Latest / Daily Comedy News with Johnny Mac / In-Depth Comedy Talk with Jason Zinoman of the New York Times
Transcript
- 0:02Calaroga Shark Media. I've got a great one for you today. My guest
- 0:11is Jason Zenniman, critic at large for the Culture section of the New York
- 0:15Times. Jason writes a column about comedy, and we talked comedy for the
- 0:19better part of an hour on his biopage on the New York Times dot com,
- 0:23Jason Wrights. I cover comedy with critical rigor and curiosity and explore how
- 0:27it reflects and influences the broader cultural and intellectual landscape. I'm particularly interested in
- 0:31work that is innovative or unexpected, but it's enough if it's just really funny.
- 0:35My aim is to always capture the comedy scene in its complexity while translating
- 0:40it clearly for a broad audience. That is a theme that came up several
- 0:43times during this discussion. I just want to give you some notes on the
- 0:47recording here. So we recorded this on a program called squad cast, basically
- 0:52zoom for podcasters, and when you do that, you don't quite get studio
- 0:55quality sound, and sometimes you get little dropouts. The reason I'm bringing this
- 0:58up is I just want to be clear. There were three different points where
- 1:00I used a program called descript which has a feature called regenerate, where I
- 1:07used it to regenerate short phrases said by Jason. Nothing materially changed, The
- 1:11words aren't changed. It just regenerated the wave so that it didn't fade a
- 1:15little bit. Just want to be clear about that. Also, when I
- 1:18use the script, it has a couple of neat buttons that I use every
- 1:21day on this podcast. One is remove retakes, so when I recorded every
- 1:25day, believe me, I stumble and I start over and descript has a
- 1:27one button remove retakes. It's wonderful. There's also a feature that I used
- 1:32on this interview, which is remove filler words, because when you listen to
- 1:36Johnny Max speak the way Johnny Mack does over the course of an hour,
- 1:38there are a lot more ums and you knows than you might get during a
- 1:42typical ten minute script that I've edited down. And there's also a one button
- 1:46click called shortened word Gaps, which just tightens the pacing. So I've used
- 1:49all those features on this interview. Nothing materially changed. But I just want
- 1:53to be clear that I did in a traditional podcasting way, nothing nefarious.
- 1:57I did edit the audio all right, And here's my interview with Jason.
- 2:00I've been a fan of your work. I don't even know how to explain
- 2:04it. It's not stupid. There's a lot of stupid in comedy, and
- 2:08I don't feel like you do takes. I feel like you write really thoughtful,
- 2:13smart pieces. And I've been quoting you in episodes for months and then
- 2:17the other day I freaked out. I go, wait, what if his
- 2:20name is pronounced Zinoman? And I've said it wrong forty five times? And
- 2:23then I actually checked. I was like, anyway, So I'm curious about
- 2:27your approach as someone who just does off the top of his head ten minute
- 2:31podcasts and maybe a half assed written substack. I know how long it takes
- 2:37me to do that, so to appreciate what you're doing for The New York
- 2:40Times. Also, you've got to be putting out a ton of work.
- 2:44First of all, let me say, if you call me Zinoman, I'm
- 2:46not going to complain the it's like cinnamon, but I'll take any reference.
- 2:52I'll take any pr is good pr and the Zionoman sounds also always more like
- 2:57the superhero version of my name. But yeah, it's a lot of work.
- 3:00It's a lot of work. Although that makes it sound. Sometimes it
- 3:06comes very easily, as I'm sure, and sometimes more work doesn't always mean
- 3:10better work. Is one thing I've learned, and that's one thing that's evolved
- 3:15over the course of this. For instance, I would say when I started
- 3:19this job, I spent a huge I spend a huge amount of time most
- 3:24of my time going out to see shows clubs, and I still do that,
- 3:30but I don't do it as much as I used to, and that
- 3:34has to do both with how comedies change, but also I think that I
- 3:38try to spend a little bit of time every week thinking about letting my mind
- 3:45roam and thinking of ideas, and then if I have a good idea,
- 3:47I try to find the right form for it that because so sometimes sometimes that's
- 3:53a review, sometimes it's an essay. Sometimes it's a bigger piece and it's
- 3:57a profile. And it's funny like the things that I write in a in
- 4:02an hour or a half hour are the most popular, and the things that
- 4:05I sweat over, like I'm working on something now for months and no one
- 4:11cares. I feel like I totally know that one yes, yes, and
- 4:15they're sometimes they're wrong, but they're not always wrong. Sometimes you cannot trust
- 4:20you you. Let's put this way. As I'm first a critic and I'm
- 4:26a big believer in something, I'm a big believer that your first impression isn't
- 4:31always right, but it's always important. So you have to be really sensitive
- 4:35to your first impression of something. And it's why people like Pauline Kal,
- 4:40who's probably the critic who most inspired me as a kid. She would write
- 4:45she would go see a movie and go home write the review right away,
- 4:47and because she really valued that first impression, I'm happy to hear that you're
- 4:51not clubbing as much as he used to. One of my guilt trips.
- 4:56I run Serious XM Comedy for ten years ten years ago now, but even
- 5:00then it was hard to go see shows because I was still expected to be
- 5:02in the office and be a manager from eight am until six call it.
- 5:06So to stay out till one point thirty in the morning doing shows was difficult.
- 5:12I tended to rely on the people who were younger on my staff,
- 5:15and then to keep my knowledge fresh, I'd hit festivals and as I always
- 5:18tell this audience, if you go to a festival, don't go see Chris
- 5:21Rock. You can go see Chris Rocks some other time, go hit all
- 5:24those smaller shows. That's where the action is. I'm upset that Montreal is
- 5:29gone, or perhaps back or this new group that bought it, But no
- 5:31Montreal. This summer is a bummer. It's interesting to hear what you do,
- 5:35because I think that's a very smart strategy. It's I have taken the
- 5:40opposite approach, which isn't necessarily better, which is that, if anything,
- 5:44I undercover festivals because I feel like a lot of the people you see at
- 5:48festivals I already see New York. But what that means is like comedians from
- 5:56other cities when they come through here, I make a point of trying to
- 6:00see them, or I try to go to La periodically to see that.
