Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E070: Bitcoin is the Real Hurdle Rate with Richard Byworth
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop, and
- 0:04we're going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous
- 0:07excrement ever assembled in the history of that business,
- 0:131974198792972000 and whatever we're going to call this, it's
- 0:19all just the same thing over and over.
- 0:21We can't help ourselves. I say when we sell.
- 0:26Hey, OK. I say when we sell.
- 0:33Everyone, welcome back to the last trade.
- 0:34This week we have Richard Byworth and I'm joined by my Co
- 0:38host Michael Tanguma and we have Brian Cabela's this week
- 0:41standing in for Jesse. So Richard, how are you doing?
- 0:44Great to see you. Yeah, very good.
- 0:47Thanks, Jackson. Great to be here with you guys.
- 0:50Appreciate it. So, Richard, really excited for
- 0:53this one. I know sees Capital, you guys
- 0:55are doing a lot in the alternative space primarily
- 0:58focused on alternative investments.
- 1:00And I know you would categorize yourself as a Bitcoiner.
- 1:03So really excited to hear more about your traditional finance
- 1:07background and then talk a lot more about your journey into
- 1:10Bitcoin, how you think about it as an allocator, among many
- 1:14other things, getting a pulse on Switzerland in the European
- 1:17market. So maybe the best place to
- 1:19start, Richard, would just be to get a better sense of your
- 1:21background in traditional finance.
- 1:24I know you've worked in many different capacities for maybe
- 1:28two decades or so, plus or minus.
- 1:30So we'd love to just hear more about your path and ultimately
- 1:33what led you here today. Sure.
- 1:37Well, look, thanks and always, always good to connect with
- 1:41fellow Bitcoiners. And so, yeah, looking forward to
- 1:45this chat. So look, to give you a quick
- 1:47understanding of where I came from, I was an investment banker
- 1:51for pretty much the first, I think 18 years of my career.
- 1:57I worked in London as a trader. I was trading convertible bonds
- 2:02predominately for Japanese underlyings.
- 2:06So you think about MicroStrategy and what they've been using for
- 2:10their capital structuring, they're generally using
- 2:14convertible bonds. That's the most efficient
- 2:16product. That's what I was trading from
- 2:192000 basically through to 2005 six.
- 2:24I moved to Tokyo at the beginning of 2005, so I was
- 2:28working for Nomura, the Japanese investment bank.
- 2:31I moved to Tokyo at the beginning of O5, did five years
- 2:36there. Tail end of that was obviously
- 2:39Lehman. You'll end up, don't know if
- 2:42you're aware, but Lehman Brothers got bought by two banks
- 2:47essentially. So Barclays bought the US
- 2:50operations and Nomura bought the European and Asian operations.
- 2:55So we ended up merging the most cowboy bank on Wall Street with
- 3:00the most aggressive bank in Japan.
- 3:02And you can imagine the cultural shocks were were fairly violent.
- 3:08So it was it was fun. And I definitely think I could
- 3:11probably write a book about that, that whole experience.
- 3:16But then, you know, interest rates went to zero.
- 3:20I think everyone in banking started to realize that we were
- 3:23going to have a major problem with, you know, inflation at
- 3:26some point. And so I, I bought gold in 2012
- 3:31after dismissing Bitcoin from the junior kid on my desk.
- 3:35He was talking about it in 2009 in Tokyo.
- 3:39So I was like, can you just stop talking about scams on the
- 3:42Internet and sell derivatives to your clients, please?
- 3:46And so, yeah, we, I started buying gold in 2012 just as a
- 3:53hedge, just as a way to just protect against what was for me
- 3:58at that point, an inevitability of the failure of, of, of Fiat
- 4:02currencies. And then in 2017, I, I was
- 4:07getting to the point where I wanted to leave banking for
- 4:09good. I was completely done with it
- 4:11mentally. And I was reading this book
- 4:14called Sapiens by Yuval Harari. And I agreed with a lot of what
- 4:20he was talking about with the future and models for society
- 4:23and humanity, etcetera. But he kept bringing out this
- 4:27Bitcoin thing, which I remembered as a scam from my kid
- 4:31on the desk in 2009. And I was like, why is he
- 4:33talking about this? Like, so I figured I'd probably
- 4:37better find out what it was and started reading about it middle
- 4:41of sort of 2017, which you'll remember was, was a fairly
- 4:45frothy period. So I was like, OK, I'm just
- 4:48going to buy some of this thing. So I turned to my grand on the
- 4:50desk at the time and just being completely tech non savvy and I
- 4:55was like, Herman, can you just, can you just buy everyone on the
- 4:58desk a Bitcoin? It was trading at $1000 at the
- 5:01time. And I then went away for summer
- 5:06and I took a bit of a sabbatical and I came back and Bitcoin had
- 5:08tripled. I was like, Herman, did you buy
- 5:11everyone that Bitcoin? And he's like, I thought you
- 5:12were joking. I was like, screw this.
- 5:16I was like, OK, fine, I need to do this myself.
- 5:19I need to work it out. So at that point I started
- 5:21working out, made the usual error that a lot of people made.
- 5:25I was like, Oh well this Litecoin thing is really cheap.
- 5:28I could buy like 20 of these. So I bought some Litecoin.
- 5:31It went up 5X in the period of five weeks.
- 5:34And I was like, OK, what the hell is going on here?
- 5:37So then I started investing in the space and I invested a
- 5:40mining company, which coincided with me leaving the bank.
- 5:44I was going to join a private equity company, and the mining
- 5:49company founder that I'd invested in said, hey, if you've
- 5:53left the bank, would you come and help me build this business?
- 5:58I was like, how am I going to build a mining business?
- 6:00I'm a finance guy. Like, he's like, no, no, no.
- 6:02He's like, people are running around.
- 6:04I was in Hong Kong at the time. People are running around Hong
- 6:06Kong with suitcases full of cash.
- 6:09They've got no idea what regulation means in this space.
- 6:12If we build a regulated player, you know, we could be very
- 6:15differentiated and attract what will eventually be institutional
- 6:19flow. I was like, OK, that's a good
- 6:20story. So we, we started building this
- 6:23firm, it was called Digenex. The firm expanded very rapidly
- 6:29and we ended up listing the company on NASDAQ through a SPAC
- 6:34in 2020, at which point flows were getting difficult and we
- 6:40were competing with FTX and Binance, who could onboard
- 6:42people in 3 minutes. We'd take three weeks to onboard
- 6:46people. So it was, it was a very painful
- 6:49experience. So we were struggling a bit.
- 6:51And so we were looking for an acquirer and then my chairman
- 6:55found Binance as the acquirer and I was like, I'm not getting
- 6:58in bed with those guys. So I stepped down and I was
- 7:03sitting on the beach in 2022 when Mark sees the son of the
- 7:10family, sees capital. Obviously the namesake called me
- 7:15and said, would you come and run my hedge fund business?
- 7:18And I was like, well, yeah, but I'd want to keep my hand in with
- 7:22crypto. I think there's some very
- 7:23interesting alpha in in hedge funds using crypto as the
- 7:29arbitrage mechanism. And yeah, that then progressed
- 7:33to where we are today. We're obviously very involved in
- 7:38the Bitcoin space here in Switzerland.
- 7:40I I got involved with Relay. I don't know if you know those
- 7:44guys, the dollar cost averaging platform here in Switzerland,
- 7:48which is probably the biggest in Europe.
- 7:51And in fact, maybe given the swan situation, it's probably
- 7:54the biggest in the world now. But yeah, fantastic guys.
- 7:58So I sit on the board of that company very close to them.
- 8:02And so, yeah, that's my sort of Bitcoin focus.
- 8:07That's that's an awesome story. Yeah, it's an incredible.
- 8:10Story You went from the cowboy from one set of Cowboys to the
- 8:13the another set of Cowboys in the Wild West.
- 8:16You've been from from. 18 to 23 you've definitely seen some it's
- 8:20also. Interesting to me that you, you
- 8:23sort of stepped into the mining space initially because at least
- 8:27for me, when I was, so I started sort of understanding Bitcoin
- 8:30roughly the same time for him, late 17, early 18.
- 8:34And it wasn't until I started really digging into the mining
- 8:38side of things that I started to understand why Bitcoin was
- 8:40fundamentally different than everything else through proof of
- 8:43work and all these other mechanisms.
- 8:45And so it's very curious that you, you were sort of still in
- 8:48the your altcoin phase, but then you you latched on to mining as
- 8:51something that felt maybe like real and tangible perhaps.
- 8:56Yeah, it's a very interesting comment.
- 8:58And actually we were GPU mining. So we weren't ASIC mining.
- 9:02So we were GPU mining. And if you remember, Ethereum
- 9:05was still proof of work back then.
- 9:07So we were actually mining Ethereum.
- 9:08It was, it was the most profitable to be mining.
- 9:13But but to your point, I didn't, I didn't understand Bitcoin when
- 9:16I started at the company. I ended up becoming the CEO of a
- 9:18crypto company at about the same time that I became a Bitcoin
- 9:22maxi. So I'm sitting there just
- 9:24completely misaligned value prospect in terms of what we
- 9:29were building. And I remember the exchange guys
- 9:31going, hey, Rich, you know, we want you to join the listing
- 9:34committee because we want to add XRP to the exchange.
- 9:39I was like, no, never shit coin. And by the way, we have to
- 9:42delist everything else and we should be predominantly focused
- 9:46on Bitcoin and just doing Bitcoin derivatives.
- 9:48And so yeah, it it became a bit of a problem with the with
- 9:52running the company. At Onramp, we believe that
- 9:55Bitcoin is the most important asset of the 21st century.
- 9:59The hard part is securing it right.
- 10:02There are shortcomings with keeping your coins on an
- 10:04exchange, but also with setting up your own self custody
- 10:07arrangement. On Ramp solves for these
- 10:09concerns. Our multi institution custody
- 10:12solution maximizes security and minimizes counterparty risk,
- 10:16ensuring that your Bitcoin remains securely in your
- 10:18possession and provides built in inheritance planning to ensure
- 10:22your family is protected as well.
- 10:24On Ramp provides Peace of Mind for your Bitcoin journey,
- 10:27whether for your whole stack or for part of it as a compliment
- 10:30to your existing self custody set up.
