Latest / Change My Relationship / Faith Vs. Magical Thinking
Transcript
- 0:00You're listening to an audio recording by Change My Relationship, featuring
- 0:04licensed marriage and family therapist and author Karla Downing.
- 0:08These audios are designed to provide you with practical solutions
- 0:11based on biblical truths for all your relationships.
- 0:20One of my subscribers
- 0:22asked me to differentiate faith versus
- 0:26magical thinking, and I thought that was a great idea.
- 0:30So first of all, why the difference?
- 0:34Why do we have to make the difference?
- 0:36Because
- 0:38my ministry is to people in difficult relationships.
- 0:42So that's what we're dealing with people in difficult relationships
- 0:46or difficult life circumstances often look for a simple solution.
- 0:52They're in pain, and they're looking for a way out of their pain.
- 0:57And when we are in pain, often
- 1:02God wants us to.
- 1:03Not often he wants us to go to him, and he wants us to come to him
- 1:08and pray and ask him for help and depend on him and trust him.
- 1:13That's a given.
- 1:15The whole Bible talks about that. But
- 1:19at the same time, he wants us to use wisdom
- 1:24and to make really good and right decisions.
- 1:28Using common sense and taking into consideration
- 1:34that we need to take a stand for what is right
- 1:36and that we need to speak truth and all the principles that I teach,
- 1:40and that we have a right to set boundaries to protect ourselves.
- 1:43Maybe not just a right, but a responsibility to set boundaries,
- 1:48to protect ourselves, and to say no to things that are
- 1:51that are wrong and things that are not okay.
- 1:55So we have a tendency, though, to want to believe that
- 2:01there is going to be a simple solution that's going to be a fix.
- 2:04And sometimes in difficult relationships, that gives way to
- 2:07what is magical thinking.
- 2:09Magical thinking thinks, if I just
- 2:12trust and
- 2:13wait and hope, it'll just happen and everything will be okay,
- 2:17and I won't have to do any of this tough stuff.
- 2:20I won't have to set boundaries and I won't have to speak the truth.
- 2:23And I won't have to make a decision as to whether or not I have to get a divorce
- 2:27and leave this person or separate.
- 2:30Give this person an ultimatum.
- 2:32I won't have to confront my child and think about kicking my kid
- 2:36out of the house, or saying no to somebody who's going to be very upset with me.
- 2:42I just won't have to. I'll just.
- 2:44I'll just have this thinking that it's just going to go away.
- 2:47Doesn't deal with the tough questions and the tough choices.
- 2:51It instead uses faith
- 2:54as an excuse to not do the hard work, to not do the things that have to do
- 3:00with standing up for what is right and doing the things
- 3:04that we have responsibility to do in our difficult relationships.
- 3:07But they're not easy and they're not fun.
- 3:10So here is the difference.
- 3:16Faith is in God.
- 3:19Always need to have faith in God.
- 3:21But magical thinking is in specific outcomes.
- 3:25So faith will say in a circumstance my faith is in God,
- 3:30not in specific outcomes.
- 3:33So I'm in this situation going to hang on to God and trust God
- 3:38and believe in God no matter what happens, no matter what the outcome is.
- 3:43But magical thinking is, oh, it's it's going to all be better.
- 3:46It's going to all be fine.
- 3:48Everything's going to be great.
- 3:50Faith wants God's will.
- 3:53Magical thinking wants your will.
- 3:56So in faith, I'm saying, God, whatever
- 3:59is your will in this marriage, whatever your will in my life,
- 4:03whatever happens, I will trust you, I will.
- 4:07I'll trust that you're working your will out in this circumstance.
- 4:12But magical thinking is my will.
- 4:15My will is this marriage works.
- 4:17My will is that
- 4:18I don't have to make a hard decision and kick my kid out of the house.
- 4:23My will is that my child gets help for that drug situation.
- 4:27My will is that my parent changes
- 4:31and my parent doesn't
- 4:33continue to to act this way or doesn't isn't going to, continue
- 4:38abusing me or
- 4:41abusing my spouse or abusing my child. So
- 4:46the next one is faith.
- 4:48Trust God no matter what happens.
- 4:51Magical thinking is disappointed when things don't happen
- 4:56like you want them to
- 4:59go like you believe or imagine they'll happen.
- 5:02So faith says God, no matter what It's like job.
- 5:06Though you slay me, I will trust you.
- 5:08Doesn't matter I am, I am
- 5:12there, but
- 5:14magical thinking is discouraged
- 5:17and maybe even, It's a faith crisis.
- 5:20When things don't happen like you expect them to happen.
- 5:23It's like God disappointed me. God let me down.
- 5:25God didn't do what I believed that he was going to do,
- 5:30or what he told me he was going to do it because it can literally become a crisis.
- 5:35Faith knows that God doesn't violate people's free will.
- 5:40Magical thinking believes that God's going to violate
- 5:44a person's free will to make things happen the way you want.
- 5:48So faith recognizes, okay, God has my good in mind,
- 5:53and God doesn't want this situation maybe to happen,
- 5:57but God isn't going to violate this person's free will.
- 6:01This person still has choice.
- 6:03So I don't have any guarantee that things are going to go like I believe
- 6:07that they're going to go or that I'm I have the faith to believe they might.
- 6:12God, if you can save this marriage.
