Latest / Reformed Thinking / Works Righteousness Is Wrongly Inferred from Reward | John Calvin

Transcript

Works Righteousness Is Wrongly Inferred from Reward | John Calvin · Reformed Thinking

0:00
Welcome to Reformed Thinking, the show that helps you build a
0:02
strong and clear understanding of the Christian faith.
0:05
I'm your host, here to walk with you through fascinating
0:08
insights. And I'm here to help us distill
0:10
those insights, connecting them to a broader understanding.
0:13
Together, we take a stack of sources, articles, research your
0:16
notes, and distill valuable knowledge, offering a shortcut
0:19
to being truly well informed. Today, we're diving into a topic
0:22
that sits, well right at the very core of reformed theology,
0:26
doesn't it? And it's one that has puzzled
0:27
many believers, this interplay between God's grace, our good
0:32
works, and the concept of heavenly reward.
0:36
If Scripture speaks of reward for our efforts, does that imply
0:40
our works somehow earn us anything?
0:42
Or is salvation purely, absolutely a gift?
0:45
It definitely sparks discussion. It's a crucial question,
0:48
absolutely. It touches upon our
0:49
understanding of God's very nature, His character, and our
0:52
place before Him. We'll look at texts that may be
0:55
on the surface might seem to suggest human merit, right?
0:59
But when we look closer, you know they consistently unfold a
1:01
message of divine generosity and free grace.
1:05
We have some really rich material before us today.
1:08
We're drawing heavily from the Reformer John Calvin's
1:11
systematic thoughts on this subject.
1:12
Yes, his institutes are central here.
1:14
Our deep dive today will reveal how Kelvin carefully handles
1:18
these seemingly conflicting ideas, showing them to be parts
1:22
of a harmonious whole. It reviews a beautiful coherence
1:26
in God's plan. Our mission really is to clarify
1:29
how God's promises of reward genuinely motivate believers,
1:34
how they comfort us without ever functioning as a means to earn
1:37
salvation. That's the key.
1:39
Which is always received through His grace alone.
1:41
Always. It's a delicate balance, maybe,
1:44
but one the sources illuminate quite clearly when you dig in.
1:47
OK, let's unpack this apparent tension right at the start.
1:50
Then, when we hear about rewards in Scripture, it can sometimes
1:53
feel like our good deeds contribute to our salvation, or
1:56
maybe that God owes us something for our efforts.
1:59
That feeling is common. Yet Reformed theology holds that
2:03
salvation is by grace alone, through faith alone in Christ
2:06
alone. So how do we reconcile this?
2:09
It feels like a fundamental theological challenge.
2:12
It does, and that's a perceptive observation.
2:14
The sources clarify this by setting up a core distinction,
2:17
one that's just foundational to understanding God's blessing.
2:21
The Kingdom of Heaven is characterized as a son's
2:24
inheritance, not servants wages. Inheritance, not wages, OK.
2:29
This distinction is absolutely vital.
2:32
It means the Kingdom isn't something earned through labor.
2:35
You know, like a paycheck for hours worked.
2:38
It's something received solely by being adopted as sons by the
2:42
Lord. It's the result of a
2:43
relationship, a family status, not some transaction based on
2:47
performance. OK.
2:48
The sources highlight this by explaining that the son of the
2:52
bondwoman shall not be the heir, but the son of the free woman.
2:55
That directly illustrates this difference between an earned
2:58
status and a born into, or, well in our case, adopted into
3:02
status. Adopted into, Yeah.
3:03
This understanding is foundational to seeing how grace
3:06
operates, even when the idea of rewards pops up in Scripture.
3:09
So it's about family status, being part of God's household,
3:12
not about earning a paycheck or meeting some kind of quota.
3:15
That makes a significant difference in how we approach
3:18
our works then. It really does.
3:19
Can you give us some examples from the sources where scripture
3:22
itself makes this clear, even when it talks about rewards for
3:25
our actions? Certainly.
3:26
Let's look at Matthew 25, verse 34.
3:29
Here Christ is talking about the final judgment, right?
3:33
And he lists various good, good works the righteous performed
3:38
feeding the hungry, clothing the naked, visiting the sick.
3:41
The Sheep and the Goats Passage. Exactly.
3:44
And he then calls the elect into possession of heaven, saying,
3:48
Come, you who are blessed by my Father, take your inheritance,
3:52
the Kingdom prepared for you since the creation of the world.
3:55
OK, so the works are there, they're mentioned.
3:57
They are clearly listed, yes, but the basis for them receiving
4:00
the Kingdom isn't their labor. It's not because you did these
4:04
works. You've earned this.
4:05
Instead, he immediately adds, They possess it by right of
4:08
inheritance. This shows the works are
4:10
present. They're evidence of a changed
4:12
heart, sure, but the underlying right to the Kingdom comes from
4:16
their adopted status. And inheritance prepared for
4:18
them. Prepared for them before they
4:20
ever performed a single good deed.
4:23
The works are the fruit, you see, not the root of their
4:27
possession. That's a crucial nuance.
4:29
The works are present, but the basis of possession is
4:33
different. What other passages highlight
4:35
this distinction, directing us away from any notion of human
4:38
merit being the foundation? Well, Colossians 3.24 gives us
4:42
another clear illustration. Paul encourages servants to
4:46
faithfully do their duty, you know, and hope for recompense
4:49
from the Lord, he writes. Whatever you do, work at it with
4:53
all your heart as working for the Lord, not for human masters,
4:57
since you know that you will receive an inheritance from the
4:59
Lord as a reward. There it is again.
5:02
Reward is called inheritance. Notice the phrasing.
5:04
Yeah, they will receive a reward, but this reward is
5:08
specifically identified as the inheritance.
5:11
This freezing, as our sources point out, is a deliberate
5:13
caution. Against what?
