Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Jordan Peterson Losing License
Transcript
- 0:00Hayters earned listeners. A lot of you have been asking me to react to
- 0:04the new developments in the news story regarding Jordan Peterson and his license being revoked
- 0:11or threatened to be revoked. So let's get into it. I know a
- 0:15little bit about this, but not a lot about it. I've heard things
- 0:19here and there, and I as a therapist and a professor and a supervisor,
- 0:24someone that is very concerned about ethics and the law, not only for
- 0:28myself and my own practice, but I oversaw a lot of practicing clinicians.
- 0:33I have a lot of interest in this story. So let's watch some of
- 0:37the news stories and familiarize ourself with the situation. This first video is on
- 0:43the YouTube channel for the CBC, which I believe is the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation.
- 0:50I'm guessing CBC, where people are attempting to make us speak their language.
- 0:55He is no stranger to speaking his mind. What the judiciary is doing
- 1:00and supported the college is wrong, as we all know, and Ontario Court
- 1:03says the province's College of Psychologists and how the authority to tell Peterson to take
- 1:07social media training or face possible disciplinary action. Okay, so we're hearing from
- 1:15the news reporting that the College of Psychologists of Ontario. I'm actually looking at
- 1:21their page right now. It sounds like a college right, like a school
- 1:25university. But I'm ninety percent sure that thee of Psychologists of Ontario is the
- 1:32government regulating body regarding licenses for psychologists in the Province of Ontario. In my
- 1:38neck of the woods in Seattle. In Washington State, we would call that
- 1:44the Washington State Department of Licensing. So this governmental agency is in charge of
- 1:49distributing licenses, making sure that the applications for licens sir for medical and mental
- 1:56health professionals is on the up and up. There's a certain criteria. Also,
- 2:00they are in charge of making sure that you're doing what you need to
- 2:04do to keep your license renewed. There are certain requirements every year that you
- 2:07have to meet. Also, if there are complaints from the clients, or
- 2:15from colleagues or from the public, then those complaints are submitted to the licensing
- 2:20board. And in Canada or Ontario, I believe it's this College of Psychologists.
- 2:24So we're hearing that they are requiring what did they say in Ontario court
- 2:30says the Province's College of Psychologists and how the authority to tell Peterson to take
- 2:35social media training or face possible disciplinary action. Okay, so they're saying social
- 2:40media training, what does that mean and why? Maybe we'll get into it.
- 2:46And then they say, if you don't do this social media training,
- 2:49then the College of Psychologists of Ontario, this government agency will impose sanctions on
- 2:57his license. Will that be revoking his license? Could be, but that's
- 3:00usually not the case. There's an escalation. People have complained about me.
- 3:05In fact, well I know about one person that's complained about me. I
- 3:07actually consider it to be kind of a badge of honor. For the first
- 3:14twenty five years of my career as a professor in a therapist I was absolutely
- 3:17paranoid about anyone complaining about my license, as is the case for all my
- 3:23colleagues anecdotally. We are a paranoid group of people that worry about the smallest
- 3:29of things. But anyway, so someone has complained about me and the complaint
- 3:34this is all speculation because it's not in the complaint record, but I believe
- 3:38I'm pretty sure the complaint happened during the Johnny Depp I ever heard trial.
- 3:43If you followed me when I was watching that trial and reacting to it.
- 3:46You know that I went through quite a lot emotionally during that time. I
- 3:53am used to commenting in my way. I speculate. I don't diagnose from
- 3:58afar, provide different points of view from different sides, because I don't know
- 4:02the real situation when I'm watching these videos. I don't know Johnny Depp,
- 4:06I don't know Amber Heard. I wasn't there for the psychological assessments. Of
- 4:11course, wasn't there during the incidents that they were going over. So I
- 4:14tried to provide a lot of caveats and a lot of speculation, you know,
- 4:17making sure that I couch it in speculation, and I would say,
- 4:21well, you know, it could be this, it could be that.
- 4:24And along the way, apparently I was pissing off everybody because everyone was either
- 4:30on one side or the other, and since I wasn't completely on one side
- 4:32or the other, I was this horrible person. And so some people,
- 4:40or at least one person, decided to take action against my license, which
- 4:43is really incredible, to try to prevent me from working with my clients because
- 4:49of an opinion that I said. It to be clear, I'm pretty sure
- 4:54during those videos I would always say, I don't know what's going on with
- 4:57Johnny Depp amber heard, but here let me give you my clinical experience regarding
- 5:00what they're talking about. That's generally what I always do, because that is,
- 5:03in my opinion and based on a lot of research myself, the more
- 5:08ethical thing to do on social media. The point is, the complaint about
- 5:13me was that I was calling myself doctor Kirkkonda, but I am not a
- 5:19medical doctor or something like that, which is just astonishing that someone just didn't
- 5:27google that or something. So I actually framed that complaint. The government sent
- 5:31me a letter saying that the complaint was found to be unfounded, meaning that
- 5:38they didn't even investigate it because the complaint just didn't really make any sense.
- 5:43It was self evident that it didn't make any sense, and so they sent
- 5:46me a letter and I actually framed it. Anyway, let's go back to
- 5:49the or face possible disciplinary action. So it's actually an indefinite sentence conditional only
- 5:56on what on what my compliance by what standard to capital off a social media
- 6:02communication X. So, yeah, it is a sticky area, but there
- 6:09are things to consider, not necessarily just regarding Joran Peterson, but in my
- 6:15opinion the actions of our entire profession on social media. It is a relatively
- 6:21new thing for us as mental health condissians to consider the ethical codes. The
- 6:29literature, the research literature doesn't really reflect yet what we're dealing with. We're
- 6:33still trying to figure it out, and I think that this case provides a
- 6:39way for us to further that figuring out who the hell is that. It
- 6:44followed complaints about some of Peterson's online posts, like what about actor Elliott Page?
