Latest / Ensombl Advice Australia / Investment Podcast #42 - Driving Bottom-Up Performance
Transcript
- 0:00The Ensemble podcast is intended for professional financial advisors.
- 0:03This content is created in partnership with our sponsor, Alan Gray Australia Pty Ltd, ABN 48112 316168, AFSL 298487, and is limited to publicly available information.
- 0:14Before acting on any general advice, you should consider whether appropriate and obtain financial advice from a qualified financial advisor.
- 0:20Ensemble does not hold an AFS license and does not provide any financial advice or services or endorse any general advice.
- 0:26If a PDS, TMD or IM exist, you should obtain a copy and review it thoroughly before making a decision.
- 0:34Hey guys, this is Ben Nash from Pivot Wealth and one of the Ensemble co-founders and I'm pumped to be involved in the investment podcast for Ensemble.
- 0:43Our advice business is built around younger, higher income clients where investments is a big part of the picture and the Ensemble crew have asked me to host this podcast where I'll be sitting down with some of the sharpest people in the market to talk about portfolio construction, asset allocation, the mindset and psychology side of investing and what's actually working right now.
- 1:06When you choose Alan Gray, you are not just buying an investment, you are buying into a distinctive investment philosophy.
- 1:12That philosophy is simple.
- 1:14To take a contrarian approach, apply it consistently and invest for the long term.
- 1:19This is how we've been investing in Australia since 2006 and how the broader group has been investing globally since 1973.
- 1:26Our highly focused investment approach lets you take advantage of our time-tested contrarian philosophy on an Australian and global scale.
- 1:34For more information, go to allangray.com.au.
- 1:37Hey, guys.
- 1:38Welcome back to the Ensemble Podcast.
- 1:40And today, I'm here with Chris Hestelow.
- 1:42Chris, welcome.
- 1:43Thanks so much for having me, Ben.
- 1:44Chris is a Senior Investment Specialist at Allangray.
- 1:47And look, with all the stuff going on in markets, the world, can you pick your brain, get that crystal ball dusted off and see what's happening?
- 1:55So maybe to start, what are you seeing out there?
- 1:58There's a lot going on.
- 1:59Sure, there is a lot going on.
- 2:01I think perhaps to start, it's probably important to mention that we tend to look at things at Alan Gray through a contrarian lens.
- 2:07So, we spend quite a bit of time thinking about what's popular, where people might be getting a little bit over their skis or potentially overpaying for assets.
- 2:15Yeah.
- 2:16And we think about what has been left behind, what people find uncomfortable to invest in.
- 2:21And the reason that we do that is that that's often where we find things that are trading at a discount to what they're really worth.
- 2:27That broad pessimism gives us the opportunity at times to find a bargain.
- 2:32So in markets today, and in terms of what we're seeing, it's quite interesting because I think we've seen a bit of a reversal away from what has been very popular and a little bit more capital flowing towards some previously unloved areas.
- 2:44If we start with
- 2:45So, Australia, healthcare has had quite a torrid run over the past year.
- 2:50But in the recent reporting season that just finished in August, it was the best performing sector up 18%.
- 2:56Interesting.
- 2:57For a number of years, it's really been financials and consumer discretionary that have done quite well.
- 3:02And they were two of the weakest sectors.
- 3:04Yeah.
- 3:04Well, the healthcare is definitely not going anywhere.
- 3:07Everyone's spending more and doing more.
- 3:09So that's interesting.
- 3:11Yeah.
- 3:12I mean, historically, that sector has commanded quite a premium relative to other sectors if you look at things like forward price earnings multiples.
- 3:18But it compressed quite a lot with some of the big names like CSL selling off quite a bit.
- 3:24Yeah.
- 3:25And we're really seeing that in global markets too.
- 3:27You know, over the past year, the value style of investing has been outperforming the growth style.
- 3:33You've had emerging markets outperforming developed markets.
- 3:36And you've even had smaller companies slightly outperforming large companies.
- 3:39And all those three things are against the trend of preceding years or a bit of a reversal.
- 3:46And so it, frankly, has been quite nice to be a contrarian in that sort of environment.
- 3:50We generally tend to do a bit better when there is a bit of a reassessment, a bit of a refocus on the fundamentals and a bit of a rotation away from what has been very popular and towards some unloved areas.
- 4:01Yeah, interesting.
- 4:02Look, I can't really go on without asking about AI because it's something that's so wild, I suppose, out there in terms of like the pickup in AI.
- 4:12use of it.
- 4:13I think a lot of businesses, companies, stuff's getting disrupted by this.
- 4:18And then you've got these companies that are on a tear.
- 4:24The big ones, XAI through SpaceX, OpenAI and Anthropic winding up for listing as well.
- 4:33And you just see them and then all of the companies in that ecosystem around them sort of going to the moon.
- 4:40But then there's also a lot of questions about, is it overcooked?
- 4:44How much can it keep going?
- 4:46What impact does it have?
