Latest / The Film Hobbyist / Superman (2025): Moral Cognitive Dissonance
Transcript
- 0:11Come on in and spend some time with the film
- 0:14hobbyist. My name is Lydia, and I love movies.
- 0:31We're here in my attic room. You're sitting on
- 0:36a forest green Walmart futon with a black metal
- 0:39frame. I'm in an old desk chair with cracks in
- 0:43the pleather lining. And next to me is a plain,
- 0:48black, folding chair. When I share with you my
- 0:53ideas and opinions about movies, they are just
- 0:57that, my ideas. I read plenty of film reviews
- 1:02and watch video essays, but I always try to ensure
- 1:06that I'm not sharing anyone else's thoughts but
- 1:09my own. I don't want to take credit for anyone
- 1:12else's ideas. What would be the point? This doesn't
- 1:17mean my thoughts aren't influenced by other people,
- 1:20but I am not going to talk about a film unless
- 1:23I have enough of my own personal thoughts to
- 1:26share. Today, we are going to talk about James
- 1:31Gunn's Superman, released this past summer. Because
- 1:35of the high profile of this film, There are a
- 1:38million reviews and think pieces and video essays
- 1:43to read or watch on this topic, with a wide variety
- 1:47of opinions and perspectives and ideas. I've
- 1:51read and watched a great deal of them, and I
- 1:54didn't have anything unique to contribute to
- 1:57the conversation. But someone in my life did.
- 2:02And today... I'd like to present his thoughts
- 2:05to you, along with my own research and knowledge.
- 2:09I will be discussing plot specifics, so if you
- 2:13haven't seen this film, track it down on HBO
- 2:16Max or check it out from your local library.
- 2:20But because I don't want to just relay someone
- 2:25else's words, I invited this person here to join
- 2:29us. Sitting here with us... In this plain, black
- 2:33folding chair is my husband, Caleb. Hello there.
- 2:38I'm really glad to join you in the garret. Caleb
- 2:43and I have watched so many movies together. When
- 2:46we were first dating, we used to watch movies
- 2:49every Friday. We thought our tastes were pretty
- 2:52similar. But when we got married, it became apparent
- 2:56that there were some distinct differences. A
- 3:01fact which came starkly into focus while on our
- 3:04honeymoon when I described the movie The Scorpion
- 3:07King as, quote, a great movie, only for Lydia
- 3:13to come to a very different assessment of the
- 3:15film's quality. It's a terrible film! Ah, but
- 3:19so memorable. As you can tell, we have some different
- 3:23tastes. I, for one, love cheesy and sincere movies.
- 3:28Hilarious, romping, barely -heard -of adventures
- 3:31like Surf Ninjas, and full -hearted, heroic films
- 3:35like 2001's Spider -Man. Stories that leave you
- 3:40with hope for the future, even in the face of
- 3:42difficult circumstances. I have my limits with
- 3:47films. I don't do bleak or heavy. I have a low
- 3:52threshold for horror. I find if I overstep these
- 3:56limits, the stories follow me and make my life
- 4:01more difficult. And I would say I have an even
- 4:05lower tolerance than Lydia. I am deeply affected
- 4:08by dark themes without hope. Lydia has had to
- 4:13watch me more than once after a film hit hard
- 4:17and left a cloud hanging over me for a week.
- 4:21I'm particularly bothered by plots involving
- 4:23cruelty to animals, especially dogs. I'd been
- 4:27following news about James Gunn's Superman for
- 4:31a long time, and it really seemed like it might
- 4:34be the kind of movie that Caleb would really
- 4:37like. I did watch it first with a friend, partially
- 4:41because the timing worked out, and partially
- 4:44because I wanted to make sure that it would work
- 4:47for him. Especially that nothing too terrible
- 4:50happened to the dog. I would feel so bad if I
- 4:54hyped up a movie that was actually not okay for
- 4:57him. It's happened in the past, and it's always
- 5:01so hard. But Superman was great, and we both
- 5:06really liked it. Agreed. My broad take on this
- 5:10Superman. is that it gave me a similar feeling
- 5:14to how 2001's Spider -Man made me feel as a boy.
- 5:18Full of hope, with a thrill of heroism. This
- 5:23version of Clark is one of the kindest iterations
- 5:26I've seen. Even while fighting a kaiju, he's
- 5:30going out of his way to check in on everyone,
- 5:33making sure they're okay. At the midpoint, his
- 5:37motivation for turning himself over to the government
- 5:41is so that he can find out what Lex Luthor has
- 5:44done with crypto. Towards the end, in what I
- 5:48think is one of the most impactful moments of
- 5:51the film, Clark holds up a falling building to
- 5:54allow a woman to escape in her car across a bridge.
- 5:58Once clear, she looks back to see him rising
- 6:02into the air out of the settling rubble. Rays
- 6:06of light shining around him while the score swells.
