Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #58: How YOU Can Help Reverse the Tide of Political Violence
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan political analysis.
- 0:06I'm your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:08So this is going to be a little bit different today.
- 0:13Definitely not as energetic.
- 0:16Our topic today is political violence, but especially how we can push back against the
- 0:23acceptance of political violence.
- 0:26And it's a little less straight up civics oriented, though, of course, that is still very
- 0:30important to today's topic.
- 0:34This past week saw the assassination of conservative Republican activist Charlie Kirk.
- 0:41A few months ago, it was liberal democratic politician Melissa Hortman in Minnesota.
- 0:47And as a few other examples, democratic Pennsylvania governor Josh Shapiro and
- 0:53republican president Donald Trump evaded assassination attempts.
- 0:58Just a few examples.
- 1:00This political violence is something that we need to address now or matters are going to get
- 1:06worse, and this country will eventually fall apart.
- 1:09It's easy to just assume that it's going to keep going because it's been going for just
- 1:16about two and a half centuries now, but you can't just assume that.
- 1:23Unfortunately, political violence is not anything new.
- 1:26It's been around since the beginning of human civilization, and there is some inclination in
- 1:33human nature toward dissension and strife.
- 1:36But it doesn't have to spill over into bloodshed.
- 1:39And all too often, that's what happens.
- 1:43And even for those people who wouldn't ever dare to physically act out against people they
- 1:50disagree with or even threatened to do so, There is still a disturbing level of acceptance
- 1:57or even justification given when the target of violence is someone we disagree with.
- 2:03But the good news is that we can all be part of the solution just with some simple changes and
- 2:11that we can all be better about how we engage with politics.
- 2:16We have to be.
- 2:18And this is going to take Democrats, Republicans, and independents to band together
- 2:23to fix this problem.
- 2:24It's going to take conservatives, liberals, and those in between to get us through this.
- 2:29So today, we're going to go over reasons why people feel justified in using or supporting
- 2:35political violence and ways that we can all begin to turn back this tide of violence and
- 2:41its acceptance.
- 2:43And before we can talk about how to turn back the violence, we need to understand why people
- 2:50think it is okay to be politically violent to get physical or even verbal against other
- 2:58people that they disagree with.
- 3:01So seven reasons why people feel justified in using or supporting political violence.
- 3:08First reason is the sense of moral superiority, and moral superiority in general can happen to
- 3:16any one of us.
- 3:17I've definitely felt it at times.
- 3:19Obviously, not to the point of supporting violence, but people don't just feel like their
- 3:25opinion is correct.
- 3:26They think that they are morally better than people because of their opinion.
- 3:31In a previous episode, I talked about compromise and whether we really want
- 3:36compromise.
- 3:37And one of the things I talked about that was a barrier to compromise is the presence of
- 3:45moralized attitudes where people feel that they are standing on business basically that they
- 3:53are they have to stand on their moral principles and that for them to budge is not
- 3:59only wrong, but that would be immoral of them to do so.
- 4:03So they have to stand firm.
- 4:05It's not even about winning.
- 4:06It's about adhering to rules that they have established for themselves.
- 4:12And having these moralized attitudes is going to make you more likely to support political
- 4:17violence.
- 4:17That might sound weird because, oh, well, if you think you're morally superior, how are you
- 4:21going to justify violence?
- 4:23A lot of people will tell themselves it's for the greater good or that they're just
- 4:29preventing violence from the other side.
- 4:31It's it's amazing the mental gymnastics that people can do when it comes to politics.
- 4:39You're convinced that somebody else not adhering to your rules means that they are
- 4:45being immoral and that they are a threat to morality in general.
- 4:48So they there has to be somebody that stands up against it, even if that means assaulting
- 4:54people or even killing them.
- 4:57And it's just this general strong desire to be right, to be correct.
- 5:02We convince ourselves it is morally correct and just to destroy the quote unquote other.
- 5:10So there is no talking to other people.
- 5:15We have to go until one side or the other loses.
- 5:21Second reason that people feel justified in using political violence is that they treat
- 5:27politics as an existential crisis.
- 5:30This is something that happens way too often, where basically every political battle is seen
- 5:36as a battle for the soul of America or for the soul of the community.
- 5:42When you think the existence of other views is a threat to your existence, you wanna destroy
- 5:47that threat.
- 5:48It's just that basic instinct of there's something threatening me.
- 5:53There's something threatening that the people the people I care about.
- 5:56I have to make sure that they don't do that.
- 5:59I'm going to stand up against them.
- 6:01And there's an outsized influence of people who think that they are being existentially
- 6:07threatened.
- 6:08They have more incentive to participate more frequently in politics, so they have more
- 6:13impact on political decisions, and their policies reflect the fact that they think that
- 6:18there's an existential crisis going on.
- 6:22Reason number three that people feel justified in using political violence is that people feel
- 6:30that they're not heard and that their rights are being taken away.
- 6:34When we don't think we're being heard, we lash out.
- 6:37And that's not just in politics.
- 6:38That's in other dynamics and situations.
- 6:40We're talking to a family member or a friend, spouse, significant other.
- 6:45We think they're not listening.
- 6:47We'll sometimes yell at them.
- 6:48You're not necessarily get physical, but you might yell at them because you think that
- 6:52you're not being heard, that you're not being understood.
- 6:56And beyond politics, think of how many times people have used violence when they feel like
- 7:02their voice isn't heard.
- 7:03And to some extent, that anger is understandable.
- 7:07You you when you think that you're not being heard, don't don't expect people to not be
- 7:15angry about that, but it can't spill over to actual violence.
