Latest / Saigalseatrade Podcast / The Energy Paradox: Oversupply Ahead, Volatility Now - Part 1
Transcript
- 0:10What if I told you that by 2026 the world could be swimming in
- 0:14an oil surplus of over 3,000,000 barrels a day, while at the same
- 0:19time wars, sanctions and politics could suddenly wipe
- 0:23millions of barrels off the market overnight?
- 0:26That's the paradox we are living in and today we are unpacking it
- 0:30all. Freight rates, crude flows, OPEC
- 0:33Plus, manoeuvring, sanction games and what it all means for
- 0:37us. Welcome back to the Segal Sea
- 0:39trade podcast. I'm research analyst Shruti,
- 0:41your host today and we've got our in house expert, Mr. Sandesh
- 0:45Gandhar joining us today. Thanks Shruti.
- 0:48Thanks for inviting me. It's been pleasure to be here
- 0:51and we have a lot to discuss today.
- 0:54So let's start Sandesh right at the heart of it.
- 0:57The oil market today feels like a tug of war on one side, and
- 1:01the International Energy Agency is warning of a 3.3 million
- 1:05barrels per day surplus by 2026. But on the other, we have got
- 1:09geopolitical flashpoints everywhere, from Russian
- 1:12pipelines under attack to US naval buildups near Venezuela.
- 1:16So, Sandesh, can you paint the big picture for our listeners?
- 1:20And why does this paradox exist? And what are the forces pulling
- 1:24in opposite directions? Please tell us.
- 1:26Well, Shruti, that's a fantastic way to kick things off, you
- 1:30know, because if you talk to anyone in the business, whether
- 1:33it's the traders they are sitting in Genoa or ship owners
- 1:36in Athens or anyone in the market, the word you will hear
- 1:40over and over again is the paradox.
- 1:42The market is full of contradictions right now, and
- 1:46understanding them is key to Survivor.
- 1:50So let's start with some of the numbers because numbers never
- 1:53lie even if they sometimes mislead.
- 1:56So we have the IEA, they put out their report in September
- 2:01outlook projecting global supply growth in 2025 will hit about
- 2:062.7 million barrels per day and another 2.1 million barrels per
- 2:10day in 2026. Now, if you think about that, we
- 2:15are not talking incremental growth.
- 2:18We are talking the equivalent of adding an entire OPEC country.
- 2:23So every single year for two years in a row, we will see that
- 2:28growth. But here is the twist on the
- 2:30demand side. Growth is more modest because in
- 2:342025, the IES says the global demand will rise by just 0.74
- 2:41million barrels per day. And that's not nothing.
- 2:44But when you stack it against the incoming supply, you know
- 2:48the imbalance jumps right out at you.
- 2:51By 2026, the world it could be swimming in the surplus of, you
- 2:56have rightly mentioned more than 3.3 million barrels per day.
- 3:00And that's an ocean of oil with no immediate home.
- 3:04Now, if I stopped right there, you would think the market is
- 3:08doomed to collapse, The prices should be crashing.
- 3:12But that's where the paradox comes in.
- 3:13Because while the long term fundamentals scream and
- 3:17oversupply, the short term reality keeps getting jolted by
- 3:22some of the factors like geopolitics, conflicts,
- 3:25sanctions, and ultimate sheer uncertainty.
- 3:28Take the example of Russia, Ukraine drought and missile
- 3:32strikes on Russian refineries. They have knocked out roughly
- 3:351.1 million barrels per day of refinery capacity.
- 3:39And that happened in the overnight.
- 3:41And that's not just numbers on a spreadsheet, that's a diesel,
- 3:44gasoline, fuel oil, you know, that's suddenly not coming to
- 3:47the global market. So every ship owner who moves
- 3:51Russian clean products into Africa or the Middle East feels
- 3:55that disruption immediately. Let's take another example of
- 3:58Venezuela, but just a few months the US mood warship and those
- 4:04are 7 in numbers, plus a nuclear submarine and then 2000 Marines
- 4:10into the Caribbean. At the same time, Washington
- 4:13imposed 25% tariffs, so those 25% tariff on any non-us buyer
- 4:20of Venezuelan oil. So think about what that does.
- 4:24So China which had been taking nearly 0.9 million barrels per
- 4:28day from Venezuela suddenly finds those barrels more
- 4:33expensive. Now most of these barrels, they
- 4:36have been taken by the Chinese teapot refineries and now they
- 4:40have to decide one more thing. Do we pay the tariff or do we
- 4:44try a ship to ship transfer in the dark fleet or do we hunt for
- 4:48the alternatives like the Brazilian Tupee or US Mass?
- 4:52Now this Chinese teapot refineries, they are in an
- 4:56uncertain moment of whether they have to continue buying momentum
- 4:59from the Venezuela or find the different alternatives from the
- 5:02global market. Now that you have given Russia
- 5:06and Venezuela's example, can you also shed some light on the
- 5:09Middle East Gulf since we have been monitoring the Saudi Arabia
- 5:13who have been slashing their OS? PS.
- 5:15Well, Shruti, you have got the Middle East.
