Latest / SPEAK LIKE A CEO / 289: How to Run Virtual Meetings That Energize, Not Drain with Andrew Brodsky
Transcript
- 0:00Do you get too many messages and are on too many Zoom calls and then have no energy left
- 0:04at the end of the day?
- 0:05I know this happens to me. Zoom fatigue is real and so is information overload and fortunately
- 0:10there are signs, spec strategies that can get you better results from your virtual communication
- 0:14while preserving your energy. And to find out what these are, I speak to Andrew Brodsky.
- 0:21Andrew is a manager professor at the University of Texas at Austin and the author of Ping,
- 0:24the Secrets of Success for Virtual Communication.
- 0:27A week's law of my video meetings often feel often how to fix them. The biggest myths
- 0:31about remote work communication, eye-opening research on brainstorming, authenticity
- 0:36and trust in virtual settings and what leaders must do to create healthier, more effective
- 0:40remote workplaces. This is very timely and relevant. Most of us develop virtual communications
- 0:45habits during COVID that may be on service anymore. So let's upgrade.
- 0:50Andrew, welcome to the show.
- 0:53Thanks for having me on.
- 0:54As an expert in virtual communications, would you say that in-person communication
- 0:58is always better?
- 1:00I would say definitely not. If you're someone who's had hours and hours of wasted meetings
- 1:07in an any given week, you know that in-person communication is not always best.
- 1:11So the trick is to make sure you don't error too far on the other side. There are some
- 1:15people who say we should get rid of meetings altogether and just do email and just as a
- 1:21quick example, this conversation you and I are having, I'm someone who's talking
- 1:25if you're going to ask me a whole bunch of questions, it'll take us half an hour, hour
- 1:30doing it live synchronously. If we did this via email and you sent me all these questions
- 1:34and I had multi-paragraph lung answers, it probably took me a week to write up and edit
- 1:39and proof and send back. And that's just one of those examples where synchronous meetings
- 1:44with Ed's video in-person is better. So finding that optimal balance is really what's
- 1:49that makes a lot of sense. Well, you're based by the way. So we can-
- 1:52I'm based in our arsting Texas.
- 1:53All of St. Texas. So I'm in Berlin, Germany, which means even getting together in person
- 1:57isn't really an option if we are honest, right? So we'll probably take months to set up and
- 2:01you know be at great expense and you know time spend. So virtual meetings do make a lot of
- 2:07sense in many instances. But I wonder what we haven't figured out about them. A few years ago,
- 2:11during COVID you know everyone obviously started to use Zoom and Google Mead and whatnot.
- 2:17That's great. But I think we kind of stagnate it on our journey to become better at using
- 2:22these tools. And that stagnation is one of the things I really focus on in the book.
- 2:29So many of us get into communication habits or routines and don't question our assumptions
- 2:35or approach to our interactions. And that is a huge sync of productivity,
- 2:39worsens relationships. If for instance if people are having email chain,
- 2:45even though a quick phone call might solve the issue, they'll just stay in email because
- 2:49they're already in email and it'll take weeks to resolve something. Or if a group has always had
- 2:54a meeting for something, they'll keep having a meeting for it. Even though it really would be
- 2:58handled much better via even an instant message or an email. And so taking a second to question
- 3:05your assumptions can really help save you a lot of time at work. Even though it feels like more
- 3:10effort, the payoff can be pretty massive. What assumptions are wrong generally speaking?
- 3:17There's a whole lot of them, but I'll pick on a couple of my favorite ones. So the first is one
- 3:22we already hit on. There's this kind of in-person default bias. The idea that it's not just that in-person
- 3:28is best. So that's part of it. Everyone assumes in-person is best and everything else is worse,
- 3:32which is not true in any cases. But the other part of it is they try and make every interaction
- 3:38like in-person. So we want to make video interactions as much like in-person as possible.
- 3:45My management department, my university during COVID, they wanted to do some bonding activity.
- 3:52So the idea they had was let's get a comedian. So there's 20 of us on Mutants Zoom, all these
- 3:58professors and this comedian's coming and making jokes while we're all on mute here. And it just
- 4:03went really badly as you can imagine. So rather than trying to make everything like in-person,
- 4:10it's thinking more about, okay, what are the strengths of this mode of communication? And how can we
- 4:15best leverage them as opposed to making everything just look like in-person? What are the strengths?
