Latest / Film And Whiskey / The Searchers / Woodford Reserve Kentucky Straight Malt Whiskey
Transcript
- 0:00In 1950, director, John Ford and Star.
- 0:03John Wayne gave the world, an epic tale of a tenacious War,
- 0:07veteran with vengeance. In his heart.
- 0:09In 2022, we visit an unexpected place in search of a great malt.
- 0:14Whisky, the film is the Searchers, the whiskey is
- 0:17Woodford. Reserve, Kentucky straight malt
- 0:20whiskey. And we'll review them both.
- 0:22This is the film and whiskey podcast.
- 0:43Welcome to the film and whiskey podcast, where each week, we
- 0:46review a classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 0:49I'm Bob book, I'm Brad G and this week we are looking at John
- 0:53Ford's 1956, Masterpiece The Searchers Brad.
- 0:59This is a movie that I'm not going to lie, I don't know that
- 1:02I've been looking forward to talking about this movie.
- 1:05Like it's it's one of the highest reviewed your highest
- 1:09rated movies of all time. When the AFI first did their 100
- 1:12best films list in 1998, it came in at 96 and the next time they
- 1:17did it in 2007. It was number 12.
- 1:20So we're talking about a movie that is very highly revered.
- 1:24And we've mentioned it a lot of times on this podcast before
- 1:27that people like De Palma and Spielberg and Scorsese, hold
- 1:31this movie in super high esteem and yet it's a really
- 1:35controversial movie. It's a movie that a lot of
- 1:37people are very critical of for its portrayals of Native
- 1:41Americans and racism and having your main character.
- 1:45Be such a virulent and violent racist.
- 1:48And there's a lot to Grapple with in this movie and so I
- 1:52can't say that. I was like rubbing my Palms
- 1:54together. Like oh boy, oh boy, we get to
- 1:56watch The Searchers this week. In your dipalma's together.
- 1:59Hey, that's what people come to us for right there, that's it,
- 2:06man. Bee puns.
- 2:07All right, everybody will be back next week.
- 2:12That's honestly, probably the best thing we can contribute to
- 2:14the conversation about the search awesome.
- 2:16This picture ba-bye, I came into this movie, just being wildly
- 2:22excited. Because I remember watching this
- 2:25movie when I was young with my dad and Really enjoying it.
- 2:29And I didn't always, like, westerns my view of westerns as
- 2:33a kid was, like, my dad likes them and they're often very long
- 2:37and very boring. This one, I did not remember
- 2:41being boring. I remember really enjoying as a
- 2:42kid and so I was kind of excited to come back to it and see
- 2:46where, you know, where I was at with it.
- 2:48Now that I've got a few years of movie critiquing under my belt,
- 2:52there you go. Yeah, I think this is my third
- 2:54time seeing the film. I remember watching it in high
- 2:56school and just not being impressed with, At all.
- 2:59But I also think that I watched it on like a VHS that I rented
- 3:03from the library. So, like, you don't get the
- 3:05vistas of the John Ford cinematography.
- 3:09You don't have to rent from the library.
- 3:10Bob, you borrow the free. They actually charged me.
- 3:14They were like, no, no, that's five dollars for you because
- 3:17racism, because rates at some man.
- 3:21Yeah, so I didn't like it. The first time I saw it.
- 3:23I went back and try it again. A few years later.
- 3:25Because again, like all these filmmakers that I looked up to,
- 3:28To said that there was something there and I just I didn't click
- 3:30for me and so this was I think only my third time seeing it and
- 3:34I got to say man I got a lot more out of it this time but as
- 3:39a result of a lot of the conversations that you and I
- 3:41have had on prior episodes of this podcast.
- 3:45And I think what I'm most excited for today is to draw
- 3:48comparisons to other films, we've seen and bring up points
- 3:51from conversations. We've had because they've really
- 3:54helped me in terms of processing.
- 3:56What you see on screen here in this movie.
- 3:58Yeah, there is so much happening in this film.
- 4:01What I really love about it, if I had to kind of boil it all
- 4:05down, the characters in this movie are fascinating and the
- 4:09cinematography is gorgeous and that there's just so much to
- 4:14love in those two veins. That for me the movie just moved
- 4:20at a really nice Pace to illustrate what the story was
- 4:25trying to tell you, you know, it's not the fastest.
- 4:28Paste Western I've ever seen, but it definitely has a Cadence
- 4:31to it that gives you the feel for this, you know, five year
- 4:35Journey that our main characters go on.
- 4:38So that's actually my first question is it a five-year total
- 4:42Journey? Because I remember like the
- 4:44first time they come home, they say, oh, you guys have been gone
- 4:47for two years and then after that, they go back out, you
- 4:51know, searching and he writes her a letter and then they come
- 4:54back the second time and she said, you've been gone five
- 4:56years and only one. So I didn't know if that meant
- 4:59that they were gone for like seven or eight years total or if
- 5:02it was just one long chunk of five years, that's a very good
- 5:06question. Bob I'm, you know, just for the
- 5:09the feel of it I'm going to say it was like 7 years.
- 5:11Yeah, let's just say it because that that makes it feel a little
- 5:13more epic because you know spending five years of your life
- 5:17searching you know the great vast plains of the West is
- 5:21absolutely nothing. That's just, you know, Child's
- 5:24Play. I think that you've hit the nail
- 5:26on the head by using the word Epic.
- 5:28Rick. And that's, you know, this movie
- 5:30is known for the the Lush cinematography and the Monument
- 5:34Valley settings that John Ford loved to return to.
- 5:37But this is one of the most beautiful looking of all
- 5:39westerns. And what's really funny to me
- 5:42Brad will get into talking about it later is how about half the
- 5:45movie is like it looks like a mega Budget on location,
- 5:51gorgeously rendered movie and then the other half is like, all
- 5:54right, we've got a garage and I need you to like pay The walls
- 5:58to look like we're outside at a campsite and then like the other
- 6:02part of the movies, just like real rough looking, when it
- 6:04comes to the sets, but I wanted to say with the, the Epic nature
- 6:09of the movie. This is something that David
- 6:11lean would go on record saying he watched this movie over and
- 6:14over and over again before he made, Lawrence of Arabia to
- 6:17learn how to film a landscape and we've got Lawrence of Arabia
- 6:21coming up here just in a few weeks on the podcast.
- 6:24So I'm really excited to see again the the points of
- 6:27connection. Action that we're going to find
- 6:29between the Searchers and so many other films that we've done
- 6:31before and are doing, you know, in the coming weeks.
- 6:34Yeah, I mean the movie that is known for its Vistas got its,
- 6:40you know, the Searchers was at stomping grounds.
- 6:43It will. So like, there's got to be
- 6:47something that you're looking for when it comes to the
- 6:49Searchers. And I, yeah, I guess my hope is
- 6:52that people don't let the the conversation around the
- 6:56Searchers steer them away. From the movie because I think
- 6:59it's a really worthwhile movie that a is just a beautiful film
- 7:04and be I think it probably adds to the conversation on how
- 7:09racism is depicted in films. Mmm, and like, what is taboo and
- 7:14what is actually like helpful to the conversation?
- 7:18And I will get into that later, but I think this movie is, is
- 7:21successful on a lot of fronts. Bob, totally agree.
- 7:24All right, man, let's go ahead and jump into Brad explains
- 7:27this. Is the part of the podcast where
- 7:29Brad breaks down the plot of the movie that he has just seen
- 7:33often for the first time. And again, remind me this, this
- 7:36is not your first time seeing it, right?
- 7:38No, I saw when I was young, so this is my second time seeing
- 7:42it, all right? You've got 60 seconds on the
- 7:44clock. Can you break down the plot of
- 7:46The Searchers? Yeah.
- 7:48Ethan Edwards is a Civil War veteran of the Confederate side
- 7:53of the war. He returns home to Texas, he Is
- 7:59unmarried. So he goes back to his brothers
- 8:01Homestead. His the whole family is really
- 8:04excited to see him. They go out to search for some
- 8:09Native Americans who have been stealing cattle, killing cattle
- 8:13at a neighbor's Ranch. And it turns out that they were
- 8:16doing that, just to distract the men so that they could go raid,
- 8:19the actual Homestead. His brothers family is mostly
- 8:23all killed and his two nieces are taken by The Native American
- 8:28tribe, the Comanches, the and the rest of the movie is he and
- 8:34man who was adopted by his brothers family, as they search
- 8:37for the two girls who were taken.
