Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Trial Tutorials: Examination of Expert Witnesses
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to our latest installment of trial tutorials,
- 0:07Examination of Experts. I'm Alla Policastro,
- 0:10Director of Education and Professional Development
- 0:12at Beverly Hills Bar Association. And today I'm
- 0:15delighted to welcome back our speaker, Michael
- 0:17Gibelson, and special guest, expert witness,
- 0:19Ben Shepard. Michael is a partner at Robbins
- 0:22Kaplan, where he is a business trial lawyer with
- 0:25extensive experience representing individuals
- 0:27and companies in real estate and other business
- 0:30disputes involving false advertising, unfair
- 0:33competition, class actions, misappropriation
- 0:35of trade secrets, supply agreements, copyright,
- 0:38and trademark. He's a past chair of the California
- 0:41State Bar's litigation section and a fellow of
- 0:44the American College of Real Estate Lawyers.
- 0:47He has secured significant trial victories across
- 0:49a wide range of industries. He frequently writes
- 0:52and speaks on litigation skills and strategies
- 0:54with a focus on making trials more effective
- 0:57and understandable for juries. Ben Shepard is
- 1:00a director with Berkeley Research Group in Los
- 1:03Angeles. He is a CPA and a certified valuations
- 1:06analyst and has over 35 years of professional
- 1:09experience and over 30 years of entertainment
- 1:12industry experience. Ben serves as an economic
- 1:15damages and forensic accounting expert witness,
- 1:18having testified more than 90 times. Ben also
- 1:21has long time leadership positions with both
- 1:23the ABA forum on entertainment and sports, as
- 1:26well as the annual Cal CPA entertainment industry
- 1:28conference. I can't wait to hear what they have
- 1:31to share with us today. So I'm going to turn
- 1:32it over to Michael and Ben. Good afternoon everyone
- 1:39and thanks for joining Ben and me for this presentation
- 1:42on an examination of expert witnesses direct
- 1:45and cross and As Allah said, I handle a wide
- 1:49range of cases. So this year it's been everything
- 1:51from a donut machine supply agreement to a real
- 1:55estate case related to a warehouse that had a
- 1:59lease that was terminated. And right now I'm
- 2:01in trial on an unlawful detainer case that relates
- 2:04to a retail facility and just finished up a trial
- 2:06related to sexual abuse. of a minor. So the range
- 2:11of things that we talk about in trial is obviously
- 2:14wide and so our goal today is to talk about as
- 2:17many of the principles that apply to these concepts
- 2:21as possible in both direct and cross -examination.
- 2:24But Ben and I have come at it, we thought would
- 2:27be best from the damages perspective, which affects
- 2:30many cases, obviously. And so, Ben, why don't
- 2:33you just talk about the range of cases that you
- 2:36work on that might give people a background to
- 2:39yourself. Thanks, Michael. Hi, everyone. It's
- 2:42great to be here. Thanks for joining us. So in
- 2:45addition to a lot of entertainment work, so like,
- 2:47for instance, I've worked on the last couple
- 2:49of projects, a combined entertainment and restaurant
- 2:55facility near Yucca Valley, and then also on
- 3:00a recent case involving an investor in major
- 3:08studio motion pictures. I've also done projects
- 3:10in other types of industries. One of the most
- 3:13recent ones I did was worked on economic damages,
- 3:16or at least in the rebuttal sense for a gas station
- 3:21in Boron along the US Highway 58 that was not
- 3:27developed into a truck stop. And so the owners
- 3:33had sued the bank. that was part of the transaction.
- 3:38So that was a very interesting piece and got
- 3:41me a lot of information about truck stops, independent
- 3:45and the big ones. So where we started, thought
- 3:49we'd start today is in talking about... the takeaways
- 3:53for the entirety of our presentation so that
- 3:56you can then leaf in the rest of the discussion
- 3:58to those. And by starting at the end, we start
- 4:01with making a positive first impression and last
- 4:03impression. Hopefully we've made a positive first
- 4:05impression so far, Ben. but also to leave people
- 4:09with the takeaways. These will be in the material,
- 4:11so feel free to not take notes. And when we talk
- 4:15about making a positive first impression and
- 4:19last impression, this really is about thinking
- 4:21about the first question that you start with
- 4:24to introduce the expert and the last question
- 4:27and answer that you leave people with on both
- 4:29direct and cross so that you have those set in
- 4:33your mind that they're not going to go sideways
- 4:36because of either a lack of preparation or a
- 4:39lack of a deposition answer that you can use.
- 4:42The second is in direct examination developing
- 4:46reliability, not just admissibility. And what
- 4:49we mean by that is about using the rules. of
- 4:53evidence, federal rules of evidence, the evidence
- 4:56code in state courts, in order to think about
- 4:59what the legislature has determined is sufficiently
- 5:02reliable and the courts have determined is sufficiently
- 5:04reliable to be considered as evidence, because
- 5:07it isn't just that threshold, it's also some
- 5:10justification and logic about why that evidence
- 5:13should be listened to and relied upon. Ben, why
- 5:17don't you take this one about the importance
- 5:19of focusing on what's important rather than everything?
- 5:22Yeah, simply put, you've done so much work as
- 5:26an expert and as counsel, and you will not have
- 5:29time to get to everything that you did and everything
- 5:32that you found. So you have to really focus on
- 5:35what you want to get across to the jury. And
- 5:39the next, finding the most efficient path. My
- 5:42favorite quote on this is Einstein's to make
- 5:44it as simple as possible and not any simpler,
- 5:48but not simpler, I think is his exact words.
- 5:50And the idea is that It's not just about dumbing
- 5:53it down, but rather about making it important
- 5:56and essential points that need to be understood
- 5:59by the jury. And that's yours, Ben, here. Oh,
- 6:04yeah. So you really want to be clearly understood.
- 6:09So you need to take your time, but certainly
- 6:12get to the point of what you're trying to say.
- 6:14I know that I tend to go a little fast in terms
- 6:17of my speech, so I have to remind myself. just
- 6:20make sure you get the points across that you
- 6:22really need to and then move on. Then the last
- 6:25of these is, of course, keeping the expert credible,
- 6:28but also keeping them in their lane, making sure
- 6:31that they don't... veer outside of it just to
- 6:33try to make a point or because you didn't have
- 6:36another witness or the right witness or because
- 6:38the order at trial gets out of order, ensuring
- 6:42that the direct examination that you get from
- 6:45the witness is staying in their lane, staying
- 6:47within their area of expertise because if you
- 6:50get outside of it, it winds up becoming easier
- 6:53and easier to cross examine the witness. Next
- 6:59is on cross -examination, the scaffold that we'll
- 7:01talk about today is about this issue of reliability.
