Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Biden Weighs In On Strikes, Ford Bites the Apple, Hardware Standard - Subscription Optional
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] All right, Tuesday already. We have Steve Greenfield in the studio, kind of, for this morning's show.
- 0:06We're talking about Joe Biden's comments on the UAW, uh, contract negotiations, and Ford making moves in software as a subscription. Wherever I go. The people really wanna know.
- 0:16Who I am It's more than talk with them They stop and they stare when they see me They're actually doing things Which is a little funny to me Which is nice to see. Steve, good morning Watch how I walk Hey, Paul.
- 0:22How's it going? It's- Thanks for having me. It's going well. It's good to have you here. Um, is Atlanta experiencing the heat waves this summer, or is that, like, just normal Atlanta summer?
- 0:30Well, normal Atlanta summer, but th- this next week actually is gonna be the hottest week of the year, interestingly enough, for some reason, in August. So who knows with Atlanta. I know. I know.
- 0:39Are you traveling a lot, uh, in the summer, or are you experiencing, uh, a slowdown? It's been a slowdown, but I'm about to, to ramp back up.
- 0:45I've actually got two speaking engagements in the Middle East at two different mobility conferences. So we're starting to expand our reach globally now. Wow. Which is great. No, no joke. Yeah.
- 0:53Well, I heard it's hot over there, too. I imagine it is. [laughs] Yes. [laughs] So it's just, it's just like, uh, just like conditioning. Um- Yeah. So, uh, let's talk about a few things going on.
- 1:03Obviously, uh, SOTU CON is coming in hot September 26th and 27th. Can't wait. I cannot wait. Uh, we can't wait to have you there. We have, uh, lots of amazing guests. Mike Stanton from NADA is gonna be there.
- 1:14Jamie Butters, editor of Automotive News. Dealers upon dealers and operators and practitioners. Over 1,000 rooftops already represented in the speaker list.
- 1:22And we're probably just about 50% through, uh, announcing speakers. So it's gonna be an amazing couple of days. Um, also, we have a new show that's launching, uh, t- well, it launched last week.
- 1:33The next episode's launching today. It's The Wheelhouse. Uh, it's gonna be a 1:00 PM live stream on LinkedIn.
- 1:38Um, if we're ever gonna get in trouble for things that are said on a show, this is probably the one, but that's okay- [laughs]... because it's hosted by a GM of Mercedes-Benz of Easton, Daniel Gover.
- 1:49So if he says anything, we can just point at him and be like, "I don't know. What do you want me to tell you? He's the deal- Right... he says what he wants." [laughs] It wasn't me. It wasn't me. It doesn't.
- 1:58And, and some, at some point, Brian Cramer from Cars is probably gonna get the hook from the PR department, too. They're gonna be like, "Yeah, a little too close to that one, buddy."
- 2:04[laughs] But, uh, if, if, if you haven't seen it yet, check it out. It's a lot of fun to watch. It's also a lot of fun to listen to. And, uh, it's kinda modeled after ESPN's Around the Horn. There's sound effects.
- 2:13It's fast-moving. And, um, you know, you'll, you'll learn a little something as well. But, uh, we have some news to talk about today. So, so let's get into it.
- 2:22Um, kind of in the ongoing saga, uh, President Biden has now entered the conversation in the contract negotiations between the UAW and the Big Three.
- 2:30He said, "I'm asking all sides to work together to forge a fair agreement." Uh, you know, just a pretty, pretty, like, down the middle kind of comment.
- 2:39He said in a statement as he urged union auto workers in the Detroit's Big Three to reach a new agreement, uh, before their contracts expire.
- 2:46He stressed the need for middle class supportive contract, um, amid industry tech shifts, while the UAW, represented by 150,000 workers, uh, considers to strike if no agreement is made by that deadline of September 14th.
- 3:00Um, and the potential strike could lead to, uh, a potential $400 to $5 million per week- Mm-hmm... uh, decline in production. Uh, Steve, we haven't heard your comments on this, the whole contract negotiations, the talk.
- 3:13What's your perspective on the whole situation? Yeah, so this is pulling out the hammer, right? The biggest hammer you can have if Biden gets involved. I mean, things get really messy.
- 3:22But things can get resolved really quickly, and maybe both sides aren't happy. But I think it's, um... W- nothing good can come from a strike, right? I understand both, both sides have really dug in.
