Latest / Newcomer Pod / Index Ventures' Danny Rimer Talks Figma's IPO and VC Bets
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, everybody. It's Tom Doughton here.
- 0:02Welcome to this week's episode of the Newcomer podcast, shortly
- 0:06known as Newcomer. I'm joined here by Eric,
- 0:08Newcomer, Madeline Renberger and our special guest, Danny Rhymer
- 0:12of Index Ventures. Welcome to the show, Danny.
- 0:15Thank you very much. Nice to be here.
- 0:17Are you, by the way, in the San Francisco Index Ventures office?
- 0:20Are you? Where are we right now?
- 0:22Thank you for asking. I'm actually in our New York
- 0:24office. That makes.
- 0:26Sense. That makes sense.
- 0:27What is happening this week? Figma is going public and you
- 0:31are on the board. So I imagine it's a good week to
- 0:33be in New York. Indeed, it is a good week.
- 0:36It's always a good week to be in New York, but definitely this is
- 0:40a momentous week. Is it a New York Stock Exchange
- 0:43or is it NASDAQ? New York Stock Exchange.
- 0:46You get to go. You get to go do the whole the
- 0:49whole place. Circumstance exactly.
- 0:51Do a little ringing. Exactly right.
- 0:53Yeah. I mean, we'll go deeply into
- 0:55Figma in a second here, but this is not your first IPO here.
- 0:58Have you done the bell ringing before?
- 1:00Have you been on the floor as one of your companies was was
- 1:03out there? I've been to the NYC and NASDAQ
- 1:06for my companies. I'm very privileged, but my
- 1:10policy is actually not to ring the bell because I feel like,
- 1:15you know, it's really about the team and the founders and their
- 1:20family. And so it, it's not something
- 1:22that I think makes sense for for us to do.
- 1:25Skulk in the background, you know.
- 1:27Yeah, exactly. That's really.
- 1:29From the sidelines, happy to be there.
- 1:31That's. Right.
- 1:32The floor is dangerous, though, because reporters hang out
- 1:35there. I know the one time I ever did a
- 1:37Stock Exchange debut thing, I was like really snaking around
- 1:41the floor trying to find the investors in that company.
- 1:44So that's very bold of you to hang out there.
- 1:46Yeah. Thank you.
- 1:47Yeah, yeah. I did the Uber one and I'll
- 1:50always remember, you know, Travis Kalanick was up in the
- 1:53balcony because sort of like, couldn't be in the fray with
- 1:56Dara and everybody. So it was a sort of funny
- 1:59dynamic, that one. I mean, you know, Ubers done
- 2:01well, but that was a reminder like, oh, the day itself can be
- 2:04painful because I think the markets are just not good.
- 2:07And so it was a hard one. Yeah.
- 2:09Anyway, we are recording this on a Wednesday and this will come
- 2:12out on Friday after Figma story. For you guys, I mean, you were
- 2:32one of the first, maybe the 1st VC investor in, in Figma.
- 2:36So you, you and Dylan Fields go go way back.
- 2:39What's the origin story? Yeah, we were indeed.
- 2:41So the origin story is is quite a long one.
- 2:44I mean it's it's sort of interesting right in this
- 2:46industry. I was just reflecting, you know,
- 2:49for other investments that we've made, that I've made, that I've
- 2:52gone public and also that have had liquidity events.
- 2:55It's not always a long journey, but this has been 13 years.
- 2:59You know, he was 19 when I when I first invested or when, when
- 3:03index first invested. So it's definitely been a
- 3:06journey with ups and downs and with chapters.
- 3:09And so there's something really gratifying of being able to
- 3:14remember and reflect on on this journey.
- 3:17Sorry, that was a long winded even preamble to your question,
- 3:20Tom, but I was just, you know, I was, I was getting a little
- 3:23philosophical about it. Well, the length I think is key
- 3:26to this, both that Figma raises sort of pre traction and some of
- 3:31your bet. Your bet is like before they
- 3:33really had sort of the viral take off and then obviously
- 3:36before. They had a URLI think, right?
- 3:38They didn't even know what part of.
- 3:39The URL, that's right. And then down the line, there's
- 3:42the acquisition that wasn't of Adobe trying to buy it for $20
- 3:45billion. Yeah, there's there's precede
- 3:48and then there's pre URL. Yeah.
- 3:50Exactly. To answer your question, so
- 3:53first met Dylan when he was an intern at another company that I
- 3:57was on the board of called Flipboard, which was this really
- 4:00sensational company in its time where Mike McHugh, who was the
- 4:05founder of Tellme, which was another company that we had
- 4:09invested in actually that I wrote his first check ever in
- 4:13that one that sold to Microsoft. And, and Dylan was an intern and
- 4:19at the time just really remember his enthusiasm and his amazing
- 4:24ability to communicate information with enthusiasm, but
- 4:29also with detail and then lost touch with him because he was an
- 4:33intern. I've taken a note that I should
- 4:35do a better job on tracking interns and then resurfaced
- 4:39after I was having a conversation with, with Jeff
- 4:43Weiner from LinkedIn, who's, who's a good friend.
- 4:46And I was telling him about this thesis that we had on who's
- 4:49going to inherit the mantle of the most important business
- 4:53franchises out there like Microsoft Office and Adobe
- 4:57Studio. And, and he said, well, you
- 4:59should talk to this intern that I can't get to stay at LinkedIn
- 5:03called Dylan Fields because he wants to do something around the
- 5:06area of design. And I think you'll really enjoy
- 5:09the conversation. So that was that was How I Met
- 5:12him again. He came to to pitch what was not
- 5:16Figma at the time, but to pitch his idea with Evan, his Co
- 5:21founder. Well, and so much about Figma,
- 5:23you know, you mentioned, you know, it's about design, but
- 5:26essentially the customers for it are UX designers, people that
- 5:30are trying to kind of mock up what a product is going to look
- 5:33like, like what a, you know, a digital experience is going to
- 5:36look like. I mean, that industry has
- 5:38changed a lot in the 13 years or so since you first made that
- 5:42investment. I mean, can you kind of situate
- 5:44to us like a bit in time like how Figma has evolved to a point
- 5:48where, you know, they are a company that's going public, but
- 5:52also one that probably is facing more competition and and threats
- 5:56than they have, you know, well, very different kind of
- 5:59competition and threat than they did, you know, in their earliest
- 6:01days. I mean, how have they evolved?
