Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Why This Wall Street CEO Says Bitcoin’s Price Isn’t Nearly High Enough
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous extra
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of darkness, 1974198792972000 and
- 0:18whatever we're going to call this, it's all just the same
- 0:20thing over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when we sell. Hey, OK.
- 0:28I say when we sell. And you're back with another
- 0:34episode of The Last Trade. This was one of the funnest
- 0:37podcasts we've done to date. We had Ted Smith, former CEO of
- 0:40Sotheby's and I believe Madison Square Garden, among other firms
- 0:44on the podcast. It was wide-ranging.
- 0:46He's super engaging, high vibes kind of guy.
- 0:49I think you guys are going to really enjoy it.
- 0:52Quick word from On Ramp. On Ramp provides a financial
- 0:54services built on multi institution custody.
- 0:57At the end of the day what we provide is our clients and our
- 1:00clients friends and family. Peace of Mind.
- 1:02No more having to deal with a hardware device tucked in a sock
- 1:05drawer or having to worry about a third party custodian send you
- 1:09phishing emails and wonder if your assets are OK.
- 1:12Now we completely understand that you know one, not one size
- 1:15custody fits all. So you don't have to move all
- 1:17assets over to multi institution custody.
- 1:19But I will say, signing up, going through our onboarding
- 1:23process, it's self onboarding now or you can have concierge,
- 1:26but then getting a test transaction through doing a
- 1:29withdrawal and really feeling the power behind having multiple
- 1:32independent institutions have to verify with you over video
- 1:35verification before movement of assets is super powerful.
- 1:38We encourage you to check us out.
- 1:40You can reach out at hello at honor@bitcoin.com or Michael at
- 1:43honor@bitcoin.com if you want to shoot us a note with questions
- 1:46or you can sign up for a consultation or just again
- 1:49through the self onboarding now. I hope you enjoyed the show.
- 1:51We'll talk to you later. OK.
- 1:54And we're live. It's the last trade.
- 1:57There's five of us here. We got some special guests as
- 1:59well. For those who are not on video,
- 2:02we can just rattle off the names real quick.
- 2:04So we have big Tim Kotzman. Tim is showing up to the podcast
- 2:09today from the backseat of a taxi cab.
- 2:12Tim, great to see you not. A police car.
- 2:14It's not a police car, it's a taxi cab.
- 2:17Not this time. That's the next episode.
- 2:19Stay tuned for next week. And so we got Michael as well,
- 2:22Michael Tanguma and Brian Cabela's on the on ramp team.
- 2:25Gentlemen, good to see you. I see you guys enough so we
- 2:27don't we don't need your introduction.
- 2:29And then Ted Smith. Ted, it's great to meet you just
- 2:33before we hit record here. Thanks for joining us today.
- 2:35You're the you're the guest of honor this week.
- 2:37How are you? Wow.
- 2:38Thank you. It's great to be here, Jackson.
- 2:40Appreciate it. Excellent.
- 2:42Well, certainly want to get more into your background on the back
- 2:45half of the show. But what we do here at the last
- 2:48trade is we always pull up the Bitcoin price chart.
- 2:51And so this was actually Tad, just so you know, this is a very
- 2:54sad moment for us the past several months because we just
- 2:56looked at 80K for week after week, what felt like it was an
- 3:00eternity. And then last week we started to
- 3:02see some positive momentum. It's actually I think it was cuz
- 3:05Brian wasn't on the podcast last.
- 3:07Week, so that might have been it.
- 3:09So finally we have some green candles to look at.
- 3:12The price is getting close to 100K.
- 3:14Gentlemen, what are your thoughts here?
- 3:16What's what's driving Bitcoin right now?
- 3:20Just broader, broader recognition of its inherent
- 3:24monetary properties. I think just people getting
- 3:27educated every day. I, I, you know, put out our
- 3:29newsletter this morning and what I was really talking about is
- 3:32just, you know, we we've said this in the past, but on a risk
- 3:35adjusted basis, if you consider all of the backdrop, all of the
- 3:39positive tailwinds that are constructed for Bitcoin adoption
- 3:42going forward. 96 K whatever at 97 K it's just extremely
- 3:47mispriced. It's it's in arguably arguably
- 3:51the cheapest bitcoins ever been. If you're considering where we
- 3:54are, how we sit here today with government adoption, government
- 3:57support, corporations adopting it.
- 4:01And again, the education is just permanent permeating around, you
- 4:05know, this isn't a tech stock. This is a superior monetary
- 4:09asset that you can store value into the future.
- 4:12And that's that's really all this is.
- 4:13And and you know, I've been saying this for weeks, but you
- 4:15know, with everything going on, it's really the most bullish
- 4:19I've ever been on Bitcoin. Even when we were hanging out in
- 4:21the 70s and the 80s, it was it was only a matter of time before
- 4:25we started to move back up. So great.
- 4:28Great to be back in the 90s with you, Jackson.
- 4:30But yeah, this is everything's going according to plan in my
- 4:33mind. Just week after week, my
- 4:37complaints push the price higher.
- 4:40And so just a quick recap. So it's actually May 1st, we're
- 4:42recording on Thursday. This will come out tomorrow
- 4:44morning. Just to recap what happened in
- 4:46April, it was it was a crazy time in markets.
- 4:50A lot happened in the span of a month.
- 4:52We had the announcements of the tariffs on April 2nd, all sorts
- 4:55of volatility, uncertainty in terms of trade relations, what
- 5:00was going to happen with the yield curve.
- 5:02Bonds are spiking as well. What actually where we ended up
- 5:05in terms of asset class performance was gold was about
- 5:086% up for the month of April, peaked at about $3500 an ounce.
- 5:12I think we're sitting close to 3233 hundred.
- 5:15So still incredible performance for year to date.
- 5:19NASDAQ and S&P were both about flat.
- 5:21I want to say NASDAQ might have returned 1% in the month of
- 5:24April, S&P was just about flat and Bitcoin 12% in the month of
- 5:29April. It didn't feel like that in the
- 5:32trenches in the middle of the month that did not feel like
- 5:34this is the outcome we're going to have.
- 5:35But Ted, maybe I'll throw it over to you.
- 5:38What what do you make of just what happened in the month of
- 5:40April in in markets and with Bitcoin?
- 5:42Well, the context for me, for my answering your question is I'm a
- 5:47strong ardent proponent of the liquidity philosophy and how it
- 5:51drives Bitcoin and asset prices. Whether you credit Michael
- 5:55Howell or Raul Powell or Julian Patel, take your pick and
- 5:59liquidity has been on a monster run in the last 6 to 8 weeks.
- 6:03Gold has been telling you that story.
- 6:05It's sort of front loaded it. Bitcoin is coming in very strong
- 6:09to catch up. And you could argue the dip
- 6:11prior to the last sort of period of time was baked in when
- 6:16liquidity began to shrink in October of last year.
- 6:19I'm definitely on that train. The fact that we have buyers
- 6:23emerging everywhere, we've got strong secular bullish trends,
- 6:27all of that to me says number go up.
- 6:31And if anything, it feels a little bit like the tail end of
- 6:34the chopped solidation we had last year, except that the
- 6:40liquidity situations probably even more bullish right now.
- 6:43So I'm not surprised. I think the other thing that I
- 6:46would observe in the month of April and you put your finger on
- 6:49it is it was interesting to see the NASDAQ, which is also
- 6:55liquidity sensitive go One Direction and Bitcoin go a
- 6:58different 1. And I would attribute that now
- 7:01this is just armchair, you know, post hoc trading analysis if you
- 7:06will, if that much. I would say that the stocks in
- 7:10the NASDAQ were much more sensitive to the economic cycle
- 7:15and also frankly to the effect of potential tariffs and the
- 7:19uncertainty than Bitcoin. Was Bitcoins essentially immune
- 7:22to it? In my opinion, if anything, it's
- 7:24a positive. And then the final point.
- 7:26And so therefore, you would see them diverge quite naturally,
- 7:28whether you call that a flight to safety or you call it a
- 7:31limited flight to safety, which is to say Bitcoin is safe in a
- 7:34tariff world. I'll take that as a friendly
- 7:36amendment from the floor. And the final thing I would pile
- 7:38on to this is that Bitcoin is probably sniffing out that the
- 7:43Fed is going to move. Now whether they move on rates
- 7:46or whether they move on the supplemental leverage ratio or
- 7:50whether they do whatever was best and said yesterday
- 7:52so-called Treasury buyback, I'm not sure there'll be some fancy
- 7:56version of non QE, QE and Bitcoin sniffing that out.
- 8:01Yeah, that's a great, you know, summary of what's going on.
- 8:04I think you and Brian, you know, brought the the sophisticated
- 8:08right side of the curve. I'll go on the other side and
- 8:10say, you know, maybe it's not just fully Michael Sailor, but
- 8:14there's about nine other sailors in the market currently right
- 8:16now that are heavily bidding this price up and accumulating
- 8:20BTC, whether it's GameStop, what is it Metaplanet just coming
- 8:25into over the US And then I'm sure there's no shortage of
- 8:28behind the scenes pre specs that are picking up BTC ahead of
- 8:32going public. So there's a lot of demand.
- 8:35And then you have the tailwinds as Tad alluded to with
- 8:37liquidity. We pulled up that chart
- 8:39previously. We've talked about for the past
- 8:40few weeks, you know, gold front front ran that cycle and we've
- 8:45seen it kind of temper off. And this is I think what
- 8:47happened like 6 months ago as well where gold broke out and
- 8:50then kind of like, you know, took a step back and Bitcoin
- 8:53ran. And if that's what is ahead of
- 8:54us, we have a pretty exciting next cut a few weeks or months
- 8:57ahead of us. I came across this chart that
- 9:02reinforces more of the relationship between Bitcoin and
- 9:05gold. And so this is from Tephra
- 9:07Digital. And Ted really ties into a lot
- 9:10of what you just said in terms of liquidity cycles, gold tends
- 9:13to front run. But if you look here, it looks
- 9:15like we're just with the price action this week, Bitcoin seems
- 9:19to be sniffing out the increase in global liquidity, which Ted,
- 9:22I believe you mentioned was the past, what, 6 to 8 weeks or so.
- 9:27And then so this is the ratio of Bitcoin to gold.
- 9:30And so you can see here it tracks over the past three years
- 9:33or so through the collapse of Luna and FTX, the the initial
- 9:39launch of the Bitcoin ETF's. And you can see what that really
- 9:42dramatically increased the ratio of Bitcoin to gold, which really
- 9:45just speaks to investor ability to get access to this asset
- 9:48class, which previously really felt uninvestable for a lot of
- 9:52people. But I'd argue now if you look on
- 9:54the right hand side of this chart here, we've seen a, a
- 9:58decrease of the Bitcoin to gold ratio, meaning gold
- 10:01outperforming Bitcoin really in the month of April and March as
- 10:04well with uncertainty and just yeah, general uncertainty around
- 10:10tariffs, recession, growth fear, etcetera.