- 7:20And sometimes the perception of rights being taken away is not accurate, but sometimes
- 7:28people have these feelings of victimhood, this sense of being unfairly and unjustly treated,
- 7:35which leads people to greater support for violence.
- 7:37Now sometimes that is the case.
- 7:39Sometimes people's rights are being taken away or they're being suppressed, And that's
- 7:44something that we do need to address.
- 7:46But we cannot address it by being violent, by being willing to kill each other over it.
- 7:57Fourth reason that people feel justified in using political violence, and this is arguably
- 8:03one of the biggest ones, if not the biggest one.
- 8:06It's a higher usage of social media that is associated with more support for political
- 8:13violence.
- 8:14Studies have shown that, and it makes sense.
- 8:18Ironically, even though it's social media, there is more dissociation from each other by
- 8:24being on social media all the time.
- 8:26You're just those chronically terminally online people that become more detached from personal
- 8:33relationships and start seeing others as not real people.
- 8:36People become those keyboard warriors and feel super powerful behind a computer screen because
- 8:42they don't have that human interaction.
- 8:45So they just think this person is just exactly what I see.
- 8:51And so this social media just really incentivizes that kind of behavior by social
- 9:00media algorithms and showing you what you are predisposed to agree with.
- 9:07People online all the time see this inciting and outrage content even more than the average
- 9:16person does.
- 9:16We all see it, and we all are affected by it.
- 9:20But people who are just online four or five six hours a day, especially on social media that
- 9:25whole time.
- 9:27It's a more pronounced problem for for them.
- 9:30They're the content is already engineered to create more engagement And what creates more
- 9:36engagement?
- 9:37Anger, frustration, bitterness, distrust, and all these things can incentivize people to be
- 9:48more supportive of political violence if not actually use it themselves.
- 9:53And it's just these echo chambers that also allow just the voices calling for rage and
- 10:00violence to take over more of the sound space for people.
- 10:03So that's that's all they're hearing, and then that's all they seek out.
- 10:08Another reason why people feel justified in political violence is just there's this higher
- 10:15level of effective polarization, which whether it is the most effectively polarized we've
- 10:22been, that's that's a debate that many people have had, and whether it is or it isn't isn't
- 10:29the point.
- 10:29The point is there is a very heightened sense of effective polarization, effective being our
- 10:35thoughts and feelings about each other.
- 10:38There's the partisan polarization, how far the parties are, the ideological polarization, how
- 10:44far the conservative and liberal camps are, issue polarization.
- 10:49And yes, those can lead to affective polarization.
- 10:52But if affective polarization tends to more feed into those, and you can have very stark
- 10:59views based on party or ideology or issues and still get along with other people.
- 11:06But a lot of times, that's not what happens, but it's really the effect of polarization that
- 11:11is what we need to watch out for.
- 11:14And effective meaning or affective polarization leads to these feelings of hate, fear, anger,
- 11:24disgust, distrust towards this quote unquote other side, this whole in group out group
- 11:30nonsense where there is that other group and they're terrible and everything about them is
- 11:35terrible.
- 11:36Our group is great.
- 11:37We don't do anything wrong.
- 11:38It's always the other person, the other group.
- 11:41And when you feel these things, you feel you're more likely to be supportive of violence
- 11:47against that other group because they are causing you these negative emotions, whether
- 11:53it's they actually are contributing to those negative emotions or it's just your bias.
- 11:58In any case.
- 12:01You see them as they're the ones who are causing me to feel anger and bitterness and
- 12:06disgust and all these negative emotions.
- 12:09We have to destroy them.
- 12:12Another reason that people feel that political violence is okay is a distrust of political
- 12:21institutions and deeming them illegitimate.
- 12:24And, unfortunately, there are a lot of political actors that feed into that and say
- 12:28it's these institutions that are the problem.
- 12:29But conveniently, if I'm there, we're going to fix that.
- 12:33Now you probably have somebody specifically in mind when you hear that.
- 12:36But the problem is there are a lot of people that do that across the political spectrum.
- 12:42It's not just a one person thing or a one side thing.
- 12:44This is something that happens a lot across political views.
- 12:50We have a serious issue with distrust of political institutions.
- 12:54Yeah.
- 12:54We we should want to see them get better.
- 12:56Yes.
- 12:57A lot of these institutions have major flaws.
- 13:00Of course, they do.
- 13:01They're occupied by human beings and human beings created them.
- 13:05So these institutions are not flawless by any means, but deeming them illegitimate,
- 13:11especially if it's only based on who occupies the office is a dangerous notion.
- 13:17So if our opinion of the legitimacy of the Supreme Court is based on whether we agree with
- 13:23their conservative majority or we don't, That's dangerous.
- 13:27Even if you if you're considering them legitimate because it's conservative majority.
- 13:32That's a problem.
- 13:33Because what happens when it becomes a liberal majority?
- 13:35Does it suddenly lose its legitimacy?
- 13:38And then the people who thought it was or who think it's illegitimate now, they're gonna
- 13:42suddenly think it's legitimate if the Supreme Court flips.
- 13:46That's not how we should be treating things.
- 13:50It should not be to the point where we have no regard for these institutions unless it's
- 13:56conveniently occupied by people we agree with.
- 13:59That's not the way to go about things.
- 14:02And so if you don't trust these institutions at all because of and it's based on who's in them,
- 14:11you are gonna be more likely to support violence against those occupants and those
- 14:16institutions.
- 14:17They're actual buildings.