5:15
Against crediting everlasting blessedness to the works
5:17
themselves. It steers our attention, our
5:20
focus toward our adoption by God as the true foundation for
5:23
receiving what's promised. It's subtle but vital.
5:25
It is. The reward comes because we are
5:28
heirs, not because we are employees punching a clock.
5:32
This reminds me of a powerful example from the Old Testament
5:34
cited in our materials. Materials.
5:36
It really drives this principle of inheritance over wages home.
5:40
Can you take us to Abraham and his son Isaac and how that story
5:44
illustrates this? Yeah, it's an excellent
5:46
illustration. Let's think about Abraham.
5:48
What's really striking is that before Isaac, the son of
5:51
promise, was even born, indeed before Abraham performed many of
5:55
his great acts of faith, God promised Abraham a vast lineage,
6:00
said his descendants would be like the stars, the sand on the
6:03
seashore. Right, the initial promises in
6:04
Genesis. And God also promised that all
6:06
nations would be blessed through his offspring.
6:09
This promise was given purely by God's grace, totally unmerited
6:13
by anything Abraham had done before.
6:14
OK, pure promise. Then years later, we find
6:17
Abraham, commanded by God to sacrifice Isaac, his only son.
6:20
The ultimate test. Truly staggering demand.
6:23
Yeah, After Abraham's agonizing yet complete obedience, God
6:29
renewed and expanded the promise, swearing by himself
6:32
because Abraham had done this thing and not spared your only
6:36
son. So Abraham performed this huge
6:39
act of obedience, and a blessing followed.
6:42
On the surface, it really looks like a direct reward, doesn't
6:45
it? A consequence of his
6:46
faithfulness. It certainly does appear that
6:48
way on the surface, but our sources highlight a truly
6:51
critical point here, which is Abraham received the same
6:54
blessings, the vast lineage, the blessing to all nations that God
6:57
had already promised him before the command to sacrifice Isaac
7:00
was even given. Oh wow, so God just reaffirmed
7:02
what he'd already said he'd do. Exactly.
7:04
He affirmed what he had already freely granted.
7:07
This shows that God rewards the works of believers not by paying
7:11
them something they earned or were owed, but by showering them
7:14
with benefits he had already freely granted out of his own
7:17
disposition and prior promises. His reason for blessing them was
7:20
his own mercy, not their prior works or some newly created
7:24
obligation on his part. So grace comes first.
7:26
Grace precedes and enables any obedience, and the reward is
7:30
simply the gracious fulfillment of a promise already made, a
7:34
fuller experience of a blessing already secured.
7:37
It just totally removes any notion that God was somehow
7:40
obligated to Abraham because of his deeds.
7:42
No, he was just being faithful to his own character and his
7:45
words. Precisely.
7:46
That Abraham illustration is really striking.
7:48
It makes clear that God's promises are rooted in his
7:51
character and his prior grace, not our deeds.
7:55
But then it raises another question, why does God promise
7:58
rewards for works at all if he's already given everything by
8:01
grace and his own good pleasure? Is he just holding out a carrot
8:05
or or maybe giving us a spiritual puzzle to figure out?
8:08
Yeah, that's the logical next step, isn't it?
8:10
The sources are clear that God does not trick or mock us when
8:13
he talks about rewarding works with what he'd already given
8:16
freely. OK, so it's not a trick.
8:17
No, rather His intention is different.
8:20
He wills that we be trained through good works to meditate
8:24
upon the presentation or fruition, so to speak, of those
8:27
things which He has promised. Train through good works to
8:29
meditate upon fruition. Can you unpack that a bit?
8:32
Yeah, think of it like this. Imagine a child who's promised a
8:35
magnificent inheritance, say, a vast estate, beautiful gardens,
8:40
grand halls. They don't earn it.
8:42
It's a gift, right? A promise from their loving
8:45
parent. But as they grow, they're given
8:48
tasks on the estate. Maybe they help tend the
8:51
gardens, learn its history, assistant upkeep.
8:55
They're not doing these things to earn ownership.
8:57
They already have the promise of ownership.
8:59
But the work teaches them how to manage it, to appreciate its
9:02
beauty, to understand the responsibilities that come with
9:05
such a gift. So the work shapes them for the
9:08
inheritance. Exactly.
9:10
Their daily work builds character, teaches stewardship,
9:13
cultivates a deeper longing and anticipation for the day they
9:16
fully come into possession. Similarly, our good works aren't
9:19
payments for heaven. They were God's way of shaping
9:22
our hearts, sharpening our spiritual senses, making us more
9:25
attuned and eager for the full realization of the blessed hope
9:29
that's already ours by grace. It's spiritual preparation.
9:33
Giving us tangible ways to occupy ourselves while we await
9:36
the full realization. Drawing us to the ripeness of
9:39
that fruit that God intends for us.
9:41
OK, so good works bring us to the ripeness of that fruit,
9:45
preparing us to receive the full scope of God's promises.
9:49
What biblical support is there for this idea of training and
9:52
preparation rather than earning? Well, Colossians 1 verses 4:00
9:56
and 5:00 is a good example. Paul says the Colossians
9:59
occupied themselves with duties of love for the sake of the hope
10:02
laid up for them in heaven. Laid up for them.
10:04
Right. A hope they had heard of through
10:06
the gospel. Their actions were connected to
10:08
their hope, but critically, their actions weren't the source
10:11
of that hope. The hope was laid up for them,
10:14
indicating something already secured awaiting them.
10:17
And Peter's statement in First Peter 1.5 also fits here.
10:21
He says the godly are guarded by God's power through faith unto
10:25
the salvation that has been repaired to be manifested in its
10:28
time. Prepared, guarded, manifested,
10:31
not earned. Exactly.
10:33
Again, salvation described as something prepared and guarded
10:36
by God, something to be manifested later with faith as
10:40
the means of access, not works as the means of earning.
