Latest / First Encounter—A Historical Romance Podcast / S1 E13—Life During the Medieval Period in Historical Romance with Alison McKenzie
Transcript
- Andie James: Hello everyone and welcome to First Encounter. I am Andie James, a historical romance enthusiast and author. And it's the start of a new month. So that means we're doing an indie author interview, which I'm always very excited to do. our guest this month is Alison McKenzie. So welcome, Alison. Very excited to have her. Andrea Shea: Hey everyone, it's Editing Andie here. I'm currently going through and editing this fantastic episode that I did with Alison Mckenzie. But unfortunately, for some reason, the last minutes of conversation, Alison just is not part of. just me talking to nobody. I have no idea what happened, so I want to apologize in advance that this episode is cut short a little bit. Andie James: a special love for all things revolutionary. She left undergrad with a minor in history and went on to library school so that she could indulge her other passion, which is connecting people with books. That is also an excellent passion. I think many of us have. ⁓ and you can find her online at Blue Sky and Instagram @amckenziewrites. And that, of course, is going to be linked ⁓ in the notes and I'll posted online and Andrea Shea: terms of content, didn't miss a ton. it was about some of Alison's further plans and where to get her books. I will make sure to have links on the best ways to find and her books in the show notes. you can find that below. But anyways, it's still a fantastic conversation. Please listen. I just want to know why it cuts off abruptly. And my sincerest apologies to Alison Andie James: All that good stuff. So you'll definitely be able to figure out and find how to connect with Alison because after this conversation, I'm hoping you're gonna want to go read her books. welcome Alison. Thank you so much for agreeing to join me. Alson: Hey, thanks so much for having me. Andie James: Yes. Yeah. And I will note, I mean, maybe it's not a big deal, but I'm impressed. We're recording this on July first, which is Canada Day, and Alison is Canadian and she's still joining me, so Andrea Shea: that we don't the very end of our conversation. But everyone, I hope you still enjoy happy reading and happy listening. Alson: Honestly, it's fine. Like it Canada Day is whatever. I donated fifty dollars to the native women's center and that's my that's my Canada Day celebration, as it were. Andie James: There you go. I love it. I love it. All right. Well, we have lots of fun things to talk about today. So Alison the author of the Lovers of Linden series. ⁓ first book is The Blacksmith's Bride. And so hopefully some of you have read that. I still need to because I only read the new one. I'm a terrible person, but I'm very excited to read it after having read the new book. Andrea Shea: Okay, editing Andie again here. That is where our conversation abruptly ended in terms of ⁓ Alison's not being So again, I for this. I'm not sure what happened, but I'll look into the software and hopefully this won't happen again. But in the meantime, I really hope you enjoyed this episode. I had such a fun time chatting with Alison. ⁓ Her books I think are really unique in our current historical romance landscape. Andie James: And her the second book in the series, the one that I read and we're going to be discussing today, is this beautiful one. If you're watching online, you can see Alison's holding up the cover. It is called The Tailor's Treasure. book two in the Lovers of London. ⁓ I comes out August 12th. So if you're listening to this right when this episode drops, it's not yet out, but it will be in a few days. So launching August 12th, Tailor's Treasure, book two in the series. I loved it. Andrea Shea: And I really, really appreciate them. So I hope you will take time to go and check out Blacksmith's Bride before new book, The Tailor's Treasure, becomes available on August 12th. And again, all the information on where to find Alison's books and more about her is linked in our episode show notes below. thank you for listening. Happy reading. ⁓ Bye. Andie James: I wasn't really sure what to expect going in, I'm not gonna lie, because I just was like, ⁓ new series, new author for me. This is great. And it was fantastic. So Alison, do you want because it's not out yet, I don't want to like majorly spoiler-y this. So do you wanna kind of give us a little bit of a summation of what this book's about and the whole series and why you decided to write it? Just a few small questions. Alson: Thank you, Roger. Sure, yeah. So ⁓ I'm gonna start on the assumption that anyone listening hasn't read the first book and is coming into this completely fresh. ⁓ so the books are set in Linden, which is a small town in England that I made up in the 1300s. I set it in that era specifically because in the aftermath of the Black Death epidemic of the 1350s. That was really sort of the breaking point where the feudal order ⁓ started to break down and we started to move more into an agricultural era. Agriculture was already the dominant economic form, but at this point ⁓ serfdom was starting to crumble and people were starting to own land on their own as opposed to having to rent it from the feudal lord. ⁓ so that was kind of what inspired me to set the series in this time period because it is such a pressure point in terms of early modern history. So the first book in the series, Blacksmith's Bride, is a friends to lovers story. My main character, Elizabeth, finds out that she is pregnant out of wedlock by the lord of the Manor, who is obviously not going to marry her because she is a peasant. ⁓ and she's commiser and she's ⁓ kind of venting about this to her best friend Matthew, who she does not know has been in love with her since they were ⁓ And he blurts out, you know, I would marry you. And she's like, wait, really? And he's like, ⁓ Well well, I can't take it back now, so yes. ⁓ and they get married and things go from there. now in that book you meet Matthew's older sister Isabel, and Isabel is a character I really love who has given me no end of headaches because she does not want to be perceived. And that extends to her author. It took me like the first book took me maybe six months to write. This one took me three years. Andie James: Well Yeah. Mm-hmm. ⁓ wow. Alson: She was fighting me, kicking