- 8:40Eventually they find out that one of them has been killed and
- 8:42they keep searching until they're able to rescue their
- 8:45nice. And that's pretty much it I
- 8:48think. Yeah, I mean you know, we left
- 8:51out that John Wayne's character is just the worst.
- 8:53Human being of all time, is it? I mean, He's saying I'm sorry
- 8:59think of he's having some other bad human beings I would say
- 9:02he's up there for sure but it does the right thing in the end.
- 9:05Yeah, well I don't know how long I'm gonna be able to go today
- 9:11without going really deep on this movie because I think the
- 9:15only way this movie works is when you look at it through
- 9:18certain prisms of interpretation and and you understand that what
- 9:24they're doing with the John Wayne character does not mean
- 9:26that they are endorsing. What the John Wayne character is
- 9:29doing but you also try to get inside the mind of the John
- 9:32Wayne character and figure out like what's driving Ethan aside
- 9:36from just hatred and racism like what's what's the root cause of
- 9:39all this. And I think it takes you in some
- 9:41really interesting places. But again, like this is the kind
- 9:45of thing. We would normally discuss on the
- 9:46back part of the episode. And now we just have to kind of
- 9:49talk about like who gave a good performance but it's just it's
- 9:53really hard to talk about this movie without just immediately
- 9:56jumping into. Psychoanalyze this main
- 9:59character. Yeah, I mean, when you jump into
- 10:03the character of Ethan Edwards, he might be one of the most, one
- 10:09of the more nuanced characters we've ever looked at, especially
- 10:13in a western. Mmm, westerns are kind of known
- 10:16for. I mean, if I'm being honest
- 10:19there, the Ridiculousness of the characters.
- 10:23Like I think about the movie McLintock.
- 10:26Sorry, McClintock, I'm gonna talk forgot the exclamation
- 10:30point and like John Wayne's character in that is, you know,
- 10:36a little over-the-top as is every other person in that
- 10:40movie. I mean, he has, he has Marine
- 10:44O'Hara over his knee and he's spanking her right?
- 10:47And like other people are laughing at them, and it's just
- 10:50a ridiculous movie. And I think a lot of westerns
- 10:54can kind of fall into that vein, even some the Clint Eastwood
- 10:57stuff. This one is not that Bob.
- 11:00No, it's not. And I think this is a good place
- 11:03to kind of talk about. You know, let's at least start
- 11:05talking about the characters racism and motivations because
- 11:09you know, John Wayne is has not aged.
- 11:13Well, let's just say it like that.
- 11:14Like just check the Mythos of John Wayne is not aged well into
- 11:182022. And his off screen Persona, I
- 11:23think often gets conflated with his on-screen persona, but every
- 11:27once in a while, John Ford would do some sort of little what's
- 11:34the word subversive thing with with John Wayne and get him to
- 11:38play a character that went against type and not just went
- 11:40against tight but like actively interrogated, the things that
- 11:44the John, Wayne type is known for doing and that's kind of
- 11:48what you get here and I always found it funny that people look
- 11:51at Ethan Edwards in this movie and how he's a complicated
- 11:55character who is objectively, a horrible.
- 11:58A person. And they they try to question.
- 12:01John Ford, for being like, why would you make this the hero of
- 12:04the movie? Why would you make us root for
- 12:06this person? When I think the whole point of
- 12:09the movie is to ask that difficult question and it's a
- 12:12lot more problematic when he's just doing casually racist
- 12:17things in the movies. Like, McClintock.
- 12:20That never go, examined. Do you know what I mean?
- 12:22Like, that movie is just super misogynistic and probably
- 12:25racist. But like, yes, but because it's
- 12:27not, Explicitly. So or it's not like dealing with
- 12:31themes of racism, it's almost like we don't even talk about
- 12:34that but I find those to be the more problematic roles than this
- 12:37one. Yeah, this one the way his
- 12:41racism is portrayed. I think that you have Jeffrey
- 12:45Hunter who plays Martin pawley who, you know, is the second
- 12:49lead in this the way those two interact really gives you kind
- 12:55of like, I don't know, the the the yin and yang of this movie
- 13:01that, you know, John Wayne's character really represents
- 13:05chaos and darkness and evil in a lot of ways and and Martin
- 13:11pawley represents like the pure-hearted search and
- 13:17preservation of an innocent Soul.
- 13:20Yeah. Like I think that I think that
- 13:23the way those two characters are written, I don't like honestly I
- 13:27don't understand why people. I would hate on Ethan Edwards so
- 13:29much because they love anti-heroes nowadays, right?
- 13:33Like all the like all the Batman's have to be these dark
- 13:36brooding almost evil Heroes and and if we love that like this is
- 13:42just a really early version of an antihero.
- 13:45Yeah, I mean, I don't know if I would go that far.
- 13:47I think he's still. I think it's of just a
- 13:49complicated character and you could call him the protagonist
- 13:51because he's like the main character of the movie.
- 13:54He's definitely not a hero and I don't understand, I think It's
- 13:58too simplistic to read this movie in that way.
- 14:01That to suggest that John Ford didn't know what he was doing
- 14:04here. And in fact, like all
- 14:06indications show that John Ford actually like made the character
- 14:10significantly darker than what was actually in the script and
- 14:14had him doing more explicitly racist things.
- 14:16So that it was so obvious to the audience, what kind of person he
- 14:21was and to take a step back from, you know, dissecting this
- 14:24character I think at the end of the day this is probably John
- 14:27Wayne's best. And he doesn't win an Oscar for
- 14:29this movie. He doesn't win until True Grit
- 14:31in 1969 which is again a more conventional John Wayne type
- 14:35performance. And I think because you have him
- 14:38playing against type here because Ford is drawing out this
- 14:41kind of character that interrogates, the idea of the
- 14:45white man in the west and this sense of the Comanches are
- 14:50corrupting. Our white Heritage is such an
- 14:53interesting character and Wayne actually, I think does a great
- 14:56job in this movie in the first Few scenes, he's playing John
- 15:00Wayne and I'm like, oh God. It's going to be another one of
- 15:02these movies, isn't it? And as the movie goes on, you
- 15:04know, Ford uses these incredible close-ups.
- 15:08And every time he does a close up on John Wayne's face, I've
- 15:12never seen it looking so Haggard, and tired, and rundown,
- 15:17and sad, and it's not the heroic, kind of cocky, you know,
- 15:22Swagger of a normal John Wayne performance.
- 15:25This is a very different type of man, and I think Wayne She does
- 15:28a really good job portraying that.
- 15:30Yeah and and once again I think it's really the performance of
- 15:33Martin pawley that are of Jeffrey Hunter as Martin pawley.
- 15:37That kind of draws out those nuances in his in his character
- 15:43that it is Polly. Who provides someone for Ethan
- 15:50to bounce off of, who is a conscience to show?
- 15:54How deep and how far gone Ethan, Edwards is yep.
- 15:58And hopefully, you know, at the end of the movie, when he
- 16:00doesn't kill his knees. It's hopefully, because he's
- 16:05been watching, you know, Martin's dedication to the cause
- 16:09of saving her. That has also redeemed, Ethan's
- 16:12heart as well. All right, let's talk about
- 16:14Jeffrey Hunter a little bit and I guess I'll just start by
- 16:18saying, I think that John Wayne out acts everyone in this movie
- 16:23by a lot. Yeah.
- 16:25And when John Wayne is your best actor by a lot Um, do you know
- 16:30what I mean? Like I think the simplest way to
- 16:33say it is that everyone else in this movie is acting as if they
- 16:38are in a western that was filmed in 1956.
- 16:41Like there's a certain type of acting that you see in westerns,
- 16:44I don't know how to explain it. I guess you could call it over
- 16:47acting but it never gives the sense of oh this is probably
- 16:52what it was like on the frontier.
