Latest / The Climate Resilience Podcast / Creating resilient landscapes: What happens when we work with nature?
Transcript
- 0:02Phil Emonson: Hello and welcome to the Climate Resilience Podcast brought to you by JBA Consulting.
- 0:07Phil Emonson: I'm Phil Emonson, and in this podcast series, we unpick some of the complexities, challenges, and opportunities on the topic of climate resilience with some inspirational thought leaders.
- 0:17Phil Emonson: Whether you're working on local adaptation projects, planning for climate risk, or simply looking for hope backed by science, you're in the right place.
- 0:25Phil Emonson: If you enjoy these conversations, be sure to follow the podcast and subscribe wherever you listen.
- 0:30Phil Emonson: Share with your friends and colleagues too, anyone interested in building a more resilient future.
- 0:35Phil Emonson: Now, let's jump into today's episode.
- 0:38Phil Emonson: Climate change is increasingly bringing pressure to the landscapes, the ecosystems, and the communities that we value most.
- 0:47Phil Emonson: Today I'm joined by Ben Eardley from the National Trust to discuss how one of the UK's largest landowners is responding to these climate pressures, progressing with ecological development, and helping to drive the broader systems changes that we need to achieve long-term resilient landscapes.
- 1:04Phil Emonson: We'll discover what happens when we stop trying to control landscapes, but really work with them.
- 1:09Phil Emonson: And it's going to be a great conversation.
- 1:11Phil Emonson: So, Ben, welcome to the podcast.
- 1:12Phil Emonson: It's super to have you with me this morning.
- 1:14Phil Emonson: Perhaps you could start by introducing yourself.
- 1:17Ben Eardley: Yeah, thanks, Phil.
- 1:18Ben Eardley: So, yeah, Ben Eardley, I am, what do they call me now?
- 1:21Ben Eardley: I'm a nature recovery project manager for the National Trust.
- 1:25Ben Eardley: So that basically means I sit across a number of landscape scale projects.
- 1:29Ben Eardley: Um, everything from river restoration to landscape recovery schemes to um manage coastal realignment.
- 1:35Ben Eardley: So I do lots of that restoration conservation kind of work, but at a landscape scale, really, that's my focus.
- 1:43Phil Emonson: Excellent.
- 1:44Phil Emonson: Well, look, we've got a lot to go at this morning, um, lots of potential avenues, and really looking forward to just getting into it.
- 1:51Phil Emonson: Um, the place I'd like to start is um, as we have done on previous episodes of the podcast, actually, is just to start by exploring what pressures your um assets and estates are exposed to now with the impact of a changing climate.
- 2:08Phil Emonson: As I said in the introduction, the National Trust is one of the UK's largest landowners.
- 2:12Phil Emonson: So clearly um impacts being felt, and I would imagine particularly acutely this summer with all of the extreme heat and drought.
- 2:19Phil Emonson: So, yeah, what impacts are causing you greatest concern at the moment across the National Trust estate?
- 2:28Ben Eardley: So, from the the portfolio that I work within, so Somerset, I think the obvious thing to say is the natural environment.
- 2:34Ben Eardley: So I see that very markedly.
- 2:37Ben Eardley: So the impact on wildlife, the habitats that we manage, and the pressures that that puts the teams under that that manage those areas of land.
- 2:46Ben Eardley: So we manage a lot of protected landscape.
- 2:48Ben Eardley: So here at the Holnicote Estate, where I'm sat today, you know, we've got warmer temperate rainforest, we've got um upland heath at Dunkere, you know, all of those areas are suffering pressure due to global heating and the more extreme weather that we're seeing.
- 3:03Ben Eardley: And then the dialogue that we have with our tenant farmers, it's very clear that those businesses are under a lot of pressure this year with this historically dry weather, dry hot weather that we've seen, those farm businesses are uh are under a lot of pressure.
- 3:16Ben Eardley: And again, that that puts those, there's the the environmental impact of that, there's the economic impact of that, but then there's also the social impact of that as well.
- 3:24Ben Eardley: Um, so you see those guys are under a lot of pressure to keep those businesses going in the face of some really quite significant uh environmental pressures.
- 3:34Phil Emonson: And what you've just touched on there, actually, in terms of the social, the environmental and the and the financial impacts that you're seeing directly with tenant farmers is uh plays plays right in the conversations that we have on this podcast all the time about the very interconnected nature of um resilience and and building resilient landscapes, um, simply because of the very um dependent um uh and and multi- and cross-sectoral um dependencies that exist.
- 4:03Phil Emonson: Um this summer, as you have alluded to, we have seen record-breaking temperatures, um successive heat waves from late May, I think, and we're now in late August.
- 4:18Phil Emonson: Um and and and the temperature continues to be high.
