Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The Truth about Compassion Fatigue for Lawyers: Managing Empathic Overwhelm with Claire E. Parsons of Bricker Graydon LLP
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Truth About Compassion, Fatigue for Lawyers, Managing Empathetic Overwhelm.
- 0:13I'm dealing with that myself right now, so I'll be watching this program later.
- 0:19My name is Dean Sirwin.
- 0:21I'm the chair of the Beverly Hills Bar Association's Law Practice, Management, and Wellness
- 0:26section.
- 0:27We try to do programs every month, trying to do some on wellness and mindfulness at least
- 0:35every other month, every three months or so.
- 0:37So please watch this space.
- 0:39Today's speaker is Claire Parsons.
- 0:43I'm going to introduce Claire in a moment, but first, a little bit of housekeeping.
- 0:46This is a webinar.
- 0:48We've got about 100 of us in here.
- 0:51Probably more will be joining.
- 0:53It's clicking up as I speak.
- 0:56This is a webinar.
- 0:57That means that there's no direct interaction between you and the speaker, but there is
- 1:03a Q&A button.
- 1:05So you can use that Q&A button to post questions.
- 1:08Now let me answer some of the questions that commonly come up that are more procedural.
- 1:13Yes, there are materials.
- 1:15There are links that will be posted in that Q&A or in the chat that will be available for
- 1:21all of you to see.
- 1:24You won't be able to post in the chat.
- 1:25You can post in the Q&A if you do have a question.
- 1:28If your question is where are the materials, how do I get my credit for this and things
- 1:32like that, check the chat first.
- 1:36There will be someone monitoring the Q&A.
- 1:39Program materials just went up in the chat.
- 1:41There will be someone monitoring the Q&A and Claire will be answering questions maybe during
- 1:48the process, probably at the end as well.
- 1:51This will be at least an hour long so that we all get the credit.
- 1:56The lovely part of this is this is one of the presentations for the BHBA on demand program
- 2:01that we have here for your MCLE needs, my MCLE needs as well.
- 2:06Last time I did my compliance, it took literally about a minute and a half.
- 2:10I logged into the BHBA Plus platform and everything was right there in my locker.
- 2:16I did a couple of clicks and bam, it went off to the bar.
- 2:18It was really lovely.
- 2:20You can go and look at BHBA and demand.
- 2:22It's effectively MCLE YouTube from the Beverly Hills Bar.
- 2:27We have dynamic, exciting, really exciting, some of these are very exciting programs that
- 2:34are on contemporary issues.
- 2:36If there's a big case, we get a program up usually within a week about it.
- 2:40Plus things like this, other practice things, litigation, there's at least one a day that
- 2:48are live and you can watch them all on BHBA Plus at your leisure.
- 2:53Thank you and please take advantage of that.
- 2:56Claire, Claire E. Persons is a seasoned attorney with 15 years of experience specializing in
- 3:01litigation, school law, municipal law, and employment law in Kentucky and Ohio.
- 3:07She has successfully handled civil rights and tort litigation, served as general counsel
- 3:11for school districts, and contributed as the general editor of Alexis Nexus Legal Treatise
- 3:17on Employment Contracts.
- 3:19Beyond her legal practice, Claire is a dedicated mentor, advocate for attorney well-being,
- 3:24why we're all here, and a recognized leader in both the legal community and professional
- 3:29organizations.
- 3:31Looking forward to this program.
- 3:32Thank you for being here, Claire.
- 3:34Take it away and I will go off camera.
- 3:38Thank you, Dean, and thanks everyone for being here today.
- 3:41I want to talk today about compassion fatigue and what I'm actually going to do.
- 3:47I use the term compassion fatigue for the title of this session, but I actually am going
- 3:52to talk to you about how I think the better term for the phenomenon we know as and know
- 3:57and probably have experienced as compassion fatigue is actually more appropriately characterized
- 4:03as empathic overwhelm most of the time.
- 4:07And I think this is a very timely thing that I know lots of us are probably dealing with.
- 4:12And I know California specifically is having a whole lot of stress and strain right now,
- 4:18and many lawyers and people who are in helping professions are dealing with that.
- 4:23So I want to talk to you about this today, but I want to let you know that I'm not just
- 4:29a mindfulness and compassion teacher.
- 4:32I'm a lawyer who still practices.
- 4:34I have kids.
- 4:35I have a busy life.
- 4:38And these practices actually have helped me continue practicing law.
- 4:43They are things that I came to in my life because I struggled quite a lot early on in
- 4:50my law practice with anxiety.
- 4:54And then at times it would spike into depression.
- 4:56And so I ultimately started meditating about 10 years ago in order to figure out some better
- 5:03ways of handling stress.
- 5:06And one of the things that I came along with that was an understanding of compassion, including
- 5:12self-compassion, which we are going to talk about.
- 5:15And you don't know this yet, or maybe you do, but we're going to talk more about this
- 5:19later on in the session about how mindfulness and compassion really work together.
- 5:24And they can provide really powerful tools for us as lawyers, but also can support our
- 5:31well-being and contribute to an overall happier life.
- 5:35And that's not a life where we're putting on rose-colored glasses and trying to pretend
- 5:39that difficulty doesn't exist.
- 5:41It's about changing the way we relate to it.
- 5:45And in that change is where we can get some power back and find some more stability.
- 5:51So the topics I'm going to talk about today, the mindfulness and compassion, these are
- 5:55things that can be cultivated over the course of one's life.
- 6:00There is actually a wonderful eight-week course on compassion cultivation that hails from
- 6:05your state of California.
- 6:07Stanford University has a great program called Compassion Cultivation Training.
- 6:12There's another one called Mindfulness Self-Compassion.
- 6:16There's all kinds of other courses and programs and retreats and things that you can study
- 6:21with respect to mindfulness and meditation over the course of a life.
- 6:24I've been doing it for 10 years.
- 6:26So we can't learn all of this in an hour, but I can give you a few insights about what
- 6:32this is, a few areas where you might want to explore further if you are so inclined.
- 6:37And then for those of you that aren't, I can give you a few tips about some basic strategies
- 6:44and skills that might help from the compassion standpoint, you know, more in-the-moment practices.
- 6:50But that's what we're going to do.
- 6:52And then the first thing we've got to do, though, of course, is you're here for your
- 6:55CLE credit, so we're going to talk about ethics.
