10:14have a government contract, you
- 10:15start to get worried about
- 10:16whether or not you're going to
- 10:18be able to pay your employees.
- 10:19So you start to see kind of a
- 10:21you here, we're kind of at this
- 10:24place where we're just kind of
- 10:25barely positive and any kind of
- 10:27of disruption, any additional
- 10:29shock to the economy can kind
- 10:30of tip us over to the point
- 10:33where we actually turn negative.
- 10:34And that could be really
- 10:36problematic for the economy as
- 10:37we kind of move forward.
- 10:38>> And we know that the
- 10:40September jobs report was
- 10:41supposed to come out last
- 10:42Friday, and that didn't because
- 10:43the lights are off at the
- 10:45Bureau of Labor Statistics. But
- 10:46there has been some other jobs
- 10:48data that has come from other
- 10:49entities that have kind of said
- 10:51the US labor market is losing
- 10:52some steam, and so we'll
- 10:54certainly get that iju a
- 10:55u.ow do you see? Yeah. Our
- 11:04pleasure. How do you see this
- 11:05shutdown and what are you most
- 11:07concerned about at this
- 11:08juncture or beyond?
- 11:09>> Well, I would agree with
- 11:10what's been said so far. And I
- 11:12would also add that there are
- 11:13also ripple effects at the
- 11:15local level. Some estimates I
- 11:16did earlier this year, you know,
- 11:18for every $1 million. This was
- 11:20the estimates I got from a
- 11:22modeling system. For every $1
- 11:24million in federal funding lost,
- 11:25you have about a total of $3
- 11:27million lost contractors,
- 11:30suppliers to the government,
- 11:32and then the employees of the
- 11:35government not being able to
- 11:37spend as well as the employees
- 11:38of these suppliers to the
- 11:41government, whether it's
- 11:42someone who sells linen or
- 11:46other things to a parachute
- 11:48manufacturer. We have a couple
- 11:50of apparel manufacturers for
- 11:51the military here in Kentucky.
- 11:53I don't know how badly the
- 11:55military is going to be
- 11:56affected, but that's a that's a
- 11:58key supplier. Humana does
- 11:59Tricare insurance for the
- 12:00United States military. It also
- 12:02is a is a medicaid provider,
- 12:04along with anthem and a couple
- 12:06of other major insurance
- 12:07companies. So when you have
- 12:10cuts or rollbacks and spending,
- 12:13it has a ripple effect. And
- 12:15that affects local restaurants,
- 12:17landlords for people who can't
- 12:18pay their rent, can't pay their
- 12:20mortgage or what have you. And
- 12:23it also impacts local property
- 12:25taxes, sales taxes, etc. as
- 12:28that spending dries up. So you
- 12:31only have you not only have the
- 12:33initial impact of of either
- 12:34cuts or freezes in federal
- 12:36spending because people aren't
- 12:38getting paid anymore or certain
- 12:39bills aren't being paid. But
- 12:41you also have these
- 12:43consequences at the local level,
- 12:44somewhat of a ripple effect as
- 12:46well. So you could see that
- 12:48play out in the state sales tax,
- 12:51local property taxes. If this
- 12:53continues much longer, it will
- 12:55have a more significant.
- 12:56>> And as we're on the cusp of
- 12:58iss meinth sulkyminseio
- 13:02Tt'rit. mn,ouseth sulhao alit
- 13:06ou, atheyokn,a
- 13:09pa o the reason there's a
- 13:11showdown around this right now
- 13:12is that the government has not
- 13:13been fully operating for the
- 13:15entire year. So we're talking
- 13:17about a shutdown, but in fact,
- 13:19there have been partial
- 13:20shutdowns of different parts of
- 13:21government for months and
- 13:23months. And that's part of what
- 13:25I think the Democrats in
- 13:26Congress are saying. Is that,
- 13:27okay, we agreed to a continuing
- 13:29resolution, but then if the
- 13:31president then chooses not to
- 13:32spend the money that's
- 13:33appropriated, then what are
- 13:35they agreeing to anyway? Right.
- 13:36So sort of part of the push is
- 13:38not just to prevent health care
- 13:40costs from more than doubling
- 13:42for 20 million Americans, but
- 13:43also ensuring that when funds
- 13:45are appropriated, they're not
- 13:47then impounded or these pocket
- 13:48rescissions, these sort of
- 13:50weird terms that basically mean
- 13:52article one of the Constitution
- 13:53says that Congress has the
- 13:55power of the purse. And I don't
- 13:56know how many Kentucky
- 13:57legislators I've seen on here
- 13:59who say, you know, on this show
- 14:00that we have the power of the
- 14:02purse. The same rules apply in
- 14:04federal level. And so why would
- 14:07they agree to a continuing
- 14:08resolution if the president is
- 14:09just going to spend only what
- 14:11he wants to? Department of
- 14:12education has been cut in big
- 14:14ways. They laid off 4000
- 14:16workers on Friday, big cuts to
- 14:19National Institutes for health.
- 14:21Obviously federal research
- 14:22funding. We've seen cuts to Job
- 14:23Corps. You know, we've seen
- 14:25cuts to AmeriCorps. We've seen
- 14:27cuts to PBS right through this,
- 14:30through this process. So I
- 14:31think there's a there's a we
- 14:33shouldn't talk about this as a
- 14:34normal situation, a normal
- 14:36shutdown debate like the 20
- 14:38we've had before. This is about
- 14:41whether the Constitution is
- 14:42going to be followed regarding
- 14:45Congress's ability to direct
- 14:48how much and what is
- 14:50appropriated. And so, you know,
- 14:52I think that's that's a debate
- 14:53worth having.
- 14:54>> Is there a debate worth
- 14:55having? And do you all see it
- 14:58the same way as Mr. Bailey?
- 14:59>> Well, I think there is a
- 15:00debate worth having in terms of
- 15:02when you go through and you
- 15:03look at these various types of
- 15:05government programs.
- 15:05Policymakers have different
- 15:06opinions about the benefits and
- 15:08costs, about different programs.
- 15:09And so there's important debate
- 15:10to have about how big will that
- 15:12safety net be? Because we are
- 15:14talking about reductions to
- 15:16benefits that will affect a
- 15:18number of people. But there are
- 15:20also costs associated with that.
- 15:21So with any government program,
- 15:23you've always got to look at
- 15:24the cost and benefits. But it's
- 15:26not obvious to me that that's
- 15:29what's really going on here in
- 15:30terms of, you know, going
- 15:32through and looking at our are
- 15:34we providing services where the
- 15:36benefits are greater than the
- 15:37cost? You know, there was some
- 15:39discussion early in the year
- 15:41about government efficiency.
- 15:42And that's a good thing to
- 15:45discuss. You know, I don't know
- 15:47of anybody who is opposed to
- 15:48government running more
- 15:49efficiently, but it gets more
- 15:51complicated when you actually
- 15:52start getting into these
- 15:53different types of government
- 15:54programs and thinking about,
- 15:55well, what exactly types of
- 15:57services should they be
- 15:58providing? We're making this
- 15:59type of investment. What
- 16:00returns are we gettingor
- 16:02olisef isssgtSoI in ites tsth
- 16:08u ve l odiertdt,
- 16:12ea Dto a y hechnereir seomvaatns
- 16:22anhi to carry on?