- 4:23Phil Emonson: Um that has had an impact on the landscape, as you have alluded to, habitats, wildlife, um probably also water resources uh very acutely.
- 4:34Phil Emonson: Um what has that uh revealed to you working um in North Somerset at Holnicote, um, which we'll which we'll talk about, by the way, um, in terms of those in terms of those vulnerabilities to our landscape?
- 4:49Ben Eardley: Yeah, so I've seen it firsthand.
- 4:51Ben Eardley: So I live in North Devon, I I work in Somerset and just sort of moving across that Exmoor landscape, it's just really clear there's a, you know, we've got a lot of the same thing in regard to habitat and land management at the moment.
- 5:04Ben Eardley: There's there's a real kind of there's a real lack of variety.
- 5:07Ben Eardley: You haven't got this, you know, you haven't got a mosaic of habitats, which I think like very simply is probably what you want if you want to develop more resilience in the landscape, um, is is it's greater dynamic complexity.
- 5:21Ben Eardley: And what this long dry period has really revealed to me at Holniocte and elsewhere is that we we don't have that in the landscape at the moment.
- 5:29Ben Eardley: Um we haven't got that, you know, looking at the laws and principle, we haven't got bigger, better, more, more joined up.
- 5:34Ben Eardley: You know, we've got fragments of disconnected habitat, if you're thinking about natural habitats, but even then in the farmed landscape, I think historically it's very much been geared around still is, you know, food production and efficiency and going down a certain route and not necessarily building in resilience and adaptability.
- 5:55Ben Eardley: And I think with the more extreme weather that we're seeing, this flick-flacking of like very hot, very dry through to you know very wet.
- 6:02Ben Eardley: Um there's that there's that extreme flip-flacking in the weather, and and that's gonna get that's gonna that that's gonna be amplified in in the coming decades.
- 6:13Ben Eardley: And I don't think we're preparing for that with a landscape that's that's adapted and is able to cope.
- 6:21Phil Emonson: And again, we'll come back to that uh as as we move through this conversation, but really interesting in these sort of opening exchanges and and discussions just to get your thoughts on that.
- 6:30Phil Emonson: Um I'd I'd like to early on um pick up this point about Holnicote, right?
- 6:35Phil Emonson: Because we've mentioned it three or four times probably already.
- 6:38Phil Emonson: No, sorry.
- 6:39Phil Emonson: So this is this is great because it's a real um flagship, I I think, um, case study and exemplar of working with natural processes um across a large estate and land holding there.
- 6:53Phil Emonson: So tell me uh and and listeners then um what Hunica is, where it is, and and what it's achieving.
- 7:02Ben Eardley: Yeah, so it's the largest bit of contiguous land that the National Trust has got in the in the southwest.
- 7:08Ben Eardley: Um it's about 12,500 acres and is a mix of protected landscapes.
- 7:15Ben Eardley: So I've already mentioned um, you know, Horn of Wood, we've got we've got the Upland Heath, we've got Triple S I salt marsh.
- 7:22Ben Eardley: So, you know, sort of over half of the landscape is protected landscape.
- 7:26Ben Eardley: So it's you know, it's it we have have to manage, we we have a responsibility to look after that land and manage it to a certain condition.
- 7:33Ben Eardley: Um, and and and so we're quite hamstrung in that regard.
- 7:37Ben Eardley: And then the rest is a mixture of you know, tenant farmland and and and in hand land.
- 7:43Ben Eardley: So that that's land that we own and manage.
- 7:45Ben Eardley: And from a river catchment point of view, we own most of two river catchments, the Aller and the Horner.
- 7:52Ben Eardley: And so historically, that's led to Holnicote being uh yeah, I think I'd say at the forefront of thinking about how we manage rivers in a different way.
- 8:03Ben Eardley: Uh so JBA were involved in the early days of the Source to Sea project, which is very much focused on mitigating the impacts of flood, so extreme weather of a kind.
- 8:13Ben Eardley: And that was the early days of NFM natural flood management and schemes to address that.
- 8:20Ben Eardley: And and and our thinking at Holnicote has evolved with, I guess, the thinking um around river restoration.
- 8:27Ben Eardley: And where we are now is where I'm at is that trying to connect more the terrestrial and aquatic um systems, ecosystems.
- 8:36Ben Eardley: So, in a basic sense, just just just reversing historical drainage, reconnecting that water with the landscape and creating wetland and and linking that to the wider landscape management, to the management of that farm, those protected landscapes, and integrating it as as much as I can.
- 8:53Ben Eardley: Um, and that's why I think Holnicote gets a reasonable amount of publicity is because we're able to effect change at scale, but also monitor it.
