Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul Podcast #3 - The Electoral College and Contingent Elections
Transcript
- 0:02Hello.
- 0:02Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast with your host, Hall Raider, non partisan
- 0:08political analyst.
- 0:09Today, we're
- 0:10gonna talk about the presidential election,
- 0:13you know, the thing that's coming up just around the corner, because I have other offices
- 0:18up for grabs, but we're gonna talk specifically about the presidential election.
- 0:23And, more specifically, the electoral college and contingent elections, More on that in a
- 0:30minute.
- 0:31To be president, you have to win 270 electoral votes.
- 0:35There's 538 of them, and you have to win a majority to win the presidency.
- 0:40If you don't win the majority or a majority, We'll go to what's called a contingent
- 0:46election, which is where the US House of Representatives decides the election.
- 0:51It's not that simple, but before we get to that, let's talk a little bit about the
- 0:55electoral college.
- 0:56Let's say It concept is sort of confusing to, well, even to people that are more seasoned, in
- 1:05politics.
- 1:06A lot of it that that, that, the really nooks and crannies of it and all that I've only just
- 1:10recently learned,
- 1:11but let's talk about what
- 1:12the electoral college exactly is.
- 1:14It's not actually called as such in the US constitution, but it is what actually decides
- 1:21our elections.
- 1:22We go by state and whatever the popular vote Whoever, whichever candidate wins the popular
- 1:28vote of that state, they get the electoral votes.
- 1:32Now, usually, the electoral votes, and the popular vote choose the same candidates.
- 1:37The proportion of the votes might not be the same.
- 1:39Someone who might win a lot more of the electoral college votes, a a higher percentage
- 1:45of the electoral college votes compared to the popular election, or it might be a little bit
- 1:50closer.
- 1:52But there are a few cases where the popular vote Did not or the electoral college did not
- 1:59pick the same owner as who would have won if it was a straight up direct election where it was
- 2:04just whoever won the most popular votes won.
- 2:08And though, like, specifically there's 5 in them.
- 2:11And so the first one, we go to 18 24, which we'll we'll talk a little bit more about,
- 2:17later, but, we had non Quincy Adams, son of John Adams, who went up against Andrew Jackson,
- 2:24and it was a fairway race.
- 2:26And, again, a
- 2:28little bit more about that later, but, John Quincy Adams won over Andrew Jackson with a lot
- 2:35of controversy that wasn't necessarily about the electoral college itself.
- 2:40But, again, more on that later.
- 2:42In 18 76, during the reconstruction era after the civil war reconstruction being the direct
- 2:53era after the civil war trying to rebuild the south.
- 2:57And in 18 76, there was a lot of controversy as to whether Rutherford Bee Hayes or Samuel
- 3:03Tildan Hayes being the Republican, Tilton being the Democrat as to who actually won the
- 3:10election.
- 3:10And so the both party's arrogant, and the Democrats agreed to let Rutherford B.
- 3:17Hayes be elected president, loud Republicans agreed to end reconstruction in the south.
- 3:22And then Democrats who used to who hadn't had a strong grip on the south beforehand before the
- 3:29civil war or during the civil war, And Republicans took a lot of that power.
- 3:34They're on the reconstruction era.
- 3:36Democrats had started
- 3:36to take it back slowly,
- 3:38or, actually, not slowly, rather quickly.
- 3:42And then in 18 88, we had Benjamin Harrison, great grants, or grandson, excuse me, of
- 3:48William Henry Harrison, who was a president for a month, and he defeated Cleveland without
- 3:55winning the popular election.
- 3:56And then, you know, rematch over Cleveland beat Jim and Harrison, then Cleveland became the
- 4:02only nonconsecutive or the only president to serve 2 nonconsecutive terms in an office.
- 4:09Donald Trump has the opportunity to
- 4:11do that in 2024.
- 4:13We'll see how that goes.
- 4:15Then in 2000, which was probably, the most infamous, example of
- 4:25the popular vote winner not winning the electoral college was Thornton Avenue Butch
- 4:29over Albergh.