- 14:19And whenever and especially when their officials that we don't support are in those
- 14:23buildings, we become supportive of violence against them, bombings, shootings, whatever
- 14:33means to incite violence against those symbols, not just the people in them, but those symbols.
- 14:39That is a very serious problem we have, and it's fueling this distrust of political
- 14:44institutions where they're just there's something endemically wrong to the point where
- 14:49we have to do something against that threat.
- 14:52That's not something that we can't that's not something that we can be doing that we should
- 14:58be doing.
- 14:59We can't there's criticism is is perfectly fine.
- 15:07You should be able to criticize them, but it should not get to the point where you're
- 15:10actually willing to be violent against those institutions and those officials.
- 15:15And then the last reason I want to cover of why people feel justified in using political
- 15:23violence is the problem of disinformation and misinformation.
- 15:28So both are factually wrong, but misinformation is not intended to deceive.
- 15:34Disinformation is intended to deceive.
- 15:36You think disinformation, deceive, they they both start with the same letter, d, but they
- 15:44both can lead to more acceptance of violence.
- 15:49So if I think one one big thing is that people.
- 15:55Supports or they they perceive that the quote unquote other side is more supportive of
- 16:01violence than they actually are, and that's something we're gonna talk about a little bit
- 16:04more later.
- 16:07There are a lot fewer people that are accepting of violence than we think there are.
- 16:11It's just they have an outsized influence.
- 16:14Misinformation, you might really think that the other side, quote, unquote, is more supportive
- 16:20of violence, but you're just mistaken.
- 16:24You're misinformed.
- 16:25So mistaken, misinformed, deceive, disinformation.
- 16:33But that still may lead you to be more violent in retaliation.
- 16:37You might think that retaliation is justified because, well, they're gonna be violent, so
- 16:41we're gonna be violent in in turn.
- 16:43And when it's disinformation, it's even worse.
- 16:47You might know that they're not actually more inclined to violence like you're saying they
- 16:54are, but you're purposely saying that so that you do incite violence.
- 16:58And then it becomes a self fulfilling prophecy of now that side supports violence.
- 17:05Now my side is going to be more supportive of violence, and then it's just this vicious cycle
- 17:10that goes back and forth.
- 17:13Now that's the doom and gloom portion.
- 17:18Now we need to talk about ways that we can tamp down political violence and its acceptance
- 17:25because we can do this.
- 17:27There are positive aspects to this.
- 17:31There are things that can be done.
- 17:34This is not this is not this is not have to be the way things are.
- 17:40So I'm gonna talk about eight ways that you can tamp down political violence.
- 17:46And really, so much of this issue starts with self awareness for everybody.
- 17:52You're a hardcore liberal democrat, hardcore conservative republican, super moderate
- 17:58independents, and everything in between and outside of those.
- 18:02Everybody needs to be more self aware because all of us can be better.
- 18:07So we need to stop constantly blaming other people.
- 18:10Stop blaming this other side.
- 18:13Democrats and liberals need to stop blaming conservatives and republicans.
- 18:16Conservatives and republicans need to stop blaming liberals and democrats.
- 18:19Modernists and independents not need to stop just blaming both of the sides or the one side
- 18:26that they tend to not support.
- 18:29Everybody can be better.
- 18:30I can be better, and I try to get better every day.
- 18:36Sometimes we feed the fuel or the fire that's fueling polarization and the desire for
- 18:43violence unintentionally.
- 18:46We need to stop engaging with these kinds of things, especially on social media that fuel
- 18:52these flames.
- 18:54Stop thinking that we know more about another group than we actually do.
- 19:00There's so many ways that we can start to be more self aware about.
- 19:07How we can?
- 19:09Solve this issue.
- 19:10Because even if we're not actually supporting political violence, we may do things that
- 19:15unintentionally exacerbate it.
- 19:18It's that whole thing I talk about in my educational email course about how ways that we
- 19:22unintentionally inflame polarization.
- 19:26And, of course, polarization leads to more support for political violence.
- 19:32So if we are cognizant of how we can unintentionally exacerbate polarization, we can
- 19:40then stop or not stop, but we can mitigate this acceptance of political violence.
- 19:49So so much of this starts with self awareness.
- 19:53Now more specific ways that we can help tamp down political violence.
- 20:00One way, improved civics education.
- 20:03Greater civic knowledge has been shown to lead to less polarization, less likelihood to be
- 20:10manipulated by people because people who are deliberately manipulating, whether it's
- 20:15politicians or social media grifters, they know that a lot of people are just going to listen
- 20:22to what they have to say because they tend to agree with them so they can give them false or
- 20:28misleading information about how government works, and people will listen to them because
- 20:33they are not giving any critical thought to what these grifters are saying.
- 20:40But when you have civic education, when you improve it in schools, when you have better
- 20:46continuing education for adults so that they can learn civics, especially because if they
- 20:52had poor civics education when they were in school, even if you improve civics education in
- 20:58schools now, which obviously is great and we should be doing that, That doesn't help the
- 21:03adults who are already out of school, so we need to do what we can to improve civics
- 21:09education for them as well, which is obviously a lot easier said than done.
- 21:15But civics education is in a poor state.
- 21:18Even the most basic knowledge of government isn't well known, like even naming just one US
- 21:25Supreme Court justice or knowing that there's three branches of government.
- 21:29There's a disturbingly low percentage of people who know those things.
- 21:34Even just those basics like that, knowing that little bit of civics can make a world of
- 21:43difference, especially because when people don't have civic education, they also tend to
- 21:47have low political efficacy.