- 6:49Peterson said the doctor who removed Page's breast was a criminal? Another was
- 6:54directed toward a former Yeah, I remember hearing about that sort of thing.
- 6:58It's pretty awful, right. It's one thing to talk about politics, or
- 7:03to talk about traditional gender roles, I guess, or to talk about free
- 7:10speech. These are all things that I think are associated with Jordan Peterson.
- 7:14But to go after a specific two individuals, not only Elliott Page but also
- 7:19the physician to just publicly state that it's wrong that someone had gender affirming care,
- 7:30that one what to It's literally unscientific to say that because we understand through
- 7:36science that for some people, their gender identity is different than the body that
- 7:43they were born into and to actually feel themselves changing their body is very,
- 7:49very important. If you're a private citizen, it's not great that you say
- 7:55those kinds of things, but you don't have a licensing board that is dictating
- 8:00whether or not you're following the standard of care and whether or not you're following
- 8:03the ethical codes which involve following the science, also involve making sure that you
- 8:09represent the profession well, also involve making sure that you're not harming people.
- 8:15You know, imagine if you're a transclient and you want to see Jordan Peterson
- 8:20or you're assigned Jordan Peterson, and you heard about these public statements by Jordan
- 8:24Peterson, then that's a problem. That's why we have licensing boards right in
- 8:28the same way that we have a driver's licensing board. Right, you can
- 8:33have your driver's license revoked. You know why do we have that, Well,
- 8:37because if it is found that you are irresponsible and dangerous with your driving,
- 8:43then there could be sanctions including revoking your license, saying you just can't
- 8:48drive anymore because we have determined that you're a liability and that you're going to
- 8:52harm people, you're a high risk, and so we're just going to take
- 8:56away your ability to drive. It's the same with the license to practice.
- 9:01We need some safeguards to protect the public. Again, if you're just a
- 9:05pundant someone that is just having a YouTube channel, or you're not a practicing
- 9:09clinician, then not great, but okay. But if you're practicing, that's
- 9:16what a license is. It is a license to practice, a license to
- 9:20be in the care of individual clients and patients. And if this happened to
- 9:26me, let's just say that this happened to me, that someone complained about
- 9:31me or whatever, and the licensing board came to me and said, you
- 9:33need to go through this social media training because of these four things that we
- 9:39identified as a risk to your clients and to the public. I wouldn't be
- 9:45enthusiastic about that, but i'd comply. I certainly wouldn't freak out about it,
- 9:50especially if I got the impression that they weren't out to get me or
- 9:54anything, you know, sort of paranoia about it. You know, I'd
- 9:58go through it, and maybe I'd learn a couple of things, being like,
- 10:01okay, at least I'd learn where their standard was, that sort of
- 10:05thing, and then I'd probably change my behavior. I don't know how that
- 10:09would go. So, you know, it's not that big of a deal
- 10:13that it's not like the jack boot thugs are showing up on Jordan Peterson's doorstep
- 10:20and hauling them away to a re education camp or so. It's just it's
- 10:26just like, hey, you know, these few things are probably not great.
- 10:30You can say all the other things, but these few things, who
- 10:33knows what their motivation was. But you know, I could imagine that being
- 10:35the case, right for Ottawa City counselor, who uses they them pronouns,
- 10:41describing Caltherin McKinney as quote an appalling, self righteous, moralizing thing, inciting
- 10:46any type of hatred that could lead to, you know, a risk to
- 10:50someone's well being does start to cross that line. Yeah, it's a well
- 10:54understood phenomenon that has been around for as long as human society has been around.
- 11:01That you don't have to say the thing to communicate the thing. You
- 11:05can say phrases like I want to make sure that our borders are strong,
- 11:11but really what's being communicated is actually there's a Black Mirror episode that a recent
- 11:18Black Mirror episode that did this pretty well. There's a scene with a politician
- 11:22and he doesn't say outright I'm a racist and I want to get the brown
- 11:28people out of Britain. But he talks about immigration, he talks about,
- 11:33you know, strong borders, this kind of thing, and that's what he's
- 11:37communicating is he wants to get rid of the brown people, and the voters,
- 11:39the white voters that are also a racist receive that communication. So you
- 11:46know, who knows what Jordan Peterson meant to communicate. But it's possible that
- 11:50it was received that way. It's also possible that it was communicated that I
- 11:54don't know. So that is something that you have to be responsible for,
- 11:58and I think about that all the time. As someone in social media,
- 12:03I sometimes will say things that will be interpreted in a way that I didn't
- 12:07mean it to be, and so I will apologize for that, or I'll
- 12:09try to get out ahead of that, or I'll try not to say it
- 12:13like that, or I'll try to make sure that I really explain myself fully.
- 12:16It's part of the reason why I yamer so much, because I don't
- 12:20want to be misunderstood, which happens sometimes. The court wrote, Peterson cannot
- 12:24have it both ways. He cannot speak as a member of a regulated profession
- 12:28without taking responsibility for the risk of harm that flows from him speaking in that
- 12:33trusted capacity. Don't bloody well lecture me some dim with judge with a liberal
- 12:37bias? Did lecturing me about taking responsibility for what I say? Peterson says,
- 12:43both it okay, Yeah, yeah, if I believed I was right,
- 12:52I might think similar things. I wouldn't say them on the internet,
- 12:58but yeah I might. I might if I thought like him. I'm just
- 13:03trying to be in his shoes that I also wonder about his personality. Like
- 13:09I said earlier, if it were me, I'm pretty sure. I mean
- 13:11again, it depends on the circumstance, but I would just do it.