- 4:30My state foreman had in particular a controversy with what they called hanging
- 4:35chads, recently trying to determine the, at the time of his whole punching
- 4:41smarts and They they had to determine who exactly the whole punches were for because they
- 4:48weren't exactly on the, circles for the candidates.
- 4:55That's the basic gist of it.
- 4:57But they were trying
- 4:57to figure out the letter's intention and eventually the civil Supreme Court rule in
- 5:03favor of George W.
- 5:05Birth.
- 5:06He won the electoral votes for Florida and won the overall election.
- 5:12And then the most recent example being 2016 were Donald Trump defeated Hillary Clinton,
- 5:18but, he did not win the dealer vote either.
- 5:24So with the electoral college, what it's not just simple.
- 5:30Whoever wins the popular vote of a state gets those electoral college votes.
- 5:36What happens is the electoral colleges represented by electors.
- 5:39And is a 2 part process.
- 5:411, the for the first part, potential electors are chosen by each state's political parties.
- 5:47And then the second part is voters choose the presidential candidates and no veterans are
- 5:52also thereby technically choosing those state electors who would then officially vote for
- 6:00that presidential candidate.
- 6:02Now those names for those electors may or may not appear on the ballot.
- 6:05None of those presidential candidates depends on the state's laws.
- 6:08There's no constitutional provision or federal law that says these electors have to choose the
- 6:14candidate who won the popular vote of that state.
- 6:17Now, SCOTUS also ruled, a while ago that the constitution does not Rexire, these electors
- 6:24can be completely free to choose a candidate either.
- 6:27So local parties and and often do require these electors to sign pledges to vote for these
- 6:34party's nominees.
- 6:36Now with these electors still decide to choose somebody else, these are what we call Safeless
- 6:42electors.
- 6:43Many of these state laws have ways to punish them.
- 6:46Might be a fine, or they might just get replaced the might get disqualified from being
- 6:51an elector and then replaced with somebody else.
- 6:55The way we determine the electoral college votes by state is that it's equal to or each
- 7:02state, it's equal to the number of US house representatives and US senators each state has.
- 7:08So you would, on a minimum, have 3 electoral college votes because every state gets 2
- 7:14senators and at least one US house rep, US house reps are based on the state population,
- 7:21US Senate was meant to be an even number for each state.
- 7:27And all about a couple of caveats there is that ethnic state except Maine and Nebraska is a
- 7:32winner take all system at Maine and Nebraska.
- 7:35There's 2 electoral votes that go to whichever candidate wins the overall popular vote of
- 7:40those states, but you've got an extra one for each one of the districts that you win popular
- 7:47vote of as well.
- 7:49So like what happened in 2020, Donald Trump
- 7:52won the overall popular vote of Nebraska, but he won or
- 7:58he, but he won only 1 2 of the 3 Districts popular votes.
- 8:04Nebraska 2 actually voted for Joe Biden, so Joe Biden actually got 1 electoral vote from
- 8:10Nebraska while Donald Trump got four of them.
- 8:14And then DC, even though it's not a state, also gets 3 electors, a little more on that, sooner.
- 8:21But as for the evolution of the electoral college, number of electoral college votes in
- 8:2717 89, which was the first presidential election.
- 8:30George Washington was for all intents and purposes not challenged for president, but
- 8:35there was only 69 electoral votes at that time.
- 8:39But Okay.
- 8:40Time, obviously, the number gets much bigger.
- 8:431852, it gets to 2 196, 1900, it gets to 447.
- 8:48And then since 1964, we've had 538, electoral votes because that's when DC, the first
- 8:56election that DC got,
- 9:013, electoral votes following the 23rd amendment.
- 9:06Speaking of those amendments, some of
- 9:08the amendments that directly impacted the electoral college and contingent elections,
- 9:12which were We're gonna get to, the 12th Amendment.
- 9:18So before the 12th Amendment, the electoral vote majority winner became president, the 2nd
- 9:25place we'll get her became vice president.
