Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Don’t Get SLAPPed in Family Court: Spotting and Managing SLAPP Issues in Family-Law Cases
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to today's program. Don't Get Slapped
- 0:06in Family Court, Spotting and Managing Slap Issues
- 0:09in Family Law Cases. I'm Allapoli Castro, Director
- 0:13of Education and Professional Development at
- 0:15Beverly Hills Bar Association. Today's program
- 0:18is presented by BHBA Family Law Section, which
- 0:20is sponsored by White, Zuckerman, Warsowski,
- 0:23Luna, and Hunt LLP. They provide a wide variety
- 0:28of resources to complete almost any project,
- 0:31large or small. They also provide traditional
- 0:33accounting and tax practice services. We invite
- 0:36you to contact them to discuss your specific
- 0:38accounting needs and learn how they could be
- 0:40of service to you. And now I am delighted to
- 0:43introduce our speaker today, Brendan Begley.
- 0:46He is a certified appellate law specialist and
- 0:49shareholder at Wintraub Tobin, where he spearheads
- 0:52the firm's appeals and writ group. Brandon handles
- 0:56appeals in various practice areas, including
- 0:58family law, anti -slap litigation, employment
- 1:01law, trust and probate litigation, commercial
- 1:03litigation, civil rights law, and other various
- 1:07areas. He frequently tops best lawyer lists and
- 1:10is a frequent speaker and contributor on topics
- 1:13related to appellate practice and labor and employment.
- 1:16We can't wait to hear what he has to share with
- 1:18us today, so I'm going to turn this over to him.
- 1:20Thank you so much for the kind introduction and
- 1:23thank you all for attending my seminar today.
- 1:26If it wasn't for that generous introduction,
- 1:28you might think that you tuned into Conan O 'Brien's
- 1:31podcast about how he's going to try out for a
- 1:33science fiction film. But no, this is indeed
- 1:36Don't Get Slapped in Family Court. And I want
- 1:38to help you all be able to spot anti -slip issues
- 1:41that have been creeping into all kinds of different
- 1:44areas of law, not just civil cases, but probate.
- 1:50employment, and now even in family law, we're
- 1:52seeing it in family law. So you don't want to
- 1:54find out about this after you get hit with an
- 1:56anti -slot motion. You know, before we get started,
- 1:59though, I have to do the standard disclaimer.
- 2:01I'm going to give you guys a lot of information
- 2:04about this, and then we're going to do some hypotheticals.
- 2:06And in between the two, I'm happy to try to answer
- 2:10questions on the Q &A. I'll stop and we'll see
- 2:12if there's any questions I can answer. Of course,
- 2:14as you all know from being at these MCLE seminars,
- 2:18I'm not going to be giving you legal advice about
- 2:19a specific case. I'm just going to be trying
- 2:22to answer questions so that we can have a better
- 2:24grasp of how anti -slap might work. I'm going
- 2:27to treat your questions as hypotheticals. So
- 2:31what will we cover today? Well, we've got to
- 2:35start by talking about me, me, me. And so let
- 2:37me tell you why I'm excited about anti -slap
- 2:39and have been for about 25 years and why I think
- 2:42you all should be too. In another lifetime, I
- 2:45was a journalist, a newspaper reporter, had these
- 2:48stone tablets and we chiseled out things. You
- 2:51don't see too many newspaper reporters anymore.
- 2:54But I was one of them way back in the day and
- 2:56I wrote some very honest and fair stories about
- 2:59a public entity in particular that wasn't used
- 3:03to any kind of criticism. It was a local fire
- 3:05department. They were trying to make a transition
- 3:07from. Be an all volunteer department to a professional
- 3:11department. There were some bumps along the way
- 3:13and they were used to nothing but positive coverage
- 3:17about how the Dalmatian didn't bark on the fire
- 3:20truck at the 4th of July parade, but behaved
- 3:23itself. And so when I started writing some stories
- 3:26about some of their spending decisions and some
- 3:28of their personnel decisions. They didn't like
- 3:31it and they sick lawyer on me who went to a law
- 3:33school who taught him that. the best lawyers
- 3:36are the ones who know how to yell, insult, and
- 3:39cuss. And if you do these things to people, then
- 3:42you're going to make America's best lawyers list
- 3:44every year. And so that's the way he treated
- 3:46me. He threatened me with defamation claims and
- 3:49emotional distress claims, and it kept me up
- 3:51at night. I was really worried about this because,
- 3:54you know, my little newspaper, I mean, probably
- 3:57wouldn't have a lot of money to defend me. And
- 3:59if he only sued me and not the newspaper, I mean,
- 4:01I was what you call a stringer. They might not
- 4:04have had to have indemnified me like they would
- 4:06a normal employee. So it didn't stop me from
- 4:09writing my stories. A judge I used to clerk for
- 4:11nicknamed me Battle and Brendan. I mean, I've
- 4:13never walked away from a good fight. and so I
- 4:16kept on writing my stories but I had some sleepless
- 4:18nights and you know I had to make sure that my
- 4:21sources were you know corroborated and you know
- 4:24I didn't misspell anything in my story and I
- 4:27wrote some good stories as a result some really
- 4:29outstanding stories and he never sued me but
- 4:31after I got out of law school and started practicing
- 4:33the anti -slap statute had it had been around
- 4:36but it didn't have the teeth it had it just got
- 4:38these teeth that it has today and I discovered
- 4:41it and I thought you know what If that anti -slap
- 4:44statute was around when I was a newspaper reporter,
- 4:46I would have slept easily every night. I would
- 4:48have told that lawyer, go ahead and sue me because
- 4:50you're only suing me to shut me up, not because
- 4:53I said anything wrong. And I'm going to hire
- 4:55some lawyer like me in the future who's going
- 4:58to file an anti -slap motion. and is not only
- 5:00going to freeze discovery so you can't run up
- 5:03a big old bill on me, but it's also going to
- 5:05force you to prove your case at a very early
- 5:07stage without the benefit of discovery. And if
- 5:10you can't do that, you're going to pay my attorney's
- 5:12fees. And so listen, I think anti -slap is great.
- 5:17Some people have some you know, reservations
- 5:20about it, and we could have a debate about, you
- 5:22know, pluses and minuses, like everything, you
- 5:25know, there are some problems with it. But enough
- 5:28about me, let's talk about you. What do you think
- 5:31about, not only that I did this as a journalist,
- 5:33but then because I got interested in anti -SLAP,
- 5:36I expanded it to employment law. And so there's
- 5:40a published case out there, Virgos v. McNeil,
- 5:43and that was a civil rights employment case,
- 5:45and I, you know, I want to say among the first
- 5:48to find a way to use anti -slap protection in
- 5:52an employment litigation case. Now, since then,
- 5:55it's really spread to lots of other areas. So
- 5:58what we're going to cover, other than me, we're
- 6:02also going to focus on how to recognize claims
- 6:04that could get you either in trouble or give
- 6:09you an opportunity to file an anti -slap motion.
- 6:12And so there's two reasons we're going to do
- 6:15that. You want to avoid pleading the claim that
- 6:17might get you into trouble. And you also want
- 6:20to be able to know how to attack a claim that
- 6:22might lead to really great anti -slap remedies.
- 6:26And because we're talking about things that come
- 6:28in two, I'm going to tell you right now, anti
- 6:31-slap has two prongs. The first prong, the first
- 6:34step is to figure out if the claim asserted against
- 6:37your client is protected under the anti -slap
- 6:41statute. And we're going to talk a lot about
- 6:42what that means, but that's the only the first
- 6:45step. A lot of people think if it's protected,
- 6:47that's the end of the story. The claim is going
- 6:49to get thrown out. But no, that's just step one,
- 6:52prong one. Does the claim arise from protected
- 6:55activity? If it does, all it does is shift the
- 6:58burden to the plaintiff or in a family law case,
- 7:00the petitioner to show that he or she has a likelihood
- 7:04of success on the claim. And, you know, that's
- 7:08not a hard thing to do. And so I see anti -slap
- 7:10as kind of a heightened pleading standard. You
- 7:12might remember, you know, for fraud, you have
- 7:15to plead with specificity. Well, if you're going
- 7:18to file a lawsuit against somebody that challenges
- 7:20their free speech and petitioning activities,
- 7:22you should have to do a little more than just
- 7:24make the allegation and then run up their bill
- 7:26for discovery. You should be able to show that
- 7:29your case has some minimal merit before it can
- 7:31proceed. And that's all an anti -slap motion
- 7:32does. That's the way it's supposed to work. So
- 7:37what we won't cover, I'm not going to get into
- 7:39a detailed discussion about whether or not it's
- 7:41good or bad policy. If any of you have questions
- 7:43about that, you know, the what abouts, listen,
- 7:46I'd love to talk about anti -SLAP. Give me a
- 7:48call. You won't even have to buy me a drink.