- 13:15I'd be like, Okay, you know, let's see what this is like.
- 13:18And if it ends up being draconian, then I guess I'll cross that
- 13:22bridge when I get to it. But I don't know what they mean by
- 13:24social media training. Maybe it's actually quite pleasant. Maybe it's just an hour
- 13:30of talking with someone. Maybe I'll learn something that's a reflection of my personality.
- 13:35I don't know what labels we would put to it. Flexible at the
- 13:39very least, but Jordan Peterson, given the way that he behaves, it'd
- 13:43be hard to imagine that he would do that, right. Also, given
- 13:48the things that he talks about, the sort of things that he preaches,
- 13:52and his followers, I'm going to take a guess and say that they would
- 13:54consider it to be, you know, a real beta move if he were
- 13:58to submit in that way, you know, that alpha beta cut thing.
- 14:05There's an obsession with power that they have in humiliation. I imagine a lot
- 14:09of these folks experience a lot of powerlessness and a lot of humiliation growing up
- 14:13and their families, in schools, this kind of thing, and so there's
- 14:16just this obsession with establishing themselves as the alpha or trying to determine who is
- 14:22the alpha. And to me, I didn't really go through those kinds of
- 14:26traumas, so to me, I'm just like, Okay, yeah, that's
- 14:28something to pay attention to, but it's certainly not the focus of my life,
- 14:31you know. And so I imagine that given his personality, or given
- 14:37what he preaches, or given what he thinks his customers or looking to him
- 14:41to be like, it would be really hard for him to just be flexible
- 14:46and go along with it and see what happens. And the college overreached this
- 14:48law professor disagrees. When it comes to licensing bodies of like certain regulated professions,
- 14:56there are limits that are imposed that are part of upholding that the integrity
- 15:03and the professionalism that comes with being a lawyer or being a psychhology right exactly.
- 15:09I was saying that earlier, we need some kind of standard. There
- 15:13has to be some kind of otherwise, why does the regulating body exists at
- 15:20all? If you want to be a private citizen, a non clinician,
- 15:22a non license clinician and spout politically or whatever within reason, yeah, okay,
- 15:31But if you are in the care of patience and you're representing the profession,
- 15:37then there are standards. There are certain things that you have to consider
- 15:45and saying the things that Jordan Peterson says, it's probably beyond that threshold.
- 15:50You know, if you drive drunk and are caught five times in a month,
- 15:56there are standards you should have your license sanctioned or removed because you're unsafe
- 16:03to the public. If you're a clinician and you are saying bigoted things about
- 16:07individuals that are one being harmed by the things you're saying, and also you're
- 16:14inciting a whole group millions of people to also be bigoted. Not only that,
- 16:22but you're also you have a license to practice. You have a license
- 16:25to treat individuals, including trans individuals. So do we want a known bigot
- 16:32of trans people to be licensed by the government to provide care to trans people?
- 16:37No? No. The decision will, no doubt only add fuel to
- 16:44the fire worldwide between Peterson's supporters and attractors. Peterson says if he loses his
- 16:49license in Ontario, he'll get one elsewhere. In the meantime, he plans
- 16:52to appeal the court's decision and you know, to be cynical about it.
- 16:57Another angle to this is that this is just helping his career, gives his
- 17:03base his followers more rage, and because he can control the narrative about that,
- 17:11because you know, it's the licensee board probably doesn't have a big YouTube
- 17:15channel or a big Twitter following, you know, or even cares to,
- 17:18so he can control the narrative in that way. It gives him a lot
- 17:22of content to talk about. You know, I don't want to accuse him
- 17:26of anything, but there's a possibility that if he wasn't famous, he might
- 17:30say, well, okay, fine, I'll do it. But he might
- 17:33be thinking well, this actually could mean more cloud, more money, more
- 17:36fame. This actually kind of proves different points that I've been making about the
- 17:41overstepping of culture and the government, that that's what I've been basing my entire
- 17:47career on. That I believe that's how we got started was around these issues.
- 17:51So, you know, I don't want to accuse him of anything,
- 17:53but it's possible that it's actually a savvy move to push back. You know,
- 17:57even if he does lose his license, he'll be a martyr, right,
- 18:00So, yeah, that's kind of depressing to think about. I am
- 18:11now going to be required the college can go ahead with this to put me
- 18:15into a re education program with their so called social media experts. And that's
- 18:22also by the way of profession that does not exist until I learn my lesson
- 18:26whatever that is, regardless of how much time that takes. That's a funny
- 18:30thing to say that social media expert is a profession that does not exist.
