Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / NCUA’s Deregulation Wave Hits Loan Participation: What the Change Means for Your Credit Union
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker: Hey everyone, this is Mark TriCal with another
- 0:01episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03NCUA is in a deregulatory mode.
- 0:07I've done a couple podcasts relative to some of the earlier deregulations.
- 0:12They've been coming out and they've been coming out in waves.
- 0:15I they just came out with seven or eight and the one I'm gonna talk about.
- 0:18Wave seven or eight.
- 0:19That is, and the one I'm gonna talk about here today is going to be the
- 0:23most recent one that came out went into the Federal Register on March 25th.
- 0:27And it has to do with taking the guardrails off on participation loans or
- 0:32the regulation that creates guardrails.
- 0:34And that's why this podcast is called When the Guardrails come off.
- 0:38So again, it relates to indirect vehicle loans.
- 0:41I'm gonna touch on whether or not Inwe still has the tools that it
- 0:44needs when this regulation comes off.
- 0:45And by the way, I'm going to refer to this rule as a rule.
- 0:49It's actually a proposed rule, but when you only have one board member
- 0:53and that board member proposes a rule, odds are eventually it'll go final.
- 0:56Although with the caveat of does, can one board member act when will there
- 1:01be a replacement to that board member?
- 1:03And I'm hearing some rumblings that there could be a change
- 1:05soon at the NCA board level.
- 1:08Stay tuned for that.
- 1:09When that does happen, I'll also have a podcast relative to that.
- 1:12So again if you want to comment on this proposal which in
- 1:16general I'll steal the lead.
- 1:18I think it's a good proposal.
- 1:19It's a better one than some of the past ones, which I've framed as changing.
- 1:23Happy to glad.
- 1:24And there's a little bit of happy to glad here, but I think it does
- 1:27do some real deregulation here.
- 1:29So NCOA has had a rule it's been in place on participation loans for 20 years.
- 1:35They put that rule in place in 2020, excuse me, in 2006.
- 1:40And of course it is 2026.
- 1:42Easy math, 20 years.
- 1:45So what the rule said when it was put in place in 2006, indirect lending
- 1:50at the time was growing very fast.
- 1:52In the mid two thousands, credit unions were partnering with auto dealers and
- 1:56bringing in third party servicers.
- 1:58Often at that juncture without adequate due diligence or with
- 2:02the controls in place to manage the related concentration risk.
- 2:06So NCO a's concern at the time is that institutions were walking into
- 2:09these programs without fully actually understanding what was going on.
- 2:13So it made bright line caps.
- 2:16What were the bright line caps?
- 2:18The bright line cap was a 50% of net worth limit for the first 30 months
- 2:22of a program and a hundred percent of net worth limit after the 30 months.
- 2:28And a waiver from the regional director was required if you wanted to go above.
- 2:33A hundred percent.
- 2:34This applied to both federal credit unions and federally insured state
- 2:38charters from different regs.
- 2:40NCS was 7 0 1 2 1 H for the feds and for the states.
- 2:43It was linked to 7 41 0.203
- 2:46C.
- 2:47The rule was simple, but it was blunt, and it worked as a trip wire.
- 2:51And NCA by the way as most likely NCA for commercial loans,
- 2:55they used to do waivers, right?
- 2:56If you wanted to go over 80% LTV, you had to write the regional director.
- 3:00And they've got, they got away from requesting waivers there.
- 3:05They used to have waivers for fixed assets.
- 3:07If you wanted to go over 5%, that got away from creating waivers and
- 3:11bright line caps and went to more principled based principles based.
- 3:17Okay, principles based regulations.
- 3:22So what is NCA proposing now?
- 3:24So what it's planning on doing, again, proposing to do, is deleting
- 3:29the, that entire framework, it's going to remove 7 0 1 2.
- 3:34H for federal credit unions, and it's going to remove 7 41 0.203
- 3:40for federally insured state chartered credit unions.
- 3:43The waiver process will be gone similarly to how they got rid of other
- 3:47waiver processes and, the appeals provision of course, you can't appeal
- 3:52these things if the rules go away, so they'll clean that up, right?
- 3:55So what will replace it?
- 3:56The board of directors will set its own policies, similar to,
- 4:00again the comparison of LTVs.
- 4:02If you want to do a commercial LTV of 90%, you just have to
- 4:06explain why it makes sense.