- 4:47You've got this broader market cycle thing that's happening as well that says that maybe markets are a bit toppy, but then there's like, can AI just make everyone a million times more productive and then just keep our share market rally going for the next 15 years or something?
- 5:05How are you guys looking at it and what are you doing to play the AI trade?
- 5:08Yeah, so it probably depends a little bit whether we're talking about the Australian market and global markets.
- 5:13So maybe we'll split them into those two buckets again.
- 5:16In Australia, opportunities to invest are a little bit more limited than in global markets.
- 5:21You know, we don't have a very large tech sector in Australia.
- 5:26Some people are seeking exposure through materials, things like copper that have seen a real pickup in demand.
- 5:34We're being a bit more cautious there.
- 5:35We have a little bit of exposure in BHP and Rio Tinto, but below benchmark weights.
- 5:40We've been lighting there as quite a bit of excitement has come into the space.
- 5:46We haven't been able to get our heads around some of the valuations on some of the data centre operators.
- 5:51We don't have exposure there.
- 5:52Where we have had some exposure over the past year has been in a company called Sims, which has historically been a metal recycling business.
- 6:01Happened to have this part of the business involved in recycling data centers.
- 6:05So recycling and reusing the memory chips, the GPUs, the racks, some of the metal.
- 6:15And that business has just completely taken off and a massive increase in earnings for that component.
- 6:20Frankly, wasn't part of our original investment thesis.
- 6:23So we were aware of it.
- 6:24It didn't ascribe at much value.
- 6:26Yeah.
- 6:27Kind of saw it as a bit of a free option alongside a company that stacked up on its own fundamentals without that piece.
- 6:33But that's been quite a nice beneficiary.
- 6:35Yeah.
- 6:36I wouldn't have thought that data centers would be old enough to be recycled yet.
- 6:39But look, I suppose that makes sense.
- 6:42Well, with these chips, you know, a new one is coming out all the time and the video releases a new chip.
- 6:47And, you know, it isn't just turning it into scrap.
- 6:50They are kind of wiping some of these CPUs and things and allowing reuse or allowing them to be there as backups.
- 6:59I've got all the rare earths and stuff in there, right?
- 7:01Yeah.
- 7:01Just turf that stuff.
- 7:03Yeah, that's right.
- 7:03Yeah.
- 7:04But then when you go to global markets, there is a lot more opportunity.
- 7:07And we run what we call the Alan Gray Australia Balance Fund, which we lean on our sister company, Orbis, for the global exposure in that fund.
- 7:16And they've, frankly, played it quite well.
- 7:18So we had quite a decent exposure in these Korean semiconductor names that really found themselves at the nexus of one of the biggest bottlenecks of all time.
- 7:27Yeah, yeah.
- 7:28And dramatically increased their pricing power.
- 7:31Okay.
- 7:32An example would be a company like SK Square that we started to buy back in January 2025.
- 7:37Yeah.
- 7:39It's a holding company with exposure to SK Hynix, the memory major in Korea.
- 7:44And as you saw that bottleneck establish itself and their pricing power increase and their earnings dramatically increase, that was a company that did very, very well in the fund.
- 7:53Yeah.
- 7:54Yeah.
- 7:55Again, it didn't look extremely expensive because profits had risen so much, but we did start to get a bit nervous around some frothiness in the sector.
- 8:05You had these three times leverage ETFs coming out in Korea and a bunch of retail money rushing into the space.
- 8:11So we exited SK Square in the balance fund in June, and that proved to be a good decision too because there was- They come back a little.
- 8:20bit.
- 8:20That's right.
- 8:21There was quite a step down in July.
- 8:22Today, where we have exposure in the Balance Fund, we have zero exposure in the Magnificent Seven tech companies in the main hyperscalers, where a lot of people have quite a decent exposure to.
- 8:34We do retain some exposure in Samsung and TSMC, but we probably have more exposure in some potentially indirect beneficiaries like energy because AI is energy intensive.
- 8:46Yeah.
- 8:47Well, I'm keen to get into that no magnificent seven play because I think that is a bit against the grain.
- 8:52But what is your perspective just broadly on the markets when it comes to where we're at in the market cycle, what's going on, particularly with the really big AI players, open AI and anthropic companies?
- 9:07you know, that are probably the next couple to come up.
- 9:11Do you think investing in those sorts of things makes sense?
- 9:13Because I know for a lot of advisors that everyone's, well, particularly a lot of people listening to the podcast would be using these tools and, you know, you sort of, you can see what's possible there.
- 9:27Then we're getting a lot from our clients as well that they're wondering whether they should be doing this.
- 9:32I know when the SpaceX float was happening, we were getting a ton of questions for clients and obviously,
- 9:37Musk pushed out to ComSec and got exposure, which is really different to how you would typically see these things going out.
- 9:46Are these investments a good idea?
- 9:47What do you think advisors should be?
- 9:49How should they be managing that conversation with their clients?
- 9:52Yeah.
- 9:52So, I mean, I agree personally that the technology is going to be transformative.
- 9:58I mean, sometimes us old value investors or contrarian investors can be perceived maybe as funny duddies and we don't want to be perceived like that.