- 6:03Yeah. I mean, you know, just to give
- 6:05you context, when we invested in Figma, the concept that we were
- 6:12interested in is at the time, most of the startups that we
- 6:16were working with used Sketch and Dropbox.
- 6:19So Sketch for design internally and Dropbox for transferring
- 6:24those files between people because.
- 6:27You were an investor in Dropbox. In Dropbox and and reached out
- 6:30to Sketch, but Sketch did not want to take investment at the
- 6:33time. And so it was quite, you know,
- 6:36Sketch was a good product, but it was quite complicated for for
- 6:41versioning reasons and for sharing reasons.
- 6:44And then and then Figma came up with this concept of multiplayer
- 6:48from the get go. And so that felt like all of of
- 6:52these headaches around designing and sharing, we're going to go
- 6:56away by this new means of designing and sharing
- 7:01immediately. That's really what led to the
- 7:04interest that we had in Sigma. It's.
- 7:07Like there was this thing called cloud and they could serve the
- 7:10designs. It's amazing what a different
- 7:12era it was. Yeah.
- 7:14I was like, oh, there's new careers that were being created
- 7:17in the types of designers. There are new ways of file
- 7:19storage. There are new types of software
- 7:22that can be developed. And then I think, you know,
- 7:24jumping to today, you know, there's the this sort of will
- 7:29designers and product managers be coders?
- 7:33And you know, Figma has come out with four new products this
- 7:36year. I mean, some are targeted
- 7:38marketers and so there are lots of categories they're trying to
- 7:41go after. But I'm curious like
- 7:42specifically on this, like design is the beginning of code.
- 7:47Do you see that as like it's more just sort of like the mock
- 7:51up or do you think designers will be like real coders or
- 7:54what's sort of your sense of how these sort of like make tools
- 7:57are going to develop? Yeah.
- 7:59It, it feels as though, you know, fundamentally the
- 8:03relevance and the core of design has only become more significant
- 8:10since our investment. I mean, it already was becoming
- 8:14slightly more significant. Like I, I remember that Facebook
- 8:18at the time would offer more money if you're an employee at
- 8:23Facebook and had given a reference that was hired and it
- 8:27came from you. So you'd get paid more as a
- 8:29reference check for a designer than for an engineer at
- 8:33Facebook. That was back then in the day
- 8:35and sort of highlighted the fact that the importance of designers
- 8:39is increasing just merely from what the market was going to
- 8:43command. And I think that that design
- 8:46relevance has only increased over time and that the lines
- 8:51between who's a developer, who's a product manager, who's a
- 8:55designer has really blurred. And with all of this AI
- 9:01technology that is enabling, you know, with, with vibe coding and
- 9:06the the notion of being able to instantaneously create software,
- 9:13the role of design as the primary differentiator seems to
- 9:18me more relevant than it ever has been.
- 9:21Are you bullish on vibe coding as being sort of an essential
- 9:24way that stuff gets created? You know, that's a really good
- 9:27question. I, I think that the notion of
- 9:32ease in actually manifesting something, but whether it's
- 9:38through being in a mode, in a vibe mode or being very
- 9:44deliberate on what you want to code, irrespective that's
- 9:49happening, that trend is more core.
- 9:52Now the question is, you know, what is the result of that mode
- 9:57that you're in? And design is going to be
- 10:00central in whatever mode that you're in.
- 10:02So I don't know if that's helpful.
- 10:04I, I think it's premature to know whether there is indeed
- 10:08this mode. You know, the way that I'm
- 10:11thinking about it, Eric, and maybe this is not a good
- 10:13parallel is if you think of jazz, I'm a huge fan of jazz.
- 10:18You know, jazz is a vibe concept.
- 10:21Like the vibe of improvisation is what creates the genius of
- 10:27jazz. Whether that translates to
- 10:29something like coding, I don't know.
- 10:32I think the jury's out. Irrespective, the layer of
- 10:36design is going to be critical. The jazz parallel is an
- 10:39interesting one because it's also, you know, the
- 10:43improvisational aspect. I understand the parallel there.
- 10:45But jazz is also highly technical.
- 10:47You have to be like a very skilled musician to be able to
- 10:50really have the fundamentals to to to, you know, mess around in
- 10:55the way that people do in jazz. Whereas vibe coding to me sort
- 10:58of lowers the bar of entry. Yeah, people who are not
- 11:01typically software developers can at least, you know, put
- 11:04together a website rather than, you know, having an expert need
- 11:07to do it. We're talking about a lot of
- 11:09worlds that I'm I'm I'm an amateur and an aficionado.
- 11:13Isn't it? It's a VC job?
- 11:15Yeah, exactly. You cover it.
- 11:16Exactly. Exactly.
- 11:18But no. Yeah.
- 11:19But you know, there are some, there are some musicians who can
- 11:23read and write and are really technical, and there are some
- 11:27musicians who never learn. Go all by ear, yeah.
- 11:30Yeah, so they don't compose anything, but it's off ear and
- 11:33then and then they're phenomenal musicians.