10:43
These passages show works are a response to a hope already
10:47
given, not a way to acquire it. This all brings us to a really
10:51
illustrated story cited in our sources, the parable of the
10:54
vineyard workers. Now this one, this one is often
10:57
misunderstood, isn't it? People get hung up on the
10:59
perceived unfairness. Oh, absolutely.
11:02
But in the context of grace and reward, it takes on a whole new
11:05
dimension. How does this parable from
11:08
Matthew 20 shine a bright light on the nature of God's grace in
11:12
relation to reward? This parable is just central to
11:15
understanding that reward is truly grace.
11:17
It describes A householder who goes out early morning to hire
11:20
laborers for his vineyard agrees to pay them a denarius for the
11:23
day. Standard day's wage.
11:24
Right then he goes back at the third hour, 6th, 9th, even the
11:28
11th hour hires more workers, telling them he'll pay them what
11:31
is right. OK.
11:32
Yet at evening, when it's time to pay, he tells his foreman to
11:35
pay everyone the same wage, a denarius, starting with those
11:39
hired last. And the early birds weren't
11:41
happy. Not at all.
11:42
The ones who started early, who had sweated in much labor all
11:45
day, they expected more. They complain saying essentially
11:49
these guys only worked one hour and you've made them equal to
11:52
us. That's the part that always
11:54
puzzles people. Those who worked all day got the
11:57
same as those who worked just an hour.
11:59
It seems profoundly unfair by our human standards of Labor and
12:03
pay. It almost feels like a rebuke of
12:05
hard work. It does.
12:06
It directly challenges our deeply ingrained ideas of
12:10
equitable pay based on effort. But an ancient writer whose work
12:14
The Call of the Gentiles is attributed to Ambrose, gives a
12:17
clear and profound interpretation.
12:21
What's the interpretation? He states that the equal payment
12:23
reveals the excellence of His grace.
12:26
God does not pay the price of their labor, but showers the
12:29
riches of His goodness upon those whom He has chosen apart
12:31
from works. So it's about God's goodness,
12:33
not their work. Precisely, and the vineyard
12:36
owners response to the grumblers is key.
12:39
Friend, I am doing you no wrong. Did you not agree with me?
12:42
For a denarius? Take what belongs to you and go.
12:45
I choose to give to this last worker as I give to you.
12:48
Am I not allowed to do what I choose with what belongs to me?
12:51
Or is your eye envious because I am generous?
12:54
Wow, that puts it starkly. It does.
12:57
Even those who sweated in much labor are meant to understand
13:00
that what they received was a gift of grace, not the reward
13:04
for their works. The parable radically shows that
13:06
God's goodness and generosity just transcend our human ideas,
13:09
a proportional reward based on effort or merit.
13:12
His generosity is freely given, not earned, yes.
13:15
So the parable demonstrates that the reward is not about earned
13:18
merit, but about the boundless kindness of God.
13:22
What does this mean for eternal life itself?
13:23
That's also called the reward of works.
13:25
Is it still truly grace or is there some earning involved
13:28
then? No, it is absolutely,
13:30
unqualifiedly still Grace. The sources explain that when
13:33
eternal life is termed the reward of works, it refers not
13:36
simply to our initial communion with God, which is given by
13:39
adoption alone. Rather, it pertains to the full
13:42
possession or fruition of blessedness, the complete
13:46
realization of our inheritance. Fruition like the full
13:49
enjoyment. Exactly.
13:50
Think of it this way, Adoption makes you a child in an heir
13:54
immediately, but the full fruition of that inheritance
13:57
living in the fullness of your new status.
13:59
Maybe that comes later. Christ's own words point to this
14:03
ultimate enjoyment. Mark 10.30 In the world to come,
14:07
eternal life. Matthew 25.34 Come take
14:10
possession of the Kingdom. The reward isn't the entry
14:14
ticket to heaven, but the glorious, full experience of
14:18
living in our heavenly home, complete with all the blessings
14:21
of being in God's presence. And Paul's words about the
14:24
redemption of our body come to mind here, don't they?
14:26
It's not just spiritual, but physical too, part of that full
14:28
fruition. Yes, precisely.
14:30
Paul terms adoption, the revealing of adoption that will
14:33
happen at the resurrection, interpreting it as the
14:35
redemption of our body. Romans 8.
14:38
This highlights that the reward is the full manifestation of
14:41
what God has already granted through adoption.
14:44
It's the glorious revelation of our status as His children,
14:47
encompassing both spirit and body in perfect resurrected
14:51
form. And this entire process is a
14:54
further act of His grace. As Peter also states, the reward
14:58
of faith is eternal life. That underscores that faith is
15:01
the instrument for receiving this grace and apprehending this
15:04
blessedness. The receiving hand.
15:05
Faith is the receiving hand, the channel, not a meritorious act
15:09
in itself that somehow earns eternal life.
15:12
It's really important not to deduce merit from this.
15:14
The sources warn against those who, well, rudely insist on a
15:18
correlation between human merit and divine reward, which wanders
15:22
very far from God's own plan. OK, it's becoming clear that
15:25
reward doesn't mean we earn salvation, but it's a way God
15:28
interacts with us, maybe encourages us.
15:30
So what's the primary aim of these promises of reward, if not
15:33
to make us feel like we've earned something?
15:34
Why does God even bring up reward if it's not about merit?
15:37
Right. The sources are clear.
15:40
The Holy Spirit does not approve the worthiness of our works as
15:43
if they merited such a reward. Scripture's aim is not to allow
15:47
us to be exalted in God's sight, as if we could stand before Him,
15:52
puffing out our chests with our accomplishments.
15:54
Quite the opposite, you're saying.
15:55
Quite the opposite. It's aim is rather to restrain
15:59
our pride, to humble us, cast us down and utterly crush us in our
16:04
own estimation. Utterly crush us.
