Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / The Tsunami of Terrible Sadness
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You, Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information please.
- 0:06Visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:23This is I love you. Keep going.
- 0:25It is Thursday, October 24th, 2024, 7:35 PM Pacific Daylight
- 0:31Time. And we talked about the
- 0:35earthquake of abandonment terror last week.
- 0:38So I thought that we would talk about the tsunami of terrible
- 0:42sadness this week. Mainly we're we're talking about
- 0:51this because of exploration and the things that get in the way
- 0:55of exploration. I'm doing a workshop on Saturday
- 0:59may have noticed about exploration and we, I tried to
- 1:06figure out a way that I could talk about advanced mentalizing
- 1:10in a way that would have broader appeal.
- 1:12And exploration turned out to be the vehicle for talking about
- 1:17advance mentalizing and, and what, what you need to be able
- 1:20to, to mentalize in order to explore it in a, in a deep way,
- 1:25in a primary way. And then because one of my
- 1:30lifelong explorations is photography, I thought I would
- 1:34use that as an illustration. So that's what we're going to do
- 1:37on Saturday. But the earthquake of
- 1:40abandonment terror and the tsunami of terrible sadness are
- 1:44this sort of 1-2 punch that takes out your exploration.
- 1:48And so it can be useful to talk about it in that way.
- 1:54If you grow up in a family system where who you are is
- 1:57appreciated and you have caregivers who are curious about
- 2:01that and they support you in developing that authentic nature
- 2:09of who you are, then you learn to express yourself
- 2:14authentically and you learn to pursue the experiences that come
- 2:22from the activation of that authentic self.
- 2:26You might even call it a creative self that arises in
- 2:30response. But if you grow up in insecure
- 2:34and disorganized family systems, then the authentic expression is
- 2:38not highly valued. And what is valued instead is
- 2:44the the either in a, in an insecure way, the role that
- 2:50works in the family system that that you are in some ways
- 2:54pressured to adapt to, or in a disorganized family system.
- 3:00Really they're what happens are these extreme defenses that that
- 3:08arise in order to manage the environment that you're in.
- 3:14One of the things about this though is if you are required to
- 3:18be a certain way in the family system or you you avoid any kind
- 3:24of authentic expression in the family system because you need
- 3:27to protect that. You need to preserve it from
- 3:30what can go wrong in a family system.
- 3:33Then you spend the time, energy and resources you have
- 3:38developing the insecure or disorganized self.
- 3:43And the authentic self is, is in some ways set aside the false
- 3:50self is what Masterson used to call it, or I guess he's he's,
- 3:55he's not on the planet. But the in that school of
- 3:58thinking that early understanding of how personality
- 4:02forms and how it is either anchored on to the authentic
- 4:07sense of self or anchored on to the false sense of self that's
- 4:12required in the family system. We develop this really, you
- 4:19know, pretty well defined, pretty functional, pretty good
- 4:24false self. But our our authentic self is
- 4:27not in that way developed. And so we get good at navigating
- 4:33the world in disguise of the inauthentic self-expression.
- 4:38We get pretty good in, in insecure organized family
- 4:44systems of going after secondary exploration, the gathering of
- 4:49time, energy and resources that are necessary to support a life.
- 4:53But we don't get so involved in, in the, in the activities that
- 4:59provide meaning for us because our our way of operating in the
- 5:03world is not centered in, in authenticity.
- 5:06It's centered in inauthenticity. Then even if we were to discover
- 5:10what was important for the inauthentic self within the the
- 5:14the family system, it wouldn't resonate at that meaning level
- 5:18that a primary exploration attached to the expression of an
- 5:25authentic self. Would that all making sense so
- 5:29far in this frame, in those kinds of family systems, when
- 5:35the reaction to the present moment conditions is in the
- 5:39authentic experience, what it tends to do is cause a strong
- 5:46abandonment here. This is the earthquake of
- 5:49abandonment here, because either you're afraid to express it
- 5:55because you need to protect it, or you are afraid to express it
- 6:00because it isn't valued in the family system and you're
- 6:02redirected into something else, often with the accompaniment of
- 6:07shaming for being interested in the kinds of things that you
- 6:13might be interested in. And what's held up instead is
- 6:18this idea of who you need to be in the family system.
- 6:21So the family is valuable. The way that it worked out in in
- 6:26in my family system was we had a presentation that we needed to
- 6:32be outwardly facing. And there was a lot of pressure
- 6:38to maintain that public facing presentation, but it didn't
- 6:42match at all what was happening within the family system.
- 6:47And we weren't permitted to really talk about what was
- 6:51happening in the family system, mainly my mother's drug
- 6:56addiction and really sort of low functioning in my dad's really
- 7:02sort of sadistic treatment of us.
- 7:06It was just not allowed. And so the contrast between that
- 7:10outward facing ideal family and the inward reality of it created
- 7:16these really sharp schisms which we needed to protect ourselves
- 7:22from because it for children, the world needs to be ordered.
- 7:27It needs to be within a range of intensity that that's
- 7:32manageable. And as soon as things exceed
- 7:34that, we become quite frightened as children and it interferes
- 7:42with our ability to function very well.
- 7:46That all making sense when you look at that spike of
- 7:53abandonment terror of what the mind does immediately is come up
- 7:58with versions of reality, you know, inauthentic alternatives
- 8:03that are relieving of the abandonment here.
- 8:06So you have you're not so far down the rabbit hole of
- 8:09inauthenticity, a sense of what the authentic experience is and
- 8:15it spikes the abandonment terror.
