Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Trust Is Not an Internal Control: David Reed on Fraud and the Supervisory Committee
Transcript
- 0:00Mark Treichel: Hey, everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark Trakel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03I'm excited today to be here with David Reed of Reed & Jolly.
- 0:06David, how are you today?
- 0:08David Reed: I'm doing absolutely fabulous, Mark.
- 0:10Thanks for, uh, thanks for having me on board.
- 0:12Mark Treichel: You got it.
- 0:13Well, I've had you on a couple times, and I first met you back at NCUA.
- 0:16You helped us do some strategic planning, as I recalled, and that was, those were
- 0:20always fun sessions, and I always enjoy chatting with you here on the podcast.
- 0:25But if someone isn't familiar with your work or hasn't seen, uh, seen or heard
- 0:29you on the podcast, could you kind of give a little bit of your back- of
- 0:32your credit union-related background?
- 0:34David Reed: Yeah, absolutely.
- 0:35So I'm a recovering general counsel.
- 0:38Uh, I've been an attorney for, uh, for, uh, a lot of years.
- 0:42Uh, but I spent about eight years as a senior executive general counsel with
- 0:46a federal charter, and that's how I, um, kind of fell into the cooperative
- 0:52movement, uh, in the late '90s.
- 0:54Uh, and then uh, not long before, uh, we met and I always think may
- 0:59you live in unique times- Right
- 1:01so that would've been probably, uh, '08, '09, uh, I left and
- 1:06left and formed my own practice.
- 1:09I practice with a gentleman by the name of Bruce Jolly, and all
- 1:11we do is focus on, uh, credit unions as outside general counsel.
- 1:15And I do, uh, an awful lot of, of training, uh, both virtually and live.
- 1:20And then I do, uh, you know, a handful of strategic planning sessions, and
- 1:24then, you know, top it off with a few, uh, operational you know, projects,
- 1:28be it uh, you know, be it governance, be it, uh, collections, be it credit
- 1:32reporting, what- whatever comes along.
- 1:34And, uh, and, and just loving life.
- 1:37It's, it's a great industry and I'd like to think I could bring I could bring a
- 1:42unique voice, uh, and experience to it.
- 1:45Mark Treichel: No, I get that.
- 1:46I get that.
- 1:46And, uh, I had recently done one or two podcasts, two podcasts on
- 1:51Jackson Area Federal Credit Union.
- 1:52I think you had listened to one of those, and you shot me a text or an
- 1:55email, and we were kind of chatting back and forth, and I think you were j-
- 1:59just on the cusp of doing a supervisory committee fraud-type training.
- 2:04So, uh, that kind of triggered us to then say, "Hey, it's time
- 2:06to get back on the podcast."
- 2:08So, so let's, I'm gonna tee it up.
- 2:10Jackson Area Supervisory Committee, fraud.
- 2:13Uh, so- What's going, what's going on in your world?
- 2:15David Reed: I mean, uh, you know, in a tribute to, I guess
- 2:18it's, uh, is it Macaulay Culkin?
- 2:20You know, it's, it'sâ¦
- 2:21Mark Treichel: Right.
- 2:23David Reed: Um, and yeah, and w- when I, when I shot you that, I was just kicking
- 2:28off a two-day national, uh, supervisory committee school And talk about timing.
- 2:37And, and, you know, in our world, uh, uh, maybe we probably don't need to say it,
- 2:41but for all of the, uh, all of, uh, of the viewers and listeners, you know, no
- 2:45one relishes when events like this happen.
- 2:48But it would be and no pun intended, it would be just about criminal if
- 2:52we didn't take the opportunity and ask the what if questions, right?
- 2:56Yep.
- 2:56And, um, I told that group ⦠Uh, I have a visitor who's
- 3:01gonna, who's gonna say hello.
- 3:01Mark Treichel: All right.
- 3:03David Reed: Um, and, uh, I told that group that the you know, their timing couldn't
- 3:08be any better because i- in- in my initial review of what was going on, you know,
- 3:14the largest credit union fraud, um, that had ever been, um, committed, and that we
- 3:19were gonna be utilizing those allegations, and let's say that word several times,
- 3:23allegations, allegations, allegations.
- 3:26Um, and, um, we were gonna be using that a- as a learning tool, as a process to
- 3:32ask ourselves certain questions a- as far as looking at looking at what we do
- 3:37feel we know so far, and then looking at the general structure, uh, of a
- 3:42federally chartered credit union and the vast majority of state-chartered
- 3:45credit unions, and then really breaking down the role of each of the players
- 3:49a- and, uh, and bringing back the question, which, which is gonna be
- 3:54would we catch that at our credit union?
- 3:58And so that's where I am with it.
- 4:00Like everybody else, I'm monitoring what comes out uh, at least as of a few hours
- 4:05ago, uh, what I'm able to see publicly.
- 4:08And, and I know we both appreciate that, right?
- 4:10In between interviews and chatting with people that are in different
- 4:14positions we always have to stick to what is known publicly.
- 4:19Mark Treichel: Sure.
- 4:19David Reed: Um-
- 4:20Mark Treichel: Right
- 4:20⦠David Reed: uh, but the last big thing that happened was that the NCUA's,
- 4:24uh, lawsuit, of course, was expanded.
- 4:26Uh, they added additional allegations, and they added a third person, right?
- 4:31And I think when you and I talked, uh, it was right before they did that.
- 4:34So now we kind of have the, the triangle, if you will, right?
- 4:38And, uh, not, not Cressy's fraud triangle but the, you know, we ha- we have,
- 4:44um, you know, the fraud was allegedly committed by the CEO, her husband, who
- 4:48was a highly placed regulator, uh, in the state of Mississippi, and now we have,
- 4:54I believe, a branch manager who came in at the invitation, uh, allegedly, of
- 4:59the CEO, and was a longtime, uh, friend.
- 5:04Mark Treichel: Yeah, boy, you know, the, the more people that, uh, that you getâ¦
- 5:07Obviously the husband, wife, uh, that doesn't surprise me and, and, uh, if
- 5:11you've only got one person doing it, it makes it impossible for them to ever go
- 5:14on vacation 'cause there's no one- Right ⦠there to put, when the water comes g-
- 5:19through the hole in the side of the boat, you gotta have someone to hold it there.
- 5:22Absolutely.
- 5:23Maybe that's the, maybe that's the role the branch manager played over time.
- 5:25It got, uh, the juggling of all the, of all the fraud and keeping it from
- 5:29be- getting caught, maybe that's why that, uh, that person came in.
- 5:32But of course, we know that ultimately there will be an
- 5:35inspector general audit by the NCUA.
- 5:37Uh, they'll do a lot of interviews.
- 5:38They're doingâ¦
- 5:39the fact that they're suing, that's gonna the documentation that comes
- 5:42from that suit, uh, will help the IG do what they're gonna do there.
- 5:47But so going back to the training and the classes that you've had,
- 5:50so would we have caught that?