- 7:50I will talk about why I think it's still good
- 7:52if you want to engage in a discussion about that.
- 7:54I'm happy to do it, but not during this webinar.
- 7:57And we're not going to do a detailed analysis
- 7:59of SLAP exceptions. They're out there. It's in
- 8:01section 425 .17. of the Code of Civil Procedure,
- 8:05the very next statute after the anti -slap statute.
- 8:09There are some exceptions. You need to know about
- 8:11them, but that'd be a whole seminar in itself
- 8:14to talk about what the exceptions are. Just take
- 8:17a look at them if you find yourself maybe getting
- 8:19close to an anti -slap case. We're not going
- 8:23to do a detailed exploration of slapbacks, but
- 8:25I do feel obligated to at least tell you what
- 8:27they are. They're outlined in the the statute
- 8:30after the exception, section 425 .18 of the Code
- 8:34of Civil Procedure. A slapback works like this.
- 8:38If I sue you, if I file a slap against you, a
- 8:41strategic lawsuit against public participation,
- 8:44and it's meritless, and you file a slap, anti
- 8:50-slap motion, and you get my claim thrown out,
- 8:53well then there's that. And so you're going to
- 8:55recover your attorney fees. But you know what
- 8:57you're not going to recover? is your emotional
- 9:00distress and those kind of damages. And you're
- 9:04not going to get punitive damages against me.
- 9:06You're only going to get your attorney fees.
- 9:08Well, you might therefore also have a malicious
- 9:12prosecution claim against me. I mean, I filed
- 9:14this case against you that got thrown right out
- 9:16on an anti -slap motion. I couldn't even show
- 9:18it had minimal merit, which means it probably
- 9:20didn't have probable cause. And so you can file
- 9:23a malicious prosecution claim against me. And
- 9:26as you're going to see, as I talk more about
- 9:28anti -slap, A malicious prosecution claim is
- 9:31per se subject to an anti -slap motion. Anytime
- 9:34anybody files a malicious prosecution claim,
- 9:36it's malpractice, in my opinion, not to file
- 9:38an anti -slap motion to challenge it. So now
- 9:41you file your malpractice act, I'm sorry, your
- 9:43malicious prosecution action against me, and
- 9:46guess what I'm gonna do? I'm gonna file an anti
- 9:48-slap motion, woo -hoo, and then I'm gonna subject
- 9:50you to the same treatment as you subjected me.
- 9:53Well, your malicious prosecution is what's called
- 9:56a slapback. That's a slapback. And so you cannot
- 10:00pursue anti -slap remedies the same way in a
- 10:03slapback that you can in the initial case. There
- 10:05are restrictions. It's harder to do. And so you
- 10:08will still have your malicious prosecution claim
- 10:11against me. And I might try to file an anti -slap
- 10:13motion against it. But my anti -slap motion is
- 10:16not going to have all the teeth that yours did.
- 10:19So that's a slapback. So we're not going to talk
- 10:22any more about that. You just need to know what
- 10:24it is. I'm not going to go into a detailed assessment
- 10:27of claims that don't enjoy prong one protection
- 10:30because, you know, they're illegal as a matter
- 10:32of law. I'll just say this much about that topic.
- 10:36If you, if I sue you for defamation or employment
- 10:41discrimination or, you know, domestic violence
- 10:44restraint and order, if I sue you for any of
- 10:46these kinds of things and, you know, I can, you
- 10:49file a motion against me and anti -slap and you
- 10:51say, well, it arises from protected activity,
- 10:54I can't really defend that by saying, no, it's
- 10:57not protected because the conduct was illegal.
- 10:59That's a step two concern. I got to do that at
- 11:02step two. It doesn't defeat the claim at step
- 11:04one. So except in a very rare exception that's
- 11:10outlined in this California Supreme Court case,
- 11:12Flatley v. Morrow, where if the activity that's
- 11:17supposedly protected is illegal as a matter of
- 11:19law on its face, without any declarations to
- 11:23prove the bad stuff happened. If you can just
- 11:25look at it and you can see this is extortionate
- 11:27on its face and therefore it's not protected.
- 11:31So extortion is usually the exception, but I
- 11:35could spend an hour talking about that one case
- 11:37alone and how it works. So we're not gonna get
- 11:39a lot of detail about that. Again, my point is
- 11:41to help you all recognize anti -slap issues so
- 11:44you don't. file a petition that can be attacked
- 11:48by an antislapped motion or so that if you get
- 11:51hit with a petition that can, you know what to
- 11:54look for to figure out what else you have to
- 11:56find out to pursue that antislapped motion. We're
- 11:59also not gonna do a detailed coverage of antislapped
- 12:01motions in federal court. I'm just gonna tell
- 12:04you they're out there. You can file them in federal
- 12:06court, but it's very rare for a family law case
- 12:08to wind up there. So you probably don't need
- 12:10to worry about it. Just know. It doesn't work
- 12:13exactly the same as it does in state court. Okay,
- 12:18what else we won't cover? I'm not going to go
- 12:20into detailed how -to's about how to file the
- 12:22motion. I'm not going to do detailed what to
- 12:25do's if you get hit with a motion. I will say
- 12:27if you get hit with an anti -slap motion, right
- 12:29away you should be thinking about how am I going
- 12:32to get discovery? I'm going to have to file an
- 12:34ex parte application to get leave to do discovery.
- 12:38You can't wait to file your opposition papers
- 12:41and ask for it. You have to You have to do things
- 12:43double fast in that regard. I'm not going to
- 12:46do detailed what abouts in connection with attorney
- 12:48fees. Although attorney fees are an important
- 12:50issue here, you're going to see it is the 800
- 12:53pound gorilla in many of these cases. And I'm
- 12:56not going to cover detailed oh no's about the
- 12:58discovery freeze or the immediate right to appeal
- 13:01or how to preserve or overcome or execute or
- 13:03defend against any of these things. I am going
- 13:06to say some things about it just so you can understand
- 13:08the gravity of what an anti -slap motion can
- 13:11bring. All right. So why do we have anti -slap
- 13:15law? I mean, just to make things more complicated,
- 13:18right? It might seem that way, but no. It sort
- 13:21of came out of the kind of textbook example of
- 13:24anti -slap and why we have it is you have a big
- 13:27box store that's going to build one of their
- 13:30big box stores in your neighborhood. And you
- 13:33run a small business, and they're going to run
- 13:34you out of business. And your neighbor is an
- 13:37environmentalist and is concerned about, you
- 13:38know, These animals are going to be crossing
- 13:41the road. They're already on the endangered species
- 13:43list are going to get run over by all these crazed
- 13:46shoppers running to the big box store to get
- 13:48the bargains. And then you got other people who
- 13:50are just concerned about the routine. Traffic
- 13:53pollution, noise pollution, those kinds of things.
- 13:56And so, you know, you get together with them
- 13:57and you start circulating the petition because
- 13:59you want to tell the city council, the zoning
- 14:02commission or the board of supervisors. They
- 14:05shouldn't green light this project. You know,
- 14:06it's not going to be good for your community.
- 14:08Let them build it somewhere else and people can
- 14:10drive 10 miles away to get there, but don't build
- 14:12it right here. And the big -box store decides,
- 14:16you know what, you're interfering with us because
- 14:17you're making it harder for us to open our operation.
- 14:20You've not really defamed them. You've not really
- 14:24committed the tort of interference with prospective
- 14:27economic advantage or contractual relations.
- 14:31You've not committed the tort of infliction of
- 14:34emotional distress because what you're doing
- 14:35is not outrageous. In fact, it's constitutionally
- 14:37protected. But if there was no anti -slap, protection,
- 14:42you'd have to march through discovery up to a
- 14:44summary judgment motion probably to show that
- 14:47your petitioning activity is constitutionally
- 14:50protected, and that's pretty expensive. And all
- 14:52you're trying to do is protect your neighborhood.
- 14:54And when you realize you're going to have to
- 14:56spend 20, 50, $100 ,000 defending yourself against
- 15:00this frankly meritless case, this strategic lawsuit
- 15:04against public participation, you're going to
- 15:06give up the fight. And so right here in the statute,
- 15:10425 .16A, it doesn't say all that about big box
- 15:14stores, but it says there's been a disturbing
- 15:16increase in lawsuits that are brought just to
- 15:19chill the valid exercise of First Amendment rights.