- 6:58If you do have some questions, use a Q&A.
- 7:02I'll try to catch them if I can.
- 7:04If you have insights or thoughts, feel free to use those too.
- 7:09So I don't know.
- 7:10Do you guys have the slides already or the poll questions?
- 7:13You should have already gotten one about mindfulness.
- 7:17Yeah, so thank you.
- 7:19I'll prompt you next time.
- 7:21I maybe didn't realize that.
- 7:22So first of all, before we get started, I want to ask you guys what you think about mindfulness.
- 7:28Is it about being calm?
- 7:31So consider this one as we go on.
- 7:34And I can answer that as we go on.
- 7:38I don't want to mess your answers up.
- 7:42But first of all, let's talk about compassion fatigue and what we're talking about there.
- 7:48So compassion fatigue, this is what many people come to describe as compassion fatigue.
- 7:55And really, when you look at these symptoms, it's something that is like overwhelming exhaustion,
- 8:01shows up as cynicism, feeling demoralized.
- 8:05You might see numbing behavior show up where you're Netflixing or getting on Amazon or
- 8:11eating too much or drinking too much.
- 8:13All of those behaviors that some of us do when we kind of want to check out, we may
- 8:19have loss of productivity or efficacy or just feeling checked out.
- 8:24And we may have also dark moods, low moods or loss of energy.
- 8:30And so this is often what we're talking about when people say compassion fatigue, this is
- 8:35what they're talking about.
- 8:37And so this is what many lawyers do experience and people in helping professions do experience.
- 8:46And the thought behind the name compassion fatigue is that we're taxed out because we
- 8:51have given so much or too much.
- 8:54And going back to that poll question about mindfulness is about being calm.
- 9:01For those of you who answered true, mindfulness often can result in increased feelings of
- 9:07calm.
- 9:08When you meditate, you often, one of the reasons lots of people do meditate is because they
- 9:12find calm.
- 9:13But what I will just encourage you to consider is that mindfulness is not just about being
- 9:17calm.
- 9:18So I would answer that question false, you know, because it's actually a lot more than
- 9:24that.
- 9:25We're going to talk about how mindfulness can actually help you when you're not calm.
- 9:29And that's actually why some of this is really important.
- 9:32We also have a new poll question about just whether you have experienced or observed any
- 9:37attorney's struggle with issues in the case or just meaning there are emotions because
- 9:42of stress and just how often that you may have seen that.
- 9:50So when it comes to what is compassion fatigue or this phenomena, compassion fatigue, empathic
- 9:56overwhelm, what does this have to do with our ethical duties as attorneys?
- 10:01Now I want to just review the rules and kind of help you understand that emotional management
- 10:06and self care are required.
- 10:08I think they're implicitly required in terms of our ethical duties or at least they are
- 10:13assumed because we are humans who have to implement these duties.
- 10:18And as humans, managing our emotions and learning to take care of ourselves is part of that
- 10:23job.
- 10:24So let's take a look at some of these rules real quick.
- 10:28So one of the rules that sort of implies this duty of caring for our own emotions and needs
- 10:35is that competent representation means legal knowledge and skill, of course.
- 10:42It also means thoroughness and preparation.
- 10:46And what does preparation mean and what does thoroughness mean?
- 10:49And I think all of us know that when we handle a case, it's not just looking at the law,
- 10:56investigating the facts, but also dealing with the people, dealing with our own emotions
- 11:01if we have to go make that closing argument in front of a jury, or dealing with our own
- 11:06emotions if we have to go walk into a difficult meeting or participate in something where
- 11:12someone is losing their job or being disciplined or maybe facing criminal penalties or my mother
- 11:20was a family lawyer, maybe have limitations on or a totally different view of what their
- 11:26family life looks like going forward.
- 11:30This is all part of what we do because we don't just represent legal issues, work on
- 11:34legal issues, we represent people.
- 11:37And so understanding that those emotions come into our case is part of what we do.
- 11:42When you look at the comment to rule 1.1, you get a little bit more sense of this is that
- 11:49competent handling of a matter means inquiry and analysis into the elements of the problem.
- 11:55And it also talks about attention.
- 11:58And when I'm a litigator, that's kind of where my first experience in law comes from.
- 12:06And litigation is much more of a marathon than a sprint.
- 12:09So it's not just attention in the moment for a given day, but that sustained attention.
- 12:15And that sustained continuing to check back in on the status of cases and keep things
- 12:19moving.
- 12:20And I'm sure that that same thing happens with the transactional folks who might be
- 12:24in the audience too.
- 12:27Putting a deal together takes that kind of sustained work.
- 12:30And it really takes managing that sense of burnout that does come up.
- 12:36I have certainly experienced some symptoms at times on particular cases when it comes
- 12:40to burnout.
- 12:41It happens and so learning to manage that is part of being an effective lawyer and also
- 12:46just taking care of yourself as a human.
- 12:50Another place where this comes up and this obligation to manage one's emotions and care
- 12:55for oneself, I think if you look at diligence, it comes in a little bit more clearly too
- 13:01where we have to act with commitment and dedication to the interests of our clients.
- 13:08We have to exercise professional discretion about the means we use and whether they're
- 13:15representative of our client's interests and then treating everybody in the legal process
- 13:20with courtesy and respect.
- 13:22And in this day and age where a lot of us are yelling at each other, it can be a real
- 13:29struggle to do.
- 13:30People involved in legal processes tend to not be the happiest people.
- 13:35And so we do often get stressed.
- 13:37And as your poll results on question two would indicate, sometimes or frequently, the majority
- 13:45of people have seen attorney struggle to manage an issue in the case because of emotions or
- 13:51stress.
- 13:52And only the minority of people have not seen that or have only seen it in the past.
- 14:00And for those 10 or 11 who haven't, you guys help us all stay calm and steady, please,
- 14:07because most of us have experienced this and I experience it myself and my cases.
- 14:12So that's why when you can learn to cultivate these better responses for yourself, you actually
- 14:20help the entire profession.
- 14:22You help your clients.
- 14:23And there's a lot of power in that.
- 14:28When you look at the comment to rule 1.3, I point out procrastination here and this kind
- 14:34of comment that talks about procrastination because I do know that one of the biggest
- 14:40concerns that one of the issues I faced as a young lawyer was procrastination.
- 14:44I know it's a common problem for many professionals just from a time management standpoint.