- 5:17We have a Saudi Arabia. They cut the official selling
- 5:20prices by dollar one to 2.2 per barrel to Asia, you know, just
- 5:25to defend the market share. And that's a clear signal.
- 5:29And the signal is Riyadh isn't willing to give up barrels even
- 5:33if the prices come under pressure.
- 5:35So it's the old market share defense playbook and every time
- 5:39Saudi Arabia cuts OS PS, Atlantic sailors like us, some
- 5:44of the West African players like Angola, Nigeria and then the
- 5:48Latin American player like Brazil have to rethink where
- 5:52their cargoes go. And that directly impacts the
- 5:55tanker demand and specifically the VLCC demand because an open
- 6:00arbitrage can flip VLCC flows almost an overnight unless they
- 6:06are available in the spot market and not bounded with the term
- 6:11contracts. Now for the refineries and for
- 6:15the traders or for any individual entities those are
- 6:18into the crude oil business. So this environment is kind of
- 6:23madding but also reach with the opportunity.
- 6:26So let me give you a real world example.
- 6:28Earlier this year, the brand Dubai EFS spread collapsed to
- 6:32almost 0. Just a few months earlier, it
- 6:35was trading around dollar for per barrel.
- 6:37And that collapse meant one simple thing.
- 6:40Atlantic barrel suddenly became competitive in Asia.
- 6:44So overnight you had the US Gulf Coast crude, Brazilian Tupee,
- 6:48even the West African greats like Bonnie Light making the
- 6:52long haul trip to the East. The barrels are going to China.
- 6:56So that's millions of additional barrels sailing into Asia and
- 7:00with them there was a surge in VLCC demand.
- 7:03Now for the ship owner this paradox is even a sharper
- 7:07because one week freight looks flat with the plenty of tonnage
- 7:11open and then within the next week or drone hits the Russian
- 7:15pump station, or OPEC announces an unexpected supply tweak as
- 7:20suddenly VLCC freight rates they can jump to 30 to 40% and that
- 7:25happening within a week. I have seen the owners described
- 7:29it like riding a roller coaster blindfolded.
- 7:32So if you feel the climb, you feel the drop, but you can't
- 7:36always see the next one coming. And then here is the kicker.
- 7:39Even though the base case is lying under the oversupply, the
- 7:44reality is that the market really trade on the base cases
- 7:48because they trade on the perception and on sentiments
- 7:52with respect to the market demand and on the fear of the
- 7:56next shock. We have seen a strike in Doha, A
- 7:59flare up in the Black Sea a few years back, a new round of
- 8:03sanctions from Brazil's a month back.
- 8:06So those are things that light a fire under the prices, which
- 8:11means that the refiners have to keep 2 timelines in their head
- 8:15at once. The structural timeline which
- 8:18says the oversupply is building and then the tactical timeline
- 8:23that says volatility is the only certainty.
- 8:27So Shruti, to answer to your question, the paradox exists
- 8:31because the oil market is being pulled into two opposite
- 8:34directions. So structurally too much supply,
- 8:38tactically constant disruption. And for our audience, you can't
- 8:43just look at the headline balance.
- 8:44You have to understand both the slow moving tectonic plates of
- 8:49crude oil supply and then crude oil demand and sudden earthquake
- 8:54of geopolitics which today driven by the tariff weapon
- 8:59which was very uncertain few years back.
- 9:02Because in this market, both can sink you or make you a fortune
- 9:06depending on whether you are prepared or not.
- 9:09So Sandeshya often said that trading is about spotting
- 9:12dislocations. Can you please explain that to
- 9:14our listeners? Maybe give us a real example
- 9:17like you just did a moment ago, like the Brent Dubai spread
- 9:20narrowing to almost zero recently.
- 9:22And how does something like that suddenly redirect millions of
- 9:25barrels and reshape the tanker markets?
- 9:28You have picked a phrase that almost a religion for most of
- 9:32the people in the crude oil tanker market and that is spot
- 9:36the dislocation. So let me explain what it means
- 9:39in simple terms. So in a perfectly efficient
- 9:42world, oil should move smoothly, prices should reflect supply and
- 9:47demand and the arbiter should barely exist.
- 9:51But the truth is markets are messy pricing differential.
- 9:56That means the pricing that we see on benchmark basis freight
- 10:00cost for the different types of tanker vessels, specifically in
- 10:04the crude oil tankers, then the refinery needs or the refinery
- 10:08procurement patterns. So they don't always line up
- 10:12neatly and this is specifically for the refineries who time to
- 10:16time switch their procurement patterns for crude oil with
- 10:19respect to market balance and with respect to the market
- 10:22demand. So this is the fundamental
- 10:25currently. And if they don't exist, that's
- 10:28a dislocation. Now I have mentioned the BRAIN
- 10:31Dubai exchange of futures for swap, the EFS.
- 10:34You know it is the single important barometer for the East
- 10:38West trade flow. So think of BRAIN as Atlantic
- 10:41World's benchmark and Dubai as the Middle East or the Asian 1.
- 10:45So when Brent trades at the Hepti premium to Dubai, Asian
- 10:48buyers naturally prefer the Middle Eastern crude because
- 10:51it's cheaper than Brent. But when that premium narrows or
- 10:55even disappears, the whole equation flips.