- 15:22And so when they first passed this law, you know,
- 15:27trial courts were constrained it very, very narrowly.
- 15:30Well, worse than trial courts, appellate courts
- 15:32were. the Court of Appeal in various districts
- 15:34was constrained it very narrowly and making it
- 15:36really hard to file these anti -slap motions
- 15:38and so the legislature amended it to include
- 15:41this highlighted thing uh to this end this section
- 15:44shall be construed broadly and so it's supposed
- 15:46to be it's it's not considered as broadly as
- 15:49it should be in my opinion but we'll talk about
- 15:51that a little bit that's kind of why we have
- 15:53it there we have anti -slap though so that people
- 15:56can engage in these protected activities without
- 15:59having to spend loads of money in order to do
- 16:02it. And so if an anti -slot motion freezes discovery
- 16:06so that we can figure out if this case has minimal
- 16:09merit, if it should proceed. And if not, make
- 16:12that plaintiff or petitioner pay the other side's
- 16:15attorney fees for having to file the anti -slot
- 16:17motion and get rid of this thing so it doesn't
- 16:19clog up the courts and run up the defendant's
- 16:22bill or the respondent in a family court action.
- 16:25Well, why should you care? I mean, this all sounds
- 16:27like great do -gooder stuff and, you know, but
- 16:29your clients aren't out there circulating petitions,
- 16:32you know, to stop the big box store. So you're
- 16:35a family law lawyer. Why should you care? Well,
- 16:37because if you file a petition that contains,
- 16:40you know, an anti -slappable allegation, you're
- 16:45going to get hit with a discovery freeze. And,
- 16:48you know, it's going to not only put a freeze
- 16:51on discovery, but it's going to force you and
- 16:55defending against the anti -slot motion to give
- 16:56the other side the very best evidence you have
- 16:59without them propounding one interrogatory, one
- 17:02document request or taking one deposition or
- 17:05subpoena in one third party. They're not gonna
- 17:07have to do any of that. They're gonna force you
- 17:09to hand over your very best evidence right at
- 17:12the beginning of the case. So even if they don't
- 17:13prevail on the anti -slot motion, they are gonna
- 17:16be ahead of you in the discovery campaign. They're
- 17:19gonna get all kinds of stuff from you and you're
- 17:20not gonna get it from them. So okay, I know in
- 17:23family law, there's often not as much discovery
- 17:26as there is in civil action. So I might not have
- 17:29won you over yet. You might not really be alarmed
- 17:31about you have to understand anti -slap to be
- 17:34a really great family law practitioner. Well,
- 17:37there's also the moving party is going to recover
- 17:40his or her attorney fees. If they beat you on
- 17:42anti -slap motion, they're going to get some
- 17:44real money. A standard amount is going to be,
- 17:47I'd say, between $30 ,000 and $60 ,000. I only
- 17:50saw one case that I know of where it was under
- 17:52$10 ,000. Normally, in today's, well, with the
- 17:56inflation that we all have for who knows how
- 17:59long, it's going to be probably $30 ,000 to $60
- 18:01,000. I'd shrug my shoulders and say, it sounds
- 18:03about right. I'll tell you what, there's published
- 18:05decisions that go well into the six figures.
- 18:08They award anti -slap. people who move for anti
- 18:13-slap relief and get it. There's cases, appellate
- 18:15cases that published appellate cases that affirm
- 18:18recoveries well over the century mark, well over
- 18:21$100 ,000. All right, so your client is not going
- 18:24to be happy if you draft a petition that subjects
- 18:27him or her to an anti -slap motion. And really,
- 18:30I would never want to be the lawyer explaining
- 18:32to my client, well, not only are they going to
- 18:35strike that allegation, but you're going to have
- 18:37to pay. your arch enemies, your wayward ex -spouses
- 18:44attorney fees, not just mine, but theirs too.
- 18:46Your clients are not going to be happy about
- 18:48this. On the other hand, if you get hit with
- 18:50an anti -slap motion and you can show it's frivolous
- 18:53and you defeat the anti -slap motion, you can
- 18:56get a recovery of attorney fees too. That's going
- 18:59to be a little bit harder to do. It can be done.
- 19:01I've seen it done. If you're the non -moving
- 19:06party on the anti -slot motion, it's harder to
- 19:09get fees. But if you're the moving party on the
- 19:11anti -slot motion and you prevail, you're going
- 19:13to be getting a whole lot of money back and your
- 19:15client is going to be thrilled. All right. Well,
- 19:20to get those fees, for the non -moving party,
- 19:24it's going to depend a lot more on prong one.
- 19:26The party who filed the anti -slot motion, you're
- 19:30going to have to be able to show that they couldn't
- 19:32even get past Prong 1 to show that it was protected
- 19:34activity. If they get past Prong 1 and lose at
- 19:38Prong 2, you're probably not going to recover
- 19:40your attorney fees because Prong 2 is your burden.
- 19:42If you file the petition that gets challenged,
- 19:45somebody files an anti -slap motion against you
- 19:47and they get past Prong 1, at Prong 2, the burden
- 19:50shifts to you to show a likelihood of success.
- 19:51And so if you show a likelihood of success, that
- 19:54doesn't mean that their motion was frivolous
- 19:56because they achieved their burden on their motion.
- 20:00So it's very unlikely to get that. But there
- 20:04are published cases that say you get them, and
- 20:07both of them are PROM1 cases. Let's see here.
- 20:14All right, you still might not care, okay? You're
- 20:17like, yeah, attorney fees, I only take wealthy
- 20:21clients. And so they can afford to pay it and
- 20:22they always want to be aggressive. So they don't
- 20:24mind the discovery freeze and they don't mind
- 20:26the attorney fees. Why should I care about antislapped?
- 20:29Well, here's the last reason. Because if somebody
- 20:33files an antislapped motion, whether it gets
- 20:35granted or denied, there is an immediate right
- 20:38to appeal. Either party can appeal. Whoever wasn't
- 20:41happy with the outcome can appeal. And so it
- 20:43doesn't sound that bad. Well, not only is discovery
- 20:46going to remain frozen during the pendency of
- 20:48the appeal, and being an appellate specialist,
- 20:50I can tell you that appeal is going to take every
- 20:52bit of a year and a half, maybe two years, maybe
- 20:55even a little longer. Well, I should say every
- 20:58bit of a year in three months, more likely a
- 21:01year and a half, maybe even closer to two years.
- 21:03And not only is discovery going to remain frozen,
- 21:08but proceedings in the case. I mean, if your
- 21:12family law judge thinks that there's any overlap
- 21:14between other things going on and the anti -slap
- 21:17claim, everything is going to stay frozen. Now,
- 21:21change circumstances and this and that. Sometimes
- 21:23there's other things you still can't be doing.
- 21:25It just depends on what the nature of the claim
- 21:27was that was attacked. But there's going to be
- 21:30a stay in proceedings while that appeal goes
- 21:31on to some extent. And so that might not be what
- 21:35your client wants. OK, hopefully I have you all
- 21:40thinking, all right, if I get hit with one of
- 21:42these space alien anti -slap motions, I'm going
- 21:47to need to know how to deal with it. And so I'd
- 21:48better be on the lookout for them anyhow. I better
- 21:50be able to at least recognize if there's going
- 21:53to be an anti -slap problem somewhere on either
- 21:55side. And so you want to know the basics of how
- 21:58it works, at least enough to know how to be able
- 22:00to spot an anti -slap issue. So how does it work?
- 22:03Like I told you, there's two prongs. and it's
- 22:06spelled out in Section 425 .16b, like Brendan.
- 22:12And so number one says if the cause of action
- 22:16is against somebody for doing something that
- 22:20is in furtherance of their First Amendment rights,
- 22:23then the anti -slap motion advances to the next
- 22:27step where the court has to decide if the plaintiff
- 22:30has established that there's a probability of
- 22:32prevailing on the claim. I didn't say it already,
- 22:35I'll say it now. That's like a summary judgment
- 22:37standard. I know there's no summary judgment
- 22:39motions in family court, but you all had Civ
- 22:42Pro in law school and you remember summary judgment
- 22:44is like just a tribal issue of fact. If one says,
- 22:47you know, it was this day and the other says
- 22:49it's that day, it's tribal issue of fact, we're
- 22:51not going to grant the motion. We're going to
- 22:53let it proceed and we're going to have to have
- 22:54a bench trial to figure out was it that day or
- 22:57the other day. All right. In making the determination,
- 23:00though, the court can consider not only the pleadings,
- 23:03but also affidavits and declarations and exhibits
- 23:07that are attached to those things. And so it
- 23:09is like a summary judgment motion. It's not like
- 23:11a demur. It is a summary judgment -like motion.