- 9:02Ben Eardley: You know, we've got well over 15 years of monitoring, you know, hydrological and ecological, so we can look at the data and pick out trends about how the application of those nature-based solutions has impacted those ecosystems and those physical processes.
- 9:18Phil Emonson: I had um I had the luxury probably a decade ago now of visiting Holnicote with um probably one of your predecessors there, Nigel Hester.
- 9:28Phil Emonson: Um it was a great day.
- 9:31Phil Emonson: And uh it certainly in those very early days of of the work JBA were doing there, but it's great to see um the the the landscape, um, the wetlands, the the restoration of those natural um courses.
- 9:46Phil Emonson: And looking at photographs online um as I'm doing right now, it looks lush, it looks green, it looks connected during a period of, as I look out of my window, a very dry and parched landscape uh and very brown.
- 10:02Phil Emonson: And I'm sure the surrounding countryside in North Devon, um North Somerset is um is that same colour at the moment.
- 10:09Phil Emonson: So it an interesting case study, as you say, in terms of that that connectivity of the rivers and their natural um surrounding environments.
- 10:18Ben Eardley: Um yeah, just very just very quickly, just a shout out to Nigel because he's I've got a lot like Nigel, you know, set a lot of this in motion um, you know, a few years ago now.
- 10:27Ben Eardley: But Nigel is still involved, so he's now one of our beaver champions.
- 10:30Ben Eardley: So he works with us to uh to to to monitor um beaver activity and work as a local champion in the in in the community.
- 10:38Ben Eardley: So that's a that's a really nice story.
- 10:40Phil Emonson: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 10:42Phil Emonson: It's just just on this point then of this summer in particular and the very acute conditions that we're seeing, and we're already hearing that um the Met Office are forecasting that 27 will be the hottest year on record as a combination of um human-induced climate change, but also the El Nino effect superimposed on top of that.
- 11:02Phil Emonson: Um, we know that as as you have alluded to, that we're going to be facing um difficult decisions in in future and difficult years ahead.
- 11:12Phil Emonson: Um what what what have you learned, I suppose, locally at Holnicote this this year in particular, um, about how we can realistically then balance protection and restoration and adaptation during really acute conditions?
- 11:33Phil Emonson: Because you would have you would have thought that during a period like this, some something has to give, right?
- 11:38Phil Emonson: Um, so so what what what have you learned this year that you can then take into future years?
- 11:45Ben Eardley: I I think you've got to mainstream it.
- 11:47Ben Eardley: I think at the moment cost of conservation and restoration is quite niche.
- 11:50Ben Eardley: Yeah.
- 11:51Ben Eardley: So I think you you you you and I will know about Holnicote as a case study in this way, and it and it's great, right?
- 11:56Ben Eardley: But it's quite small in scale relatively.
- 11:58Ben Eardley: Um and unless we link in this, for want of a better term, like working with natural process, call it whatever you want, nature-based solutions, just giving nature and water and all of those kind of natural processes, a bit of space and a bit of time, that's got to be integrated with wider land management practices.
- 12:16Ben Eardley: Otherwise, we're doing the same thing, conservationists are doing the same thing and expecting different results.
- 12:22Ben Eardley: Farmers and other land managers are doing the same thing and expecting different results.
- 12:26Ben Eardley: And got to find a way of this approach becoming more mainstream, more business as usual.
- 12:32Ben Eardley: And I think for that to happen, government need to really start to understand the importance of it.
- 12:38Ben Eardley: Because what this summer showed me is government, the media jump on the it it all gets sort of polarized and sensationalized, you know.
- 12:46Ben Eardley: So it's all wildfires, climate change.
- 12:48Ben Eardley: And yeah, then when it starts to rain, our focus on that will die off and it'll be like flooding, rainfall, and it we sort of leaped from one extreme to the other, just like the climate's doing.
- 12:56Ben Eardley: And we need to find a way of of developing that that kind of more detailed, nuanced, uh perhaps like a little bit more boring, sort of middle ground, because that's where I think that's where the important work is to be done.
- 13:10Ben Eardley: And rather than you know, the right wing press, the left wing press talking about, you know, wildfires, um, rewilding causing wildfires or rewilding is the answer, you know, there's probably a sensible middle ground.
- 13:21Ben Eardley: And that's where the truth of it is.
- 13:24Ben Eardley: And and and I think that's what this summer has brought home to me is we need to make this thing part of how we manage the land, part of how we produce our food, and that's when you're going to scale it up and achieve some real change and develop that systems change and resilience.
- 13:38Phil Emonson: Brilliant.
- 13:39Phil Emonson: Um that resilience piece then is the place I'd like to go next.
- 13:44Phil Emonson: Um we have probably traditionally seen landscape management then as a function of agriculture and conservation.
