Latest / Common Sense Rankings Podcast / CSR Podcast #15: Week 1 Recap, the CSR Top 25 and Games to Watch in Week 2
Transcript
- 0:12Hello and welcome to another episode of the Common Sense Rankings podcast.
- 0:16This is episode number 15, where I will be going over the week one results on the field.
- 0:21I will rank the conferences based on what happened in those week one games.
- 0:25We'll talk about the top 25 teams in the initial Common Sense Rankings of 2026.
- 0:30We'll discuss the AP poll, including what voters voted particularly well and which ones leave some to be desired.
- 0:36And then we'll talk about the most important games for the CSR in week two Of the 138 FBS teams, 134 of them played in week one with four teams having a bye after playing in week zero.
- 0:5148 teams played FCS competition while the remaining 86 played another team from the FBS.
- 0:57The story going into the season was the lack of big game juice in week one.
- 1:01There were just seven games between teams from the ACC, SEC, Big 12, Big Ten, and Notre Dame in week one.
- 1:08We will see more than double that in week two with 16 such matchups this upcoming weekend.
- 1:14So when we're talking the CSR, the first thing we need to establish is conference strength.
- 1:18So which conference performed the best in week one has claimed that top spot?
- 1:22That will be the SEC.
- 1:24They went 16 and 0 in week one, but it's not the undefeated record that puts them atop the CSR conference standings.
- 1:30It's the number of conferences against which they won.
- 1:33They played and defeated teams from eight of the other nine conferences.
- 1:37That puts them firmly in the top spot going into week two.
- 1:40Texas beat Texas State from the Pac-12, and South Carolina beat Kent State from the MAC.
- 1:46As those were the only games the SEC plays against each of those conferences this season, they're guaranteed to have winning records against both for the duration of 2026.
- 1:55Oklahoma also won its first game against a Mountain West team this season with the second and final matchup between the two conferences being the Sooners game against New Mexico in week three.
- 2:05With all the success the SEC had in week one, the first team to beat an SEC school will have the best resume building win so far this season.
- 2:14In second in the Common Sense conference rankings is the Big Ten.
- 2:18They went 16 and two in week one with the lone losses being Wisconsin to Notre Dame on Sunday and Rutgers to Massachusetts on Thursday.
- 2:25They played six different conferences and own winning records against all six.
- 2:30The Big Ten has confirmed a winning record over the Pac-12 this season, winning the first three matchups of the five they are scheduled to play.
- 2:37Since the Big Ten has a winning record against the second most conferences, a win over the Big Ten will matter more than any other conference but the SEC.
- 2:45So you'll see Notre Dame and UMass high in the early season Common Sense rankings.
- 2:50Where the Big Ten trails the SEC right now is not success but its diversity of opponents.
- 2:55Nine games the Big Ten played was against the geographically sensible MAC or an FCS school, whereas the SEC played 12 games against FBS opponents and spread those opponents out over more conferences.
- 3:07The Big Ten definitely carries their future in their own hands and, and the rest of the non-conference slate starting in week two will be crucial for Big Ten's superiority There was a tie for the third best conference between the ACC and the American, both of which have winning records against four other conferences after week one.
- 3:26The ACC is currently eight and five out of conference.
- 3:29Three of those ACC-Big 12 matchups have already been played with Big 12 reversing the script after week zero.
- 3:37Pitt will need to beat UCF in week two for the ACC to have a chance to win that head-to-head with the Big 12.
- 3:43The ACC will fortunately have a winning record over the American for the entirety of the season as Duke's revenge win over Tulane was the only matchup those two conferences will have all year.
- 3:54They also won their first two of three games against the MAC, confirming a secon- second conference against which the ACC will finish ahead.
- 4:01The American is tied with the ACC having a positive record against the Big 12, C-USA, Mountain West, and Sun Belt.
- 4:10Uh, the Tulsa win over Oklahoma State gives them a one and oh record against the Big 12, and they are undefeated against the remaining conferences.
- 4:18Sitting at nine and six out of conference, that is led by Memphis, who is likely the top team in most voters' minds in the group of six.
- 4:26A win against an ACC or an American foe will count the same in the CSR if it happened before week one Going through the rest of the conference strength, ranked fifth is the Big 12 with a positive record against the ACC, Sun Belt, and Pac-12.