- 10:07I mean, I think everyone in our organization is using AI.
- 10:10I don't know.
- 10:11I don't know.
- 10:13Yeah, I don't know.
- 10:14But we are using it.
- 10:18We think it's incredibly useful.
- 10:19We have enterprise tools.
- 10:21I think it is really helping us in a lot of ways.
- 10:24But just because something is a very good product and very useful does not necessarily make things a good investment.
- 10:32At the end of the day,
- 10:33it really comes down to the price you pay.
- 10:36And so for these new IPOs, it will come down to the price at which they're offered.
- 10:41We would consider them.
- 10:42I would say, at least with SpaceX, we certainly weren't able to get anywhere near there to take an investment.
- 10:50And sometimes when there is a lot of excitement, it is human nature to bid things up and to potentially overpay.
- 10:59like any company, we will assess them on a fundamental basis when we're in a position to do so with what they bring to market.
- 11:05Yeah.
- 11:06And what's your thinking around, though, the broader impact of AI on the markets and the market cycle?
- 11:13Do you think it has the potential to actually change, at least in the shorter term?
- 11:19As they keep talking about this, AGI is coming and
- 11:24For me, I'm sitting there and I'm not an AI expert or a deep investing expert like you guys are, but I wonder if this productivity can then go into companies and then it's driving truck line revenues and it's driving down expenses, then that sounds like something that could potentially mean that the market cycle extends out beyond what it otherwise would.
- 11:47But then on the other side, you've got like, you know, you see all these stories of these companies that are spending more on AI stuff than, you know, what it is that they're saving on the other side.
- 11:56So obviously, you guys sort of think about it a bit.
- 11:59I'm keen to hear.
- 12:00Look, there are some, I guess, polarizing views.
- 12:03There's some camps in the extremes on either side.
- 12:06You've got Elon Musk talking about an age of...
- 12:09abundance and you know, you may as well.
- 12:12Shouldn't even invest.
- 12:12Shouldn't even need to invest.
- 12:14Shouldn't even need to invest.
- 12:15That sounds okay.
- 12:17And then, and then you have, I guess what they're calling the doomers and concerns around job displays and everything like that.
- 12:23I mean, when you look at the data now, unemployment has not really fallen.
- 12:27So I'm not, I'm not saying it, it may not pick up, but you can see the concerns reflected in share prices.
- 12:34Yeah.
- 12:36And in some areas, we think those concerns may be a bit overdone.
- 12:41So to think of an example, you might have something like a DEXUS in Australia, which is very exposed to office.
- 12:48There are a number of concerns around white-collar job displacement layered on top of things like
- 12:56the shift to hybrid work and rising interest rates.
- 12:59And you can see the pessimism being impounded into those type of share prices.
- 13:05That is one scenario where we think investors have taken it too far.
- 13:09Of course, nothing gets cheap without some hair on it, but Texas does have some very, very high quality assets and today trades at a very substantial discount to their net tangible assets and the cost of replacing those assets.
- 13:20Not a lot of suppliers coming online.
- 13:22So we're looking for those opportunities.
- 13:25We may be proven right or proven wrong, but we think that's an area where it's gone too far impounding some of these fears into the price and have used that to take a bit of a stake in the company.
- 13:35Interesting.
- 13:36Well, we just were in a large co-working space with all private offices.
- 13:41And we recently, we've been in the same building for three and a bit years or something, but we recently changed our office because our team had grown.
- 13:49And at that time, we looked around at the market and
- 13:52It's, it's, there, there weren't very many good options.
- 13:55Like for when you were looking for, you know, 50 desks or something.
- 13:58Yep.
- 14:00And there's, there's not a ton of options in, if you're looking for a quality spot, like good location around the CBD.
- 14:05And it's interesting because people are saying, oh, commercial property, you know, commercial property is taking a hit and you can sort of see it on high street, but I don't know for a premium office spacing, it seems pretty in pretty hot demand.
- 14:17Yeah.
- 14:18Yeah, I'd agree with you.
- 14:20I mean, there's just not a lot of supply coming online.
- 14:24And yeah, I think, I mean, this is maybe getting a little bit more philosophical, but I certainly like coming into the office.
- 14:30I think it's good for people to be spending time with their colleagues.
- 14:33I think you learn a lot better.
- 14:37when you're with colleagues, particularly colleagues that are a lot smarter than you, of which there's many at Alan Gray in that bucket.
- 14:43So yeah, I mean, again, I just think probably the fear's a little bit overdone.
- 14:48There were all these predictions of dramatic job losses.
- 14:51A lot of businesses are talking about their productivity gains, but again, unemployment rates in the US and Australia are very, very low.
- 14:57Perhaps you might start to see that come through, but we're certainly not now.
- 15:00And we are a few years into quite powerful models being used.
- 15:04Mm-hmm.
- 15:05Yeah, super interesting times.
- 15:07Keen to, though, bring it back a little bit closer to home and talk about what you guys are seeing in the Australian market where you might be seeing the biggest opportunity at the moment.