- 10:33For more information, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 10:37What was it ultimately rich that led you to the more Bitcoin
- 10:42purest or maximalist position? I don't know if you touched on
- 10:46that in the story, but to Brian's point, it's like you,
- 10:49you had your 5X on Litecoin, you had I believe it was perman on
- 10:53the desk, didn't buy you the Bitcoin and then you
- 10:56transitioned into the mining space.
- 10:57You're doing some mining dimension of Etherium and some
- 11:00other coins. Where in that story did you
- 11:03really go down the rabbit hole and Bitcoin and start to
- 11:06fundamentally understand the difference there?
- 11:10You're going to laugh, but for a long time I didn't know that
- 11:14Bitcoin was limited to 21 million.
- 11:17And when I understood that, I was like, OK, normal question
- 11:22was, well, how can we be sure that it's not going to be more
- 11:26than 21 million? How, how can we be sure that
- 11:28that won't get increased? And as I mentioned in 2012, I'd
- 11:34become mentally, I'd become a hard money guy.
- 11:37I'd started buying gold. I was just like, this is the
- 11:40only way we can escape this Fiat disaster that is impending for
- 11:45sure. And yeah, when I understood that
- 11:49Bitcoin was 21 million, I think I started listening to a lot of
- 11:52Bitcoin focused podcasts. And I listened to the Pomp
- 11:57podcast with Murad where he was talking about Bitcoin.
- 12:03And it was October 2018. And I remember I listened to it
- 12:08just before going to bed and I woke up that morning and I was
- 12:10like, I need to buy Bitcoin. I need to buy a lot of Bitcoin.
- 12:15And so I went out and bought it at 6000 and then it immediately
- 12:19halved to 3000. And when then I, I was like, OK,
- 12:24no, this is an opportunity. And just kept going.
- 12:27So it was good. But yeah, that that was my
- 12:30moment, yeah. I've never heard anybody else
- 12:32recently bring it up for years because that's an old school pod
- 12:35that single handedly might be the best podcast that's ever
- 12:37been done about Bitcoin in 60 to 75 minutes.
- 12:40Yeah, it's. Absolutely.
- 12:41Very strong. And it's very prescient, like
- 12:44everything has like literally happened to AT that was
- 12:46described in that podcast from like the market structure
- 12:50forming to the adoption cycles. And the unit bias is a funny
- 12:53thing that you reference because I think that's most people in
- 12:5617. You get in and then you just buy
- 12:58all this other crap. And similar to you, you look at
- 13:01it, you're like, well, this all can't be valuable.
- 13:02Like what? What's actually happening here?
- 13:04And you quickly find out, OK, there's some value here, but
- 13:06it's not everything. Exactly.
- 13:09I think the unit bias was another thing that progressed me
- 13:12further down the road. It's like when you get to the
- 13:15point of thinking of everything in Bitcoin, like, you know, when
- 13:20you're in banking, you're kind of a slave to this ridiculous
- 13:24salary that you've got. You can never leave.
- 13:26You're locked up in stock, right?
- 13:29As a managing director in a bank, you've got a shit ton of
- 13:31stock. You if you leave, you lose the
- 13:33stock, right? You have to get fired to be able
- 13:38to hold onto your stock, which is a fairly ridiculous incentive
- 13:41structure. But but that, that's how it is.
- 13:45And so you're, you're kind of a slave to this system.
- 13:49And when you, you know, I mean, I remember when I was back in
- 13:532015, I would have a spreadsheet with my U.S. dollar value of
- 13:59everything. And you sort of, you got your
- 14:01investments and you're working out.
- 14:02You'd open your spreadsheet every day.
- 14:04Like how am I doing today? But when that denomination moves
- 14:08from dollars to Bitcoin, everything changes.
- 14:11Everything just gets much more simple.
- 14:14And you know, we, we do an annual summit here for investors
- 14:19in, in Zurich. And I had Jeff Booth at the
- 14:23summit this year and I was sat with Jeff at a table while we we
- 14:30had a panel on asset allocation. So, but you know, but you had
- 14:35this group of experts, Titans of the traditional financial
- 14:40industry going, you know, I think this year, you know,
- 14:43private equity, we probably want to see another 5% allocation
- 14:46probably, you know, be dropping private credit a little bit
- 14:49because that's become a little bit overheated.
- 14:51And we sat there and were like, you know, it's just so easy, so
- 14:54simple just to be a Bitcoiner. You know, it just makes life so
- 14:58much easier. You're not messing around with
- 15:00just most of this nonsense. And it is nonsense, right,
- 15:04because it's all dollar denominated at the end of the
- 15:06day. So, you know, you're just, like,
- 15:08scrambling up the hill trying to beat that debasement rate.
- 15:12Yeah. Richard, it's a great point.
- 15:14I have a question on that just because you were brought in I
- 15:17think you said in 2022 to lead the hedge fund business at SEAS.
- 15:21So are you still doing that type of work at the company?
- 15:24And then how do you, how do you balance your investment
- 15:28philosophy or savings philosophy personally, focus predominantly
- 15:32on Bitcoin with having to also be able to speak the language
- 15:37and be knowledgeable about all these alternative investment
- 15:39strategies like how do you manage that personally?
- 15:43Well, look, I mean, I, I traded against hedge funds and sold to
- 15:46hedge funds for my entire financial career.
- 15:49So I know the product very, very well.
- 15:52So I can speak about it. And like, you know, being a
- 15:55bitcoiner as you all are, I'm sure you've had the same
- 15:58experience. There are some people that are
- 16:00just not ready to go on the journey, right?
- 16:03And so, you know, when you're talking to a guy, he's a
- 16:06billionaire and he's looking to allocate capital and he's
- 16:09looking to put 10% of his money into hedge funds.
- 16:12You know, you can say, look, maybe you could think about some
- 16:16of the alpha prospects that are available in this different
- 16:19asset class and start to move him down the track towards that.
- 16:24But you know, I mean, I had a meeting this morning with a guy
- 16:27who's who's starting off with 20 million allocated to hedge funds
- 16:32and he was like, don't ever talk to me about crypto.
- 16:34I don't want to hear it. Super smart guy, double PhD
- 16:37like, but it's just not going to happen.
- 16:40So, you know, you have to understand that some people are
- 16:43ready and some people are not. And you know, I think this is
- 16:48this is what I'm trying to do here.
- 16:50You know, when I do the summit, the investor summit, every year
- 16:52I have a, a Bitcoin. I come and speak at the summit.
- 16:56This year, obviously we had Jeff Booth last year we had Dan
- 16:59Tapiero and Scaramucci, which was fun and then we had Willy
- 17:04Woo the year before that. So just gentle education of
- 17:09these more traditional mindset investors because you you can't
- 17:13just, you know, throw everything at them all at once.
- 17:17I mean, it's a, it's a big journey.
- 17:19I mean, we've all been on a you, you guys mentioned 2018.
- 17:23I'm sort of a 2018 vintage bitcoiner as well.
- 17:26It's it's taken a long time to get to this point, right?
- 17:29So yeah, you can't expect these guys to get there all at once.
- 17:33It's incredibly exciting to have someone like yourself with your
- 17:36background involved because it's, it's like a cheat code
- 17:39when you have professional experience in a different domain
- 17:41and you come in because you can understand the the frame of
- 17:44reference so you don't hit them over the head with the hammer.
- 17:47Because historically in bitcoins first call it 10 to 15 years.
- 17:50It's the have fun staying poor. It's just pushing people
- 17:53actually away from the asset, even though we just historically
- 17:56didn't recognize it as such. And we see this in the West
- 18:01specifically. Or like with the registered
- 18:02investment advisor groups, you can have the resident bitcoiner,
- 18:05the resident, you know, even rationalist that understands
- 18:08this stuff and it's all in. But then it's very hard for them
- 18:12to put their investment advisors or gives any kind of
- 18:17acknowledgement of like, Hey, maybe you want 123 percent
- 18:19because of this historical stigma that comes with crypto or
- 18:23Bitcoin. And so it's a very, you have to
- 18:25be very convicted to be able to like even start to have that
- 18:28conversation, which requires tact and and discretion that I
- 18:33think is required from somebody that understands that cohort.
- 18:37You can't come from outside and you're like, you need Bitcoin
- 18:39because you don't know what their pain points are and what
- 18:41they're like incentive models are.
- 18:43So it's a really exciting next, I think decade we're going to
- 18:45see because this 18 to 23 vintage is really brought in
- 18:48professionals that I don't think historically we're in the space.
- 18:52Yeah. And Michael, to that point, I'd
- 18:54say it spot on. Yeah, I was going to say, oh,
- 18:57good, Rich, to Michael's point as well, it's, it's interesting
- 19:02because there's a you have to be able to effectively communicate
- 19:07to people and speak their language, right.
- 19:08So one of the challenges as it relates to Bitcoin in an asset
- 19:13allocation framework is that Bitcoin, you can make the case
- 19:17of Bitcoin as its own asset class.
- 19:19But if you go back to folks who are allocated to public equities
- 19:24and private equity, you know, real assets, venture, whatever
- 19:28it may be, you, you get stuck in this conversation where you're
- 19:31trying to fit this new asset class of Bitcoin into an
- 19:35existing bucket. And we've done some work around
- 19:38that, right? And trying to figure out and it
- 19:40it'll depend on the investor in their framework and how they're
- 19:43approaching it. They may say Bitcoin is more
- 19:45akin to a real asset because they see value or properties
- 19:49that exist within gold, right, in terms of scarcity.
- 19:53But you can also make the case that Bitcoin has like more of a
- 19:56venture feeling, not in the same way that we'd say that, you
- 20:00know, cryptocurrency is venture capital, but in the sense that
- 20:04Bitcoin as a protocol is following.
- 20:08An exponential adoption rate, which we do see with other tech
- 20:12plays, right? So I'm curious, Rich, like when
- 20:14you, you mentioned earlier communicating the alpha
- 20:17prospects of Bitcoin to some of these traditional allocators.
- 20:22Do you typically try to fit Bitcoin into one of these
- 20:25buckets to speak their language? Or do you really just make the
- 20:28case that Bitcoin is a stand alone asset class and does that
- 20:31resonate with the folks that you're speaking with?
- 20:36Yeah, it's a really good question.
- 20:37It's something that I've sort of changed tack on a little bit
- 20:41recently. And I think the the problem is
- 20:44all of us are capable of sitting down at a dinner and convincing
- 20:48someone they need to buy Bitcoin.