- 7:05So even if it's admissible, is it reliable under
- 7:08the rule? So in other words, just because a judge
- 7:11says, yes, it's coming into evidence, is there
- 7:13enough of a basis for it to be believed as against
- 7:16the opposing testimony? Ben, take this one, please.
- 7:22Yes. So especially when you have an effort that
- 7:27works with a number of folks in preparing and
- 7:32coming up with the conclusions. It's important
- 7:35for the expert to review the work that was performed,
- 7:38how you got there. So the journey is just as
- 7:41important as the destination. Next is about the
- 7:46idea that there is direct and cross examination
- 7:48at all and likely opposing experts. And there
- 7:53usually are things that are Common ground among
- 7:57both sides and and usually the plaintiff will
- 7:59have the burden of presenting them and explaining
- 8:02those things and will Take a bit longer on areas
- 8:04of expert testimony than the other But there
- 8:07is a question to be decided and for all of what
- 8:10we're going to talk about today These are judgment
- 8:12calls that you're making their decisions that
- 8:14are to be made and the decision to be made is
- 8:17whether you understand what the differences are
- 8:20between the opposing experts analysis and how
- 8:23you highlight those or un -highlight them if
- 8:26the other side is going to for a reason that
- 8:28you think is unimportant. So to figure out what
- 8:31those differences are and then make decisions
- 8:33about how to highlight them as appropriate. Michael,
- 8:37do you mind if I step in for a second? Please.
- 8:40So it's important to understand the sensitivity
- 8:43of various assumptions and data that you've used.
- 8:47as well as the opposing experts to understand
- 8:49if you're challenged about using a different
- 8:53assumption or different data, you have a good
- 8:56idea in terms of whether or not it's going to
- 8:58mean a little or a lot. And having that information
- 9:02upfront is certainly going to help you be able
- 9:04to effectively respectfully push back on the
- 9:10use of that different data or different assumptions.
- 9:13So let me get to reviewing and using the deposition.
- 9:17Ben, you have a story about this one that you
- 9:20thought to share. So I have sometimes questions
- 9:28that pop up where the question was not specifically
- 9:34asked. And I have to remind counsel that that's
- 9:38a different question. And sometimes you do have
- 9:43to go back and make sure that you understand
- 9:45what you've been asked and how you've answered
- 9:48so that you can effectively at least say, oh,
- 9:51yes, I remember we talked about this as the deposition.
- 9:54So even if there is a slight difference, then
- 9:58the difference may not seem so large in that
- 10:00context. And from the examiner's perspective,
- 10:04You know, of course you'd love to have a yes
- 10:06in the deposition and a no at trial and then
- 10:09be able to read that difference. And it seldom
- 10:13happens. It sometimes does. It's more commonly
- 10:15the I don't knows that are beneficial or the
- 10:18I don't recalls or I'd have to go take a look
- 10:21and read back the data or read back some person's
- 10:24deposition. But it is as important to think about
- 10:28those other pieces of the deposition that you
- 10:30can use for the purpose of showing that the witness
- 10:34is not playing by the rules, or that they just
- 10:36weren't prepared before and now they're just
- 10:38a shill for the lawyer. And so think about the
- 10:42deposition beyond just the question of whether
- 10:44the answer is different, but also about the process
- 10:48and whether the expert has engaged in the process
- 10:50in an appropriate way in order to follow the
- 10:55rules, because people like rule followers, obviously.
- 10:58And the last on cross -examination, just that
- 11:00it's not always about you that you've got to
- 11:04anticipate opposing counsel's comments and questions
- 11:07and make a decision about whether you want to
- 11:09do that in your direct examination. Ben, you
- 11:12had some thoughts on this one? Yeah, I've had
- 11:14a couple of times where opposing counsel, they
- 11:16really don't even mention my analysis. It's typically
- 11:21just. looking at documents that I may not have
- 11:26included, but the other expert, the opposing
- 11:29expert has relied upon in their analysis and
- 11:32just trying to use me as a tool to establish
- 11:36the reasonableness or the fact that I just didn't
- 11:39do the same work as the opposing expert. So the
- 11:44next bit of our discussion today, we'll go through
- 11:48quickly because it's just about what comes from
- 11:50the rules, but using these takeaways as our first
- 11:54scaffold for the direct examination and then
- 11:58the cross -examination. Now if we apply the rules
- 12:02that have been created about what courts and
- 12:05legislatures think are are reliable evidence,
- 12:08not just admissible evidence. And we think about
- 12:11how those different opinions fit into the case.
- 12:15It's a discussion about why there's no single
- 12:17tried and true rule about expert opinions, about
- 12:22testimony, et cetera. So we start with my wife's
- 12:26grandmother who had lots of opinions, but she
- 12:29was an expert about none, at least according
- 12:32to me. But she thought she was an expert, but
- 12:35it didn't really matter. It was really about
- 12:37non -expert opinions. And so when we think about
- 12:40expert examination, we should think about these
- 12:42types of opinions as well. Effectively the same
- 12:45rule in federal court and state court. Some nuances
- 12:48that you need to pay attention to that arise
- 12:51also from the discovery. But in thinking about
- 12:54non -expert opinions, think about them in the
- 12:56same way, about the reliability of those opinions
- 12:59and giving a jury or a judge a reason to rely
- 13:02upon them. So next, that all starts with the
- 13:07disclosures that are required to be made and
- 13:09one that's commonly not made by people that completely
- 13:13upends the testimony at trial is about witnesses
- 13:18who must provide a report. And if the witness
- 13:20is retained or specially employed to provide
- 13:22expert testimony, and this is the part that usually
- 13:25gets missed, or whose duties as the party's employee
- 13:28regularly involve giving expert testimony. And
- 13:31the question is how regular it has to be in order
- 13:33to be somebody who prepares a report. But it's
- 13:38certainly notable because it is often missed
- 13:41and often given a short shift if the witness
- 13:46is not somebody that is regularly a part of litigation.
- 13:51And so in C of Rule 26, you don't have to provide
- 13:57reports for people who are not required to provide
- 14:00written reports. But you still need to provide
- 14:03an adequate summary of the facts and opinions
- 14:05to which the witness is expected to testify in
- 14:08a broad enough way to allow that person to ultimately
- 14:12testify at trial. And this one too is often missed
- 14:15because people at the time of these disclosures
- 14:17are not thinking sufficiently about even non.
- 14:21expert opinion, lay opinion, that they want to
- 14:24come in at trial. And the rules apply similarly
- 14:27in the Code of Civil Procedure under 2034 -260
- 14:31about the people whose opinions are going to
- 14:34be offered and then also about parties or employees
- 14:38of parties for whom declarations must be. provided.