- 15:16Yeah.
- 15:16Okay.
- 15:16So we just talked about the REITs.
- 15:18That's been one area.
- 15:19In addition to DEXIS, we have a stake in Mervac, real estate, one of these very, very depressed areas where we think we've been able to pick up some assets at discounts to intrinsic value.
- 15:29Another area would be some packaging companies.
- 15:33So here I'm thinking of Aurora and Amcor.
- 15:37These are not exciting, sexy businesses.
- 15:40They're not the SpaceX's or these things that are smack bang in the AI thematic.
- 15:45Aurora really manufactures aluminium cans and glass bottles.
- 15:51Some bottles are a bit nicer than others.
- 15:52They have the fancy Grey Goose bottles, but bottles nonetheless.
- 15:55Yeah.
- 15:56And Amcor is really in food and beverage packaging predominantly.
- 16:01But we think boring can be beautiful when it affords you the opportunity to buy something cheaply.
- 16:05Yeah.
- 16:06Again, like all investments, they're not without their own risk.
- 16:09Amcor has a bit more debt than we would like.
- 16:12Aurora on the glass side has struggled.
- 16:16But at this price, we think it makes sense to step in.
- 16:20And you'll hear me coming back to that theme quite a lot.
- 16:22I mean, we think...
- 16:23For every asset, there is a price that makes sense to own it.
- 16:27And so that's what our analysts spend their time doing is assessing whether or not a company is fantastic or going through a tough time, what we think it's really worth.
- 16:38And we look at what the share price is doing relative to what we think it's really worth.
- 16:43Interesting.
- 16:44Well, that seems to make sense.
- 16:46What about then if you're looking more broadly and you did obviously you touch on a few things
- 16:52things around the Asian markets and a little bit of US.
- 16:54But just in terms of global markets, I know that's a bit of a focus for you guys.
- 16:58What are you seeing there?
- 16:59Yeah.
- 17:00So within our balance fund, one of the largest collective exposures on the equity side would be energy.
- 17:07Now, energy is not necessarily out of favor at the moment.
- 17:10You've seen oil prices rise as a result of the closure of the Strait of Hormuz and Iranian tensions in the Middle East.
- 17:19But it seems like the market is pricing in quite a speedy return to lower oil prices from here.
- 17:24I mean, we're recording on the 11th of September.
- 17:27Overnight, the oil price rose quite a bit and the energy sector in terms of listed equities in the US fell.
- 17:35It doesn't seem like spot prices are being reflected or there's a large expectation that they will fall quite dramatically from here.
- 17:43We think there's been a long-term underinvestment in energy supply broadly.
- 17:48AI and the energy intensive nature of these data centers is certainly likely to increase the demand, particularly for baseload power like LNG in the coming years.
- 18:01And so we have some exposure there.
- 18:02Not all of it is in say oil and gas majors.
- 18:06One interesting company that is a position in our
- 18:10a company called Kinder Morgan, which owns a lot of the pipelines over in the US that LNG flows through both for domestic consumption and for export.
- 18:20One of the things we really like about that company is about 70% of their contracts are either take or pay or hedged, meaning that no
- 18:31Those contracts are signed and the company gets paid.
- 18:33So we see that as a company that has a relatively stable earning stream, is relatively high yielding and somewhat inflation protected and trades at a reasonable price.
- 18:46And so we quite like that.
- 18:48Again, no investment is without its risks.
- 18:51It remains fairly correlated to energy prices, probably more so than we think it should given the nature of a lot of those contracts.
- 19:00But we think the investment case stacks up.
- 19:02And we also like the fact that there's a lot of alignment there.
- 19:04Rich Kinder is the chairman.
- 19:07He owns around 10%.
- 19:08Other staff own some significant stakes.
- 19:11And we like that in companies where you can get.
- 19:14Yeah.
- 19:14I was going to ask you how you guys look at that from a leadership perspective and business case because you say that there's a price for every asset.
- 19:25But it's like if sometimes you see a company and it's like clearly a bit of a basket case, how do you guys sort of balance those two things out?
- 19:34Yeah.
- 19:35So I guess it just is another element or data point that feeds into the valuation.
- 19:42So, you know, we wouldn't, if we had a dim view on a management team, it wouldn't necessarily prevent us from taking a stake in that company.
- 19:52But it is something you have to think a lot about as an investor.
- 19:56And again, it comes down to whether that's reflected in the price.
- 19:59One thing we spend a lot of time thinking about is governance of a business along with capital allocation.
- 20:05So their record, you know, even a structurally impaired company might be, and I mean a company that's going to have declining earnings, right?
- 20:15in future years may be an attractive opportunity if you pay a very low price for it.
- 20:21However, if that government, if that management team goes out and does silly things with those earnings that are still being generated, that can be a big problem.
- 20:32And so,
- 20:34You know, we think a lot about governance and capital allocation.
- 20:39We speak to a lot of management teams about these elements.
- 20:42And where we can, you know, we try and get across our views as well on what's appropriate.
- 20:49Yeah, interesting.