- 11:35I don't know what's going to happen there, but what's clear
- 11:38is that again, this notion of there are all these tools at
- 11:44your disposal. It's probably never been as easy
- 11:47to create music as today, but at the end of the day there is this
- 11:52layer that happens where you have to take whatever your
- 11:56output is and really work on it to make it resonate.
- 12:00I mean, you know, I interviewed Dylan at Cereal Valley AI Summit
- 12:04London not too long ago and we had a great conversation.
- 12:08Obviously I played with a lot of big Mas products before that.
- 12:11You know, I'm pretty bullish on Figma.
- 12:14Like the design tool, I get the story of like extending it to
- 12:19sort of like different categories, like you're doing a
- 12:21business plan, you're a marketer or whatever.
- 12:24To me, the make and the sort of like vibe coding thing is, I
- 12:27don't think it's like existential necessarily to
- 12:29lovable. I mean, sorry.
- 12:31Well, lovable existential to Figma and the threat of lovable
- 12:36is clearly there. But like I do think there's like
- 12:39is make sort of quintessentially Figma or not to me is like this
- 12:44sort of interesting question because in some ways like design
- 12:48and Figma are so like intentional and you have like
- 12:50these rules and you're like, OK, these are our design principles
- 12:53and we like stick to them. And in some ways, like these
- 12:57vibe coding efforts are so like hacky, you know, and obviously
- 13:01we're going to try to sort of bring those two worlds together.
- 13:04And I I guess I can't tell yet whether I really think they they
- 13:07meld well or or not. Yeah.
- 13:10I mean, I we'll have to see. I mean, I'm super excited about
- 13:14Figma Make obviously, because I think that the notion of having
- 13:21all these tools at your disposal to mean that the entry point for
- 13:27you to start making things is lowered and then there are all
- 13:33these tools at your disposal to make the output much more
- 13:38sophisticated. That whole journey is really
- 13:41enabled through Figma Make and I suspect that that's going to
- 13:46mean that what we're going to see out there, AI and the trend
- 13:51of AI is undeniable, right? Like as bearish as we were about
- 13:54crypto is as bullish as we are about AI, so.
- 13:57Index was bearish on crypto. Yeah, I didn't know that you you
- 14:00could have dropped that one in there.
- 14:01Danny, what's that about? Oh no, no, we were we were just
- 14:04just, you know, like not Bitcoin, but like the the whole,
- 14:07you know, the web 3 concept of crypto.
- 14:10You know, this is fundamentally web 3, right, like AI is web 3
- 14:14for sure. And so the concept of what Figma
- 14:17make can do in terms of getting more and more people to actually
- 14:23create things and then have all of these tools at your disposal
- 14:28to really refine what your output is going to be is super
- 14:33exciting. I mean, Eric's sort of maybe in
- 14:35a Freudian sense dropped lovable in there.
- 14:39It's the elephant. It's the tiny elephant in the
- 14:41room though. High valuation, but yeah.
- 14:43What's your take on them? And the reason I want to ask you
- 14:45specifically beyond just the Figma side of things is that
- 14:48when I think Index, I really think you guys are maybe the
- 14:51most, you know, the one of the largest, most aggressive players
- 14:54in the European tech market. And lovable is if they can
- 14:59really, you know, hit their numbers and achieve what a lot
- 15:02of people are expecting could be one of the bigger breakout hits
- 15:05from Europe in a while. I mean, have you had a chance to
- 15:07to look at them and. You know, not, not a ton.
- 15:10I mean the reality is I mean as you know, we look, we, we do
- 15:13focus on few geos, right, Like we focus on on the US, on
- 15:18Europe, on Israel and that really is our core like across
- 15:21the board, that's our core. I mean Figba is 85% of its users
- 15:25are international. So we see it as a as a global
- 15:29phenomenon. There are a number of really
- 15:31exciting new players, lovable being one of them.
- 15:34But you know, beyond that, don't don't have much of.
- 15:37A thing you're saying you can't hammer us about one European
- 15:40startup we want to hit all the best all over the world, or I'm
- 15:42trying to understand the global point.
- 15:45No. So in other words, you know, the
- 15:47the global point is when we look at companies, we look at the the
- 15:51geos that we think we have a good enough understanding in
- 15:56picking what we think will be the best teams to go after.
- 16:00So we don't sort of view ourselves as primarily European
- 16:04or primarily US or primarily Israel and then we try to find
- 16:08global winners. So my point is, you know, if it
- 16:11has global appeal as it does with Figma that that ticks the
- 16:16box of what we're looking. For I see, but not because like,
- 16:19oh, Europe is our turf and we need to yeah, I.
- 16:22See, no, no, no, no, no, no. So you know, like, so for
- 16:25instance, we looked at Stripe and Audien and we thought, you
- 16:28know, for a lot of reasons, Audien made enormous sense for
- 16:31us. Jan my partner who who was
- 16:34behind that, you know, looked at the space and thought Audien was
- 16:37a phenomenal opportunity, which it ended up to be, right?
- 16:42I covered Adobe when I was at the Wall Street Journal, and I
- 16:45had the blessed experience of writing about the Adobe Figma
- 16:50deal falling apart. My predecessor on the beat was
- 16:53the one who wrote the story about the Adobe Figma deal
- 16:55happening. It's a weird situation where I
- 16:58imagine when the, you know, acquisition first gets
- 17:01announced, that comes off as like a big victory.
- 17:03It's an exit. It's, you know, one of the
- 17:06things you hope for when you back a company 10 years before
- 17:09that. Explain to me what was going
- 17:11through your mind when the deal first happened and whether you
- 17:13were optimistic it would actually go through.
- 17:15You know, the reality is we really look to invest in
- 17:20entrepreneurs who want to build a stand alone business because
- 17:24it's just impossible to assume that a company is going to get
- 17:29acquired and that that's a really great exit strategy.