- 8:18Then the mind immediately generates a version of the
- 8:22self-expression that is designed to relieve the abandonment
- 8:27terror. And if you express that it does
- 8:30in fact relieve the abandonment terror and the system comes back
- 8:34into balance and the delusion in that Buddhist sense of it that
- 8:41you're not seeing clearly what actually is happening is that
- 8:46that that's preserving the balance, that's preserving the
- 8:50relationships. But actually what it is is in
- 8:55some sense annihilating the authentic self, annihilating the
- 9:00passageway where you would derive meaning.
- 9:05Mary Oliver says this one wild and precious life that you have.
- 9:12So you go that route and a little while later you're
- 9:14starting to get angry and it's it comes from deprivation.
- 9:21You're not free to express your authentic self.
- 9:24You're not free to request the things that you authentically
- 9:28need to happen. And so you come into a state of
- 9:32deprivation where your authentic needs are not being met.
- 9:35Even if the inauthentic needs are taken care of, because the
- 9:40authentic needs are not being taken care of, there's still a
- 9:44sense of deprivation. And then you get angry at the
- 9:48people that are forcing you into this inauthentic expression and
- 9:54this state of deprivation. And so there's a separation the
- 10:01other people that you might rely on.
- 10:06All right, I've just explained that to you.
- 10:08Now it's all resolved and you can just be authentic in the
- 10:11next moment, right? Which is unfortunately not true
- 10:16because of this bummer called conditioning.
- 10:24We anticipate in that process of generating conceptual reality
- 10:31what a potential outcome would be.
- 10:35And if over and over again in our childhood experiences, when
- 10:38we accidentally let the authentic expression slip and
- 10:43we're immediately chastised in some way for it, our capacity to
- 10:49step out that inauthentic expression is inhibited by our
- 10:53anticipation of what's going to happen.
- 10:58And Mudit. George, sorry to interrupt.
- 11:04Can you share ways in which people are inauthentic?
- 11:13I have one of my one one example that I like and if it isn't good
- 11:17we can try another. So you go to a movie with
- 11:20somebody and you sit down there and it's the worst movie you've
- 11:24ever seen. I mean, it is terrible.
- 11:26You can't even believe that you you want to go to the manager
- 11:29and ask for your money back. It was so bad.
- 11:33And then as you're walking out of the theater, the person looks
- 11:36at you all doe eyed and said that was the best movie I ever
- 11:40saw. What are you going to do?
- 11:46The authentic thing would be, that was the worst piece of shit
- 11:49I've ever seen. What did you like about it?
- 11:51Right. But you may think that they
- 11:53would abandoned you if you did that.
- 11:55And then you would be too frightened to express yourself.
- 11:58And then you would say, yeah, that was a pretty good movie.
- 12:01Which would be the inauthentic expression, right, Christian?
- 12:09I don't know if this is. Maybe this is manipulative in
- 12:13some way, but when when I am with someone and I want to
- 12:17elicit their opinion and I feel like they're likely to give me
- 12:19the inauthentic expression, I will hold my own opinion back
- 12:27and then I'll elicit their opinion so I can get it without
- 12:30like being in reaction to mine. Then I'll let it RIP and I'll be
- 12:34like, no, I fucking hated this thing.
- 12:40And the question is whether it's manipulative or not.
- 12:44Well I wanted I want the authentic expression so.
- 12:52In in a secure relationship where you feel confident that
- 12:56the relationship isn't going to be threatened by your opinion.
- 12:59You're free to express whatever you want, right?
- 13:02Oh, you thought that was a good movie.
- 13:05I'm completely baffled. What what about it?
- 13:08Right? And that thing Mudit.
- 13:10So it's essentially expressing opinions.
- 13:14That's the only way somebody can be.
- 13:17It's inauthentic. Well, you're inauthentic by not
- 13:22allowing somebody to see your authentic response.
- 13:28However, however it happens. How so?
- 13:32Most of the time it would be opinions of people.
- 13:38Well, how else do you communicate, if not in a verbal
- 13:42exposition? Body language?
- 13:46Do you? Do you restrict the expression
- 13:49of body language? Respect, expression of
- 13:54attention? It isn't necessarily always
- 13:59language and in fact, language is also accompanied by the whole
- 14:04expression of the body. And so I, I work in, in this
- 14:12mode quite a bit in, in zoom land.
- 14:16And I can tell you that some people are hypersensitive to
- 14:20whether I'm looking directly at the screen or not.
- 14:22And if I look away even for a moment, they chastise me for not
- 14:27a paying attention. I even had somebody said, how
- 14:31dare you look away from the screen.
- 14:33I'm paying for your time so that that we people are very
- 14:39sensitive to the whole expression.
- 14:42So it doesn't have to be a language opinion.
- 14:45It could just be the feeling of you when somebody reaches out to
- 14:49touch you. Do you lean into the touch?
- 14:52Do you stay the same? Do you with, do you pull away
- 14:55from the touch? All all of that is what's being
- 15:00expressed. Sorry, that's a preoccupied
- 15:03state of mind, right? I also have this thought.
- 15:06The. Eyes moving somebody.
- 15:10So is that an expression that I'm feeling that you are not
- 15:14paying attention to me, hence that abandonment is there?
- 15:19Right. The abandonment arises, but then
- 15:22how do you, how do you allow yourself to know that?
- 15:27So if you went into an immediate dismissing view, you would, you
- 15:31would think that they were actively rejecting you, right?