- 6:12By this point in the movie, we know he's not
- 6:16hesitating there as some self -aggrandizing show
- 6:20of his power. This Clark is hesitating because
- 6:25he wants to make sure she has cleared the crumbling
- 6:29road before moving on. In the face... of a lot
- 6:34of cynicism in the recent movie landscape, including
- 6:38within the superhero genre. This Superman is
- 6:43heartwarmingly sincere. He genuinely cares and
- 6:48regards his abilities as a vehicle for compassion.
- 6:52So, yes, I loved it, especially Clark's character.
- 6:57I really liked the dynamic between Lois Lane
- 7:00and Clark Kent. It's something I understand as
- 7:04a somewhat pessimistic, worst kind of scenario
- 7:07person married to a self -described hopefulist,
- 7:11as opposed to an optimist. I also loved how compassionate
- 7:16Superman was, not just fighting bad guys, but
- 7:19really doing his best to mitigate harm. He even
- 7:23tries to find a peaceful solution with Lex Luthor's
- 7:27henchmen during a fight. It really was some of
- 7:30the things I talked about regarding Rebel Ridge
- 7:33a few months ago. A different paradigm for an
- 7:36action hero. This movie gave me a level of excitement
- 7:41with a story I haven't had for a long time. And
- 7:45I knew that had I watched this as a teenager,
- 7:48I would have stills from this movie on my school
- 7:52book covers right next to Peter Parker and Mary
- 7:55Jane from Sam Raimi's Spider -Man. and Will Turner
- 7:58and Elizabeth Swann from Pirates of the Caribbean.
- 8:02But Caleb noticed a flaw in this film. A little
- 8:07niggling knot. The trouble comes in the form
- 8:12of the Justice Gang. It is made explicitly clear
- 8:16when they first appear during the fight with
- 8:19the Kaiju that they hold to a different set of
- 8:22values than Superman. While Clark spends precious
- 8:26moments trying to figure out how to safely get
- 8:29the creature out of the city alive, the Justice
- 8:31gang quickly resorts to violence, dispatching
- 8:35the creature without much thought. The movie
- 8:39holds both ideologies up next to one another
- 8:42as an intentional contrast. And it's clear within
- 8:47the narrative that we are meant to agree with
- 8:50Superman's approach. Self -sacrificing and believing
- 8:54in others, giving them a chance when no one else
- 8:57will, can and does actually bring out the best
- 9:01in people and can inspire them to courageous
- 9:04acts, as in the case of Metamorpho. And this
- 9:09is where I think that certain plot choices contradict
- 9:12the narrative heart of the film. At the end of
- 9:16the movie, the Justice gang comes to rescue Jarenpour
- 9:20instead of Superman. And how do they solve this
- 9:24problem? In exactly the opposite way that Superman
- 9:29would have. They brutally, nonchalantly kill
- 9:34the soldiers and president of Baravia. The film
- 9:38wants us, the audience, to cheer for this as
- 9:42a big heroic moment. Even Superman doesn't offer
- 9:46a critique to what they did. and I think that
- 9:49choice foundationally compromises so much of
- 9:53what is done to prop up Clark's character. It
- 9:56effectively says, kindness, compassion, and inspiring
- 10:01people is great, except for the people we've
- 10:04decided are the real bad guys. They are unredeemable,
- 10:08so killing them is okay. The issues with this
- 10:12are acknowledged in a small way. Upon seeing
- 10:15the Justice Gang's actions on the news, The U
- 10:18.S. Secretary of Defense remarks, Metahumans
- 10:21make the rules now. What do laws and courts mean?
- 10:26What do borders mean? When an incredibly powerful
- 10:29being can go anywhere they like, start or stop
- 10:33whatever actions they want, whose choices really
- 10:37matter anymore? These are important questions,
- 10:40and I'm hoping we'll see those themes develop
- 10:43more in future films. But it doesn't solve for
- 10:47me the core tension. Namely, that Clark is able
- 10:52to keep his hands clean by letting other people
- 10:55do the killing instead of him. Even with as much
- 10:59as I love this movie, I think this narrative
- 11:01dissonance hurts the overall composition of the
- 11:04film. I think this is where we have to look at
- 11:09James Gunn's past. He might be the co -head of
- 11:13DC Studios today, but he started out in an entirely
- 11:17different sector of filmmaking. Troma Studios,
- 11:21a scrappy, independent film company. Troma specializes
- 11:28in schlocky, B -movie -style films. Not just
- 11:32low -budget or goofy. Kind of gross. purposefully
- 11:40transgressive, offensive, and completely in bad
- 11:45taste. Now there's definitely a market for that.
- 11:50It's very much not my cup of tea, but it helps
- 11:55make a lot more sense of Gunn as a filmmaker.
