Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP327: Customer Reviews - Maximising The Impact On Conversion & SEO And Handling Negative Reviews
Transcript
- 0:00There's 1.3 million YouTube channels that share unboxing
- 0:02videos and a research company in the last year said that around
- 0:0755% of shoppers for use unboxing videos to influence purchase
- 0:11decisions. So there's a lot of data showing
- 0:13this is happening. And again, this is something
- 0:15where I can see more and more brands exploring and testing out
- 0:21You listen to Inside Commerce, a weekly ecom strategy, technology
- 0:24and CX focus podcast hosted by experienced digital consultants
- 0:27and re platform specialist James Get and Paul Rogers.
- 0:30Get insights into ecom strategy leading brands.
- 0:32Hear from industry thought leaders and leading tech vendors
- 0:34with practical advice to help you improve your online CX.
- 0:40This episode is sponsored by Worldpay.
- 0:41Today we are drilling into customer reviews and we're going
- 0:46to look at the state of customer reviews, good effective strategy
- 0:50in 2026 where it's been evolving to and the tech and some of the
- 0:55like new players in the market. And the reason why we're
- 0:57focusing on this topic specifically is the all I have
- 0:59of these conversations all the time.
- 1:01People are always trying to work out how they can best collect,
- 1:04use customer reviews, manage it, deal with negative reviews,
- 1:09etcetera. It's it's challenging and
- 1:10there's a lot of tech out there and therefore choice sometimes
- 1:13is quite difficult to make. But online reviews are still a
- 1:15critical trust signal and impact conversion saw a study ended
- 1:20last year from Bird Eye State of Online Review 2025 that said
- 1:24just one single reviews associated with around 600
- 1:27additional searches. That's quite interesting to
- 1:29start. And also reviews, comments are
- 1:32increasing. So more people when they leave
- 1:34reviews are adding comments rather than just putting a
- 1:37rating in. I think I saw it, it's over 80%
- 1:39now have comments versus 70% in 2020.
- 1:42But the average character count is decreasing.
- 1:44So people are taking time to comment.
- 1:46They're being more concise in what they're leaving, which is
- 1:49why this leads into one of our key points around the sentiment
- 1:51analysis and having to interpret review data.
- 1:54So because reviews influence search visibility, customer
- 1:57trust, improve purchase decisions, this is a a key
- 2:00discussion point. Anything you want to add to
- 2:02that, Paul? No, I was just going to say, So
- 2:05one of the things we'll probably talk about is the information
- 2:08people are asking for as part of a product review in particular.
- 2:13And I wonder whether some of the character count trend is due to
- 2:17people asking more about size and fit and quality and whatever
- 2:22else. But if you're interested in
- 2:24that, I've not heard that before.
- 2:26Yeah, it is interesting, but you're right, the the, the art
- 2:29of being more precise in what you're asking for rather than
- 2:31just saying, hey, leave a review, let us know how we did,
- 2:33which is incredibly open-ended. And also it especially if you
- 2:38get negative reviews, if you just allow, if you just
- 2:40encourage A rant versus being very precise as I let us know
- 2:43what we could improve very specifically.
- 2:46Let's get into it. So the first thing I want to
- 2:48start with is that fake reviews are a problem and customer trust
- 2:53and the impact of fake reviews on that is something that brands
- 2:56need to think about. I saw a stat recent about 15% of
- 2:59reviews are fake. And the AI and AI factors into
- 3:03every single bloody conversation we have these days.
- 3:05But AI is compounding the issue because fake review generators
- 3:10are using AI to increase the velocity and efficiency at which
- 3:14they can generate it and use an AI to, to to, you know, to
- 3:18basically sends what looks like quality signals, like coming
- 3:23from a country of trust, not from a shady IP, etcetera.
- 3:26So there's all these dynamics. What are you having
- 3:31conversations with customers about the impact of fake
- 3:33reviews? Is it becoming more of a
- 3:34discussion? Point.
- 3:36So no, not really. I think the only time I've ever
- 3:41really come up against this is when I used to work for a
- 3:44retail, small retail group that had lots of very small sites and
- 3:50people in the business used to submit fake reviews because it's
- 3:54such low volume. And you know, they wanted to if
- 3:57they were going to surface reviews, they kind of wanted to
- 3:59have a certain level etcetera. And I think maybe that probably
- 4:03still exists at SMB, but I haven't actually seen the impact
- 4:06of, yeah, product or service reviews with AI.
- 4:10But I'm sure, like you said, I'm sure it's a big thing.
- 4:12And I think you only have to look at LinkedIn and some of the
- 4:15comments that appear on posts after a few days and stuff like
- 4:18that to see, you know, how much of this stuff is is happening.
- 4:23So it doesn't really surprise me, but I've not really had it
- 4:26come up. No, so I, I was going to a few
- 4:29people who are concerned about what the impact will be or could
- 4:32be. And I guess my, my hold of what
- 4:35there are two bits. We're going to come on to the
- 4:37Trustpilot conversation later on because unfortunately Trustpilot
- 4:40because of the nature of the platform, it's not just linked
- 4:44down limited down to a person with a subscription who's asking
- 4:48people to give verified reviews. There is an, there is an entire
- 4:52Black Hat industry sat behind it that's trying to do that.
- 4:54And therefore there is a challenge in that platform
- 4:56specifically to weave that out. But I think where I am or not on
- 5:00the fake reviews is that you need to be aware that it
- 5:02happens. You need to be aware that the
- 5:04that AI tooling is starting to be used increasingly for this.
- 5:08Therefore, you've got to have a, a really good monitoring process
- 5:13in place and we'll come on to sentiment LS to spot any change
- 5:17in patterns and trends in that because you need to react to it.
- 5:20So you've got to monitor, you've got to look at suspicious
- 5:23activity. And then you've got to also have
- 5:25really good conversations with vendors, your workers to
- 5:27understand what their platform controls are and how you can
- 5:30weed out and block or delete or remove.