- 5:51So what were some of the discussions with the supervisory committee,
- 5:55um, i- if, if I was a fly on the wall o- of those trainings, whatâ¦
- 5:59To the extent you can share, you know, specifics of- Oh,
- 6:02David Reed: No, a- absolutely ⦠maybe.
- 6:03Well, I think you'll recognize the themes.
- 6:06First of all, i- in every single element, management, staff the
- 6:11auditors, the examiners, uh, the insurers, l- let's remind ourselves,
- 6:17this is a very human process, right?
- 6:19Right.
- 6:20So we can have regulations, we can have best practices, but at the end of the
- 6:23day, somebody somewhere is gonna say to themselves, "Okay, you know, I, I think
- 6:28David, you know, I think David's a thief.
- 6:31I think David's doing something wrong."
- 6:32And when that's a well-loved person, right, under the view of, let's
- 6:36say, the board or the supervisory committee or an examiner not a CPA,
- 6:40uh, you know, opinion on it, but whoever, not the, um, their auditor,
- 6:44someone who's known them for years and years it becomes a tough question.
- 6:48P- people, they're like, "Oh, well, you know, I've known him for so long."
- 6:52And so my lead in would be this, always remember that trust is
- 6:57not an internal control, right?
- 7:00A- and so that's what I, uh, I led with on this.
- 7:04I said, "Let's break down what we know."
- 7:09Uh, and y- y- you know, we, we know from the supervisory committee perspective,
- 7:15the, the, uh, the top of their obligations are, are all focused on internal controls.
- 7:22When you look at, look at it from the federal perspective, I mean, 715 is
- 7:26just internal controls as mentioned dozens and dozens and dozens time.
- 7:29Uh, i- in the actual marching orders, 715.3,
- 7:32uh, you know, i- it, it, two of the four kind of, uh, pillars of that
- 7:37just talk about internal controls.
- 7:39Are, you know, are, have they been set up, created by management, set
- 7:42up to do what the board wants to do, and then tested by the, um, you
- 7:47know, by the board of directors.
- 7:49So it was a very good focus to take that word that's used all the
- 7:53time a- and make it meaningful.
- 7:55Sure.
- 7:56It, it's not a regulatory word.
- 7:57It, it is, it's policies, it's procedures it's philosophies, it's, it- it's
- 8:03you know, random audits, it's dual controls, it's all of these things.
- 8:07Um, so that's what I focused them on.
- 8:09And it- it's one of these, you know, situations that, yeah, th- this
- 8:13it's horrible for the members and the, a- and the Jackson community.
- 8:17It, it's just horrible.
- 8:18They will never regain that trust.
- 8:20The immeasurable damage that this has done i- is you know, will continue
- 8:25for years and years and years to come.
- 8:27However, also for years to come, we'll be looking at this.
- 8:31Mark Treichel: Sure.
- 8:31David Reed: And, and, and we will be breaking out, uh, you know, again,
- 8:35n- not as a gotcha way, but the would'ves, could'ves, and should'ves.
- 8:39And so that was my initial focus.
- 8:40And, and I, I will say that one thing I continued kind of throughout i- is, again,
- 8:47when we look at the allegations, if we just look at the behavior, and I don't
- 8:53think I need to say uh, allegedly anymore.
- 8:55A- again, these are all just, I'm speaking from the NCUA's lawsuit as amended.
- 9:00Mark Treichel: You got it.
- 9:01David Reed: And if we look, as memory serves me, from 2024 to that fateful
- 9:08meeting, I believe in May, April or May of 2027 you know, we're looking
- 9:14at, uh, you know, over $20 million that passed not just out of a credit
- 9:19unit, which let's face it, would just be an unbelievable uh, uh, fraud.
- 9:25Um, well, unfortunately not unbelievable.
- 9:27It would be a massive fraud.
- 9:28But we're talking about, uh, monies that passed either through the CEO's account.
- 9:34Mark Treichel: Right.
- 9:35David Reed: And then when she was confronted, she shut down
- 9:38that account, and another 10 to $12 million passed through her
- 9:43husband's account at the credit unit.
- 9:47And I, I look at that a- and I just say to myselves, "Okay, you know, how many,
- 9:54uh, how many people in this roomâ¦"
- 9:55And there were probably, I don't know, there were over 100 people in the room.
- 9:58How many of the people in the room, when you think of yourself as insider abuse,
- 10:03insider loans or, or account activity-
- 10:06Mark Treichel: Right
- 10:06David Reed: how many of you are just looking at that?
- 10:09And we've both seen that, Mark, unfortunately.
- 10:11I mean, typically it's with a much smaller credit union- Sure ⦠where
- 10:14you have a procedures, uh, audit that's not real, you know, real good and, and,
- 10:19you know, you ask the question, "Did anybody look at the CEO's account?"
- 10:24A- and, and, and everybodyâ¦
- 10:25Well, not everybody, but oftentimes people goâ¦
- 10:28I remember working a fraud that made some amount of national headlines, and,
- 10:33uh, i- in trying to do my job, but also to answer those nagging questions I
- 10:40asked the supervisory committee, I said, "Well, in looking at your documents
- 10:43that you provided me, it said that you did random loan audit- audits."
- 10:49And this particular fraud, uh, a good amount of the money was, was moved
- 10:53through non-existent loans or improperly, uh, modified or, or created loans.
- 11:00And I said, "It says that you did random loan audits, and you've
- 11:03been doing that for a while."
- 11:04I, I said, "Tell me how you did that."
- 11:06And the first thing out of their mouth is like, "Oh, yeah, we're very proud of it.
- 11:09We had a worksheet.
- 11:10We would go into the meeting room.
- 11:12The CEO had the, uh, had the, uh, selection of loans we were gonna review,
- 11:18even did the initial filling out.
- 11:20We looked through those.
- 11:21We could ask any questions, so we thought we did a, a really thorough job."
- 11:24Mark Treichel: Yeah, he made our job real easy.
- 11:26David Reed: Real easy.
- 11:26What about the CEO?
- 11:27And they're like, "Well, what about him?"
- 11:30Mark Treichel: Yep, yep.
- 11:31Yeah, those insider account reviews, it's important for NCUA to look
- 11:34at them, it's important for the supervisory committee to look at them.
- 11:38It's, you know, you, you can't view it as stepping on toes, uh,
- 11:42or you know, it diff- some of the questions the supervisory committee
- 11:45has to ask are difficult, right?
- 11:47Some of the questions that a, a, an internal auditor that's on staff that
- 11:51has to ask management is difficult.
- 11:53And clearly some of the questions NCUA has to ask, uh, it, it sits into the
- 11:59same vein, and then it is human, right?
- 12:02Absolutely.
- 12:02So you hear a pl- you hear a plausible answer, right?
- 12:05But going back to, was it, was it Reagan?
- 12:07Um,
- 12:09David Reed: trust- Trust but verify
- 12:10⦠Mark Treichel: trust but verify, right?
- 12:11David Reed: Yeah.
- 12:11Salt, salt too.