- 16:54It's just know. These people are in a western
- 16:56and it's the same kind of acting.
- 16:58In whether it's in a John Ford movie, or whether it's an
- 17:00episode of Gunsmoke on TV, they all act the same and Jeffrey
- 17:04Hunter and Vera Miles and everybody else in this movie
- 17:07acts in that way. And the only person who's doing
- 17:11anything remotely different from that is John Wayne.
- 17:14And I think honestly like maybe that was even intentional by
- 17:16John Ford as another way of demonstrating that this person
- 17:20Ethan is so far out of the norm of what you would see, in a
- 17:23movie like this, and also to demonstrate, he doesn't belong
- 17:27here and that's kind of Like the last image of the movie is like,
- 17:30he doesn't, this, this person is doomed, to never have a home and
- 17:34to be forced to wander and suffer the consequences of like
- 17:38what he's done in life and I kind of wonder if the way that
- 17:41the other actors are acting kind of helps tip that off a little
- 17:47bit because Ethan acts so differently than everyone else.
- 17:50Yeah, he like just has this burdened look to him and and he
- 17:57just Feels weary and like, when I think about the life of a of a
- 18:04Rancher Cowboy, you know, Civil War veteran in the mid and the
- 18:11late 1800s, I think of Ethan Edwards.
- 18:14I don't think of somebody like anybody else I've ever seen in a
- 18:19western because, like you said, there's, there's a specific type
- 18:22of acting that was going on in westerns and the janja's comes
- 18:27in That. And he blows it up.
- 18:29Yeah. Like he just absolutely takes it
- 18:33to another level. And like you said, I feel like
- 18:36when I'm watching Ethan Edwards, I'm watching somebody who was
- 18:40alive in that time period and has has lived in the dust of the
- 18:47desert for decades. It almost seems like it would
- 18:50belong more at home in the kind of spaghetti westerns that you
- 18:54would see a decade later. And that's not to say that those
- 18:56movies are not over-the-top either.
- 18:58But when I think about the good, the bad, the ugly, and the
- 19:01moments in that movie, where Clint Eastwood goes and visits
- 19:04the home of, you know, a farmer and his wife or whatever and how
- 19:07they just look. So beaten down by life and they
- 19:09act so much more, you know, naturalistic I guess.
- 19:13And it also seems to be like one of the few Hollywood
- 19:16performances that allows the main character to get that sort
- 19:20of haggard look about him, similar to what we saw with,
- 19:24with Bogart in Treasure of the Sierra Madre.
- 19:26I think that's another good example of something.
- 19:28Like this. But I said all that to say
- 19:31Jeffrey Hunter not a great actor and also like, it's so obvious
- 19:38when it's put up against what John Wayne is doing here.
- 19:41Yeah, I think that I almost didn't even notice it because I
- 19:46knew I was watching a western. Hmm.
- 19:48And like growing up watching enough westerns you just you
- 19:52know what to expect and you're almost okay with it.
- 19:56Like I don't know. It's like when you watch a
- 19:58cartoon versus watching Game of Thrones like, there's certain
- 20:02tropes that are going to happen in a cartoon that don't happen
- 20:06in a TV show, like, Game of Thrones, they're both television
- 20:08shows but you know, you're okay with one thing because you've
- 20:12grown up watching them and I think that's kind of how I feel
- 20:15about Jeffrey Hunter in this movie.
- 20:17I'm like oh yeah he's great man. He's, he's just kind of a whiny
- 20:21young guy who was trying to do his best in the world and he
- 20:25knows that he's in a western movie and same thing with Vera
- 20:28Miles. Yeah.
- 20:29I mean, before we get to Vera Miles, the Jeffrey Hunter thing
- 20:32for me is very much like watching Mark, Hamill in the
- 20:36first Star Wars, where he's like him.
- 20:39I was gonna go get some power converters, like the think, just
- 20:42the whole movie and I'm just like, oh, that's Jeffrey Hunter.
- 20:45He's just doing that with for the whole new.
- 20:47You want to start the Star Wars fight from season 1 again like
- 20:52we can get into it man. We don't need to talk about the
- 20:54surgeries that he might even saying that like and again, I
- 20:57did. I did kind of think, Mark,
- 20:59Hamill was not great in the first Star Wars movie, but it's
- 21:01more just that like, the whiny little boy, Act only goes so far
- 21:05and in Star Wars after, you know, in like the second and
- 21:07third act like, all right, we're done with that.
- 21:09Now, in this movie, you know, it's like five to seven years
- 21:12later and now he's like a grown man, and he's still doing that
- 21:15whole thing. And I just liked by the two-hour
- 21:18Mark, I was, I was done with Martin pawley.
- 21:22I will say. All right, so you mentioned Vera
- 21:24Miles. Vera Miles is a good actress.
- 21:26This is at least the second movie that we've had her on the
- 21:28podcast. Probably her.
- 21:30Most famous role is in Psycho where she plays, mmm, Janet
- 21:33Leigh's, sister. Alfred Hitchcock was obsessed
- 21:37with Vera Miles. He wanted to make her, like the
- 21:39next big thing. I think she was supposed to be
- 21:41the lead in Vertigo and then she got pregnant and so he couldn't
- 21:45use her in Vertigo is either vertigo or North by Northwest
- 21:48and and then she never really took off after that.
- 21:51And she She, you know, the rumor has always been that.
- 21:53Like once she got pregnant, like Hitchcock wasn't interested in
- 21:55her anymore and just like yeah, you know, you know, the creepy
- 22:00old man being a creepy old man. I think she's fine here.
- 22:03But once again, she's doing the like I don't know if they're
- 22:07just like directing these two people as if to say like you are
- 22:1216 years old, when they're both clearly late 20s or older, but
- 22:17they're acting like 15 year, olds the whole movie.
- 22:19And I think that really just got super Eating and got on my
- 22:22nerves after a while, huh. Yeah, once again, I guess a I
- 22:27was kind of wrapped up in John Wayne's performance and be.
- 22:31It, it just didn't strike me as any different than any other
- 22:35Western I'd seen. Hmm.
- 22:36So it felt like it just fit what the movie was going for as far
- 22:41as as their romance would go. So yeah, I wasn't really
- 22:45bothered by her performance. I thought that she was
- 22:50appropriately. Ridiculously funny, as I would
- 22:54expect her to be in a western sure.
- 22:56Now, on the other hand, if there's somebody in this movie
- 22:59that comes in and just matches, John Wayne, like, tit-for-tat,
- 23:04in this movie, it's Ward Bond. Who is a, John Ford regular and
- 23:10a super unsung underrated actor. I mean, he's been in so many
- 23:15movies, like he popped up in a bit part in Gone With the Wind,
- 23:18he was Burt in, He wasn't Burt, he's in It's a Wonderful Life.
- 23:23He drives the cap and It's a Wonderful Life.
- 23:26Yeah, and births. The cop Bert's the cop.
- 23:28Okay. And Ernie is the cab driver,
- 23:30right? That's where they got Bert and
- 23:31Ernie from for Sesame Street, yes, okay, maybe he is Bert, I
- 23:36don't know whatever, he's in, It's a Wonderful Life.
- 23:39He's at his best in this movie, he is so good in this movie in a
- 23:43very thankless role in a role that really doesn't contribute
- 23:46to much to the the main Central plot of the movie.
- 23:50Except that. That he's a much smarter person
- 23:53than John Wayne gives him credit for playing this, you know, this
- 23:57dual Texas Ranger who is also a pastor and I think Brad that I
- 24:02want to draw attention to one scene in the movie because it's
- 24:04going to become really Central to my analysis on the movie
- 24:08later. And it's the scene at the very
- 24:10beginning where he comes to visit and he happens to look
- 24:16into another room in the homestead and John Wayne's.
- 24:21Brother's wife is in this other room, like holding a piece of
- 24:25his clothing or something and just cradling it and like
- 24:29caressing it. And you can tell that he's not
- 24:32eavesdropping, but he seemed something that he isn't supposed
- 24:34to be seeing and he just kind of very silently processes.