- 20:50You know, you can talk about price, you can talk about
- 20:52exponential exponentiality, you can talk about adoption of the
- 20:56Internet, you can talk about digital gold, all of these
- 20:59things. But the problem is that it
- 21:01always comes down to the same problem.
- 21:03And I had this exact example with a friend of mine recently.
- 21:06We sat down to dinner. He'd just sold his business and
- 21:09he'd, you know, he made several million.
- 21:12And he was like, hey, Rich, you know, we hadn't seen him for a
- 21:14few. I hadn't seen him for a few
- 21:15years. And he's like, hey, Rich, should
- 21:18I put all my money in Bitcoin? You know, is a, is a joke, is a
- 21:22good fool joke. I'm like, OK, yeah.
- 21:24But by the end of the dinner, by the way, you're going to say,
- 21:26yeah, I want to put all my money in Bitcoin.
- 21:28And he did. And at the end of the dinner, he
- 21:30was like, OK, so yeah, no, I need to like, what should I do?
- 21:34I was like, look, first of all, you can't put all your money in
- 21:37Bitcoin because if you do, when it goes down 50%, your wife is
- 21:43going to call me and she's going to go rich.
- 21:45You're an asshole, right? And what it needs for you is to
- 21:51go on this journey. You need to understand why I'm
- 21:55so convicted, so convicted that you are now completely
- 21:58convicted, even though when you go and buy it and see it drop
- 22:0250%, you go, what the fuck was I doing listening to rich?
- 22:04Sorry, excuse my language, but yeah, I mean, this is this is
- 22:09the problem. If you get people excited about
- 22:13the potential for price appreciation, because we do all
- 22:16know where it's going and we can all be very convincing about
- 22:19that, then they're going to buy it and they're going to sell it
- 22:22at the wrong time. So what I try to do now and this
- 22:27this also works well with that very I know everything kind of
- 22:32person, which are much harder to orange pill.
- 22:36You know, these are the guys, you can't tell them anything.
- 22:38They know everything about everything, right?
- 22:40Of course, Bitcoin is just some idiot project that you're
- 22:43involved with. So with them, this also works
- 22:47well. So the way that I present it is,
- 22:49look, you spend your whole life working for, you know, that
- 22:54moment where you're able to walk away and go, I'm free, I've made
- 22:58enough money and, and I can retire and I can go and live on
- 23:01the island or do whatever it is that I want to do.
- 23:05So you have a vote right here, right now, you have a single
- 23:09vote and you can make that decision, right?
- 23:11You can vote to store the time and energy of your labour in a
- 23:16system that can constantly be debased without your control by
- 23:22the control of a bunch of old guys sitting in a room deciding,
- 23:27you know, what they're going to do with monetary policy.
- 23:29And debasement rate is normally around somewhere between 10 and
- 23:3315% in recent years. Or you can put your time and and
- 23:38energy into a system where that cannot be debased, that is
- 23:42purely algorithmic, is controlled by no one, and is
- 23:47100% finite. And you know what everybody says
- 23:51when you say this to them? Yeah, of course.
- 23:53But and you're like, of course, but what?
- 23:55Like that is the vote that you have right here right now.
- 23:59But the challenge is understanding what I've told you
- 24:02about that second system. It's understanding that
- 24:05everything I've just told you is true about that second system.
- 24:08Because the answer is of course, if you just understand that what
- 24:13I've told you is correct, then the answer is of course.
- 24:17And that's been very effective with people lately.
- 24:22Yeah, I, I really like that, that framing, I guess 11 thought
- 24:27on that and I'm sure you've experienced this as well.
- 24:30I started my career in traditional finance space.
- 24:32And and like you were saying, like there's a lot of those
- 24:34people who are very, very smart, intelligent folks in their own
- 24:39right. But I think that leads them down
- 24:43this path of hubris to the extent where even if you make
- 24:48that argument that you just laid out, they won't believe that
- 24:51second system because in their minds, well, one, they just
- 24:55haven't done enough research as you.
- 24:57So it seems too good to be true, right?
- 24:58Like on paper, if the second system existed, to your point,
- 25:02obviously you would store your time and energy in that system.
- 25:05But there's that hurdle of really, I think it's just like
- 25:08ego and hubris for a lot of these folks.
- 25:11And, and at this point of the, the, the sort of trajectory of
- 25:15this thing, we're 15 years in. Those folks have seen multiple
- 25:20cycles, right? Like they hurt.
- 25:21They must have heard about Bitcoin within the past five to
- 25:2410 years at least once or twice, right?
- 25:26So they've seen these cycles play out and now they have an
- 25:30inherent bias because they didn't act on it prior, right?
- 25:33They, they didn't do the more they didn't do incremental
- 25:35research last cycle or the cycle before.
- 25:38So now when someone tells them like, hey, maybe you should
- 25:40consider this, it does take a massive amount of, you know,
- 25:46killing their own ego to some extent and admitting maybe they
- 25:49were wrong in the past. And I think that's particularly
- 25:52hard for a lot of folks in the traditional finance space
- 25:55because they have made, you know, very successful careers in
- 25:57their own right and, and done amazing things.
- 25:59So it's it's particularly hard for those folks.
- 26:02And then the other, the other piece, which you mentioned
- 26:04earlier, which I like, and I think, you know, maybe as
- 26:08Bitcoiners, we just need to do a better job of, of doing like
- 26:11public service announcements that there are only 21 million.
- 26:14Because that's, that's something I hear a lot too, is if, if you
- 26:17haven't done any work and you've only heard of Bitcoin, there's a
- 26:20good chance you actually don't know that there's only 21
- 26:23million. And then the other component is
- 26:25also the unit bias. It's like those two things.
- 26:26If we could just try to eliminate those, that would get
- 26:29past a lot of hurdles for folks. Yeah, the unit bias is a
- 26:33problem, people. We'll always say, well, I was, I
- 26:37was in a very senior guy runs a asset management company,
- 26:43billions and billions of dollars.
- 26:46And he was like, so how much is 1 Bitcoin?
- 26:48And we got to the point in the conversation, he was like, OK,
- 26:50I'm thinking about buying, you know, one for each of my kids.
- 26:54How much is 1 Bitcoin? And my, at the time it was
- 26:56$70,000 and he's like $70,000. He's like, I'm way too late,
- 27:01I've missed it, right? And and that's the problem,
- 27:04yeah, it's the unit price. And so that's what's
- 27:07fascinating. I think we're at an inflection
- 27:09point because Jackson brought it up and this comes across, I
- 27:12think anyone that's having conversations with a traditional
- 27:15financial crowd or traditional finance crowd of where does it
- 27:18sit, what bucket, How do I think about it?
- 27:20And I think a component of all of this is in any cell is you're
- 27:24competing with the status quo. So what are people used to doing
- 27:27and how do you get them to move? And if you're looking at
- 27:30Bitcoin, you're like, maybe there's some room to go or run,
- 27:33but it's like at best 123 percent, it's it's magic
- 27:36Internet money S why do I care? Like I'm willing to miss out.
- 27:40But yesterday with what BlackRock and Larry Fink came
- 27:42out with that it's like, I don't know the exact quote, but it's
- 27:45referencing mortgage, the mortgage market and anywhere
- 27:48between 10 to 50 trillion, whatever the the like cap, he's
- 27:51saying it's his standalone asset.
- 27:53That's something we've started a coalesce around here at on ramp
- 27:56when we talk with whether it's pensions or just in any
- 28:00institutional allocator and referencing.
- 28:02Let's segment Bitcoin from crypto and then let's segment
- 28:06that. This is its own bucket, as you
- 28:07would think about in a traditional like 6040.
- 28:10This is its own asset class by itself.
- 28:12Because once you start looking at like that, it's like, well,
- 28:14how much room can it move? And so once that narrative
- 28:17starts to grow, coupled with I'm convinced that the six figure
- 28:20mark, that 100K is really what gets like friends like yours
- 28:24that looked at it at 70 K. And it's like, oh, it's too
- 28:27gone, too far gone. Because at 100K you're like,
- 28:29wait, where, where does this train stop?
- 28:31Is it does it stop at 10, like a million, 10 million?
- 28:34But right now the psychological barrier IS70K maybe goes to 0.
- 28:37But at 100K, it's like, what would cause this to go back to
- 28:39zero? And then now you start looking
- 28:41at on the in the other direction.
- 28:45Yeah, I definitely agree. I think, I think the problem for
- 28:48a lot of people is that unit bias.
- 28:50I think that I wasn't exactly sure what Larry said.
- 28:53Did he basically say that it is going to take a chunk of the
- 28:57mortgage market? I think he said Bitcoin could
- 29:00grow to be as large as the US housing market, if I'm not
- 29:03mistaken, which was about a $50 trillion number.
- 29:05Yeah, I'll find, I'll find it. And you know, he said this after
- 29:08because his bags are packed and that's why we're sitting like at
- 29:1060 seven, $68,000 because he's like, all right, it's it's it's
- 29:13go time. I'll find the tweet and I'll
- 29:15pull. I'll pull it up.
- 29:16Yeah, no, I, I saw the headline pop up.
- 29:19I just don't recall. I, I didn't read it, but yeah,
- 29:26yeah, BlackRock coming into the scene has been significant for a
- 29:29lot of our investors. You know, this, I remember, you
- 29:33know, going and meeting with investors and, you know, you get
- 29:35introduced as the Bitcoin guy and they're like, Oh yeah, Jamie
- 29:39Dimon says it's a scam or Christine Lagarde says it's a
- 29:42scam. And now when they see one of
- 29:47these folks, IE Larry Fink saying no, no, this, this is
- 29:51legit. This is an asset you need in
- 29:53your portfolio. This is now changing
- 29:56conversations quite significantly.
- 29:59So Larry's arrival is is very, very helpful for the
- 30:05institutional Orange building. Absolutely.
- 30:09Yeah, No, that's that's a great point because this time last
- 30:14year it was still uncertain that if the USETFS would be approved.
- 30:21I think we were kind of nearing certainty just based on how that
- 30:24court decision went, I believe in August.
- 30:27But it certainly has helped from our conversations with the
- 30:31traditional allocators, thinking family offices, registered
- 30:35investment advisors, institutional allocators.
- 30:38When we were reaching out to those folks in summer of 2023, a
- 30:42lot of them were kind of like get lost, right, because the
- 30:45Bitcoin price is $25,000. There was no, there was really
- 30:50no expectation that there would be ETFs approved in 2024.