- 10:13But I'd argue now we're really poised to see this number or see
- 10:16this ratio go higher because we have gotten through this period
- 10:19now of consolidation and correction in the Bitcoin price.
- 10:24And it's, I always like to joke about this tad because it's kind
- 10:28of a blessing and curse. We do this podcast because a lot
- 10:31of it can be redundant, but it's also important to help investors
- 10:35remain convicted in the thesis. And so I could probably close my
- 10:40laptop and never look at Twitter or X again.
- 10:43And I would feel very confident that Bitcoin goes higher because
- 10:46I know the structural situation of the Fiat system is more debt,
- 10:49more dollars, more liquidity, etc.
- 10:52But it's good at least to have a pulse, maybe for those who don't
- 10:55have the same conviction that we do, that things are looking to
- 10:58improve here in terms of liquidity expanding, which will
- 11:01drive the both gold and the Bitcoin price higher.
- 11:04Yes. And I love that point.
- 11:05I mean, for me, this is the North Star for huddling and to
- 11:10allow you to hang on during the tough patches.
- 11:13But for those who try to trade in and out or take positions,
- 11:17it's a little bit tougher to use this kind of analysis, the one
- 11:19that I'm mentioning, the one that you're mentioning, because
- 11:22the timing of these things has a high degree of variability.
- 11:25And if you have limited time issues on an option trade or
- 11:28trading position or any sort of time sensitivity, it's a bit
- 11:31more, it's a bit more problematic.
- 11:33But if you step back, you're a Diamond Hands Hodler and you
- 11:36just need that positive reinforcement.
- 11:38This is exactly the kind of chart you want to see, and
- 11:40exactly the kind of analysis you want to look at.
- 11:44Absolutely. One thing I wanted to jump to, I
- 11:47think we wanted to start here, but we just got, we got too
- 11:49excited, we got too excited about 97 K.
- 11:52So we had to just briefly chat about that.
- 11:54But I want to pull up this clip here and let me know if the
- 11:57audio isn't coming through. But we're going to take a look
- 11:59here at what the Black Rock CIO said about the digital asset
- 12:02space, and particularly in Bitcoin.
- 12:04I'm not a deep enough student of kind of the institutional
- 12:10ecosystems in the other coins right now.
- 12:12But in terms of the conversations that we've had
- 12:16with institutional investors, they are really largely focused
- 12:23on Bitcoin right now, particularly in this
- 12:26environment. Ethereum is still a a distant
- 12:30second so. Yeah.
- 12:32So we're not even talking about revenue generating protocols or
- 12:36anything like? That and remember, we're talking
- 12:38about, you know, the, the, you know, institutional investors
- 12:42who are, you know, broadly in 6040 equity bond portfolios and,
- 12:48and looking to figure out what that, what the new sources of
- 12:51return and diversification will be for them.
- 12:54They want both of those and that's what's bringing them to
- 12:58private markets. It's bringing.
- 13:02Yeah, it's a, it's a great clip. It kind of comes back to we
- 13:06discussed last week with I think it was the head of institutional
- 13:09on Coinbase's side referencing pensions, endowments, family
- 13:13offices, starting to look at gold as a trade and then
- 13:16indirectly BTC because of its properties.
- 13:19I think historically, we've obviously said bitcoins, digital
- 13:22gold, but that was more of us trying to sell the market versus
- 13:25the market fully, like embracing or appealing to that.
- 13:28And with gold's breakout inflationary environment in the
- 13:316040, kind of moving away from a nominal or a real return.
- 13:36Now you're starting to see that I think liquidity flow from
- 13:39gold's trade into BTC. And that's what I think she's
- 13:42referencing in the markets also picking up on.
- 13:44And that's kind of the divergent that we saw with the NASDAQ and
- 13:48then hard assets like Bitcoin and gold.
- 13:49And I don't think that's historically been there.
- 13:51We wanted it to be there. And on the margins, you know,
- 13:54for the Paul Tudor Jones and Druckenmiller's.
- 13:56But for the rest of the market, I don't think that trade has
- 13:59been as at the forefront, but it's starting to become which is
- 14:02obviously ultra bullish. Yeah.
- 14:05And the the bigger signal from that clip to me is the the clear
- 14:09distinction or delineation that she's making between Bitcoin and
- 14:12the rest of crypto. And I think that's kind of what
- 14:14the interviewers question was trying to get at was, you know,
- 14:17are institutional allocators actually thinking about these
- 14:19things differently. And and her answer I think is
- 14:23very telling that particularly in this environment of market
- 14:26uncertainty and tariffs, etcetera, people are looking for
- 14:31incredibly neutral stores of value.
- 14:33They're not looking for high beta tech exposure, which I
- 14:36would characterize sort of the rest of crypto charitably, as
- 14:40you know, much more akin to technology stocks relative to
- 14:44Bitcoin being, you know, this purely monetary asset.
- 14:48And so that was the biggest take away from that clip for me is
- 14:50like she's telling you how these people are thinking.
- 14:53They're talking to folks every day.
- 14:55And so that again, going back to like the education component,
- 14:58like the idea that Bitcoin is truly different than the rest of
- 15:01crypto is continuing to manifest in the brains of, of allocators
- 15:06across the world. And, and you know, the, the key
- 15:10point there is like the reason that's happening is because the
- 15:146040 isn't working. Bonds and equities are going
- 15:16down. So you actually need a real
- 15:18diversifier. You don't need higher beta tech
- 15:20risk, You need something else. It's going to preserve value.
- 15:23And so that's, you know, Bitcoin is, is sort of fulfilling that
- 15:27role that, you know, people have been studying it for a long
- 15:29time, have understood, but the broader market isn't there yet,
- 15:32obviously. And so I think that's, it's just
- 15:34a really clear signal that, you know, slowly but surely the
- 15:38these these concepts and these ideas of Bitcoins true nature
- 15:42are, are starting to emerge. Yeah, one thing to call out, it
- 15:46wasn't in that clip. Both encourage anyone listening
- 15:49to go check out the podcast. It was very informative on Black
- 15:52Rocks overarching, you know, Bitcoin, but digital asset
- 15:56securitization strategy. And she referenced something
- 15:58we've kind of like speculated on that 50% of the flow into ibit
- 16:03has been purely from retail investors that weren't
- 16:06comfortable with getting access to any other Bitcoin product.
- 16:09And she referenced that in like, I want to say 22.
- 16:12They had initially launched a private placement and maybe even
- 16:15before then they were strategizing.
- 16:16Do we really want to offer Bitcoin because of its
- 16:18accessibility? So simple.
- 16:19You can download a mobile wallet, you know, River Cash
- 16:22App, Coinbase, but they had to go full circle and realize we'll
- 16:27know people want the ibit brand or the BlackRock brand.
- 16:29They want that, you know, security around it of the rapper
- 16:32along with Coinbase. But it's interesting because
- 16:36like they saw that they're sophisticated enough to know
- 16:39that there's probably better products out there, but there's
- 16:41also the market that's still coming up the curve.
- 16:43And I think they're going to go full circle and ultimately have
- 16:45to do a bunch of other things like in kind delivery once the
- 16:47market gets educated. Because the thing we talked
- 16:49about here, Ted, is the ETF's are great, but anybody that
- 16:52builds a material position outside of 2 to 3% of our
- 16:54portfolio wakes up and realizes what counterparty risk looks
- 16:57like in the Bitcoin space. And then they ultimately are
- 16:59going to ask or look for better products.
- 17:02You know, I, I agree and institutional investors are
- 17:09really very different from the mindset I think of the retail
- 17:13investor or even the what I would call the non institutional
- 17:17family office investor or ultra high net worth investor.
- 17:20And the fundamental difference is if for an institutional
- 17:23investor, it's not their money. And and that is such a key point
- 17:27because when you are investing someone else's money, you have
- 17:31fiduciary responsibilities and you have to have evidence based
- 17:35approaches. And evidence based approaches
- 17:37often are quantitative. They often have earnings
- 17:39statements, they have cash flows, they have analyst
- 17:42reports. When you think about all the
- 17:43sort of apparatus of institutional investment, all of
- 17:46that stuff is a necessary precondition of investing at a
- 17:51fiduciary, a legally fiduciarily acceptable level for other
- 17:56people's money. And so that means institutional
- 18:00investors, everything else are probably or are least likely to
- 18:04be slow to invest in an asset that does not produce Fiat cash
- 18:08flow. A very important point,
- 18:10everything else being equal, you're and so then the question
- 18:13is, why is it that anyone would invest in something that doesn't
- 18:16produce Fiat cash flow? And the answer to that is
- 18:19overwhelmingly narrative. The narrative of Bitcoin versus
- 18:24gold of of Bitcoin versus liquidity, of Bitcoin versus
- 18:27safety, of Bitcoin versus counterparty risk, those
- 18:30narratives. And what's so powerful about the
- 18:33ETF and so powerful about the environment that we're in now.
- 18:37And by the way, the narrative has changed dramatically right
- 18:40in the last six months. Suddenly the regulatory risk
- 18:42around Bitcoin has faded away. So that narrative risk is
- 18:45essentially gone. Liquidity is rising.
- 18:48Safety is a new narrative that's come on the and when you look at
- 18:51the change in narrative from the perspective of an institutional
- 18:55shareholder or institutional investor, it's a completely
- 18:58different situation. It looks a lot more like gold.
- 19:00And that means it's safe for you to put it some into someone and
- 19:05into the money that's not yours. And so I look at it and I say
- 19:09the institutional investors are not surprising to me that in
- 19:13this narrative environment, they're prepared to take a gold
- 19:17looking like flyer, well, not really a flyer, but wade into
- 19:20this new pool and that should probably accelerate as the
- 19:24narrative continues to get better and better and better.
- 19:26But that's a totally different situation from retail because
- 19:29retail is perfectly comfortable when they're doing their own
- 19:31money investing in a narrative or frankly even investing in a
- 19:34flyer. So back to what Yano was saying,
- 19:38what's the narrative of Bitcoin versus, say Ethereum versus say,
- 19:43Solana versus say Sweet from the perspective of an institutional
- 19:47investor, very different, the narratives for those, if you're
- 19:51not investing your own money, those are a long putt for an
- 19:55institutional investor. Yeah, it's, that's really well
- 19:59said, Ted. And and you know, the other
- 20:01thing I, I would point out is, you know, just, you know, we,
- 20:06we've talked about the liquidity conditions we talked about.
- 20:09This divergent in, you know, Bitcoin being more recognized
- 20:13for its true nature. But you know that if Jackson, if
- 20:17you could pull up that other tweet from tougher digital that
- 20:20shows the actual sort of restrictions that are still in
- 20:26place around the ETFs at most banks and wire houses around the
- 20:29country. It's really remarkable to think
- 20:32that, you know, these ETF products were the most
- 20:34successful sort of financial products ever launched, all the
- 20:37capital that's come through them, yet, you know, most people
- 20:42still can't access them through their traditional brokerage.