- 4:20For instance, if we're talking about video to start there, there's some really cool research that
- 4:26shows that chat during video meetings can be beneficial. It allows more people to interact during
- 4:32the meeting. And it allows many people who wouldn't have spoken up and provide something during the
- 4:36meeting to add in that input. If you think about the way meeting works, only one person can talk at
- 4:41a time. And if you have a meeting with 20 people, chances are most of those people aren't going to get
- 4:45to talk, provide their input. So if you come up with norms during a meeting saying, hey, we'll use
- 4:51the audio channel for talking live with this. But everyone else that provide feedback as we're
- 4:56going in chat on this, it allows a lot more productivity, a lot more people to get their voice in.
- 5:02And that's one of the advantages of that. Another example, brain storming.
- 5:08So everyone loves having the whiteboard and they're just shooting off ideas and it feels exciting
- 5:14when we're on a conference room. But research shows that early stage brain storming is better done
- 5:20via text and separately. Interesting. Three reasons. One, we can each only say an idea at time when
- 5:28we're in a room. So if you have 10 people to each come up with 20 ideas, that would take hours
- 5:33to say them. But if we each type down 20 ideas, it'd be real quick. Second, when you're in a room,
- 5:39you're everyone's staring at you. And you're nervous to say an idea that really is
- 5:44disconforming, that disagrees with everyone else. That's way out there because they're all just
- 5:49looking at you. And when you're behind a computer just typing it up, you feel more comfortable
- 5:53saying doing something much more rigid. And lastly, when someone else has an idea in a meeting,
- 6:01our brain sticks to that idea. And every idea we then have there afterwards is kind of just
- 6:07variations of that because we've heard it now or anchored on that idea. So early stage brain
- 6:13storming is better done via text and separately. And then when you want to actually decide on which
- 6:18idea to use, that's when you want to be because that's when there's a lot of back and forth that's
- 6:23valuable. Interesting. Interesting. So early stage brain storming, we do separately. And then for
- 6:29instance, in a select group, we would share our ideas and then get together. This is fascinating.
- 6:35I never heard anyone say this, but it makes a lot of sense when I think about how I develop ideas
- 6:39and things usually best done by yourself, being quiet, just sitting down pen and paper,
- 6:44you can prefer that just writing rather than typing or speaking. So that is extremely helpful.
- 6:50And what I loved about the book, so ping. And I grabbed this in a look at bookshop because I
- 6:57thought this is such a cool topic. And it hasn't felt me through the usual ways. Normally, I get
- 7:03recommendations through my network. Anyone who sort of research in communications, I kind of,
- 7:08hear about this, but this was in a major bookstore right there, which suggests that people really
- 7:13want to find out more about this topic. And I particularly like the table you developed the idea
- 7:19about communication mode richness and the two dimensions, which I hadn't thought about. So could
- 7:24you speak to that? Of course. So there's a number of ways that researchers categorize different
- 7:31modes of virtual communication. And first, just to define virtual communication, it's any
- 7:36communication that happens electronically. Text, instant message, video calls, also telephone
- 7:43calls are virtual because they happen over your smartphone or voice over IP. Basically,
- 7:48anything that's not in person or sending a snail mail letter across the postal office. But
- 7:55so there are two of the primary ways in which researchers tend to think about different modes of
- 8:01communication and how they varied. One is on Q variety. So how similar are the nonverbal
- 8:08behaviors and the cues to in person interactions? How many are there? And then the other one is
- 8:14synchronicity. So how real time is a communication? Is it labbed? Like email? Is it instantaneous?
- 8:22More like in person. And one thing to remember is that even small differences on these dimensions matter.
- 8:29When it comes to video calls, for instance, they are very slightly less synchronous than in person
- 8:35in directions, because there's data transfer speeds. So there's like fractions of a millisecond that
- 8:40it takes for my video to reach your computer. And the problem with that is that studies, these studies
- 8:47have found that even small lags can interrupt the flow of conversation, which is why video calls
- 8:54occasionally have people interrupting each other more than they would in person. Or there are
- 8:59those awkward pauses while we're waiting for to be sure the other person is done. So even slight
- 9:06changes can be quite meaningful. You go, no, no, you go. No, you go. Exactly. Exactly. It doesn't happen
- 9:11in real life. A tiny bit in real life, but not nearly. It happens a whole lot more of a video.
- 9:17Yeah. So the real distinction is not between in person or virtual, virtual as in video call.
- 9:24It's more about do I see the other people or do not see them? Is that right?