- 30:54But now the conversation has changed materially.
- 30:57And one thing that we plug into a little bit is the 13 F filings
- 31:01and just taking a look to see under the hood who actually owns
- 31:05these financial products. And there's, you know, as we all
- 31:09know, there's pensions involved in the asset class, there's a
- 31:11lot of registered investment advisors that, you know, they
- 31:15prioritize their fiduciary duties.
- 31:17So the 13 F filings, right, it allows us to take a peek under
- 31:20the hood and see what type of investors own the Bitcoin ETFs.
- 31:25And we have pension funds that have shown up this year, right,
- 31:29very large ones in the United States that are only just
- 31:32dipping their toes in with A10 basis point allocation.
- 31:35But that's, you know, much larger than zero.
- 31:37I think in terms of nominal value, it's 160 or $180 million
- 31:41investment. Now there's a couple of pensions
- 31:43involved and then there's the registered investment advisors
- 31:46that are fiduciaries for their clients.
- 31:48So they're either recognizing that there is a big value
- 31:51proposition in allocating the Bitcoin further clients as an
- 31:54uncorrelated asset that, you know, an emerging asset class,
- 31:58or that means also that their clients are reaching out to them
- 32:00directly and asking for Bitcoin exposure.
- 32:02So I just wanted to touch on the point that you made that having
- 32:06the CEO of the world's largest asset manager being now an
- 32:11advocate for Bitcoin and having a product and having skin in the
- 32:13game, right, and having an incentive for Bitcoin to be
- 32:16adopted by his business and his clients is a huge tailwind that
- 32:21really hasn't has only started to materialize.
- 32:23It's really just the first inning.
- 32:24I think a lot of people don't understand that yet.
- 32:28Yeah. And I think, you know, we talked
- 32:32about podcasts before. I think the work that you guys
- 32:34do with this podcast and just having more and more education
- 32:38out there. If you remember when we were
- 32:40talking about that Murad podcast, it was actually quite
- 32:44hard to get good quality Bitcoin content back then.
- 32:48And I think what's interesting is now there's just so much, you
- 32:53know, even we're at CS Capital, we launched a podcast recently,
- 32:56obviously not a Bitcoin podcast, but what we do is we focus on a
- 33:00particular issue in the world, be it climate change, food
- 33:04security, energy security, something like this.
- 33:07And then we'll dig into the problem.
- 33:09We'll talk about a solution. And more often than not, the
- 33:13investment proposition by the expert that we've brought in
- 33:17ends up being Bitcoin is amongst other things.
- 33:21So it's quite funny that we've got this podcast, we're trying
- 33:25to address real problems. Obviously, we've designed it for
- 33:29institutional investors and alternative investors.
- 33:32And the conclusion often at the end is, well, probably need a
- 33:37bit of Bitcoin. Yeah, that's fascinating.
- 33:42I mean, all roads do lead to Bitcoin one way or another.
- 33:45I'd be curious on that vein in particular.
- 33:47Rich, I know. So I'd come across your podcast
- 33:50this week just taking a look and seeing what you've been up to in
- 33:52preparations for this. And was it Eric sees?
- 33:57That was on the podcast recently.
- 33:59I caught a bit of that episode and that was interesting to hear
- 34:02just his entrepreneurial background and you know all the,
- 34:06the work that they've done over the decades with CS Capital.
- 34:09One thing that you mentioned that's really interesting to me
- 34:12and if you could share it, that'd be that'd be fascinating.
- 34:15Just like the investment case for Bitcoin in the fiscal
- 34:19perspective and well, the fiscal perspective, and then also just
- 34:24the asymmetric opportunity that exists within Bitcoin due to its
- 34:28properties are are pretty easy to explain or for someone to
- 34:32understand if they are willing to do the work and pay
- 34:34attention. But maybe in terms of
- 34:37geopolitics or energy, like some of the conversations you've had
- 34:41early on in the podcast, how have you found those lead into
- 34:44Bitcoin or, or how did these people come in with their
- 34:47background and maybe not see Bitcoin before and now after
- 34:50having a conversation, they're willing to open up their eyes
- 34:53and see a new perspective of how this could be a technology that
- 34:57could help to solve a problem there?
- 35:01Yeah, I think the energy security one is, is probably the
- 35:03most interesting. I always talk, talk about the
- 35:06fact that El Salvador's volcano bond when it eventually launches
- 35:11will be a complete game changer for broad energy security for
- 35:17energy rich nations or resource rich nations.
- 35:21Because if you think about a country like, say, Argentina, so
- 35:26Argentina is extremely rich in energy resources, in resources
- 35:32in general, but also has huge amounts of hydro in the north,
- 35:37huge solar panel farms up in the north as well with the
- 35:40propensity to grow massively. And they're still taking, you
- 35:46know, loans from the IMF, right? So if you could imagine a way
- 35:50that you can monetize all of that clean energy and start to
- 35:55use that for the benefit of the nation and then even do a sailor
- 36:00and raise even more money on the back of expansion of that
- 36:03infrastructure, making you even more energy secure.
- 36:07You actually move to a point of actually being, you know, having
- 36:11the IM FS involvement being completely redundant and so
- 36:15freeing these countries that have been really held in poverty
- 36:20for a very long time due to not being able to have, you know, a
- 36:24monetization of their resources that they have in cut in their
- 36:29country. Like you look at much of Central
- 36:31Africa, it's the same situation, you know, really heavily reliant
- 36:37on IMF loans to stay afloat, but you know, very resource rich
- 36:42countries. So this is this is the, the, the
- 36:46gap that we discussed actually in the first episode with the
- 36:49with a brilliant guy, a guy called David Lake, who we had on
- 36:53the podcast. He is a bitcoiner now as well.
- 36:58So he was at the summit with Jeff Booth.
- 37:01So yeah, we've we got him over the line as well.
- 37:04But yeah, I think a lot of these experts come at this, come at
- 37:08their particular problem. And look, we all know, we all
- 37:12know that meme fix the money, fix the world, right?
- 37:15And it's actually really true when you when you have a lot of
- 37:18these issues, Bitcoin does have a propensity to be able to
- 37:21change it. And one of the people that I
- 37:23want to get on the podcast to talk about environmental
- 37:26problems and, you know, climate change, I have young kids and
- 37:29you know, they, they're very worried about the environment.
- 37:33And that's something that is being focused on in their
- 37:37schools. And we see it more and more, you
- 37:39know, if you think about Bitcoin as a methane capture tool for
- 37:46gas flaring or landfill sites, this is actually a very, very
- 37:52interest, interesting way to monetize Bitcoin mining with
- 37:57stranded energy. So again, you actually reduce
- 38:00the amount of methane going into the environment because it's
- 38:02just it's cheaper and quicker for the landfill to burn it all
- 38:06off as opposed to potentially combust it in a way that will
- 38:11will create energy because no one's going to take that energy.
- 38:14But now you've got Bitcoin miners that can turn up and and
- 38:18reduce that that climate change impact.
- 38:20So yeah, lots of different avenues to that point, Jackson,
- 38:26where Bitcoin can fix the issue. Yeah, it's it's incredibly
- 38:30bullish for humanity and productivity because I don't
- 38:34know what is the most energy dense or oil rich.
- 38:36I think it's at least top three is Venezuela and Latin America.
- 38:41But the problem is that they don't have any currency or the
- 38:44currency continuing to be debased.
- 38:45They can't coordinate economic activity.
- 38:47And that's a very like extreme example to get the energy out of
- 38:51the Earth. But that's that's an extreme
- 38:53example. We experience this here
- 38:54anywhere, right? Where if you don't have a good
- 38:56form of capital, you can't plan for the future.
- 38:58You can't if it's continued to be debased, you cannot take a
- 39:01loan out plan. You see cut, you know, again,
- 39:03micro example, a restaurant goes out of business because their
- 39:06inputs are constantly changing and so they don't change them
- 39:08fast enough on the output, on the price for the customer and
- 39:12they get offsides. But what you just described
- 39:15bypasses that because ultimately you can source capital Bitcoin
- 39:19from anywhere in the world. You can structure a product, you
- 39:21can hold the capital in in a unit that's not being debased.
- 39:25You can coordinate that capital to go and pull the energy out of
- 39:28the earth, mind the BTC and then get it out.
- 39:32And that's just like the again, extreme example, but that plays
- 39:36anywhere. You don't even need any.
- 39:37You know, you can figure out your legal constructs.
- 39:39Obviously in different regions. It's going to matter, but even
- 39:43setting the mining to set up a wallet, we see this a lot in
- 39:45Texas where a lot of our teams base that Texas and Middle East
- 39:50are crime to get Bitcoin because they understand commodity
- 39:53commodities. And a lot of these investors
- 39:55maybe don't really want Bitcoin per SE to hold, but they want to
- 39:59mine it at A at a price less than the spot price and then
- 40:02auto convert into Fiat. And they set up their own
- 40:06wallets in these like limited partner structures.
- 40:08So they'll mine to it. So you can imagine you can start
- 40:10to set up. Some of those structures in any
- 40:12market to invest and bring resources that historically
- 40:15would not have been able to because you didn't have the
- 40:17financial structure in place. It's it's incredibly exciting.
- 40:23It is we're in a completely new paradigm and I I really do think
- 40:26that volcano bond is the catalyst to really start to
- 40:30change things with these IMF indebted countries.
- 40:34Does your Bitcoin custody setup keep you up at night?
- 40:37Maybe you still have coins sitting on an exchange.
- 40:39Worried about hackers? Or maybe you've set up your own
- 40:42self custody but don't feel safe with your Bitcoin savings
- 40:44stashed on a little plastic device in your desk drawer?
- 40:48Gain Peace of Mind with Onramp and our multi institution
- 40:51custody solution. Here's how it works.
- 40:54Onramp creates a dedicated multi sig vault just for you. 3
- 40:58separate institutions each hold a key, Onramp bit go and coin
- 41:02cover, but none can move funds unilaterally.
- 41:06Instead, only you have control over your coins with on ramps
- 41:10multi institution custody. You'll sleep better at night
- 41:13knowing your Bitcoin is stored with best in class security on
- 41:16chain with fault tolerant multi sig.
- 41:19If you believe your Bitcoin is going to be worth a lot someday,
- 41:22don't jeopardize that future by exposing your coins to hackers
- 41:26on exchanges, $5 wrench attacks in the real world, or perhaps
- 41:29most importantly, the risk that you might screw something up
- 41:33with a highly technical self custody set up.