- 12:12Salt too.
- 12:13Absolutely.
- 12:13The nuclear, the nuclear treaty, and I use that all the time.
- 12:16I call him Uncle Ronnie.
- 12:17No, no disrespect.
- 12:19Right.
- 12:19But, uh, a- absolutely.
- 12:20And, you know, going back to that human part you know, the internal
- 12:24auditor, all right, well, u- under proper best practices, they should
- 12:28have a direct line to the supervisory committee or audit committee- Yeah
- 12:31dotted line to the CEO because they're an employee.
- 12:33And yet we all know if that CEI looks at him and says, "You know,"
- 12:37uh, this, uh, if this, uh, CEO looks at him and says, "You know what?
- 12:40I don't have time for this today.
- 12:41Come back," that auditor's probably gonna slink away.
- 12:44The supervisory committee, uh, um, you know, hey, they know this person.
- 12:48They've known this person for a while.
- 12:49They just got approved for a great, uh, you know, training adventure somewhere.
- 12:54So, the examiners- Yeah, ⦠didn't bring up anything on it.
- 12:57The auditors didn't bring up anything on it, so, you know, what's the issue?
- 13:01Mark Treichel: Um- Did, did, did you have any discussions
- 13:03about, um, agreed-upon procedure?
- 13:06So there's, in my mind, there's the full opinion on it required over 500 million.
- 13:10David Reed: Yes.
- 13:11Mark Treichel: There's, there's agreed-upon procedures below 500, and
- 13:14then there's the actual, the supervisory committee doing it themselves.
- 13:18Oh, my gosh.
- 13:18David Reed: Did you kind of- Yeah, yeah,
- 13:19Mark Treichel: yeah.
- 13:19The, uh- Did you, did you pivot into those three?
- 13:21Did you talk about-
- 13:22David Reed: I call it the clip- I call it the clipboard audit, yeah.
- 13:24Mark Treichel: Right?
- 13:24Yeah.
- 13:25You
- 13:25David Reed: know- And you have to be very, very, uh, kind of very, uh,
- 13:28um, ob- obviously very small on that.
- 13:30Yeah, so, we did have discussions on all of that.
- 13:33And again, so in addition to internal controls, let, let's stick with,
- 13:37you know, we'll be Sesame Streets and, and stick with the letter
- 13:39I you know, independence, right?
- 13:42That much of what- should have detected this the alleged behavior.
- 13:49It seems to me that the an occasional review of the senior executive's
- 13:55accounts, even if it's just volume, right?
- 13:58Even if you don't look at, uh, you know, Tiffany's a- and a Hong Kong jeweler
- 14:04a- and real estate agents in Boca.
- 14:06Even, even if you just look at volume that should be able to be done remotely.
- 14:11Sure.
- 14:12You know, if you have to go in and ask the CEO to release the hold on
- 14:18their account, to unblock it, uh, or to, "Could you print these?"
- 14:22I mean, "Can you just print your account statement?
- 14:24Oh, hey, David, I'll, I'll just print these out.
- 14:26Let me tab them and highlight them because you may have some questions,
- 14:29so just divert your attention to the brightly yellow-colored things."
- 14:33That's right.
- 14:34"And I have a story about that usually involves a joke or something that will
- 14:38raise your concern about me and- Sure ⦠and show me your love and affection."
- 14:41Sure.
- 14:42So most of these should be able to be done uh, you know, with-
- 14:45without anybody else looking at it.
- 14:47And let's face it, you know, uh, you know, NCA will tell you, uh, my gosh,
- 14:51you know, uh, CPAs will tell you, "We're not conducting a fraud audit."
- 14:54Mark Treichel: Correct.
- 14:54David Reed: But if they're conducting an audit on the internal controls of
- 15:00the most risky people within the credit union- A- and, and I say this all the
- 15:06time to, uh, to supervisory committees.
- 15:08I, Iâ¦
- 15:08How many of you guys do, pop teller audits?
- 15:11And, you know, a third of them proudly raise their hands, and I
- 15:14go, "Okay, you know, no offense, but you're wasting your time," right?
- 15:17Because, uh, they are the least likely to hit you big.
- 15:20You know why?
- 15:21'Cause you count their money before they start, and you
- 15:23count their money afterwards.
- 15:24The most likely to cause problems, and statistically we know this from, uh, you
- 15:28know, NCUSIF statistics, e- especially at, at credit unions below a couple hundred
- 15:32million, is gonna be internal fraud.
- 15:34You know- Right ⦠who has the greatest access?
- 15:36Who are the single points of compromise?
- 15:38Who can cover their trails?
- 15:39Who know, who knows what you're looking for, when you're coming?
- 15:44Who packages most of this stuff?
- 15:46And it's them.
- 15:47So yeah, it does go back into that trust but verify.
- 15:50And I- I would imagine a lot of people that, that, that are watching your
- 15:56podcast, uh, are looking at other people maybe around the room or are making
- 16:00a note, you know, on a piece of paper somewhere, and they're coming back and
- 16:03they're saying, "D- do we look at that?
- 16:05I don't ever recall looking at that.
- 16:07Is that something we should be doing?"
- 16:09Mark Treichel: A- a- and how often, right?
- 16:10And, uh- Right ⦠and, uh, yeah, it's, uh, it's cra- And, and then,
- 16:14like, the, you know, the volume, right?
- 16:15You talked about 20 million going through one account.
- 16:18You shut it down.
- 16:18You have got 10 million going through the other account.
- 16:20But 20 million, roughly, that's probably 10, t- 10, 12, 14% of
- 16:24the credit union's assets, right?
- 16:26David Reed: D- d- d- d- It just- Yeah.
- 16:27D- don't evenâ¦
- 16:28I mean, that that's this.
- 16:29The percentage, 95 million on a 260 million, and then overnight, of
- 16:35course, overnight all the sentences were redone because it went from the
- 16:39$260 million, uh, credit union to suddenly, the $160 million credit union.
- 16:45Mark Treichel: Sure.
- 16:45Sure.
- 16:46And then, and I mean, I, and going back to the first podcast I did, when I looked at
- 16:49the data, I ran ana- I ran some analysis to compare it to other credit unions.
- 16:54It was the only credit union over $5 million in the country that
- 16:58had a loan-to-share, loan-to-asset ratio of less than 27%, and was
- 17:04borrowing money of any kind, right?
- 17:07So you don't have any loans, but you need, you have this need for
- 17:10millions and millions of dollars of borrowings 'cause you need the cash.
- 17:15Lo- a logical thing, and 20, uh, uh, hindsight is 20/20.
- 17:19I mean, I, when I was an examiner, I was on two years, Went up to, I, I'd
- 17:24done a follow-up at a state-chartered in the Midwest, and, uh, the state didn't
- 17:30trust this guy and, and, uh, uh, lo and behold he ended up having stole money.
- 17:35The time I came back the next time, uh, it, it got, it, it got, uh,
- 17:39it got bloody in a lot of ways.
