Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Bad Therapists & Rational Suicide
Transcript
- 0:00So, Bob, I have a bunch of emails. What do you say?
- 0:02Lightning round? Lightning round? Middle tier patron and YouTube member Eliza from
- 0:09Portland. She says, I've noticed lately that when I receive mail from a
- 0:14company or a phone call from an unknown number, I often have a physical
- 0:19dread reaction. You're nodding your head. What does that nod mean by?
- 0:24I think this is pretty common. Yeah, do you have that? No,
- 0:28I don't get dread when the phone rings, and I don't get dread
- 0:30when I get mail. But I have heard of this, and I think
- 0:33it's amplified since the pandemic. Why because we all isolate? Yeah, and
- 0:38so I think we're just scared of contact. Yeah, yeah, going on,
- 0:43I think when this happens, When this happens, I think, uh
- 0:47oh am, I in trouble, which doesn't really make sense. I'm wondering
- 0:51if that knee jerk response points towards a particular schema. When I notice it,
- 0:57it seems like a blinking neon sign pointing to a in my worldview,
- 1:00I'd love to hear what you think about this. So what do you think,
- 1:03Bob? Yeah, that sounds like a plausible explanation for getting scared when
- 1:08you get a phone call from a strange number. How much of your life
- 1:14is it affecting? Like, in an average day, are you living in
- 1:17fear? Do you ever have worry thoughts that you're gonna get a call or
- 1:22a piece of mail? Right, So, I'm just wondering how big an
- 1:26impact on your day it has. And if you're writing us, I'm imagining
- 1:30it's somewhat sizy. So I'm sorry about the suffering you're in. It's treatable,
- 1:37you know, It's just a phobic thing. Phobia is actually, if
- 1:40you have to have something man in the psych realm, phobia is like the
- 1:44best thing to have because the treatments are really fast and they work really well.
- 1:48So what would they do? Exposure therapy, which is basically a graduated
- 1:52and mindful exposure to the thing. And it's kind of like telling a joke.
- 1:57If I tell you a joke, if it's a good joke, you'll
- 1:59laugh the first time, and if I tell it to you a hundred times,
- 2:01by the end, you're just bored with it. Exposure therapy worked very
- 2:06similarly. That's a great analogy. I've never heard that. I'm gonna steal
- 2:08that from right on. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So anyways, when
- 2:13people do good exposure, the ultimately become bored by the what used to be
- 2:19a trigger. Yeah, I used to have this about ten years ago regarding
- 2:23phone calls, because I was going through a time when maybe one out of
- 2:27every twenty phone calls was a difficult emotional experience for me, and so it
- 2:32just became generalized to anyone calling that my heart rate would start to increase.
- 2:38Was it me, You're afraid of me? Yeah? No, it was
- 2:40a work related And that might've even been longer than ten years ago. And
- 2:46I noticed that that I'd become jumpy when the phone would ring. And it's
- 2:52a rational response to any irrational situation that if it sticks with you through times
- 3:00when it doesn't make sense, then the irrational harm that you went through is
- 3:06now being echoed into the future unfairly to you. And so you deserve to
- 3:09go through exposure, and you don't have to get a therapist for it.
- 3:14Necessarily you can, but if you understand the principles and are good at regulating
- 3:20your emotions and taking care of yourself, then that graduated mindful exposure will typically
- 3:25work on your neurons such that you don't have that reaction. You can also
- 3:30work on your automatic thoughts in the meantime, you know, the cognitive therapy
- 3:35side. Middle tier patron Joscelyn G. Good old Joscelyn G. She writes,
- 3:39She writes in a lot. She writes in and says, Hi,
- 3:43Kerk and Bob, you were both in a recent dream of mine. The
- 3:46dream was set in the future and in multiple universes. This is neat.
- 3:53I must have lived millions of lives in this dream. The people in the
- 3:58dream that these dreams I'll have sometimes and my wife Stacey will almost always say,
- 4:04how do you remember so many details about your dreams? Do you?
- 4:08Can you remember a lot of details about unless it's unless I'm just waking up.
- 4:13I can remember lots of details of dreams. Sometimes. That's fantastic.
- 4:17I don't think everyone has that. Now. The people in the dream were
- 4:21me, the director, Kirk and Bob so just chamming in. I don't
- 4:27know what she means by the director, but it's capitalized, so maybe it's
- 4:31some sort of like God or something. I don't know. So Joscelyn G.
- 4:36The director, me and you and the dream our objective in the dream
- 4:43was to find all timelines where I reached a certain safe house. By the
- 4:47way, this is sounding like low key second season. Oh yeah, did
- 4:50you watch it? I did? Did you like it? I did?
- 4:54I like first season better, but yeah, me too, Me too.
- 4:58I'm really digging Showgun though the mini series I have not started it yet.
- 5:02Is it all published now? No? I think the penultimate episode was released
- 5:08today. So our objective in the dream was to find all timelines where I
- 5:13reached a certain safe house. Reaching the safe house was very important. The
- 5:17safe house was pure procured why is that hard for me to say, procured
- 5:23by the director at great risk. She would deliver me to the safe house
- 5:30in each timeline where I agreed to go with her. Kirk and Bob were
- 5:33charged with hosting me in the safe house once I arrived. Each time,
- 5:38I spent weeks living with Kirk and Bob until it was time to leave.
- 5:43I wonder what we did to entertain ourselves during that time to pass the time
- 5:46podcasting sections of the house were in disarray. Bob would express how displeased he
- 5:55was with the state of its construction. In particular, Oh my god,
- 6:00it sounds like me. He expressed frustration over how the wooden parts in elaborate
- 6:06closets were shoddy, and he would frequently walk me through his detailed plans for
- 6:13fixing each section. How boring. Yeah, are you sure this was a
- 6:16dream? I remember feeling like he was spending an inordinate amount of time being
- 6:23frustrated with the way the house was built, but he never actually worked on
- 6:28any of the areas. Oh that's a fascinating image. Whenever I try to
- 6:30support Bob and encourage him to follow through with his plans, he would become
- 6:34unresponsive. I would give him a hug to try to bring him back into
- 6:40the present, but it didn't help. Just chiming in. What do you
- 6:44think about this? How does Joscelyn G see you? Oh? Well,
- 6:54I'd say that I am in this dream a critical inner voice, and the
- 7:00house the safe house is you know, you could say it's her heart or
- 7:04her soul, and for some reason there's a part of her that criticizes and
- 7:12isn't it at least ostensibly isn't interested in change or getting things better, just
- 7:18bitching and moaning and overly focused on the minutia as opposed to taking any really
- 7:26substantial action. So maybe I'm the part of her that's scared going on.
- 7:31When the day finally came to leave the safe house, Kirk gave me a
- 7:36big hug and said it was time to go. He said going now was
- 7:42going to do a lot of good for a lot of people. So I
- 7:45hugged Kirk back and thanked him and Bob for taking care of me in the
- 7:48safe house so I could evade a vague threat. I remember stepping in and
- 7:53out of various modes of transportation until reaching a bright and futuristic world. Wow,
- 7:59sounds like an amazing Just what a dream. Cow, that's a great
- 8:03dream. Yeah, all right, let's stick a break, an early break.
- 8:05We get back more emails. What do you say? Yep, all
- 8:11right, we're back from the break. Let's do an opp here, Bobby
- 8:16G, Bobby G and Jocelyn G. Let's scroll down on my documentary.
- 8:24Okay, So these people became patrons at the end of twenty twenty one,
- 8:28and they are all from god knows where. We have Evelina, Wendy,
- 8:33Hillary, Divina, Divina, Heather, we have Foolia, Danielle, Paula,
- 8:41Leanna, Christy, Nina, Adina, Alison ai Or al, I'm
- 8:48not sure which one that is. Jeanette, Aaron, Rachel, Vicki,
- 8:52Susan Vaughan, Monica, Ronda. Ron is a great name because it's just
- 8:58one letter added to my last name of Honda. Oh that's right. And
- 9:01my sister had a best friend named Rhonda, and we thought it'd be funny
- 9:05if they got married because she'd be Randa Honda. Oh yeah, that's terrible,
- 9:09Samantha. You've all Jean Percy, Charles, Olivia, Pablo, Rebecca,
- 9:18Saul's, med Azy, Camilla, and Femke. Oh, good Oldfemke.
- 9:22I know you. Thank you for being a patron and staying at patrons
- 9:26through thick and thin. There was this lovely woman I went to college with.
- 9:31She was really friendly. I really liked her. Her name was Greta,
- 9:35and I often thought she should marry me. She could be Greta Gettle
- 9:39be terrible, all right. This next email is from middle tier patron and
- 9:48YouTube member Mary from Arizona. They write in a lot with some good questions.
- 9:54Hi, doctor Kirk and or Bob. As a child, I had
- 9:58a lot of behavior issues at home, shouting, disobedience, lying, etc.