- 15:37And you would feel a loss of proximity if you were
- 15:41preoccupied. And and then you would be
- 15:43eliciting a return to proximity, which is what the demand would
- 15:48be. If you're fearfully preoccupied,
- 15:50the demand would be sharp like that.
- 15:52And if you were more in a helpless preoccupation, it would
- 15:56be more seductive to get your attention back.
- 16:01Oh, I see. It's seductive, not aggressive
- 16:04like a dismissive person. Right.
- 16:08And a dismissing person could come seducing or they could come
- 16:13bullying. It depends on what they think
- 16:15would be more effective. They're not really committed to
- 16:17it because they can switch on a dime.
- 16:19The bullying doesn't work, they just switch back to seductions.
- 16:23You mean the sweetness, right? The sweetness?
- 16:25Yeah, the sweetness. Thank you.
- 16:33One of the things about attachment conditioning, of
- 16:35course, is it it it you develop skills at, at picking up beyond
- 16:42language, but you can also, because of childhood attachment
- 16:47conditioning have a very limited way of gathering information.
- 16:52And you could be one of the outcomes of childhood could be
- 16:56that the only way you have any sense of somebody else is in
- 17:00language, what they say. You have no real way of checking
- 17:04whether what they're saying to you is true or not.
- 17:07Because of of the your limited capacity to pick up on facial
- 17:12expressions in body languages, you restrict emotions.
- 17:16So you don't have good empathy or your own internal emotional
- 17:24state is so dysregulated. You can't really TuneIn on the
- 17:28empathetic experience cause your your internal life is so chaotic
- 17:33making sense. So you let's say you recognize
- 17:46that this process of your authentic expression arises, but
- 17:50it activates an intense abandonment terror.
- 17:57But you decide that you're going to begin this process of pushing
- 18:01into authentic expression, and you push in and make the
- 18:07authentic expression, or you recognize that you haven't, and
- 18:11you repair it as fast as you can, and the abandonment terror
- 18:16spikes up. But these things are waves.
- 18:20So the spike is this wave that arises and passes, and then that
- 18:27earthquake of abandonment terror causes the the reaction of the
- 18:32tsunami of terrible sadness and it comes rushing over you.
- 18:39And then when we begin to take apart the terrible sadness, what
- 18:43the terrible sadness is, is a reaction to the experiences of
- 18:49your authenticity being lost in the in the childhood conundrum.
- 18:57And because of the different ways in which attachment
- 19:00conditioning affects the development of attachment, it
- 19:03also affects the way that the terrible sadness accumulates.
- 19:12And they're around different kinds of experience.
- 19:18So Jordan, you're muted. Sorry, when you reference the
- 19:38tsunami of terrible sadness is are you referencing something
- 19:44similar or the same thing to like the pool, what you would
- 19:49call like the pool of poison and pain?
- 19:57I think that often the pool of poison and pain activates in
- 20:00response to the activation of the tsunami.
- 20:03But the tsunami is really a reaction to the present moment,
- 20:08the terrible sadness, and it often exceeds the window of
- 20:11tolerance. So it could also be accompanied
- 20:13by self generated emotion and and then it could also activate.
- 20:20The pools and so you have all three of them activating, but it
- 20:23usually starts in the in the response to the.
- 20:28I I see. So follow along with the
- 20:30metaphor of the pool and that you know, tsunamis and what have
- 20:36you occur on the surface. Yeah, but it could be that the
- 20:40tsunami is so intense that it's then pushed into the pool.
- 20:43So you could have a pool that matches pretty well with that
- 20:47terrible set. OK.
- 20:49That makes that makes sense. Thank you.
- 20:52So what happens with the with the, the, the terrible sadness
- 20:57is it's a recognition of how your conditioning has affected
- 21:01your your life and in dismissing people.
- 21:09The terrible sadness is really oriented and began with the
- 21:14realization in childhood that nothing you did and you tried
- 21:19everything, nothing you did change the equation where your
- 21:25your caregivers would actually be responsive to you.
- 21:28There was nothing that you could do in the authentic expression
- 21:33of yourself which would get them to be responsive to you.
- 21:37And what you ended up having to do was to abandon yourself and
- 21:42become the idealized version that the that your caregivers
- 21:47wanted of you. And in that abandoning of self,
- 21:52you also abandoned awareness that that was what was
- 21:55happening. It's the process of developing
- 21:58the skill of idealization where you strip out any anything
- 22:03negative and live in these idealized expressions of the
- 22:13mainly of the caregivers and the life that they provide for you.
- 22:18And one of the things that really intensifies the
- 22:21experience of the terrible sadness is that it had so little
- 22:26to do with the things that really mattered to you, that all
- 22:29of that had to be handed over in order for you to operate in this
- 22:36idealized version that the that was demanded of you.
- 22:40Sometimes there's a a kind of self accusation that you should
- 22:45have done something differently than that.
- 22:48But I do want to reassure you that all children submit.
- 22:55They really don't have any choice in the matter.
- 22:57There wasn't leeway for you to have chosen yourself.
- 23:02The three-year old hobo that walks out the door, you know,
- 23:08doesn't happen. Hi, Ruben.
- 23:14I can't give you an example from my childhood.
- 23:18One day my sister went outside, got on her tricycle and rode off
- 23:25and, and everybody, all the adults started looking in the
- 23:29neighborhood. They couldn't find her and and
- 23:32eventually the police were called and she rode off in the
- 23:36morning. At like 5:30 in the afternoon,
- 23:39the police cruiser pulls into the driveway and he opens the
- 23:44trunk and takes my sister's tricycle out of it and she opens
- 23:47the back door and my sister climbs out of the back door.