- 9:30For a Q variety that does matter. So if you can't see them, you're missing the hand motions,
- 9:36the facial language here. You're missing a whole lot of numberable behaviors. But just because
- 9:41you see them, it is not exactly the same. And here's again, where small differences matter.
- 9:47Over video, you can't see the lower half of people's bodies. So you can't see some numberables.
- 9:52But even in video, things differ a little bit from in person. As an example, eye contacts.
- 9:58In person, eye contact, simple. I'm looking at your eyes. You're okay in my eyes. It seems like
- 10:03we're paying attention to each other. Over video, you've got this choice of, okay, do I look at the
- 10:08other person's screen? Do I look at my screen? Or do I look at my webcam? Usually in most displays,
- 10:15other person's video displays can be on the left side of your screen or the right side of your
- 10:20screen. You'll be on the opposite. And if you're looking at one of those to the other person,
- 10:24it actually looks like you're not maintaining eye contact because your webcam is either
- 10:28located in the top center of your screen or sometimes on a stand in between two monitors.
- 10:33So there's this awkward decision you have to think about is, well, where do I look during those
- 10:37video interactions? So where do we look? There's a number of studies that have shown that
- 10:44the appearance of eye contacts. So it looks like you're looking at them matters.
- 10:50It's been shown in job interviews that the interviewers rate interviewees better
- 10:55who maintain eye contact. So to do that functionally, you need to be looking at your webcam.
- 11:01But there's a bunch of shortcuts you can do to fix this. The lowest tech version is just drag
- 11:06the screen you're looking at, whether it's other person, to right under your webcam.
- 11:11The mid tech options are there's like hanging stick on webcams you can put on your computer
- 11:16or their webcam stands at bend and you can kind of bend in the middle of your screen.
- 11:21The more high tech options now, there's actually teleprompter screens that put the camera behind
- 11:27your screen. There are AI tools that will center your eye contact for you. Although you do want
- 11:32to be careful because those can be really creepy. If you like turn your head to the side but your
- 11:37eyes are still facing the center of the screen so you won't you know fire be where we're selling
- 11:42those. Yeah. But it's just this idea that these are things you need to be mindful about interacting
- 11:46virtually that don't come naturally to us from interacting in person. So understanding how these
- 11:52things appear on the other side is really important to making sure that your interactions go as you
- 11:58want. Yeah. And I presume also to have the camera switched on because that's something I see
- 12:02from time to time that people are in a video call but switch off the camera. Okay, sometimes it's
- 12:06unavoidable fair enough but as a general rule would you say leave the camera on? I would say
- 12:12not as a general rule. It depends is the answer. There's research that shows in different situations
- 12:18cameras on as better others camera off. Cameras on is better if you want to show that you're engaged
- 12:25or show the illusion that you're engaged. It makes it seem like you're really more attentive
- 12:30even though you may not be. You could still have you know dinner recipe or a game up on your
- 12:34computer screen and they don't know. Just because your cameras on doesn't actually mean you're
- 12:38more engaged. It just looks like you are. But presenting that illusion is better if you have your
- 12:42camera on. The other thing it's useful for is especially early in relationships and you want
- 12:48to build trust. Cameras on is useful because we don't trust what we don't know. If we don't know
- 12:54what someone looks like if we don't know their mannerisms it's hard to feel like we can trust them
- 12:59because there's so much information missing and having that camera on can be handy there.
- 13:05On the other side there's a whole bunch of studies that have shown this effect called zoom fatigue
- 13:10or video conferencing fatigue. In that being on camera is exhausting. You're staring at yourself to
- 13:16see if you like broccoli in your teeth. You're making sure your nonverbal behaviors are good. You know
- 13:22that they're all kind of seeing you on camera and it's much more attentive you know much more
- 13:26salient to you because your webcam is sitting right in front of you. And so turning your camera off
- 13:33can reduce fatigue and reduce stress bringing this all together. The you know a little framework
- 13:40to think about this. If it's a new relationship or engagement is important camera on. If you've
- 13:45got an existing team everyone kind of knows each other. You've already built impressions. You know
- 13:50one more meeting is not going to change up people feel about each other. The cameras off can be
- 13:54better because then people in that meeting can save that energy more for focusing on the task at
- 14:00hand and then there less fatigue following the meeting. Interesting and thought about this but it
- 14:06is true being on camera is a little fatiguing I guess for some people more than others and then more
- 14:10things to think about right. What about my hair? What about my background? What about the children
- 14:14and pets running around? I haven't cleaned my room so all of that good stuff and we come back to
- 14:20more sort of the the real technical stuff and the energy management and all that but you also
- 14:25developed a specific approach that helps us systematize this right there's one thing some knowing
- 14:31all the tips and that the research but tomorrow I'm on like five video calls. Talk me through the
- 14:37ping approach what what should I think about. Yeah I love when there's a good framework in a book
- 14:42because there's always so many recommendations like trying to wrap it around remember them all so
- 14:46I tied all of the recommendations in the book into the ping framework because it's the ping book.