- 10:03So as a child had a lot of behavioral issues. I was shouting,
- 10:07I was disobedient, I would lie, et cetera. And by abusive
- 10:11and mentally ill mother brought me to family therapy multiple times to fix me,
- 10:16but she regularly fired the therapists, and I think she sought out ones that
- 10:22would show signs of kind of transference with her. I would be abused after
- 10:26the session if I brought up anything that she felt made her look bad,
- 10:31and if I brought up anything that made me vulnerable, she would use it
- 10:35later to hurt me. Okay, So just summarizing here, Mary saying that
- 10:39the mom who was abusive and mentally ill would drag her into therapy and would
- 10:48and presumably the behavioral issues were in response to the parenting if it was abusive,
- 10:54right, and the kid was being scapegoaded dragged into therapy, and then
- 11:01the mom would fire the therapist. And presumably if the therapist wasn't playing ball
- 11:07or something, And if Mary brought up anything that made her look bad,
- 11:13then her mom would abuse her. Yeah, it's pretty awful. And if
- 11:16Mary said anything vulnerable or her mother would use it as ammo. Yeah,
- 11:20going on, I don't think any of them, any of the therapists ever
- 11:24had time to get the full picture. But I still find myself feeling a
- 11:28lot of resentments towards my therapists who intentionally or not made me feel like I
- 11:33was the problem and that I deserve to be abused. I think this lingering
- 11:37resentment still has an impact on my therapeutic relationships now. I feel like this
- 11:41lingering sense of suspicion. I feel a lingering sense of suspicion that if I
- 11:46admit to having done things like fighting with my mother as a child, my
- 11:50therapists are going to turn on me. I'm also just plain hurt about what
- 11:56happened. I feel like I tried to trust these professionals as a child.
- 12:00They just ended up being another part of the framework my mother constructed to protect
- 12:05her ability to abuse me. How can I bring this up with my current
- 12:09therapist in a way that respects the reality of how I feel about these past
- 12:13experiences without being completely unfair and unkind to all therapists out there, Bob,
- 12:18what do you think? I think you should just take this note in and
- 12:20read it to them wherever your therapist is. This is a really lovely note.
- 12:24It's you're very articulate, about what you're feeling and the pain that you're
- 12:31in, which you know really makes all the sense in the universe, and
- 12:35what your goal is, and your goal is some kind of healing, right,
- 12:39But you're concerned that your therapist will take it personally or something. I
- 12:43doubt they will, but maybe they will, but probably not. But you
- 12:48want it to go well. You want it to go well. So this
- 12:52is I think if you just took this letter and read it, if I
- 12:56was, if you were my client, I'd be like in I'd feel tender
- 13:01and full of admiration. Yeah, and very careful moving forward about triggering this
- 13:11or stepping on those or you know, prodding those wounds of yours, and
- 13:18absolutely prepared for apology in those inevitable moments when I misstep, because it wouldn't
- 13:26ever be out of intention. But you know, people are fallible, including
- 13:30therapists. So good relationships are characterized by the quality of their repairs, not
- 13:35by whether or not they ever had the breaks ever happened. And along those
- 13:41lines, allow me to apologize to you, Mary, even though I wasn't
- 13:46one of those therapists, but I have been one of those therapists. I
- 13:50don't know if I was, but I'm sure that I was in that as
- 13:56a therapist, and the first ten years of my career, about a third
- 14:01of my clients were teenagers and their parents, and I undoubtedly had situations where
- 14:09I gave the impression that I was not on the kid's side and that I
- 14:18was not really interested, or that I was on the parents side, even
- 14:24though the parents were being harmful, maybe even abusive, I don't know.
- 14:28I mean, the kinds of situations that I'd be hired to work with were
- 14:31often chaotic to begin with and short lived. Because what Mary is saying,
- 14:39I can imagine what a lot of these situations were was that the mom would
- 14:45find a therapist that was affordable, that had something that was you know,
- 14:48a slot that was available and was nearby home enough during a crisis of some
- 14:56sort, and you make the appointment, you get in there and there's just
- 15:01a lot to process. Plus, as a therapist, it's hard to sometimes
- 15:07bond with kids because kids are kids and teens or teens and they are guarded
- 15:15or you know, they might even be just flat out hostile because they're being
- 15:20dragged into therapy. If I was escape good, I might be playing hostile,
- 15:24right they're not champion at the bit to talk about their feelings with a
- 15:28therapist, you know, and it can be hard to navigate that. So
- 15:35but even if you weren't like that, Mary, which is you know,
- 15:37it's possible that you were open. It sounds like a very very difficult situation.
- 15:43And the way you're wording this email, it sounds like you're allowing for
- 15:48the strong possibility that these therapists were good therapists and that they just weren't given
- 15:54the cards to play a good hand with the mom would pull them out of
- 16:00therapy if the therapist decided to push back on anything, or if the therapist
- 16:06didn't react counter transference wise the way that the mom was looking for. But
- 16:11allow me to apologize on their behalf by saying that Mary, I kirk Am
- 16:21sorry for having made you feel this way. You deserved so much more than
- 16:29that. You deserved a therapist that really spent the time at the very least
- 16:37could have had a solo session with you, with the mom not there,
- 16:44and I could have said something to you like, I don't know what's going
- 16:49on here, and there's a possibility that you're being mistreated. There's a possibility
- 16:56that I'm actually participating in it, and I just want to throw it out
- 17:02there because I know through experience that teenagers don't have a lot of power,
- 17:04and you know, the kind of behaviors that your mom's complaining about can absolutely
- 17:11be a result of just a lifetime of mistreatment by somebody or multiple people,
- 17:17including your mom. I don't know, but I do detect something's going on
- 17:22there with your mom, and I'm doing my best to please her, because
- 17:26if I piss her off, I'm guessing she's going to pull you out of
- 17:30therapy, and I don't want that. But I don't feel good about that
- 17:34because that's going along potentially with something that's really bad that that's happening. And
- 17:41you know, I understand if you don't want to open up to me because
- 17:44maybe you've had some bad experiences and your mom's dragging you in here. But
- 17:48I care deeply and I'm dedicated to trying to help you, in particular your
- 17:56mom as well. I want to help her, but I do not want
- 18:00to continue going down the road that I have been going down the past few
- 18:06weeks without telling you that I'm sorry for what's been happening, and you deserve
- 18:15so much better, and I'm trying, and there have been times when I've
- 18:19been convinced by your mom that you were the bad one, and I,
- 18:27as an adult, I guess it's easier for me to relate to adults.
- 18:33So that's on me, And that's terrible that I did that to you,
- 18:38and I gave you, you know, a few sessions ago, I was
- 18:41giving the impression that I thought, you know, I was giving you a
- 18:48vibe of judgment that you did that thing. You know, you broke the
- 18:52rules in that way, and I was exasperated with you and frustrated, and
- 18:56I had a vibe of dismissiveness to you, which I feel terrible about.
- 19:03And you deserve better from I'm just doing maybe a smaller version of what your
- 19:08mom does. That that's not okay, and it's hard, but I'm an
- 19:14adult and i'm a professional, and I know better. And you're the one
- 19:18that's suffering. You're the one that doesn't have power, You're the one that's
- 19:22been through a lot of trauma, and you deserve my best and I haven't
- 19:27given you that. And I just wanted you to know that unless I don't
- 19:33get a chance to tell you that. So I'm sorry. To you,
- 19:37Mary, So, Mary, I say that to you from the heart because
- 19:42I've been there personally as a clinician, and it's hard, you know,
- 19:51you have not it's not an excuse. But you have eight clients a day
- 19:55and you are, you know, under the thumb of a boss that's telling
- 20:00you you have to produce more and finish your paperwork and pay your bills on
- 20:07a very limited income, and you have clients that are of varying levels of
- 20:17enthusiasm but to talk to you, and you're just trying to get through your
- 20:21day and your care and you have empathy and you have compassion. But you
- 20:27get burnt out, or you get confused, or you get tossed around by
- 20:34a powerful personality that your mom might have had, You get intimidated, you
- 20:41get hurt by a teenager that isn't super accommodating socially, you know, because
- 20:48teenagers don't necessarily accommodate their therapists egos the way that an adulthood. And you
- 20:59can feel hurt by that as a therapist, and it can be a lot.
- 21:03And it's not an excuse because, like I said, I'm the adult,
- 21:07I'm the professional. I get paid, I'm trained I know better,
- 21:10and I have measures to stave off the problems, and if I don't engage
- 21:15in those measures, then that's that's completely my fault. And it's not hard,
- 21:19it's not rocket science to imagine that a disobedient teenager might not be inherently
- 21:29evil, that they might be a product of a lot of mistreatment and deserves
- 21:34so much leeway and care, and at the very least statements from the therapist
- 21:44along the lines of you deserve better, and I'm sorry for not being a
- 21:48good therapist to you. So I've been there, and you know I apologize
- 21:59to you for that. All right, take a break, get back,
- 22:03Marie Mills. What do you say about all right? Back from the break?
- 22:08Another opp These people also are from god knows where. We have Tracy
- 22:14Annalise, Sarah Matthew, not Sarah Matthew, but Sarah Kama Matthew. I
- 22:18knew is Sarah Matthew once? Oh really last name Matthew? Huh? Were
- 22:23they a good person or a bad person? They were a lovely therapist.