- 21:49We've talked about that in several episodes before you have internal political efficacy,
- 21:53how much people think they know and how much they actually know, an external political
- 21:59efficacy, how much people think they can affect politics and how much they actually do.
- 22:05When you have low political efficacy, in either case, it tends to make you more susceptible to
- 22:13manipulation or even accepting of violence.
- 22:18You don't for example, in the internal side, you don't know as much about politics.
- 22:24You might think you know way more about politics than you actually do, but you listen
- 22:28to all these people who you agree with because, oh, well, you know what?
- 22:32They know what they're doing, so I'm just gonna listen to them.
- 22:36And sometimes those are the people who are trying to manipulate you.
- 22:39And if they're not outright calling for violence, they're trying to tell you that other
- 22:43side is being violent.
- 22:45And then that's makes you more accepting of violence in return.
- 22:51And then external political violence when people think they can't affect government when
- 22:54they think their voice isn't being heard.
- 22:57A lot of times, they'll be more accepting of, you know what?
- 23:01I'm gonna be violent against these institutions.
- 23:03I'm gonna go blow up this building.
- 23:05I'm going to shoot people in this building.
- 23:06I'm going to stab people in this building and the people who are in the government in these
- 23:12buildings.
- 23:13People start to think like that, at least more so.
- 23:19And, also, improved civics education will make us better at recognizing misinformation and
- 23:24disinformation.
- 23:25It's And also important to recognize when which is happening too, but much of the this
- 23:31misinformation and disinformation is meant to incite violence.
- 23:34It's or at the very least, it's meant to incite rage, which a lot of times leads to violence.
- 23:40So an improved civics education will do wonders in tamping down this political violence.
- 23:48Another way that we can all help tamp down political violence, Distinctly acknowledge each
- 23:58other's humanity.
- 24:00Obviously, a lot easier said than done, especially when we're already in a heightened
- 24:04state of emotion.
- 24:06Even if we think people are jerks or terrible people, we have to recognize they are still
- 24:11human.
- 24:12Let's take Charlie Kirk and Melissa Hortman for existence.
- 24:16Youth let's say let's for the sake of argument, let's just say they're both bad people.
- 24:22Charlie Kirk was a terrible person.
- 24:23Miss Melissa Horman was a terrible person.
- 24:25Just for this exercise, we'll say that that's the case.
- 24:29That's just them.
- 24:30So let's say that you do decide to be violent against them.
- 24:35They are still people, and they have a lot of people that care about them.
- 24:41They both had spouses.
- 24:43They both had children.
- 24:46They both had extended family and friends that loved them and cared a lot about them.
- 24:53People who didn't have anything to do with your grievance.
- 25:00So even if you think you're proving a point against them and what they stand for, you're
- 25:10still leaving a trail of broken lives who had nothing to do with this.
- 25:16They might not even share the same views as the murder victims because let's call it what it
- 25:24is.
- 25:24These are murders.
- 25:26Charlie Kirk was murdered.
- 25:28Melissa Hortman was murdered.
- 25:30Josh Shapiro and Donald Trump were subject to attempted murders.
- 25:37This is.
- 25:39You're not just affecting.
- 25:42Those specific people when you kill them, when you incite violence against them, you're
- 25:47affecting all these other people that had nothing to do with what you were upset about.
- 25:54So why is that okay?
- 25:59So you're not you're not just refusing to acknowledge that the people that you supported
- 26:04violence against were humans, even if they if you think they're jerks.
- 26:10You're basically not acknowledging the fact that the people who cared about them, who loved
- 26:16them were also are also human.
- 26:23There is a very disturbing level of dehumanization that we see in today's politics.
- 26:30And to some extent, we're all guilty of it.
- 26:34Sometimes we see somebody as one dimensional that we are pissed off at, that we're just
- 26:41furious at.
- 26:42Even if we don't actually support violence against them, we still oftentimes dehumanize
- 26:49them in our minds or in our speech.
- 26:56But that's just not this is not that's not how we should be going about this because it's
- 27:05gonna affect a lot more people when you dehumanize them, and it just starts inciting
- 27:10more and more people even if we're not intending to do that.
- 27:14And I wanna go back to something that previous guests of mine, Guy and Heidi Burgess of the
- 27:19Conflict Information Consortium, talked about on this podcast a couple months ago.
- 27:25Two big words that can help transform our political dialogue, and that's listen and
- 27:33respect.
- 27:35You do not have to agree with people, but you do have to let them say their peace.
- 27:41If you're really going to treat them as human beings, you cannot just suffocate their
- 27:46opinion.
- 27:48If you really see people as equals in terms of humanity, You're not going to shut them out.
- 27:58You may get very angry.
- 27:59You may you may, you know, put your fingers in your ears and go, I can't hear you.
- 28:05But to actually try to forcibly suppress that opinion.
- 28:12That is treating them as less than human.
- 28:15And, unfortunately, for for all that America stood for in terms of freedom of speech, at
- 28:23least ideally, that is an ideal that we have not lived up to in a lot of cases.
- 28:30There are many cases where we were acting completely antithetical to that.
- 28:39Listen and respect.
- 28:42We're all human beings here.
- 28:44Even if we think that that person over there is a jerk, we're all human.
- 28:50Another way that we can help tamp down political violence, We cannot be apathetic, and
- 28:56we cannot tune out of politics.
- 28:58Now this is going back to episode 50 of this podcast, which talked about political apathy.