- 3:31On one side, the OEMs are really worried about setting precedent.
- 3:34And other side, you know, the, the, the unions are saying, "Hey, you know, give us what's due," especially given the last couple years have been so profitable. I mean, it's been so profitable for OEMs and dealers.
- 3:44They're looking at it and saying, "Give us our fair share." Mm-hmm. But I mean, n- nothing good can come from a strike. I can appreciate Biden now signaling, "Hey, I might have to get involved here."
- 3:53Um, if nothing else, it just makes both parties that much sharper with their negotiation, 'cause they realize, you know, daddy's behind the scenes and may, may intervene here.
- 4:02Uh, but, um, hopefully for, for the state of, like, the industry, for the state of the economy, for everybody, this thing does get resolved. And I think, you know, Biden's just doing what he has to do at this point.
- 4:13I mean, you would expect him to signal that, "Hey, w- we're, we're, come, come, comes the shove here, then I'm gonna have to get involved." You know, Jamie Butters was at a David Kane's event earlier in the year.
- 4:23It was probably sometime around May. And he said the one thing that people aren't talking about that he thinks is going to be a big topic of conversation is this strike.
- 4:31Um, you know, Shawn Fain kinda knew the scene when he came in. Seems like he's not playing around. Um, you know, he's obviously going very hard on the demands in the front. Seems like a very tough negotiator.
- 4:42Um, I guess we'll see. I, I don't know what he was... Do you know what he was doing before he had this position? I'm not certain. No, I'm not certain. No? But, yeah, I mean, g- good for him.
- 4:50He's built a brand around himself. I'm, I'm certain that the, the, the, the unions are rallying around him. He's playing tough guy for now.
- 4:57But, you know, w- negotiation tactics 101 is to anchor, you know, the opposition to something way out there. Mm-hmm. You can always come off of that. Mm-hmm.
- 5:05But if you can anchor them and set expectations way out there, you can come off of it and come up with a reasonable sort of, like, negotiation at the end of it. But, um, it definitely has been interesting to watch.
- 5:15And hopefully, fingers crossed, it doesn't get to the point of actually having a strike. Yeah. I, I agree with you.
- 5:20I mean, you have parts suppliers already, like, just barely keeping up, and, um, all types of just, like, normalization that maybe is starting to happen. Right. Yeah. And so, um, yeah.
- 5:32Well, we'll, we'll see what happens. Well, I'll tell you what, one of the Big Three, um, is not waiting around for things to happen. So speaking of Ford- Stop Segway TimeAll right, so Ford has done it again.
- 5:45They appointed another former Apple [ding] executive. Peter Stern is president of its new business unit, which is called Ford Integrated Services. He's gonna lead the company's customer experience strategy. Good call.
- 5:56[ding] Stern was vice president of services at Apple and oversaw, uh, some common things you may be familiar with, like Apple TV+, iCloud, Apple News+, Apple Books, and Apple Arcade, as well as its ad and cloud service.
- 6:09So obviously, a lot of experience with shifting to subscription-based revenue streams.
- 6:15His team at Ford is going to bring together hardware, software, and services across all three units, uh, their ICE unit, their Model E unit, and their Ford Pro.
- 6:23And he's gonna manage, uh, some new services I had never heard of. Ford Next Venture Studio, and this is gonna include some out-of-vehicle experiences, kinda like out-of-body experiences- [laughs]...
- 6:34that, that utilize car cameras for non-driving activities. So, uh, here's a quote from Jim Farley and then get your thoughts on it.
- 6:40Uh, Jim Farley says, "Everyone is so focused on the EV transformation, um, but I keep saying the biggest change in our industry is going to be digital product and physical service."
- 6:50So having a digital product that has a physical service attached to it. He said, "Our industry is littered with bad choices about subscription service, and that's not the direction we're going in." Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 7:03So th- th- so yeah, th- this sends a strong signal that they're gonna be more cus- customer-centric, bringing an Apple executive in. You know, Ford's been probably the most aggressive that we've heard.
- 7:11They've been very successful with Ford Pro. I mean, th- th- their announcement earlier this year that they've got 400,000 subscribers on Ford Pro, and the revenue's up 60% year-over-year. Mm-hmm.
- 7:21I think, um, th- they, they, they, they believe that they can get to $2,000 per year per, per vehicle in subscription products. And I think it's, you know, the world is their oyster. And I, I know it's interesting.