- 22:26Yeah. Jimmy Courtney, Tom Danielle, oh another Danielle, Emily, Aaron,
- 22:33Mandy with an I E. Mandy with an I E. Ros Saye,
- 22:41Natasha, Maureen, Marley, Kayla, Nora Marta, Alice, Aya,
- 22:48Justin, Morgan, Alex or another Alex. Was there an Alex before
- 22:55in the previous one? I don't know Marin, Mikayla, t Katie,
- 23:00Crystal, Diana s Conley, and Kendall. That is the hell of a
- 23:04list. It's a hell of a list, really, just the kinds of
- 23:08solid names that you like to hear in the morning, that you like sponsoring
- 23:15your podcast. Yeah, thanks for helping me that. I don't know what
- 23:18I was saying. Okay. This next email is from a middle tier patron,
- 23:23Kristen from New Jersey. She says, Hi, Doctor Kirk and Bob,
- 23:27I recently turned thirty, and I am struggling to decide how to move
- 23:32forward with a relationship with my parents. Recently two thirty, I'm struggling to
- 23:36decide how to move forward with a relationship with the parents. Growing up,
- 23:38my parents afflicted a lot of emotional and psychological abuse, particularly using fear,
- 23:44guilt, name calling, and lots of shaming. I really relate to Bob's
- 23:48discussions of shame. I have struggled with PTSD my entire life as a result
- 23:53of my parents' abuse of me as an adult. With the help of my
- 23:57therapist, I have cut way down on my contact with my parents. I
- 24:03see them maybe six times a year now, and each time I see them,
- 24:08it still takes me a few weeks to a month to recover from the
- 24:12increase in PTSD symptoms from our interactions. Okay, so just summarizing here,
- 24:21lots of abuse and with the help of the therapist, she's cut down from
- 24:27I don't know, sound maybe like twenty five times a year contact to six
- 24:32times a year contact and each time it takes a few weeks to a month
- 24:37to recover from the increase in PTSD symptoms. So that means most of the
- 24:42year, at least half right, they're thrown into their PTSD sytems because of
- 24:51being exposed to triggers and or being abused continuing to be abused by their parents.
- 24:57My question is do you you have advice for me in deciding how to
- 25:02move forward with my relationship with my parents. Somewhere in my heart, I
- 25:04know that I am moving towards cutting off all contact with my parents, but
- 25:10I am still stuck between a rock and a hard place. I really don't
- 25:14get anything out of the relationship, and I see them purely out of fear
- 25:18and guilt. I keep trying to remember how horribly they have treated me,
- 25:22but then I get so overwhelmed that I go back to my it's not so
- 25:26bad defense mechanism. I would love to hear your thoughts. Thank you.
- 25:30PS Bob. I am definitely working with my therapist on this one. She's
- 25:33great. So thoughts on this spot, you know, because you might be
- 25:38able to relate on some level. So what are your thoughts on this?
- 25:42Well, relationships with your folks are sticky. They're sticky, you stick to
- 25:49them. There's likely a very deep survival mechanism that has to do with you
- 25:56blaming yourself for ever, when you're a kid and you're being abused, one
- 26:03of the functions of shame is it keeps you from being terrified all the time.
- 26:07So it's easier for me to think that I'm the problem, not my
- 26:11mom or my dad, because the idea that they would be the problem means
- 26:18that I live in terror, whereas opposed to I could try to be a
- 26:21better person. That's functional shame. So you get triggered, and I imagine
- 26:26shame comes right along right behind you. And you're stuck with this question,
- 26:34which is, you know, how do I break off contact with them?
- 26:40So I think if you're banking on a sense of certainty that you're gonna yep,
- 26:45this is the right thing to do, you're probably kidding yourself. You
- 26:48probably never have a complete sense of certainty. So one possibility is to just
- 26:56ask yourself the question, if I had to break up with them today,
- 27:00what would I do? Like yes or no? And then tomorrow I'll ask
- 27:06myself the same question if I had to break up with them today, what's
- 27:08my voat if I had to break up with them? And each time and
- 27:12just notice what the answer is, And the answer is probably going to be
- 27:17a trend towards your wisdom. But there's the snow getting out of the fact
- 27:21that you're probably going to have an avalanche, maybe from outside if you take
- 27:26a stand, but most surely from inside. The attack will come. And
- 27:33it's an artifact of being a human growing up in abuse. The having shame
- 27:38actually promotes survival because living in terror is intolerable. But being a bad person
- 27:45we can somehow we can do. Not that you are. It's just this
- 27:48is what our bodies, this is how they direct us so that we can
- 27:52survive. So good luck. Yeah, yeah, beautiful, we said Bob.
- 27:59I will add that the primary motivating place for clients that have worked with
- 28:07in the situation and for myself is anger. Anger is an emotion we feel
- 28:12when there's an injustice and there is a massive mountain of injustice that's continuing to
- 28:18be added to in your life. And the only way you can feel the
- 28:26motivation to protect yourself and correct the injustice at least moving forward is to feel
- 28:33that anger. And there's so many barriers to feeling anger when one goes through
- 28:41abuse. It's a very scary emotion. It is underdeveloped. It has a
- 28:45lot of associations of like danger or when you saw other people getting angry,
- 28:55they were abusive, so you associate those things. Is one of the best
- 29:00emotions we have as organisms. It's one of my favorite emotions. When I
- 29:07feel angry, I feel the power to act on my behalf or on other
- 29:14people's behalf. It's a wonderful feeling to have anger and to know where to
- 29:19point it, and if you can get there, then it will just naturally
- 29:27motivate you to protect yourself in whatever way that is going to look you're saying
- 29:33that you think you're headed towards a place of no contact, but you don't
- 29:37really know. You know, that's one possibility, but there are many possibilities.
- 29:42There's another future in which you do stay in contact to some extent,
- 29:47but through your connection with your rights and your anger, you push back in
- 29:52the moment and say, I don't like that, and if you're ever going
- 29:57to see me again, you're going to knock that shit off. And I'd
- 30:00kindly ask you not to do that anymore. And they adjust. I've seen
- 30:04that happen. I've seen abusive parents adjust. I've seen them not adjust,
- 30:08but I've seen them adjust. And then you can get a win win where
- 30:14you can retain some of the goodness and grow into the future and not be
- 30:21abused anymore. So anger support. Now you have PTSD, so the you
- 30:29know, the initial stages of recovery is PTSD treatment and specialized trauma recovery.
- 30:37It would be hard to just move forward with this anger in that time,
- 30:44but that is the end goal. And I've done that with many clients,
- 30:48and it's hard. You know, it'll take me. Given what I'm hearing
- 30:52from you, it would not surprise me if it would take five years of
- 30:57every other session, have half the session dedicated to this topic of anger.
- 31:03Because what happens when you don't even feel the anger, even though it must
- 31:07be happening, it's weird. How do you get in touch with that self
- 31:12with that emotion? How do you let it out? How do you neurologically
- 31:18engage? It's not a conscious decision that we make, so it takes a
- 31:23long time. But without it, you're just intellectually trying to protect yourself,
- 31:29and that just isn't possible. You have to feel the anger. It's sort
- 31:33of like eating when you're not hungry, or I don't know, trying to
- 31:40sleep when you're not tired. It's really hard for us to do those things.
- 31:44It's really hard to advocate for yourself if you don't feel the anger.
- 31:48There's so many other reasons to avoid sticking up for yourself that if you don't
- 31:56have that internal power of your anger, then no amount of intellectual decision making
- 32:07around injustice is going to win. You know. Another email here anonymous middle
- 32:13tier patron. She says, Dear doctor kirknbop, my therapist recently had to
- 32:19cut the frequency of my sessions due to circumstances outside of his control. When
- 32:24he told me this, I spent the remainder of the session intensely sobbing and
- 32:29hyperventilating. Okay, so just summarizing, the therapist said, I have to
- 32:35cut back from every week to every other week or something, and that's due
- 32:40to something outside of his control. I'm trying to think what that would be,
- 32:44like his own health, or the agency is forcing him, or he's
- 32:52yeah, I'm just trying to figure out what that would be. Some kind
- 32:54of internal office policy bureaucracy, like an increasing caseload possibly, or he's renting
- 33:04a room and the lease person is saying you can only have Mondays and tuesdays
- 33:10now or something. And then when he told her this, she spent the
- 33:16remainder of the session intensely sobbing and hyperventilating. I also had a re emergent
- 33:22self harm urge and a passive suicidal ideation for the first time in over a
- 33:28year. The intensity of my emotional response was surprising and concerning to my therapist.
- 33:34He has since gently told me that we need to focus more on me
- 33:37becoming a secure base for myself so that my well being doesn't depend so intensely
- 33:44on the therapeutic relationship. Just checking in, Bob, you have a furrowed
- 33:49brow. I'm not sure. I mean, I'm not there, so what
- 33:51do I know? But I'm not sure that if I'm a therapist then I
- 33:54have to cut back on seeing my client the way we originally agreed. That
- 34:01I'm making my problem there's and dictating what their treatment plan ought to be.