16:05
That sounds harsh. It sounds harsh, but it's
16:07
crucial. It's counterintuitive for us, as
16:10
human nature often seeks self exaltation, looks for ways to
16:13
accrue merit. The purpose isn't to praise our
16:16
effort as worthy of God's perfect standard, but to remind
16:19
us of our inherent inability to stand before Him in our own
16:22
strength. That sounds like a powerful
16:24
countercultural message, especially today in a world that
16:27
often measures worth by achievement and contribution.
16:30
Yeah, if it's not for pride, then why promise it?
16:32
Why hold out a reward if it just humbles us?
16:35
It is for a weakness that's the key.
16:37
The promise of reward is given to relieve the weakness of our
16:40
flesh by some comfort, preventing us from collapsing,
16:43
allaying our weariness. OK, comfort for weakness.
16:46
Think about the challenges of the Christian life.
16:49
We're called to renounce possessions, even ourselves, to
16:52
live under the discipline of the cross.
16:54
We often face despair, slander, affliction, tribulations.
16:58
As the source describes, wherever believers turn their
17:01
eyes in this world, they're confronted solely with despair,
17:05
a sense of being utterly out of place.
17:08
Paul himself recognized this, didn't he?
17:10
We are, of all men, most to be pitied, if we hope, only in this
17:13
world. Right, First Corinthians 15.
17:15
The promise of reward provides a hope that extends beyond the
17:18
immediate hardships, beyond the visible difficulties of this
17:22
life. It provides a divine
17:24
encouragement. So the promise of reward is a
17:27
divine antidote to discouragement, a way to keep us
17:30
going when the spiritual path gets tough, when we feel
17:32
overwhelmed by the trials of this world.
17:35
Precisely. It is the Lord's way of warning
17:37
us to hold our heads higher, to direct our eyes farther, so as
17:40
to find in Him that blessedness which they do not see in the
17:44
world. Looking beyond the present.
17:46
Yes, this prize, reward or recompense is a compensation for
17:51
their miseries, tribulations, slammers.
17:54
It changes all the evil things believers have suffered into
17:57
greater goods. It's God receiving his people
18:00
from toil into repose, from affliction into a prosperous
18:04
state, from sorrow into joy. From poverty into affluence,
18:08
disgrace into glory. Exactly.
18:10
It utterly reshapes their present suffering by placing it
18:13
in the context of a glorious future that God has already
18:15
promised out of his gracious disposition.
18:18
It gives present suffering eternal significance.
18:20
This redefines how we view our spiritual efforts and the
18:23
challenges we face. So a life of holiness, keeping
18:27
the commandments, enduring, suffering.
18:29
These are not access points to the Kingdom, meaning they don't
18:31
grant us entry. Rather, they are the path God's
18:34
chosen walk, the means by which we journey towards the Kingdom
18:37
rather than the things that get us into it.
18:40
Is that correct way to think about it?
18:41
That's a perceptive way to frame it.
18:43
The sources state that holiness of life is the way not indeed
18:46
that gives access to the glory of the heavenly Kingdom, but by
18:49
which those chosen by their God are led to its disclosure.
18:52
Led to its disclosure. It aligns with the truth that
18:55
God's good pleasure to glorify those whom he has sanctified.
18:59
Romans 830 Again, God's plan is to bring those He has set apart,
19:03
those He has made holy, to the full revelation of His glory.
19:08
The reward comforts our weakness, gives us a future
19:10
hope. But doesn't puff up our hearts.
19:12
Exactly. It does not puff up our hearts
19:14
with Vainglory because it's not about our worthiness to earn it.
19:18
It is entirely about God's plan to bring His sanctified people
19:21
to the full manifestation of His own glory and goodness.
19:24
OK, now one of the challenging aspects of human nature is our
19:28
tendency to rely on our own efforts.
19:30
Even if we understand the principles of grace, we might
19:33
still wonder deep down how our imperfect works could ever be
19:36
pleasing to a perfectly holy God, let alone worthy of any
19:40
kind of reward. What do the sources tell us
19:42
about this fundamental tension? Yeah, this is a crucial area.
19:45
The sources make it absolutely clear that any righteousness
19:48
imputed to our works, or they're being judged worthy of reward,
19:51
happens only through pardon. Only through pardon.
19:54
Our works are inherently defiled with some foul dregs.
19:58
That's striking phrase defiled with some foul dregs.
20:00
It comes directly from our sources.
20:03
Calvin uses it, and it's designed to profoundly humble
20:05
us. It means that even our most
20:08
outwardly righteous actions, the ones we might feel proudest of,
20:11
are, when held up to God's utterly perfect holy standard,
20:16
still tainted. Well, they're mixed with
20:18
imperfect motives, maybe a touch of pride, a hint of
20:21
self-interest, or just the inescapable imperfection of our
20:25
fallen human nature. It's like finding a small
20:27
impurity, a drag in what seems like perfectly Clearwater.
20:31
This isn't meant to discourage just from doing good, but to
20:34
absolutely demolish any notion that our works in and of
20:38
themselves could mirror anything from a perfectly holy God.
20:41
They simply cannot satisfy Him on their own terms if weighed
20:44
according to the standard of His judgement.
20:46
So our best efforts, even our purest intentions, when
20:49
scrutinized by God's perfect standard, they fall short.
20:52
They're never truly clean enough to earn anything on their own.
20:55
That's the clear message, indeed.
20:57
And to prevent discouragement, because recognizing this truth
21:01
could lead to despair. Scripture teaches that our works
21:05
are pleasing only through pardon.
21:08
This is where God's compassion covered over.
21:11
Whatever unrighteousness was in them, He wiped out by his
21:14
boundless kindness. What in them deserves
21:16
punishment? So it's not that our works
21:18
become perfect. No, it's not that they suddenly
21:21
become perfect in themselves, it's that God's grace and
21:24
forgiveness make them acceptable to Him, covering their inherent
21:27
flaws, making them presentable in His sight.