- 24:37This information that he's seeing and he sees Ethan come in
- 24:41the room after him and he doesn't make eye contact with
- 24:43either one of them but you know, Ethan gives her a kiss on the
- 24:45forehead and it's very obvious that Ethan's in love with his
- 24:49brother's wife and she is in love with him.
- 24:52And it's never touched on again, for the rest of the movie.
- 24:54But I actually think that scene is like the driving force behind
- 24:58this whole film, and it only really works because of how good
- 25:03Ward Bond is in that scene. Yeah, he just has this silent
- 25:08intensity and intelligence to the way he watches, what's
- 25:13unfolding in front of him, where it all clicks into place for him
- 25:18and because of that, it clicks into place for the Z because I
- 25:22don't think that there's enough in the other scenes to pick up
- 25:26on these. You know, the wife's love for
- 25:29Ethan and and you know his love for her and yet that little
- 25:34scene like you said it provides the main thrust for why he would
- 25:39be willing to search for her and I believe it at some point, man,
- 25:44I'm trying to remember if it's him or somebody else.
- 25:46I think he goes it's not what Martha would have wanted.
- 25:49Yeah, when he's talking about Debbie being, you know, a
- 25:53Comanche Indian essentially, right?
- 25:55And so that's like his justification for why he would
- 25:58kill her and it like, that's kind of the only call back to
- 26:02it. But it's such a powerful move to
- 26:05move from the first part of the movie of like, oh, like they're
- 26:08in love with each other and they can't be together.
- 26:11Once again, establishing the John Wayne cannot live in this
- 26:14world forever to the end of the movie.
- 26:16Where it's like, this is my reason for killing my niece,
- 26:20which is a brutal. Dark sentiment have in a
- 26:23western, you know, just a little bit.
- 26:26All right, before we go to break Brad, is there anybody else that
- 26:28you want to touch on in the cast?
- 26:30I mean, obviously, we know we've got Natalie Wood, who has been
- 26:33on the show a few times and it just happens to find herself in
- 26:37some of the best movies ever made.
- 26:38Like she's Debbie in this movie for four minutes and just like,
- 26:42all right, check that off the, you know, off the list and here
- 26:45in one of the greatest movies of all time, she doesn't really
- 26:48contribute anything. But our boy John qualen.
- 26:51From Grapes of Wrath shows back up in that van.
- 26:54He's back not as good this time. No, not quite as good.
- 26:58He's doing a voice that I would describe as Swedish Geppetto
- 27:02like he kind of sounds like. Well, my peanut oil Kyoto, but
- 27:05he's doing it with a Swedish accent, 100%.
- 27:08So you know, it feels like he was going, I don't know.
- 27:12I guess you're against any was going for Swedish.
- 27:14I it sounded to me like he was trying for Italian almost yeah,
- 27:17that's what I'm saying. Like it went back and forth
- 27:18between Norway and Italy. It wasn't great.
- 27:24I don't care. I like seeing him.
- 27:26It was great to see him. My favorite character in the
- 27:28movie, by by a country mile. Oh, good expression.
- 27:34Charlie maccorry. Oh yeah.
- 27:36Played by Ken Ken Curtis and Curtis, they like are trying to
- 27:41sell, he's just the worst match for Veer miles that you could
- 27:47ever imagine. And then they were like, you
- 27:49know, we need to give him something.
- 27:51And so he starts playing on his guitar and singing, I think Skip
- 27:55to My Lou and he has like a phenomenal voice but that he
- 28:01starts talking again. And like, if you haven't seen
- 28:04the movie, I'm genuinely not exaggerating when I say it.
- 28:08Just gotta sound like this and he goes Lori, I love you so
- 28:14much. It's just not a voice that a
- 28:17real human would have liked at all.
- 28:21But then he It's singing. And he's got this beautiful like
- 28:23country little to his voice and you're like, oh he's he's 100%
- 28:28just putting this on, it's ridiculous that I I'm here for
- 28:34it 100%. The funny thing is, he has the
- 28:37jawline and that sort of like, really chiseled Look to Him and
- 28:42the same almost the same teeth as John Carradine who we've been
- 28:46talking about with other Ford movies.
- 28:48And I was like that, that's not John Carradine.
- 28:50It'd be so much older by the The time, we got to this movie.
- 28:52Who is that guy? You know, and it's obviously no
- 28:55relation but it's so funny because we had just talked about
- 28:59the Carradine's in last week's episode and then Ken Curtis
- 29:02comes in here and like messed with my mind for a little bit
- 29:04because he looks like he could be related to them.
- 29:08And that's what I think. I love about this movie is that,
- 29:10while it is this kind of dark portrait of a man trying to
- 29:16reckon with who he is. It's also just this really kind
- 29:21of Light-hearted tale about a young man trying to balance out
- 29:27Duty versus love. And the shenanigans that he gets
- 29:31into, you know, Finding himself with a Native American Wife.
- 29:36And, you know, fighting the most ridiculous person ever and
- 29:41Charlie maccorry. And it, it's just light-hearted
- 29:44in the right moments and serious.
- 29:45And most of the film that I, I just like, what Ford was able to
- 29:50do with this, Movie. That's really interesting to me.
- 29:54I'm looking forward to our conversation in the second half
- 29:56of the episode because I have a feeling that the things you
- 29:59really liked about this movie and that helped sell it to you
- 30:02are probably going to be my least favorite parts of this
- 30:05movie. And yet, it sounds like we
- 30:07actually might come out in a similar place when we give our
- 30:09final scores here. So I think we're in for a good
- 30:12conversation here, Brad. Let's hit pause.
- 30:14Now, let's try this Woodford. Reserve, malt, whiskey, what do
- 30:17you say? Let's get to it.
- 30:25Alright, so today we are checking out Woodford.
- 30:27Reserve malt, whisky Kentucky, straight malt whiskey Brad.
- 30:32This is a very interesting whiskey from Woodford, because
- 30:35it's not a single malt. Like it is not made completely
- 30:38from malt, it's only 51% malted barley in the mash bill so it is
- 30:44just barely enough malt to be called a malt. 51% malted barley
- 30:497%, corn, 2% Rye. So this is very close to being a
- 30:53bourbon. If we're talking percentages
- 30:55here, like all of their releases or most of them, at least, it
- 30:58clocks in, at 90.4, proof it is not age stated, but it is listed
- 31:03as a Kentucky, straight malt. So, I'm assuming everything in
- 31:06here is at least two years old, probably older than that, Brad.
- 31:09The reason we're pairing this up today is because we have talked
- 31:12with the master distiller of Woodford.
- 31:14Chris Morris on many occasions. And very recently, we just saw
- 31:18him at the Kentucky bourbon. Evil and we talked about how his
- 31:21favorite movie is the Searchers. So we said, you know, in honor
- 31:25of Chris Morris, let's have some Woodford.
- 31:27And this is the next one. In their lineup that we have not
- 31:30yet. Tried, I'm excited to get into
- 31:32this malt. Yeah.
- 31:33I was in saying, this is a part of their Series where they try
- 31:36to honor each of the original grains that we used here in
- 31:40America to make whiskey. And I've got to say man, this is
- 31:45a beautiful smelling whiskey. I was really Blown Away with the
- 31:49notion Those. So I'm starting to realize that
- 31:52the note of like young grain that I associate with like, a
- 31:57really young bourbon smells a lot like malt because this
- 32:01smells like a really young whiskey to me and I don't know
- 32:04that it necessarily is I mean it's possible that all this is
- 32:06just you know two years and a day old who knows, but I think
- 32:11I'm just picking up a lot of the maltiness but because there's so
- 32:13much corn in the mash bill, this just kind of presents to me as a
- 32:18really, really young. And I can't quite shake that and
- 32:21I think it's because we've never had a malted whiskey where it's
- 32:24like almost equivalent Malta corn ratio.
- 32:28So that's really screwing with my pet, like, not my palate but
- 32:30my nosing here is this? Just smells like a really young
- 32:33bourbon to me. See, I didn't feel like it was a
- 32:37young bourbon at all II. Got a lot of peanuts and caramel
- 32:41on the nose, there was some cherry cordial and then it was
- 32:44almost like a little bit creamy. Almost like a whipping cream and
- 32:49I I thought it was like really decadent the only part of it.