- 34:09That doesn't sit well with me, just based on what's been written here.
- 34:13What do you think about the statement of that they need to focus on helping
- 34:17her to become a secure base for herself. Well, if they haven't been
- 34:22doing that from the start by indirect means, than what the heck have they
- 34:27been doing? Like, the idea of therapy is one idea of the way
- 34:30to think about therapy is you internalize a good object. So my therapist is
- 34:35like that part of me that coaches me, that believes in me, that
- 34:37supports me, that loves me, that cares about me. That is my
- 34:43guiding star. Now, the thing that's inside me is the guiding star,
- 34:46but the therapist is maybe the face that my body puts on it. Because
- 34:52all people learn by modeling, and they learn that they're lovable by being loved.
- 34:59So therapy, as I understand it, personal therapy, personal counseling,
- 35:04as I understand it, is about developing an internalized good object so that I
- 35:09can have a secure base. That's the basis through which it's developed. So
- 35:14just saying well, you have to do this, I think it's sort of
- 35:17either redundant or therapist guilt. What do you mean by therapist guilt? Maybe
- 35:27the therapist just feels really bad about, you know, the circumstance and the
- 35:30impact it's having on the client, and they're in their panic, are scrambling
- 35:36for what to do to help the person, and coming up with this as
- 35:43a sort of a you know, treatment plan or whatever so that they don't
- 35:47feel like such a jerk face. Yeah it has that looked to me,
- 35:52but hard to tell. Yeah, we don't know. I mean it's just
- 35:55a we get the really narrow window. It's also impossible to become a secure
- 36:00your base for yourself. By definition, that's like telling a two year old
- 36:06that they could become a secure No, you can't. Nobody can. Nobody
- 36:09can. Now if he was saying something like, well, under the circumstances,
- 36:17given that I can't see you every week, and I'm gonna have to
- 36:21see you other week or whatever, and it's going to create a lot of
- 36:27difficulty for you suicidal ideation and self harm. Then we have to figure out
- 36:34some other solution here to help you so that you don't hurt yourself. Okay,
- 36:43yeah, but to basically at least the way that anonymous military patron is
- 36:47painting it to blame the client, as you were saying, of like,
- 36:52there's something wrong with you that you can't cope with this, right, yeah,
- 36:55right, right, right right? That nicely put that through The captures
- 37:00a lot right there. Going on to accomplish this, he will shift his
- 37:02approach to be less of a caretaker moving forward. He also mentioned that therapy
- 37:08is not meant to last forever. He has reassured me that he is not
- 37:13terminating with me right now, which is difficult for me to believe. You're
- 37:16shaking your head. I find this ghastly. Right. Yeah, of course
- 37:22therapy is not supposed to be forever. But the only reason people say that
- 37:25is because they get nervous about how long it takes. Come on, therapists,
- 37:30just take a breath and relax. Therapy takes a long time, so
- 37:37don't say this to your client, And you know, who are we to
- 37:39decide what other what value others get in the thing. I say to my
- 37:45clients regularly, I love you. You're welcome to come here as long as
- 37:49you find it helpful. So you know, I think that this is a
- 37:53mistake, and it's again, perhaps out of guilt, little horrified, aren't
- 37:59I going on? Ever since this happened, I have felt incredibly betrayed and
- 38:02abandoned, even though the mature part of me knows that my therapist is doing
- 38:07this out of care and concern for my well being. Maybe I've talked about
- 38:10all of this with my therapist and he responded, well, However, I
- 38:14feel like the more I reveal about my innerdependency, the more my therapist is
- 38:19going to distance and sell from me, which terrifies me. I am curious
- 38:22about whether you have any thoughts on how to regulate trust while refocusing on my
- 38:27ability to self regulate. This therapeutic relationship has been life changing for me in
- 38:31a lot of fundamental ways, and I want to preserve it as best as
- 38:35I can while trusting my therapist's professional opinion that our dynamic needs to shift.
- 38:40So she's asking for how do I regain trusts in the relationship while refocusing on
- 38:47my ability to self regulate. What would you say to that, I'd say
- 38:51that they don't necessarily have task alliance anymore. So it seems like we ought
- 38:57to go back to the drawing board and instead of I'm your therapist telling you
- 39:01what your treatment plan ought to be, perhaps the two of you ought to
- 39:05just discuss how do we deal with this new circumstance and what is our task?
- 39:13But it doesn't look like you're buying into what the therapist is saying.
- 39:16Your task got to be. So you need task clients or you can't trust
- 39:23right. I think specifically that, at least for you and me, I
- 39:30guess we would recommend that if the therapist could handle it, that he continue
- 39:37continued to be a quote unquote caretaker and a secure base while just seeing the
- 39:43client less often. Yeah, I mean, to me, that's the obvious
- 39:46answer. That's pretty straightforward. Right. If I had a client and I've
- 39:50been in situations like this and the client has a meltdown and I feel bad,
- 39:55but I manage that kind of transference and I actually see it as a
- 40:00sign of good therapy, is occurring, and I would say to the client
- 40:06that I'm with them, and although it feels like I'm abandoning you, I'm
- 40:12not. And it's just going to be less often in terms of us seeing
- 40:15each other. But I absolutely am still going to be thinking about you and
- 40:20I will be there for you when I can be, and hopefully this new
- 40:27less frequent schedule will be enough for you. I know it doesn't feel like
- 40:31that right now, and it probably won't feel like that in the short term,
- 40:35but after a few months, I'm hoping that it will be sufficient,
- 40:39because there's no reason to believe it wouldn't be. So let's let's see what
- 40:44happens. And you're totally okay with this reaction. It's normal to have this
- 40:50reaction. It's it's inevitable to some extent, it's par for the course,
- 40:57and let's make sure that you don't hurt yourself in the short term. But
- 41:01I'm going to take a guess and say that once your body it shifts and
- 41:05adjusts to this new schedule, that you will feel that trust. That's a
- 41:09very different response than you need to learn how to take care of yourself.
- 41:14Yeah, because for the patron to regain trust well, how do you know
- 41:24what's now? What patron isn't laying out in terms of detail is all the
- 41:30good things. But I hear that in her email that he's life changing,
- 41:35he's been there so you know, and he did respond, Well, he's
- 41:39also saying he's not planning on terminating, so it might just be an adjustment
- 41:45and as possible that he just doesn't. This happens a lot where therapists are
- 41:50actually providing corrective experiences regarding this object that you refer to, but they don't
- 41:54know that. They don't refer to it that way, they don't think about
- 41:58it that way. Yeah. Freud himself, actually, I think, was
- 42:00doing this and didn't know he was doing it. Yeah, yeah, it
- 42:04seems obvious, but that's retrospect because he would over time have a number of
- 42:09different theories. But you know, one of his main theories was that he
- 42:14was an archaeologist, digging around in one's unconscious and unearthing things, making the
- 42:21unconscious conscious and through that mental health would be facilitated. But me, looking
- 42:29back, I think what was happening is that these clients for the first time
- 42:34had someone that was non judgmental and caring who spent the time to get to
- 42:40know the individual and didn't reject them and accepted them as they were. Yeah.
- 42:47I think if a person had the good luck of meeting Freud and being
- 42:51one of his clients or patients or whatever he calls it, that would be
- 42:53quite a thing. Yeah. He ain't perfect. I'm not saying he's perfect,
- 42:57but from all accounts, he was a very caring, empathic person.
- 43:00Yeah, but didn't value that because of the patriarchy and saw it through this
- 43:05other Plus, he loved archaeology. Yeah, yeah, you I know,
- 43:08all over his offices artifacts. Yeah, Bob and I have both been to
- 43:14his office in England. Did you know that he was I think only there
- 43:17for a year, just a year, yeah, yeah, yeah, and
- 43:22then he passed right yeah yeah yeah, mouth cancer. Yeah. Let's take
- 43:29a break, get back another email. What do you say? Right?
- 43:36All right? To the third opp This is a continuation of the God Knows
- 43:40Where people from twenty twenty one patrons and it's really great. You know they've
- 43:45been patrons for three years, almost three years. We have Sarah Deanna,
- 43:52Rocky, Mia, Melissa Halley or Haley, Monica, Alexander Anna and another
- 44:00Melissa. There's two Melissa's there, Paul Esther. That's a great name.
- 44:05Esther, kind of fun to say. Esther, It's like Stacy's an esthetician,
- 44:10Mary, El Lara or Laura, Samantha, s Isha, or Isha,
- 44:16Julia, Cheryl, Cindy, Fourth, Vaughan, Jan Gabby, Sarah,
- 44:22Brooke, and Terese. Thank you so much for becoming a patron number
- 44:28one and number two staying at patron this whole time. This next email,
- 44:32anonymous patron says Hi Kirk and Bob, longtime listener, first time questioner.