- 4:07How much of you'll do, et cetera, et cetera.
- 4:09Here will be the same.
- 4:10If you wanna do more than a hundred percent concentration
- 4:13risk, you'll just have to ex.
- 4:15Explain it based on your credit union size, complexity, and risk profile.
- 4:19So again, pr, so the justification is it's principle-based supervision.
- 4:23It replaces the bright line with exam-based judgments calibrated to
- 4:27each credit union, it reduces the regulatory burden in theory board the
- 4:31boards know their credit unions best governance is what they need to do.
- 4:35We don't need to prescribe.
- 4:36NCA does not need to prescribe what you need to do, and it's
- 4:39being driven by President Trump's.
- 4:42Executive order 1 4 1 9 2, which creates a 10 to one deregulation
- 4:47mandate to eliminate costs of 10 rules for every new one that is proposed.
- 4:53Part two, the tools that remain and why they're more powerful than
- 4:57than what this reg created anyway.
- 4:59So this is where you get into the happy to glad.
- 5:02It's bigger and better than happy to glad because this is a rule that
- 5:06really doesn't need to exist because they have other ways currently have
- 5:10already taken care of that there.
- 5:12They're said another way.
- 5:14NCAA's best tool was never that bright line cap.
- 5:17What's the best tool?
- 5:18It's NCAA's concentration risk letter to credit unions, which
- 5:21is current active a guidance, which is current active guidance.
- 5:25Okay.
- 5:25But in that guidance, it talks about board approved limits.
- 5:29You need to create specific concentration limits tied to net worth by policy, not
- 5:33by regulatory default risk rating systems.
- 5:36Quantified documented frameworks for assessing individual.
- 5:40And aggregate exposure.
- 5:41And we see a lot of this coming up, by the way, concentration
- 5:45risk and what's your risk?
- 5:46Appetite?
- 5:46Seeing a lot of that in our conversations with credit unions scenario and
- 5:50sensitivity analysis, you need to do stress testing on concentration
- 5:54positions under adverse conditions.
- 5:56So again the bright line goes away, but you still need to do all
- 6:00these things as it relates to the.
- 6:02Co concentration risk letter.
- 6:04It talks about data warehousing creating an infrastructure to track migration,
- 6:08vintage analysis and servicer performance.
- 6:11Regular board reporting, periodic reporting on the individual and aggregate
- 6:15exposures, not just annual reviews.
- 6:17By the way, we have a great podcast on what should be in
- 6:20the perfect credit union annual.
- 6:22Monthly report, and again, perfect.
- 6:25From an NCOA perspective.
- 6:26Of course, there's what the CEO wants in the report.
- 6:28There's what the board thinks they want, and there's what NCOA thinks they want.
- 6:31And sometime, sometimes board reporting can get quite cumbersome because
- 6:35every time you layer something on the report gets longer and again,
- 6:39the board members are, unless you're in a state charter, that allows.
- 6:43In a state that allows boards to be paid, the boards tend to be volunteers
- 6:48and you can overwhelm them, but board reporting is required on concentration,
- 6:53risks, et cetera, et cetera.
- 6:54The a hundred percent threshold concentrations exceeding a hundred
- 6:57percent of net worth require documented board rationale.
- 7:01So it's there in the concentration risk letter but they're
- 7:03getting rid of the regulation.
- 7:04Maybe they'll tweak the concentration risk letter.
- 7:07Although it's been my argument that they have some really good old
- 7:10ladder that they don't wanna touch.
- 7:12And the reason they don't wanna touch is that if they touch
- 7:15them, it gets fingers on it.
- 7:16And you can, it is kinda like going to Congress and you wanna get, the
- 7:20back when the Federal Credit Union Act was changed to resolve the field of
- 7:25membership issue in order to get the field of membership issue resolved the
- 7:29member business loan cap came in because banks were successful in lobbying that.
- 7:34So same holds true if you at NCOA, if a staff member wants to get a
- 7:38letter to credit unions changed.
- 7:40They risk it actually going away, right?
- 7:42That you bring it up to an NCA board member and say, Hey,
- 7:44we need to tweak this letter.
- 7:45They go, what letter?
- 7:46I didn't even know we had that letter.
- 7:47Let's get rid of it.
- 7:48Or they'll say, that's great, but we're gonna water it down so you can
- 7:51end up losing ground from a safety and soundness perspective as a regulator.