21:30
Our works aren't inherently meritorious, but God by His
21:33
kindness accounts them as such, for Christ's sake.
21:37
That shifts our entire perspective, doesn't it?
21:39
The idea that even our best efforts, which we might have
21:41
taken pride in, are only acceptable because they are
21:44
covered by God's pardon. It almost sounds too good to be
21:47
true. Or maybe for some it might even
21:49
feel like it devalues human striving for good.
21:52
How do we hold on to the dignity of striving for good while
21:55
acknowledging its utter dependence on divine
21:57
forgiveness? What does Augustine cited in our
21:59
sources say about this? Augustine's words are quite
22:02
fitting here and serve as a powerful reminder of Grace's
22:05
precedence. He asks a critical question, To
22:09
whom should the righteous judge have awarded the Crown if the
22:12
merciful Father had not bestowed grace?
22:14
Implying no one. Exactly.
22:16
It implies that without God's prior act of grace, no human
22:20
action could ever be deemed worthy of a heavenly crown.
22:24
He also states how could there be righteousness unless the
22:27
grace that justifies the ungodly had gone before?
22:30
Grace comes first again. It means grace is the
22:33
prerequisite for any righteousness, even in our good
22:35
deeds, because it first justifies the ungodly, making
22:38
them capable of doing anything pleasing to God.
22:41
It's God's initial act of kindness and justification that
22:44
makes all subsequent good works possible and acceptable.
22:48
So grace is the prerequisite. It's all rooted in God's initial
22:51
kindness and his act of justification rather than our
22:53
performance. Precisely.
22:55
Augustine further calls eternal life itself grace, because even
22:58
though it is rendered to works, it is given for God's free
23:01
gifts. He makes a compelling comparison
23:04
between two men, one may be of marvelously holy and perfect
23:08
life, and another imperfect but faithful, who accuses himself
23:12
and all his wrongdoings and praises God and all his good
23:14
works. Augustine concludes that the
23:16
latter shall be delivered on account of his right faith that
23:19
he has in God, since it works through love.
23:22
Faith working through love. Yes, and this is a key point.
23:25
The righteousness of good works depends upon the fact that God
23:29
by pardon approves them. It is God's acceptance and
23:32
forgiveness, applied to us through faith in Christ, that
23:35
lend any value or acceptability to our deeds.
23:37
So while works are important as fruit of faith.
23:40
Their acceptance and any reward from them flow entirely from
23:44
God's gracious covering and approval, not their inherent
23:47
perfection. OK, now we often hear phrases
23:50
like treasures in heaven or rewards for suffering and some
23:53
people definitely misinterpret these to mean earning salvation
23:56
or maybe a higher place in heaven through merit.
23:59
How do the sources help us understand these statements in
24:01
light of grace avoiding that trap of works righteousness?
24:04
Right passages like Luke 16.9 talking about making friends of
24:08
the mammon of unrighteousness, or of First Timothy 6
24:11
admonishing the rich to be rich in good works and treasure for
24:15
themselves a good foundation for the coming age.
24:18
Yeah, those verses. Those are key.
24:20
The sources tell us that good works are likened to the riches
24:23
we shall enjoy in the blessedness of eternal life.
24:26
The emphasis here isn't on earning eternal life itself, but
24:30
on how these works relate to the enjoyment or the fullness of
24:33
that life already given by grace.
24:35
It's about where we place our affections and resources, what
24:38
kind of satisfaction we're seeking.
24:40
So it's not about earning a spot in heaven, but about directing
24:43
our focus and resources differently, investing in what
24:46
truly lasts and brings satisfaction in the new
24:48
creation. That's an accurate way to look
24:50
at. But if Christ's statement is
24:51
true, where our treasure is, there resides our heart.
24:54
Matthew 6.21 Yeah. Then, just as worldly people
24:57
pursue earthly delights that are fleeting and ultimately
25:00
unsatisfying, the levers should ensure they transfer the things
25:03
they want truly to enjoy to a place where they will have life
25:06
unceasing, knowing this present life will soon vanish like a
25:09
dream. A spiritual relocation strategy.
25:12
That's a good term for it. Moving our affections and our
25:15
true investments from the temporary and perishable to the
25:18
eternal and truly satisfying it prompts A radical reevaluation
25:22
of our priorities. This sounds like a spiritual
25:24
relocation strategy. How do we transmit our
25:28
possessions or our efforts to heaven if they can't physically
25:31
go with us? What does that practically look
25:33
like in our lives today? Well, the primary way mention is
25:36
by providing for the needs of the poor and demonstrating
25:39
tangible love to our neighbors. What is given to them, the Lord
25:42
reckons, is given to Himself. That's Matthew 25.40 again.
25:46
Treating others as we would treat Christ.
25:48
Yes, the sources cite Proverbs 19.17 He who gives to the poor
25:53
lends to the Lord, and 2nd Corinthians 9.6 He who sows
25:56
bountifully shall reap bountifully.
25:58
These acts of love and generosity are deposited in the
26:01
Lord's hand. Deposited like a bank account.
26:03
In a manner of speaking. And he, as he is a faithful
26:07
custodian, will one day repay it with plentiful interest.
26:11
It's a divine accounting system where God ensures our acts of
26:14
kindness and mercy are preserved and multiplied, bringing joy not
26:17
only in this life, but especially in the blessedness of
26:20
the life to come. It assured us our kindness isn't
26:22
wasted. This highlights God's incredible
26:25
faithfulness and generosity, but again, for some it might still
26:28
feel like it ties works to a return, a spiritual quid and pro
26:32
quo. How do we ensure we don't slip
26:34
back into a works righteousness mindset here, thinking our
26:37
charity earns us something, even if it's just interest?