- 18:36Well, there are experts on social media. There are also experts on social
- 18:41media within the psychologist profession. There are things on your resume that probably should
- 18:47be present, like a certain amount of training experience, maybe publications, that
- 18:52kind of thing. So to say that a social media expert is a profession
- 18:56that doesn't exist now, I don't know what the licensing board in Ontario means
- 19:00by social media expert like for me, I consider myself to be an expert
- 19:06on the ethics of mental health clinicians using social media, not only because I
- 19:11have fifteen years of experience doing it, but I have also spent a lot
- 19:15of time researching the clinical literature regarding ethics in general. Not only because I'm
- 19:21a supervisor and a professor and have to oversee a lot of people in their
- 19:26practices and also teach people about ethics. I also supervise supervisors, I train
- 19:32supervisors of clinicians, and so I also spent a lot of time writing a
- 19:37white paper that's available on my website regarding clinicians using social media. I have
- 19:41consulted with a lot of ethics experts. I've consulted with a lot of other
- 19:45clinicians on social media. So I would consider myself, especially when you campare
- 19:52myself to just all the other people in my profession, because there's not a
- 19:55lot of people that know a lot about this because it's fairly new to us,
- 20:00right, So you know, I would consider myself an expert in that
- 20:03area. Is that considered a profession? No, you know, it's not
- 20:08my job title for example, by their judgment, or they can take my
- 20:14license away. Jordan Peterson is heated and incredibly salty following an Ontario court ruling
- 20:21against the psychologist and conservative media personality. Now the ruling upholds a regulatory bodies
- 20:27order that he takes social media training in the wake of Oh interesting, so
- 20:33that must be why everyone was wanting me to talk about this. So because
- 20:36I was a bit confused. So the regulating body a number of months ago,
- 20:40maybe seventy months ago, said that in order for him to keep his
- 20:45license, he has to go through this social media training. And then there
- 20:49was an appeal to the courts it sounds like from Jordan Peterson, and the
- 20:53judge upheld it and said that indeed, you do have to go through this
- 21:00training. I would have loved to have seen that hearing, to hear the
- 21:03specifics, because this could go a lot of different ways. It could go
- 21:07in a direction war. I believe that the government is actually being totally reasonable
- 21:14and saying, look, Jordan Peterson, there's nothing wrong with you speaking your
- 21:18mind about these kinds of things. I might personally disagree with that the things
- 21:22you're saying, but you have the freedom to advocate for those kinds of issues.
- 21:27But for these kinds of issues, like where you're being bigoted against trans
- 21:33people, that is something that we established long before we even knew who you
- 21:37were. That is something that is unethical and not the standard of care,
- 21:41particularly because you might have trans clients, So it could be something like that,
- 21:48or if we saw the hearing, we might have seen a judge and
- 21:52the government just not liking Jordan Peterson because they just don't like him and they
- 21:56don't like the things that he says and are coming down on him in a
- 22:00very draconian unfair way. Remember, Peterson, who's a professor emeritus with the
- 22:06University of Toronto Psychology Department, was ordered by the College of Psychologists of Ontario
- 22:12to undergo a coaching program on professionalism in public statements. Now, as you
- 22:18can imagine, some of his posts on Twitter have drawn a lot of negative
- 22:22attention, and that was really the okay, so that is more detailed professionalism.
- 22:26Yeah, it's hard to know what they mean by that, and that
- 22:29is one of those areas of the standard of practice end of ethics that is
- 22:36really squishy, and I have some negative feelings about even the whole category at
- 22:42times. Of course, professionalism is important to some extent, but it's so
- 22:48interpretable. In fact, I remember so in the ethical codes for the very
- 22:53different ment health professions. There are different categories of ethical considerations and you have
- 23:00things like client care and confidentiality and the relationship and benefiting the public, and
- 23:07one of them is professionalism. We have an ethical obligation to be professional.
- 23:11Well, what is professional and what is unprofessional? That might be some obvious
- 23:17things, right, But the reason why I have a negative feeling about this
- 23:19whole category is because I remember in graduate school almost thirty years ago, in
- 23:25one of the books the authors and again this isn't a rule set in stone
- 23:30ethical considerations. Ethical codes are guidelines, are things that we should be thinking
- 23:36about. There are some hard and fast rules like don't have sex with the
- 23:37client, But the vast majority of ethical dilemmas that we run into that there's
- 23:42not a clear idea of what we're supposed to do. And even court precedent
- 23:47doesn't really help with this, because one judge might rule this way, and
- 23:49one judge might rule another way, So it gets confusing, and on one
- 23:55hand, that can be very distressing to us as clinicians, because we just
- 23:57want to be told what to do. You know. Imagine every time you
- 24:00got in the car, you're like, I'm pretty sure I'm supposed to drive
- 24:03on the right side of the road if you're in the United States. But
- 24:06I've heard people getting in trouble for driving on the right side of the road,
- 24:10So I guess we'll just drive down in the middle. I mean,
- 24:11that's an exaggeration, but it kind of is like that. In our field.
- 24:15There's not a clear rule about these kinds of things. And the more
- 24:19I've learned over the years, that is definitely a good thing, because every
- 24:23situation is different. Anyway, the point is is that in this book that
- 24:27I read again that was just written by an author, their opinion that if
- 24:33you after hours, so you work as a therapist and then Friday night you
- 24:38go out with your friends and you have some drinks and you appear to be
- 24:44intoxicated, that was identified as unprofessional conduct. It was unethical for that clinician,
- 24:52according to this one author, that they went out with their friends on
- 24:56Friday night. Now, this particularly bothered me because you know, when I
- 24:59was reading this, I was twenty five years old, and you know I
- 25:06did that kind of stuff, and so I was like, wait what.
- 25:11I didn't want to be unethical. I wanted to follow the rules. But
- 25:15I'm thinking, so I've been unethical every Friday night since I've been in graduate
- 25:18school. I don't understand what. You know, there's a there's a line,
- 25:22right, but where is that line? Right? One person might look
- 25:26at another person and say, oh my god, that person is so drunk
- 25:29and all they're doing is singing karaoke or something. Right. Another person could
- 25:33look at them and be like, they don't look that drunk. That seems
- 25:36pretty north. Where is the line? What's looking intoxicated even mean? Right?