- 44:37In my adult life, I've had only one therapist. I've seen her since
- 44:42my early twenties and I'm now in my late thirties. I've known she is
- 44:46an older person, but never knew her exact age. So let's see,
- 44:52I've only known I've only had one therapist. I've seen her. It sounds
- 44:57like fifteen years a little bit more maybe, yeah, And I've known that
- 45:01she was an older person, but I never knew how old she was.
- 45:05Recently, she mentioned that she was soon going to celebrate her eightieth birthday.
- 45:09I was excited to hear this because I finally knew how old she was.
- 45:14And now I'm wondering what are her plans for retirement? What happens if she
- 45:17suddenly passes away? Is there a backup clinician until I find a new one?
- 45:22What should I look for in a new therapist. I feel like we've
- 45:27finally arrived at the core of my therapy. What will happen to all my
- 45:30progress, particularly since it's difficult to find a good therapist? Should I start
- 45:35looking for a new therapist now? Just in case I'm feeling a bit lost?
- 45:38Bob, what do you think? Well, you know me, I
- 45:43say the same thing I always say, which is you know how to talk
- 45:45about this with her? And Wow, somewhere between fifteen and eighteen years,
- 45:52that's lovely good for you. And clearly you're with somebody who's very dedicated and
- 45:59committed to her learning her craft and doing doing good job. And apparently we
- 46:05don't know the therapist situation, but I'm imagining if she's eighties, she's doing
- 46:07this because she loves it, not because she necessarily has to, like the
- 46:12way you maybe do when you're in your thirties and you're starting out. So
- 46:17but you should talk about it. You should you should talk about all these
- 46:22things that these are legitimate questions. And it's not like she's not thinking about
- 46:25them. Sure she is. I know therapists who practiced well into their eighties,
- 46:31But have you known anyone that was in their late eighties or nineties as
- 46:35a therapist? IRV how Old's IRV y'allam. Yeah, he still has clients.
- 46:40Does she tell clients? I don't know. Last time I heard about
- 46:44him, you told me because you talked to him, and he was seeing
- 46:47clients. I think I know he was seeing supervises, supervise thes okay,
- 46:53but maybe he was also seeing clients. He's ninety two, ninety two,
- 46:57and he's he's pretty sharp, so yeah, I think that, if not
- 47:01fully sharp. Honestly, when I interviewed him a few years ago, didn't
- 47:05seem like anything was lost. So yeah, I mean, it's possible,
- 47:10Patron, that your therapist will be with you another fifteen years. Yeah,
- 47:15could be. It's not impossible. It's also possible that your therapist will want
- 47:20to retire or we'll start to experience dementia. You know, Paul David was
- 47:24on the podcast not too long ago and discovered at the age of he's around
- 47:30eighty and discovered that he had Alzheimer's and was declining quickly and had to terminate
- 47:37with all of his clients. That could happen, or suddenly passing away or
- 47:43having a serious illness that could capacitate your therapist. It could happen. So
- 47:50in terms of your questions, though, unless your therapist can tell you something
- 47:53about the likelihood of anything happening along these lines, you know, like if
- 48:00I were in your shoes, Patrin, this is what I would ask my
- 48:02therapist. I'd say, so, you know, not to be weird or
- 48:07invasive, and you certainly don't have to answer these questions. But after hearing
- 48:10that you're eighty, I don't be agist, but I'm wondering about your plans
- 48:15for retirement or how your health is doing, because I selfishly very much like
- 48:23you and don't want you to not be my therapist every week. And you
- 48:29know, I obviously care about you as well as a human being. But
- 48:32I'm just wondering what the future holds for me, and do you have any
- 48:37plans or what's the outlook or what's going on? You know, your therapist
- 48:43might say, well, actually, come to think of it, I mean,
- 48:45I was thinking about retirement maybe in the next five years. I don't
- 48:49know, certainly, not anytime soon. I'll certainly tell you what you know
- 48:52with a lot of advanced notice, or they'll say no plans to retire.
- 48:59I haven't even really thought about it. I don't have any need to do
- 49:02that. I have a small private practice, and that's my plan is to
- 49:07continue doing it until I can't do it anymore. And I'm healthy now and
- 49:12my parents live to be one hundred and one, so and I've lived a
- 49:15healthy life and maybe I finally figured out how to do it. Yeah,
- 49:20So I don't see any thing happening there, got it. I would imagine
- 49:24at least another ten years in me, so I wouldn't worry about that now.
- 49:29That doesn't mean that the therapist can't have a sudden event of some sort.
- 49:34And it's realistic to think about that, you know, in my circle,
- 49:37like I think about life expectancy to be I don't know, maybe like
- 49:43ninety or something, but the average is seventy four or something like seventy two
- 49:46in the United States something like that. So it's seventy two for men,
- 49:51right, seventy six fort so different for ethnicities. But it's a thing to
- 49:59live into your you know, especially with all your cognitive abilities and energy abilities
- 50:04in terms of having the energy to work. So it is realistic to think
- 50:08about these questions now in terms of these other questions patron, about should you
- 50:13start preparing well, unless your therapist said that she was imminently going to close
- 50:21the practice or have some compromise, there wouldn't be any point in preparing because
- 50:25even if you got a few names of therapists that were good, you wouldn't
- 50:30know by the time you needed them if they would be available or anything.
- 50:35So what I would do is I would just ask your therapist to please inform
- 50:39you if they weren't planning to already if there were to be any sort of
- 50:45event like this occurring, because there wouldn't. I don't think be much sense
- 50:50in reaching out now to therapists to set something up on the off chance,
- 50:55because it could be at the very least a couple years, if not ten
- 51:00years. So there's that. But I would start preparing emotionally because this is
- 51:07something that I'm kind of passionate about that being in denial of our demise and
- 51:13our decline only causes problems. We shouldn't be focused on it and bogged down
- 51:19by it. But being realistic about life from an early age, I think
- 51:24is helpful. That's what I have found since I was a teenager. For
- 51:30some unknown reason, I hadn't really experienced any kind of loss until I was
- 51:35a lot older than a teenage teenager. So usually you know when someone was
- 51:38thinking about death and the impermanence of life, it's because something happened when they
- 51:44were young, but didn't happen to me. But I just somehow started really
- 51:49thinking about it, and I periodically will check in with that. I have
- 51:54two bowls over there on the other side of my office, and I figured
- 52:00out my life expectancy, which I think is about seventy eight or seventy eight
- 52:04for Asian Americans and Asian American men, I think. And so I was
- 52:09fifty three, I'm fifty three. So I got fifty times twelve, which
- 52:15is I think six hundred rocks, little polished rocks. They look like jelly
- 52:22beans. And every first day of every month, I take out one rock
- 52:28from the pile and put it into this other bowl that symbolizes the passage of
- 52:32time. And I do this because it's gratifying to me to recognize reality and
- 52:42it realigns my priorities and helps me, I think, to prepare. I
- 52:47don't want to have to prepare. I wish I didn't have to, but
- 52:53I don't want to be blindsided by the milestones that are quickly being passed and
- 53:00are approaching. I don't like that feeling of being unprepared emotionally, So I
- 53:07think it's important for all of us to have that realism. And it won't
- 53:12take away the pain Patroon. When your therapist does decide to retire, or
- 53:19you're or the universe takes your therapist away from you, it will be very,
- 53:24very painful. It is going to hurt. It is going to be
- 53:30a lot of sadness, and there's going to be confusion. That's the other
- 53:36side of the coin of attachment. You can't have one without the other.
- 53:40It's a good thing that we become so attached to people. What a wonderful
- 53:46gift this therapist and the universe have given you to have such a wonderful relationship
- 53:52that lasted so long, that was probably very much needed. Right man,
- 53:57this could be the biggest loss you ever experience in your entire life. Yeah,
- 54:02it's going to hurt, and you don't want to be bogged down by
- 54:07that right now and be demoralized or paralyzed. But recognizing that, I think
- 54:13is actually what's happening for you. You know, this franticness of the questions
- 54:16is a way to solve that problem. There's no way to solve it.
- 54:20Yeah, it's going to fucking happen. It's going to happen, and if
- 54:23you acknowledge it, and to some extent it sounds weird, but for all
- 54:30of you out there, you included Bob, you have a wonderful therapist right
- 54:34now. Yeah, at some point that's going to end in all likelihood one
- 54:38way or the other. I guess the only way for it not to is
- 54:42if you die suddenly, and so you don't have to experience it. It'll
- 54:45still end. I just don't have the experience of it. But in all
- 54:49likelihood ninety ninety percent of the time he'll retire or you'll terminate or something,
- 54:57and so it's going to happen. And at the at the very beginning of
- 55:01an attachment, I think some minor acknowledgment of that reality is helpful. I
- 55:08think to put things in perspective, to not have this childish fantasy that everything
- 55:14lasts forever, because things don't. And this is why you have traditions in
- 55:19world religions and cultures around the world where they emphasize the impermanence of life.
- 55:25Like the Tibetan monks who came to my university and made those mandalas with sand.