- 20:45And so this is like a massive sort of signal to me that like,
- 20:50you know, I don't think we've even scratched the surface of
- 20:52what these ETFs flows could look like over the next five years,
- 20:56despite them being, you know, so you know, exceptionally
- 21:00performing over the past year. This just tells you like, you
- 21:03know, that that slow moving approach your referencing Tad
- 21:06is, is certainly still the case. You know, I think Tepra puts out
- 21:12this chart every few weeks and and you see you see new check
- 21:14marks every couple weeks, but it is, it is a slow process.
- 21:19And so I think just as these channels continue to open up as
- 21:22as that Overton window continues to shift and people continue to,
- 21:26you know, recognize Bitcoin for what it is, you're going to
- 21:29start to see, you know, pretty incredible flows into a lot of
- 21:32these products. Yeah.
- 21:34One of the incredibly remarkable things about this too is that
- 21:39the Bitcoin ETF's were still the most successful ETF complex I've
- 21:43been in particular last year, even with all the restrictions
- 21:46here. So you can see about $30
- 21:47trillion of assets under management restricted from fully
- 21:51participating in the Bitcoin ETF complex.
- 21:53Despite that there was $50 billion of inflows last year,
- 21:58right? So and bitcoins a small market
- 22:00still, it's 1.81 point $9 trillion today.
- 22:03So it doesn't take a ton to move the markets.
- 22:06And Brian, just reinforcing what you said there.
- 22:09We haven't really seen, I feel like it's the first pitch,
- 22:12right? It's it's not even the full
- 22:13first inning for Bitcoin adoption within the managed
- 22:16wealth space, within the institutional space.
- 22:18Tad, one thing I would love to hear your thoughts on too, is
- 22:21particularly on gold in the institutional investment
- 22:24community. Because I remember a handful of
- 22:26years ago before I switched over into the, the Bitcoin space, we
- 22:30would have investment strategy calls.
- 22:32I, I worked on a manager research desk.
- 22:33So we looked at hedge funds and all sorts of private asset
- 22:35strategies. But we had a monthly investment
- 22:37strategy call and gold like was never really talked about by the
- 22:42investment strategy team. It was maybe, oh, if you want to
- 22:44express a bearish view on XYZ, you might want to have 1% of
- 22:48your portfolio allocated to gold.
- 22:50But we really haven't been for several decades in an
- 22:52environment where people actually think about neutrality,
- 22:56sovereignty as part of your counterparty risk, as part of
- 22:59their investment thesis, at least from my purview.
- 23:01So are you, would you agree in terms of your experiences?
- 23:05And do you think now that these themes are more in vogue as it
- 23:07relates to allocating capital in the institutional space?
- 23:11Well, specifically from the institution space, we can pivot
- 23:15to ultra high net worth or retail in just a minute.
- 23:17But remember that in a world where you can do what gold does
- 23:25and do it with an instrument that uncontroversially produces
- 23:29Fiat cash flow a la bonds, you don't have any need to go to
- 23:34gold again. So from the perspective of
- 23:37investing someone else's money, the first thing they're going to
- 23:40ask is, well, what am I going to get and when?
- 23:41Right just that's the client is going to say, what am I going to
- 23:45get and when? So in a world where bonds are
- 23:47satisfying the need to produce the cash flow, you don't
- 23:52actually have to have gold as a narrative at all.
- 23:54What's remarkable about this period and the prior period
- 23:57where gold wouldn't parabolic in the recent in recent history is
- 24:01the basic idea of 6040 broke down and that the cash producing
- 24:06or Fiat cash producing instruments were not doing the
- 24:08job. And in that environment you got
- 24:11to say, and I think Jackson, for the reasons you said, in that
- 24:14environment you got to say, OK, well I need something else.
- 24:17And so it's not going to produce, it's not going to
- 24:20safely to an institution produce cash flow.
- 24:23So it's going to have to have a narrative that's tried and true
- 24:26and take one 5000 years old that has lots and lots of statistical
- 24:30correlations with unusual of event that are risk off and does
- 24:35well. And then by the way, you can
- 24:38divide every possible financial chart by gold and see every Fiat
- 24:42chart in the world divided by gold.
- 24:44We all know what those look like.
- 24:45And you say, OK, well this narrative is really powerful.
- 24:48It's tried, tested, it's formally an actual form of
- 24:52sovereign currency around the world.
- 24:55So OK, it's worth a try. I get it.
- 24:59And that's how in my mind institutions think, which is I'm
- 25:02going to default to the tried and true if the tried and true
- 25:07doesn't and doesn't produce cash flow, I've got to have an
- 25:09absolute rock solid narrative. So.
- 25:15Yeah, It makes a ton of sense. And those markets are small to
- 25:18begin with as well. There was actually I wanted to
- 25:21pull up a chart here. It's like if you're managing
- 25:24considerable capital as an institutional investor, you
- 25:27don't want to be moving, you don't want to be moving markets
- 25:30by scaling into a position or in and out of the position.
- 25:32And so I think that's still a large impediment to Bitcoin
- 25:35adoption is if you look at this, you look in the top right side
- 25:39here, Bitcoin 1.8 trillion. It might be a little bit higher
- 25:43than that today, but it fluctuates, right?
- 25:44And so this was actually a chart of of money and then also
- 25:48precious metals crypto Bitcoin markets produced by Nye Day just
- 25:52to show that the markets that actually exist for a non
- 25:56sovereign store of value is incredibly small.
- 25:59I mean, gold is a $22 trillion market.
- 26:02The entire precious metals industry is only 24 trillion.
- 26:05So Bitcoin 1.8 total crypto market caps about 3 trillion.
- 26:10I think it's down about close to 20% from all time highs a few
- 26:14months ago. But so these, particularly
- 26:17Bitcoin in the crypto space, will have to actually expand in
- 26:20terms of their market capitalization.
- 26:22There needs to be more liquidity, at least in my
- 26:24opinion, before institutional investors will come in, in scale
- 26:27here. But there's really not many
- 26:29other options to go to. I mean, there's gold.
- 26:30And then I hadn't really heard much about platinum or Palladium
- 26:34outside of a few like niche macro funds that I worked with
- 26:37back in like 2019-2020. Same with silver.
- 26:41You know, I love about your point, Jackson.
- 26:42I mean, lots of lots of elements that I love, but I got to say
- 26:45one in particular, how funny it is that even that with the
- 26:49institutions, which are the highly rational investors in
- 26:52theory, right versus the D gens, the number has of Bitcoin, for
- 26:58example, has to go up significantly from here in order
- 27:03for them to put money to work, which in turn will make the
- 27:05number go up. I mean, when you think of think
- 27:08about that for just a minute, meaning it's the price isn't
- 27:10high enough for them to have interest is really what we just
- 27:13said. Now, in a world where the supply
- 27:15could adjust, you know, you would just print more Bitcoin,
- 27:18print more Bitcoin, print more Bitcoin and provide supply.
- 27:21So the institutions could come in in this world.
- 27:23You don't get that option in this world.
- 27:26Bitcoin has to hit a certain minimum efficient scale for the
- 27:30very super large institutions to make it to, to come in in a way
- 27:33that adjusts their portfolio results in some meaningful way.
- 27:36And that means, and by the way, we ain't even talked about
- 27:40sovereigns, forget institutions for just a minute, that that
- 27:43means we're just beginning. What'd you say?
- 27:45First inning, bottom of the first, I don't remember.
- 27:47What you said it. Was baseball.
- 27:49I grew up in Denver. We didn't have baseball there.
- 27:50So I you know, I'll, I'll tell you by into the first quarter
- 27:54whatever you like. Love it.
- 27:56Yeah, this is, this is something we talk about a lot because that
- 27:59paradox or reflexivity is embedded in a lot of things.
- 28:02One of them is you may have seen this chart, Riverhead sourced it
- 28:06where you see, you know, I think most people would educate and
- 28:10know that this has been a retail driven phenomenon.
- 28:13Our thesis says it'll continue to be for a number of reasons. 1
- 28:15is simply because individuals are consensus of 1, so they can
- 28:19allocate much more material wealth than like you reference
- 28:22governance going to getting consensus will take much longer
- 28:25to take that view and then take a larger position.
- 28:28But then also because the individual holds the vast
- 28:31majority of this asset, they are by nature the most sophisticated
- 28:35because they've been in the market the longest.
- 28:37And so they're the ones that are looking for the most
- 28:39sophisticated products. And that's ultimately something
- 28:42that you haven't seen from the traditional, like smart money,
- 28:45Wall Street building products and services.
- 28:47Like the ETF, again, is sophisticated for, you know,
- 28:51pension endowment. But for an individual that's
- 28:53holding $100 million, that's the last thing they're going to want
- 28:56to put their assets in. And so from a market structure
- 29:00perspective, it's something we pay attention a lot about and
- 29:02how we build our products because we're preparing for when
- 29:05the market has more material positions, they get more
- 29:07educated and they naturally are going to look for the same
- 29:09products that the individual, which has never really been
- 29:12seen. And so when we talk with
- 29:14institutional allocators and specifically large Trad 5 firms,
- 29:17some CR model and are starting to talk about what's maybe
- 29:20incorporating, but others are like, why would anybody ever
- 29:22want anything other than an omnibus wallet full of a bunch
- 29:26of coins? And it's like, well, let me
- 29:27explain why. And so that's a huge opportunity
- 29:29And I know you said on the investment side to actually
- 29:32invest in products and services that are ahead of that curve.
- 29:36Exactly, exactly. I couldn't agree more.
- 29:39So hey, right, the headline number go up.
- 29:43Tim, can you can you point higher for us just to make sure
- 29:46we're on the same page here? Tim Orange coin is good.
- 29:50What's going on with this tie situation?
- 29:51I don't know if you feel bearish.
- 29:53Casual Tim, what is this? You know, it's opposite, Dave.
- 29:57The price is going up. So you know, there's there's no
- 30:00possible way that the tie could be long enough, right?
- 30:03I don't, I don't just don't know how it would go if Jackson asked
- 30:07me for the tie reveal. And how long is the tie right?
- 30:10I don't have a tie that goes all the way down to my shoes.
- 30:12So there's just no tie today. I think the audience is going to
- 30:16be very upset about this, Tim. They might not even be able to
- 30:19publish the episode. Yeah.
- 30:21Tim, can you, can you speak to a rumor I saw on on Twitter this
- 30:25morning that NVIDIA is considering putting Bitcoin on
- 30:28the balance sheet? Was that the other large
- 30:30corporate that your buddy AP Apagus was referring to?