- 23:14And they get decided faster than summary judgment.
- 23:17Summary judgment is now like, what, 110 days
- 23:19or something like that. Anti -slap, you're going
- 23:21to see it has to move. It's supposed to move
- 23:23along kind of quick. And so the basic logistics
- 23:26is you have to file the anti -slap motion within
- 23:2860 days of being served with the complaint, is
- 23:32what the statute says, but a complaint, as you're
- 23:33gonna see, also means petition. Or, you know,
- 23:38any time after that, if the court says it's gonna
- 23:40give you extra time. 20 years ago when I started
- 23:42doing this, courts were more generous about giving
- 23:45you extra time. Not so much anymore. Listen,
- 23:48try not to avoid, if you have to file an anti
- 23:50-slap motion, try not to miss that 60 day deadline.
- 23:53because usually they're going to exercise their
- 23:55discretion and say no you missed it and that's
- 23:57it. Now not only do you have to file it within
- 24:0060 days the statute says it's got to be heard
- 24:02within 30 days not like summary judgment right
- 24:04where you get like 80 or 100 days notice or something
- 24:07like that now you got to do it within 30 days
- 24:10the court's supposed to hear it within 30 days
- 24:12but there's a caveat there unless the docket
- 24:15conditions require a later hearing they always
- 24:17do these days you know for me anti -slap hearings
- 24:21in the last year or two have been four to six
- 24:23months out. But you know what? Discovery remains
- 24:26frozen during that whole time. Once you file
- 24:28the motion, discovery is kaput. So again, if
- 24:32discovery is a concern for you, you want to be
- 24:33on the lookout for anti -slab vulnerability.
- 24:37All right, so I told you. The statute uses the
- 24:40word complaint, but it's not confined to complaints.
- 24:43The Court of Appeal has treated this provision
- 24:45expansively, and so it includes petitions. A
- 24:50complaint can include a petition. It can also
- 24:52include a cross -complaint, and a plaintiff can
- 24:56be a petitioner, and a defendant can be a cross
- 24:59-defendant and a respondent. So listen, it stretches
- 25:01into probate and family law clearly. It even
- 25:04stretches into arbitration, as this slide indicates.
- 25:10DVRO request. Listen, I'm going to let the cat
- 25:11out of the bag here. You've been wondering, tell
- 25:13me how this applies to family law. I'm kind of
- 25:15getting a picture now, but how is it going to
- 25:17show up in family law? Listen, I think the most
- 25:18common area you're going to see it in family
- 25:20law is in DVRO request domestic violence restraining
- 25:25order requests, and especially probably renewals
- 25:30for those requests, depending on how the renewal
- 25:33petition is fashioned. It will also show up if
- 25:37you or your client gets sued for things you say
- 25:41or do in connection with the family law action.
- 25:44And listen, that is limited only by your own
- 25:46imagination. I got some hypotheticals here and
- 25:49it's based on real life stuff. So you'll get
- 25:52to see how creativity just takes a little creativity
- 25:56to find a way to expand anti -slap into this
- 25:58stuff. So DVRO requests. Well, listen, there's
- 26:02one published opinion that didn't analyze anti
- 26:05-slap coverage. But it said an application for
- 26:08an order under the Domestic Violence Prevention
- 26:10Act is like a civil harassment petition under
- 26:14the Code of Civil Procedure Section 527 .6. And
- 26:19so it's a cause of action that can be subject
- 26:21to an independent lawsuit. And so another published
- 26:26decision says it also didn't analyze anti -SLAP
- 26:31coverage, but it reasoned that when a DVRO request
- 26:35is filed in a pending dissolution case. You can
- 26:38file it as a separate action on its own, but
- 26:40if there's already a dissolution action going
- 26:42on, you can file a DVRO request in that action.
- 26:45If it's filed in a pending dissolution case,
- 26:48it's a quote -unquote motion in that case. Well,
- 26:53Brendan, the guy that looks like Conan O 'Brien
- 26:55told you a complaint is a petition or a cross
- 26:59-complaint. Is it also just a motion? Well, that
- 27:04question is kind of unanswered. There's some
- 27:07reason to think maybe you can argue about that.
- 27:10I think most courts are going to say, yeah, a
- 27:12petition or a request for DVRO is going to be
- 27:17like a cause of action, and they're going to
- 27:20treat it that way. But there's an argument that
- 27:22some people could make that maybe it's not really
- 27:24a complaint. And so let's explore that for just
- 27:26a minute. There's another published decision
- 27:29that did analyze anti -SLAP coverage. but not
- 27:33the narrow question about if you file a DVRO
- 27:36request in an existing dissolution case, is that
- 27:40just a motion? You know, unlike if you file it
- 27:43in its own separate case, it's clearly going
- 27:44to be a complaint or a petition. What about that?
- 27:47Well, this case didn't answer that narrow question,
- 27:50but it did clearly say in a published, citable
- 27:53decision that a DVRO request is subject to an
- 28:01antislapped motion. It clearly said that. I just
- 28:03didn't analyze this one other question that we're
- 28:05talking about right now. Now, in yet another
- 28:08published decision that also analyzed anti -slap
- 28:11coverage, a different Court of Appeal held that
- 28:13the anti -slap motion can be filed to challenge
- 28:16a petition for injunctive relief under California's
- 28:19civil harassment statute. but it cannot be filed
- 28:22in response to the TRO, temporary restraining
- 28:25order procedure, in that statute. And the Domestic
- 28:28Violence Prevention Act also has a similar thing
- 28:30where once they file that request, it's like,
- 28:32I don't know if it's actually an ATROS, right,
- 28:34an automatic temporary restraining order, but
- 28:37there is a TRO that comes with that. And so you
- 28:41cannot really use an anti, I wouldn't think you
- 28:43can use an anti -slap motion to attack a TRO,
- 28:46but you can use it to attack the whole ultimate
- 28:50request for a longer injunction. And so that's
- 28:55how I interpret it. I want to tell you about
- 28:57a different case also. And this case is kind
- 29:01of, for me, a little bit out from Mars, but it
- 29:03is out there. It's unpublished, though. So you
- 29:05cannot cite it. You cannot cite it, and courts
- 29:08cannot rely on it. Trial courts cannot rely on
- 29:10it. Don't even try to cite this case. But it
- 29:14says that a DVRO request is a cause of action
- 29:16that's subject to the anti -SLAPP statute. So
- 29:19far so good. I think that makes sense in terms
- 29:23of anti -slap logic. And that's regardless of
- 29:26the fact that it was filed as a motion in an
- 29:28existing dissolution action. Remember, I want
- 29:30to repeat, this is an unpublished decision. You
- 29:32can't cite it. But nonetheless, this Court of
- 29:35Appeal affirmed the denial of the anti -slap
- 29:38motion because the anti -slap motion didn't move
- 29:41to strike the DVRO request, but only the DVRO
- 29:45remedies requested therein. Listen, That's going
- 29:49to be a tough argument to make, in my opinion.
- 29:52It's a good thing this opinion is unpublished.
- 29:54I think the California Supreme Court would have
- 29:56throttled that. I don't buy that logic one bit.
- 30:00But nonetheless, you might attempt that pitch.
- 30:04I mean, one court bought it. One court of appeal
- 30:06said that's the case. Now, in mentioning this
- 30:08case, I do want to, if he's out there, Andrew
- 30:11Stein at Hirsch Manus, LLP, I want to give him
- 30:15credit for bringing this to my attention. And
- 30:17actually, he's the one that gave me the idea
- 30:18about maybe being able to challenge DVRO as not
- 30:22a complaint, a DVRO request in an existing case.
- 30:25So my thanks to Andrew. I didn't dream this one
- 30:28up myself, but I was already on the lookout for
- 30:30anti -SLAP and other kinds of DVRO situations.
- 30:33So. I'm glad to know that there's somebody out
- 30:36there like Andrew who thinks about these things
- 30:38like I do and is on the lookout for them. So
- 30:43we're going to talk more in the hypotheticals
- 30:47about DVROs, and you'll hear more from me. And
- 30:49if you have questions about it, let me know.