- 13:56Phil Emonson: But now we talk about catchment resilience, and and you've already alluded to the interconnectivity of aquatic and terrestrial environments, the intrinsic role that water and wildlife play uh uh in that space.
- 14:09Phil Emonson: What does then um catchment resilience mean to you operating at the National Trust in practice?
- 14:19Ben Eardley: I think people understanding essentially mainly sort of fresh water, freshwater habitat, and and the role that that plays in the wider landscape.
- 14:29Ben Eardley: So I think again, even within the trust, river restoration water has been a side element of that wider landscape management.
- 14:37Ben Eardley: As and as one of the water advisors that I work with, Joe Neville always says, like water should be one of your first considerations when you're looking at how you manage the land.
- 14:46Ben Eardley: You know, it's it's integral to your soil health, you know, how your trees grow, how your sward develops, you know, the wildlife you're going to bring into sight.
- 14:54Ben Eardley: And I think understanding the context of that is is is really, really important.
- 15:00Ben Eardley: I think for me as well, it's about people often talk about restoration, and I'm not massively keen on that term because it it always speaks to restoring something that's been lost.
- 15:10Ben Eardley: And I think for me, it's about looking at the landscape you've got now, the climate that we've got now, and probably you know, are likely to have in the future and uh the other environmental factors, so the social and the economic factors you've got now, and then looking at the landscape you've got and saying, right, what's the best we can do with this now?
- 15:28Ben Eardley: Rather than you know, looking back with rose-tinted glasses and getting all romantic about you know ecosystems and habitats that we had and have lost, and we want to restore those.
- 15:36Ben Eardley: How can we best utilize the landscape, you know, functionally to deliver what we need now in terms of farming, but also in terms of um, you know, habitat for wildlife.
- 15:47Ben Eardley: Um, and and I think that's where not everyone might agree, but that's kind of where I'm at with it.
- 15:54Phil Emonson: That's really interesting.
- 15:55Phil Emonson: And and um just on that point about you know landscape and farming, resilience isn't just a the the above-ground bit, you know.
- 16:02Phil Emonson: It we we we had um Professor Jack Gilbert on the podcast earlier in the year.
- 16:07Phil Emonson: He was one of the leading um soil experts globally.
- 16:11Phil Emonson: It's a fabulous conversation.
- 16:13Phil Emonson: But I remember talking to him and and and asking him um, you know, what does a resilient soil look like?
- 16:18Phil Emonson: And he said it looks like a sponge.
- 16:19Phil Emonson: Yeah.
- 16:20Phil Emonson: And um uh, you know, it has the capacity to almost live and breathe and and absorb, um, but really work um with the above-ground environment beautifully.
- 16:34Phil Emonson: Um, and it's a really good episode, actually.
- 16:36Phil Emonson: I'd recommend go back and have a have a listen to that one.
- 16:39Phil Emonson: And um, just coming back to that point.
- 16:40Phil Emonson: Oh, that's just just to jump on that.
- 16:42Ben Eardley: So I would wholeheartedly agree.
- 16:43Ben Eardley: And that's that thinking outside of the channel, thinking outside of your you know, typical wetlands.
- 16:47Ben Eardley: So Holly Purdy, who's one of the brilliant tenant farmers that we worked with when everyone last week was getting excited about those pictures of the wetlands.
- 16:54Ben Eardley: Holly was sort of, we we had her, she was in the press release, she gave us a quote, which is amazing.
- 16:57Ben Eardley: But her point was that on her farm, you know, even outside of the areas that were typically wet, because she's managed her sward in a slightly different way, you know, she's organic, extensive grazing, you know, native breeds.
- 17:09Ben Eardley: Uh actually her grazing was still pretty good, and her soil condition is still pretty good because she's she's managing that, she's managing it for that, you know.
- 17:18Ben Eardley: So her focus isn't just on it, is on quality produce, but her key drivers are soil health and the uh quality and diversity of a support and the wildlife is a is a key indicator of that.
- 17:33Ben Eardley: So for her, that that farm is a you know is an ecosystem and that's the way she approaches it.
- 17:38Ben Eardley: So that's that taking that wider view, you know, looking at landscape management in the round and putting nature sort of at sounds a bit a bit fluffy, but at the heart of what you're doing, you know, see nature as critical infrastructure and critical to the success of those farm businesses.
- 17:53Ben Eardley: And I think that's where, sort of broadly speaking, there's a bit of a disconnect at the moment because it's it's it's seen as sort of a an add-on, whereas it should be central.
- 18:03Phil Emonson: Yeah, yeah.
- 18:03Phil Emonson: And that's a beautiful segue actually into where I was thinking of taking this next, which is uh have we spent, do we spend too much time focused investment trying to solve siloed individual problems rather than at that system's attachment landscape scale, where actually we see you know more um you know systemic problems or we're able to address things in a more holistic way.