- 32:54It wasn't very it even kind of smelled a little thin like like
- 32:59you can kind of tell when a whiskey is going to have some
- 33:01legs and this didn't have that but honestly I sat with this
- 33:08just smelling it for about 10 minutes and I couldn't stop
- 33:12getting all sorts of like creamy Cherry nutty notes and I really
- 33:16liked it. I I'm going to give the nose a 9
- 33:18out of 10 Wow. All right I'm definitely not
- 33:21there. I am picking up some of the
- 33:23peanuts that you're talking about and for me it almost
- 33:25tastes like when you crack open a fresh canister of Oats, not
- 33:30like oatmeal but just like steel cut oats or something.
- 33:32Like there's this, this very kind of freshly cut grain to
- 33:37this and I think again, I'm trying to distinguish it from
- 33:41being a young bourbon because that's not what this is.
- 33:43But it's definitely grain forward.
- 33:46I think I'm I am. What's the word?
- 33:49Word cautiously optimistic. But I'm just going to give it a
- 33:52six and a half on the nose. Well, in the.
- 33:54And then we got into the taste and Bob, I will say it was
- 33:58pretty disappointing when I got into it.
- 34:02The first note that I wrote down was thin, it is like I don't
- 34:08know if I've ever had a Woodford product, that promised so much
- 34:11and then came across so thin and I was really struggling to get a
- 34:16lot of notes on it. I think I got kind of a cocoa
- 34:18and pepper. Flavors going on.
- 34:21Yeah. But not a ton outside of that.
- 34:24I was struggling with the palette.
- 34:26I'll give it a six out of ten. Yeah, I'm with you it's thin.
- 34:30I thought it did. It had a lot of flavor
- 34:33concentrated into it. The problem is that there's just
- 34:35not many flavors going on. And so for me, it's just kind of
- 34:41like Oak all the way through and Woodford, is for me, at least
- 34:45very Oak forward. In general.
- 34:46Like, their bourbon zoki, their double oaked is obviously very
- 34:49very Aoki. This just kind of tastes like
- 34:51Barrel to me and behind that. There's, there's black pepper,
- 34:56you're right about that. And then there was just like
- 34:59this little wisp on the back of my palate, which I've never
- 35:02gotten on a whiskey before of celery or like a coriander.
- 35:07Like there's just something I like it.
- 35:09Just tasted like I snapped into a fresh stalk of celery.
- 35:13It was really interesting. It almost gave it kind of like a
- 35:16like that vegetal note we get on Rise sometimes and Like that.
- 35:20But there's very little sweetness here for me.
- 35:23There's not a lot of complexity. Again, I don't mind it but I
- 35:27just don't think it's great. I'm going to give it a six and a
- 35:29half on the palate. Yeah.
- 35:30And I think the Finish is about where the the palette was for
- 35:34me, it became very malty, very Oaky, some of that pepper kind
- 35:39of stuck through to the end, it had a little bit of a Kentucky
- 35:43hug to finish things off, but nothing amazing.
- 35:47I think I'll stick it. 6 out of 10 for the Finish.
- 35:49Oh yeah, I think for me the Finish is probably the high
- 35:51point of this. I just took a second Sip and the
- 35:54cocoa is really coming through on the second sip.
- 35:57I like that a lot and its present on the Finish.
- 36:00There's not a ton of Oak left on my pallet their way, the way
- 36:03that it was when I first took a sip and so I think the Finish is
- 36:06nice and mouth-watering. It's not an especially hot
- 36:09whiskey. Like I'm not feeling it going
- 36:10down but that gets back to your note of it being thin earlier.
- 36:15I still think the Finish is probably the best thing here.
- 36:17I'm going to give it a An 8 out of 10 on finish.
- 36:21Yeah. And then on balance I'll give it
- 36:24a six and a half on balance. I think it's disappointing off
- 36:27the nose that I really enjoyed. But overall I think once you get
- 36:32into what you're getting into with this whiskey you kind of
- 36:35know what's happening and it gives you what you expect from
- 36:40the palette on. So yeah, I'll give it a six and
- 36:43a half on the balance. I'm gonna give it a seven.
- 36:45I think this is a pretty good whiskey, it just kind of drinks.
- 36:48Like it's 80 proof or 85 proof rather than 90 proof.
- 36:53And with you on that like there's is just a very thin kind
- 36:56of watery experience. I guess I just don't know Brad
- 37:00like Who's this for? Hmm you know what I mean?
- 37:05And I yeah like this is going to sound like one of the most
- 37:07critical things I've ever said about a whiskey and I don't mean
- 37:10it that way because listeners to this podcast.
- 37:13Know I love Woodford Reserve but like there's really good
- 37:17American single malts out there. There's really good blended
- 37:21Scotch out there there's really good single malt scotch out
- 37:23there that I would recommend to beginners in the world of malted
- 37:27whiskies and I just don't know. Like is this supposed to be a
- 37:31game? Gateway into drinking malt is
- 37:33this just like hey this was a fun thing for us to make, so
- 37:36we're going to keep putting it out.
- 37:37I don't really know who I'm supposed to be recommending this
- 37:40to yeah, I'm with you man. And I think that kind of takes
- 37:44us into our value category. You know, this is this is priced
- 37:47with all of their Baseline offerings.
- 37:49It's 36 dollars in the state of Ohio.
- 37:52And I think you can get that pretty readily across the
- 37:54country. I don't know like a 5 and a half
- 37:58for Value because I'm with you that there's a There's the
- 38:02reality that I just don't know who would want to pay $35 for
- 38:07this. Because I think there's a lot of
- 38:10other options out there in this price range.
- 38:13That might just give you a better experience with malt.
- 38:16I agree, I don't see. This is the hard thing is like,
- 38:20what are we comparing it to, to know that?
- 38:21It's a bad value, where we comparing it to woodford's,
- 38:24Bourbon because this is markedly worse than their bourbon rate.
- 38:30Are we comparing It to a blended whiskey.
- 38:33That's $35 like a monkey shoulder because I think this is
- 38:36probably like about as good as monkey shoulder, but I probably
- 38:39still PicMonkey shoulder. I mean, it has a monkey on the
- 38:43bottom. That's true.
- 38:44This has no monkeys. So Point points off for no
- 38:47monkeys. Yeah, I guess that's what my big
- 38:50struggle is. Like, it's hard to find a value
- 38:51on this. I don't think 36. 35 dollars is
- 38:54really overpriced but I just don't really know what's the
- 38:57comparison Point here. So I'm going to give it a six
- 39:00out of ten on value. That brings me out to a 34 out
- 39:03of 50 Bobby. I'm sitting at a thirty two
- 39:06point five out of 50. Oh wow, okay.
- 39:09All right. So that brings us to a 66 and a
- 39:11half out of 100 or a thirty. Three point two five out of 50
- 39:16which is kind of one of our lower ones this season Brad.
- 39:20And here's the thing, I don't think this is a bad whiskey.
- 39:23Hmm. I don't even know that I would
- 39:24call this a mediocre whiskey. Like it's it's not bad but yeah,
- 39:29I don't know that there's anything here for me to be like
- 39:31Yes, go buy a bottle or even yes, drop eight to nine dollars
- 39:36on a poor of this at a bar, right?
- 39:39Like it's good if someone has it at their house, like it's
- 39:41certainly worth drinking, but among Woodford products.
- 39:45This is probably one of my least favorites.
- 39:48Yeah. I mean if you have a group of
- 39:49people that you're, you know, drinking whiskey with and, you
- 39:52know, five people want to go in on a bottle, go for it.
- 39:56Like yeah. It's worth spending a few bucks,
- 39:58have a few pores but overall, I think I'm Man, I don't know if I
- 40:02can recommend at the bar or, you know, in your house.
- 40:06All right. Well, that is been Woodford.
- 40:09Malted whiskey, Brad. Let's get back into talking
- 40:12about the Searchers, what do you say?
- 40:13Yeah, I'm super pumped man. Let's get back to it.
- 40:19All right, everybody that was Woodford, Reserve.