- 4:41Of all of the conferences, and especially of their fellow c- power conferences, the Big 12 has the best chance to improve their stock.
- 4:48They've yet to play the Big Ten, Conference USA, MAC, or Mountain West, so they do have ample opportunities to increase their standings in the CSR.
- 4:57The Mountain West sit six and six out of conference and started two and O against both Conference USA and the MAC.
- 5:02They'll need to win just one more game against CUSA and two more against the Mid-American to solidify a winning record against both come season's end.
- 5:11The Sun Belt went 10 and four in the opening weekend, but eight of those wins were against FCS opponents.
- 5:16They do sport a winning record against just Conference USA at this point.
- 5:20They're tied with the Pac-12, who had a tough opening week but did feature Colorado State's win over Wyoming from the Mountain West to give them a head start in their three matchups against that conference.
- 5:31At the bottom of the pile are the MAC and Conference USA.
- 5:34The MAC's UMass win over Rutgers is the only win that either of those conferences have against FBS competition, with the rest of those teams going seven and 17 in their first week.
- 5:47And there is our order of conference strength.
- 5:48A win over the SEC is worth the most right now in common sense rankings, followed by the Big Ten and then the ACC and the American tied for third.
- 5:57On the other side, a win over Conference USA or MAC is worth the least, and then slightly more than that is Pac-12 and a Sun Belt win.
- 6:05So given the conference strength metrics and interconference records coming out of week one, we have a very straightforward process in ranking our teams.
- 6:12First, direct wins are going to matter the most because we-- though it's really all we have now after week one.
- 6:18And more direct wins is going to impact the CSR more than fewer.
- 6:22So having two wins over FBS competition will look better early in the season than having just one a win over a better conference is going to get you more points in the Common Sense rankings.
- 6:33We'll also look at those teams who beat a school that already has another win, as that is an additional feather in the cap for those teams looking to be ranked.
- 6:41And then we'll also go over a few of the early season tiebreakers that are necessary as we have such few data points.
- 6:48So who is number one?
- 6:50We have two teams that are starting both two and O against FBS competition, that is Southern Cal and Memphis.
- 6:56The teams have s- equal direct win points with both teams beating a Mountain West school in week zero, and then Memphis beat Arkansas State from the Sun Belt in week one.
- 7:07USC then beat Fresno State in week one.
- 7:10So based on direct wins, they have an equal amount of points in the Common Sense rankings.
- 7:15So what we need to look at is how those teams then perfor- performed against their other opponents.
- 7:20Memphis beat UNLV in week zero, who then went on to beat Hawaii in week one.
- 7:25On Southern Cal's resume is a win against San Jose State, who then went on to beat Eastern Michigan out of the MAC.
- 7:31Because that Hawaii win is going to be seen as more impressive because of the Mountain West stature in the Common Sense rankings, Memphis then gets the number one ranking courtesy of their win over UNLV, with Southern Cal then going into the number two spot Since no team beat an SEC school in week one, the following group of teams either A, beat a Big Ten team, the second-best conference, or B, beat a school that already had another win.
- 7:58The three schools that fall into that category are Massachusetts, Miami, and Notre Dame.
- 8:03UMass and Notre Dame handed the Big Ten their two losses, while Miami beat an ACC school, Stanford, that had beaten a Mountain West school in week zero, putting all three schools tied in the CSR points.
- 8:15With many ties needing to be broken early in the season, the first tiebreaker used is conference affiliation.
- 8:21Notre Dame, having only played a Big Ten school, is being seen as equal to the Big Ten at this time.
- 8:26They then get the number three spot courtesy of being in the best, quote-unquote, conference.
- 8:31Looking at Miami and UMass, the ACC is seen as more impressive than the MAC, so the ACC school Miami will get the number four spot, while the final team to beat a Big Ten school, UMass, is number five in the first week of the Common Sense rankings.
- 8:46For the record, if the result from Ann Arbor had been deemed official after the first Hail Mary attempt, Western Michigan would have fallen into this group with a Big Ten win.
- 8:54They would have locked up the number six rank in this initial CSR.