- 6:04But I miss things for sure, And there's no question that you could.
- 6:09It's funny. The truth is that there's like a pool of performers in New
- 6:12York, and if you go often enough, you see them all and it's
- 6:17changing, but it doesn't change radically. It doesn't change like the number of
- 6:21people changed. I still like to go, and I think I pick up
- 6:26things. I learned things from going. But now the thing is you could
- 6:30probably the most time efficient way is probably just to look at your computer and
- 6:33fillow. Because everyone's online and there's so much material online, and a lot
- 6:40of consumers of comedy are first accessing comedy not from clubs but from a clip
- 6:49on a TikTok or Instagram. So that has to change. I feel like
- 6:57if the way that we have to have along with the consumers. Yeah,
- 7:02and for any content creator, no matter of the format. We're all living
- 7:06in a headline world, right, So the easiest thing to write is why
- 7:11Joe Rogan, Shane Gillis and Nikki Glazer are something that'll get the clicks as
- 7:15opposed to Hey guys, Jen Marco Cireesis awesome, Just it doesn't do the
- 7:19same. Uh. But CIESSI will contact you and be like, how come
- 7:24you're not con righting about me? He's fantastic Switching gears I wanted. One
- 7:30of the main things I wanted to talk to you about Dave Chappelle. It
- 7:34bothers me that he has seemingly chosen to turn his legacy into The second line
- 7:43in his oh bit is going to be something about the trans community. And
- 7:46he's so much better than what he's done on the last few specials, which
- 7:49is Jason you know why I had you on today because of the trans And
- 7:53he slaps his knee and he mugs for the camera and he gets a laugh,
- 7:55and he's so much better than that. And I don't know why he's
- 8:00dug in on that. To be curious to your thoughts, it's a good
- 8:01it's a good question. Look, I loved Dave Chappelle. I've wrote an
- 8:07ebook on Dave Chappelle eight years ago, searching for Dave Chappelle. I grew
- 8:11up in Washington, d C. Where he's from. I have I'm around.
- 8:16He's a few years older than me, but I've been following his career
- 8:20since the since the eighties. I have a tremendous he's incredible comedian. His
- 8:24sketch show, I think people have now forgotten about it, but it's one
- 8:28of the greatest comedies ever on television, and he's one of the greatest.
- 8:33He's one of the greatest stand ups. I think it's his first specialist terrific
- 8:39and he still has a lot. I say all this as a way to
- 8:41be like it's one of the I'm agreeing with you. And one of the
- 8:46reasons it's depressing is that when we talk about Dave Chappelle, we tend to
- 8:48talk about these culture war things and because that's what he's put out put forth,
- 8:54and so why has he chosen to do that? I think Gerard Carmichael
- 8:58made us ask the more question recently. My sense, if I again I'm
- 9:03just speculating, is that Chappelle always liked two didn't you know? Prized?
- 9:13His freedom prize is independence he and I think I think the good faith,
- 9:20genuine interpretation is that when he did trans jokes and people said got offended or
- 9:28said, don't you his first instinct is to then double down right, And
- 9:33that's always been his first instinct. It's been his first instinct through his whole
- 9:35career. We can go chapter in verse. Even before he was famous.
- 9:39I've written back before his Chapelle show, he had a big falling out on
- 9:43his comedy on a ABC show called Buddies. I've traced this in ambols has
- 9:48served him in this case. Look, it may have served him well for
- 9:52his audience. He's still selling out, he's still popular, but for his
- 9:56art, I agree with you. I think it's kept him in a rut.
- 10:00And I'm still optimistic when I see a new Dave Chappelle thing. I
- 10:03hope he moves past it. But yeah, what's interesting to me the last
- 10:09one came out is that I don't even think it caused that much controversy.
- 10:11I think people are just bored. Yeah, I imagine in your travels you've
- 10:16run into him. He'll do sets and I'm being generous with that. He'll
- 10:22he'll take stage time and he's not even really working out. He's just talking
- 10:26to the audience when he does that downbeat, soft spoken Dave, and he'll
- 10:31just come out with some brilliant things just to listen to that. Maybe it
- 10:35an't even funny and he's got that there, and I just I'd like to
- 10:39just see him do something else. But to your point, Dave Sapelle announced
- 10:41his new Netflix special already. The conversation is going to be, is he
- 10:46going to bring this up again? And it's I think he nailed it.
- 10:48It's boring, It's it's predictable. I mean, like, if you were
- 10:50to say, like, what's the least interesting thing for him to do next,
- 10:54it would be to talk about that again. That's the part of it
- 10:58which flabbergasting. I think that the thing the other issue might be is that
- 11:07he always had these two modes, which was doing like a stand up set
- 11:11with this with more traditional collection of jokes in his very idiosyncratic style, and
- 11:18what you described this like, he would go into go into clevit. He
- 11:20would be on stage for four hours. And there was something incredible about those
- 11:26sets. He could go places that others could not. And I believe he
- 11:33got she fell in love with that, and there's something indulgent about those and
- 11:37I think that's true for not just in terms of the amount of time he's
- 11:43spending there, but also they became very self serious. This bothers me less
- 11:48than other people. But I think another reason people got bored with him is
- 11:52that he seemed his material seemed less punchline driven. It seemed less about being
- 11:58funny and more about being profound. And if he's saying things that are profound
- 12:03and poetic, that's fine, and maybe it's better than fine, it's great.
- 12:07But if he's saying the same thing over and over again, that's a
- 12:09problem. All right, new premise off all the recent protests that Jerry Seinfeld
- 12:15ran into, I find myself wondering what if Jerry went political? Now I
- 12:20know that's crazy. He's seventy years old, and it's very easy to just
- 12:24write it out and go, hey, do you ever notice but what if
- 12:28Jerry showed off and went all in? Could you ever imagine that in a
- 12:31million years? No? But I mean I would be interested. I think
- 12:37there's another question which is similar, which is what if he went vulnerable or
- 12:43introspective personal? And I think there's room for that. I think that he
- 12:48I don't think I think people would be interested in either in going political.
- 12:52I don't think he wants to, and I don't think he has to.