- 23:50She looks at me and she said I could have got away.
- 24:05But to where they said they found her 7 miles away, which is
- 24:09on a tricycle. Quite a triumphant attempt.
- 24:20The In the preoccupied dilemma, the the terrible sadness is
- 24:36linked to the idea that you again, it's this abandonment of
- 24:46self, but it has a slightly different coloring to it.
- 24:51The terrible sadness of the dismissing is that everything
- 24:55you do, everything that you try, nothing succeeds and attracting
- 25:00the attention and care of your caregivers in the in the
- 25:04preoccupied mind. The problem is that because the
- 25:10the the the child becomes dependent on the emotional
- 25:15regulation of the caregiver, and because the child is often role
- 25:18reversed into caring or the caregiver.
- 25:22The the child who who is seduced into this belief that the the
- 25:29caregiver can't really survive or function without the
- 25:32intervention of the child. Of what the child begins to see
- 25:38is that they are the ones who abandoned themselves and they
- 25:43are the ones who chose to stay and take care of the caregiver
- 25:48when the time came for them to be able to go off and do some
- 25:53something else. And so the, the terrible sadness
- 25:57for the preoccupied person is the, the sense of the self
- 26:01abandonment. I, I didn't take the
- 26:04opportunities because I couldn't tolerate the, the loss of
- 26:09proximity. That making sense.
- 26:15The terrible sadness for disorganized people is around
- 26:21the great betrayal the, the caregivers actually harm the
- 26:28children and they either do it in a hapless way or they do it
- 26:32in a sadistic way. And the, the idea that you would
- 26:37have a caregiver that then harmed you is so terribly
- 26:42difficult to hold. The and the and the betrayal is
- 26:47felt in such a deep way that, and the sadness surrounding that
- 26:54is held in such a deep way that that that's that experience.
- 27:02And so when we talk about the activation of the terrible
- 27:06sadness in response to the activation of exploration, often
- 27:15the activation of that abandonment tear and then that
- 27:18activation of the terrible sadness interferes with the
- 27:22capacity to actually engage in a meaningful way with exploration.
- 27:32Organized insecure people tend to be really focused on social
- 27:39status as a way of validating themselves.
- 27:44They tend to be very focused on secondary exploration, which
- 27:48means they're also focused on what is societally and
- 27:52culturally valuable. And if they get to a place where
- 27:58they have to choose between what is authentically meaningful to
- 28:04them and something that is valuable culturally or
- 28:08societally or that offers access to a high social position, it's
- 28:14very difficult for them to choose their authentic
- 28:17exploration and to choose meaning and to abandon the, the
- 28:23cultural values that can come from achievement.
- 28:28Even when the experience of achieving doesn't provide a, an
- 28:35effective enough source of meaningfulness, it's, it's still
- 28:42hard. What happens to disorganized
- 28:45people? And on the, the preoccupied end
- 28:50of disorganization, so fearfully preoccupied people is they
- 28:53become so controlling they they squash any kind of collaboration
- 29:00that might help them in, in exploring the in order to take
- 29:11big risks in exploration, you kind of have to have a safety
- 29:16net. Otherwise, the the risks,
- 29:21particularly if the risks would lead to to a kind of emotional
- 29:25dysregulation that you would have a hard time managing.
- 29:32You tend to be more reluctant to take a big risk if if there
- 29:39isn't some place to catch you. And that safety net, of course,
- 29:47is the the social network that you put around yourself when
- 29:51you're in that fearfully preoccupied mode of thinking and
- 29:56you're extremely controlling about everything.
- 30:00That demand, that insistence on being in control of everything
- 30:06actually has the the opposite effect that you might want in,
- 30:10in that it pushes people away from you rather than draws them
- 30:14in to support the the collaborative experience of that
- 30:21social support. Going out and taking risks and
- 30:24coming back into an expression of that fearful avoiding people.
- 30:31The main difficulty for them is that they don't trust themselves
- 30:38particularly to evaluate who would be trustworthy and who
- 30:41wouldn't be trustworthy to collaborate with, because the
- 30:47experience of their childhood was really ordered around their
- 30:54trusting people and then being exploited and betrayed by them.
- 30:59And because of most of the time in childhood, that's a kind of
- 31:07trying to think of the anyway, those relationships that turn
- 31:13sour in that way are often cultivated over time so that the
- 31:18child's trust is invoked and the child's attachment is invoked
- 31:23and then betrayed. Is that all making sense, Henry?
- 31:29Was that last part for disorganized or preoccupied
- 31:33people who don't trust themselves to evaluate who to
- 31:36trust or not? Disorganized, avoided, more
- 31:40fearful, avoided people. That's true, I think.
- 31:43OK. Thank you.
- 31:45Fearfully preoccupied people tend to be controlling, and
- 31:48that's how they manage it. And fearfully avoided people
- 31:53because they're capacity to identify who will harm them and
- 31:57who won't harm them is been compromised.
- 32:03They don't they're reluctant to go into collaborative
- 32:10relationships because of that. That reluctance is greater than
- 32:22ordinary reluctance. So that in organized attachment
- 32:28systems, so there is always some slowness at the beginning in, in
- 32:33the formulation of relationships because you don't really know
- 32:36who the person is and you want to find out who they are.