- 16:23>> I would add. The only thing
- 16:25I would add to that is I
- 16:27certainly think that's a debate
- 16:28worth having. And Congress
- 16:29needs to have that debate. And
- 16:31they should have it in the
- 16:32context of an open government,
- 16:33ideally. And that would be
- 16:35representative of a functioning
- 16:36Congress. And I think that in a
- 16:37lot of ways is a big part of
- 16:39our problem right now is that,
- 16:41you know, putting a government
- 16:42shutdown on the table is
- 16:44something that we need to get
- 16:45out of the habit of. And if you
- 16:47look back at, say, the past ten
- 16:49years of policy making out of
- 16:50Washington, this is
- 16:51increasingly becoming a habit
- 16:52and it's becoming somewhat
- 16:53normal. And so we'd like to get
- 16:55to a point where, yes, have
- 16:57these debates. I think the
- 16:58debate that Jason just pointed
- 17:00out surrounding things like
- 17:02rescission votes, for example,
- 17:03that's a debate that they need
- 17:05to hash out. That is their job.
- 17:07That's the thing they need to
- 17:08lean into and figure it out.
- 17:10But they need to do that
- 17:11against the backdrop of an open
- 17:13government.
- 17:13>> Yeah. So let's talk about
- 17:14interest rates. Right. So what
- 17:16does this do to that if a
- 17:18prolonged shutdown continues,
- 17:19what does it do to the idea
- 17:21that the fed could cut interest
- 17:23rates beyond December. Is that
- 17:25bleak become bleaker.
- 17:26>> No, I mean I think when you
- 17:28start looking at how a fed
- 17:30excuse me, how a government
- 17:32shutdown plays into the overall
- 17:33economy, if it does slow things
- 17:35down, then, you know, that may
- 17:38prompt the fed to look at this
- 17:40in terms of how do we prop up
- 17:42the economy. The fed, of course,
- 17:44has this dual mandate. You know,
- 17:45they want to maintain stable
- 17:47prices, low inflation, low
- 17:50inflation and full employment.
- 17:52And so, you know, for some time
- 17:54now we've been fighting the
- 17:56inflation part of that. And so
- 17:57we've had high interest rates
- 17:58which are really designed to
- 18:00slow down spending. The idea is
- 18:02if you increase interest rates
- 18:03you make it more expensive to
- 18:05fund consumption because that
- 18:08those interest rates are higher.
- 18:09So if you're funding that
- 18:10through debt, through your,
- 18:13your, your credit card, or if
- 18:15you're purchasing a house and
- 18:16you're looking to to get a loan
- 18:18for that, that makes it more
- 18:20expensive. So that slows down
- 18:21consumer demand. And when you
- 18:22slow down consumer demand, that
- 18:24eases some of that price
- 18:25pressure. So I think if the fed
- 18:27looks at the situation in terms
- 18:29of a government slowdown, then
- 18:31what they're likely to see is
- 18:32that that could be affecting
- 18:34jobs. And so they might look to
- 18:36kind of prop that up and maybe
- 18:38actually lower interest rates a
- 18:39little bit more aggressively
- 18:40than what they have.
- 18:41>> One of the challenges with
- 18:43this, of course, is that all
- 18:45these decisions are tied to
- 18:46high quality government survey
- 18:47data. That's a good point. And
- 18:49this is where we're really
- 18:50going to start entering into a
- 18:52big problem. Already. The fed
- 18:53will be operating so far
- 18:54without September jobs data. We
- 18:56are getting to the point soon
- 18:58where the survey gathering
- 19:00process that the Bureau of
- 19:02Labor Statistics goes through
- 19:03to, to gather that data for the
- 19:05current month that we're in,
- 19:06we're getting close to that,
- 19:07the start of that process. And
- 19:09so that will start to have this
- 19:11ripple effect where the fed
- 19:13will be in a position where
- 19:14it's trying to make very
- 19:16important decisions, as Doctor
- 19:18Clark just pointed out,eled
- 19:20erisomprriar daegog bdog whli
- 19:27okt tngliDPthc
- 19:33menvtmt rm have
- 19:43started producing estimates,
- 19:44and other firms have started
- 19:45looking through a bunch of
- 19:47different metrics. But, you
- 19:48know, our government survey
- 19:49data has always been very, very
- 19:51high quality and has always
- 19:53been the linchpin for how the
- 19:54fed makes a lot of these
- 19:56decisions. This will also spill
- 19:58into a lot of decisions at the
- 19:59state level. So if you look at
- 20:01our consensus forecasting group
- 20:02in Kentucky that makes
- 20:05projections around revenue
- 20:06growth and revenue expectations,
- 20:09they use a number of different
- 20:10inputs, including things like
- 20:12good high quality government
- 20:13survey data. And so the fed is
- 20:16really going to find themselves.
- 20:17They're already in a very
- 20:18difficult situation as they're
- 20:20trying to balance their dual
- 20:22mandate, but now they're going
- 20:23to be potentially doing that
- 20:24with far less quality data than
- 20:26they normally do.
- 20:27>> Not only because of the
- 20:30government shutdown, but also,
- 20:32you know, there's some threats
- 20:33around the politicization of
- 20:34the data. I mean, the Bureau of
- 20:36Labor Statistics commissioner
- 20:38was fired because the jobs
- 20:39report was not satisfactory.
- 20:41And so there's a new BLS
- 20:42commissioner. So even when we
- 20:44do open the government back up,
- 20:46there's also pressure on the
- 20:47fed, you know, fed board
- 20:51members. So you know, it's it's
- 20:54an economy that is slowing down.
- 20:57Job growth is weak to
- 20:58nonexistent. It's also a very
- 21:01imbalanced economy in the sense
- 21:02that about half of the
- 21:04consumption right now is
- 21:05happening is is coming from the
- 21:07top 10% of people. Wealthy
- 21:09people are doing very well
- 21:10because the stock market is
- 21:12soaring. There's an AI boom in
- 21:15the in the tech stocks that are
- 21:18producing AI data centers are
- 21:20being built. There's a good
- 21:22argument to be made that
- 21:23there's a bubble developing in
- 21:24the AI industry. Also in in
- 21:28crypto, we know how that turns
- 21:30out. We've had bubbles before
- 21:31in recent history in the.com
- 21:34bust, in the housing bust, if
- 21:36that is, if that continues to
- 21:38develop, it's something the
- 21:39Federal Reserve will have to
- 21:40deal with. But if it if it
- 21:42breaks, then we're in bad
- 21:44trouble. And you know, for the
- 21:47those people at the top are
- 21:49doing very well for the bottom
- 21:5080% of people. They're not
- 21:52they're not keeping up with
- 21:53pretty much keeping up with
- 21:55inflation at this point in
- 21:56terms of their income. There's
- 21:57not real wage growth. We're
- 21:59seeing a rise in youth
- 22:00unemployment rate. The black
- 22:01unemployment rate is going up.