- 14:42Again, going quickly through these, but the lawyer's
- 14:44declaration that is required to be provided is
- 14:47somewhat substantial and even under state law
- 14:49does provide for the substance of the testimony
- 14:52to be disclosed. And so if I'm the potentially
- 14:56cross -examining witness with the direct going
- 14:59on on the stand, I'm absolutely thinking about
- 15:02what the scope of the direct testimony is that's
- 15:04coming in. when I'm talking or when I'm listening
- 15:08to the direct testimony to see if that testimony
- 15:11has been disclosed in the expert disclosures.
- 15:15And just to stay on disclosures from one moment
- 15:18here, you'll see this lots of times when people
- 15:22have not thought all the way through their case.
- 15:25They'll talk about or describe the substance
- 15:27of the testimony from the perspective of this
- 15:30or from the perspective of that in the case.
- 15:32of this disclosure that was made in a title insurance
- 15:35case that I handled. And so the only difference
- 15:38was the perspective of these people and not the
- 15:41actual opinions that were to be offered. And
- 15:43so it's something to talk about with the court
- 15:45about whether it's cumulative testimony or not.
- 15:48But this also then drives when you're thinking
- 15:50about your direct examination. which of the witnesses
- 15:53you want to put on the stand. If you wind up
- 15:55only getting one of those witnesses in because
- 15:58it's the exact same opinion that's to be offered,
- 16:01the judge may not allow multiple perspectives
- 16:04on that issue to come in at trial. And there's
- 16:08provision for that in the Civil Code of Civil
- 16:10Procedure as well that would allow a motion to
- 16:15reduce the list of employed or retained experts
- 16:17to be able to testify. And so if you don't have
- 16:21a plan for experts that relates to trial where
- 16:24you've already thought backward about what that
- 16:26testimony looks like, you either could face a
- 16:29motion that is a pretrial motion to exclude one
- 16:33of those experts or at the time of trial on the
- 16:36basis of of information being cumulative. Next
- 16:40is about the times when you can offer statements
- 16:45and learned treatises, periodicals, or pamphlets,
- 16:47first under the federal rules. We just call these
- 16:50reliable sources. And you should note that these
- 16:53are multiple requirements, again, that you have
- 16:55to think about in preparing for your direct examination
- 16:59if you expect any of this information to get
- 17:03in. Unlikely, of course, that you're going to
- 17:05ever have a need to put in an entirety of a learner
- 17:09treatise or some periodical or a manual or a
- 17:12set of standards. But nevertheless, it is something
- 17:15that you have to think about both on direct and
- 17:18across in particular, if you're planning on cross
- 17:21-examining a witness about this, to know the
- 17:23rules of their admission. And this usually gets
- 17:26set up in the deposition, again, preparation
- 17:29before the deposition that leads to the trial
- 17:31examination. And Ben, do you often get called
- 17:35into cases where there are standards or periodicals
- 17:39that are the subject of cross -examination for
- 17:41you? Yes, sometimes when I'll have cases that
- 17:46relate to valuation theory and I'm using valuation
- 17:51databases that are commonly used, also in cases
- 17:55where I have to go back to professional standards,
- 17:58let's say for a CPA. So, absolutely. And in using
- 18:04those periodicals, is the subject usually of
- 18:07direct examination or cross -examination that
- 18:10people are examining about them? Typically, it
- 18:15would be cross -examination. It wouldn't necessarily
- 18:18be direct. And so in cross, these are often put
- 18:24to you as the basis for questions about how you
- 18:27did your work and whether you did it in the same
- 18:29way as you do in the rest of life as a CPA? Yes,
- 18:34the questions being, or let's say the evaluation
- 18:37work, well, how often is this used? This is something
- 18:40that's used by most every CPA or CBA or evaluation
- 18:44analyst, and how publicly available is it with
- 18:48looking at accounting standards, trying to establish
- 18:52how are these standards applicable and are these
- 18:55the right standards to use? And the standards,
- 18:58of course, relate to all kinds of things like
- 19:01standard of care for you name it kind of issue
- 19:04as well as the way that people do their jobs
- 19:07or like in the situation of appraisal, the approved
- 19:10appraisal practices that are a part of the statute
- 19:13as well. Correct. The California equivalent Under
- 19:19721, I'd strongly encourage you to look at, this
- 19:23is actually, I should have said honorable Lawrence
- 19:25Riff, who's a judge here in his article, The
- 19:28Evidence Slayer, talks about the kinds of evidence
- 19:31that you can use and should use and why it's
- 19:34valuable for further reading here. But if we
- 19:38move on, the standards under California law are
- 19:42similar. but have different elements. And I would
- 19:46just encourage you to pay attention carefully
- 19:47to these elements and write them right in your
- 19:51outline or your examination and get them in your
- 19:53deposition ahead of time so that you can walk
- 19:56through them easily. Because going back to what
- 19:58we talked about on the scaffold before of getting
- 20:01to the point, it can be a complete sideshow.
- 20:04If you start talking about what's in or outside
- 20:06of some journal or some treatise, if it's not
- 20:09really to the point and if you can't crisply
- 20:12get it into evidence. The other principle that
- 20:16comes out of depositions that will or will not
- 20:19allow you to get in certain evidence at trial
- 20:22is the Kenimer questions about what opinions
- 20:28you've already formed at the time of trial or
- 20:30at the time of deposition so that at trial you're
- 20:34limited to those opinions. And I presume that
- 20:37people may have heard of Kenimer, but not always
- 20:39seen it in action. And the most important corollary
- 20:43to it is sorry, the most important corollary
- 20:49to it is to make sure that you get all of the
- 20:53opinions out, even if it means asking your own
- 20:56witness in deposition, whether there's additional
- 20:59work to be done. And if not, then go ahead and
- 21:05answer those questions. But then you talked about
- 21:08leaving the door open and what happens there.
- 21:10We'll talk about the Easter bee case in a minute.
- 21:12But what are the usual ways that you get Kennemer
- 21:15questions asked of you? Well, in deposition exactly
- 21:20how you listed it here, but I typically try to
- 21:23leave the door open just in case there's additional
- 21:26information that the opposing expert is using
- 21:29or additional information that comes down the
- 21:31pike or perhaps the opposing expert has work
- 21:36product or conclusions that I may need to. to
- 21:41review for potential rebuttal work. So I'll try
- 21:44to leave the door open just to provide the opportunity
- 21:47to be able to do that if need be. And sometimes
- 21:50you get experts like this one that I had in a
- 21:55case. Again, this is from the title insurance
- 21:56case, but it's a very seasoned expert who felt
- 22:01that he liked to hear his own voice. And so said
- 22:04at the end of one of my questions. So let me
- 22:06give you the very short version. and started
- 22:10with the phrase a century and a half ago and
- 22:13started talking and then told me about what happened
- 22:15in the 1870s. And then his answer went on for
- 22:20six more pages of testimony and said, I'll stop
- 22:24there. Again, I can go on. And so the point again
- 22:29for cross -examination or direct examination,
- 22:32you should be aware of it, but cross -examination
- 22:34in particular at trial this deposition, if left
- 22:39like this, is useless for trial other than demonstrating
- 22:42that the witness was playing games and was not
- 22:45following the rules. And again, juries don't
- 22:48like people that don't follow the rules in front
- 22:50of them in particular. And so if you went back
- 22:52and you asked that same question and you had
- 22:54six pages of deposition testimony to review as
- 22:59his answer. It would be shown very quickly that
- 23:02he were not doing this. I'm sure at some point
- 23:04everyone would be sleeping and the judge would
- 23:05stop you from reading the entirety of this answer.