- 18:33Phil Emonson: Um I don't know what your thoughts are on that.
- 18:35Ben Eardley: Yes, and I would say we what we tend to do is we take already complicated issues and we tend to make them more complicated, even if you're just looking at from a conservation point of view.
- 18:44Ben Eardley: Um, and I think there's a lot of focus on sort of exemplar projects and um you know, sort of one-offs.
- 18:49Ben Eardley: And I think what we need what we need to be doing is focusing on the basics.
- 18:52Ben Eardley: You know, like a good sports team, you they always say, you know, focus on just doing the basics well, you know, like repeating that over and over again, and that's that that's your foundation for a successful sports team.
- 19:03Ben Eardley: Um, and I think for conservation and land management, we need to focus on that as well, and focus on what are the sort of the core things we need to do, just generally across the board to build a really solid foundation of resilient land management.
- 19:17Ben Eardley: And that's something that you know, sort of some key simple foundations that conservationists, farmers, whoever can agree on.
- 19:23Ben Eardley: And that's kind of your starter for 10, and then you build on that.
- 19:27Ben Eardley: Um, and I think until we get there, until until also we simplify the at the moment you've got you talked about people being siloed, and we in terms of the regulatory system of those organizations involved in conservation and land management, you know, you've got Natural England, DEFRA, the Forestry Commission, the Environment the Environment Agency, and to make anything happen on the ground is hugely complicated at the moment and time consuming.
- 19:49Ben Eardley: Even for an organization like the National Trust that can throw a bit of resource at it.
- 19:52Ben Eardley: You know, imagine if you're a you know a small-scale farmer with a you know a relatively small land holding, how are you gonna get your head around it?
- 19:59Ben Eardley: You know, you want to make a difference in terms of climate change and resilience in your business, but it's hugely complicated at the moment.
- 20:04Ben Eardley: You know, we've we've got to, and I know it sounds very trite, but we've got to simplify it, we've got to make this stuff easier to do and more cost-effective to do at scale.
- 20:12Ben Eardley: Um, otherwise, I think we're we're just expecting doing the same thing over again and expecting different results is crazy.
- 20:19Phil Emonson: And and and I will bring you back to what do we need to do to make those changes happen?
- 20:23Phil Emonson: Um, uh, because I think that's a really interesting conversation.
- 20:27Phil Emonson: Um, so we'll we'll we'll return to that one, don't worry.
- 20:29Phil Emonson: Um just before we move on, um at JBA, the outcome, the output rather, from from all the work that we do across all our many different disciplines improves resilience to people, place, assets, landscapes, and organizations.
- 20:46Phil Emonson: Right, those are our sort of five pillars of resilience.
- 20:49Phil Emonson: Um I'm really interested to understand, probably from the the Holnicote uh example, but elsewhere as well from your experience.
- 20:58Phil Emonson: What evidence do you see that investing in um I'll use that word restoring, but restoring ecosystem function can improve resilience to people and and place and provide those benefits at catchment scale?
- 21:16Phil Emonson: You know, what what are you what evidence are you seeing?
- 21:19Ben Eardley: So I think this there's there's two aspects to that for me.
- 21:22Ben Eardley: The first is the physical data that we've got to demonstrate that this approach works.
- 21:26Ben Eardley: So we work with a few academic institutions, University of Exeter, Nottingham University, Hume University.
- 21:33Ben Eardley: So we've got hard data to show that the interventions that we're undertaking at scale are fundamentally reducing downstream flood risk for communities.
- 21:43Ben Eardley: You know, we've knocked well over 40% off the flood peak through these river systems.
- 21:48Ben Eardley: We've increased the lag time through the system significantly, we've knocked uh 40% off uh dubility downstream, we've raised groundwater levels significantly, uh, all the Ecological indicators are trending upward in terms of fish numbers, aquatic inverts, you know, biodiversity and abundance.
- 22:09Ben Eardley: This approach of developing interconnected wetland at scale has a significant positive impact on delivering multiple benefits for local communities and wider communities, like we've got the data to back that up.
- 22:24Ben Eardley: And I think we're also showing now that it also can benefit local farmers in terms of providing, you know, diverse grazing, you know, throughout the year.
- 22:37Ben Eardley: So we've been working with some of our tenant farmers to graze these different areas of habitat, and it's it's providing them with a different way of utilising the landscape for their livestock, and that seems to be going really well.
- 22:49Ben Eardley: And then I think the other element of me, the other element of this for me is the um the impact on the local community in terms of how the landscape feels and how people are interacting with it.
- 23:03Ben Eardley: And I think for me, the last few years, as we're seeing a more nature-rich landscape, um, we are seeing the local community get much more involved with that and the and wider community so visitors and and engage with it.