- 22:04Most people are are struggling
- 22:05in this environment. So if
- 22:07we're if we're looking at a
- 22:09situation where prices may go
- 22:10up because of tariffs, where
- 22:12there's additional economic
- 22:14loss from these, you know,
- 22:16budget cuts, you know, I'm very
- 22:20concerned about how the average
- 22:21Kentucky and the average
- 22:22American will fare.
- 22:23>> Yeah. Doctor Lambert.
- 22:24>> I was just going to to to
- 22:26add to to what's been said the
- 22:28first quarter of this year, we
- 22:30had negative economic growth, a
- 22:32contraction in GDP. Second
- 22:35quarter was better. We had
- 22:36growth. So we avoided a
- 22:37recession. So the fed is
- 22:39rightly concerned about rising
- 22:41unemployment, a soft economy,
- 22:43stagnant economy. But at the
- 22:46same time, I think the August
- 22:48inflation report was 0.4%,
- 22:50which if you multiply that
- 22:52times 12, you don't compound it.
- 22:54You just take a simple average
- 22:56would work out to be about 4.8%
- 22:58a year, which is fairly high.
- 23:01So the the tricky problem for
- 23:03them, I think, is to avoid some
- 23:05type of stagflation where you
- 23:06have some type of high
- 23:08unemployment and high inflation
- 23:09at the same time, like what
- 23:11occurred during the 1970s of
- 23:13the tariffs exacerbate this
- 23:16problem of inflation. It cuts
- 23:18across all income levels,
- 23:21basically. And with the
- 23:23announcement yesterday, maybe
- 23:26two days ago, of 100% tariffs
- 23:28now on China, with so much
- 23:30being brought in from China,
- 23:32you know that that's really
- 23:34going to make this a tricky
- 23:36situation to try to, I don't
- 23:38know, for a better term to have
- 23:40some type of soft landing or
- 23:42steady growth. But it's yeah,
- 23:46you want to try the Fed's
- 23:49operating policies. It's
- 23:50difficult. You can attacked one.
- 23:52You can attack. You can attack
- 23:54ryifcu.t se te ment or you can
- 24:00>> We do want to have a
- 24:01conversation about tariffs a
- 24:02little deeper here in just a
- 24:04moment. But I do want to go
- 24:06back to how the markets are
- 24:07performing, and they are
- 24:08seemingly to remain optimistic.
- 24:09If we can define what
- 24:10optimistic means, maybe there's
- 24:11a good metric or definition of
- 24:13that. What is that? And that
- 24:14gold is on a bull run, right.
- 24:16So what what explains that. So
- 24:18the markets are responding
- 24:20perhaps differently than the
- 24:21American consumer and the
- 24:22confidence they seem to be
- 24:23having that's that's declining.
- 24:24>> Well, I think you know the
- 24:26markets are looking past kind
- 24:27of some of this short term
- 24:29uncertainty that we see here.
- 24:30You know, so when you think
- 24:31about the value of a stock,
- 24:33it's not just the value that it
- 24:34has today. It's the value that
- 24:36it's going to have into the
- 24:37future. So so when investors
- 24:39are looking at this, they're
- 24:40looking for an opportunity to
- 24:41buy something that they think
- 24:42is going to perform well into
- 24:44the future. And so that all
- 24:45gets kind of baked into the
- 24:47price. And yes, you know the
- 24:48stock market has been doing
- 24:50very well. You know, we've seen
- 24:51a few days where, you know,
- 24:53we've we've seen some pretty
- 24:54significant decreases as the
- 24:55market responds to the news of
- 24:56the day, but generally, you
- 24:58know, we you know, as we saw as
- 25:01we were coming into 2025, you
- 25:02know, there was a lot of
- 25:04uncertainty. You saw the market
- 25:06reacting to the the
- 25:08announcements of additional
- 25:09tariffs. And, you know, it
- 25:11responded negatively to that
- 25:12because that was affecting the
- 25:13potential for businesses to
- 25:15make profits. And so, you know,
- 25:17that caused a devaluation of
- 25:19the market. Since kind of that
- 25:21initial reaction, we've seen
- 25:22the market do very, very well.
- 25:24You know, it does seem to be
- 25:25suggesting that that investors
- 25:26are fairly optimistic or, you
- 25:29know, see an opportunity long,
- 25:31you know, after kind of kind of
- 25:33this immediate situation that
- 25:34we're in as far as the gold
- 25:35situation, you know, there's a
- 25:37lot of folks who are looking to
- 25:38kind of hedge their bet. And
- 25:40traditionally, what tends to
- 25:41happen is that when you start
- 25:43to get concerned, when some
- 25:44people start to get concerned
- 25:45about the the economic
- 25:47situation, they look to gold as
- 25:50a safe haven. And so you're
- 25:52seeing some investors trying
- 25:54maybe to diversify, trying to
- 25:55kind of get ahead of what they
- 25:57perceive as as some concern.
- 25:59And you're.
- 25:59>> Thinking about you're not
- 26:00buying bricks of gold, right?
- 26:02It's a little different.
- 26:03>> It is a little different.
- 26:04But but essentially you are
- 26:06making investments in the gold
- 26:07market. And that has been
- 26:08driving some of that price up.
- 26:10>> Yeah. This question real
- 26:12quickly before we talk about
- 26:14tariffs. This is Martin Rivers
- 26:15from Lexington. He says quote,
- 26:17Kentucky has a hefty budget
- 26:18reserve trust fund and some
- 26:20want to use it to help various
- 26:21programs. Would it be wise to
- 26:23hold on to the trust fund until
- 26:25federal until federal budget
- 26:27issues are resolved? What do
- 26:29panelists believe is the right
- 26:31percentage to hold in the
- 26:32ndr.ivs,oo qstn.Reserveru
- 26:36chas Ble, u' bnh
- 26:39onhiprratoal about
- 26:41what that adequate number is.
- 26:43What's your thoughts? First
- 26:44before I go to well.
- 26:45>> You know, a budget reserve
- 26:46trust fund is first and
- 26:48foremost a rainy day fund. So
- 26:49when it rains, you need to be
- 26:51able to pull it down to help
- 26:53fill gaps in in funding because
- 26:57of economic conditions that are
- 26:58temporary. And to the extent
- 27:01that when the when the
- 27:02legislature meets and develops
- 27:03the next two year budget, there
- 27:06are holes in that budget that
- 27:08are are the result of an
- 27:10economy underperforming due to
- 27:12the impacts of all the things
- 27:13that we're talking about. It is
- 27:15it is absolutely imperative
- 27:17that the legislature use
- 27:19portions of it to to do that,
- 27:22because to fill those gaps,
- 27:24because services are going to
- 27:26be hurt, people are going to be
- 27:28laid off. And it's at a time
- 27:30when if the economy is hurting,
- 27:32those services are even more
- 27:34important. So it it plays a
- 27:37countercyclical role. There's
- 27:39$3.7 billion sitting in there.