- 40:22Kentucky straight malt whiskey whiskey, that Bob and I were
- 40:27decent on, that's okay, yeah, it was fun.
- 40:33You know what we are more than fine with Bob, is it to fax in a
- 40:37falsehood, it's two facts enough also this is like, really,
- 40:43really quickly. Turning into my favorite
- 40:45segments of our podcast, like a blast.
- 40:47It's fun. It's fun to do.
- 40:49It gives some some interesting facts, it creates a little bit
- 40:52of competition which, you know, we're Americans.
- 40:55So we're suckers for that. It's a good time man.
- 40:59So for those of you who don't know, this is the part of the
- 41:01podcast, where Brad will present three things to me all of them.
- 41:05As fact, when in reality, one of them is a complete lie.
- 41:08And I have to guess which one is the LIE.
- 41:11Brad has been getting better and better at writing these and so
- 41:13it's been getting very hard but I'm well over 500 now I think
- 41:17Brad I think I'm like a and six are the year.
- 41:20Does that sound right believe? So yeah you've been on a run for
- 41:23a while here well that ends soon my friend.
- 41:25I know I know you well enough and I didn't do a whole lot of
- 41:29research on the making of this movie.
- 41:31So this might be the day you get me Brad but hit me with your two
- 41:35facts and a falsehood. Well, I will say this is a
- 41:38little bit of a Scramble for me because one of my facts had been
- 41:42that David lean washes as inspiration for Lawrence of
- 41:46Arabia and I almost kept that to myself and just say so There may
- 41:50or may not be a portion of the first half of the episode where
- 41:53I'm not listening to you. And instead looking up another
- 41:57one to right? Do you just do just want to let
- 42:01me do a 50-50 coin. Flip on the two remaining things
- 42:04I don't. I'm so mad at myself.
- 42:08I mean, if you were like one and 12 right now than sure, yeah,
- 42:12I'd give it to you, but here's the this competition Bob, here's
- 42:14the thing that thing about David lean came directly off of the
- 42:17Searchers Wikipedia page, Age and I was like, no bread.
- 42:21Does more than just read the Wikipedia page?
- 42:23I could probably get away with saying this David lean thing.
- 42:26Yeah, sure. Of course.
- 42:30All right, Bob fax number one John, Wayne a decently famous
- 42:36actor. He loved the role of Ethan
- 42:38Edwards so much that he ended up naming his youngest son.
- 42:42Ethan. Yeah.
- 42:43And I managed to the role that yikes, you know, that's a big
- 42:46No-No. Fact.
- 42:49Number two, and Baxter was originally cast to play Lori
- 42:54jørgensen. However, she took the role of
- 42:56nefertari in a little old movie, nobody's problem.
- 43:00Only heard of called The Ten Commandments which led to Vera
- 43:03Miles being cast in the role. Instead fact number three Lena
- 43:07would played young Debbie Edwards and Natalie Wood?
- 43:11Her older sister played Teenage W Edwards.
- 43:17Should I scan the Wikipedia page?
- 43:19Very quickly is what I should. Yeah.
- 43:22Cheating. Cheating is the answer, Bob
- 43:24shootings, always the answer. I think three is true.
- 43:28I mean, I, I'm pretty sure the actress's name was Lana wood.
- 43:31So I'm going to assume that was Natalie, Wood, sister and
- 43:35Baxter. Seems like she would be too old
- 43:37for this role but John Ford has demonstrated that he doesn't
- 43:41care how old you are. You can still play a teenager
- 43:44But you know, and Baxter very famous for All About Eve and she
- 43:48was clearly in her mid to late 20s then and it we're talking
- 43:52six years after that. Now I just feel like she was
- 43:55probably too old for this movie. The John Wayne thing I'm staying
- 44:01away from because it seems like a stupid idea to name your kid
- 44:05after your most racist character.
- 44:08However, I mean who's to say, it's John Wayne, right?
- 44:11So I'm going to say twos the falsehood But I wouldn't and
- 44:16Baxter. Yes, I won't be surprised if
- 44:19one's the falsehood, but I'm going to say to Bob, you are
- 44:24nail on the head. Correct.
- 44:26All right, and Baxter, I looked it up because I wanted to check
- 44:31the age difference to make sure that they weren't, you know, too
- 44:34far off. Do you want to know how much
- 44:36older and Baxter is than Vera Miles?
- 44:39How old was Vera Miles? Well, I'm sorry.
- 44:42I'm not sure how little they were with.
- 44:43They were in this. She's six years older than that
- 44:47beer - wow. And you too.
- 44:49You literally just said, you're like yeah, she's probably about
- 44:52six years, too old for this role.
- 44:55Well yeah, you nailed it, man. I got it.
- 44:57All right. Cool, Anne was born in 23 and
- 45:01Vera was born in 29. All right.
- 45:02Well, there you go, ma'am. I'm having a good year so far a
- 45:06good season. It dude.
- 45:08All right, Brad. Well from the the highest highs.
- 45:11Dive immediately into the racist.
- 45:13Undertones of this film is nose dive right into that.
- 45:18Honestly, I'm weirdly excited for this conversation because
- 45:22I've had so many questions about media and their depiction of
- 45:29things that are like taboo and like the question that I guess
- 45:34I'll use to frame this conversation and maybe this is
- 45:38more towards modern media, but I think you can apply it towards
- 45:40older. Films as well at what point is
- 45:44the parody of something bad. Not bad, because it's a parody.
- 45:50Hmmm. Does that make sense?
- 45:53Yeah, like, I feel and, you know, I'm going to use political
- 45:56terms here, and I hope people don't get too much into an
- 46:01uproar about it, but like, I feel like when I watch more
- 46:05left-leaning, things like Saturday Night Live, it feels
- 46:10like they will often parody somebody who is racist or
- 46:14somebody who, you know, they don't like.
- 46:17But they'll We'll have those characters do really bad evil
- 46:20racist things but it's funny because we're making fun of it
- 46:23but I'm like at what point and and I just brought up Saturday
- 46:27Night Live the right does the same things.
- 46:29I'm not trying to like, you know, cast stones here.
- 46:32And what I'm trying to point out is like, at what point is
- 46:36portraying racism, just bad and at what point is it helpful
- 46:42because we go, oh yeah, we all know that, that's bad and it's
- 46:46good for young. Generations to see it so they
- 46:49can see how bad it is and not do it themselves like that.
- 46:52It's does that make sense? It's really funny that you
- 46:54brought up Saturday Night Live because I was thinking about a
- 46:56similar show, 30 Rock, which I think is a hilarious show.
- 46:59I love 31 and in the first season of 30 Rock the character
- 47:04that's played by Jane Krakowski. Yep.
- 47:07As a flashback and you find out that that this very white, very
- 47:12blond woman is actually of Native American ancestry and
- 47:16that your parents did It approve of her dream to be an actress
- 47:19and they kicked her off the reservation.
- 47:21And I think to get back to what you're asking.
- 47:24The reason that I think that scene works.
- 47:27And the funny thing about it is, I've seen people poopoo that
- 47:30seen as like, this is racist. Why would you, why would you
- 47:34even portray this? The reason that scene works is
- 47:36because the Native Americans are not the butt of the joke in that
- 47:40scene, like the the whole joke is she's a white person and
- 47:45we're trying to portray. We're trying to play this off.
- 47:47To you that it that it would even be plausible that she's a
- 47:51Native American. And I think the fact that Native
- 47:56Americans are in on the joke but not the butt of the joke.
- 47:59I think plays a big role in it and so I kind of want to use
- 48:02that as my framing device to talk about the racism in and of
- 48:06this movie because I don't have a problem with anything.
- 48:10John Wayne's character is saying, you know, in terms of
- 48:13like he's very clearly racist, he's very clearly wrong.
- 48:16He's very clearly Blinded by hatred and the movie does a very
- 48:20good job of portraying that and like there's there's really no
- 48:24ambiguity there. And so anyone who has a problem
- 48:27with that I think is just not watching the movie close enough.
- 48:30I think there is a legitimate conversation to be had though
- 48:33about the way that John Ford kind of muddies up the waters a
- 48:36little bit because it seems at times like he's trying to make a
- 48:39statement about this, this violently racist person, but
- 48:43then he throws in kind of like a slapstick humor scene.