- 7:55But again, this is a pretty good letter.
- 7:57And I think it is one they maybe over rely on some instances or don't
- 8:02necessarily ha have enough consistency on.
- 8:05But the principles created by the concentration risk letter
- 8:09generally work quite well.
- 8:12And then there's always, the catchall safety and soundness authority, which
- 8:15is more powerful than a fixed cap.
- 8:17A lot of times when I'm having conversations with credit unions,
- 8:20they'll say this is the regulation they referred to, and I could look at it
- 8:23and glance at it and go, yeah, that's their general safety and soundness.
- 8:27Authority regulation, which is what they have to link things to now because
- 8:31they've been under a mandate from the past couple of NCA boards to not
- 8:36rely overly on guidance, even though I'm telling you that they have this
- 8:40guidance that they will be relying on as it relates to concentration risk.
- 8:44They, the guidance is out there.
- 8:46They don't want to say in a.
- 8:49Dora that you need to do it for that reason, so they'll link it back to
- 8:52the safety and soundest authority.
- 8:54So why calibration beats a hard stop Because, if you've got a $200 million
- 8:59credit union that has a hundred percent of net worth in a certain type of
- 9:03loan, but doesn't have a lot of capital and doesn't have a concentration risk
- 9:07policy, and you have a $2 billion institution that has runs a best in
- 9:12class indirect program for 15 years.
- 9:15There, there's a substantial difference in the safety and
- 9:18soundness of those two examples.
- 9:20And by getting rid of that regulation, which really doesn't mean a lot,
- 9:24and focusing more on safety and soundness and the principles from
- 9:27the letter to credit unions, NCUA can still do what they need to do.
- 9:33So what so what?
- 9:35Examiner corrective actions are in their toolkit.
- 9:38They can require reduced concentration limits.
- 9:41And they do that by saying you need a concentration limit and you
- 9:44need to explain why you need that.
- 9:46But they might not necessarily accept that until they get to a number that they think
- 9:50is they won't tell you a number, but they will tell you that you need to tweak it.
- 9:53And oh, by the way.
- 9:55There is an internal NCOA instruction that says if your net worth concentration
- 10:00risk of a certain product exceeds X percent you need to get the
- 10:05regional director's approval on that.
- 10:07If it re, if it.
- 10:09Exceeds why percent You need to get the office of examination
- 10:13of insurance approval.
- 10:14And guess what?
- 10:15If you have to go get higher levels approval internally at NCUA for
- 10:19someone to bless a program, the examiners are less likely to bless
- 10:24that program without a very robust concentration risk policy program,
- 10:30risk appetite, et cetera, et cetera.
- 10:31So all these things bleed together.
- 10:33And they could require you to red reduce your current exposure.
- 10:37Whether that's member business loans, whether that's indirect auto loans,
- 10:40whether that's signature loans.
- 10:42I've seen this frequently in the last few years.
- 10:45And they could require you to cease lending until, don't cease doing
- 10:50this until you have a better program.
- 10:51Cease doing this until you comply with the commercial loan rule.
- 10:54All these tools still remain in place for the examiners, which
- 10:58is why this regulation going away really doesn't harm them.
- 11:01Now, where does this get a little bit complicated?
- 11:04And where does NC a's proposal?
- 11:05What does NCA.
- 11:07Proposal not necessarily addressed?
- 11:10There's a sophistication gap.
- 11:12I mentioned different credit unions have different programs, different credit
- 11:15unions have different levels of expertise.
- 11:18The 2006 rule wasn't targeted at large, sophisticated credit unions.
- 11:22It was a trip wire for smaller institutions, those without management
- 11:26depth experience or concentration risk frameworks, removing that trip wire.
- 11:31And tho those credit unions must fill that void on their own.
- 11:35The bet is at NCA that they will and that they'll do it in a safe and sound manner.
- 11:40The challenge is, NCA will only catch problems when an examiner is in the
- 11:45building or is asking to review things.
- 11:48Not every credit union is examined every year by the time
- 11:51a concentration issue surfaces.
- 11:53In an exam, an ex, an exposure may already exist.
- 11:57Now they have, trends that they look at and that'll determine whe
- 12:00when and where they go places.
- 12:02But as I've talked a lot about here, a lot recently, they've lost 27% of their staff.