- 29:06Apathy lets the worst parts of politics fester and become worse because the more effectively
- 29:15polarized people who are absolutely not apathetic, in fact, they're they have the
- 29:21opposite issue of caring too much.
- 29:24They have an outsized influence on politics because they participate much more often than
- 29:29the non polarized people who are a lot of times are more apathetic or at least inconsistent in
- 29:36how much they participate.
- 29:42But there is a lot of.
- 29:46The reasons that people have have apathy or disenchantment, they just don't want anything
- 29:51to do with politics, not because they don't care, but because they're frustrated and
- 29:54they're tired.
- 29:55A lot of it is understandable, and we should acknowledge those reasons people have for being
- 30:01apathetic or disenchanted.
- 30:05And not everybody has to get involved in politics, but we do need a lot more people to
- 30:11at least stand up and say, no.
- 30:13We are not we are not having this anymore.
- 30:16This is not how we're going to be as a country.
- 30:19We need to teach people why apathy and not doing anything makes things worse.
- 30:26You may think politics doesn't concern you, but boy, oh boy, that could not be further from the
- 30:31truth.
- 30:32It does concern you.
- 30:34You don't have to eat, sleep, and breathe politics twenty four seven like some of us do.
- 30:39I mean, I don't do it twenty four seven, but I do consume politics much more than I'd like to
- 30:45sometimes.
- 30:46And in fact, it's better that you don't consume it twenty four seven because then you get to
- 30:51the opposite issue of caring too much.
- 30:54But you don't but you do need to be willing to actually push for real change that pushes back
- 31:01against polarization and violence.
- 31:06So that's something we really need to work on.
- 31:09That's one of the most difficult things is trying to get apathetic people to not be
- 31:13apathetic because, well, they're apathetic.
- 31:17That doesn't mean that that can't change.
- 31:19That has changed for lots of people over the course of history, but that is something we
- 31:26need to make sure that we do not do, and we teach people who are apathetic.
- 31:32Hey.
- 31:32Look.
- 31:33This is not gonna get any better.
- 31:35This and this does involve you.
- 31:40Another way we can help tamp down political violence and its acceptance is responsible
- 31:46social media usage.
- 31:49Do not angrily engage with rage bait.
- 31:52That is exactly what rage baiters want you to do.
- 31:55They want you to get angry and to tweet, comment, post angry stuff and response, and
- 32:04then that just lets that content circulate.
- 32:07We circulate content meant to make people more accepting of violence or or of at least anger,
- 32:14can lead to violence even when we're not intending to.
- 32:21So when you see social media content that is ignorance in insightful, not insightful as I n
- 32:32s I g h t f u l, more I n c I t e f u l.
- 32:38It's inciting content.
- 32:42Take a step back.
- 32:43Think about what should my response be.
- 32:46Do I need to say something?
- 32:50Am I doing what the person who posted this content wants me to do, which is to get angry
- 32:59and respond.
- 33:02Every one of us can be better in this regard because we all see things that piss us off
- 33:06because that's we're humans.
- 33:08It's a very human emotion to be angry, and it's not necessarily inherently wrong to be angry,
- 33:14but it needs to be productive anger.
- 33:17Need to be angry at the willingness of people to be violent, but we also need to be careful
- 33:25that we don't engage all the time with content that is meant to incite violence.
- 33:34Another way to tamp down on political violence.
- 33:37This is something that we this is maybe one of the biggest issues to tackle right now.
- 33:44Don't only focus on one side.
- 33:47It's pretty obvious even though people are wanting to just deny this.
- 33:53Political violence is a problem across the board.
- 33:57Republicans are dying for their views.
- 33:59Democrats are dying for their views.
- 34:01Independents are dying for their views.
- 34:04Nobody should be dying for stating their opinion.
- 34:09So we need to stop making excuses for bad behavior of the side we are inclined to agree
- 34:14with.
- 34:14And not not just even excuses, sometimes just complete disregard.
- 34:18There are a lot of people on the left that are saying, boy, the right is so violent.
- 34:22And then there are a lot of people on the right that are saying, the left is so violent,
- 34:26completely ignoring whatever their side does it.
- 34:31I mean, just two months ago, three months ago, liberal Democrat Melissa Hartman was
- 34:41assassinated.
- 34:43And now just last week, conservative liberal or excuse me, conservative Republican Charlie Kirk
- 34:51assassinated.
- 34:53Two very different political or sets of political opinions.
- 34:59How can we say that it's just one side being violent?
- 35:04Because it's not.
- 35:07It is very clearly a problem across the political spectrum, and just having these
- 35:12politicians, social media grifters, regular people say otherwise is unconscionable.
- 35:20Now see, I'm I'm I'm getting a little frustrated here too.
- 35:23I need to bring it back a little.
- 35:26I need to make sure that I'm not going off here.
- 35:30But we need to stop making excuses for bad behavior of the side we are inclined to agree
- 35:34agree with or even worse, flat out ignore that bad behavior.
- 35:40We cannot just be mad when one side is doing something wrong.
- 35:45In this case, inciting violence or accepting violence.
- 35:49We have to call out justifications of violence unequivocally.
- 35:54Yeah.
- 35:54But Charlie Kirk said no.
- 35:56Yeah.
- 35:57But Melissa Horman said no.
- 35:58It does not matter.
- 36:00Even if they are jerks, we're jerks.
- 36:03Even if we find their views anathema, this isn't we cannot under under any circumstances
- 36:12say that these murders were okay or that they had it coming or, oh, you know, this this was a
- 36:20very sad thing, but they said no.
- 36:24Full stop.
- 36:26This is not how.