- 12:56I don't even think he's got to. Cut from the last interviews from him,
- 13:01he doesn't seem like he wanted it to come out with any special ever
- 13:03again. And he wouldn't need to. He wouldn't need to see any people
- 13:07forget. But he came up at a time when everyone didn't need to release
- 13:13specials, and he didn't. He for most of his career he didn't release
- 13:18specials, and he could and he did just he did obviously did just find
- 13:24Some people think that he has gotten more political, but I'm with you.
- 13:28I don't think he. I don't think he has. I thought I found
- 13:31all the backlash of the popsarts movie bizarre. I liked it. I thought
- 13:35it was this is a silly movie. We're having fun, my friends are
- 13:39in it. Want you to turn your brain off for ninety minutes. And
- 13:41people seemed like mad that that movie even exists. It was weird. I
- 13:46know, you mean, I think some people were mad about the interviews in
- 13:50which he said things like, you know, the PC left and the were
- 13:54ruining sitcoms or whatever. But yeah, there was the initial response from some
- 14:00I think one film critic called it the worst movie of the decade or the
- 14:03year or something, and I was like, that made no sense to me.
- 14:07That made zero How you could that there's something going on outside of the
- 14:11screen to think that a movie with that ambition and also that amount of there's
- 14:16plenty of talent on screen there is the worst movie. And it's not funny.
- 14:22I say ambition, a low ambition. It's not a movie that's swinging
- 14:24for the fences. Yeah, it's not like he made some bro dude version
- 14:28of Oppenheimer and missed the politics of it. It's a pop starts movie.
- 14:31Yes, it's a popp bar. It's it was a it's a bizarre response,
- 14:35but I that's the age we're living in, right that, I think
- 14:39the more hyper hyperbole you you mentioned if you put Joe Rogan in the title
- 14:45against a lot of hits. The other way to get it is to have
- 14:46a more extreme point of view. Right, all right, we'll take the
- 14:50break here back with Jason Zenimann after this the rest of Tom Brady, I
- 14:54feel like it. It cuts through, seems to have done well. Did
- 14:58Nicky Glazer step up in class? Did Tony Hinchcliff step up in class?
- 15:03Or these now names that the civilians would know? Actually, let me sidebar
- 15:05there. This comes up a lot. There are a lot of really popular
- 15:11comedians. But if you and I walk down the street and grabbed one hundred
- 15:15people in New York City and said, hey, Andrew Schultz, what are
- 15:18we going three for one hundred, I think you're right. I think you're
- 15:22right. Yeah. No, you're putting your finger on a big phenomenon of
- 15:28the moment, which is like, what does it mean to be a famous
- 15:33comedian? In twenty twenty four, Andrew Schultz played Mason Square Garden, right,
- 15:37And there was a time when that was like hardly anybody, hardly nobody
- 15:43had played Masters for a Garden, but he's played massots for Garden, and
- 15:46as you said, I think most people don't know who he is. But
- 15:48I think that's not just a question of comedy. That's a question of the
- 15:52culture in general, which is that it's so fragmented, it's so balkanized that
- 15:56you as long as you have very passionate fans in your niche, you can
- 16:03sell a lot and be very successful even without being widely known. I think
- 16:06it's also answers the previous question, which is the wiser everyone so worried about
- 16:10Jerry Seinfeld. All the people who became famous in that generation have a kind
- 16:15of fame that's way bigger than the kind of fame you get now, with
- 16:19the exception of Taylor Swift, if you manage to get famous. Even Drogan,
- 16:25I think, is an example of this where Rogan likes to protact like
- 16:27he's anti establishment, anti mainstream media. But I have this sort of pet
- 16:33theory that the difference between his fame and Tim Dillon Andrew Schultz, who will
- 16:37never be as famous as Joe Rogan, is that Joe Rogan was on Fear
- 16:41Factor, and Joe Rogan was on news radio and he hosted a after Bob
- 16:47Costas left. Later he or he had an NBC talk show for a second.
- 16:52Though, that's a bigger fame than these podcast fames that you get now.
- 16:56It's a kind of fame that reach which is a much broader demographic than
- 17:03you reach out. I must have a race from my brain. There was
- 17:06a Joe Rogan late night show. I did a piece a year ago.
- 17:11It's now it seems already maybe longer than that seems very dated. When Daily
- 17:15Show was doing rotating guest hosts, and I was making an argument for how
- 17:21this might not be a terrible idea to do permanently. This is before they
- 17:22announce John Stewart, which is a better idea, but are once a week.
- 17:26But although I guess they still do, I guess they are to entertaining
- 17:29guest hosts around with John Stewart. And I was looking around for precedent,
- 17:33and I realized that in the late nineties NBC did this after maybe an some
- 17:41of the details wrong, but it's in my story. After you know a
- 17:45letterman, and they had a crazy series of people who I like hosted for
- 17:51a week than a week, and among those people were Joe Rogan and he
- 17:55had he interviewed and eight people he interviewed. It was a similar version to
- 18:00his podcast, but it was on NBC and I was really shock it.
- 18:06I couldn't find any versions of it online, but I nailed it down that
- 18:10had happened. I found it on an old like TV guy those things.
- 18:12Oh wow, You're gonna send me down a rabbit hole, and I didn't
- 18:15forget. I will circle back to my Nikki Glazer question, but now I'm
- 18:18like three questions deep. I just had Mark malcoff on and he retriggered my
- 18:22late night obsession. And I spent the week watching YouTube videos. And somebody
- 18:26made this homebrew thing about the Carson Letterman, Tom Snyder trifecta, and I
- 18:32just I'm back into that whole move. And I know you wrote a Letterman
- 18:36book. Can you explain to me why I worship twelve thirty Letterman lasted a
- 18:44year and a half at eleven thirty Letterman after spending a decade going man.