- 14:49And I think there's a common idea in our brains that procrastination is often caused by laziness
- 14:55or just not being very good at time management.
- 14:58And sometimes that's true.
- 14:59You know, sometimes we can learn better strategies and approaches for handling things.
- 15:03But I will say that anxiety or sometimes, you know, not just not wanting to face something
- 15:09in a case, you know, that can come up.
- 15:12And when you get that burnout on a case and that frustration with continuing to deal with
- 15:18it and that overwhelm, procrastination can become a lot more likely and it creates problems
- 15:26in itself.
- 15:27And so I point out this one just to kind of highlight that and maybe express some solidarity
- 15:32for any of those of you who have experienced procrastination over the years.
- 15:37This is not the point fingers, but just as a reminder that it is important to address
- 15:41because it can lead to practical consequences for us in our cases.
- 15:46And then when we look at all the roles relating to relationships and our behavior in court,
- 15:53it comes through even clearer.
- 15:55Our job as lawyers is not just to win, it matters how we treat people in the process.
- 16:00And so why we're here today is to talk about how we can treat ourselves better and treat
- 16:08and learn some better skills for managing what we have to do as a lawyer.
- 16:14And when I teach about mindfulness and compassion, one of the things I like to point out is that,
- 16:25you know, when we talk about mindfulness and compassion, we're really talking about skills
- 16:32for life and for work.
- 16:34I know that a lot of times people get the idea that mindfulness is just meditation or
- 16:39compassion is just being nice.
- 16:42And there are a lot more fundamental and powerful than that.
- 16:46So I'm going to get into that a little bit more and try to connect those dots for you
- 16:50here.
- 16:51So the reason I mentioned earlier that I don't prefer the name Compassion Fatigue is because
- 17:00I actually think compassion is more of a solution or a potential helper to us as lawyers than
- 17:09it is a problem.
- 17:12So compassion fatigue, as we talked about, is really kind of this burnout, physical or
- 17:17emotional impact that kind of happens when we help others.
- 17:22And often it can happen when we are helping people through stressful or sometimes even
- 17:28traumatic experiences, which lawyers do occasionally have to work with, especially some who may
- 17:36do family or criminal law or personal injury where there are massive injuries.
- 17:42I mean, those kind of things are real and they are real for lawyers.
- 17:45And you don't have to actually see an incident to have that experience.
- 17:50But let's talk about why people use the term Compassion Fatigue.
- 17:55We think of it as Compassion Fatigue because we think the problem is helping others.
- 18:01In reality, I think it's something else.
- 18:04And one thing I want to point out, I think we have a whole question now about empathy.
- 18:13So Compassion Fatigue and the use of that term, I do think comes from a misunderstanding
- 18:19of compassion, what that means, and empathy, what that means.
- 18:24So we have a poll question and I'm asking about empathy and whether you think empathy
- 18:30is always good.
- 18:33And by that I mean you can't have too much empathy.
- 18:37Empathy is if empathy is added to a situation, it makes the situation better.
- 18:42That's the question.
- 18:45And the reason I'm asking this question is that I think culturally there is a strong
- 18:52preference for empathy and there are lots of messages around empathy being good.
- 18:58And I'm not here to tell you that empathy is bad or it's unnecessary because it's actually
- 19:02fundamental to compassion itself.
- 19:05But I want a question about whether it is always good.
- 19:09So part of the reason that people talk about Compassion Fatigue is that they don't understand
- 19:15empathy.
- 19:17And I want to ask you, looking at these images, we have people hugging, we have people celebrating
- 19:25someone, we have people lamenting something together, and we have people yelling at each
- 19:29other.
- 19:30And I want to ask you which one you think is empathy or which one or is it all of them?
- 19:38And I think part of my point here is I think that all of these actually are empathy and
- 19:46we're going to talk a little bit more.
- 19:48So effective empathy happens when we take on the emotions of other people.
- 19:54And that is an actually really important part of our physiology as humans.
- 20:01In good times it binds us together.
- 20:04If you watched the Super Bowl, if you enjoyed any of that or the Kendrick Lamar concert,
- 20:09depending on how you, I'm not a football fan so it was a concert for me, if you experience
- 20:14big things like that where you're together and you're experiencing that collective joy
- 20:19or you win a trial and your team celebrates together, that's a wonderful kind of empathy.
- 20:25And I don't want to take that from you.
- 20:27But the thing is with lawyers, what are we dealing with most of the time?
- 20:31We're not dealing with those kinds of collective joy.
- 20:34We are dealing a lot of times with disappointment and we are dealing with anger and stress.
- 20:39And so the idea that culturally I think a lot of times we're told we need more empathy.
- 20:45Like if people were more empathetic, our situation in the world would be better, right?
- 20:51We'd have less fighting if people were more empathetic.
- 20:54And I think what those people are really trying to say is if people understood each
- 20:58other better, we would probably make better choices.
- 21:02And I would agree with that.
- 21:04But let's talk a little bit about empathy and compassion in comparison.
- 21:10So when we are in empathy, as I said earlier, we're feeling someone else's feelings.
- 21:16But when we are in empathy, we are kind of isolated and we're isolated in our experience.
- 21:22So what happens in empathy is that we feel their feelings, but then we experience it
- 21:27individually and we experience it in ourselves.
- 21:32And the result is very powerful, but it is isolating and it burns us out quickly.
- 21:38It takes a lot of energy.
- 21:40There's not a lot of rewards and it can overwhelm us very quickly.
- 21:44Now compassion is actually different and empathy and compassion have been studied in clinical
- 21:49settings and they actually have seen that they affect very different parts of the brain,
- 21:54although there is some interconnection.
- 21:57Compassion is when we experience suffering and that can be our own or someone else's
- 22:03suffering and we feel or express an inclination or a willingness to help.
- 22:11So that's what compassion actually is.
- 22:14And when we do that, when we have that response, our focus is not just on ourselves or on our
- 22:22feelings and we don't just zero in on the bad feelings.
- 22:26What our focus is is humanity.
- 22:29And so the experience is actually one of connection and the result is much more stable, durable,
- 22:38and it supports health.
- 22:41And I know this is a little bit, this may be a little bit hard to accept automatically,
- 22:46so I'm not just asking you to take me at face value here.
- 22:51I think this is something you can experience in life and I have experienced in life that
- 22:56compassion actually can reward you with positive hormones like oxytocin, dopamine, serotonin,
- 23:02and you can feel that.