- 36:28Things should be.
- 36:30It's murder.
- 36:33There's no saying, oh, they called it upon themselves.
- 36:35No.
- 36:36That's not how we should be treating this.
- 36:41We have to call out acts of violence unequivocally and make sure that we're calling
- 36:48it when it's left and right and middle, whatever.
- 36:54And when it's being justified, we have to call it out each time and not just overly focused on
- 37:01one side doing it.
- 37:02Even if we're gonna say, well, yeah, my side is doing it too, but this side is way worse.
- 37:07The left is way worse about it.
- 37:08The right is way worse about it.
- 37:10That is still contributing to the problem because now still people think they're not
- 37:16being heard.
- 37:16They're like, we're doing it.
- 37:18No.
- 37:18No.
- 37:19No.
- 37:19You are the one who was way worse about it, and then we're still not getting anywhere.
- 37:23We're not actually fixing anything because we're concerned about making the other side
- 37:28look worse.
- 37:33Another way that we can tamp down political violence and its justification, we need to
- 37:41clearly support pluralism and democracy, not the suppression of voices or authoritarianism.
- 37:50Pluralism and democracy are directly antithetical to the forces that incentivize
- 37:57anger.
- 37:58And there's been a lot of talk lately about authoritarianism.
- 38:02Is Donald Trump authoritarian?
- 38:03Is he not?
- 38:05That's that's outside of the purview of this discussion, and that's not gonna help anything
- 38:09anyways.
- 38:10That's something that other people can talk about.
- 38:16But if we are going to stand against authoritarianism, we cannot employ the same
- 38:21tools that authoritarians use, like making people choose a side.
- 38:27That is exactly what authoritarians do now.
- 38:30There are.
- 38:31Yes, there are some cases where you do have to take.
- 38:34A stand on something.
- 38:35Not saying that that's not the case, but to constantly tell people that if you don't side
- 38:41with us, you are part of the problem.
- 38:43That is not helping anything.
- 38:45That is just going to make people more accepting of violence.
- 38:47Like, no, no, no.
- 38:49My side is correct.
- 38:50Yours is wrong.
- 38:50You know what?
- 38:51We have to take you out.
- 38:54No.
- 38:54That is not what we can do.
- 38:57That is not what we should be doing.
- 39:02Demonizing people who think differently than us.
- 39:04That's a thing authoritarians do.
- 39:08Taking this cult of personality or just agreeing with anything that we or the people
- 39:16that we tend to support and then not taking them to account for anything.
- 39:25That's something that authoritarians do too.
- 39:27They tell you that this particular person can't do anything wrong and that they shouldn't be
- 39:33called out or that their apparatus that they use cannot be wrong.
- 39:39No.
- 39:40Yep.
- 39:40They absolutely can be wrong.
- 39:43Anybody can be.
- 39:44Every single person can be because they're human beings.
- 39:48We need to stop treating people as infallible.
- 39:51Doesn't matter if their name is Donald Trump or Kamala Harris or Greg Abbott, Ron DeSantis, J.
- 39:58B.
- 39:58Pritzker, Gavin Newsom.
- 40:00It doesn't matter.
- 40:03Nobody should be treated as if they can't do anything wrong.
- 40:06There's not a single person that we should be looking at to act as if to to constantly brown
- 40:13nose, to constantly be sycophants to.
- 40:20That is going to make things worse.
- 40:22That is going to make people more accepting of violence.
- 40:26Because if they just accept everything that their chosen person does, even if that person
- 40:33calls out violence, they're gonna say, the the supporters are just gonna say, yeah.
- 40:38Well, you know what?
- 40:39They're always right about everything, though.
- 40:43No.
- 40:45We cannot treat people as infallible.
- 40:48We have to clearly support pluralism and democracy and letting people say their peace.
- 40:57We don't come up with the best solutions by shutting people out.
- 41:01That's that never leads to the best policy.
- 41:05It just doesn't because people people who dissent, even if their side is, quote, unquote,
- 41:15wrong, they might still bring up reasonable opposition to a policy you have, and you can
- 41:23say, oh, you know what?
- 41:24I never thought about that.
- 41:27You don't get that with the suppression of voices and authoritarianism.
- 41:30You do get that with pluralism and democracy.
- 41:35And then lastly, one reason or one way the last way to tamp down political violence.
- 41:42And, of course, these are by no means all the ways that you can do it.
- 41:46These are just some ways that simple ways that any of us can go about individually tamping
- 41:54down political violence.
- 41:57Recognize that calls to violence are not the norm.
- 42:01I know it's very easy to assume that it is and to just see all these people that are outraged
- 42:12and everything and to think that they're more numerous than they actually are.
- 42:17Again, it goes back to that's some people think the other side is way more violent and calling
- 42:23for violence than they actually are, and that happens both ways, both left against right and
- 42:28right against left.
- 42:30People calling for violence is not the norm.
- 42:33They are just having an outsized influence and an outsized voice because of things like social
- 42:38media algorithms and the human proclivity for anger.
- 42:44There's a major exaggeration of how many people want violence in politics, and then that
- 42:49misperception leads to others accepting retaliatory violence.
- 42:55So then it becomes a self fulfilling prophecy.
- 42:57We say, oh, well, you know what?
- 42:58They're gonna be violent to us, so we have to be violent to them.
- 43:00We have to protect ourselves.
- 43:04But that just makes political violence a bigger issue.
- 43:11So all that to say, progress starts with all of us.
- 43:17We cannot completely erase violence and polarization, but we can mitigate a lot of it.