- 14:51So P's for perspective taking I for initiative and for nonverbal G for goals.
- 14:56Great. P for perspective taking means or focuses on the fact that when we're interacting virtually
- 15:03we tend to become much more self focused. When you're when you're writing an email you're just looking
- 15:09at the key you know text on your computer screen even in a video call you're just looking at the
- 15:13small square of the person you're interacting with was when you're in person there is someone
- 15:19standing right there in front of you you're not forgetting about it and you're focused on how
- 15:23they're going to react. That's why we often say things on virtual communication we wouldn't in
- 15:28person because they're not standing in front of us you know they're not as salient. So taking that
- 15:34step to make sure you think about well how is this going to hit on the other side how someone else
- 15:38going to interpret this is valuable. Yeah. I for initiative the center point about initiative
- 15:45is that many people think okay this mode has this strengths and weaknesses and they accept them
- 15:50as fixed and that's the wrong approach. You want to think about well what's missing from this
- 15:55mode and how can I edit back in. There's some cool studies showing that text based negotiators
- 16:02perform worse than in person or video negotiators and the reason is they build less rapport there's
- 16:08less trust. But what these researchers found is that when they had a group of the text based
- 16:13negotiators right before they negotiate over text do a five minute phone call just to schmuz as they
- 16:20said or socialize that those text negotiators who schmuzed right before going to text they did
- 16:26better not just for themselves but for the person they were negotiating with they got more win wins
- 16:32and so thinking about okay maybe email instant message it's missing that small talk how can I
- 16:38infuse that back in in a natural way. So taking a moment and thinking about what can I do to make
- 16:44this better as opposed just accepting things the way they are can improve outcomes. N is nonverbal
- 16:50yeah we've already talked about eye contact but there's tons of other ones so for instance typos
- 16:56can relay emotion in email time a day that's an email sent can relay power video calls we mentioned
- 17:02eye contact but also your background you're lighting there's research on all these different
- 17:07things and making sure that you're on point with your nonverbal behavior it is going to be one of
- 17:11the most important things to making sure your message is effective. I can't wait to quantify this
- 17:16to what extent is verbal for this nonverbal it means is there you see different percentage
- 17:20of numbers floating around but would you say they're both equally important or is one more important
- 17:24to the other. I think yeah so I think if you've seen exact percentages they're going to not be
- 17:30accurate because so much matters based on different situations so for newer relationships nonverbal
- 17:36behaviors will often matter a lot more than for existing ones because for existing ones they know
- 17:41the meaning of your words they can fill in those gaps where it's for newer relationships they're
- 17:46trying to understand how does this person feel they're doing a lot more guesswork so they're trying
- 17:52to use all that information that's available there so it really depends on the context which
- 17:57won't be more important but they are always both important you don't want to forget about one of them
- 18:03that's right but people pay more attention to what they say than how they say it in my experience
- 18:08so that's probably why we should focus on a little more because it's it's kind of
- 18:12underappreciated a little bit and especially sort of using your hands your body language
- 18:18in a video course so what about the distance to the camera what about your hands how much
- 18:23of my upper body should I show is that so best practice based on science yeah so I've yet to see
- 18:29a good research study that actually focuses on distance from camera hand language what's
- 18:35been clear from some of those studies is that having a good camera having good lighting having
- 18:40good sound all of these things matter because it makes interaction feel more natural feel more
- 18:45professional in those settings as well yeah make sense and the G and the ping oh yeah yeah so
- 18:54yeah this is the state the last for the most important here G is goals I wish I could just say
- 19:02there's one best communication mode it'd be a very simple advice and there's one best way
- 19:06to use each one but that's not the case yeah it depends on your goals we already talked about
- 19:11cameras on verse off an idea here is what's more important showing engagement or saving energy
- 19:17and there's a lot of other examples too for instance email or instant message may be more productive
- 19:22but you're not going to build a stronger relationship often than necessarily so thinking about okay
- 19:28is productivity more important for our team here or is building relationships more important here
- 19:33and actually being thoughtful and mindful about well what are it is our key goal here and what
- 19:38is going to best achieve that as opposed to just saying okay videos better cameras on better we're
- 19:43always going to do that that's a wrong approach to things yeah and the goals I mean is it also to
- 19:49go into call let's say video call with a clear agenda and a clear goal of what you want to achieve