- 27:40That is a that is a very large
- 27:42sum of money that's much larger
- 27:44than the benchmarks around what
- 27:47states need to prepare for
- 27:48recession. So there's ample
- 27:49room to use that to help fill
- 27:52the gap. I don't think it's the
- 27:53only thing that that they can
- 27:55do or should do, because it's
- 27:56not the only reason we have a
- 27:58$300 million shortfall. And the
- 27:59biggest reason, or at least as
- 28:01big a reason, is the impact of
- 28:03the cuts, the individual income
- 28:04tax. Our largest revenue source
- 28:07is, is, is, is being reduced.
- 28:09It was at 6%. It's going to be
- 28:113.5% on January 1st. It was
- 28:13almost half of our revenue at
- 28:14one point. You can't replace
- 28:15that. And so there's going to
- 28:17have to be something done on
- 28:19the tax side as well. But
- 28:20absolutely in the short term
- 28:22you should be able to use you
- 28:23should use it is the
- 28:25responsible thing to do to
- 28:26H dyoee dto A us
- 28:31>> Yeah, $3.7 billion is a very
- 28:34significant amount of money,
- 28:35but it could be eaten up
- 28:37extremely quickly depending on
- 28:38how it gets utilized. And so
- 28:40the legislature has been very,
- 28:42very cautious with utilization
- 28:44of those funds. And we should
- 28:45point out that we don't
- 28:47normally have budget reserve
- 28:48trust fund balances. That is a
- 28:49fairly a fairly new phenomenon
- 28:51within Kentucky. And I think
- 28:53it's the result of a lot of
- 28:54hard work of our General
- 28:56Assembly to make sure that they
- 28:58have been taking these excess
- 28:59dollars and putting them in a
- 29:01budget reserve trust fund, so
- 29:02that we can use them not only
- 29:04for rainy days like we've
- 29:06discussed, but also for
- 29:08opportunities. One of the
- 29:09things that doesn't get talked
- 29:10about quite enough, I think
- 29:11with that budget, with the
- 29:12budget Reserve trust fund, is
- 29:14that it's also a revenue
- 29:15generator. And so that's
- 29:16something that has also been
- 29:17generating revenue through
- 29:18interest. And so that that's
- 29:20been another nice benefit. We
- 29:22saw a very large expenditure
- 29:24from our budget reserve trust
- 29:26fund in the 2024 budget cycle.
- 29:28And we'll likely continue to
- 29:29see returns from those
- 29:31investments. They spent money
- 29:32on things such as
- 29:35infrastructure, health care,
- 29:37education, a whole range of
- 29:38things where I think we need to
- 29:40be very cautious, though, is
- 29:41taking funds from the Budget
- 29:43Reserve trust fund that will
- 29:44essentially be reoccurring
- 29:46expenses. And that's something
- 29:47where I think they need to be
- 29:49very, very careful.
- 29:50>> And they haven't really done
- 29:51that. They've one time.
- 29:52>> Money that they have
- 29:54absolutely avoided that. And I
- 29:55think that's the right thing to
- 29:56do. I would anticipate there
- 29:58will be a robust conversation
- 29:59heading into the 2026 session,
- 30:00where we might see a similar
- 30:02piece of legislation to what we
- 30:04saw in 2024, where they made a
- 30:06series of very targeted
- 30:07investments that will also
- 30:08provide a return for Kentucky
- 30:10taxpayers down the road. But
- 30:12when it comes to using those
- 30:13funds for reoccurring expenses,
- 30:14that's when we might be putting
- 30:16ourselves into a fairly
- 30:17dangerous situation down the
- 30:18road. And keeping in mind,
- 30:20again, those dollars can get
- 30:22consumed very, verquklf
- 30:24Bgebuetg pbaythe pef rpes
- 30:28'srahtit a stsfpocyke he dan
- 30:32giin. You know, it starts
- 30:35off with you mentioned the
- 30:36consensus forecasting group. It
- 30:37starts off with an estimate,
- 30:38and it is just an estimate.
- 30:40With our forecast, we never are
- 30:42spot on. It's going to be off
- 30:44to some degree. And so when we
- 30:46start thinking about what is an
- 30:47appropriate amount for the
- 30:48budget reserve trust fund, it
- 30:49really comes down to what level
- 30:51of uncertainty do you have, not
- 30:52only your estimates, but in how
- 30:54things play out throughout the
- 30:55budget period, where you start
- 30:57seeing expenses come in higher
- 30:58than what your anticipated tax
- 30:59revenues come in, maybe lower
- 31:01or higher than what you
- 31:02anticipated. So a budget
- 31:04reserve trust fund is a really
- 31:06key element to managing that
- 31:07uncertainty. How big that
- 31:09should be? I mean, you know,
- 31:11there are some guidelines out
- 31:13there, but it really comes down
- 31:15to kind of your your appetite
- 31:17for risk. How much do you have
- 31:20in there kind of reflects how
- 31:22much risk you're willing to
- 31:23tolerate, what sort of other
- 31:25types of tools you have to
- 31:27address this? Are you willing
- 31:28to make cuts in terms of
- 31:30programs? As you start to see
- 31:32that you don't have enough
- 31:33revenue, so they really have to
- 31:35balance a lot of different
- 31:36things when they think about
- 31:37how much should we actually put
- 31:39in terms of these funds that we
- 31:40have, how much should we set
- 31:42aside for these rainy days? And
- 31:43then utilizing those, as you
- 31:45mentioned, gets really tricky
- 31:47because you don't know how long
- 31:49that uncertainty is going to
- 31:50last or how long those, those
- 31:52lower revenues are going to
- 31:53last. So you've got to make
- 31:54some really hard decisions
- 31:55about should we actually make
- 31:57cuts now, maybe a little bit
- 31:59more moderate level, or should
- 32:01we use the rainy day fund
- 32:03because we think maybe this is
- 32:04going to be a temporary thing
- 32:06that we can get through
- 32:07relatively easily. So it's it's
- 32:08a really difficult balancing
- 32:09Tsueio Gahead,lymer
- 32:14Doctor Lambert.
- 32:15>> I was just going to say
- 32:17quickly that I think next year,
- 32:19Frankfort is going to have a
- 32:20lot of people going to them
- 32:22with their hats in their hand
- 32:23because of federal budget cuts.
- 32:26Working with. I'm working with
- 32:28a group of graduate students at
- 32:30the University of Louisville.
- 32:33We're looking at a mental
- 32:35health organization that serves
- 32:37the Louisville area, as well as
- 32:39other counties surrounding
- 32:41Louisville, and they're worried
- 32:44about the effect of Medicaid
- 32:45cuts having to turn people away.
- 32:47And when you do things like
- 32:48that, you get into, well, well,
- 32:50some people lose their jobs if
- 32:52they don't get the appropriate
- 32:53mental health treatment. So I
- 32:55think the next year and of
- 32:57course, Congress, some
- 32:58congressmen have even said that
- 33:00the states have to pay a bigger
- 33:02share of certain programs like
- 33:04Medicaid, and that they need to
- 33:06pony up more money. So I think.
- 33:07>> Congressman Brett Guthrie
- 33:09has said that he.
- 33:09>> Wasn't going to mention his
- 33:11name, but.