- 23:16Ben Eardley: And there's uh there's like a feel good to it, you know.
- 23:20Ben Eardley: So people have got really involved with um, you know, the beaver uh project and the wild release, but also, you know, we're just seeing with with all of this habitat going in, you know, we're seeing a wider variety of easily um easy to view wildlife.
- 23:36Ben Eardley: So we've had white stalks, cranes, we've had the white-tailed eagles here, and you people are engaging with that, and I think it makes them feel good about their local landscape.
- 23:44Ben Eardley: Um, and so for that, that that is a that for me is a is another knock-on positive impact is is that people re-engaging with their landscape and and and and and seeing it in a new way.
- 23:56Ben Eardley: And and I think feeling invested in it, and I think that's fundamentally important.
- 23:59Ben Eardley: You know, you talk about that systems change.
- 24:01Ben Eardley: I think people have got to feel invested in the landscape and part of it, and then they will they are more likely to be involved in wanting to create a positive change.
- 24:10Ben Eardley: And that goes for the farmers as well, I think, is if if they're part of it and driving it, then it helps to overcome those, you know, those the the the cultural barriers to managing the landscape in a different way.
- 24:24Phil Emonson: That's brilliant, yeah.
- 24:25Phil Emonson: So so local communities not only benefiting in terms of um reduced flood peak downstream and increased um lag time, giving them better time to respond um and plan, but also that experience that they're having with the landscape and that investment, because yeah, as you say, it's creating a nice environment for them to visit or or or work in, um, and lots of interconnected multiple benefits.
- 24:58Phil Emonson: Um we have spoken then quite a bit about um there needs to be some wholesale systems changes because actually what you're doing up there um uh at Harneco is is a relatively, you know, it's a it's a it's a great case study, but it's a relatively small um, you know, um uh um case study in in geographical extent.
- 25:26Phil Emonson: So what we really want to see is more of that impact at scale.
- 25:31Phil Emonson: So the question is, you know, how do we make those wholesale systems changes that that will allow us to do that and replicate the success of Honiko in lots of different environments?
- 25:40Phil Emonson: So there will be plenty of barriers to that large-scale transformation.
- 25:46Phil Emonson: Um, you have alluded to some of them in terms of the fragmented nature of our um um uh legislative frameworks.
- 25:56Phil Emonson: Um, but what other what other barriers um exist at the moment, maybe in terms of policy or funding um legislation, etc.
- 26:06Ben Eardley: I mean funding's always very piecemeal, isn't it?
- 26:09Ben Eardley: So you you lurch from one bit of funding to the next and and trying to keep and try and keep some continuity and momentum.
- 26:16Ben Eardley: I think the easiest win there, I say easiest win, it's not easy at all, is I I think there's been an attempt to revamp the agri-environment schemes and incorporate sort of working with nature as a part of those.
- 26:32Ben Eardley: But but for me, it's still that still feels quite fragmented as you've got um you've got certain government agencies uh administering that and it's not necessarily connected with others.
- 26:44Ben Eardley: So you know, you've got you've you've got natural england doing one bit, the environment agency doing another bit, you know, forestry commission doing another bit.
- 26:50Ben Eardley: And I think if you're gonna create like farmers are amazing at creating and managing change in the landscape, right?
- 26:57Ben Eardley: So they're they're if we're talking about that wide that that wider level, you know, there are other stakeholders as well, but if you want to affect large-scale change, we are we need to get the farming community involved and delivering this stuff.
- 27:12Ben Eardley: And it has got to be made easier for those guys to access agro-environment schemes that that enable and deliver this change.
- 27:22Ben Eardley: Because any any any any any kind of land management is subsidized, isn't it, really?
- 27:26Ben Eardley: So you just need to government needs to think about what they're subsidizing and why.
- 27:30Ben Eardley: And and and it needs to be easy for these guys to understand the benefits of doing it or not doing it, and then easier for them to access and deliver.
- 27:40Ben Eardley: Because at the moment it's it's quite onerous.
- 27:43Phil Emonson: Yeah, yeah.
- 27:43Phil Emonson: So so just making the whole the whole process.
- 27:46Phil Emonson: I was sort of gonna ask, well, what's stopping that at the moment?
- 27:49Phil Emonson: But it is it is just the complexity of um dealing with so many different stakeholders, so many different consents, permits, yeah.
- 27:56Ben Eardley: So so if you're so so say if you were a farmer that wanted to deliver some wetland on their land, and it wasn't even main river, it's ordinary water course, you're probably gonna need a land train's consent.
- 28:04Ben Eardley: So that's your you know that that's that's probably your um your your local authority.
- 28:10Ben Eardley: Um you you you you're gonna need to, you might you might need to do some um some ecological works, you might need to get um natural England involved.