- 30:34I have no idea. It really seems like a rumor
- 30:36mill at this point, right? So yeah, I as soon as I woke up
- 30:41at 5 or 6, right before I texted Michael for the very first time,
- 30:46right? I saw an account that has a lot
- 30:49of followers, but right underneath the announcement, the
- 30:53comments are like, so what's your source?
- 30:56What's the source? I am the source, right?
- 30:59And I'm like, this is this thing doesn't have legs as of yet.
- 31:03Truth is it it to me it doesn't make a lot of sense, right?
- 31:07Because when you when you think about some of the most
- 31:09successful companies in the world, NVIDIA is right at the
- 31:14top of that list. And this for them is a net
- 31:17distraction if you ask me. I don't know what it would do
- 31:21necessarily to their shareholder base.
- 31:22I'm not sure in the near term, you know, and I you quoted
- 31:26Sailor just a minute ago, Tim, I think you're spot on.
- 31:28Sailor says really the people that are very young and or
- 31:32desperate are the ones who are appropriate for this.
- 31:35And in the case of corporations, he always points at zombie
- 31:38companies or companies that are shells that are the ones that
- 31:41are right for it. And I think he's right.
- 31:43I think the most successful companies in the world actually
- 31:46can afford to be the last ones to do it.
- 31:49So I don't know why NVIDIA, I don't know why NVIDIA would be
- 31:53on that list. And if it were, by the way, to
- 31:55me, I, I'm not an NVIDIA shareholder anymore, but I used
- 31:58to be it it to me. If it were, I'm not sure it
- 32:01wouldn't be a sell. Interestingly enough, it it
- 32:04would be it would be signaling something to me that's a little
- 32:06strange so. How about the subsidiary for
- 32:11Metaplan? I want coming to the US in
- 32:13Miami. Have any thoughts?
- 32:16I'll throw it over to the group. I'm pulling the tweet up as I
- 32:19speak to it. But so backed by $250 million of
- 32:22initial capital to essentially give access to U.S. markets to
- 32:26Metaplanet. Yeah, I mean, Tim, this is kind
- 32:30of our TAD. Excuse me.
- 32:31This is exactly what you pretty much just said, right?
- 32:33In terms of the video is going to be potentially one of the
- 32:36last companies to adopt it. They don't really have the
- 32:38urgency or need to, but companies like Metaplanet have
- 32:42seen wild success in adopting a Bitcoin treasury playbook.
- 32:45So gentlemen, what do you think about this announcement that
- 32:49just came out, I believe yesterday or today rather?
- 32:53Yeah, it just seems like, seems like every day there's a new
- 32:55announcement about some sort of corporate adoption, whether
- 32:59it's, you know, something like this launching A subsidiary or
- 33:03all these the SPAC deals that we've seen with 21 capital.
- 33:06And you know, I know there's a number of other ones in the
- 33:09works. It seems like there's a, you
- 33:12know, at the margins, at least, as you know, this is not a
- 33:14widespread phenomenon just yet, but at the margins, it does seem
- 33:19like there's, you know, people scrambling to, to get Bitcoin
- 33:23in, in a vehicle that is accessible to public markets
- 33:26effectively. And so I think, you know, you
- 33:29know, if we're first pitch, first inning, whatever it is,
- 33:32like I, I think we're just scratching the surface of, of
- 33:34companies attempting to do this. I think one thing we've also
- 33:37talked about is like, you know, while this, while this broadens
- 33:42the landscape, broadens the access for people with a
- 33:46brokerage account, people that you know, aren't necessarily
- 33:49ready to manage private keys or hold the underlying.
- 33:53That's all well and good. But I think the reality is, you
- 33:57know, people are going to wake up in five years and not
- 33:59necessarily want proxy exposure through a levered vehicle.
- 34:04And so I think it's going to be very interesting to see how it
- 34:07plays out. We we talked with Pierre Rashard
- 34:09last week about this and you know, our question to him was
- 34:13kind of like, is there a, is there a level of saturation?
- 34:15Do we need all of these public companies that are basically
- 34:19Bitcoin proxy leverage exposure? Is there a point at which, you
- 34:25know, the market just doesn't need all these different
- 34:27vehicles? And does, you know, is there
- 34:29some economies of scale that just lead all the capital to
- 34:33flow towards strategy predominantly?
- 34:36Ted, I'm curious your view there like it, you know, because we're
- 34:39seeing more and more of this in your view, do do sort of public
- 34:43market investors need all of these different options?
- 34:45Is it, is it, you know, there's obviously going to be
- 34:47differences, right, like leverage ratios, how much risk
- 34:50they're taking. So, so there's sort of like a
- 34:53different, you know, different flavors of these things.
- 34:55But is in your mind, is there a saturation point where like the
- 34:58market's like, all right, we don't, we don't need all these
- 35:00Bitcoin treasury companies. Well, they all have the same.
- 35:03Well, let me step back. If they're all shells or
- 35:09approximately shells, I mean, obviously sailors got a 500
- 35:12million software business in it, but it's a, but they're
- 35:15essentially shells. Then the question is how do they
- 35:19differentiate themselves And any market where you have a whole
- 35:24bunch of competitors that have very low levels of
- 35:26differentiation to me is not something that's an exciting
- 35:29investment. And so when I look at it, I say
- 35:35with respect to strategy, stroke micro strategy that has and you
- 35:39said it Brian, you said they've got huge scale, which you know a
- 35:44sailor doesn't buy into this thesis at least as far as I can
- 35:48see. But the huge scale will give
- 35:50them things to do other than Bitcoin per unit share going up
- 35:55in the future as that and ways to innovate around that, that I
- 35:58think will be tremendously important.
- 36:01The rest of them in order to differentiate themselves, they
- 36:04have to be doing something materially different.
- 36:06The thing that has me intrigued back to your point about
- 36:09Metaplanet, where we started on this is so in terms of their
- 36:15announcement, what I'm the story I'm going to tell you may be
- 36:17entirely coincidence and I'm not being cute.
- 36:19I'm actually just entirely coincidence.
- 36:21So I've been eyeing Metaplanet for a couple of days thinking,
- 36:24you know, I, I really like the way it's moving.
- 36:26It might be fun to put some something for the kids in there.
- 36:29So I called JP Morgan yesterday and I said I'd like to buy
- 36:33Metaplanet. And interestingly, I'd tried
- 36:36them about six weeks ago and at that time they were sort of
- 36:40talking about getting a stock in the Japanese exchange and I
- 36:43almost lost the will to live. I said, think about the
- 36:45paperwork. I'm, I'm not doing that.
- 36:47So then I, I saw that they have this MTPLF little OTC ticker now
- 36:53and it's like 2 bucks, 93 or something at the current trading
- 36:56price. And it's, by the way, if you
- 36:57look at the, it's moving up very nicely.
- 36:59And I think Simon's doing exciting things and you know,
- 37:02it's a higher beta option than strategy.
- 37:05Maybe a little bit around the edges.
- 37:06It'd be worth having putting some for the kids, you know, you
- 37:08never know. So I called JP Morgan yesterday,
- 37:11said can I have some MTPLF, and they looked it up on the screen
- 37:15and they said I got to call you back.
- 37:16They called compliance and they said it's an OTC stock, less
- 37:19than $5, we won't sell it to you flat out.
- 37:23So I sit there and I think, OK, well, maybe if I were Simon
- 37:27Grovich, I would say, well, I would want to be over here in
- 37:31the US with access to US capital and to make it really easy to
- 37:35people like Tad who want to buy some.
- 37:38Maybe this is coincidence, but there's your story.
- 37:42But they're separated entities, right?
- 37:43It's not like a feeder like a feeder.
- 37:45Fun like this is completely different because my
- 37:47understanding is metaplanet success comes from the arbitrage
- 37:50with that current market and all the other ancillary things like
- 37:52this would be fundamentally different.
- 37:53So be trading on its brand recognition a lot.
- 37:56I couldn't agree more and you have high expectations for the
- 38:00level of information I'm going to take in before I buy.
- 38:04Yeah, I think that's the interesting aspect of this.
- 38:07It always reminds me of the zero to one book.
- 38:09If if anybody has a monopoly, they never tell you it's a
- 38:12monopoly. And then if you don't have a
- 38:13monopoly, you always say you have a monopoly.
- 38:15And so Sailor saying that, you know, he doesn't really have a
- 38:17Moat is him telling you maybe he does have a Moat.
- 38:20It feels very Pareto distributed.
- 38:22There's going to be a large winner.
- 38:23I like the notion of that's been thrown around as like a, you
- 38:27know, strategy was the Immaculate Conception in the
- 38:29corporate treasury game. You can only do it once, but
- 38:32TBD. But to your point, it's hard for
- 38:34us to in good faith be excited about some of this stuff because
- 38:37it all looks the same and it's hard to tell somebody why don't
- 38:40you just buy spot BTC. But obviously for for Bitcoin
- 38:43and if it gives institutional capital a reason to to get
- 38:45exposure, it's good, but it's hard to see the return profile
- 38:48makes sense and. By the way, it's actually
- 38:51worthwhile not at this point in the cycle if you still believe
- 38:54there is a cycle, I do believe there's liquidity cycles.
- 38:57It's actually cause for concern. What do I mean when you have,
- 39:02call it X, more than a dozen, maybe 80, whatever the number of
- 39:07companies is, whose sole focus is to try to differentiate on
- 39:11providing some version of alpha with respect to a Bitcoin
- 39:15treasury strategy. And you can imagine that would
- 39:21be an invitation for the marginal person to be adding too
- 39:25much leverage, to be extending themselves too far, to put too
- 39:29much risk into the system for the hedge funds that are buying
- 39:32and and trading it, to be borrowing too much from their
- 39:34banks. All of it intensifies the level
- 39:38of both enthusiasm on the way up and the potential risk on the
- 39:41way down South. Look, I don't mean I'm bullish
- 39:46on these things. I think things at this point in
- 39:48cycle look very good. But this is a party with
- 39:53leveraged Bitcoin equity that is going to really be raucous.
- 39:56And you know, a little farther in the cycle, a little bit
- 39:59bubblier, a little bit more speculation, a little bit more
- 40:02parabolic curves on these assets, and you can bet your
- 40:04bottom dollar I'm a stand near the door.
- 40:07Yeah, I mean, you said this in a lot more sophisticated way than
- 40:09I have or will ever. But this is the sentiment I've
- 40:12been sharing internally and externally is I grew up with the
- 40:16understanding, you know every, you know, there's no such thing
- 40:20as a free lunch and money doesn't grow on trees.
- 40:22And ultimately if it also, you know, the marginal cost of
- 40:26production things trend to. And if you're printing money out
- 40:29of thin air to buy an underlying hard asset, ultimately that has
- 40:32to go back and mean revert and. As they say, you either run out
- 40:36of money or you run out of air, and neither one of them is good.