and screaming every single step of the way. ⁓ when we meet Isabel in the Blacksmith's Bride, she married an older wealthy man who did not treat her well, and he has just died or is dying. He dies in the book. This is not too much of a spoiler. You you know pretty much from the jump that he's on his way out. and she is left with no money, no home of her own, and most importantly, no legal right to her infant son. Andie James: Yeah. Alson: Unless she stays with her in-laws who also do not like her. So when we meet her at the beginning of Tailor's Treasure, she is very much stuck and very much depressed and convinced that like this is where her life ends. This she's not going anywhere ⁓ and she's at the market one day and she bumps into this woman named Constance, who is our titular tailor. That's T-A-I, not T-A-Y, as in Taylor Swift. ⁓ ⁓ she's she's having kind of a shit day. Andie James: Yes. No. tailor as in occupation, clothes maker. Alson: She's just gotten beer spilled over her by the local drunk. Her kid got lost in the market. And Constance's like, hey, you seem to be going through it. Do you like want to go back to my place, get cleaned up, like have a meal, maybe? and from there, things sort of progress. ⁓ Constance is also in a bit of an economically precarious situation. Her husband, who was the moneymaker, was disabled in an accident, and so they're running short on money. And it turns out Isabel is a really skilled embroiderer, so she's like, hey. Do you want to work with me? Like, can we partner on this? And Isabel agrees to this. And this is kind of a turning point in her life where she starts to both realize some certain things, certain things are awakened in her, let's say, and also she is starting to be pushed towards the idea that she can actually try and pursue happiness for herself, which is something that she's never really done. And one thing that really kind of was the impetus for this book, I knew I wanted to write a book for Isabel. Like halfway through Blacksmith's Bride, I was like, she's the next main character. and one of the things that interested me about that is that Blacksmith's Bride ends with Elizabeth's child being born. and for her, this is a happy ending. She wants a family, she's married to a man she loves, like this everything is settled. She's good. And obviously that's true for a lot of people. You get married, you have kids, this is the goal, this is what you're working towards. But I wanted to look at a character who has had that, who's gotten married and had a kid, and it hasn't actually been a good thing for her. And now she's at the point after that where she's like, Well, what the hell do I do now? I've actually got a blog post on my Substack about a trend that I call epilogue babies, which is like when a story, not always a romance story, but often, we just like smash cut forward. ⁓ Andie James: Yeah, yes. Alson: Like a couple months, years later, and look, they've got a baby and everything's great. Don't even worry about all those problems we had in the story. We've gotten past it. And it's always bugged me because it always kind of implies that a baby is an achievement in it in and of itself. It's not like Andie James: Okay. Alson: This is a person who you then have to care for and worry about and raise and teach to be a human for the next 18 years. It's just kind of treated as a trophy. So I wanted to look at what happens in motherhood in a circumstance like this where she still has a lot of problems to overcome. And I wanted to look at that in the context of like her deciding who she is as a person, as opposed to defining herself by what she can do or needs to do for others. Her child, obviously, but also her. her family, her brother. ⁓ so that was really kind of what inspired the premise for this. Andie James: Yeah. No, it's great. I, we'll get into this a little more later, but I mean the fact that Isabel is a mother like ⁓ important to this story. ⁓ mean it defines all her ⁓ maybe not defines but motivates all her decisions and and and just everything that she's doing. And so definitely want to touch on that more in a minute. Alson: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Andie James: but we'll talk about that more later because I think that is really important. So I think that's interesting that that was your launchpin because you're right. I mean, the baby epilogue is ⁓ ⁓ very much. ⁓ I'm guilty of having written that in myself, not so much the way that like the baby is the prize or the you know, whatever, but it's like right. But it is, you know, these people now in the future, yeah, have child because it's putting their whatever. Alson: Yeah, but it's like it's a sign that everything's good now. You had a baby and that means that there's a bow tie. Exactly. Exactly. And I'm also like like I said, this is how the first book ended. I am not not guilty of this. But I wanted to kind of problematize that a bit and kind of look at what happens after. Andie James: Yeah. Right. We all are. No, I think that's great because I mean, there's nothing wrong, with ending your book with people having children, because many, many, many people have children. ⁓ do not Yeah, there you go. I mean, I'm actually a childless cat lady 42, but you know, But it's a natural thing for many, many people. I don't think the fact that we're writing and people having children, like Elizabeth at the end of that book. Alson: Yeah. I'm a children's librarian in my day job. I love kids. Andie James: People at the end of my books, I don't think that's an issue. I think it's the way in which that child is treated, like you said, right? Like what does that symbolize and and and so what comes next? So I love that that was kind of your your thoughts and your impetus here. But before we dive more into some of the detail of all of this, I want to s take a step back and I want to learn a little bit more. Alson: Mm-hmm. Andie James: About your own journey with romance and historical romance. ⁓ the the bio you provided talked about how you are a history nerd, which we love, and you always love books, obviously. So, how did you come to romance as maybe a reader? And then what's kind of your writing journey and what made you decide to write historical romance? So, kind of three parts to this very big question I'm asking you. Alson: Yeah. Yeah, I don't know. Yeah. So my first historical romance ⁓ I don't