- 33:11>> He said it on this, on these
- 33:14airwaves several times. This
- 33:15question from Dwight and
- 33:16Jefferson County. And he's
- 33:17talking about he says, House
- 33:18Bill one, H.R. one, actually at
- 33:20$3 trillion to the national
- 33:22debt. Did that happen? And
- 33:23where did that money go?
- 33:25>> Yeah, I mean, H.R. one was
- 33:28not at all about reducing the
- 33:29deficit. It increases the
- 33:31deficit because of the enormous
- 33:32tax cuts that are in the bill.
- 33:35Two thirds of the tax cuts go
- 33:37to the wealthiest 20% of people.
- 33:41So those that were skewed to to
- 33:44those who, you know, are the
- 33:46those folks who have seen their
- 33:48stock portfolios grow, have
- 33:49seen their incomes grow
- 33:50dramatically, and the cuts that
- 33:52they made to Medicaid and to
- 33:54Snap is the other big cut
- 33:55that's being passed off to the
- 33:57state where we're having to
- 33:58pick up a portion of the Snap
- 34:00program costs for the first
- 34:01time in the history of the
- 34:02program. That's going to be it
- 34:04could be hundreds of millions
- 34:05of dollars a year in the next
- 34:07budget. And we're likely not
- 34:08going to have revenue growth
- 34:10because of the sagging economy
- 34:11and the income tax cuts.
- 34:13Where's that going to come from?
- 34:14If we're not willing to tap the
- 34:16rainy day fund and do other
- 34:18talk about other ways to
- 34:19generate revenue? But yeah, I
- 34:22mean, I think that those cuts
- 34:24were huge, but they only
- 34:26partially offset the cost of
- 34:27the tax cuts. So we continue to
- 34:29grow the national debt. That's
- 34:31going to be a problem. At some
- 34:33point we're going to have to
- 34:34raise taxes, especially at the
- 34:36top. And in the near future
- 34:38it's you know, that's on the on
- 34:40the agenda.
- 34:40>> So at the time we have
- 34:42remaining, we want to shift and
- 34:43talk about tariffs and how it
- 34:45hits Kentucky homes and
- 34:46particularly Kentucky's farmers.
- 34:47So it's harvest time for
- 34:48Kentucky's grain farmers. But
- 34:50they'll find and they'll find
- 34:51they're going to be hard
- 34:53pressed to turn a profit
- 34:54because China is not buying
- 34:56American soybeans. It's gotten
- 34:57so bad that President Donald
- 34:59Trump says a government bailout
- 35:00for farmers could be announced
- 35:02soon. Our June Leffler talked
- 35:04to farmers a couple of weeks
- 35:05ago, and they say they need
- 35:07help now.
- 35:09>> It's warm and dusty in the
- 35:11soybean fields for two months
- 35:13round the clock, Matt Gieseke
- 35:15will run the combine. It cuts
- 35:17the stalks and separates the
- 35:19beans from the pods. His
- 35:21farmhand collects the beans and
- 35:23carries them over rolling
- 35:25fields towards the road.
- 35:27>> Put it on a truck and send
- 35:29it to Jeffersonville, Indiana
- 35:30to consolidate grain and barge.
- 35:31They put it on a barge and ship
- 35:33it down to the Gulf.
- 35:35>> But the going price for
- 35:36soybeans is low and likely
- 35:38won't rebound soon.
- 35:40>> It's a free market, and so
- 35:42the price is decided by trading.
- 35:45And, you know, it's just like
- 35:47anything else. You've got too
- 35:48much supply and not enough
- 35:50demand. The price is going to
- 35:51be low.
- 35:52>> Why the low demand? China
- 35:53isn't buying.
- 35:55>> So 25% of our soybeans in
- 35:57general from the United States
- 35:58are exported to China. And
- 36:00basically this entire year,
- 36:02China has not bought a single
- 36:04soybean.
- 36:05>> President Donald Trump's
- 36:06trade policy has meant
- 36:07reciprocal tariffs between
- 36:09China. So the soybeans China
- 36:11needs to feed its pigs are
- 36:13coming from Brazil and other
- 36:15South American countries.
- 36:16Instead.
- 36:17>> Running quick calculations
- 36:18on Soybean Acre this year and
- 36:20estimate losses for each
- 36:21producer to be somewhere
- 36:24between 100 and $200 per acre.
- 36:26>> With that math, Isaac could
- 36:27be missing out on more than
- 36:30$100,000.
- 36:30>> So that's causing a lot of
- 36:33stress in farm country across
- 36:36the US, because the prices are
- 36:38just depressed right now, to a
- 36:41point where a lot of people
- 36:42aren't making any money.
- 36:43>> Prominent Kentucky
- 36:44Republicans do not support
- 36:46Trump's trade war. US Senator
- 36:48Mitch McConnell says it's
- 36:49hurting customers and
- 36:51businesses, including farmers.
- 36:53But Kentucky's top agriculture
- 36:55official supports Trump's moves.
- 36:57Commissioner Jonathan Schell
- 36:59says, quote, for decades, our
- 37:01trade deals left America at the
- 37:03mercy of countries that didn't
- 37:05always have our best interest
- 37:07at heart. When you look at
- 37:08China, for example, it's not
- 37:10just about buying soybeans,
- 37:12it's about intellectual
- 37:13property theft, buying up
- 37:15farmland and creating
- 37:16instability around the globe.
- 37:18The president's approach is
- 37:20about protecting our
- 37:21sovereignty while still working
- 37:23to expand markets for our
- 37:24farmers. This farmer says he
- 37:27can't wait for a trade war to
- 37:29become a trade deal.
- 37:30>> Whether you support him or
- 37:32not, there's things that you
- 37:34can agree with and disagree
- 37:35with. And I'll say that that,
- 37:37you know, a lot of his trade
- 37:39policies right now because it's
- 37:42hurting the farm country so bad.
- 37:44I'm kind of I'm at a point
- 37:46where I'm, you know, I'd say
- 37:48disagree with them. I know
- 37:49President Trump had put out a
- 37:51tweet or whatever you wanna
- 37:53call it, that he's going to
- 37:54meet with China in four weeks.
- 37:56Four weeks is a long time away.
- 37:57>> The strains of farming are
- 37:59here and now. Inflation is high
- 38:01and so are loan interest rates.
- 38:03>> Because we buy things and
- 38:05our input costs are up 60%
- 38:07since 2017. And our and then
- 38:10we're receiving prices for the
- 38:13crop that, you know, are back
- 38:15in the 70s, 70s and 80s kind of
- 38:18prices.
- 38:18>> Farming associations are
- 38:20looking for more soybean
- 38:21markets at home. That means
- 38:23expanding biofuel consumption,
- 38:26something that's in progress.
- 38:27>> But every other country that
- 38:29bought beans in 2022 only made
- 38:32up 61% of China's demand. So
- 38:35China is the large player. If
- 38:37we're trying to piece a bunch
- 38:38of exports from different
- 38:39countries, I don't think we
- 38:41ever get to the demand we saw
- 38:43from China, or at least not
- 38:44this year. It would have to be
- 38:46the long term gain, and we'd
- 38:47have to see demand from those
- 38:49countries increase over time.
- 38:50>> The future of agriculture
- 38:51weighs on the farmers of today
- 38:53and tomorrow.