- 40:39Exactly. And then the the last part in
- 40:41all of that is more of this is kind of like bird's eye view.
- 40:45But historically in bitcoins 15 years, there's always been these
- 40:48centralized concentrations of the capital that are aggregated
- 40:51and then they kind of diffuse or disperse like it throughout.
- 40:55And we never know where the assets go, but they're always
- 40:57just gone, right. You have FTX, you have blocked
- 40:59by your Celsius, you have all these things, you never really
- 41:00know who's holding them. And you know, not to get
- 41:03conspiratorial, but it's just always like funny because we're
- 41:05always like blame it on the underlying, but we never know
- 41:08where the actual, you know, there's a lot of people holding
- 41:10paper BTC that have been waiting for claims for three years.
- 41:13And what you just described is kind of a proxy for that where
- 41:16you have 10 different entities absorb a lot of BTC.
- 41:19They blow up the BTC goes somewhere and disperses, but you
- 41:22never really you're going to point to the like the animal
- 41:24spirit. So you're never going to point
- 41:25behind the strategy. And so there's just a lot of, I
- 41:29think a lot of wisdom in what you're sharing that the market
- 41:30should pay attention to because we're going to get into the
- 41:33animal spirits again as liquidity increases and people
- 41:35are going to forget previous cycles, you know, cautions.
- 41:39Like Michael, you're exactly right.
- 41:40I mean, we, we forget the Fed in terms of liquidity right now is
- 41:44basically tight. I mean, it continues to be
- 41:47tight. I'm not talking about
- 41:49necessarily the rates, although I happen to believe they're too
- 41:51high and I'm entitled my opinion.
- 41:53Jay Powell actually runs the show.
- 41:54It doesn't matter what my opinion is.
- 41:56But I also think liquidity is a bit tight and the liquidity
- 41:58you're seeing around the world is mostly not US liquidity
- 42:01except insofar as the dollars rolling over and the yields on
- 42:03the tenure a little lower because of growth expectations
- 42:05changing. The reason I say that is it's
- 42:08been a while since we had a really, really RIP roaring
- 42:12parabolic move. And we've, you know, it's easy
- 42:18to say we've forgotten. I mean that little thing we had
- 42:22last in the fourth quarter of last year and that was nothing
- 42:25compared to what this thing could do.
- 42:26When the when the Fed, I mean the Fed starts printing dollars,
- 42:29the whole world wants dollars. And when it starts printing
- 42:31dollars, like really printing dollars, we've had an unusually
- 42:35long period of tough, tight money relatively for the Fed,
- 42:40we're going to forget those animal spirits are going to be
- 42:42explosive, and it'll be. Exactly the moment where we
- 42:45don't want to, you know, where we don't.
- 42:46Want to leave the party? And to throw more gasoline on
- 42:49that, now you have a friendly administration and regulatory
- 42:51environment to digital assets. And so you're just throwing, you
- 42:55know, like a dynamite or whatever the analogy be on top
- 42:57of the, the, the, you know, building on fire.
- 42:59And it's just going to be a pretty It'll be fun for a while.
- 43:04I mean, a perfect example strategy then MicroStrategy was
- 43:08a heck of a lot easier to sell at $400.00 than it was at
- 43:13$544.00 last November. What do I mean, it's at $544.00
- 43:20even though it's gone up a hundred $150.00.
- 43:22And like, what was it a week? I mean, you guys would know
- 43:25it's, it says the FOMO sense is overwhelming.
- 43:29OK, now's the time to sell. It's just hard, really hard.
- 43:33It's a lot easier at 400. And you know, it sounds kind of
- 43:35a yawn. In fact, what is it, 396 or
- 43:37something today? It's easy to buy and sell today,
- 43:39even on the day of earnings. So, and that's the mindset.
- 43:45Ted, do you have any thoughts on just we didn't talk at all about
- 43:48sovereign accumulation of Bitcoin or mining or what I'm
- 43:53gener, I'm generally just curious to hear your thoughts.
- 43:55We talked a little bit about institutional adoption, but we
- 43:58haven't talked much about sovereign central banks.
- 44:01I think it's incredibly early for that, but I would love to be
- 44:04wrong about it. I think it'd be interesting to
- 44:07see what happens if the US moves forward with starting to
- 44:11accumulate Bitcoin in more of a budget neutral manner.
- 44:15But what are your general thoughts just in terms of like,
- 44:18I guess my question would be, what do you make of the 1st 100
- 44:20days or so in terms of the US policy with Bitcoin and digital
- 44:24assets? And then what are your thoughts
- 44:26through the end of 2025 then however many months, that is
- 44:29seven months or so on U.S. policy, but then also just
- 44:34sovereign game theory around this asset class?
- 44:38So I would characterize the first 100 days of policy by this
- 44:42administration with respect to Bitcoin and the strategic
- 44:47reserve, which is let's stay narrowly focused on that for
- 44:49just a minute or sovereign accumulation.
- 44:51I think of Bitcoin strategic reserve as appropriately sober.
- 44:57And what I mean by that is they've launched a study.
- 45:01Six months is a good period of time for a study.
- 45:04I think they're actually really thinking it through.
- 45:07There are all sorts of dynamics for the world's reserve currency
- 45:10leader to think about a Bitcoin reserve.
- 45:13It's easy to announce the intention.
- 45:15One they didn't go into. The sort of.
- 45:19They didn't do a self immolation of printing dollars to buy
- 45:22Bitcoin without taxpayer support, without the extra
- 45:25education, all these different things.
- 45:27They're thinking it through and they're proceeding cautiously.
- 45:29In the meanwhile, they are galloping on the stablecoin
- 45:33legislation, which has clear and present benefits for the US
- 45:35dollar and the US Treasury bill situation.
- 45:38And they are actively working toward some version of what we
- 45:41call the Fit 21, which is the financial market restructuring
- 45:45or structuring, so people will know what a token is and clarify
- 45:49which regulatory agencies make sense.
- 45:52So for me, the fact they've queued the strategic Bitcoin
- 45:55Reserve carefully and thoughtfully, they're not slow
- 45:58walking it because they're actively moving along on it, in
- 46:00my opinion. But it's appropriate that it
- 46:03goes slower than the other two. And now that's a slightly
- 46:08different answer than countries that are in the back to the
- 46:12sailor quote, the young and the desperate.
- 46:16The young and the desperate are really all about Bitcoin.
- 46:19And you can think about what countries in the world are both
- 46:22either young or desperate. And in those instances, as long
- 46:26as the IMF in particular makes it hard for them to adopt
- 46:31Bitcoin, then you could imagine a world where those things where
- 46:35those countries are in effect doing some version of a
- 46:38strategic Bitcoin reserve. But what's more likely for them,
- 46:41honestly, what do they really want?
- 46:42What they really want is stable coins.
- 46:44What they really want is the US dollar and to be on the US and
- 46:47have U.S. dollar currency pegged, in my opinion.
- 46:50So stable coins will be good for them.
- 46:52So I don't see in the near term a lot of countries adopting it
- 46:59except with respect to what I would call the US dollar
- 47:03adversaries. As a hedge example, if I'm in
- 47:08China or I'm in Russia or I'm in a place where I'm concerned
- 47:11about the long term ability of my ability to use the US dollar
- 47:14in any capacity with the recent weaponization of the dollar.
- 47:17I'm not trying to say any political, I'm just saying the
- 47:21Biden administration put in place is pretty tough sanctions
- 47:23for Russia after the Ukraine invasion of the use of the
- 47:25dollar. I've now if I'm a country that
- 47:27is often adverse to the United States interests, I would
- 47:31certainly be buying gold for the reason that we said and I would
- 47:35potentially quietly be accumulating Bitcoin, Bitcoin.
- 47:41And the reason is it's almost a call option on the future
- 47:43reserve system. You're not sure how it's going
- 47:45to play out, but the one thing you can pretty much guess is
- 47:49that Bitcoins going up and the more of those you have, the more
- 47:55power you'll have, the more seats you'll have at the table
- 47:57to figure out what the final monetary world's going to look
- 47:59like. So that was a long winded way,
- 48:01but I hope it was helpful. Yeah, I think, I think this kind
- 48:05of underpins some of that. This chart recently came out, I
- 48:08think Incrementum put it together, but it's showing close
- 48:11to $325 trillion in global debt money supply and then ultimately
- 48:17hard assets, gold and Bitcoin only make up 5% of that.
- 48:20And so in a world full of debt and counterparty or potential
- 48:22counterparty risk, specifically around adversaries, IE, you
- 48:26know, Russia and Treasuries, you may want possession being 9/10
- 48:31of the law. If you take delivery of that,
- 48:33you're hedging yourself out from the counterparty risk of a, you
- 48:36know, the US dollar or corporate bonds or bonds.
- 48:39And so I think this is part of that stacking.
- 48:42I never thought of the, there's an interesting aspect you
- 48:44mentioned about the IMF and that kind of ties into what we've
- 48:48talked about as a little inorganic in the hash rate.
- 48:50Like post the past 24 months, it's kind of really, I mean,
- 48:53it's gone insanely parabolic where it's been rumored, you
- 48:56know, that certain countries are mining with nuclear energy.
- 48:59And that would be a very kind of like subtle way to start
- 49:03establishing a reserve without actually buying in the open
- 49:06market by leveraging natural resources.
- 49:08And that goes back to the the hungry and young countries are
- 49:11probably already doing this today, some in Latin America and
- 49:13some in the Middle East, by the way, all of this.
- 49:17At both your point and my point, my point more so than yours
- 49:20which is more forward-looking even than mine.
- 49:23All of this is a, call it a medium term answer, medium term
- 49:28being sort of five years. Because at the rate of AI and
- 49:32agentic transactions and the use of agentic AI to conduct
- 49:37e-commerce and deal with currencies, the dollar, some non
- 49:43digital version of currency isn't going to cut it.
- 49:45And in that world, again, what I would want to do is I'd want to
- 49:50have some Bitcoin, which is the perfect digital form of capital
- 49:54if I'm a country or sovereign nation, just to make sure
- 49:57everything comes out OK for my people.
- 50:01Yeah, it's if you're a sovereign nation by the name of Italy.
- 50:04Apparently we're concerned about Bitcoin.
- 50:07I saw this. I saw this article today.
- 50:12It was the Bank of Italy talking about pretty much saying that
- 50:15they don't like the pro Bitcoin, pro crypto stance that the Trump
- 50:20administration has taken, citing that Bitcoin and crypto assets
- 50:25with their high price volatility pose meaningful risk to
- 50:28investors. They also somewhere in this
- 50:30article as well, it was I believe Italy, maybe France as
- 50:33well, didn't necessarily like the idea of pro dollar dominance
- 50:37via stable coins. So Ted, do you, do you think
- 50:41that this is, is this related at all to the trade wars, trade
- 50:45alliances? Do you see like how do you see,
- 50:48I guess the EU in terms of adoption of Bitcoin digital
- 50:53assets, stable coins? Do you think that the dollar is
- 50:57going to consume more of that market in global trade via
- 51:00stable coins? Or do you think that we're going
- 51:02to see more fragmentation because there's just like this
- 51:04battle between, there's just been this ongoing battle of D
- 51:08dollar, D dollarization or not? Yeah, there's a great book, Hat
- 51:14Tip to Marc Andreessen, published in 2014 by a guy named
- 51:18Martin Gurri GURRI called The Revolt of the Public.