- 18:48If only I didn't have to stay up till one thirty in the morning,
- 18:51if only Dave were on at eleven thirty, I would watch Dave every night,
- 18:53And then a year and a half into it, I don't know if
- 18:56it was just I was in my mid twenties and going out and doing things
- 18:59people do and not watching late night TV. But twelve thirty Letterman is my
- 19:04north star. Eleven thirty Letterman, okay, And then he'll put out something
- 19:08on Netflix and it takes me three weeks to watch it. What is wrong
- 19:11with me? It's so funny that you asked me this question today, because
- 19:15you and I are identical on this point. And just today somebody sent me
- 19:21a podcast in which it was the guy who'd wrote that was the Letterman podcast,
- 19:26Mike Chris Som, and he said, oh, I mentioned you on
- 19:30a podcast, and he was on a podcast with somebody else, sorry to
- 19:32be on a podcast talking about another podcast, but my name came up and
- 19:36it was asking I guess the podcast? Hast said, how do you press
- 19:40him when he was on your podcast about why he focuses so much on his
- 19:44late night twelve thirty show and not on his CBS show, And there was
- 19:47a kind of there was a they were upset, both of them because they
- 19:51both really there. They both liked the CBS show. And it made me
- 19:53wonder for a second, because I putting aside me for a second, I
- 19:56think to people who are younger, who maybe didn't grow up with that show,
- 20:02the CBS show means more. But I've watched both as an adult,
- 20:07so my opinions on them are not just like nostalgic. And despite what they
- 20:12said in this podcast, the reason I didn't is because I agree with you
- 20:15that from nineteen eighty two to ninety three David Letterman on NBC made some of
- 20:23the most brilliant talk show comedy and most innovative talk show comedy ever that really
- 20:33created a sensibility, invented all kinds of forms mainstream to sort of irony.
- 20:40That is really significant, that deserves that will be here to your point about
- 20:44legacy, that will be the lion's share of his legacy. Now, his
- 20:48first couple of years in the CBS Show are probably arguably the more popular and
- 20:52were more covered more because of the late night wars, and some of them
- 20:57were quite good, and they were periods in the CBS show that were better
- 21:02or worse. But in my opinion, the NBC show was vastly more ambitious
- 21:07and better than the CBS show. Now that again, there are big exceptions
- 21:11to certainly his response to nine to eleven and many other ones. He still
- 21:17was David Letterman. He still was doing great work. But and my book
- 21:21is essentially a book length answer to the question of why right. If you
- 21:25want to know why, that is by my book, Letterman Last China Malee.
- 21:29And part of it has to do with him, Part of it has
- 21:30to do with the network, but a lot of it has to do with
- 21:33what's around him and the writers around him, and the relationship between the writers
- 21:37and Letterman and all that. I would say that you were just smart and
- 21:41discriminating, and that's that's why I think what attracted me to it was the
- 21:48whole twelve thirty vibe. And once Conan found his fastball, he's had the
- 21:52same vibe of maybe this bit isn't working, but I know it, you
- 21:56know what, we all know what. Let's just stick to it and left
- 21:57together with it. And then you go to eleven, which is a different
- 22:00animal, and you have to wear an o'mani suit, you have to wear
- 22:03shoes, and it just was more. I've always called it establishment Letterman as
- 22:07opposed to the twelve thirty, Like we're off our game tonight, we got
- 22:10forty seven minutes left whatever, yep, yep, yep. No. I
- 22:14think it was clearly a bigger, more show, busy show in a big
- 22:18theater where the previous show was intimate, and it felt like conspiratorial between the
- 22:23viewer and Dave, and it was going backstage and doing all these fourth wall
- 22:27breaking things. It was very different there was It was a very I would
- 22:32make the argument that it was the things that really made him unique. The
- 22:38new version of CBS was going directly against. That doesn't mean that he was
- 22:42totally different. He still had some lot of reverence. And I think what's
- 22:47interesting that you bring up what he's doing now. It's remarkable if you would
- 22:51have told me, the young version of me who loved his late night show,
- 22:55that Letterman would be now doing a show in which he interviews famous people
- 23:00and is incredibly complimentary and gushing about all of them and solicitous. What made
- 23:07him really stand out as an interviewer in the eighties, and you can just
- 23:11go and look at the press on this is he adopted a kind of almost
- 23:15hostile, if not skeptical, attitude towards the celebrities who came out and promoted,
- 23:21and that was part of his appeal. So it's interesting he's I don't
- 23:25blame him, you know, but it's quite a one eighty. The next
- 23:29rabbit hole I want to go down is trying to track down clips of his
- 23:32daytime show. Until I watched that Homebrew doc this week, I had no
- 23:36idea that Patricks or viewer mail were leftovers from the daytime show. I've barely
- 23:40seen clips of that. It's incredible, it's incredibly out there. There are
- 23:45yeah, yeah, yeah, if you go on YouTube, there's They're not
- 23:48all of them, but a huge number of them. And he and Meryl
- 23:51Marco a lot of the great stuff from the Late night if not most of
- 23:56it, were established in the Morning Show. And they had Andy Kaufman as
- 24:00a maybe his most one of the most brilliant appearances ever was on the Morning
- 24:04Show. There's incredible Steve Martin appearance they did. I'm pretty sure they definitely
- 24:10did stupid Patrick's first in the Morning Show. I think they might have done
- 24:12viewer mail, a lot of the man on the Street stuff. Hal Gurney,
- 24:15the director started with him on the Morning Show, started there. It
- 24:21was the wrong time slot, but they were trying things there that it was
- 24:26the blueprint was established there and just when they figured it out, they got
- 24:30canceled, and I think that that's what was the secret sauce to the show
- 24:33is that by the time that they started on late night, they had a
- 24:37much better sense of what they wanted to do than they would have if they
- 24:41did have the morning show. When I recently watched Mullaney, I went for
- 24:44a whole ride here. So, just to catch you up on my resume,
- 24:45a big chunk of it, I worked in talk radio w or New
- 24:48York and did a lot of phone screening, which is relevant to what I'm
- 24:52setting up here. As I was watching Mulaney, my initial reaction was,
- 24:56oh, my goodness, twelve thirty Dave is back. This is so loose
- 25:00and goofy, and I loved it. And then I started screaming and this
- 25:03is arrogant. Somebody needs to produce this thing. And my sticking point was
- 25:07when they went to callers, because as a call screener, I can tell
- 25:11you civilians cannot take tell a story. And I'm screaming at my TV saying
- 25:17Jerry Seinfeld is sitting there. I could have hosted that when hey, Jerry
- 25:21has that movie going and then shut up for ten minutes. I would did
- 25:25you enjoy me? Lee? I really think something's there. I'd like to
- 25:27see more of it just and maybe this is counter to my whole twelve thirty
- 25:32Letterman argument a little more focused. Oh, I'm with you. I really
- 25:36enjoyed it because I like novelty, and I like experimentation, and I like