- 17:41Uh, but the first ⦠I, I started going, how did I not see this
- 17:44when I was in here six months ago?
- 17:46Right.
- 17:46And it w- You know, you got 24 hours, 32 hours, 40 hours.
- 17:50You get an answer to this, you get an answer to this it makes sense.
- 17:53Uh, and, and you move along.
- 17:55But yeah, that trust but verify is a, a big thing.
- 17:58So what about, uh, any discussions, any thoughts in when you're having those
- 18:02training about the sh- should CPA opinion audits be required below 500 million?
- 18:07David Reed: I mean, boy, th- th- this has been a question, and I, I put
- 18:10this up, I put this up there with the should the currency transaction report
- 18:15threshold, uh, be raised from $10,000?
- 18:18'Cause chance ⦠I, I, I don't know, uh, but chances are that number has p-
- 18:23has been set at 500 million for almost as long as CTRs have been set for 10,000.
- 18:28Right.
- 18:28And, and my gut feeling is yeah, absolutely.
- 18:32And I have, I have a, a number of clients that are below 500 million- They
- 18:36do ⦠uh, that are getting CPA audits.
- 18:37Yeah.
- 18:37Because let's face it, CPA audits add value.
- 18:40They add you know, they add extra accountability, they add extra assurance,
- 18:45which is what internal controls and everything else, you know, is.
- 18:48And we haven't even gotten into the, that whole, if you ever need
- 18:51an example of, of why you need to verify financials this is it, right?
- 18:55Right.
- 18:55Because that $95 million wasn't where, uh, it was supposed to be.
- 19:00And I'm gonna go ahead and use a, uh, a, a regular regulatory phrase and say
- 19:05credit unions need to be aware of their size and complexity So they need to
- 19:10know what oars they have in the water.
- 19:11They need to know what doors and windows, you know, they have open and available
- 19:17to offer their products and services.
- 19:19A- and, at some point, uh, you know, that cost ⦠A- a- and, you know, the two big
- 19:26things I always hear, oh, it costs too much or when the CPAs come in, especially
- 19:31when they come in the first time, they're gonna take so much staff time away.
- 19:36Yeah, if I had to pull that number somewhere, and, uh, and of course you
- 19:41go back to the hindsight, you know, I, I, I would pull that number down to 250.
- 19:45I, I think that's a, I think that's a, a, a safe number.
- 19:48And let's face it we have a situation with the advent of technology and the
- 19:54efficiencies that that offers that 20 years ago you didn't have smaller
- 19:58credit unions that were offering an almost identical- Absolutely
- 20:01product load- Yeah, very important ⦠to the big, to the big ones.
- 20:04And now you have a $100 million credit union, if you go to their
- 20:07website a- a- and, well, do you have Zelle, do you have Apple Pay?
- 20:11Can I do this?
- 20:12Can I do account to account?
- 20:13Can I, do you have commercial accounts?
- 20:15Hey, my brother has a marijuana dispensary, can you work with him?
- 20:18Yes, yes, yes.
- 20:20So I mean, I do think that that $500 million, uh, i- if somebody's just
- 20:25counting on that, uh, I, I think they're counting on the, on the wrong fingers.
- 20:29Mark Treichel: You're right.
- 20:30And, and I can't emphasize enough, if you're at 450, if you're at 425, if
- 20:34you're at 350, r- the reg might not require, the act might not require
- 20:38you to get your opinion audit.
- 20:39But if you're not getting an opinion audit you might wanna rethink that,
- 20:43'cause you can- Absolutely ⦠you can afford it, and it's worth, it's worth
- 20:46every penny as far as, uh, you know, a little bit of the Good Housekeeping
- 20:50Seal of Approval, if you will.
- 20:52David Reed: No, and, and I think that's what it is.
- 20:53That's what the CPA uh, that's what that CPA signature, uh, uh, gives you.
- 20:58And, um, I just did a training on, um, on a supervisory committee,
- 21:03uh, making that decision, do they retain their auditor, do they change
- 21:06the auditor, what's that look like?
- 21:08But especially if you're getting it done for the first time go,
- 21:11let's go back to that independence.
- 21:12You can add scope to it, right?
- 21:16So we, we know what the, uh, what the current NCUA regulations say
- 21:20about what has to be in that audit.
- 21:22But, you know, I tell people all the time, you know, it's a
- 21:24little bit like a cafeteria plan.
- 21:25If you wanted to add a segment on, on, on a relatively detailed review
- 21:30o- of uh, you know, senior executives, insider, uh, um, you know, accounts,
- 21:36you can just add that, right?
- 21:37I mean, that, that, that, that just, boom you add it, uh, you
- 21:41add it right, um, right on there.
- 21:44And, going back and looking at this, uh, you know, I, I don't think I had
- 21:49been aware of that I guess I had, 'cause I think you had mentioned
- 21:51it before, the, uh, the loan to share a- a- and, and borrowing.
- 21:56Uh, but, you know, I, I also think about the fact, okay, this person's entry
- 22:00point, I think, to the to the credit union was a CFO, and when they ascended
- 22:05to CEO, they never filled that spot.
- 22:09Mark Treichel: Ah, well, she's very efficient.
- 22:11David Reed: Ve- You know, and you know what?
- 22:12Hey, Mark I don't mind doing this work.
- 22:14It's all right.
- 22:15Yeah, right.
- 22:15Now, I'm gonna keep my mind out, 'cause boy, I'd love a, a good go-getter,
- 22:18but for right now, I can handle this, and we'll save some money.
- 22:21Mark Treichel: Yeah, board, you know, that frees up more training opportunities-
- 22:24David Reed: Absolutely, yeah
- 22:25for the board.
- 22:25Have you guys ever been to the Galapagos?
- 22:29Mark Treichel: That's right.
- 22:29That's right.
- 22:31Oh, boy.
- 22:32Uh, I've got a couple other topics written down here I wanted to kick off you, but,
- 22:35um, what, any, any other thoughts on fraud or supervisory committee before
- 22:39I pivot into a couple other topics?
- 22:41David Reed: Yeah, I mean, uh, uh, we can we as a, as a credit union,
- 22:46and again, I, I think I should also confess that I'm a con- I'm a
- 22:49recovering supervisory committee member.
- 22:51There you go.
- 22:52I served on the supervisory committee for 10 years.
- 22:54I was, I was chairman, I think, for six or seven years.
- 22:57But you can create a process, not only an audit plan, and you don't need an
- 23:01internal auditor for an audit plan.
- 23:03This is just what you're gonna look at, but you can build it out.
- 23:07A- and you mentioned this earlier, you know, the how often you can
- 23:09build it out, that periodically you, you look at these kinds of things.
- 23:13And there are already processes within the credit union that are designed to
- 23:18tech- detect unusual behavior, right?
- 23:20Such as, oh, I don't know, countering the financing of terrorism, you know,
- 23:23Bank Secrecy Act, all of those things.
- 23:26And, you know, i- is the supervisory committee getting that information?