- 5:34Reviews clearly are not legit. Now, a negative, legitimate
- 5:38review is not something you can it should be removed and you
- 5:40should just be managing it. We'll come to that.
- 5:44So the the next let's, let's start, we'll start with, I guess
- 5:47the use of reviews the on the site piece.
- 5:49Then we'll go through lots of different elements here.
- 5:52But one of the key points you want to talk about as I use of
- 5:55review content on the site, widgets, positioning
- 5:57opportunities, where, where do you think, how do you think
- 6:01people should be using these now?
- 6:02Yeah. So I think this is a really
- 6:04interesting area and I think we could do a whole episode on it.
- 6:06So I think that historically when and even now for a lot of
- 6:11brands or retailers, you're going to like a design process
- 6:15or you decide to introduce reviews and you have like a
- 6:18default widget from all of the vendors that you're going to
- 6:20look at. And historically 100% of PDPS,
- 6:25this is for product reviews of PDPS, we'd have that exact same
- 6:29kind of UI kind of template, like elements of in the
- 6:32template, etcetera. And now it's just one way of
- 6:35doing it. And as a result, premium brands
- 6:38wouldn't go nearer and also users could only, you know, read
- 6:43all of the reviews in the order that yet being chosen by the
- 6:48retailer. Whereas and then like a few
- 6:51years back, Yopo started allowing for API integration.
- 6:55So you could essentially just pull the data out of the API and
- 6:57then display it however you wanted.
- 6:59And then nowadays a lot of the vendors have that.
- 7:02And I think that nowadays I think brands should be largely
- 7:07either going with a company that has a really flexible which it
- 7:10all going down that route and being really creative around how
- 7:14they use the content. So a lot of our more premium
- 7:17brands will actually only show size and fit feedback or they
- 7:22might show like star ratings and then like pull out specific
- 7:26snippets of information or they won't show widget at all, but
- 7:30they'll display certain bits of feedback with other kind of data
- 7:34that they think is useful. So I think overall kind of thing
- 7:38I'm saying is that I think you can be a lot more intentional
- 7:41around like how you want to display feedback or how you want
- 7:46to use the widget. And I think there's an
- 7:49opportunity there to select Nick from our team has done a lot of
- 7:53testing around, you know, really using the size and fit data and
- 7:57like promoting that and like really prominent position and
- 8:00then having ACTA to then go and explore the data.
- 8:02And I think there's just a lot of room to be creative now with
- 8:06this kind of stuff. And then I think alongside that
- 8:09you have things like the ability to use AI to like group reviews
- 8:15by topic. You then have the ability to,
- 8:19you know, we talked a bit earlier about in the emails you
- 8:22can ask or in the kind of review requests you can ask different
- 8:27leading questions so that you can profile them a bit more.
- 8:30So you could say like younger audience fought this and older
- 8:32audience like by size, whatever. So I think that's one thing
- 8:38that's changed the product review landscape.
- 8:41And then I think also, we work with a lot of premium and luxury
- 8:44brands. And I've always, as we always
- 8:46say on these, I'm pretty blinkered in that world.
- 8:49But a lot of those are a lot more open to using product
- 8:53reviews. And either they're just
- 8:55collecting all the data in the background and then showing
- 8:58certain bits of information and position in a certain way, or
- 9:02they just got so much flexibility from a style and
- 9:05perspective that they're more open to, yeah, reviews on the
- 9:10PDP. So I think that's all around
- 9:12product reviews. But yeah, you see at the same
- 9:14thing. Ready to grow your business
- 9:16online? With World Pay E-commerce you
- 9:19can deliver fast, secure payments your customers love,
- 9:23backed by global reach and real people powered support.
- 9:27Scale with confidence and enhance your customers
- 9:30experience with World Pay E-commerce.
- 9:34I think the I think the reality for a lot of people is that in
- 9:37order to do use the APIs correctly and therefore have
- 9:40full control of that UI. PS that requires extra
- 9:44engineering, extra recent. I'm not seeing for a lot of
- 9:46people initially that investment.
- 9:49I think a lot of people still still see it as let's get the
- 9:52widget in. That's easy.
- 9:53That's default, especially when you're working in like the SAS
- 9:56world and there's and it's the third party app, plug them in
- 9:59and play the pro. But I fully agree with you
- 10:01because I've had this on 2 projects with the app where the
- 10:05app and the styling controls are so crap that you are not only
- 10:09does it not align with your brand colour palette per year,
- 10:13you're restricted into exactly where it sits, how it looks.
- 10:16So I, I think it should be a conversation in a lot of re
- 10:20platform projects, stuff like that never gets the top level
- 10:24priority because of all the conflicting priorities.
- 10:26I think the bit where I where I have a lot of conversations with
- 10:30people is, and it's the booking.com principle, which is,
- 10:33I call it multi boys. A review is not just here's your
- 10:36rating snippet, here's the reviews at the bottom of the
- 10:37page you click down to it's how do you use content like you're
- 10:41saying around the user journeys to reinforce key points and in
- 10:46order to influence decision parts.
- 10:48And so this is things like elevating testimonial content,
- 10:52the verbatim text where are embedding it, having an image
- 10:56where a review text is overlaid over it and curating that.
- 11:00And that's a bit, you know, or even a content section within
- 11:04the page that is right up by the, you know, the the call to
- 11:07action sent space where it is basically I, you know, and it is
- 11:11pulling out the things that normally people are so sizing in
- 11:14in fashion. Yeah.
- 11:17So I I think that's, that's an area that people do not exploit
- 11:20enough. I agree.
- 11:22I think it's really interesting because I'm almost trying not to
- 11:26touch on the trust pilot thing. Just pre episode James and I had
- 11:30a bit started a bit of a debate around this that I think it like
- 11:34that's quite interesting as well.
