Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP192: Getting Your Ecommerce Marketplace Data Right & Selling Effectively, with eCommeleon
Transcript
- 0:02Thanks for listening to the Re Platform podcast, sponsored by
- 0:04Crown Peak and Elastic Path and hosted by me, James Gerden
- 0:07Rogers. Thanks for joining this your
- 0:09first episode. We hope you enjoy it.
- 0:11We've got a lot of time and effort to bring you really cool
- 0:13guests, lots of interesting content.
- 0:15It's all completely free of charge.
- 0:16Please help us keep that that way.
- 0:18Tell other people about the podcast, spread the words, Share
- 0:21our posts on LinkedIn and Twitter.
- 0:23And the best thing you can do to help is give us a rate on Apple,
- 0:25Spotify, YouTube or where else you listen or watch.
- 0:28So thanks. We have enjoyed this episode.
- 0:30Let me set up and then I'll introduce our guests.
- 0:32We're talking about third party ecommerce, marketplace
- 0:34integrations and data management.
- 0:36With the Chameleon, we're going to cover common challenges for
- 0:39retailers, selling on 3rd party marketplaces, handling data
- 0:43setups and imports and data feeds and all the management
- 0:46among other things. So welcome to Jesse Mac.
- 0:48How are you doing, Sir? Thank you for the great intro
- 0:52James. I'm doing really well and it's
- 0:54really nice to be on this side of the table.
- 0:57Yeah, yeah, we recently, I came on your podcast recently, so
- 1:00we're doing tit for tat podcasting, which is great.
- 1:02So yeah, this is and this is a really important topic as well
- 1:05because marketplace commerce has really grown our last few years.
- 1:08More retailers are looking at, at launching their own
- 1:11marketplaces. People are exploiting A wider
- 1:13base of marketplaces for their third party selling rather than
- 1:16just like Amazon. So I think this is really
- 1:18getting you guys obviously well placed to give some expertise in
- 1:20there. So before we start asking the
- 1:22questions, you want to give people a bit of your background.
- 1:24I know that you're from the UK, but you wind up working Germany.
- 1:28You're at E Chameleon, so do you want to do what you do, how
- 1:31you've got there? And then also give us that
- 1:33elevator pitch on what E Chameleon is.
- 1:38Yeah, for sure. I guess I'll preface it by
- 1:41saying I'm the sales marketing front.
- 1:47That E Chamedium, but my business partner Edward, he's
- 1:49the brains behind the operation. He actually founded an agency
- 1:52back in 2007 where the original purpose was helping specifically
- 1:57Channel advisor users to expand internationally by marketplaces.
- 2:01And over the years, this agency kind of grew to bring in other
- 2:06tools, other technologies. We worked with pretty much every
- 2:09major channel management tool. That is out there and we would
- 2:13help sellers primarily from the UK and the US to expand into
- 2:16Germany, France, Italy, Spain, originally via eBay.
- 2:19But then Amazon came into play. And as more and more
- 2:23marketplaces became available at this agency, we would basically
- 2:27trying to help our sellers to succeed on those marketplaces
- 2:32using the existing technology that they had.
- 2:35And what we now sell as the Chameleons started out as a
- 2:38series of internal tools at that agency.
- 2:42That were designed to plug some of the gaps that were missing in
- 2:44existing channel management tools specifically with regards
- 2:48to dealing with large sets of product data.
- 2:51You know we had sellers with sometimes millions of skews,
- 2:54more commonly it was within sort of 1000 to 100,000 skew range,
- 3:00but across every category in multiple languages and obviously
- 3:04if you're selling on. Just your own website.
- 3:07You have a lot of control over how a listing is allowed to
- 3:09look. How long can a title be?
- 3:11Do you want to call this tshirt? You know, dark blue or royal
- 3:14blue or Navy blue? But as soon as you start selling
- 3:17on external channels, you have to give up some semblance of
- 3:20that control. And the marketplaces tend to
- 3:26have their own requirements as to how that data has to look,
- 3:29what they want to receive. And so we had to build some
- 3:32internal tools at this agency, which my business partner whose
- 3:34PhD is in. Some some form of mathematics
- 3:38and data science even I don't understand it completely but
- 3:41he's a genius with what with with regards to product data and
- 3:46marketplaces now he oversaw the creation of tools designed to
- 3:54complement the channel management tools which would
- 3:56solve that problem and and that is what we now sell as external
- 4:00tools via Recommedian and and since then we've we've also gone
- 4:03into that. Channel management space started
- 4:06building the APIs to be able to transfer the data which was
- 4:09created to the marketplaces and also to collect order
- 4:13information from the marketplaces to pass it on to
- 4:16ERP systems or order management systems or wherever it needs to
- 4:19go. So that's kind of the very Long
- 4:22story short, but and I guess you also asked who I am, my role
- 4:27there is that I'm one of the two founders.
- 4:31As I said, I take care of more of the sales marketing.
- 4:35Customer slash external facing stuff, whereas my business
- 4:40partner deals with making sure we've got a good product that's
- 4:42that's working and operational. Great.
- 4:46And I'll ask first question. So I guess what are the biggest
- 4:50and most common issues you're seeing for brands and businesses
- 4:54that you know, selling direct but then also selling on
- 4:56marketplaces and how are you addressing them with your
- 4:59platform? I guess the first probably the
- 5:03biggest issue is the the amount of choice that a ecommerce
- 5:08business has. If they open the door to the
- 5:11idea of selling on 3rd party marketplaces, it's very easy to
- 5:14say yeah, we'll add Amazon, especially if you're a reseller
- 5:17and your products are already being you know the products that
- 5:20you're selling are already being sold by a competitor on Amazon.
- 5:23Very very easy to add your listings to theirs and and
- 5:27simply wait until you get the buy box or.
- 5:30Fight for the fight for the cheapest price to be able to
- 5:34sell the products on Amazon as well.
- 5:36But really as he as he mentioned, the marketplace space
- 5:40has changed a lot in in the last few years.