- 12:07They didn't lose 27% of the new people.
- 12:09They lost 20% of the seasoned people, the most experienced people.
- 12:12And in c, a staff will fill those voids.
- 12:15They will rise to the occasion, but the.
- 12:20Body of work of someone who's been at NCA for 35 years, 30 years, 25 years, and
- 12:26their understanding of exams and their comfortable and their comfortableness,
- 12:31if that's a word with risk, is different than someone who's been on
- 12:35two years, five years, 10 years, right?
- 12:37The longer term folks see more gray and have more experience the
- 12:41younger term, see more black and white and may miss some things.
- 12:45They may overreact to some things.
- 12:47They will grow into their roles and they've got a lot of talented people.
- 12:51But that is an issue that.
- 12:53Theoretically and in reality will create some issues for credit
- 12:58unions that are dealing with this.
- 12:59And then there's the consistency question.
- 13:02Principal.
- 13:02Principal based supervision is only as good as the
- 13:04consistency of its application.
- 13:07NCUA has three regions with varying examiner experience and as I mentioned,
- 13:12and the bright line rule eliminated a little bit of that regional
- 13:15variability, although it still came up.
- 13:17Through these other areas that I'm talking about on the safety and
- 13:20soundness, and it came up through concentration risk requirements
- 13:25via the letter to credit unions.
- 13:28So what should a credit union consider doing now?
- 13:31There's four steps.
- 13:33Really in my mind, regardless of where you're at, if you are not
- 13:36already doing that, you should take a look at re review your board policy.
- 13:40If your current indirect vehicle policy references the old 50 and a hundred
- 13:44percent net worth limits as a ceiling, that policy, when this proposed rule
- 13:49becomes final will need to be tweaked.
- 13:52Run a concentration risk letter checklist.
- 13:54Pull out the NCA guidance.
- 13:56And look at it and say, have you done all these things?
- 13:59It's always good to take a look at your policies.
- 14:01NCOA has a really good webpage where they say, here's the
- 14:04policies that are required.
- 14:06Here's how frequently you are required to update them.
- 14:08But when this rule is finalized, it would be a great opportunity to take a
- 14:12look at the concentration risk letter and compare it to your policies.
- 14:17And then probably most importantly, document your rationale.
- 14:20What are you basing your concentration risk limits on?
- 14:23Why are you comfortable with it?
- 14:26Building it into your policies, building it into your strategic planning, and.
- 14:31Lastly if you like these changes, consider submitting a comment letter.
- 14:36NCUA takes these very seriously and comment letters are due by May 26th.
- 14:42If you like the rule, tell 'em if you think the rule shouldn't be canceled.
- 14:45And you think that maybe NCOA should get rid of the concentration.
- 14:50Letter to credit unions in addition to this.
- 14:53Tell them that, or, 'cause NCA does listen.
- 14:55They could be, as I mentioned earlier, they could be at some sort
- 14:58of transition point, leadership wise.
- 15:01If Halman goes to the job that he's accepted.
- 15:04And if Trump and Congress approve the person who is rumored to
- 15:08be coming in as chair, there's gonna be a transition there.
- 15:11And this could possibly get slowed down.
- 15:13By a new person coming in like that.
- 15:15But I do believe that this one has an extremely high probability of being
- 15:21finalized, which is why I've taken the time to talk about it here on the podcast.
- 15:26Bottom line, the tools remain the same.
- 15:28Exam authority and concentration risk guidance letter.
- 15:31Are more flexible and sophisticated than the older bright line cap
- 15:35for well-managed credit unions.
- 15:37This change is appropriate.
- 15:39The regulatory floor was constraining institutions, credit unions that
- 15:42had outgrown the need for it.
- 15:44The risk is at the margins.
- 15:45Smaller credit unions, less experienced management.
- 15:49We're are gonna have thinner exam coverage and UAS exam coverage is thin anyway.
- 15:55So again, in closing, keep your policies updated, take a look at them,
- 16:00and as always we're here to answer any questions that you might have.
- 16:04And I've got some other podcasts on some of the other deregulation
- 16:09efforts that NSU has, that'll be coming out here in the next few weeks.
- 16:13I want to thank you for listening.
- 16:16Thank you for watching if you're on YouTube and stay tuned.
- 16:19For more to come soon on the other deregulation efforts.
- 16:23This is mark Kel signing off with flying colors.