- 51:22And the central thesis of it is the traditional way to think
- 51:25about politics has always been wrong for quite a it's been
- 51:28flawed. And the way to better think
- 51:30about it is there are those who believe that the power of the
- 51:35center needs to retain control over all aspects of what a
- 51:39system or social system or economic system do.
- 51:42And the other is the periphery of that system trying to pull
- 51:45power back to the people, to the populace.
- 51:49It's exactly the reason I, I say that as a framing device is
- 51:53Europe is the epitome of the center.
- 51:56They are all about a monstrous bureaucracy in Belgium.
- 52:00And even when they're not operating as a monstrous
- 52:02bureaucracy in Belgium, telling everybody what to do, their
- 52:05countries are little versions of Belgium that are telling
- 52:07everybody what to do. So this is exactly the opposite
- 52:10of the sort of philosophy that you have that is sort of Bitcoin
- 52:14oriented, frankly, right, which is Bitcoin is all about the
- 52:17periphery. It's giving people power, it's
- 52:18giving people autonomy. It's giving people libertarian
- 52:21freedom. It's giving them choice.
- 52:23That is exactly what Europe does not want you to have.
- 52:28What they want you to have is no longer fall, fall in line.
- 52:33They want you to be a good citizen.
- 52:35They want you to go forth and within the framework of their
- 52:38controls, create great tech companies if you can and, and,
- 52:42and employ people and they want you to have a happy life and
- 52:46good for them. That's a totally different way
- 52:47to approach it. But is it any surprise that the
- 52:52bureaucrats don't want Bitcoin anywhere near them?
- 52:58The last thing, the last thing the European Central Bank wants
- 53:01is a population of 300 + 1,000,000 people running around
- 53:05with Bitcoin or Satoshi's. Because you don't have enough
- 53:07Bitcoin for that. But you know what I mean, A
- 53:08bunch of SAT's. They don't want you stacking
- 53:10SAT's. That makes all sorts.
- 53:12That makes their life a lot easier, a lot more difficult.
- 53:15So to add what Ted said, they want you to do all that also
- 53:18with no power. Depending on what?
- 53:20Country. Yeah.
- 53:21No power? Exactly.
- 53:22Exactly. Yeah, so, you know, look, Europe
- 53:26has wonderful qualities to it. It has the most amazing people
- 53:30in the world. It's one of the greatest museums
- 53:32on earth, if not the greatest museum on earth.
- 53:34It's a fence house. It's incredibly creative people.
- 53:37I'd rather eat food in Europe any day.
- 53:39But I I prefer our policies to theirs for sure.
- 53:42Hi everyone, I hope you're enjoying the podcast.
- 53:44Ted was a riot. We're looking forward to having
- 53:46them on other other episodes. Quick word from on ramp.
- 53:51Obviously, you may all know that we provide multi institution
- 53:53custody, which you might not know is that we offer a whole
- 53:55suite of financial services across the board.
- 53:58Maybe you're not ready to onboard, but your friends or
- 54:00family might need a trusted counterparty that provides then
- 54:03Peace of Mind as they're buying Bitcoin or need access to loans,
- 54:06tax advantage accounts via IRA's or just the ability to get
- 54:10access to our private client services so they can get white
- 54:12glove treatment, virtual family office access to private equity
- 54:16exposure in the Bitcoin ecosystem.
- 54:18If any of that's appealing, please feel free to shoot them a
- 54:21note, share this podcast with them or our website.
- 54:24And as a quick reminder, if you like and subscribe to our
- 54:27YouTube channel and via your favorite podcasting app, it goes
- 54:30a long way for people to find the the high signal in the
- 54:32space. Where do we go from here?
- 54:35So we've been recording for close to an hour now.
- 54:40I don't know if any of you guys wanted to flag some topics we
- 54:44didn't cover already. There was the Charles Schwab
- 54:46CEO, which could be interesting. But yeah, Michael, go ahead.
- 54:50Yeah, before going in transition, I think any topics
- 54:53that like rattle off a lot of the public market stuff that's
- 54:56going on, I think Galaxy they're filed is coming or is is filing
- 54:59to come to the US Schwab announcing I think getting a
- 55:03little bit louder about the launching crypto trading.
- 55:08There's a few others on the banking side, I think rumoured
- 55:12potentially Ripple. I think Ripple's been rumoured
- 55:15almost by everyone. But with Circle there's a lot of
- 55:17like at the highest level of finance positions or the table
- 55:22being set for what people are setting up for this new
- 55:24administration, the liquidity flow coming in.
- 55:27So I think Tad or anybody just chat a little bit about that
- 55:30because I think it's the complete opposite side of what
- 55:34we just talked about with Europe in the sense that something we
- 55:36talked about for weeks that we know we're coming into an
- 55:39inflationary environment. People need to hold hard assets
- 55:42if they're going to come outside of that and have, you know,
- 55:44purchasing power to buy things. And I think the US knows that
- 55:47and that's part of this new strategic version of getting
- 55:49Bitcoin in everyone's, you know, IRA or ETF or just spot.
- 55:54So it's it is promising to see the innovators in the highest
- 55:58levels of finance trying to embrace that.
- 56:00But also just curious on where the risk lies or who's doing it
- 56:03right, who's not? Well, I think it's going to be
- 56:06for me a, a pattern of let's experiment and innovate and if
- 56:13it works, keep doing a little bit more of it, keep doing a
- 56:15little bit more of it, keep doing a little bit more of it.
- 56:17And if it doesn't work, adjust. I'd rather see that which I
- 56:21think is a very sustained. It's a little, it's like the
- 56:23difference between a melt up in the stock market or in the
- 56:26crypto market or Bitcoin market rather than a parabolic move.
- 56:30I don't think we need parabolic moves.
- 56:32We needed to roll some bad things back parabolically, you
- 56:35know, swiftly and they did that. But now in terms of innovating
- 56:38going forward, I think we can move at a healthy pace.
- 56:41And I think a Galaxy coming here is terrific.
- 56:44Novogratz is great. I think he's got a great firm.
- 56:46I think all of those adjustments are make sense.
- 56:49The one thing I would say, which you didn't mention, Michael, if
- 56:53I May, is by the time this podcast comes out, but at this
- 56:58moment, we're still 2 hours or one hour and 53 minutes from the
- 57:01close today and tonight is strategies earnings.
- 57:05And we do have Tim Kotzman on the phone on the.
- 57:07Don't you think we ought to get him to commit himself right now
- 57:10before the earnings come out about how that's going to go and
- 57:12what's going on? Don't you think?
- 57:14I think so. Yeah, I think we ought to ask
- 57:16the maestro, what's your prediction, Tim?
- 57:19When this is aired tomorrow, they're going to be able to
- 57:21listen to this and then look at the screen and what are they
- 57:24going to see? What do you think?
- 57:26They're going to see AV shape recovery like every single time
- 57:30with Bitcoin, with MSTR, right? You'll have the curse Dales and
- 57:34the Peter shifts of the world posting their posts, and then
- 57:38you'll see the the after hours and tomorrow morning the price
- 57:43trying to to tank and then just ripping right back up.
- 57:47I mean it just a tail. The last big one time meaning
- 57:51the last the last big one was. Wasn't his 21 + 21 plan back in
- 57:56November if I'm not mistaken? Do you think we're going to get
- 58:00a $21 billion ATM at the equity or is he going to double down
- 58:03and go for more? Yeah, I was going to say 21 at a
- 58:05minimum. Wouldn't be shocked to see 42 or
- 58:10whatever 42 * 2 is or $121 million. 2 * 2 is if he actually
- 58:15does an $84 billion equity issuance at the market.
- 58:20That may be a V, but my prediction is it'll be a deep
- 58:22one. Yeah, yeah.
- 58:24Or $121 billion ATM. I think anythings on the table.
- 58:29So it'd be interesting to see what happens at 5:00 PM Eastern
- 58:32Standard Time. I'm sure you can find watch it
- 58:36on your own or find a group on social media that's doing a
- 58:39watch party. That's how big this is.
- 58:43What Tim, give us some insights into what's going on in that
- 58:46that world? This is something that I
- 58:48personally don't follow as close.
- 58:50I know the conference is coming up in the next couple days.
- 58:53You got different derivatives. There's the MSTY, you know, the
- 58:57other publicly trade, I guess maybe on that, what's going on,
- 59:01but also what's the sentiment like with an E21 launch and how
- 59:05do people feel about that, you know, from a flow perspective
- 59:09and interest from that segment of the market, the true North
- 59:11market? Well, we had an awesome true
- 59:15North call last night, invite everybody to go watch that.
- 59:19Dan in particular was kind of on fire with like just different
- 59:23theories and even mentioning Joe Burnett, I think actually came
- 59:28up with this idea of if you think that strategy does not
- 59:31actually own any Bitcoin, then you can like sort the stock, but
- 59:36long something else. And like it was a very
- 59:40interesting way to basically still get 10% and be hedged in
- 59:45case strategy doesn't have any Bitcoin, right, which we we
- 59:48believe they do have a lot of Bitcoin as of this morning.
- 59:54I think the what is it? Cantor Equity Partners is like
- 59:575.2 XM NAV. So that's an interesting story.
- 1:00:03Last night I kind of lost my cool little bit and said, look,
- 1:00:05we can stop, stop talking about GameStop until they actually put
- 1:00:10Bitcoin on their balance sheet, right?
- 1:00:12It's a little too much Free Press.
- 1:00:13The vibe is off in my opinion there.
- 1:00:16And yeah, there was there was something else that I'm missing.
- 1:00:23Conference coming up. Oh yeah, the the conference, the
- 1:00:26first ever true North World on Cinco de Mayo.
- 1:00:29So Monday, that'll be a lot of fun.
- 1:00:32So that we'll have about it's sold out.
- 1:00:34I think about 150 people. We have like a whole page full
- 1:00:40of sponsors. Of course the sponsor ticket was
- 1:00:42only 500 bucks, but you know, when you see UTXO and Deloitte
- 1:00:48and these other names up there, you're like, all right, we're
- 1:00:52we're in business, you know, as far as just, you know, getting
- 1:00:56to know people and and so that'll be basically a four hour
- 1:00:59podcast live, right, 12 to 4, then the strategy party, then
- 1:01:04the True North Party. So that'll be a lot of fun.