- 48:47Where this imbecile Moe's is pretending to be a Native
- 48:52American and using all the most offensive stereotypes to do
- 48:55that. And the, the joke in that scene,
- 48:58is an even like, hey, Moses, dumb, the joke in that scene is
- 49:02like, isn't it funny that he's doing these things?
- 49:05And I think that's part of where if you're going to talk about
- 49:09things that have not held up. Well from this movie, it's those
- 49:12kind of things where it's like John Ford seems to almost be
- 49:16undermining the argument. He's trying to make by including
- 49:18those things. I don't know.
- 49:19Does that make sense? It does and I'm curious how you
- 49:23feel about the miscommunication scene because I feel like which
- 49:29one which one is this when when Martin shali is trading for
- 49:35some, you know, a blanket and some Goods.
- 49:38Oh yeah. You know, he doesn't realize
- 49:40that he's actually trading for a wife and I'm kind of curious
- 49:44because there's part of me, that's like there's a lot like
- 49:47it all. Feels like a Trope that when,
- 49:49you know, when white people meet a foreign or a native tribe of
- 49:56some sorts, it's like, oh yeah, they're they're not able to
- 49:59communicate and they miss communicate and they trade the
- 50:01wrong things. So it doesn't feel like it's
- 50:04outside the realm of the miscommunication between races,
- 50:08you know, Trope but it doesn't. It just didn't fit super well.
- 50:15No, it didn't and There's so many directions, we can go here.
- 50:19But one thing that I really love is something that Roger Ebert
- 50:21wrote about this movie, and he basically said that, like the
- 50:24Fatal flaw of this movie, is that it's trying to be two
- 50:27movies in one and it's trying to be this really serious and dark
- 50:32and kind of like soul-searching movie when it's about John
- 50:36Wayne's character. And then it's trying to be like
- 50:39this sort of over-the-top broad comedy.
- 50:42Every time we returned to the home front and that it just the
- 50:46The Clash of those two. Owns doesn't really work and
- 50:50this is something that I wanted to talk to you about because it
- 50:52sounds like from your point of view that actually really made
- 50:55the movie work for you. But I think for me, it almost
- 51:00serves to undermine the point of the movie and a scene, like what
- 51:03you're talking about I think is a perfect illustration of that.
- 51:06Where it becomes like slapstick, it's like that slapstick.
- 51:10It's okay to have little moments like that, but it just seems to
- 51:15upend what towards trying to get at in so many other parts of the
- 51:19movie. Well, I think that the issue
- 51:22with, you know, specifically the, I'll just keep calling it
- 51:25the miscommunication trading sequence, the issue with it,
- 51:30isn't that the miscommunication happens, it's the way that that
- 51:34Martin pawley responds to it and how like you said earlier, how
- 51:39childish he is. He, you know, she like, lays
- 51:42down next to him, not, not even in a sexual way.
- 51:46Like she just lays down next to Her now husband and he takes
- 51:50both feet rears back in like, kicks her down this hill and you
- 51:56know, John Wayne is laughing about it and Martin's telling
- 51:59him to shut up like like it's not funny and and it's just not
- 52:04funny. None of it's funny but I think
- 52:06that that scene could have worked, you know, I think that
- 52:10if there's The Accidental communication John Wayne pokes
- 52:13out a little bit but then they just get on with the seriousness
- 52:16of their hunt. And, you know, she helps them
- 52:19with their hunt. I think that there could have
- 52:21been a meaningful interaction there of like, you know, Ethan
- 52:25realizing like, you know, maybe maybe I'm not as as right about
- 52:30these Native Americans, as I thought I was, and there could
- 52:34have been a meaningful relationship there and her death
- 52:37could have felt more powerful and I'm like that, it just felt
- 52:40like there's a missed opportunity with her character
- 52:43to make some slapstick comedy jokes.
- 52:45Yeah. No, I totally agree.
- 52:47N, I don't know, this is I guess what I'll do now, if it's okay
- 52:51with you is I want to present what I think is actually the
- 52:54better way of reading this movie and the racism obviously is
- 52:58there and it's a lens through which to read this movie.
- 53:01But if I can give a preview of my pick for, let's make it a
- 53:05double, we've been doing this thing every week where we pick a
- 53:08movie to serve as a double feature for the movie that we've
- 53:11just seen and Brad. If I had to pick a movie to line
- 53:15up with this movie, it would be one that we just recently.
- 53:17Currently watched and it would be Raging Bull and it's because
- 53:21of what is driving both of the main characters in these movies.
- 53:25And it wasn't until I really started reading through this
- 53:28little book from the British Film Institute about the
- 53:31Searchers written by the author. Edward bus comb and he talks
- 53:34about how the best way to look at this movie is through the
- 53:37sexual lens and how that key scene with John Wayne like
- 53:43longing and lusting. After his, brother's wife is the
- 53:46key to this. Movie that he has internalized
- 53:50his own kind of self-hatred for doing this to his brother and
- 53:54then he gets his brother and his brother's wife killed in his own
- 53:58eyes and he internalizes that even further.
- 54:01And it's very similar to what we saw with Jake LaMotta in Raging
- 54:04Bull where he has this outward hatred and pushes everyone away.
- 54:09But it's because of his own kind of impotence and, you know, like
- 54:14sexual impotence but also inability to Relate to other
- 54:18people and that he gets to the point where he's almost like
- 54:20calling down divine retribution on himself and the way Busco and
- 54:25reads this movie is that John Wayne's character is motivated
- 54:30mostly by revenge for what this, you know, this Chief did to the
- 54:36long-lost love of his life. But he points out that those two
- 54:40characters Scar and Ethan are basically mirror images of each
- 54:43other that they're, they're equally brutal towards the In
- 54:48that they know how to, you know, psychologically damaged their
- 54:53enemy. And it gets to the point where
- 54:56he wants to kill Natalie Woods character because he sees her as
- 55:00being corrupted, by the the Native Americans because he
- 55:03assumes that she's been raped or they've had sex with her in some
- 55:06way. And he has this almost like
- 55:09Travis Bickle, kind of view of like, he's like, sexually messed
- 55:14up from lusting after his brother's wife.
- 55:17And because of that like he takes that his own self hatred
- 55:20out on the Indians, the Native Americans and saying like oh
- 55:23like they're corrupting our white women that way and the
- 55:27more I thought about this interpretation the movie the
- 55:29more I'm like, oh I actually think this is the best way to
- 55:31read this character. That his own inner self conflict
- 55:35and self-loathing is what is motivating his Psychopathic
- 55:39violence toward them. You know, there's a great
- 55:41chapter in this book where he talks about that scene, where
- 55:44John Wayne goes off and just like massacres a Native
- 55:47Americans. And you they just never talk
- 55:49about it again. But you can only imagine like
- 55:52what he did to all of them. And he reads the ending of this
- 55:56movie where John Wayne rides into this little village finds
- 56:00scar dead and scalps. Him as sort of like this is John
- 56:05Wayne's, final Act of Revenge. He did something like to violate
- 56:09this man's body that he saw as being equivalent to what this
- 56:14guy did to the love of his life. And because of that, his his
- 56:19bloodlust is, I don't know satiated and that's what allows
- 56:22him to go back to Natalie Wood at the end of the movie and not
- 56:25want to kill her anymore because he you know, his need for
- 56:29vengeance has been met and I'm like, okay I get it now.
- 56:33Like I actually think that really put this movie in
- 56:36perspective for me is holding it up in a very similar light to
- 56:39what we saw from somebody like Jake LaMotta in Raging Bull.
- 56:43Well and it also for me Illustrated the negative end
- 56:51place that you come to in a when you in a search for vengeance
- 56:55and it's easy for us, you know, in 2022 to look back and cast
- 57:01blame and say, who is wrong and do all these things.
- 57:03But in the end, what you have is two different civilizations,
- 57:08doing really brutal, horrific things to one another and this
- 57:12movie straights like to what end like at what point is enough
- 57:18enough is ook scars, dead and scalped.
- 57:22Okay, now we're done, but do we really think it's done?