- 20:51Well, look, we've just been through reporting season here in Australia.
- 20:55What's your read on what's come out of that and, you know, sort of where we're positioned?
- 21:00Yeah.
- 21:00So I think my colleague, Tim Hillier said it best.
- 21:04He's on our analyst team and he said to me, it felt like Mr. Market was standing there with a champagne bottle in one hand and a knife in the other.
- 21:13And depending on whether the company exceeded market expectations or fell short of market expectations, bottles were popped or the company got knifed.
- 21:23It wasn't perhaps quite as volatile as back in the February reporting season.
- 21:28But I read it might have been Goldman that said there was still more than 50% of companies on the ASX that had a more than 5% share price reaction on the day it announced.
- 21:39That's quite a sharp move.
- 21:41Heading into reporting season, our largest overweight was in healthcare.
- 21:45As I said, it had had a bit of a torrid time over the past year.
- 21:50And a lot of those names caught a bit of a bit and did quite well.
- 21:54So here I'm thinking of companies like Ancel, the glove manufacturer.
- 21:57CSL, which we started to build a position in last year, an absolute market darling that used to trade at over $300 and fell to the 90s.
- 22:07And Ramsey Healthcare, which is also operating in a tough space with many private hospitals being unprofitable and Ramsey being relatively well positioned.
- 22:18That was nice to see.
- 22:19Of course, we didn't get through completely unscathed.
- 22:23Two detractors from our portfolio were QBE, which had a little bit of a weaker underwriting result than some expected, and also Endeavor, which owns BWS and Dan Murphy's, and there's been a decline in demand for alcohol that has crimped margins.
- 22:41But on the whole, it was a good period for us, and it was nice to see that rotation from QB.
- 22:45from some underperforming or from some popular areas into underperforming areas.
- 22:51Yeah.
- 22:52One of the things that I've been reading about just recently is around the fact that if you look at an index, that the index volatility is saying relatively stable.
- 23:02And this is, I think it was based more around the US markets.
- 23:05but that you're seeing a lot more volatility within individual stocks, like there's more price sensitivity.
- 23:11Can you maybe unpack that a little bit for us and what's actually driving it?
- 23:17It's hard to say what's driving it, but I would agree with your premise.
- 23:21Perhaps I think some of that individual share price volatility has come from the enormous shift we've seen into passive stocks.
- 23:29and what I might call benchmark-aware investing.
- 23:31So not passive, but the portfolio ends up looking quite similar to the index.
- 23:36That's really taken a lot of the active managers, especially the fundamental active managers, out of the market.
- 23:44And so when there's a sell-off and a share is becoming cheaper than it's really worth, there is less people standing there to start picking up that exposure.
- 23:53Yeah, interesting.
- 23:55And so perhaps that's an element.
- 23:59There's a lot of weight going into passive investments and that gets split up just based on the market cap, the size of the companies that are in the index.
- 24:07There's less fundamental investors out there relatively that are looking at these companies and deciding what their cash flows look like, what their balance sheet looks like, whether this warrants an investment.
- 24:20Yeah.
- 24:21I know that it's one of the things though as an advisor that your clients start to get concerned about because they tend to, they're not necessarily, even if they're invested in the index, they're not necessarily looking in the index that much, but they see these share prices bounce around and that's what leads to the questions they're saying.
- 24:37Is there a buy opportunity?
- 24:39Is it overcooked?
- 24:40Is it going to crash or should it be out of the portfolio?
- 24:43So yeah, it is an interesting one.
- 24:46I think that's right.
- 24:46I mean, I think a lot of people don't look beneath the surface and think about the exposures that you're taking when you invest in an index.
- 24:53Yeah.
- 24:54You're actually taking some quite concentrated bets, but they've come to be seen as a default product.
- 25:01Yeah.
- 25:01And of course, they have done very, very well for quite a long period of time, so I understand that.
- 25:05Yeah.
- 25:06And so going back to reporting season, are you guys changing anything as a result of what we've seen from those announcements?
- 25:13Yeah.
- 25:13So nothing too major in the short term.
- 25:16I mentioned Dexas.
- 25:17That would have been our largest ad during August.
- 25:20And there's also been some trimming of the stocks that have done very well for us and a bit of rotation from those in our portfolio into some that have underperformed.
- 25:28Mm-hmm.
- 25:29If I think about portfolio changes, probably where there's been more change over the past year has been in the fixed income side of our balance fund.
- 25:37For a long time, we were underweight fixed interest and much shorter duration than the benchmark, which is a measure of interest rate risk.
- 25:47As yields have increased over time, and they've quite dramatically increased in a lot of countries, but including Australia and the US...
- 25:55To us, it's made more sense to add some duration and to add some fixed interest exposure in the fund.
- 26:00So today, duration in the fund is over four years.
- 26:03That's still below the composite benchmark, but more than twice where we had it three years ago.
- 26:09And we've added quite a bit to Australian government bonds predominantly.
- 26:14Okay.
- 26:15We're still a bit cautious in the US due to the fiscal decisions that are being made there.