- 5:43Obviously it was bolstered a lot by the e-commerce boom through
- 5:45COVID, but even before that there were more and more
- 5:48marketplaces opening up. You know nowadays you've got in
- 5:50the UK, you've got Debenhams, Decathlon, B&Q, the Superdrug.
- 5:55There's no end of well known businesses.
- 5:59Which are becoming marketplaces. A lot of these are actually more
- 6:04drop shipping models than marketplaces.
- 6:05And it's kind of a strange distinction, but there is one in
- 6:08terms of who's the actual legal seller of record.
- 6:11But effectively, a lot of businesses have realized that by
- 6:14becoming a marketplace, it's a good way to add products to your
- 6:20site where you're already getting a lot of traffic without
- 6:23having to take any kind of inventory risk and without
- 6:25having to buy a bunch of products that you don't know if
- 6:27you're going to be able to sell or you don't know if it's going
- 6:29to. Quite matched with your buyer.
- 6:30You can just say, hey, you know what, sell a random company X
- 6:35connect to our website. You can put your products on
- 6:38here and we'll see if it sells. If it sells well, then they'll
- 6:40probably just do what Amazon does and create their own
- 6:42version and start selling them anyway.
- 6:44That's I guess, the risk. Right.
- 6:48Yeah, I think we've definitely seen that trend a lot recently.
- 6:51I think partly driven by. Increased cost of acquisition
- 6:56and people looking for like more channels and like to diversify
- 6:59and partly I guess just to because there's so many new kind
- 7:04of more niche marketplaces popping up and so many people
- 7:08are like you say doing drop shipping.
- 7:09So I think a lot of people are kind of jumping on that
- 7:12bandwagon at the moment. So your product integrates with
- 7:16ecom platforms like Shop 5, Big Commerce, Salesforce, Adobe.
- 7:21How are you managing that integration?
- 7:23Do you have kind of connectors or apps or you kind of typically
- 7:28go more down the bespoke route and kind of building out API
- 7:31connections per customer? So what we typically say is that
- 7:35E chameleon, the whole thing with the chameleon is
- 7:39flexibility adaptation. We typically say that E
- 7:41Chameleon is a custom solution that is available off the shelf.
- 7:45So. There's a for a lot of sellers,
- 7:48a very standard channel management solution will be
- 7:50enough. Plug in, press go.
- 7:53It's easy. If you're selling fashion or
- 7:55something with very clean homogeneous data, it's quite
- 7:59simple to bolt on something like that.
- 8:01For a lot of sellers that are maybe in more complicated
- 8:04categories or that maybe got more legacy software to deal
- 8:07with, it gets a bit more challenging to bolt on an
- 8:11external piece of tech for the integrations and that's where.
- 8:15And that's more our sweet spot. So what we tend to do in those
- 8:19situations is we need to look first at what the seller is
- 8:21actually doing, what other technology do they have and
- 8:25where can we fit in that. You mentioned Adobe.
- 8:26We don't actually have an integration with Adobe because
- 8:29to be honest, it's not really worth building one for a lot of
- 8:33people moving away from it from my experience.
- 8:37But what we need with an integration is we need somewhere
- 8:41to get some form of product data.
- 8:43It in some cases it's just an EAN or a skew and an inventory
- 8:49amount and the rest of it will be created in the Chameleon.
- 8:52So then we don't need to get anything else and we generally
- 8:54need somewhere to send order data from a marketplace, whether
- 8:57that's an ERP or a shop system or an order management system.
- 9:02So the technical connections that we need are not that many.
- 9:07The rest of it is on the marketplace side and again,
- 9:09that's where then? We already have all of those
- 9:11existing. So it's purely just about making
- 9:13that initial connection between the existing systems and and E
- 9:16Chameleon, we've got a very simple API if the customer, if
- 9:21the seller has their own developer resources in house.
- 9:25But really we can also work with anything that exports product
- 9:29data and imports all the data even by a CSV or whatever format
- 9:33they need. So it's again, it's kind of what
- 9:36does that seller need and how can we fit into that process,
- 9:40attract your complete product discovery growth engine, create
- 9:45relevant shopping experiences that convert into sales and grow
- 9:48online revenue with personalized search, merchandising and
- 9:52recommendation solutions powered by AI.
- 9:54Find out more at attract.com. The data important and cleansing
- 10:01is always fun. I know we talked about it when
- 10:03we we first connected and some businesses still rely on loads
- 10:07of different spreadsheets adding loads of different forms of
- 10:11rules to change and map data, which can be very, very
- 10:14challenging to maintain. One question people have is how
- 10:18much effort do they need to put in to get data cleaned and ready
- 10:22for your tool to use versus what automation tools and processes
- 10:26do you bring to the table as standard to transform their base
- 10:29data into marketplace ready stuff.
- 10:35So this depends a lot on the category.
- 10:38It also depends a lot on the the channels that they want to sell
- 10:42on. Some marketplaces do make it
- 10:45easy. They have fewer requirements or
- 10:48they they change their requirements less frequently.
- 10:51eBay changes their requirements quite a lot, as does Amazon.
- 10:54So I guess the larger marketplace changes that change
- 10:57their requirements a lot. I guess the first thing I would
- 11:00say is that it's not necessarily bad to work with spreadsheets.
- 11:05A lot of sellers will use Google Sheets these days because it's
- 11:07easy to then connect that to other other systems.
- 11:10One of our products is a PIM solution.
- 11:12And what we try to use there is what we refer to as a single
- 11:18source of truth, where we, we help our sellers to create very
- 11:21granular product data so that for example, they only have to
- 11:25say, yeah, the Tshirt's dark blue, but if we know that on
- 11:28auto it has to be Dunkel Blau and on.
- 11:31Run by it has to be royal blue based on that particular
- 11:34category and subcategory. We can build automations around
- 11:37that. But again, that's a very
- 11:40different automation for an apparel seller than it would be
- 11:42for someone selling secondhand iPhones.