- 9:27There was no joint tickets where Wow.
- 9:32You were the president chose a vice presidential running mate, and then you voted
- 9:35for that ticket, that whole ticket.
- 9:39It was actually it's only had, you know, better still only got one vote, electrics, had 2.
- 9:49Yes.
- 9:50Electrical electrics, representing the electoral college got oh,
- 9:57No.
- 9:57I'm sorry.
- 9:58After the 12th amendment, which was in the early 1800s, electors then started to cast 2
- 10:05votes, one for president, one for vice president instead of every candidate running by
- 10:12themselves, and then the 2nd place investigator became the vice president.
- 10:16That's how several times we got, president of one party and then
- 10:21a vice president of another party happened with John Adamson Thomas Jefferson who were with
- 10:27friends and became political enemies and eventually became friends again, died on the
- 10:32same day.
- 10:34And so the with the 12th Amendment that was 18 forget exactly when, but
- 10:39I think that became into effect 1804.
- 10:42But with 12th Amendment, now president vice president were a distinct contest.
- 10:50And then we had the 20th amendment, which set new expiration and start dates for congress and
- 10:55president, moved the, inauguration date from March 4th to January 3rd, following the
- 11:04election, and the responsibility of contingent election was removed from that lame buck
- 11:10session of Congress when given to the newly elected Congress.
- 11:15And then in the 23rd, Amendment DC gets a number of electors equal to what they the
- 11:22number of com members of Congress, they would have done if they were a state.
- 11:27And, sorry, that's 3 electoral votes.
- 11:29It's been elect 3 electoral votes.
- 11:32Since this was implemented.
- 11:35And you've seen a lot of states, or some states that have greatly utilized or decreased in
- 11:43electoral college representation over the years.
- 11:46An example of a major increase was California when it became a state.
- 11:51It was only 4 electoral votes back at 1852, over the next 6 years, it skyrocketed up to 13.
- 11:59From 1912 to 1928 then became 22 in 1932.
- 12:05And then the last couple of decade, it's been 53, but this year, it'll be 52.
- 12:10It's the reason why being not because it got smaller In Populogent, it don't get smaller
- 12:16population, but the percentage of the overall
- 12:20merchant.
- 12:22The California's population as
- 12:24a percentage of the overall nation's population.
- 12:28Slightly decreased, so they lost 1 US House District.
- 12:33And, hence, they lost 1 electoral college vote.
- 12:37Flared was another, excuse me,
- 12:39Florida is another example where it slowly crept up until they post World War 2 population
- 12:45boom, it went up to 10 to 14 electoral votes or from 10 electoral votes in 1960 to 14 in 1964.
- 12:55And then now it's peaked with 30 in the news census.
- 13:01Other cases where there's been major decreases have been due.
- 13:05We're at 30 as much as 36 electoral votes in 1824, It peaked around, you know, it peaked at
- 13:1347, from 19 32 to 19 48.
- 13:18Then it'll have a shock drop off from 39 in 19 82, 34.
- 13:22In 1984, but now it's currently 26th.
- 13:25The new census drops another, like, borrowed vote from its numbers.
- 13:32And there's been an a couple of cases where there's been a major increase and then major
- 13:38decrease building the right for
- 13:39a while was becoming a really major,
- 13:46factor in the electoral college went from 11 electoral votes in 1860 to 6 or yeah.
- 13:54And then just to 16 electoral votes.
- 13:56The next presidential election peaked at 29 electoral votes from 1912 to 19 around 30.
- 14:06And now it's but now it's currently down to 19.
- 14:09It also lost, electoral vote, with the
- 14:11new census.
- 14:12Because every year every 10 years, the
- 14:17census leads to redistricting, which leads to different numbers of electoral college votes
- 14:23because percentage of these states early percentage of the overall populations that the
- 14:23state populations make up go up, go down.
- 14:35They might still stay about the same.
- 14:38This obviously just depends on
- 14:38how much states have have grown.