- 11:35All around. One of the pros of trust pilot
- 11:37is that it's like a wreck, almost like a recognized
- 11:40consumer brand. And I think sometimes that I've
- 11:43seen people like use that kind of word in the image gallery,
- 11:46like you say, stuff like that. But yeah, I think it'd be really
- 11:49interesting to get on to that in a little.
- 11:51Bit I know we are going to come onto some of the, the, some of
- 11:55the, the critical sides of it because there is negativity
- 11:58around it in the market and there exists for a reason.
- 12:00But that that's not been disingenuous to them because
- 12:03yes, I've seen one of the clients I've worked with tested,
- 12:06put in a trust pilot widget into their basket checkout flow and
- 12:10actually found it had an improved check out flow and
- 12:15complete and next step rate. So yes, there is a, there is a
- 12:18consumer awareness piece that can have a positive influence.
- 12:23Next thing I want to talk about is let's let's go to the the
- 12:28opportunity that AI presents talked about fake reviews and AI
- 12:31is causing a bit of an issue there.
- 12:32But there's a big opportunity around using AI tools for things
- 12:35like the sentiment analysis and driving insights out of reviews
- 12:41to help you better understand what you can do.
- 12:43Whether this is product feedback that helps you tweak and improve
- 12:47products or it's improving content on the page because the
- 12:49signposts aren't clear and people had a misconception of
- 12:53what the product is, does was, etcetera.
- 12:55So where where I know that you do work around this, I know that
- 12:59you obviously have your own like census feedback tool, which is
- 13:03separate to, yeah, custom reviews, more like MPs stuff.
- 13:06But where are you seeing this headed and how are people using
- 13:09it? So I think AI, there's probably
- 13:12a few different things under here.
- 13:14So I think there's a lot of room.
- 13:16So a lot of the vendors have started doing using AI for like,
- 13:19yeah, more like almost like breaking out the key themes and
- 13:24providing more insight around those.
- 13:27And I think that's really useful to a customer from a front end
- 13:31perspective. But as you said, I think there's
- 13:33also a lot of our clients now are using AI there and
- 13:38particularly like the higher volume 1.
- 13:40So Charlie from Dick dot Marks, I think we've had on here
- 13:43before, like she's done a lot of work around using review data to
- 13:49really understand by skew the feedback that's like the, the
- 13:55feed, the feedback from the customers around different areas
- 13:57of the product. And then they're using that as a
- 13:59business to like improve in different areas.
- 14:02And I think that's 10 times easier now from an AI
- 14:05perspective. And I think any level of
- 14:07feedback like we use it like you say with census, actually the
- 14:13integrated, okay, I like 2 plus years ago and we used it to like
- 14:18group all the themes and we use it like a global level and we're
- 14:21looking at everything but also within the census as well just
- 14:25to show the theme. So I think anything like that
- 14:27where you are kind of processing information and summarizing or
- 14:31grouping, I think there's shed loads of yeah, opportunity and
- 14:35opportunity to get more digestible data in different
- 14:38areas of your business. But I think the bigger probably
- 14:42one of the big ones have been out and the reason why companies
- 14:44like Trust Fighter and other companies that manage reviews
- 14:49have kind of become a bit more popular is because of the LLMS.
- 14:54So I think it was published a while back that Trustpilot was
- 15:00being used and there are a few different kind of service review
- 15:06type companies that were being used a lot to understand
- 15:11sentiment and within open AIS algorithm.
- 15:15And I think that has led to people investing more in that
- 15:19area. And I think because of the
- 15:22nature of how you talk with an LLM and particularly ChatGPT,
- 15:27because people are asking what is the best, what is the most
- 15:29suitable for all of that kind of stuff, the kind of sentiment
- 15:34context is has become a lot more important.
- 15:37So I think that also led to a lot more people kind of
- 15:41investing in this area, considering this area, looking
- 15:45at the types of reviews they've got, looking at, you know, the
- 15:49volume of reviews. And so, yeah, so that's the
- 15:53other one around AI where there's probably a bit of a need
- 15:59to like just invest a bit more time and understanding as a
- 16:02business like how you sit in some of these places.
- 16:06Yeah. And I think this is one of the
- 16:07biggest challenges because you we had this historically with
- 16:10Google and Google basically add a set of approved review sources
- 16:15that it used as trust signals in its algorithm.
- 16:18And Trustpilot's one of them. Google reviews.
- 16:20There are there are obviously many others.
- 16:23And I find this really interesting because it's, it's
- 16:25actually quite hard to decide where to go because it's not
- 16:28just a technology decision and a feature decision, but it's also
- 16:31that wider signalling decision. And I, I, I'm really interested
- 16:36in the use of Google reviews as well.
- 16:37And I not massive brands typically don't focus there, but
- 16:42smaller brands, local businesses where they have a, a more kind
- 16:47of condensed geographical reach and businesses with stores where
- 16:52actually they want to build up reputation around the stores
- 16:55and, and look for Google reviews and that local audience for you.
- 16:58And Google reviews are still one of the, for Google search,
- 17:02obviously, but also from an LLM point of view and into the, the
- 17:05AI models. I think it's an area that's
- 17:09really under exploited in a lot of smaller businesses.
- 17:12I, I know myself as an independent consultant, I focus
- 17:15on Google reviews and nothing else.
- 17:17I don't ask anybody to, to give me reviews by any other
- 17:20platform. Although coming onto the, the B
- 17:22to B side clutch is looking like it's more of a signal in LLMS
- 17:26now. But I've done testing on Google
- 17:28reviews again in my rankings and I've just seen that when I focus
- 17:32on collecting them like really good quality reviews, there is a
- 17:37a short at least to medium term sudden impact on ranking for key
- 17:41queries I think. And to be honest, I was going to
- 17:44say as well. So I use Google reviews all the
- 17:46time. So I'm very into coffee and I
- 17:52will travel far and long or whatever the phrase is to buy
- 17:56like the best coffee, everything else.