- 41:36Onramp's Multi institution Custody eliminates single points
- 41:39of failure, reduces your personal attack surface and
- 41:42technical burden, and provides access to financial services
- 41:45that allow you to confidently secure your Bitcoin, including
- 41:49inheritance planning, insurance backed warranties for all
- 41:51balances and transactions, low cost trading and more.
- 41:56Bitcoin is a once in a species asset.
- 41:58Secure it right. Learn more at onrampbitcoin.com.
- 42:02Yeah, because you don't have to touch the the traditional
- 42:04banking rails, which is important.
- 42:05I'm not sure if you're familiar. So Brian and I are partners at
- 42:08AI believe it's the first Bitcoin denominated venture
- 42:10fund. So we invest across, you know,
- 42:13we're agnostic. So we invest in the Bitcoin
- 42:15ecosystem because we've been very close to it and we we kind
- 42:18of are building. So we spot a lot of gaps that
- 42:19need to exist in the market structure, which is why I'm
- 42:22interested in talking about Switzerland because we've been
- 42:24looking at, you know, different companies looking to get set up
- 42:27there. Well, we're ultimately agnostic.
- 42:29We're looking at anything that's looking at the world through a
- 42:31lens of wool. Can I produce more Bitcoin by
- 42:34delivering value to the world and then sweep it into BTC?
- 42:37But when we invest from our LP's invest in Bitcoin, we invest in
- 42:40the companies in BTC. And then the companies is the
- 42:43kicker. They value the underlying unit
- 42:46more than the dollar. So they hold their treasury or
- 42:48at least a portion in BTC, which extends their runway and gives
- 42:51them an unfair advantage because they're more discerning with how
- 42:53they allocate capital. And you never have to touch the
- 42:56banking rails in a situation like that.
- 42:58You can because some people want to allocate dollars or some
- 43:00people need to accept dollars, but something like that had
- 43:02never been able to be done before.
- 43:05And so when you don't have to touch the traditional financial
- 43:07rails, all sorts of different manifestations can come in that
- 43:10are effectively more productive if you ever had to send a wire
- 43:13or anything that has to do with, you know, Swiss rails, Swift
- 43:15Rails. That's fascinating.
- 43:18See. Do you charge a performance fee
- 43:20on the returns over the Bitcoin allocated?
- 43:24Yeah. So hurdles are all.
- 43:25Everything's denominated in BTC. Amazing.
- 43:29Yeah, amazing. We should chat offline about
- 43:32that. Definitely happy to.
- 43:35I probably have some people that would be very interested to to
- 43:39look at this. And we honestly think this is
- 43:42just the future as well. We were the first.
- 43:44But ultimately when you go back, everybody kind of knows this.
- 43:47But the past 100 years have effectively been an anomaly,
- 43:49right, on this Fiat standard. If you go back, if you think
- 43:52about even allocation and capital, I like to joke and say
- 43:57never would have been like Henry Ford is a great example that
- 44:00built all of his wealth with his bare hands.
- 44:02Give all of that money to somebody that's never built
- 44:05anything or allocated. It doesn't make any sense.
- 44:07Somebody that was investment banking or you know, academic to
- 44:10say, here's money to go find net new builders to build because
- 44:15you've never built anything. So how would you know how to
- 44:16back test any of the process? But that's effectively what
- 44:19exists in Venture today. And that's why we see a lot of
- 44:21capital just burned or lit on fire.
- 44:24And so the angle is you take existing builders, but then with
- 44:29the lens of the alignment of a unit that can't be debased and
- 44:34is not, you're not trying to play hot potato because right
- 44:36and LP wants to get rid of the dollars because they're on fire
- 44:40all day long. So they need to go and find any
- 44:42allocator to put the capital to. And then the allocator needs to
- 44:46get rid of the dollars because they want to get more management
- 44:48fees. They want to raise a larger
- 44:49fund. Like people try to raise
- 44:50hundreds of millions of dollars in bitcoins.
- 44:51Like you don't need $100 million, There's nothing,
- 44:53there's not that many companies invested don't make that kind of
- 44:55money. So you try to raise a capital,
- 44:58but then every you have a hammer, everything needs to look
- 45:00like a nail. So then you're out there just
- 45:02looking at companies and this is where you see these companies
- 45:04get bit up without naming names, and now they're like crazy
- 45:06valuations that can't produce the returns.
- 45:10And then those people get told by the allocators, hey, run, go
- 45:14hire as many people, go scale as possible.
- 45:15But it's just like that. That doesn't make any sense.
- 45:18Bitcoin's cyclical. So you literally go higher,
- 45:20expend all that energy, destroy all that Bitcoin.
- 45:23Well, what if you just change that whole dynamic?
- 45:25Now the LP is more discerning with the BTC, the GP is more
- 45:28discerning with the BTC. And the most important part is
- 45:32the actual entrepreneur. The allocator is the most
- 45:34discerning with the underline. It's not to say you don't spend
- 45:37the Bitcoin, you just don't misuse it and you you look at
- 45:41the opportunity costs on AdWords hires through that lens of is
- 45:44bitcoins growth, will this outpace bitcoins growth by the
- 45:47the derivative returns? I think this is very interesting
- 45:51when you think about value alignment as well.
- 45:53When you factor value alignment into this, obviously when you're
- 45:56doing venture, you're backing a founder, right?
- 45:59And I think what's very interesting for you is you're
- 46:02backing founders that are Bitcoiners.
- 46:04Like they have that mentality, or at least you know where their
- 46:08mentality is going, right? Because Bitcoiners tend to end
- 46:12up in the same place. You've got a long term mindset,
- 46:16low time preference, as you say, you're very careful where you're
- 46:20going to allocate that Bitcoin because it's so precious, right?
- 46:24It's not, it's not those dollars.
- 46:25OK, fine, let's do this, let's do that.
- 46:27Let's run around, try and create some frenzy.
- 46:31Know when it's Bitcoin you're allocating extremely carefully.
- 46:35And that's, that's insaling perceptive because it's
- 46:37something Brian and I talk about where individuals in the Bitcoin
- 46:41venture space will talk about. Well, you allocate, it's kind of
- 46:44like leverage on top of Bitcoin. And I look at that as a
- 46:46negative, not as a positive because outside of a few things
- 46:49like buying and custody Bitcoin, there's not really a lot of
- 46:52venture type returns. But so you're basically layering
- 46:56and risk on risk because like lightning is a great example.
- 46:58We've never really found a use case.
- 47:00So you're layering on how do I like potentially find a use
- 47:03case. So you get the risk of venture
- 47:06plus you get the risk of the volatility of Bitcoin because if
- 47:08you invest in venture that's already risky, but then you
- 47:11invest in the perceived or the potential use case for a new
- 47:15form of bitcoins use, which generally outside of buying and
- 47:19holding from a venture perspective, it's not, it's very
- 47:21hard to justify a return. But what Brian and I talked
- 47:25about, and this is the firm's called early Riders in us being
- 47:28agnostic to it's not dedicated to just solely Bitcoin
- 47:32infrastructure is to your point is that as individuals like
- 47:36yourself that come from backgrounds of 10 plus years
- 47:40professional experience, they're going to look at their existing
- 47:43firms and look at it through the lens of understanding Bitcoin
- 47:45deeply. And they're going to say this is
- 47:47full of fat and bloat and inefficiencies, especially with
- 47:50deflationary tools. And now I can go and out compete
- 47:54them because I know all of where all the gaps are, use a better
- 47:57form of money. So you get the benefit of
- 48:01underlying better form of capital from an entrepreneurial
- 48:03perspective. And then you get the upside of
- 48:06them looking at the world through the lens of
- 48:07understanding Bitcoin, but not the risk of, oh, I'm going to go
- 48:10find the next way to scale Bitcoin, the next third layer
- 48:13and all the things associated. So it's interesting you picked
- 48:16up on that because that's where we're really excited.
- 48:17The number of entrepreneurs or LP's that we have in the fund
- 48:21are just like world class because when you have high
- 48:23signal, the right people find you because it's like, oh, this
- 48:26is what's been missing. Absolutely, absolutely.
- 48:30I think it almost might be the ultimate hack for venture
- 48:33capital. You know it's Bitcoin only
- 48:36companies allocating in Bitcoin. And you're, you're right,
- 48:39because this is the ultimate hack to actually getting back to
- 48:42efficient use of money, right? It's just like, I really like
- 48:46money. Money doesn't grow on trees and
- 48:48we forgot about it. And so it might put now
- 48:51everybody thinks money grows on trees.
- 48:53Everybody wants the next round, you know all the stories, but
- 48:55the reality is Bitcoin doesn't grow on trees and Bitcoin has
- 49:00opportunity and Bitcoin has, you know, there's a cost of capital,
- 49:03it's Bitcoin. And as everyone starts looking
- 49:04at the world through that, you literally get to the most
- 49:07efficient use of that capital. And the kicker is, I like to
- 49:10joke, it's like on a scale of one to 10, whether it's listed
- 49:12companies or unlisted companies, there's a certain amount of fat
- 49:15that exists because we've been on this Fiat standard.
- 49:17So the goal is to as Bitcoin, you start to look, you start to
- 49:21look in the most and those people will out compete all the
- 49:24other people over a long and a time horizon because just the
- 49:27most efficient use of that money, even if it takes longer.
- 49:29And this is what Henry Ford figured out very early on when
- 49:32there would be deflationary periods.
- 49:33He would sell everything even though he had to take it at a
- 49:36loss. And then he'd close down the
- 49:37factory, get more efficient and come back and outrun everyone
- 49:40because that's what you're supposed to do when
- 49:42misallocation of capital happens, not continue to paper
- 49:45over. And we just kind of all forgot
- 49:47about this. You.
- 49:51You really? Need some of the history on
- 49:53that. Yeah, you picked up on one of
- 49:55the core things to me is just the sort of realignment of
- 49:59incentives in private investment venture, whatever it is.
- 50:02I think those incentives got very distorted over the past
- 50:06fifty to 100 years as we had basically, you know, free money
- 50:11that could be printed infinitely that distorts all the incentives
- 50:14down the line from LP's to GPS to founders.
- 50:17We're just sort of going back to a time when when those
- 50:20incentives were more aligned. And the other really fascinating
- 50:22thing about this for particularly the entrepreneur
- 50:25and the founder is you, you might only need to raise capital
- 50:30once, maybe twice, but you might just be able to do it once and
- 50:34extend your runway as as your Bitcoin treasury grows and then
- 50:38you can avoid, you know, further dilution into the future.