- 38:54>> You know, people want to be
- 38:56a doctor and I want to be a
- 38:58farmer. And they're like, oh,
- 38:59that's easy. It's a lot harder
- 39:00than it looks. I that's exactly
- 39:02what I want to do. That's the
- 39:04only thing I want to do.
- 39:05>> Sebastian Giglio is a high
- 39:07school senior debating taking
- 39:08up a trade, going to college or
- 39:11farming.
- 39:11>> You have to put food on the
- 39:13table and you don't really get
- 39:14paid much for it. And most of
- 39:16the time you're losing money.
- 39:18So how do you how do you figure
- 39:20out how to do that? I guess
- 39:21that's the hard part.
- 39:22>> Farmers in Trump went
- 39:24through a trade war before in
- 39:25his first term as president,
- 39:26the government bailed out
- 39:27farmers then, and Trump has
- 39:29suggested doing that again.
- 39:31>> While we don't want
- 39:32government payments, we need
- 39:34some help at this point.
- 39:36>> But reports say that likely
- 39:38won't happen until the federal
- 39:39shutdown ends for Kentucky
- 39:42tonight. I'm June Leffler.
- 39:44>> Thank you so much, June. I
- 39:45want to come to you, Doctor
- 39:47Lambert, because this is kind
- 39:48of your wheelhouse here on ag
- 39:50policy when it comes to this.
- 39:51So tell us what you think and
- 39:53what you heard, your response
- 39:54to what you heard from those
- 39:56farmers.
- 39:56>> Well, I it's a tremendous
- 39:58problem. And again, yesterday,
- 40:00the passage of or the enactment
- 40:02of 100% tariffs against China
- 40:04is not good news. Apparently
- 40:08they thought they were going to
- 40:10be able to work out a deal. Now
- 40:12they're not going to be able to
- 40:14work out a deal with the
- 40:15Chinese. This also helps our
- 40:17foreign competitors with
- 40:18certain products. I was in
- 40:20Glasgow, Scotland last summer
- 40:21and took a tour of the
- 40:23Highlands. Some of the Scottish
- 40:25whiskey manufacturers there,
- 40:28the distilleries, and they
- 40:30thought it was good news that,
- 40:32you know, United States and
- 40:34this applies to Kentucky,
- 40:35Kentucky bourbon, you know,
- 40:37whiskey made here in the United
- 40:39States was going to face
- 40:40retaliatory retaliatory tariffs
- 40:42from our trading partners. And
- 40:44they saw it as an opportunity
- 40:46to to gain in sales. So we not
- 40:50only have the problem of not
- 40:52being able to export and to
- 40:53make money, but again, we're
- 40:55losing out to foreign
- 40:56competition. They're going to
- 40:58gain market share. The other
- 41:00thing with with tariffs, if you
- 41:03do see the foreign goods coming
- 41:05into the United States many
- 41:08times, many corporations,
- 41:09instead of trying to keep their
- 41:11prices the same and gain market
- 41:14share, they just raised their
- 41:16prices to match the foreign
- 41:18competition once they got. Once,
- 41:20the goods get here. So whether
- 41:23the consumer often doesn't
- 41:26benefit from this, and
- 41:27oftentimes the jobs never come
- 41:28back. They're in manufacturing.
- 41:31We won't have manufacturing
- 41:33like we had in the 70s and 80s,
- 41:35which I think a lot of people
- 41:36imagine where you're going to
- 41:38have thousands of people, again,
- 41:39working at GE Appliance Park,
- 41:41like when my mother worked
- 41:42there in the 1970s, almost
- 41:4425,000 people, six buildings
- 41:47going almost seven days a week,
- 41:49year round. It won't be like
- 41:51that. There's more automation,
- 41:53there's artificial intelligence.
- 41:54So. Tariffs. Economists
- 41:58traditionally agree that most
- 41:59economists have agreed over the
- 42:02years that they they usually
- 42:03don't work out too well.
- 42:04>> Do you all agree. And it
- 42:06seems like that the Treasury
- 42:08secretary says that, you know,
- 42:10he's denied thatarfsre
- 42:11>> Tariffs are most definitelyn.
- 42:16attacks and they do affect
- 42:18consumers. And trade wars are
- 42:21not good for the economy on
- 42:22both sides. Economists
- 42:24generally tend to indicate that
- 42:27free trade among countries is
- 42:30beneficial for both countries.
- 42:31In most situations. We can talk
- 42:34about some exceptions here in
- 42:35just a minute. But but the idea
- 42:37is it really gets down to the
- 42:39issue of comparative advantage.
- 42:41We can can produce certain
- 42:44things here in terms of goods
- 42:46and services, very, very well.
- 42:48We can specialize in that. And
- 42:50other countries can specialize
- 42:51in the things that they have
- 42:53comparative advantage in. And
- 42:54in total, what ends up
- 42:55happening is we increase
- 42:56overall production by
- 42:57specializing in the things that
- 42:59we're really, really good at.
- 43:00As a result of that, our
- 43:02quality of life goes up. We
- 43:04have more goods and services
- 43:06available and they tend to be
- 43:08cheaper. So when we enter into
- 43:09a trade war, we tend to disrupt
- 43:12that and we end up actually
- 43:14reducing the amount of goods
- 43:16and services that are being
- 43:17produced. Now, that's not to
- 43:19say that there aren't some
- 43:20winners with that, right?
- 43:21Because we can see that, you
- 43:22know, if we increase tariffs on
- 43:25some particular good from a
- 43:27foreign country, we're
- 43:28protecting some of the domestic
- 43:29industry potentially. So they
- 43:31might see, well, the foreign
- 43:34competition has become more
- 43:35expensive. So they may see an
- 43:37increase in demand in terms of
- 43:39their what they're producing.
- 43:40So that can be good for some
- 43:41industries. But generally these
- 43:43tend to be things that are very
- 43:46costly for both businesses and
- 43:48for consumers. For businesses,
- 43:50we import a lot of the
- 43:52materials that we actually put
- 43:53into the things that we produce
- 43:55here. You know, even in
- 43:56Kentucky, we bring them from
- 43:58Mexico, we bring them in from
- 43:59Canada. So when we put tariffs
- 44:01on those, those items, we
- 44:03increase the cost of the things
- 44:04that we're actually doing. So
- 44:06that could be harmful for those
- 44:07businesses. For consumers it
- 44:08increases the cost.o
- 44:10Yh. t eno. e n
- 44:14>> Ihi t pce tt uju r, ne Ihinks
- 44:18just a great example of how
- 44:20these tariffs actually affect
- 44:21people in their daily lives.
- 44:23And they also illustrate why
- 44:24these tariffs are such an awful,
- 44:26awful economic policy concept.
- 44:28To help put these things a
- 44:30little bit into perspective,
- 44:32this is real money on the table.
- 44:34We often think about these
- 44:35things in abstract concepts.