- 23:04Most of the time in life we don't always slow down to notice it, but there is a very distinct
- 23:09difference physiologically in terms of what happens when we're in empathy versus when we
- 23:14respond with compassion.
- 23:17And so just to kind of show how this might work, with compassion in terms of the response,
- 23:25now here's where parts of compassion can get a little confusing.
- 23:28So at the beginning of a compassion response, we may feel a little bit of distress.
- 23:34It may feel a lot like empathy because we will be becoming aware of some kind of suffering.
- 23:41You know, and I'll give a real basic example.
- 23:46When I was actually doing my education relating to compassion, I was meditating one night and
- 23:55there was a dog outside barking in my neighborhood and he was barking and I could just hear that
- 24:01he was upset.
- 24:02It didn't go on for a protracted period of time, but it was long enough in the meditation
- 24:07where I could hear the dog barking and I was upset for the little dog.
- 24:12I'm a dog person.
- 24:14And ultimately, and I could just watch over the course of one, two minutes or however
- 24:18long the dog was outside barking and you could hear the upset in the dog's bark.
- 24:23And you have dogs, you hear these things.
- 24:25And I started to notice my concern.
- 24:28I noticed that I wanted the owner to come and let the dog in.
- 24:34And then I even started to think about, well, what can I do?
- 24:38Do I need to go outside and help the dog get in?
- 24:41And then, and so there was that belief that I could change things and make a difference.
- 24:46And then at the end of it, I noticed that for the rest of my set, I felt very calm and
- 24:52relaxed.
- 24:53And so anyway, the dog did make it in the house.
- 24:55The dog is safe and well.
- 24:57So don't worry about the dog.
- 24:58But what I'm saying is this is kind of just, it gave me a great example to sort of watch
- 25:02this in practice.
- 25:04And this happens to us in real life.
- 25:06If you slow down and notice it, you don't always have to break it down in these little
- 25:11steps and you don't necessarily have to practice it this way.
- 25:13But this is the, these are the steps of compassion that have been shown to occur in the body,
- 25:20in the brain, when we have that experience in clinical settings.
- 25:24And so empathy is part of this, but it's not the entire experience.
- 25:31So ultimately what we do with compassion is kind of go beyond empathy and reach more towards
- 25:37our connection and our humanity.
- 25:45So compassion is a natural and human and innate function.
- 25:51So is mindfulness.
- 25:53Both of them are ingrained in us unless we have some kind of condition or potentially
- 25:59some kind of impact on our brain that may affect that.
- 26:02But these are natural functions.
- 26:06But they are also things that we can train up and that we can practice and make stronger.
- 26:13So one of the analogies, I have a book and I'll talk about that at the end a little bit,
- 26:18but in my book where I teach about mindfulness and compassion, I have an analogy where I
- 26:23talk about mindfulness and compassion being similar to cooking.
- 26:28Okay.
- 26:30So you know, if you think about a peanut butter and jelly sandwich, which I will never criticize,
- 26:36I think it's one of the best culinary inventions in the world.
- 26:39I still partake in them all the time.
- 26:43That's a very simple thing.
- 26:44And most of us, you know, even as kids, we knew how to make a peanut butter and jelly
- 26:48sandwich or something similar to that, right?
- 26:51But if you practice your cooking skills and you move beyond that, you can eventually learn
- 26:55to make really much more elaborate, arguably healthier, more satisfying meals.
- 27:02And I have cooked my whole life and now I have a lot of skills with cooking that I didn't
- 27:07have when I started out with peanut butter and jelly sandwiches.
- 27:10So what you've got now.
- 27:12You've got a great, wonderful start with mindfulness and compassion.
- 27:16It's in your heart.
- 27:17It's in your brain.
- 27:18You're wired for this.
- 27:20But with some practice and with some specific attention, you actually can train these things
- 27:27up.
- 27:28And so because we don't have an eight week span of time to talk about these things and
- 27:34we don't have years and years, what I wanted to zero in on today is what are the three
- 27:40areas that we could talk about in an hour window where I could give you an introduction
- 27:46to things that help for lawyers and that can make a difference in terms of specific, tangible
- 27:52practices in your life.
- 27:54These are things you can study for years or the rest of your life, but these are the thing,
- 27:59these are kind of the areas I would start with.
- 28:02And the places where I would start, if you want to think about cultivating more compassion
- 28:08and supporting your life and your law practice are mindfulness, specifically building stability
- 28:16in your mind and equanimity.
- 28:19And then thinking about the zone of tolerance and specifically your zone of tolerance, moderating
- 28:25and modulating that to help yourself so that you can support others better.
- 28:32And then the final one is common humanity.
- 28:36And that's something that really leans into that connection aspect that is really important
- 28:42when it comes to compassion.
- 28:46Okay, so I don't know if we are, yeah, we have our next slide up now.
- 28:52So mindfulness, we're going to talk about that.
- 28:54And the poll question is mindfulness helps you manage emotions because it trains you
- 28:58to clear out your mind of troubling thoughts.
- 29:03Okay, so let's talk about mindfulness.
- 29:06So, this is actually an analogy I use in my book too.
- 29:11In this case, I've got fun slides with really professional graphics that I made on Canva
- 29:17myself to illustrate it.
- 29:19So, mindfulness is this cave number one, okay?
- 29:24Mindfulness is the capacity to be non-judgmentally aware of what is occurring in your life right
- 29:31now.
- 29:32Okay?
- 29:33That's really it.
- 29:34It's the capacity for awareness without reacting to or judging it.
- 29:39Now, what I've talked about though is mindfulness plus compassion, right?
- 29:45It's really difficult to separate mindfulness and compassion.
- 29:48They do work together.
- 29:50But when you have that clear awareness and you also have compassion, which is the ability
- 29:56to respond to suffering with a willingness to help, that changes your experience directly
- 30:04drastically.
- 30:05And it can, and this is a rough graphic to illustrate a point, but it can be like redecorating
- 30:15your inner living conditions, right?
- 30:17It does add a little bit of softness and a little bit of comfort to getting through life.
- 30:24Not necessarily that it takes all the bad stuff away, but it also makes us resist the
- 30:29bad stuff a little bit less and remember to respond with kindness a little bit more.
