Latest / Future Engineering Bets / Tariffs Are Now Deciding Where Car Companies Build | Future Engineering Bets
Transcript
- Fred Warner: So tariffs now seem to be the factory planner. On the 24th of October, Audi announced their very first US factory. At a Trump rally. $4 billion investment to build 200,000 SUVs a year creating 4,500 jobs. So you've got the same car makers with four very different markets around the world. You've got the US market very low, the Europe and the UK market is around 30%, and the Chinese market is around about 50%. Very different. Our car output last year in the UK was the lowest since 1952. Let me say that again, the UK had its lowest output of automobiles since 1952. We've already seen massive capital write downs around EVs as automotive companies scaled up to meet EV demand that simply wasn't there. So they've had massive capital write downs. Now they have to make capital decisions on where they put their plants. And if those don't work out because policies change, there'll be massive capital write downs. Hello and welcome to another episode of Future Engineering Bets. I'm Fred Warner of 7Q Ltd. And today we are talking about tariffs and the impact they're going to have on capital allocation. Now remember, Future Engineering Bets is all about capital allocation, planning, assurance, recovery, going forwards in the future. And we want to know in the EV and the automotive space, what's going on. I've got some really interesting talking points around North America, China. EU and the UK and seeing where capital is flowing and where it's changing right now that could affect your businesses if they're in the automotive space, So tariffs now seem to be the factory planner. On the 24th of October, Audi announced their very first US factory. At a Trump rally. $4 billion investment to build 200,000 SUVs a year creating 4,500 jobs. That's the Q7 and the Q8 SUVs. Now those cars are currently built in Slovakia today and Volkswagen, the board, have been accused of abandoning their own rules in order to do so. Now this isn't fully signed off, it has got to pass the board and there are voting seats there with which the labour forces have an influence over, so it's not an absolutely done deal but having announced it you can't imagine they're not going to go through with it. now deciding where car companies put their capital? It would look like it's the US presidential office and the tariff situation forcing capital allocation, which is exactly what they've done it for. But where does that leave Europe? We can talk about Europe in terms of the electric share of new cars. Europe have hit around about 30% of new cars in September were electric. That's nearly three quarters higher than the same time last year. The UK is at 28%, which is up more than a third. Interestingly, the US is around six or 6.4%, which is 40% lower since the tax credits ended China, nearly 50% of car sales calculated this is, it's not a published official figure, but using various data that we have, around about 47 to 50% of cars that are new are EVs in China. That's huge, Absolutely huge. So you've got the same car makers with four very different markets around the world. You've got the US market very low, the Europe and the UK market is around 30%, and the Chinese market is around about 50%. Very different. So why are tariffs now appearing to decide? Well, European cars are paying 15% tariffs to get into North America, as you may well know. In May, Trump was threatening a 25% unless you build in the US. Now that is forcing car companies to consider things. And whether or not these things, such as the Audi plant are gestures that will be signed off and they're going to wait to see 2028 play out, well, that's too late in terms of setting up the capital. So maybe it's a single plant and you bide your time and play the rest later. The Supreme Court struck down emergency tariffs but not the car ones so boards are having to plan around tariffs now. For Audi, tariffs cost them around 1.2 billion last year. So if you think of a 4 billion investment in a factory, that's around about a three and a half year return on investment just on tariffs alone were they to continue paying them. I am interested in this point where we've got the presidential election and no one knows what's going to happen around that. Betting that it'll come down probably isn't a safe bet right now. You'd probably assume you're safer to bet that it's going to stay the same or potentially go higher and therefore you've got to plan forwards on that basis. Now in Europe, production is moving around as well as reducing. Now Mercedes is growing production in Hungary, where costs are quoted as being around about 70% lower than in Germany. Volvo is cutting two and a half thousand jobs. At Stellantis, Europe is the only region where they're actually losing money. And a shocking stat for you, in the US, Volkswagen's electric car sales have fallen overall by 86%. Now, it's not just that the tariffs are affecting it, but the rules are changing. So America won't renew its trade deals with Mexico and Canada as it stands. We've all seen in the news that Canada is going on a lot. So