- 28:18Ben Eardley: Um you might need planning consent if the amount of earth you're moving is above a certain amount.
- 28:22Ben Eardley: Um and I think more of this stuff needs to be permitted development.
- 28:27Ben Eardley: You know, certain stuff is permitted is agricultural permitted development.
- 28:30Ben Eardley: I think, you know, some of these more simple restoration interventions, applications, call them whatever you want, need to be permitted development and just made easier for both farmers and NGOs to deliver.
- 28:43Ben Eardley: Because at the moment it is um it's not unless you know what you're doing, and quite often unless you know who the right people are to talk to, then it can be very difficult to deliver.
- 28:56Ben Eardley: I often say that a lot of the work we've got done at Hunuker is um is delivered despite the system, and it's because we've worked with people that are willing to work in the grey areas, you know, and and just help us navigate that morass of you know bureaucracy and process that's in place at the moment.
- 29:14Ben Eardley: And that sounds really negative, but if if you do want to achieve um change at scale, there needs to be a revamp of the system.
- 29:23Ben Eardley: You can't just keep ticking along with this with with a slightly tweaked revamped um regulatory and funding framework and expect different results, you know.
- 29:32Phil Emonson: And our government listening.
- 29:35Ben Eardley: Uh, I think if if if I'm perfectly frank, we have I have had lots of conversations with senior executives from various organizations at Holnicote, and I think people at a strategic level get it.
- 29:48Ben Eardley: Yeah.
- 29:48Ben Eardley: I don't think that change in process or approach makes it down to officer level on the ground because when you you're still dealing with you know a lot of delay and rigmarole and bureaucratic process when, say, you're putting in a FRAP application or a planning application, and it it's you you're almost starting from scratch every single time.
- 30:11Ben Eardley: Um but but a lot of a lot of good stuff is getting done.
- 30:16Ben Eardley: But like I say, that's getting done despite the system, yeah, not because of it.
- 30:20Ben Eardley: But for me, that one of the most important things about this is the people, and I think conservationists can often focus on the process and the detail.
- 30:28Ben Eardley: But for me, again, the way you the way you achieve this systems change is good relationships, good communication, you know, developing that working practice across people at scale.
- 30:38Ben Eardley: And I think what's really evident to me in the UK is we have got lots of amazing people.
- 30:43Ben Eardley: So I think I think the people are there, the willingness to change is there.
- 30:47Ben Eardley: You just need the frameworks to support that and allow farmers and the NGOs to deliver.
- 30:52Phil Emonson: Yeah.
- 30:52Phil Emonson: So many of our episodes on this podcast have come back to exactly what we've just said effective partnership working.
- 30:59Phil Emonson: Yeah.
- 31:00Phil Emonson: And you know, breaking down traditional silos.
- 31:04Phil Emonson: Um there's there's that phrase that I I take from the Anthropy Conference that I'm a big uh fan of down in the Eden project at Cornwall, which is um leave your silo at the door.
- 31:16Phil Emonson: Um so uh yeah, everyone seems to have their thing, don't they, Phil?
- 31:23Ben Eardley: So everyone's like their bit of conservation they work off, their species that they're focused on.
- 31:27Ben Eardley: And I think because conservation's hard and restoration's hard, people get very like they get very focused on that and very entrenched.
- 31:34Ben Eardley: And I think just as we would like, say, the farming community to to be a bit more sort of open-minded, a bit more, you know, look up and and and take in the wider picture, I I think that can also be said for the the conservation and restoration sector as well.
- 31:49Phil Emonson: Yeah.
- 31:50Ben Eardley: And I think we need to to look up, like listen to others, like let's all just chill out a bit and think about how we affect that change at scale.
- 32:00Phil Emonson: So on that point then, um, if I invited you back on the podcast in 2036, because we'll still be going and it will be a hugely successful 10 years for the podcast, but if we were to sit down in 10 years' time, right, what would success, and I'm not I don't mean at Hunuker, I mean nationally, what would success look like?
- 32:23Phil Emonson: And and what do we need to do, you know, today to get us there in 10 years' time?
- 32:30Ben Eardley: Well, I th I think I I think I've already touched on what I think we need to get us there.
- 32:34Ben Eardley: We need to need to be a core part of how we produce our food and manage our land.
- 32:38Ben Eardley: And I think it needs to be seen as not a not an add-on, like people talk in terms of like nature-friendly farming, or but it, but it again it's sort of nature on the fringe.
- 32:48Ben Eardley: And I think uh the the natural environment, those um ecosystems on which we depend need to be a core part of those, of the way we produce our food.
- 32:59Ben Eardley: You know, soil health needs to be a you know a core sort of success indicator for our farming businesses rather than it just being dominated by yield um and those other sort of key metrics.