- 8:59As we look to continue filling out our top 25, the next 12 teams will- ranked will have a win over the ACC or an American school.
- 9:08SMU gets to be number six due to their opponent, Florida State, already having won a game.
- 9:12After the Mustangs, the rest of the group files in according to conference strength and then by win margin.
- 9:17So seven through 10 are going to be SEC schools in order Florida, LSU, Alabama, and Ole Miss.
- 9:24Next comes three Big Ten schools with wins over the ACC or American, Indiana, UCLA, and Illinois.
- 9:31Virginia and Duke are numbers 14 and 15, followed by two Big 12 programs in Cincinnati and Colorado.
- 9:38Next up are teams that have a win over the Big 12, the fifth-best conference according to the CSR.
- 9:43In order, that is Auburn at number 18, Tulsa at 19, and North Carolina at 20.
- 9:49We had four teams with wins over a Mountain West school.
- 9:51They are the sixth-best conference thus far.
- 9:54That will be Oklahoma, Iowa, Colorado State, and Texas.
- 9:57And then the last spot in the top 25 goes to Mississippi State, courtesy of their 49-point win over the Sun Belt's Louisiana Monroe.
- 10:05The CSR had eight SEC teams, five Big Ten, five ACC, two each from the American and Big 12, and then one from the MAC, Pac-12, and then that independent in Notre Dame filling that last spot.
- 10:17If you're looking for the entirety of the 138 schools ranked, you can visit commonsenserankings.com to see the full breakdown.
- 10:25So what would our college football playoff bracket look like if we used the week one common sense rankings?
- 10:31The teams that would get byes would be Memphis, Southern Cal, Notre Dame, and then Miami.
- 10:36And then the first round games to be played at the home stadiums of the higher ranked team would include number five UMass hosting the Big 12 champ Cincinnati.
- 10:45Even though they're ranked 16th, the Big 12 champ is guaranteed a spot in the college football playoff.
- 10:50Next, we would have number six SMU hosting number 11 Indiana, number seven Florida holst- hosting number 10 Ole Miss, and lastly number eight LSU hosting number nine Alabama.
- 11:03So based on the statistical evaluation of all of the teams in FBS, did the AP poll do a good job of evaluating those teams?
- 11:11The answer is not really.
- 11:13There are 69 AP voters this year, and those 69, uh, pollsters combined to get 12 of the top 25 correctly ranked.
- 11:22Memphis was the biggest miss.
- 11:23They are unranked, although they did get plenty of votes.
- 11:26They are the number one team in the CSR.
- 11:29Other misses were UMass, Florida, UCLA, and Illinois.
- 11:32UMass receiving zero votes was a little bit of a surprise to me.
- 11:36Louisville was the only one-loss team that was ranked in this week two poll, and then Boise State and Western Michigan, even though both teams lost, got actually more votes compared to their preseason ranking.
- 11:48So which voters did particularly well?
- 11:49The first is David Jablonsky, who had Memphis higher than any other voter at number 22.
- 11:54As they are number one in the CSR, I felt that was a worthy shout-out.
- 11:59He also only had undefeated teams in his poll, which is another point in his favor.
- 12:05He was one of 14 voters that included only one-and-O or two-and-O teams in their poll this week.
- 12:11I'm particularly fascinated by Dylan Sinn's ballot from the Journal Gazette.
- 12:14He had USC the highest of anybody at number six.
- 12:17I completely agree.
- 12:19They deserve a little bit more credit because of their two wins.
- 12:21He also had Georgia Bulldogs lower than anybody else at number nine.
- 12:25Again, I agree, an FCS win should not matter as much when evaluating team success.
- 12:31He also included three teams that were O and one, Louisville, Boise State, and Western Michigan.
- 12:36So Dylan was a little all over the place.
- 12:38I would be fascinated to pick his brain on his thought process.
- 12:42A few voters did not do particularly well after week one.
- 12:45The first is Brian Fonseca.
- 12:47Sorry, Brian, but you left Miami off your ballot.
- 12:49I'm sure it was a mistake, uh, but it is worth mentioning that a potential national championship contender both has first-place votes and is completely left off of a ballot, which might be the first time in AP poll history.
- 13:01Murray Evans had 10 of their 25 ranked teams.