- 30:35And I think anybody who's been through a difficult situation probably has experienced the fact
- 30:40that somebody being kind to us or helping us or just being there, it actually does make
- 30:46things a lot better, even if it doesn't fix it.
- 30:48Okay, so we got the results back.
- 30:51So mindfulness helps you manage emotions because it trains you to clear your minds of troubling
- 30:56thoughts.
- 30:57I'm going to actually go with false on that one too, but I, for the people who said true,
- 31:03I can understand why you did that because one of the things that does happen with mindfulness
- 31:08practice, whether through meditation or other practices like yoga, one of the things that
- 31:13often happens is that your mind does kind of calm down in terms of thought generation.
- 31:20You do start to become a little bit more aware of the quality of the thoughts, including
- 31:26the negative ones.
- 31:27You develop some skills for managing the thoughts and that's kind of what we're going
- 31:31to talk about next.
- 31:33So mindfulness is actually something where we, we learn to be more present in our life
- 31:38and so the impact of thoughts is shifted.
- 31:42It doesn't mean we're always pushing those thoughts away or we never have them.
- 31:47It's more about generating better skills for responding to and managing the thoughts.
- 31:52So let's talk about the elements of mindfulness.
- 31:55So the elements of mindfulness really are non-judgment.
- 31:59So things arise and we don't react to them and that's sort of where equanimity comes
- 32:06in, where we remain steady and stable even in the face of change or difficulty.
- 32:12And then the other aspect of mindfulness is the non-doing.
- 32:17So part of that as lawyers is, you know, those regular breaks and pauses.
- 32:24And so that's a really important thing, learning to pause and greet our life and be with our
- 32:31life as it is instead of immediately doing something about it, which would, you know,
- 32:38generally sometimes be reactionary and is not always productive.
- 32:42And then there's another thing about mindfulness that's really interesting in that if you
- 32:47do meditate, if you ever get to that point, you will notice that you have some capacity
- 32:53to shift your attention.
- 32:55So a lot of mindfulness is learning to be with things, but some of mindfulness is also
- 33:00learning what you don't have to be with and developing greater skill about shifting your
- 33:06attention to something else, sometimes to support yourself or sometimes because it's
- 33:11more productive.
- 33:12And so we're going to talk about a few quick strategies that you can use and that ultimately
- 33:20might serve as a launching pad for more study and practice if you so choose.
- 33:28So let's talk about some really basic things that could kind of start with mindfulness.
- 33:34So consistent meditation practice is probably the best way of doing this or consistent yoga
- 33:40practice might be another way.
- 33:43But some really basic things that you can start to like play with and incorporate in
- 33:48your day are three things, grounding, breath focus, and then noting.
- 33:54And that's really noting when something happens and learning to let go.
- 33:58And we're going to talk about these real generally, but there are things that you could literally
- 34:03study and practice for years.
- 34:06So one thing, one thing, and I don't know if I've gotten to the poll question yet, I
- 34:13assume that'll just pop up when we get there.
- 34:15I'm not sure what slide number I'm on, just to let you know.
- 34:19So grounding practices are the first really basic one.
- 34:25And there is this term grounding is used in a lot of different ways.
- 34:29And so sometimes you might hear it used in different ways.
- 34:34When I'm using it here, I'm actually pretty specific about what I mean by grounding.
- 34:39And I'm actually pretty literal too.
- 34:41I'm talking about getting back to the ground to the very basics.
- 34:46And really when when I need to ground, I think the most effective way for me is to look for
- 34:54something steady, calming, soothing, not moving, you know, steady, heavy, big.
- 35:03And so a lot of times if you do have an established breath practice, whether it is pranayama like
- 35:10breath work, or it is a meditation focus practice, the breath can serve that grounding
- 35:17function because it is something where you're real familiar with it, you're well aware,
- 35:22you know how to get the sensation of your breath, and it can bring you back.
- 35:27And so breath focus actually can be a really good way to ground you and root you, anchor
- 35:33you in the present moment when things are difficult.
- 35:37The breath is an excellent tool for this because the breath is one of the ways that our brain
- 35:43can talk to and calm down our nervous system.
- 35:47Another way to do that because not everybody feels comfortable with and really safe with
- 35:53their breath and that's okay.
- 35:55But another way to do this to ground is simply to feel the sensations of one's weight.
- 36:06And specifically when you're seated, you can feel your weight pressing down into the chair.
- 36:12You can feel your feet resting on the floor, your hands resting in your lap.
- 36:20Another way to do this is to look for something large, heavy, and stable, not moving in your
- 36:28visual plane.
- 36:30And then finally another way of doing this is even to connect with the sound of stillness,
- 36:37right?
- 36:38To connect with quiet in your environment and to notice that quiet.
- 36:44And that can be, you know, depending on your environment, you might have to choose which
- 36:48one works best for you.
- 36:50But to do that for a moment, what it does is one, it can disrupt the flow of thought
- 36:56that sometimes increase our anxiety.
- 36:59But two, it brings us back to right now.
- 37:02I do find that when our thoughts get keyed up, especially by emotion, they go to the
- 37:06future, they go to the past, they're negative, and they make things sometimes worse.
- 37:13And we get a little disconnected from what is the problem right now that I have to solve.
- 37:18Is there a problem right now I have to solve?
- 37:22And you find sometimes that there actually isn't one or it's not necessarily as big as
- 37:26your mind is making it out to be.
- 37:27So that's a quick grounding practice.
- 37:30Again, this is something that you can expand out and there are literal like 20, 30 meditation
- 37:36practices just based on this.
- 37:40And so this is a quick thing you can do is one I have used in my law practice.
- 37:44I used it in my first oral argument with the federal circuit court.
- 37:50And it was enough just to keep me steady to get through that.
- 37:55So I mentioned the breath already.
- 37:58And we do have another poll question here.
- 38:00How often am I aware of where my attention goes?
- 38:04Like, you know, if I kind of space out, if I kind of lose myself in something, and this
- 38:09is not even a judgment call about losing yourself.
- 38:13Sometimes it's excellent to lose yourself, you know, and not be so self conscious all
- 38:17the time.
- 38:18But how often are you aware when that occurs?
- 38:24Now one way you can bring yourself back to that awareness is by finding your breath.
- 38:28And as I mentioned, it's a wonderful tool because our breath when we especially when
- 38:34we exhale, that is equivalent to pushing on the the the brake pedal on your car.
- 38:41It slows things down.