- 43:27And there are improper ways to move forward that will make things worse, even if we think
- 43:33we are making things better.
- 43:35So it goes back to that whole self awareness aspect.
- 43:39We have to make sure that we are really moving in the right direction.
- 43:44We have to be self critical, not just critical of other people.
- 43:47We have to be critical of ourselves.
- 43:51And one of those things to think about, attacking critics of the victims who aren't
- 43:59happy about the murder of these victims, but they still disagree with the victims' policies.
- 44:07We need to be careful about how we address that.
- 44:10We cannot use the fact that they disagreed with these victims' politics as an excuse to silence
- 44:16these dissenters.
- 44:19Now at the same time, using those victims' politics as a justification for murder needs to
- 44:24be contempt.
- 44:25So people going to say, well, you know, Charlie Kirk said such and such.
- 44:30Well, you know, Melissa Hortman said such and such.
- 44:32No.
- 44:33That is not okay.
- 44:34But at the same time, we should not just be just because somebody disagreed with their
- 44:40politics at some point.
- 44:42We should not be using that to silence their views or kick them out of office or make them
- 44:46lose their jobs.
- 44:50Because that is a complete overreaction and also just an excuse to seize the moment for
- 44:56yourself and for your side by saying, oh, you know, they weren't so critical of the victims.
- 45:01These victims wouldn't have died or some sort of ridiculous justification like that.
- 45:11If the critics of the victims are in some way justifying the murder, that is something that
- 45:19needs to be condemned and needs to be forcefully condemned.
- 45:23But victims or critics of the victims who aren't happy about their murder and are not
- 45:32going, yeah, but and saying, well, they had it coming or something like that.
- 45:37But they were critics of these victims in the past.
- 45:42We cannot be silencing them either.
- 45:44That is just going to make things worse.
- 45:46And then those people being silenced, they may start to suddenly decide, oh, you know what?
- 45:51The only way I can be heard is if we start to make ourselves be heard with physical force.
- 46:02And, again, need to emphasize this cannot emphasize this enough.
- 46:07This is not a one-sided thing.
- 46:09This is clearly not a one-sided thing because people across the board are being killed for
- 46:15their beliefs.
- 46:16So only attacking one size violence is absurdly biased and then just makes others angrily
- 46:21retaliate.
- 46:22No.
- 46:23You are the one who is violent.
- 46:26Stop focusing only on one size reaction to the murders.
- 46:30When we when people on the right treat Charlie Kirk's murder as much more heinous or people on
- 46:38the left treat Melissa Hortman's murder as much more heinous, that is also a problem.
- 46:45Make no mistake.
- 46:47Charlie Kirk and Melissa Hortman's murders are both horrific, and one is not more important
- 46:52than the other.
- 46:55And we shouldn't be treating anybody's murder for their views as more important when we agree
- 47:01with their views.
- 47:03That is a horrible way to go about things.
- 47:05That is a very inhumane way to go about things.
- 47:13So be willing to call out your side as well.
- 47:15Be willing to forcefully condemn when left and right and middle do it.
- 47:22Now what about if we think other people are calling for violence?
- 47:27You have to be really careful with that.
- 47:29We cannot treat words as violence unless they are deliberately calling for attacking other
- 47:35people because there is this notion, and again, it goes back to some of these reasons that
- 47:40people justify violence in their heads of this.
- 47:43These moralized attitudes or treating politics as an existential crisis.
- 47:49Where we see somebody's words and because they think differently than us, we think they're
- 47:56being violent.
- 47:58That is in itself a rather violent way to think.
- 48:05So we need to make sure that other people are clearly calling for violence.
- 48:12And that's actually pretty easy to tell if we're not letting our bias think for us.
- 48:20You're saying, yeah.
- 48:22Good.
- 48:22Charlie Kirk had it coming.
- 48:23Yeah.
- 48:24Good.
- 48:24Melissa Hortman had it coming.
- 48:25Josh Shapiro and Donald Trump.
- 48:28They should have gotten what they were what was coming to them.
- 48:31That is words as violence, and that needs to be condemned.
- 48:39But when you're just saying, I when when you are giving the proper notice of these murders
- 48:51as being as horrific as they are, but you, in the past, were critics of Charlie Kirk or
- 49:00Melissa Hartman's views.
- 49:03That is not violence Because you weren't actually calling for violence.
- 49:09You were saying I did not like their policies or their views.
- 49:14So we cannot treat words as violence unless they are actually calling for violence.
- 49:20Because do do otherwise is very problematic, and that leads to these issues of suppressing
- 49:25other people's voices, which leads to more violence.
- 49:31And already touched on it before, but needs to be stressed again.
- 49:36The apathetic and disenchanted need to get more involved, which is obviously a lot easier said
- 49:44than done.
- 49:45And those feelings are very understandable to some extent, but we need them to get involved.
- 49:51Otherwise, the polarized voices that are calling for violence and or only focusing on
- 49:56one side being violent, they're going to win.
- 50:02And then we're not going to fix our broken political discourse.
- 50:08And also, stop worrying so much about winning.
- 50:12We are so wrapped up in whether we're winning in terms of on my policies.
- 50:20They have to be the ones that win the day.
- 50:24It's that's not all that it's about.
- 50:27And sometimes you're you're not right, or it's still an opinion, but and there's no objective
- 50:35right or wrong, but you don't have everything figured out.
- 50:39None of us do, and we need to stop acting like we do.
- 50:44So this whole thing about, oh, we need to win at all costs.
- 50:49Okay.
- 50:50If you win your policy now, but what happens when the other side wins?