- 1:01:08Yeah, I'm hearing from people that people are just, you know,
- 1:01:12coming into next week in Orlando, very business minded,
- 1:01:15right? People are all the things that
- 1:01:18you've touched on so far in the show.
- 1:01:20They're they're looking to raise capital, they're looking to
- 1:01:24build relationships. They're looking to, I mean
- 1:01:28everything from building a business to trying to get a job
- 1:01:30to trying to get on a board. I mean, it's like up and down
- 1:01:35and all around just people really getting in position for I
- 1:01:40think what's about to happen. So I think that's super
- 1:01:44interesting. I think the what you guys were
- 1:01:49talking about a little bit earlier, maybe it's not
- 1:01:56attractive from an investment standpoint for the 500th Bitcoin
- 1:02:01Treasury company, but it's probably it's still interesting
- 1:02:05to them if they are the web design company and the only one
- 1:02:11that's putting Bitcoin on their balance sheet.
- 1:02:13The interview I put out yesterday on the Treasury's pod
- 1:02:16is actually literally that a web design company in the UKI think
- 1:02:21it's a $6 million business to go to the Bitcoin for corporations
- 1:02:24handled there. You know, they're doing
- 1:02:26announcements about adding two or three or four Bitcoin to
- 1:02:29their balance sheet. But if they're the market leader
- 1:02:31in that segment, what does that mean as the CAGR on Bitcoin goes
- 1:02:37down? Do they just dominate that
- 1:02:39sector and obviously just do whatever they want?
- 1:02:42But as an example, you know, maybe it's maybe it'll get an
- 1:02:47investing audience, maybe it won't.
- 1:02:52But a lot of what we talked about last night on True North
- 1:02:54was, you know, if you're going to not buy more Bitcoin or more
- 1:02:59MSTR shares and you're going to allocate to something further
- 1:03:05out the risk curve or or with a different risk profile, it's
- 1:03:08just something to be thoughtful on.
- 1:03:10And then quickly on the structured product front, if
- 1:03:14Bitcoin is the hurdle rate and Bitcoin is just the best
- 1:03:18performing asset for the foreseeable future, call it the
- 1:03:20next five years, the next 10 years.
- 1:03:25I think there is a place for all these products so that investors
- 1:03:29can become educated and analyze what's the best product and
- 1:03:35between a suite of products really build their their new
- 1:03:39portfolio of the sixty 40s on the way out and bitcoins on the
- 1:03:43way in. But you still have everyone
- 1:03:47having different needs. I think right, just dialing in
- 1:03:51those different volatility factors through these different
- 1:03:53structured products could be you know is very powerful and and
- 1:03:56will continue to be so. Yeah, 111 angle of that is, you
- 1:04:00know, if you add the President's son to your to your board, that
- 1:04:03could always help in the, you know, profile of the corporate
- 1:04:07strategy that that could be a differentiator.
- 1:04:11One of the the things I struggle with and by the way, I 99% agree
- 1:04:18with my buddy Tim here is if he and I happen to agree by the
- 1:04:23way, about the hurdle rate, which that's appropriate to use
- 1:04:26for people who in effect are selling Bitcoin to do something
- 1:04:29else, to invest in something else.
- 1:04:31When a company undertakes A leverage Bitcoin equity
- 1:04:34strategy, think about how the dynamic of how they allocate
- 1:04:38capital inside the company becomes.
- 1:04:41On the one hand, they can put capital into their Bitcoin
- 1:04:43treasury strategy, which is growing between 40 and 50% a
- 1:04:46year, depending on which internal rate of return you want
- 1:04:48to use. On the other hand, they can put
- 1:04:50it in, I don't know, a web design business or whatever else
- 1:04:53the other business is how many businesses in the world are
- 1:04:57delivering a consistent volatile but consistent internal rate of
- 1:05:04return at the rate of Bitcoin dot dot dot without doing any
- 1:05:09work. Think about that very few.
- 1:05:13So the moment, and this goes back to the NVIDIA point we
- 1:05:15made, the moment you bring Bitcoin into a treasury strategy
- 1:05:19from the perspective of a classic corporate machine.
- 1:05:23If capital within the corporation is being financed
- 1:05:26externally and then going to the most exciting investment
- 1:05:29projects, Bitcoin inside the machine will suck all of the
- 1:05:34capital out of all the other projects that don't perform at
- 1:05:38the level of Bitcoin. The treasury strategy by
- 1:05:41definition will eat the whole enterprise from the inside out.
- 1:05:45Now, if you aren't in the in that capital, if you were simply
- 1:05:48outside like investors, we all are, we already making that
- 1:05:51decision. Why would I want to invest in, I
- 1:05:53don't know, X Company, General Motors or Eli Lilly?
- 1:05:56I'll make one up when I could put it over here in Bitcoin.
- 1:06:00And that to me is a, for me, a higher return on capital.
- 1:06:04The same problem you're once you're inside a corporate hat,
- 1:06:07you have the same problem. So I find it very difficult to
- 1:06:10see that companies that have businesses other than the
- 1:06:13bitcoins treasury strategy, unless those businesses are the
- 1:06:17rare few on earth that are effectively money printing
- 1:06:19monopolies will be able to sustain A and grow a Bitcoin
- 1:06:24treasury strategy. If their capital allocation
- 1:06:26process is thoughtful. I don't see how it works.
- 1:06:29Yeah, Ted, I like you. You know, we haven't we hadn't
- 1:06:32met formally, but you effectively just described how
- 1:06:35we built this business on a Bitcoin standard and then we
- 1:06:38spun out a venture firm that's Bitcoin denominated.
- 1:06:41Tim is an advisor on. But it was with that exact
- 1:06:44understanding that when you look at every preference when you're
- 1:06:48building a business, from hiring to how you spend on ads or
- 1:06:50whatever underneath the sun, it's not to say it has to you
- 1:06:53don't spend the money because that's what it's for, but you
- 1:06:56need to make sure you're more discerning and the return on
- 1:06:59capital is higher. And the realization was that the
- 1:07:02incumbents have too much pork and fat built in.
- 1:07:05And so the people the firm's called early riders because the
- 1:07:08early adopters of the strategy are going to leave the firm
- 1:07:11because they they won't be listened to and then they come
- 1:07:13build with us on that standard. But when you build on that
- 1:07:16standard, you're inherently more efficient and you're going to
- 1:07:20out compete the others, not only because you hold a better form
- 1:07:22of money, but constraints are the design surface of the world.
- 1:07:26And so when you put constraints on yourself, you're going to
- 1:07:27come to the most efficient outcome.
- 1:07:29And that's how we actually rebuild.
- 1:07:31So that whole imploding happens. And in parallel, we're going to
- 1:07:33build on a better standard AI. And I love that, Yeah.
- 1:07:37That's awesome and and by the way, give it five more years and
- 1:07:40you can be sitting on the beach and your agentic AI can do it
- 1:07:43for you. The only other thing I would say
- 1:07:45for people who don't care about MicroStrategy but care a lot
- 1:07:47about Bitcoin, what my what Tim was talking about tonight is
- 1:07:52really important also because if Sailor comes in not 21 billion,
- 1:07:57but 42 billion or 84 billion or whatever billion it is that he
- 1:08:01does as an ATM, that is new demand for Bitcoin and not a
- 1:08:07little bit so up and to the right as Tim famously says.
- 1:08:15I guess I'm going to go to the beach for the next year.
- 1:08:17You're here to hear it. Make it a good beach.
- 1:08:21That's the advice. No financial advice today, but
- 1:08:23the only advice I have is making a good beach.
- 1:08:25I love it. One thing, Tad, that we do on
- 1:08:30every episode, There's actually two more things I want to do.
- 1:08:32I want to do quickly, the single point of failure of the week.
- 1:08:36And so I'll explain that in just a second.
- 1:08:37And then I want everyone to be prepared to have maybe a bullish
- 1:08:42and a bearish thing that they want to share just quickly and
- 1:08:45Tad, if you if you're interested and you want to would love to
- 1:08:48just hear a little bit more about your background if you
- 1:08:51have the time. So you think about if you want
- 1:08:55to do that or not. Why I just pull up the single
- 1:08:57point of failure of the week, which is here we go.
- 1:09:05Ledger confirms physical scam letters requesting seed phrase
- 1:09:08and fake security upgrade. So I actually think this ties
- 1:09:12into the Charles Schwab CEO interview of this week.
- 1:09:16So ultimately, Bitcoin is perceived to be uninvestable by
- 1:09:20many people still because of maybe they're not opening up the
- 1:09:25block, but they're opening up the Journal or Bloomberg and
- 1:09:28they're reading about the couple that loses $5 million of Bitcoin
- 1:09:32because they throw their hardware wallet out or they read
- 1:09:35headlines about FTX or whatever the next FTX will be blowing up.
- 1:09:40And this perception just plagues investors, both retail and
- 1:09:44institutional, because what's embedded in investing in Bitcoin
- 1:09:48is not necessarily, oh, I invest in Bitcoin and it goes to zero.
- 1:09:52I don't we all think it's not going to zero.
- 1:09:54I think we're long past those days.
- 1:09:56But what's even worse is I buy Bitcoin, I'm right about the
- 1:09:59investment thesis, but I mismanage the asset.
- 1:10:03And so ultimately it's probably worse to make the allocation and
- 1:10:06then and then one day not have the allocation anymore because
- 1:10:10you lost your device or you end up on the next FTXI think
- 1:10:14ultimately this ties into the Schwab news because the CEO said
- 1:10:19very confidently that they would be the premier firm for crypto
- 1:10:24or something along those lines. And so they would actually want
- 1:10:27to launch a spot Bitcoin and perhaps other crypto asset
- 1:10:31trading custody solution within the next 12 months.
- 1:10:34And the CEO mentioned that their clients trust Schwab, right?
- 1:10:39And so naturally, people may want to hold off on making an
- 1:10:43allocation into the space until they actually can work with a
- 1:10:46firm that they trust. And so this is something I don't
- 1:10:51think any of our audience would necessarily fall for a scam like
- 1:10:54this. But the unfortunate reality is a
- 1:10:56lot of people do. I think somewhere in this
- 1:10:58article it may have mentioned or might have been somewhere else,
- 1:11:02the amount that was scammed in similar manner last year, it
- 1:11:06might have been $12 billion of Bitcoin and crypto.
- 1:11:09So. It can I point, can I just pull
- 1:11:11something really quick up because it just basically it'll
- 1:11:13it'll make it more. This is similar from the block.
- 1:11:17This is unrelated. I mean, it's definitely related,
- 1:11:20but it's different incident. There was an elderly, elderly
- 1:11:23person. They probably weren't always
- 1:11:25elderly. Maybe when they bought this they
- 1:11:27were a little bit younger, but they lost $330 million in BTC.