- 23:31Because, I'm gonna guess, and, and I don't know this, and shame on me, I should
- 23:34look it up, but I- I'm gonna guess, I'm gonna bet dollars to donuts, and, you
- 23:39know, you know me, I love a good donut.
- 23:41I'm gonna imagine that the CEO was also the Bank Secrecy Act officer.
- 23:46Um, which means any reports that came up unusual, unusual activity, which
- 23:50of course could be volume-driven- Sure ⦠uh, would've gone to their desk.
- 23:55So, you can hardwire in these lessons learned.
- 24:02You can do it in a way that's not going to kill morale or esprit de corps.
- 24:08You can do it in such ways that it's a lot ⦠It's behind the scenes, right?
- 24:12And reinforce the fact that, you know, what's one of the biggest
- 24:16things, if not the biggest thing, keeping honest people honest?
- 24:19It's fear of detection.
- 24:21Mark Treichel: That's right.
- 24:21Right?
- 24:21It's the, it's the cop car that doesn't have anybody in
- 24:24it that makes you slow down.
- 24:24David Reed: Absolutely, yeah.
- 24:25Which, a- and but, uh, maybe occasionally, right, as we're reading
- 24:29more and more, occasionally one day out of seven, there is somebody in
- 24:33Mark Treichel: it.
- 24:33There is somebody, yeah.
- 24:34David Reed: Right?
- 24:34It's, it, it, it's the Russian roulette of enforcement.
- 24:37And a- and I guess the last thing I would say on this i- is gonna be, events
- 24:41like this um, you, you know, obviously this is the most dramatic event that
- 24:45I could ever recall but on any fraud event it wasn't one thing, right?
- 24:50Uh, it, it, you know, there had to have been a cylinder- Sure ⦠of,
- 24:53of, of failures that did it.
- 24:55And, a- and we talked about having that second person that's there, right?
- 24:59So that removes a lot.
- 25:00So I'm gonna go on vacation.
- 25:02"Hey I need you to answer this."
- 25:04And now somebody gets this email or report, and it doesn't have my name on it.
- 25:09Uh, you know, you have to understand that.
- 25:11And flip side, it only takes one of those cylinders of failing.
- 25:17Right.
- 25:18Yeah.
- 25:18A whistleblower.
- 25:18Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 25:19David Reed: Uh, an auditor who happens to notice, "Wow, wait a second that
- 25:22investment, uh, verification form from this corporate, it's usually pink,
- 25:28and the one they handed me was blue.
- 25:29That, that's weird."
- 25:30And they look into it, and everything unfolds.
- 25:33Mark Treichel: Well, that, that was ⦠There, there was
- 25:35the ⦠you just triggered a thought, uh, the, the fake CDs-
- 25:39David Reed: Yeah
- 25:39⦠Mark Treichel: uh, uh, in Syracuse a- a generation ago.
- 25:41David Reed: Yeah, yeah.
- 25:41I was getting ready to say it was, it was up north.
- 25:43Mark Treichel: Yeah, it was a guy who worked for me and, and,
- 25:45uh, they were at the diner.
- 25:47David Reed: The diner, absolutely.
- 25:48And,
- 25:48Mark Treichel: and the, and the the waitress said that,
- 25:51asked what they were doing.
- 25:52They said, "We're in town doing an exam at-" "Oh, I'm a member there."
- 25:56And the ⦠One of them said, "Hey, is, is this what their CDs look like?"
- 26:00And they say, "Oh, no, that's the old letterhead."
- 26:02A- and it turned out that they had this old letterhead.
- 26:05They used fake CDs to, to show that they had- Right ⦠or it was, it was the bank.
- 26:10It was the local bank's, uh- Right, right ⦠letterhead.
- 26:13And the letterhead showed that they had CDs which secured the loan, but
- 26:16there weren't, there were no CDs.
- 26:18Right.
- 26:18And, um, l- so good, good sleuthing uh, on that on that audit.
- 26:22Well, and,
- 26:22David Reed: and just an absolute happenstance.
- 26:24And again, caused them to ask a simple question a- and it led to all that.
- 26:28Again, I mean, what we want with supervisors, we, we want
- 26:31that natural curiosity, right?
- 26:34Combined with a process that's designed to maximize their role, and their role, by
- 26:39definition, is to shine that flashlight.
- 26:42Mark Treichel: Right.
- 26:42David Reed: Are the financials correct?
- 26:44Are the policies being followed?
- 26:46Are all those internal controls are theyâ¦
- 26:48Not only are they being followed, but are they good enough?
- 26:50Mark Treichel: Absolutely.
- 26:51And then if you can play it kinda like Columbo, I'm dating
- 26:53myself there, but oh yeah, one
- 26:55David Reed: more question.
- 26:56One, one more
- 26:56Mark Treichel: question.
- 26:56Right?
- 26:56David Reed: One more question.
- 26:58I lo- I, oh man, I love Co- and that show was on for, like, 20 years.
- 27:01Mark Treichel: Peter Falk.
- 27:02It was, yeah, yeah.
- 27:03I gotta I gotta queue that up and watch some of those.
- 27:05Those, those were good.
- 27:07All right, so, I've got three other things I've got written down here.
- 27:09You can pick and play with any of them, but we've previously
- 27:12talked about succession planning.
- 27:14We've previously talked about collections, and then we have the
- 27:17whole cornucopia of the NCUA board.
- 27:21Sure.
- 27:22You've got Hauptman wanting to go over here.
- 27:23You've got Cruz having had his hearing but not having had his vote.
- 27:27David Reed: Right.
- 27:28Mark Treichel: And you've got Harper and Ostka wanting to get back on.
- 27:31And a- so NCUA board, succession planning, collections.
- 27:36Any, any thoughts on any one of those or all
- 27:39David Reed: three of them?
- 27:39Bead round.
- 27:39Yeah, a- absolutely.
- 27:40So let, let's invert up.
- 27:41Invert up, that's right.
- 27:42One of my, uh, one of my daughters is an attorney.
- 27:45A- and, uh, and she has a sense of humor, a bit of an irreverent
- 27:49sense of humor uh, like her old man.
- 27:52And uh, a couple of years ago, she sent me a T-shirt and it said it
- 27:58said, "So long, Chevron deference."
- 28:01"We'll miss you."
- 28:03And, uh, and it was, uh, it was, uh, it was just, it was absolutely fabulous.
- 28:08So I'm anticipating that I'll have a Humphreys executor,
- 28:12Mark Treichel: That's, you know what you're getting for Christmas
- 28:14⦠David Reed: yeah, there you go.
- 28:15Right?
- 28:15There you go.
- 28:15Or any of your listeners, when they get my email address, I'll
- 28:18be happy to give you my, uh-
- 28:19Mark Treichel: There
- 28:19David Reed: you go
- 28:19my PO box, and I, I have no problem, uh, you know, giving you guys, uh, you
- 28:24know, good references for good gifts.
- 28:26Um-
- 28:27Mark Treichel: Very good
- 28:27⦠David Reed: so I mean, i- it is in the same, I'm almost speechless,
- 28:31Mark, and that, that's hard for me.