- 17:34Maybe things will change over time, but certainly it's proven
- 17:38to be a terrible idea. It also is a means of of
- 17:43separating folks who are there for the economic return of
- 17:47starting a company versus those who are on like a mission like
- 17:51Dylan and Evan were to democratize designs through this
- 17:54platform. So really we always assumed that
- 18:00Figma was going to be an independent company.
- 18:03In addition to that, in most of the cases, just from a return
- 18:08standpoint as AVC, the returns are much greater if the company
- 18:14is an acquirer rather than acquirer, right?
- 18:17Like if you are a public company, you're much more likely
- 18:22to become the one that acquires rather than be acquired.
- 18:25So there are a lot of economic reasons why being a stand alone
- 18:29company makes a lot more sense with a few exceptions.
- 18:33So if you go back there, the first point would be we were
- 18:37very happy for Figma to stay independent.
- 18:40Were you against the deal when it first was being discussed?
- 18:43What I was going to say, on the other hand, you know, we always
- 18:46respect what the founders want to do, right?
- 18:49Like at the end of the day, we are privileged to be on this.
- 18:53Ryan will be as helpful as possible, but they're running
- 18:55this, they're running the show. So if the team thought that it
- 19:00made economic as well as structural sense to be acquired,
- 19:05then we weren't going to vote against it.
- 19:07I. Mean, it was clearly a huge
- 19:08valuation, right? I mean, it was $20 billion
- 19:11three. Years.
- 19:12Exactly. Right.
- 19:13I mean, analysts hated the deal. Adobe analyst Adobe.
- 19:17Yeah, exactly. So it's like clearly from a
- 19:19fiduciary point of view, it seemed like a good deal for.
- 19:22No, that's right. That's right.
- 19:24And just like just like Wiz is a good deal, you know, I mean the
- 19:28Google Wiz acquisition makes makes a lot of sense.
- 19:32So if it makes economic sense, if it it makes structural sense,
- 19:36if it's what the company wants to do, we're obviously going to
- 19:39play ball and be supportive of it.
- 19:41Then there's the question of like all the regulatory
- 19:44approvals that are necessary and how much of A hurdle that's
- 19:48going to be. And so we never high 5 ourselves
- 19:51when when a deal gets announced because we know that the journey
- 19:55is going to be so long. Can you talk about the company
- 19:58resilience point of view? I mean, just being an, you know,
- 20:02tiny entrepreneur, I can imagine you think.
- 20:04I think you have the exit. You're like, OK, we we've made
- 20:07it to a certain like, you know, goal post.
- 20:10And it's easy to lose steam. And certainly lots of companies
- 20:13sell and then do lose steam. You know, what did it take for
- 20:17Figma to to stay strong, to get to this point of going public
- 20:21after sort of seemingly almost hitting a sort of goal post?
- 20:25Yeah, that's such a good question.
- 20:27And I, I actually must say that if I were the, maybe that's part
- 20:33of the reason why I'm not an entrepreneur, right?
- 20:36Like I would find the just the the morale issue, but also just
- 20:43the the schizophrenia involved of thinking that you're going to
- 20:47be part of a company, thinking that you have to be independent.
- 20:50Now they're the great enemy. Adobe's our friend.
- 20:52We love them. Now they're archrival.
- 20:55And this goes on in and out for 12 months.
- 20:58That is really challenging. It was amazing to see how from
- 21:02one day to the next, I think, you know, having finality,
- 21:07having clarity and also and just like always having the drive to
- 21:14build a stand alone business. Back to your point on value,
- 21:17like the it's very clear this was not out of necessity from a
- 21:21Figma standpoint, right? Like they had a great business,
- 21:25but from one day to the next, they turn the page, they offer
- 21:29this awesome severance package for anyone, no harm, no foul who
- 21:34wanted to leave less than 5% as I think 4% of the employees
- 21:39decide to leave and take that huge package.
- 21:42And then the rest from one day to the next, like we are just
- 21:45going to build the most awesome independent company.
- 21:49We're so excited about this and they just went for it.
- 21:52And to your point, Eric, you know, I mean, they announced in
- 21:55in the Bay Area and in London, you know, they came out with as
- 21:58many products in a year as they had in the whole history of
- 22:04Figma prior. So you can just imagine how much
- 22:07of A driving force it was to show the world, to show
- 22:12themselves what they could do. Yeah, my, my sense as a reporter
- 22:17covering them or met with them during that time was like
- 22:20extreme compartmentalization on Figma's part.
- 22:23Like, I went to their offices and obviously this was a
- 22:27regulatory matter, but they just couldn't talk about Adobe.
- 22:30It was as if the deal didn't exist as it went through, and
- 22:34they were just trying to run things business as usual.
- 22:37And then, you know, when the deal eventually falls apart,
- 22:40there was an interesting kind of media push I saw from the
- 22:42company's part to sort of talk to the press and say, like,
- 22:46things are good. You know, we all have it in
- 22:48line. This all worked out.
- 22:49And Figma, you know, is in a good position despite the fact
- 22:53that, you know, they've been in this purgatory for the last 12
- 22:56months. This is a benefit that that not
- 23:00all companies have is that Figma truly has a community right like
- 23:05they they do not have sort of uninterested customers.
- 23:11What they're doing, I know when I was doing prep for the Dylan
- 23:14thing, I went on Reddit like you can read all the like.
- 23:17Everybody has strong opinions about what they should do.
- 23:19It's a very invested customer base.
- 23:21And not only that, they were an invested customer base that did
- 23:24not like the Adobe deal because they were worried that Adobe was
- 23:27going to fuck. Up the product.
- 23:28Exactly, I'm using this product, right?
- 23:30Yeah. Yeah.