- 1:11:32This was a phishing scam, I believe, or social engineering.
- 1:11:34I'm sorry, but it goes to Jackson's point that there's
- 1:11:38just a lot of education still coming into the space.
- 1:11:40Yeah, this was social engineering.
- 1:11:43And yeah, it just do your diligence.
- 1:11:45Make sure you know who your counterparties are and don't
- 1:11:47pick up the Google phones or the emails that get sent that say
- 1:11:50reset your password or I think yesterday I got hit with a, a
- 1:11:54firm, I won't mention the, the name of the firm, but it was
- 1:11:56like it was obviously a phishing e-mail and they said, you know,
- 1:12:00pull your assets off to like another wallet.
- 1:12:03The level of sophistication when it comes to hacking as this
- 1:12:06asset grows, we're only at 2 trillion today market cap for
- 1:12:08BTC. What happens when it's 5 or 10
- 1:12:10trillion? It's going to be the Wild West.
- 1:12:13So just be vigilant. Yeah, I I think that's good
- 1:12:18advice. I mean, you know, for me, it's a
- 1:12:21very real question about do I fear the sort of counterparty
- 1:12:27risk that I in in theory make myself immune to by cold storage
- 1:12:34on the one hand, or would I rather just have it at my, you
- 1:12:41know, in an ETF form at JP Morgan and know that I'm going
- 1:12:46to call them now, 1 is so analog and ancient and almost boomer
- 1:12:50that you got to laugh at it. But think about it.
- 1:12:52It's not so much that it's the relative level of security and
- 1:12:56it's and by the way, you don't even need to be hacked.
- 1:12:59It can just be an error. I'll tell you, I have been
- 1:13:02sitting on an e-mail literally for three weeks from Coinbase
- 1:13:05because Coinbase is taking their wallet where I have my NF TS and
- 1:13:09they want to merge the assets in that back into the Coinbase main
- 1:13:13app. And I got to tell you, this is
- 1:13:15just, I want to get in there and deal with this like I want
- 1:13:18another hole in the head. I, I know that I've got some,
- 1:13:20you know, I've got some nice NFTS there and I don't know how,
- 1:13:23you know, I'm going to send them back to this thing.
- 1:13:25This is just a total nightmare. I think one thing I know is I'm
- 1:13:27going to send them out of the wallet and they will not be in
- 1:13:30the Coinbase account. Wait and see.
- 1:13:32And this is not even a hack. So I, I look at that and I say
- 1:13:35security has many different dimensions depending on the
- 1:13:38cohort that we're talking about. And people that are absolutely
- 1:13:41fluid coders think cold storage is an absolute slam dunk and I'm
- 1:13:45a complete idiot. On the other hand, it's it's
- 1:13:49tricky, you really do. The cohorts are very sensitive
- 1:13:51to different aspects of security and so it's all around us.
- 1:13:55Is it Schrodinger's cat about it being alive?
- 1:14:00Is that and. By the way, the famous book that
- 1:14:02I also recommend, in addition to Revolt to the public, is called
- 1:14:04What Is Life? That he Wrote.
- 1:14:06It's about 120 pages long and it is extraordinary.
- 1:14:12What is it? Can you say that again?
- 1:14:14What is life? OK, so.
- 1:14:18We'll have to look that. Up the reason I brought that is
- 1:14:20because there's a 1.5 trillion, I know you guys or your firm's a
- 1:14:25very large investor in Ledger and this is where the majority
- 1:14:28of assets sitting at 1.5 trillion and folks that have
- 1:14:32like certain amount of assets will upgrade to our product.
- 1:14:35They usually diversify. So they'll park some in multi
- 1:14:37institution, but what's come up increasingly is like inheritance
- 1:14:43and all the things associated, they're like, no, I got it.
- 1:14:45Like I got it, but I need to do this for my wife or loved ones.
- 1:14:47Like, OK, but what's come up is they haven't touched the device
- 1:14:52in like 3 years or five years. And so generally, it's like, to
- 1:14:55your point, it's the last thing you want to do because you're
- 1:14:58always in sales, right? Competing with the status quo
- 1:15:00and status quo is just doing nothing.
- 1:15:02And I came up with this like, it's like Schrodinger's box in
- 1:15:05the sense of like, you don't know if the assets are still
- 1:15:07there. So if you don't touch it,
- 1:15:09they're still there in your mind, but you're afraid if you
- 1:15:11go touch it, they're not going to be there.
- 1:15:13And similar to your circumstantial like if I don't
- 1:15:15do anything, I think I'm good. But if I go do something now I
- 1:15:18can mess everything up and go to 0.
- 1:15:20And so that's been an interesting and and a shill for
- 1:15:23us. We help in that whole process,
- 1:15:24but it's just such a key thing. And you bought it at 10K, now
- 1:15:28it's 10 million and you're like, man, I don't want to deal with
- 1:15:30this. It's still there.
- 1:15:31If I don't touch it, it'll always be there.
- 1:15:34Yeah, it's I, I 100%. So in fact, the best place to
- 1:15:37keep my art, I think, is with Pascal, point of Ledger I, I, I
- 1:15:41think you're exactly right. But I just need to get it over
- 1:15:43there. And I fear, you know, all the
- 1:15:47sort of steps I need to go through to do it.
- 1:15:50And all I can see is my art disappearing and not being
- 1:15:53recoverable. So I'm terrified.
- 1:15:55Yeah. And so I know we're coming up on
- 1:15:57time, but this ties in a little bit of your background.
- 1:16:00I would love to hear a little bit of the Sotheby's journey in
- 1:16:02particular and how that led to digital assets if it did.
- 1:16:05And the main reason why is because in a different life, I
- 1:16:07worked for a high end auction company for a very small time
- 1:16:09and Heritage was the place we actually sent numismatic coins
- 1:16:13up in Dallas to. And so I was always familiar
- 1:16:15with Sotheby's and I kind of took an accelerated approach to
- 1:16:18Bitcoin because being younger, I collected like baseball,
- 1:16:21basketball cards and then Pokémon.
- 1:16:22So I knew scarcity. And once I heard 21 million and
- 1:16:24having to be in like the auction business for a little bit, it
- 1:16:27was like, well, of course this thing has value.
- 1:16:29It's just now you have to underwrite how much value it has
- 1:16:31and what happens to be almost everything.
- 1:16:33And was always wondering if that was a product of kind of what
- 1:16:36influenced your journey to understanding this space or
- 1:16:39whether it's something completely unrelated?
- 1:16:43Michael, you said it better than I could have there.
- 1:16:46There's literally not a ray of light between what you just said
- 1:16:50and and my journey. None.
- 1:16:53Yeah, yes, scarcity. I guess it's just the thing that
- 1:16:56makes us all tick. And then once you you get it.
- 1:16:58And now you just have to figure out how scarce is this thing and
- 1:17:00how much does everyone else want it.
- 1:17:01And if it's super scarce and everybody wants it, well, then
- 1:17:03there's value. And as you.
- 1:17:05Implied and as you implied and I was alluding to earlier, in
- 1:17:11parts of our economy or assets where they don't produce Fiat
- 1:17:15cash flow, narrative drives the price.
- 1:17:19So that's how you can sell a Picasso for $20 million, which
- 1:17:24is paint and canvas. It's the narrative.
- 1:17:28And by the way, you can have two Picasso's that look almost
- 1:17:30identical, and one will go for 20 and one will go for two.
- 1:17:33And what's the difference? The year they were painted?
- 1:17:36Narrative. You know what the kids call it
- 1:17:38these days? I like to it's, it's all vibes.
- 1:17:40You know, it's all vibes. You get masa, you get masa and
- 1:17:42you get some, some tether and you get some loud guys.
- 1:17:45And now you got the vibes for the next the next big thing.
- 1:17:49But they're right. I mean, we're think of us as a
- 1:17:52species. We're all about the vibe.
- 1:17:54We are so and, and by the way, anyone who invests on Wall
- 1:17:59Street and is very focused on the analyst reports and earnings
- 1:18:03and the PE, all that stuff, if they don't think those stocks
- 1:18:07are vibes, well then they haven't seen the list of the
- 1:18:10highest performing stocks in the first corner in the S&P 500,
- 1:18:13which as I recall, Palantir is right at the top.
- 1:18:16Yeah, You know, it's the strongest, strongest vibes is
- 1:18:19Tim Kotzman. He came on the scene and you
- 1:18:21know, the vibes just have been getting stronger week after
- 1:18:23week, him showing up. You know, my first talk with Tim
- 1:18:27Kotzman and this I'll never forget because it was November
- 1:18:305th, it was Election Day. So I've always, I've sort of got
- 1:18:33it always sort of logged into my mind.
- 1:18:35It was Election Day. So your life changed forever
- 1:18:37that day in more ways. Than so many ways Brian so many
- 1:18:42ways so yeah I have been the CEO of Sotheby's I sold that company
- 1:18:47I am a partner in one roundtable partners and 10 T holdings which
- 1:18:52as you noted before I'm the former CEO of Madison Square
- 1:18:54Garden and I've had a long career basically at the
- 1:18:57intersection of technology disruption and creative
- 1:19:00businesses and a whole range of things but honestly Michael, I
- 1:19:04couldn't improve one minute on your statement of how you came
- 1:19:07to Bitcoin mines exactly the same which is when you
- 1:19:10understand that value is what we say it is then it's very easy to
- 1:19:13see that a piece of code could have tremendous value so.
- 1:19:16You got it. Nice, you nailed it.
- 1:19:20Well, I guess we could wrap it. We I don't want to go over, we
- 1:19:23didn't do the bullish and bearish, but I also want to be
- 1:19:25respectful of everyone's time. No bearish takes this week,
- 1:19:28Jackson. We're back in the 90s.
- 1:19:30We're RIP roaring. I'll say world coin coming to
- 1:19:34the US, but we'll, we'll save that for, we'll save that for
- 1:19:37another, another time. The only reason I'm bearish, the
- 1:19:41only reason I'm bearish is because next week you're going
- 1:19:44to see some things that are going to make you even more
- 1:19:49bullish. I'll leave it at that.
- 1:19:53All right. You'll definitely leave it at
- 1:19:54that, Tim. The only reason Tim's bearish is
- 1:19:57because we're not bullish enough.
- 1:19:59I got it. Well, Tad, thank you so much for
- 1:20:01joining us this week. It was a lot of fun.
- 1:20:03I really enjoyed it guys. Thank you.
- 1:20:04Appreciate it. Thank.
- 1:20:05You all, it's a pleasure to be here.
- 1:20:07Yeah, this was a lot of fun. Thank you.
- 1:20:09Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:20:12If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:20:14episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:20:17app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:20:18today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:20:21Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Rat Media is
- 1:20:24for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:20:26nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:20:30Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:20:32to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact
- 1:20:36to schedule a consultation with one of our private client
- 1:20:38advisors.