- 26:23So we have very little in terms of nominal US treasuries.
- 26:27We have more exposure in treasury inflation-protected securities where the coupon and the principal ratchet up or adjusted for inflation.
- 26:37Okay.
- 26:38And so do you think bonds are back to you?
- 26:39Because I know that for advisors, I think a lot would put off the –
- 26:44particularly as we went through the rate increasing cycle and bond prices just got pumped and everyone was sort of thinking that this, you know, bonds are safe and it's all good and we should be keeping our, you know, target asset allocations.
- 26:58But a lot of people got burnt by that pretty hard and realized that bonds aren't always, you know, the safe thing that they are.
- 27:06But what do you think for client conversations today?
- 27:09I mean, they are certainly far more attractive than they have been in recent years.
- 27:13And that's almost just a mathematical outcome of the yields that you're being offered.
- 27:17And I get it.
- 27:18It's human nature, right?
- 27:19So yes, bonds have done terribly for an extended period or duration has done terribly for an extended period because those yields are rising.
- 27:28But your starting point in terms of yields matters a lot.
- 27:31You know, if you are happy to have
- 27:33a large exposure to bonds in your portfolio when they were yielding 1% or 2%, you should be much happier to have exposure now when the Aussie 10-year is at 5.2% and I think the US 10-year is at 4.9%.
- 27:47Now, our duration is not that high.
- 27:49So there are, of course, yields could go higher and that would result in a capital loss.
- 27:56Yeah.
- 27:58However, as those yields rise, they get incrementally more attractive to own.
- 28:02And so that's the reason that we've taken duration in the portfolio up a bit.
- 28:06Elsewhere, I would also say, you know, the portfolio manager on our balance fund, Alec Cutler, said to me the other day, you know, he thinks a lot of emerging markets are behaving in a more fiscally responsible way than many development markets.
- 28:18Yeah.
- 28:19And so it's also important to look across the allowable investment universe.
- 28:23And he's finding some interesting opportunities in the sovereign bond space outside of the US and taking some small exposures there where it makes sense.
- 28:32Okay.
- 28:32Interesting.
- 28:33Well, look, one of the things that jumped out at me was looking at some of your stuff and you talk about this bottom-up investing approach.
- 28:41Can you explain that to us?
- 28:43Sure.
- 28:43So-
- 28:44Sometimes it's a bit easier to explain things by explaining what they're not.
- 28:49I think a lot of, particularly in the multi-asset space, a lot of people take what I'd call a top-down approach to investing.
- 28:55The process starts with a bit of a macroeconomic view of the world, what they think interest rates will do, which countries they think might grow faster than others.
- 29:03And they form a view of their world and the return they might expect from different asset classes.
- 29:09And they decide on their exposure to these different buckets.
- 29:12And then eventually that filters down into manager selection or potentially individual security selection if the manager does that.
- 29:19We take the entirely opposite approach from that.
- 29:22So we have quite a well-resourced team.
- 29:24We have 17 analysts working directly on the Allangare Australia Balance Fund in terms of contributing ideas.
- 29:30And they all start at the individual asset level.
- 29:32So whether that be an Australian company or global company, a sovereign bond, a corporate bond, a commodity position, everything starts at the individual security and making an assessment of is that an attractive opportunity.
- 29:45Yeah.
- 29:46Every individual opportunity is fighting for its rightful place in the portfolio.
- 29:51And our asset allocation is almost just an outcome of selecting those assets with the best risk reward characteristics.
- 29:58We, of course, then step back and we run risk tools over the portfolio.
- 30:01We make sure that we're not overly exposed to a concentrated factor.
- 30:06that we don't want.
- 30:08We run a risk overlay where we can reduce market risk and we can make adjustments to our currency exposure.
- 30:14But the starting point for us is that individual security level.
- 30:18And I think it works well because the quality of information is greater when you're looking at an individual company or an individual bond, rather than starting at a huge macroeconomic level and trying to make predictions and adjust portfolios.
- 30:32based on those types of views.
- 30:33Well, I think those sort of forecasts, it's very notoriously hard for anyone to get right at that level.
- 30:39Yeah.
- 30:40We certainly don't have an edge.
- 30:41And so we don't employ macroeconomists.
- 30:45We just try and focus at the asset level.
- 30:47Yeah.
- 30:48Nice.
- 30:49One of the things you touched on there is about currency and how much of an issue do you think currency is for investors at the moment?
- 30:56Currency is always a huge issue for investors or something that should receive a lot of thought.
- 31:03The fact is that, let's say you invest in the US and the companies you invest in appreciate 10%.
- 31:10If the US dollar weakens relative to the Aussie by 10%, you've received zero return, essentially.
- 31:16Yes.
- 31:17And that happens a bit.
- 31:18Yeah, absolutely.
- 31:20I was fortunate I was in the US in April and there was a nice little bump in the Aussie dollar relative in that time.
- 31:27And I was like watching the money and it wasn't what I expected.
- 31:30And I was on holiday, so I wasn't watching the markets that closely.