- 44:36But so far this year, the
- 44:39federal government has raised
- 44:41around $195 billion in tariff
- 44:43revenue. And that's about twice
- 44:44what we raised last year. Those
- 44:46are real dollars that are being
- 44:48paid by households, primarily
- 44:49because oftentimes when an
- 44:51importer picks up these tariffs,
- 44:54they eventually pass them down
- 44:56and those fall eventually onto
- 44:57consumers. And this is coming
- 44:59at a time, as we've already
- 45:00been dealing with really
- 45:02significant inflation. And as
- 45:03Jason rightly pointed out,
- 45:05really high cost of living,
- 45:07fully phased in. I think that's
- 45:09one of the things that's
- 45:10important to remember about the
- 45:11current tariff situation is a
- 45:12lot of the tariffs that have
- 45:14been proposed going back to a
- 45:15Liberation Day have not
- 45:17actually been fully phased in,
- 45:18if fully phased in. Some of the
- 45:20estimates out there suggest
- 45:21that they could run as high as
- 45:2324, $2,500 per year per
- 45:25household, and that's a really
- 45:27significant hit. And I think
- 45:28one statistic I do want to
- 45:30throw out here, to really
- 45:31illustrate the significance of
- 45:32this shift in domestic economic
- 45:35policy, is the calculated
- 45:37average effective tariff rate
- 45:38A wt ds ateaaround 1to2%
- 45:43xe They fall at differente
- 45:50rates on different products
- 45:51coming from different places.
- 45:53And so it's really hard to say
- 45:55here's what the average tariff
- 45:56rate is right now. So they
- 45:58calculate an average effective
- 45:59tariff rate. And that is the
- 46:01highest that it's been going
- 46:03back to about the 1940s. If
- 46:05fully phased in the tariffs the
- 46:06president has discussed, we'd
- 46:07be looking at an average
- 46:09effective tariff rate closer to
- 46:10around 17%. That would be the
- 46:13highest it's been since the
- 46:151930s. So if you're trying to
- 46:16think about the direction of
- 46:17economic policy under this new
- 46:19tariff regime, we are
- 46:20essentially taking economic
- 46:21policy back almost 100 years.
- 46:24And that tells you a whole lot
- 46:26about what's going on here and
- 46:28just how archaic of a concept
- 46:30is that is at play here.
- 46:33>> Yes. Go ahead.
- 46:34>> Jason, I just want to add
- 46:35that it's part of the problem
- 46:37with the tariff policy is and
- 46:38we've made some reference to it
- 46:40is the the on again, off again
- 46:42chaotic nature of it. I mean
- 46:44the, the 100% tariff on China
- 46:46that was threatened. I think
- 46:47they're rolling back. They're,
- 46:48they're backing off on that
- 46:49today. We've had rates up to
- 46:51almost 200% on China that were
- 46:53then dropped down. If you
- 46:55create that kind of uncertainty
- 46:56as a business, you're not going
- 46:58to be able to make investment
- 47:00decisions because you have no
- 47:01idea what actual tariffs are
- 47:03applied to, to which country
- 47:06and which product. So the the
- 47:08the chaos is part of the
- 47:10problem. The blanket nature is
- 47:11part of the problem. I mean,
- 47:13we're we've got a 35% tariff on
- 47:15Canada, you know, close trading
- 47:17partners. I mean it's sort of
- 47:19all across the board. That's a
- 47:21problem. Having said that, I
- 47:22will say we need to think about
- 47:24why we got how we got to where
- 47:26we are, where this sort of
- 47:28policy can be promoted and in
- 47:29some cases be popular. The way
- 47:31in which we have pursued kind
- 47:33of a globalized economy, where
- 47:34we put down these barriers on
- 47:36tariffs, have allowed people to
- 47:40buy cheap things at Walmart,
- 47:41but have created real painful
- 47:45job loss in the Rust Belt and
- 47:47in manufacturing communities
- 47:49that we as a country did little
- 47:51to nothing to help those people.
- 47:52Right. So the way in which the
- 47:55economy was globalized was
- 47:58deeply harmful to, you know,
- 48:00lots of people gained a little
- 48:02bit. A bunch of people gained
- 48:04lost a lot. And and those folks
- 48:07are frustrated by that, and
- 48:08they want a different policy. I
- 48:10don't think we're going to go
- 48:11back to what we had in terms of
- 48:13entire free markets. So there
- 48:15is a role for tariffs, but it's
- 48:17a strategic role for tariffs.
- 48:19It's in particular industries.
- 48:21You know every country that's
- 48:23wealthy used tariffs at some
- 48:25point to help become wealthy.
- 48:26And in this country we're at
- 48:28risk of becoming an entirely
- 48:30post-industrial economy where
- 48:31we do no manufacturing where
- 48:33and, you know, where we don't
- 48:36have access to semiconductor
- 48:37chips, where we, you know, we
- 48:39don't have the innovation that
- 48:40comes off of manufacturing. So
- 48:42there is a role, but it's not
- 48:43this this is chaos, and this is
- 48:45just raising the prices for for
- 48:48Christmas toys at a time when
- 48:51people can't afford them and
- 48:52threatening industries like,
- 48:53like soybeans that are facing
- 48:56it is turning into a trade war
- 48:58that is harmful to both
- 48:59countries.
- 48:59>> I was going to say Halloween
- 49:01decorations have gone up quite
- 49:02a bit too. If you go to Home
- 49:04Depot or a place like that,
- 49:06because so much of that comes
- 49:07from overseas. Jason is right.
- 49:11We have never adequately funded,
- 49:14funded these job training
- 49:15programs, which are supposed to
- 49:17help people who have lost jobs
- 49:21because of plant closures or
- 49:23business closures. That's been
- 49:24a constant criticism ever since.
- 49:27Those programs, I believe, were
- 49:29first enacted. I'm not 100%
- 49:30sure, but were first enacted in
- 49:32the 1980s that that they exist,
- 49:35but they have never been
- 49:36adequately funded to take care
- 49:38of people, retrain them, etc.
- 49:40And getting back to the point
- 49:42about business uncertainty,
- 49:43earlier this year, Churchill
- 49:44Downs announced in Louisville
- 49:47$900 million investment in
- 49:48redoing its facilities. More
- 49:51places for people to watch the
- 49:53races, etc. and then all of a
- 49:55sudden, because of the economic
- 49:56uncertainty over unemployment,
- 49:57tariffs, etc. they rolled that
- 50:00back significantly. So there we
- 50:02lose a lot ore iesen
- 50:05beusofhi uerinecom cma.>>ocr are
- 50:10of the reasons that we heard
- 50:11from the Trump administration
- 50:12about their trade policy is
- 50:14that it will encourage
- 50:15companies to shift and that
- 50:17they will diversify their
- 50:19supply chains and they will
- 50:20onshore their production in the
- 50:22U.S. Has that ever happened?
- 50:24And is that a possibility that
- 50:26it would.
- 50:26>> We see some of that. But I
- 50:29think the uncertainty that
- 50:31Jason mentioned is really going
- 50:34to limit the degree to which we
- 50:37see any real reshoring based on
- 50:40the policies that have been
- 50:41implemented so far this year.
- 50:43It's not clear whether or not
- 50:44these tariffs are going to hold
- 50:46up to legal challenges. It's
- 50:47not clear whether or not
- 50:49they're going to be sustained
- 50:51by the next administration.