- 10:58Suddenly Atlantic barriers look competitive into Asia.
- 11:02And if you have lower freight rates for the VLCCS, that is
- 11:05even more competitive and more preferred product for the flows
- 11:09coming to Asia, specifically China and Korea.
- 11:12That's exactly what we saw recently.
- 11:15So back in June, the EFS was around dollar for a barrel.
- 11:19So at that level, US Gulf Coast and the Brazilian barrels, they
- 11:24struggled to compete into Asia. But by September, the EFS has
- 11:28collapsed to nearly a 0. And that's a seismic shift.
- 11:31So in the crude trading term, it's like opening a floodgate.
- 11:35So let me give you the math. Let's say for pricing parity, if
- 11:39you use price matrix, US Gulf Mars or WTA was around 68.25 or
- 11:4568.42, Brazilian 2P at 69.09, W African Django at 70.62, while
- 11:53the Murborn was around 69.39. So these are all dollars per
- 11:58barrel. And then Saudi Arab Light at
- 12:0071.18. So that meant Atlantic barrels
- 12:05were suddenly 2-3 dollars cheaper delivered into Asia than
- 12:09their Middle Eastern counterparts and the refiners
- 12:12specifically in China and India. Those are the 2 nation who are
- 12:16the largest importers of crude and are extremely price
- 12:19sensitive so they will buy the cheapest compatible barrel every
- 12:23time. So Sandesh, let me just stop you
- 12:26there. You just mentioned about cheaper
- 12:28deliveries to Asia. How do you think this will
- 12:30affect the VLCC market, say in the short term or in the long
- 12:34term? And how do you think will the
- 12:36fundamentals work around well? When you have dollar two or
- 12:39dollar three cheaper Atlantic barrels coming into Asia, VLCC
- 12:43specifically started booking eastbound like clockwork.
- 12:47So we saw US expert to Asia climb and the Brazilian flow
- 12:52surge and even the West Africa barrels rerouted from Europe to
- 12:56China. So the millions of barrels per
- 12:59week changing direction just because one spread collapsed.
- 13:03This isn't just about the crude pricing, it reshapes the tanker
- 13:07markets overnight. A cargo that might have gone for
- 13:11short haul into Europe suddenly travels 12,000 nautical miles to
- 13:15China or 24,000 nautical miles to China when we consider the
- 13:20round trip wise. And that ties up VLCC for more
- 13:24than six weeks instead of two. So the multiplier effect on the
- 13:28turn mile demand is an enormous 1.
- 13:31So freight rates, they react fast to this demand.
- 13:35So owners who had been complaining about the weak
- 13:38earning suddenly see the fixture spike.
- 13:41And here is the story. I remember talking to someone in
- 13:45Singapore who said the EFS is like my morning weather report.
- 13:49If it's wide, I know the Middle East is in control.
- 13:51And if it narrows, I started calling my US Gulf desk.
- 13:55So that's how deeply this one spread dictates the flows.
- 13:58And here is the catch. These dislocations don't last
- 14:02forever because the market is smart.
- 14:05Arbitragers rushing cargoes move and pretty soon the spread
- 14:09widens again. And that's why the discipline
- 14:11matters here. So it's also why OPEC Plus
- 14:14watches this like Hawk. We have seen the Saudi Arabia's
- 14:17OS pickers like I have mentioned earlier.
- 14:20So dollar one to 2.2 per barrel for October cargoes into Asia
- 14:25where a direct respond to that narrowing EFS.
- 14:28So they saw Atlantic barrels flooding east and then they had
- 14:32two options. First one is defend the price or
- 14:34defend the market share. And you know Saudi Arabia always
- 14:38do what they do the best, chose the market share over the
- 14:42pricing. So when we say all the spotting
- 14:45dislocation, this is exactly what I mean.
- 14:48You are not just staring at flat prices, you are watching the
- 14:52relationships brand versus Dubai time spread, the freight
- 14:55economics or earnings that we talked about from the ship
- 14:59owners perspective or the refinery runs.
- 15:02So because when those relationships breakdown, you
- 15:05know that's where the opportunity lies.
- 15:07And for the ship owners, I will say the lesson is same.
- 15:11Don't just track the freight indices.
- 15:13They should watch the crude spreads because they are the
- 15:15forward signal. So a ship or the vessel is fixed
- 15:19out of the US Gulf to Asia isn't just a rate, it's a reflection
- 15:22of spread collapse 1000 of miles away.
- 15:25So to simplify for listeners, a dollar four to dollar zero move
- 15:29in the brain. Dubai spread may sound like a
- 15:33small number, but in the crude oil market or in the freight
- 15:36market, it's the butterfly that flaps its wings in London and
- 15:41causes a hurricane of VLCC bookings in Singapore.
- 15:45Well, thank you Sandesh for that detailed overview.
- 15:47And with that, we come to an end to this episode.
- 15:50To all our listeners, do not forget to share and subscribe to
- 15:53our podcast. Until next time, navigate safely
- 15:56and stay tuned.