- 7:33Every time I post a LinkedIn article on this, there's always this visceral reaction. People say like, "How dare they?" You know, there's somebody in the industry that posted this today on one of my LinkedIn posts.
- 7:42I wo- won't mention his name, but you know, you can't install a, a, a feature into a vehicle and not activate it for the owner. But you know, I was thinking this morning, it's like m- I get cable TV into my home.
- 7:54That's a great- [laughs] yes. They can, they can toggle on ESPN or toggle off ESPN based on what I'm spending. And it's like I don't complain.
- 8:01I mean, that's a nice feature to have that I can pay for it any given month that I want it. So I think that, you know, we've entered a new era where this is inevitable.
- 8:09I think, I think, you know, positioned correctly, consumers will love it. It'll be a great feature, uh, that they can toggle on or off features as they d- within vehicles. Mm-hmm. But, um, I, I, we'll, we'll, we'll see.
- 8:19There's, there's still friction to be had, I think. You know, that's an interesting point about, like, where are we conditioned to already do that? Even a thing like internet speed, right? What do you want? Totally.
- 8:28The line's coming into the house. You want us to flip it to f- you know, 50 megabytes, 100, a gig? Um, I, I, you know, this, it's just we're not used to it, right? Right.
- 8:36It's that new change, and we operate, like you pointed out, that way in so many other areas. But- Right...
- 8:42you know, I thi- I think when, when the conversation around the heated seats came out, remember BMW, I think that was, that was a little bit more of a rub. Like, what do you mean? Like, I have to...
- 8:51You're gonna charge me for the heat, too? You know, it just- Right, yeah. It's like as if we're just conditioned. No, no, like, you have to... You're entitled to a warm butt if there's a seat.
- 8:59[laughs] You know what I mean? It's- Yeah... one of those. But, um, let's go a little further into the story. So speaking of hardware standard, uh, you know, kind of functionality optional. Stop. Segway. Time.
- 9:10[upbeat music] Okay, so, um, th- this new, uh, this new VP, Peter Stern, he wasn't playing around or wasting any time because in a, in a press conference, he also said it's going to be hardware standard, functionality opposite, um, optional as Ford is making hands-free driving software, BlueCruise it's called, uh, standard on many Ford and Lincoln models.
- 9:34So basically, they're going to install the hardware on every vehicle, and this is a first for them. And then obviously you can turn it on or activate it if you want. Following the lead, right?
- 9:45Tesla installs the hardware on every vehicle.
- 9:47He says, "I firmly believe that when services deliver value to a customer, it's appropriate for customer to pay for the services, and it allows them to take their money, invest in delivering even better services.
- 9:58So as we have them paying for services, we can make them better."
- 10:01He says, "Of course, we're committed to delivering a great experience for every customer, whether they pay for a subscription and service or not, but we can do better for them when we have a subscription, and we can have a service that's paid for."
- 10:12So customers can activate BlueCruise, um, at purchase for three years at $2,100. Um, you know, they get a 90-day free trial, and then if they activate it, three years for $2,100.
- 10:23They can pay $800 a year if they wanna buy it annually or $75 a month. And, uh, some select Lincoln models, so the higher end ones, are gonna come standard with it for four years.
- 10:34So, uh, this is a little bit further into the conversation of what we were just talking about.
- 10:39Yeah, but all, all, all those sensors, the cameras, the LiDAR that are needed for this thing are gonna be installed in the vehicle, like you said, Paul. And, like, how are people gonna react?
- 10:46It's like, if I don't wanna pay for it, then don't pay for it right now. Six months, nine months later, you might decide to pay for it. And, you know, a consumer should say, "Wow, at least I have the option." Mm.
- 10:55I think- That's a, that's a good thing. I think the contrary point would be, like, especially in a time where we're having so many affordability conversations, and that's at the top, right?
- 11:03If that wasn't at the top of the pile in conversation right now, I think there would be less contention around it. But right now- Right... when it's saying like, "Hey, we...
- 11:10We're trying to get cars that, uh, meet the affordability to bring that average new car payment down," which is up to, like, I think it's up to, like, 750 or something like that, um, to bring that down.
- 11:20You're spending the money to add these components into the vehicle. Can't you just give me a stripped down version that doesn't have any of that fancy stuff, I don't want it, to make a cheaper car, right?