- 11:44And so that's where we have to adapt the system that we've got
- 11:49specific to the seller. Moving a chameleon aside, I
- 11:53think any sort of more generic setup, regardless of if you've
- 11:57got a PIM or not, or if you don't, if you are managing in
- 11:59spreadsheets. I think the most important thing
- 12:01is to keep product data really granular.
- 12:05What I mean by that is if you're selling laptops, for example,
- 12:09it's very easy to have a product title like Asus laptop, bunch of
- 12:14random numbers, capacity of wrap, how much RAM, how much
- 12:20storage space has it got, what other special features has it
- 12:22got? And most laptop sellers will
- 12:25typically just pack all of that information into a title.
- 12:29And then they have to type it all in again in a bunch of
- 12:31different places because they've got to fill in a field called.
- 12:33How much RAM has it got? They have to fill in a field
- 12:35called, how much hard drive space is there?
- 12:37Etc, etc, etc. By keeping that data granular
- 12:41and having one column for the brand, another one for the
- 12:45product type, another one for the RAM, another one for the
- 12:48storage space, the seller can then create a title with.
- 12:52I mean we have a special functionality for it called a
- 12:55string builder where you can kind of put them together in a
- 12:57specific order. But you can do it with Excel
- 12:59with concatenate cells and just pack that information together
- 13:03in a specific structure, so to say.
- 13:07And then you can. If you want to get re smart with
- 13:09Excel, you can combine that with lookup lists to translate it.
- 13:13You can have different structures based on different
- 13:16product types and it's very easy to then build out other
- 13:22information off the back of this data.
- 13:24But you first need to have very clean and granular data at the
- 13:27beginning that you're working with.
- 13:29Yeah. One of the the common issues is
- 13:31normalization, where different people have entered data over
- 13:34time and you've got, you know, category trees that vary.
- 13:38So you might have somebody who's put men, somebody who's used
- 13:41men's different marketplaces to have different needs.
- 13:44In terms of the exact requirements, how, how do you
- 13:47handle that? Because do you have a
- 13:48standardized map for key marketplaces where it's
- 13:52literally okay, We understand that A = B and we'll do that
- 13:54mapping for you. Yeah.
- 13:59So I guess that's that's something that you mean
- 14:02specifically with the Chameleon, how how we handle it with our
- 14:06technology. Yeah, because a lot of the time
- 14:08people, I mean, most times merchants I've worked with who
- 14:10need help, their data isn't a bit for mass and they're trying
- 14:13to avoid having to go through manually and sort everything out
- 14:17and look at tools that can help take away some of that heavy
- 14:20lifting from them. Yeah, so.
- 14:25That is something that's very different, not just channel for
- 14:29channel, but you know, it's not just Amazon versus eBay versus
- 14:33auto versus on by. It can be Amazon UK versus
- 14:37Amazon US, but it can also be Amazon men's clothes, Amazon UK
- 14:41men's clothes versus Amazon UK women's clothes.
- 14:45And it can even be as granular as you know, completely
- 14:47different rules for men's trousers versus men's tshirts.
- 14:50So we have to be a little bit careful.
- 14:54With an automation perspective that we don't just build
- 14:57something for Amazon, just for eBay.
- 14:59So we tend to work more from a seller perspective because in
- 15:03the same sense that every marketplace is different, every
- 15:05seller is different. If we were to build something
- 15:08that works for Amazon, it probably wouldn't work for 9% of
- 15:13the sellers that would need it. So we look more at what the
- 15:16seller needs than what the marketplace needs.
- 15:19But it's about providing that information and making it
- 15:21available to them in a way that they want it to be received.
- 15:25So one way we can solve that, for example is as simple as with
- 15:27look up lists. One thing we also do is I
- 15:31mentioned the single source of truth.
- 15:32We have a functionality that allows a user to predetermine
- 15:37certain values for specific fields.
- 15:40So if they've got a field called gender.
- 15:44And they know that they've got 20 different people in the team
- 15:46that might add something to that.
- 15:48They've got someone in the warehouse, someone in the
- 15:49marketing team, someone in the product team, Someone, anyone,
- 15:53anywhere could potentially type in men's.
- 15:56Maybe they write it with a lower or an uppercase M, Maybe they
- 16:00forgot add an apostrophe, or they don't.
- 16:03Maybe the multilingual team start adding German text in the
- 16:07wrong area. What we do in the community is
- 16:09we can limit. That with drop downs.
- 16:12So instead of having to type a field, they can simply select
- 16:15one of the predetermined values and then that will be connected
- 16:18to on Amazon Germany. It's not men's, but Menna, and
- 16:25you know whether it's going to be that then Kind of makes it
- 16:28easier to keep that data clean by restricting what the input is
- 16:32allowed to be, if that makes sense.
- 16:38Great. And I guess on that topic,
- 16:41Marketplace at Amazon have a surprisingly long list of data
- 16:45fields that can be used, some of which are essential, some of
- 16:49which have not. How are not.
- 16:51How much are you kind of inputting with the client or
- 16:55kind of like helping the client on that side?
- 16:57And how do you kind of stay on top of that to make sure that
- 16:59you're kind of, yeah, guiding the client, pushing the client
- 17:02towards best practice? So this was.
- 17:06This is kind of the core functionality or the core, the
- 17:09original product. I guess I would say with E
- 17:11Chameleon, this was the bit that was missing with the channel
- 17:14management tools that we used to use at the agency was
- 17:16understanding which fields we have to give in for which
- 17:20marketplaces, in which category, in which language and how do we
- 17:23have to give them what values are allowed to be in these
- 17:25fields. So what we the way that we
- 17:28solved that with E Chameleon is that we've got a generic logic
- 17:33that works for any marketplace. Whereby we we integrate those
- 17:38requirements from the marketplace and then we can show
- 17:42the seller based on this marketplace in this country, in
- 17:46this category, in this sub sub subcategory.
- 17:50These are the values you're allowed to enter.
- 17:53That's kind of the step one and the Step 2 is then automating
- 17:56that and that then depends on the product type again if there,
- 17:59if it's a seller that's got 50,000 products across 30
- 18:02categories. There's a lot less that they can
- 18:05or should automate in that case. We then have specific tools that
- 18:09help them work very efficiently. Again, I mentioned we had
- 18:12sellers with millions of SKUs sometimes.