- 23:31I mean, I would have said, I would have said it was sort of
- 23:33mixed. Like there were some, there were
- 23:34definitely members of the community that could see the
- 23:37benefit of not of like having one suite where they would pay
- 23:40for everything etcetera. But yeah, I mean, the reality is
- 23:44the the community is vested in the company feels like and
- 23:49correctly feels as though, you know, it's thanks to them in a
- 23:53lot of ways that the company is successful that they've given so
- 23:57much input and they've bought the subscription.
- 24:00And so I think that in the back of all the all the fig mates
- 24:05minds was like we, we got to deliver for our community here.
- 24:09Yeah. You obviously have really
- 24:11conflicted feelings about this since as you were saying, you
- 24:14would have preferred them to remain an independent company.
- 24:17They did. The return will end up probably
- 24:19being better because of that over time.
- 24:21That's still to be seen. Yeah, right.
- 24:24Well, they have the opportunity, at least now it's.
- 24:26Money in the hand several years ago, but, you know, like you're
- 24:29saying you want to be an acquirer.
- 24:31If they continue to grow, there's upside, you know?
- 24:33Yeah. Well, but so, but here's here's
- 24:34my question though. I mean, did you think the
- 24:37regulatory intervention here was good or bad?
- 24:41Was it overreach? I mean, was there a strong case
- 24:43that this was some anti competitive move by Adobe?
- 24:47And you know, like where do you stand on that?
- 24:50Because it obviously has implications for your other
- 24:52companies, you know, whether regulators are going to be more
- 24:55accepting of deals. I mean looking back on it, like
- 24:58what's this the right call? Like is, are we in like an
- 25:01overly austere regulatory environment?
- 25:03Yeah. I was going to ask just to
- 25:04clarify like what do you have, has this changed like any
- 25:07perspective you give to your other portfolio companies about
- 25:09whether they should pursue, you know, M and AR IPO, even if IPO
- 25:13is always the goal? You know, there's, there's only
- 25:16so much I'm going to say here folks.
- 25:18I would say that regulatory bodies just need more fluency
- 25:21when they are going to come up against a potential acquisition.
- 25:27And that's what I wished had been the case in the Adobe Figma
- 25:32situation. And we'll see what happens with
- 25:35with other situations. I can't really comment more on
- 25:38that. I wanted to talk about, you
- 25:40know, venture broadly and sort of move sort of beyond the Figma
- 25:44story. I'm curious, you know, how much
- 25:46is every index deal right now an AI deal or how do you think
- 25:50about like the pervasiveness of AII mean, you know what
- 25:55Anthropic is now, I guess raising it at $170 billion
- 25:59valuation. I feel like we we're obsessed
- 26:02about vibe coding. Clearly, I think people are
- 26:04worried about unit economics of some of these companies like
- 26:07cursor. I don't know like where are
- 26:09where are you on this or like everything needs to be AI right
- 26:12now in terms of like indexes, focus.
- 26:15That's sort of what I was trying to allude to when when I was
- 26:18saying bearish and bullish. I mean, so we have an equal
- 26:21partnership, everyone's got to vote.
- 26:23And we really look forward to one of our partners having
- 26:27conviction behind behind something because we want to
- 26:31back their enthusiasm. In the case of the last crypto
- 26:35wave or the the first solar wave, like there was no one
- 26:40around the table who was excited about it, right?
- 26:43In the case of AI, we're all super excited about it.
- 26:47And it does really feel like a monumental shift, you know, like
- 26:52there was the Internet and there was mobile and there's AI and
- 26:58it's undeniable and it's super exciting.
- 27:01And it has implications across the board, including how quickly
- 27:07companies get started, what the PNL looks like, what it looks
- 27:12like over time, what the characteristics of an
- 27:15entrepreneur are that are going to be well equipped to go after
- 27:19it in this chapter of AI, what it will be in future chapters of
- 27:24AI. How much is business to business
- 27:27AI today? When will the business to
- 27:29consumer wave happen? Right?
- 27:32What will it look like? You can.
- 27:33Answer all these questions. These are all great questions.
- 27:35I mean, Mark Zuckerberg literally this week, Yeah.
- 27:39You know, like, oh, I just asked questions.
- 27:41Yeah. I don't have to answer them.
- 27:43The no. I mean, Mark, Mark Zuckerberg
- 27:45was saying like this week, I think, you know, today when
- 27:49we're recording it that, you know, they want to be sort of
- 27:51the consumer approach to AI that I think there are a lot of
- 27:55people focused on productivity, but you know, their teams can
- 27:58really figure out how can you use this to sort of self
- 28:02actualize and get everything out of your life that you want.
- 28:05I mean, the question in the topic is sort of consumer in AI
- 28:10and obviously you've done consumer investing and thought
- 28:13about it this a lot. I mean, there's a certain
- 28:15argument that like consumer and AI is just like catchy BT and
- 28:19that the great consumer investment, just like you needed
- 28:21to hit Facebook, you needed to hit open AI and that's like the
- 28:24consumer investment. So that would say, oh, there's
- 28:27no like consumer wave to come. It's sort of like there was one
- 28:29big company and and that's it. Yeah, I don't know.
- 28:32What do you think about that notion and where?
- 28:34Where do you see opportunity for a consumer wave?
- 28:37Well, I guess I'll be out of a job, Eric, if that happens.
- 28:40I know you. And I think we will be very
- 28:43unhappy that scale we let's Alex join meta if that if that was
- 28:48the case as well, right? No, I think.
- 28:51You are a big investor in scale, which he you know, had this big
- 28:54deal and then you're not a big you're not an investor in
- 28:57opening eye right just. Correct, Correct.
- 28:59Right. Sorry.
- 28:59Yeah, just translating that for people who aren't like deep in
- 29:02it. Sorry about that.
