Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Salary Adjustment When Your Role Has Expanded
Transcript
- Lucas: We got a question this week from a listener named Priya, and I think it's going to hit close to home for a lot of people. Priya is a marketing manager at a mid-sized software company. When she was hired two years ago, her role was squarely about content marketing and campaign management. But over time, she's picked up data analytics for the team, she's become the de facto project manager for a cross-functional launch, and she now supervises two junior staffers. Her title is still 'Marketing Manager' and her salary hasn't moved a dollar since she started. Luna: And that is the classic 'scope creep without pay bump' scenario. I think every professional I know has experienced some version of this. Lucas: Right. And Priya's question is straightforward: how do I ask for a salary adjustment that reflects what I'm actually doing now, without sounding like I'm complaining? And that's our focus today — not 'how to ask for a raise in general,' but specifically how to handle the situation where the job itself has changed under you. Luna: And honestly, if this conversation helps you think through a career move or decision, that's the kind of thing that makes Office Hours worth a coffee to support. There's a link at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo — listener support is what keeps this show ad-free. Lucas: Yeah, it's a small thing that makes a big difference. So let's get into Priya's case. The first thing I'd tell her — and anyone in this situation — is to resist the urge to frame the conversation around fairness or frustration. You don't want to walk in and say 'I'm doing way more than I was hired for, this is unfair.' Even if it's true, it puts your boss on the defensive. Luna: So what's the alternative framing? Lucas: You frame it around value and market data. Priya needs to document exactly how her role has expanded. Not just 'I do more stuff' but specific, measurable additions. For example, she's now running the quarterly analytics review that goes to the VP of Marketing. She's managing two direct reports — that's a people-management component that wasn't in her original job description. And she's leading that cross-functional launch, which is a project management responsibility that typically comes with a premium. Luna: So she needs to build a case, almost like a business case for her own salary. Lucas: Exactly. And the key is to anchor her ask to external benchmarks, not internal feelings. She can look at salary surveys for marketing managers with people-management responsibilities, or for marketing analytics roles. The Bureau of Labor Statistics has occupational data. Sites like Glassdoor and LinkedIn Salary are imperfect but useful for ranges. She wants to find three to five comparable roles at similar companies and see what they pay. Luna: And what number should she target? The market median, or something above? Lucas: I'd say target the 50th to 60th percentile for the expanded role. If she's now effectively a marketing manager plus analytics lead plus team lead, look at the market rate for that combination. She might find that the market pays, say, eighty-five thousand for her original role, but a hundred and five for the hybrid role she's actually doing. That twenty-thousand-dollar gap is her anchor. Luna: And she should prepare for the meeting by writing a one-page summary of the role evolution, with bullet points and those benchmark numbers. Lucas: Yes. And she should request a specific meeting — not a 'hey can I talk to you for a minute?' type thing. Send a calendar invite with a subject line like 'Discussion about role scope and compensation alignment.' That signals that it's a professional conversation, not a complaint session. Luna: What's the actual script for the first two minutes of that meeting? Lucas: I'd open with something like: 'Over the past eighteen months, my responsibilities have expanded in a few key areas that weren't part of my original role. I've documented those changes, and I've also looked at market data for roles that encompass this broader scope. I'd like to discuss how we can align my compensation with the role I'm currently performing.' That's direct, professional, and data-driven. Luna: And if the manager says 'we don't have budget right now' — that's the most common pushback. How does she handle that? Lucas: First, she shouldn't accept that as a final answer. She can say, 'I understand budget cycles are tight. Can we identify a specific date or milestone — say, the start of Q3 or after the upcoming product launch — when we could revisit this? And would you be open to a mid-year adjustment if I can demonstrate continued impact?' That commits them to a timeline. Luna: And she should ask for a specific number, not a 'fair increase.' Lucas: Right. 'I'm requesting an adjustment to one hundred and five thousand, which is the market midpoint for this combination of responsibilities.' That gives them something concrete to take to HR. If they come back with ninety-five, she can negotiate. But if she just says 'I want a raise,' they'll offer three percent and call it a day. Luna: One thing I'd add: timing matters. If Priya's company just went through layoffs or a bad quarter, her ask will be a harder sell. But if they just landed a big client or she just finished a high-profile project, that's leverage. Lucas: Great point. And she should also consider whether her manager has the authority to approve a salary adjustment, or if it needs to go through HR. If it's HR, she might need to provide even more documentation — a formal job description revision, for example. Luna: And what if the manager says 'we can't change your salary but we can give you a bonus or a title change'? Lucas: A title change without a salary change is a trap. It locks her into a higher title but still at the old pay, which hurts her future earning potential because other employers will ask about her current pay. A one-time bonus is better than nothing, but she should still push for the base adjustment. Base salary compounds over time — bonuses don't. Luna: So the strategy is: come prepared with data, lead with the role evolution, ask for a specific number, and don't accept a 'no' without a timeline. Lucas: Exactly. And one last thing: if after all that, the company still says no, Priya has a clear signal that her growth is not valued there. That's useful information for her career planning. She can start looking externally with a clear understanding of what her market value is. Luna: And that's the silver lining. Even a 'no' can be a step forward if you use it to make a better decision about your next move. Lucas: Yeah. Priya's situation is tough, but it's also common. And the fact that she's thinking strategically about how to have this conversation puts her ahead of most people. Luna: If you have a career question you'd like us to tackle, you can send it to us — details are in the show notes. Lucas: And if today's episode helped you think through a similar situation, consider supporting the show at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It keeps us independent and ad-free. Luna: Thanks for being here. We'll see you next time.