- 28:32It goes back to that may you live in unique times.
- 28:34W- with the changes to Humphrey's executor, right?
- 28:37And let's remember, this administration, Trump 47, without being, uh, political,
- 28:42did not get everything it wanted i- in all of its Supreme Court cases.
- 28:46Right.
- 28:46And, and we know that their, uh, um, that their protocol is to push
- 28:52things absolutely to the edge to bring things up to the various levels a-
- 28:57and then if it doesn't work, okay, they go back to the drawing board,
- 28:59they see where the boundary's drawn.
- 29:01For Humphrey's executor what we appear we have no matter what vote, is that
- 29:06the administration has the ability to remove um, board members and,
- 29:10you know, again, carve out for the Federal Reserve board members with
- 29:14some amount o- of cart- carte blanche.
- 29:16Now, depending on how the wording is i- in, in the controlling documents,
- 29:21we know the Federal Credit Union Act did not have a for-cause wording, which
- 29:25probably does not bode well to the, for the prior board members, although I, I'm,
- 29:30I'm making no, predictions about that.
- 29:32You know, what, what I would say is that my primary concern i- is going
- 29:38forward- Right ⦠uh, that you're just gonna have at the highest level
- 29:42of these agencies, you're gonna have a clean sweep every administration.
- 29:46Because this is not, uh, this is not a Republican versus Democratic, issue.
- 29:50Now, people may say how it's applied in a particular time, it's not.
- 29:53You know, again, y- you've been inside DC, I've been inside DC for 40 years now.
- 29:58This is an executive thing.
- 30:00How much power does the executive want?
- 30:02People forget that when the Biden administration took over for the Trump 45
- 30:07administration, they only rescinded 30% of their executive orders I've had people
- 30:14guess, "Oh, they rescinded all of them."
- 30:16Really?
- 30:16You know, they, 80%.
- 30:17It was only 30%, which means that, you know, that a Democratic uh,
- 30:21president and their people looked at that and said, "Ooh, you know what?
- 30:24We're gonna keep that in our back pocket."
- 30:25Uh, what that means is, and no offense to, uh, uh, to, to well-placed, uh, you know,
- 30:31former bureaucrats, but this is gonna hand so much more power uh, to the bureaucracy.
- 30:39Uh, because you're not gonna have, uh, um, these board members that
- 30:44have been on for long enough to understand what's going on combined
- 30:47with the potential chilling effect.
- 30:49All right, uh, y- you're asking me to serve and you have- Right ⦠two
- 30:52years left on your term?
- 30:54Yeah.
- 30:55I gotta tell you, you know, I'm, I'm a, I gotta work for a few more years and- Sure
- 30:59I don't know if that's, if that's gonna work.
- 31:00So that will have a, an interesting impact uh, on you know, on, on
- 31:06the bureaucracy, on the machine.
- 31:08And again, I'm not saying good, bad, or indifferent.
- 31:10What I'm saying is i- i- is that this is gonna go beyond the next couple of years.
- 31:16Now could Congress come in a- and make changes that, that- Good point
- 31:20fix all this?
- 31:20Great point.
- 31:21Absolutely.
- 31:21A- and this, it seems to me that the Supreme Court i- in numerous
- 31:25of the cases, have come in and said well you can fix this."
- 31:28Mark Treichel: Right.
- 31:28" David Reed: But this is what we have right now."
- 31:30So, so that's gonna be quite interesting, uh, moving forward.
- 31:34A- and as far as what you just said about, uh, about the current chairman,
- 31:37Hauptman, he already has a spot.
- 31:39Mark Treichel: He's
- 31:40David Reed: got a job.
- 31:40And, and I don'tâ¦
- 31:41You know, he, the Public Accounting Board, which I think, uh, the pay
- 31:45for that is, is dramatically higher.
- 31:48Mark Treichel: Yes.
- 31:48David Reed: A- and so, uh, John Cruz, who, who is, uh, well-versed in financial
- 31:53services, having been, uh, you know, at, at, at Treasury for some period
- 31:56of time uh, so he'll, he'll be coming in, uh, whenever they vote on that.
- 32:01You know, who knows how this is gonna be received af- after the decision.
- 32:05And then the question becomes, okay will there be, uh, will every one of
- 32:10these boards now have, the maximum number of, you know, reds appointed,
- 32:15and just wait on everything else?
- 32:17Y- you know, uh, it, it leads a lot, uh, to a lot of questions.
- 32:20So those are my thoughts on that.
- 32:22Mark Treichel: Those are good thoughts.
- 32:23And, you know, uh, who, who are they gonna get to take the positions?
- 32:27You know, if you gotâ¦
- 32:27Y- 'cause they get people that will move to DC, right?
- 32:30And thinking they've got four years, they're taking a term that
- 32:33has four years left, or five years left, or three years left, or-
- 32:37Or whatever.
- 32:38And if, uh, if a term isn't a term- You're gonna get a, a different
- 32:43pool of people who are willing- Oh
- 32:45David Reed: no, a- absolutely ⦠to come do it And, and a different
- 32:47pool you know, it's naturally gonna gravitate to people that say, "All
- 32:50right, my, you know, my life cycle is going to be, uh, uh, learning."
- 32:56" And then, uh, doing business and making money to provide for my family
- 32:59and my retirement and all of that.
- 33:00And then the final season is gonna be service."
- 33:03Right.
- 33:03So I mean, that, that's kind of the model that- Yeah ⦠that you
- 33:06know, hopefully people do a little service all the way through, right?
- 33:08Mark Treichel: Yeah, yeah.
- 33:09David Reed: Um, but now you're gonna get people that are at, at the other
- 33:11end of the career as opposed to- I like,
- 33:12Mark Treichel: I like that take.
- 33:13I like that that ⦠I think that's the glass half full is you'll get people that
- 33:16are saying, "Hey, this is, this is my second or third career, not my first or
- 33:21second career that I'm gonna parlay- Right
- 33:23into something," right?
- 33:24David Reed: So that could, that could be good, that could be bad, and I'm
- 33:26sure we've both known people that have had presidential appointments a- and
- 33:30it comes with its own set of decisions.
- 33:32I mean, I have been, uh, uh, you know, blessed to have dear friends that
- 33:36we've sat down over a nice meal and, and laid it out, and it's everything
- 33:40from this is what I'm gonna make, uh, this is how I'm currently positioned.
- 33:45This is how that one year cooling off period after I leave is gonna impact me.
- 33:50Mark Treichel: Yep.
- 33:50David Reed: And this is how I'm gonna ⦠This is how I'm probably gonna
- 33:53be treated when I go back to my industry having served- Right ⦠you know, at
- 33:57the foot of, Pickett administration.
- 33:59Mark Treichel: Sure.
- 34:00David Reed: Sure.
- 34:00And, and it, it, it's difficult.
- 34:01Mark Treichel: It's difficult indeed.
- 34:03Very good.