- 25:41And what's wrong with a clinician having a life? What's wrong with us
- 25:45doing things with our line? We're supposed to just stay home because we want
- 25:48to avoid any risk of being identified as being unprofessional. You know what if
- 25:53I went to home depot and I was buying a toilet or something and I
- 25:59made that's what she said joke? Would that be considered unprofessional? It's such
- 26:06a squishy area, so it's not my favorite area of ethics. Because I
- 26:11find that it's largely cultural. Now, if the license key board and maybe
- 26:15we'll hear I'm guessing we won't said no, no, no, We're not
- 26:18talking about some squishy area like being intoxicated Friday. We're talking about this tweet
- 26:22in which he is obviously being bigoted against trans people. You know, if
- 26:26they said something like that, Oh okay, well, then there's no debate
- 26:30there that that's unprofessional. It's all regarding his online commentary. So I'm going
- 26:33to give you the specific instances that were cited by the board here the panel,
- 26:41Oh great, I should have just waited. So we're going to hear
- 26:44the specific things that Jordan Peterson has done that they considered to be unprofessional.
- 26:48Panel, I should say the panel noted particular concern with a series of statements
- 26:52that included the following referring to Katherine McKenney, an Ottawa City counselor Cooper.
- 26:59Okay, so there's two examples that were in the last news story by CBC.
- 27:03Are the identified issues that they're saying, Look, this is what we're
- 27:06talking about. Yeah, if that's what the License support is talking about.
- 27:10Yeah, of course to refer to Elliott Page's physician as a criminal, even
- 27:15though that physician, in all likelihood we don't know, but very very likely
- 27:19that the physician was following the standard of care regarding gender affirming care. To
- 27:25refer to that physician as criminal, yeah, that's unprofessional. What are you
- 27:30doing? What's your what? There's so many problems, one being transphobic and
- 27:37bigoted. That's not okay. The government should absolutely step in if you have
- 27:42a clinician who is spouting bigoted statements about a group of people who might end
- 27:49up in his office. Yeah, the government should absolutely say, look,
- 27:53this is not okay. You can't be bigoted against a group of Canadians because
- 28:00he practices in Canada. You can't be bigoted against a whole group of people
- 28:04that might end up in your office. I thought, okay. Also,
- 28:07you are promoting bigotry. That is not the standard of care as far as
- 28:11I know within the psychological profession. Not only that, but also claiming that
- 28:17a physician is a criminal, accusing I presume a licensed medical professional of committing
- 28:26a crime. Now, I'm guessing he would say, well, I was
- 28:29just using the word figuratively. Well, then maybe you should go through social
- 28:33media training because not everyone is going to receive that as a figurative statement,
- 28:40particularly your loyal group of followers that are hanging on in your every word.
- 28:44So yeah, absolutely, if this is all that they were talking about,
- 28:47because you know, you read the story, it's like, oh, the
- 28:51government doesn't like the right wing Jordan Peterson, so they're trying to make him
- 28:56left wing or something, trying to make him into a liberal. If this
- 28:59is all that they were talking about, yeah, I would say that they
- 29:03are absolutely in the right and the judge absolutely should have upheld that for sure.
- 29:07Yeah, of actor Elliott Page stating, and again I'm quoting him,
- 29:14remember when pride was a sin? And and then he used her his dead
- 29:17name, Paige just had her breast removed by a criminal physician. Let's go
- 29:23to the next set of examples cited by the panel, A tweeting okay,
- 29:29so more examples. A tweet in which he referred to Gerald Butts, the
- 29:33former principal secretary of Prime Minister Justin Trudeaux, as a prick that one see.
- 29:44I don't really know the landscape here, but i'd have to see the
- 29:47exact tweet. But if he is saying, okay, well this you know
- 29:52this official, this government official is a prick. Is that considered unprofessional?
- 30:00I think a lot of people would say yes, But I think about for
- 30:03myself. I have said yikes to a lot of people. I've called people
- 30:07jerk faces. I might have even called him fucking assholes at times. I
- 30:11don't know. I don't know if I've ever said that before, but yeah,
- 30:15in that direction, right, is that unprofessional? I think to some
- 30:18people it would be, and maybe I'd agree with that, even looking at
- 30:22myself. But it depends on what you're saying, right, It depends on
- 30:27the point you're making. It depends on the outcome. The Elliott page one
- 30:32is a slam dunk. It's obvious. There's really no debate there. But
- 30:37this one, the prick one, I don't know. On the other side,
- 30:41how many clinicians licensed clinicians have called Jordan Peterson a prick and much worse
- 30:47names. So I don't know about that one. His tweet in response to
- 30:52a Sports Illustrated swimsuit cover of a plus sized model in which he said,
- 30:56sorry, not beautiful. I think I remember this and no amount of so
- 31:00this is his tweet. Sorry, So he's there was a Sports illustrated swimsuit
- 31:06cover of a plus size model, and he is responding to it saying,
- 31:11sorry, not beautiful, and no amount of authoritarian tolerance is going to change
- 31:15that, my God Jesus. Yeah, yeah, he needs training, because
- 31:22look, if you're at home and you have those opinions, you know,
- 31:27it's a free world. In that way, you can have those opinions.
- 31:30You cannot as a licensed clinician. As a licensed mental health clinician. Tweets
- 31:37to the entire population of the planet, including possibly some of your plus sized
- 31:44clients, by the way, that sorry, you're disgusting. Yeah, I
- 31:52don't think there's any debate there, and plus why what is wrong with you?
- 31:56What point are you trying to make? What's your problem here? Now?
- 32:02I think what his supporters would say is that no, no, no,
- 32:06he's saying that he doesn't like the liberals shoving this agenda down everyone else's
- 32:15throats of you have to believe that you know this or this or this,
- 32:20and it's not the ideas out of the problem. It's the tyranny that's the
- 32:24problem. Okay, if that's your points whatever, then say that point.