- 32:39But the, the, the defensive barriers that disorganized
- 32:43people put up are so massive that organized people give up
- 32:49before they, they get through the, the, the, the walls, which
- 32:56leaves disorganized people vulnerable to predators because
- 33:00predators don't give up. And they're the ones who get
- 33:05through the defenses because of that or the, the, they activate
- 33:13a, a, a sense of reality in, in the disorganized people that
- 33:18they're back in an abusive situation and there's nothing
- 33:21that they can do to stop it. And so they don't, they don't
- 33:24rally prevent the abuse after the the initial defenses are
- 33:30breached. And it creates in them this
- 33:34belief that they're they're that they have a target on them and
- 33:39people can identify them. And this isn't actually what
- 33:43happens. What happens is they rebuff
- 33:47everybody who puts a normal amount of pressure on and they
- 33:52they don't rebuff the people that put an extreme amount of
- 33:56pressure on. And then when they feel
- 34:03frightened sufficiently, they become passive.
- 34:06And so they don't resist. And the predators can't tell the
- 34:11difference. They just bang on everybody to
- 34:13see who, who, the, who's defenses they can get through.
- 34:22So when we're talking about this reclaiming of authenticity and
- 34:27this moving into a place where we can activate the, the
- 34:33creative sense of self, we can activate the authentic sense of
- 34:38self so that we can begin to organize around the, the
- 34:43meanings, the values that that authentic curiosity will lead us
- 34:50to. We need to be able to manage
- 34:53both the abandonment terror and the, the terrible sadness.
- 34:58The abandonment terror is a, it tends to be a spike that arises
- 35:01and passes pretty quickly. And the the terrible sadness
- 35:07tends to to be something that that lingers.
- 35:14Paradoxically, the way out of the terrible sadness is simply
- 35:17not to resist it and just allow the full intensity of the
- 35:21sadness to arise. It, like all things, is
- 35:25impermanent, and it rises and passes.
- 35:29The dismissing person has spent their entire life developing
- 35:38these very defensive structures of of sort of self
- 35:44aggrandizement to keep them away from the terrible sadness.
- 35:50And if you can allow yourself to drop into the terrible sadness
- 35:53and not get away from it and allow the full intensity of it,
- 35:58those defensive structures just fall apart because you don't
- 36:03need them anymore because you don't need to protect yourself
- 36:07from the terrible sadness. And so for organized, dismissing
- 36:12people at resolves the quickest. Which isn't to say that sitting
- 36:18into the terrible sadness is easy, but it is something that
- 36:23can be managed in preoccupied people.
- 36:27There's a lot more to do in organized preoccupied people.
- 36:32One of the things that dismissing people already have
- 36:36is a high level of mentalizing, not quite at the level of
- 36:40security, but close and preoccupied people don't have
- 36:45that level of mentalizing. And so one thing that has to be
- 36:49developed is the capacity to mentalize so that you can begin
- 36:59to discern what is authentic and what isn't authentic in the in
- 37:06that mentalizing frame, you the first step is to understand what
- 37:13is the experience of reality that you've just generated?
- 37:17Is it accurate to what's happening?
- 37:20The second part is understanding how it is, what it is about the
- 37:25experience of the present moment that you want to express and how
- 37:29do you express it so that you communicate what you want
- 37:33somebody else to know. And the better you know
- 37:35somebody, the more adaptive you are in terms of the expression
- 37:40of it. Then you make the expression and
- 37:43monitor the reaction to the expression that the other person
- 37:46makes and ensure that you understand both of that they
- 37:52understand what you've communicated and that you
- 37:54understand their reaction to that.
- 37:57And then you modify. That's the fourth piece, your
- 38:01understanding of the relationship with the advent of
- 38:06this new information. When you look at a preoccupied
- 38:12modeling of mentalizing, the preoccupied person throws up a
- 38:18presentation to the other person and then they monitor where the
- 38:23other person is going to meet their needs or not.
- 38:27And if the person if their need is not met at the end of that
- 38:30exchange, they just modify their presentation and express it
- 38:34again, monitoring only whether or not their need is met.
- 38:39And then they, it's not, they just make another expression in
- 38:43the attempt to get the need met. And so there's a lot that has to
- 38:48be built out around that. One is that you have to monitor
- 38:52well enough to know what meaning you've made of the experience of
- 38:57the present moment You have, you have to develop the mentalizing
- 39:02capacity to understand what about that you want to
- 39:05communicate. Rather than just throwing
- 39:09spaghetti at the wall and seeing what sticks.
- 39:12You actually have to formulate a way to express it that is
- 39:16authentic, and then you have to be willing to monitor the
- 39:19outcome of your expression and then modify your understanding
- 39:25that. That requires a lot of
- 39:28development of mentalizing. Then what you have to do is
- 39:32figure out how to explore. Before you even get to
- 39:36discovering what's meaningful. You have to figure out how to
- 39:40discover whether something is meaningful or not.
- 39:44And dismissing people can already do that.
- 39:47Disorganized people, depending on which end of it, if they're
- 39:51more fearful avoidant, they already have the capacity to
- 39:55explore. What they don't have is
- 39:57resilience. And fearfully preoccupied people
- 40:02don't explore particularly well. And so they have all of that to
- 40:07do, complexly disorganized people.
- 40:12Really, the circumstances of childhood to get you into a
- 40:16state of complexly disorganized are really, really harsh.
- 40:21And so there's a lot to do in terms of establishing these,
- 40:27working toward establishing epistemic trust.
- 40:33Epistemic trust is where you believe somebody is telling you
- 40:36the truth because they have evidence, right?
- 40:39And you believe that the reason that they're telling you what
- 40:42they're telling you is because because they want to be helpful
- 40:46to you. And if that's true, then you can
- 40:49learn from them. And if you don't have epistemic
- 40:52trust, it's hard to learn from them.