- 25:41things that are different. So I was tiggled by it. And just like
- 25:44you it Fello. There are bits of cable access, there are bits of
- 25:47we just with super famous people. There are bits of Lettermen there. But
- 25:51it was interesting the incongruity between the critics reaction, which was pretty glowing,
- 25:57and normal people's action, which almost most people who I talked to loathed it
- 26:03or found it unwatchable, including I should say, I'm not going to name
- 26:07it, but it was on my Facebook page. People who worked for the
- 26:10first Letterman show the wow that And I think the reason for that is one
- 26:15is what you're saying is that like he indulged a lot. There was a
- 26:18lot of dead air. There was like having the call in go on while
- 26:22you have these other people on the show. It was the thing that made
- 26:23it exciting, which is like anything could happen here is also what made it
- 26:29can make it tedious, and if it was on for a month or a
- 26:34year, I think that would have been more clear that that would become People
- 26:38are now saying, oh, we should do it full time. And I
- 26:41saw he did an interview where he was like, I'm intrigued. But I
- 26:44think that this was great for a week during a Netflix festival where they could
- 26:48get every star in the world on it and it was a lark if they
- 26:52if it was a permanent thing, I think its flaws that you've enumerated would
- 26:59be more clear. Yeah, I wear many hats, and in my career
- 27:03as a podcasting executive and bec as a programmer, it's serious. I would
- 27:07explain to people talk to me about show twenty three, because even I can
- 27:11call in some celebrity favors and I can book a great week of shows just
- 27:15for myself. What happens when it's week forty seven? And to your point,
- 27:19Jerry Seinfeld's not in town. Who are you talking to? Who's the
- 27:22guest? Now it's back on the host. They'll sample for the guests,
- 27:25they will come back for the host. Is the way I teach that what
- 27:27let me ask you what how the call in aspect what works in that?
- 27:33What do you have to do to make that? Because obviously that was a
- 27:36huge part of popular culture for a long time, that you now that was
- 27:40one of the things about that Lenny Show that I was like, oh,
- 27:42I it's interesting that he's doing this. It's not quite working. But not
- 27:48only was that on talk radio, but Larry King used to do it.
- 27:49It's so, what's the secret of that? And how come there's not more
- 27:52of it? Callers are diminishing returns, so the call screener needs to So
- 27:57if I'm interviewing, Hey, Jason, what do you want to talk to
- 28:00John about? And I have to get it out of you, and then
- 28:03I have to really try and coach you and go Okay, when you get
- 28:06on, don't bother saying Hi, don't say thanks for taking my call.
- 28:07He knows we really appreciate it. I want you to open up, and
- 28:10I just want your first sentence to be hey, da da da da da
- 28:12da da da. Now, I'm still on a tight rope because you might
- 28:15get on the air and be like, hey, thanks for taking my call,
- 28:18and it just drags everything to a halt. Unless you have a really
- 28:22good caller, you just want to take their initial point and fade them out,
- 28:26and you don't need them other than to facilitate a discussion. Point that
- 28:32said, back in the day, there were regulars who knew how to do
- 28:36it, but most civilians can't tell a story interesting. Interesting, Okay,
- 28:40no, that makes sense. Saturday Night Live, turning fifty will Lorne Michael
- 28:44stick around. I'm looking at this and going take the victory lap. You're
- 28:48eighty eighty one years old. It's not going to get any better. I
- 28:52don't see anyone going. Season fifty two was great, Lauren. I think
- 28:56you got to get out here. People who know him, like Seth,
- 28:59seem to think he's gonna stick around. What do you think? The short
- 29:03answer is, I don't know. But as you say, the people who
- 29:07are closer to it than me think he's sticking around, and the people who
- 29:10know him better than I do think he's sticking around until he can't do it
- 29:15anymore. And it's such a hard thing to replace him. I think,
- 29:18much harder than people realize that. I don't think, And God knows,
- 29:22no one's going to push him out, so I can. I guess we'll
- 29:26still be, but who knows, we'll see Look We're all gonna have to
- 29:30be thinking and writing and talking about SNL next year for a year a lot
- 29:37more. Let's not do it now because we're all gonna have to do it
- 29:41next year a lot. Will Ferrell Tina Fey in the top thirteen SNL get
- 29:47ready for all there's people who got it are gonna have to watch every episode
- 29:51of all fifty years. We're gonna have to write lists. There's gonna be
- 29:55there's a book, The Lorne Bio is finally gonna come out next year.
- 29:57Wow, by bye, Susan Morrison from New Yorker. That's probably like the
- 30:03most anticipated comedy book of next year. And I imagine that will be a
- 30:07big doorstop with all sorts of comedy dirt in it. Even if it wasn't
- 30:15the fair V anniversary, that would be week a big source of conversation.
- 30:21Did you say this thing? I'm sure you did with Kimmel and Letterman developing
- 30:25a talk show for Lunel. I just saw that before I jumped on with
- 30:27you. That's like a real life Hacks episode. I looked it up.
- 30:30She's sixty five, and when I watched Hacks my initial reaction and they addressed
- 30:34it was like, they're not going to give Deborah Vance a show at her
- 30:37age, and here we are living a Hacks episode. Yes, I did
- 30:41see that. Well, I'll believe when I see it, and I and
- 30:45but I think, why not. I feel like she's one of these people
- 30:48who've been around for a long time. I think I saw her open for
- 30:52Kat Williams at Barclays a little while ago. I just saw her pop up
- 30:57in a movie from like the nineties. Anyways, I think she so,
- 31:03yeah, she's paid her dues. She deserves a show, just like just
- 31:07like Debora Vance says, all right, three hours ago, I asked you
- 31:10if Nicki Glazer has stepped up in class. I think yeah. I think
- 31:14that she was probably the big winner of the Netflix weekend. I think,
- 31:18although it's funny, I think there's one what was interesting about her week is
- 31:23she was the star of the roast on Netflix and then she released a special
- 31:30on HBO Max on Max and which raises the question why didn't Netflix have that
- 31:37special? And I do think that that points to another issue, which looking
- 31:44to the future, which is is are these other streamers going to start to
- 31:49eat into Netflix's territory and the fact that they didn't have Nicki Glazer, which
- 31:55they did have her previous special, and she clearly is still figure on their
- 31:59streamer. Was interesting to me. Did she raise the thoughts? Yeah,
- 32:01I think so. But she's been steadily building for a while. You could
- 32:05her reality show is doing well. She has an incredible First of all,
- 32:09I think I find her very incredibly consistent, amazing work ethic, talented in
- 32:14a lot of different ways. She's somebody who I think could go in a
- 32:17different direction with a special, could be more. She's so on talk shows
- 32:23she's so good and so revealing and so introspective, and on specials she is
- 32:30sometimes, but she's usually just like a killer joke, just an incredible joke
- 32:34teller. I feel like if you could sort of merge those two things,
- 32:37she'd have a real blockbuster. It was a weird week of press. She
- 32:43crushed so hard on the roast, there was no buzz on the special.