- 50:40So it's, it's again, it's fully just aligning the the incentives
- 50:44between all the different parties involved and, and really
- 50:47just rethinking how capital should be allocated within a
- 50:51Bitcoin lens. Absolutely, absolutely.
- 50:56I like it. I think for me it really comes
- 51:02back to the values as well because you want to make sure
- 51:05you're investing in a founder that is honest.
- 51:07And I don't know why, but it just Bitcoin leads you to more
- 51:13of a honest purist way of thinking, right?
- 51:18Bitcoin is truth. It leads you to truth.
- 51:20You want to represent that same truth in you, right?
- 51:23So when you're backing a founder, you need a founder that
- 51:27you can trust, obviously, that you can trust him to make the
- 51:30right decisions. And that that truth aspect, that
- 51:33long term mindset, all of these things come together for Bitcoin
- 51:38and the value system that it creates.
- 51:40So outside again, I think you guys have found an interesting
- 51:44hack here. It's impressive how fast you
- 51:46picked up on it cuz I don't know how quick like a sharing cuz
- 51:49it's obviously a little bit novel, but you hit the nail on
- 51:51the head. There's nothing more scarce than
- 51:53the human capital, like scarce than Bitcoin.
- 51:56And that's the component, the way to execute on this.
- 52:00And the beautiful part about Bitcoin is when you meet
- 52:02somebody, you know, right off the bat, I like to joke and it's
- 52:04like we all agree that on we agree on 90% of things, we don't
- 52:08want people taking our money. The last 10% is on the margins
- 52:10on like, you know, you know what's happening here in local
- 52:12politics. And once you cut through all
- 52:14that noise, you just immediately know like where somebody stands.
- 52:17And then you can start to build on the merits of like, you know,
- 52:20the professional experience and things like that.
- 52:22So it really isn't interesting kind of cheat code to to find
- 52:25the right operators from a founder perspective or just like
- 52:28folks that have joined our firm, you kind of know right off the
- 52:30bat where they where they sit. Yeah, I was in, I was in
- 52:36Amsterdam with the boys at Relay and they had a lot of the team
- 52:40there and it's just, it's, it's so good to see them so
- 52:46enthusiastic and so driven and so excited about what they're
- 52:50doing because they're so behind passionately what they're
- 52:54building because they believe so much in the underlying Bitcoin
- 53:01behind the whole system. So yeah, it's, it's, it just
- 53:06creates the best outcomes I think for for venture investors.
- 53:11Yeah, Rich, maybe on, on that Bane.
- 53:13I'd be curious to hear more about what you're seeing in
- 53:16Europe as it relates to Bitcoin only businesses, Bitcoin
- 53:20institutional adoption, whatever, wherever you want to
- 53:23take it. But maybe a perspective that you
- 53:25have that we don't necessarily have being based in the States.
- 53:29And you, again, whether you want to touch on specific companies
- 53:34or specific countries within Europe that you're seeing more
- 53:37adoption, more favorable regulatory environment.
- 53:41But really, I'd be curious to hear what you're seeing in your
- 53:43seat. Yeah.
- 53:47I mean, one thing that I found quite interesting in in
- 53:50Switzerland is that you have this crypto Valley in Zug which
- 53:55has been around for a while and there's some big, big Bitcoiners
- 53:59that live there and and stay there.
- 54:01And what I found is though, that not a lot of them are purest
- 54:08Bitcoin Maxis because I think that because they've been in
- 54:14crypto, I was talking to someone about this the other day,
- 54:17because they've been in crypto for so long, they get the inside
- 54:20track on, you know, this new token that's going to list or
- 54:26whatever. And so they can make the 500X
- 54:29and then convert it back into Bitcoin.
- 54:33And so in a funny kind of way, they're still shit coiners.
- 54:37And so they're not quite of the Bitcoin mindset that you see
- 54:42much more in the international community.
- 54:45So I always go to the Bitcoin conference in the USI just, as I
- 54:50said, got back from Bitcoin Amsterdam.
- 54:52You know that mindset that you get at a Bitcoin conference to
- 54:55the people that you're likely to meet there, they're pure
- 54:58Bitcoiners, right? Whereas when you talk to someone
- 55:01at Crypto Valley and Zerg where even though these guys are
- 55:04massive holders of Bitcoin, they're still shit coining
- 55:08around and mucking around in this nonsense, which is
- 55:12something that I, I find quite weird.
- 55:16Even if you say to a Bitcoin, I look, you can, you can go and
- 55:21invest in this token and make a quick 500%, they're not going to
- 55:26do it. They're pretty much not going to
- 55:28do it because they're like, well, yeah, but no thanks.
- 55:31I don't, I don't want to run the risk of losing my Bitcoin and
- 55:34I'm very relaxed with my Bitcoin.
- 55:36When we talk about asset allocation, you don't even need
- 55:38to bother with it. I know that I'm going to be
- 55:40making, you know, significant multiples in a dollar based
- 55:44system anyway, so I don't need to muck around.
- 55:48So I think that's quite an interesting thing that I've
- 55:51discovered here being in Switzerland.
- 55:54I would say in terms of Bitcoin only companies, they're quite
- 55:59rare. Obviously Raleigh is, is 1.
- 56:03I think Relay's competitors, I mean Relay have done a very,
- 56:07very good job of marketing across Europe and, and being out
- 56:11there and being trusted and you know, they're just so passionate
- 56:14about what they do. I think most of their
- 56:17competitors have disappeared or fallen away.
- 56:21So those are Bitcoin company or bit or they were Bitcoin focused
- 56:25companies that have have sort of gone away just because they've
- 56:29been out competed by Relay. But yeah, it's it's not so, so
- 56:36robust over here in terms of Bitcoin only companies.
- 56:39What we are starting to see and obviously again through my
- 56:42involvement with Relay is we're seeing more and more corporates
- 56:47bit real estate companies through to just general, you
- 56:51know, carpentry companies putting Bitcoin on their balance
- 56:56sheet. Slowly starting to understand
- 56:59that this can be a very interesting way to manage the
- 57:03treasury of the company. So this is something that is
- 57:07somehow getting out there. I don't know how it's getting
- 57:12out there, but people are are discovering it more and more.
- 57:15And yeah, so corporate adoption in the small and medium sized
- 57:20enterprises are are getting getting O fait with Bitcoin.
- 57:28But yeah, Bitcoin only companies is they're still quite rare.
- 57:32And as I say, the Swiss community is still a little bit
- 57:36shit coining. That mirror is pretty much very
- 57:39similar to the US. It's very hard to be Bitcoin
- 57:42only because unless you're going to, you know, cell phone and
- 57:45have been holding Bitcoin or like we said, reference finding
- 57:48on the, the Bitcoin allocator side, it's very hard to convince
- 57:52institutional capital to look at that because they're still
- 57:54looking at it as a diversification, you know,
- 57:56multiple asset sector versus how can you build a strong business,
- 58:01which to their credit, it's very hard to build a very profitable
- 58:04or any kind of profitable Bitcoin business because they're
- 58:06not a lot of things to do with it other than buying and
- 58:08holding. But curious, rich on the, the
- 58:13banking and lending side, because in the West, we're
- 58:15still, however, like in the US specifically, we still haven't
- 58:18seen, there's obviously the lot of the, the regulatory hurdles
- 58:24that have been in place that are starting to get lifted.
- 58:25I think there's like 2 SEC exemptions being wine, one other
- 58:28from a banking perspective that are letting them custody the
- 58:30asset. But it was shocking to me to
- 58:32find out that there's multiple Swiss banks that allow clients
- 58:35to the custody and then allow them to lend against the asset,
- 58:38which I think is just a natural part of the market structure for
- 58:40folks that don't want to sell and want to do other things with
- 58:43the underlying curious like what's built into that?
- 58:46And is that just part of Swiss banking and being very forward
- 58:49thinking or is there any other kind of factors involved?
- 58:54It's, it's not, I mean the, the Swiss banks, you know, they've
- 58:58been watching their pie get reduced obviously by US
- 59:04regulation in terms of how you deal with US clients and just
- 59:09being very clamped down on the whole banking secrecy side of
- 59:13things that really impeded the, the Swiss banking advantage that
- 59:20they had for many years. Now they are having to push into
- 59:26being more innovative and so that's why you've seen many of
- 59:30the Swiss banks adopt crypto and be more broad.
- 59:35I think that what they're doing on lending on Bitcoin is
- 59:39impressive. We still bank sees.
- 59:44So we have as part of the overall group.
- 59:46We actually have a private bank as part of us as well, and we
- 59:52haven't got to the point of lending money against Bitcoin
- 59:55yet. That requires obviously a system
- 1:00:00that is 24/7. And so this is, you know, it's
- 1:00:05quite far away from the way that the traditional banking
- 1:00:09infrastructure works. You know, it's very hard to
- 1:00:12imagine bankers working on a Saturday or Sunday and dealing
- 1:00:17with margin calls and dealing with this type of thing.
- 1:00:21And so I'm not actually sure how the banks that are doing in
- 1:00:25Switzerland. Are actually doing it yet it
- 1:00:28seems very early and very nascent and I think they
- 1:00:32probably only do it with clients that have significant assets
- 1:00:36where they're not going to have a margin call and the LTV loan
- 1:00:40to value is very, very low. But yeah, it's, it's not
- 1:00:45something we've we've got comfortable yet in our banking
- 1:00:48division. Yeah, it's not for the faint,
- 1:00:51faint of heart. Maybe we can chat when we talk
- 1:00:53about earlier writers offline. My my previous company, I think
- 1:00:56we're the only retail lender left standing in the 2022 space.
- 1:01:01And it goes to your point. They'll the loan to values have
- 1:01:03to be right. And then it's you're it's a 24/7
- 1:01:07game and you have to have really good relationships with your
- 1:01:10clients and and really protect them from themselves.
- 1:01:13And then the the kicker is not rehypothecate or generally
- 1:01:17people get in trouble is with the rehabilitation, especially
- 1:01:19in traditional finance because they're not used to the
- 1:01:21volatility profile of Bitcoin. And so they think it's, it's not
- 1:01:25risky to go get some, some, you know, interest on that lending
- 1:01:29in one or two hands removed. But then that happens.