- 30:52But for now, we're going to move on and we're
- 30:53going to talk about amended complaints. There's
- 30:55a warning I want to tell you about. If you see
- 30:59a petition that has a claim in there that you
- 31:02can attack with an anti -slot motion, you gotta
- 31:04do it within that 60 days. Now, if the other
- 31:07side, let's say 50 days later files an amended
- 31:11petition, that does not restart your deadline.
- 31:14If it has that same allegation in there, your
- 31:16deadline expires 60 days after the original complaint,
- 31:19not 60 days after the amended complaint. So you
- 31:22have to get on that. Now, by contrast, if you
- 31:25have an initial complaint that doesn't have a
- 31:28claim that's subject to anti -SLAP coverage,
- 31:31but then you get an amended petition, that does
- 31:34have that, the 60 days starts from service of
- 31:36the amended petition. So just be aware of that
- 31:40trap door. Now, you heard me talk about the two
- 31:43prongs. I'm going to say it again. There's two
- 31:45prongs to anti -slot. The first step decides
- 31:50whether or not the claim arises from protected
- 31:52activity. And then the second step only gets
- 31:55triggered if the party that files the anti -slot
- 31:58motion surmounts that hurdle and shows you're
- 32:01suing me. for activities that are protected by
- 32:04the anti -slap statute. And then that shifts
- 32:05the burden to the plaintiff or petitioner in
- 32:09family law cases to show that he or she can achieve
- 32:13a likelihood of success, has a probability of
- 32:15success. And so that's the Supreme Court case,
- 32:18Baral. There's more about Baral I'll tell you
- 32:21about. But first, I want to talk about prong
- 32:24two, which is also says in Baral, like I said,
- 32:26it's like a summary judgment -like procedure.
- 32:28Listen, if the claim has merit, it shouldn't
- 32:31be that hard to sign a declaration creating a
- 32:34tribal issue of fact that shows my claim should
- 32:36proceed. It shouldn't be thrown out at the anti
- 32:39-slap stage. So when I hear people say anti -slap
- 32:42has thrown out too many claims, I feel like,
- 32:44well, it's only thrown out claims that if they
- 32:46were good claims, the lawyer wasn't smart enough
- 32:48to be able to make a tribal issue of fact by
- 32:50having the client sign a declaration. It really
- 32:53shouldn't be that hard to beat prong to if your
- 32:55claim has married. All right. So what is protected,
- 33:01all right? Because I'm here to talk about prong
- 33:03one. So you recognize what's protected. So you
- 33:06know if the petition you're about to file is
- 33:08going to get met with an anti -slap motion, or
- 33:11so that you know if the petition you just got
- 33:13can make you a hero for your client, because
- 33:15you can file an anti -slap motion and recover
- 33:17attorney fees from the other side. You need to
- 33:19be able to recognize. And so how do I do that,
- 33:21Brendan? Tell us. You haven't told us. How do
- 33:23we recognize it's anti -slap? something that's
- 33:26anti -slapable. Well, it's right there in the
- 33:28statute. It's subdivision E like Edward of section
- 33:31425 .16. And so it's got four different activities,
- 33:35four different categories of activities that
- 33:37are protected. And the first one is any written
- 33:39or oral statement or writing made before legislative
- 33:43executive or judicial proceeding or other official
- 33:45proceeding authorized by law. If you're about
- 33:47to sue somebody and your recovery from them hinges
- 33:51on them being liable for something they said
- 33:54in court, Anti -SLAP coverage. So DVRO renewal
- 34:01requests are a good example here. You know what?
- 34:03I want to renew my DVRO. I already got one. But
- 34:06the other side appealed, and they said all this
- 34:08nasty stuff about me in the appellate brief.
- 34:10And so I don't think they've learned their lesson.
- 34:12And so I want to renewal. Well, you're suing
- 34:15them for renewal based on what they said in the
- 34:18last appeal. That's probably going to be protected.
- 34:22Along those lines, subdivision E2 says, any written
- 34:27or oral statement or writing made in connection
- 34:29with an issue. It's under consideration by an
- 34:34executive judicial legislative executive judicial
- 34:38body or any other official proceeding. So, you
- 34:42know, if if you've got a DVRO and you want to
- 34:45renew it and you're renewing it saying, well,
- 34:48you know, my ex is telling our former neighbors
- 34:51that you know, I made up a bunch of lies when
- 34:54I got the first one. Well, guess what? You know
- 34:57what? He or she is talking about an issue that's
- 35:01under consideration or reviewed by a judicial
- 35:03body, right? That the initial DVR was under consideration
- 35:07then. So that's probably going to be protected
- 35:10too, which means, you know, if you file a petition
- 35:13that alleges these things, you're going to be
- 35:15faced with the prong to burden of showing the
- 35:17likelihood of success without the benefit of
- 35:19discovery. A couple of other things that are
- 35:22protected too, they're going to come up less
- 35:24frequently, I think, in family law cases. And
- 35:27going back to the two I just outlined, they've
- 35:29already been in family law cases. There's been
- 35:31anti -slap motions on these things. So I'm not
- 35:33just imagining that it's happened, and I'm going
- 35:35to tell you more about it when we get into the
- 35:37hypotheticals. But these other two subsections
- 35:41of 425 .16E, They are protected activity, but
- 35:46they're probably not as likely to happen in a
- 35:48family law case, but you still need to know a
- 35:50little bit about them. And so I'm just going
- 35:51to cover these really fast. Part three and part
- 35:54four, they actually overlap and part four actually
- 35:57overtakes part three. Part three says any written
- 36:01or oral statement or writing made in a place
- 36:03open to the public or public forum that's in
- 36:06connection with an issue of public interest.
- 36:09Part four says any other conduct, which can also
- 36:13include speech. in furtherance of the exercise
- 36:15of constitutional right of petition or the right
- 36:18of speech in connection with an issue of public
- 36:20interest. So both of them, it's got to be a matter
- 36:22of public interest. Public interest doesn't mean
- 36:24everybody in the United States is concerned about
- 36:26it or everybody in California or everybody in
- 36:29Los Angeles or everybody in Beverly Hills or
- 36:33everybody in a school district. It can even be,
- 36:36you know, a homeowners association. It doesn't
- 36:37have to be all of them. Public interest can be
- 36:40kind of narrow, but both these prongs say it's
- 36:43got to be a matter of an issue of public interest.
- 36:47Part three says it's got to be somewhere open
- 36:49to the public. Part four says it doesn't have
- 36:51to be, and I'm going to skip ahead because I
- 36:53want to get to our hypotheticals. I'm just going
- 36:56to tell you right now, it doesn't really have
- 36:58to be in a public forum or a place open to the
- 37:02public. So just take it from me. You don't really
- 37:05need that component. You're still going to have
- 37:07a good anti -slap motion as long as it's a matter
- 37:09of public interest. All right, what is a matter
- 37:12of public interest? What's an issue of public
- 37:13interest? There's a lot of cases that address
- 37:15this. Some of them go different ways. And so
- 37:17you got this one ceiling case that says the personal
- 37:21details about a reality star are a matter of
- 37:23public interest. But then you got this other
- 37:26case, Bernstein. that says a defendant's celebrity
- 37:29status on its own is not sufficient to make anything
- 37:31the defendant says or does subject to anti -slap
- 37:34protection. All right, so a little bit of tug
- 37:36there. You got to read a little more to figure
- 37:38out which way it goes. Now, by contrast, this
- 37:42case where, you know, frankly, this company was
- 37:45selling these pills that said they were going
- 37:46to enlarge women's breasts. I took pills when
- 37:49I was 19 or 20. You can tell by my complexion
- 37:52I don't get very tan, and I know the sun is dangerous
- 37:54for me. I took these pills to make me tan. If
- 37:57these breast enlarging pills work as well as
- 37:59my tan pills, I mean, you're not going to get
- 38:02your money's worth. This would be my prediction.
- 38:05But anyhow, somebody sued this company for false
- 38:07advertisement, and that company filed an anti
- 38:09-slap motion. And the court of appeal said, a
- 38:14dietary supplement's ability to enlarge women's
- 38:17breasts as an allegedly safer alternative to
- 38:20surgery is not a matter of public concern. So
- 38:23don't anybody misunderstand me who's listening
- 38:25to this. I am not saying the size of women's
- 38:27breasts, whether they're celebrity or not, should
- 38:29be a matter of public interest at all. This is
- 38:32not my point. But my point is there are, as we
- 38:35know, a number of women who do pursue this visual,
- 38:42if you will. And so they might elect for surgery,
- 38:46they might elect for you know, this dietary supplement.