- 40:56An epistemic trust of is compromised in insecurely
- 41:02organize people because you don't, you don't really focus so
- 41:08much on the evidence. In secure relationships, you
- 41:15tell somebody something, but you have to have evidence to
- 41:18demonstrate that it's true. Whereas in insecure
- 41:21relationships, people don't check the evidence.
- 41:26So people can say whatever they say.
- 41:27And the reason for that is that as a child, if you checked up on
- 41:32your caregiver, you would see that what they were telling you
- 41:36was often not true. And that's worse than accepting
- 41:42something that isn't true as true and then disorganize people
- 41:48because there's the the conundrum of being harmed by the
- 41:53people that are taking care of you is.
- 42:02Once you of course, can ride out the spike of abandonment tear
- 42:08and you can ride through the wave of terrible sadness, then
- 42:12you can get to the place of activating the authentic self
- 42:17and beginning the process of discovering what's actually
- 42:20meaningful. Henry.
- 42:26Yes. I was wondering if there is a,
- 42:30if you have a good resource for kind of the terminology on all
- 42:34this stuff and the like, the frameworks of how it all fits
- 42:37together. I think I can get tripped up
- 42:39sometimes on fearful dismissive. Just all the different
- 42:45attachment terms. Do you have our poster?
- 42:51I don't think so. We have a poster.
- 42:55OK, you might have one here. Yes, this is a poster.
- 43:09And this has all the different attachment strategies and all
- 43:13the different responses that you're likely to experience in
- 43:17different activities that people engage in.
- 43:22It includes the terrible sadness and the earthquake and all the
- 43:26rest of it. So it, it and it.
- 43:29Because most of this terminology is mine, this is a good example.
- 43:37If you're. It's on our it's on our website.
- 43:41You can order it. Sweet.
- 43:44Thanks so much. I'm I'm mix.
- 43:48So in the original attachment development, Mary Ainsworth and
- 44:00John Bolby hooked up these three different aspects.
- 44:05Secure, anxious, avoidant, anxious, ambivalent.
- 44:09That was the original 3. And those are child categories
- 44:15because the original testing was of children in the strange
- 44:19situation which was Mary Ainsworth.
- 44:22Then they wanted to see whether these attachment strategies
- 44:24carried over into adult life. And in order to identify the
- 44:29adult categories, they named them differently.
- 44:32Secure became secure, anxious avoidant became dismissing.
- 44:39Anxious, ambivalent became preoccupied.
- 44:42So the adult categories are secure, dismissing and
- 44:49preoccupied Mary Maine and Eric Hesse up at Berkeley.
- 44:58Mary Maine was a postdoc with Mary Ainsworth, went through the
- 45:08strange situations that they couldn't classify, which they
- 45:11called CC and discovered disorganization.
- 45:15So that became the 4th category. So they had CC and then then
- 45:21they had disorganization which is around the loss of coherence
- 45:24in the transcript. And so when you look at
- 45:30attachment, some of them match child categories and adult
- 45:34categories and some don't. But you could call it a five way
- 45:41secure, dismissing preoccupied, disorganized and cannot
- 45:47classify. I like to talk about this
- 45:53organization because we work with a lot of disorganized
- 45:56people. And this is not really true of
- 45:59of the research community because they're doing research
- 46:02is at elite universities where disorganized people are not as
- 46:05popular. What do you know about getting
- 46:10into an elite university? It's competitive.
- 46:12What do you know about fearful disorganized people?
- 46:16That they're not reliable, They can't do it.
- 46:19But I like to talk and these are colloquial psychology,
- 46:25psychotherapy type terms, fearful avoidant, fearful
- 46:31preoccupied. But then I also like to talk
- 46:35about complexly disorganized, because complexly disorganized
- 46:38people can be preoccupied, avoidant, or secure, sometimes
- 46:46even. And so in the map that we talked
- 46:49about, we have for adults a secure dismissing, helplessly
- 46:57preoccupied. And then on the disorganized
- 46:59side, we have fearfully preoccupied, fearfully avoidant,
- 47:02and complexly disorganized. Would it?
- 47:11I wanted to ask about the theory.
- 47:15I know there's a lot of complexities in how people
- 47:19behave in different attachment styles, but how useful is that?
- 47:23If somebody wants to move to secure attachment, isn't simply
- 47:30doing IPF enough the details unless I want to be somebody
- 47:39wants to be a trainer? I don't think that IPF on its
- 47:45own is enough. It's a three pillar approach and
- 47:49you have to do all three pillars.
- 47:50So depending on how you do it is is what's different.
- 47:55IPF will not really develop mentalizing enough, so you have
- 48:02to have some focus on mentalizing in order to move
- 48:07into secure functioning relationships.
- 48:09You also have to have a higher level of emotional regulation
- 48:13and alternative regulation strategies to what you have in
- 48:18insecure, disorganized attachments.
- 48:20So you have to do mentalizing and emotional regulation
- 48:23training in order to develop the capacity for that.