remember which of these came first. It was either Rose Lerner's In for a Penny or Courtney Milan's The Governess Affair. Like I remember reading The Governess Affair more clearly, but In for a Penny might have come first. I like I said, I'm not entirely clear. I could probably go check my Goodreads, but whatever. But ⁓ Andie James: How many of us can remember? Alson: But I so that was kind of what started me reading romance, because I liked these books so much that I sought out the other books these authors had written, and then I was like, okay, what else can I find that kind of scratches this itch? And then I also ⁓ got into other historical romances kind of a bit sideways because I read ⁓ Melissa Scott, Amy Griswold's Lynes and Mathey series, which if you're if you're not familiar with it, is kind of a detective, a magic detective series set in alternate Victorian London. Andie James: Right. ⁓ Okay. Alson: And a gay couple at the center of it. And I read those and was like, I love these, but there's only two of them. they have been ⁓ mentioning third book for like 15 years now. I will be first in line if if it ever comes out. But please, please. ⁓ but I read those and was like, okay, what else can I find that kind of scratches this itch? And someone recommended ⁓ KJ Charles's The Secret Case Book of Simon Feximal Andie James: Yeah. ⁓ my goodness. Alson: And then if you KJ Charles, she's got a huge, yeah, huge backlist. So like after I read Simon Feximal, I read the Magpie books, and then I read like ⁓ Think of England, which is still one of my favorite romance novels. And then like it just goes from there, Snowball Rolling Downhill. So that was how I got into reading romance. Writing romance is not something I considered for the longest time. I think like because I started when I started writing as like a the grade schooler. Andie James: Agree, Charles. There's always a good answer. Alson: I was mostly writing fantasy because at that point in my life that was what I was reading almost exclusively. Like I was reading historical fiction, but I hadn't like conceptualized that as something I could write as well. ⁓ it was the the Royal Diaries and the Dear Canada series. I was obsessed with them. I still have all of them. ⁓ but yeah, so I was mostly writing fantasy. And then I Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Alson: The way Blacksmith's Bride actually came about was when I was in college, I was in like a role-playing group on Live Journal with some friends. And we were doing a role-playing game based on the BBC TV show Robin Hood that ran in like the early 2010s. It's not a good show. It's not a good show, but we had a great time with it. and Elizabeth was my character, and she was like obviously an original character. Andie James: Yeah, yeah, yeah. I know exactly what you're talking about. It's not great, but I watched it anyway. Yeah. Alson: And she was always kind of in the back of my mind after that, like for years after to be like, I wonder what she's up to. And then when the pandemic hit, so I graduated from library school in August of 2020. And then I was kind of at loose ends because obviously the job market was not great at that point. ⁓ So I signed up for a writing challenge called Get Your Words Out. It was like, okay, try writing a hundred thousand words in a year. And I was like, okay, what can I write for this? What Andie James: Not so much, no. Alson: What like low pressure thing can I start putting pen to paper on? And I thought back to Elizabeth and I was like, okay, now I can go back and write her story with no expectation that anything would come of it. It was just supposed to be a fun, like, side project. And I finished it and I looked at it and went, I want to share this with people. So that was how I got started. And then I once I'd done that, I was like, well, now I have to write Isabel's story because I left her in a bad place in the first book. Andie James: I love that. Yeah. Alson: And then once I did that, I was like, well, now I've got all these other characters I need to follow up on, and the rest is history. So that was how I kind of got into writing romance, was I started reading it fairly early, like I would say again, about 15 years ago now when I was in college. And then the writing of it came later as something that I kind of fell into almost by accident. Andie James: There you go. Well, it's a happy accident. I'm glad it happened. No, it's fun. I mean, well, I say it's fun as I'm pulling my hair out trying to finish a manuscript right now. Alson: It was, yeah. I'm I'm very pleased with that. I know, right? I was like, I really hope people like this book because it took a lot of blood, sweat and tears. Andie James: It does. It does. Well, I loved it. and I so there's a couple things I think you've touched on some of these already, but I want to kind of probe a little deeper. So one is the the time period and the setting. I I think for what's being written right now, it's pretty unique. I wouldn't say in all of like historical romance it's unique. Alson: Thank you. Okay. That was when I was querying, I got that a lot. I I I literally did have several agents tell me, you know, Middle Ages, people want knights, people want lords and ladies, ⁓ not so much these random peasants living very unglamorous lives. That was why I ended up indie publishing. Andie James: Yeah. Well I'm sorry that they turned it down, but I'm glad you still published. Alson: Yeah. I mean it it's fair. Romance historical romance, especially I find is a very risk-averse genre. It honestly drives me a little crazy that you see all these articles about like, why is historical romance dying? Why is Harlequin shutting down their historical romance line? And I'm like, 'Cause you're not doing anything new. It's because you've been doing the same thing for 30 years now, and people are bored if you would take risks if you would try new things. Andie James: Yeah. Alson: you would be able to retain some of that audience or get a new one, but there's just no will to take the risk because they would rather rely on what's what's a guaranteed sale. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. I hear that. it's it it's hard, I think to but I'm glad though that I feel obviously right now since traditional publishing isn't doing quite as much or willing to take those risks, I feel like the indie space is where it's most robust right now. It's just hard to be seen. Alson: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Absolutely. There's so much cool stuff happening in the indie space. Like you and I both know Katherine Grant, you and I both know Jane Hadley, like ⁓ Courtney Milan went, I think, fully indie a couple years ago. Just like there's so much happening in this space that would not be in the traditional publishing space. And the interesting thing too is that once indie authors like when indie authors get big enough, then traditional publishers come around and go, ⁓ actually. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Right. They shoulder tap after you've done the work. Yeah. Alson: Like that's what's happened with Yeah, that's what's happened with K J Charles is that they've scooped her up now that she's built an audience publishing stuff with either independent or very small presses that traditional publishers I think probably would never have touched. Andie James: Yeah, yeah. I love KJ Charles so much. ⁓ but yeah, so you did set this, like we said, in a time period that right now I think we don't see as much if we do. I mean, because this is more Middle Ages, like you said. ⁓ so it's not like Viking at all. It's not, you know, like there it there's you know, it's kind of this in between some of the things we're seeing written. and Alson: Yeah. Mm. No, no. Yeah. Andie James: I do. You you just mentioned it, but this is focused on pretty everyday people. And I found it very refreshing to just kind of see different struggles, I guess, coming from someone who writes about the aristocracy in Regency England. I mean, ⁓ there is a lot of us, yeah. ⁓ but I think, you know, it's it's just nice to see different challenges and how that shaped Alson: Yeah. There. There's a lot going on there. Andie James: the story. because these are people really struggling with economics. It's not a money issue. It's not a class issue because they're all just kind of peasants together, right? but it's it's really interesting. I mean, you mentioned Constance is the one now trying to figure out how to support the family. ⁓ and she can do that as a woman. That's another thing, right? The women's roles, ⁓ because her husband's been injured. Alson: Yeah. Yes. Andie James: but and then also, I mean, we can touch on this a little bit more when we go into the motherhood stuff in a bit, but there's also the fact that, you know, Isabel doesn't have rights as a mother to her child. Alson: Yes. Mm-hmm. No. That was really kind of like I said, I I struggled to write this book for a long time. What really cracked it open was a book by Barbara Hannawalt. And I don't have the title on me right now, but it's basically about like family structures in the Middle Ages. And she talks about how ⁓ a man died, ⁓ could will wardship of his child. Like he could say basically, I want this person to be my child's legal guardian. Andie James: It would. Alson: And that was not automatically the mother. In fact, it often wasn't automatically the mother. Now, this was more common in ⁓ wealthier families like the landed gentry, the aristocracy. in Isabel's case, her husband was a merchant, so wealthy enough that he could say, I want my child raised by these people, not these people. ⁓ and so there was money tied up in that, obviously, because if the child is inheriting, then whoever has the wardship has access to those funds. Yeah. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. As access. Yes. Mm-hmm. Alson: I actually I read a book by by Erin Langston called Forever Your Rogue, which is a read. And I read it like last year as I was doing edits on this and I was like, damn it, she scooped me because it's very similar. swear to God, I swear I didn't read it till after I finished writing this. ⁓ like, this is this is the exact same conflict. Son of a ⁓ Yeah, it it's the same thing. We're like Andie James: Yes. Yeah. Yeah. That happens to me with every book I write, I swear. Very different setting though. It's okay. Alson: Very different setting. Different setting, different sexual orientation, a lot of difference. but it was a thing for like most of history is that custody did not automatically go to the mother if the husband died and he decided where the custody went. So if the mother was in a situation where she did not ⁓ basically have a good relationship with the people who had that wardship, she was really stuck. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alson: ⁓ Margaret Beaufort, who was the mother of Henry the Seventh of England, the man who founded the Tudor dynasty, she was actually she was from a very wealthy family, and shers was a very difficult story. She was married off and gave birth at the age of 13, which was I should say, I should say, very rare for this time period. The fact that her husband impregnated her at that age was like a matter of comment for people. He was not supposed to do that. ⁓ Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alson: But after she gave birth, she did not get to keep the baby. Like it was taken off to be like nursed out basically in another aristocratic household. She didn't see him for years. And this was fairly common. Mothers were not actually expected to raise their babies themselves. They were sent off to learn how to be whatever their class status was, what how to be a merchant, how to be a knight, how to be a lord in a different family. Andie James: Yeah. I just ⁓ I can't even imagine. I don't know. Yeah. Alson: I know it's and it's interesting. There was an article, I think, in The Atlantic recently arguing that ⁓ people in history did not experience emotions the same way we did. And it's very difficult to really parse that because obviously we don't have access to their emotional processes. We only have words, and often in a case like Isabel's, we wouldn't even have that because she's probably not writing things down. But we do have letters. from mothers like at the time who were like writing to their child's guardian, like, are they okay? Did you make sure to like feed them this? Did you make sure to teach them this? Make sure to tell them that I love them. They cared. They did care. They might not have had the same living setup that we would understand as a family, but they very much love their children. Andie James: Right. ⁓ for sure. Yeah. No, I think I mean it's just it's a different norm. And