- 6:15But magical thinking is.
- 6:17Yeah. God, you're going to change
- 6:20my husband's heart.
- 6:21You're going to change my kid’s drug addiction.
- 6:23You're just going to take it away.
- 6:25You're going to change this person's mind, and.
- 6:28And you're going to take away
- 6:30all of these things that are hindering our relationship.
- 6:34And again, when that doesn't happen, you're disillusioned
- 6:39because you're like, why didn't God do what I believed he was going to do?
- 6:43Why didn't God make my husband change?
- 6:45I get letters like that all the time.
- 6:47Emails from people I've been praying for 20 years
- 6:51that God would change my spouse's heart.
- 6:54And now my spouse's leaving me.
- 6:57Why did God not answer my prayers?
- 6:59Well, he did, but magical thinking
- 7:03is that your God's going to force this person to change.
- 7:06And God doesn't do that.
- 7:08He doesn't force somebody to change.
- 7:11He allows them to make choices.
- 7:12And unfortunately and unfortunately, we get caught
- 7:17in the pathway of that person's choices.
- 7:21Faith moves forward doing your part.
- 7:25Magical thinking waits and doesn't do your part.
- 7:28So it's kind of like a kind of like a cop out.
- 7:31It's like, okay, I'm just going to believe that God's going to fix this.
- 7:34And in the meantime, I'm not going to do any of this tough stuff.
- 7:37I'm not going to set boundaries. I'm not going to speak truth.
- 7:39I'm not going to change myself.
- 7:41I'm not going to do this stuff that I need to do in order
- 7:45to do my part to deal with this difficult situation.
- 7:50Now, here are some examples.
- 7:53Faith would trust God to work in your difficult relationship,
- 7:56but you know that it's not going to happen unless the other person is open to it.
- 8:02Magical thinking is convinced that the other person will change.
- 8:06So you're just going to keep tolerating the mistreatment
- 8:09and not set boundaries or speak the truth to protect yourself.
- 8:13Faith.
- 8:14Trust that God will could heal your marriage could help heal your marriage.
- 8:20But since your spouse has filed for divorce,
- 8:24you recognize that your spouse is going forward with a divorce.
- 8:28So you get an attorney to protect your rights and stand up for your rights.
- 8:32But magical thinking believes God's going to heal my marriage.
- 8:37And so you don't get an attorney, and you don't stand up for your rights,
- 8:41and your spouse gets to walk away with everything
- 8:44because you didn't stand for yourself, because your magical thinking
- 8:48just believed that everything was going to be better.
- 8:51Faith trusts God to work in the addict's life,
- 8:55but you still do everything that you can to not enable to speak the truth and love.
- 9:00To take care of yourself, to make plans
- 9:04for yourself, to to live your life.
- 9:07If the addict
- 9:09doesn't
- 9:10change or isn't changing or never changes,
- 9:13but magical thinking believes that the addict is going to change.
- 9:17So you put your life on hold, waiting for the change to come,
- 9:21and you continue to enable because you just think that everything's
- 9:25going to magically be better, especially if you're loving
- 9:30and you're just waiting for it
- 9:32to instantly change.
- 9:35Faith trusts God to heal your sickness,
- 9:38but still goes to the doctor to get the treatment.
- 9:43But magical thinking believes that God's going to heal your illness
- 9:48and does not go to the doctor.
- 9:51So basically
- 9:54waits for that instant healing, but doesn't do your part
- 9:58in making sure that you're getting proper treatment.
- 10:03So I think at this point you can kind of see the difference.
- 10:06We want to have faith, but we don't want to have magical thinking.
- 10:11So at this point, it would be kind of give it a little bit of thought.
- 10:16Do you tend towards faith or do you tend towards magical thinking
- 10:21in your difficult relationships and your difficult circumstances?
- 10:26You can tell at this point
- 10:28which one is the healthiest and scripturally.
- 10:33Basically, we are commanded to have faith.
- 10:37We know that.
- 10:38But magical thinking gets us in trouble.
- 10:40It will get us very disillusioned with God.
- 10:43It will actually increase the possibility
- 10:47that things will not turn out like we want them to,
- 10:50because we're not doing our part in those difficult relationships.
- 10:55So I hope this has helped you to contrast the difference between faith
- 10:59and magical thinking,
- 11:03and I hope that you take some time.
- 11:05If you're not familiar with my materials and my studies
- 11:10and my books, to go to changemyrelationship.com
- 11:14and you might not, might you would really enjoy my book Change
- 11:19My Relationship 365 Daily Devotions for Christians in Difficult Relationships.
- 11:25This will help you with magical thinking
- 11:28versus faith on top of many, many more things.
- 11:33So God bless you and thank you for watching.
- 11:36Thank you for listening to Change My Relationship.
- 11:40We hope you will subscribe to these podcasts and share them with your friends.
- 11:44Karla would love to hear from you.
- 11:46She welcomes ideas for a future podcast, as well as your feedback
- 11:50on how the podcasts have helped your life and relationships.
- 11:54You can email her at.
- 11:55karla@changemyrelationship.com
- 11:59For more information on Change My Relationship and Karla
- 12:02Downing's ministry, including her books, studies, devotionals, podcasts
- 12:07and YouTube videos visit changemyrelationship.com.