- 18:15So we've got tools in E Chameleon that you can very
- 18:18efficiently and categories, attributes, items, specifics,
- 18:22etc. To hundreds or thousands or
- 18:25hundreds of thousands of SKUs very quickly and for the sellers
- 18:30that do have more. Consistent product data, again
- 18:33sellers like fashion products or certain other categories.
- 18:36It is possible then to automate a lot where we can say Okay
- 18:40based on this Amazon browse tree node, this is going to be the
- 18:43best eBay category and then based on this Amazon within this
- 18:50Amazon feed product type, here's the values that we're allowed to
- 18:53enter. These are the ones which are
- 18:55required fields and these are the values for those required
- 18:57fields. Maybe we can automate 90% of it
- 19:00and the seller can quickly then see an E chameleon which bits
- 19:03they have to add on extra in order to get the listing lives.
- 19:06Which ones are then kind of optional fields which are
- 19:10recommended which would then enhance the listing and help the
- 19:13algorithm push the listing and that then cause effectively for
- 19:19every channel. And that's so the advantage of
- 19:22the chameleon is that. It's exactly the same process
- 19:26whether it's for Amazon, whether it's for eBay, whether it's for
- 19:29auto, Walmart, Kaufland, Orlando, you name it.
- 19:32They don't have to understand that themselves.
- 19:35There's a mapping in the back end of the chameleon which
- 19:37either will set up for the sellers or if they're a little
- 19:41bit more technical, they can set up themselves quite easily,
- 19:45which will then help somebody with less marketplace expertise.
- 19:48Understand that for this channel this is how I can create the
- 19:51listings and then it's just a case of going through the drop
- 19:53downs. And I guess as part of that
- 19:56mapping process, there will be values that need to be
- 20:00transformed or kind of optimized as you say.
- 20:04How does E Chameleon kind of support that?
- 20:09And do you have any intention of adding any kind of like AI
- 20:13layers or anything like that? Obviously something that had to
- 20:16be touched on. Yeah.
- 20:19AI is a tricky one in this sense.
- 20:22So it's definitely on the roadmap.
- 20:24It's definitely something that we're looking into.
- 20:28It's very easy to build an AI tool and plug it in.
- 20:32We're a lot more focused on the quality than AI concurrently
- 20:39allow us to deal with. Sure, you can get a 95% accuracy
- 20:48and have 95% of your listings categorized and have some
- 20:51product descriptions created. That's not something that we
- 20:54specifically need to do right now because there's other tools
- 20:57out there that can do that. And there's enough options out
- 21:01there for a seller to get product descriptions created
- 21:04using an AI tool. That 95% isn't enough for us.
- 21:10Our sellers that we work for come to us because they want to
- 21:13make sure that 100% of the listings alive with
- 21:15marketplaces. The algorithm is very punishing
- 21:22is the word. The algorithms tend to penalize
- 21:25based the algorithms penalize a seller disproportionately based
- 21:32on a disproportionately to what is actually happening.
- 21:35If that made sense, one bad review will disproportionately
- 21:42affect your overall sales success and one product out of
- 21:4710,000 which is incorrectly categorized triggers and kind of
- 21:55a knock on effect. Where other products get looked
- 21:56at more closely, your overall seller account gets looked at
- 21:59more closely, and for us it's about getting 100% of it.
- 22:05Right. And just one sub question, just
- 22:07that I think just gives good context the episode.
- 22:10What does your average client look like?
- 22:13Like how big are they typically? Yeah, who?
- 22:16Who are you currently working with?
- 22:18It's a big range. We have sellers that have 80
- 22:23products on two channels and we have sellers that have multiple
- 22:29accounts where they will have multiple brands across multiple
- 22:33categories with thousands to 10s of thousands of SKUs which have
- 22:38different connections per brand or different marketplaces per
- 22:41brand. There isn't really a sweet spot
- 22:46for it. I mean, we have products
- 22:46starting from €29 a month. So we have a number of sellers
- 22:49that are just very small sellers that are purely using us to, for
- 22:53example, get order information from Zalando into their Shopify
- 22:56store and they use Shopify as an order management system.
- 23:01It's not ideal for that perhaps, but it's enough that they can
- 23:04get started and and they can kind of grow it from there.
- 23:07We also have sellers that are, you know, fifteen £20 million a
- 23:12year, companies that are connected to multiple
- 23:14marketplaces and switch to us from other channel management
- 23:17tools because they want to grow it.
- 23:19And they're limited from the product data perspective where
- 23:22even though they've got a good tool of the moment that gives
- 23:25them an API to connect to marketplaces, they've got too
- 23:28many products that they can't manage the product, they decide
- 23:30of it to take advantage of the API.
- 23:32So they've switched to us from other tools to be able to do
- 23:36that. Realistically, though, we're not
- 23:39really pigeonholed into any kind of category like that.
- 23:45Okay, makes sense, yeah, I just thought that would be quite
- 23:47useful contact. Talking about the all the data
- 23:51validation and data cleaning stuff, one of the features I
- 23:54really liked was that you have you have to show different
- 23:58product data views between source data and output data
- 24:00which shows what's being transformed and changed.
- 24:02Do you want to just talk people through what that is and what
- 24:05value that is adding to merchants?
- 24:10Yeah, we've talked a lot about automation.
- 24:14This isn't sort of something that Chameleon is special for.
- 24:18It's quite easy. Again, whether it's with AI or
- 24:21with Excel, it's very easy to say turn this data into that
- 24:24data. The problem is that with most
- 24:26existing tools, at least most of the tools that all of the tools
- 24:30that we worked with at the agency you would put product
- 24:34data in, There would be some kind of business rule or look up
- 24:36list or conversion that would then create a listing on, for
- 24:40example, Amazon. On eBay, you wouldn't know the
- 24:42output of that rule until you saw the listing on Amazon.
- 24:45So you don't know if you've accidentally put your skew in
- 24:47the title, like that's wasting random title real estate.