- 48:28You can do that in the therapeutic side through therapy
- 48:34where you engage in some mentalizing and emotional
- 48:36regulation therapy, or you can do it with the meditation
- 48:41approach that we like. And then you also need some
- 48:45instruction on how secure collaborative relationships are
- 48:49supposed to function. Because if you grew up in a
- 48:51household where insecure, disorganized relationships are
- 48:55modeled, you don't actually know how they're supposed to be
- 48:59operating. And you can think that the the
- 49:03way that people are responding to is actually not a good way
- 49:06when when it's it's more secure. So for instance, the the
- 49:12preoccupied person needs constant proximity and they're
- 49:14willing to sacrifice their own exploration in order to maintain
- 49:19the proximity. But a secure person won't allow
- 49:21that proximity because it interferes with their their
- 49:25exploration. And so they would want some kind
- 49:28of space in a relationship where they could explore and that that
- 49:33would be acceptable, but it wouldn't necessarily be
- 49:36acceptable to the understanding of a preoccupied person how it's
- 49:40supposed to work. So you also have to have the
- 49:43education around and the modeling of how relationships
- 49:47are supposed to function so that you can move into that kind of
- 49:51relationship. All three of them have to
- 49:53happen. Yeah, sorry, I thought.
- 49:56Yeah, when I'm when I said IPF, I meant mentalizing as well
- 50:00occupied. Does IPF as well as mentalizing
- 50:05work? Will he automatically feel not
- 50:08the need to be in physical proximity eventually?
- 50:13Yes, I would think because they would value their own
- 50:18exploration and the, they would have alternative ways to
- 50:21regulate themselves so that the anxiety that propels them to
- 50:24seek constant proximity would be managed in a different way and
- 50:28they wouldn't need to that when you earn security, one of the,
- 50:33the remarkable things is that anxiety goes away.
- 50:41It's, and I like to say it's not that you get better tools for
- 50:44managing the anxiety. It just doesn't come up anymore
- 50:46the way that it used to come up. So you don't have to manage it
- 50:50because it's been resolved. Dismissing people become more
- 50:56spontaneous and and they stop rehearsing everything and and
- 51:02stop managing the presentation of everything at they get to
- 51:08where they don't anticipate rejection, which is how they
- 51:13experience the abandonment anxiety, the constant over
- 51:17monitoring to avoid rejection and shame.
- 51:21They don't. They don't need to do anymore.
- 51:24So that drops away. That that the rejection doesn't
- 51:28come up in the conscious experience at all?
- 51:31Or does it come up and they're like, wait a second, this is
- 51:33just another thought they would. Well, it's, it doesn't come.
- 51:39We're all sensitive to being accepted by the people that we
- 51:43want to be accepted by. But so you have an awareness of
- 51:48that happening, but it doesn't turn into that intensive animate
- 51:52anxiety or that intense anticipation of rejection so
- 51:58that it changes the way that you present yourself from authentic
- 52:03to inauthentic. But it still arises in
- 52:06awareness. It arises in levels that still
- 52:11allow you to present yourself authentically.
- 52:16That's the main difference. Is the the and that anxiety or
- 52:21that that anticipation of rejection prevent you from
- 52:26expressing yourself authentic, whereas when it's in a level
- 52:32where it doesn't prevent the authentic expression you, you
- 52:36continue to gather the information that you can express
- 52:39yourself authentically and not risk the relationship it's.
- 52:45Almost like a tolerance scale that you develop and you have
- 52:49more tolerance now to be slightly more authentic than.
- 52:53Right. Pushing that more and more.
- 52:55And the more you do it, the more conditioned you become to
- 52:58anticipate a positive response from the authentic expression to
- 53:02where there's very little resistance to being authentic.
- 53:07And, you know, I use the minesweeper metaphor.
- 53:11The old PC game, you ever played it?
- 53:14Sometimes you click on a square and half the board opens up.
- 53:18It's remarkable how fast you can move into authenticity in
- 53:22certain areas, and then you get into another area.
- 53:25It's so compacted and so difficult because there's so
- 53:30much conditioning around. Alex.
- 53:36Yeah. Hi.
- 53:38So the terror and the sadness, how long could these last for a
- 53:44lifetime? Good.
- 53:49Unless you do something about it.
- 53:52But how long do they last in the moment of activation?
- 53:56Is that what you mean? Yeah, I think so that that maybe
- 54:03I understand better. It's more on the scale like
- 54:04minutes, hours. The initial last of it is
- 54:11seconds. But then how do you manage a
- 54:15intense emotional experience? Do you use thoughts?
- 54:20Most people use thoughts to manage it.
- 54:22What kind of thoughts you use to manage it?
- 54:24And does that just keep it going?
- 54:27So let's say you have you're dismissing person and you have
- 54:31the spike of abandonment tear, which you don't really allow
- 54:34yourself consciously to feel. And then you just hear your mind
- 54:38giving you all the reasons why you're going to be rejected.
- 54:42I'm too short, I'm too tall, I'm too thin, I'm too fat.
- 54:47I'm too this or that. I mean, the mind will generate
- 54:50that whole string of reasons why you're going to be rejected.
- 54:54And then you're you're amping up the the response, amping up the
- 55:01saddest maybe that kicks off the somaticized emotion of that
- 55:06particular experience over and over again.
- 55:08And then the weight of that intense emotional experience,
- 55:12which is that at this point entirely thought driven,
- 55:16prevents you from making the expression, which reinforces the
- 55:21idea that the rejection is inevitable.
- 55:24And then that. And then once you're into the
- 55:28activation of the terrible sadness around, you're always
- 55:31going to be a rejected. You're always going to be alone.
- 55:33This is never going to work out. That can go on for days because
- 55:37it's thought based. They don't have clarity on it.
- 55:42Just stop it. That can go on.
- 55:49And then if it's a somatosized emotional experience, that is a
- 55:51strong activation in the pool that that can last for days too.
- 55:55So yeah, you really need to to develop the clarity to see
- 56:00what's actually going on in order to break it apart so that
- 56:06it doesn't happen so much that making sense.