- 14:38You can still grow in population, but still lose an a a US House District and therefore an
- 14:52electoral carriage vote with your state whereas, but it doesn't grow at the same rate
- 14:53as, say, a
- 15:01Florida.
- 15:02Because Florida's had that post World War 2 population boom, and it's been going on since
- 15:07then.
- 15:09Now, finally, we're gonna put to these contingents elections.
- 15:13So house chooses the president and senate chooses the vice president.
- 15:20So so there's been talk about possibly contingent
- 15:23elections for president, but what you may not realize
- 15:23is that the vice president also gets to, although the vice
- 15:28president's the method for choosing
- 15:31the vice president is a lot simpler than the one for, for the president.
- 15:42Big caveat, though, is that for the president, it is the congressional delegation that is
- 15:49sworn in following the election, not the size of the winners, not the previous one.
- 15:54So the next Congress gets sworn in, and then they have to immediately do it by ballot.
- 16:01And, also, they choose among the 3 candidates with the most electoral votes each state as a
- 16:02credible, fast votes for a president.
- 16:11So state with multiple representatives will need to sum to a selective decision there.
- 16:16We can conduct an internal poll.
- 16:18It doesn't 2, 3, 4, whatever, states that only have one move as house rep, which are those
- 16:24really small states like, say, a Wyoming, I want to consult anybody.
- 16:28They can pass their vote.
- 16:30So it's not
- 16:31we straight up, straight up vote by each individual member of of the US House.
- 16:42It was not 435 with Revos because that's the number of US house reps that there are.
- 16:48It's actually 50 because each state counts as a single vote.
- 16:52So all the people in California All the US house reps in California won't vote.
- 16:58All the ones in Florida, one vote.
- 17:00Wyoming, one vote.
- 17:01Idaho, one vote.
- 17:03Doesn't matter the size of the state because that's just well, I mean, that's just how how
- 17:08it's set up, but they most vote immediately and by ballot.
- 17:12And if they don't get it resolved, by the time a resident would be inaugurated, the vice
- 17:17president serves as a president until it actually gets resolved.
- 17:21Now as for that vice president, how the senate system works is they choose among the 2
- 17:26candidates who receive the most electoral votes and then
- 17:29excuse me.
- 17:31Now each senator has a vote and majority of
- 17:34the senate is needed to win.
- 17:36So unlike with the house, they don't have to do it.
- 17:39And it's they're not told that they have to do it immediately and by ballot.
- 17:42So the one time it didn't happen, they did it by voice, though.
- 17:45We'll get to that,
- 17:46shortly.
- 17:47But like I said, with the house does not,
- 17:51like to present by inauguration date, which is January 20th.
- 17:55The vice president elect acts as president until an impasse is resolved.
- 18:00Oh, I should have mentioned before about the lame duck.
- 18:05Session
- 18:06of congress being moved from March 4th January 3rd.
- 18:08That is for congress, to get all, inaugurated.
- 18:12Hence, how they have that time frame for them to, cast a ballot for contingent election if
- 18:20the US house should need to do that.
- 18:23Now as for when we've seen contingent elections, or at least as we know it, It's post
- 18:3112th amendment.
- 18:33For present, we've only seen it once in 18 24.
- 18:37I mentioned it earlier, so the correct target of 18 24.
- 18:41We had the electoral votes split up amongst Andrew Jackson, John Quincy Adams, William
- 18:47Crawford, and Henry Clay.
- 18:50And, Henry Clay has a habit of pairing in a lot of major, debates and events in that time of
- 19:00American history in the early 19th century.
- 19:05So the story goes, clinically, is not proven, but it's suspected that this is what happened.
- 19:12So, Clay, I believe, was the 4th place vote getter.
- 19:16Andrew Jackson was first, John Quincy Adams was second, Mobetti won a majority of the electoral
- 19:23vote.