- 23:08But you'd have to find an artful way to use it.
- 23:11Of course, the other artful way is to break it
- 23:13down and start asking very small questions because
- 23:17you've given him the opportunity to explain the
- 23:20six page answer and provide you with an outline
- 23:23for the actual questions that you wind up asking
- 23:25at the time of trial. And so again, this kind
- 23:30of a deposition winds up being useless in cross
- 23:33-examination at trial. And so your examination
- 23:36has to be thought of in the deposition, not just
- 23:39from getting the information, which is very helpful
- 23:42to understand the entire history of title insurance
- 23:44law, but for purposes of using it in cross -examination,
- 23:49your answers are going to have to be much, much
- 23:52shorter than that. So then if we move on to the
- 23:56Kennemer questions again, and ask any other opinions
- 24:00you have in regard to the purpose functions or
- 24:02processes of preliminary title reports. Even
- 24:04this witness, after six pages, was willing to
- 24:06say no, followed by another pithy question after
- 24:11he was catching his breath. Are you familiar
- 24:12with those details of the Bob's loan, whether
- 24:14that was required or not? Right now, no, I'm
- 24:16not. And so while he can pontificate about...
- 24:20encyclopedic knowledge of title insurance by
- 24:23getting to the questions of the small questions
- 24:25and the small answers. Those are the only ones
- 24:27that are going to be taken on board in cross
- 24:30-examination. That was very easily. And the point
- 24:33here being, make a point, have a point to be
- 24:36made with your cross -examination questions and
- 24:38then get those in the deposition to use. Then
- 24:43we talked about Kenamer and then the caveat to
- 24:46that is Easterby. Ben, you want to talk about
- 24:49what you've done and experiences you've had about
- 24:52getting that additional information? Yes, there
- 24:55are times when, let's say, you're working on
- 24:59a damage opinion for a film. that had been released
- 25:08but is still going through different phases of
- 25:12its exploitation journey. And you get additional
- 25:16ultimates and additional participation statements.
- 25:19So you're able to fill in more of the knowns
- 25:22and take out some of the things that are lesser
- 25:25known but you still try to estimate. And then
- 25:29offering up a second deposition based upon whatever
- 25:32the new opinion and new information are is just
- 25:35essential if you're gonna try to avoid a statement
- 25:37of prejudice. Yeah, and that's been done. Yes,
- 25:40absolutely. So now we turn back to the rules
- 25:42quickly just to remind you that it's an and at
- 25:46the end of part C here that you have to show
- 25:49that you have scientific, technical or other
- 25:51specialized knowledge. There are sufficient facts
- 25:54and data for the report. that the opinions are
- 25:56the product of reliable principles and method
- 25:58and that you've reliably applied those principles
- 26:01and information. And then we get to the other
- 26:06types of opinions that are beyond common experience
- 26:09and just simply would assist the trier effect
- 26:11based on matter that's perceived by or known
- 26:13to the witness at or before the hearing. So you
- 26:16need to walk through these rules so that you
- 26:19can articulate what the basis for the opinion
- 26:21are when called upon. And then And the cross
- 26:26examiner is going to have to make a decision
- 26:28in real time. If you've not brought a motion
- 26:31beforehand, sometimes it'll be precluded at trial.
- 26:34But whether do voir dire or not voir dire, meaning
- 26:37ask questions of the witness to test the foundation
- 26:40of those opinions in the middle of trial. And
- 26:43it is a disruption and you'll look silly for
- 26:46doing it. But if you know that you've got something
- 26:48on the person, I wouldn't hesitate. And all of
- 26:51these are, of course, wrapped up in the Daubert
- 26:53decision that is oftentimes Daubert motions are
- 26:57required to be brought while in advance of trial
- 26:59to prevent that interruption in trial. And if
- 27:03you haven't read it or don't know it, then you
- 27:05should read the Sargon Enterprises case that
- 27:07relates to the court's gatekeeping function,
- 27:10which is. our version here in California of the
- 27:13Daubert test that articulates those principles
- 27:17about gatekeeping. There's many cases that have
- 27:19come after it. But most importantly, the goal
- 27:22is to exclude speculative or irrelevant expert
- 27:25opinion. And where to draw the lines is a very
- 27:28difficult one in some cases, particularly where
- 27:32there are contract interpretation issues involved.
- 27:35And so if you think about it in terms of the
- 27:40principles underlying the reliability for this
- 27:43rule. And it asks the reasons for the expert
- 27:46opinions are part of the matter on which they
- 27:48are based, just as is the type of matter. In
- 27:52other words, the opinion itself should be the
- 27:56subject of gatekeeping, but so should the reasons
- 27:58for the opinions. And the best place to do this
- 28:02is in the deposition of opposing experts, so
- 28:05that you can then quote that if there's appropriate
- 28:08ways to, again, find common ground among the
- 28:10experts, just so that you can point out what
- 28:13those differences are. And in approaching direct
- 28:16and cross examination, this is the two by two
- 28:21data set that I use in order to figure out how
- 28:24to characterize a particular expert. Of course,
- 28:28on the bottom row, if the person's just not qualified
- 28:31at all, they're not going to testify. But in
- 28:34this matrix, if you start with the person who's
- 28:36qualified and the hired gun, Ben, why don't you
- 28:40talk about the difference between the people
- 28:42that you've seen opposing you who are just hired
- 28:44guns and those who are not, but who are qualified?
- 28:53I'll try not to cast dispersions. I have seen
- 28:56a couple of examples where you have, let's say,
- 29:00someone's coming in. And their damage analysis
- 29:05is effectively just throwing everything against
- 29:07the wall. They're not necessarily well, they
- 29:11don't know the details behind the case. But let's
- 29:14say they've done this sort of comparative analysis.
- 29:18for other projects and they think they can just
- 29:20apply the same types of analysis without without
- 29:24looking at the details. And fortunately, I've
- 29:28been able to really successfully rebut those
- 29:31types of experts. And everybody understands that
- 29:35experts are getting paid for their work. But
- 29:37again, if they're stepping outside of their lane
- 29:39or just thrown up against the wall to see what
- 29:41sticks as has been suggested, then it It's your
- 29:46job as the cross -examiner to make that immediately
- 29:49apparent. And in doing so, consider the psychology
- 29:54of why it is that people choose sides or believe
- 29:57one person or another. If it looks like they
- 30:00are the hired gun and that's what you're attempting
- 30:02to ferret out through the examination, then that's
- 30:06the road you go down. If they have an impressive
- 30:08revisme, it may be great. But if it's not a resume
- 30:12that applies and they don't have experience in
- 30:14this particular discipline, even if it's to the
- 30:18broader discipline, then they may be qualified
- 30:22generally to offer opinions about lots of things.