- 55:35They would spend I don't know, a week making this thing meticulously,
- 55:38and then there was this ceremony and they just wipe it clean. And it's
- 55:45this continual reminder. Why do we need that, even the monks need to
- 55:50have that reminder, because it's tempting to believe in the fantasy of permanence,
- 55:54which is not helpful because when the universe shows us of the impermanence, it's
- 56:02ten times worse when we have a fantasy that that will never happen. That's
- 56:07my belief, and I'm pretty sure that's the belief of a lot of traditions
- 56:10around the world. If you force yourself to feel the grief of reality as
- 56:17it comes, then you're not thrown off a cliff into grief and confusion when
- 56:27things do come to an end. I'm not making anything up new here,
- 56:30but I am saying that, patron, because I think that's what you're actually
- 56:36experiencing what you're given an opportunity to wrestle with. And in our culture,
- 56:42Western culture, American mainstream culture, we don't acknowledge this. We don't have
- 56:47practices of making something and purposely discarding it to remind us of the impermanence of
- 56:55life. So many people around me, close to me, people very close
- 57:00to me. Whenever I talk about this, they change the subject or they
- 57:07frame it in a way that denies what I'm actually saying. Yeah, yeah,
- 57:13people are afraid to face. Yeah. It's intolerable because we don't have
- 57:17guidance or a culture around that, and I find it to be liberating.
- 57:22It sucks. I wish it weren't true. I'm not inviting in permanence.
- 57:28I'm not inviting death or loss or grief. But when I acknowledge it,
- 57:34I feel that pain. But through it, I for myself anyway, there's
- 57:39a serenity that can be somewhat attained, rather than a state of terror that
- 57:47I'm denying. It's a different feeling, a feeling of disappointed serenity and somewhat
- 57:57bracing for the pain, but acknowledging that there's nothing you can really brace for.
- 58:01You can't you just have to take it. It's not an all positive
- 58:05feeling, but I'd rather have that than a sense of unprocessed terror that I'm
- 58:10constantly tamping down with fantasy. So with you, Patron, it's going to
- 58:15come to an end, and it could be soon, it could be later,
- 58:17but it's going to come to an end. And that process is a
- 58:21wonderful thing to talk about in therapy, right, I hope. So I'm
- 58:24just imagining the humanity of two people, you know, one of them is
- 58:30in their late thirties and one of them is eighty having a frank discussion about
- 58:32the valuing of their relationship and a recognition of somewhere or another it's impermanent.
- 58:39Like that's man, that's two turkeys in the same turkey soup. That's us,
- 58:45two turkeys in the same turkey soup. Now we all turkeys in the
- 58:47same turkey soup. Oh, we're not separate. We are all in it,
- 58:54and it is all impermanent. And yeah, everything that's in you is
- 58:59in me. Next email, lower tier patron Alisha from Tacoma. She says,
- 59:07Hi, Kirkabob, I was hoping you both could provide perspective on a
- 59:12topic that I am currently struggling with. In one of my classes, we've
- 59:15been asked to watch movies and make diagnoses for the characters. So it sounds
- 59:21like a psychology program. Yeah, very common thing. One of the movies
- 59:25is called All Too Human, which, by the way, is a horrible
- 59:29movie. What is this movie? All Too Human movie? All Too Human
- 59:37Movie is a twenty eighteen movie starring people I don't recognize. Name the name.
- 59:46Well, let's see. There's Katina A, Donna Dias, and Teresa
- 59:52Ann and Jeffrey Arrington. Does it have a synopsis of this story? Yeah,
- 59:57it is. After struggling with years of your depression, Mark has decided
- 1:00:00that today is a day to end his misery. There seems to be no
- 1:00:06moral or spiritual philosophy that can bring about Mark's salvation and convince him that suicide
- 1:00:12is not the most pragmatic choice to make. Hmm, sounds like a religious
- 1:00:15movie. Honestly, it's bringing me down, man. This sounds awful and
- 1:00:22the main character portrays the perspective of someone who is suicidal. The character was
- 1:00:27also struggling with existentialism and found himself to be an atheist. While the movie
- 1:00:32was dreadful to watch, I do understand much of what the character was thinking
- 1:00:36and feeling due to my own previous struggles with suicidality. If someone is determined
- 1:00:42to commit suicide and they truly do not want to be here due to the
- 1:00:45years of immense pain and accumulated traumas, why are we so insistent on keeping
- 1:00:52them alive, particularly when they can't find their own meaning or reason to be
- 1:00:55here. I've struggled with suicide in the past myself, and while I know
- 1:01:00I will never follow through because of my son and the effect it would have
- 1:01:04on him, I would be lying if I said I didn't understand what that
- 1:01:07person felt, and I find myself having immense empathy for him. It made
- 1:01:12me wonder why we insist that people stay alive if their pain is so intense.
- 1:01:17I'm not a proponent of suicide and would never encourage someone to kill themselves,
- 1:01:22but I would love some perspective on this, and hopefully some reassurance that
- 1:01:27I'm not alone in this way of thinking. Bob, what do you think?
- 1:01:30Yeah, Well, my first thought is the reason we have such rules
- 1:01:35around it is because we're all because we have a fairly universal fear of death,
- 1:01:42so we have a lot of rules, and I think it's just easier
- 1:01:47to have a rule to preserve life than it is to sort of try to
- 1:01:52make a case. You know that there are you know, those of us
- 1:01:55where suicide is a valid, you know, response to things like if you
- 1:02:00try to do that, you're going to encourage death. So it's just easier
- 1:02:04to say, we do not do that, we do not, we don't
- 1:02:07walk down that path. Philosophically, I agree with most of what you're saying
- 1:02:13here. You know, I think people have a right to determine, you
- 1:02:17know, how they live and if they want to, how they die,
- 1:02:23and it isn't really anybody's business. The thing that I think about when this
- 1:02:28stuff comes up is I have an ethical responsibility and a legal responsibility, and
- 1:02:34as long as I meet that, I'm okay with what my client might do.
- 1:02:37So I will do everything I can to protect life because I have a
- 1:02:45legal and ethical and I think a moral obligation to do that. Because most
- 1:02:49of the time when people are suicidal, they aren't intent. I should restate
- 1:02:55that it is by and large situation and at least thirty percent of the time
- 1:03:01the decision is made within five minutes, which is not a considered decision.
- 1:03:07So so given that that's the case, we're probably better off trying to prevent
- 1:03:12it because the vast majority of the time people are glad they're not dead.
- 1:03:19So but you know, people that are suicidal will fight for, you know,
- 1:03:24their right to kill themselves. Yeah, okay, I get it,
- 1:03:30and I think that the situation you're describing that's in that film. First off,
- 1:03:35that film just sounds like bullshit, Like it's a very black and white
- 1:03:38image that I've reached this conclusion that you know, come on, man,
- 1:03:42that just sounds like a masturbation on a screen, really, is all it
- 1:03:45sounds like to me. So so anyways, but you know, fine,
- 1:03:49okay, so some writer thought, oh, this is an interesting topic,
- 1:03:52let's just put it on the table, you know, and it's fine,
- 1:03:53you know whatever, and make a movie. Unfortunately, they make graduate students
- 1:03:58watch it. That character, that that situation that's portrayed is rare, beautifully
- 1:04:09said. The only thing I'll add is that, yeah, generally speaking,
- 1:04:13as Bob was saying, the vast majority of people who think about suicide eventually
- 1:04:15will thank others for encouraging them to live because it's a temporary solution that people
- 1:04:23will think about seriously, and when the you know, the pain subsides and
- 1:04:29the support is given and there's no longer thwarted belongingness than the motivation, the
- 1:04:35intent to kill oneself usually will go away. And you know, maybe even
- 1:04:41like ninety nine percent of the time. So even if someone in the moments,
- 1:04:45even if it lasts for a month, is intent on killing themselves,
- 1:04:49for society, for family members, for clinicians to not be in support of
- 1:04:58that decision, and to do everything we can to fix the underlying problem,
- 1:05:04that's what we want to be doing. Having said that, I'm dealing with
- 1:05:09this right now. Paul David, someone very close to me, a second
- 1:05:14father in a lot of ways, is going to kill himself this year.
- 1:05:17I think in the fall is when he is telling me that it's likely to
- 1:05:21happen. He's making that choice because he does not want to have a life
- 1:05:30in the future in which his brain and personality disappear but the body moves on.