- 50:52Given that uncertainty, I think
- 50:54a lot of these businesses are
- 50:55going to be really hesitant to
- 50:57make substantial changes to
- 50:58their supply chain until they
- 51:00really understand how that is
- 51:01going to play out. So in theory,
- 51:05it could potentially bring some
- 51:07of these things back, but it's
- 51:08not necessarily clear that that
- 51:11that's entirely a good thing
- 51:13because it's going to be costly
- 51:15to bring those jobs back. You
- 51:17know, we we did lose if you go
- 51:20back to the 1990s, you know,
- 51:21Kentucky had a lot of of
- 51:23textile textile manufacturing.
- 51:26And we lost those jobs. And
- 51:27those were painful job losses
- 51:29for those who were in that
- 51:30industry. But what we actually
- 51:32gained with free trade was
- 51:34advanced manufacturing. We
- 51:36gained jobs that were much
- 51:39required, much higher skills
- 51:40and paid much better wages. So
- 51:42we were able to actually, in
- 51:44Kentucky, you know, do really
- 51:45well in terms of manufacturing
- 51:46that I think overall has been
- 51:48good for the state. When we
- 51:50talk about exceptions where
- 51:52where maybe there are there is
- 51:55some some valid use of, of
- 51:58increasing tariffs is when
- 52:00other countries are engaged in
- 52:01other types of unfair trade
- 52:04activities. And China has been,
- 52:05you know, a player in this, you
- 52:09know, there was some discussion
- 52:11of rare earth elements and, you
- 52:13know, in the 100% tariff on
- 52:14China as a result of some
- 52:15policies they're making with
- 52:17rare earth elements. You know,
- 52:18rare earth elements are
- 52:19critical to a lot of the
- 52:21consumer goods, a lot of the
- 52:22military goods. And to the
- 52:24extent that China reduces the
- 52:26rest of the world's access to
- 52:27some of those materials, then
- 52:30maybe it makes sense for the US
- 52:32to think about what appropriate
- 52:33policy would be in response to
- 52:35that. Is that tariffs, is that
- 52:38subsidizing development in the
- 52:39US? Those are our policy
- 52:41discussions that I think the US
- 52:43should be thinking about, and I
- 52:44think they are thinking about
- 52:46things. But yes, there are some
- 52:48instances where it is
- 52:49appropriate to look at what's
- 52:51going on with a trade partner
- 52:53and maybe respond in kind.
- 52:55>> Yeah, doctor, all.
- 52:56>> I think as Mike said, you
- 52:58know, you probably will see
- 53:01some examples of domestic
- 53:02reshoring. And proponents of
- 53:04tariffs will be really quick to
- 53:06point that out. What they won't
- 53:07be quick to point out, though,
- 53:09are also the job losses that
- 53:10will absolutely outpace any
- 53:12form of domestic reshoring that
- 53:14we have, especially at a macro
- 53:16level when we look at the whole
- 53:17picture. And so that's
- 53:18something we need to be careful
- 53:20about in this conversation, is
- 53:21to to be cognizant of what the
- 53:23data is showing us, what the
- 53:24overall picture, because you
- 53:25will see these little hints
- 53:27here and there where companies
- 53:28are able to make that work. But
- 53:30those will generally be few and
- 53:31far between. Our argument at
- 53:32the chamber in this instance,
- 53:34would be that there's better
- 53:35ways to achieve those goals of
- 53:37reshoring a lot of these
- 53:39manufacturing jobs by doing
- 53:40things like having a favorable
- 53:42regulatory environment, having
- 53:43a pro-growth tax climate,
- 53:45having reliable and accessible
- 53:46energy, a strong competitive
- 53:48workforce. Those are the types
- 53:50of things that we need to have
- 53:51in place to which.
- 53:52>> The Trump administration
- 53:53would say they're doing as well.
- 53:55Yeah.
- 53:55>> So you have, on the one hand,
- 53:57some of this pro-growth policy
- 53:58that would help facilitate. And
- 54:00then on these, on the other
- 54:01hand, policy that absolutely
- 54:02negates what the other hand is
- 54:04doing. And I think that is in a
- 54:06lot of ways reflective of kind
- 54:07of what we're hearing in
- 54:09economic data these days, which
- 54:10is sort of this floundering
- 54:11economy. And so I think if you
- 54:13pull back on those tariffs
- 54:15created a lot more certainty in
- 54:17government, I think we'd be on
- 54:19a much brighter trajectory
- 54:20right now.
- 54:20ou wree' headed.
- 54:25Doctor Lambert.
- 54:26>> A little pessimistic to a
- 54:29certain extent. I know that,
- 54:32you know, the Trump
- 54:34administration is is arguing
- 54:35for tariffs, a path, a certain
- 54:39path to go down. Excuse me. As
- 54:42far as keeping the economy
- 54:43going or keeping it on a on a
- 54:46good path, I would argue that
- 54:49in some economists like Larry
- 54:51Summers and James Galbraith
- 54:53have argued this as well, that
- 54:54we're in some type of period of
- 54:56secular stagnation in our
- 54:58economy, and we're not
- 55:00investing enough. And we can
- 55:02debate about welfare programs,
- 55:04Medicaid, Social Security, etc.
- 55:06but put that aside for a minute,
- 55:08and let's look at whether we're
- 55:09really investing in our roads,
- 55:11bridges, etc. And there's the
- 55:14argument among those folks and
- 55:17others that that were not. And
- 55:19that's why our economy is is so
- 55:21stagnant and so slow. Since the
- 55:232008 2009 recession, we don't
- 55:25have enough investment in
- 55:27research and development
- 55:29technology. People will tell
- 55:30you we're investing plenty now,
- 55:32but these folks are arguing
- 55:33that we could do even more,
- 55:35given the amount of savings out
- 55:37there and the amount of surplus
- 55:38that's being generated.
- 55:39>> Yeah, well, we'll leave it
- 55:41there. Good conversation. This
- 55:43was right on time, and I hope
- 55:45that your students will go back
- 55:47and watch this, perhaps for
- 55:48some extra credit and viewers
- 55:50at home as well. And we thank
- 55:52you for joining us tonight.
- 55:53Make sure you join us each
- 55:55weeknight at 630 eastern, 530
- 55:56central for Kentucky Edition,
- 55:57where we'll show you more great
- 55:59stories like what June Leffler
- 56:00brought us about the soybean
- 56:02situation and the tariffs there.
- 56:04And then, of course, Bill
- 56:05Bryant and a team of
- 56:06journalists will be in this
- 56:08studio to discuss the news of
- 56:09the week on comment on Kentucky
- 56:11Friday at 8:00 eastern, 7:00
- 56:12central next Monday night. A
- 56:14great goody for you, the 250
- 56:16years of Lexington. Lexington
- 56:19250, a three hour documentary
- 56:21will air in this time slot. It
- 56:23will start at 7 p.m. eastern
- 56:25time next Monday. So we won't
- 56:27be with you, but we do hope
- 56:28you'll tune in for that
- 56:30wonderful documentary by our
- 56:31producers here at KET. Thanks
- 56:34for watching, and I'll see you
- 56:35tomorrow night.