- 11:29So I think that's the contrarian point that's probably coming up.Yeah, that, that, that, that'll be the PR around it, right?
- 11:37Just say like, "Hey, because we can normalize, um, um, the, the, the manufacture of these vehicles, every car gets configured the same way. We've managed our supplier network as a result.
- 11:47The actual cost of building the cars is cheaper now." Mm-hmm. "And it's offset by those users that want to pay for a subscription, so your car's actually cheaper despite the fact it's got more electronics in it."
- 11:58The interesting thing will be is whe- whether or not, you know, consumers figure out ways to hack these things.
- 12:03You saw recently that, you know, there, there's some researchers that have figured out how to hack and activate heated seats on Teslas now- Yeah... aftermarket.
- 12:11And, uh, you know, T- Tesla has not responded, but I gotta imagine Tesla isn't gonna look favorably on folks getting in and, and toggling on features that otherwise would be paid. Mm-hmm.
- 12:20And how will the OEMs react to hackers? Yeah, that... I mean, it's, it's gonna be a never-ending battle, right?
- 12:26But fortunately with software updates over the air, it's gonna be typically, like, you're gonna need your car updated.
- 12:32And it's just, is that experience gonna be more like the Apple your system needs to be updated experience, or the Windows your system needs to be- [laughs]... updated experience [laughs] is the real question.
- 12:43Because that's gonna- Right, right. Yeah... that's really gonna color the entire, and the entire, you know, user experience on how easy and automatic is it.
- 12:51Have you h- do you own a car that has software over-the-air updates? I do not. Yeah. I, I don't either. Um, so I, it's, there's still, like, this, this question, right, around what is that like? How is the car connected?
- 13:03Is it seamless? Is it annoying? Um, you know one thing I, I, I brought up to my son, my son is 16, the other day, and he's, he's about to, you know, he's shopping for his first car.
- 13:12He's about to get his license in a month. And, um, you know, he's considering leasing either a new Sportage or purchasing- Nice... uh, like a Honda Pilot with, like, you know, 180,000 miles on it.
- 13:25He's in this, and, and I- Yeah... I ha- it's got this system, it's got all this tech integrated, which is why he likes the Sportage. And I asked him, I said, "Hey,
- 13:33if the auto, if your car served you up ads on your welcome screen," right? I said, "Would you, would you let it do that if it gave you a discount for the car?" And he was like, "Absolutely not.
- 13:46That would be so annoying." I was like, "What if they gave you, like, $100 a month discount?" He's like, "No way. It'd have to be..." I was like, "How much would it have to be?"
- 13:53He said, "It would have to be, like, half price," he said. So that, that's my 16-year-old's view on that. [laughs] Right, right, right.
- 13:58But that, that's something I don't think we've seen yet, but, but I'm curious now with all these software updates, it makes a really reasonable place is that's where you would push advertising.
- 14:07Have you ever heard- Right... or thought of anything like that? We've seen some startups that are, are working on that, too, and there might be a revenue share back to the OEM. Mm.
- 14:15Kinda the same way that if you're on Waze, it'll show you a McDonald's or gas stations nearby. Yes. Mm-hmm. I mean, tho- those in some cases are sponsored, right? People are paying Waze for those sponsorships, uh, spots.
- 14:24And you know, they're, right now I don't know if there's any revenue share back. I don't, I don't imagine that there is. I mean, Google owns Waze.
- 14:30But you can imagine the future, on the dash if the dealer wants to advertise, you know, "Come in today, get tires or brakes repaired," because we can sense that your car needs them right now.
- 14:39There, there will be opportunities for, for dealers to push advertising, I would imagine, that are consumer-friendly advertising- Yes... to the screen.
- 14:46And, and, you know, there, there may be third parties like McDonald's or Starbucks that pay some kind of revenue share back to either the OEM, likely the OEM, not so much the, the actual dealer.
- 14:55But they'd have to, like, you know, cr- cross the threshold of, like, some kinda compelling consumer value, because you wouldn't want your screen too cluttered.
- 15:02You may be able to opt in or out of which vendors actually can advertise to you on your screen. Yeah. Well, it'll be interesting. I mean, where there is attention, there's opportunity to make money.
- 15:13Steve, thank you so much for joining us on the show today. Um, whatever you're doing out there, tech, no tech, whatever it is, go serve some people. They're in front of you. [upbeat music]