- 24:51Or you don't know if there's a random hyphen on the end of your
- 24:54title because the field that was supposed to follow the hyphen
- 24:58was empty and now you've just got a random hyphen on the end
- 25:01of your title. Or you're missing a keyword, Or
- 25:03maybe you've accidentally put your German content onto your
- 25:05French marketplace. There's a number of reasons why
- 25:10you would want to be able to do this, but one of the key things
- 25:13of the community is you can always see your product data
- 25:16either in the source, in the mapping, or in the output.
- 25:20And the output is effectively the data which has been
- 25:22generated for the specific channel.
- 25:25So you can see what information is being created by a chameleon
- 25:29for Amazon UK versus what the data is.
- 25:31It's being created for eBay versus for Xalander and so on.
- 25:34Even for the Shopify store that's connected, we often will
- 25:38connect the shop system to the PIM so that the seller is only
- 25:43creating all product data for all channels, including their
- 25:47own website. Through this process, they can
- 25:49see Okay if there's an issue on the sales channel.
- 25:52Then they can go back and look at where the problem might lie.
- 25:55Is it an issue with my source information?
- 25:57If so, where is that coming from?
- 25:58Have I uploaded it? Have I typed it in manually?
- 26:01Is it coming in from an API, from my ERP, or from an upload
- 26:05file from one of my manufacturers?
- 26:08If it's not there, is it in the mapping?
- 26:09Is there a problem with how this title, for example, is being
- 26:12created? Nope.
- 26:13OK, it's not there. What's in my output?
- 26:16Looks good there. Okay.
- 26:17So then there's an issue with how that's being sent from
- 26:19ecommedian to, say, Amazon. But it means that they can check
- 26:23every step of the process to figure out where a problem lies
- 26:26and then solve it very quickly themselves without having to get
- 26:30in touch with seller support or, you know, reach out to us.
- 26:33Or, you know, something that people can work with themselves.
- 26:39Yeah, that makes sense. And another area that's really
- 26:44important to people is the the speed of identifying issues and
- 26:48fixing them. And being able to that
- 26:50practically rather than having to to react to issues.
- 26:53How do you handle this? What sort of dashboard in the
- 26:55reports does E community and provide as standards so people
- 26:59can quickly find example where there is an invalid product
- 27:02title or there is a missing attribute that is required for a
- 27:05specific channel And being able to look at that in bulk so they
- 27:08know like I've got 40 products. I've got a fix on Solando for
- 27:11example. There's a few different, there's
- 27:16a few different ways to see that in Eco Medium.
- 27:19The first I would say is on the mapping section.
- 27:24So on the mapping, you can very quickly see if there's a
- 27:26validation error somewhere. Now we call it a validation
- 27:29error because in addition to the marketplace validation, i.e. for
- 27:34this specific category and subcategory, is your title too
- 27:37long? Have you added a value that you
- 27:38weren't supposed to? Are you missing a value
- 27:41somewhere? We can see that from the
- 27:43marketplace requirements and compare that with the data
- 27:46that's been created. The seller can also add their
- 27:48own custom validation rules. For example, I don't want my
- 27:52title to include this specific word, or I don't want my
- 27:57descriptions to be longer than X characters, whatever it might
- 28:02be. So that is the same
- 28:04functionality. They can kind of enhance it
- 28:05themselves with custom validations.
- 28:09The way that we show that is it depends again per channel that
- 28:15is then connected because there's obviously the initial
- 28:18validation side. The problem that we often have
- 28:22is that if we take Amazon again as an example, the requirements
- 28:26that we receive from the marketplace are often, sometimes
- 28:31not the same as what the marketplace actually wants to
- 28:33receive. What I mean is that Amazon might
- 28:36update their requirements for a particular category but not
- 28:39update their own systems. So we can create what seems like
- 28:44that perfect listing, but Amazon will still reject it because
- 28:47they haven't updated their own systems to know that there's a
- 28:49new value that's been added. So we also have to give the
- 28:52option that even though ecommedium will give the
- 28:55warning, we, we do allow the seller to override that warning
- 28:59and add their own values to make sure that the listings can still
- 29:01go live. Sometimes it's just necessary to
- 29:05be able to override that. The other reporting, of course
- 29:08it's necessary is error reporting.
- 29:10So again, that's different per channel.
- 29:12What kind of reports do we get from the marketplace?
- 29:16Some marketplaces just send an e-mail.
- 29:20So we'll try and show that information as best we can.
- 29:23If it's available via API, again, we show it as best we can
- 29:26and then allow the seller to quickly get to the SKUs which
- 29:30are affected by the errors so they can quickly solve those.
- 29:33With other marketplaces, it can be an issue that if there's an
- 29:37error anywhere in the feed, the whole feed is blocked.
- 29:41So you might have one intern that quickly adds an apostrophe
- 29:44to men's when it shouldn't have one and suddenly all the
- 29:47listings go off live that were fine yesterday.
- 29:50So what we do is we also validate before we send the data
- 29:54to the marketplace and in those cases then we'll remove those
- 29:59items from the feed automatically before it goes to
- 30:01the marketplace. So that that and it doesn't
- 30:05happen. Right.
- 30:08And I guess, I think. I'd say James knows a lot more
- 30:12about marketplaces than I do. It's actually just send him.
- 30:15This is a big gap in my knowledge and one of the areas
- 30:18that he's put down in the notes here is deactivation and the
- 30:22fact that there's a key requirement to be able to remove
- 30:25items around things like add to stock, out of stock recall.
- 30:29And I guess it'd be good to from your side just to explain that
- 30:33and why that is the key requirement for my knowledge.
- 30:36But also kind of how you handle that with marketplaces where
- 30:39there's not an API available in that instance.
- 30:43Yeah, I guess, let's see, That's the crux of it.
- 30:48There's not always an API for it.
- 30:50And that's, that's where it can be tricky to solve sometimes.
- 30:53I guess what James is probably referring to there is the fact
- 30:57that it is sometimes necessary to quickly remove an item from a
- 31:00marketplace. Whether it's because it's, as
- 31:03you said, a recall or because it's out of stock.