- 34:03Very good.
- 34:04So,
- 34:04David Reed: Succession planning
- 34:05⦠Mark Treichel: succession planning.
- 34:06So give me the, the shotgun wedding, uh, succession planning update.
- 34:11David Reed: Absolutely.
- 34:11Well, because again, it, it's a natural, uh, flow in the conversation 'cause- Yeah
- 34:15⦠there is no succession planning- Right,
- 34:16Mark Treichel: yeah
- 34:17David Reed: for these boards.
- 34:17It, it's natural.
- 34:18Mark Treichel: Right.
- 34:18David Reed: Um, I, I am a huge fan of the the junior varsity governance model.
- 34:27I like the associate board members.
- 34:30Uh, I think where appropriate, you could also do associate supervisory committee
- 34:34or audit committee members, right?
- 34:36They all have to have the same entry point, they all have to have
- 34:38the same qualification, uh, bond ability, uh, non-disclosure uh,
- 34:42um, commitment and all of that.
- 34:45But it, it, it adds to that deeper bench, and I, I talk about that, train
- 34:48on that all the time, the deeper bench.
- 34:50And I think that the new rule, whether you think you needed a new rule or not,
- 34:54I think one of the things it has done for those credit unions that have done
- 34:59something other than, "Here's the policy.
- 35:03All, all in favor?
- 35:04Boom.
- 35:05Now it's in the book, we don't think about it again," it's ha- it's
- 35:08having them think about that process.
- 35:12Um, it is service on the board should not be a lifetime appointment.
- 35:18Mark Treichel: Sure.
- 35:19David Reed: And again, I'm not saying it's about age, right?
- 35:21There, I have seen top tier volunteers who were octogenarians, right?
- 35:27Who were, who, who were way older.
- 35:29Uh, and they're great.
- 35:30Innovative ideas, commitment to the purpose.
- 35:31And I've seen some that are in their 30s and 40s who, let's face it,
- 35:35that, that's children's age, right?
- 35:37Um- Right ⦠i- i- that, that are not focused, not really helpful.
- 35:41So looking at your own governance documents and saying to yourself,
- 35:46"Do you realize that every nomination of an incumbent is a reselection?"
- 35:54I mean, if I could just get that in everybody.
- 35:56So remember, three- it's not, y- y- if your nominations policy is, oh, uh,
- 36:00all incumbents are welcome to to be on the board again, ⦠And because
- 36:04we know how it works most of the time, if there are three openings, right?
- 36:07By-law, standard by-law say you gotta do at least three.
- 36:10Most of them stop at three.
- 36:11Very few say, "Oh, we're, we're gonna go ahead and nominate five," and go through
- 36:15the time and expense and uncertainty- Right ⦠of throwing that out.
- 36:18So it's typically three for three.
- 36:19So if all three say yes, we're done.
- 36:22All right, well, did you evaluate?
- 36:24And then of course that brings the bigger question.
- 36:25Well, if we evaluate them, which we should do, right?
- 36:29Did they show up?
- 36:31Well, let me back up.
- 36:32I- I'm a pretty simple guy.
- 36:33Here's what I expect of volunteers, right?
- 36:36Show up, be prepared-
- 36:39Mark Treichel: Yep
- 36:40⦠David Reed: participate-
- 36:41Mark Treichel: Yep
- 36:41⦠David Reed: play well with others, right?
- 36:44I don't need you to be an expert in this.
- 36:46I don't need to know your arbitrage philosophy with the Hungarian currency.
- 36:50I don't need to know that.
- 36:51I d- those four things, we're good to go.
- 36:53But if you're gonna evaluate the people that are up for, not just
- 36:56nomination, but re-nomination, which means re-selection, then what are you
- 37:02gonna do with the other six people?
- 37:03Or maybe you're gonna review them.
- 37:05Well, should we review every year?
- 37:07Well, if you review every year, then whoever's up for nomination
- 37:13then they're already covered.
- 37:14Mark Treichel: Right.
- 37:14David Reed: Um, and- Got it ⦠uh, you hear all the time, you know,
- 37:18the biggest the biggest uh, comment that you, uh, at least that I hear
- 37:23i- is uh, we can't find volunteers.
- 37:26We can't find volunteers."
- 37:27All right, well, you have to be deliberate about it.
- 37:30Where are you looking?
- 37:31Well, let's back up a few steps.
- 37:32What are you looking for?
- 37:34'Cause wouldn't it be good, if we're gonna evaluate our people, wouldn't
- 37:36it be good if we had a basic job description that focused on, I
- 37:39don't know, show up, be prepared, participate, play well with others?
- 37:43Mark Treichel: We posted a fl- And then add anything else ⦠we
- 37:43po- we posted a flyer at the VFW
- 37:47David Reed: What if we put, uh, VFW at, at the local high schools?
- 37:50Right.
- 37:50Uh, and everybody that you participate with, "Oh, you know what?
- 37:53Uh, we, we really help high school students because we have we have high
- 37:57school branches," or, "We do, we do these poverty programs, you know, these you
- 38:02know, you come in the poverty games where you're given a certain amount of money."
- 38:05Well, that's great.
- 38:05Who coordinates that?
- 38:07Uh, w- anybody a member of the Lion's Club, Kiwanis Club, Chamber
- 38:10of Commerce, Knights of Columbus, uh, the local temple, the local mosque?
- 38:15You know, financial wellness- ⦠and cooperative
- 38:18movement, we go in together, right?
- 38:20We
- 38:20Mark Treichel: go hand in
- 38:20David Reed: glove.
- 38:20I don't know.
- 38:21I'm, I'm thinking, wouldn't it be cool to work for some, uh, or, you know,
- 38:24organization one way or another that was, not for profit, n- not entirely
- 38:29for charity, maybe for service.
- 38:32Mark Treichel: Right.
- 38:33David Reed: Yeah, just, I mean, I, throw that net out there.
- 38:37Mark Treichel: Absolutely.
- 38:37David Reed: So I have, uh-
- 38:38Mark Treichel: The wisdom of crowds, absolutely.
- 38:40David Reed: Oh my God, wisdom of, how much does that bull weigh?
- 38:43Mark Treichel: That's
- 38:43David Reed: right.
- 38:44Right?
- 38:44The law of large numbers.
- 38:46There we go.
- 38:46We could ge- we could geek out all day, Mr.
- 38:48T.
- 38:49But I'm somewhat hopeful that this is getting people's attention.
- 38:52I have seen a deliberate movement over the last several years.
- 38:57I mean, when I walk into a boardroom to work with a credit union, when I
- 39:01go into a training or something like that, I am seeing younger faces, right?
- 39:06Good.
- 39:06That's what we hear.
- 39:06Uh, newer faces.
- 39:08Mark Treichel: Yep.
- 39:08David Reed: And I think that that's good.
- 39:10And i- it's, it's doable, but for somebody to look at me and say, "Well, the CEO's
- 39:15looking for other volunteers," okay, well, that's good as long as that's,
- 39:20you know, one of several sources.