- 1:05:35He also doesn't want to be a burden on the people around him,
- 1:05:42and he I think also doesn't want to leave behind a legacy of what he
- 1:05:45might become after right, the kind of behaviors that you might see. I
- 1:05:51mean, there's a wide variety of things, but sometimes people can be quite
- 1:05:57deranged and paranoid and violent. It's not all the time, of course,
- 1:06:02it's a minority of the time. But you know that that's where you just
- 1:06:04have no idea. I mean, you're just stepping into the unknown when you
- 1:06:08are diagnosed with Alzheimer's like that. So he wants to leave before that happens,
- 1:06:14and are we supposed to as a society tell him that he shouldn't do
- 1:06:16that? You know, there are people that will do that, and I
- 1:06:19think that we have in the past this alignment between religious notions of you can't
- 1:06:27play God with life, including your own right, and it's a sin,
- 1:06:30and I think in Catholicism it's like one of the worst sins, mortal right,
- 1:06:35not the venal. What does that mean? Venial sin? You know,
- 1:06:39you say a couple of him Mary's and you're good with God. Mortal
- 1:06:42sin you go to Hell no matter what, yeah, or even if you
- 1:06:45confess. I don't know. I mean with suicide, I remember hearing and
- 1:06:53I'm not Catholic that by definition you go to hell because you can't confess because
- 1:06:57you're dead. You can't. You can't kill yourself and then go to church
- 1:07:00and confess. You can't confess that you killed yourself. You could maybe do
- 1:07:03it before the fact that God's probably a stickler for timing. So there's that.
- 1:07:11And in the past, because of our general denial of mental health and
- 1:07:15our weirdness around death, we would as a society also say it's not okay.
- 1:07:19I think in some areas it was illegal, was it not? It
- 1:07:23is still illegal, isn't it? Is it? Yeah? Do people get
- 1:07:27charged for attempting? No, nobody gets charged as for the crime, but
- 1:07:30it is illegal to kill yourself. Yeah. So in Washington, and I
- 1:07:34think in most in the United States in general. Yeah. Yeah. So
- 1:07:39it's this thing in the past where you had the law and politicians and society
- 1:07:44and religion were all on the same boat. But now we're in a situation
- 1:07:48where that's not so much the case, right where we're saying, well,
- 1:07:53sometimes it's actually morally okay, maybe even superior morally. So there's that,
- 1:08:00and then that opens the door to well, what about depression? Right,
- 1:08:03And Canada and the United States are going to have to wrestle with these questions
- 1:08:08because they are opening the door to death with dignity, you medically assisted,
- 1:08:15legally sanctioned suicide for things like Alzheimer's or terminal brain cancer or something. And
- 1:08:24it's a natural question of just like, well, what about things like treatment
- 1:08:28resistance depression. Someone goes through twenty five years of all the medications and all
- 1:08:33the psychotherapy and all the ect and all the behavioral and all the diet and
- 1:08:36all the everything and the lifestyle, and every day is utter pain and suffering
- 1:08:45and they don't want to do it anymore. How is that any different from
- 1:08:48someone that is suffering from ongoing debilitating pain or from the looming future of Alzheimer's
- 1:09:00or something. You know, it starts to open those doors. So we
- 1:09:02have to ask those questions of ourselves, and they're difficult questions. The thing
- 1:09:06is, though, that this question has been mulled over patron Alicia from Tacoma
- 1:09:13in our field for decades, and it goes back to some extent to a
- 1:09:18major figure in this field called Nico Spijeers or Spears, I don't know how
- 1:09:24to pronounce his name. Speeders. He was prominent a suicideologist and a suicide
- 1:09:31prevention advocate, so he was a very important person in the field of suicide
- 1:09:36prevention, and in nineteen eighty he published a book about a topic that would
- 1:09:43later be termed rational suicide. And it's complicated, and I go into more
- 1:09:48detail in my suicide deep dive, but basically, rational suicide is when someone
- 1:09:55is experiencing unbearable pain with no relief that is expected to occur in the future,
- 1:10:00and after a long period of various solutions not working, the person makes
- 1:10:03a conscious decision to end their life. And Nico Speeders or Spears or something.
- 1:10:12I looked up how to pronounce that name in the past, I feel
- 1:10:14like I want to do it now because Speeds just sounds so funny to me.
- 1:10:16Right now, pronunciation pro I have to look pronounci spiders. That sounds
- 1:10:26better. So Nico Spigers was supporting even though he was an expert in suicide
- 1:10:33prevention. He was writing about, Hey, well, sometimes it's actually maybe
- 1:10:41ethical and morally important for us to consider allowing at the very least, if
- 1:10:45not supporting, an individual's decision for rational suicide. You know, it's thoughtful,
- 1:10:53it's been all other avenues have been explored. It's unbearable, and there's
- 1:10:59just no likelihood of it reducing in the future of the pain. And then
- 1:11:04in nineteen eighty one, a year later, he and his wife actually killed
- 1:11:08it themselves together. Wow. At the same time, he had a terminal
- 1:11:12illness and was in tremendous pain, and she and his wife was suffering from
- 1:11:18an ongoing difficult disability and also just didn't want to live without him, so
- 1:11:24they killed themselves. And you say this to a crowd of people, like
- 1:11:29in on Oprah or something, and you're going to get a lot of gas.
- 1:11:32Sure, But what Alicia is saying is I think, in essence,
- 1:11:39what about free will? Are we not a free country? Why are we
- 1:11:43so dogmatic and draconian and just black and white? It's just because it's simpler,
- 1:11:51and what's the harm, right, Because if someone decided, now,
- 1:11:56what people will say, which is valid, is like, hey, you
- 1:11:58know, what about the kids? What about the people around you? Totally
- 1:12:00balid, Yeah, but they're not the one going through the suffering, you
- 1:12:05know. And there can be a viable situation for me anyway. And I've
- 1:12:11never been faced clinically with this kind of call, like writing some letter of
- 1:12:16support or something, So this is all made at a distance for me.
- 1:12:21But I can imagine a situation which I was working with a parent who had
- 1:12:27kids, maybe even young kids, who had exhausted all avenues over the past
- 1:12:31thirty years and really put their heart and soul into trying to find a solution
- 1:12:36and was suffering endlessly, just constantly, all day long, and was just
- 1:12:44absolutely miserable, and there was no likelihood of relief in the future and over
- 1:12:53time. As a client, if they are consistent in this wish and they're
- 1:12:58going to do everything in their power to to help their kids and prepare whatever,
- 1:13:01you know, I could see myself internally, at the very least not
- 1:13:06being aghast. I couldn't know, of course, because I'm not in their
- 1:13:11shoes, but I wouldn't even subtly judge them or or push back or you
- 1:13:17know, there's ways that therapists can say, well, you know, I'm
- 1:13:20just curious if you've really thought about all the options, or you know,
- 1:13:25the kind of questions we ask, oh, sure, questions, Yeah,
- 1:13:28like well, what do you think the impact on your kids will be?
- 1:13:30You know, that kind of a it's not saying it, but it's kind
- 1:13:32of saying it, right, you know, I could I could see myself
- 1:13:36avoiding stuff like that It's not that I wouldn't ask those questions, but in
- 1:13:41the end, right, yeah, in the end, you could understand and
- 1:13:45respect somebody's choice. Yeah. And I'm not a fan of government and society
- 1:13:50and particularly religion dictating what us humans should think and do. I think that
- 1:13:58we should have the right to make her own decisions about especially things like this.
- 1:14:03It's complicated. Well, it's simpler if you just have a rule,
- 1:14:06right, So we thrive on that. That's easier for us to not have
- 1:14:12to think about a thing. Hey, do you remember Eva? We went
- 1:14:15to grad school with her? Yeah, you remember her? Do you still
- 1:14:17know her? No? But I wish I did because I missed her.
- 1:14:21She was really cool. Yeah, we were friends because we worked at the
- 1:14:25agency together in Federal Away et feder Away. Yeah. Oh, I think
- 1:14:28I should have known that. Anyways, And for those who don't know,
- 1:14:30she was kind of like Rebecca in my life a lot of ways. Oh
- 1:14:35yeah, hey, right on. Yeah. Anyways, she wrote a paper
- 1:14:40I think in ethics or I think it was an ethics class about this subject,
- 1:14:44and she did some research because she was sort of pro I mean,
- 1:14:47we didn't have the term for it, rational suicide. She was pro rational
- 1:14:50suicide in which she discovered, if I remember right, was in the countries
- 1:14:56that had legalized rational suicide, doctors were giving prescriptions and they were the needle
- 1:15:03was moving, and they were becoming much more loose about who they would give
- 1:15:08it for. And it's something like the pendulum swung from This is a specific
- 1:15:13kind of situation too. Oh it could be, it could be justified under
- 1:15:16other circumstance that you know, before the rules were made, you know,
- 1:15:20they were against So she and I remember her being surprised by that. I
- 1:15:25think she thought, oh, no, people will be careful, and what
- 1:15:27she found is actually quite the opposite. Yeah, it's funny, that's interesting.
- 1:15:30I hadn't thought about that, but I've I've heard reports of that,
- 1:15:34anecdotes, and it makes sense because it makes sense. It's sort of like
- 1:15:39when you first made marijuana as a legal prescription, right in the initial months,
- 1:15:46you would probably find very careful administration of that prescription, whereas fast forward
- 1:15:54a couple of years and you just need an authorized clinician to open up a
- 1:15:59shot and have a philosophy of like, well, it's not my problem or
- 1:16:06it's not my duty to monitor this substance. And so I'm just going to
- 1:16:12hand out prescriptions that all people have to do is say they have back pain
- 1:16:15or they have trouble sleeping, their appetite. I know who did it.