- 32:30But to point to a particular individual, a plus size model and say you're
- 32:36not beautiful. Sorry, not beautiful. And the only reason why anyone would
- 32:43say, essentially what he's implying is the only reason why anyone would say you're
- 32:46beautiful is because of tyranny. Tyrants are trying to force us to believe that
- 32:53you're beautiful and you're not. I mean, yeah, you need training and
- 33:00the public deserves to be protected from you, because remember, this is not
- 33:06a license to speak, This is not a license to tweet. This is
- 33:10a license to treat individuals, to treat possibly people who identifies plus size,
- 33:17possibly transpeople. The government is saying, if this is what you're believing and
- 33:22or saying, we do not think you are safe to treat these kinds of
- 33:28people, our citizens who are paying our bills to regulate this profession. And
- 33:35you know, it's depressing because the little bit that I did pick up on
- 33:37in the news, if you just read the tagline, it does feel like
- 33:42a tyrant coming down on someone for free speech. But that is not what
- 33:45is happening here. It doesn't look like that's what's happening. A vindictive former
- 33:51client whose complaint about him was a pack of lies. The Inquiries, Complaints
- 33:57and Reports Committee of the College of Psychologists of Ontario found that doctor Peterson quote
- 34:02appear to be engaging in degrading comments about a former client and making demeaning jokes.
- 34:09Is it unprofessional? Is it not? Okay? Yeah, I mean
- 34:13you could make an argument that it does not only harm that particular client,
- 34:17because the client might hear that and say, wow, that hurts my feelings.
- 34:22There are ethical standards regarding us as clinicians talking about our clients, and
- 34:27it's complicated, but in general, we obviously have to protect the confidentiality of
- 34:31the clients in the vast, vast majority of case. There are some exceptions
- 34:36that rule, but most of the time we are expected to not reveal the
- 34:40identity of the clients, including saying anything or revealing anything about the client that
- 34:45could help someone discover who that person is. You know, it's not just
- 34:51not saying the person's name, for example, but if I describe a lot
- 34:54of details about their life, like where they work or this kind of thing,
- 34:59then BOO could figure out who they are. Another thing is that it's
- 35:01also important that we consider if the client is hearing us talking about them,
- 35:07that we might even want to obscure even to that client. That we're talking
- 35:12about them, because if we're speaking about them off the cuff, on Joe
- 35:16Rogan, we don't want to harm that person. That's our primary mission,
- 35:22that's our prime directive. That is the first thing we should be thinking about,
- 35:27especially when you don't have to write. That was the principle that I
- 35:30was taught in graduate school, which is that only talk about your clients if
- 35:35it's very important that you do. So, if you're just having a conversation,
- 35:38then no, do not talk about your clients. So what would justify
- 35:45talking about your clients? So education is the main reason why we might talk
- 35:49about our past clients to supervisees, to students, and maybe to the public
- 35:52right. And the other guideline is that when we do talk about our past
- 35:58clients, when we have justification, so we want to do everything we can
- 36:01to obscure that person's identity. And there are a few different practices, and
- 36:06this is the practice that I've followed since I've been in social media for fifteen
- 36:09years and I've been a professor for twenty five plus years. There are three
- 36:15different practice. One is you literally just get written permission from the client to
- 36:19talk about them, and I've done that before, because I've written a book
- 36:22about supervision, and in that book, I actually wrote about some clients,
- 36:27and for some of those clients, because the situation was so specific and I
- 36:30didn't want to change anything about it, actually went to the client and got
- 36:35written permission to I sent them the chapter and said, this is exactly what
- 36:37I'm going to say, is I'm okay with you. I also have to
- 36:39consider that the client might feel pressured by me to agree to that, even
- 36:45though they don't really want to. And so if I have any reason to
- 36:47believe that that would be the case, I can't even ask them. I
- 36:51just have to not do it. So that's one is just to ask for
- 36:53permission. Of course, Another is to mix things up so much that the
- 37:00client wouldn't even recognize themselves. So you have the gist of the story is
- 37:05true, but there are details thrown in or mixed up such that the client
- 37:09would say, oh, that kind of sounds like me, but it's not
- 37:13me that kind of thing, So you're fictionalizing the story, right. Another
- 37:17practice is that you literally just make someone up. You can composit a lot
- 37:23of different people together, a composite client from a lot of different experiences.
- 37:28This is a completely made up fictional client anyway, So when he talks about
- 37:36a particular client saying very demeaning things about that client. Yeah, in our
- 37:40field, we're always talking about risk versus benefit and what's the benefit there?
- 37:45How do you justify taking that risk of harming a particular individual. What's the
- 37:52upside to that? Does it justify? So the question is does the benefit
- 37:57outweigh the risk? For Jordan Peterson as he speaks in a degrading way about
- 38:02a past client who made a complaint against him, I'm guessing the answer that
- 38:07I'm guessing is no, the benefit does not outweigh the risk, and thus
- 38:10you need some training. You just need some guidance about if you're going to
- 38:15be a licensed clinician, then you should refrain from doing those kinds of things
- 38:20because it could harm the client and the public. Stated that referring to the
- 38:29physician who performed Elliott Page's surgery as a criminal was inflammatory and unprofessional, and
- 38:36so, after its review, here's what happened. The panel concluded that Peterson's
- 38:39conduct poses moderate risks to the public, which includes the potential of undermining public
- 38:45trust in the profession of psychology. Now, Jordan Peterson is not alone in
- 38:51these problems. I have seen so many people send me videos of what looks
- 38:59to be licensed clinicians on TikTok in particular, who are saying things, in
- 39:05my opinion, that are very very questionable, some things that are obviously questionable.