- 19:24So, Clay makes a deal with John Quincy Adams, although they both would deny this that with
- 19:30John Quincy Adams, the point in can replay as, an eye office in John Quincy's administration
- 19:39that He would influence the members of the US house who supported Henry Clay, he would
- 19:45convince them to vote for John Quincy Adams.
- 19:48Henry Clay at the time was the speaker of the house, so he real wielded considerable
- 19:53influence.
- 19:54And so when they came to cast ballots, they, the electoral or the US house reps that
- 20:05supported and replayed through their support to John Quincy Adams, John Quincy Adams, 113 of
- 20:12the 24 States, while Andrew Jackson only 17, and then Crawford only 14.
- 20:18And Soon after Henry Clay was appointed as the secretary of state in John Quincy Adams.
- 20:26Administration led to charges of corrupt Bargain, so it's often referred to as the
- 20:31correct market of 1824.
- 20:33And kinda hangs over to
- 20:36me Adam's term.
- 20:38And when leasing
- 20:4128 arrives, Andrew Jackson and John Quincy Adams, They oh, excuse me.
- 20:47Sorry.
- 20:49They become or that they have a rematch and Andrew Jackson beat some pretty handily.
- 20:57And so That was the one time we had a contingent election for president.
- 21:03For vice president, we had won in 18 36.
- 21:06So unlike the house, it is not required to be done by ballots or immediately, And in that
- 21:14case, they decided to do it by floats vote, and they did it by alphabetical order of senators'
- 21:19names, said, I support so and so, and the others would say, I support, whoever, And,
- 21:25Richard Mentor Johnson was elected pretty comfortably to be Martin Van Buren's president,
- 21:31Martin Van Buren, being the guy with those crazy mutton chops, crazy good mutton chops
- 21:36might I add.
- 21:38So it's been 200 years now since we had a contingent election per president and
- 21:44a 180 something for the vice president.
- 21:49So
- 21:51One might ask then it doesn't really beg the question, but one might ask, what's the
- 21:56possibility of seeing a contingent election in 2024?
- 22:00It could happen with a third party winning a state, though, That's very unlikely.
- 22:07A lot of times, a third party candidate gets hyped up and, but it never actually come close
- 22:14to, like, an 8 state.
- 22:16So you're it's probably gonna be the same thing with RFK, we we can talk about that, on another
- 22:22episode about RFK junior's chances, Robert, that that being Robert F Kennedy,
- 22:30as in the son of former presidential candidate, and he's her general Robert F Kennedy who was
- 22:38assassinated just like his brother, John
- 22:41F Kennedy, who was president back in the sixties, But he's he's he's not he's probably
- 22:49not going to win a state.
- 22:50We'll talk about that another time, but, theoretically, he could win a state.
- 22:57Let's
- 22:57there is a way where
- 23:00the for Kamala Harris and Donald Trump could lit an electoral college immediately at 269
- 23:09votes each, and then they would have to move to a contingent election.
- 23:15And I read about the possibility of this, several months ago back when it was Joe Biden,
- 23:21who was the Democratic nominee before he stepped down and Kamala Harris became the
- 23:26Democratic candidate or 2024.
- 23:31At in this scenario assumes that the states are the states that voted the same way they did in
- 23:392016 2020 where Meaning, if they voted in 2016 as for the Democrat, it'll be claimed in that
- 23:47case, and they also voted Democrat in 2020, or if they voted Donald Trump, both in 20162020,
- 23:55For this exercise, we'll assume that they vote the same way again.
- 23:58So they vote democrat again, or they vote republican again.
- 24:03It's not necessarily gonna happen because Nevada is potentially up for grabs, and Donald
- 24:08Trump could win that even though it's gone democrat the last couple times, but for this
- 24:12exercise, we're gonna assume that if not a close democratic again.
- 24:16So there were 5 states that vetted for Donald Trump in 2016 and that flipped from him in
- 24:242020.
- 24:25And one congressional district in Nebraska or that winner not winner take all system comes
- 24:31into play.
- 24:33There was Arizona, Georgia, Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin, and then the 2nd
- 24:38congressional district of Nebraska.