- 30:25They may have testified about lots of other things.
- 30:27And so I consider what the subject of cross -examination
- 30:30is that you'd have might be all of those other
- 30:33cases and all the other times when they have.
- 30:36issued opinions about something else and this
- 30:38is somebody that just turns out somebody hired
- 30:40at the last minute because of their resume and
- 30:42not because of their knowledge or approach. Next
- 30:46in the matrix is obviously if the person is not
- 30:49qualified at all, that's very easy and that can
- 30:52be a focus for cross -examination because they
- 30:55just don't have what it takes in order to be
- 30:57an expert. It is difficult for juries to assess
- 31:01the qualifications of competing experts sometimes
- 31:05if it's based upon participation in obscure disciplines
- 31:09or obscure associations and the different publications
- 31:13are very difficult to compare to one another,
- 31:18then it's going to take a lot, but the unqualified
- 31:21witness is usually somewhat easier. We've seen
- 31:26more lawyers showing up as witnesses lately just
- 31:29because they've participated in a variety of
- 31:32practice areas over the course of their careers
- 31:34and have this as their retirement plan. And so
- 31:38if they've not actually engaged in the business,
- 31:39but instead have participated as consultants
- 31:43in one way or another, oftentimes that comes
- 31:46through. And that difference should be made apparent
- 31:48if you have an expert in the discipline. But
- 31:50again, this is about back to the scaffold of
- 31:53focusing on the differences between the experts
- 31:55in your direct examination to set that up for
- 31:59who's coming next. Witnesses that I like in particular
- 32:03are who we call newbies, including a party. who's
- 32:06eminently qualified, but perhaps just hasn't
- 32:08testified before. And so those witnesses take
- 32:11substantially greater amounts of preparation,
- 32:13but nevertheless come off with a different sort
- 32:16of credibility. They, if they're a party or a
- 32:21party employee, have the bias that you're going
- 32:23to have to overcome and it will require a greater
- 32:26examination on direct to explain why it is that
- 32:30they, in fact, have not only the qualifications
- 32:34but also the independence despite their employment
- 32:37relationship in order to render the opinions.
- 32:40One way to think about that particularly with
- 32:42employees is whether they've been doing the job
- 32:44all along and the opinions that they're offering
- 32:47now are the opinions that they formed during
- 32:49the course of their job before the litigation
- 32:51ever began. So this is not some Johnny -come
- 32:54-lately opinion but rather just the conclusions
- 32:57that were reached as part of their regular duties.
- 33:02But the education about that issue is very important.
- 33:05The preparation of the witness is very important
- 33:07in order to prepare that person for the feeder
- 33:10of the courtroom. One thing about experts in
- 33:14particular, though, is that everybody hates a
- 33:16know -it -all. And if Einstein is the classic
- 33:19know -it -all, you dislike him because he talks
- 33:22in letters and formulas, and you dislike him
- 33:25because he was very, very good at the violin,
- 33:27which is a little bit more obscure than, say,
- 33:29guitar. you need to find who is the other Einstein
- 33:33in this expert. The beach -going, bike -riding,
- 33:36smiling Einstein that is somebody that people
- 33:40like and want to have a beer with is relatable.
- 33:44And so a good place to start in thinking about
- 33:47your expert selection, which really is the first
- 33:50step in preparing the direct examination, is
- 33:53really about how the witness presents. And it
- 33:57may be that they're an academician. It may be
- 33:59that they're an engineer. But if that person's
- 34:02not going to be able to communicate, then the
- 34:04goal and the difficulty is figuring out how to
- 34:07get them to communicate in an appropriate way.
- 34:11Hey, Michael. Yes, sir. No, I just wanted to
- 34:13jump in real quick. So I mean, something that
- 34:17I have to remind myself. So like, for instance,
- 34:19I had a recent case where I was up against an
- 34:22equally qualified expert. And based upon what
- 34:27the jury decided, uh, it was obvious that I,
- 34:30I had a much better job and I did a much better
- 34:33job in terms of relating and explaining to the
- 34:35jury. And so for me, it's weird. I get often
- 34:40asked by random folks, uh, for information, like,
- 34:44you know, in the middle of an Aldi, someone asked
- 34:46me, Hey, do you know where the, the, the peanut
- 34:48butter with the flax seed is? I, it's just, it's
- 34:51just the weird thing. My wife was with me. Um,
- 34:54and so, you know, regardless of whether I knew
- 34:56where it was, but I just have to remind myself,
- 35:00be that approachable person. Let the jury want
- 35:04to hear from me. And this is, as far as I'm concerned,
- 35:09required reading for lawyers that are examining
- 35:12experts, because these two books, Blink by Malcolm
- 35:16Gladwell and Thinking Fast and Slow by Daniel
- 35:18Kahneman, who's an economist, both of them talk
- 35:23about the subconscious ways that people react
- 35:25to things, whether it's unconscious bias or whether
- 35:29it's just subconscious reactions based upon the
- 35:31temperature in the room. All of those things
- 35:34affect people's ability to take on information
- 35:37and to react to that information in real time
- 35:41about the way that you get to answers and the
- 35:45way that you process information. And in that
- 35:49regard, you've got to think about who, not Einstein,
- 35:55who the people are that are going to be deciding,
- 35:58you don't have Einstein's. But people often talk
- 36:02about juries as keep it simple, stupid. And I
- 36:07never think juries are stupid. And the examination
- 36:11of expert witnesses, I don't prepare for juries
- 36:16who are stupid. They're not. If juries and jurors
- 36:21were stupid, then we as the trial lawyers are
- 36:24the ones who are stupid for putting our cases
- 36:25to them and not settling them in advance because
- 36:29it does add a level of uncertainty. And so all
- 36:33of these people, you've got to remember the folks
- 36:35that are the ones who are going to be deciding
- 36:38what are important cases. They're not ignorant.
- 36:41They've just not been involved in some discipline
- 36:43that is involved in this case necessarily. And
- 36:47so you have to teach them enough to understand
- 36:49what's going on. You have to give them enough
- 36:51information to make a decision and make a choice.
- 36:55And you have to give them the tools in order
- 36:57to do that credibly in a way that your client's
- 36:59going to understand what the outcome is. And
- 37:01so if the jury just doesn't understand the case
- 37:04at the end, it's the lawyer's fault for not presenting
- 37:08the information in a way that was understandable.