- 38:49And if they're considering that, they might want
- 38:51information to know about it. And so it might
- 38:53be a matter of public interest. There's a lot
- 38:55of women out there that might want to know about
- 38:57this. And so I'm not convinced that it's, you
- 39:01know, a safer alternative to a common surgery
- 39:03is less a matter of public interest than a reality
- 39:06star's personal decisions. I'm just not convinced
- 39:09of that. But luckily in family law, I don't think
- 39:11you're going to see prong three and I'm sorry.
- 39:13Subsection 3 and Subsection 4 protected activities
- 39:17too commonly. If you do, you're going to have
- 39:19to read up on them. All right. So I already talked
- 39:22about how Subsection E4 overtakes E3. And I'll
- 39:28say what is or is not a matter of public interest.
- 39:30The California Supreme Court did try to address
- 39:32it in this FilmOn .com Inc. case. And don't feel
- 39:37like you have to scribble all these cases that
- 39:39I'm mentioning in the slideshow, because they
- 39:40are all in your handouts. I got a little blurb
- 39:43about each one of them in your handouts. If you
- 39:45find yourself in E4 territory where you're trying
- 39:47to figure out if something is a matter of public
- 39:49interest, you're going to want to look at this
- 39:50filmon .com case. I could spend a whole hour
- 39:54talking about that issue alone, so we're just
- 39:57going to kind of move past it, okay? But the
- 39:59case is cited in your handout. Now, what if a
- 40:04complaint alleges or a petition in your world?
- 40:07What if a complaint or a petition alleges both
- 40:09protected and unprotected activities? Well, the
- 40:12unprotected, the allegations of protected activity
- 40:16are gonna be stricken, okay? Unless they support
- 40:19a distinct claim on which the plaintiff has a
- 40:22probability of prevailing. That's gonna be very
- 40:25rare. This case, this California Supreme Court
- 40:27case came out and it kind of upended. It used
- 40:29to be you had to get rid of the whole cause of
- 40:31action or the whole claim. But now all you have
- 40:33to do is show that they can't establish liability
- 40:37based on the one protected activity. And so you're
- 40:39going to get your attorney fees. Some of the
- 40:41cause of action is going to survive. But you
- 40:43as the party that moved for anti -separate relief,
- 40:45you're going to get your attorney fees back.
- 40:46And that's going to demoralize the other side.
- 40:48And it's going to take some of the wind out of
- 40:49their sails. That's been my experience. All right,
- 40:53so. Well -established claims. Listen, if you
- 40:55see a malicious prosecution claim or an abusive
- 40:57process claim, you should be seeing the Conan
- 41:00O 'Brien astronaut. Every time you blink your
- 41:03eyes, you should be thinking, this is anti -slap
- 41:06right here. It's going to be malpractice not
- 41:09to file an anti -slap motion, probably. Defamation.
- 41:12Listen, not all defamation claims are going to
- 41:15be anti -slappable, but a lot of them are. That's
- 41:18a very common area where you see anti -slap,
- 41:20both slander and libel. Interference with contractual
- 41:25relations or prospective economic advantage.
- 41:28Also, a lot of anti -slap stuff in that area.
- 41:31Infliction of emotional distress claims give
- 41:33rise to anti -slap motions quite a bit, but I
- 41:35want you to keep in mind, not prayers for emotional
- 41:38distress damages. It's got to be the IIED or
- 41:41the NIED claim. Negligent or intentional infliction
- 41:48of emotional distress. It's got to be a cause
- 41:50of action, not just You want damages because
- 41:52somebody did something else bad to you. All right,
- 41:56emerging. I already told you I brought it into
- 41:57the employment world and there's been some up
- 42:00and down there, but the California Supreme Court
- 42:02said courts of appeal. It's just like Brendan
- 42:05Begley said it is. So stop saying employment
- 42:07claims aren't covered by anti slap. They are.
- 42:10If the claim arises from protected activity,
- 42:13probate petitions to disinherit in accordance
- 42:16with the no contest clause, that's going to trigger
- 42:18anti slap, you know, scrutiny. very, very frequently.
- 42:23That's not so close as other kinds of claims.
- 42:26That's going to be, it's not as per se as malicious
- 42:28prosecution, but in my opinion, it's right up
- 42:30there. There's also other kinds of probate petitions
- 42:33that could trigger it. Courts of Appeal have
- 42:36not heeded the construe prong one broadly mandate
- 42:41that's statutory and by the California Supreme
- 42:43Court. They've published some petitions that
- 42:46I disagree with that say certain kinds of probate
- 42:48petitions are not subject to antislapped. My
- 42:51prediction is someday the California Supreme
- 42:53Court will take that up and say, you know what?
- 42:55They're wrong. Don't do that anymore. I've seen
- 42:57it in landlord -tenant disputes. And listen,
- 43:00it's here now. It has arrived. It's not, I'm
- 43:03just warning you, it's coming. Family law requests
- 43:05for DVROs and renewals have been hit with anti
- 43:08-slap motions. And also civil actions against
- 43:12family law litigants are their attorneys, you
- 43:14know, for litigation related statements or conduct
- 43:17either during trial are in connection with oftentimes
- 43:20enforcing a family law judgment. You're going
- 43:23to see anti -slap stuff here. There's going to
- 43:25be anti -slap activity. Okay. So listen, the
- 43:30varieties of anti -slap kinds of claims are unlimited,
- 43:33actually limited by only someone's imagination
- 43:36and creativity. And that's because the statute's
- 43:39definitional focus, as the California Supreme
- 43:41Court has said, is not on the form of the plaintiff's
- 43:44cause of action, but the defendant's activity
- 43:46that gives rise to the asserted liability, and
- 43:49if that is protected under anti -slab. We have
- 43:54some hypotheticals. I'm going to look down at
- 43:56the screen. I see chat, but I don't see Q &A.
- 44:00Let me just see if there's something in chat
- 44:02that I should be looking for. I don't think so.
- 44:04I think it's supposed to be in Q &A. I'm not
- 44:08seeing a question there. I don't see questions
- 44:11in Q &A, which means I guess everybody is understanding
- 44:15it because I'm explaining things perfectly clearly.
- 44:18So going on that, let's cover some of these hypotheticals
- 44:20so that you can really see where the rubber meets
- 44:22the road. Hypothetical number one, you got sympathetic
- 44:26cohabitator who obtains a three -year domestic
- 44:30violence restraining order against abusive cohabitator
- 44:33and of course, abusive appeals. And listen, I
- 44:35get calls like this all the time. I got a restraining
- 44:37order against me, but my evidence was better.
- 44:39than theirs. Help me, it's an injustice. Everybody
- 44:43who gets these DVRs on them, they almost all
- 44:45want to try to appeal it. And so in appellate
- 44:48briefs, abusive cohabitator calls sympathetic
- 44:51cohabitator insulting names and insists that
- 44:54sympathetic lied to the trial court. Well, not
- 44:58so shockingly, the Court of Appeal affirms the
- 45:00judgment because it's based on he said, she said,
- 45:03and they defer to the trial court in those contests.
- 45:06Well, so sympathetic later goes back, you know,
- 45:09the three -year term is running out. So she goes
- 45:12back to renew the DVRO for however much more
- 45:14time she can get. And she alleges that abusive
- 45:17made sympathetic continue to feel fearful during
- 45:22the three -year period of the initial DVRO because
- 45:25he called her vicious names and dishonestly questioned
- 45:28her credibility in his appellate briefs. And
- 45:31so my question to you is, Should abusive file
- 45:34an anti -slap motion to strike that request for
- 45:37DVRO renewal? And because I can't really single
- 45:41you out and point at you and ask you or have
- 45:43you raise your hands and take a guess. And it's
- 45:46going to take you a minute to type in the Q &A.
- 45:48I'm just going to skip ahead and answer these
- 45:49hypotheticals. Well, as you've learned from my
- 45:53presentation today, these motions have been used
- 45:56to challenge DVRO requests and successfully.
- 46:01A renewal request remains untested. I've not
- 46:03seen an appellate decision on that at all, either
- 46:06published or unpublished. I did see a DVRO renewal
- 46:10request where the renewal was 100 % based on
- 46:13what the other side said in an appellate brief
- 46:18or in court in the prior litigation. And that
- 46:22to me is just, that clears prong one easily.