- 31:05And even though the even though it says it's in stock or for any
- 31:08other number of reasons, maybe suddenly can't ship it to Europe
- 31:11and you need to remove it from all of your European
- 31:13marketplaces. Some marketplaces do provide an
- 31:17API and then it's a very simple toggle any communion, add it or
- 31:21remove it from the feed. With other marketplaces, you
- 31:24maybe have to be a little bit smarter.
- 31:26We'll often do that with simply marking the item out of stock.
- 31:30That's not ideal because some marketplaces do penalize you for
- 31:33being out of stock. So then you really have to think
- 31:35about like, is this the best way to do it?
- 31:40But in this situation, it's probably unavoidable.
- 31:45So sometimes we'll have to mark an item as out of stock and that
- 31:47will then remove the listing. How we mark the items out of
- 31:52stock. It can also be a bit flexible,
- 31:54so it could be that there's a field.
- 31:56So often we will receive a field from our sellers.
- 31:59It's for example active, yes, NO10, etc.
- 32:03True, false. And we will build, we could
- 32:07build a look up list off the back of that which then if the
- 32:11stock level is so for example, if the active field is yes, the
- 32:18stock level is the stock level. If the active field is no, the
- 32:21stock level is zero. Could also be that for this
- 32:25particular marketplace, it's okay to go out of stock and we
- 32:27want to make sure we've got enough stock for another
- 32:30marketplace. So you might say that the stock
- 32:32level is the stock level -10, so that you've got a buffer.
- 32:36There's a number of different ways to skim that cap, but I
- 32:39guess that's the advantage of working with it from a product
- 32:42rated perspective rather than treating it as numbers.
- 32:49That makes sense. And then?
- 32:53What support do you provide to help customers who aren't as
- 32:56experienced in creating some of these feeds and I guess like in
- 33:02terms of how you operate, what level of kind of professional
- 33:05services or like guidance or advice you provide in versus
- 33:09just standalone kind of you know product slash SAS style
- 33:13approach. Yeah.
- 33:17We fall into the SAS category, but coming from the agency
- 33:22background, it's kind of hard for us to give our customers a
- 33:27tool and let them run with it. We try as much as possible to
- 33:31take a much more hand holding approach, particularly with
- 33:34sellers that have less or no marketplace experience.
- 33:39Marketplaces can be a bit dangerous if not done properly.
- 33:42In a lot of cases, you'll see someone set up an Amazon store,
- 33:46try it for themselves for a few weeks, make a bunch of mistakes,
- 33:50realize they've made a bunch of mistakes and they don't know
- 33:51what they're doing. And then that's a much harder
- 33:53account for us to pick up and run with, because the algorithm
- 33:56already knows that this seller doesn't know what they're doing.
- 33:59As opposed to a completely fresh account where you have a little
- 34:02bit more opportunity to benefit from that early day, letting the
- 34:08early days, letting the algorithm know that you know
- 34:10what you're doing and letting it push you through that.
- 34:14To your question, what we do to help, it really depends on what
- 34:17the seller needs. I mean we we come from the
- 34:19account management perspective. We have a lot of account
- 34:22managers in our team who will manage an entire marketplace
- 34:26account. We're not a marketplace agency
- 34:30anymore per se, but we still have that expertise and and for
- 34:35specific customers what we do is we will help manage elements of
- 34:39that business to help them help themselves, if that makes sense.
- 34:43The idea of E Chameleon is it's something that anyone can use
- 34:46without any marketplace expertise, but it doesn't need
- 34:50that set up. It does need to be brought to
- 34:53that point where for that specific seller, with their
- 34:56product range, with their categories, with the channels
- 34:58that are interesting to them, that they know where to go in E
- 35:01Chameleon to benefit from it, to have that marketplace expertise
- 35:03which is then built into the tool.
- 35:07How long it takes to get to that point is different per seller,
- 35:09different based on how much expertise they've got in house,
- 35:11other expertise. You can have someone that's
- 35:13very, very technical but has no idea about marketplaces.
- 35:16You can have someone that has sold on 20 marketplaces but
- 35:19doesn't even know an API is. So it's different for for
- 35:24different sellers, but we try as best we can to offer that
- 35:32additional service for the right sellers.
- 35:35But of course, we are first and foremost a software company.
- 35:38It's not something that we can offer that we can do for
- 35:39everyone. So in those, in a lot of cases,
- 35:41it's just a case of pure customer service.
- 35:43We'll do an initial onboarding anyway to get them to that
- 35:46point. And then it's usually just
- 35:48random questions, hey, where do I find this button?
- 35:50How do I get a delivery note? How do I print an invoice?
- 35:53And for those situations we have a kind of like a slight
- 35:57alternative that we use where any of our sellers can sign up
- 36:01and and they can communicate either with our team directly
- 36:04and pretty much everyone on our team is active on that.
- 36:07So they can always someone can always jump in and do a quick
- 36:10screenshot, Hey, you gotta press here.
- 36:12And it's also something that our sellers can use to communicate
- 36:15with each other if they want to. And in terms of coverage,
- 36:19because yeah, we you've already mentioned quite a lot of
- 36:21different marketplaces on this and yeah, most people will be
- 36:26selling into. One or two of the big ones like
- 36:29an Amazon, maybe an eBay. More niche ones might be a folks
- 36:33here on Etsy. Can you just talk us through if
- 36:35we take like Europe and then North America, what are some of
- 36:39the the less common marketplaces you guys already work with have
- 36:45have done data feeds and integrations with you know I'm
- 36:49talking about the lines like a Zalando which isn't as commonly
- 36:52used. I guess the easiest way is to
- 36:59say most of them our. Well, maybe pick out.
- 37:05We'll pick out some of the more. Popular ones that people are
- 37:08really demanding and you'll see more traction with.