- 37:13And so it's really a collaboration, I think,
- 37:16Ben, between being likable and approachable as
- 37:19you are, but then giving chunks of information
- 37:21that you think are necessary. So how do we meet
- 37:25that challenge? Michael, if you don't mind. Please.
- 37:32You also have to try to figure out, well, the
- 37:34transactions that you're dealing with, how can
- 37:37you make those transactions relatable to the
- 37:39folks that are on the jury? Trying to explain,
- 37:42let's say, how profit participation is working
- 37:45in entertainment space. or ultimate projections
- 37:50work. I mean, I've had to explain that to a jury
- 37:53before and you can do it. You just have to take
- 37:55some time to really think about how to keep it
- 37:57simple and how to focus in on something that
- 37:59they might have experience with. So the first
- 38:03place people are running today is AI. AI is not
- 38:07the answer. At least it's not all of the answer.
- 38:09It can be a very good start. And I'd encourage
- 38:12trying a number of different prompts about being
- 38:16a highly qualified trial attorney as the preface
- 38:19to your prompts in order to have whatever AI
- 38:23engineer you're using create an outline for examinations
- 38:26after it'll review a bunch of testimony for you.
- 38:29But it is never the final answer for the same
- 38:32reason that woman doesn't have hands growing
- 38:33out of her face. But at the same time, it is
- 38:37also good for helping you prepare demonstrative
- 38:41exhibits. And that is another way to help people
- 38:43understand complicated things. In that regard,
- 38:47I'd encourage you to go look at this PowerPoint
- 38:50presentation called You Suck at PowerPoint. It's
- 38:53really an excellent way to think about what is
- 38:56good and bad PowerPoint to help you think through
- 39:00what your next trial is and the way that in the
- 39:02examination you explain things. After you do
- 39:06that, I'd encourage you to go look at Google
- 39:07Images. If Google is just a set of all the ways
- 39:13that people in the world have thought about illustrating
- 39:18complicated formulae, then this is for example
- 39:21net present value. This is all the ways that
- 39:23people have thought of, not all of them, but
- 39:25many of them, the ways that people have thought
- 39:27of explaining and educating people about what
- 39:30net present value is. And then it becomes up
- 39:32to you to make the decision about whether you
- 39:34use the very simple or the very complicated version
- 39:37of that. So in that regard, we turn to the case
- 39:42at hand here. And if we look at, well, Ben, why
- 39:47don't you describe what we've created as a basis
- 39:50for discussion? Yeah, so this is what we're showing
- 39:55is the process for how to take the findings that
- 39:59you have and turn those into the demonstratives
- 40:03that you want to share in front of the jury.
- 40:06So in this case, this slide is just simply identifying
- 40:10how much Nathan earned. You see the dip in that
- 40:15second period and then it goes back up and it
- 40:17has a little bit of an increase over time. And
- 40:20that's just the most basic presentation. It doesn't
- 40:23necessarily tell you what should have been expected.
- 40:27It just tells you what actually occurred. So
- 40:31if we talk about this then, we are not focusing
- 40:35on the very specific details of Nathan's history,
- 40:40but that ultimately is the question in the presentation
- 40:43of both direct and cross is the level of abstraction
- 40:47to focus on, whether you want to get into the
- 40:49nitty gritty of why he even had. point three
- 40:52million dollars in sales during this period of
- 40:56time when he was out of work or whether you want
- 40:59to talk about things in a gross way over a five
- 41:01year or a 10 year period of what his earnings
- 41:03were compared to others. And you also want to
- 41:08take a look at what others in his firm, others
- 41:12in the industry and the general economy, were
- 41:14there other factors that went into play in terms
- 41:18of how these earnings were built? And what could
- 41:22Nathan reasonably have expected to do in earnings
- 41:26save for the injury? So at the risk of actually
- 41:30doing a little role playing. Ben, let me turn
- 41:34to a bit of direct examination from you. As if
- 41:38you were on the stand, on direct, what factors
- 41:41are important in considering the effects of Ben's
- 41:44injury? What I would expect to review or to include
- 41:53would be what this person's team was able to
- 41:56do from from let's say Nathan's earnings or my
- 42:01earnings, it would also be looking at the time
- 42:05cycle or the sale cycle. So like for instance,
- 42:09if you were out of pocket, let's say your real
- 42:13estate agent, you're out of pocket for six months,
- 42:15your pipeline is dead. How long is it going to
- 42:18take you to reinvigorate that pipeline? So the
- 42:22timing of your earnings and potential damages
- 42:28could be affected by that pipeline. Will his
- 42:33losses stop at the end of this chart in 2025?
- 42:39Maybe. It's possible that they would continue.
- 42:42You have to look at what the rest of his company
- 42:45is doing and looking at the industry. He may
- 42:51have certain challenges that prevent him from
- 42:55being able to catch up. It could be nothing to
- 42:57do with him, just more of having something to
- 43:00do with the fact that he's lost out on opportunities
- 43:03that he's not able to make up. So we don't know
- 43:06how long that... that period of damages is going
- 43:10to be. It could be five years. It could be 10
- 43:12years. But at some point, you would have to expect
- 43:14that this person is going to catch up. You also
- 43:18have to take into account how long this person's
- 43:22career is going to be. Maybe this person only
- 43:24has 10 years in the business anyway. So you certainly
- 43:27don't want to consider or think about doing the
- 43:32damages analysis in perpetuity. That would be
- 43:35wrong. I'm sorry. You mentioned the term before,
- 43:37discount rate. What is a discount rate? A discount
- 43:41rate takes into account or the way I like to
- 43:44describe it is the likelihood of achieving projections
- 43:48over time. Go ahead. Sorry. Why do you have to
- 43:54apply a discount rate or discount factor in calculated
- 43:57Nathan's lost earnings? because there's certain
- 44:00uncertainty once you get past, let's say you're
- 44:02looking at the actual damages or information
- 44:06known through 2025, as you go forward, there
- 44:09may be general uncertainties, there may be generally
- 44:11economic uncertainties, other industry uncertainties,
- 44:15and uncertainties with the real estate transactions
- 44:20in general. So you certainly don't want to not
- 44:25discount those potential future projections,
- 44:30you certainly want to be conservative with regards
- 44:32to those, the projections that you're making.
- 44:36That's a term that's important in this analysis,
- 44:38conservative. What do you mean by conservative?