- 17:58And I used to use all these different websites, all these
- 18:00different apps. And then I actually found
- 18:02there's a pretty good correlation between Google
- 18:04reviews and actually which the best ones are.
- 18:06As long as you like factory and other things as well.
- 18:08And then, yeah, now for restaurants, exactly the same, I
- 18:11think Google reviews for those types of listings and yeah,
- 18:15really come along. And then as you say, as far as I
- 18:18know, the reviews is still the biggest ranking factor for local
- 18:24listings things. So I think I completely great.
- 18:26I think if you've got stores, it's definitely something that
- 18:29you should be. I think a few of our clients do
- 18:31really push that for retail orders.
- 18:33So in there if they're using Shopify POS like within the all
- 18:38the confirmations of things that will kind of push people to
- 18:40leave reviews and things. But yeah, I completely agree.
- 18:43The only other thing I was going to add that I missed on the
- 18:45previous thing was product reviews as well.
- 18:47So I think a lot of people are using product reviews within the
- 18:51little kind of chat bot interfaces to support kind of
- 18:57Q&A on PDPS and also again can have an impact from the kind of
- 19:03Geo slash AEO side. Yeah, it did.
- 19:09Next topic I wanted to chat about is video reviews because
- 19:13there has been an increase in the number of of dedicated tools
- 19:18out there like Ascender, judge me, he's got capability, Luke's
- 19:22there are lots, the shop ecosystem, there are Shopify
- 19:25centric ones as well. So I guess I'm calling these
- 19:28more testimonials because it feels that the format is
- 19:31different to to review it. Yeah, you've got a video
- 19:34snippet, you've got somebody directly talking to the camera
- 19:37as a purchaser. It's these are used with
- 19:41influencers a lot, but actually now more forms the direct
- 19:44customer review thing. I haven't haven't implemented
- 19:48this directly myself. I spoke to quite a few people
- 19:50and said they should be testing and piloting it.
- 19:52What's your take? Are you seeing this as a trend
- 19:56in the premium space or or not at all?
- 19:59So definitely, so I would say historically, we've probably
- 20:04been 100% like fashion or mostly fashion.
- 20:08Then we've kind of done a bit more on beauty more recently.
- 20:12In beauty, it's absolutely massive.
- 20:14And I think the UGC and Gem or in beauty is massive.
- 20:18And I think some of that, some of it's come off the back of,
- 20:21yeah, like you said, influencer marketing and I think TikTok and
- 20:25even Instagram, like where people are essentially paying
- 20:29the influence. To like actually have the
- 20:31experience and talk for it. And then as that's performed
- 20:34really well in ads and organically, I think people have
- 20:38then started to experiment on site.
- 20:41So yeah, some of the beauty brands we've worked with use.
- 20:44So video wise is 1 we've worked with a lot and there's a couple
- 20:47more as well. And then they've started to
- 20:50introduce that type of content alongside like before and after
- 20:54that kind of stuff. And then they've realized that
- 20:56it has a really good impact. So then they've made it more
- 20:59prominent. And yeah, I would say it's I
- 21:02don't really, really beauty when I think we've see it as like a
- 21:08big trend and that high impact area.
- 21:11But I do think in general, like UG 6, the other side is like the
- 21:16ads world, like Uvcs have gone crazy, like with all the trends
- 21:21around, like all the creator economy and everything else,
- 21:24like people are experimenting a lot with like UGC creative and
- 21:29even things like product reviews and ads, like you know what we
- 21:32said, similar to like the product, the image.
- 21:35So yeah, I think I think beauty is probably the biggest one for
- 21:38video reviews, but creative as well, I think a big one.
- 21:43Yeah. And I think this is a really
- 21:44good point that certain product types are not going to be so
- 21:47naturally well suited to it. I was just, I was having this
- 21:50conversation recently, I mean in like the home and garden space
- 21:54in cookware. And I think this is this could
- 21:56be really quite an interesting test bed because if you take
- 22:00buying a really nice new frying pan or steak pan or whatever it
- 22:03might be actually hearing from somebody who's used it and how
- 22:07it cooks versus like other types of pans and what it's good for
- 22:11and how easy it is to maintain and the quality.
- 22:13I think there are certain areas where actually it spills out
- 22:15really nice to outside of the obvious ones around beauty
- 22:18fashion. And for me, this is this, this
- 22:21is this is classic test bed opportunity could because you
- 22:24can cherry pick a set products where you know you've got high
- 22:27interest, but actually maybe it's high price point.
- 22:30It's hard. The conversion rates are
- 22:31typically a bit lower. The ability to cherry pick and
- 22:34test on a subset of products and then validate what the impact is
- 22:37before rolling it out. It's it's such a no brainer to
- 22:40me. I actually think homewares is
- 22:43another one. So actually thinking now
- 22:45thinking about it a bit more, so beauty tech, we've worked a
- 22:48little bit and that's another one.
- 22:49So I'd imagine that all of that kind of consumer technology
- 22:52space would be another area for this.
- 22:54But actually like I do think homewares and kind of furniture
- 22:58as well. I've seen some we've had.
- 23:01We've got one client that's in the furniture space and I know
- 23:04they've been talking about it because certain people in the
- 23:07business have seen it work before.
- 23:09Yeah, I find, yeah, Well, I work as you know, I know with a a
- 23:13furniture bar at the moment and I'm intrigued by this as well
- 23:15because I can see in some of the product areas I could imagine it
- 23:18working well. But there are certain products,
- 23:20especially high end products which are very much that they
- 23:23are personal aesthetic and emotion LED rather than
- 23:26functional LED. And I can't see it working so
- 23:29well in a non functional thing because you you could afraid
- 23:32you'd take a really big sofa. Well, I don't like that fabric.