- 37:13Yeah, so I mean specifically here in here in Germany we're
- 37:15seeing a lot of requests for auto Zalando Kaufland
- 37:19particularly is growing Kaufland's kind of the German
- 37:21version of Tesco household name brick and mortar stores all over
- 37:25the place recently became a marketplace by acquiring one of
- 37:29their competitors. Auto is a very is more like A
- 37:35and there isn't really a good UK equivalent.
- 37:39I guess maybe like a House of Fraser kind of slightly higher
- 37:43end that is less so these days. Started out as a catalog
- 37:48business and is now a marketplace.
- 37:50There's a few other hurdles with auto and that you need to have a
- 37:52German business entity and warehouse and customer service
- 37:57which is obviously hurdles for smaller UK companies.
- 38:02We work with most major, most marketplaces.
- 38:05One of our from the technical perspective, we built E
- 38:08comedians specifically to be able to add new marketplaces
- 38:11quickly because most channel management tools were originally
- 38:14built for Amazon or for eBay. So when they want to add Allegro
- 38:18or Auto or the Lando, they have to go back to a much earlier
- 38:23stage and rebuild a lot more things.
- 38:25To be able to add a new channel then we would have to.
- 38:29Quite often we add new channels in a few hours, Miracle
- 38:33marketplaces for example. We can connect in a few hours
- 38:35and that's why I said it's have to kind of answer which ones
- 38:39specifically because we can offer all of them.
- 38:42There's with Miracle in particular, there's a lot of new
- 38:46marketplaces being built on that technology where I've never
- 38:51heard of it, but we'll get something.
- 38:52For example, Airbus has a marketplace and I'm like okay,
- 38:57how what like who's going to be selling?
- 38:59What do they sell? Do they sell like airplanes, Do
- 39:00they sell parts? I still haven't figured out the
- 39:02answer to that question, but we've got one seller that wants
- 39:05to sell on the Airbus marketplace and it's, you know a
- 39:07couple of hours work for us to connect that for him.
- 39:09It's a lot easier to be able to do that and it means we don't
- 39:12have to charge him for you know a five week development project
- 39:16which for this small seller that wants to add on a slightly niche
- 39:20marketplace even for him would be prohibitive.
- 39:23But now he can try out that marketplace.
- 39:25And and for us it's, I mean we're a small team, we're only
- 39:2810 people at the moment. So we do have to be a little bit
- 39:31careful about dev resources about what our team can build.
- 39:35In terms of marketplace integrations, I'm very proud of.
- 39:38They do a really, really good job of building solid, stable
- 39:41marketplace integrations in a very short time.
- 39:44To the point that we actually also make those integrations
- 39:46available white label to some of our competitors who are able to
- 39:52then connect to more marketplaces than they would
- 39:53otherwise be able to do so. I'm out of interest, so I've
- 39:59definitely seen that trend, particularly with Miracle.
- 40:03Where brands are looking to essentially further monetize
- 40:07traffic and yeah, I spoke to like TV shopping channels,
- 40:11things like that and like you say some really niche businesses
- 40:13that maybe you wouldn't expect. One thing that I found is when
- 40:18people have tried to create a business case in the past
- 40:21miracles quite high cost. Are you seeing any other
- 40:24players? So Convictional is one we had on
- 40:26the podcast in the past that I was really impressed with and I
- 40:30think they were a bit more modular.
- 40:32And are you seeing any other kind of major players or is it
- 40:35mostly miracle you're saying? Marketplacer is a big one that I
- 40:41am seeing moving there from Australia.
- 40:43Originally they that's I think they single handedly made eBay
- 40:48redundant in Australia. It went from being like only
- 40:51eBay to now there's like 40 main relevant marketplaces in
- 40:56Australia. Seems like every every category
- 40:59has a solid marketplace player. And now they're entering Europe.
- 41:04They've also got some a team in North America.
- 41:08They've got a big Swedish marketplace coming soon.
- 41:11They've got a big UK marketplace, a couple of German
- 41:13ones coming. So they're definitely one to
- 41:15watch. Yeah, It's a really interesting
- 41:18area. I don't know if you say some of
- 41:20the stuff around H and M's marketplaces, but across their
- 41:23business. So it's like loads of focus on
- 41:27it. So they've got their own
- 41:28marketplace and then they're also selling other brands on a
- 41:31lot of the brand sites. Now that I think it will be a
- 41:33trend that we see a lot more over the next year or two on the
- 41:38order management side. So some marketplaces and again
- 41:41James has had some notes there, but some marketplace have kind
- 41:44of more specific order management requirements for
- 41:47examples Orlando. So can you talk us through what
- 41:52happens when an order is placed with Zarlando in particular and
- 41:56how this kind of interacts with the ecom platform?
- 41:58And then also what your typical customer is doing from an order
- 42:02management perspective generally?
- 42:05Yeah, marketplaces get messy with order management.
- 42:09This begins with the really simple stuff, like what a
- 42:15marketplace calls express delivery.
- 42:19You might need it to be called Express International.
- 42:21This isn't an order coming from your own website anymore or even
- 42:24an existing B to B customer. It's it's a completely new
- 42:27external channel. Every potential field of
- 42:30information related to that order is probably going to come
- 42:33in a different way than you're used to.
- 42:37EMAG in Romania we've seen addressed line 1 fields with 500
- 42:40characters, which just breaks some ERP systems, you know,
- 42:44maybe they're only allow 20 characters or 200 characters and
- 42:47so we have to break it down into 3 lines for it to be accepted.
- 42:51There's other requirements such as, so I mentioned some
- 42:55marketplaces actually operate what I would consider to be more
- 42:59of a drop shipping model. They call it a marketplace.
- 43:02But there are marketplaces where the marketplace or the website,
- 43:06whatever you wanna call it, is actually the seller of record.
- 43:09Which means that the marketplace seller has to do everything,
- 43:12kind of. On behalf of the marketplace,
- 43:15they have to print out a specific delivery note, a
- 43:17specific invoice that has the marketplace logo and business
- 43:20information and bank information and and all the company
- 43:24information from this marketplace as if they were
- 43:27nothing more than a fulfillment provider.