- 19:55during the next 30 minutes say yeah and this is a thing with meetings video calls in particular
- 20:02really can just drag on and on because it's easier for people to become distracted others may not
- 20:08notice that others are losing attention at some point so coming into the meetings with a clear
- 20:14agenda a clear plan you know time for each thing a set and time for meetings you don't want to say
- 20:21okay let's meet until we figure it out because meetings will expand to fill the time available
- 20:26they will keep going and the other thing is making sure the people in there are the ones who need to
- 20:31be in there there's studies that show that shorter meetings video meetings with fewer people are the
- 20:37least fatiguing of them yeah so those it's better to have a few shorter half hour meetings than one
- 20:44three hour long meeting if you're going to do it so it says more frequent short touch points which
- 20:48are is a better approach generally with having video meetings totally involved with that and you
- 20:53said fatiguing and I think that's a big issue I mean in large organizations in particular once I
- 21:00work with but also what I hear from other people is that they have so many virtual meetings so many
- 21:06video calls that it takes up a big chunk of their day which drains them of energy and then they
- 21:11have to sort of fit that what they would call real work either very early in the morning or late in
- 21:16the evening and that of course is very tiring and can lead to burnout and also some very
- 21:22productive I presume so from an organization perspective we're talking to leadership now
- 21:27what can leaders do to help reduce them of meetings or make them better and just having a general
- 21:35organization approach to virtual meetings great question this is one of the things I talk a lot
- 21:41about when I'm consulting with executives one of the approaches is to really become more explicit
- 21:48and have conversation amongst communication norms yeah for instance being had in the conversations
- 21:55with with your team thinking about okay what are we going to meet for what are we going to use
- 21:59text-based communication for or phone and it's not just stopping there it's talking about okay what
- 22:05are our response speed expectations there's studies on the email urgency bias which shows especially
- 22:12after hours for emails if you get an email you think the sender wants to response more quickly
- 22:18then it turns out they actually do so if you were to send me email after hours I'd be like oh
- 22:23here's so important they've got you know consulting podcast books and I'm like I need to respond
- 22:29quickly but in your end you're like I'm emailing 50 people I don't care if he responds for a couple
- 22:36weeks here and so having and that the problem is this really creates stress on the recipients
- 22:42because they're constantly needing to check their phones be attached to their devices so having
- 22:47conversations saying okay if it's email let's expect responses within 24 hours if it's instant
- 22:52messages slack messages maybe two hours that way if you're in a meeting or focused on working
- 22:57wait till after and if there's an emergency let's say we'll do a text message and the benefit of
- 23:03this is a fewfold one you don't have to be attached to your device constantly during work in
- 23:09after hours you know just listen for the text chime if there's an emergency otherwise you can check
- 23:14it when you're ready to and this gives you more time to detach after work it increases focus during
- 23:20work as well makes a lot of sense and I want to how many companies and your experience actually
- 23:27have such a communications protocol or strategy do you have a number I've seen I've never seen
- 23:34one yet at least you know before I work with them yeah who had like a full one I have seen many
- 23:39organizations being much more mindful about their communication as of yeah so for instance Shopify
- 23:44became famous because they basically canceled all the meetings of everyone's calendars and now they
- 23:49have a meeting calculator that shows how much money is being spent based on having people in that
- 23:55meeting so there are organizations taking much more mindful approach this I've yet to see the
- 24:01full like let's think about response times and all that and as a nice edit benefit to there's
- 24:06that email we all hate to send where it's like should I follow up because I haven't heard yet should
- 24:10I you know hey just circling back but if you've set the clear like okay we respond to this within
- 24:16this time this within this time you know once that time passed it's completely cool to follow back
- 24:22up with them because it's passed that time and people no longer left wondering being stressed
- 24:26about all that because we made the implicit more explicit when it comes to communication arms
- 24:31within the organization I think everyone in organizations should have this they should have a
- 24:37common understanding that is written down in a document accessible to everyone and part of the
- 24:41onboarding of how we communicate why because 88% of knowledge workers time is spent communicating
- 24:49mostly virtual but also in in meetings right so if that is most of what anyone does but we leave
- 24:56it almost up to chance or just you know how we developed over the years without questioning in
- 25:02the productivity losses and also the losses in terms of mental health and energy and just