- 23:35I don't like that colour. I think that becomes, I'm not
- 23:38saying it wouldn't and you've got to test everything, but I
- 23:40think there are certain product sets where I could see it having
- 23:43a greater impact. I think it's slightly different
- 23:46actually. So we, the brands we're working
- 23:47rather competing, I guess similar price point, similar at
- 23:51the end of the market. And I think it's probably less
- 23:55UGC and more interior designers. And it's maybe like, yeah, being
- 24:02able to show more like genuine lifestyle content.
- 24:06And also I think about if it's safer, I think having content
- 24:11where people can actually see like someone sitting on it and
- 24:14stuff like that. Yeah.
- 24:15But I think you've got to control it a lot more, I guess
- 24:19is, is probably. Yeah, the key message of that.
- 24:22Yeah, well, as of all these things, This is why we have
- 24:27testing and This is why we we look and explore rather than say
- 24:30no, it's not going to work. Because there've been times when
- 24:32I thought something won't work and it works brilliantly.
- 24:34And time is when I think something is going to work
- 24:36brilliantly. It doesn't.
- 24:37And that's the joy of learning. OK, so that's video review
- 24:41platforms. That's another one of the, and
- 24:43let's not say emergent, it's clearly a trend, but it's a
- 24:46growth area. And that leads me into something
- 24:50that's intrinsically linked, as you mentioned about the
- 24:52brilliant thing about getting these reviews is you have you
- 24:55have basically permission based content that you can then use
- 24:58wider in your sigh in marketing journeys.
- 25:00Social media is a review destination and this is, I mean
- 25:04this is happening. Lots of reviews are going into
- 25:07social media directly rather than you controlling it through
- 25:09your review engine. And one of the areas that I
- 25:13think is really interesting discussion point today is
- 25:15unboxing. There is, you know, there is
- 25:20obviously the control element of unboxing where you work with
- 25:23specific customers influences, you invite them to unbox it and
- 25:26record it. But there are people who are
- 25:28creating their own content and channels out there for unboxing
- 25:33big brand retail products, which then has a massive ripple impact
- 25:36to their audience. One of the one of the channels
- 25:39that I was reading about earlier this year is a Canadian creator,
- 25:44a channel called Unbox Therapy. He's got 24.6 million
- 25:47subscribers. So you've got there's 1.3
- 25:50million YouTube channels that share unboxing videos.
- 25:52From some data I saw from YouTube and a research company
- 25:57end of last year, their data from some interviews said that
- 26:01around 55% of the shoppers use unboxing videos to influence
- 26:05purchase decisions. So there's a lot of data showing
- 26:08this is happening. And again, this is something
- 26:10where I can see more and more brands exploring and testing
- 26:14out. Where do you think this is
- 26:15headed? So I actually been this, so I
- 26:18kind of forgot this is in the questions and actually I think
- 26:21it integrates of some of what I was saying about earlier.
- 26:23So I think creators and influencers are kind of merged
- 26:27and because it's so expensive when people and because it
- 26:32resonates so much of a certain audience, I think a lot of
- 26:36people are investing a lot of money there.
- 26:39And then they're using the content within ads in
- 26:42particular, but also on site as well, kind of like social proof
- 26:46and also having that benefit of like, you know, if someone's a
- 26:49really prominent creator, kind of having that as a bit of a
- 26:53Halo effect as well. But yeah, I think to be honest,
- 26:56for a number of years, I think that kind of younger audience
- 27:00has kind of grown up with this massive trend around this stuff
- 27:04and same applies to influencers. And so, yeah, I think massive
- 27:08trend that I think is impacting both the outside and content
- 27:15being used more on site as well. Yeah, yeah, 100% for me it's
- 27:21obviously reviews are important because it's trust, it's
- 27:23credibility, it's that persuasion piece and we know
- 27:26that influences purchase decisions.
- 27:27But I think the point the UTS out is the most important is it
- 27:31is the the wider content benefit of having UGC and how you can
- 27:34use it, but having permission based content that you have the
- 27:38rights to use as well. I think that is massive because
- 27:42it this is when review content goes from we've invested in
- 27:46reviews and we use it on PDPS to well actually our time to value
- 27:50on this content is far quicker because we're using it across
- 27:53marketing for acquisition. We're using it on the site in
- 27:57other content journeys. Yeah, the applications are quite
- 28:00extensive. The next topic that I really
- 28:03want to pick up and it was in our newsletter last week.
- 28:07For those who haven't read it, we're covering it now on
- 28:10negative reviews. How to handle them.
- 28:13I, I, you know, we put a bit of a spiel in the newsletter about
- 28:16the do's and the don'ts. And an example from someone I
- 28:20thought handled it really well in on a Shopify app when he had
- 28:23a critical feedback about the app and did it very, very
- 28:25professionally. Where what?
- 28:28What do you think is the state makes reviews and what good
- 28:32practices for managing these? So I think I'm, I don't this, I
- 28:37don't know loads about this area and it's never really something
- 28:40I've been put into. But I've always felt from a
- 28:43personal perspective, the only way you can really deal with a
- 28:47negative review is kind of attack it head on.
- 28:50And, And I guess, yeah, it's obviously not an easy area and
- 28:54you've got to kind of have a good kind of argument.
- 28:58And I think if it's service based, you've kind of got to
- 29:00make up, make it up to that person whilst, you know,
- 29:05avoiding A trend or ever under it.
- 29:08But I think if it's product based, yeah, you've kind of got
- 29:10a yeah, just kind of create a narrative where people can
- 29:16understand it and at least see that you're trying to do
- 29:19something about it. But again, it's not, it's not
- 29:21really qualified. I don't know if if that's the
- 29:24best thing to do. It's kind of what I've probably
- 29:26reacted best to. Official, I mean.
- 29:29I think there are some some classic do's and don'ts and the
- 29:32experience I've got is basically not allowing negatively.
- 29:38I've had some businesses where IAC suite person said we are not
- 29:42to spend any negative reviews where they are basically not
- 29:45contravening the terms and conditions of a review platform
- 29:47that they use. And they have, they've decided
- 29:49to they do what totally do what they want.