- 43:29And so they have to print that out, stick it in the box, It
- 43:31can't be an Amazon Prime box for example.
- 43:33You can search channels, you can't use your your FBA.
- 43:37That, then, is what has to reach the consumer.
- 43:41Some marketplaces at the point of sale, you have to generate a
- 43:44return tracking code. Now most order management
- 43:49systems these days that have anything to do with marketplaces
- 43:52can typically handle that. But for a seller that's using,
- 43:55for example, Shopify as an order management system, it can be
- 43:59trickier to do that. So then you might need another
- 44:00plugin that can generate a return tracking code that we
- 44:04would then need to be able to access to pass on to the
- 44:06marketplace. So there's a lot of.
- 44:11Minor what what seemed like minor issues, but every single
- 44:16marketplace will handle these issues differently.
- 44:20They'll all have minor requests, minor changes that need to be
- 44:23made to the process and these add up and and So what we do at
- 44:26the community is we try and solve that part of the puzzle.
- 44:29We're not an order management system, but we collect the order
- 44:33information. We make it possible for the
- 44:36marketplace specific issues to be solved, like creating a.
- 44:41Delivery note or an invoice as Orlando and then passing that on
- 44:46to an e-mail address that's connected to a printer that can
- 44:49then print that out, stick it in the box for example at the three
- 44:52PL. or at the warehouse location.
- 44:56We then take that order information and we'll pass it
- 44:58into the seller's system so that they can then do the order
- 45:03management process. But again, it's like, does that
- 45:06seller need a specific tag that differentiates?
- 45:09Because some sellers will want marketplace channels to be
- 45:12connected differently than their own website channels.
- 45:15Some sellers want it to be broken down by Zalando and
- 45:18Kaufland and eBay and Amazon. So we need to attach different
- 45:22tags or different information to that order before we pass it on.
- 45:25Sometimes the seller, the buyer on Amazon, adds a has a typo,
- 45:31and so the seller needs to be able to quickly log in to a
- 45:33chameleon to fix something before it's passed on to their
- 45:35system. There can be a number of
- 45:37different issues that come up. In that process, but our goal
- 45:41there is to really try and solve the marketplace specific side of
- 45:44it so that the seller can just kind of carry on with their
- 45:47existing processes. There's already a lot of
- 45:51functionality in in the platform and everyone has a road map.
- 45:55So where are you headed? Like what are you focused on?
- 45:57What? What are other merchants
- 46:00demanding of you and what are you planning to release?
- 46:03I guess 2023-2024? So from there's a few, there's a
- 46:11few different areas. And one major thing for us is
- 46:15simply building out more marketplace integrations.
- 46:19We've got what I believe to be a very solid stable solution now
- 46:25for selling on multiple marketplaces.
- 46:27Where we still lose compared to some of our competitors that
- 46:30have been on the market for 20 years is that we don't have as
- 46:33many marketplace integrations as they do.
- 46:36So we're playing catch up there, but as I mentioned we're able to
- 46:38add new marketplaces quite quickly.
- 46:40So that for us is a big folks point just repeating what we've
- 46:45got for whichever new channels come in that are either
- 46:49interesting for our customers or where we think if we add this
- 46:52connection it will attract new customers.
- 46:55So that's a big one for us. Another one obviously you
- 46:59mentioned Paul AI, we're definitely looking into that.
- 47:02Again, I'm. It's a very quickly developing
- 47:05space and I want to make sure that we don't get lost in the
- 47:07noise of becoming some content generation tool that is just the
- 47:11same as all the others. We put a huge amount of value on
- 47:15the quality being specifically for marketplaces here.
- 47:18It's very easy to tell ChatGPT or something that's using the
- 47:22Open AI API to create an Amazon title that's 500 characters, or
- 47:28description that's 500 characters.
- 47:30But we want to make sure that it fits in more.
- 47:34With what we're doing, which is quality content for and and
- 47:38accurate content for marketplaces that actually helps
- 47:40the seller grow organically. So it's an area that we're
- 47:44exploring, but can't really say, yeah, exactly what that's going
- 47:47to look like. And and yeah, other than that
- 47:51we're looking at, we'll be hopefully building out the team
- 47:55in the next year or so to compliment what we've got be
- 47:59able to look after more accounts.
- 48:01As we as we slowly grow but we're you know we're only three
- 48:03years old as a company even though our our expertise comes
- 48:08from the agency which was founded back in 2007.
- 48:11The Chameleons only been on the market for coming up four years
- 48:17and it's growing what we've got, we've gone through all the
- 48:21typical growth had growing pains that you'd expect from a company
- 48:24that was founded a week before the COVID.
- 48:27We kicked off our go to market strategy a week before COVID
- 48:30hit. And with everything else going
- 48:32on, you know, it's it's been a bit of an uphill battle, but
- 48:34we're seeing a number of different options now for us to
- 48:38to grow and it's just making sure that we're grabbing as many
- 48:41of those as we can without losing.
- 48:42Focus Cool. Really enjoyed this marketplace.
- 48:49Commerce is is on everyone's minds at the moment.
- 48:51People are exploring, do they expand more into third parties?
- 48:55Do they launch their own marketplaces?
- 48:57What technology should they use? So I think.
- 49:00Topics around this are really important for people, so thanks
- 49:02for coming on Jesse and taking the time to share a bit more
- 49:04about ecomming and some advice on on the selling and
- 49:07marketplaces. We hope everyone listening has
- 49:10enjoyed it. Keep your ears open for our next
- 49:12episode, we drop them every Tuesday and don't forget to give
- 49:14us that rating on Apple, Spotify, YouTube or wherever you
- 49:17might be listening or watching. Thanks very much.
- 49:19Until next time. More information on this topic
- 49:29Head over to Replatform dot FM for our audio podcasts to
- 49:32discuss a project. Or if you'd like to chat about
- 49:34any of the topics covered in this episode in more detail,
- 49:37please reach out to myself, James Gird, or my cohost Paul
- 49:39Rogers by LinkedIn and Twitter. Thanks again for listening and
- 49:42keep your ears peeled for the next episode.