- 50:55And based on how you treated them, they retaliate against you and just completely erase
- 51:00everything you did and suppress your voice when you try to suppress their voice.
- 51:04And then it's just gonna keep going back and forth, back and forth.
- 51:07It's this vicious pendulum that just keeps swinging.
- 51:13Yes.
- 51:14Obviously, when we're fighting for something we believe in, we're going to want to win, but it
- 51:20should not come to the point where we think that our existence is threatened because we
- 51:25lost.
- 51:28We should not be getting to the point where winning is the only thing.
- 51:36This isn't sports, and even then in sports, we get so wrapped up in winning.
- 51:43Sometimes.
- 51:47You're not going to win, and that's that's how it is.
- 51:51You don't always have to win.
- 51:53And even if you do win, what what cost are you winning at?
- 51:57If you're deteriorating politics further or you're inciting violence even though you won,
- 52:04Is that really actually helping anything?
- 52:06No.
- 52:06If anything, any one thing can be taken away from this podcast episode, it's that political
- 52:15violence meant to silence opposing views is under no circumstances an acceptable course of
- 52:21action.
- 52:22Now, unfortunately, political violence as a whole is not entirely avoidable, not with how
- 52:28human nature is.
- 52:30But the problem is we treat it as unavoidable even when we can stop it.
- 52:34This does not have to be the norm.
- 52:36We do not have to just accept that people are going to die just because they profess what
- 52:41they believe.
- 52:41Certainly not in this country.
- 52:44And in a lot of other countries, it's expected.
- 52:47It cannot be the case here.
- 52:49And, obviously, it'd be nice if no country did it, but we cannot be accepting of silencing
- 52:58views through violence, through death because we did not like the views of that other person
- 53:05or we just didn't like that person, period.
- 53:09We just can't have that.
- 53:11That is not what America is about, and that's not what we should be about.
- 53:20But to leave this on a on an even more positive note, I know there's a lot of this was
- 53:26negative.
- 53:27Positives are that we can do something about this.
- 53:31We can make things better, but I want to end on an especially positive note.
- 53:37There are a lot of groups that are pushing back against violence and its acceptance that you
- 53:43can look into.
- 53:45You don't necessarily need to start getting fully involved in these groups, but you can and
- 53:53even if you don't donate to these groups, you can still promote their work and show people,
- 53:58hey, there is a better way to go about politics.
- 54:01There's a webinar I just went to this last Sunday that's called dignity over violence.
- 54:05It was hosted by braver angels.
- 54:07So September 13, it just happened.
- 54:09That brought together a lot of individuals and representatives of groups that are trying to
- 54:14build bridges that are trying to mitigate polarization.
- 54:18I'm gonna leave you with more than a handful, but these aren't by far or by not by any means
- 54:24the only groups that are involved in this.
- 54:27I wanna make sure I make that clear.
- 54:30But just some of the examples of groups that are trying to make politics work better, that
- 54:35are trying to make political discourse better.
- 54:38Braver angels, Listen First Project, Beyond Intractability, Constructive Dialogue
- 54:44Institute, One America Movement, National Civic League, National Institute for Civil Discourse,
- 54:49Living Room Conversations, More Perfect Union, Bridge USA, American Pluralist Alliance
- 54:55Pluralist Alliance, excuse me, Civic Health Project.
- 54:59All of these groups can use your help even if you simply just promote their work.
- 55:04And I'm gonna do everything I can to try to help their work as well and and doing my own
- 55:11thing.
- 55:11And you can help all that too.
- 55:15You can show people, hey.
- 55:17This is not what politics has to be.
- 55:20We can come together and forge a better path forward.
- 55:27So just wanna leave you with that.
- 55:30We we can make things better.
- 55:32This is something that we can't sugarcoat, but at the same time, I hope you're leaving it with
- 55:37a more optimistic view of what American can be.
- 55:44And I know it's it's very difficult.
- 55:46I admittedly, I have trouble with it too.
- 55:51Sometimes I think about all this stuff that I'm doing here, and I think about, is this even
- 55:57worth it?
- 55:57Is anybody even listening?
- 56:01And sometimes you just gotta keep going.
- 56:03And and this is not just saying it for you.
- 56:05Sometimes I have to tell myself this too.
- 56:08So I really wanna make sure that people realize that, and that's all of us can do small, simple
- 56:19things to make things better.
- 56:23So that's gonna do it for today's episode of the podcast.
- 56:26As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 56:28Please like, comment, and subscribe.
- 56:31This podcast is on YouTube, Spotify, and Apple podcasts.
- 56:35Links in the show notes, my Facebook page, Paul Reitter, author and speaker, LinkedIn profile,
- 56:41my five day educational email course that doesn't talk specifically about violence, but
- 56:46it talks about political polarization, which feeds into political violence And some of the
- 56:53mistakes we make that can accidentally inflame polarization and make it worse.
- 56:59Why we make those mistakes and how we can make how we can correct those mistakes.
- 57:04The.
- 57:08Bymymedium.com profile, my book on Amazon, why independents rarely win elections and how how
- 57:16they could become more competitive.
- 57:18That's not arguing for or against independents, just talking about ways that they can improve
- 57:25their fortunes.
- 57:27So you don't have to be a Republican or Democrat or independent to read the book.
- 57:30It's something that everybody can get something out of.
- 57:34And my website, paulraider.org.
- 57:37So gonna wrap it up here with that.
- 57:40And once again, thank you so much for listening.
- 57:43And until next time.
- 57:45Take care.