26:40
That's always the danger, isn't it?
26:42
Slipping back into that mindset, the sources are clear.
26:44
These testimonies duly infer nothing except the pure
26:47
inclining of God's mercy toward us.
26:49
OK, it points back to his mercy. Yes, he permits none of them to
26:54
be lost in order to quicken us to well doing, to encourage us.
26:57
This happens even though the services we offer are in
27:00
themselves unworthy even of his glance.
27:02
Unworthy even of his glance. Strong words.
27:05
They are. It means the motivation for good
27:07
works isn't their value in terms of merit, but God's kindness,
27:12
His gracious disposition which ensures our efforts are not in
27:15
vain. It's His gracious choice to
27:17
acknowledge and reward our efforts, not an obligation based
27:20
on their inherent worth. So our actions are prompted by
27:23
His mercy, and their reward flows from it too.
27:26
Exactly demonstrating his character rather than
27:29
establishing our merit. Yeah, let's consider another
27:31
area where reward comes up, Suffering and tribulations.
27:35
Paul in 2nd Thessalonians 1.5 says suffering makes us counted
27:40
worthy of God's Kingdom. That's a strong phrase.
27:42
Counted worthy. How do we grasp this worthiness
27:45
without it implying merit from our pain or endurance?
27:48
Yeah, counted worthy can definitely trip people up.
27:50
The sources explained that no worth of merit is there meant
27:53
it's not about earning worthiness through suffering.
27:56
So what does it mean then? Instead, this worthiness
27:58
signifies that God the Father wills that we whom he has chosen
28:02
as sons be conformed to Christ, his first born.
28:05
Conformed to Christ, like becoming more like Him.
28:07
Yes, just as Christ suffered before entering His glory, so
28:11
too through many tribulations, we must enter the Kingdom of
28:14
heaven. That's Acts 14.22.
28:17
Suffering isn't earning our way in.
28:19
It's part of the process of being shaped into the likeness
28:22
of our Savior. It's about being made suitable,
28:24
relationally identified, not about making ourselves
28:27
inherently worthy through our pain.
28:29
That's a really poignant image. Suffering is a mark of identity,
28:32
almost like a family Crest, a way we mirror his path.
28:36
But I think for many listeners, even those who understand
28:38
Reformed theology, the idea of suffering is still deeply
28:42
uncomfortable, often seen as something to be avoided at all
28:44
costs. How do we help someone move from
28:47
viewing suffering as mere hardship to understanding it as
28:50
a significant mark of God's children without sounding
28:53
dismissive of real pain? What's the practical comfort
28:55
here? That's a vital consideration.
28:57
Absolutely. We must never minimize real
28:59
pain. The comfort isn't in denying the
29:01
pain, but in understanding its context.
29:04
When we suffer for Christ name, it's as if certain marks are
29:07
branded upon us by which God commonly designates the sheep of
29:10
his flock. Branded like ownership marks.
29:13
In a sense, in this way we are accounted worthy of God's
29:16
Kingdom because we bear in our body the marks of our Lord and
29:19
Master. Galatians 6.17.
29:22
These are the signs of God's children.
29:25
This includes carrying the mortification of Jesus Christ in
29:28
our bodies so that His life may be manifested in us.
29:30
That's Second Corinthians 4 point, Son.
29:32
Mortification, putting sin to death, right, and the suffering
29:35
that comes with following Christ.
29:36
Yes, the practical comfort is this.
29:39
Our suffering is not meaningless.
29:41
It connects us to Christ in a profound way, identifying us
29:45
with Him and His own experience. It assures us that we are truly
29:48
His, that He is working in us, and that our experience aligns
29:51
with the path He himself walked. It gives our pain a purpose
29:55
beyond itself, a purpose tied directly to our relationship
29:58
with God. That connects suffering to a
29:59
deeper spiritual reality, one that is truly comforting, not
30:03
just a painful experience. What about God's justice in all
30:07
this? Hebrew 6.10 says God is not so
30:09
unjust as to forget your work and the love that you showed in
30:12
His name. That sounds very much like God
30:15
owes us something for our efforts, which again seems to
30:17
challenge this grace alone framework.
30:20
How do we reconcile justice with pure grace here?
30:23
That's a vital point, and it's where a deeper understanding
30:25
God's character comes in. When the sources speak of God's
30:28
justice in these contexts, it's not the justice of paying a debt
30:32
owed based on our merit. OK, so not transactional
30:34
justice. No, instead it refers more
30:36
precisely to the truth of the divine promise, His own
30:40
unwavering faithfulness to His Word and His gracious
30:42
commitments. His justice is His faithfulness
30:45
to Himself and His promises. So his justice is about his
30:49
reliability. Exactly.
30:51
It's an assurance that God will never relegate to oblivion his
30:54
children's service, and that the trouble born for His name will
30:57
not be in vain. It's God upholding His own
31:00
character and His prior gracious declarations, not looking at a
31:04
Ledger of our earned wages. His justice here is about His
31:07
integrity and following through on what He is freely promised to
31:10
do for His children. So God is faithful to His Word,
31:14
not paying a debt for our efforts, but demonstrating His
31:17
faithfulness to his prior commitments to us, the
31:20
commitments he made out of his own disposition.
31:22
You've captured the essence perfectly.
31:24
Augustine's saying is fitting here.
31:25
The Lord is faithful who made himself our debtor, not by
31:28
accepting anything from us, but by promising us all things.
31:31
He made himself our debtor by promising Wow.