- 38:43It's a signal to the body that you've got enough oxygen, things are okay.
- 38:48Let's slow down.
- 38:50If you want to calm the body down, the breath is a wonderful way to do it.
- 38:55And so I want to go over just taking a real deep breath real quick and what that actually
- 39:00means.
- 39:01I know that, you know, we people tell us to take a deep breath when we're stressed out,
- 39:06but they don't always teach us how to do it.
- 39:08And so one thing to consider and is just where are you noting the breath?
- 39:15First of all, you can bring attention to your nose, your sinuses, you can bring attention
- 39:21to your chest or your belly.
- 39:26And you might want to kind of check here, are you feeling like the cool air coming in
- 39:31and the warm air going out more?
- 39:32Are you feeling that sensation in the air flowing in in your throat or sinuses?
- 39:39Are you feeling the motion of your lungs rising and falling?
- 39:42Or are you feeling it most in your belly as your diaphragm kind of pushes in and out?
- 39:52I am a belly person personally, but just for now, go with whatever feels the strongest
- 39:58to you.
- 39:59And then I encourage you to take a deep full breath all the way in.
- 40:08Hold it for just a moment and then let it go all the way out.
- 40:14So a real deep breath takes around five to 10 seconds.
- 40:18And that means if you take five or 10 deep breaths, that's one or two minutes.
- 40:22And if you can do that, you know, if you even have that much time, that's enough time to
- 40:27catch yourself and to slow yourself down.
- 40:31And so connecting to those physical sensations of the breath, if that's accessible to you,
- 40:37that is one really excellent tool that you can use in law practice in your workouts,
- 40:42you know, to get a hold of your breath in a lot of situations and it can bring you back.
- 40:48And if you can do five or 10 deep breaths, you know, that's the building blocks of a
- 40:54meditation practice.
- 40:55If you want to go on with that, not that you have to, but it is something where I actually
- 41:00started with a minute of meditation with a timer on my phone and I over time built that
- 41:06up to 30 minutes.
- 41:08And so it is something where truly a few deep breaths, it can make a difference in the moment,
- 41:14but it's something that you can use later on as well in other contexts.
- 41:21And then the last mindfulness practice is I think it's awesome that so many of you are
- 41:28aware when you're aware of where your mind goes.
- 41:31That's awesome because I was often lost in thought and I had to really intentionally
- 41:37work to catch myself, but it's wonderful that so many of you are.
- 41:42And then it's actually frankly even good that so many of you are aware when a situation
- 41:47prompts you.
- 41:49That's good that you can check in that way.
- 41:51And so that kind of shows you that that mindfulness, it's a natural function.
- 41:56It's just something that we can also train up.
- 41:59And then noting is the final mindfulness practice.
- 42:01And what that really means is you note when something happens and then you let something
- 42:07go.
- 42:08And I have the picture here of the fish with the hook because what happens with our experience
- 42:13often is that we get hooked by things.
- 42:16And that's where a lot of thoughts, reactions, and some of our difficulty kind of comes.
- 42:23And I'm not saying that all of this is self-created, but what I am saying is that the normal habits
- 42:27of mind kind of operate to sometimes create more difficulty for us.
- 42:34So one of the real basic practices here is, you know, just so if you if you for instance,
- 42:41notice that you've got a case or a situation that's difficult for you and it's creating
- 42:44a lot of thoughts about it and fears, you may just notice, oh, I'm thinking, right.
- 42:53And just by noting your thinking, it helps you realize that those are thoughts and it
- 42:59gives you an opportunity to change what you're doing, right.
- 43:04Or you might notice I'm feeling, right.
- 43:06I'm feeling and you might even say I'm feeling fear or I'm feeling anxiety.
- 43:11But when you notice that you're thinking or notice that there's a feeling or emotion there,
- 43:17it gives you a little bit of control where you can learn to maybe take care of the fear
- 43:22by talking to a colleague or sometimes when I'm afraid about a case, I realize I'm nervous
- 43:27about something.
- 43:28I need to talk to my client about that area of risk and figure out a strategy for managing
- 43:32it.
- 43:33And so so I'm not always saying that you have to push these things away, but I am saying
- 43:37when you can note them and not get so sucked in, that is a game changer from the standpoint
- 43:46of getting some distance enough from it that you can respond more reasonably to it.
- 43:54Instead of getting caught in the thought cycles and getting thought in the anxiety, caught
- 44:00in the anxiety where you're kind of forced to assume that all the thoughts and the feelings
- 44:06are speaking to a truth, a truth that you can't escape.
- 44:10And that's not always true.
- 44:11So the practice might be to just note them as thinking, to note the feelings as feelings,
- 44:18or to note like if an observation happens in your visual plane or you hear something,
- 44:24to note what it is that you're experiencing.
- 44:27And actually this is an entire meditation practice in and of itself, but it is also
- 44:32something that I know that I do in my normal life, especially when it comes to the thinking
- 44:37and feeling.
- 44:38And sometimes like what I might have to do when the thoughts are very copious is I might
- 44:43have to write them down or talk it out to kind of get a little more distance from it.
- 44:48So I'm not saying you can always do it by yourself, but this initial noting and recognition,
- 44:54that is a ground level mindful strategy that can make a big difference.
- 45:01So let's talk now about window of tolerance quickly.
- 45:04We've got a few more minutes.
- 45:07So window of tolerance is actually a concept that if any of you have had any training with
- 45:13respect to trauma or work with respect to trauma, you may have heard this term.
- 45:18And it is actually one that I learned from some of my training in trauma sensitive mindfulness.
- 45:24And not to say that everyone out there has necessarily experienced traumatic experience,
- 45:30though it is very common that many of us have.
- 45:35But it is something that's really applicable and I think it's something that really makes
- 45:39a lot of sense for lawyers.
- 45:40We're dealing with difficulty and stress in our work.
- 45:44So understanding how to moderate that for ourselves, it just makes sense to think about
- 45:50it.
- 45:51And I know when I got this training on trauma, I just was like, why didn't I learn this?
- 45:55I wish I would have learned this in kindergarten.
- 45:57Now I do think some of the schools are learning things like zones of regulation for kids.
- 46:01And I think that's great.
- 46:03But in case you haven't, that's what I wanted to talk about here.
- 46:05Here is, we are kind of expected to perform optimally most of the time, but we're often
- 46:12in suboptimal circumstances.