- 25:07general vitality of the business it's just huge so why doesn't every leader does this and
- 25:12just sit down and say we respond to this and we don't respond to that and this is what we
- 25:17use select for and this is what we use email for and this is what we use our company wiki for
- 25:21and so on and so forth yeah why and I do want to get silver lining because we all feel
- 25:27overwhelmed with all the new communication technology it can exhausting stressful but there's
- 25:32been a whole lot of benefits one which you and I already talked about is the fact that we're
- 25:36across the world from each other we can talk but even when it comes to focus at work there's a study
- 25:42that showed that the more people used instant message the less they felt interrupted at work
- 25:47the reason being is the old way whenever is whenever you had a question you go over to your co-workers
- 25:52cubicle or office and ask them but the problem was stop you really quick yeah you're interrupting them
- 25:57every single time you have a question now if you just send an instant message they can answer it
- 26:02when they finish whatever they're on and so this communication allows people to more separate
- 26:07their interactions in ways that can yield greater focus if you approach it strategically
- 26:13it makes a lot of sense yeah it's that business or leader who's doing that really well you already
- 26:17mentioned Shopify but maybe there's some other examples we can learn from yeah you know let me talk
- 26:21about examples of people who have communicated really well so all leaders have had good communications
- 26:27and bad communications but there's a couple that like stood out particularly well to me that
- 26:32really fit well into this framework too so Jeff Weiner the CEO of LinkedIn back when they were
- 26:38acquired by Microsoft so that you know when your company gets acquired it's very concerning
- 26:42from employees they're concerned they're going to get fired it's going to change the way everything
- 26:46does and so he sent an email out about this and emails can often come across as cold and they
- 26:52tend to be often self focused and I have the quote from him here that he said and that I thought
- 26:57was just really great in this email he said no matter what you're feeling now give yourself some time
- 27:04to process the news you might feel a sense of excitement fear sadness or some combination of all
- 27:10those emotions every member of the exact team has experienced the same but we've had months to
- 27:17process this is a really great example here of saying like I know you could be feeling anything
- 27:24I'm not trying to say I feel it too I realize I'm in a different position than you are
- 27:30and it's not trying to necessarily executives often fall in the like I'm right there with you
- 27:35approach and the employees are like no you're not you're worth a hundred million dollars like this
- 27:40is not the same experience here and so engaging in that kind of perspective taking that's especially
- 27:46helpful virtually is really useful yeah that makes a lot of sense I agree I think they they
- 27:54they have a very strong communications culture as far as I can see anyone who doesn't really go
- 27:58any examples of someone who's doing it really badly and we don't have to name names but we can
- 28:02anonymize them yeah if you prefer and during COVID there were a whole bunch of viral things that
- 28:08went out about layoffs I talked about one of them in the book where better the mortgage company
- 28:13had this viral video of the CEO basically saying you know last time I did this layoff I layoff
- 28:21like this I cried and talking about focusing on how said he was to engage in this layoff and it
- 28:29went viral here's the thing as an employee you're probably pretty lucky that your CEO is actually
- 28:38crying about this layoff and to have a CEO who's being so willing to be vulnerable about that
- 28:44but here's the problem it hits really really poorly on the employees side that he's so self-focused
- 28:49and this is the problem with virtual interactions getting back to his perspective taking
- 28:53he's sitting there in a room by himself with a webcam facing him so he's focused on his emotions
- 29:00if he was in a room with the employees and saw their faces much more so right in front of him
- 29:07that's focused would have shifted and so the idea here is this is one of the ways that when we're
- 29:12sitting in a room by yourself from front of a computer screen that we end up being self-focused and
- 29:17potentially what is in authentic ways and it would be generally nice just comes across really
- 29:24really badly here yeah but it sounds performative right it sounds like this this person maybe felt
- 29:32it maybe didn't but it felt like he was putting on a performance in order to you know soften the
- 29:38blow on him or whatever it feels very self-referential and performative which is something an important
- 29:44thing to double click on right performative versus authenticity so how do we correct that authenticity
- 29:50code in virtual communications I did some research across a number of sites some was with managers
- 29:56some was with negotiators also I did some research with parents and teachers in international
- 30:02schools in Vietnam so as a teacher and a private school your parents are sort of your customers
- 30:09but you have to tell them like oh yeah your perfect little angels failing the class and so it creates