- 39:09So Jordan Peterson is not alone. However, They also argue that as
- 39:15a member of the college, Peterson is obligated to maintain its professional standards.
- 39:22Peterson, however, said his tweets on subjects like gender dysphoria are based on
- 39:25his informed knowledge and are in fact professional to the highest order. And he
- 39:31even denied so his notion that gender affirming care for Elliott Page is a criminal
- 39:42act and invalid is in his opinion, professional on the highest or not just
- 39:47professional, but professional on the highest order. Yeah. I don't think you're
- 39:55going to find a lot of agreement on that one. So if Jordan p
- 40:00digs his heels in on this, which it seems like he is, then
- 40:04yeah, I'm pretty sure his license is going to be revoked. I mean,
- 40:07when I first heard about that story, I thought, oh, his
- 40:10liss is being revoked, and then I read a little bit into us.
- 40:13Oh, his license isn't being revoked. He's just being required to go to
- 40:15a training, No big deal. But then hearing how stubborn he is about
- 40:20it, that, yeah, I think the only answer is that they have
- 40:24to doing that. The opposite is actually true. This is my favorite quote
- 40:29from him. He says, I think I've done demonstrably more than any psychologist
- 40:36has ever produced to increase the prestige of and trust of the practice of psychology
- 40:42around the world. My god, I don't know that much about Jordan Peterson.
- 40:47It's hard not to know some things about him, given the culture that
- 40:52we live in, and also people sending me a lot of his videos and
- 40:55whatnot. And full disclosure, I did listen to his podcast, like years
- 41:00and years ago. There were two or three episodes I listened to. At
- 41:04first, it was just lectures about connecting history and the Bible and psychology and
- 41:12well being. And you know, if I listened to it again, maybe
- 41:15I'd be a little bit more scrutinizing of it. But I remember liking it
- 41:19in the beginning and thinking, Wow, he's making a lot of interesting connections.
- 41:22And you know, among all the things that I listened to while I'd
- 41:24go on walks in the morning. I wasn't a terrible waste of time.
- 41:30I remember getting to episode four or five and losing a little bit of interest.
- 41:32I don't remember why exactly, but then, of course the controversies came
- 41:37out, and then I've learned about him more since then. But anyway,
- 41:40so my impression of him did not include this. I mean, of course
- 41:45it didn't exclude this, but I didn't realize he was of this sort.
- 41:52Now. I don't know what's going on with his personality, but I will
- 41:54say that someone in his position who would say this to the public. It's
- 42:02one thing to think it, or to say it while you've had a couple
- 42:07of drinks with friends. It's another thing to type this out on your phone
- 42:12and be like, Yep, this is the message I want to put out
- 42:15there. I've done demonstrably more than any psychologist has ever produced in the entire
- 42:22history of the profession to increase the prestige and trust that not only in Canada
- 42:34or in North America, but around the world. Yeah wow, yeah,
- 42:39even if you thought this to be true, of course, there's no way
- 42:42to measure this. But even if you thought this was true, like you
- 42:45think pretty highly of your of yourself. It's another thing to state it as
- 42:51if it makes sense to me. Who knows. But I would hope that
- 42:57his followers, at least a portion of them would read this and think,
- 43:00well, come on, mister Peterson, I don't think you have to go
- 43:05that far. It's just it's embarrassing. Yikes. So four people. For
- 43:15some people who go through a particular kind of relational trauma when they're young,
- 43:20they develop a defensive structure that is needed to combat the constant pain that they're
- 43:28going through emotionally, feeling inferior and feeling rejected, feeling worthless, and this
- 43:34defensive structure in their mind, and then their behavior is there to suppress that
- 43:40and to distract them from that, to counter it. And not everyone resorts
- 43:46to this defensive structure, because, of course, it's something that children develop
- 43:52when they're one, two, three, four or five years old and is
- 43:54refined as they get older. So how would a three year old no to
- 44:00adopt a certain defensive structure. But apparently it's available to us naturally enough that
- 44:06enough people will exhibit this pattern such that they will resort to believing that they're
- 44:12not only worthy of love and not only worthy of attention because they're not getting
- 44:16enough of that. They're only worthy, but they're superior. They're better than
- 44:22other people. They're perfect, they're wonderful, they're better than other people,
- 44:28you know, and they're very focused and hyper vigilant about keeping on top of
- 44:32that what we call narcissistic supply. They have to constantly work at, you
- 44:37know, they're obsessed with it at the expensive depending on how severe they are.
- 44:42But if they are severe, you know, they'll they'll sacrifice anything.
- 44:45They'll sacrifice their relationships, their happiness, they'll sacrifice even getting to know what
- 44:50they want. A lot of times, these individuals they appear to be chasing
- 44:54what they want, but it isn't actually what they want. They're focused on
- 44:59how things look to others and to themselves. They both want to be seen
- 45:02as superior to others. They want others to everyone understand I'm superior, I'm
- 45:07the best in the world, and also to themselves because it's abhorrent to them,
- 45:12it's intolerable to them, it's very scary to them when other people do
- 45:15not see them as superior. They don't need to be seen as worthy,
- 45:19they need to be seen as superior because they're trying to counteract. They are
- 45:23overcompensating for the constant voices and messages inside of them that are saying they're worthless.