in terms of building around North America, it makes it also harder to plan unless you're fully vested in America. even Mexico isn't a safe bet anymore. Now China is making a lot of cars and it needs somewhere to sell them. China's home market actually fell 28% in September whilst its EV exports rose 164%. So their export market is absolutely booming, most of it coming to the UK and Europe and other places in the world, but its own market's falling. Interesting. So if you want to make money in America, the Chinese need to think about what they need to build there, they need to hire there To bring cars into Europe, there's tariffs, plus they're going to put a cap now on the hybrids because that's really exploded. And Chery is moving into old Nissan factories in Sunderland, according to all the deals that are looking to go through. And everyone is landing on the same place, which is build here or pay (in USA). And this is the new geopolitical landscape that all the manufacturers are facing. And the UK is kind of caught in the middle. Our car output last year in the UK was the lowest since 1952. Let me say that again, the UK had its lowest output of automobiles since 1952. A staggering statistic and really a rather sad situation for UK car manufacturing in general. Sunderland, which is a Nissan plant, is running at under half capacity, which is why they're doing a deal giving their capacity over to the Chinese. Now the UK needs Europe and is currently outside of Europe. Now there's an offer on the table to join the Made in Europe badge but in order to do that the UK has to match tariffs for any other region and that will include China. Currently the UK isn't putting any additional tariffs onto Chinese imports. So the UK has to decide whether or not to go with the Made in Europe badge or determine its own tariffs. It can't have it both ways. If you're a betting person, you'd have to bet on UK joining the EU tariff scheme and the Made in Europe scheme because we need to export our products into Europe and we need our products to have the Made in Europe badge on them. course where that's happen China won't be very happy and the UK as always is worried about that. So let's think, what are the key questions when you're thinking about building a plant, you're doing your programme of the R &D design, you're thinking about where to put your money. So you need to be thinking about will the policies, global policies we're now reacting to last. We've already seen massive capital write downs around EVs as automotive companies scaled up to meet EV demand that simply wasn't there. So they've had massive capital write downs. Now they have to make capital decisions on where they put their plants. And if those don't work out because policies change, there'll be massive capital write downs. Next question. Which power trains are they going to build? Is it going to be all EV? Is it going to be a mix of hybrid and ICE and EV? Is it hybrid and EV only? There it seems that the world is opening up a bit, the US is now slowing down, it's marched towards EV, China's marching on and Europe's saying well if we go fully EV we might not have an automotive market in the future, maybe we do need to consider alternative options such as hybrids and sustainable fuels. Now collaboration seems to be the thing going forwards. The UK, the European and global automotive manufacturers are now in a state of saying we need to share. We need to share platforms which we're all very familiar with, but do we need to share the capital that goes into the plant and the building of the cars as well so that we can de-risk and try and protect ourselves from the wave of Chinese imports that are flooding the markets at the moment. In terms of timing, with two years from a presidential election, none of us know what's going to happen. It makes it very difficult, but if you were betting, you do need to bet that the tariffs will stay and if anything it'll get harder to get into North America assuming things don't change. So in terms of cost planning, really what people are looking at does moving plants into different locations beat the tariffs or not? And that's really the calculations of where do you take the pain of paying? So let's face it, there's real challenges between the US markets, which is really impacting the European OEMs significantly. You've got the Chinese flooding the European markets as well with their own cars, and the UK deciding whether not to join the Made in Europe banner. Now, you've got the midterms in November, and you've got an EU-UK summit on the 20th of November, and an EU... vote on the car CO2 coming up in December and of course the ZEV mandate when the UK releases its update on that. We'll know more about whether or not a more technology neutral approach will be taken across Europe to allow people to have greater choice, to allow automotive manufacturers to survive, to protect millions of jobs across Europe that are currently at risk of being downsized and reduced. A lot to think about, a lot to plan around. Lots of challenges coming our way, but do like and share. Please do follow and send this to somebody you know. And I'll see you in the future.