- 44:41Well, you're trying to retain credibility with
- 44:44the jury. So the thing that you want to do is
- 44:47try to present something that's reasonable. I've
- 44:51seen folks who have presented damages analysis,
- 44:54like the one case that we talked about before,
- 44:57was just unreasonable as compared to the facts
- 45:00of the case. Facts that the opposing expert did
- 45:03not take into account. So taking all those factors
- 45:08into account, the jury decided that the opposing
- 45:11expert's analysis was not conservative, was significantly
- 45:17overstated. awarded something that was a lot
- 45:22closer to the alternative damages analysis that
- 45:24I had prepared. So let me go to the next slide
- 45:27and break the rules of you suck at PowerPoint
- 45:31just for the purposes of showing people. So before
- 45:34we were looking at a line graph, now we have
- 45:36a bar graph or a column graph. What was intended
- 45:40to be shown by this one, even though you'd have
- 45:42to reacquaint people entirely for purposes of
- 45:45the direct? Yes, again, this is part of the evolution.
- 45:48This is not necessarily something we'd show to
- 45:50the jury. But for us to understand, how do we
- 45:54explain to the jury that there is a disconnect
- 45:57between what Nathan was able to earn versus what
- 46:01he could have earned? So in this case, you see
- 46:04here that his team had a slight downtick in the
- 46:13in the first part or the first half of 2023,
- 46:17but it wasn't anywhere close to the down tick
- 46:20that Nathan had personally because presumably
- 46:22because of his injury. And then also with the
- 46:26columns, there is a dramatic increase that a
- 46:30little difficult to see on the columns. But if
- 46:31we go to the next slide, the steepness of that,
- 46:36the period of the team after the accident, how
- 46:40do you characterize that? Well, you'd have to
- 46:43go back and get information from the from the
- 46:48other members of the team from management of
- 46:51the team as to what was happening for these for
- 46:56these other agents and Was there a was there
- 47:01a reason you need to understand? Why Nathan didn't
- 47:06was not able to generate an increase in sales
- 47:09or increase in earnings consistent with the team
- 47:12to the extent that that was not related to any
- 47:16other issue that could be identified and discounted
- 47:22from the analysis or taken out from the analysis,
- 47:25you could potentially include that as part of
- 47:27damages. And did you go get that information?
- 47:30Yes, we did. We looked at that. We identified
- 47:33that the leads that other folks were generating
- 47:40were more significant. And that it was the question
- 47:43of Nathan, even though he was exhibiting the
- 47:47same sort of effort, he was in a negative position
- 47:53from the growth that other agents were able to
- 47:59achieve that he wasn't able to because he had
- 48:02lost so much time in those six months. So he
- 48:07had lost those opportunities. And if I could
- 48:09step out of character for a moment. putting a
- 48:11slide up like this makes a juror ask, well, you're
- 48:15taking me away from my job and my friends and
- 48:17family for days and days and days. And there's
- 48:19this little sliver over on the right here that's
- 48:22different. And so if we look at this graph, that's
- 48:25massive from zero to $35 million in sales. But
- 48:29if we get much closer and we look at things differently,
- 48:32especially if that's the only thing on the chart.
- 48:34But if we start getting more and more specific
- 48:37as we approach things, and we focus on what the
- 48:41damage period is, it's perhaps easier to see
- 48:43what that delta is or the difference is in the
- 48:47numbers just by changing the y -axis and the
- 48:50number on the y -axis. And then if we get farther
- 48:52along in that analysis to what the actual lost
- 48:56earnings are, you can see, and now back into
- 49:00character, and you prepared this graph, Mr. Shepard,
- 49:04what does this show? Well, this shows the difference
- 49:06between what what was reasonably expected for
- 49:10Nathan. I wanted to point out that in the previous
- 49:14slide, we saw a significant increase in the team.
- 49:18The analysis or the two slides before. Yes, exactly.
- 49:21Thank you. And so even though the the slope or
- 49:28the increase that we have in the but for case
- 49:31is not the same as the increase for the team.
- 49:35So we took a conservative approach in terms of
- 49:38what the additional business Nathan would have
- 49:41expected in his business to grow. So we used
- 49:46a lower number. So our analysis was also conservative
- 49:49in that respect. And so if we go to the next
- 49:52slide that you prepared, what is depicted here?
- 49:57What is depicted is the difference between what
- 50:01I believe is a reasonable expectation of what
- 50:05Nathan could have earned in sales but for or
- 50:10not having the accident and what actually occurred.
- 50:13And did you calculate the total of the lost sales?
- 50:17I did. The difference between the expected and
- 50:21what actually occurred was $7 .4 million. And
- 50:24it's handy that we put it up on the slide like
- 50:26that. Yes, it's very nice. So, you know, the
- 50:30goal winds up being if that's the most important
- 50:32number in the punch line, then doing what's first
- 50:35and last that that's where you end. And if it
- 50:38happens to stay up on the screen for too long,
- 50:39I know that the plaintiff himself and you wouldn't
- 50:42be offended by that during the cross examination
- 50:45for the punch line for your analysis. But in
- 50:50that regard, let's just get back to principles
- 50:53for a minute. And we had a question. Let me answer
- 50:55it in real time, which was. The question was,
- 50:58must an expert be deposed prior to trial or may
- 51:00they merely be engaged to testify at trial? And
- 51:03the answer there is it depends on the case. There's
- 51:06time for disclosures that are statutorily mandated.
- 51:10And no, you need not take the other side's deposition.
- 51:13If you do, you'll have more fodder for cross
- 51:15-examination, and it's strongly encouraged, but
- 51:18not absolutely necessary. But you are definitely
- 51:22hamstrung at the time of trial if you've not
- 51:24taken the other side's opposing expert. So what
- 51:28are all the sources in order to prepare for that
- 51:31deposition and trial? I mean, there's prior testimony,
- 51:34so to speak, that people give under penalty of
- 51:37perjury in all sorts of ways, and all those are
- 51:40fodder for good cross -examination. And there
- 51:44are, once you get those... types of information,
- 51:49whether sworn under penalty of perjury or written
- 51:51in some sort of an article, there is a line of
- 51:54questioning that you can do in depositions that
- 51:57looks something like this. Let me ask you then,
- 51:59when you've submitted declarations in court,
- 52:01have you always been the sole author of those
- 52:02declarations? Because you know that they were
- 52:04signed under penalty of perjury, which has some
- 52:07level of formality to it. But this was that same
- 52:10expert that I talked about before, and his answer
- 52:13was, you bet you I have. Yeah, you bet you I
- 52:17have been. You've always been the sole author.
- 52:20And what I'd suggest is that that's maybe not
- 52:23the path to go down. But let's look at what the
- 52:26other question was that we asked him. I said,
- 52:28so even when you write reports that are not declarations,
- 52:31those are your views and your opinions that you
- 52:33would swear under penalty of perjury of it being
- 52:35true? So I was asking him to go farther than
- 52:38he had done. or was required to do. He says,
- 52:41yeah, under rule 26, you don't swear under penalty
- 52:43purging, but I would. And in declarations, you
- 52:45do. And they're all my direct work product, my
- 52:47wording. And so whether it's training an expert
- 52:50for the direct examination or otherwise, I'd
- 52:54suggest to you that a better answer is one that
- 52:56Ben might give. Which is something like, well,
- 52:59I work with a highly credentialed staff of CPAs
- 53:02and PhDs to review and verify all the data and
- 53:05analyze complicated situations, as is customary
- 53:08in forensic accounting. So in many ways, my declarations
- 53:10are the product of a number of really smart people.