- 30:15this awkward situation where you need to be really warm but maybe you're not feeling warm
- 30:20which gets into the findings of these studies I focus on two types of authenticity in virtual
- 30:25communication the first is true authenticity where you feel what you're trying to show and the
- 30:31second is something researchers call surface acting and the idea behind service acting is that
- 30:37they're often at work we need to show emotions we're not actually feeling so maybe you need to
- 30:43congratulate a coworker on something great that happened a promotion or whatever else but you're
- 30:49really mad you spoke coffee in yourself in the morning you had a horrible commute you had to fight
- 30:53with your partner or your kid or something you don't want to go to that coworker be like I wish
- 30:58you could be happy for you but I you know I had a bad commute like that would be bad or if you have
- 31:04to on the other side of it maybe you're in the mortgage business or a loan business and you
- 31:09need to deny a customer alone or your manager executive was to fire an employee but you're in a great
- 31:16mood maybe you proposed your partner the day beforehand and they said yes you don't want to go
- 31:22to that employee and say I'm in the best mood ever I like I'm gonna get married by the way I
- 31:28need to fire you or like I need to deny you know I'm a great mood but unfortunately your loan is
- 31:33not here so being truly authentic is bad in many situations yeah bring bring it to virtual communication
- 31:40if you're truly authentic go with the richest mode whether that's in person or video because you
- 31:46want that authenticity to shine through so in personal videos better than email text for true
- 31:53authenticity yeah got a service acting it's a different story because the problem is is that people
- 32:00can see when you're not being truly authentic so if you accidentally grimace or you've got to
- 32:06look away or facial expressions people can pick up on these things because we leak emotional
- 32:11information when we're engaging in visual interactions I found in these studies that people who
- 32:16engage in service acting are more likely to choose text-based communication what is service acting
- 32:22sorry yeah so that was the explanation was like this idea of when you're showing emotion
- 32:26with that actually doesn't exist underneath you so it's this idea that you're doing you're
- 32:31you're acting but just on the surface with your emotion oh sorry surface yeah so it's like
- 32:38service with a smile so it's those examples I gave were you're not really feeling the motion
- 32:43but you wanted to display it on the outside and so for service acting this idea of you're
- 32:50faking it but for a good reason you know maybe you're laying off the employee and you don't want to
- 32:55tell them how happy you are because it's something else that happened or you're congratulating the
- 32:59coworker and you don't want to tell them how upset you are about something unrelated so in those
- 33:03cases those people who are engaging in this kind of service acting they tended to use text-based
- 33:08communication because they felt it was the easiest to hide it was the safest it was the lowest
- 33:12effort but that's the wrong choice what I found in these studies is that audio communication
- 33:19so telephone cameras off is the best for this kind of authenticity because visual communication
- 33:25people can tell you're faking if they see you on video if they see you in person they know you're
- 33:29faking it but email comes off as so low effort and so inauthentic because the choice of the
- 33:36mode just makes it seem like you're faking it or you don't care you don't care yeah you can imagine
- 33:41something great happens to your life and someone who you've interact with previously over phone
- 33:46in person just send you an email saying congratulations that's great news like it just feels
- 33:52I'm caring so the nice thing about audio is that it's much seen as much more authentic or
- 33:59effortful than email or instant message but it doesn't have all the emotional leakage that video
- 34:05an in person does so it doesn't have all those cues you have to worry about it's just your tone of
- 34:11voice and your word choice you don't have to worry about your face your hands anything else so
- 34:16there's this sweet spot in the middle that many people often miss interesting and if we now throw
- 34:21AI into the mix so emails get written by AI and even the people we see on screen in the future we
- 34:28may not be sure anymore if they're real or if they're an avatar how are we going to deal with that
- 34:34challenge yeah there's a bunch of news stories it's come out recently about people using AI
- 34:37versions of themselves for video interviews so my view is on this is that for communication that
- 34:47matters your words will always be important think about it this way most of the time others won't
- 34:55realize that you copy and paste an email from chat GPT or Gemini or perplexity or copilot whatever
- 35:01else but they will once every so often whether it's 1% of the time or 5% of the time maybe it uses a
- 35:08word you don't normally use like elevator prolific maybe you talked to your coworker in person
- 35:15about something like and they mentioned this past weekend their whole family had a stomach bug
- 35:20and it was like awful and then you then a couple days later you copy and paste an email from
- 35:25chat GPT to them that starts with I hope you had a great weekend exclamation mark completely missing