- 45:30They're worthless, they're worthless. So to drown that out, they have
- 45:32to overshoot it right, and they have to be very compulsive about and obsessed
- 45:37with making sure that everyone understands they're superior, because if everyone understands it I'm
- 45:42superior, then I can kind of relax and feel like maybe I'm not worthless,
- 45:47you know. To them, they feel like they're establishing balance by being
- 45:52superior, because there's this voice of inferiority that's happening, and if they can
- 45:55match it with superiority, then they feel like okay. So not only they
- 46:00have to signal to other people as spirit, but they have to signal to
- 46:02themselves. So they have to reassure themselves in their minds, and by establishing
- 46:08themselves and by holding themselves a certain standards, they get envious of others because
- 46:13if anyone else is even at their level according to whatever metric they're following,
- 46:16by the way, then that threatens how they feel about themselves. And then
- 46:21they have to contend with that voice, that voice is saying you're worthless.
- 46:23Look, that person is better than you at that one thing. That means
- 46:28you're worthless. You know, it's not just that that one person is better
- 46:30than you and you're still a good person, or that person is better than
- 46:35you but you're still good at things. It's very black and white. That
- 46:37person is better than you, therefore you're worthless. And they have to establish
- 46:43that they are better than the other person. They depending on the degree of
- 46:45pathology and their methods, they might just try to compete, or they might
- 46:51actually try to tear the other person down, or they might just tear the
- 46:53other person down in their mind or whatever. There's various different things that they
- 46:57might do. So that's a thing. And I have not considered that.
- 47:04I'm not diagnosing from afar. I'd be ridiculous even if this was representative of
- 47:09his personality. It's just hard to know. It's it's complicated. There's even
- 47:15a there's even a world in which he knows this is going to piss off
- 47:19liberals, so he says that as a way of trolling. I don't know,
- 47:24but I just thought I point that we've seen this before and other politicians,
- 47:29this grandiosity, this obsession with needing to be the best. And actually
- 47:36if for people that I've treated people with this disorder, and it's some you
- 47:40know, the general republic tends to frame narcissists as like these maciavellian people that
- 47:45get away with things and are just laughing themselves to sleep every night. No,
- 47:52people that suffer from narcissistic personalite or it is one of the most miserable
- 47:58conditions you can ever have. Because of what I've been talking about, but
- 48:00also because of your defensive structure, actually reduces the chance that you will ever
- 48:07get help or ever change, because you believe that you're better, You don't
- 48:10need other people's help. You think you're perfect, and to question that is
- 48:15to undermine your entire defensive structure, and therefore you're worthless. So for someone
- 48:21to suggest you go to therapy, or even for the idea to pop into
- 48:22your head, it is terrifying to these individuals, yea, even when they
- 48:28do find themselves in my office or an office of a therapist that knows what
- 48:34they're doing already. I say that because not to say that I'm superior,
- 48:37but personality sorders are particular. Each one is very particular. Narcissistic personality disorders
- 48:44very particular as it's a very particular presentation. It almost never presents an office
- 48:50the way that people talk about it. People with narcissic personalise sorder can be
- 48:53very likable individuals. Contrary to what a lot of people on the internet will
- 48:58say. They can exhibit empathy at times, they can exhibit humility at times.
- 49:01It just depends not only that, but also it is very challenging.
- 49:07Personality stories are very challenging anyway, but narcissisic personality sort carries with it its
- 49:13own challenges as therapist because we are very common counter transference. A very common
- 49:19reaction from a therapist is to feel like you're being shut out by the client,
- 49:22like you don't matter. You know, the conversation will look like a
- 49:27therapy session, but every time you meet with the individual as a therapist,
- 49:30you just get this feeling like you like you're nothing, actually like you're worthless,
- 49:35even though it's not being overtly communicated to you that you're worthless. You're
- 49:38just being marginalized and dismissed. But even but it's subtle, you know,
- 49:43it's a it's a very subtle experience. And if you don't have a lot
- 49:46of supervision and experience and awareness of your own feelings and your own therapy yourself
- 49:52as a therapist, it's very, very easy to conclude that the client doesn't
- 49:57really want therapy or doesn't need therapy, might, even in a nice way,
- 50:00just raise the question like, so, you know, what do you
- 50:02want to get out of therapy, and then things just kind of fizzle out
- 50:06because the therapist isn't aware of that seduction into that idea that the narcissistic client
- 50:15doesn't need. Anyone has it all figured out that kind of thing. It's
- 50:21complicated. But so my point is is that people with this sort are miserable
- 50:27human beings and it's very hard for them to recover given what I'm talking about
- 50:30in addition to other barriers. So if Jordan Peterson is even somewhat on that
- 50:37spectrum, I feel really bad for him because it's a lot of suffering.
- 50:40It's a lot of pain, and it's a lot of just constantly on the
- 50:45treadmill of trying to gain some foothold and self esteem and worth and never finding
- 50:52it because they're looking for it in all the wrong places. They're looking for
- 50:55it in how they come across to other people in these ideas of superiority and
- 51:00inferiority and competence, instead of actually finding someone that loves you for who you
- 51:05are, regardless of how competent or incompetent you are. That's what was missing
- 51:10when they were young, and given their defensive structure, they might not ever
- 51:14get it for their entire life. I mean, just think about that.
- 51:16That because of their trauma's early in life, it sets up a defensive structure
- 51:21that creates a massive barrier to them ever getting any kind of real attachment,
- 51:29real connection, real love, real security from anyone. I don't know about
- 51:35Jordan Pearson. The little bit I do know about his family life, it
- 51:38sounds like it's going okay, So I'm going to take a guess and say
- 51:42that that's not the case. But I will say that, you know,
- 51:45there's a spectrum there, so it can create a lot of suffering anyway.
- 51:50All Right, Well, I think that's probably enough out of me, and
- 51:52everyone, please take care of yourself because you deserve what you really really do
- 52:00or or or