if you're in that and that seems regular to you, you might not love it, but you might not question in the same way. Alson: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. And that's the norms is something else I want to get into a bit later. Not with the mother end piece so much, but with the the sexuality and how they define themselves and how they experience marriage was another kind of you wanna get into it now? Let's get into it now. Yeah. Andie James: Mm. Well, let's why don't we talk about that right now? Because we haven't really even like touched on that, but obviously Constance and Isabel are two women who fall in love. So how did you decide that you wanted to write a sapphic story? What was some of the things that you wanted to hopefully portray through that? Alson: Yes. ⁓ I don't remember what moment it clicked for me that like, ⁓ Isabel's clearly a lesbian. I knew I knew it like halfway through writing Blacksmith's Bride. And I think part of that was that obviously I wrote her into an unhappy marriage in the first book. And sometimes marriages just suck, especially like marriage is made for financial advantage. It is what it is. But I also kind of wanted to explore what how a woman who is just like genuinely not attracted to men at all. Andie James: Yeah. Okay. Alson: And does not necessarily have access to the idea that this is a possibility, would navigate that. Because and I talk about this a bit in the book, there's a bit, ⁓ I don't want to spoil too much, but where she's talking about how she struggled to conceive for a long time and she thought that was her fault because she wasn't enjoying sex with her husband. And in the Middle Ages, it was believed that a woman had to orgasm in order to get pregnant. And so, in her mind, in the world as she is experiencing it, she is failing as a woman. Andie James: Right. Alson: Because she's not enjoying sex with her husband, because she's not conceiving a child, like this is her fault in the the world as she understands it. ⁓ Constance is a bit harder to get into without too, too many spoilers in terms of her family structure. but suffice it to say that Constance is someone who is both raised, I think, with a much stronger sense of self than Isabel is. Andie James: Right. Alson: Who is raised in a much more stable family structure and therefore has more room to explore. And also who is, and again, I'm trying trying to kind of talk around spoilers, but who is exposed to the idea of queerness at a young enough age that she's like, ⁓ this is just a thing. This is just how people are sometimes. This is how I am. And it's not a source of angst for her because she is not experiencing the same pressures, some external, some internal. Andie James: Ha ha ha Yeah. Mm-hmm. Mm. Alson: That Isabel is. And sort of one of the one of the really fun things that I got to write in this was like when these two meet, they are coming from such completely different directions. And they're both like, ⁓ I didn't realize anyone, I didn't know that people kind of experience the world this way. This is, I kind of assume that everyone saw and understood things the way I did. Because, and I do talk about this in the book, and I had a fun writing this scene. ⁓ in the Middle Ages, there Andie James: Right. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Alson: There is a common historical misconception that being gay or being a lesbian was punishable by death all through history. ⁓ that is not the case. Now you could be punished for what was called sodomy, and what sodomy covered was basically any sex that was not procreative. So like oral sex is sodomy, ⁓ mutual masturbation is sodomy. And Andie James: Yes. Mm. Alson: The other interesting thing is that lesbianism was not criminalized unless, big unless, unless you were doing something penetrative. So, like, fingering's okay because that doesn't count. ⁓ dildos, big no. Because you are usurping the man's position. That is when you become a threat to the social order. That's what that's so fascinating to me. And this goes honestly. Andie James: ⁓ yeah. can't do that. Yeah. Interesting. That makes perfect sense to me though, like mindset wise. Alson: And this is something, this is something that goes all the way back to ancient Rome, where their conception of sex and sexuality was you are the penetrator, in which case you are the person with social standing, you are the further up in the hierarchy, or you are the person being penetrated, and that makes you socially lesser or female. Like if you are feminine, if you are being penetrated, no matter what your actual class status is. Andie James: Mm. Alson: And that I think is kind of the skeleton key to understanding everything about the way sex and gender is conceptualized in the Western world. Like everything descends from that. Absolutely everything. Andie James: Yeah. Yep. That makes sense to me. Yeah. I don't know. Have you read Jenna Bigelow's books? Set Ancient Rome Alson: I have so because they're, I think they're Kindle exclusive, I've been trying to figure out how to get my grubby mitts on them because don't have Kindle. I've been putting ⁓ requests in at the library. Of course they also struggle with Kindle exclusives. So if and when I am able to get my hands on them, because I really want to read them, I'm really excited to see. Like, this is also a period that most people don't write in. So I'm really curious to see what she's doing with it. Andie James: Yeah. Yes. Yeah. Yeah, they're great. She was my guest three months ago-ish, I think. Yeah. So, ⁓ but yeah, interesting. I mean, she definitely looks at kind of the different attitudes where it's like it's accepted and not at the same time. And that seems kind of kind of like here where it's like they're not necessarily gonna be public about this. They're not gonna broadcast it, but they're also part of this, like you said, I don't want to spoil too much, but part of this maybe is just who Constance is. But even Isabel, like Alson: ⁓ nice. Yeah. Andie James: She doesn't have some moral crisis accepting this about herself. It's more just how will this happen in my life? Alson: No, no, it it's not like Yeah, it's not like I'm attracted to woman and that says something about me. Because the other interesting thing about the way sexuality was sort of thought of in this period is that it wasn't something you were, it was something you