- 57:26Do we really think that Ethan isn't going to find some other
- 57:30Grudge to hold against someone else?
- 57:33Like this might be a weird comparison.
- 57:35But like, when I think about a person like Michael Jordan, he
- 57:39is, you know, revered for his Competitive Edge that he Find
- 57:44absolutely anything to be hateful towards others about and
- 57:49use that to beat them on the court.
- 57:51Well, what happens when you have a human being like that?
- 57:54Who doesn't live in a civilized era where we compete on a
- 57:58basketball court? What happens when it happens in
- 58:00the late 1800s and the man has a gun and just insatiable desire
- 58:07for vengeance. Well you see what happens here
- 58:11and so I think that's for me kind of the Reputation of the
- 58:14movie that that, I walked away with was like, like, why is
- 58:20violence the answer to Violent? Like where does the cycle end
- 58:23kind of a weird? Yes, where does the cycle end?
- 58:26And, you know, for Ford in this movie, it ends when he scalps
- 58:29him, but I left the movie watching, you know, the door
- 58:33closed on, on Ethan, Edwards just wondering who's his next
- 58:39victim. Mmm.
- 58:40Yeah. And I think, honestly, watching
- 58:42through raging Really helped me appreciate this movie more,
- 58:46because we both set it on the Raging Bull episode that like
- 58:49the final 30 minutes of Raging Bull more than makes up for any
- 58:52flaws in the earlier, part of the movie and I really felt like
- 58:55that same thing here. I felt like the deeper that he
- 58:59goes into his vengefulness and his inability to be pulled out
- 59:03of it. It's really just hurting
- 59:05himself, I mean, in addition to other people, but he becomes an
- 59:08almost unrest, curable figure. And even though he returns
- 59:13Debbie, To her home. At the end of the movie, it's
- 59:16very clear that like he has made his bed.
- 59:18He believes that he needs to lie in it that he it's almost like
- 59:23he feels like he needs to be punished for what he's done and
- 59:25for what he's believed. And for the secrets that he's
- 59:28been keeping in his heart, this whole time and that because of
- 59:30that, he doesn't have a home, he can't be invited into the home
- 59:33at the end of the movie. And I just, I really loved this
- 59:37guy Edward bus comb and his interpretation of the movie
- 59:40because he sees so much Parallel between Scar and Ethan that when
- 59:46Ethan looks across its car and he wonders like did he rape the
- 59:50love of my life? He's angry at scar beak and he
- 59:55wants to kill scar because he sees scars like an extension of
- 59:57himself like he raped my brother's wife.
- 1:00:03Well I wanted to have sex with my brother's wife and so he
- 1:00:05actually carried out the action that I hate myself for wanting
- 1:00:09to carry out. And so like when he goes to kill
- 1:00:11scar when he cuts his scalp off at the The end of the movie.
- 1:00:14It's like his almost like his way of exercising that demon
- 1:00:17from himself. And I actually think like, I
- 1:00:20don't know, man. I really love to hear your take
- 1:00:22on this because I didn't really think about it in these terms
- 1:00:25until just earlier this evening. And I'm just kind of working it
- 1:00:27out here on are. Yeah, I mean I I think that our
- 1:00:32culture has slowly come to believe that the sexual impulse
- 1:00:38is the key impulse to the human existence and Personally, I just
- 1:00:44disagree with that, I don't think that that is the core
- 1:00:50impetus for why we live as humans.
- 1:00:53Think there's some other stuff going on, but it's movies like
- 1:00:56this that represent the cultures shift towards that because I
- 1:01:00think you're 100% right. I think what Ford is trying to
- 1:01:02portray here is like that Wayne had or you know, Ethan has this
- 1:01:07Forbidden Love and he's not allowed to act out on it but the
- 1:01:12key is if he Is violent enough. He could have acted out on it
- 1:01:17and if he was more like scar, he could have gotten what he wanted
- 1:01:21to and he hates that in himself and he hates that scar.
- 1:01:25Got to do what he wanted to do, because he was more violent than
- 1:01:28Ethan was and he wasn't Bound by propriety.
- 1:01:32And so for the rest of the movie, Ethan is not bound by
- 1:01:35propriety anymore. He's chosen the, he's chosen the
- 1:01:38path of violence. All right, man.
- 1:01:42Well, we got really deep on this and I think for good reason,
- 1:01:45this is a really good movie. I don't think everything works.
- 1:01:48And I, you know, we haven't even really talked about the fact
- 1:01:51that John, Ford hired, a German guy to play his main bad guy in
- 1:01:55scar who very obviously does not look Native American when whole
- 1:02:01very obviously chose a name, you know, and he chose a part of the
- 1:02:06Navajo tribe to play the rest of the Native Americans in this.
- 1:02:10Just does not look Native American at all which is like, I
- 1:02:14feel like we could we could talk about that for a half-hour.
- 1:02:16And itself is like, well, is it a good thing that he chose a
- 1:02:20non-native, American, to be the evil Native American?
- 1:02:24Yeah. Or is it even more insulting?
- 1:02:27Like I don't even, I don't know. I feel like you could look at it
- 1:02:29both ways, like our actors aren't good enough.
- 1:02:32Yeah. In evil.
- 1:02:34But then it's like, what would you want to be portrayed that
- 1:02:36way? So I don't know, but like I'm
- 1:02:39saying there's a lot of flaws. With this movie, but I think
- 1:02:42what it's setting out to Do It. Ultimately accomplishes.
- 1:02:45I am much higher on this movie than I thought.
- 1:02:47I would be even like 2/3 into watching it.
- 1:02:50I'm going to come out to an eight and a half on this film.
- 1:02:53Bob you never let me do my make it a dub.
- 1:02:55Oh yeah. What would your bb?
- 1:02:58I think that my double feature mostly based on the plot but
- 1:03:02also based on the tortured main character Gone Baby Gone.
- 1:03:09Oh, nice. Wow.
- 1:03:10That would be a heavy back to back, geez, man.
- 1:03:14I literally almost changed it because I was like, that might
- 1:03:18be the most brutal four to five hours you would ever spend
- 1:03:22watching movies. What a Greta?
- 1:03:24How good is gone. Baby gone, dude, it's so good.
- 1:03:28I've never gonna watch it again. It's that good.
- 1:03:33I just except when you fire it up right after the Searchers
- 1:03:37apparently. Oh, man.
- 1:03:39Yeah, it's so good. So catch it, you were bringing
- 1:03:42up Raging Bull earlier can I just say that that final scene
- 1:03:46with Pesci and De Niro might be the saddest seen in any movie
- 1:03:52we've ever watched weather like in the parking garage together.
- 1:03:55Yeah. Oh yeah.
- 1:03:57It's go. Yeah, just brutal.
- 1:04:02Well folks, we hope you've enjoyed today's installment of
- 1:04:04filming this key. Brad.
- 1:04:06What would you give this movie out of 10?
- 1:04:08I'm going to give it a 9 out of 10 Bob?
- 1:04:09Yeah. Yeah, I think it is truly one of
- 1:04:12the greatest westerns ever made and I'm just a huge fan of this
- 1:04:17movie. Alright so we are coming out to
- 1:04:20an average of an eight point seven five out of ten but we'd
- 1:04:23like to know what you think. So, please reach out to us on
- 1:04:26social media, you can find us on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and
- 1:04:29new Leon Tick-Tock at film whiskey.
- 1:04:32Or if you want, you can jump onto our Discord.
- 1:04:36Discord is a really cool place. It's kind of like a private
- 1:04:39social media. Our only the people you want to
- 1:04:41talk to her on there, and we just have a blast, talking about
- 1:04:45movies and whiskey, and all sorts of other things.
- 1:04:49So if you want to join the conversation, go to the end of
- 1:04:52any of our show notes and you can find a link to our Discord
- 1:04:54there. Next week, we'll be wrapping up
- 1:04:57our John Ford miniseries with a much lighter movie than the
- 1:05:01Searchers. It's 1952, s The Quiet, Man.
- 1:05:05So we'll see you for that one next week, but until then, I'm
- 1:05:08Bob book, I'm Reggie. She and we'll see you next time.