- 32:46It was very strange. The special kind of came and went and people were
- 32:51still talking about the roast. I think that's partly us to do with just
- 32:54Netflix and alsoasts that roast guy. So, although I don't know, maybe
- 33:00you can know more than I, but I felt like I saw conflicting reports
- 33:04about the ratings. That's another example of something that was like an hour too
- 33:08long that if it was not live, there's no question it would have been
- 33:14edited down an hour and would have been better, and probably I would assume
- 33:19it would have got higher ratings. But I saw some reports that I got
- 33:22crazy ratings. I saw others that Cat Williams got better ratings. Now who
- 33:25knows but the but I don't. I think her special didn't do worse because
- 33:30of that roast. I think because it's like you're saying before, there's still
- 33:34a ton of people who don't know Nico Lasers right, He's a tremendous and
- 33:37successful stand up comedian. But that that rose still raised her profile because it
- 33:43was a thing that everyone was talking about and it was trending for days.
- 33:45So ratings wise, I think I saw what you saw the first weekend,
- 33:50that more people watched Kat quote unquote live than the roast. But I saw
- 33:53something last night that vague numbers here, two hundred and thirty nine million view's
- 34:00eyeballs whatever the Netflix metric is on day one, but it held that number
- 34:05all week, so it seemed like it had legs off the buzz. I
- 34:09think part of Nicky and you brought up Netflix versus HBO, HBO Max,
- 34:15HBO Max. They've goofed up the brand. So this week Hannah Einbender has
- 34:20a new special. Normally HBO specials come out Saturday at ten pm, and
- 34:27Hannah is this out on a Thursday. And then I started wondering, so
- 34:30is this not an HBO special? Did she get a Max special? And
- 34:35what the heck does that even mean? And does it matter? And it's
- 34:37just it's confusing. Most civilians aren't gonna care. But I just looked at
- 34:42it and I'm like, so is this special? Somehow? I don't mean
- 34:45this is dig but like lesser, it's not the equivalent of a Saturday night
- 34:47HBO special from back in the day. It's a Thursday Max special. I
- 34:52don't know. They've confused me. Yes, No, I think they that.
- 34:55I think they've given up a lot of the prestige of their brand.
- 35:01That said, or that's said, and clearly like they're that the company is
- 35:05not doing well. They're going to lose Charles Barkley and inside the NBA that
- 35:08are in debt. Right that said, all right, let's try to defend
- 35:13them a little bit, which is that what I think they're trying to do,
- 35:15which is the smart move that they can't compete with Netflix in terms of
- 35:19money and in terms of scale, And now you've got Hulu coming in which
- 35:23is going to have a big special every month, and they've already signed up
- 35:28people like Gaff again and Savashia Mescalco. What what Max is doing, I
- 35:35think is trying to get the kind of slightly ardier dar Carmichael, Julio Torres,
- 35:42Hannah Einbeinder. They're not going for the biggest mass appeal in a way
- 35:47that I think is consistent with their traditional brand writ large, but it doesn't
- 35:54mean the same thing that it did in the seventies when they had the whole
- 35:59market it to themselves, or the nineties when they had Chris Rock and it
- 36:04was like a major events. Those days are gone, so now the big
- 36:08events tend to be on Netflix. So what do you do if you're a
- 36:13secondary streamer? And I think they have a decent strategy, and that's I
- 36:16think what I like. I agree with your point that it's a mess and
- 36:20confusing to be a consumer of comedy these days and to fight where everything is
- 36:24and I think in a couple of years is going to look different. And
- 36:28what I hope it looks like is that each of these platforms has a personality,
- 36:34has a style, and people who want that can go there right what
- 36:39it will probably be will not be. That will be a mess. So
- 36:42that's why I like the fact that h that Max, even though it's not
- 36:45Friday, seems curated in a specific taste. Well they had even in this
- 36:52century, maybe not for comedy, but for drama shows that they could have
- 36:54thrown this conversation on Sunday night at nine pm and people would have sampled it
- 36:58and assumed it was prestige. Maybe it is, maybe it's not, but
- 37:01we would have gotten the goodwill off the first episode. People would have tuned
- 37:05in. That's true. That's true. No, it's interesting. I didn't
- 37:07realize about that Hers was coming out on Thursday. That's I wonder why.
- 37:13All right, let's take one more break here. Don't forget you can get
- 37:15these shows add free. You know, four ninety nine a month gets you
- 37:16this and all the other things on the network. Link in the show notes.