did. The idea of being gay or being a lesbian did not come about until the late 1800s with the work of sexologists like Magnus Hirschfeld or a bit earlier called Carl Heinrich Ulrich, who started to study it as a specific field and say, actually, we think this is inborn. This isn't just. Andie James: Right. Okay. Mm-hmm. Alson: Something anybody could wake up in the morning and decide to do. And that again explains a lot about the way our culture talks about sex and sexuality is kind of descended from that where it's like, well, it's a choice. Anybody would be doing this if they could. So the the important thing is to refrain from doing it, you have to be strong and resist the temptation. ⁓ and like you like you you see people saying that and you're like, mm, do you do you have some things about yourself that you're maybe struggling with? But but no, like. Andie James: Yeah. Alson: It's not in this period so much I am self I am a lesbian, I am a woman who loves women. It's this is something I feel like doing and that's not really anyone's business and it doesn't change who I am as a person. Andie James: Yeah, no. It was great. I loved reading it. 'Cause I was like I feel like, you know, more of the portrayals that we see currently ⁓ the genre because they are ⁓ in that like Regency Victorian, which we're starting to get. I mean, that shift like you were talking about is more like early Vic or like late Victorian. ⁓ Alson: Mm-hmm. Yes. Yeah. Andie James: But it's more of they're also written from people from our time period. But you know, it's more of kind of that inner struggle and sometimes shame and sometimes there's, you know. ⁓ and I appreciate books where that's not true because we don't want to be always portraying like we want to see the joy. We wanna see self-acceptance and yeah. Alson: Yes. Yeah. Yeah. There's a book that I go back to a lot. It's called ⁓ Strangers Homosexual Love in the Nineteenth Century. So again, obviously Victorian. ⁓ but it has a really great bit in the intro where it talks about how because relationships were not legally recognized for most of history, ⁓ we have in terms of records ⁓ ⁓ they got caught. So we have trial transcripts, we have people shaming them, we have Andie James: Yeah. Yes. Mm-hmm. Alson: Basically, we have a skewed idea of what gay life looked like prior to the twentieth century because most of what we have regarding them is when they were getting in trouble for it. We don't know about the people who were just quietly living their lives because they didn't write it down. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Alson: Yeah, Rhea Brodel, who's an artist, has a really great series of art books called Butch Heroes, which is about people throughout history who were assigned female at birth and went on to present male and have relationships with women. And she doesn't like assign a gender identity to them. Again, we can't know, but it's basically like these are people who for who transgressed the idea of the gender they were born with. Andie James: Right. Alson: And a lot of them like no one even noticed until they died and they were getting ready for the burial and people went, Whoa, wait a second. Whoa, my. ⁓ yeah. So it's I think a lot of the history here gets not erased on purpose, but erased simply because we don't have access to it because history is ultimately what gets written down. And a lot of it just didn't. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Well, I appreciated, and I hopefully this isn't too spoilery, but ⁓ that a lot of the of what was ⁓ keeping them apart wasn't the that they were two women in love, it was the circumstances ⁓ that Isabel found herself in and needing to protect her essentially as a mother. ⁓ Alson: Mm-hmm. Okay. Yeah. Andie James: And so I appreciated that, that it wasn't just kind of the we can't be together because society won't accept us and you know. Alson: Yeah. Yeah. It's like I think the first book in the series is So when we talk about society, sorry, I'm this might be a bit clumsily worded, I'm trying to figure out how to phrase this. When we talk about society in historical fiction, a lot of the time it involves like social condemnation, like social shunning, social disacceptance. And in the first book and in this book, the bigger issue I was focused on is ⁓ you said economic, which is true, but also just the the way society is structured in terms of who can do what. So it's not about so much what people will think is what we are able to do, what's what restrictions are put on us based on the social stations we were born into. ⁓ because and maybe it's just me as like a autistic person who just never gave a damn about social structures even as a kid. It gave my parents no end of headaches. But I just like Andie James: Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Right. Yeah. Alson: It it's not even like a conscious, ⁓ I don't write about people worried about society type thing. I just it's not something I can get my head around. And I'm more interested in the restrictions based on structures, on structural oppression. And and saying that makes it sound really grim. It's it's not grim. They have a good time. They have fun. And it's a romance, I'm not spoiling too much. There's a happily ever after. But I'm I guess Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. It's a romance. Alson: Yeah, I guess I'm I guess what I'm saying is I'm more interested in how people navigate the restrictions put on their lives. And I think a lot of the time the temptation I I'm also trying not to sound judgy because I I'm like judging the way anyone else writes their books, but I think a lot of the time the temptation when we deal with this is in fiction. Andie James: Yeah. Okay. Alson: is to be like, and then they overthrew the the feudal system or the hetero patriarchy and everything changed and everything was good. And like obviously it feels great to read that. I would love it if that happened. But I think there is there is also like something interesting and valuable in they didn't change the world. They didn't like overthrow anything. They didn't start a revolution, but they were able to find a way to make it work for them. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alson: Which is I think how it happened most often throughout history and kind of the way I want to write it is not they changed the world, but they made the world they made a world for themselves. I I dedicated the book to like to the I think the way I phrased it was to those left out of the history books, which sounds so corny, but it's it's Andie James: Course. No, it's true. Alson: It's that quote by Laurel Thatcher Ulrich, ⁓ well-behaved women seldom make history that often gets kind of misinterpreted as so be a badly behaved woman. What she actually meant by it in context was women who are quote unquote well-behaved, who don't rock the boat, who do what is expected of them, who do like the quiet work of keeping things running, are often left out of history books because they're not doing anything extraordinary. They're just doing the quiet work behind us. Yeah. Andie James: Right. There's no reason to note. Yeah. Alson: There's nothing especially notable about it. They're doing what every other woman was doing, but in that work, they are keeping the world turning. Andie James: Yeah. ⁓ amen. For sure. think it's interesting you mentioned that in the first book, you know, we meet Isabel's husband and you also mentioned, you know, she feels ⁓ a lot ⁓ of ⁓ Alson: She's Andie James: ⁓ yeah, I was gonna say shame. I don't know if if that's the right word, but I think that is the right word about, you know, how for a long time she couldn't get pregnant, she couldn't whatever, but I think she she judges herself harshly for some of the choices she has had to make in her life. and you know, you talk about how it was really this marriage for economic benefit with her husband. And, she really like she that because she had to take care of her brother. Alson: It's one of them, yeah. ⁓ yeah. Andie James: you know, protagonist of the first book. and she really judges herself pretty harshly for some of those choices. And it's like, no, you're again some of those restrictions that you're talking about, like you could only make so many decisions. And so her learning to come to peace with some of that, I think, is a really interesting arc kind of in this book. Alson: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, Isabel is really hard on herself and she can also be really hard on other people. And I think she is someone who has like very firm ideas about what should be. And she's like, well, I have to make that happen. And if I don't make that happen, it's because I did something wrong. ⁓ and something that I kind of found as I was writing is that when you compare Isabel's relationship with Matthew to Constance's relationship with her brother Jack. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Alson: Constance and Jack just like actually talk about stuff. Like it's not always easy. They still have conflict, they still butt heads, but they are able to be open with each other in a way that Isabel and Matthew have not been able to manage for most of their lives. And part of that is the age gap between them. Like Isabel's almost, I think, is it how much older is she? She was 15 when she got married and he was nine. So she's six years older. Andie James: Yeah. Alson: But also that she was thrust into a caregiving role at an early age when their parents died. And so she was not able, she did not have the luxury of time to just be his sister. She had to be his sister and his mother and his guardian. And so and she was like, Well, I am the one who has to hold all of this together or it's all gonna go to shit. ⁓ and so sh she is just someone who is constantly like, I am the one holding the line, and if I let go, everything falls apart. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Well I Alson: Yeah. She might also have a touch of autism. Like I don't I'm not gonna be like, read this book for neurodivergent rep, but I think that might be part of like the way her brain works. Andie James: You know, it's interesting. I didn't necessarily think of that as I was reading it, but say you saying that, like I can Alson: It it was something that I didn't think of until I was editing it. And then I was like, wait a second. But that's also just you always put some of yourself into your characters. And I was like, ⁓ that's where that came from when I gave her those traits. Andie James: Yeah. ⁓ it's a little bit. No. Well, I am truly very excited to go back and read the first book and kind of see how you know she she's portrayed in that book and and how she became formed in your brain to become who she is in this book. And I can see Alson: You Yeah. Yeah. She's interesting from Matthew's perspective because Matthew is kind of like simultaneously, I love my sister. She did so much for me. I want to take care of her. Also, she's a huge pain in the ass because she's always nagging me. ⁓ and she's weirdly controlling and like get off my back and let me live my life. It's very like they're as adults now, and Matthew's only 20 in the first book, so he is like just on the cusp of adulthood. Andie James: I'll just Alson: They're still kind of learning how to relate to each other as adults rather than as siblingslash guardian child. Andie James: Well, it's very real, I think, the way that it's portrayed. I mean, even if you haven't had to have the differing dynamics in that sibling relationship, like they have had to have, I mean, there's always good and bad when you're that close to someone, right? ⁓ and you've had kind of that experience growing up together with someone. But ⁓ Alson: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And in this book, the Tailor's treasure book, we also have Constance's relationship with her older sister, which is I think a lot more like Isabelle and Matthews dynamic where it's like, I love you, you've done so much for me. Can you please unclench little bit? Andie James: Yes. ⁓ But that can be hard when you're in that caretaking mentality, right? ⁓ it's interesting, ⁓ know, when we first just started chatting here, you said that this book took you so much longer to write, and it was so hard to kind of conceptualize it. ⁓ and it's interesting because I ⁓ Alson: It's like yeah. Mm-hmm. Andie James: I can see that from like a writerly perspective. It's really hard when you have these characters who they don't show a lot to the world. And so it's very, ⁓ they're very guarded. And so it's kinda like you as even though you're creating these people, it's like you have to figure out like ⁓ behind these layers, ⁓ do we ⁓ this and and ⁓ Alson: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Andie