- 56:11But the initial spike is a few seconds.
- 56:29The longest activation of the pool I ever had was 12 days.
- 56:32So it even that's finite in a sense.
- 56:36But it was a it was a wild ride. I'm was on the dismissing side
- 56:42of things, so anticipating rejection was the the way that I
- 56:49experience it, but also being disorganized.
- 56:52Rejection meant being killed. So it was pretty.
- 56:55It could be intense, Henry. One thing I've been wondering
- 57:02for a while is which, if any, attachment style would be closer
- 57:07to secure between preoccupied or dismissive?
- 57:14Really, if you look at the cascade, it's secure dismissing,
- 57:21helplessly preoccupied, fearful, avoidant, complexly disorganized
- 57:28and fearfully preoccupied in terms of and mainly what you're
- 57:33talking about is the skill set and what has to be developed in
- 57:38order to come out of it. So avoidant avoidance is closer
- 57:45to secure than preoccupation is and that mainly has to do with
- 57:49the capacity to explore. So if you look at the fearful
- 57:54avoiding people can explore better than fearfully
- 57:56preoccupied people and complexly disorganized because they have
- 58:00the avoidance component and the preoccupied component too, they
- 58:05have better exploration. And then at the at the far end
- 58:10is the fearfully preoccupied person who has very low
- 58:13mentalizing, very low emotional regulation and very little
- 58:18capacity to explore. That's why it why it's harder.
- 58:26OK. That makes sense.
- 58:27Yeah. Thank you.
- 58:28That's cool. Dismissing, you know, if you
- 58:32look at the mentalizing frame on a scale of 1 to 9, secure people
- 58:37tend to come out six or higher without any intervention.
- 58:42Dismissing people are in the four to five range, organized
- 58:46preoccupied in the three to four range, and disorganized people
- 58:50are below 3 in terms of mentalizing.
- 58:53So there's a lot of, there's a lot to do in order to come out
- 58:59of that. Epistemic trust tends to be
- 59:05intact more or less in organized people and it tends to be really
- 59:09broken and disorganized people. So you also have to repair
- 59:13epistemic trust in order to be able to learn from somebody.
- 59:16You can't learn from somebody. You can't get help to resolve
- 59:20this. So the part of it is also the
- 59:25repair of epistemic trust. And then of of course, how do
- 59:31you pick trustworthy people, which is one of the other
- 59:36impediments in for disorganized people.
- 59:40How do you do it? Because your epistemic trust is
- 59:45broken and you most of the time really don't monitor whether
- 59:50people do what they say they're going to do.
- 59:56Well, we've talked for a longer time than we normally do, but
- 59:59maybe what let's do just a quick.
- 1:00:03Loving kindness, practice. OK, let go of the meditation.
- 1:00:09How's that? So on Saturday is the second of
- 1:00:13the exploration half day longs. It starts at 9, ends at 1:00
- 1:00:17Pacific Time. I'm hoping it'll be a good
- 1:00:21class. We'll talk about.
- 1:00:25We talked about intermediate states of mentalizing in the
- 1:00:31first one and we'll we'll do the advanced set in this one and
- 1:00:36relate that to how those advanced stages of mentalizing
- 1:00:42really do further primary exploration.
- 1:00:47And then in November, I'm going to do a workshop called Family
- 1:00:53Archaeology or Home for the Holidays from the attachment
- 1:01:00perspective, so that you can go home, but and actually take a
- 1:01:06look at how you, your attachment conditioning unfolded for you as
- 1:01:13a child. And also to try and navigate
- 1:01:17the, the family relationships in a way that you can get something
- 1:01:21out of it. I I really am convinced that
- 1:01:26because to be loved by our caregivers is so fundamentally
- 1:01:30important to us as children, that if we can as adults develop
- 1:01:36a sense that there was love there, it's really useful to us.
- 1:01:40And that if we can do that when we go home, instead of the
- 1:01:44constant cycle of being disappointed that they didn't
- 1:01:47meet the needs that you had then or they can't meet the needs
- 1:01:51that you have now to really focus on the things that they
- 1:01:55can do and the expressions that do feel good.
- 1:01:59And so you can set aside the difficult parts and really just
- 1:02:03accept the things that are are there.
- 1:02:06That's a process of seeing it clearly.
- 1:02:09And then the needs that they can't meet, you can go out into
- 1:02:11the world and find people that will meet them.
- 1:02:13And we'll, we'll be happy to meet them so that you don't go
- 1:02:17without. I think that there's this,
- 1:02:19there's a kind of deprivation that's activated when you go
- 1:02:23home and you're still trying to get from them things that they
- 1:02:26can't really give you. And then you have peace at home
- 1:02:31and you have a sense of the value that you have for them.
- 1:02:34Obviously they're this is based on what's actually there, not
- 1:02:38not a pretend setup. And then we'll be into the
- 1:02:45holidays and and the year will be over and we can all look
- 1:02:49forward to what's next. I've been told by my person who
- 1:03:02let's see here supposed to drop a couple of things into the
- 1:03:07chat, which I'll try and do now. The I do offer the class on a
- 1:03:28donation basis. Really appreciate any amount if
- 1:03:33you have resources, it helps me and help support the work that
- 1:03:40we do here at Metagroup. And then if you're curious about
- 1:03:46our. If you're interested at all in
- 1:04:08the the Exploration Workshop, there's a link.
- 1:04:18Good to see you. Thank you for your practice.
- 1:04:20We'll see you soon. Bye now.
- 1:04:24Thank you. Bye.