- 1:01:32Rich, on the so your point about just Swiss banking having to be
- 1:01:36more innovative just given some of the US regulatory environment
- 1:01:41changes over the years. I'm curious like for Bank CS or
- 1:01:45just for other private banks in Switzerland that are rolling out
- 1:01:50Bitcoin and crypto related services, is that more so demand
- 1:01:55driven? Are your private clients asking
- 1:01:58for these types of products directly with their existing
- 1:02:01banking relationships? Or is it more of a proactive and
- 1:02:06aggressive move by private banks to differentiate themselves
- 1:02:11among the banking sector in Switzerland?
- 1:02:13How how do you think about that? And maybe what are some things
- 1:02:17that you're excited about within the bank, if you can share or
- 1:02:20just about Swiss banking in general as it relates to Bitcoin
- 1:02:23related services and adoption? Yeah.
- 1:02:28I think it's a bit of both. So when when we get through the
- 1:02:33bull market cycle, which is probably going to happen next
- 1:02:36year, you're going to have a huge amount of clients wanting
- 1:02:39to get access to Bitcoin directly.
- 1:02:43But you know, you're going to have a whole host of shit coins
- 1:02:46that they're going to want to trade.
- 1:02:47And they're going to want to trade it in custody at their
- 1:02:49bank rather than at an exchange that they probably don't trust
- 1:02:54as much. So, you know, I think the
- 1:02:58conversation at sea started in 2020-2021 and the product was
- 1:03:04launched in 2022 where obviously there wasn't a lot of demand by
- 1:03:08then. I think it launched just a few
- 1:03:10weeks before FTX, but then you know, now that's building again.
- 1:03:16Obviously being a crypto bank, they've had onboarding of
- 1:03:20clients that have crypto holdings seizes a very respected
- 1:03:25name in Switzerland. It's not very well known outside
- 1:03:29in the US, but it is a very respected name if you look at
- 1:03:32the other providers that predominantly crypto firms.
- 1:03:36So seize is actually one of the very few actual real banks that
- 1:03:40existed prior to crypto that's actually offering crypto
- 1:03:46services. But I would say, yeah, it's a
- 1:03:49little bit of both. There's a little bit of, you
- 1:03:53know, having to innovate, having to drive things forward, having
- 1:03:56to find ways to compete in the back of, you know, banking
- 1:04:00secrecy going away. But then there's also that
- 1:04:03little bit of the demand side coming through through the bull
- 1:04:07market cycles. But also you've got a
- 1:04:09generational change happening in wealth as well.
- 1:04:12You know, you're starting to see the millennials, the the Gen.
- 1:04:17Z's start to inherit money. Switzerland's a really
- 1:04:21interesting place because it doesn't really have inheritance
- 1:04:23tax, which is why you still have some very wealthy families here
- 1:04:29because they're not getting destroyed every generational
- 1:04:31change through inheritance taxation.
- 1:04:35So, you know, that's obviously not the case for the US It's not
- 1:04:38the case for the UK where I'm from.
- 1:04:40So it's been quite another culture shock for me here is
- 1:04:44just how wealthy some of these families are.
- 1:04:47I mean, it's just like everybody's worth 10s of
- 1:04:50millions, which is at least, you know.
- 1:04:54So, yeah, there's some very wealthy families and they we're
- 1:04:59seeing that generational change now.
- 1:05:01So the Gen. Z as the millennials are
- 1:05:03starting to pick it up and they are paying attention to this
- 1:05:07space. They're interested in Bitcoin,
- 1:05:10they're interested in crypto. Unfortunately, they're
- 1:05:13interested in, you know, NFTS and other nonsense as well.
- 1:05:17And you know, every time I hear one of them sit down and say
- 1:05:20talk to me about web three, I'm like, oh, please, I can't.
- 1:05:25But yeah, it's again, it's a bit like, how do you sit in a
- 1:05:29meeting and talk about hedge funds with a guy?
- 1:05:31It's the same sort of thing. You've got to kind of come to an
- 1:05:34investor where they're ready and help guide them to to the right
- 1:05:39place. So rich I was.
- 1:05:41I thought that was an interesting point that you made
- 1:05:43about there not being inheritance tax in Switzerland
- 1:05:46and just the idea of generational wealth there and
- 1:05:50that being more prevalent than in other countries.
- 1:05:53And that ties into something you mentioned as well, just as
- 1:05:55relates to Bank CS getting into Bitcoin and crypto related
- 1:05:59services and being a trusted name and a traditional finance
- 1:06:03firm, a banking partner that these families are already
- 1:06:06familiar with. Whereas the other companies that
- 1:06:08are participating in the space are more crypto native and don't
- 1:06:12have the same brand recognition and level of trust that your
- 1:06:15firm's established. And we've seen that a lot too as
- 1:06:19it relates to our business and how we think about expansion
- 1:06:22plans. Just one anecdote is that we
- 1:06:25have a sister company in the Middle East in the in the UAE on
- 1:06:29Ramina. And part of the idea there is
- 1:06:31that people want to work with businesses that are local to
- 1:06:34their region and that that have trusted partners in the
- 1:06:38traditional finance space. So I just wanted to react to
- 1:06:41that because I think there is we would all agree that Bitcoin has
- 1:06:44a ton of alignment as it relates to generational wealth.
- 1:06:46And there's obviously much more of a bias and interest in
- 1:06:50Bitcoin by millennial meals and Gen.
- 1:06:51Z than there are in baby boomers.
- 1:06:54And then there's this massive transfer of wealth happening
- 1:06:56that's really just underway now and will happen over the next
- 1:07:001520 years where you have somewhere between like 70 or $80
- 1:07:04trillion of wealth that's being transferred from the baby
- 1:07:08boomers to these younger generations.
- 1:07:10And they all have a more of an inclination toward Bitcoin and
- 1:07:14digital assets. So I think that's a huge
- 1:07:15tailwind and it really positions well for bank sees because
- 1:07:20you're ahead of the curve as it relates to being a really
- 1:07:23trusted name in banking and traditional finance and being
- 1:07:26early to the Bitcoin and crypto native services as well.
- 1:07:32Yeah. No, absolutely.
- 1:07:33I mean, we're excited about being positioned where we are.
- 1:07:36And I think Sees Capital is obviously very well positioned
- 1:07:40to help advise some of these families in terms of the way
- 1:07:43that they want to, they want to allocate the product that we
- 1:07:47currently have is AUS dollar denominated product that
- 1:07:51provides a return in dollars. So I'm very interested about
- 1:07:55what you're saying because we've had, we've had some interesting
- 1:07:59demand from Bitcoin Bitcoiner clients where they're like,
- 1:08:03look, love the fact that you can deliver a 15 to 20% return
- 1:08:08product, but it in dollars, but I'm never going to sell my big,
- 1:08:12sell my Bitcoin $4 to get a 15 to 20% return.
- 1:08:18So what can you do in Bitcoin? And so we're at the point where
- 1:08:22we're starting to say, OK, is there something to do here?
- 1:08:26If we were to deliver a product denominated in Bitcoin, maybe a
- 1:08:31lower return than 15 to 20%, take the risk right down.
- 1:08:35As you said, Mike, you know, you want to make sure that you're
- 1:08:37super careful with the allocation of that Bitcoin, like
- 1:08:40you must not lose the Bitcoin, right?
- 1:08:43So maybe take the volatility of the fund down, be much more
- 1:08:47cautious with the strategies that you're allocating to.
- 1:08:50And then, you know, maybe you can get a 5 to 10% return with a
- 1:08:55volatility around 2 and a sharper around 2 as well.
- 1:08:58You know, that then becomes a very interesting product for
- 1:09:01Bitcoin. So yeah, we're kind of we're
- 1:09:06going down and seeing what we can offer in terms of these
- 1:09:11types of products. But I think, you know, coming
- 1:09:13back to the comment that we just we were discussing earlier
- 1:09:16about, you know, what you guys have done and having ABTC
- 1:09:20denominated venture fund. I think that's something that,
- 1:09:25you know, we could have some sort of discussion about as as a
- 1:09:30product that we would be not officially promoting.
- 1:09:33But you know, when people come to us and say they're looking at
- 1:09:36Venture, I think that this is, this could be a very interesting
- 1:09:40thing to be looking at. Yeah.
- 1:09:42And you guys are in a really interesting spot, maybe one of
- 1:09:46the best because I didn't recognize that SEES was
- 1:09:49historically a traditional bank and then adopted Bitcoin as a
- 1:09:52strategy. Because then it allows for all
- 1:09:54sorts of like esoteric cross collateralization products,
- 1:09:58which can help you get to those returns.
- 1:09:59Because it's generally really hard just to get to a BTC return
- 1:10:02if you're like lending it out for other people to trade it.
- 1:10:05Because they're, the problem with all that is they're
- 1:10:06denominating their return in dollars.
- 1:10:08And that's where people get offsides.
- 1:10:09But if you're able to structure products where BTC's infused in
- 1:10:14a in some kind of debt facility or whatever you would create for
- 1:10:18that return because you have the clients and the assets you can,
- 1:10:21you can do that. You're awesome first.
- 1:10:26I missed the question, Mike. I'm sorry.
- 1:10:29It was no question. It was basically a recognition
- 1:10:30that you guys are in a unique spot to do some kind of Bitcoin
- 1:10:33denominated return profile because you have other assets
- 1:10:36that you can incorporate into a structured product.
- 1:10:39You're not, you're not sitting at a like a hedge fund or a
- 1:10:42crypto lending desk lending out Bitcoin to traders to swing it
- 1:10:47around to potentially give you back your two to 5% or whatever
- 1:10:50you're doing. You can structure it in
- 1:10:51traditional products that are less volatile have like, you
- 1:10:54know, claims on it from other regulatory, you know,
- 1:10:57relationships that you know that this asset sitting infused with
- 1:11:01these other assets when you make loans out or however you would,
- 1:11:04you know, source the additional capital for investors parking at
- 1:11:07Bitcoin with you. What I would say is that one of
- 1:11:11the things that we're obviously doing with the dollar based fund
- 1:11:15is we're allocating to strategies where hedge funds can
- 1:11:19use it as collateral, right? So they're using the dollar as
- 1:11:23collateral, they're doing a basis trade or they're doing a
- 1:11:25volatility arbitrage trade. But now we switch that out and
- 1:11:28we say, OK, it's Bitcoin. Like your startup companies, we
- 1:11:33say take the Bitcoin, make the return on the Bitcoin.