- 53:13And so I wouldn't, and it goes on, but I wouldn't
- 53:15back away from the fact that other people were
- 53:18involved in the work, so long as you're making
- 53:20sure, as Ben does, that he is supervising the
- 53:23work that's performed, it's being performed in
- 53:26an appropriate way. Next is about the themes
- 53:30of the case and the idea that you're using these
- 53:35various terms that you bring into your cross
- 53:38-examination that are just gifts from the other
- 53:41side. If they use things like secrets or this
- 53:46one where something is the cardinal sin of the
- 53:49escrow profession, I mean, those kinds of things
- 53:52that you find in the testimony, you're going
- 53:54to want to weave into your examination. of cross
- 53:59-examination in particular of witnesses. You'll
- 54:01use it in opening statements, you'll use it in
- 54:04your direct or cross -examinations, and then
- 54:06you move on. Ben, you've also had experience
- 54:10with Sanchez being brought up in cases that you've
- 54:13worked on. Could you describe what the Sanchez
- 54:14holding is that has been important? Yeah, so
- 54:18I worked on a trade secret misappropriation case
- 54:21relating to a couple of real estate firms in
- 54:24Orange County. And I was going to be the rebuttal
- 54:29expert for a person who was withdrawn, was not
- 54:35allowed to testify at trial, because the data
- 54:39that this person had relied upon from the plaintiff
- 54:45was not data that was prepared in the normal
- 54:49course of business. It was prepared for the purpose
- 54:52of trial. They could not, the company, or the
- 54:59plaintiff could not establish, for lack of a
- 55:02better term, provenance over how that data was
- 55:05prepared, accumulated, and provided to the expert.
- 55:10The judge just couldn't get their arms around
- 55:14whether or not the data was reliable. And so
- 55:18the judge... ruled that the data could not be
- 55:24presented or included due to Sanchez and the
- 55:28attorneys for plaintiff had to withdraw or not
- 55:31allow the opposing expert to testify. And what
- 55:35the Sanchez case is basically about is that an
- 55:38expert is not permitted to simply repeat out
- 55:41of court statements of others as if they were.
- 55:45his or her own, and even though it's hearsay.
- 55:49It effectively says, yeah, you can rely upon
- 55:52it in the abstract for your opinions, and a jury
- 55:54will decide whether it's reliable or not, but
- 55:57you're not going to be able to repeat those statements
- 56:00unless or what you're relying upon, unless the
- 56:03hearsay is admissible itself. For example, if
- 56:06you've got test results, then you're going to
- 56:09need to have somebody come in and testify to
- 56:13what those test results are in order to have
- 56:16that test come in and form a basis for the opinion,
- 56:19at least as the expert makes it up. So if you
- 56:22look at this article that's cited, it's included,
- 56:26there's a hyperlink in it too, in the materials
- 56:28I'd encourage reading about Sanchez. It's a good
- 56:31article on the topic. And so if we start here,
- 56:35this is also problematic under Sanchez. where
- 56:39you have somebody that testifies in response
- 56:42to questions. Did you believe that that document
- 56:44was reliable for some reason? Well, I was told
- 56:46it was reliable. And then they go on, it's not
- 56:49as reliable as I prefer using my normal course
- 56:51of business. That's just a hallmark of information
- 56:54that's not reliable. We go straight to the company
- 56:57and get the real number. So you're doing something
- 56:59in the case that is different than what you do
- 57:03in the ordinary course of of the work that you
- 57:07would perform outside of litigation. Again, not
- 57:10credible in order to do that. And so we go back
- 57:14to the two by two to think about how to respond
- 57:19to examinations. And just if you want to talk
- 57:21about the hired guns you've seen along this matrix,
- 57:25Ben, for your piece. Oh, yeah. So. What we've
- 57:30discussed before, the person, the expert who
- 57:34had just thrown this analysis against the wall
- 57:36in this other trade secret misappropriation case,
- 57:40the jury determined that the work they did was
- 57:43not credible because they didn't really consider
- 57:45detailed information, the detailed facts relating
- 57:49to the plaintiff's normal operations. The analysis
- 57:54was just too esoteric and didn't really apply
- 57:57to the fact pattern. So I've seen that happen
- 58:01before, and I've also seen it where the opposing
- 58:05expert kind of talked over the heads of the jury,
- 58:10and the jury just didn't get it. And not that
- 58:15the jury wasn't smart, but the other expert just
- 58:17did not take the time to try to find relatable
- 58:21explanations for that so that the jury could
- 58:24understand. And as far as style, there are as
- 58:27many different styles to examine the hired gun
- 58:29as there are bar numbers. So you've got to find
- 58:32your own way. But with hired guns, there's a
- 58:35lot more leeway that you have to examine people
- 58:38in a credible sort of way than going after some
- 58:42newbie party employee witness that just came
- 58:44out of the accounts payable department to come
- 58:47and provide testimony about the way that interest
- 58:49is calculated. And so I would think about, you
- 58:52know, there are some people who just have one
- 58:54speed, And that's fine if they're going to go
- 58:56through practice in that way. But I would suggest
- 58:59that you think about in direct across examination
- 59:01who the witness is that you've got in front of
- 59:04you. And so the newbie, for example, where there's
- 59:06just incomplete, incorrect foundation or facts.
- 59:09the jury can feel sorry for them for having gone
- 59:12there or been put there by their employer. And
- 59:16yet if they're not applying the right standards
- 59:18or if they don't have all the facts, that's very
- 59:21easy to very politely invite them to leave the
- 59:24stand having said nothing of value and at the
- 59:27same time come off the stand without an opinion
- 59:30that can be relied upon by the jury. And you
- 59:33haven't lost points in the process because of
- 59:35that. Let me stop the share as we hit our time
- 59:39and just invite questions. If you'd like, you
- 59:43can submit them through the Q &A form, I believe.
- 59:47And Ben and I can hang out. But if people are
- 59:50departing, thank you all very much for your attendance.
- 59:52I appreciate it, as I know Ben does as well.
- 59:55And thank you, Ben, for participating today.
- 59:57Thank you. It was a pleasure. All righty. It
- 1:00:02looks like we do not have any current questions.
- 1:00:04Of course, if you feel like asking anything,
- 1:00:07you can go ahead and email Mike and Ben at their
- 1:00:11listed contacts. This concludes today's presentation.
- 1:00:14Thank you so much for your time, Michael and
- 1:00:17Ben, and thank you so much to our audience. Have
- 1:00:19a great afternoon, everybody. Thank you. Thank
- 1:00:22you.