31:34
Right. This means God's faithfulness to
31:36
His gracious pledges ensures a reward, even though our services
31:39
are unworthy even of His glance. Tribulations, therefore, serve
31:43
to strengthen our hope in God's Kingdom and confirm His
31:46
faithfulness. They are a means by which God
31:48
accomplishes His purposes in us, not a currency by which we earn
31:52
His favor. Our suffering isn't a bargaining
31:54
chip. No, but a Crucible in which our
31:57
faith is refined and our future hope confirmed by a God who
32:01
keeps his promises. This brings us to another
32:03
central point of discussion often debated in Christian
32:06
circles, Paul's statements in First Corinthians 13 about love
32:10
being greater than faith and hope.
32:12
Now, if justification is by faith alone, as Reformed
32:16
theology teaches, how can love be greater?
32:19
Does this mean love justifies more powerfully, or is somehow
32:22
more meritorious in God's eyes? This seems like a contradiction
32:26
to many. Yeah, this is a vital
32:28
distinction, and 1 the Reformers clarified with great care.
32:31
The sources addressed this directly, refuting the argument
32:34
that because love excels faith, it therefore justifies more
32:37
powerfully those who held this view, often termed Sophists or
32:41
Pharisees, in the sources. OK.
32:43
Those terms, what do they mean by them in this context?
32:45
Right, good question. It's important to understand
32:47
these not just as insults, but as theological categories.
32:51
Sophists often referred to certain scholastic theologians
32:54
of the late medieval period, whose reasoning, from the
32:57
Reformers perspective, sometimes emphasize human capability and
33:01
merit in a way that obscured God's absolute grace.
33:04
And Pharisees, of course, alludes to the ancient Jewish
33:07
group who, in their zealous adherence to the law, often
33:11
missed its deeper spiritual intent and sought righteousness
33:14
through their own meticulous performance.
33:16
Both groups, in Calvin's view made a similar error.
33:20
What error? They looked for the basis of
33:22
righteousness within human actions or inherent goodness
33:25
like love, rather than solely in God's unmerited favor.
33:28
In Christ's perfect work, they argued that love, being
33:31
inherently good and pleasing to God, could by its own intrinsic
33:34
worth, merit righteousness and thus offer a stronger path to
33:38
justification than mere faith. So their reasoning was that
33:41
love, by its own inherent goodness, could earn
33:44
righteousness. They believe love was the key to
33:47
earning God's favor rather than simply receiving it.
33:50
Yes, that's their reasoning. However, the sources firmly
33:53
state that the power of justifying which faith possesses
33:56
does not lie in any worth of works or in any intrinsic
34:00
quality of faith itself. So faith isn't inherently worthy
34:03
either. No.
34:04
Instead, our justification rests upon God's mercy alone and
34:08
Christ's merit. Faith, in this framework, is
34:10
simply an instrument whereby we obtain free the righteousness of
34:14
Christ. It's the receiving mechanism,
34:16
the open hand, that apprehends Christ's righteousness.
34:20
OK, love doesn't act as this instrument for obtaining
34:23
righteousness. Love is a consequence, a fruit
34:26
of justification, not its cause. So faith is the hand that
34:29
receives Christ's righteousness, the channel of justification,
34:33
while love is something else entirely.
34:35
In this context, it seems like Paul's talking about two
34:37
different categories of greatness.
34:39
You've hit upon a critical insight there.
34:41
When Paul says love is greater than faith, he means it is more
34:44
fruitful in terms of its outward expression and benefit to
34:47
others. More fruitful.
34:49
OK, it extends farther in its influence and reach within the
34:52
Christian community and beyond. It serves more actively,
34:55
benefiting others through its deeds.
34:57
And crucially, it flourishes forever, whereas the use of
35:01
faith continues only for a time. Why only for a time?
35:05
Well, faith is trust in what is unseen.
35:07
When we see God face to face, the object of faith is seen, and
35:11
faith in that sense is no longer needed, but love.
35:14
Love continues. It's an eternal characteristic
35:17
of God and His people. OK, so Love's greatness is in
35:20
its enduring quality and practical expression.
35:23
Exactly. Paul is talking about the
35:25
enduring quality and practical application of love, not its
35:28
ability to justify us before God.
35:30
That's a truly illuminating distinction.
35:32
So Love's greatness is in its qualities, its duration, its
35:35
practical expression, not its ability to justify or earn.
35:38
The sources even use a striking analogy to illustrate this
35:41
logical error of confusing different kinds of greatness.
35:44
Indeed, a really helpful one to argue that love justifies more
35:48
because it excels faith is as if someone argued that a king is
35:52
more capable of making a shoe than a Shoemaker is because he
35:55
is infinitely more eminent. OK, that's clear.
35:59
A king might be greater, but not better at making shoes.
36:02
Exactly. The analogy clearly shows that
36:05
different excellences do not equate to the same functional
36:07
power, especially regarding justification.
36:10
A King's greatness lies in His rule, His Majesty, His
36:14
authority, not in his shoe making ability.
36:17
Similarly, love has its own preeminent place in the
36:21
Christian life, but that place is not to justify.
36:23
The sources lament that those who argue for justification by
36:26
love overlook God's mercy and Passover.
36:29
Christ, in whom lies the sum of righteousness.
36:32
They are looking for merit in human actions rather than simply
36:35
receiving the gift of Christ's perfect work and God's free
36:38
mercy. This leads us to yet another
36:40
point of confusion for many Christ's own words in Matthew
36:43
19,007 when He tells the rich young ruler, If you would enter
36:47
into life, keep the commandments.
36:49
Doesn't that sound like a direct instruction to earn salvation
36:52
through obedience? A straightforward path of works
36:54
that seems to contradict everything we've been discussing
36:56
about grace. Yeah, on the surface it might
36:58
seem so. It's one of those verses people
37:00
point to. But the source has clarified
37:02
that Christ did not accommodate his replies to those with whom
37:05
he saw that he had to deal. Meaning he tailored his answer.