- 29:03Yeah, I just assumed everyone was fascinated.
- 29:06But even I, Senator, like OK, I think I know which investments
- 29:10you have, sorry. No, I think that the business to
- 29:13consumer area of AI will not be one company or two companies
- 29:18that, you know, it's really challenging to build a core
- 29:23competency to the level of sophistication necessary to get
- 29:29millions of users, hundreds of millions of users to leverage
- 29:34products. And so history would serve us
- 29:37well to assume that there's not going to be 1 beneficiary or
- 29:42even 5 beneficiaries of a specific sector, but hundreds of
- 29:49beneficiaries. That's true with all the sectors
- 29:51that we've invested in. You know, when I mean, we've
- 29:54been investors in, in the gaming industry for a long time, right?
- 29:58And when when we looked at it, you could have said like, you
- 30:01know, there's Activision and there's EA and Epic, but you
- 30:05know, like King got sold to Activision and Supercell.
- 30:09And then we have this Turkish company Dream Games that's doing
- 30:12super well with this game called Broil Match, which there's no
- 30:16way that you haven't seen ads for.
- 30:19Yeah, I think I've seen ads. I've not played it.
- 30:21OK. So, so my point is that you will
- 30:25always have these entrepreneurs that have such passion and
- 30:30knowledge on specific sub areas that they're going to be able to
- 30:35build these phenomenal companies as a result of that.
- 30:39And I don't see why that would not be true for AI.
- 30:43In fact, I suspect that it will be more true because the scale
- 30:47of these companies is going to be so much greater, so much
- 30:51faster, which is what you're seeing with the likes of of Open
- 30:55AI and Anthropic of Cursor and a bunch of other companies.
- 31:00Kind of in the weeds, but do you think that, you know, to have
- 31:02all of these winners, we'll need sort of like the iPhone moment
- 31:05for apps beyond Chachi PT like to have this consumer
- 31:09application like, you know, the birth of the iPhone allowed, you
- 31:12know, Airbnb and all of these great and Uber to come exist,
- 31:15right? And so we're so early in this AI
- 31:18paradigm shift like where could this be headed?
- 31:20Is it just too early to tell where the next big, you know,
- 31:23companies that could win on top of this next layer are beyond
- 31:26the chat bot? I'm surprised at how early we
- 31:29are that this is not, you know, it's the companies are being
- 31:34formed today. It's still surprising to me on
- 31:38how few consumer AI opportunities we see in relative
- 31:45terms to business happening. Consumer deals to index that's
- 31:48what you're you're like thank you get building.
- 31:52Founders, where are you? Come out, come out.
- 31:56Listen, every founder wants an excuse.
- 31:57I heard you on a podcast. You asked for this company.
- 32:00You better meet with me now. So watch what you we will get
- 32:03what you wish. For so we will.
- 32:05I promise that we will. I mean, Madeline, your question
- 32:09was really just the in the iPhone moment is that there's
- 32:11going to be like a transformational piece of
- 32:13hardware. I imagine that like allows all
- 32:16of these apps to be, you know, consumed on a on a, you know,
- 32:20per person basis. And I mean, we're, you know,
- 32:22we're recording this. I think the day that, you know,
- 32:25Meta has their earnings and Zoc talked about how he views, you
- 32:29know, their AI bet is one that is predicated at least partly on
- 32:32these like wearables and and glasses and obviously we've
- 32:35seen. I need to get some Raven.
- 32:37Yeah, they've been obviously putting tons into wearables.
- 32:40Yeah, you need to get the the Raven meta glasses.
- 32:42Do you need to, I don't know. I mean, well, I don't know, I
- 32:46guess we'll get to a point of social acceptance.
- 32:47Every time I see Zuckerberg on a podcast wearing those things, I
- 32:50really, really don't like it and, and him and him with it.
- 32:54So maybe I'll just be late to the party.
- 32:56Why he insists on being the spokesman for these like We're
- 32:59Human videos, but you know. Yeah, I know him going on Theo
- 33:03Von wearing the glasses and talking about how he doesn't
- 33:05drink coffee was not a great moment of like human interaction
- 33:09for him. But but and, you know, I mean,
- 33:11to be fair, we also have, you know, the true GOAT of, of
- 33:14hardware with Johnny. I've, you know, being part of
- 33:17open AI and that's a big part of Sam Altman's belief that, you
- 33:20know, this is going to be a trillion dollar product at some
- 33:23point. I mean, where where are you on
- 33:25the hardware stuff? Do you meet with hardware
- 33:27companies? Do you believe there is
- 33:28something that's going to be kind of a unifying force with
- 33:31all of these AI applications? We definitely meet with hardware
- 33:35companies all the time. I would say I'm not sure I would
- 33:37have put Johnny I've as the true GOAT, I think.
- 33:40I think his boss, Steve Jobs, gets that title.
- 33:43But I'm with you. I'm with you.
- 33:44Well. Someone's here at your torch,
- 33:46Yeah. You get to tell your story if
- 33:48you're still alive. So yeah.
- 33:51You can't libel the dead so. OK, OK.
- 33:54But yeah, I mean, I think hardware is also, I mean, we'll
- 33:58see. I mean, these tariff things, I
- 34:00don't even know how to think about this.
- 34:02I don't live in the US, So I'm trying to digest that and what
- 34:07the implications would be for the supply chain and what the
- 34:10implications would be on creating the type of hardware
- 34:14that you're talking about. Do I think that you need a
- 34:18fundamentally new platform in order for AI consumer services
- 34:25to be of paramount importance? I'm not convinced of that.
- 34:31I think that mobile devices take us a long way.
- 34:35Does that mean that there won't be some new hardware devices
- 34:39that could transform the way that we interact with
- 34:42technology? No, I think that will happen.