- 46:15And so thinking about what is our comfort zone, what is our growth zone, and what is
- 46:21our overwhelm zone.
- 46:22And starting to navigate that and look for those clues, it can actually make a big difference.
- 46:29So that's what we're going to talk about here.
- 46:31So one thing to think about is, and we have a new poll question, how often do I check
- 46:38in with myself to determine how I feel or what I might need?
- 46:44And I will tell you that that is one of the most important functions of my meditation practice.
- 46:50I do it at the end of the day, but it is a wonderful time to check in.
- 46:54And it's one of the reasons I appreciate it so much.
- 46:57In case you don't do that, or in case you don't have those gaps of time where you do
- 47:01have some time for reflection, there are ways to do this in the moment.
- 47:05And so when you're looking to see what zone you're in, whether you're hypoaroused, under
- 47:12stimulated, you're hyperaroused, you're overly stimulated, or whether you're in your safe
- 47:21growth zone, whether you're in the place where you need to be, you want to look at three
- 47:26things, it's just three little steps.
- 47:29Take a moment to pause, and you look around for clues about how you're doing, how you're
- 47:34feeling, you know, what's going on in my thoughts, you know, how fast are my thoughts, what's
- 47:40the quality of my thoughts, what's happening in my mind, how do I feel in my body, you
- 47:45know, a quick scan, and we're going to go through a strategy for learning to do that,
- 47:49what's going on in my environment, you know, what has happened in the last day.
- 47:54And then you kind of gather up all the evidence of this.
- 47:57Well, I'm hungry, I've got a headache, I had a difficult day this morning, my kid was late
- 48:02to school, I had a difficult meeting, and I feel just exhausted, right?
- 48:10And then you assess, what is the data telling us?
- 48:14What is the plan going forward?
- 48:15Well, first I need a snack, I need to close my eyes for five minutes, I need to get a
- 48:21cup of tea or, you know, a coffee, and I need to take a minute to think about what I'm
- 48:27going to do next in the rest of my day, right?
- 48:30That is a quick way to do it, so pause, gather, assess is how you determine what zone you're
- 48:35in.
- 48:36And this might sound like baby stuff, but remember, when we are in stressful situations,
- 48:43when we're dealing with stressful situations, and we're focused so much on everyone else,
- 48:47the easiest thing in the world is to forget ourselves, and what a lot of us do in stress
- 48:52is regress back a little bit to our earlier times in life.
- 48:56And so remembering some of these fundamental things can actually make a difference.
- 49:00And as your whole responses indicate, it can be a struggle for us to check in to determine
- 49:07what our needs are.
- 49:09So thank you for answering that honestly, everyone.
- 49:13And for the people who do check in a lot, great job, but for those who don't as much,
- 49:19it's something you can learn to do.
- 49:21I definitely have, and it can make a difference in your work.
- 49:26So one quick way of learning to check in with yourself.
- 49:30And one of the, I think, biggest signs for most of us on this is the body, and it's one
- 49:36of the most, I think, overlooked areas for lawyers.
- 49:41Because we're in our heads, because we're doing work that often involves computers that
- 49:45takes us out of our bodies, it can be a good thing to get back into it.
- 49:50Now I say this with caution.
- 49:52If you are not used to checking with your body, it could take a little bit of time for
- 49:57you to feel much and notice much.
- 50:00So don't judge yourself.
- 50:02And if you do have any history of trauma, there can be a little bit of safety factor
- 50:07for you.
- 50:08And if you're working with any professionals, talk to them before you do real extensive
- 50:12body type work.
- 50:13But with this practice, this is really just a real check in, right?
- 50:18And it's a practice that I've learned to do.
- 50:20So there's an extensive, longer meditation practice called Body Scan that is really kind
- 50:28of wonderful and relaxing, feels good for many people.
- 50:32I find it is especially useful for trying to get to sleep.
- 50:37But this is kind of a very shortened version of that that I use in my day every day where
- 50:43I check in.
- 50:45And with this practice, if you want to kind of follow along and see if you can feel these
- 50:49areas and notice anything, just go for it.
- 50:51If that feels good to you.
- 50:54Were you checking with your eyes and your brow?
- 50:56Are they crinkled?
- 50:58Are they crunched up?
- 51:00Is there tension?
- 51:01You check in with your jaw.
- 51:02Again, is there tension?
- 51:04Or does it feel kind of open and good?
- 51:08You check with your neck and shoulders.
- 51:10What are you feeling in your neck and shoulders?
- 51:11Are they up like this?
- 51:12Are they falling back?
- 51:14Are they relaxed?
- 51:16Your chest and your belly.
- 51:18Do you feel your heart beating fast or is it slow?
- 51:21How is your breath?
- 51:23Is your belly tensed up and tight?
- 51:26Your hips?
- 51:27Are they relaxing in your seat?
- 51:29Or do they feel tensed up too?
- 51:32And then your hands.
- 51:33What is the temperature of your hands?
- 51:35Are they resting?
- 51:36Are they clenched?
- 51:38Are they cold or warm?
- 51:42And you can do this very quickly.
- 51:44And the reason that I've identified these places, you may, if you try this practice,
- 51:49you may actually identify other places where you experience, get more useful information
- 51:54about checking in with where you are.
- 51:57But the reason that I identify these areas is that these areas tend to be the places
- 52:02where emotions register, where stress hides for most people.
- 52:08And so it can be a good practice to check there.
- 52:10You know, go to, if you're wondering to know how you are, looking at the places where emotions
- 52:16show up is the good place to start.
- 52:19But as you play with us, if you think that you have a better thing, a better approach
- 52:23that works for you, you absolutely use that because sometimes these things can shift and
- 52:29change for all of us.
- 52:32All right, and our final piece is on common humanity.
- 52:38And this sounds, you know, a little bit kumbaya.
- 52:42I concede.
- 52:44And you know, when we're talking about compassion, we might get that idea that it's about being
- 52:48a saint.
- 52:49And it's really not.
- 52:51What I really am talking about is being a human and recognizing that you are human and
- 52:57that sometimes when you have difficulty, that's difficulty that is shared by others in humanity.
- 53:04So when I talked about empathy, about how it's taking on someone else's emotions, one
- 53:10of the things that happens with empathy is that we spotlight.