- 1:11:37And then that then is providing you as they say, you know, maybe
- 1:11:41you're not going to make the same spread as you might make
- 1:11:43with the dollars, but we don't care if it's a, you know, 358
- 1:11:48percent return in Bitcoin, then I think, you know, and any
- 1:11:54Bitcoin or I know will be pretty happy with that as a return
- 1:11:57profile delivered to you by a Swiss banking group.
- 1:12:00And that's that's the thing that's starting to be of
- 1:12:05interest. And I think that's why what you
- 1:12:07guys are doing is also of interest.
- 1:12:10Do you have any target IRR on the fund?
- 1:12:15That's a good question. Brian May be able to speak to it
- 1:12:19a little better. On the would I look at it, I
- 1:12:21look at it a little, I look at it from the opportunity cost of
- 1:12:24the Bitcoin that's being given up and then where we look at
- 1:12:27from an equity perspective. So the percentage of Bitcoin
- 1:12:31like we basically have a higher hurdle rate.
- 1:12:34We make an allocation of looking at double digit equity
- 1:12:37percentages in businesses. And to Brian's point, because
- 1:12:40ultimately we look at a company raising once, if not maybe twice
- 1:12:43total. And so it's less from a total.
- 1:12:46Like when you look at IRR from a acquisition perspective, most
- 1:12:51companies from venture are looking to get acquired.
- 1:12:54And a lot of this thesis was based on building on ramp where
- 1:12:56we built with Bitcoin as its denomination because we were
- 1:12:59spending our own money to build the fund.
- 1:13:01And so the way we looked at is from a downside, how do we
- 1:13:04protect and the downside is from a Bitcoin positive business.
- 1:13:07So we can, you know, pair bills and feed our family.
- 1:13:10And the upside starts to look like venture from equity value
- 1:13:13being delivered to the enterprise value of the company.
- 1:13:16So you get the downside protection of a solid business
- 1:13:18and the upside of anything where it can go.
- 1:13:20But it's just, it's in congruence with like how you
- 1:13:23would build in general because you would, you don't know, I
- 1:13:25like, you know, like a baby, you don't know if it's going to be
- 1:13:27Michael Jordan or it's just going to play high school
- 1:13:28basketball. You can only foster the
- 1:13:30environment in which it's been brought into the world.
- 1:13:33And same thing with an entrepreneur.
- 1:13:35And so to your point, the downside is protected by
- 1:13:38reoccurring revenue to return the BTC back to the investor.
- 1:13:43So the downside is protected by the reoccurring revenue to
- 1:13:46return back to the investor from the OR the allocation
- 1:13:49perspective. The upside is the equity value
- 1:13:52from an acquisition perspective. And then just depending on the
- 1:13:55type of firm you might be able to buy hold that you're
- 1:13:58returning capital to LP's investors similar to like
- 1:14:02something how we think about honor.
- 1:14:03If you're building this as a generational like private
- 1:14:05banking firm. And then the upside for certain
- 1:14:08investments would be like, well, it's bright for a bank.
- 1:14:10This is partially where we're looking at certain lending
- 1:14:12businesses because banks are just going to need to buy this
- 1:14:14because it's very right for acquisition versus building
- 1:14:18because the custody is really fundamental to all lending that
- 1:14:21even though nobody talks about it because you got to make sure
- 1:14:23the underlying is secure, transparent, or you basically
- 1:14:26get what you wake up one day and you're offsides.
- 1:14:29And it's part, I don't know if Jackson shared of maybe we can
- 1:14:32pull it up, but our models really like the the cornerstone
- 1:14:36of all of this because we feel that we have this in in bitcoins
- 1:14:40adoption, this inflection point where the market believed the
- 1:14:45market effectively is believed, especially on the Bitcoin side.
- 1:14:47We're going to scale with self custody.
- 1:14:49We're going to scale with plastic devices.
- 1:14:51And if you really think about it, it's just like literally
- 1:14:53impossible to to do simply because at a certain point
- 1:14:55people just start breaking in everybody's houses and like
- 1:14:58robbing their families. Like that's just what happens
- 1:14:59when you hold billions or hundreds of millions of dollars.
- 1:15:03But then the other alternative was you leave it all on
- 1:15:05Coinbase, which also can't happen.
- 1:15:08And so that's really, yeah, big component of this is that
- 1:15:12nobody's really bringing solutions to the market of like,
- 1:15:14how do we actually create structured products when
- 1:15:17somebody's holding, which we all probably on this podcast believe
- 1:15:20somebody's going to hold anywhere between 70 to 100% of
- 1:15:23their wealth and BTC, Well, that's not going to happen on a
- 1:15:25plastic device. Like people will never get
- 1:15:27there. You'll just hold the base
- 1:15:28dollars because at least they can't burn down or get hit with
- 1:15:31a hurricane. The other side of it is you're
- 1:15:33not going to leave it on Coinbase because we all know
- 1:15:35that's the probably the worst thing you could ever do if
- 1:15:37you're holding your wealth and BTC.
- 1:15:39And so that's where this multi institution model comes about.
- 1:15:42But then you can start to really with the new design servers
- 1:15:45create other structured products.
- 1:15:47So lending is a great example because now you have it's
- 1:15:50basically governance built into the the custody model, which you
- 1:15:54can't do with gold, right? That's kind of where gold
- 1:15:55failed, as you had to leave it with a central entity.
- 1:15:59Mike, I have a question for you in terms of this is a debate I
- 1:16:03had in Bitcoin Amsterdam. I was on a panel talking about
- 1:16:07both venture and hedge fund strategies in in crypto and
- 1:16:10Bitcoin. And the the the question came
- 1:16:15and the way I answered it was the question was can you invest
- 1:16:20in a non profitable company and have them put Bitcoin on the
- 1:16:24balance sheet? So my question to you is, do
- 1:16:28you, is your funds Series A, are you targeting cash flow positive
- 1:16:33businesses or are you still at very early stage seed for these
- 1:16:37businesses in terms of what you're doing?
- 1:16:40It's, it's a great question. I don't think nonprofitable
- 1:16:42businesses should put Bitcoin on their balance sheet or not to be
- 1:16:46nonprofit, not to be nonprofitable.
- 1:16:48It's just it's it's actually more of an art than a science,
- 1:16:52because if you don't have any more bullets in the chamber, you
- 1:16:55can't do it. If you do have bullets in the
- 1:16:57chamber, then you can't because you have to basically price the
- 1:17:00risk. And what I mean by that is this
- 1:17:01isn't similar like what we weren't profitable when we
- 1:17:04started on ramp, but we put all of our treasury in Bitcoin
- 1:17:06because we had bullets in the chamber.
- 1:17:07We know people, we can raise capital.
- 1:17:08I hold Bitcoin, I could lend it to the business.
- 1:17:10So you have to be able to have bullet that it's a it's a it's
- 1:17:13an art than a it's more art than science.
- 1:17:16But then to your other point, we're pre seed, seed, seed, but
- 1:17:19ultimately like I would say less of around.
- 1:17:22We're at the end of the day value investors.
- 1:17:25And so we when everybody talks and venture about access, it's
- 1:17:28like there's no such thing as access in Bitcoin.
- 1:17:30People will take your money if you go to them.
- 1:17:32Like if you put on Twitter, I'm restarting a company.
- 1:17:34People like any Bitcoin, unless it's like some crazy fun that is
- 1:17:38just like completely unaligned people will take Fiat money.
- 1:17:43But where access really comes out is if you've built and you
- 1:17:45know how to build and people don't need your money, they need
- 1:17:48your expertise. And so one of our recent
- 1:17:50companies that's come in is already cash flow positive,
- 1:17:53generating about 3 to $4 million, doesn't need the
- 1:17:55capital. They've been approached, but
- 1:17:57they've been hitting their head against engineering design and
- 1:18:00all the things that you need to when you're trying to scale.
- 1:18:02And so they're literally giving us a double digit percentage of
- 1:18:05their business to incorporate all the things.
- 1:18:07And so we're going to just start generating BTC right into the
- 1:18:10fund, right off the investment. And so that's the idea there.
- 1:18:19And going back to your earlier question, Rich, just on the sort
- 1:18:22of target, I would think of it more as like a multiple
- 1:18:25uninvested capital of like 1.25 X in Bitcoin terms.
- 1:18:30That would be in Bitcoin terms. So that's, that's sort of what
- 1:18:33you were sort of alluding to around like it's perfectly fine
- 1:18:39if the if the numbers themselves are smaller, if they're in
- 1:18:41Bitcoin terms, right. And so it's like, absolutely,
- 1:18:44that's sort of the mindset you have to get behind.
- 1:18:45Mm hmm. Yeah, no, I'd agree completely.
- 1:18:51Well, Rich, very good, want to be mindful of your time we're
- 1:18:55closing up here. Anything we didn't touch on that
- 1:18:59maybe you just wanted to share some quick thoughts on or if
- 1:19:01not, where's the best place to directs people that enjoyed the
- 1:19:05show today and want to either follow your work or your podcast
- 1:19:09or get in touch with you? I appreciate that, Jackson.
- 1:19:14Yeah. The podcast is called Seize the
- 1:19:16Future Syz. One word.
- 1:19:19You can find it on Twitter. It's on obviously on YouTube and
- 1:19:22Spotify and all of that. And then I'm at Richard Byworth
- 1:19:27on Twitter and I think on LinkedIn as well.
- 1:19:32LinkedIn is, I think I'm the only Richard Byworth in the
- 1:19:36world. So you'll you'll be able to find
- 1:19:39me. It's a bit of a rare name, but
- 1:19:42yeah, if I'm not the only one in the world, I'm the one that's
- 1:19:45working at Seas Capital. So there you go.
- 1:19:49Awesome. Well, it was a pleasure, Rich,
- 1:19:50really enjoyed getting to know you today and appreciate all the
- 1:19:53perspectives you shared. So thanks for coming on.
- 1:19:56Yeah, this is a great. Chat, guys, it was a lot of fun.
- 1:19:58Yeah. Thanks, Rich.
- 1:19:59Thank you. Thank you.
- 1:20:02Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:20:04If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:20:06episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:20:09app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:20:11today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:20:14Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Rat Media is
- 1:20:16for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:20:19nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:20:22Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:20:25to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact
- 1:20:28to schedule a consultation with one of our private client
- 1:20:31advisors.