- 39:22But-
- 39:22Mark Treichel: Right, yeah
- 39:23⦠David Reed: if the CEO's the only person finding volunteers, 'cause
- 39:26they're the only ones in the community well, then eventually you have
- 39:29a board that's made up of people that may feel beholden to the CEO.
- 39:34Well,
- 39:34Mark Treichel: we're back to where we started.
- 39:36David Reed: You know what?
- 39:36It's funny.
- 39:38It's funny how that- I love it ⦠how that works out, isn't it?
- 39:43Mark Treichel: The circle's complete.
- 39:44Yeah.
- 39:44The circle's complete.
- 39:45Well, very, very-
- 39:46David Reed: I mean, I knew a credit union once that on the supervisory
- 39:48committee they looked around one day and they found out that most
- 39:51of the people on the supervisory committee were neighbors of the CEO.
- 39:55Mark Treichel: Ah there you go.
- 39:58And he had a lot of pool parties.
- 40:01David Reed: Yeah.
- 40:01They, they, they probably had a lot of, uh, a lot of
- 40:03different types of parties, yeah.
- 40:04Mark Treichel: Very good.
- 40:05Very good.
- 40:05David Reed: Um, and on the collections, on the collections-
- 40:07Yeah ⦠uh, item when you continue to look at the statistics, right,
- 40:12i- it's the haves and the have-nots.
- 40:14Mark Treichel: The K economy, yeah.
- 40:15I-
- 40:15David Reed: I- I- it is just, it, it is absolutely uh, happening.
- 40:20People forget, and I don't know what the exact number it is, but clearly
- 40:24less than 20% of the population is being directly impacted by what's
- 40:29going on on Wall Street, right?
- 40:32And so you have a, a, a large proportion of people that are
- 40:36still having trouble every month.
- 40:38If they have to choose between afterschool programs for a child
- 40:43or making that minimum credit card payment, we know how it's gonna work.
- 40:47A- and, um, credit unions need to leverage, just did something just recently
- 40:54on this, need to leverage all of these analytics, uh, all of this technology.
- 40:59And I'm, I'm hesitant just to say AI.
- 41:01It's about more than that.
- 41:02But, uh, you know, I have a s- I had a simple message yesterday.
- 41:06If your credit union is already using all these analytics to discover
- 41:11opportunities to loan to people maybe you're even beyond that.
- 41:16You wanna find a way to, to underwrite even more risky loans so that you can
- 41:21serve greater parts of your community.
- 41:22Boy, I'm, I'm all for all of that.
- 41:24Why not use all that data you're already, uh, accessing and try to be predictive
- 41:30on people that may be in trouble, right?
- 41:32Because by the time they hit one of those traditional buckets, 30
- 41:36to 60 60 and over, reportable.
- 41:40You know, by the time they hit that you know, by the time a person hits two
- 41:44payments or three payments past due, they're not gonna talk to you anymore.
- 41:49And it doesn't matter that you could walk them through, right?
- 41:52Collections only has the two moving parts, right?
- 41:54Willingness to pay, ability to pay, but both of those are, uh,
- 41:59both of those are built on the fact they've gotta talk to you.
- 42:01Mark Treichel: Right.
- 42:02David Reed: And by the time they get two or three payments past
- 42:04due, they're not gonna talk to you.
- 42:05Mark Treichel: They don't wanna talk to anybody about it.
- 42:06David Reed: Nope.
- 42:07Mark Treichel: Nope.
- 42:08David Reed: They wanna run and hide.
- 42:08So, so that's what I would talk about.
- 42:10And, you know, marketing departments, lending departments, uh, strategic
- 42:14thinking and all of that are looking at leveraging all of this
- 42:17technology, uh, in order to serve more members, which I love it.
- 42:21Turn that inside, right?
- 42:23Turn that inside and, um, you know, serve the members that
- 42:27may have the greatest need.
- 42:29People that have that unexpected expense, that health issue, a, an adult parent
- 42:32that comes back in, a relationship that didn't work you know, their overtime that
- 42:36suddenly gets cut off, or whatever it is.
- 42:38Turn those analytics and see if you can be proactive in helping those, right?
- 42:42I mean-
- 42:42Mark Treichel: I love it.
- 42:42I love it.
- 42:43That's, that, I think that's a good, a good place to wrap, on how, finding,
- 42:47uh, ways to use technology and tools to hurt to help those members that need
- 42:53the most help at any particular time.
- 42:55David Reed: And I think it also builds on a theme, and this will
- 42:57be my my, my closing thought.
- 42:59It builds on the theme of you probably already have the tools
- 43:03or the processes within your credit union to do an awful lot.
- 43:06Are they being activated?
- 43:09And even if they're being activated, a- a- are they being properly reviewed, right?
- 43:14So on the collections front, uh, if you already have this information,
- 43:17are you only using it to the people that you wanna give a loan to?
- 43:20You know, what about the person that you can pull up something
- 43:22and say, "Hey, you know what?
- 43:23David Reid's payroll didn't come in this month.
- 43:26Maybe we should reach out to them."
- 43:28Flip side, on those internal controls and things like that, you
- 43:32already have those tools there.
- 43:33You may even already have the results.
- 43:34Are you looking at them?
- 43:35Yep.
- 43:36Mark Treichel: Yep.
- 43:38Excellent point.
- 43:39Well, David, this has been a lot of fun, as always.
- 43:41Always enjoy, uh, catching up with you.
- 43:43If, uh, if someone is listening or watching and they want to chat
- 43:47with you about anything we talked about here or about, or anything
- 43:51else about credit unions, what's the best way for them to reach you?
- 43:54David Reed: Yeah, send me an email david@reidandjolly.com,
- 43:58and I think you're gonna put that up in the notes a- as well.
- 44:01Will
- 44:01Mark Treichel: do.
- 44:01David Reed: Will do.
- 44:01Uh, that's by far the best way to reach me.
- 44:04Uh, again, I, I love what I do.
- 44:06I love our industry.
- 44:07I think we're gonna continue to, uh, you know, to go strong.
- 44:11And, you know, we're in some turbulent waters as we almost always are one
- 44:15way or the other, so let's, uh, let's work together and get through it.
- 44:18Mark Treichel: Yeah, just gotta keep paddling when
- 44:20you're in those tur- turbulent
- 44:21David Reed: waters.
- 44:21That's exactly right.
- 44:22You know?
- 44:22Yeah.
- 44:22Uh,
- 44:23Mark Treichel: we're-
- 44:23David Reed: And, and, and don't answer the question with, "This
- 44:25is always the way we've done it."
- 44:26Mark Treichel: We've always done it this way.
- 44:27Yeah.
- 44:27Always.
- 44:27Not a good answer.
- 44:28Not a good answer.
- 44:29All right, David, I wanna thank you.
- 44:31Listeners, watchers, I wanna thank you as always for listening or watching.
- 44:34I hope you'll do the same again soon.
- 44:36This is Mark Trakel signing off with flying colors.