James: you know, what's made them this way and I yeah, I don't know. That made s it just made sense to me when you've said that. Alson: Yeah. Yeah. No, and the first book was a lot easier because Matthew was very much a character who wears his heart on his sleeve. And Elizabeth is a bit more guarded because she has also been through some of the same stuff Isabel has in terms of like having to look after her siblings and having to take on responsibilities from a young age about as far as like the household financials go. But she is also someone who is very practical in a sense of she's like, Okay, we have a problem, let's sit down and talk about it. Where Isabel is more that John Mullaney quote of like, I'll keep all my feelings right here and then one day I'll die. Andie James: Well, and one other piece of this too that we again just kind of touched on before but didn't really dive into is and this is always true of people that aren't kind of in the the upper classes, but these women are working. And that is something that obviously is accepted. It's necessary for them in terms of their economic circumstances. And, you know, even in the midst of our Regency and Victorian books that, are so Alson: Is really. Andie James: profligate, but I mean they that is still the reality of people that aren't in necessarily the the merchant or upper classes, right? That people had to work. They had to survive. And so I loved the depiction of, Constance trying to ⁓ wrangle navigate this thing that she it's not that she's inept, but it was primarily her husband's. Alson: Okay. Yeah. Yeah, and she's like, I'm I have to take over and I'm not good at this. Andie James: Yeah. And so she's trying to figure out how do I get business, how do I keep that business when I'm maybe not as skilled as he was. and but and I love too though that you know, Isabel's skill, her embroidery, that that provides kind of another ⁓ Alson: Yeah. Andie James: It's almost like when she gets that opportunity don't wanna like speak for her. I don't know if she's your character, but it's it seemed like you know, it was this thing that she wasn't seeking to do. She didn't necessarily feel like she was missing, but when she had the opportunity, it was like so much in her life was sad and not fulfilling. And maybe she could have this opportunity to like do something and like be good at something and and produce something meaningful. Alson: Yeah, go for it. Yeah. Yeah, it's like that moment where you're like she's spent her whole life struggling and kind of defining herself by her value to other people. And then she starts the embro like she does the embroidery for fun and then Constance is like, ⁓ that's gorgeous. And she's like, Wait, what what is this? Praise for something I did that's not something I did because I had to do s like I'm good at something. And like the thing is Andie James: Right. Yeah. Let's do Yeah. Yeah. It's a good feeling. Yeah. Alson: She's good at a lot of stuff. Like sh again, she managed her household. She takes care of her kids. She looked after her little brother. But it's a lot of stuff that people did not praise her for, either because they were in a position like her younger brother, who's not necessarily going to recognize that, or they were people like her in-laws who just thought of her as beneath them anyway. So they're just like never gonna say a kind word to her. And hearing, hey, you're really good at this. I really like what you're doing here. I think you're really talented is Andie James: Mm. Alson: kind of opening a door for her where it's like, ⁓ people can be nice to me. That's a thing that can happen. Andie James: Yeah, for sure. Well, you mentioned that this opened up kind of this other world for you and there's other characters. So can you tell us anything about maybe what's next? I mean, I know this one's just getting relation to the world, but Alson: I know. So I have tentative plans. I don't want to promise anything because honestly, my year has been so crazy, just like day job related, I've been like just inundated. ⁓ I have tentative plans for about five books in the series total. So ⁓ yeah, so in the first book we meet Roger, who is a friend of Matthew's. Andie James: I understand. I understand. Wow. Love it. So excited. Alson: And the funny thing was, like, there's a one-off line in that book where Matthew's like, ⁓ so my sister turned you down, huh? And Roger's like, yeah, she was mean. Because the thing about Roger is he's ⁓ he's kind of like our sex positive king. He he's a bit of slut. He's having a good time. so like it was just like a one off to look like enforce like this is his character. He just hits on every woman he meets. And he's if they turn him down, sure. And if they're ⁓ good for it, cool. Andie James: What? Alson: ⁓ but I had a lot of people say to me, ⁓ so Roger and Isabel is the next book. And I was like, What? Say what? I had no idea I'd written that. ⁓ so no, I have a plan for Roger's book. Roger's book is one that again, like I've kind of been struggling to plot just in terms of figuring out what the internal conflict is. ⁓ because Roger is someone who's quite happy with himself. Like he's fine. Andie James: Yeah. Alson: He's he doesn't have that sense that Isabel has of like I need to be, I need to prove myself or I need to do better, et cetera, et cetera. He's fine. So I'm like, okay, what's your ⁓ what is the the romancing the beat thing? to become wholehearted, they have a hole in their heart, they need to become wholehearted. I need to figure out where that I can't say that, we need to figure out where Rodger's hole is. And then ⁓ there so Marjorie, who we meet in this book, I have thoughts for her as well. Because one of the things I was kind of exploring with this book as well is like how different women navigated marriage in this era. Because we have a lot of like we've got Constance's marriage, which again I don't want to spoil too much, but there's stuff going on there. Andie James: Uh-huh. Okay. Yeah. Alson: We have Isabel's marriage, which was miserable. We have Leah, who we meet very briefly, who is getting married and thrilled about it. And then we have Marjorie, Constance's niece, who was just absolutely kicking and screaming against the concept. She's like, absolutely not. Get me the hell out of here. ⁓ have thoughts about what I'm gonna do with Marjorie.