- 34:45But I don't think that they're mutually exclusive.
- 34:48And, you know, the, the challenge with hardware, it's
- 34:51sort of interesting. Like hardware used to be really
- 34:55challenging. Like when we invested in Sonos,
- 34:58that was a big bet. And I think part of it was our
- 35:02love of music because it took a long way, took a long time for
- 35:06that company to be successful. And it's still, you know, a
- 35:09challenging space, but hardware was difficult at the time
- 35:13because of all the inventory that you have to buy upfront in
- 35:16order to to sell it and you only have very small windows of
- 35:20selling. So hardware investment maybe for
- 35:22other firms, we have difficulty with it.
- 35:24Then it became a lot easier because of just like the
- 35:29seamlessness of the world is flat and you know, the supply
- 35:33chain, all of those components working really well and a global
- 35:38audience. And now it's a new environment.
- 35:41I have no idea how hardware is, you know, can you build truly
- 35:47mass scale hardware devices in one single country?
- 35:52I don't know if that's possible or not right?
- 35:54I. Mean, I think a related question
- 35:56is just when we move to mobile, there was like a new
- 36:00distribution channel. So even forget like that it was
- 36:03a new device. It was just like, OK, there was
- 36:05the App Store and even cloud. It's like, OK, you can easily
- 36:09sort of embrace new things. It creates new like consumption
- 36:12patterns. So there's a new distribution
- 36:14model. It feels like the AI like
- 36:17platform shift. There's a new technological
- 36:20capacity, which to some degrees, I think as a technology investor
- 36:23is probably the most exciting part.
- 36:25It's like you can literally create new things that you
- 36:28couldn't before, but there isn't that straightforward.
- 36:30Like I'm a new business. I'm going to dominate this new
- 36:33channel, and that's how I'm going to grow.
- 36:35Like, do you see that Channel coming into being or it's still
- 36:38like this? This paradigm is sort of the old
- 36:40channels. Yeah, I think that for the
- 36:42moment the the paradigm are the old channels.
- 36:46I think they will be really interesting to see what the new
- 36:48channels are, whether you need new channels.
- 36:52It is also a concept like fundamentally there's a means of
- 36:57actually distributing things that are in bits and bytes.
- 37:00So effectively, right now I'm not sure that you need that
- 37:04intermediary anymore. How much better could it get?
- 37:07Because we have the cloud and mobile revolutions behind us,
- 37:10like we have all of this in our pockets right now.
- 37:12That's right. When you think about the cost
- 37:14structure for for some of these companies and yeah, I, you know,
- 37:18we were talking a little bit about coding apps before.
- 37:20I'm particularly obsessed with this space right now.
- 37:23Like there's a ton of do you, are you guys in any of them, by
- 37:25the way? Yes, we are.
- 37:27We are in augment. OK.
- 37:29There's an interesting dynamic playing out where these
- 37:32companies like Augment, like Cursor, raising a lot of money,
- 37:35big valuations. There's no question in my mind
- 37:37that AI coding is transformational.
- 37:40There's probably no going back for that.
- 37:42But who will end up being the big winners here?
- 37:44Like we've seen anthropics, Claude, code really to me out of
- 37:48nowhere become incredibly popular and dominant in the
- 37:51space. They obviously have a lot of
- 37:53money, keep raising more to be able to maybe burn on what could
- 37:57be a money losing product. Like are you bullish on non
- 38:01foundation model companies? To what layer does the value
- 38:04accrue? That's yeah.
- 38:06Who's going to win the models, make the money or do the
- 38:07applications? Yes.
- 38:10Everyone, everyone makes the money.
- 38:13Yeah. Encoding it can go, I mean
- 38:15brown. I, I think, I think the, the
- 38:18business models are not clear, but given the growth that is
- 38:25being experienced, one has to assume that the business model
- 38:30can make sense over time. And I am bullish on that.
- 38:34I don't think that they've been figured out.
- 38:36And I think that both on the application layer and on the
- 38:39infrastructure layer, there are great businesses that can be
- 38:43built, but I don't think there's a clear model yet that is out
- 38:49there. But if you would talk to
- 38:52investors across the board where you can witness just
- 38:57extraordinary growth, unprecedented growth, their
- 39:01perspective that you're likely going to be able to build a very
- 39:05strong business model that supports this type of growth is
- 39:09very likely. I wanted to take the last couple
- 39:12of minutes and talk about venture capital and just like
- 39:16where the VC business is today, I guess temperature in the air
- 39:20like our, our sort of continued point of view honestly has been,
- 39:24there would have been this terrible downturn except for AI.
- 39:28And so like telling the temperature story of venture has
- 39:31been very hard because it's like, well, obviously they're
- 39:34very enthusiastic AI valuations, but there's been some limited
- 39:39partner pessimism. Or how do you make sense of
- 39:42where we are in the venture capital industry right now?
- 39:45You know, Eric, I'm, I'm relatively old, let's face it.
- 39:49So I'm a student of history and I tend to say the more things
- 39:54change, the more they stay the same.
- 39:56So there's the cyclicality of what happens within the market
- 40:03and then there's the. Unconditional, unwavering
- 40:08adoption of technology across the globe that continues to
- 40:14grow. And so I'm not sure that we
- 40:17would have had a massive correction if AI hadn't
- 40:19happened. I actually think a lot of the
- 40:21fundamental fundamentals of a lot of SAS businesses are really
- 40:26strong. It's just that they're not, you
- 40:29know, back to this growth concept that we were talking
- 40:31about, They're not growing in the same vicinity of what you're
- 40:35seeing with a lot of AI companies.
- 40:37And then there are companies that are on that juncture of,
- 40:41you know, are they SAS businesses, are they AI
- 40:43businesses? Are they a combination?