- 29:51And actually I've seen evidence in the data that products that
- 29:56have only glowing 5 star reviews and that is it.
- 30:00I mean you're talking hundreds and hundreds of the reviews.
- 30:02Actually it doesn't have a positive impact on conversion
- 30:05because people start to distrust it.
- 30:07And it's it's really hard because there is no fixed line
- 30:10of if you go above this number of five star reviews without any
- 30:14others, then there's a tipping point.
- 30:16But I've seen some analysis done by some of the big CPG brands
- 30:20around average ratings and they found that between 4.4 to 4.7
- 30:24out of five have better conversion rates than 4.895,
- 30:28which is interesting. So I think the number one point
- 30:31is, is your you made is you. Don't ignore it.
- 30:34A negative review has come for a reason.
- 30:36I, I think we need to trust customers to realise that if
- 30:39somebody's posting an imbecilic review, that's clearly just them
- 30:43ranting that, that most people are going to it understand that
- 30:46that is not the retailer's fault.
- 30:48And you can manage them professionally and calmly and
- 30:50not engage in it and in in flame.
- 30:53But actually, if somebody's pissed off that something's gone
- 30:56wrong, like the product, they didn't like the product or they
- 30:59got annoyed for whatever reason, ignoring it doesn't change it.
- 31:02And if you don't change it, that sentiment confessor and more
- 31:05people can experience the issue they've had.
- 31:07So taking it, taking it offline for me is the number one thing
- 31:10is if somebody's negative, respond professionally and say,
- 31:13you know, and it's not about going on.
- 31:15I'm so sorry, I'm so sorry. So don't apologise for things
- 31:17where you haven't done something wrong, but just say, look, you
- 31:20know, we, we understand what's going, what the problem is, we'd
- 31:25love to get this resolved. View Here's our e-mail address.
- 31:28Message us or DMSCX and we'll call you straight back.
- 31:32Doing that we show to people you care, but then you can take it
- 31:34offline and you can, you can filter out an ongoing diatribe
- 31:38of emotion. Basically, I think there are a
- 31:40few things where it's fundamentally important to do so
- 31:43that you don't end up causing like a ripple effect.
- 31:47Yeah, I think so. I think products, I have had
- 31:50some kinds of being a bit careful with how they send out
- 31:53review requests to certain products just haven't performed
- 31:56really well. But I think you just got to take
- 31:58that as a business and try and improve product.
- 32:00This did remind me of the situation I had recently.
- 32:03It's a bit random, but I went to, I was in Corfu and there's a
- 32:08restaurant that I have and this is just an annoying situation as
- 32:11a reviewer, so that I'd always go to a really good restaurant,
- 32:15always had a great experience. And then I'd heard the owner was
- 32:19quite rude in the past. And then and I went there with
- 32:22my wife and child. We were trying to get table and
- 32:26it was like really quiet and I was like, I've got a table in an
- 32:30hour of her. And then she was just like
- 32:32really rude. No.
- 32:35And then I'd explain that I'd be good enough for years and
- 32:37everything else and she was like, I don't care.
- 32:39Like really, really rude, really bad experience.
- 32:41Then she was super rude to all of us.
- 32:43And I think they realistically they could have given us a
- 32:45table, but she's decided not to. So a little bit of a Pretty
- 32:49Woman moment without them, like rich guy coming in and giving me
- 32:52loads of money. And then I left a review and I
- 32:55was like kind of because I think it'd been a bit of a trend of
- 32:59what others should get a bit more involved.
- 33:00I have to review to say I'm really bad experience everything
- 33:02Cars problem with Google reviews is she they can then respond or
- 33:07she can respond. Then you can't respond anymore.
- 33:10So she basically responded and was like, you've never been
- 33:12there before. You were really, really
- 33:15everything like saying loads stuff and I couldn't respond.
- 33:17So actually she ended up winning because she kind of made me out
- 33:22to just be like some kind of maniacs that never been to the
- 33:25restaurant before. And that was just like having a
- 33:27go. And then I just couldn't
- 33:30respond. So I just had to leave it at
- 33:32that. Yeah, it it is for what I mean,
- 33:36The thing is, once you see a, an increase in the number of views
- 33:39posting a similar thing and you know, the owners are always
- 33:42saying, no, you're in the wrong, then this this is where the
- 33:46ability to read and discern reviews is important.
- 33:48If someone just looks at a star rate and they're going to see it
- 33:51dropping and if they look at the verbatim from the reviews
- 33:53they're going to see you're not I say, but I know what you mean.
- 33:55It's frustrating when when somebody's like that, but I
- 34:00just, I just, I think the number one take away is you can't
- 34:04ignore them. You've got to understand what's
- 34:06driving them, therefore what's driving them.
- 34:07And, and I have seen this before years ago where actually what
- 34:10was driving them was a competitor basically getting
- 34:13people to leave shitty reviews. If you understand that and you
- 34:16can build evidence, you can at least take that back to
- 34:18whoever's owning the review engine.
- 34:19But also you can start to counter it.
- 34:21You can create APR policy around it on how to deal with this and
- 34:24manage it proactively and how to communicate to your genuine
- 34:27customers. But ignoring it, it doesn't go
- 34:29away. It's going to be negative
- 34:32reviews, so that's only next reviews.
- 34:35Now let's talk about the tech. So there's always innovation
- 34:39technology, there's always new partners coming in.
- 34:41There's there's ecosystem centric ones.
- 34:43There's general platforms that are agnostic to the E com
- 34:46platform you're on. You know, there are long
- 34:48standing review providers like trustpilot and FIFO.
- 34:51You've got slight, you know, slightly more modern, but well
- 34:54established and across 1000 thousand brands like the yacht
- 34:57pose reviews dot IO. And then you've got slightly new
- 35:02ones that are really grown as well, sort of Kendo.