37:08
Precisely this rich young ruler was accustomed to the persuasion
37:13
of law righteousness. He was blinded himself with
37:16
confidence in works seeking what were works of righteousness
37:19
whereby salvation is acquired. Christ's answer wasn't a general
37:23
path to salvation for everyone, but a specific, tailored
37:27
response to this individual's self perception and legalistic
37:30
mindset. The ruler thought he could earn
37:32
it. He believed he could, by his own
37:34
efforts, earn eternal life. So Christ directs him to the
37:37
standard he thought he could meet.
37:39
So Christ's answer was tailored to expose the rulers own
37:42
self-confidence and his misunderstanding of true
37:45
righteousness rather than endorsing works.
37:48
Righteousness is a viable path. It was more like a diagnostic
37:51
than a prescription for salvation.
37:53
That's the key. The ruler is rightly sent back
37:56
to the law, where in there is a perfect mirror of righteousness.
38:00
For Christians, understanding the commandments is crucial, not
38:03
for earning salvation, but for realizing our own inability to
38:06
meet God's perfect standard. The law shows us we can't do it.
38:09
Yes, we too must know. How could they flee to Christ
38:13
unless they recognize that they had plunged from the way of life
38:16
over the brink of death? The law acts like that
38:20
diagnostic tool, a spiritual mirror.
38:23
When we look into it honestly, it doesn't show us our own moral
38:26
goodness that can earn favor. Instead, it reveals our
38:29
blemishes, our imperfections, our deep need for a savior.
38:33
The law then serves to humble us and show our desperate need for
38:36
a Savior, rather than acting as a checklist for earning God's
38:39
favor or an entry visa to the Kingdom.
38:41
Precisely, only by distinguishing how great is the
38:43
difference between their life and divine righteousness that
38:46
consists in accepting the law, are they made aware that in
38:49
order to recover salvation, their refuge is in Christ.
38:52
We see the gap. See the gap?
38:54
Since none of us is capable of keeping the commandments
38:56
perfectly, we must be take ourselves to another help, that
39:00
is to faith in Christ. The law exposes our spiritual
39:04
bankruptcy and drives us to the one who can provide true
39:06
righteousness, Christ Himself. It leaves us with no option but
39:10
to look outside ourselves for salvation.
39:12
So the law, far from being a path to earn salvation, becomes
39:16
a tutor that points us to Christ, who offers true rest to
39:19
those burdened by their inability to keep the law.
39:22
It's a guide to our spiritual need.
39:24
Absolutely. While the law calls for perfect
39:26
obedience, a single sin makes 1 guilty of death because he is
39:30
offended against God's majesty, James 2 point nail 11 reminds
39:33
us. For whoever keeps the whole law
39:35
and yet stumbles at just one point is guilty of breaking all
39:38
of it. Guilty of all of it.
39:39
This stark contrast highlights that true righteousness is
39:43
utterly beyond human attainment. This underscores the absolute
39:47
necessity of Christ's perfect righteousness, which is received
39:51
through faith alone. It is Christ who fulfills the
39:54
law perfectly on our behalf and provides the rest we cannot earn
39:57
by our own strenuous efforts. The law serves to show us how
40:01
much we need His perfect fulfillment.
40:04
We've unpacked a lot today, going through layers of meaning
40:06
in these vital concepts. Grace rewards works.
40:11
What's the ultimate synthesis? How do these fit together in a
40:13
reformed understanding? What's the main take away for
40:15
our listeners? Well, the core principle, the
40:17
bedrock remains that our justification and salvation rest
40:21
entirely upon God's mercy alone and Christo's merit alone.
40:25
Mercy and merit, Gods in Christ, not ours.
40:27
Exactly. Faith serves as the instrument,
40:29
the channel through which we freely obtain Christo's
40:32
righteousness. Our good works while certainly
40:34
valuable and expected as a result of our salvation.
40:37
They're not optional, but. They're not optional, no, but
40:39
they do not merit salvation or create the righteousness that
40:41
justifies us before God. They are not the cause of our
40:44
acceptance with Him. So works are not the cause of
40:47
our salvation, but rather a response and evidence of it.
40:51
They flow from salvation rather than creating it.
40:53
You've put it well. Works are a grateful response to
40:56
God's saving grace. They're also a means by which we
40:59
are trained, remember, trained to anticipate and experience the
41:03
full fruition of the blessings already granted to us through
41:05
adoption. They are a sign of being
41:07
conformed to Christ, a spiritual alignment with his character,
41:11
and any reward attached to them is a manifestation of God's
41:14
boundless kindness, His gracious disposition.
41:17
Not a payment. Not a payment for our efforts or
41:19
an earned bonus. His compassion covers the
41:22
imperfections of our works, making them acceptable and
41:25
pleasing to them even though they are inherently defiled with
41:28
some foul dregs. This entire dynamic is just a
41:31
testament to God's pure grace from beginning to end.
41:34
That brings a profound coherence to these ideas.
41:37
God's faithfulness to His promises ensures that our
41:40
efforts, however imperfect, are not lost.
41:43
But this is always due to His grace, not our merit.
41:46
This is the divine balance that allows for both human action and
41:49
divine sovereignty. And that concludes our deep dive
41:52
into the nature of rewards, grace, and good works.
41:55
We hope this exploration has provided you with a clearer
41:58
perspective on this crucial aspect of our faith.
42:01
What stands out to you from today's discussion?
42:03
Maybe the next time you hear talk of rewards in a spiritual
42:06
context, you'll be able to consider if it's truly about
42:09
earning something, or if it's about the incredible generosity
42:12
of a God who has already given us everything through his Son
42:15
and who then, by his own free choice, blesses our grateful,
42:19
though imperfect, response. It's a concept that truly
42:22
humbles us, doesn't it? Directing our attention away
42:25
from ourselves and towards the glorious, unmerited favor of
42:28
God. Thank you for joining us for
42:30
this deep dive. Until next time, keep pondering
42:33
these truths and seeking to understand more fully the riches
42:36
of God's grace.