- 46:26That easily clears prong one, which means even
- 46:29if you beat that anti -slap motion, you cannot
- 46:31recover your attorney fees because the anti -slap
- 46:34motion wasn't frivolous. Okay, so we've learned
- 46:37today, right? A complaint includes a petition,
- 46:40which would certainly include a DVRO that's brought
- 46:43in its own separate action as this hypothetical
- 46:46was, right? This is a cohabitator, not a spouse.
- 46:49It's a cohabitator. And so this is going to be
- 46:52a separate independent DVRO action. And so that's
- 46:55a petition that's covered by anti -slap. And
- 46:57it's not the form of the cause of action that
- 46:59counts, but the defendant's activity. In this
- 47:02hypo, the plaintiff, the petitioner, alleged
- 47:05that the respondent said these things in court.
- 47:09And so that's clearly prong one. And so look,
- 47:13even if those things that the, you know, abusive
- 47:17said in court were misguided, insulting, dishonest,
- 47:21you know, and it's going to be squarely protected
- 47:24under prong one, I believe. So you turn to Pro
- 47:28-Ing 2, right? Just because it's under Pro -Ing
- 47:301, that doesn't mean you lose and you're going
- 47:32to have to pay attorney fees. If you can show
- 47:33a likelihood of succeeding, then you're going
- 47:36to be okay. Well, at Pro -Ing 2, a common argument
- 47:38is privilege. It was privileged. But here, you
- 47:44probably can't assert that privilege. Section
- 47:4647B says, anything you say in court is privileged.
- 47:49Now, there's a caveat to that. There's an exception.
- 47:52It's the divorce provisio, right? That's 47B1
- 47:57of the civil code. It says, if it's filed in
- 48:01an action for dissolution or legal separation,
- 48:04the privilege doesn't apply. Well, this isn't
- 48:06an action for legal separation or dissolution.
- 48:08This is an independent DVPA action. The divorce
- 48:15provisio is probably not going to apply and a
- 48:18privilege probably would. I think this would
- 48:20probably be a successful anti -slap motion. A
- 48:23lot of family law judges though, they're not
- 48:25that familiar with anti -slap. A lot of them
- 48:29are prosecutors and never saw an anti -slap motion
- 48:32before because it's not applicable in any criminal
- 48:34case. So I got to tell you, if you file it and
- 48:38it gets denied by a judge who doesn't know it
- 48:40so much, you might file an appeal. I got to warn
- 48:44you, I'm not trying to discourage you, but I
- 48:45just got to let you know many courts today still
- 48:47refuse to abide by the mandate that they have
- 48:50to construe anti -slap broadly. And they have
- 48:53gone so far, in my opinion, appellate courts
- 48:56are, some of them are so craven to shrink the
- 49:00coverage of anti -slap rather than do what the
- 49:02legislature said and construe it broadly, that
- 49:04they'll punish lawyers for all kinds of, using
- 49:07any kind of creativity if they can. I cite this
- 49:10case, it's in your brief. It affirmed a sanctions
- 49:13award, you know, an attorney fees award saying
- 49:17that the anti -slap motion was frivolous. They
- 49:19said it was frivolous to contend that a theme
- 49:21park could be considered an artistic work. And
- 49:24I just can't resist saying one thing about that.
- 49:27If you have an idea that you can share with me
- 49:29about how a place where you go to take your kids
- 49:32and it triggers their imagination to imagine
- 49:35some really interesting kinds of things and stuff
- 49:37they read in Disney stories is not artistic.
- 49:44But the California, the United States Supreme
- 49:46Court has said patently offensive pornography
- 49:49is protected as an artistic work and it triggers
- 49:52your imagination to go in a different direction.
- 49:55Please explain this to me. My phone will be ready
- 49:59to take your call. I want to hear about it. But
- 50:01the point I'm making here is you can be sanctioned
- 50:05for being created with anti -slot motions if
- 50:06the court of appeal thinks it's frivolous and
- 50:08some courts are maybe a little more likely than
- 50:10we would want to find things frivolous. And so
- 50:14you need to also be aware of this SAV Maiden
- 50:16case that says, you know, courts are naturally
- 50:18wary of anything that might cause a chilling
- 50:21effect on the ability of victims of domestic
- 50:25violence and other abuse to obtain protective
- 50:28relief. Well, so that's a serious public policy.
- 50:31We want these people to be protected. You know
- 50:33what else is a serious public policy? Anti -discrimination
- 50:36and employment and housing. That's a serious
- 50:39public policy, but... the California Supreme
- 50:42Court has spanked the Court of Appeal, numerous
- 50:45courts of appeal, who tried to say, no, no, no,
- 50:47you can't do this in discrimination claims because
- 50:49that would jeopardize the ability of these plaintiffs
- 50:51to get rid of discrimination in our state. And
- 50:56the California Supreme Court said in the Wilson
- 50:58case that I cited to you, no, that's the wrong
- 51:00focus. It's not how important the public policy
- 51:03is. It's what are you saying the defendant did?
- 51:06And if you're saying the defendant or the respondent
- 51:08should be liable because they engaged in activities
- 51:10that are protected by anti -slap, guess what?
- 51:13You're subject to anti -slap. All right, hypothetical
- 51:16number two. Dastardly spouse testifies at a hearing
- 51:20and a divorce action that prim spouse is a skank,
- 51:23right? A skank who is an active member of both
- 51:28Antifa and the Prowboys and NAMBLA. I won't spell
- 51:32NAMBLA out for all of you, but some of you might
- 51:34be old enough to remember this group. So this
- 51:38is quite an array of organizations to belong
- 51:40to, I got to say. So Dastardly's lawyer, Sharpie
- 51:44Wordsmith, advocates to the family court that
- 51:47Pram should not get custody or unsupervised visitation
- 51:50with the kids for those reasons. you know, memberships
- 51:53in these crazy organizations. PRIM sues both
- 51:56Dastardly and Sharpie for defamation, infliction
- 51:58of emotional distress, interference with prospective
- 52:00economic advantage, because you know PRIM had
- 52:04applied for a job at the courtroom, at the courthouse.
- 52:07Dastardly and Sharpie file an anti -slap motion
- 52:10to strike those claims. Will their motion succeed?
- 52:14I won't wait to see what you guess. Let's just
- 52:16cut right to it. This hypo is to remind you there's
- 52:20two prongs, right? There's two prongs. It's not
- 52:23enough that the activity is protected under prong
- 52:25one. It also has to be meritless under prong
- 52:28two in order for the anti -slap motion to succeed.
- 52:31And so they likely can clear prong one because,
- 52:34you know, the allegedly actionable statements
- 52:36were in connection with litigation. That's clear.
- 52:39So, due to the divorce provisio, we already talked
- 52:41about that. This is a divorce case, remember.
- 52:45Privilege probably isn't going to have the teeth
- 52:47that it would in a different case at prong two.
- 52:50All right, so that's going to be out. However,
- 52:54Dasterly might also have a hard time defeating
- 52:56the claim. There's other ways to defeat it. He
- 52:58might say, you know, the membership in the organization
- 53:03is a provably false statement. But all PREM has
- 53:07to do is sign a declaration and a real saying,
- 53:09I don't belong to those organizations, and you
- 53:11get past prong two. Now, on the other hand, there's
- 53:14also some other things. Dasterly may Partly prevail
- 53:17on prong to because calling her a skank is a
- 53:20non actionable opinion. And so he cannot get
- 53:24liability. You know, there cannot be liability
- 53:26based on whether or not she's a skank. That's
- 53:27an opinion. And moreover, if dastardly only has
- 53:30evidence to prove that prim belongs to one or
- 53:32two of the organizations, but not all three.
- 53:35It's possible for dastardly to prevail partially
- 53:38on the anti -slot motion under brawl, which says,
- 53:40you know, the protected activities, if you can't
- 53:43support them, then out they go. And the. party
- 53:46that move for anti -slap relief gets their attorney
- 53:48fees. Hypothetical number three, sensitive spouse
- 53:54and insulting spouse entered a marital settlement
- 53:56agreement that concluded their divorce in 2015.