- 24:42We have Trump took back Michigan and Pennsylvania, but he still loses, Arizona,
- 24:49Georgia, and Wisconsin.
- 24:52And 2nd district of Nebraska, again, they would both tie at 269 votes.
- 24:59So what happens after that?
- 25:01Well, we talked about how a contingent election has, where it's not a single individual US
- 25:08house member that, sup that that Casa vote, it's the state delegations as a hell that
- 25:16passed
- 25:16a vote.
- 25:16So it's with Steve potential or fifty votes that are going to be cast.
- 25:25As of right now, obviously, we can't say for sure how those are gonna play out in 2024.
- 25:32So we'll we'll assume that if we assume that the majorities of state delegation stay the
- 25:39same, meaning ones that are Republican majorities now stay Republican majority after
- 25:46the 2024 election, The Democratic majority ones stay a Democratic majority after 2024 for
- 25:52election.
- 25:53And in the case of Minnesota, North Carolina, both of those are evenly split between
- 25:58Republicans and Democrats, there are 26 states that are Republican majorities.
- 26:04And there are 22 that are democratic majorities and then those 2, Minnesota and North Carolina
- 26:09that I mentioned.
- 26:10Now, again, that might not happen to be the case, but that's unlikely We're gonna see any
- 26:17of the Republican states, chained to a democrat changed to a democratic majority.
- 26:23I mean, theoretically, it could happen, but based on what a
- 26:28lot of election prognosticators suspects, how they rate their, elections in terms of how
- 26:38likely a Republican or is gonna win or how likely a Democrat
- 26:41is gonna win or whether it's a toss-up.
- 26:44Based on those and just general credits and trends,
- 26:48it's unlikely that any of the Republican majority delegations are going to flip.
- 26:53There's pus possibility that a couple of the Democratic ones flip.
- 26:58And then even if North Carolina and Minnesota become democratic majorities, it would still be
- 27:0426 of 50 states that are Republican majority congressional delegations or US house
- 27:10delegation specifically.
- 27:12And so we would assume that that they're gonna vote for Donald Trump, and considering that he
- 27:18is the republican candidate.
- 27:21And so Donald Trump would be the likely winner.
- 27:24That's probably what would happen in a contingent election.
- 27:28Now if it was a straight up vote where you,
- 27:33reached US house rep, made a choice with it.
- 27:38And so it was 435 votes.
- 27:40Then maybe Pamela Harris would win in that case, but that's not how it works.
- 27:46So Donald Trump would probably win a contingent election.
- 27:50So Democrats serve I mean, obviously, you don't want it to Rich.
- 27:54If you're it's a running and election, you don't want it to go on as long as possible.
- 27:58You'd rather just win.
- 28:01But it would Democrats would probably like it a lot more to end without a contingent election
- 28:09than republicans would.
- 28:10Is the short version.
- 28:12So that does it for today for electoral college and, votes and the, contingent elections.
- 28:21So thank you very much for listening.
- 28:23But before we go, as always, We're gonna have a random question at the bay.
- 28:27And today's random question is is a hot dog a sandwich?
- 28:34It's a very important question.
- 28:36And, I am of the opinion that A hot dog is not a sandwich.
- 28:42My theory of sandwich is that you have to have 2 separate slices of bread and the ingredients
- 28:50in between.
- 28:51That's the short version of it.
- 28:53So hot dogs They much always have a piece of bread that's connected together.
- 28:59They have, like, a little spine there.
- 29:02And then you close it, but they are not 2 separate, pieces of bread.
- 29:06I think it's cheating if you decide to hold a bread, heart, and then still and then
- 29:13kinda make call it a sandwich, then that's cheating.
- 29:15That does not count.
- 29:17So that has nothing to do
- 29:19with contingent elections, but that's why it's
- 29:20a random question of the day.
- 29:22So, anyways,
- 29:24thank you very much for listening to my RAM Rooms again, and hope you found this very
- 29:29informative.
- 29:30And until next time, take care.