- 53:14Okay, so that when we feel someone else's emotions, we feel their emotions, them as an
- 53:20individual and we spotlight them as, you know, particularly having a hard time.
- 53:28And we kind of forget other people.
- 53:30We kind of forget broader situations.
- 53:34And for some of us, that may be a necessary part of doing our job some of the time.
- 53:40You know, for those of you who are in the plaintiffs bar, you know, you probably at
- 53:45times in your practice have to focus and spotlight on the needs of your client and or advocate
- 53:51for them strongly.
- 53:53But I bet when you need to go into a mediation and you need to think about resolution, it
- 54:00really helps to be able to shift the tension and focus to what are the interests of my
- 54:04defendant and the code defendant, what are the interests of the attorney in that other
- 54:10room and their client, because that's how we can solve problems and meet in the middle
- 54:16and figure out a solution to a problem.
- 54:18So empathy is something that forces us to spotlight individuals and focus on that.
- 54:24But what compassion does is actually it's big enough for everybody.
- 54:28So with that spotlighting effect, one of the things that happens is that we can forget
- 54:33ourselves as lawyers.
- 54:36Compassion is big enough for other people.
- 54:39It is big enough for groups of people.
- 54:41It is big enough for you.
- 54:44And that is one of the most important things that I talk about when I talked to other lawyers
- 54:49about these things is self compassion.
- 54:51So one of the reasons that compassion actually can help us is that it can help us break down
- 54:58some of these judgments and barriers in particular focusing on what we need for ourselves and
- 55:05not just because that's selfish, but because it actually supports our work and our interaction
- 55:12with other people.
- 55:14So one of the ways, and again, you can study compassion and practice compassion for a long,
- 55:20long time.
- 55:21It's a project of a lifetime.
- 55:23There's courses that you can do this extensively over.
- 55:26And if anyone wants to reach out to me at the end for any of that information, I'm happy
- 55:29to share it with you.
- 55:32But this is some short ways that you can kind of think about this in practice.
- 55:37And we have our final poll question about self compassion.
- 55:40And it says self compassion only works when you can feel soft and warm emotions towards
- 55:45yourself.
- 55:48So common humanity is actually for other people, and it's also for yourself.
- 55:53And one thing that kind of happens and gets in the way of this is a judgment.
- 55:58And so we may have judgments about people who are different from us.
- 56:02We may have judgments against opposing counsel who make arguments or demands we don't like.
- 56:07We may have judgments against the parties that we're working against based on something
- 56:10they did.
- 56:12And one of the things is I'm not trying to take your judgments away or tell you you're
- 56:16wrong.
- 56:17But when we are in a place of judgment, it can create stress.
- 56:21And if you pay attention, it often doesn't feel good.
- 56:25And so one of the things that can come up is that you may need to be effective in your
- 56:31practice to learn how to moderate that judgment.
- 56:35I have done a case before where I had to cross examine a difficult opposing party.
- 56:41And in preparation for that, I actually did loving kindness meditation where I sent them
- 56:47good wishes because I wanted to be stable and not come into this with real, I didn't
- 56:54want to look aggressive in the approach.
- 56:57And it really helped me.
- 56:58So one quick practice is just like me remembering that that is a human being just like you.
- 57:05So the opposing party makes the settlement demand that I think is ridiculous.
- 57:09And instead of that judgment place, I instead tell myself that opposing counsel is an aggressive
- 57:16advocate for their client just like me.
- 57:19That opposing counsel demands things that they think their client is entitled to just
- 57:23like me.
- 57:25And it's something that just helps remind you of the humanity of the person you're dealing
- 57:30with.
- 57:31It can work in context outside of law practice as well.
- 57:35And you can also do this for yourself.
- 57:38So the best, the just like me version of common humanity for yourself is the best friend test.
- 57:46So when you make a mistake, and I'm sure none of the lawyers on this call have ever made
- 57:50a mistake, but if you did, you know, if you did.
- 57:53How would you treat with your best friend with that mistake?
- 57:57How would you talk to your best friend who didn't understand something well enough or
- 58:02didn't write the brief good enough or didn't get the result that you know, you wanted in
- 58:07the case?
- 58:08How would you talk to them?
- 58:10And I bet it's a lot different than how we normally kind of talk to ourselves.
- 58:15So again, self-compassion is something that can take some years and some time and effort,
- 58:20but it is something that really makes a big difference.
- 58:23And the answer in this one you guys did great.
- 58:26Yes, self-compassion, it is false.
- 58:30Self-compassion is not just about warm and soft emotions towards oneself, although cultivating
- 58:34that is part of it and can help.
- 58:37Self-compassion is really much more, and these are the elements of it here.
- 58:41It's about noticing that you're having a hard time.
- 58:44It's about recognizing that your hard time is part of the human experience, and it's
- 58:50about giving yourself what you need.
- 58:53And so these are really the steps for self-compassion, and it can really be as simple as saying,
- 58:59this is hard, and recognizing that your difficulty is part of a human experience and one that
- 59:07lawyers and people across the world experience, and then giving yourself the support you need.
- 59:13These are the elements of self-compassion as defined by Kristin Neff, and you can study
- 59:18a whole lot more about this, and I've got more about this as well if anyone needs it,
- 59:23they want to reach out.
- 59:25I am about out of time, but if you do want more, if you want to try meditation, I'm in
- 59:30a group called the Mindfulness and Law Society, and we do free virtual sits twice a week.
- 59:37So feel free to join those.
- 59:38If you Google Mindfulness and Law Society, virtual sits, you can find it, but if you
- 59:43can't, I've got my email next and you can reach out and find more.
- 59:48I also, if you want to learn more, the book is How to Be a Badass Lawyer, which talks
- 59:53about mindfulness and compassion and how meditation can support that, and I have all
- 59:58kinds of stuff, many of which is free, free downloads and meditations and blog posts on
- 1:00:04the blog, Brilliant Legal Mind.
- 1:00:07And this week I actually talked about heart-based practices, including compassion, so feel free
- 1:00:13to check that out and follow.
- 1:00:15And if you need anything more, find me on LinkedIn, send me a message, or email me at
- 1:00:20C Parsons at Rick or Graydon.
- 1:00:23Thanks everyone for being here.
- 1:00:26I don't think I got any questions, but feel free to reach out if you need anything else.
- 1:00:33You may be eligible for CLE credit in your state.
- 1:00:36Visit bhba.org slash podcasts for more information.