- 54:00This year, sensitive petition to modify child
- 54:03custody and child support due to change circumstances
- 54:06while insulting filed another, I shouldn't say
- 54:10another, a counter petition to enforce some provision
- 54:13of the marital settlement agreement. And so insulting
- 54:16discovery responses in connection with those
- 54:19competing petitions revealed facts indicating
- 54:22that insulting may have used misrepresentations
- 54:25to induce sensitive to enter the MSA in the beginning
- 54:28back in 2015. And so based on these discovery
- 54:32responses, sensitive files and amended petition
- 54:35to set aside the MSA under family code section
- 54:392122. Well, sensitive's amended petition for
- 54:43set -aside alleges that the fraud was not discovered
- 54:45until it was revealed in insulting's recent discovery
- 54:49responses to written discovery. So that's kind
- 54:52of tolling, right? The claim for fraud set -aside
- 54:55gets told until you discover it, and you didn't
- 54:57discover it until you learned about it in discovery.
- 55:00And so can insulting file an anti -slap motion
- 55:03to strike sensitive set -aside petition? Aha!
- 55:08Unfair trick question. Yes, of course you can
- 55:11always file an anti -slap motion. Even if it's
- 55:14not protected activity, you can still file it.
- 55:17Yeah, the question is, really the better question
- 55:19is whether it would be advisable to file such
- 55:22a motion because if you can't surmount prong
- 55:24one, there's probably a pretty good chance that
- 55:27you're going to get hit with attorney fees because
- 55:29your anti -slap motion was frivolous. And so
- 55:33that would seem to be an insurmountable obstacle
- 55:37here. Because the claim in question was merely
- 55:39triggered by information developed in discovery
- 55:42and the discovery proceedings themselves are
- 55:46not a fact that must be proven to establish liability.
- 55:50The discovery only goes to the tolling, not the
- 55:53liability. Listen, I've not seen this actually
- 55:57analyzed in a published decision, but that's
- 55:59how I would analyze it. In my opinion, that just
- 56:04goes to tolling, not liability. And so, yeah,
- 56:07you got this from discovery. You could have got
- 56:09it from your neighbor too. That's just how you
- 56:10got it for tolling. That's not what gives rise
- 56:12to liability. What gives rise to liability is
- 56:15that, you know, the other spouse concealed information
- 56:19and therefore, you know, committed the fraud
- 56:21when they induced you to enter the marital settlement
- 56:23agreement. Okay, so the actionable conduct in
- 56:31this hypo is probably not protected. Even if
- 56:33it were, again, you know, you'd have to make
- 56:36sure the anti -slot motion was timely, and then
- 56:40we're on to prong two, right? So let's go to
- 56:42hypothetical number four. Yeah, you know what?
- 56:46I see a couple questions. Let me stop and look
- 56:48at the questions before we do this. Why wouldn't
- 56:51privilege have the teeth on account of it being
- 56:53in a family law case? Because section 47B1 has
- 56:57the family law provisio that says that statements
- 57:00in a family law action are not privileged like
- 57:02they would be in anything else. How does this
- 57:06jive with family code section 271 sanctioning
- 57:09parties for? Yes, great question. Oh, you know
- 57:12what? When I see a case that actually does that,
- 57:14I'll expand this presentation to talk about section
- 57:17271 of the family code, which says that a court
- 57:21can sanction somebody for what obstructing or
- 57:25preventing, you know, voluntary resolution. But
- 57:28it's not just in the course of settlement, right?
- 57:30It's frivolous motions and all that stuff. That
- 57:32is litigation abuse, right? And so, yes, I think
- 57:37that 271, a motion for sanctions under section
- 57:41271, also could possibly be subject to an anti
- 57:46-slap motion. But it's going to depend on what
- 57:49you're saying in there and what you're looking
- 57:50for. Listen, if any of you are really thinking
- 57:54about this seriously, give me a call and we'll
- 57:56talk about it. But if I really go on and on,
- 58:00I'll be thinking all day about this and we won't
- 58:02finish in time. We only have two minutes left.
- 58:04Thank you both for the excellent questions, though.
- 58:07I have to get you past the, you know, the one
- 58:10-hour mark, so I'm going to do this one more
- 58:11hypo to get you there. And oh, looks like there's
- 58:15one more question. I'd rather ask answer questions
- 58:17than do hypos. I'm not seeing it, though. No,
- 58:21no open questions. All right. Last hypo, then.
- 58:25Sensitive spouse propounds written discovery.
- 58:27Sounds familiar, right? to insulting spouse in
- 58:29a case seeking modification of child custody
- 58:31in a move away order. Insulting, snarky, and
- 58:35insulting discovery responses deeply hurt sensitive.
- 58:38Based on those snarky and insulting responses,
- 58:40sensitive files a separate lawsuit asserting
- 58:43an infliction of emotional distress claim against
- 58:45insulting and insulting's lawyer, right? Sharpie
- 58:48Wordsmith. So, sensitive's new lawsuit alleges
- 58:51that reading those snarky insults was the cause
- 58:54of emotional distress. Can insulting and the
- 58:57attorney Sharpie file an anti -slap motion to
- 58:59strike the emotional distress claim? Yeah, absolutely.
- 59:03Again, you can always file it, but the question
- 59:06is, can you avoid liability for filing a frivolous
- 59:12anti -slap motion? And so how likely is it to
- 59:16succeed? Well, I think the motion here is likely
- 59:19to get press prong one and thereby avoid award
- 59:22of sanctions because unlike the previous hypothetical,
- 59:26It's the protected litigation conduct, right?
- 59:28Writing and serving responses to written discovery
- 59:31that actually gives rise to liability. That just
- 59:33doesn't explain tolling. It gives rise to the
- 59:37liability. I think it remains questionable if
- 59:40allegedly actionable conduct is privileged or
- 59:43unmeritorious for some other reason. Gosh, I
- 59:47thought that would have got us to 130, but it
- 59:49looks like I'm still sitting here at 129. If
- 59:52you don't mind me going a couple of minutes over
- 59:53everybody, please forgive me, but I want you
- 59:55to get all the credit you're supposed to. Hypothetical
- 59:58number five, nasty spouse engaged in a pattern
- 1:00:01of severe abuse against innocent spouse that
- 1:00:04resulted in the San Diego County Superior Court
- 1:00:07granting innocence request for a five -year DVRO.
- 1:00:12Innocent later moved to Lassen County. and petitioned
- 1:00:15the Lassen County Superior Court, both for a
- 1:00:18divorce and to renew the DVRO that was about
- 1:00:21to expire. A few months later, before the hearing
- 1:00:23to renew the DVRO was to be held, Innocence's
- 1:00:26attorney did as Innocent instructed and voluntarily
- 1:00:29withdrew the request to renew the restraining
- 1:00:32order, given the geographic distance from NASTI.
- 1:00:35However, Innocence's attorney did so without
- 1:00:39getting the malicious prosecution released from
- 1:00:40NASTI. who later sued innocent and innocence
- 1:00:43attorney, alleging malicious prosecution, abusive
- 1:00:46process, intentional and infliction of emotional
- 1:00:49distress, all that, based on their request for
- 1:00:51a new DVRO. Is it slap time yet? Yeah, you bet.
- 1:00:55Listen, I'm not saying I'm really happy that
- 1:00:57somebody who might be deserving of a DVRO. can
- 1:01:00get this kind of anti -slap relief, but a malicious
- 1:01:03prosecution arises from protected activity under
- 1:01:05the anti -slap statute because really per se,
- 1:01:08it involves the filing and prosecution of an
- 1:01:10underlying lawsuit. And so that's going to be
- 1:01:13per se protected. You know, the IIED claims also
- 1:01:16arise from, you know, stuff that's barred by
- 1:01:19the litigation privilege. So, you know, prong
- 1:01:21one and prong two are both problematic in this
- 1:01:23hypothetical. So I hope leaving you with that
- 1:01:27gives you enough, I don't know, not keep you
- 1:01:30up at night anxiety, but enough, I guess, concern,
- 1:01:33not anxiety to think about, I'm going to be on
- 1:01:36the lookout for anti -slap stuff from now on
- 1:01:38as a family law practitioner. I need to know
- 1:01:40about it because I don't want my client to get
- 1:01:43hit with it, and I want to give my client anti
- 1:01:45-slap relief if he or she is entitled to it.
- 1:01:48With that, we're only one minute over. You can
- 1:01:51read through the rest of the hypotheticals if
- 1:01:53you want in the handout. All the cases I talked
- 1:01:56about in the statutes are cited in there. And
- 1:01:59the statutes are kind of excerpted, but the important
- 1:02:01stuff is in there, the stuff that's important
- 1:02:03for our purposes today. So I want to thank you
- 1:02:06very much with that. I'll conclude. And by all
- 1:02:08means, any of you have follow up questions, give
- 1:02:10me a call or email me. I'll be happy to take
- 1:02:12some time to talk to you.