- 40:46You know, I think that's sort of what is playing out with the
- 40:48Figma IPO this week. And so my view is that, yeah,
- 40:53the more things change, the more they say the same.
- 40:55I don't think that the venture business has fundamentally
- 40:58changed that much in terms of the craft of investors looking
- 41:05to assist entrepreneurs that have global ambition to
- 41:10transform the world and make it a better place through whatever
- 41:14they're working on. However, there are a lot of
- 41:18elements that make the scale of what's going on very different
- 41:24and enables a lot of folks who aren't necessarily coming in for
- 41:31the same level of clarity to participate.
- 41:36In other words, there are a lot of tourists that are involved
- 41:39both on the investment side and on the entrepreneurial side.
- 41:43But the fundamentals of company creation, company formation and
- 41:49venture capital trying to help fuel the best businesses has not
- 41:54changed. Helps to have the Wiz exit.
- 41:56Now you have Figma, you're like, we're, we're doing fine.
- 41:59I, I feel like there are a lot of venture firms that, you know,
- 42:02just have a lot of companies that were marked up a ton in
- 42:052021 and I don't know, are not as optimistic about sort of the
- 42:10SAS companies making it to the next level.
- 42:12Or you must have some unicorpses or, or you, you don't see any
- 42:18hangover from that 2021 no period.
- 42:20I. Mean certainly, Eric, but if you
- 42:23had talked to us in the history of index, right, we've been
- 42:26doing this for 20 plus years. That has always been the case.
- 42:29There have been always companies that and cycles where companies
- 42:34that we thought were doing phenomenally well have hit
- 42:37serious roadblocks, stumbling blocks.
- 42:39And then companies that we didn't expect to do well have
- 42:44hit a cord, have the right management team and are
- 42:47experiencing explosive growth. That hasn't changed.
- 42:51I mean, if you're talking about the the industry of venture, you
- 42:55know it from our perspective, it's really maintaining the
- 42:59discipline index today is really not that different from what it
- 43:03was. We have multiple partners all
- 43:06doing their work, all contributing in making the
- 43:12overall funds successful. That that hasn't changed.
- 43:16And the IPO itself for you, I mean you're we're recording this
- 43:19on the precipice of there actually having been one.
- 43:22What's your sense on, on where that's going to be like?
- 43:24Is this an indication of things to come?
- 43:27Can we actually expect more of them this year?
- 43:28Yeah. So I think definitely, I mean, I
- 43:31think look, there are two things that I would say.
- 43:34The first is the best companies can go public in any market,
- 43:37right. You've seen that so many times
- 43:40before. Google, Facebook, irrespective
- 43:43of market, great companies go public.
- 43:45That being said, there's no question that there are a lot of
- 43:50reasons why the IPO conditions are really good right now for a
- 43:56number of companies that have been developing real businesses
- 44:00over the last years. And there's an enormous amount
- 44:04of appetite from the buy side. And there are retail platforms
- 44:08like Robin Hood that are also showing quite a bit of
- 44:12sophistication from the from the retail investor.
- 44:15So I think that's going to continue to happen and we're
- 44:18seeing it across our portfolio. You know, I mean, yeah, Fardul
- 44:23is the partner involved with Wiz and we have Marta is involved
- 44:27with Revolute. You know, Mike was involved with
- 44:29Scale. Like we have a number of really
- 44:32exciting companies out there. Great.
- 44:34Well, thank you so much for coming on.
- 44:36I think the last thing just to sort of end on a piece of
- 44:40advice. I mean, if you were to give a
- 44:42piece of advice to a startup founder right now, like whether
- 44:45they're looking for a category or just starting a business,
- 44:49like what would be your, yeah, core piece of advice for them?
- 44:52Come and visit index. All right, what?
- 44:57This is the consumer. This is the call for consumer AI
- 44:59companies again. There's a call that we're we're
- 45:02open for business across the board.
- 45:04Please, Tom, also businesses business to business.
- 45:07No, I think, I mean the biggest piece of advice that I would
- 45:10give, and I'm not, I wouldn't be surprised if you would give the
- 45:14same advice, is that there's so much ebullience in the market.
- 45:19There's probably a better word than that, but that's the one
- 45:22that came up. You know, there's just so much
- 45:24froth that everyone wants to be in this environment, whether
- 45:29it's AI or entrepreneurialism or venture, like there's so much
- 45:35froth around it that I think people forget how freaking tough
- 45:40it is. You know, we were talking about
- 45:43like the reason that I keep on cutting back, like Figmas took
- 45:45thirteen years and there are a lot of ups and downs along the
- 45:49way. And it wasn't evident that Dylan
- 45:51was going to be CEO throughout the way.
- 45:53You know, he'll tell that to you himself.
- 45:55So, so I think that you really have to be passionate about what
- 45:59you're doing and see the purpose in it rather than think that
- 46:04this is going to be just a sensational, you know, job that
- 46:08is going to pay off well and is and is worth sort of entering
- 46:11the game. Yeah, there are a lot of people
- 46:13who see dollars right now, but it's like you have to.
- 46:15It's like, oh, that's an interesting idea.
- 46:17Like go find someone to actually build that, like build the
- 46:20product. And then then maybe, you know,
- 46:23you'll have the start of something.
- 46:25In some ways, I feel like the AI story that it's like, oh, it's
- 46:28so easy to build a product now, has created this proliferation
- 46:32of like company ideas. Right.
- 46:35And maybe to bring it back to Figma design could be a
- 46:38differentiator for your company actually functioning well if
- 46:41you're vibe coding a company if the design is not good, doesn't
- 46:45come through. So we need Figma main to bring
- 46:47us all there. Thank you so much.
- 46:50Danny Rymer, thanks so much for joining us.
- 46:52Thanks so much folks. Take care.
- 46:54Bye bye.