- 35:05And then even new ones like lip score, where when you work with
- 35:09clients and they're asking you and they're saying, well, we're
- 35:12looking at review brighter. How do you advise them to assess
- 35:15and select on the tech? And we're not going to go, we're
- 35:17not going to try and compare them all Possibly what, what,
- 35:21what the decision criteria. So I think, I think it varies.
- 35:25So I think focusing on product reviews first, I think quite
- 35:29often we've been quite hamstrung because I think some of the
- 35:32smaller vendors in Shopfire like amazing.
- 35:35I was talking to someone over there about Judge Me is business
- 35:38and it's like it's an incredible business.
- 35:40Like I think they've got a great product where it's relevant.
- 35:43And then I think a Kendo have grown really fast as well.
- 35:47But quite often, where maybe the clients will want the API kind
- 35:53of up for the front end as a minimum, I want markets
- 35:56integration. They might want the ability to
- 35:59use syndication, or at least that quite often people will be
- 36:03like that is an absolute must. It will select a vendor based on
- 36:06that so that Yacht Poe can use bizarre voices syndication and
- 36:10then they won't actually end up doing it anyway, which can be
- 36:13quite annoying. And then the other thing is they
- 36:16might want an integrated kind of Instagram capability for like
- 36:22curating Instagram content, that kind of stuff.
- 36:24So they've typically been just the type of client we work with,
- 36:27the kind of things that often lead us to Yacht by who I think
- 36:31are a good vendor. I think a lot of people might
- 36:33question, you know, how far the products come in the last couple
- 36:37of years or whatever. And you do pay a bit of a
- 36:39premium for it still, but I think they're flexible and
- 36:43they're well in integrated into the Shopify world.
- 36:46And also the API can be even more important if you're working
- 36:50in other ecosystems. And to be honest, you don't have
- 36:53many options in the other ecosystems anyway really.
- 36:56But I think I've always been impressed by the smaller ones.
- 36:59But we've always kind of needed to go down the route of
- 37:04particularly yacht fair. We do have, we've got a client
- 37:07using Trustpilot product reviews and we're obviously going to
- 37:09come on Trustpilot and I think there's some benefit from a kind
- 37:13of trust signal perspective, but the review side isn't as
- 37:16flexible. But I believe they're rebuilding
- 37:18it all anyway at the moment and they want to try and, you know,
- 37:21become the market leader on that side.
- 37:23One thing I just googled was purely out of interest in the
- 37:26background, not that I wasn't paid attention was I just wanted
- 37:29to understand the trend around FIFO.
- 37:32So I just looked at Google trends with FIFA and Trustpilot
- 37:36and Trustpilot. It's been like growing
- 37:37ridiculously and the volume is like not compatible.
- 37:41But I, I thought that was really interesting because a few years
- 37:44ago FIFO was so prominent and I feel like I just haven't really
- 37:47seen it anymore. But yeah.
- 37:50And then the service review piece, there's not many players
- 37:52around and I'm sure we'll get on to our discussion on where it's
- 37:58not needed. And yeah, why you doing those?
- 38:01Considerate. But yeah, why?
- 38:03What's your view? Because I think you've been
- 38:04working some other ones of it. That, and I'm saying, so cost is
- 38:08important because you've got to, you've got to weigh up the
- 38:12benefit of a more feature rich platform with whether you, you
- 38:16have the bandwidth and resource to use it.
- 38:19And I, I always bring this back with clients because you don't,
- 38:23because the, the vast majority of these vendors we talked about
- 38:27have an export import process because they know that people
- 38:31move. So you're not stuck if you go
- 38:34with a lower cost 1 now and then you want to upgrade and move and
- 38:38tap into more feature, more features in a couple of years
- 38:40time. So I think that's a really
- 38:42important discussion point because everyone wants the
- 38:44world, but they can't use it. But you're right, this
- 38:47syndicate, I'm glad you put out syndication that is critical for
- 38:50were brands where they have really established retail
- 38:53channels and those big retail like soup, soup brands selling
- 38:57supermarkets is a great example. And a lot of those are using
- 39:00bizarre voice and therefore, the syndication will enable reviews
- 39:03of those products to be pushed in, but also to pull them back
- 39:06from where those products are being sold elsewhere.
- 39:08So the benefit your own website, that can be massive because you
- 39:11can go from 30 reviews to 250 reviews overnight.
- 39:15And the credibility is huge. And the impact on PDP at the
- 39:18basket rate and the version is big.
- 39:19So yeah, I think that is often the tipping point for justifying
- 39:23spend on a higher platform. But not everyone's ready to use
- 39:27it, as you say, and it's pointless getting a platform
- 39:30you're not ready to use. So, yeah, yeah, I think you're
- 39:32spot on on that. Let's get, we've got about,
- 39:35we've got about 5 minutes left and in our podcasts before Paul,
- 39:38I run away to do other stuff. Trustpilot is really important
- 39:41to talk about actually because I think we kind of tease out some
- 39:44of the negatives and positives and this has not been
- 39:46deliberately critical to them, but they have definitely.
- 39:49I think there's been a challenging few years where
- 39:51Trustpilot, although it's in consumers minds, it's still very
- 39:55prominent actually with retailers.
- 39:57There's been a lot of frustrations and there's been a
- 39:59lot of frustrations because. Of the ability for people to
- 40:03gain Trustpilot to, to basically push lots of fake reviews
- 40:09against brands that aren't so credible.
- 40:11And also there are major brands on there who aren't using
- 40:15Trustpilot. There are brands like Amazon and
- 40:18Zara. They don't use Trustpilot.
- 40:20Amazon for an obvious reason. It's got some review engine but
- 40:23actually they they exist because you can create a review against
- 40:27retail or if the retail is not paying for a subscription.
- 40:29And they have insanely low review scores that are
- 40:32disproportionately low to the actual average reviews they get
- 40:36through other third parties. So Amazon has got 1.7 rating on
- 40:39Trustpilot, Zara 1.3 I think something like that.