- 1:16:17Yeah, well, the same could happen with these drugs that even if you
- 1:16:21have ninety nine percent of clinicians that are very careful about this, you only
- 1:16:27need one to set up a specialty, and they have a very lax attitude,
- 1:16:34and they might even have an articulate way of justifying it, just like,
- 1:16:38look, it's not up to us to decide if someone is on this
- 1:16:42planet or not, and if they meet this set of criteria. And we
- 1:16:47might look at that person and say, well, your criteria are pretty loose,
- 1:16:51But who's to say, you know, if it's a victimless crime,
- 1:16:57right, someone is deciding for themselves. And even if it's only been a
- 1:17:01year of suffering and they've only tried one or two things to mitigate the depression
- 1:17:06and the suicidality, you know, you could see someone making a justification.
- 1:17:11You're going you're not going to get a lot of a lot of consensus around
- 1:17:15that. Of course, Well, if I have a vested interest in a
- 1:17:17person's request for a prescription. In other words, if I make money on
- 1:17:23it, my moral compass is going to get a little wonky. That's just
- 1:17:27normal humans, right, not good, just normal right. And or you
- 1:17:31have a philosophy of depopulation of the planet is a good thing, huh,
- 1:17:36which you know, I'll hear people say that for you guys. Yeah,
- 1:17:40I'll hear people say stuff like that. You know, they'll they'll say,
- 1:17:43like, well, the deaths in this war are a good thing because there's
- 1:17:46so many people on the planet. War the deaths from COVID is a good
- 1:17:49thing because there's so many people on the planet. If you are emphasizing certain
- 1:17:56aspects of world fairness, like climate change and energy usage and resource management,
- 1:18:02and you emphasize that over other kinds of folki, then you could see a
- 1:18:09clinician saying, Hey, if people want to leave this planet, I'm all
- 1:18:14for it. There's too many people anyway, So any you could imagine,
- 1:18:16I could imagine, and it might already be happening in these communities. I
- 1:18:21will say that Paul, who is going through the process of getting authorization to
- 1:18:29kill himself in Europe and Switzerland, it is not easy. I mean,
- 1:18:33if anything, they make it so hard that I'm guessing a lot of people
- 1:18:40either just give up out of frustration, or you know, the Alzheimer's kicks
- 1:18:45in before they can finish the process, or they die before they can finish
- 1:18:49the process. So anecdotally, at least, I'm hearing the opposite really,
- 1:18:57which is that I think it's too much many hoops that you have to jump
- 1:19:00through. I mean, Alzheimer's pretty you know, pretty understandable. Course,
- 1:19:06there is no cure. There is no reversing the process once it begins.
- 1:19:13In our current technology, it's a done deal. You can slow it down
- 1:19:17maybe, maybe, but there often is a well understood progression based on what's
- 1:19:25been happening in the past. You know, year, you can take these
- 1:19:29measurements and say, okay, by and by x date. In all likelihood,
- 1:19:33you will not even be able to remember simple words that I will tell
- 1:19:40you, you know, ten seconds later, you know, I'll tell you
- 1:19:43like puppy, and then ten seconds later I ask you to remember that word,
- 1:19:45and you won't remember that word, among other kinds of symptoms like you
- 1:19:49don't recognize people. You know you're going through with your mom, Yeah,
- 1:19:53like what's that? Like? Well, she lives in New Jersey and I
- 1:19:56live in Washington, so I don't see her much. Her deterioration is she
- 1:20:01can't find words. She she mixes up words. She and she knows it,
- 1:20:08and she gets frustrated by it, though at least when she speaks to
- 1:20:13me, she generally has good humor. But I think it's exactly what you
- 1:20:16would expect. Is she's losing her mind in her personhood a little bit each
- 1:20:23day, and she despises it. And she's in memory care now. She
- 1:20:28knows it. Yeah, she knows that it's happening. Yeah, and so
- 1:20:31there's some point they don't know what's happening, right, No, No,
- 1:20:33she's aware that it's happening. And you know, she's she's been in memory
- 1:20:41care since November and not November October, so about well a few months,
- 1:20:49and hates it, even though I suspect she's you know, she's very lucky
- 1:20:55if for a person with Alzheimer's, it's a pretty nice place and it's safe
- 1:20:58and she will not be mistreated. And she lives five minutes from my brother
- 1:21:02and he's there pretty much every day. But imagine that that you live in
- 1:21:06your house with all your things and your freedoms and then now you're basically kind
- 1:21:12of like a prisoner in a in a hotel. In a hotel, yeah,
- 1:21:15a little bit smelly hotel, yeah yeah. And it might be nice
- 1:21:19on some level, but it's clearly an institution. It's clearly like a hospital.
- 1:21:26You don't have all your things or your freedoms, or you don't have
- 1:21:29your freedom's familiarity kinds of stuff. You know, the bed isn't really yours.
- 1:21:32The closet, no, no, she they moved. They bought her
- 1:21:35a bed to like it is her bed now. But but but everything that's
- 1:21:40familiar is for the most part mostly gone because I mean her she can't go
- 1:21:45to the kitchen and yeah, she's got to ask someone for something right or
- 1:21:49go to the right the main hall where the tea is or whatever. She
- 1:21:54can't she can't do it in her own place, when her right time.
- 1:21:58Like like you take it for granted it because oh I want a cookie,
- 1:22:01I get up and I go get a cookie. You know that I can
- 1:22:03walk out the door and just do whatever I want right right now. It's
- 1:22:08like I think I'll go for a drive, no or donut? So tell
- 1:22:14me, is it that way that if she were to attempt to walk out
- 1:22:17the door. They would prevent her. It's locked, right, you have
- 1:22:20yeah, I mean it's prison you have you have to have a coat.
- 1:22:23You have to know the coat. But you know, I get it,
- 1:22:25and it's for their benefit. But just imagine that feeling you're a prisoner.
- 1:22:32Yeah, yeah, God yeah. And and as it's happening, you're losing
- 1:22:39yourself. All the things that make a life worth living, all the things
- 1:22:42that you've accumulated through experience, hard won wisdoms are leaving you a little bit
- 1:22:47every day. God. And you know, and I can relate to Paul
- 1:22:53in that for us, you included, we are standing on a foundation of
- 1:23:00self esteem regarding our intelligence. And if we lose that, like, oh,
- 1:23:04forget, what's the point. I don't know what I'm good for.
- 1:23:08I don't know why I would stick around if I couldn't think, right,
- 1:23:12that not think like being a cognitive human and an intellectual. But my capacity
- 1:23:16that's connected to my intelligence is most of the value of my existence. Yeah,
- 1:23:23me too, Yeah, yeah, yeah. So even if I lost
- 1:23:27twenty percent, like a loss, I don't know what And I'm pretty sure
- 1:23:35that's in my future. My grandma went through that starting around eighty eighty five.
- 1:23:43Dementia, Yeah, just sort of regular not Alzheimer's, but just regular
- 1:23:47cognitive loss. And by the time she was like ninety five, she was
- 1:23:57pretty different and like a child, like a happy child, but still her,
- 1:24:01you know, there were still elements of her. But when she was
- 1:24:05younger, she was an articulate, educated, funny, dry In fact,
- 1:24:15I'll play right now a clip of my grandma giving a speech Oh cool at
- 1:24:23my parents' twenty fifth anniversary in nineteen eighty eight. Okay, and then when
- 1:24:28you went to school in grammar school, I just love to watch him go
- 1:24:32because he was like, how do you do it? So then when he
- 1:24:44became high school student, my father, my husband, George, said,
- 1:24:47I'm amazed. He said, I didn't think you would ever make it.
- 1:24:54He gave a fine athlete. And okay, so we're back and yeahs complicated
- 1:25:02topic and thanks for bringing up, Alicia. It's something that I think about
- 1:25:08myself. In conclusion, I'll say that, like I said, I'm never
- 1:25:13in this situation where I have to make that clinical call and I don't know
- 1:25:17what I would do. You know, I could see myself internally thinking,
- 1:25:21I think this person deserves support. But what if, right, you know,
- 1:25:28what if recovery is just around the corner. I can imagine if you
- 1:25:31don't have at least an awareness of where the break is, if you're not
- 1:25:35even tapping it as you go, you're probably there. I can't imagine not
- 1:25:41having those kind of thoughts. And the consequences are so big. Yeah,
- 1:25:46you can't come back from that decision if I authorize this or support this.
- 1:25:54What if? What? You know? There's all there's always that scene in
- 1:25:57the movie when the governor has stay of execution and calls the guy and then
- 1:26:01the guy in the prison is writing down and is running to the execution room
- 1:26:06and he gets there too late. You know what if that happens, right
- 1:26:10right, I just shouldn't stay out of that. That's just yeah, I'll
- 1:26:14just do a couple therapy then, Yeah, that's that's fine with me.
- 1:26:16That's good. That's good enough. Well, that does it for that episode
- 1:26:19of psychology and Seattle. Everyone out there, please take care of yourself because
- 1:26:23you deserve it.