- 13:05That is 40%, uh, either have a win over an FCS program or already have one loss.
- 13:10That is the highest of any AP poll voter.
- 13:13So we'll see if they can improve going into next week's rankings.
- 13:17Looking ahead to week two, we'll have one matchup between CSR top 25 teams.
- 13:22That'll be Illinois and Duke on FS1, middle of the afternoon.
- 13:26That's one of three Big Ten ACC matchups in week two, with the others being Wake Forest-Purdue and Boston College versus Rutgers.
- 13:34If the Big Ten can win two of those games, it'll lock up a winning record against the ACC for the rest of the season.
- 13:40The ACC will need to take two of three in order to make sure they can claim Big Ten superiority, uh, by the end of the season.
- 13:48Two other high importance games for the ACC are both matchups against the Sun Belt.
- 13:52They play only three times against that conference, with the first two happening this week.
- 13:56The first is Virginia Tech and Old Dominion, the other is Clemson and Georgia Southern.
- 14:02The SEC and Big Ten play three times in 2026, and they all happen in week two.
- 14:06Oklahoma and Michigan play early afternoon, Minnesota hosts Mississippi State in the middle of the day, and Ohio State plays Texas in prime time on ABC.
- 14:15That Ohio State-Texas tilt is the only game between AP-ranked teams in week two, number one versus number four.
- 14:22As I said, those are the only three games between the SEC and Big Ten, so whichever conference can take at least two of those will claim a better head-to-head record against the other and raise the value of a win against a team from that conference.
- 14:36The Big Ten will also kick off play against the Big 12 for the first and second time this season.
- 14:41Iowa and Iowa State will renew their rivalry in prime time on NBC, while Oregon will visit Oklahoma State at twelve noon Eastern on ESPN.
- 14:49Those two conferences again play only three times this year, so if the Big Ten is going to raise itself to the top conference in college football, they will need to have a winning record not g- just against the SEC this weekend, but also the Big 12.
- 15:04In addition to the Big Ten's huge matchups, the SEC and the Big 12, uh, will need to see some results in week two as well.
- 15:11The SEC currently leads one-nil after Auburn's win over Baylor, but the two conferences will play their final three games this weekend.
- 15:20Kansas against Missouri on Friday night, Texas A&M versus Arizona State on ABC at 12 noon, and Arkansas versus Utah claims the late-night spot on ESPN.
- 15:30The Big 12 would need to claim all three of those games in order to have a winning record against the SEC, while the SEC just needs to win two of the three in order to secure that dub against the Big 12.
- 15:41There are 26 teams that are currently undefeated who play an FBS opponent this week, so the most likely top teams will come from that crop.
- 15:49Memphis and USC continue to play FBS opponents, so they will have an inside track to that number one ranking.
- 15:55The aforementioned Power Four matchups as well as Pittsburgh-UCF will likely determine most of the rest of the top 10.
- 16:02We are also guaranteed to have one team in the SEC with a loss as Alabama and Kentucky both begin SEC play.
- 16:10To reiterate the instructions given to AP poll voters, ballots are meant to be filled out based on game performance, not preseason expectations or future speculation.
- 16:19The Common Sense Rankings hold firm to that goal.
- 16:22The CSR reflects the teams with the best resumes up to that point in the season.
- 16:27While the voters and the social media accounts that put out rankings each week vary from that standard, a win over a Big Ten team should count more in a team's favor than a win over an FCS team, even if you include winning margin and other advanced metrics.
- 16:40To be clear, I have UMass at number five.
- 16:43I don't think Massachusetts is a top five team, nor will they be at any point in the season.
- 16:48But if we're trying to assess what teams have the best combinations of wins and losses at this point, with the limit information we have, their win over a Big Ten school must count for something.
- 16:58We'll be saying goodbye to the Minutemen from the top 25, at least for a while, as their next two games will both be against FCS competition.
- 17:07I'll be updating commonsenserankings.com each week throughout the season to reflec reflect the top resumes in the sport.
- 17:14I'll also be posting consistently on the socials at ComSenseRankings.
- 17:18Thank you again for joining us for episode 15 of the CSR podcast.
- 17:22As you go about your day-to-day, please use some common sense