- 35:32what you talked about in person and the thing is AI will never know everything that's in your head
- 35:38so as a result there are these slip ups and the problem is if someone realizes you used AI
- 35:44to communicate with them whether that's reading a script during a video call copy and paste an
- 35:48email from AI what they realize at once they're going to question whether every single interaction
- 35:55you've had with them virtually has been AI in the past and if they're questioning whether
- 35:59every single interaction you've had in the past has been AI their next question is going to be
- 36:03well why am I interacting with this person in the first place if I could just ask AI the same
- 36:08questions and you don't want people asking why are they interacting with you at all and that's
- 36:13the worst outcome you can have so can really break trust exactly and that's not to say there's
- 36:19not a use for AI it's great for editing brainstorming low stakes repeated interactions but for the
- 36:25important interactions making sure the words are yours is going to be really valuable such a good point
- 36:32and it comes back to using AI in the right way not in the wrong way right to to do the work for
- 36:37us not to do the thinking for us to polish our words not to give us the words we should use I
- 36:44think that's such an important distinction yes now from a leadership perspective before we wrap
- 36:50up I wanted to get actionable and for anyone's listening okay what I like three quick things we
- 36:55can do and introduce to my virtual communication better in our organization I think that's the question
- 37:01many people have on their minds yeah so three quick things one actually get in the create the
- 37:09routines to have people question their communication habits and choices we just get into these patterns
- 37:14that we never question we always do the video meeting for this we do email so getting into that
- 37:19habit second making the implicit more explicit when it comes to communication I we talked about
- 37:25norms around response times and what mode we use when but also making sure that you're saying things
- 37:32in your communication so it's clear there's so many misinterpretations that happen in email
- 37:37instant message because people assume their message their intent is clear but on the recipient
- 37:42side it's not clear to them so being clear like I'm excited or I'm disappointed actually spelling
- 37:49it out more can avoid a whole lot of those misinterpretations that can create some major conflict
- 37:54in organizations yeah and lastly encourage learning about this there's so much information so
- 38:00much science on how to communicate better across technology and learning how to do that better
- 38:07and encouraging your employees to do that better has been shown to improve productivity improve the
- 38:12strength of relationships and also improves everyone's overall well being because they figure out
- 38:17how can I detach from this communication better how can I make sure I recover how do I balance this
- 38:23in the right way and those three things together can yield a whole bunch of benefits and what you
- 38:29go further and and say hey why don't you bit more radical like to be looked at Shopify right take
- 38:34out all the meetings only put put the the necessary ones back in or have a cost counter oh if I'm
- 38:41right 10 people to one hour meeting gosh that's you know five thousand dollars that's crazy would
- 38:47you go as far so sometimes you need a pretty extreme change to fix things that said I'd be
- 38:55personally wary of something that extreme because sometimes it pushes too far to the other side
- 39:00so if you make people concerned about meetings because every time they're looking at it they're
- 39:04seeing dollar signs huge amounts of them then you might have people avoiding meetings when they
- 39:08really need them so it's finding that balance that's really key as opposed to going to one extreme
- 39:14or the other yeah that makes a lot of sense wow thank you Andrew that is so good and so timely
- 39:20and so important and there's always my last question what's your best piece of communications advice
- 39:26my best piece of communications advice is to question your assumptions we all feel like we
- 39:32kind of are good at this even though we're not and the thing is humans by most estimates have been
- 39:38interacting for over a hundred thousand years in person if you look at the scale of human history
- 39:44of how long we've been interacting virtually it's a very thin slice this just doesn't come naturally
- 39:49to us so questioning your assumptions about what's best being willing to experiment and you may
- 39:54find that things can work out a lot better than you even expected yeah I love that both mindset
- 39:59learning approach the beginners mindset when it comes to virtual communication which really for
- 40:04most of us started like five six years ago in earnest right like really for hours every day
- 40:10and yeah we're getting we're getting better at it so I appreciate it and I think organizations are
- 40:14also learning how to use these fantastic tools in a very deliberate way that improves
- 40:20well-being and productivity rather than hindering them but like any tool it can be they're
- 40:24for good or for bad Andrew Brodsky you're though of paying the secrets of successful virtual
- 40:29communication thank you so much thanks for having me on and thank you for listening