- 31:33I had a look and I was like, oh, this is actually quite nice.
- 31:36So sometimes it works in your favor.
- 31:38Yeah.
- 31:38So, I mean, the Aussie has been quite strong recently.
- 31:41We have been for quite a few years underweight the US dollar within our balance fund.
- 31:47And that view really came about, we rely heavily on Orbis, our sister company that has quite strong resourcing on the currency side.
- 31:55They use long-term purchasing power parity models and just found the US to look expensive to them.
- 32:00For quite a long time, that was a headwind for us as the US dollar remained strong.
- 32:05But in the past year, that's really turned into a tailwind and had a benefit to returns.
- 32:11We talked a little bit about yields earlier.
- 32:13You know, the Australian 10-year government bond yield is a bit above the US, maybe by about 30 basis points.
- 32:19And that's supportive to currencies more in the short term too.
- 32:23Yeah.
- 32:24So do you think, should we be more hedged?
- 32:27I know that's a hard question to answer, but for advisors that are investing, obviously, Australia is a pretty small pond.
- 32:35For most risk profile allocations, we'd have is sort of 50 for a high growth investor plus percent allocation.
- 32:43What's your take?
- 32:45Well, look, I certainly can't provide any advice or guidance, but I can talk about what we're doing in our portfolio.
- 32:51And at the moment, we are overweight the Aussie dollar relative to the composite benchmark.
- 32:56We remain very underweight the US dollar.
- 32:58But we're also looking at other stores of value to make sure we're appropriately diversified.
- 33:03So we have a decent amount invested in the Norwegian krona.
- 33:09We have some Canadian dollar exposure.
- 33:10We have some exposure in the yuan.
- 33:12So we have a team that is, you know, it does get quite technical and outside my area of specific expertise, but they are thinking very, very carefully around the fiscal position of these countries and where their currencies sit on long-term purchasing power parity models and making those decisions.
- 33:31Which does make sense because they can move a lot faster than what the markets actually do.
- 33:35Well, like obviously markets can move fast as well, but it's like those currency gains can come.
- 33:40pretty quick and then it undoes all the hard work that you do as an investor or as an advisor uh as well keen to chat a bit about gold there's obviously you know we're just by martin place here and you know there's about three months that i was walking past avc bullion and every day there's like people camped out there uh that that's died off a little bit although they've got a nicer barrier thing down there now um what's the what's your perspective on gold
- 34:05It was fascinating, wasn't it?
- 34:06I work in Martin Place too.
- 34:07I mean, it was always the morning after a very strong day for gold too.
- 34:11Yeah.
- 34:11Those days where you had a 5% sell-off, it would really quieten down.
- 34:15It was quite amazing to see human nature in action like that.
- 34:18I put a post up and called them lunatics, which I stand by, but I caught a lot of hate about this post because, I don't know, you're not supposed to call people lunatics or something.
- 34:28But the way I see it, it's like as an investor, as an advisor or whatever, it's like you should
- 34:35set a strategy and you should execute on your strategy.
- 34:37Of course, your strategy should change and evolve and be refined over time.
- 34:40But as you say, these people are there and it's often after a big run-up, most of the time run-up in prices and sometimes down.
- 34:50And sometimes people are buying and some people are selling.
- 34:53But either way, it's like if you're to the point where you feel like you need to go big camp out on Martin Place to do this because of what happened yesterday, that tells me that your strategy is wrong, right?
- 35:02Yeah.
- 35:03I think so.
- 35:03I mean, if you're feeling those emotions like, I am missing out, and you're seeing large share price returns, and that is what's prompting your investment, that is where people should take ports.
- 35:14In terms of gold, it was a lot easier to invest in gold a few years ago.
- 35:18So from around 2019, we had an approximate 5% exposure to physical gold held by an ETF within our balance fund.
- 35:26But back at that time, there was a lot more cost curve support for gold.
- 35:31All-in costs of producing gold had risen quite a lot, more than the gold price had risen.
- 35:36And so parts of the cost curve were unprofitable.
- 35:39And we like those situations when it comes to commodities where there's some fundamental economic support for the price.
- 35:45Now, the price has risen a lot.
- 35:48And so, there is less of that economic fundamental support from the economics of the industry.
- 35:53And you become more reliant on these themes around fiscal responsibility and the potential cushioning effects or the lower correlation with other assets, which make it a nice thing to hold in a diversified portfolio.
- 36:06So, we have reduced our exposure to physical gold in our portfolio.
- 36:10Today, it sits at around 3%.
- 36:11Mm-hmm.
- 36:12We do retain some exposure to some gold miners like Barrick and Newmont, but in our view, it certainly warrants a lower exposure than it did a few years ago before you saw this dramatic increase in price.
- 36:24All those people got into Martin Place.
- 36:28One thing, you touched on the magnificent seven and also like the ETFs and index funds and concentration risk.
- 36:38I think a lot of markets around the world are relatively concentrated, ours included.
- 36:43How worried do you think we should be as advisors guiding our clients around this concentration risk?