- 33:11Ben Eardley: And I I think for me, success would look like you know a much more nature-rich landscape, but within that farming landscape.
- 33:20Ben Eardley: So not just you know, sort of fragmented, disconnected, protected bits of habitat, but that being linked up through, you know, farms that are fundamentally managed differently, and that uh nature and increased ecosystem sort of function is a is is a core part of.
- 33:43Ben Eardley: That's what I think success would look like for me.
- 33:46Ben Eardley: And and and farmers that are talking passionately about those things, you know, regenerative farming again, not being seen as fringe, but but but and and and I think these I don't I think farmers are already thinking about this kind of thing, you know.
- 34:03Ben Eardley: I but I think they at the moment it is it is hard for them to encompass it within their business, like I say, because of those issues that we touched on before.
- 34:11Ben Eardley: So I think let's make it easier for those guys to to to be part of the conversation and be part of driving that systems change forward.
- 34:20Ben Eardley: And then I think in 10 years' time you could be in a situation whereby your farms and wider landscape management look very different.
- 34:28Phil Emonson: Um I'm gonna throw in the final question now, Ben.
- 34:31Phil Emonson: Um, I've really enjoyed this conversation, it's been it's been absolutely superb.
- 34:35Phil Emonson: Um our introduction to the podcast talks about hope backed by science.
- 34:41Phil Emonson: So what gives you hope?
- 34:44Phil Emonson: Um, what gives you hope that we can make the changes that we need to see to create those nature-rich landscapes that you've alluded to, those resilient landscapes, that we can achieve that in in future.
- 34:57Phil Emonson: And I know you've you've you've alluded to some of those um green shoots and those great case studies that you're seeing.
- 35:04Phil Emonson: What is it that gives you hope day today?
- 35:07Ben Eardley: I think the thing, because working in the environment sector is not easy, hey.
- 35:11Ben Eardley: Um, but the thing that gives me hope is how quickly things can recover.
- 35:16Ben Eardley: And I'm not a very patient person, but it's one of the reasons I love working in you know, waterscapes, wetlands, freshwater habitat, cooler, whatever you want, is is is is how quickly if you if you if you create a pond or you reconnect a river with its floodplain, or you um uh or a beaver um uh create creates a wetland, damn, dams a river, the pace at which other wildlife utilize that and you start to see you know that ecosystem, you know, evolve and change.
- 35:50Ben Eardley: And you know, that you create a pond the next day you've got aquatic inverts, and then you know, it's if you give nature a bit of space and a bit of time, you know, it it it it it it delivers for us.
- 36:03Ben Eardley: You know, like I heard it sounds really fluffy, but I can't remember where I heard it.
- 36:06Ben Eardley: But a few weeks ago I I heard about like somebody said um nature, the natural world, it's like in terms of what it provides for us, it is the very definition of unconditional love.
- 36:16Ben Eardley: You know, it does all of this stuff like for nothing and it and it and it benefits us as a as a species, a civilization, as a society.
- 36:26Ben Eardley: And I think if we just give it a bit of space and a bit of time, you know, it it it'll let's not overthink it.
- 36:35Ben Eardley: You know, that that's generally all that we need to do.
- 36:37Ben Eardley: And uh I think that there will be significant positive change.
- 36:41Ben Eardley: And it would those things that you know you're focusing on on this podcast, say, you know, climate resilience.
- 36:46Ben Eardley: But I think that's the fun that that's that's the fundamental aspect of it, is um, you know, the natural world's there, it's is it's willing to do the heavy lifting for us.
- 36:55Ben Eardley: We just need to to give it the tools to enable it to do it.
- 36:58Phil Emonson: And what a place to finish.
- 37:00Phil Emonson: Ben, I'd like to congratulate you on all the amazing work that you're doing at Holnicote and the and the successes um that you're seeing there.
- 37:08Phil Emonson: Um, it's been a super, super conversation this morning.
- 37:11Phil Emonson: Um, thanks for coming on the podcast.
- 37:14Phil Emonson: Thanks, Phil.
- 37:15Phil Emonson: So we've reached the end of our time today.
- 37:19Phil Emonson: If you've enjoyed listening, please hit the subscribe button so you're ready for our next episode in a month's time.
- 37:24Phil Emonson: And if you'd like to support the show, consider sharing it with others or leaving us a short review wherever you're listening.
- 37:31Phil Emonson: It really helps more people to discover and enjoy the podcast.
- 37:34Phil Emonson: Thanks for joining us.
- 37:35Phil Emonson: I'm Phil Emonson, and you've been listening to the Climate Resilience Podcast brought to you by JBA Consulting.
- 37:44Ben Eardley: If you give nature a bit of space and a bit of time, it delivers for us.