- 37:20Go to Calieroba dot com slash plus check it out. Maybe you can
- 37:24help me sort my feelings here. I've been struggling with this one. As
- 37:29close as I've gotten is special versus hour. So every comedian tweets out,
- 37:34hey, check out my new special on YouTube. And if we graph everything
- 37:38out, at one end, I don't know, there's Carlin at Carnegie,
- 37:42and at the other end there's I happen to have a still camera at the
- 37:46Chuckle Hut Tuesday night at ten pm, and everyone's using the word special,
- 37:51and I have got a new special. I don't even know what I want
- 37:54from you, but help me not everything is a special that. It's very
- 37:59fuzzy these days. Right, here's my glass half full version. I feel
- 38:04like it's the best of times, the worst of times. There's more specials
- 38:07than ever now are more releases than ever, and the goods part of that
- 38:12is the funniest comedy out there. Doesn't tend to be the most famous people
- 38:17for totally boring reasons. They have other things to do then work on their
- 38:22jokes, right, They're busy, right, So the people who tend to
- 38:27be have the most worked out jokes are the kind of mid career comedians who
- 38:32have trouble getting a Netflix deal, right, and now they have a place
- 38:38and an outlet to release their stuff YouTube, right, so you see people
- 38:45like Nathan McIntosh who or the next one I saw is Renon Hirschberg, or
- 38:52who has one coming up soon, Liz Meal. These weren't a time where
- 38:57these people. Now you can see their stuff not only as eavy as you
- 39:00can see the stuff in HBO, but easier. And I think that's a
- 39:05good thing. And I don't want to stay oither and that's not special.
- 39:07And this is special because not only is it not true that they're worse there,
- 39:12in many cases they're often better. But two, it's like, cool,
- 39:15what's the point in policing these genres? I do think we'll look back
- 39:20and we'll say, man, there was more bad comedy then than ever,
- 39:22but there's also more great comedy than ever. It's harder to find the good
- 39:28stuff now because there's so much of it. And that's part of our job
- 39:32is to be like, hey, like, all right, everybody knows Joe
- 39:37Rogan and the Roast and all this, but that's not really the best comedy.
- 39:40Nobody who knows comedy thinks that's the best comedy. That's increasing to the
- 39:45point that we started with it, which is like all right, how have
- 39:47our jobs shifted? We've got to cover the big stuff because that's what people
- 39:52want to read, and that's important. But I think we have an increasing
- 39:54responsibility to be like, Okay, let's look at what's going on in these
- 39:59on YouTube tube, on TikTok, etc. And find the good stuff.
- 40:02You've been incredibly generous with your time. Let me pick your brain and I'll
- 40:07let you go about comedy snobbery when I ran serious comedy. So I'm sitting
- 40:12at a desk five days a week, got the radio on from May to
- 40:15six. All I'm hearing is the best stand up comedians performing their best material
- 40:21that they've pressed. And it fried my brain. And I call it the
- 40:24Emperor of Rome syndrome. So if I go see a show, I don't
- 40:28laugh. I am now a psychopath, but my brain is analyzing and going,
- 40:31oh that's hilarious, and I'm thinking it just in the manner I did.
- 40:36Oh that's really funny, Oh great callback, Oh wow, this is
- 40:38an awesome set. Has doing what you do? Has it fried your brain?
- 40:43It's a really good question. The short answer is yes, that when
- 40:46it becomes your job. First of all, if you see comedians in the
- 40:49back of comedy clubs. They don't laugh right the way regular people do,
- 40:52and it's no different than people like you and I who do. Often you're
- 40:58not the best audience member. One weird phenomenon of my job is I feel
- 41:01bad sometimes I think something's funny, but I don't laugh, and I know
- 41:06it makes me a bad Sometimes I fake laugh, just like if it's if
- 41:08I'm in a small room where the laugh really matters, or having someone stonefaced
- 41:15is like going to disrupt the proceedings, like I'll fake laugh, which I'm
- 41:19not as convincing as a fake which comes up ridiculous. You do what you
- 41:22do. But so I do think that it's a danger of the job,
- 41:27which is you, and it's something you have to be aware of and you
- 41:30have to factor in because you don't want You want to be in touch with
- 41:37both your honest reaction to something and also what how the ordinary consumer receives the
- 41:43stuff. I like it's self justifying, but I tend to think that the
- 41:46advantages of being experienced and well versed in comedy and knowing the vast site of
- 41:53the history of the form and seeing enough to know what's good versus bad must
- 41:58ambitions is not what didictable, what's cliche? All that stuff outweighs the negative
- 42:04of becoming of not laughing quite as much. And I also will say this
- 42:08that like the moment when you aren't excited about seeing something, the moment when
- 42:14you get cynical or jaded about comedy is when you when I'll quit. So
- 42:20that's something you got to always be kicking the tires on, or I have
- 42:23to be kicking the tires on which I do. Have you ever run into
- 42:28I ran into this early in my career, not so much lately, but
- 42:30hey, you're not a comedian. How come you're doing this and all this?
- 42:34And I was explaining, like, I don't play guitar, but I
- 42:37can recognize that Eddie van Halen's pretty good at it. Like I'm not claiming
- 42:42to be a comedian. I'm a dude in a basement. Or I was
- 42:44a radio programmer. I don't know. Yeah, that doesn't bother me the
- 42:47If anything, I consider it a benefit of plus because uh uh, in
- 42:53the fact, you'll never find me doing the gimmick piece of oh. And
- 42:59then I went and tried stand up and I bombed, and I learned how
- 43:02much I respected that to me, respecting the artists, whether it's a comedian
- 43:08or whether it's a theater artist or a film artist, is becoming as good
- 43:13as I can be at my job, which is fundamentally different, like comedians
- 43:19couldn't. Comedians are good at what they do, and what I do is
- 43:22quite hard as well, And it also looks easy, right, Just doing
- 43:25comedy is easy or looks easy, but is actually incredibly hard. Being a
- 43:31critic covering an incredibly diverse, complicated field is and then translating that into prose
- 43:37that both the expert and the casual fan can understand without limiting the complexity of
- 43:44a nuance. That's very tricky, and that's enough of a challenge for me.
- 43:49And I actually tend to think that not being a comedian helps me in
- 43:53that job, besides the fact it reduces the conflict of interests and keeps your
- 43:59independence, etc. But I think that it's a fundamentally different skill set.
- 44:05And so when people say, oh, you're not a comedian, I said,
- 44:07that's right, I'm not a comedian. Yeah. Sorry. When I
- 44:10was programming the stations, and I still program for Live one, I wanted
- 44:15to make sure I was coming in at civilian eye level, and the civilians
- 44:19are listening to Jim Gaffigan. You and I can go to a club and
- 44:22be too cool for school and deep dive. But it's the same thing I
- 44:25brought up nine times, But play the hits. No, You've got to
- 44:29look. I don't understand people who do it my job. I know there's
- 44:32some of them who say this, and I respect a lot of them,
- 44:36or I respect all of them who it's hard. There's a hard job.