- 36:50Yeah, so I think it certainly is something to think about, especially in the context of making sure clients are appropriately diversified.
- 36:58I mean, if you think of the ASX 300 index, the Australian Stock Market Index, you can think about it a little bit like a plane with two major engines and then a whole lot of smaller engines.
- 37:09And those two main engines are financials and materials, and they make up 60% of your power.
- 37:14And within those, it's really the banks and the iron ore miners that are driving things predominantly.
- 37:18Yeah.
- 37:19For a long time, both of those engines were chugging along very nicely.
- 37:23And as a result, index returns have been very, very strong, above very long-term averages, if you look over the last decade or so.
- 37:30Recently, we seem to have lost one of those engines being financials.
- 37:34You've had rising interest rates.
- 37:35You've had these CGT changes that are coming in.
- 37:38That's really dented confidence.
- 37:40You've had the battler debacle, which the bank's maybe not directly exposed to, but certainly not helpful.
- 37:46Thankfully, the materials has picked up a lot of the slack and been very strong over the past year, and the index has managed a positive return.
- 37:54But it's worth thinking about a situation in which both of those things weren't firing.
- 37:58That's not a prediction, but it is a risk that exists when you have that type of concentration.
- 38:04In that environment, things would get quite rocky quite quickly, and you would want exposure to those other smaller engines on the plane wings.
- 38:12Yeah.
- 38:12So for us, you know, it's about running an appropriately diversified portfolio.
- 38:17The iron ore miners and the banks would be two of our largest underweight positions in our portfolio and making sure we have exposure in what are a lot of attractive opportunities that exist outside of those two main areas.
- 38:29And then to your point, not a dissimilar story when you go to world markets, you know, out of the MISCY World Index exposure, which is probably the number one index global exposure,
- 38:4072% is in the US in just one country.
- 38:44And a lot of that index is exposed to technology names and wedded to this AI theme.
- 38:49So again, it's done very well for people.
- 38:53I'm not saying, I'm just saying it's appropriate to think about diversification and what might be held alongside something like that.
- 39:02to ensure one is appropriately diversified.
- 39:05So again, in global markets, we are spending a bit more time finding some more interesting opportunities in emerging markets in the UK and in this type of area.
- 39:14I think it is a really difficult one for advisors because people have strong views about this stuff that some clients are right into investing and others are less so, but like...
- 39:23And again, it seems to be across them that they have different views that some will be like, oh, that seems like it's overcooked, even though they're probably not basing that on the 17 investment analysts, you're poring over this stuff every day.
- 39:35And then you've got others that they don't want to be missing out on that side either.
- 39:39And so, yeah, I think it's a difficult line to tread through those conversations with clients one way or the other way.
- 39:46Yeah.
- 39:47And thankfully, you don't need to make a binary choice, right?
- 39:50So, you know, I think it's not a bad thing to have different views within an overall portfolio.
- 39:56Yeah, I think it's okay.
- 39:59As they say, you know, the only free lunch when it comes to investing is diversification.
- 40:05And so, diversification works at many different levels.
- 40:08It works in terms of
- 40:09individual securities that works in terms of countries.
- 40:12It can also work in terms of just having a different thought process and an approach within an overall diversified portfolio.
- 40:19Makes sense.
- 40:20Look, Chris, my last question for you is that just for the advisors that are listening in out there, for them, what do you think is the most important message for them to be getting across to their clients in terms of investing in markets today?
- 40:33I put you on the spot a bit with that one.
- 40:34Sorry about that.
- 40:35No, that's all right.
- 40:36It's a great question.
- 40:36I'm just thinking about it.
- 40:37I mean, to me, okay, so as an investment professional, I spend all my time thinking about companies and assets and how we can eke out alpha for clients.
- 40:46But when I really think about it, I think a huge amount of the value that an advisor adds is just making sure people don't make silly mistakes.
- 40:54And we do a lot of work to try and deliver a few extra percentage points of returns for investors after fees over the long term.
- 41:02But if you can stop someone making a big mistake when they're a bit panicky and going to cash in a down market or something of that nature, that frankly will have probably a bigger impact on the overall life of that client.
- 41:17So I think it's all about communication with clients, making sure you're there for them when they're going through something in terms of an emotional fear due to the movements in markets.
- 41:29And just keeping that level of communication up and guiding them through those kind of times.
- 41:34Love that.
- 41:35Well, Chris, thank you again.
- 41:36Really appreciate your insights.
- 41:38For anyone listening that's keen to understand more about Alan Gray and what you guys are about, what's the best way for them to do that?
- 41:43Yeah, so jump on our website, alangray.com.au.
- 41:47All people can even reach out to me directly if they wanted to.
- 41:50My details are on the website.
- 41:52Awesome.
- 41:52Well, Chris Heslow, thank you, sir.
- 41:54Appreciate you sharing your insights.
- 41:56Guys, on that note, we'll leave it there for today and we'll catch you next time.
- 41:59Thanks so much, Ben.
- 41:59No worries.
- 42:00Bye for now.