- 40:44And there are loads of sites advertising black cap reviews
- 40:46for brands to push fake reviews in.
- 40:50And there's also evidence of of single reviewers who are adding
- 40:54loads and loads of reviews on this on one particular business.
- 40:58So it's clearly like fake generation.
- 41:00So you know, that's one of the problems of having an open
- 41:03product. So, and you know, those are the
- 41:07issues, there are other issues, but those are the primary ones
- 41:10where it then it created a bit of retailer frustration because
- 41:15memory days have to go up the levels of subscription in order
- 41:18to combat that and balance it with genuine verified positive
- 41:21reviews. And I think that's the battle
- 41:23they have. So they, they might have a good
- 41:25technical platform and they might actually have some really
- 41:28good benefits to the, to the capability, the feature and the
- 41:31consumer awareness. But there has to be that
- 41:33balancing act because I think a few retailers I know have moved
- 41:36away because of seeing that as just too much of A cost
- 41:40challenge. Yeah, I think it's I think it's
- 41:44really interesting. We obviously talked a bit about
- 41:46before and I will say I've recently become friends with
- 41:49chess pilot are not friends, but John T who I'm sure a lot of our
- 41:53listeners will know is someone that E way in red box did you?
- 41:57And then he's moved into their director of partnerships role
- 42:01and it's kind of built out a team with a number of people I
- 42:03know. And then I did a talk and their
- 42:06kind of sales kick off and I think 1 I think it's a super
- 42:08interesting business because I just got so much data and I
- 42:12would love to have access to that data.
- 42:14Just I think it yeah, be super, super interesting.
- 42:17But two, I totally see where you're coming from some of those
- 42:20points. And I think I've certainly been
- 42:23in a situation where clients have been like I've got coming
- 42:25to a business said I've got this cost line that's several
- 42:28thousands pounds a month and it's Trustpilot, do I need it?
- 42:30And realistically, you kind of want to say no, but you've got
- 42:33to be a bit careful because if you don't have that kind of
- 42:37incoming stream of positive reviews, you're only really
- 42:40allowing for the negative reviewers who will naturally go
- 42:43there. And like, no one will ever go
- 42:46and leave a positive review or very few people.
- 42:49But obviously all the negative reviewers would immediately go
- 42:51to that place. We have glass doors kind of
- 42:54similar actually, to be honest. Like there is like there's a
- 42:56whole world around the Lister. And that being said, I do think
- 43:00they do have like genuine trust around them, which makes this
- 43:04even more complex. And I do think consumers
- 43:08recognize the brand like yeah, a lot.
- 43:11So I feel like it is quite a complex area and actually what
- 43:15would be great because I do think there's some real benefits
- 43:18to trespire that. I just think that situation I
- 43:20completely agree with you. Like it is really tricky and
- 43:23complex and obviously you know, they've they monetize really
- 43:27well as a result of that situation.
- 43:30But I wonder if we get someone on, I don't know, I don't know,
- 43:32a public company. So I don't know how open they
- 43:36yeah. I think it's important to be
- 43:38balanced is is that there are a lot of really good people
- 43:41working at Trust Pint. I've worked with many of them
- 43:43over the years and and they generally try and help and
- 43:45retailers to to improve what they're doing customer reviews.
- 43:49The problem is the model is fundamentally flawed because
- 43:54anyone can post a review and you're right, people who are
- 43:56angry will go to Trustpilot. And you, if you're not a an
- 44:01active subscriber of it and therefore all your reviews
- 44:03aren't going through it, you are disproportionately reflected,
- 44:07whereas your reviews elsewhere are far, far higher.
- 44:09And I think that's the problem. And it is a hard conundrum to
- 44:12unpick. But the reason for talking about
- 44:13this is not to name and shame. It's just transparency.
- 44:16When people think about this, they've got to think about these
- 44:18dynamics because if you go and Trustpilot, you've got to be
- 44:21incredible priority and you've got to be there for the long
- 44:24haul, maintain it because otherwise you'll end up that
- 44:27rating will start to come down again if you're not proactively
- 44:30pushing reviews into it. OK, so I guess that's that's the
- 44:35end. I know that that we both got
- 44:37hard to stop. My key takeaways are basically
- 44:42reviews is focus on the questions you're asking people.
- 44:44You raised this. Actually, I'm stealing.
- 44:46I'm kind of sounds like I'm stealing your take away.
- 44:48Focus on the questions you ask people to get more structured
- 44:51and useful and and focus reviews.
- 44:54Be be proactive in monitoring and responding to reviews,
- 44:57including negative ones, and make sure you use review content
- 45:00outside of PDPS. Don't limit it those of mine.
- 45:03Anything else you'll not add before We wish everyone a fond
- 45:06farewell? Is great.
- 45:09Yeah. No, I don't think so.
- 45:10From my side, I think, yeah, really good, interesting
- 45:13discussion. And like I say, we'll try and
- 45:15get someone from Trust Python. Yes, hopefully they don't hate,
- 45:18hate me for raising these issues, but I think it's
- 45:20important because they are out there and people are talking
- 45:22about it. I do still like them.
- 45:24It's OK and look. Thanks for all the list for
- 45:27listening. As always, hope you found it
- 45:28enjoyable. Any questions, anything you
- 45:31agree with, disagree with, Hit Paul and I up on LinkedIn and
- 45:34then hopefully you'll be back to listen again Next week.
- 45:38You're listening to the Insidecommerce podcast hosted by
- 45:40experienced consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers.
- 45:43Insidecommerce is your fast tracked additional knowledge
- 45:46featuring interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 45:49industry thought leads and the C-Suite key tech companies to
- 45:51explore the latest digital strategy, customer experience
- 45:54and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 45:56really mean and get practical advice based on the experience
- 45:59to help fine tune your ECOM strategy and tech.
- 46:03Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James and Paul if you'd
- 46:05like to discuss an e-commerce project.
- 46:08We hope you enjoy the latest episode.