- 44:38But my audience, my primary audience, is the reader, and there I
- 44:45don't see. The comedy world is not my community. I'm a journalist who's
- 44:50working in my and my audience is the reader. I have obligation to be
- 44:55fair to the artists, and I know I hear from them, and I
- 44:59know I want their respect as I want anybody else's respect. But I do
- 45:04think it's important for people, just as I think it's important for comedians to
- 45:08see their audience their primary audience, not they're only audience, their primary audience,
- 45:12as they're people sitting in front of them are watching their special that I
- 45:15have to think about what the reader wants first, and when I get away
- 45:21from that, I think I could run into problems. So yeah, I
- 45:23think there's room. People have different points of view on this, but but
- 45:28yeah, it's funny because I'm a critic, but I'm also a reporter,
- 45:34so I talk to comedians interview them. I learn a lot from that that
- 45:38helps me understand what they're trying to do. There's value in that, but
- 45:44there's also value in independence and distance, and you sometimes can see and you
- 45:50know, comedians frankly understand this better than other artists because they're often critics of
- 45:54whatever social conditions, politics, whatever, and they can often diagnose something more
- 46:01perceptively than people in the newscan because they have or journalists can because they have
- 46:08a little more distance. So distance can be an advantage as well, and
- 46:14it keeps you out of the fights. There are enough to name particular names.
- 46:19There are comedians who do really well and aren't respected by the brick wall
- 46:23cigarette smoking crowd in the village, and I will name names. I worked
- 46:28with the blue collar guys. Larry, the cable guy, Dan is the
- 46:31nicest guy you'll ever meet, unless Jeff Foxworthy is in the room. They
- 46:36are awesome people, and you know, I've been backstage with them, and
- 46:39Larry would write Jeff a joke that just didn't work for Larry's act, and
- 46:44Jeff would write something a little naughty and pass it back and forth. And
- 46:47they're not They're just trying to make people laugh. They're not going, oh,
- 46:51Larry the Cable Guy, this is high art, like it's just jokes,
- 46:53and some of that, especially in New York, that bitterness about somebody
- 46:58else's success would get fatiguing. You know what else, Larry the Cable Guy
- 47:01is good at what he does. I've when I wrote about them, I
- 47:07made a point of I went to Beaumont, Texas to see that tour.
- 47:13I didn't I wanted to go to like there, and I watched all of
- 47:16them, and Larry, I believe, came last. And I think that
- 47:22was the right move because he's a he's a killer, and he is an
- 47:25incredibly dense, punchline rich set. Not every joke is great, but if
- 47:32you don't like it, another one's coming down the pipe fast. You know,
- 47:36it's not like the hippis obviously brand of comedy, and it's a character
- 47:39driven comedy, which it feels there's it's you don't see it quite as much
- 47:45in the clubs as he used to but anyways, the Yeah, I think
- 47:49it's the kind of journalism that I do, and not everyone has to be
- 47:53like this, but I try to have Catholic tastes. I try to meet
- 47:58artists where they are. That doesn't mean that everything is equally good, but
- 48:02I think that's part of the fun of the job is seeing people of artists
- 48:07of wildly different genres, aesthetics, ambitions. That's what makes this fun to
- 48:15follow. I love that you went to Beaumont when I first put together Blue
- 48:20Collar Radio. The first time I met them, I went to see a
- 48:22show. The show was a Nashville and I specifically asked them, please don't
- 48:27vip me. Put me in the upper deck with the civilians. And I
- 48:30sat there and I paid attention, and I was just trying to take the
- 48:32vibe in. And I always remembered the two things that got big applause where
- 48:37y'all ever been to the Walmart? A mention of Jimmy Buffett and a mention
- 48:42of Elvis, And I factored that into my programming. Whereas the Raw Dog
- 48:46Channel was if it were a person, maybe it would be Bill Burr and
- 48:50a real fu in a rock and roll kind of vibe. And blue Collar
- 48:53Radio was god Flag country veterans, straight people by acker barrel, straight down
- 49:00the middle, and it did tremendously well. Yep, yep, No,
- 49:04it's true. And that's one of the great things about stand up is that
- 49:09you've got all these regional forms that are that do well. Sometimes I worry
- 49:17that the internet's sort of flattening that out. And I wrote a story last
- 49:22year about how the internet is the Internet hurting distinct local scenes because there used
- 49:30to be like Boston at a specific aesthetic that you could have SA San Francis,
- 49:34which was different than San Francisco, which was different than DC, which
- 49:37was different than Nashville. But now since everyone is in the same room together
- 49:42online, this idea of oh, the comedians and my senior are the only
- 49:45ones I know coming up is obsolete? And is that going to stand off
- 49:49the edges of local difference? And I don't know some people I talked to,
- 49:53some people in various local scenes who suggest that's happening. And there's so
- 49:58much out there. We're nearly an we're in and we've really only talked big
- 50:01comedians'. We haven't talked alt, we didn't talk improv, we didn't talk
- 50:06sketch. We didn't talk one person shows like somebody like Natalie Palamini is just
- 50:10doing amazing work. There's just so much out there. I just saw her
- 50:15new show, which, I'll be honest with you, I was like,
- 50:19how can she top Nate? But I saw her new show which at the
- 50:24Netflix Festival in la and it was the best thing I saw there. It
- 50:28wasn't finished, but it was thrilling. Hard wait to see it when it's
- 50:32done. It's basically like a rom com where she plays both She plays both
- 50:37parts of this romance, and the physicality of it is incredibly inventive. I've
- 50:42neversed anything like it. Yeah, the whole clowning scene is boom. That's
- 50:46just great. Jason. You've been very generous with your time. I hope
- 50:51you'll come back down the road when there's an excuse for me to ask you
- 50:53to come on again other than just hey man, want to fill an hour
- 50:57for me. But this was fantastic thing. This was incredibly fun. Thank
- 51:00you for asking, and it's great to have a conversation with someone who knows
- 51:02their stuff. He was fantastic. I enjoyed the heck out of that,
- 51:06and he was very gracious with his time on this program. Tomorrow a look
- 51:09at the best comedy specials of the year so far. See it then