- 11:58His baseline is boundary pushing. Now Gunn has
- 12:04talked at length about how While Troma's spirit
- 12:08of gritty filmmaking has stayed with him, some
- 12:12of his attempts to be edgy as he emerged into
- 12:15his own directing career in the 2000s are things
- 12:18he has left in his past. He's talked very much
- 12:22about how he identifies with the character of
- 12:25Rocket Raccoon from Guardians of the Galaxy,
- 12:27someone who pushes everyone out at arm's length
- 12:31with an abrasive sense of humor. and who has
- 12:34to learn to humble himself and participate in
- 12:37a positive community. And on one hand, there
- 12:41are definite themes that have emerged post the
- 12:45Marvel era. Gunn's whole shtick at this point
- 12:48is building up teams of messed up, morally dubious
- 12:53individuals learning to choose to do good while
- 12:57relying on each other. Every project he's done
- 13:01since then has this perspective. See the Justice
- 13:04Gang. On the other hand, he still has a warped
- 13:09streak. Caleb and I have only seen Guardians
- 13:13of the Galaxy Vol. 2 once. At the time, it got
- 13:17written off as a slighter, merely funny film,
- 13:20which absolutely baffled us. Maybe it was just
- 13:24that we were parents of a toddler, but the mass
- 13:28infanticide plotline highly disturbed us. particularly
- 13:32the cavern filled with tiny skulls. Now, we liked
- 13:38that movie, too, but it's not one we ever wanted
- 13:42to watch again. And when we heard that Guardians
- 13:453 was very well made, but contained an extreme
- 13:48amount of animal cruelty, even as part of a plotline
- 13:52against animal cruelty, we decided it wasn't
- 13:56for us. I probably would be fine watching it.
- 14:00But I know Caleb wouldn't be, and I'm not sure
- 14:03I could forget that fact while watching it. In
- 14:07a similar vein, there is a sequence in this film
- 14:10where Superman has to fight off a horde of enemies,
- 14:14all while holding onto a baby. I do not like
- 14:20this sequence. It goes on for far, far too long.
- 14:27All the while... The baby is in serious, imminent
- 14:31peril. As a dad, that is the stuff of nightmares.
- 14:37And even though the baby is fine in the end,
- 14:40it feels unnecessarily gratuitous. I was immensely
- 14:45grateful to be able to skip over the entire scene
- 14:48on my second watch through. Now, this... Moral
- 14:54cognitive dissonance, this attempt to have your
- 14:57cake and eat it too with regard to radical kindness,
- 15:01might not be a flaw. There's a possibility this
- 15:06could be a plot point explored in future movies.
- 15:09When James Gunn first announced his slate of
- 15:12films for DC Studios, the stories he was working
- 15:15on, he announced a film based on The Authority.
- 15:20This is a fairly obscure superhero group, but
- 15:24here's how Gunn summarizes them. And here, that's
- 15:34not a good thing. The Authority are anti -heroes
- 15:38who get carried away. They begin by intervening
- 15:43to do good and end up doing harm instead by prioritizing
- 15:47their idea of what's good instead of real goodness.
- 15:53This movie might not come out. It no longer has
- 15:57a release date. But considering the way Gunn
- 16:01talked about it initially, there are definitely
- 16:03ideas in here that might come out in a future
- 16:06movie. And in that case... What seems like a
- 16:10flaw to us right now might just be the groundwork
- 16:13for a future conversation about the problems
- 16:16with moral relativism and the limits of vigilante
- 16:19justice. If there's a future movie where Superman
- 16:24has to face off against the authority initially
- 16:27founded because of his actions, that's just good
- 16:31storytelling. But a lot can change in film development.
- 16:36Gunn might never actually address this. And even
- 16:40if he does, right now, in 2025, the response
- 16:45to the Justice Gang's actions is pretty sad.
- 16:49I've read a lot of reviews and watched a lot
- 16:53of video essays about this film. And what Caleb
- 16:57and I see as a flaw, most of the internet sees
- 17:00as a strength. This film isn't about real political
- 17:05conflict. But it kind of is. There are multiple
- 17:10unjust invasions happening right now in our world.
- 17:14It's hard to believe that it's a coincidence
- 17:16that Baravia is in Eastern Europe with a Russian
- 17:20-accented president, that it's also an ally of
- 17:24the United States, and that its army is prepared
- 17:27to shoot brown -faced children. And there are
- 17:30several real -world leaders who have perpetuated
- 17:34violence against innocents with seemingly no
- 17:37consequences. When there is such evil being committed,
- 17:42it can be tempting to just want someone to make
- 17:46it stop by any means necessary. Which is why
- 17:51I think this version of Superman, this Clark
- 17:56Kent, To him, everyone is important. Everyone
- 18:06is worth saving, even when it is the thing which
- 18:11requires greater effort. Even his enemies deserve
- 18:15his every attempt to bring them around. As a
- 18:19non -human, Clark shows us that all humans are
- 18:24infinitely valuable. I want to leave you with
- 18:29a quote from Pa Kent given to Clark at his lowest
- 18:34moment. When he's questioning everything, all
- 18:38of his choices and actions. Parents aren't for
- 18:43telling their children who they're supposed to
- 18:45be. We are here to give you all tools. Help you
- 18:52make fools of yourselves all on your own. Your
- 18:57choices. Your actions. That's what makes you
- 19:03who you are. Thanks for coming.